Pobal: Financial Statements 2018
Contributions 203–409 of 618. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Is there a forum whereby the school can engage with Pobal to outline what is happening on the ground as a result of the categorisation? I have met representatives of the school and visited it, as have other Deputies. The categorisation does not reflect what the school experiences or the area. Is there a way that it can engage with Pobal with a view to having the agency take its concerns on board?
Comment on this
If it is about funding that we administer, all our schemes always try to ensure we are available to talk-----
Comment on this
It is not about funding.
Comment on this
Exactly. We will need to talk to the school and maybe communicate with the Department of Education and Skills because-----
Comment on this
It is about the Pobal map, and the indices or criteria used.
Comment on this
In that instance, we need to talk to the Department of Education and Skills about the way it interprets the data there.
Comment on this
I thank our guests. We will revert to them on the matter.
Comment on this
The Department of Education and Skills will be contacted. To clarify, where are we leaving that topic?
Comment on this
We will undertake to talk to the Department of Education and Skills on the specifics the Deputy raised.
Comment on this
It is a general issue. The point the Deputy made applies to other locations. A school might have students who are not from deprived areas but it might be located in a deprived area, and vice versa.
Comment on this
It may be that the index does not suit the purpose the Department of Education and Skills is trying to serve with its designation of schools. It is a question for the Department to be aware of that and what it means for what it is trying to achieve.
Comment on this
We will ask Pobal to talk to the Department of Education and Skills and to revert to us then.
Comment on this
Pobal might also engage with the school that wrote to it. It was quite recently.
Comment on this
Absolutely, although it has written directly to Pobal.
Comment on this
The Deputy's point could be used as an example, given that many of us will be aware of similar cases where the geographical area is too large, and where there are pockets therein that should conform to the categorisation but do not.
We might separate the services Pobal provides. Having talked to people on the other side who engage with it, although not from the childcare perspective, I note that its services are targeted and focused on outcomes, and that it certainly puts organisations through their paces to ensure there will be good outcomes. That is definitely a positive in Pobal's work on, for example, community employment schemes and community services. Nevertheless, in other countries, the delivery arm of such work is local government, whereas we have a centralised, fragmented system.
As has been noted, a plethora of organisations deal with childcare. There are not only the individual childcare providers but also the State providers. Local authorities provide planning permission and ensure that the ratio of childcare provision in buildings is as is set out in high-level policies. There are also county childcare committees, Tusla and so on. It is fragmented. It is interesting when one hears from somebody on a reception desk at a local authority that if non-Irish nationals ask for services, they expect the services to be delivered at the local authority level but they are not. We should accept that the service is fragmented to begin with. We are not especially good at organisation building.
How are Pobal's staff levels determined? There were 442 members of staff in 2018. In its briefing document, Pobal stated its current challenges have resulted from rapid growth over a short period. What certainty has Pobal about staff? What has been the profile of the staff growth over a couple of years?
Comment on this
For the period 2014 to 2018, inclusive, our staff numbers doubled, which was reflective of the programmes of work we have taken on on behalf of the Department of Children and Youth Affairs primarily. Much of that relates to Better Start, the access and inclusion staffing model, which is about mentoring and quality-supporting community childcare providers around improving and implementing the Síolta and Aistear curricula. Approximately 140 of the staff are related to that during that period.
Comment on this
While the figure will include administrative staff, what are the other disciplines?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy refer to disciplines right across our staff profile?
Comment on this
I refer in particular to those that have resulted from the growth.
Comment on this
It is mostly early years specialists because that is the nature of their work. They need to be able to speak with authority in respect of those childcare, early learning and care services. Some 140 of those staff would come with early childhood education qualifications.
Comment on this
Does Pobal have vacancies?
Comment on this
We have a number of vacancies but we stay on top of matters through our resource allocation or requisition process.
Comment on this
So there is not a big shortage of staff at the moment?
Comment on this
No. One of the bigger challenges we have is that the workforce is primarily female. We build additional staff into the workforce plan to allow for the normal leave requirements that arise in that gender profile.
Comment on this
One of the other challenges Ms Shakespeare describes is the perception of Pobal being overly bureaucratic. Does that come from both the childcare side and the community employment side or is there a difference in that perception or that reality?
Comment on this
Pobal administers the programmes and the grant management in accordance with the programme rules that are defined, as a matter of policy, by the funding Department. While there will be different programme rules and guidance, the principle remains the same in the context of our role in verification, checking compliance, following through with audits or requiring agencies to submit documentation to Pobal to demonstrate the outcomes focus, on the one hand, and probity in respect of Exchequer funding, on the other.
Comment on this
On the compliance checks and reviews and the 3,747 contracts reviewed in 2018, Pobal found that 50% of the contracts that were reviewed were found to be the subject of either moderate or major non-compliance. Almost one in five, or 19%, were non-compliant in a major way. Can Ms Shakespeare describe what major non-compliance looks like?
Comment on this
As we might have referenced in our earlier exchange with Deputy Munster, major non-compliance is the concept of a child being registered with a facility and the consequent non-attendance of that child in that early learning and care facility. Compliance visits are only conducted on funded programmes from the Department of Children and Youth Affairs. The early learning and care sectors are subject to compliance visits.
Comment on this
Are there repeat offenders? Is it a question, for example, that children are enrolled and then do not turn up? Is it up to the provider to then notify Pobal? What happens in such cases?
Comment on this
It is exactly as the Deputy described it. Children are enrolled or registered with the programme and they may not attend. While the compliance visit officers look at a snapshot in time, they are proportionate in their review of that attendance. For example, it is only when it relates to a pattern of non-attendance that it becomes a non-compliance issue. We recognise the fact that family circumstances need to be flexible and that a mother or father might need to take a day off, for example. It is only when that is a sustained pattern in that snapshot period that it then becomes an issue of non-compliance. The registration is amended as a result of the compliance visit and non-compliance is addressed in that context going forward.
Comment on this
In some parts of the country, it will be difficult to find places in childcare facilities and then, for example, somebody signs up to a certain facility and does not send the child to it. The provider can then end up being non-compliant and, at the same time, somebody else requires the place. An element of fair play has to involved in this. Is there a financial penalty, for example, for people who are non-compliant having signed a child up or is it all on the provider?
Comment on this
It is all on the provider. The money follows the child and the service is funded on the basis of the registration and the subsequent attendance of the child. If the child is not attending, the money does not flow. Before we reach that scenario, we work with the provider involved to support it to ensure and maximise attendance.
Comment on this
Does anything stand out in the context of certain locations? Is there any profile of deprivation involved? Does anything stand out which suggests other actions need to be taken?
Comment on this
I will pass that question to my colleague, Mr. Jerry Murphy.
Comment on this
Larger providers and the community providers were targeted last year. It is often the community providers, especially those in disadvantaged areas, that have particular difficulty with issue. This is often because they are working in difficult circumstances. It is not that there is a casualness on the provider's side. If, however, a provider is working in an area with a lot of families that fact particular challenges etc., as opposed to working in an area where family circumstances are generally more advantaged, it can be difficult. There are patterns and there are real challenges for particular sets of providers, which is why there is flexibility, the importance of which Ms Shakespeare mentioned.
Comment on this
Would Pobal give feedback to the Department on initiatives that might be taken or additional supports that might be required in order that providers do not find themselves in a position of non-compliance?
Comment on this
Yes. Pobal and the Department have worked together, including being co-located in a single office in respect of the development of the national childcare scheme over the past two and a half years. A significant amount of the attention in the development of that scheme has been directed at learning from the existing schemes and amending the rules, the way matters work and the processes to try to bring more business reality to the scheme, including with this issue.
Comment on this
We all accept that margins are tight for providers. I echo some of the points that were made earlier in the context of not having delays and simplifying the process because the overheads of administration can be reduced. It is important to do that in respect of such an important programme. On that programme, primary school teachers will say that the differentiator that used to be noticeable, whereby people could afford to send their children to preschool, is not that noticeable now and they will say there is a strong educational advantage to the programme that is being run.
On the recovery process to which our guests referred, where a grant is repayable, what is involved? The longer a debt stands, the more likely it is that payment will not be made. Some of these debts have stood for up to one year, some for more than one year, some for up to five years and some for more than five years. I suspect that when it goes beyond five years, the chances of getting a repayment are almost nil. What is Pobal's recovery process and what effort does it put into getting early resolutions?
Comment on this
I will talk about the early years sector where early learning, childhood and care providers may have over-claimed on the basis of attendance. We are mindful of the fragile environment in which early learning and care providers are working. We have an integrated case management team that works on an individual basis with each early learning and care provider to agree the repayment. In the current community childcare subvention programme, prior to NCS, and many individuals are choosing to remain on some of those legacy schemes. We have an opportunity, because there is a prepayment in advance, to work with that provider to agree a repayment plan that is proportionate and reasonable in circumstances where they may have over-claimed. In addition-----
Comment on this
Yes, we do so in an agreed way with that provider to ensure that at all times the sustainability of learning and care for that community is the priority and that it is not harmed in any way. In addition, where providers find themselves in difficulty with that funding from a sustainability perspective, there is also a sustainability fund to which applications can be made. That goes through an approval process with the Department of Children and Youth Affairs and we go back and work with the provider involved in order to achieve full repayment in respect of the over-claim that may have occurred.
Comment on this
Do the other sectors feature at all in the overpayments?
Comment on this
The funding model is somewhat different in early learning and care. The money follows the child and the registration, whereas it is done a little differently for programmes. I may hand over to Mr. Lehane to address the debt recovery process from a finance perspective.
Comment on this
For non-early years, we typically seek to get all the financial statements from these organisations to make sure that they are compliant with the payment of the grants each year. There is also a procedure when grants are not being paid. Three follow-up letters are issued to each of the grantees seeking recovery. Sometimes grantees will respond and we enter into a repayment plan with them. If others do not respond to us, they are put on a debtor management scheme and we feed that back to the Department for further action, whether it is a write-off or legal action.
Comment on this
Does anything in particular stand out? Is there anything substantial or are we talking about relatively small amounts?
Comment on this
It varies. There is a substantial amount outstanding for one but the rest are relatively small.
Comment on this
What is the substantial one?
Comment on this
I understand it is approximately €400,000. I understand that company is going into liquidation.
Comment on this
Is that a scheme or what is it?
Comment on this
I will have to come back to give the Deputy the full details of that, if I could.
Comment on this
It is a non-early years provider. It is a social inclusion protector.
Comment on this
Mr. Lehane might send us a note with as much as he can without disclosing the identity.
Comment on this
Surely if one provider owes €400,000, the witnesses can tell the committee who that is in more detail?
Comment on this
I do not want to provide wrong information. I want to double-check it.
Comment on this
We want the right information. It seems that there is only one. I could understand if there were 40. One group somewhere has overclaimed by €400,000. I will have my own questions in a minute but it seems that it would be very obvious to the witnesses who that was.
Comment on this
I cannot recall it straight away but I can come back to the committee on it.
Comment on this
Could one of Mr. Lehane's colleagues make a phone call? The letter that goes out says to have a facility to make contact to get further details. Can somebody make a call and come back to us?
Comment on this
Those are the questions that I wanted to ask.
Comment on this
We will try to get an answer shortly. I thank Deputy Murphy and call Deputy O'Connell.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. My first question relates to the charitable status of community crèches. The witnesses are probably aware that I was going to bring this up because Revenue was in here. I understand that the status is granted because it is an education provider, so it falls under that category. Why do community crèches have charitable status while non-community crèches that engage with, and are compliant with, the early childhood care scheme cannot avail of that? Is there a reason? I understand the not-for-profit element. It seems an unfair advantage. If there was a community crèche down the road and a private operator, it would be unfair for competition. Do the witnesses think that all crèches should be granted charitable status if they want it or that the way that we are going, with community crèches having charitable status, is okay? If there is a profit, do community crèches use surplus money to employ additional staff? Are they eating into their profits and, therefore, having better ratios and better services? Do they provide a better service than the person up the road who is trying to operate a business? It is about fairness in the system. In parts of Dublin, there can be a community crèche that appears to have an advantage over nearby private providers.
Comment on this
I understand the Deputy's question as being whether Pobal has a view about all crèches being offered the opportunity to have charitable status.
Comment on this
With respect, that is a matter for the Charities Regulator.
Comment on this
We had the regulator and Revenue in and they said it was basically Pobal's responsibility.
Comment on this
When we engage with early year learning and care facilities, we ask them whether they feel they satisfy the criteria to register as a charity, which is primarily driven by their charitable objects as a company, and whether they engage in fundraising activities. That is my understanding of it.
Comment on this
Does Ms Shakespeare see crèches as education providers?
Comment on this
Absolutely. Early learning and early years.
Comment on this
I know that many other people have spoken about these overclaims. It appears to me that children were registered in a particular crèche. They may only have required three days, from Tuesday to Thursday, but the crèche was claiming for five days or a version of that. I have been through the scheme. I have three children and happened to have them when this all came in. Private crèches are very specific about signing forms and when the child will be in. It is very easy to monitor who is in a crèche each week. I do not understand how this situation could emerge. There is €400,000 from this particular group. What is the total outstanding amount owed for overclaims?
Comment on this
The overclaim for the 2018-19 period is €1.1 million.
Comment on this
What is the outstanding amount on Pobal's books?
Comment on this
The outstanding amount is €690,000 with repayment in process for those providers that overclaimed.
Comment on this
Some €690,000 is left. There is some €1.1 million plus €313,000. Surely Ms Shakespeare knows how much money was overclaimed or fraudulently claimed?
Comment on this
Yes. It is €1.1 million for 2018 and 2019, and €300,000-----
Comment on this
Ms Shakespeare must have the figure, a bit like the guy who owes €400,000. Surely there is a figure for the total overclaimed over the lifetime of the scheme?
Comment on this
With some €1.1 million plus €313,000 for the year before, what is the total?
Comment on this
The Department of Children and Youth Affairs may want to speak on this. The Department received advice that the rules that were in place for the year prior to that were not ones which allowed clearly defined levels of overclaims, so we-----
Comment on this
The only overclaims that can be defined are for those two years.
Comment on this
The system allowed it before that.
Comment on this
There was a lack of clarity which would have allowed-----
Comment on this
With respect, if one is claiming for a child for five days and the child is only in for three, there is not much ambiguity about that.
Comment on this
The ambiguity was about the terms used within the rules. It was about attendance in some places but in other places, it was about registration. If a child was registered for five days, some providers would understand that to be acceptable.
Comment on this
Why does Mr. Murphy think there was such a jump in overclaims between 2018 and 2019? How did it treble in a year? Did somebody say that this is a great gig to be involved in, since crèches can be paid for the children without even having to have them in the place? Why did it jump so much?
Comment on this
It related to the type of compliance review and the type of programme that was reviewed for the 2017-18 period. The lesson we learned was that with the agreement of the Department, the community childcare subvention programmes would be targeted in the 2018-19 period with a particular focus on the larger contract holders. The intention was to maximise that review to identify what the overclaims that have been mentioned might amount to.
Comment on this
We do not know the identity of the entity that owes €400,000. Do we have any idea what its turnover might be? What proportion-----
Comment on this
We have information on that. I apologise for the confusion. It was an early years grouping, rather than a non-early years grouping. The total amount was €483,000.
Comment on this
The name of the grouping was West Clare Early Years. It was a consortium grouping that managed early years provision across west Clare. It had facilities in Kilrush, Kilkee, Kilmihil and elsewhere.
Comment on this
The total for the whole group came to €500,000.
Comment on this
The whole group went at the same time. This followed an audit by-----
Comment on this
In the end, it went into liquidation. By the way, there were issues involved here that were referred to the Garda. When Pobal audited the group, it realised that there were significant problems with record-keeping. I need to be careful in this regard because the case was referred to the Garda. There were significant issues with record-keeping. When the board of the group considered these issues, it decided to cease activity and subsequently went into liquidation. This meant that any of the approaches to recovery that we would normally take was simply impossible.
Comment on this
Pobal is not going to get anything back.
Comment on this
There is no point wasting any more money. We handed over €500,000 to a consortium in County Clare to run crèches.
Comment on this
It overclaimed and the system allowed it. We are able to go back on a couple of years only.
Comment on this
No. We cannot go back further than those years. I cannot give the Deputy a guarantee that the problems in these areas did not begin before the years in question. This was a classic case. Obviously, such amounts of money are very significant. I remind the Deputy that the major capital investment that was made by the State in some cases resulted in a significant set of crèches in west Clare that was not previously available. Our role was to engage with local communities and groups to ensure these facilities were brought back into use as quickly as possible. That has resulted in a series of contracts being put in place. New providers in each location are using these facilities and making these services available to the people of west Clare.
Comment on this
Do we know what the turnover of the group in west Clare was in this two-year period? I am trying to find out how significant a proportion of its total turnover the €483,000 accounts for.
Comment on this
In the interests of accuracy, it would probably be better for us to go away, put those figures together and come back to the committee with them rather than attempting to provide them now.
Comment on this
Yes. If its turnover was €1 million, half of it was fraudulently obtained.
Comment on this
I expect that between the five centres, the turnover was significantly more than that. We would not look at the records because it is a series of centres. I think it would be much safer to come back to the committee with an accurate figure.
Comment on this
I think we could do with a very detailed note on how something like this happened. Almost €500,000 that should have been used to help children to be educated has gone missing, essentially. It was overclaimed and was not used for the purpose it was supposed to be used for because the children were not even there. I would like to ask about the other entities that are going to pay back money. How can they pay back money if they are non-profit entities? How are they going to manage the reality of this? My understanding is that there is not much margin in this business for childcare providers that are legitimately claiming for children who actually exist in the crèche. If this money is going to be paid back, how will that be managed by non-profit entities? Is the reality that none of this money will come back?
Comment on this
Some €400,000 has been received back, and a further €690,000 is expected back, from agencies that are in a repayment plan managed through Pobal and its integrated case management function. As I have said, we are very mindful of the need to work with the provider to repay, while balancing that with our duty to ensure the early learning and care facility is sustainable into the future. We work with providers across a number of strands to improve governance and the service. There is a general stream of seven different types of support that we provide to providers when they are in repayment mode. We are very mindful that we have agreed a sustainability fund with the Department in circumstances in which there are going concerns, or might be going concerns.
Comment on this
I can understand the conundrum here. Pobal really needs the childcare providers. If it had another option, it would not generally deal with the provider that took it for a ride for two years. We need the places because there is a shortage of places. It seems to me that because these operators have the places, they have been let away with it to some extent. The repayment process seems to be quite passive. If this was in the private sector, they would not get away with this sort of carry-on. This is fraudulent, as far as I am concerned. If someone is overclaiming in respect of children who are supposed to be getting a service, that is clearly and obviously fraudulent. I have had to sign forms for children as they have gone in in the morning and as they have come out. When crèches are inspected at any point, the headcount needs to be right. That brings me on to my next question about the 13 inspections that took place before the "Prime Time"-----
Comment on this
I would like to ask a question about this matter before the Deputy moves on from it. Where in Pobal's accounts is the amount that is due shown?
Comment on this
Where in the 2018 accounts are the amounts that are due to be paid in respect of these overpayments identified?
Comment on this
The identification of those amounts did not occur until 2019. They should feature in our 2019 accounts.
Comment on this
I have been trying to find this big figure, but I have not found it. Ms Shakespeare is telling me that it is not in the accounts that were laid before the Oireachtas the other day.
Comment on this
As the contract is with the DCYA, these refunds would not be-----
Comment on this
Sorry. It is the Department of Children and Youth Affairs.
Comment on this
Does it come through Pobal at all? Does it come in to Pobal and go on to the Department of Children and Youth Affairs? When the money is being repaid, where does the cheque go? Who gets the cheque?
Comment on this
What bank account are the repayments going into?
Comment on this
We have been told that there is a repayments system. Is that system with Pobal or with the Department of Children and Youth Affairs?
Comment on this
Perhaps if I can clarify this matter. As I said to another Deputy, the manner in which the payments are recouped involves a reduction in payments going forward.
Comment on this
The money is taken out of the subvention.
Comment on this
Ms Shakespeare has said that €400,000 has been recovered and €690,000 has been promised. The total is €1.4 million. All we are missing is €310,000.
Comment on this
Okay. The total for the 2018-19 period is €1.1 million, of which €400,000 has been recouped. My understanding is that the majority of the total of €313,000 for the 2016-17 period has been recouped.
Comment on this
Okay. Given that Pobal is not in command of the repayments and recoupments, can we get the Department to send us a detailed note about the debt we are talking about?
Comment on this
I would like to add that deductions are being made in cases in which providers are continuing to operate.
Comment on this
What about the providers that are not continuing?
Comment on this
The Deputy is referring to providers that have been liquidated.
Comment on this
They might have been liquidated or they might simply not be continuing in business. What happens in such cases? I understand the process that applies in the cases of providers that are continuing. Surely there are others that fall into another category.
Comment on this
They may have wound down or whatever.
Comment on this
Are the Deputies asking about recouping money from companies that have closed down?
Comment on this
They are asking about money that is due to be repaid, for example as a consequence of overpayments having been made. It could be due back for a variety of reasons.
Comment on this
The only overpayment arises in relation to early childhood programmes. There is no overpayment which arises in the context of-----
Comment on this
We are talking about overclaims, rather than overpayments.
Comment on this
Apologies. Overclaims do not arise under the other programmes that we manage.
Comment on this
If there was a change of circumstances, there might be a little bit to be paid back, but that would be a matter for the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection.
Comment on this
What was the total spend on the early childhood scheme in 2018-2019? How much was paid to crèches?
Comment on this
I refer Deputy O'Connell to page 103 of the accounts, which sets out a figure of €506 million in that regard. The spend on the early years programme was €484 million. I ask the witnesses to forward a note on the matter to the committee.
Comment on this
Yes, for the purposes of clarity, because we are getting a bit confused in this sphere. The Department did focus in on the CCS programme. That is where the jump between the two years in overclaims has occurred.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Gaffney repeat that point, please?
Comment on this
That is where the jump and identification of overclaims occurred.
Comment on this
The overclaims were identified because there was a focus on the scheme for 2018-2019. It is not necessarily the case that in the previous year there was not as much overclaiming, rather it is that the Department did not look into that year as forensically as it did in respect of 2018-2019.
Comment on this
There was more of a focus on it in 2018-2019, having evidence of which schemes were the risker schemes. We have already-----
Comment on this
Based on what Mr. Gaffney said, there is a risk, potentially, that the same amount of money was overclaimed in 2017-2018-----
Comment on this
-----but the Department did not focus on it. The Department decided instead to focus on 2018-2019. Previous to that, the system allowed such practices. What advice was given to suggest that the Department had no recourse pre-2017? From where did that advice come?
Comment on this
The Chief State Solicitor's office has reviewed the cases in that instance and the advice is that the scheme rules were not sufficiently robust to proceed.
Comment on this
What happened since 2017 to make the rules more robust?
Comment on this
The schemes were improved and clarity was brought to bear.
Comment on this
What does Mr. Gaffney mean when he says "clarity was brought to bear"? I presume there was an amendment of the schemes in order that clarity was brought to bear.
Comment on this
I would imagine the child care services were told they could not claim for children that are not on their books.
Comment on this
The programme rules and guidance under which Pobal operates were improved and clarified by the Department.
Comment on this
Yes. It is the clarification to which Mr. Jerry Murphy spoke earlier.
Comment on this
In regard to the amounts of money, I would characterise the overclaims that are identified as detected overclaims. The point I was making in the recommendation was around the need for a methodology that would allow for the identification of the underlying level of overclaims. In other words, how much should one go after and design one's compliance work specifically to try to identify where the greatest risks are and what is the best way of trying to identify those. The figure that is known may not be the full total.
Comment on this
That is my point. We are only being made aware of the ones that were chosen for examination. This is a very expensive but brilliant scheme that helps children. However, it is sad that like previous schemes, it is flawed. Given current technology, PPS numbers and so on, it is hard to understand that this could happen and so much money could be taken out of the system. Do we have any information with regard to how the money was being spent or is that a matter for the Garda? Why did the services need the extra money? Is it that these were private companies, as in the case in Clare? Where was the money spent? If it was spent on children, that would be grand. Do we have any information with regard to how it was spent?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy asking about the west Clare incidence?
Comment on this
All of the services involved, but particularly the one in west Clare.
Comment on this
That significant incidence is very different, in our point of view, from the vast majority of other cases. It was passed to the Garda because of concerns we had about where the money went.
Comment on this
To allay some of the concerns the committee might have, the programme of work from a compliance perspective was agreed with the Department at the front end of the academic years going forward such that we could be more preventative in our work around identifying registrations and non-attendance in that context.
Comment on this
Can we expect that in the next set of accounts there will be no overclaims, or relatively none? Has Pobal sufficiently informed the providers that this cannot happen again such that another chunk of money will not be overclaimed?
Comment on this
There is much greater awareness in the sector and a level of unrest as well associated with that.
Comment on this
In the context of the repayments and, as mentioned by the Deputy, the regulatory activity in the sector. It is a sector that is under development. We want to make sure that we support it sufficiently because, as rightly mentioned by the Deputy, the children are citizens of Ireland and our future. At the same time, we want to ensure probity for public money and recoupment where there has been an attendance and registration differential. One of the flexibilities that will be built into the national childcare scheme makes this much clearer. As we go forward in fully implementing the national childcare scheme across all the early learning and care providers, it builds in a degree of flexibility where mam and dad are not available to drop the child to the crèche or whatever for family reasons and so on. It will also allow for greater oversight and greater compliance as we move forward with that programme.
Comment on this
On the Tús scheme, am I correct that a person can only participate in it for 12 months?
Comment on this
I have received a number of representations regarding the scheme. I recently attended an event which was a celebration of the work of Tús. It has been brought to my attention that for many people who engage in this scheme it takes three or four months to familiarise themselves with the work and that on completion of their time on the scheme they tend to end up in jobs in the retail sector, including charitable shops and so on. Many of the participants are people who come from complex situations and have not managed to get employment and are given this pathway to work. However, the scheme expires in 12 months, which is relatively short given it takes participants three or four months to become familiar with the work. I have raised with the Minister for Employment Affairs and Social Protection, Deputy Regina Doherty, a request for the scheme to be extended to 18 months or two years such that participants can remain in it and be more useful or move to another job. The view of Tús and those who take on participants under the scheme is that the period of transition is too short. In many cases they are just settling in when they are moved somewhere else. Is there scope to extend this scheme?
Comment on this
It is a policy issue for the Department-----
Comment on this
-----even though we administer it. It is a pattern we are seeing as well, particularly now as the economy has improved. The people who avail of many of these schemes have greater depths of need than would have been the case three or four years ago. From our point of view, there is very good reason to review the design of a number of schemes to try to reflect the greater intensity of need among individual participants.
Comment on this
Many of these people just need somebody to hold their hand as they get back into the system. It is regrettable for the person who was long-term unemployed and got this opportunity that there is no scope to extend it.
On mandatory vaccinations, I understand there are constitutional issues around making vaccination mandatory. There does not appear to be a constitutional issue with child care providers insisting that children registered in a scheme must be vaccinated. Have the witnesses had any discussion with the Department of Health on this issue?
Comment on this
It is an issue that needs to be addressed into the future in light of the recent outbreak of mumps and the measles epidemic. The UK has lost its measles-free status. In the context of the administration of the child care schemes, can we insist that all children registering with a child care provider that is in receipt of State funding must be vaccinated? I do not believe there is a constitutional arising in that regard.
In regard to the 13 inspections that were carried out prior to the "Prime Time Investigates" programme, it is a matter of concern that premises would be inspected and obvious welfare issues would not be identified.
Inspectors can sometimes look in the wrong place. Has Pobal updated or changed its inspection regimes to look in the right places? If a certain amount goes into a State scheme, there is an expectation, especially with our history in Ireland, that we would have the most robust child protection and we would not return to anything like the past. It is very disheartening to see many parents so distressed. It is a major decision to go back to work and put one's child into a crèche. Has Pobal made its inspections more robust and fit for purpose so that it can weed out problems and we do not have another "Prime Time Investigates" incident?