Vote 26 - Office of Minister for Education
Contributions 1–200 of 604. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Apologies have been received from Deputy Imelda Munster. I remind everyone to switch off their mobile phones or place them in silent mode. On behalf of the committee, I welcome the two newly appointed members, Deputy Ciarán Cannon, who will perhaps arrive later in the morning, and Deputy Damien English. These are two promotions within Fine Gael.
Before we start, I wish to explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practices of the Houses as regards references witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected pursuant to both the Constitution and statute by absolute privilege. This means that witnesses have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything that they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that it is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with such a direction.
Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are also reminded of the provisions of Standing Order 218 that the committee shall refrain from enquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies.
The Comptroller and Auditor General, Seamus McCarthy, is a permanent witness and is accompanied by Ms Paula O'Connor, deputy director at the office of the Comptroller and Auditor General.
This morning we will be engaging with officials from the Department of Education to examine appropriation accounts for 2022, specifically Vote 26 - Education. From the Department, we are joined by Ms Bernie McNally in her first appearance before the committee as Secretary General; Mr. Hubert Loftus, assistant secretary general; Ms Aoife Conduit, assistant secretary general; Ms Martina Mannion, assistant secretary general; Mr. Dalton Tatton, assistant secretary general, Mr. Gavan O'Leary, assistant secretary general, and Mr. Tom Whelan, principal officer.
We are also joined by the following officials from the relevant Vote section of the Department of Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform: Ms Georgina Hughes-Elders, principal officer, and Ms Sibeal Archer, assistant principal officer. All of the witnesses are very welcome. To begin, I call on the Comptroller and Auditor General to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat a Chathaoirligh. The appropriation account for Vote 26 Education records gross expenditure of just under €10.2 billion in 2022. This represented almost a 10% increase in spending year on year. The largest element of spending in 2022 was for the pay and pensions of current and former teachers and other school staff, amounting to €7.8 billion. Payments related to the provision of school buildings and extensions and other educational infrastructure totalled €1.1 billion in 2022. This included €64 million in payments relating to public private partnership provision of schools. Grants payable to primary and post-primary schools, education and training boards and other educational organisations and institutes amounted to more than €767 million in 2022. Expenditure on school transport totalled just under €339 million. The Department’s administration costs were slightly more than €120 million in 2022.
On the receipts side, appropriations-in-aid amounted to €409 million in 2022. The majority of these receipts are pension-related contributions deducted from the salaries of current education sector employees.
The net expenditure outturn for 2022 was €9.767 billion, leaving a surplus to be surrendered from Vote 26 of just under €49 million. I issued a clear audit opinion for the appropriation account for 2022. I also drew attention to the disclosure made by the Accounting Officer in the statement on internal financial control in respect of material instances of non-compliance with procurement rules that occurred in 2022.
Comment on this
Thank you. As set out in the invitation, Ms McNally has five minutes for her opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and committee members for the invitation to discuss our appropriation account and some particular topics the committee has chosen.
Although the Chair introduced the officials, I will give their names again and their areas of responsibility in order that members will be clear on that. At assistant secretary general level, Mr. Hubert Loftus is head of the planning and building unit. Ms Martina Mannion is head of the special education and National Educational Psychological Service, NEPS, division. Mr. Dalton Tattan covers curriculum, assessment and teacher professional learning. Ms Aoife Conduit covers school transport and redress. Mr. Gavan O’Leary is from our corporate services and finance unit. At principal officer level, Mr. Tom Whelan is head of the finance unit.
We provided briefing material in advance. I hope this has been of some assistance. As the committee is aware, the Department of Education is responsible for funding, policy development and oversight to support the provision of education in schools. The Department’s net expenditure in 2022 was €9.77 billion. Net pay and superannuation accounted for around 77% of the Department’s overall budget in 2022. This provided for approximately 143,000 teachers, special needs assistants and other staff. Other expenditure included grants to schools, including capitation payments; costs associated with teacher education; the provision of school transport; and a significant capital building programme. The capital programme comprised approximately €1.1 billion, representing 11% of the gross expenditure of the Department. The overall expenditure for the year also included costs arising due to Covid-19, the war in Ukraine and cost-of-living increases in schools.
Due to pressure on expenditure in 2022, it was necessary to seek a gross Supplementary Estimate of €925 million. Of this, €200 million was for retrospective public sector pay deals agreed during 2022 as part of the extension of the Building Momentum pay deal. A further €400 million was approved for costs relating to Covid-19 support, the war in Ukraine and cost-of-living supports. The statement of internal financial control that forms part of the appropriation account provides details regarding the control systems in place. It also notes details of instances of non-compliance with public procurement rules. The Department fulfils a significant operational role nationally. For example, it is responsible for the largest payroll in the country. Some instances of non-compliant procurement arose for reasons such as urgency, the need for business continuity and initial assessments made that certain services only had a sole supplier. The Department is actively engaged with the procurement reform programme and is taking the opportunity to use centralised contracts and frameworks wherever possible. The Department has also increased its staffing resource in relation to procurement guidance and monitoring to improve compliance.
The committee has been provided with a briefing on the capital programme of the Department. The demographic trends in relation to the number of children enrolling in schools and expected to enrol are changing. Many school planning areas continue to see growth in demand. The Department is taking every opportunity to continually improve and strengthen its forward planning through better data gathering, sharing and analytics and collaboration with other agencies and sectors. Delivery of the school building programme is a priority for the Department. We have a strong track record of delivery, with all available investment being used annually.
As well as being conscious of significant national demographic trends, the Department is conscious of significant regional and local variations in demographics, which have implications for demand for school places in a given area. Migration patterns can add to this complexity. The successful enrolment of more than 18,200 pupils from Ukraine was a significant feature across the sector in 2022 and right up to date. This represents an enrolment rate of approximately 94% of the Ukrainian school-age children who have come to Ireland, one of the highest enrolment rates across Europe.
More than 163,500 children travel on school transport services every week. This number covers in excess of 136,000 pupils on mainstream services, more than 20,000 pupils on the special educational scheme and 7,600 pupils from Ukraine. As the committee knows, the service is managed by Bus Éireann on behalf of the Department. It cost approximately €340 million in 2022. As members will be aware, the Minister recently published a report entitled School Transport Scheme 2030. This was the largest review of school transport since its establishment in the 1960s. The report recommends the expansion of access to the scheme, with a view to providing transport services to an additional 100,000 pupils by 2030.
Over €2.7 billion of the Department’s budget is invested in special educational needs. A significant amount has been achieved in recent years. For example, we currently have more than 2,900 special classes across the country, which is a sixfold increase from 514 in 2011. By the end of this year, an additional 11 special schools will have been introduced since 2020. However, there is still a significant amount to be done and the Department is working intensively to ensure that all children with special educational needs can access high-quality and inclusive education in their locality.
The committee has listed other areas of interest it would like addressed at this meeting and we have included updated information on each in the briefing provided to it in advance. My colleagues and I will be happy to take any further questions on these matters. I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee.
Comment on this
I thank the delegation for coming to discuss an important issue which is causing communities throughout the State anxiety, stress, concern and fear as regards the handling of education. There appears to be a poor forward planning process in place. That is certainly evident in my constituency of Wicklow. How would the witnesses sum up the Department's current approach to forward planning, school places and the progression of new school buildings?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Brady for his question. I absolutely acknowledge there are families around the country who have concerns. Deputy Brady is from one of the constituencies in which there has been a problem. The country is divided up into 314 school planning areas and the data shows us that the planning has absolutely worked. Of those school planning areas, there are typically about ten every year in which there are problems.
We have nearly 1 million children and young people in schools, of whom the vast majority get a place without a problem. In up to ten school planning areas, however, there can occasionally be a problem, generally for reasons of very accelerated population growth. Part of the problem is not actually that there are not enough places, full stop; it is often just duplication. A significant contributor to it is that parents are applying to a number of different schools. For example, in one area recently, we found that when we eliminated the duplication, there were immediately 50% fewer places than we needed.
There is significant planning. The Deputy is advocating on behalf of his constituents and others across the country. I can absolutely assure that we will provide a school place for every child, be that a child who is attending a mainstream school with full ability or someone who has special educational needs. We will provide a place for them.
Comment on this
Ms McNally said that planning has worked, but it has not. It has failed. Forward planning has fundamentally failed. Wicklow is one example of that but there are many other examples across the State. I will quickly read a letter I got from a pupil in Wicklow only this Monday. It is very brief and says:
Hello, my name is [I am not going to give his name, for obvious reasons] and I go to St. Patrick's National School. I really love the school that I am in currently and I have made loads of friends since moving school. This year, I have to move school again since I am going to secondary school. The problem is that I do not have a place in a school yet. Every one of my friends do. I am the only one from both sixth classes in my school that does not have a place. This makes me feel a bit left out. I really hope that, in the future, I get a place in a secondary school close to home, like St. David's School or Temple Carrig School for example, and not one that is far away in Kilcoole. I hope that soon I will have a place in a secondary school and I am able to tell my friends and not have to worry about it anymore.
That is from a sixth class pupil and it is very evident as to how he, and many other pupils right across the State, not just in Greystones, have been failed. The system is not working. He is on a list. He is 78th on a list for St. David's School and 71st for Temple Carrig School.
Last week, the Taoiseach said he had solved the issue and that every child in that area now has a school place. This letter arrived on Monday. This pupil is one of at least 12 pupils in that area who are still without a school place. What does Ms McNally say to him, his parents and other parents and pupils in a similar situation who do not have a school place in Greystones and other places across the State? Does she stand over her remark that the planning process in the Department is working?
Comment on this
The planning system is working, overall. As I mentioned, for 314 school planning areas, there are, typically, less than ten areas where there are problems. Most children and young people across the country get a school place. They may not always get their first place or first preference, but they will get a school in their locality. I am not saying that we have it perfect; absolutely not.
I genuinely empathise with that young person. I have teenagers of my own and I know how important it is for them to have advanced notice and to know where they are going. Preferably, they want to go somewhere where there are some of their peers. In Deputy Brady's particular area, we have established extra places. While I know the letter mentioned a different school, there is an extra class in Greystones Community College. We are working really hard. Ideally, we would like to have every single young person sorted out much earlier in the year, but in the coming weeks, we believe we will have sorted out children-----
Comment on this
This is an annual occurrence. It is not a one-off occurrence in the Greystones area. Unfortunately, Ms McNally's words ring hollow to this pupil and his family and to the other families who are in a similar situation to the parents and pupils of last year, the year before that and so on. There is a cyclical failure by the Department to deal with this.
Ms McNally said that forward planning is working. We know that in Greystones, for example, the population target has already exceeded the target for 2030. Six years prior to achieving the population target, planning applications are now being refused by the local authority because the 2030 target has been exceeded. What kind of interaction is there with Wicklow County Council and other local authorities on that forward planning piece? There seems to be a real failure to say that the school places are not available and that the brakes need to be applied. While houses are needed, we also need the critical infrastructure such as school places. We have a problem here and we are not in a position to provide those school places. What kind of interaction is happening with local authorities such as Wicklow County Council?
Comment on this
I have to respectfully disagree with Deputy Brady that the whole system is a failure. As I said, there are nearly 1 million children and young people in the system at any one time. Every year, between 120,000 and 130,000 children come in at junior infants or first year and while I do not want to mislead parents, the vast majority of those get a school place because we are planning from years out. Deputy Brady identified himself that, in that particular area, even the local authority did not see the volume of expansion coming. It came quicker and was not foretold. We work really close-----
Comment on this
The local authority did see it. There is a planning process there. There are population targets laid down. It saw it. There was a real failure here to plan properly, both by the Department and the local authority. There was no joined-up thinking. Education is one area but there are other areas which have failed here in terms of amenities. Pupils should have a basic and fundamental right to a school place and they have been failed.
Comment on this
I could ask my colleague Mr. Loftus to come in later, if the committee has time, and he will outline the massive growth in the number of places, the number of schools in Wicklow that have seen expansion, the number of new schools at primary and post-primary and the extra places that are there. A lot is being done. The Deputy asked about local authorities, and we work very closely with the local authorities to plan. We contribute to development plans-----
Comment on this
Clearly, in this case, the Department is not working closely enough.
I want to move on to another area, namely, the use of prefabs. Again, there has been a failure to put in place the school builds in a timely and efficient manner. I have to hand the figures from 2022. The cost of providing prefabs or temporary modular accommodation for schools was €28.1 million. Do we have the figure for 2023?
Comment on this
First, temporary accommodation is sometimes necessary to enable us to be responsive, as the Deputy identified, when there is population growth, a spike in demographics in an area or an increased prevalence of special education. Temporary accommodation is needed and that is sometimes how we serve children, but we always look at the most sustainable and cost-effective measure possible.
Comment on this
In 2021, we spent €28.1 million in current expenditure on rental; in 2022, €41 million; and in 2023, €43 million. The Deputy will know there has been a massive increase in demographics, so we are serving more children. We are serving 18,200 Ukrainians, who were not there at this time-----
Comment on this
I apologise but did Ms McNally say the figure was €43 million in 2023?
Comment on this
There has been a significant increase, therefore. Was that for rental?
Comment on this
What was the figure for the purchasing of modular units?
Comment on this
I will get the Deputy that number, because we are investing a significant amount in modular, at about 19% of our budget. I will get him that exact number in a moment. Again, that is to respond to Ukrainians, special educational needs and the spike we have seen in demographics in some areas.
Comment on this
In the context of the renting of spaces and other types of properties for temporary provision for educational purposes, do we have figures for 2023?
Comment on this
In terms of rental, as the Deputy knows, the committee a number of years ago asked us to take an in-depth look at the use of rental properties over five years, and we have since done a huge amount of work on that. In February 2021, there were 396 schools that had been using rented prefabs for more than five years. That had reduced to 219 in April 2024, so there has been a significant reduction.
Comment on this
Do we have a figure for how much it has cost to purchase those modular units?
Comment on this
Yes, I can ask my colleague to come in here, but the spend on modular in 2023 was €281.9 million.
Comment on this
Yes, but to explain, that is on modular-----
Comment on this
Do we have a figure for the renting of land and premises on which to put these modular units in 2023?
Comment on this
If I could just go back to the modular, to explain, that is not temporary accommodation. We use modular accommodation for permanent accommodation. It is well accepted internationally and, in fact, encouraged internationally that we use modern methods of construction because there are both value for money and climate benefits. That modular is not temporary accommodation. Much of it is permanent.
Comment on this
I do not mean to go back to asking about Wicklow all the time, but those modular units are predominantly being put onto land not owned by the Department. Again, therefore, how much is it costing to rent spaces in which to put those modular units? Ms McNally is saying it is permanent but in many cases it is of a temporary nature in terms of the location.
Comment on this
Some of the land we are putting it on is Minister owned, but in many instances, or most instances, it is owned by patrons. We are putting it onto the land of patrons and we are not paying rent on it. The patrons are giving us access-----
Comment on this
If I could go back to the Wicklow situation, land is being rented from a rugby club, a GAA club and a tennis club-----
Comment on this
They are very small numbers. Overall-----
Comment on this
They may be small numbers but in Wicklow, it cost €6 million in one year to provide temporary accommodation by renting land, renting prefabs and so on. That is not value for money, in my book. It is a failure by the Department to forward-plan to provide education for pupils who, as a right, should have it in appropriate settings.
I will give Ms McNally an example. One of my daughters started primary school in a prefab that was totally unfit for purpose. She also attended secondary school in a prefab. She went to college in Maynooth and was educated in a prefab there too. Throughout her education, she was educated in prefabs. She is now a primary school teacher, so after 18 years of education, it was only when she became a primary school teacher that she set foot in a purpose-built classroom. That is a real failure, and there are pupils like her throughout the State who have been systematically failed by the State in the provision of education but also the provision of subject options in secondary school. There is a real failure here by the Department. There is no efficiency whatsoever and there is a real failure of forward planning.
Comment on this
If I could come in on that, the Deputy mentioned the word "failure" a lot and I have to counter that a little. I absolutely accept there are problems in many areas, but first and foremost, the Deputy opened this discussion by talking about us needing places. We do everything we can to ensure every child gets a place, and we can give him numbers on that. Sometimes, however, in a small number of cases relative to the 1 million children who are in the system, we have to spend money on rental, but that can be justified. We are doing everything we can to minimise it, but our first priority is to make sure children and young people have a school place, and that is what we do.
Second, the Deputy mentioned failing children and young people. The facts are the quality of the education system in Ireland is the envy of the world and we have hard data that shows we do provide high-quality education.
Comment on this
To finish, although I might come back in on this, when the Ombudsman for Children has stated there is an unacceptable level of stress, particularly for children with special needs, and when there is a figure of more than €320 million having been spent last year on the provision of temporary and modular accommodation, that speaks volumes about the failure of the Department and the Minister to forward-plan and put in place appropriate education for our children.
Comment on this
Good morning to everybody. I want to add to the questions on modular accommodation. A number of schools are waiting. Mr. Loftus might brief me on when they will be informed. Some of them are accommodating classes in their general-purpose areas and maybe even in school halls. Will that be remedied for the coming school year?
Comment on this
Absolutely. We have a very strong roll-out of projects, both mainstream-traditional and modular, and we are engaging with a lot of schools on that. One of the benefits of modular accommodation is that we have a framework in place that assists with procurement delivery. To add in response to Deputy Brady's point, modular accommodation is a very strong, robust, permanent solution. We have had very positive feedback on the quality of it, and we see it as an important delivery mechanism-----
Comment on this
I apologise for interrupting but my clock is ticking. I accept that. I might need a further meeting on certain projects, rather than holding up the committee-----
Comment on this
Yes, I am happy to talk directly to the Deputy, being conscious of time.
Comment on this
I know that the Department worked very hard over the summer last year and sometimes the summer is when it engages with the principal or the people concerned, but it is about being sure there will not be a continuation of the use of prefab cabins or the school hall as opposed to a classroom setting.
Turning to Ms Conduit, in March of this year, representation was made by a party colleague of the Minister to the Department of Education with regard to school transport, and a third bus was laid onto the route from Callan, County Kilkenny, to Kilkenny city. How did that come about?
Comment on this
As the Deputy is aware, a large number of children use school transport every year. Some 70% of those are eligible and qualify under the scheme-----
Comment on this
In March of this year, a third bus was laid on. Why was it laid on in March and not in September?
Comment on this
Everyone knows the context of how the school transport scheme works, and I do not have much time.
I will have to come back in repeatedly. I therefore ask the witnesses to please specifically answer how a third bus was laid on for the students who required it in September, but it only happened in March. How and why did this happen?
Comment on this
Bus Éireann works throughout the year for children who have applied for school transport and where families have paid on time, if they are due to pay for a ticket. We try to show-----
Comment on this
These were all concessionary ticket holders. All of them were.
Comment on this
In some cases, on those particular routes, there were schools that were at capacity in the area, so the children fell under the temporary alleviation measures, TAMS. The temporary alleviation measure is where children are attending their second closest school but would be eligible for their first. These children were not able to get into their closest school, so they then became eligible under TAMS-----
Comment on this
They are not concessionary ticket holders if they had been turned down by their closest school. A third bus was laid on in March. How and why did that happen? Why was it not laid on in September?
Comment on this
It was because those issues were being worked through with Bus Éireann.
Comment on this
Okay. Are there still three buses on that route?
Comment on this
Well, the information I have tells me different. which is that all students are now being accommodated on the original two buses. The third bus was laid on for one week only and all the students who could not be catered for in September are now being catered for on the two original buses.
Comment on this
To the best of my knowledge, any bus on those routes has either eligible children, TAMS children, or children who have been identified-----
Comment on this
That is not the question I asked. I asked whether there are now two buses on the route or whether there are three.
Comment on this
I will have to come back to Deputy Murphy on that one-----
Comment on this
-----I understand there was at this stage-----
Comment on this
I also ask Ms Conduit to come back about why and how it occurred. The information I have is that a Deputy who is a colleague of the Minister arranged a meeting and he was of the opinion that he would get no votes in the general election. That was mooted to the Minister in front of the parents. The parents had told him that. Then, a bus was laid on two weeks later, but only for one week.
I am aware of two similar situations in Wexford. I am not a party colleague of the Minister. I am an Independent Deputy in the Opposition. The parents in my constituency have not been given the same treatment. I would expect that if the Department were going to make an exception - this is not a TAMS exception; I have checked it - we would get the very same treatment in Wexford as Kilkenny, regardless of who the Minister is, or which Deputy is representing on the issue. Would Ms Conduit agree with that?
Comment on this
I am aware that there are children in Deputy Murphy’s constituency on whose behalf she has been in close engagement with the Department. Information has been requested. Some of those families have not applied to Bus Éireann. I urge anyone who-----
Comment on this
Some of those families have not applied on the basis that they are not entitled to the ticket because they are not going to the school that is nearest to them. The latest review says that we will do away with all that. The latest review states that, contrary to the accounts that show the figure of €339 million, Bus Éireann’s transport costs must have increased by €100 million. I say this because the review says the costs are €444 million. I do not know whether the independent review is incorrect, but the accounts here show the figure of €339 million. That is-----
Comment on this
Excuse me for interrupting. That figure is for 2022.
Comment on this
Is Ms Conduit referring to the figure of €339 million?
Comment on this
There is, therefore, an increase of €100 million to date. Is that correct?
Comment on this
That is because we are accommodating far more children on the scheme than we ever have done.
Comment on this
Well actually, you are not. In Wexford, the figures do not show that.
Comment on this
There is a 5% increase in tickets in the Wexford area.
Comment on this
That is because we are catering for the Ukrainian population.
Comment on this
Almost all of them are. We have already thrashed this through parliamentary questions. It is almost all for the Ukrainian population. Therefore, there is in fact no increase. Ms Conduit is dead right, though. When it came to catering for the population that came from war-torn countries, buses were laid on with no issue. I accept that.
There is a huge issue, as Ms Conduit will well know, with how Bus Éireann continues to refuse to allow people aged over 70 years of age to drive buses. I have been speaking about that for ten years. I have been requesting a review of it for ten years. What has the Department done about this?
Comment on this
Can I come in on that, or would the Deputy prefer to hear from Ms Conduit?
Comment on this
I do not mind, as long as there is an answer.
Comment on this
Okay. I am happy to come in on that. On the previous point, there are 163,500 children travelling on Bus Éireann now-----
Comment on this
Do not waffle with figures. I want answers, please.
Comment on this
That is the question. I thank the Chair.
Comment on this
On the funding issue, which is important, there has been a significant increase in the number of children travelling on buses, and that has warranted extra costs.
Regarding the question on the over-70s, this is a policy of Bus Éireann’s. We constantly bring it up with the company, but it tells us that it is based on evidence. There is-----
Comment on this
One can speak to the Road Safety Authority or look at international research. There is research from Finland and Canada that shows that as we get older, we get comorbidities, we go on medication, there is cognitive decline and there is eyesight decline.
Comment on this
All right. That is very clear. I thank Ms McNally. Does she understand that the Department of Transport, through the National Driver Licence Service, NDLS, has increased the medical to the age of 75?
Comment on this
In that case, what she is saying is not credible with regard to the Department. Is it?
Comment on this
I ask for a binary answer from Ms McNally, please. Is it credible to say that because of medications and because of this, that and the other, the medical age requirement has been increased by five years, yet Bus Éireann still insists on this and the Department is tendering to that company?
Comment on this
What is important here is that we look at international evidence on this. My opinion on it does not matter. The international evidence says-----
Comment on this
I would have thought the international evidence-----
Comment on this
-----was more important when it came to the medical and road safety aspects.
Comment on this
Deputy, school bus drivers are driving buses that carry up to 52 or 53 children and young people. That is a significant responsibility.
Comment on this
They can drive for a private operator, as long as they are not on the school bus run, at 80 years of age and carrying 54 or 55 children.
Comment on this
Again, I have looked at the research from Finland and Canada, as well as what the Road Safety Authority is saying.
Comment on this
It would appear that Ms McNally is more intent on reading than she is on dealing with facts.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, a significant issue within our Departments is incompetence-----
Comment on this
-----because when you apply the facts Ms McNally is speaking about to the actual facts on the ground, they make no sense. I would have thought Ms McNally, as the Secretary General, would have understood that, because one Department does not know what the other is doing with regard to driving and driver safety.
Comment on this
Ms McNally's Department is the one that is charged with the school transport system, however. It is causing very significant issues for the working parents and the taxpayers in this country. The buck should stop with you because-----
Comment on this
I am happy that it does. I am very happy about that.
Comment on this
Well, you are not being proactive in doing anything about it; you are just waffling.
Comment on this
Waffling and repeating insignificant facts.
Comment on this
I ask you not to do so.
Can we clarify this point regarding who makes the decision about the over-70s? My understanding is that private bus drivers can go beyond the age of 70. Ms McNally mentioned that Bus Éireann decided this. Is it Bus Éireann or the Department?
Comment on this
This is the policy of Bus Éireann, which operates the scheme on our behalf.
Comment on this
Chair, I have been aware of that fact for ten years.
Comment on this
We constantly discuss that with Bus Éireann. We have interrogated why that is its position, and it is about the 52 children and young people. It is a significant responsibility. Also, they are doing this for five days a week on early mornings and afternoons. If I am 71 and have bad eyesight, I might choose not to go out in the lashing rain or in fog, but school bus drivers-----
Comment on this
Ms McNally does not seem to understand that a 75-year-old driver who is driving a 52-seater can arrive at the school to take a tour to Dublin but cannot get the children from home to school.
Comment on this
This is an issue for working parents.
Comment on this
We have a new member of the committee, Deputy Cannon. He is very welcome. He can take the next slot if he is ready to do so, or he can wait a little while.
Comment on this
I am more than happy to take the slot now.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and I thank the administrative support team behind the Committee of Public Accounts for its very helpful induction over the last few days. I am delighted and honoured to be a member of a committee that does exceptionally valuable work.
I want to follow on from the most recent discussion about school transport. Over the last couple of years, I have received numerous representations from school principals and people who are involved in the school transport industry in my own constituency of Galway East, on the issue of the driving limit for the over-70s, if we want to describe it as that. My initial reaction is very similar to that of Deputy Verona Murphy in that it seems logical to extend the opportunity for people to drive school buses beyond the age of 70.
As one driver put it to me, he can drive schoolchildren in a 50-seater bus to a hurling match at 72 years of age but he cannot drive them to school at 72 years of age, and we must bear that in mind. I took the time, as I always do, to conduct a lot of research on this matter. I spoke to a lot of people in the industry and looked at the international research not alone around school bus driving but also around the piloting of aircraft. All of the research would seem to indicate that a person enters into an age of high risk post the age of 70 from the perspectives of a driver and a pilot, where a person is personally responsible for the lives and the safety of a number of other human beings. My initial reaction was the wrong one. Now, having looked at the research, I firmly support Bus Éireann and, indeed, the Department in how they approach this issue.
I urge anyone who is intent on making a well-informed decision on this policy matter to look at the conclusive research that there are significant risks post the age of 70 applying to people who are responsible for the lives of others. As I said, driving is an exceptionally important role. As a parent, one hands over responsibility for one's child's safety to one individual. If the international research shows that individuals run a risk - perhaps a small one - of not being capable or-----
Comment on this
Fine Gael's policy is anyone over 70 years should not drive any bus. That is chaos.
Comment on this
Sorry, I ask members to respect the Chair. One person has the floor. Members were not interrupted when they spoke. We must allow Deputy Cannon to speak as he is a new Deputy on the committee. Please continue, Deputy Cannon.
Comment on this
I remind members of the committee that it is not for us to question matters of Government policy. We are here to assess the appropriation accounts that are before us.
Comment on this
Members should only speak through the Chair.
Comment on this
If we were to question Government policy, then the meeting would descend into a debate every week.
Comment on this
Deputy, this is not Government policy.
Comment on this
Every member has his or her own ten-minute slot, Chair.
Comment on this
Deputy, it is not Government policy.
Comment on this
Deputy Cannon has his ten minutes. He is a new Deputy here. It is his first morning and I want to be fair to him and to try to be balanced. Sometimes other members stray into policy a little bit and I try to give them a bit of latitude.
Comment on this
We have never had another member interject within someone's time. That does not happen.
Comment on this
I do not want anybody interjecting. Deputy Cannon has the floor. Deputy Cannon, without interruption.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat. I encourage others to read the research.
Yes, the school transport system is under incredible pressure. It always has been and always will be. In terms of being able to accommodate the maximum number of children, and at a time when we are focusing on all of the climate change and climate action requirements and responsibilities that we have, the system is going to become an ever more important element of the Department's policy and, indeed, the Government's policy in general.
The town concessions that were made in allowing for children attending their second nearest school at post-primary level to access school transport were an exceptionally positive development. Is it the intention of the Department that that would be bedded in permanently in school transport provision in the future? Has an analysis been done as to how it might apply at primary level? There will be significant additional costs attached but I know from being a representative of a small rural community, and living in a small rural parish, that there are times when children living within that parish can access school transport going to schools outside of the parish but because of the geography of the parish, they are not entitled to transport within their own parish. That situation can at times dissolve or break down that sense of community and togetherness of rural parishes and, indeed, perhaps urban parishes. I know that this aspect causes a lot of concern at times for both the principals of those schools and the parents involved. Are there plans to permanently bed in the town concessions into the post-primary system and, second, to extend it to the primary system?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for his question. My colleague Ms Conduit will comment in a moment. The school transport review 2030, which the Minister has just published, proposes to recommend to the Government that we continue to invest in the school transport scheme so that by 2030 there will be another 100,000 children and young people on it. That deals with the question that has been asked. The review would give children and the young people's families access to other schools that they might want to attend. The limitations of the nearest school or next nearest school would have moved on and would reflect preferences, and we talked about preferences earlier. It would extend the eligibility to various schools and the distance criteria would be significantly reduced as well.
Interestingly, in respect of the review, the cost of extending the scheme to 100,000 children and young people is neutralised in some way because the review proposes far greater integration, wherever possible, with public transport routes. If we keep going the way we are going then the school transport scheme will cost over €600 million by 2030. If we reform the scheme and expand capacity to these extra 100,000 children and young people and integrate with public sector transport, if we give families of children with special educational needs more choice and if we continue what we are doing in special educational needs to have more special schools closer to people and have more special classes in their local communities, then we will not need to spend so much money on children travelling long distances. It will be a matter for the Government over the next few years as to whether it can deliver on the proposals in that review.
Comment on this
I am sure that the wonderful people in the building unit in Tullamore are more than aware of the consistently strong case that I have made for the provision of a sports hall for an increasingly large school in Seamount, Kinvarra, in south County Galway. I am perplexed by the approach that has been taken and perhaps somebody can clarify the matter.
At a time when we need young people to focus to a huge extent on physical activity, and again all of the international research shows that, you bed in a lifelong commitment to physical activity at a very young age. If that opportunity does not arise, then it is lost forever. Second, and sadly, at a time when all of the statistics point out that children are becoming more obese and are involved in less physical activity and at a time when girls, more so than boys, seem to leave the world of sport and physical activity in their mid to late teens, we should focus hugely on maximising the opportunities for young people, particularly in post-primary schools, to involve themselves in physical activity and physical education. Seamount College is a school in south County Galway. It has received very significant investment over the last ten years, and rightly so, because it needed to be brought into the 21st century in terms of the facilities available. For some strange reason, a sports hall has not been made available to the school. Initially, when I asked why that was the case I was told that there was a policy in place that schools do not receive sports halls during their refurbishment or redevelopment phase and that there might be an opportunity at some point in the future to provide a sports hall. That reply does not make sense because a school that is located 12 km away in Gort received a sports hall as part of its refurbishment. Also, a school in Loughrea, and rightly so, has received a sports hall as part of its refurbishment.
When I tabled a parliamentary question on this matter I was told that 21 schools across the country over the last five years have received exactly that. What is the policy? If it is a case that there is some sort of a resource management issue around the provision of sports halls, can that be addressed? When are we likely to see, not alone in Kinvarra but in every other school we seek to refurbish or redevelop, sports hall provision becoming a normal part of that refurbishment?
Comment on this
I will say two things and then my colleague Mr. Loftus will comment. As the Deputy will know, the Minister of State with responsibility for sport has a role in the Department of Education. He has a role as regards physical activity and physical education.
Comment on this
It is increasingly important for us, as a Department. We are expanding the active school flag scheme as we got additional funding to expand the scheme to more schools. The new primary curriculum has a greater focus on PE and Mr. Loftus will follow up by discussing the facilities.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for his question. The Department very much values PE halls and, equally, general purpose, GP, rooms at primary level. We see the role they play in the school itself and in the wider community and in supporting community life as important.
From the Department's policy perspective, we provide PE halls as part of new school builds but we also provide them as part of large-scale refurbishment and extension projects. The school to which the Deputy referred would not have been in either of those direct categories.
Since 2020, we have delivered or are in the course of delivering 54 PE halls across the country between projects completed, at construction and earmarked to go to construction, which we recently announced in April. In terms of GP rooms, there are approximately 100 that are at construction and that have been completed over recent years and going forward over the next year and into 2025. We are, therefore, doing a huge amount of delivery in that area. It is very important. The additional accommodation scheme is focused very much on core classroom accommodation. Certainly, from a PE hall perspective, it is important to recognise in terms of our database on information that the vast bulk of post-primary schools have GP room and PE hall facilities and there is a small cohort to pick up. We are picking up that cohort as part of our school building programme. Certainly, we see that as important going forward. However, there is a lot of delivery being done currently as well.
Comment on this
To continue that line of questioning, if a school currently has no PE hall and is not in line for large-scale refurbishment or a new building, how does it secure a PE hall?
Comment on this
When we look at statistics and things like that, we see that 90% to 95% of post-primary schools have a PE hall. Therefore, we are looking at-----
Comment on this
It is of very little use to the school if it does not. How do schools without a hall secure a hall?
Comment on this
They secure it where there is a new build or as part of a large-scale refurbishment extension project, and that is-----
Comment on this
They do not want a new build and they do not want a large-scale refurbishment project. They just want a PE hall.
Comment on this
Then, where the school is in good condition otherwise and there is not a need for a new school build or large-scale extension refurbishment, they would be looked at as part of our overall national development plan, NDP, priorities and roll-out going forward. We are conscious from a Department perspective at this point in time we have put a lot of focus on special educational needs, SEN, delivery and core classroom accommodation. They are key priorities. Along with that and as part of our roll-out, as I said earlier to Deputy Cannon, we are actually achieving through our project roll-out quite significant progress in terms of PE hall delivery.
Comment on this
It is just that I am dealing with one particular case, which I do not want to go into because the school has other issues as well. The officials think that the only way they are going to be able to secure a school hall is by pairing with a local GAA club and applying for sports capital grants. It seems crazy that Government funding is there but they are now going to have to engage with an outside entity that will give control over elements of the school building or school campus. It is a real gap. Mr. Loftus said it will go into the overall NDP priorities. To be honest, that sounds like a category for the miscellaneous. There needs to be a specific programme. Let us identify the schools that do not have it to see how many there are and give them a process. I am not saying that everybody would get it in the first year. I know of a school that is 50 years old. It is in good condition. It has lots of positives. It is a great school, but there is no hope for it ever having a PE hall. That just seems like a failure in policy.
Comment on this
I will make a couple of points. It would be Government policy to support school clubs, local facilities, the GAA or whatever, linking in with schools as well. That is important. The Minister-----
Comment on this
The schools cannot bring anything to the table. That is the problem. The GAA club can bring community money. The sports capital grant can provide money. However, the Department of Education and the school are bringing nothing to the table.
Comment on this
I would not underestimate the value and importance of a school site in facilitating that.
Comment on this
That is important in Dublin and in the Deputy's area. The Deputy will be familiar with that.
Comment on this
However, the Department is losing control when that happens.
Comment on this
The Department of Education has less control over a building over which it has 100% ownership. In any case, it was a continuation-----
Comment on this
It is not about ownership. It is about usage. There are many examples-----
Comment on this
There are many good examples whereby full usage to the school-----
Comment on this
I was continuing Deputy Cannon's line of questioning. I think everybody in the room can see there is a policy gap there. I ask Mr. Loftus to reflect on it.
Comment on this
We are operating in the context of the last few years of massive demographic growth and special educational needs. It is, therefore, a little bit about prioritisation. We do not disagree with the Deputy.
Comment on this
-----but it is about prioritisation as well.
Comment on this
What the Department has identified is a gap. It is not a priority; it is a gap. I am saying the officials should reflect on it and come back to us with a solution.
I want to focus on three areas if I can get through the next couple of minutes. I was delighted to see the school secretaries programme through which secretaries were taken onto the payroll system for the Department of Education. It provides security. It treats them equally with other professionals within the school campus. Unfortunately, I believe it has created an anomaly around the ancillary grants.
Five schools in my area have basically had their ancillary grant deducted because the school secretary salary has been effectively deducted from that grant. They now have to employ a caretaker, who is the other beneficiary of that grant. The five figures I have for a caretaker are €8,300, €7,800, €1,800, €8,500 and €10,000. None of those schools will be able to secure a full-time caretaker for that figure. There is a problem in the way we have applied the reduction to the ancillary grant. That is my first comment.
It feeds in then to my second comment. All the schools I talk about are large schools that were built in the 1950s and 1960s. Demographics have changed. They do not have the same number of pupils in those schools, but they have huge school buildings. The ancillary grant is based on capitation. We have, therefore, caretakers in huge sites in very old buildings who just cannot meet the needs. Equally, the capitation grant for the school is based on pupil numbers. There is something we have to do, which falls into the category we just talked about. On the north side of Dublin, there are a huge number of old schools that were built in the 1960s. We cannot provide new school buildings. It would not be environmentally beneficial to do that either. However, we are hamstringing them because they have a reduced number of pupils per capita. Sometimes, they have a reduced number of pupils because of other challenges they have in the area. There might be large issues in the area around DEIS and so on. Therefore, we have to look at those big schools that have low numbers of pupils and at the capitation grant. Separately, however, we absolutely need to do something immediately on the ancillary grant because caretakers are going to be laid off.
Comment on this
I will come in on that. The Deputy is right; that is a very live issue. He is right to welcome the work on the secretaries. That was a complex piece of work because I am afraid there are many legacy issues in our education system across the 4,000 schools, and many different arrangements for secretaries. It took us a while to get them on the payroll. They are on the payroll, however, and it is a great development. It is complicated, but that is live and we are working through that at the moment. Basically, schools that might be left with very little would have been getting a certain amount of ancillary money to cover secretaries. The schools told us how much and how many hours, etc., they were paying for the secretaries and we made calculations based on that. There are now some issues arising. Therefore-----
Comment on this
In some cases, more hours were being allocated than were-----
Comment on this
We made our calculations based on what we were told, but-----
Comment on this
In reality, however, a commitment was also given that the school caretakers would also be taken on to the payroll.
Comment on this
Absolutely, and they are going to be and we are going to be working through that. Therefore, it is-----
Comment on this
Is that likely to happen by September?
Comment on this
No. It will take us time. We are absolutely starting the work on caretakers, but I do not think they will be on the payroll this September. We are starting the work with them, however. If the Deputy does not mind, I will mention something.
Comment on this
We understand that schools have pressures. There was €90 million given to help them with the cost of living back in 2022. There was €60 million last year, and €21 million extra is going into their base from this September. I would also encourage schools that if they are having specific difficulties, and I know the Deputy is talking specifically about caretakers, they should go to the financial support services unit, FSSU, that we operate if they are in extreme difficulty.
Comment on this
I met with the school principals and I have a list of suggestions. For example, we need to handle insurance better. There is much more co-operation that could happen around insurance. Much more co-operation could happen, and I know it does, around the group purchase of electricity and utilities and so on. We could be supporting schools to reduce their costs a lot more. There is value for money for the Department there as well.
Comment on this
There are a lot of frameworks in place and we are continuing to work on that.
Comment on this
A school principal is the CEO of a very large organisation. Even on a school building project, for example, the amount of capacity hours a school principal puts into managing emergency works for the summer is huge. Sometimes it is very lonely at the top. The more schemes we throw at schools, while it is support of a kind, they need to be administered and managed. On costs, for example, we could be more proactive.
Comment on this
On the school building front there are supports out there. There are design teams, project managers, building officers and some of the management bodies that help with them. We are putting frameworks in place. There is a school procurement unit in the joint management body. We are trying to help principals as much as we can. We respect their role.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Loftus for last week's announcement regarding the Scoil Chiaráin special school, one of two schools. It is welcome. I argue it took a little too long to announce it, but I appreciate it. It will make a massive difference. It will also help to address the issue. We have opened 19 ASD classes in Dublin 9 and Dublin 11 over the past four years at primary school level but have only opened three at secondary school level. Somebody in the Department needs to look at the demographic flow there - 19 classes will not fit into three classes. While an additional special school will help with some choices, the whole system with the SENO needs to be reviewed. The choice parents have at primary level is important. Parents can send their children anywhere they want. It creates problems, but it is beneficial. However, for children with disabilities it adds to the anxiety. One parent told me they applied to 60 schools. I told them there is no need to apply for 60 schools as they will find a place, but they have no confidence because between September and April or May they have no certainty they will have a place. They have had to fight for every other service and believe the same effort has to be put in at primary school level. We need to review the SENO system. I would go for a central application system. I also believe we need to look at the demographic flow into second level.
Comment on this
I will start and then call in Ms Mannion. We recognise what the Deputy is saying, and that is why the National Council for Special Education received an increase of 50% in its funding. It will go from 73 special education needs organisers to 120 by this August. Many of them are being placed this month, but some will come in August. We recognise that families need support and should not have to apply to lots of different schools, so the NCSE has a role in legislation to reach out to families and help them access a school place. We are doing a huge amount.
On post-primary, we wrote to principals in post-primary schools in October 2022 to say we were planning for every post-primary school to have four special classes. We wanted to write to them proactively to say this is coming. This is what we are doing, and we are in the process of arranging for that to happen.
Comment on this
In addition to the new special classes the Deputy talked about in the area, there will be 30 new special classes across Dublin for September 2024. That is in addition to the 71 new special classes we put in last year. Some 23 of those special classes were at post-primary level across Dublin.
The Deputy mentioned forward planning. The special education unit, the planning and building unit and the NCSE spent an extensive amount of time on forward planning. We took a strategic look at where children at post-primary were coming from. In looking at that, we found that approximately one third were coming from special classes at primary, one third were coming from mainstream primary and one third were coming from within the post-primary system. The other thing we looked at with the NCSE was not just school planning area by county and then bringing it up to the national level. The bulk of children going into special classes are eight or nine years of age. We need to continue massively delivering special classes at primary level. The bulk of children coming into special classes at post-primary will be coming in the next number of years. Mr. Loftus and I work intensively every week to ensure we have that forward planning place available, so we have had more than 100%-----