We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Pobal: Financial Statements 2018

Contributions 410–618 of 618. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Ms Anna Shakespeare

I could answer that in a couple of ways. The Better Start access and inclusion model, AIM, service, which we host on behalf of the Children and Youth Affairs, does not have a statutory basis. It does not run an inspection regime. The inspection regime for early learning and care services is managed and run by Tusla and the Department of Education and Skills. This goes back to the point made by Deputy Cassells about fragmentation and providers' experience in that context. However, the primary role of the Better Start AIM staff is to support an active implementation of service improvement in the context of early education and care around the Síolta and Aistear curricula. In addition to that, their job is to carry out a classroom-based assessment to identify services that might benefit from additional funding associated with AIM, that is, cases where children with additional support needs might benefit from additional supports. The work of the Better Start AIM staff employed by Pobal is very different from the statutory function undertaken by Tusla and Department of Education and Skills staff. Does that answer the Deputy's question?

Comment on this

It does. Ms Shakespeare is saying it is their problem, not Pobal's.

Comment on this

Page 88 of Pobal's accounts refers to financial irregularities. Does that include the €400,000 referred to by Deputy O'Connell?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It does.

Comment on this

How many cases does that paragraph refer to?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Is Deputy Connolly asking for the number of cases that have been referred to An Garda Síochána in 2018?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I will have to come back to the committee to clarify that.

Comment on this

There is a paragraph on financial irregularities. I am asking for the number of cases. What is the total amount? What is the age profile of these cases? I want the details. There are financial irregularities. Pobal has been in communication with An Garda Síochána. How many cases have there been? What is the value of what is outstanding? This is basic stuff. It is included in the accounts. I am asking Ms Shakespeare to clarify that paragraph from her knowledge.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I cannot answer that question at this point in time.

Comment on this

Can anybody present do so? Can the Department or anyone else answer?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I am afraid we are not in a position to assist the Deputy at this point in time. We will have to come back to the committee. My apologies. Alternatively I can make a call.

Comment on this

This goes back to my initial point. Clearly the systems were not in place. How were these financial irregularities detected, in whatever number of cases there were?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

They were detected during audits or verification visits conducted by the compliance, audit and risk staff of Pobal.

Comment on this

Ms Shakespeare can tell me that but she cannot tell me the number of cases.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I cannot say how many cases.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Due to a lack of knowledge on my behalf.

Comment on this

That is all right. However, if Ms Shakespeare can tell me the result of audits, she must have some information.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Some 17 audits were completed in 2017. Some of the debtors we are talking about recouping go back further than that.

Comment on this

This is essential information.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I do not disagree.

Comment on this

Does Ms Shakespeare have any idea of the total value? How many cases have been referred to An Garda Síochána?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

The one piece of information we can give the Deputy now is that fewer than five cases have been referred to An Garda in the past three years. We will find further details.

Comment on this

What does "fewer than five" mean? Does that mean four and a half?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

I apologise. Of course we would much prefer to give details. We are making contact now, and we hope to be able to answer before we break. We will certainly come back immediately after. The Deputy is absolutely right. It is a critical detail that we should be able to supply.

Comment on this

It is critical that Pobal is learning. Mistakes can be made. Things happen; people do things wrong. However, the question is how often that happened and what has been learned from it. One specific case has been highlighted, with €400,000 at issue. Could the overall figure be €1 million? I am just picking an arbitrary figure.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

It may be important to point out that the management carries out financial controls in every case. If we refer an individual case to An Garda, it is because there is something completely outside of our control that we-----

Comment on this

I understand all that but the details are important at this point, if only by way of reassurance. The witnesses cannot enlighten us any further at this point.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

We cannot say more about the number of cases that were reported to An Garda Síochána. However it was certainly fewer than five. We can clarify that before we finish today. Financial verification visits were completed. In 2018, some 157 visits were completed in respect of 211 grants, in addition to the 17 audits.

Comment on this

I read all that. We have only a few minutes, so committee members have to read the material and ask our few questions. I am unhappy that the witnesses are not able to elaborate on that paragraph at this point. I ask them to come back and elaborate on the financial irregularities, with a full profile of the amount outstanding, the ages of those involved and what Pobal has learned. Are there other similar cases? These questions should be answered today.

I have a question regarding agency staff. This has come to my attention, not with regard to Pobal but with lots of organisations. Does Pobal employ staff through agencies?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Does the Deputy mean recruitment agencies?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We employ a very small number of staff - fewer than three - in this way.

Comment on this

Is the agency paid a fee for placing those employees with Pobal?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes. We have also outsourced part of the national childcare scheme, namely the parent call centre, to an agency called Abtran as part of a contract.

Comment on this

Can the witnesses give us details of that?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We can.

Comment on this

Just three staff members are employed through agencies.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes.

Comment on this

Is that all? Why did Pobal have to go through an agency for those staff members but not for the rest?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

They are typically IT staff. We use a recruitment agency to assist us in recruiting particular grades of staff that are very hard to recruit in the normal workforce.

Comment on this

Did Pobal go through a procurement process before contracting the recruitment agency?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I have two final points. I have tabled several parliamentary questions about a report on Pobal's charitable status. The Department may be able to enlighten me. A report was carried out and never published.

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

I am terribly sorry but I am unaware of that. I will certainly come back to the Deputy on that.

Comment on this

I am being vague about it because I did not bring the details with me. However, I have tabled several parliamentary questions.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

The report is available on Pobal's website.

Comment on this

That is great. My final point concerns the bike to work scheme. How many people avail of that? I refer to page 113, which addresses payroll deductions, the Revenue Commissioners and the bike to work scheme. I am interested to know how many people are using it.

Comment on this

I would like the note we receive after the recess outlining the total value of the irregularities to include the total number of organisations involved. Could we have their geographical locations? Are they predominantly located in a particular part of the country? I would also like to know how many of the 157 visits Ms Shakespeare mentioned found non-compliance. Is it always community crèches that have overclaimed or was there an equal number of cases in the private sector? It would be interesting if these cases were predominantly community crèches. The rules seem to be clear for one group and not for another. That is what I am getting at.

Comment on this

I wish to ask about the call centre. I am aware of that call centre because there are several entities whose calls go through it.

What work is done by the call centres?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

They handle queries and calls relating to the implementation of the national childcare scheme to assist parents in making an application online for their subsidy for their child or children, as the case might be.

Comment on this

Is it the financial side?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It is a helpline. So it holds the hands, in some circumstances, of parents who wish to make an application and need some of that support.

Comment on this

Does Pobal have them on contract?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes.

Comment on this

What is the duration of the contract?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Three plus two in the context of procurement, having procured for it.

Comment on this

Is there a particular element of training?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes. There is training to handle the calls, handle complaints and there is also a complaints and appeals process that will be managed as part of that.

Comment on this

Do they manage the appeals process or does Pobal do that?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We manage the appeals process but the appeals will be heard by external independent individuals and we have gone through a recruitment process for that.

Comment on this

Are they part of Pobal's staff?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

The appeals officers, as I understand it, will be on a fee-for-service basis so as and when required.

Comment on this

The second preschool year was quickly announced and there was a scaling up issue. Does that kind of a decision present Pobal with extra difficulties in terms of Pobal scaling up along with an announcement being made?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Pobal makes every effort to be the servant of Government in that regard. When a policy decision is made we do our utmost to deliver on it within the shortest timeline possible. I am not going to say that there are not challenges with that but we certainly work with the funding Department to make sure that we are in a position to deliver, as and when required.

Comment on this

Is Pobal likely to be asked in advance? Recently we had this with an organisation that delivers a service or oversight. Essentially, there were teething problems because inadequate consideration was given to what would be required to deliver a service within a defined period. Does engagement take place with Pobal?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

There absolutely is engagement, Deputy. As part of the performance delivery agreement and the agreement of the programme of work, for example, with the Department of Children and Youth Affairs, they are very clear with us what their expectation of us will be in 2020. Equally, with our lead Department, the Department of Rural and Community Development, we have an agreed signed programme of work for 2020 relating to the deliverables and what they expect us to deliver for it. That is how we manage our work as best we can. We absolutely aim to be as responsive and agile to Government demand as required.

Comment on this

Pobal has 442 employees. What is the gender breakdown approximately?

Comment on this

I am asking the Deputy's questions now.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I have the information to hand in my pack. The gender split is 357 women and 129 men as of 30 September.

Comment on this

We are finally getting it right.

Comment on this

But we have too few captains.

Comment on this

I ask the same question in respect of senior management posts. Pobal has salary scales of over €80,000, €90,000 or €100,000. What is the gender balance of the top eight or ten senior management posts for whichever figure?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

There are 11 members of the senior management team, the executive management team, of whom four are women.

Comment on this

So the majority are in the direct opposite direction when it comes to senior management.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

But the chief executive is a woman, Chairman.

Comment on this

Good. We know that is worth three men on any day. Of the 11 members, are they employees and not board members or anything else?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

No, they are employees.

Comment on this

I heard the ad that started on the radio today. It affects Pobal as a witness has said that Pobal processes the payrolls for Tús, the rural social schemes, etc. We all know that there will be no P60s at the end of year. People on Tús or community employment schemes would not have access to computers on the job. How will they get their details? How does Pobal plan to help them get their payroll year-end information?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I have to ask the chief financial officer about that question. He is in a position to answer that.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

I am not. Actually, it is a good question and I do not have an answer but I would agree to check for the Chairman.

Comment on this

I worry about this. We had Revenue here last week.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

Yes.

Comment on this

We all know that the crunch is going to come when people will look for P60s come January or February.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

Yes.

Comment on this

We know the P60s will no longer be available and 1 million letters will be issued to every employee and pensioner.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

Yes.

Comment on this

I have heard the first ads. The Revenue ad advises people to look up myAccount and they will get their details.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

Yes.

Comment on this

On the group that Pobal employs - the Tús workers and rural employment scheme employees - the one thing I am sure about is that they do not have access to computers on the job. What arrangements will Pobal put in place to ensure that the employees it pays can access their year-end summary payroll information?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We have been implementing e-slips with the implementing bodies for the period 2018. My understanding is that 86% of them have been using e-slips so the digital slips.

Comment on this

Is that option available on people's phones or laptops?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Absolutely. The digital age, as the Chairman has said.

Comment on this

So 14% of the employees have not bothered logging on yet. Is that right?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

That is as of 2018. What the picture is absolutely for 2019, I am not 100% clear. Sorry, it is 68% and not 86%. I gave the wrong figure.

Comment on this

Are one third of the employees freewheeling?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

In 2018, there were two thirds that were accessing e-slips.

Comment on this

I ask the CEO to send us an up-to-date note.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I mean in due course when the CEO replies to the other requests.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes. Thank you, Chairman.

Comment on this

I know there will be problems in the new year for so many people. Many of the people in that category of employees are not office based. The Tús and rural employment scheme employees are probably the least able to access a computer facility in the course of their work so I ask employers to help.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Sure, yes.

Comment on this

The CEO understands my request.

I wish to refer to the legacy capital programmes that are mentioned on page 20 of the briefing note that Pobal sent to us. It states:

Pobal continues to manage contractual commitments under the following programmes:

Early Years Capital from 2012;

National Childcare Investment Programme 2006 to 2011; and

Equality Opportunities Childcare Programme 2000 to 2006.

Some of those schemes have been completely dormant for over a decade. Please send us a note on what Pobal must do with them. Please outline what contractual commitments are still in place in respect of these schemes that have finished 13 years ago.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Around the legacy capital?

Comment on this

Yes. Does anyone know? Pobal must know approximately. The CEO is only a few weeks in the job and I do not expect her to know all of the answers. Does some of the CEO's colleagues know?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

Is that the type of work, Deputy, that we are still involved in?

Comment on this

I have read Pobal's note on page 20. What does it mean?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

If I might give an example, we talked about west Clare earlier and the fact that we had to keep those centres open. One of the tools that we had there was the continued management of the leans that would have been place around some of the early years capital, grants that had been made to fund some of those centres. There is that. There are elements of ongoing work of that nature. We will come back with a note.

Comment on this

Send us back a note on each one of the three that have been mentioned. When I see contractual commitments being referred to in respect of schemes that closed over a decade ago I just want to know what it is about-----

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes.

Comment on this

-----and the financial commitment. If there is a contractual commitment I need to know what that is about but I need a price tag at the end of each of them. I would expect that it is small but I do not know and that is why I am asking.

Do county childcare committees still exist? Does Pobal deal with them?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

They do and there are 30 of them.

Comment on this

I did not have time to read everything. Reference to the committees did not jump out at me in some of the documents but I am sure they are mentioned somewhere in the 150 pages. What is the role of the childcare committees vis-à-vis Pobal? Please tell me what they do that Pobal cannot or vice versa. What is their role?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We fund the community childcare committees on behalf of the Department of Children and Youth Affairs. There are 30 county childcare committees nationally. They will form part of the major operational review referenced by the Department of Children and Youth Affairs.

Comment on this

Pobal deals directly with the providers so please explain their role.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

While we deal directly with the providers, there is a series of supports that are much better dealt with locally. We contract with the county childcare committees and agree a work plan with them. The idea is that they are locally-based groups that are immediately available to childcare centres. In terms of the roll-out of the national childcare scheme, for example, we trained all of the county childcare committees who in turn train all of the local providers. The idea is that if a local provider needs to pick up the phone about an issue, the county childcare committee should be the first point of contact. Issues get escalated to us if they are of a more difficult nature.

Comment on this

Pobal funds them but it sounds as if they are part of the organisation.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

They are agents of the Department of Children and Youth Affairs on the ground, in reality.

Comment on this

Pobal funds them completely. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

We contract them.

Comment on this

Do they have any other sources of funding?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

As far as I know, all of their funding comes from the Department of Children and Youth Affairs.

Comment on this

I ask the witnesses to send us a detailed note and breakdown on these committees. I am sure some of them are quite big while others are quite small. People talk about all of the direct engagement they have with Pobal and I was just wondering where the county childcare committees fit into the picture. I ask for a detailed note on that.

In the context of the ECCE scheme, does Pobal have a role to play with regard to homeless children? How do they get their entitlements under the scheme? Homelessness must pose a particular difficulty.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

The role that we play in supporting homeless children is in the context of their registration in an early childhood learning and care facility.

Comment on this

Obviously registration must be a difficulty if children are moving from hotel to hotel and from one area to another. That must be an issue on somebody's desk.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

It is an issue and there was a particular sub-programme of the main programme-----

Comment on this

I do not see it referred to anywhere which is why I am asking.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

It is not identified as a programme for us but there is a sub-programme specifically aimed at funding for that group of children.

Comment on this

I ask that Pobal sends us a note on that.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It is the community childcare programme for refugees and children who are in transitional arrangements.

Comment on this

What does transitional mean? Does transitional refer to their accommodation?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It means they are homeless or living in temporary accommodation. There is a particular fund there.

Comment on this

To clarify, Pobal is going to send us a note on both groups.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes, absolutely.

Comment on this

We want a note on people seeking international protection and people who are homeless at the moment. We want to know how they access services. People who are moving from one hotel to another must be very vulnerable.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

If I recollect correctly, there were 750 children who received funded services under those two programmes.

Comment on this

That is good to hear. Ms Shakespeare should say that out loud. It is good to hear that they are accessing services because people would be worried that they are not. That really is good to hear.

I will turn now to page 90 of the accounts. We are dealing here with non-compliance with procurement rules, an issue with which this committee deals all of the time. Reference is made to a sum of €693,000 for software development, €350,000 for ICT business analysis and €105,000 for project management. We want a detailed note on all of those. The headings are included in the accounts but we want detailed information on each of these items. We want to know how the expenditure arose, why it arose, whether the contracts have ceased and where we are in 2019 in relation to same. The Committee of Public Accounts has been addressing similar issues with every organisation that has come before it in the last six months. We want a detailed note.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes and as I said in my briefing note, we have a full corrective action plan in place as well as a compliance improvement plan and revision to documents.

Comment on this

Yes, Ms Shakespeare said that earlier but we want to get a more detailed note. I am sure she can understand why.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Absolutely, yes.

Comment on this

Does Pobal have a suggestion box for employees or anything like that?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes, we do.

Comment on this

Can employees get a financial reward if they make suggestions? I am thinking, for example, of people recommending family or friends for employment. Is there any incentive scheme in place that rewards employees?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We have a suggestion box for all employees so that we can hear about how to improve our services and about their experience of working with us. We recently brought to our partnership committee, which is our employee engagement committee, a proposal to incentivise employees below a particular grade to come forward with candidate suggestions. This would be a cost-reduction measure in the context of recruitment agency fees. Obviously the normal rules would apply and the individuals in question would have to go through a thorough and robust recruitment process. The candidates would not have an edge as such and that is made extremely clear to everyone. A small token is given to the individual in the context of incentivising-----

Comment on this

A small token is given to the person who nominates the candidate. How does that work? If someone nominates a friend for a job, how does it work? To whom does the person make the suggestion?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

The suggestion is made to the human resources department.

Comment on this

Would the human resources department then send out an application to the person nominated?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

The person would be invited to submit a curriculum vitae. He or she may or may not make the shortlist.

Comment on this

What does the small token amount to?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I reviewed the policy a few months ago and-----

Comment on this

Is it €10, €100 or €1,000?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It is €1,000.

Comment on this

Wow. That is not too small.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

That is only in proposal at this point in time.

Comment on this

What is that subject to?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It is subject to tax-----

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

It is subject to tax and to performance. It is paid in two tranches. A sum of €500 is paid on recruitment and after the probation period, the other €500 is paid.

Comment on this

Is that paid by way of a voucher or is it paid in cash?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

It is paid in cash, with the tax deducted.

Comment on this

With the tax deducted-----

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

Yes, it is paid in cash, after tax. The sum of €1,000 is the gross amount.

Comment on this

Has the Comptroller and Auditor General come across similar schemes elsewhere? Would this be normal?

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

It is unusual.

Comment on this

Right. I ask Pobal to send us a note on this policy.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

At this stage, it is still a proposal that we have brought to our partnership committee-----

Comment on this

It probably exists at the moment in some form and Pobal is now formalising it. My interpretation of what I am hearing is I suspect there is a scheme in place that is now being formalised.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It is not in existence at this point in time. It has not been acted upon. It is a proposal that we have reviewed with our partnership committee.

Comment on this

Who came up with the proposal? I have not heard much about this kind of scheme in the public service. I ask the witnesses to send us a note on same and we will chew on it.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It is with a view to offsetting recruitment costs.

Comment on this

When there are vacancies at Pobal, are the recruitment advertisements done through an agency? How does Pobal conduct its normal recruitment process? Is it done internally?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We use Irishjobs.ie, publicjobs.ie and sometimes we use a recruitment agency if there is a particular focus on the type of individual that we are trying to attract.

Comment on this

I ask for a note on how many positions were filled using an agency and the costs involved in comparison with posts filled through the PAS. I ask for a breakdown for staff hired in the last year. I would like to know the mechanism through which they came into Pobal.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Okay.

Comment on this

That can be sent on to the committee because I would not expect the witnesses to have that information to hand now. Obviously we are also interested in the rates paid to recruitment agencies. I understand that the aforementioned scheme could be a lot cheaper than paying an agency a percentage of an annual salary. I understand that but we need to know what is going on.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

May I correct a figure that I gave to Deputy Connolly earlier?

Comment on this

Of course.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We have seven agency staff, a reduction of three from last year. I am sorry but I had the wrong figure in my head. Seven agency staff are in use at the moment.

Comment on this

That is not a lot out of 400.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

No, it is not.

Comment on this

I have a question on the seniors alert scheme, about which I am constantly being asked in my own constituency. Pobal refers to the scheme in page 10 of its briefing note. It says that the growth of the seniors alert scheme was very positive, with over 19,000 applications approved in 2018, representing an increase of 163% on 2016 levels and 52% on 2017 levels. It is mentioned again on page 18. Pobal points out that funding is available towards the purchase of equipment including personal alarms and pendants. Is that a wrist alarm and a pendant that hangs from the neck? In the first year the cost of monitoring by a registered monitoring provider is also provided free of charge under the scheme from 1 November, when a range of changes were made to the scheme. I read somewhere else in the briefing note that 10,000 people joined the scheme last year. Who does Pobal deal with in the provision of this service? What companies are involved in the scheme?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We procure services from external assistive technology agencies. We have recently reviewed the scheme with the Department of Rural and Community Development. It is a very important scheme for the Government of Ireland. It ensures that elderly people, particularly in rural communities, can stay at home safely with some assurance that if something happens they can press the button on their alarm or pendant and summon help. Somebody will contact them and will know that there is an issue.

Comment on this

Is that done by mobile phone or landline? How does it work?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It is done by both.

Comment on this

How many companies provide it? Is it done on a regional basis?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

There are four suppliers at this point. We are re-procuring for that in 2020 by agreement with the Department until 2022, with an option of extending it by a further two years.

Comment on this

I ask Pobal to send us a note on the current arrangements. Next year is next year. I will not ask our guests to disclose the names.

Comment on this

We will have a library of notes.

Comment on this

Yes, but it is good information to have. It will add to the public knowledge. We will put it all in the public domain. As we all know, it is amazing how many people watch our meetings. Before the day is out, I will receive emails and phone calls saying we should have asked about something else. Many people, especially senior and retired people, watch our meetings.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Absolutely.

Comment on this

Pobal might send us a note on the companies. It does not need to breach confidentiality but it might give an indication of how much the scheme costs for each company, who the suppliers are and whether there are guarantees.

Comment on this

Ms Shakespeare spoke about the gender breakdown and the fact that there are additional staff to cover maternity leave. What is the incidence of maternity leave? I am pleased to hear it has been provided for, given that it is a fact of life. If women are to be in the workforce, they have to be provided for. I have no difficulty with maternity leave being provided for. I recently met a group from the HSE and was told that maternity leave staff accounted for approximately one third of its workforce. Is the breakdown for Pobal similar? It might relate to the age profile of the HSE's staff.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Does the Deputy refer to the average number of women on maternity leave?

Comment on this

What proportion of staff are for cover?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I have given the committee the numbers of women versus men. I will need to confirm the figure for how many women go on maternity leave.

Comment on this

If Ms Shakespeare could outline how Pobal plans for that cover, it would be useful. It would be useful to see how one organisation compares with another.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

For example, we referenced our access and inclusion model, Better Start, which is primarily female in its gender base. A male member of that team is unusual. We build in a percentage of the staff turnover to support and ensure that the service continues. The maternity leave staff might change location based on the particular profile of individuals on maternity leave at any one time.

As for other employees, with respect, it becomes obvious when an individual has impending maternity leave. We work to ensure there is a service continuity plan with a replacement. As of September 2019, we had 39 staff on maternity leave. I would expect that a high number of those individuals were part of our access and inclusion model, Better Start, based on the profile of the employees, their gender and their relative age profile.

Comment on this

We will ask Pobal to send a note. When Ms Shakespeare made the point earlier, I was struck by the beautiful way she put it as taking account of employees' gender. I thought that if only the HSE had a similar policy, life would be wonderful. The HSE comes immediately to mind for many reasons, but other organisations, too, could benefit from the template that Pobal has drawn up. I acknowledge that it had to build it into its planning, but it could be useful for other organisations to learn from.

Finally, how many protected disclosures has Pobal received and what is their status? Have they been resolved or are they under external review?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We had no protected disclosures in 2018?

Comment on this

Is any ongoing?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

No.

Comment on this

Perhaps that is because of the gender balance.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Pobal is a very happy place at which to work.

Comment on this

It sounds like it. I thank our guests from Pobal and wish them every success in the important role they have. I also thank our guests from the Departments of Rural and Community Development and Children and Youth Affairs and the Comptroller and Auditor General for attending, and for the information they provided and will provide to the committee. The committee will sit again in mid-January and we would like to have all the answers on our desk when we return. It is a reasonable period to allow for all the answers to be provided.

The committee will now suspend until 3 o'clock, when we will meet Mr. Finnegan and representatives of the Office of Public Works regarding the new print facility in Kildare House.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I thank the Chairman and, on behalf of everybody at Pobal, wish all the committee members a merry Christmas.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Shakespeare.

Comment on this