Purchase of Komori Printing Press and Related Matters: Houses of the Oireachtas Service and Office of Public Works
Contributions 197–401 of 604. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
My understanding is that where required, it is continuing. The way the outsourcing works is that it is not something that we like to do. We like to do as much work as we can in-house but where we do not have the capacity to meet the demand, we have to outsource and we have a contract in place for that.
Comment on this
That is drawn down as it is needed.
Comment on this
There are two separate outsourcing costs. One is outsourcing because of the debacle over the printing machine, or rather the mistakes over it.
Comment on this
The second outsourcing is on a needs basis, in addition to the printer.
Comment on this
There were two printers there, is that right?
Comment on this
Yes. There were two Heidelberg printers. In 2004, to meet the printing needs, we purchased four Heidelberg printers. There were two two-colour printers and four four-colour printers. We replaced the two four-colour printers with one printer. We have literally gone from a four-printer operation to a one-printer printing press operation.
Comment on this
At the moment, that is not operational so Mr. Finnegan is still reliant on the other four.
Comment on this
We are reliant on one of the Heidelbergs because in July 2018, the second Heidelberg was traded in. The expectation at that stage was that it would be possible to install the new Komori printing, so space was made-----
Comment on this
How many machines are operational at the moment, and it is not the new one?
Comment on this
One printing press is operating at the moment.
Comment on this
That is the Heidelberg.
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan made a point in his report that the Heidelberg was more expensive at the time. Is that one Heidelberg or four Heidelbergs?
Comment on this
No. It was the suite of Heidelbergs that we needed. I used the plural in the report, printing presses, because we needed all of those presses to work together to deliver on the printing for us.
Comment on this
Were all of those bought in the same year?
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan is telling me that the overall cost of that, with all the accessories necessary to run it, was more expensive than the Komori, with all its accessories.
Comment on this
What was the overall price in 2004?
Comment on this
The cost of the Heidelbergs that were purchased in 2004 was €1.24 million. The cost of the construction works that were done at that time were approximately €1.14 million.
Comment on this
Yes. Both are VAT inclusive. That is €2.38 million, so the cost was roughly €2.4 million in 2004.
Comment on this
For four machines.
Comment on this
For the four printing presses and the works that were required to accommodate those, yes.
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan made the point that they needed maintenance and repairs, and he gave a figure for those when the spoke earlier of €45,000 in maintenance per year-----
Comment on this
That was roughly the maintenance contract, yes.
Comment on this
-----and €20,000 in spare parts.
Comment on this
What was the lifespan of those machines?
Comment on this
The Heidelbergs were bought in 2004, so when we did the business case they were 12 or 13 years old. At that stage, it was felt by the print people that they were coming towards the end of their life. They were fully-----
Comment on this
I understand that, but what was the lifespan when they were bought? Does anybody know that?
Comment on this
I would have to check that for the Deputy.
Comment on this
What is the lifespan of the Komori?
Comment on this
The expectation is that it is somewhere between 12 and 15 years.
Comment on this
Will there be ongoing maintenance and repair costs?
Comment on this
Are they built into this cost?
Comment on this
The maintenance costs are separate. There is no maintenance charge in the first two years. I think in year 3 it is €16,000, €21,000 in year 4 and €25,000 in year 5. Those figures are VAT exclusive.
Comment on this
We would need a breakdown of those maintenance costs.
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan spoke about lessons learned, which are outlined in the report, and the mistakes. What were the mistakes? I have read his report, and I have thanked him for it. I see the eight key lessons, which I welcome. What were the mistakes? Mr. Finnegan is saying that there is no denying that mistakes were made, and that they were honest mistakes. I accept all of that because mistakes are made, but it is where we go with those mistakes and how we deal with them. What mistakes were made?
Comment on this
The biggest mistake was not having architectural expertise on the project.
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan would not have architectural experience at that point because he did not anticipate any problem with the printer.
Comment on this
Looking back on it, and this is all with the benefit of hindsight, one would no longer make that assumption. If one is buying an asset, one at least needs to check if there is any architectural-----
Comment on this
Regardless of the asset.
Comment on this
I think one does. There was absolutely no sense with this machine that there was any need for architectural services. From speaking to the people, in their mind-----
Comment on this
That is okay. I heard that earlier. What other mistakes were made?
Comment on this
The second mistake was in terms of the format we use in our business cases. Again, the ancillary element needs to be built into business cases.
Comment on this
I accept Mr. Finnegan's clarification. The business concept justifying the printer was sound but the actual business case was not sound in terms of the elements that were included in the business case.
Comment on this
Correct, and the formal document that we use, the template of format for that document.
Comment on this
Did any other mistakes jump out at Mr. Finnegan, so to speak?
Comment on this
The other one is in terms of how we report on projects. Looking back on it, the management board-----
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan is calling them the management board. Is that the management committee?
Comment on this
The management committee, yes. The management board approved the purchase of the printing press in November 2017 and did not consider any progress reports on it.
Comment on this
That is a fundamental mistake.
Comment on this
That is a fundamental issue. There needs to be much better oversight.
Comment on this
Were there any other mistakes?
Comment on this
The second point, to go back to the architectural piece-----
Comment on this
I am on four mistakes. Mr. Finnegan is going back to the first one.
Comment on this
No. In terms of the mistakes-lessons learned, the flip side-----
Comment on this
I see the lessons learned. I am more interested in the mistakes.
Comment on this
In terms of the mistakes that were made, looking at it, I would not be happy that the project management of the project adhered to the best standards.
Comment on this
Is there a new project management officer?
Comment on this
We have done an extensive amount of project management training since this project took place. I am going to commission a full end-to-end review of project management methodologies in the organisation.
Comment on this
Of all projects, yes. The way we do our projects is important.
Comment on this
Were any other mistakes made?
Comment on this
The other issue is around risk, and this goes back to 2017. Things have developed since then but with a project like this which, in a sense, goes off the rails and incurs significant extra costs, we should be getting something through our risk management process.
Comment on this
That did not happen at the time. That is something we have to make sure never happens again.
Comment on this
Did Mr. Finnegan identify where that breakdown happened?
Comment on this
I believe it was the manner in which it was communicated. We had a risk register at the time but it was never put on the risk register. If I may briefly explain, we have done a lot since then. We appointed a chief risk officer last year. Ms Máirín Devlin fulfils that role. We have a new draft risk management strategy, a risk management framework, that has been to our audit committee. That will be formally adopted in the first part of next year.
Comment on this
I accept Mr. Finnegan has made changes-----
Comment on this
-----but he might allow me to stay with this for a minute because I lose my train of thought. I appreciate that Mr. Finnegan has made changes. In his first report, he clearly identified, and we all marked it, that he had not enough information. I wrote down the word "key" in terms of the note from Komori not being picked up.
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan then went back and did the report before us now.
Comment on this
In this report, Mr. Finnegan states that it was not picked up by the evaluation team. When I look at the procurement evaluation team I see there is an external procurement consultant on board, a project manager and a print facility on board. I am not sure why head of communications is on it but I might be misinterpreting-----
Comment on this
It is because the head of communications at the time was the project sponsor.
Comment on this
The head of communications had responsibility for the print unit.
Comment on this
In terms of expertise, I refer to the external procurement consultant and the print manager. The external procurement consultant in particular came in with expertise. What were the members of the team paid for that role? How did they not pick up on this?
Comment on this
I simply do not know. I have looked at the request for tender documents. The note underneath the table is clear to me but it just was not picked up by the team. I can only surmise that it may have been the fact that there was one respondent. This was the only tender on the table. I am just surmising that.
Comment on this
There would be no need for many of the changes if this team had picked up that.
Comment on this
However, they did not.
Comment on this
Regarding Komori, how many site visits did they make?
Comment on this
They made a number of site visits, three or four. I would have to get the Deputy-----
Comment on this
That is okay, but they made more than one.
Comment on this
They made one before the process.
Comment on this
As I said in my opening statement, there were site visits during the actual-----
Comment on this
I saw that but Komori was not mentioned in particular. Mr. Finnegan might clarify when they came.
Comment on this
Did anyone tell Komori that the responsibility was theirs, that they were giving us a very expensive asset and it was up to them to check it? As I understand, many other companies - Xerox and others - come and check them. Did anyone say that?
Comment on this
I did. I spoke to the managing director of their Irish agent. On Friday, I had a 30-minute conversation with him. I explained to him that I wanted to speak to him, that I was likely to be giving evidence before the Committee of Public Accounts. I put all of this to him. I said to him that when one stands back and looks at this evidence, the company ticked a box and put a note underneath it. There were site visits, there were drawings submitted of it, and there were measurements taken.
Comment on this
They made a number of visits. They were there.
Comment on this
In fact, Mr. Finnegan's note here states, "On 21 May ... the issue of head-height was discussed between the Oireachtas and Komori and those present [including Komori] were satisfied that sufficient height was available". This is of concern. They were satisfied at that point, on 21 May. Mr. Finnegan's note continues, "particularly since 90% of the operational tasks could be undertaken from the lower platform". First, Komori are saying it is okay. Everyone is agreeing that they are buying a very expensive machine but they will not worry about 10% of the operation.
Comment on this
I do not disagree with anything that the Deputy said. I found it extraordinary.
Comment on this
The Chairman is stopping me, I am afraid. My last point is in relation to this expensive machine. Was the training of the staff included in the business case and costed?
Comment on this
Last, the printer is of a high specification and it can do wonderful things, not just in black and white. Are there other possibilities for its use?
Comment on this
Definitely. As I said in my opening remarks, it is a very versatile machine. It is a well-built machine and there are other possibilities. What I would like to do is get the machine installed, get it operating, get six months to bed it down and then look at the other possibilities. In the public sector, we do an awful lot of printing and that machine is capable of doing certainly some of that printing. We can optimise the value of that machine.
Comment on this
I do not want any more questions, but on the external consultant Mr. Finnegan might just take a note.
Comment on this
I would like to know.
Comment on this
I welcome Mr. Finnegan. I want to pick up on that point. The area I want to touch on is the role of Komori in all this. We have had an extensive discussion of nearly two hours and we have not really mentioned the role of Komori. Given the detail that has been provided by Mr. Finnegan on that site visit on 21 May 2018 by its representatives, including the managing director, the project director and the managing director of its Irish agent, to the print facility at Kildare House and given that height was specifically discussed and that from the evidence available to Mr. Finnegan everyone expressed satisfaction with the head height, has there been any admission of liability on behalf of Komori in respect of this in terms of the conversations that there have been? As a follow-up question, from the legal point of view for the Houses of the Oireachtas, has that avenue been explored given that three of the senior staff within that company expressed satisfaction that everything was okay with the dimensions of the room in their physical site visit, leaving aside the drawings?
Comment on this
Okay. Yes. I suppose the - I am sorry. I am after losing my train of thought. Would the Deputy mind repeating his question?
Comment on this
There are two parts to it. One is an admission of liability by Komori in respect of this, given that its representatives conducted a site visit and expressed at least satisfaction or did not even indicate that there were any problems from that. Two, has that been followed up? Given that Mr. Finnegan has had discussions with the managing director, MD, of the Irish agent, has Mr. Finnegan explored whether there are legal avenues open to the Oireachtas in that context given that it is such a capital asset and that the company had staff on the ground examining the area in which it would be placed?
Comment on this
In the conversation that I had with the managing director, I said to him that when one looks at the paperwork for this, this does not look good. I asked him to look at the facts of it. His position is, as he stated back to me in response, that from his point of view, his company flagged the fact that there was limited head height in the tender response, that the company sent a drawing to us also and that, ultimately, as a company, it would take the view of the available height, which it said was 2.85 m, that it would have installed printing presses in printing works at and below that height. He said to me that, as a company, Komori would take the view - he was careful to stipulate that he is only the agent and that I would need to speak to the managing director of Komori itself - and the general approach it would take would be that if the customer was happy, Komori would supply the machine and that the legal obligation would be on the customer. I went back and I checked that with our legal people. Our legal people advised me that given the warnings, given the fact that there was limited head height, and given the fact that the drawings were sent in etc., we would not be in a position to argue that Komori breached its contract. That, unfortunately, is the reality.
I am exploring other avenues in terms of speaking to our legal advisers to see if there is a possibility that we would set out in writing what happened, the concerns, how we feel the procurement and the provision of the machine were dealt with, and whether they would be prepared on an ex gratia basis to make some contribution or gesture to the Houses of the Oireachtas in respect of this machine. That is something that I am pursuing.
Comment on this
Is that a definitive line for us now that we are going to do that?
Comment on this
In terms of that site visit, I refer to the difference in the use of language between limited head height as opposed to a determination that it would be inoperable if the dimensions of the room had stayed the same. Has it been determined that it would have been inoperable had the dimensions of the room stayed the same?
Comment on this
On health and safety grounds, that machine could not have been operated had those works not been done. We would be in an even worse position because we would have a machine that was fully installed, the machine would have to have been removed from the print unit, and we would have had to do those works.
Comment on this
On the areas that Mr. Finnegan explored in respect of looking at the 2004 works that were conducted for the previous printing machine as opposed to now, he alluded to the fact that the Oireachtas project team had no sense of the need for the works given that there was no one with architectural experience on the team. Had they examined that previous piece of work in 2004 given that substantial works had to be done as well to complement the installation of machines at that point? If they did so, what was costed in terms of work? Was there anything costed for this particular work prior to the issues emanating? Beyond the removal of door frames, was there any substantial work costed for the original piece?
Comment on this
On the 2004 works, essentially, what happened in 2004 was we moved from a situation where we had four printing operations in the Houses of the Oireachtas - each party had its own printing operation - and there was a decision taken at the time that there should be a centralised printing operation. The decision, ultimately, was of 2007. The machines were moved from their old locations around Leinster House - they were in different locations - and we did the works in Kildare House that are there today. The print unit that we have at the moment is, I suppose, specifically geared towards printing and that is where the costs arose.
Comment on this
Was that 2004 report referenced when they were preparing for this?
Comment on this
No, it was not. I asked colleagues from the OPW if they could get the papers because I did not have copies of the papers within the Oireachtas. That is where I got the information.
Comment on this
What was the anticipated ancillary works starting off? When the original contracts were signed, was there anything anticipated beyond the installation?
Comment on this
The thinking at the time was that there would be minor works done. There was certainly removal of door frames. There were other bits of works. I think there was reference to a wall needing to be knocked.
Presumably, there were mechanical and electrical works that would have been required but that was what was anticipated as to what the requirements would be.
Comment on this
In terms of the series of mistakes that obviously caused matters to spiral, the fact that no one involved had architectural expertise has been identified by Mr. Finnegan as key. With regard to the 30 May phone call or email that he referenced in terms of the facilities unit contacting the OPW to say that the contract had been agreed, was that the first contact between the Houses of the Oireachtas and the OPW?
Comment on this
It is the first contact I can find. I am working on the basis that it was, yes.
Comment on this
In terms of the sequencing thereafter and in the context of the human errors, I suppose the root cause of the problem stems from that. Which mistakes would Mr. Finnegan identify as being the most serious after that?
Comment on this
I suppose the general failure to pick up on head height. Maybe I am being a bit harsh.
Comment on this
On the note from Komori to the Houses of the Oireachtas that was missed, did the entire evaluation team miss that or was it sent to an individual?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy referring to the missed note in the RFT?
Comment on this
The entire team missed it. That is the puzzling thing about it. I cannot explain it but that is what happened. I have asked two of the people that were present on the day and they did not realise it was there until this issue arose. They pulled out the RFT, looked at it saw that note. It was a major oversight.
Comment on this
In terms of the admission of the significance of that in retrospect, have they admitted that would have been a serious flagging in terms of helping this process? Did they acknowledged it then? Again, I ask this from the point of view of whether they had the expertise. If they had seen that and referenced it, and had it not been missed, would the people involved have had the expertise to realise the importance of what was being flagged?
Comment on this
No, that is the pity about it. There was absolutely no sense whatsoever that height was an issue. Even if they had seen that note - this is just my own opinion but it is based on the general conversations I have had over the past number of weeks - I think they still would have gone ahead with it. It was just a major blind spot and that is what comes across time and time again, no matter where I look and who I speak to on this project. I am really sorry about the way this project worked out but there was just a big mistake made. It was human error. That is all I can say.
Comment on this
Good afternoon to Mr. McCarthy and Mr. Finnegan. I thank them and the other witnesses for coming in. Earlier, Mr. Finnegan said that the evaluation team "missed the statement on the bottom of the page, which said that the head height was limited." He later agreed that a reasonable person reading accounts should read the notes first.
Comment on this
He has just stated that the entire team missed it.
Comment on this
It is in the context of the conversation the Chairman had with him that I raise those issues.
Comment on this
These are his own words to this committee, which I appreciate the Chairman taking the time to highlight. I did not appreciate it either. In fairness to Mr. Finnegan, he said at the start that it is a privilege for him to come before this committee.
Comment on this
It is a privilege for me to sit on this side of the table, so we all have privilege in our positions here. It is important that we justify that privilege in the context of the questions and the answers and how they are asked and answered. That is something I would like to say at the start and it is not a question.
Comment on this
It is not a question. Does Mr. Finnegan believe that, in the context of something so important to the Houses of the Oireachtas and to Members, getting one tender back was sufficient? I have not read in any of Mr. Finnegan's statements or in his two reports that he went directly to printing firms and asked whether they wanted to look at this tender, when he only got one tender back. He stated under questioning that he went to European companies. As Komori is a Japanese firm, I presume it has an office somewhere here. My point is that for something so significant, did Mr. Finnegan not think to go, or did he not go, directly to firms and ask whether they had machines which would be suitable in the context of the tender?
Comment on this
The way the tendering system worked was that there were market soundings done and people were invited in.
Comment on this
Market soundings is an exercise in procurement where potential suppliers come in, discuss what they have to offer and get a sense of what is required. In the case of the printing unit, they would have a sense of what the printing unit looks like. This is done with a view to assisting in the procurement process and the specification of what is required.
Comment on this
On foot of those soundings, the Houses still only got one tender back.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Finnegan aware of how many other firms gave consideration to this tender? Were they in touch during those soundings?
Comment on this
How many of those, in his opinion or to his knowledge, were almost ready to make their products available or were close to doing so but ultimately did not? Did any inform him as to why they did not make them available?
Comment on this
One of the big issues was the timeline and the ability to supply the printer within the time specification that was required. That was definitely a big issue.
Comment on this
Why was the timeline so significant?
Comment on this
There are a number of things. First, we went out to tender in March and we had a requirement to install the printer over the summer because, obviously, the summer is a quiet time in the printing facility.
Comment on this
I get where Mr. Finnegan is going. Was there something wrong with the other machines? Were they not capable of running for another 12 months, notwithstanding Mr. Finnegan's point about cost?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy referring to the Heidelbergs?
Comment on this
They probably could have been run for another 12 months. I do not see any reason or nobody has said to me why they could not.
Comment on this
Hindsight is wonderful and I accept that. Another member asked if this process was rushed. I feel that it was and that it was rushed unnecessarily. I appreciate that there were escalating costs but, ultimately, I feel the process was rushed and it was an unnecessary rush. Notwithstanding his two reports and the apology contained within them - and the lessons learned, which are very important - the installation was not considered in the context of cost, to paraphrase Mr. Finnegan. For example, on the costs relating to the air condition unit, the machine was supposed to be installed in one room but it ended up in another. I presume that was due to its size. What I would like to know is whether the air conditioning was not already present. Was this an upgrade? Was it necessary because of the machine or was it due to happen in any event? I direct that question to Mr. Cahill.
Comment on this
The original ask to us was to remove a partition between rooms 3 and 4 in order to make one larger room and fit it in there. Komori was responsible for the installation and gave us a drawing of how that would fit and what needed to be taken down to do that. In the context of the area we are talking about, when we talk about structure, it is not the structure of the building, it is all the structure which went in in 2004, which holds all the plant above it and allows access to the air conditioning, which my colleague, Jim O'Sullivan, can talk about. It is about the amount of air conditioning because these machines produce heat and there is a need for fresh air and all the rest of it.
Comment on this
What we are talking about is that, when dealing with a room, it is all there. It is only when the ceiling is lifted that all of the plant that is above that needs to be connected, and that is a follow-on cost. Once it was lifted, then we could see-----
Comment on this
It was in the process of providing additional space.
Comment on this
In the process of providing additional space, further costs were incurred because everything had to be removed to provide extra headroom. With regard to the pile turner, rooms 3 and 4 were amalgamated to become one room. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Are we talking about a free-flowing room or about a doorway or passageway from one room to the other, or is it just open?
Comment on this
As Mr. Finnegan said, it was assumed that this machine was just going in in September.
The partition was taken down to allow for that.
Comment on this
The process of turning the printed page or flipping it putting back into the machine involves using a trolley, not a forklift. I am familiar with the two types of trolleys. Is a mechanised or non-mechanised trolley used?
Comment on this
I cannot answer that. I do not know. I would have to get that information for the Deputy.
Comment on this
Either way, a relatively small trolley lifts paper, turns it around and places it in the machine.
Comment on this
There is a half a tonne of paper involved here. The load is half a tonne.
Comment on this
I am very familiar with this, believe it or not, from one of my previous jobs. To address the health and safety aspect, which will be part of the assessment that will be made available to Mr. Finnegan on 20 December, I would like to understand this particular process. Unless the machine is dramatically faster than the older machine, that process will surely slow everything down because there is a cost associated with the time it takes to walk around the room.
Comment on this
The information given to me is that this machine is dramatically faster.
Comment on this
Once it beds in after the six-month period to which Mr. Finnegan referred, it will be interesting to get feedback on that because-----
Comment on this
-----that process takes time and costs money.
I am puzzled as to why the associated outsourcing costs of printing feature in Mr. Finnegan's report. I am puzzled as to why these have been bandied around as a total figure. The Heidelberg presses are still working. Is that correct? Are they still in operation?
Comment on this
There is one Heidelberg machine, whereas previously there were two Heidelbergs.
Comment on this
Yes, in preparation for the new printer.
Comment on this
The cost of maintaining the Members' print jobs within a reasonable turnover time - which is not the case at the moment but we will not dwell on that - meant that jobs had to be outsourced to a third-party printer.
Comment on this
That is fine. I now have clarity that it is a direct cost.
Comment on this
The emphasis all the time is on maintaining the quality of the service and the turnaround time. The service level agreements stipulate certain turnaround times. They would be adhered to pretty rigidly by the print unit.
Comment on this
As Mr. Finnegan is their boss, I would like to say that the printing staff do a fantastic job. They really do. I can never fault them. They produce a quality product. Deputy Cullinane has said that also and I repeat that point. It will be a very interesting exercise for us to review the whole process once this printer is up and running.
Comment on this
I understand the industry a little in the sense that there are certain associated costs that escalate with an older printer. The current printer is 14 or 15 years old and was probably designed four or five years prior to purchase. It is, therefore, 20 year old technology and quite old. I suspect there will be long-term cost savings. I would like the committee to receive a projection cost for the printer versus the operating cost of an inferior printer. That will be difficult to do because only one quote was received. However, there are other machines out there.
I understand where Mr. Finnegan is coming from in relation to his previous appearance before this committee. I understand that he has an account of what happened and members have been provided that account. The Comptroller and Auditor General does his thing with his office and, ultimately, members of the committee ask questions. I will highlight the point made by the Chairman, which is a worthy one, that there are only two accountants on this committee, both of whom happen to be chartered accountants. This makes life interesting for Secretaries General and other Departments. It is important that when we ask a question the witness answers the question to the best of his ability and in his words, and also that he could sometimes provide us with a bit more information. I think that in July, when Mr. Finnegan appeared before the committee, he knew some of what he knows now and, notwithstanding the fact that the note was missed, there were additional costs that were not included in the account to the reader. I know Mr. Finnegan has said these were provided further down in the notes and the Comptroller and Auditor General has confirmed that. Pulling everything together and providing the committee with as much information as possible is absolutely critical when a witness comes before us. I thank Mr. Finnegan.
After the other members have spoken, it would be interesting to hear the Comptroller and Auditor General's view. I ask Mr. McCarthy to forgive me as I was not present during the previous hearing and did not hear his commentary. I would be interested to know, on foot of today's meeting, what his views are.