Purchase of Komori Printing Press and Related Matters: Houses of the Oireachtas Service and Office of Public Works
Contributions 402–604 of 604. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
The information we were aware of was that there was a delay in bringing the asset into use. We were aware of that. It was a charge in the 2018 account. We were aware that there was a problem. Our understanding of it was that it was a health and safety consideration in relation to the capacity of the floor to carry the machine. We were not at all aware of an issue with head height. When there was any reference to structural works we presumed it was strengthening a floor. We would have received the financial statements at the end of March. I reviewed them in May and that was the first I heard that there was an issue around a recognition of a capital asset. The team had already been talking to the Houses of the Oireachtas about whether or not it was appropriate to recognise capital assets. We felt it was not and we said that assets that are not even on the premises cannot be recognised as assets on the balance sheet. We proposed a prepayments note to deal with a number of classes of assets. We were aware that there might be additional costs associated with the installation of the machine as a result of the floor strengthening, as we understood it, but it was inevitably going to be a 2019 expense. We were not thinking of it being a 2020 expense. Therefore, my feeling was that we will look back at this when we come to do the 2019 account and if at that stage there was something that was worth reporting, we would consider making a reference in the audit certificate. In fact, our first preference and expectation in a situation like this where it is a relatively small-scale expenditure but with a weakness in controls and so on would be that sufficient detail would be given in a note to the accounts to explain what had happened. Obviously, however, it was all overtaken by events. Without prejudice to whether I will report anything or encourage any further reporting in relation to the matter for 2019, it has obviously been very well ventilated here, which may mean that I do not need to draw further attention to it in the 2019 accounts or the 2020 accounts when they come to be presented.
Comment on this
As I said earlier, I probably know 100 times more about this than I did at the start. My knowledge of what was going on was limited but one of the things that struck me when reading through the documents was the way this evolved over time. I would defer to my colleagues from the OPW but one of the initial things that took up so much time was the whole load-bearing capacity of the floor. That was a very big issue in February, March and April of this year. When one looks at the history of the project, from the time the OPW said there was actually more to this than we had thought to the time the works commenced, that was over the course of a year. A lot of works took place over that year. From looking at the documents, we can see that the floor was a big issue. The architect brought in Ove Arup, the structural engineers, to look at the floor. Now that the project is over, there appear to be clear dimensions to the project. During the course of the year, however, it was actually quite unclear at stages as to what was going on. That is just the way it was. That is just how the project unfolded, unfortunately.
Comment on this
Mr. Cahill from the OPW might be able to answer my next question given that he referred to the load-bearing strength of the floor.
What weight is this machine? The OPW must have had an idea, because that is what its calculations are based on.
Comment on this
We got that information. That was part of the process, though we were not involved in the procurement. Initially we were looking at the weight that would be coming down a ramp into what was formerly a car park. We then got drawings from Komori that showed the weight to be 16,800 kg.
Comment on this
Approximately 860 kg was going down through each levelling foot that this was sitting on onto the floor. The car park originally had a slope, but work was carried out in 2004 to level it, and the question was whether that was sufficient to take the load. That was the initial query our engineers had. They were looking at the loads coming in, the size of the boxes, whether they could come down the ramp and how to manage them and get them in. The next issue was whether there would be enough capacity on the floor when the machine was operating. It turned out we did and the load could be spread out, but we had to do that exercise to inform the amount of work that was needed.
Comment on this
I refer to the Comptroller and Auditor General's previous comments. As a summary of what he said, would it be fair to say that Mr. Finnegan made no deliberate attempt to keep information from this committee in July of this year?
Comment on this
I have no sense that there was any intention in that respect.
Comment on this
Is it also fair to say that all the information contained both reports was within the accounts, just not presented in the format some members would have liked?
Comment on this
No. There was no indication that there would be building works even in the order of €200,000. That is not included in the financial statements.
Comment on this
That was not included, but the component parts and the price of the machine itself were.
Comment on this
Yes. The fact that a significant investment was being made in printing equipment-----
Comment on this
Yes. We bought a big object that was very heavy.
I hope Mr. Finnegan can answer my next question. The printer comes with a two-year free service period from, I assume, the time it is commissioned. Does that period of free maintenance kick in when it is turned on and starts printing, or is it being used while the machine has been in storage?
Comment on this
I think that is the case, but I will confirm that for the Deputy.
Comment on this
It is important for this committee to find out when that period kicks in.
It is clear based on the information provided both today and previously that a new machine was needed. While the Heidelberg printing press could have gone on for another while, it is clear that the Houses would have needed a new machine at some point in the near future to fulfil our needs. I bring this up in respect of health matters all the time, but was leasing ever considered? I know from my own operations and the large Mitsubishi printing units I use for printing photos quickly and so on, that normal business practice is not to pay the costs up front, but to sign a lease agreement with maintenance included. That way, if the machine blows up, the company will provide another one. Was that option ever considered as part of the business case, or was it a clear-cut decision to buy a new machine?
Comment on this
I think it was the latter. I do not think the leasing option was ever considered. That is another lesson. There are so many lessons from all of this for everyone involved. The other options apart from purchasing should be explored in business cases, and the calculations should be done to see what the bottom line would look like. At the end of the day, one is looking is to get the very best value one can for the taxpayer.
Comment on this
It is normal practice to lease items these days.
Comment on this
If this were a private company's books, it would not want this large figure coming out. Perhaps it is simpler when dealing with other people's money, those other people being the taxpayers. We have to be conscious of that in our decision-making in the future.
Mr. Finnegan mentioned that Komori ticked two boxes when it came to the height. Is there a legal basis for getting money back, given that Komori ticked those boxes? If height was not the company's issue, why did it send someone to the site? What is the point of a site visit? Is it about making friends, or looking at the dimensions of the room? I am not having a go at Mr. Finnegan. I am just wondering why anyone came out if he or she was not going to measure anything.
Comment on this
I get the sense that someone visited the site to have a look at the environment in which the printer would be installed. Based on everything I have heard over the past number of weeks, printers such as this have been installed in private sector organisations at and below that height-----
Comment on this
-----but that is not good enough for the public sector. We have to comply with health and safety-----
Comment on this
I want to come back to that. Mr. Finnegan said that when this issue of liability was brought up, Komori said it had installed machines in rooms of 2.85 m or below.
Comment on this
Can Mr. Finnegan elaborate on that because it is probably important? Komori said it could fit it into another room that was 2.85 m in height. I assume we are all operating off the same measuring tape. What is Mr. Finnegan's understanding of the distinct difference in the requirements between me buying such a machine for a private business and public sector workers doing the same?
Comment on this
My understanding is that health and safety is a big issue for public sector employees.
Comment on this
From what I have heard, the organisations that installed machines at or below 2.85 m did not have the same concerns for health and safety as we have. That is my understanding.
Comment on this
Do we have a list of what those concerns were? Do they relate to people banging off a hot grid, or steam coming out of the machine?
Comment on this
They are to do with head height when people are working.
Comment on this
Is there a concern that people might bang their heads when climbing up ladders to put stuff into the printer?
Comment on this
No. There are three levels on the machine. The top level requires a clearance of 2.1 m, so it is to do with the head height above the roof. There are all sorts of manual handling issues and so on relating to working on the top level. People would have to be bend if they could not clear the ceiling.
Comment on this
Do people use a cherry-picker style seat to work on the top tier.?
Comment on this
They stand on a platform. A diagram of the machine is on the screen. It is a bit difficult to read, but to the right of the screen, we have circled "1154 cross walkway" in red. That is the top height at which an operator can stand. A clearance of 2.1 m has to be left between that and the ceiling.
Comment on this
Everywhere, but the public sector takes it more seriously. Is that it?
Comment on this
The public sector has to comply with the rules 100%.
Comment on this
It is the right thing to do and we would always do that, no matter the issue. That is why we are carrying out the other works, because-----
Comment on this
Is this an Irish thing or an international problem? Does Komori encounter the same issue when supplying elsewhere?
Comment on this
It is an EU requirement, yes, but adherence to that requirement is another thing. Not everybody will adhere to that requirement. That seems to be the case. We, however, do.
Comment on this
It is not up to Komori, the company which makes the machines, to adhere to the requirement.
Comment on this
It is up to the employer. To summarise, in order to comply with health and safety rules, there was no choice but to increase the head height so that a person could stand or sit on the platform to operate the machine and do his or her job.
Comment on this
People would otherwise have to crawl around.
Comment on this
There was no choice unless people were to crawl around, yes.
Comment on this
May I add to that? The Deputy is talking about the 2.85 m. That became clear when Komori sent us its installation drawings. Komori was carrying out the installation. It sent a drawing showing areas it wanted removed so that the large pallets of machinery could be brought in. It also gave us a drawing indicating ceiling tiles to be removed. It believed there was----
Comment on this
-----350 mm of space above the tiles, but there is actually structure.
Comment on this
Who told Komori there was 35 cm, or 350 mm as Mr. Cahill would say, of space above the false ceiling?
Comment on this
To clarify, Komori asked a question about it and it was told that there was 35 cm of space.
Comment on this
Someone probably just popped a tile and put a measuring tape up there.
Comment on this
To be honest, I believe that is what happened. That is the reality. Someone had a measuring stick and-----
Comment on this
The plant, air conditioning and ventilation are held within the space above the false ceiling.
Comment on this
No, it is a structural deck which allows people to service all the plant. All of the air conditioning and so on is actually fixed to the structure of the building. This deck is a floor to allow people access. As we said before, there is an awful lot of plant up there. The deck allows safe service access to that plant.
Comment on this
To answer the Deputy's question, there is a void there but the void has structure-----
Comment on this
The void has structure within it. It is not just space.
Comment on this
This is on the basement floor. There is nothing beneath it. There is clearance of somewhat more than 2 m and then there is a false ceiling composed of foam tiles, above which there is 35 cm of space. What kind of plant fits into that 35 cm?
Comment on this
All the structure is there - steel and timber.
Comment on this
It is the structure that holds up the next floor.
Comment on this
Is the deck for servicing the air conditioning?
Comment on this
Where is the big air conditioning unit, the spinny thing, located?
Comment on this
It is located above the deck. There is about 2 m head height above the deck. That is what has been lifted up in the drawing. One can see all the pieces lifted up, which provides the head height.
Comment on this
Is that not for the whole building?
Comment on this
It allows access. It has to take the load of anyone standing upon it. The service load is 1.5 kN.
Comment on this
Is the stuff in this area is to service the area immediate underneath it or other parts of the building?
Comment on this
The ceiling has been lifted only in the area of the machine.
Comment on this
Yes. It has been pushed up in the area of the machine.
Comment on this
Perhaps I am not being clear. What is in that area? Is it just tubing and wires or is it the actual air conditioning unit?
Comment on this
Does Mr. O'Sullivan mean a flat floor or a storey?
Comment on this
There is a space there in which a lot of equipment, including ventilation equipment, is located.
Comment on this
There is air conditioning equipment on the floor of the print room itself but there is other equipment upstairs. There is a lot of plant for this.
Comment on this
I can understand that but I do not see why it is required that it be above the print room. There is no reason to have it above it.
Comment on this
That space was there because the area had originally been a double-height car park. It was opportune to put that equipment up there. Otherwise valuable space elsewhere would have to be taken up.
Comment on this
Was lowering the floor ever considered?
Comment on this
Was it considered? If something was being done to increase the load-bearing-----
Comment on this
The space required is 400 mm to 500 mm. It would be very hard to find that in-----
Comment on this
She is asking about taking down the floor.
Comment on this
Could the floor have been brought down as opposed to going up? Could more ramps have been included?
Comment on this
I would hope that if they are being put in, they are not being taken out. I will send the witnesses a note afterwards. I just wonder why the plant had to be directly above it. The first lesson learned is that one should have a specialist architect involved. I suggest that having someone who can measure would help. Is it the case that, despite all these teams and project managers, nobody was 100% in charge? Was that the problem? No one was responsible for the ultimate decision, checking that boxes were ticked, and checking the height. Nobody said that this was very expensive, very big or very heavy and asked to make sure things were 100% right before it was bought. Is it fair to say that is a failing in the system?
Comment on this
I want to be really fair to the people who were in charge of the project because they are hard-working people who have done a lot for the organisation.
Comment on this
I do not believe anyone deliberately did this.
Comment on this
I understand that but they did not have the skill set for what they were trying to do. That is it. There is a difference between knowing a lot about printing and installing a printer. That is where the problem arose. Installing a printer can give rise to architectural, mechanical and electrical issues.
Comment on this
Earlier, someone mentioned that we did not need certain parts of the machine. I just want to clarify that. There is a printing press; the plates, which make the design; the folding machines; and the guillotines, which cut. Even divided up, each of these parts is needed.
Comment on this
Otherwise it would be like buying a car without bothering with a radio.
Comment on this
One would need that. With regard to the building works and the outsourcing, two round figures of €100,000 have been given. I am always suspicious of round figures like that.
Comment on this
May I explain the outsourced element? In order to be absolutely fair and as transparent as possible, I took the outsourcing costs for this year and last year. In the previous year there had been an outsourcing charge of €8,000. I took that year, 2017, as a normal year. I then added the outsourcing costs for 2018 and 2019, which came to €116,000, and I took €16,000 away, based on the outsourcing costs for 2017. I believed that to be a fair figure.
Comment on this
That is fine. Finally, there is precedent for this issue arising in respect of the previous machine. I, therefore, cannot understand this. Perhaps I am missing something. A great amount is involved. I am not arguing that. There is history in this regard as €1.14 million was spent on works in 2004 to allow for the delivery of four Heidelberg presses.
Comment on this
We had to fit out a new printing unit. That is why the money was spent.
Comment on this
Is it fair to say that, although the business case for a new printer could be made, with regard to the constraints of the layout of these Houses, the location and cost of installation should always be considered in future?
Comment on this
With regard to proportionality, looking back to 2004, it is not unusual for such a massive amount to be required to install a machine because it is difficult to locate items in these buildings.
Comment on this
They are difficult buildings to work with. We are doing our level best but what is required is new purpose-built accommodation for the Oireachtas. Now that we have completed the historic Leinster House project, that is something to which we will turn our attention in terms of planning and development.
Comment on this
Is Kildare House a listed building?
Comment on this
It is not, no. It is a 1960s office block.
Comment on this
It is a bit like broadband in houses. It is trying to fit modern technology into-----
Comment on this
And there is a cost associated and difficulties.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Finnegan for his time today.
Comment on this
I thank him for answering the questions so honestly. I wish him the best of luck with this.
Comment on this
I will not hold up the case on this. Mr. Finnegan has been asked every question possible and all of the questions I was going to ask but because it is so serious I want to add a few comments and questions. I will begin by saying I accept the business case. I am half a businessman myself and the Oireachtas did the right thing in purchasing the machine. There is no question about that. The public in general will accept the existing printers were old, they were reaching the age where they had to be decommissioned and the Oireachtas bought a new machine. Everyone accepts this and the reasons. Are there any recovery costs from the old machines? When the new machine is up and running will there be any moneys to be recovered from the old machines?
Comment on this
As part of the contract we traded in the old machines and received €40,000 as a trade in. The new machine was €848,000 excluding VAT and we got €40,000 for the old machines so we paid €808,000.
Comment on this
Was that for the two existing machines?
Comment on this
We traded in the two machines and my understanding is the value was €40,000 in total.
Comment on this
For some reason this case has caught the public imagination. I do not know why. It is probably because of the national children's hospital and broadband. There is a general feeling out there in the public. This is a general feeling I am getting as a politician, that politics, politicians, civil servants and public servants are playing with taxpayers' money and they do not take accountability. This is the general feeling out there. This is another comedy of errors that is happening, whether in Dublin or wherever, and people are very angry over it. They are angry because we have a housing crisis, a trolley crisis and a health crisis and they see what they feel is a waste of money. I hear it myself at meetings in my area. They see it as a waste of money with no accountability. I do not want anyone's head to roll but there must be lessons learned and there must be responsibility taken for it. Mr. Finnegan named out a litany of people and various bodies involved in this over the past two years but it happened again.
I know Mr. Finnegan said there should have been an architect giving advice and that it was a mistake by someone that an architect was not brought in at the beginning. An architect had to be brought in later. I have several questions I want to ask for the public. How much does Mr. Finnegan feel could have been saved if an architect had been involved at the beginning? We hear different figures. We have heard €1.169 million, €1.369 million, €2 million and now that the OPW is involved it has gone to €2.5 million. There were figures of €1.169 million and €1.369 million at the beginning and now it has gone to €2.5 million. This is what people see and they ask how someone can stand over this type of an increase with all of the different things that went wrong. Will Mr. Finnegan show where we could have saved that money that was spent because of the mistakes that were made?
Comment on this
Before I deal with that directly I will comment on Deputy Aylward's opening remarks. I understand the public anger over this. It is a matter of deep personal regret that it happened. We speak about accountability and as the head of this organisation I am here today to account and answer every question I can. I have tried to help in every way possible in terms of preparing reports and being transparent about the process but I genuinely understand public anger. I have heard it myself. It is an awful lot of money. There is a perception, and it is correct, that the project was not well managed and nobody can deny this.
In terms of what would have happened had this project run according to plan, let me make the assumption, if I may, that the Komori printing press is the correct machine. I have no evidence whatsoever that it is not so I will make this assumption. An architect would have been brought in on day one. The architect would have advised the project team that a machine of the type it was purchasing would require significant architectural works. The cost of those works would have been very similar to the costs that turned out. Ultimately, the big costs we would not have incurred were the level of outsourcing and the storage costs.
Comment on this
Could we get a report on those costs?
Comment on this
They are in the report, yes. They are the actual costs that we incurred where we should not have incurred them; €112,000 is an awful lot of money, it really is. I understand why people are very annoyed over it. I have worked through this myself over the past three weeks. I have been very annoyed over it myself. I have worked through all of this process. Ultimately, when we look at this in the round and go back to 2004 and see the costs incurred then and the costs incurred now, they are not dramatically out of line. The cost of the equipment, I think, came in at €1.8 million. If we take out the outsourcing and storage, the costs are around €1.7 million. For me, this is a 15 year investment. It is €1.7 million over 15 years. If we do the sums it is somewhere in the order of €100,000 per year for printing. That is probably a reasonable sum, at €2,000 per week, if we were to look at what the cost would be if we were to outsource. Let us suppose the Oireachtas did not do printing at all. One of the other things that has come out of this is that Members have legitimate printing needs in terms of communicating with their constituents. This is an essential and fundamental role of public representatives. It is something we try to support Members in doing. If Members were to communicate with their constituents via an outsource model the cost would be substantially more. In the same way as doing an analysis of leasing versus buying, if we do a further analysis of just outsourcing instead of doing something I suspect that would be the most expensive option of all.
Comment on this
That is acceptable. Some of my colleagues here today have made statements such as "shopping sprees", as if Mr. Finnegan is going off spreading the money. I do not accept that either. I do not want to be associated with stating Mr. Finnegan was on a shopping spree as if he is going out buying for Santy Claus. That is not a remark that I agree with. What we need to bring back into the whole system, including us as politicians, is that the public has confidence in us to handle public money and handle taxpayers' money right and spend it accordingly. Our job on the Committee of Public Accounts is to follow the money and make sure everyone is accountable for what money they spend and that it is not being wasted. This is the most important thing. This is why I agree with the Chairman that in his remarks today Mr. Finnegan came across badly.
Comment on this
He came across as though we did not ask the right questions the last day he came before us.
Comment on this
I certainly did not mean to come across that way and I apologise if it did.
Comment on this
We have an old saying down in my part of the country, "see no evil, hear no evil". Because we did not ask the right questions we did not get the right answers. I would not like that kind of thing.
We have the costs laid out now but there is still talk about storage and training. Mr. Finnegan said there will be training. I am sure there are health and safety issues and perhaps there will be union issues regarding extra pay or extra moneys for handling the machine. Are all the costs finished with or could there be more than the €2.5 million when all of this is seen through? The machine might not be up and running as soon as Mr. Finnegan thinks. There might be further storage costs. What are the storage costs since 2018?
Comment on this
The storage costs are gone. The machine is now installed. We were paying €2,000 per month but that ended once the machine was delivered and installed.
Comment on this
Yes. I suppose the big outstanding issue-----
Comment on this
How much does Mr. Finnegan think that training will cost?
Comment on this
The training is included in the price of the machine as part of the package.
Comment on this
Yes. The essential thing for us now is to get the machine up and running as quickly as we can.
We will work with staff in the print unit collaboratively to address the concerns around health and safety and to move forward with the implementation of this machine.
Comment on this
Could there be a problems down the line if the unions are demanding extra moneys for this?
Comment on this
There could, yes, to be honest; if people took that approach. I would hope that that would not happen. We have good relationships with people. At the end of the day these people are our employees, for whom we have concern and we would aim to work with them to ensure this machine is operational as soon as possible.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Finnegan for coming in here today. He had a tough engagement and this is the second time he has been in front of us now.
Comment on this
These things need to be clarified and the public need to be assured that we are doing the right thing.
Comment on this
Could I just say that there is no one sorrier than me that we are in this position here today?
Comment on this
It is right and proper that I come in and that hard questions are asked of me in the course of that. We have done our level best to try to get the bottom of what happened with this particular project. Serious mistakes were made. There is no denying that. As an organisation we have acknowledged that. As the Accounting Officer, I am quite properly and rightly being held to account for those. There are a lot of things that we would all do differently in respect of this matter. I assure the committee that I am absolutely determined that these lessons will be learned going forward and there will be no recurrence of this type of thing. It is my earnest desire to ensure that we can do that.
Comment on this
I accept all of that. I wish to make a number of closing remarks at this point, as we have had a very long engagement with two reports.
Mr. Finnegan's last comments to Deputy Aylward were very useful, in that if it had gone correctly at the beginning, and if Mr. Finnegan had brought the OPW in on day one, and if he had said this was the printer that we need-----
Comment on this
-----the OPW would have said it would cost a couple of hundred thousand euro to get the premises right. It would have stated that it might have to stress-test the floor or to move to a different place. Had the OPW come on board earlier, the costs that it did incur to have that work done, after it came onto the scene, would have arisen in any event .
Comment on this
The point I am making is that - I am not certain that people will see it this way - I want to be totally fair because Mr. Finnegan's honesty, candour and frankness is appreciated today-----
Comment on this
----- in this regard. There is no suggestion that Mr. Finnegan was trying to hold back information, as he had the information in his notes, but in case people got the impression that our committee was not doing its job-----
Comment on this
I certainly did not mean to convey that-----
Comment on this
In conversation with people, it is possible not to see it that way but possible for somebody else to see it another way. There is no question of that ever having been Mr. Finnegan's intention. What got people is that the equipment ultimately cost €1.369 million. Then, because work had to be done on the building after the machine had been purchased, it ended up costing €1.8 million or thereabouts.
Comment on this
Had it been said at the beginning of the process that we were going to spend €1.369 million on a machine, together with €400,000 or €500,000 on structural works to accommodate all this because it is going to be here for the next 12 to 15 years and that the overall budget was going to be in the order of €1.8 million, people would have accepted it. Where the Oireachtas was caught was that there was an earlier figure out there that we mentioned in the accounts, of €1.69 million. We find, however, six months later, that to complete the process, which was still evolving at a time of Mr. Finnegan's last appearance here, it ended up being closer to €2 million.
It was the way in which the information became known. Nobody doubts the value of the work that was done by OPW and the necessity of the national Parliament to have its own printing works and not to have to outsource it and to rely upon private sector printers somewhere out on the M50 to get material in and out to it. A Parliament has to have control over certain aspects of its own activities. That is why I would say, as Chairman, that it would be important to have these facilities in-house and that they be up to scratch. Because of our location here in Dublin 2, we are fairly restricted because of space, something we understand.
Comment on this
As Deputy Aylward has said and Mr. Finnegan has recognised this himself, people are able to understand-----
Comment on this
-----the buying of a printer and then discovering that it is too big to fit into the room after it has been paid for. If that had been addressed earlier, when the printer was being purchased, we could have waited six months because of the need to do some structural works, and things might have unfolded substantially differently. The cost might not have been significantly different, however, if we had known about the costs that would be involved in the structural work earlier in the play, rather than later. People will always understand when one is initiating any project that is going to cost €1 million and ends up costing more that if one had known at the outset that it would cost a larger figure, people would have been prepared for it and would have understood it. Nobody is suggesting there was waste of any money but it is the sequencing of the way the information came out.
I acknowledge, which I also said at our earlier meeting, that Mr. Finnegan went to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission in November 2017, which is over two years ago, and said that this was going to cost approximately €1.5 million. He had not all of the detail worked out at that point and could not have had-----
Comment on this
-----but he knew it was in that ballpark figure. When all is said and done, the current position is not that far from that ballpark figure. People may disagree with my summation of this but there is a lesson there to get the budget right at the beginning, get everything factored in, get the full cost out to the public and then the progress can be monitored, rather than having costs evolving as the project evolves.
Comment on this
I could not agree more with the Chairman's analysis. Had this project been done the way it should have been done, the cost would be similar but the perception would be completely different.
Comment on this
I do not think that anybody can doubt the sincerity and earnestness of Mr. Finnegan and I thoroughly accept his apology.
If we are trying to be helpful, I will suggest how we might get a few pounds back. I see Mr. Finnegan is grinning as to how a company would ever give money back, when the room was not measured correctly. On the maintenance agreement, however-----
Comment on this
That is the key and is the point where I would fight it. I would say, come here, lads, maintain this for an extra five years and we will not have Komori all over the social media; not that I would be threatening anybody. That is where I would go with this. The company is not going to write Mr. Finnegan a cheque but it might provide five years' maintenance.
Comment on this
I will go with him to the meeting.
Comment on this
I might call on the Deputy's negotiation skills.
Comment on this
One further point that a Deputy mentioned in passing is that if the printer is of such high quality and if there happens to be excess capacity at different stages, other work in this building complex might not have to be outsourced if some of it can be done here. There may be a facility to get some value out of this printer during the quieter periods when the Dáil is in recess and there is not the same printing demand. Neighbouring public bodies in the public service, or other aspects or activities of the Dáil might be directed in that way. I will throw that suggestion out there.
At this stage, I thank all the witnesses from the Houses of the Oireachtas for coming in. Coincidentally, I believe Mr Finnegan was present at the last meeting before the summer recess and he is here now at the last meeting before the Christmas break. I also want to thank our colleagues in the OPW, as well as the Comptroller and Auditor General and his staff. Mr. Finnegan will be pleased to know we have finished our public discussion on this except for whatever information we have requested that might be worked through to us in the weeks ahead. In fairness to the public who want this thing explained, we have done our best to clarify all the issues out there and I believe we have done a good job for the public service-----
Comment on this
I believe the committee has, in fairness.
Comment on this
-----the Committee of Public Accounts and the Oireachtas. I am aware that some people still will not be satisfied but from all sides, both members of this committee and Mr. Finnegan's side, a good, honest, decent attempt has been made to deal to the best of our ability with the issues that arose here.
Comment on this
To close, I thank members of the committee for their courtesy here today. This was a very necessary meeting and I hope I have explained things fully and have provided all the necessary information.
If issues that have not arisen at this meeting come to my attention subsequently, I will write to the committee.