Purchase of Komori Printing Press and Related Matters: Houses of the Oireachtas Service and Office of Public Works
Contributions 1–196 of 604. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
This afternoon we are meeting with the Houses of the Oireachtas Service and the Office of Public Works regarding the purchase of a Komori printing press and related matters. We received a report two weeks ago from the Accounting Officer in the Houses of Oireachtas Service, Mr. Peter Finnegan, who is also Clerk of the Dáil, on difficulties experienced and a number of significant additional costs incurred following the purchase of a new printing press. We received from Mr. Finnegan a second report, to which we referred this morning under correspondence No. 2636B, on Tuesday with further clarifications. We also discussed and considered the related item of correspondence from the Office of Public Works, No. 2635B.
We are joined this afternoon by the following people: from the Houses of the Oireachtas Service, Mr. Peter Finnegan, Secretary General, and Ms Máirín Devlin, Office of the Commission and Secretary General; from the Office of Public Works Mr. John McMahon, commissioner, heritage and building services, and Mr. Jim O'Sullivan, assistant chief engineer, mechanical and electrical services.
I remind members, witnesses and those in the Public Gallery that all mobile phones must be switched off. That means putting them onto airplane mode as merely putting them onto silent can still interfere with the recording system.
I advise the witnesses that by virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to the committee. If they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence on a particular matter and they continue to do so, they are entitled thereafter only to a qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and they are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable.
While we expect witnesses to answer questions asked by the committee clearly and with candour, witnesses can and should expect to be treated fairly and with respect and consideration at all times, in accordance with the witness protocol.
May we have Mr. Finnegan's opening remarks, please?
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman for the invitation. I am in a slightly different position from the position I was in on 11 July in that my knowledge of this matter is many times greater than it was then as a result of three weeks I have spent looking at various documentation and speaking to the relevant parties that were involved in this purchase of the Komori printing press. It is important to put the narrative on the record because it will contextualise some of the questions and may indeed answer some of them.
The story starts with the business cases that were developed for the purchase of the printing equipment and the printing press in 2017. A business case was developed which was put before the management board of the Houses of the Oireachtas. The fundamental reason for buying the Komori printer was twofold: first, the age of the existing machines-----
Comment on this
When things such as the management board are referred to, can the witnesses outline who is involved?
Comment on this
Absolutely. If it is of help, I have that information in the appendix to the report, so they can see that there. The management board is the board of senior managers within the Houses of the Oireachtas. It is chaired by me as Clerk of the Dáil and Secretary General. On the board we have our four assistant secretaries, the Clerk of the Seanad, a representative of our PO group and, finally, one external member. The management board meets monthly and its meetings feed into the commission meetings.
Comment on this
It is an executive committee. The Chairman is correct.
The management board received a business case on 6 November. As I said, two main reasons were advanced for the purchase of the Komori printing press. First was the age of the existing equipment.
In 2017, the equipment we had on hand at that stage was 12 years old. The equipment was purchased in 2004 and I believe it went into operation in 2005, so we were looking at equipment that was fully depreciated. It was also proving increasingly unreliable so in terms of the maintenance costs we would incur on equipment of that age, we were spending probably about €45,000 per year on maintenance. In addition to that, we were incurring about €20,000 in spare parts when repairs were needed. I am advised by the print manager that it was not an infrequent occurrence to have a mechanic out repairing the two printing presses.
If we look at it purely in cost terms over five years and ask if the argument for buying a printing press stacks up, we note the cost of maintenance and repairs comes in at around €65,000 a year. If we multiply that by five, we are at €325,000. In addition, we were faced with a decision that if we were to continue with the Heidelberg printing presses, we would have to do a major overhaul of them because of their age. That was expected to cost €170,000. In very round terms, therefore, the cost of retaining the Heidelberg printing press over five years was somewhere of the order of €500,000. When we look at that in the context of the purchase of a new machine, and the new Komori printing press came in at €848,000, we can see the financial sense in terms of moving from the old Heidelberg to the new machine.
The second point to note is the volume of the printing. We have a significant printing operation. Last year, the Oireachtas produced, and I have produced the statistics in the report, of the order of 16 million print impressions. The year before that it was 21 million. If we go back to 2015, we produced 26 million print impressions, so the Oireachtas printing unit is quite a sizeable operation. In the circumstances, we need good, robust, versatile, well-built equipment. That was the reason we went out to tender.
In addition to the printing press, we needed a number of other items of printing equipment. We produced a tender and split it into five lots. The reason we split it into five lots was to maximise competition, and particularly to enable small and medium sized enterprises to compete for the business. That is something we like to do as a matter of policy in the Houses of the Oireachtas Service. The tender was published on 5 March 2018. The records we have obtained show that 12 companies downloaded the tender documentation from eTenders so there was a fair degree of interest, naturally enough, in the contract. That is not surprising, given the expected value.
The site visits during the tender period, which would be a normal activity during tendering, took place on 21 March. At that stage, people could go and look at the print unit. On foot of those site visits, clarifications were received on 29 March. All of those clarifications were answered and the results circulated to all of the parties concerned. The closing date for the tender was 5 April 2018.
In terms of what the request for tenders document sought in respect of the printer, the precise wording was that the tender must be able to fit into a room 12 m by 5.8 m by 2.5 m. The most important measurement is the last one, the 2.5 m, which would have been the ceiling height of the printing unit. We also stipulated that there needed to be an acceptable work area around the press.
When the tenders were subsequently received we only got one tender in, despite the initial level of interest, for the printing press. That came from Komori. In the tender response document, which I reviewed as part of the preparation of the report, Komori ticked the box saying that it met the minimum specification in that the printing press could fit into the room with those dimensions, with an acceptable work area around it. Underneath the box with the minimum specifications a note was included. The words of that note are important. They state that the headroom from the press foot boards to the ceiling is limited.
During the tender period, one of the clarifications received was from Komori. Komori asked the print facility if there was a false ceiling and, if so, if there was a height greater than 2.5 m available. The response they got back from the print facility was that there was a false ceiling and that there was an extra 35 cm available. That increased the available height from 2.5 m to 2.85 m.
To give the members a sense of the Komori printing press, it is a big machine. It is 7.4 m long, 3.2 m wide and 1.98 m in height. I spoke to somebody in the print industry recently about it and asked him how he would describe this type of machine. This would be a very experienced person in the industry. He said it was a very versatile machine. It is the type of machine one would buy if one is doing short runs, long runs and if one has many different types of print requirement, which is exactly the position we are in. He also said it was a well-built machine. He said that the company he runs has a number of different makes of printing press and that the Komori is the best of the ones he has; that is his personal view. The third comment he made was that it is economical in terms of the purchase price of the press and that it was an economical press to run. The evidence I have received is that it is a good, solid printing press.
The other point to remember about printing is that most commercial printing is a 24-7 type of operation. A printing press like this one gives us greater capacity in that area. At the moment, we run two shifts in the print unit but, going forward, there are other options as well.
Following the submission of the tenders, the evaluation team looked at them. I have listed the members of the evaluation team in an appendix. Would the Chairman like me to read it out for the record?
Comment on this
The evaluation team is the fifth group shown. The project manager, who is basically the head of the evaluation team, is the print manager. We had the print supervisor from the print facility. The project sponsor was a principal officer who is the head of communications. We had a procurement unit representative, and we also had an external procurement consultant who has done a substantial amount of work with the Houses of the Oireachtas over the years.
The evaluation team looked at all of the tenders, including the one on the Komori printing press. As I said in my report, the evidence I got was that they missed the statement on the bottom of the page, which said that the head height was limited. They proceeded to arrange a clarification meeting with Komori, being the single tender, which would be standard practice. Five Oireachtas staff members attended that meeting and three representatives from Komori - the managing director, the project director and also the managing director of their Irish agent. A variety of issues were discussed at that meeting. I have looked at the report. Interestingly, head height did not come up at that meeting. At the end of the meeting, it was agreed that Komori would submit various documents by way of clarification. Standard things one would expect in any type of procurement process would be the engineering team, the software support, the organisational chart and so on.
In fairness to them, they were very forthcoming. It is difficult for people who find themselves in a situation where they have made a serious error but I commend them on the way they have faced up to it. It is my conclusion that the mistakes that were made were honest mistakes and that is the expression I used in my report. Ultimately, the staff were trying to do their best for Members. They were trying to improve the quality of the services that we provide to Members by upgrading the printing equipment which, as I said, was 12 years old and was going to be very costly to keep on the road. The aim was to replace it with a new, modern, well-built and versatile printing press. That is the narrative. On the building side, I would have to defer to Mr. McMahon if anyone wants to know about the detail of some of the construction works. Essentially, that is the position as I found it when I conducted my investigation and drew up my report.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Finnegan for outlining the situation. A number of people have indicated that they want to speak and will be invited to do so in the following order: Deputies Catherine Murphy, Munster, Cullinane, Connolly, Cassells and Farrell. We will try to stick to ten minute slots, rather than having one lead speaker.
Comment on this
The witnesses are very welcome. I should declare at the outset that I am also member of the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission which had a robust exchange on this issue recently. It is fair to say that as a consequence of that exchange, there will be exceptional reporting so that matters such as this will be brought to the attention of the commission. The issues of insufficient head height in the building and significant additional works having to be carried out to fit the machine in were as much of a surprise to the commission as they were to anyone else.
A number of issues arise relating to procurement. There was a single response to the printer tender. Was the tender published on a Europe-wide basis? There was only one bid for the printing press contract. Was there more interest in supplying the other machinery that was purchased?
Comment on this
Ultimately we received one tender back in respect of each of the lots that we went out for. We went for five lots in total and were in a single tender situation in respect of each one.
Comment on this
That is very disappointing in the context of competition. How is a tender evaluated when it is the only one?
Comment on this
As I said in my opening remarks, when one is in a single tender situation one does a normal evaluation in terms of requirements and so forth. One asks if the tender meets the requirements. Then, under our governance structure, one submits the tender to the Oireachtas contracts committee. That is the process.
It was unusual to get just two responses. It was advertised in the Official Journal of the European Union but that was the level of interest from the market at the time.
Comment on this
Obviously this is of major public concern.
Comment on this
That concern is very understandable because a machine was bought that did not fit. We are trying to get to the point where lessons are learned, responsibility is taken and there are consequences.
In a previous discussion at this committee, reference was made to the fact that the machine in question comes in different shapes. It was suggested that a model of a different shape would not have caused a problem vis-à-vis the room height. Is that accurate?
Comment on this
The evidence I have is that in order to print the volume done of printing done in the Oireachtas, which is the equivalent of what would be done in a commercial printing works, one needs a machine of the size that was ordered. The people I have spoken to-----
Comment on this
My question is about the actual shape of the machine.
Comment on this
The height is the key issue. My understanding from discussions with various people is that once one gets into that scale of printing, one gets back a machine that has a particular height. The height that we got back is in or around what one would expect.
Comment on this
Does that machine come in a different shape?
Comment on this
If one were to add up the number of people who looked at this, it is puzzling that this issue was not noticed but the sequencing was wrong in the buying process. The sequencing should have been such that architects are brought in first. Is that accepted? What lessons will be learned from this?
Comment on this
That is the very first lesson that I have identified in my report. I said that there were a number of lessons that stand out and these will be addressed as a matter of priority. The very first one is that all of the project teams must include specialist architectural expertise where a project could involve structural modifications and where appropriate, legal external subject matter and health and safety expertise. In reality, if this project had been run the way one would have expected, we would have had an architect on the team. Discussions would have taken place at a very early stage and those discussions would have been reflected in the nature of the business case. The business case that was received referred to the purchase of an asset but did not make any reference whatsoever to ancillary works. This was looked at by a range of people within the Oireachtas, not just the project team. At the time, we had a committee that looked at business cases of this nature. That committee examined the business case. The committee in question is the business and strategy committee which was headed by the then Superintendent. It also included the head of communications at principal level, a principal from committees, a principal from the Office of Parliamentary Legal Adviser, a principal from the Oireachtas Library and Research Service, the principal and head of finance of the Office of the Commission and Secretary General, the chief translator and an assistant principal at the Office of the Commission and Secretary General. All of those people looked at it. In actual fact, three or four of the members of that business and strategy sub-committee went over to the printing unit. They went into the rooms where the printer was going to be installed but the issue of height never actually came up. There was no sense at all that height was an issue. When one looks back at the papers and the evidence, one sees that the perspective was that the project involved the purchase of an asset and the complexities around the installation of that asset were not considered at all. It was just assumed that the asset that we were purchasing, the new printing press, could replace the old Heidelberg printing presses. That was how it was at the time.
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan said in his opening remarks that he is on the management board or management committee.
Comment on this
No, other than when the management board received the business case.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Finnegan clarify if he works on a one-year or three-year budget?
Comment on this
Since it is a three-year budget, is it the case that a decision was taken, because the Oireachtas Service had money left over and Mr. Finnegan did not want to hand it back to the Central Fund, to go on a shopping spree? Was it a rush job? The decision made in this regard resulted in a printer being bought that was too big for the printing room. Is that the case? It did not fit in the print room.
Comment on this
It did not fit. The motivation for buying this printer was, first and foremost, to service the needs of Members. There was no other motivation. If we were not concerned with servicing the needs of Members and their printing requirements, we would not have done what we did. That was our motivation first and foremost.
We operate on the basis of a three-year budget. When we draw up our budgets, we look at what we need to do from a business point of view. One thing we needed to do was to replace the old Heidelberg printing presses. They were 12 years old and were going to cost us a further €500,000 over the next five years. It made absolute business sense and was a very sound business proposition to replace those.
Comment on this
That Heidelberg printer was not due to be replaced until 2021. Is that right?
Comment on this
I read somewhere that it was not due to be replaced until 2021. I asked the question about rushing into it and going on a shopping spree because in response to a question that my colleague, Deputy Cullinane, asked, Mr. Finnegan stated: "the increase of €9.7 million resulted from a strategic decision that we did because there was funding available in the final year of our three-year budgetary cycle." The service basically recommended to the commission that we bring forward ICT expenditure. Is it not the case that this is the reality of what happened?
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan stated in his first report that no discussion arose in respect of the cost of the works in the course of his appearance before the Committee of Public Accounts in July. He was aware of the matter.
Comment on this
I was because I had a briefing note, which I also inserted in my reports.
Comment on this
I am sure Mr. Finnegan will agree that we are not playing cat and mouse here. He was aware of it. There is a certain expectation that when people come before this committee that they will be forthcoming with any information and that Accounting Officers will provide full and honest accounts for whatever organisations they represent. I find it deeply concerning that Mr. Finnegan did not mention this matter and that his response was to the effect that the question did not arise. Can he provide a better explanation?
Comment on this
It might help in explaining that if I outline what it is like on this side of the room as opposed to where the Deputy is seated. When one receives an invitation to attend the Committee of Public Accounts, it is one of the most important things that one will do as a Secretary General. A Secretary General is statutorily responsible for expenditure in the organisation that he or she leads. It is a very important engagement that one gives one's full energy and attention to in the run-up to it. As part of the preparations for it, one will receive various briefing notes. The reason that a Secretary General makes sure to have as much information as possible is that he or she knows, when coming into this room, that he or she could be asked literally anything by anybody. There are no limits on the questions that can be asked. On the previous occasion on which I was here, there were no limits on the questions that were asked of me. I was asked about matters that were not my financial responsibility at all. In order to be helpful to the committee, I answered them as well as I could.
Comment on this
This was not a trivial issue. It involves a substantial-----
Comment on this
The Deputy might let me finish my answer.
Comment on this
In fairness, I think I should finish my answer and then Deputy Munster can come back in. There were no limits on what could be asked. I came in and I gave honest and truthful evidence. I was asked specific questions and I gave the best answers I could at that time. As Accounting Officer, all one can do is answer the questions one is asked.
Comment on this
That is the concern. Mr. Finnegan said that coming to the Committee of Public Accounts is an important engagement and that it is important that he gives as much information as possible. There was a gaping hole in the information that he gave. To not even mention a cost overrun of that magnitude on the basis that the question did not arise, when the subject was being spoken about, gives rise to serious concerns.
Comment on this
There was not a gaping hole in the information. As Accounting Officer, this was fully discussed with the team from the Comptroller and Auditor General's office insofar as we had information. To be fair to everybody concerned, the level of information that we had then is completely different to what we have now. On foot of that discussion, a note was inserted in the account. The primary focus of the Committee of Public Accounts when an Accounting Officer such as myself attends is to examine the account. That information was disclosed and it would be disingenuous to say that it was not.
Comment on this
My point is that Mr. Finnegan was aware of it when he was before the Committee of Public Accounts.
Comment on this
So was the Deputy because it was in the account before her.
Comment on this
I was not a member of the committee in July. Mr. Finnegan was aware that a complete hames had been made of it, that the printer was so big that it did not fit into the printing room and serious adjustments would have to be made to accommodate the printer. Was he not aware of that?
Comment on this
I was aware that there were difficulties with the printer.
Comment on this
That is my question. Mr. Finnegan was aware of it.
Comment on this
If the Deputy will let me finish, with regard to my level of awareness, I had a limited amount of knowledge available that day. I think I put in the report what I could have said had that issue been asked of me. It was very limited at that time.
Comment on this
On page 1 of the report, Mr. Finnegan states: "Having analysed the print production statistics and the financial cost of the Komori printing press I am firmly of the opinion that the business case for purchasing it is still sound."
Comment on this
That sound business case that Mr. Finnegan refers to did not involve knocking down walls, raising ceilings, a new air conditioning unit, moving to another print room and an overrun of upwards of €700,000.
Comment on this
Yes. Mr. Finnegan said that, in his opinion, the business case for purchasing it is still sound.
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan would stand over it still being sound even though the business case he refers to did not involve knocking down walls, raising ceilings, a new air conditioning unit, having to move to a different print room and an overrun of €700,000.
Comment on this
The business case is still sound. I will explain why. A challenge that we face in the Oireachtas is accommodation. The print unit is installed and operates from Kildare House. In Kildare House, we not only have a significant number of staff who run our committees and do translations for us, but we also have a broadcasting unit, a crèche-----
Comment on this
I am talking specifically about the printer and that business case.
Comment on this
That is correct, and I am coming to it if the Deputy could just bear with me. We have a broadcasting unit, a crèche, a gym and a print facility. The reality that we face as an organisation is that when we have to do a piece of major equipment installation it invariably involves structural works. I looked back, just to satisfy myself, to see what was the scale of the works that were done in 2004 when the original print equipment went in. The cost of the works in 2004 was twice the cost of the works that took place in connection with the Komori printer. That gives some sense of the scale of what has to be done when equipment needs to be installed in the Oireachtas. We are not an organisation that has the luxury of installing equipment in a greenfield site. We are not Google down in the docks. We are an organisation that functions from Dublin 2 in very cramped conditions and invariably costs arise as a result of that.
Comment on this
I am saying it on the basis that the reason Mr. Finnegan is here today is that the business case he considered sound turned out to be useless.
Comment on this
I am amazed at how Mr. Finnegan can still say it is sound.
Comment on this
I will just come back to that and look at it in another way. The business case was designed to purchase equipment to service the printing requirements of Members. That is a statutory obligation that the organisation has. In my view, it is very difficult to argue that the replacement of a printing press at €850,000, with additional costs for adaptations, etc., is not a better option than continuing with 12-year old machinery and investing more than €500,000 in that. If I did that, I would also be here before the committee and members would be rightly challenging me on whether or not I had made the right decision.
Comment on this
Was it in the business case that the supplier would measure the room first and then provide a printer? Was that either in the business case or in the contract?
Comment on this
That type of thing is not in a business case, but it would be part of the procurement process.
Comment on this
Right. Okay, but it was not in the business case. That is the problem.
Comment on this
I have just one final question. Pages 9 and 10 of the report refer to the print facility equipment. Does the new printing press require all the additional things that are listed in order to be operational? I refer to the plate-making device, the guillotines and folding machines.
Comment on this
These are all part of the printing process but my understanding is-----
Comment on this
Could the new printing press work without those additional pieces of equipment?
Comment on this
I think two of them are directly connected to it, but I would need to talk to a print expert to be able to answer that question. It is beyond my level of technical knowledge.
Comment on this
Okay, so they may or may not be required for the new printer to be operational.
Comment on this
What I am saying is that I cannot answer the question because I do not have the technical knowledge.
Comment on this
It is just that they are listed in the report and one would imagine Mr. Finnegan would know off-hand whether they are required or just part of the shopping spree.
Comment on this
One would imagine that given that they are in the report, Mr. Finnegan would know whether they were actual requirements when we are dealing with taxpayers' money, or whether they were just part of a shopping spree. Are they required for the new printing press to be operational?
Comment on this
My colleague here has just said that two of them are connected with the printing press, namely, the pile turner and the plate-making device.
Comment on this
So the plate-making device and the pile turner are required for it to be operational. The cost of the guillotine is €78,000 and the folding machine costs €128,000 which means €200,000 was spent on purchases that were not required in order for the printing machine to be operational. That is a scandal.
Comment on this
No. All of this equipment is part of the normal suite of equipment.
Comment on this
It is part of the normal suite of equipment that one would have in a print facility.
Comment on this
What are we supposed to do, fold them in our offices? Come on, Deputy Munster should not be ridiculous.
Comment on this
I am asking if the equipment is specifically required for the printing press to work.
Comment on this
My understanding is that all of those machines are necessary to do the work that the printing facility does for Members.
Comment on this
The printing facility as opposed to the printing press. We did not have those there before. We did not have the pile turner.
Comment on this
We did not have the guillotines or folding machines.
Comment on this
We did have them. So was there a need for new ones?
Comment on this
We are now looking at a cost of more than €2 million.
Comment on this
The overall cost, when one adds in the Oireachtas element and the OPW element is €2.02 million. The OPW element, as explained in the report, is general upgrading works that the OPW does. The cost attributable to the head height issue is set out in the second table, which is €314,000.
Comment on this
What was the business case budget?
Comment on this
I welcome Mr. Finnegan. He said that when one comes before the Committee of Public Accounts as an Accounting Officer that one could be asked anything by anybody. I think that is fair. One can be asked a wide range of questions, even questions that may not be material to the accounts at hand. On the day Mr. Finnegan was in, he was not asked anything by anybody, he was asked a question by me specifically in relation to office equipment and ICT services. The question was specifically regarding what was not an overspend but bringing forward expenditure in the region of €9.7 million. He mentioned on the ICT side the replacement of laptops and he also mentioned the printer, which he said cost €1.3 million. Mr. Finnegan then said he could only answer the question he was asked. The problem is if we are not given the information we cannot ask the questions. I will get to the point in a moment. Mr. Finnegan said there is one line in the report which said there may have been some difficulties. Does he not accept it would have been better at that meeting to say there were issues attached to the cost of €1.3 million and to draw our attention to page 3 of the document which sets them out? Perhaps then we would have been in a better position to ask questions. I was not aware at that meeting that issues arose concerning head height or major works that had to be done to fit the printer but Mr. Finnegan was aware of them. I think the Comptroller and Auditor General was aware of them. When there is a vacuum of information in a room, there is a difficulty. I put it to Mr. Finnegan that it would have been better at that meeting had he just said that as well as the €1.3 million, there are some difficulties he wanted to alert the committee to and that the expenditure will form part of next year's budget. Does he not, first of all, accept that it would have been better at least?
Comment on this
One goes back to the discussion. Like Deputy Cullinane, I have looked at the transcript as well. The exchange we had was very much around subhead 1(a) and the components of subhead 1(a). That is very much one's focus when one is answering questions. It is just the way it is for an Accounting Officer coming in. There was no intention on my part to withhold anything or anything like that.
Comment on this
I am not trying to catch Mr. Finnegan out and I am not saying that he consciously or deliberately withheld information. I am just saying that for us to do our job, it would be better to tell us if there are major complications with a project. In this case, Mr. Finnegan was furnished with a report in December which we then read coincidentally in The Irish Times a week after he was before the committee. The timing was very coincidental but it happened to be a week after Mr. Finnegan was here that we read about it in The Irish Times. Mr. Finnegan specifically mentioned the cost of the printer. What I am saying is that it would have been better if he had said that in addition to the €1.3 million, there are potentially additional costs and he wanted to alert us to those and then at least that would have been on the public record.
Comment on this
As I said, when one comes into the Committee of Public Accounts one tries to answer every question that one is asked. That is what I did on that day to the best of my ability. I had basically flagged this in the appropriation account. There was a note on the account regarding prepayments. That note was note 2.5.
When any group of people are looking at accounts — there are a number of accountants here in the room today — the first thing they do is read the notes. That is the reality of it.
Comment on this
I have it here. This is what it said.
Comment on this
I answered everything to the best of my ability on the day.
Comment on this
This is what it is says: "Print Equipment - €1.169m - a delay in delivery and installing the printing equipment was due to a requirement (not originally anticipated) to upgrade the print room to meet health and safety standards which will be completed in July 2019." It does not jump out that there was a major complication. The cost was €1.169 million. Mr. Finnegan had given me a cost of €1.3 million. It does not jump out at me, even with the benefit of hindsight, that that was resulting in a problem. What I am saying to Mr. Finnegan is not to catch him out or say he did anything wrong or purposely withheld information. We actually acknowledged that he is a very experienced and highly regarded civil servant. He is here as an Accounting Officer to answer questions. It would have been better had he just told us. He has now had to follow up with two separate reports to the Committee of Public Accounts. The second, which I will come to an a second, recognises and acknowledges a series of mistakes that were made. It would have been better had Mr. Finnegan told us. Does he at least accept that it would have been better had he alerted us to the potential problems?
Comment on this
I answered every question I could as best I could on the day. That note reflects the level of knowledge we had. The date of the accounts is June 2018. There is a completely different level of knowledge about this project today. That note, in my view, accurately reflected where we were at based on my review of the documents, etc., that I had. That is all one can do as Accounting Officer.
Comment on this
I am sorry but we will have to disagree on our interpretation. While there is a different degree of knowledge now, Mr. Finnegan had a very significant memo at his disposal in December, well in advance of his coming in. It set out that there were difficulties and challenges. Mr. Finnegan has given his view but I will finish with this topic by stating it is my view that he should have given us more information. He has his view. I will let the public decide who they believe is right on that one.
Let me move on to the business case for purchasing. On page 1 of the second report, Mr. Finnegan states the business case for purchasing is still sound. Does he stand over that?
Comment on this
On page 2 of Mr. Finnegan's second report, he states that having analysed the print production statistics and the financial cost of the printing press, he is firmly of the opinion that the business case for purchasing it is still sound.
Comment on this
All of the evidence that I have reviewed – I have reviewed an extensive amount over the past three weeks – suggests to me that the correct decision was made to purchase a Komori printing press.
Comment on this
Here is the difference. The rationale for purchasing the printer was sound. Nobody here is disputing the rationale or need for the printer. He went into a lengthy discussion he had with some expert – I do not know who this person is. It is irrelevant and not material to this committee. I believe he said it was a good solid printing press. I am sure it is but it just did not fit. That was the problem. Regardless of that, on the second page Mr. Finnegan refers to lessons learned. Could he read for me the second lesson he says was learned?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy want to read it himself?
Comment on this
I can. It states business cases must include an estimate of the cost of ancillary works and items. To me, that is an acknowledgement that the business case did not include an estimate of the cost of ancillary works and items. One cannot say on one page that the business case for purchasing was sound and on the following page acknowledge that one of the lessons learned was that the business case did not include certain elements. Maybe Mr. Finnegan can enlighten me as to why that is the case.
Comment on this
It is actually an issue of language. The reference to the business case on the first page essentially means the business proposition for the purchase of the printer. The arguments for purchasing it from a business point of view are still sound. The reference on the second page is to the specific matter of business cases that are part of our governance structure here.
Comment on this
I am sorry but I am going to have to disagree with Mr. Finnegan again on this. The Comptroller and Auditor General educates us and has done so for a long time on the importance of business cases. One element of a business case is the rationale. The other element is that one lines up one's ducks and that everything is, as much as possible, anticipated. That certainly was not done in this situation because Mr. Finnegan went on to say and acknowledged that there were serious mistakes. It would be better in this report if Mr. Finnegan had said the rationale for the purchase was sound but that mistakes were made in relation to the business case.
Mr. Finnegan said there was a series of mistakes. This was glaringly absent in the first report. In the first report, there was no reference at all to mistakes that were made. The second report states:
There is absolutely no denying that a series of mistakes were made during the project. These are outlined and explained in this report. However, I am satisfied, that the mistakes arose from human error. They were honest mistakes and made by staff who were seeking to improve the printing services for Members.
I have no issue whatsoever with the view that the mistakes were honest. If honest mistakes are made and people put their hands up and say that made them, we have to accept that. There is human error but it took us an awful long time to get to an acknowledgement that serious mistakes were made. I would like to know not the individual or even the department he or she worked in but whether the mistakes Mr. Finnegan states were made as a consequence of human error were made by the company selling the printer, the OPW or the people who were developing the business case? When Mr. Finnegan states there were human error and mistakes, he at least has an obligation to tell us where they were made. In what area? Was it in procurement? In what area were the mistakes made? Was there a combination of different areas?
Comment on this
Before I answer that, can I refer briefly to the Deputy's observation that it took a long time?
Comment on this
The story broke in The Irish Times on the weekend of 23 and 24 November. On the Monday morning when I came into work, I sent an email to the clerk of the committee. I told him I was going to do a report and that I would aim to have it for the committee on the following Thursday, which was 28 November. On Monday, 25 November, Tuesday, 26 November, and Wednesday, 27 November, we basically collated all the information we could in that short period. I had a team of people working with me. They worked incredibly hard pulling together the report. The first report was based on the level of knowledge we had at that time. There were certain unanswered questions that I actually could not answer at that particular time. It was not that I did not want to answer them but I actually did not have the answers.
I obviously had more time to produce the second report. I went through as many of the emails as I possibly could. I had the opportunity to sit down and do a full debrief with particular individuals. I had the opportunity to have a telephone conversation with the managing director of Komori's Irish agent. A lot more went into that. The additional time I had reflects the difference between the two reports and why I was able to say a series of mistakes were made.
With regard to the mistakes, from the very beginning the first and fundamental mistake was the absence of architectural input on the evaluation team. That was absolutely critical. If we had had architectural input on the evaluation team, in my view the issue of head height would have been identified right at the very start. That, in turn, would have had an impact on the business case. The second recommendation that I have is that the business cases must include an estimate of the cost of ancillary works and items. We would have had a truer cost for these works, which would have been incorporated in the business case.
The other issue relates to issues that arose during the course of the procurement process. Mistakes were made in terms of not picking up on the drawing that was submitted but, on the flip side of that, it would have been helpful had attention been drawn to that drawing by the Oireachtas parties. There was just no sense of the head height issue and therefore the drawing did not trigger or ring any alarm bells. Other mistakes that were made included the fact that the statement in the RFT response was missed. That was a further mistake.
Unfortunately, in this project, as I said in my report, basically there was a series of mistakes.
As the Deputy generously acknowledged, they were honest and human mistakes. That is what happens occasionally. It is regrettable that it does happen. However, as long as one has humans involved in a project, there is always the possibility of a human error. One just tries one's best to eliminate or reduce that possibility as far as one can.
Comment on this
I gave the Accounting Officer a lot of time to answer those two questions because it was important.
Comment on this
I welcome the answers I got. We said from the outset that nobody is blaming Mr. Finnegan as Accounting Officer.
Comment on this
Mistakes were obviously made. Those mistakes are now being acknowledged. I do have a view about what information should have been given at a previous meeting. As part of the commentary on this issue, there was a point made that somehow the staff in the printing presses were holding up progress with this printer going live because of pay. That is not my view. There are no issues with staff looking for extra money. No pay claims are being made by staff.
Mr. Finnegan mentioned the actual room. In the first report he gave the committee, he said it was due to go into printing room No. 1 but ended up in printing No. 2. He also mentioned earlier the pile turner. Will he confirm how this printer will work? Is it correct that the pile turner is in a different room?
Comment on this
I will actually educate you. It is a problem for us because you talked about health and safety.
This is a massive printer. The paper in the previous printers could actually be manually inputted into the machines. This cannot. There is a forklift needed.
Comment on this
It goes in under the paper and lifts up the paper.
Comment on this
One either drives it or walks with it. I am not sure.
Comment on this
In any event they would say it is a lift.
Comment on this
There is a device that lifts the paper. It has to go into the front of the machine. It prints one side and comes out the other end. The person has to bring the lift over to the other side and load up the printer. They have to go out of room No. 1 into room No. 2 over to the pile turner. It then turns the paper back on to the lift again, back in and the process is repeated. To me, that is a bit complicated. It raises genuine health and safety concerns which staff would have. That is why I am making the point.
We need to be fair to the staff in the printing presses. There was some media commentary that there were issues regarding a pay claim for operating this printer. Will Mr. Finnegan dispel that this is not the case today? Is it correct that there is no additional pay claim being made by the staff for operating this printer? Is it correct that there are genuine health and safety concerns that the staff have about operating the machine and the tight space of the room in which the printer is located?
Comment on this
I made inquiries about the forklift truck because when I heard that statement I was alarmed myself. I was told that there is no requirement for forklift trucks. A trolley is required. In actual fact, the trolley that is going to be used in connection with the new printer is slightly smaller than the trolley that was in use with the old printer. That is the information I have been given.
On health and safety issues, a range of issues are being addressed with our health and safety consultant. In addition to that, we are looking at the workflow issues in terms of the print unit. The information I have been given is that the report from the health and safety expert is due on Friday week, 20 December.
On the pay claim, on the basis of information I have been given, I am advised that on 12 November SIPTU wrote stating that following a general meeting with staff, it did not believe the current remuneration package is adequate to compensate members for the planned changes and wishes to enter into further negotiations. That is the most up-to-date position on that.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Finnegan provide a little more information to the question Deputy Cullinane asked about going out of one room and into another for turning purposes? It was not answered and it would be helpful to know.
Comment on this
I am sorry I could not answer. I will get the Deputy an answer.
Comment on this
I am concerned with some of what I have heard today.
One could almost interpret that it is in some way our fault for not asking the right questions. There is an innuendo that one answers questions but leaves it hanging that we did not ask the right questions. It might not be intentional but that feel has come out from what has been said.
I have some questions specifically about the accounts the committee discussed on 11 July.
Will Mr. Finnegan check the chart in section 9 of his report today?
Comment on this
The total cost, VAT inclusive, is €1.369 million.
Comment on this
Now let us go to the accounts presented to the committee. On page 17 of the appropriation account from the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission, included in prepayments for 2018 are capital equipment costs amounting to €1.793 million. It stated, “while purchased in 2018, they were not fully commissioned until 2019 as detailed below”. This involved print equipment, laptops and cameras. These were purchased in 2008. Does Mr. Finnegan accept his own words that they were purchased in 2018?
Comment on this
They were purchased and not commissioned.
Comment on this
Yes, they were purchased. That is why they are included. Does Mr. Finnegan accept that what was included in the prepayment was printing equipment that was purchased in 2018?
Comment on this
Purchased. This basically is delayed delivery.
Comment on this
Can I take the Chairman to the note above that? It stated, “included in prepayments in 2018 are capital equipment costs amounting to €1.793 million which, while purchased in 2018, will not be fully commissioned until 2019”.
Comment on this
Correct. There are three elements making up that figure, the biggest one which is in the next paragraph, the print equipment, €1.169 million.
Comment on this
Is a reasonable person reading that entitled to believe that the print equipment purchased was €1.169 million which was purchased in 2018?
Comment on this
It was purchased but not fully commissioned.
Comment on this
We are not talking about the installation. I am only talking about the price, the figure in the accounts.
Comment on this
No, to be honest, Chairman. I think I know what you are getting at.
Comment on this
I will tell you what I am getting at. The chart you gave us a minute ago gave us a cost of €1.369 million.
I did not like the conversation I was hearing over the past few minutes. Mr. Finnegan is referring back to the prepayments note. The note states – which you gave to us but we did not query in detail – was that the print equipment had been purchased in 2018 at a cost of €1.169 million. In this chart, he is telling us the figure was €1.369 million, out by €200,000. It had been purchased. Accordingly, he knew the price. Why did he put in a figure of €1.169 million when the cost of the equipment purchased was €1.369 million? Will he explain the two figures to me?
Comment on this
I want a valid answer because I have had innuendoes about our questioning of this figure. There is a figure of €1.169 million in the account that Mr. Finnegan referred to a number of times.
That is not the figure he has given us today for what was actually purchased. It is out by €200,000. That is the first point I am making. I thought we would conclude this matter today but I cannot allow that until we get an explanation for the difference of €200,000. My second point is that Mr. Finnegan said they did not pursue that issue in greater detail. That was July. Print equipment was listed at €1.169 million: "A delay in delivery and installing the printing equipment was due to a requirement (not originally anticipated) to upgrade the print room to meet health and safety standards which will be completed in July 2019." That is the month we were here. There is a reference there to €1.169 million. The figure Mr. Finnegan has given us today for completing all the works done, including the OPW work, is €2.02 million. That is an increase of 73%. I know he did not have the full figures for the €2 million in July but even if we had questioned that, we would only have been halfway to the figure.
The issue here is not that we did not pursue the accounts and the accounts Mr. Finnegan produced refer to €1.169 million. The public now knows that the final cost, which was not known to Mr. Finnegan fully on the day, is €2.02 million. The figures being quoted here today, 12 December, have risen by 73% versus those that were quoted here on 11 July. They have gone up from €1.169 million to €2.02 million. That is the issue. There is no indication in that text that structural work is required. The phrase "upgrade of print room" indicates that a new printer is coming in. It looked a reasonable figure. There was no suggestion it required structural works to the extent that it did. The point is that figure is nowhere near the complete figure because Mr. Finnegan did not have it. It is not fair to say we did not pursue it. The figure is 73% higher today than was reported by Mr. Finnegan in July. That is where the public have the concern. There was a budget at the beginning and the Houses of the Oireachtas Service was within the budget at that point in time, according to this. However, as the year progressed what was indicated to be €1.169 million turned out to be €2.02 million when all the other work was done. That 73% increase is why the public is concerned. Does Mr. Finnegan get that?
Comment on this
Yes. Mr. Finnegan says it is our job to examine the accounts and that is what I am doing now.
Comment on this
We can talk about printing and everything else but we are talking about the accounts and that is why Mr. Finnegan is here.
Comment on this
Just in terms of the difference between the figure that is in my report and the figure that was in the appropriation account, that is accounted for by two of the items which were not regarded as pre-payments. They come to a total of €123,000 and €78,000, respectively. That is the difference of €202,000 between those two figures. That explains it. I would respectfully point out that both the figure in my report and the figure in the note to the account are both correct.
Comment on this
Given that Mr. Finnegan referred to pre-payments on the printing equipment and gives us the print facility equipment, it would have been helpful to include that in the note today, rather than us having to extract it. A reasonable person reading those figures will see €200,000 of a difference. If we did not extract that, we would be none the wiser and we might be accused of not asking the right question. It would have been helpful had that been explained. Regardless of that, the figure has gone from €1.69 million last July to €2.02 million today.
Comment on this
If I can come in for ten seconds, what it says is: "Print Equipment - €1.169m - a delay in delivery and installing the printing equipment was due to a requirement [...] to upgrade the print room to meet health and safety standards." At no point does it say there that this will result in additional costs. That is the issue. If we had seen that, we would have asked. It appears as if there is no difficulty here. There is a delay in installing it but it does not say there is going to be additional costs.
Comment on this
I am moving on to Deputy Connolly. Mr. Finnegan wants to come back in as well. Because there were a couple of references to the accounts presented and the questions being asked and not being asked, I am stopping the meeting at this point for this intervention, to compare what was in front of us then with what is in front of us now. There is a 73% increase. That is all I am saying. Mr. Finnegan need not go through it. The schedules explain the figure we are at today and we know where we were then.
Comment on this
Okay. Just to explain as a point of information, the figure the Chair is quoting is €2.02 million. The figure that will ultimately be recorded in our accounts in respect of the upgrading work is €314,000. I am advised that figure will be reimbursed to the OPW in 2020. It will, therefore, feature in the 2020 appropriation account. The other figure that relates to the legacy works carried out by the OPW is on page 10. That is €221,000 and is paid from the Vote of the Office of Public Works, not the Vote of the Houses of the Oireachtas Service.
Comment on this
I accept that, but just in terms of accountancy-----
Comment on this
Because the equipment was basically purchased and it was in use. That is my understanding.
Comment on this
In other words, Mr. Finnegan is telling us that the folding machine and the guillotine worked with the old machine and they will now work with the new machine.
Comment on this
I think that is the case, yes. I will check that for the Chairman. The note basically records items that were purchased but not fully commissioned.
Comment on this
Not available for use is the expectation for recognition of a capital asset.
Comment on this
I understand that. Mr. Finnegan is saying the folding machine and guillotine were available for use.
Comment on this
Whether they were used is not the point from an accounting perspective. It is that they were available for use. If they are not used and there is a waste of resource because it is under-utilised-----
Comment on this
They would have been subject to depreciation.
Comment on this
Somebody might give us a note on that point as well. It is a small point but people are watching us carefully. I apologise to Deputy Connolly for cutting in.
Comment on this
Mr. Finnegan is very welcome. Táim buíoch dó as ucht na dtuarascálacha. Tá siad cuimsitheach agus déanann an tUasal Finnegan a dhícheall na ceisteanna a fhreagairt. I welcome the two reports. He has greatly attempted to answer the questions and has certainly set out the issues in a short time. Whether we are happy with the responses is a slightly different issue. Someone in Galway asked me the total cost of the printer. Can Mr. Finnegan just give that to me?
Comment on this
Yes, the printing press with all the additions - €1,798,818 inclusive of VAT. Is that correct? It is on page 9 of the report.
Comment on this
Correct. When everything is added in, to pick up on a point that I noted the Deputy made when she was considering my first report, we had inadvertently left out the storage charge of €12,000. The other thing which we have included, to give an accurate picture, is the cost of outsourcing since this problem arose. We have included a figure of €100,000. A true cost of the equipment, the works, storage and outsourcing costs is approximately €1.8 million inclusive of VAT.
Comment on this
Is the outsourcing continuing?