We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Vote 26 - Office of Minister for Education

Contributions 201–399 of 604. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

To be fair to the Chair, I think I am way over time. Am I correct in saying a figure of 25% of the total education budget is now being spent on special education?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

It is 26% of the budget, which is €2.7 billion.

Comment on this

The witnesses are welcome. I start by asking about the Mercy Convent in Naas, County Kildare. The school build started in 2017, the year the current sixth class started school, and the school will not be completed for another two years. Is that the longest there has been? The school has no PE hall as a consequence of being accommodated in prefabs. There is somewhere in the region of €400,000 per year being spent on security for the site. It looks from the outside and from a distance like the school is completed, but it is the fit-out and the internal work that need to be done. When does the Department expect the school to be open? Are there other situations where security is being paid for or is it normally the contractor that provides security as part of the contract?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask Mr. Loftus to come in on that, but by way of introduction I will say that what happened there was regrettable for everybody - the children, the families and the local community. It is rare that such a dispute arises. In that case, we know the board of management had to make the hard decision to terminate the contract. That school was, and is, the subject of an ongoing dispute.

Comment on this

Is it the only one?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There is a small number.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Disputes, conciliation and things like that are rare. It would be quite unique.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We are talking about the 2022 accounts. You can, for example, have disputes in the scenario where there is examinership or liquidation. We had zero-----

Comment on this

Will Mr. Loftus give us numbers or an example?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We had zero such cases in the 2022 accounts, the year we are looking at. The bulk of our school building projects work smoothly, get delivered and these types of scenarios-----

Comment on this

I understand that. I am looking for the ones that do not. That is what we are here for.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I have been head of the planning and building unit since October 2017. For these types of scenarios, I would be looking at low single figures. That is notwithstanding the hundreds of projects we deliver overall.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Loftus give us a note on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Absolutely, I will.

Comment on this

Is it usual for security-----

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I also make the point that in that particular scenario the Department, representing the State, took a strong and proactive approach where a project was not being delivered to our satisfaction. We represented the State's interests to make sure the school building project is ultimately delivered, and that required a termination of the contract.

Comment on this

I understand that. Windows on-site had to be replaced because they were left out in the weather. It had to be sealed. It has been quite a saga and the ones who have paid the biggest price are the children. It must be the most expensive school when you take on board that prefabs and security have had to be paid for. Is security normally included in the contract, or is it an exceptional situation to have to pay almost €400,000 per year while the site has been sitting there? Will Mr. Loftus focus on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I am conscious there is a live dispute, so I need to be careful of what I say in the public domain, but I am also conscious of being accountable to the public accounts committee. The Deputy asked about normal security scenarios. The normal scenario involves a contractor going on-site. Whether it is a school or any other building, it is responsible for that site. It takes ownership and control of that site.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

The contractor does the security. The security scenario referred to by the Deputy is one whereby the contract has been terminated. The security that has been there-----

Comment on this

I will stop Mr. Loftus there because I have a number of questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It is an important point to make.

Comment on this

I have a number of questions I want to ask, and I have little time. Will Mr. Loftus provide the committee with a note of situations where security is paid for, separate from it being included in the contract? We can look at that then.

The Department said it plans years out. County Kildare is growing rapidly and gained 25,000 people between the two most recent censuses. We have obviously had some engagement about the difficulty people are having securing school places, and we have been given an assurance that they will all get a school place this year. I am sure the witnesses will reiterate that, and I hope they will. To use it as an example, children may well get a school place, but they may not be told until June or July where they will be going to school. The applications for the school transport system have already closed.

Where students do not get a place, how does the Department provide for their school transport?

The briefing material contained a section on the climate. Does the Department consider climate at all in terms of the provision of places? I ask because where students are allocated a place it will not be located close to them. I will use the example of children travelling from Enfield to attend a school in Maynooth but there are children who cannot get into that school in Maynooth because there is a sibling policy. Children or young people cannot get into their closest school due to the criss-crossing of locations, just to provide school places. One can see the chaos the policy causes outside schools. It is not just the traffic chaos the policy causes. The policy means one parent must leave his or her job because his or her child must be brought to school because he or she is concessionary, which means that child or young person is not guaranteed a place on a school bus. Where does that policy come in at all?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Mr. Loftus might want to comment and I ask Ms Conduit to comment on school transport. Obviously, the school transport review is making recommendations that we expand the scheme, so it is not about the nearest school or the nearest to that but about our accommodating more choice that reflects the real life for families, and working families.

Comment on this

What about concessionaries?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

If we implement the whole review there will not be such a thing as "concessionary" and more people will be eligible unless they live an extremely short distance from the school. The review will assist with some of that. As the Deputy will know, we provide children with special educational needs with transport whatever school they attend. I ask Ms Conduit to comment on the issue of late applications.

The climate is a big feature of school planning. It is a case of minimising the distance children and young people must travel. We know there are problems in some of the red zones mentioned by the Deputy, such as Wicklow and Kildare. We absolutely appreciate that. I ask Mr. Loftus to comment on that first and then Ms Conduit.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Earlier there was some discussion on forward planning and I heard the point the Deputy made about Kildare being an area of significant growth. Forward planning is embedded in everything we do from identifying need and engaging with local authorities, in how we design schools and deal with the climate, in the large pipeline we have and in our very strong track record of delivery.

Comment on this

It took 45 months from the appointment of a design team in March 2012 to complete the Temple Carrig School in County Wicklow. The school sought an extension and a design team was appointed in 2021 but the school is still at the first stage 37 months later. People at the school estimate it will take them six years from beginning to end to add an extension whereas it only took half that time to build the school.

Mr. Loftus has talked about a pipeline. Does the Department ration the different stages of build by budget? Does the Department not let projects progress from stage 1 to stage 2? Does the Department look at the budget the whole time? I ask these questions because it feels like that is what happens. It takes an inordinate length of time to build and in locations that have a rapidly growing population the lead-in time is incredibly long. These are very big projects and the Department needs to do them right. There have been scenarios where projects have not been got right. How can a project that is urgent get stuck at design stage for so long that the Department must provide prefabs? Such a policy adds to costs.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We have about 1,400 projects in our pipeline at different stages. We manage them and prioritise based on need. We prioritise special education and special schools. SEN capacity is a key issue for use to prioritise and focus on. They are particular projects that will move forward.

Comment on this

Every application means there is a new school or extension needed. Please tell us more about that priority.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

That priority ultimately pans down into the additionality that needs to be provided in particular areas to add to capacity. The Deputy referenced the Temple Carrig School and it is in early design. St. David's college in the same town is a recently completed project. Greystones Community College is a huge 1,000 pupil flagship project. A letter of intent has been issued and a letter of acceptance is to issue shortly. Kilcoole, which is the neighbouring school area, has a project in late design. We are adding huge capacity when it comes to forward planning.

To give a sense of the scale of what we are delivering, out at construction currently, there is €1.2 billion worth of projects. There is 350,000 sq. m of accommodation being provided in terms of construction recently completely and another 200,000 sq. m. being added. That relates to the equivalent of nearly 7,000 primary classrooms and if one were to place them back to back then it is nearly the equivalent of 7 km of accommodation. That is huge delivery, strong delivery and very strong forward planning.

Comment on this

We have a growing population, so the Department must be ahead of things.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Yes but it is an important point in terms of an evidence base of real progress, real delivery and making a real difference to school communities right around the country.

Comment on this

I thank our guests for their presentations and briefing documents. I do not intend to be especially negative but as we are discussing this business of forward planning, essentially what we are hearing is there is nothing to see here and move on. All of us know the situation from different representations we have received. By way of example, one should never talk about policy based on a specific instance. A family moved to my constituency and they needed a school place for one child in third class. I could not find them one third class place all across east Waterford. In Tramore, a brand new school was built and an extension was added a year later. Therefore, people cannot convince me forward planning is happening when the Department needed to extend a brand new school. Similarly, I have been told there are no demographic pressures within Tramore to create new school places, yet I can see the houses, in their hundreds, going up. The analysis being done does not look at houses that will be completed in the very near future. That does not satisfy forward planning, as far as I am concerned.

Ms McNally mentioned there are 314 school planning areas and ten of them have been identified as being under pressure. Will she confirm whether the Department has committed to the ten places? Ms McNally probably has the information at her fingertips.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We can come back to that, yes.

Comment on this

It is a real issue. I want to ask about the modelling the Department uses in respect of the provision of special classrooms. We are seeing a lot of response to demand. If there is a demand for special classrooms, then the Department may or may not provide them. Again, I could talk about Tramore but I will not at this point. We have discussed this issue but I am not sure whether that was done by the Joint Committee on Autism or the Joint Committee on Education, Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science. What modelling does the Department use to forward plan? I ask because need is predictable. It should not be a case that the Department must respond to demand because parents rocked up. Instead, we should be able to look at population and plan for that.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will go back to where the Deputy started, saying that maybe there is a suggestion from the Department that we address the needs of every single child and that there is nothing to see here. We acknowledge there are problems and I do not want to suggest otherwise. In terms of systemic failure, it is my responsibility to point out that for the vast majority of children-----

Comment on this

That is not the language I used or would use. I do not think there is systemic failure. I think the vast majority of children in our school system are well provided for and I reiterate I did not use that language.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

As regards the third class child the Deputy spoke about, that is a terrible situation. I am not sure if the family has been in contact with the educational welfare service but that is a service that works with children who do not have a place and finds them a place. In addition to contacting the people around this table, there is the educational welfare service in Tusla, which is a service that is under the remit of the Department. It is the statutory role of the service to help a child to get a place.

In terms of the modelling for special education and special classes, we work proactively and do not just respond to children who arrive at the door. Earlier I gave an example of post-primary schools. We wrote to them last October 12 months to say we are planning and suggested they need to plan with us for four special classes in every post-primary school. The Department has a geographical information system in its planning and building unit, which is where we look at census data, child benefit data and whatever. We map the location of special schools and special classes so we work proactively.

To go back to some of the climate and travel issues we were talking about earlier, we are trying to ensure that we will have access locally all over the country. There is a huge amount to be done. Prevalence rates are rising. There is no definitive rate around prevalence in the Department of Health or in other Departments but we are forward planning for more than has been in the statistics to date.

Comment on this

There are international examples of prevalence rates, particularly with autism, and we have no reason to think our population is different.

I was not going to go there but as Ms McNally raised the issue of climate, I will refer to an issue that I raised with the Department at the education committee when we were discussing the public sector performance report. What the industry calls scope three emissions are not factored in by the Department in its siting of schools. I raised this previously. Ms McNally mentioned that the Department works in association with local authorities but we are not planning our new schools as active transport nodes. We discussed this in 2023. It is not the case that we site a new school and build an active travel network around it. We do a lot of retrofitting, which is much more difficult, and we often end up with bad quality transport infrastructure. What that also means is that we have an ingrained transport practice. Again, I go back to the example of Tramore. We built a massive secondary school with one road in and one road out. It is the only place in Tramore where one will hit traffic and it is absolutely insane. Poor quality active travel infrastructure was put there. When one considers the enormous investment of the State when we are building new schools, the fact that we are not proactively, in any meaningful way, engaging with local authorities to establish them as active travel nodes is concerning. I am also concerned by the fact that the Department does not consider scope one emissions. When we talk about climate, we talk about building NZEB schools, which is fine, but we are not considering the emissions arising from travelling to and from school.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We have a very strong and clear roadmap in terms of climate. We published that last year and we are making a lot of good progress in terms of the strategic planning in relation to-----

Comment on this

I am sorry to interrupt but we do not consider, as part of that roadmap, emissions as people travel to and from school. Am I correct in that?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It is part of something that we look at. It is part of something that we are conscious of, as part of the wider scheme of things. When we look at climate we look at the school building, which is one part of it. As part of the active travel, we do a lot of good engagement with local authorities around that. There are obviously limitations. Most school projects are done at existing schools, so there are limitations around that. Beyond the building side of things, in the climate piece we recognise the important role that schools play in terms of their school communities and what we can do there. There is the curriculum area in relation to that.

Comment on this

Yes but we need to be properly planning the active travel infrastructure. We can look at all the behavioural things that we like but the actual hard infrastructure has to be there, particularly when we are talking about children, whether at primary or secondary. We can lecture to people all we want about how 14-year old children should not be in a car going to school, but if there is no safe, segregated cycling track, parents are not going to let them out on their bikes.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

In the discussion earlier about school transport, active travel was a feature of that in terms of the school transport review. In our approach in terms of climate, we do a lot of engagement with the relevant Department and the SEAI. Our approach there is guided by that, by the roadmap and Government policy around the climate action plan.

Comment on this

I am sorry to cut in again but ten minutes is incredibly short and I have a list of questions as long as my arm. I am not buttering my own parsnips here but I want to talk about Gaelscoileanna in Dublin 2, 4, 6 and 8. I raise this because I have a passion for the Irish language. The people of south Dublin need a Gaelscoil but they are not getting one. There is a problem with the model under which schools apply for patronage and the Department also seems to be moving in the direction of extending existing secondary schools rather than building new schools. I am not going to ask a question on it but want to put the point across to our guests.

I want to come back to the Comptroller and Auditor General's special report on school transport from 2017 and the section on operational meetings. There was a considerable deficit identified there. Do we have a comprehensive service-level agreement in place now with Bus Éireann, which was not there previously? In those operational meetings, we did not have things as basic as terms of reference for the meetings. We did not have advance circulation of management reports. There was no evidence that discussions were taking place in relation to budgets and the actual cost of the school transport scheme. The finance reports were in bullet form with little detail. Has there been significant reform of these operational meetings in response to the Comptroller and Auditor General's report?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I thank the Deputy for asking that question. We would say that there has been full implementation of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report. In fact, we have gone even further. For example, we introduced the service-level agreement that was recommended but we have since replaced that with an even stronger governance structure of a performance-delivery agreement and an oversight arrangement. There are very strong governance arrangements in place now. We actually increased the resources in that unit so that we could improve the operations on the governance side while also looking at reform, implementing the review and so on. There are monthly meetings with detailed minutes for them now. Detailed financial and operational data is provided by Bus Éireann. We got an external person to help us to develop a template for what exactly we should be looking at in the financial returns and the process now is fairly forensic. We have an accountant working on the team who looks at these on a monthly basis. We believe that everything is being implemented.

Comment on this

If I get a second opportunity to ask questions, I will raise a range of different subjects but I have one final question on school transport for now. The Department's own briefing note refers to pilot projects for 2024 and 2025. I would like a little bit more meat on the bones on that, including the possibility of integrating with public transport services and so on. The other point I would make is that we are in May 2024 and we are talking about this being rolled out in September. We are talking about communicating with parents, telling them how they should apply and informing them of what the changes will mean. That seems to me to be a very short time period if we are actually going to meaningfully implement pilot projects. Is there something our guests can tell us about the locations? Have we a mix of urban and rural locations? What is the population catchment size that we are looking at in these instances? When will we get to view, in detail, what these pilot projects are going to look like?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Everything the Deputy said is true. We had to open the scheme and see what the application levels were around the country and get a flavour of that. We needed that information before doing this. There will be two pilot schemes. Work on them is advanced. Clearly, we are not working in isolation. We are working with Bus Éireann, the National Transport Authority, and the Department of Transport. I cannot give the Deputy any information on them at the moment. I respect what he is saying about families needing notice but the Minister will be announcing details of these projects shortly and we will, obviously, be reaching out to the families who may wish to opt in and take part in these pilots. Unfortunately, I cannot give the Deputy the details today.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We are going to take a break for ten minutes.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I thank them for the briefing documentation they supplied.

A number of issues and points have already been raised and made by my committee colleagues, especially around school transport. One particular issue crosses with special needs education. There is an ongoing issue with transportation to St. Augustine's School in Blackrock. A combination of school buses and taxis is being used. However, as the witnesses will appreciate, when the service is not reliable and there is a change to parents' routine it has huge ramifications for a family. Will the Department look at that? I know it is aware of the issue, but it is ongoing. I will leave that point there.

On special education and the summer programme, I note from the information the Department provided that 51,000 children availed of the summer programme, which is an increase of 111%. A lot of changes have been made to that programme. However, there are still challenges with offering it in some schools. What are the Department's plans for the summer ahead to try to incentivise more schools to participate in this much-needed programme that has been a great success but is not available to all families?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will answer the question on the summer programme. We will look at the specific school transport issue raised and come back to the Deputy. We have significantly reduced the number of issues with special education transport.

The summer programme is important for children, young people and their families. We have put a huge amount of time and investment into it. We have seen radical increases in the number of children accessing it in the past few years. We focused on getting more schools as we would like to see every special school offering it as well as lots of mainstream schools. We have invested significantly to get more schools involved, have had some success and continue to work on it. We have put in a lot of improvements over the years. We have a national co-ordinator now who is working with them. We have added leadership roles in the schools so that the principal does not always have to do all the work. We pay organisers and managers to do it. We also looked at the best way to get more staff. Parents want their children to go to the special school they go to for the rest of year. Where possible, they want the children to be with the staff who have been with them for the rest of the year. We appreciate that teachers and SNAs need a break in the summer so we have looked to see how we can incentivise more of the local staff to be part of the summer programme. This year, we changed the funding a little to be able to give staff their personal rate of pay, not the first increment, in order that they get what they are paid for the rest of the year. We have taken a number of initiatives to encourage and support the programme. Will my colleague Ms Mannion add to that?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

It has been a huge success. We had 13,000 children participate in 2019. That number increased to 50,000 in 2023. The number of schools participating reached 1,400 last year, which is up 12%. The registration portal for schools for the 2024 summer programme is closing tomorrow. We had 1,441 schools last year. I am pleased to say that 1,696 schools have registered already this year. There are a few new additional things which will help significantly. We have a special-school placement from the third week of May to the end of the programme whereby schools can take two graduate teachers and final year professional master of education, PME, students. That will bolster the special school capacity for the people running the summer programme. We hope those teachers and staff will get a feel for working in a special school environment and that the special schools will be able to retain them after the summer. We have a small but significant partnership between Munster Technological University and special schools in Kerry, whereby the special school staff will be supported by the university staff to develop programmes and we are trying to extend that.

The personal rates of pay Ms McNally mentioned have been instrumental in getting the number of schools up, as have the two additional roles. The organiser is the person who works on the summer programme before it happens and the manager is the person working on the summer programme, but not the teacher, who supports it while it is happening.

Comment on this

I thank Ms McNally and Ms Mannion for the comprehensive update. I hope the measures outlined will further increase the provision of the summer programme.

On the point on teachers who do not work during the summer, some of whom have to sign on, is there any engagement between the Department of Education and the Department of Social Protection to try to formalise and modernise the process? It is time-consuming not only for the individuals concerned but also for the Departments.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I am not sure whether the Deputy is aware that we recently introduced such an IT scheme. We work closely with the Department of Social Protection on a way of electronically exchanging data.

Comment on this

It is an age-old problem.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Yes, absolutely and it has been addressed now and it will-----

Comment on this

Briefly, how does it work now?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

In the past there were a lot of manual application forms-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

-----and data being filled in on them. It is an electronic system now. We share information with the Department of Social Protection using a digital system and vice versa. It is much easier for the teacher.

Comment on this

Is the teacher still required to present at the office?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I am not sure. Can I come back to the Deputy on that? I will get someone to answer that.

Comment on this

Yes, that is no problem.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Actually, Ms Mannion can answer that.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

It is an IT solution that is transferring real-time information between the two Departments. It works for school staff who are employed on a casual or substitute basis with jobseeker's benefit. Basically, it has reduced the need for payroll staff to manually complete the forms and return them to the school staff. Potentially, 100,000 forms were being completed each year. There is now a real-time solution for what was taking six to eight weeks.

Comment on this

That is great. It is welcome.

I will turn to prefabricated buildings, an issue that was raised by colleagues earlier. I will give an example from my constituency, of Gaelscoil Phádraig in Ballybrack, which has been waiting for almost 30 years. It is not all the Department's fault. It is also reliant on another school being built for Ballyowen Meadows Special School so there is a chain of issues. However, the eye-watering figure for the leasing and purchase of prefabricated buildings by the Department was mentioned. Some of them are past their sell-by date and being replaced. Where the Department has a site on which it could develop a permanent building, why has that not happened? As I said, for Gaelscoil Phádraig there is light at the end of the tunnel but it is taking a while to come through. In a broader sense, on a national scale what is being done to phase out the leasing and purchase of prefabricated buildings? I heard what Ms McNally said earlier, that there is a place for prefabricated buildings in a modern context for school facilities. However, at Gaelscoil Phádraig it was meant to be a temporary school on a temporary site and 30 years later it is still waiting. Perhaps Mr. Loftus will respond to that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

To put the national picture of rentals of prefabricated buildings and modular accommodation in context, I will make two important points. It represents about 4% of the Department's capital programme so it is a small element of it. Previously, we provided to the Committee of Public Accounts the list of schools that had rented prefabricated buildings for longer than five years. The number was 396 schools. Through our forward planning and delivery that figure is now 212 schools. The bulk of the remainder are in a pipeline for delivery. We are strong and being proactive. Purchased modular accommodation is modern and positive and we see it as an important delivery mechanism. Government policy on modern methods of construction is all about adding capacity to the construction sector, which is important for delivery. Certainly, we in the Department value that. We have a strong framework in place which provides climate-friendly solutions, including timber-frame modular solutions we are proud of.

Comment on this

Where the Department has access to a site, such as with Gaelscoil Phádraig, and 30 years later the prefabricated or modular buildings are still being replaced, that is nonsensical. Surely the Department's building unit should view that site as providing an opportunity for a permanent school.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

On Gaelscoil Phádraig-----

Comment on this

Mr. Loftus is aware of the case.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Yes, I am aware of the case. It is related to the special school projects that are under construction and good work is being done in those. That will ultimately provide the solution for Gaelscoil Phádraig.

Comment on this

I am talking about across the country where we have temporary solutions for a school rolling on for 30 years. Surely the Department takes a look at those temporary sites with a view to utilising them on a more permanent basis with more permanent structures.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Absolutely. That is what we are doing. That just reflects the scale of delivery that we are achieving. The figures that I quoted there in terms of rented solutions give a sense of the direction of travel that this is going. It is all very positive work.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Loftus for that. The issue of Gaelscoileanna was mentioned earlier and south County Dublin in particular. There is a huge demand for Gaelscoileanna in south County Dublin which is wonderful for education through the Irish language. In Cherrywood where the new town is being constructed, a number of schools are planned. I know a Gaelcholáiste is proposed there, which I would support. What is the timeline for a decision on patronage?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We are very much aware of that Cherrywood development. As part of that and our engagement with the local authority, we would have earmarked and reserved sites for that. We have built a 24-classroom primary school there. It is very much in its infancy with enrolments, but we are actively planning our roll-out in tandem with the housing roll-out. The housing roll-out has been slower than was envisaged. That is progressing and we are working on that. In terms of that-----

Comment on this

My question is specifically on patronage. I know about the building but-----

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

There are a number of schools. I think ultimately around five schools will be part of that development. We certainly see the Gaelscoileanna as part and parcel of that.

Comment on this

For the third time, what is the timeline for a decision on patronage?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Our timeline is not a fixed timeline at this point. I am conscious that we already have very significant capacity to meet current needs-----

Comment on this

In the existing schools.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

-----in the existing schools.

Comment on this

I know the sites are earmarked, but even if the building is constructed, will patronage be determined before that happens?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

These things generally work in tandem. We will work that through.

Comment on this

I presume the Department will be coming back to that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Absolutely. There was some discussion about forward planning earlier. This is where we are ahead of the game in terms of our school placement capacity to serve that development. We have an eye towards rolling that out further.

Comment on this

My last question is on the home-school liaison officers, a very important role. How is the Department's engagement with Tusla evolving?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The home-school liaison is a really important service. I think we have about 528 of them across 600 schools around the country. They are increasingly important with some of the problems young people are experiencing with well-being and so on. That part of the Tusla service is now under our Minister. We engage with it very regularly on the home-school community liaison, the school completions programme and the educational welfare officer service, which I mentioned to one of the Deputies earlier. We have very regular engagement with it. As the Deputy knows, we are looking further at DEIS at the moment. The OECD is finalising a review with its recommendations on the future of DEIS, and home-school community liaison will feature there. It is also very important with the Traveller community enrolment. We have funded some extra HSCLs on that.

Comment on this

Ms McNally might send a note to the committee on that.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Is that on HSCL generally or on-----

Comment on this

On home-school liaison generally.

Comment on this

I echo what Deputy Devlin was saying on home-school liaison. Some schools were lucky enough to be included in the DEIS bands following the recent review, but others were very disappointed. There is a particular social need in Youghal in County Cork and what happened with DEIS - to which I will return in a moment - was rather perplexing. Beyond DEIS allocation, the provision of a home-school liaison service to schools is critical in communities with that acute need. I would like to see further emphasis on that.

I am a bit perplexed about the allocation of the DEIS status. Obviously financially it is quite expensive for the Department to do it. I acknowledge it results in a reduction in the pupil-teacher ratio and the other additional benefits that come with that allocation. We have three primary schools and one post-primary school in Youghal. Following the review, despite all of them being in the same Pobal index, one of the schools got it on appeal and the other three did not. It was a primary school, the smallest of the three. The secondary school also missed out on it. I come from that area, which is economically challenged. I was mesmerised as to why one was given it on appeal and the other three were just ignored. It is often discussed here in the PAC when officials from the Department of integration and others have been before us. That town with a population of about 8,000, took on 1,000 migrants with the sale of the Quality Hotel. Per capita, it has one of the highest concentrations of IPAS and Ukrainian refugees. It is a space for families, so there are a lot of children involved here. That was not included in the analysis. I would like to get an insight from the Secretary General on that.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I thank the Deputy for his question and for acknowledging the importance of DEIS around the country. I will focus on DEIS in a minute. As the Deputy will be aware, there are children with disadvantage in schools that do not have DEIS status. A number of services and supports are put into them, things like reducing the average class size to 23 over a number of budgets, 2,000 extra English-as-an-additional-language teachers going out into the system, DEIS and non-DEIS. A number of supports are being put into place in every school. As regards DEIS, 1,200 schools have DEIS status. One child in four is in a DEIS school.

The Deputy referred to instances that happen in local communities where some schools are in and some schools are out. We know that causes massive frustration and people question why this might happen. The Deputy will understand that when there is a precious resource like this, we must have a system to do this objectively and as fairly as possible. The Deputy knows the background - we use the Pobal HP index, which has a formula for calculating it. It looks at the 19,000 special small areas. It uses census data. It looks at the profession, if any, in the family and the number of people in the family. It looks at all of these factors and then shows us where there is concentrated disadvantage. We then layer on top of that Traveller, Roma, homeless and international protection data and it identifies for us which schools should have DEIS status and which do not. On occasion, some schools lose out even though they may feel they have the identical profile to the school next door.

All we know is that the system - we have to have a system - is saying that there is a differentiation even though it might not be huge. That is the model. Nothing that any of us does is perfect. We continue to look to see how we can improve it. The OECD is working with us at the moment to see if there is a better identification model and how we might improve upon this. We are not the only Department that relies on the HP index. The Departments of Social Protection, Health and others also use it.

Comment on this

What really gets under my fingernails on this issue is the fact that this applies even in a small town. It would be different if it were in the city centre, where there is obviously huge difference. On any one street, there could be different financial circumstances, depending on the household. I think there are two brackets of Pobal index in Youghal. Even though the exact same base of data was being used, one of the four schools got DEIS status on appeal and it was the smallest of the four. I felt the Department was trying to take the cheapest option, ignoring the other three. That included the one secondary school, which was an amalgamation of three. I think it is wrong.

Youghal is one of the most affected areas in the country given the migrants who arrived in 2022. Those schools took on that burden. I have not seen anything of note from the Department to give additional resources to those schools. The need has now increased dramatically. With towns that have large centres, Youghal being one of them, many Ukrainians have gone home. Others have been moved to those centres. Youghal has one of those facilities, with almost 1,000 people. Where there is a major IPAS centre with over 500 or 600 people, no differentiation is made for that.

That community needs a heap of support but what is also happening is that other migrants are coming from a multitude of different countries to the centres, which accommodated Ukrainians primarily. Arguably, you could make the case that Ukraine was a pretty developed country prior to the war and that the needs of Ukrainians were not the same as those of IPAS immigrants or asylum seekers seeking accommodation. Families in the latter categories come in with nothing. The communities are now taking on the additional need. The Department, as part of its work, needs to say that, in respect of the circumstances in question, DEIS should be part of an emergency response. That is what I want to see from the Department. What occurred in Youghal really annoyed me. I raised it with the Minister on a number of occasions but apparently nothing can be done about it. I am really annoyed that the secondary school, which is arguably taking the heaviest burden, and two primary schools were just left out.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

As expressed by the Minister regularly, we are extremely grateful to all the schools that embraced the community coming in and did so with a sense of urgency. We may be able to get a report for the Deputy on what resources have gone into the area, if that would help. Whether the schools have DEIS status or not, we did put in 2,000 teachers of English as an additional language over recent years. A significant number of additional teachers have gone in to reflect the number of additional pupils. Teacher numbers in the schools would have increased, or, if a school was about to decrease numbers, it would have retained teachers. There are additional special education teachers and SNAs. Obviously, capitation then followed. In some instances, schools were able to access support from the planning and building unit for extra accommodation. NEPS has been available. We put regional teams into the ETBs and they worked with local schools. We do acknowledge what the schools have delivered and we will get the Deputy a report, if that would be helpful.

Comment on this

May I ask Ms McNally one very reasonable question, considering the circumstances? Would she visit Youghal?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I will extend an invitation. It would be good for Department officials to go there. I realise it is an unprecedented request to civil servants at a committee meeting, but it would be good to go down and see what it is like for one urban centre to have major accommodation centres for people – now asylum seekers – and how this impacts the schools, and also see the good work being done. I do not want to take away from the latter.

I want to use my limited time, if that is okay. Is Mr. Loftus still in the building unit?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Yes. It is an interesting job.

Comment on this

It is. I want to take my hat off to the Department after having been in Carrigtwohill Community College last week. It involves the largest capital investment ever made by the Department in the construction of a single complex, for two primary schools and a secondary school. After many years of lobbying and campaigning by the community to get the schools built, they are now built and look fantastic. Well done to the Department on that. It is good work. It took a long time but we got there in the end.

There are schools that have been given resources by the Department for the construction of sports halls. Some of them have been funded. There are schools that have been built in the Cork city area that have been provided with sports halls through additional investment or capital investment, but there is one in Mitchelstown that cannot get one. It is unclear why. PE is now on the leaving certificate curriculum but sports halls are not subject to the mandatory investment of the Department of Education. Regarding the case of the CBS in Mitchelstown, could Mr. Loftus look into how decisions on allocations for sports halls and where they go are made? Could he help with that particular case? The school authorities are very passionate about getting a sports hall. I can see the merit in an investment. It seems a biteen unfair that some schools get sports halls while others do not. Is this something Mr. Loftus could work with me on if I bring the case to his attention?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I am conscious of time at this committee meeting. We discussed the approach we take earlier with Deputy Cannon. We are doing a lot of PE hall delivery as part of our project roll-out. This is done for new schools and large-scale refurbishment and extension projects. Let me give the Deputy the national context, although I know he has a local remit. Since 2020, my job as head of the planning and building unit has entailed a national remit covering 4,000 schools. About 54 PE halls are being delivered. I am referring to projects being completed, in construction and going to construction over the course of this year. We are delivering a lot and prioritising core classroom accommodation as part of our additional accommodation scheme. Certainly, we are very conscious that some schools do not have PE hall access but over 95% of schools either have a hall or have one nearby. That is the territory we are in.

Comment on this

If I bring the case to Mr. Loftus’s attention, is it one he could look at for me to see if there is wriggle room?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Absolutely. As civil servants, we are here to serve the public and meet the needs of the Oireachtas Members. Any Oireachtas Member is free to give us information on any project.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Loftus.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Let us stay with the building theme for the moment. We have had conversations about faulty school buildings in the past but I want to revisit the matter. I will try to keep my questions short and it would help if Mr. Loftus kept the answers pretty brief as well. On how many buildings with faults has remediation been done in the past ten, 12 or 13 years?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Again, I am conscious of legal cases related to a particular issue.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

How many overall? The question has nothing to do with legal cases.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

The buildings represent about 1% of the school estate and probably about-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We are talking about 40.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Forty of the school estate and about 2% of the projects we delivered over the years.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There are about 40 schools. What was the expenditure to date on these?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

By way of context, these issues arose in October 2018, or quarter four of 2018.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I know that. There was a particular group of buildings. I am looking for a rough answer. I do not expect Mr. Loftus to have the exact figure. Roughly how much did we spend? Was it €30 million, €40 million or €50 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

The bulk of the expenditure was in the early years of the emergency period as we worked it through. In total, the expenditure was €260 million-odd, and the bulk of this expenditure was in the earlier years.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

In the past ten or 12 years, the Department spent about €260 million on remediation works due to faults.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It was to address the issues from structural and life safety issues but, importantly, it also included future-proofing the buildings in terms of climate improvements. In the particular case before the courts, the proportion in that regard was estimated to be around 30%. When you look at the global-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

How much?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Thirty percent of that-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Are the 30% still before the courts?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

The point I wish to make, if given an opportunity, is that about 30% of the expenditure was classified in the Ardgillan case as pertaining to improvements. That figure has not been classified for the other expenditure because the matter is before the courts, but it gives a sense of scale in terms of where things are at.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is what I am trying to get at. The expenditure is around €260 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

From the Department’s perspective – again, I am conscious of issues before the courts – we took a very strong programme approach to addressing the issues. Life safety and safety-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will come to that in a minute. Of the €260 million, how much relates to the Department and the public purse?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

That will ultimately be determined by the courts because-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

At this point, what is the percentage of the €260 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

The Department has carried that amount itself.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The full €260 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

-----but it is very much being claimed in the courts, obviously discounted for the improvements, including climate-related improvements, we are making in the schools.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I understand it if there are add-ons for climate-related improvements.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

But the add-ons are within that figure.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am trying to get the figure for remediation where there were faulty building works. There are 40 schools. How many construction companies are we talking about?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It was one design-and-build contractor.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

One.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It obviously would have subcontractors in the context of build and also of design.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The last day Mr. Loftus was here, this issue came up and I said that, while I did not want to be old-fashioned about it, I was struck by the fact that the response from the Department stated there is a design team and that the design team protects the interests of those individuals – in other words, the architects – employed on the project to oversee the interests of the school, the Department and taxpayer.

In these cases, there was obviously a fall-down. The design team, project team, or whatever we want to call it, did not do it. There was not a person who was calling to the site unannounced. I am saying this again and I want to know what has happened since. It is approximately two years since Mr. Loftus was before the committee. Is there now a technician or a clerk of works in place? It does not need to be anyone super-duper but Mr. Loftus and I know the fault in respect of many of those projects was that the wall ties were not put in. Where there are two rows of blocks, wall ties should go between them. You do not need to be a block-layer or builder to know that. Anybody who has ever stood on a building site would know that. They are an absolute requirement on any construction project. What measures have been taken since to ensure that the project teams employed by the Department and the schools have a technician or a clerk of works? Local authorities have clerks of works. I am not trying to be hard on anybody here but the issue would not arise in any of the local authorities with which I have dealt. Where local authorities are building new houses, a clerk of works calls regularly to ensure everything is being done properly, including the mixes and construction methods. Any shortcomings will be spotted and rectified. I am asking a straightforward question. Since the last time Mr. Loftus was before the committee, what measures have been put in place to ensure we do not end up here again? We are talking about €260 million and if the State is caught for even half of that - and it could be caught for €200 million - it is an enormous sum of money because of very simple mistakes. What has the building section of the Department done since then?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I am again very conscious of the matters that are before the courts.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mr. Loftus, please.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I am answering the question.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am asking what measures the Department has taken. New projects are ongoing. I have spoken to Mr. Loftus outside this forum about new projects, and I welcome all the new developments. I have been raising other developments with him. We do not want to have to come back to discuss developments that are happening now. We do not want whoever comes after us to be here in ten years' time saying that such a situation is continuing. Very simple oversight should be in place. What has the Department done since?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We have a range of quality assurance measures in place. They have been enhanced. Since 2017, there have been clerks of works on projects and that provision is continually being enhanced. For the design and build programme, the procurement strategy has a bigger focus on tier 1 contractors, for example. The quality control measures required by contractors are more clearly and explicitly set out.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is Mr. Loftus able to give the committee a commitment? This is our job, on behalf of the taxpayer and those who put us into these Houses. Will Mr. Loftus give me an assurance that there is now a clerk of works or a person with similar qualifications doing spot checks?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Yes. All of our large-scale projects have a clerk of works. We would have also contacted the smaller-scale projects, costing up to €1 million or more, to make a clerk of works available. We see that as important. As a general point, the primary responsibility rests with the contractor. There are design teams that carry out inspections, progress meetings and all of that. The clerk of works is an additional element to that and not the sole element.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We in this country learned one hard lesson during the Celtic tiger period. Some good work was done and some awful work was done. We cannot rely on contractors and developers alone. There has to be oversight. That was the case with private development and I am talking here about public development and taxpayers' money.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I accept that.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We cannot have such a situation. I welcome the commitment Mr. Loftus has made in respect of small and large projects. It is important that unannounced and regular checks take place. Clerks of works in local authorities are like busy bees. They go around and call unannounced regularly, sometimes on a daily basis, to check stuff. It is so important for the quality of work. Local authority houses that were built 50 years ago would not be knocked down with a bulldozer. The ones that are being built today are high quality. We have to get these big capital projects to the same level to ensure we are not getting caught. I welcome the fact that assurances have been given. That is important.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I will make some general points. We very much welcome clerks of works on our projects. Sometimes it is not as easy to get them-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

-----as it was in the past. We are looking at initiatives to help in that regard. The Cathaoirleach talked about wall ties issues and other things. I spent a day in the witness box giving evidence and being cross-examined, and the issues are not as simple as they have been portrayed. There is quite a bit of complexity.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Wall ties were one of the issues.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

They were one of the issues but there was a range of them.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Such omissions should not happen.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

In court, the contractor accepted responsibility.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I have some other questions about buildings and the school hall or sports hall issue. St. Fergal's College in Rathdowney has applied for a hall. There have been meetings with Ministers and Department officials. Some of the witnesses were at those meetings. The school is growing in size because there are Ukrainian and international protection children in town. St. Fergal's has had planning permission for a new hall for the past ten years. The permission has been extended and extended by the local authority. New classrooms have gone in, which is good, and I acknowledge that. Great work has been done by the Department in that regard. However, the missing piece remains. The answer we have been getting is one that has been heard by other Deputies. The answer, similar to an answer given to me by Mr. Loftus, is that we will have to wait until the next phase of the national development plan. Is the answer "Yes" or "No"?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It depends on the project and programme. I know the Cathaoirleach referred to a particular one but for a new-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

What is the case for St. Fergal's?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

For a new school now, it is a "Yes". For a new school now that has a large-scale project in train, it is a "Yes". For other schools that are not in that space, it is a "No" today but it is in the pipeline and it is something we will work with.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We also work with our colleagues in the Department of Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform, on the funding pipeline, going forward, to facilitate-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There are increasing numbers now in St. Fergal's. There is no sports hall in south Laois. It is not just that there is no sports hall in that school but there is none in that part of south Laois. A whole one third of the county is without an indoor sports facility. I ask Mr. Loftus to come back to the committee on that point.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We will come back to the Chair on that issue.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I also want to ask about modular building at Kolbe Special School. I have raised this matter over and over again. Ministers have come down and films and videos have been made about it. At the moment, the accommodation works have been held up and there have been different delays over the years. The staff and parents are challenged. I visited that school when the pupils were there. The staff have a very difficult job as they are dealing with people with high needs. The prefabs that have gone in are of a good quality. I am not going to knock the fact that those prefabs have gone in but we must think about what has happened. Temporary classrooms have been put in because the building dragged on for so long. If the builders were able to get onto the HSE site around the corner more quickly, we would not have to spend on temporary accommodation. We seem to be spending a lot of money before the job starts around the corner on the HSE land in the next field. I accept that temporary accommodation is sometimes required and the Secretary General made that point. I accept that it is better to have temporary accommodation than no accommodation but it makes even medium-term planning difficult. The former Minister for Education, Deputy McHugh, was down there in 2018. At that stage, it looked as if the project was going to advance but it did not. I make that point.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

On Kolbe Special School-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Just tell me where that project is at now.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

The project started with a design team being appointed at the start of 2019. Between 2019 and 2022, it went through design. In 2023, it went through tendering.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I know all that. I asked about now, Mr. Loftus.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

During 2023, we did enabling works. They were completed in April. We did the letter of intent and acceptance for the permanent school project. We expect that project to be on site this coming Monday.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Next Monday. That is good news. What is the timeline for completion? I know it is in the hands of the contractor and I do not want to put Mr. Loftus on the spot.

Roughly what time does he expect?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I would expect it to be in late 2025.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The other question relates to Coláiste Dhún Másc. We have spoken about forward planning and so on. There is a huge need for places at secondary level and at primary level, which we will come back to later in the context of Portlaoise. What is happening with Coláiste Dhún Másc?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

That is a project we have devolved to the ETB. Joe Cunningham is the chief executive there. It is a project that is in design. We can come back to the committee, if the Chairman wants, with timelines around that project-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Please do.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

-----but it is an important project, adding capacity. The Chairman referenced Portlaoise particularly but if we look across the county of Laois, and equally Offaly, the other part of the Chairman's constituency, we see that both counties are in decreasing mode in terms of primary enrolments. In terms of forward planning, therefore-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Has Mr. Loftus been in Portlaoise lately?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I am talking about the county overall-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

New housing estates have mushroomed around the place.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I am talking about the county overall. I acknowledge the issue in Portlaoise, and we are dealing with the patrons there in respect of the capacity needs in that regard.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay. We will come back to that.

Comment on this

I want to come back to what I was addressing with Ms McNally with regard to the NDLS and the ridiculousness of the fact the medical requirement is at 75 years of age, but what she has put to me are the excuses the Department is being given, except in the case of Bus Éireann. I will read from the Department's own website. It quotes the Minister of State, Deputy Naughton, as stating, "People who are 70 years of age or over can now apply for, and renew, their driving licence without the need to submit a medical report [until they reach the age of 75]". It goes on to quote Professor Desmond O'Neill from the national office for traffic medicine, in supporting the change, as stating:

This change is welcome in terms of recognising that older drivers are an exceptionally responsible group of drivers. In addition, the change is supported by international research indicating that routine medical screening of older drivers is not only ineffective but may actually unintentionally increase injury and death among older people as pedestrians.

That is a contrary international research study, but the statement comes from the same Department. I ask Ms McNally to exercise her own, practical knowledge. Many of these children are being collected, especially at primary school level, by their 80-year-old grandparents, for the lack of a bus driver. I am going to be dead frank. If I were Minister for Education and the Ms McNally came to me, as Secretary General, with that waffle, she would not be sitting where she is today, and that is as frank as I am.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I must ask the Deputy to treat the witnesses with respect.

Comment on this

I am treating them with respect. I am just being frank. I am saying that if I were in the Minister's position, I would not listen to this for two minutes. There is no question.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I am happy to answer the question.

Comment on this

I am stating the facts with regard to contrary evidence.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Can I respond? I know Professor Desmond O'Neill.

Comment on this

I do not have time. What I expect Ms McNally to do-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There is an answer to the question.

Comment on this

The Minister is now saying that, on top of the review, she is going to get the Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan, to look at the over-70s rule.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Deputy, to be fair to the witness, I must allow her to respond to the earlier question.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I worked with Professor Desmond O'Neill previously. He is a huge advocate for older people, and much of his research and commentary is about older people driving their individual cars where they get to choose whether they go out in foggy or rainy conditions, in darkness or light and so on. As I said previously, we are talking about driving buses with potentially 52 children and young people moving around-----

Comment on this

I am sorry, Ms McNally, but the extension of the medical requirement is for all professional drivers, not just people over 70 who are-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I am talking about Bus Éireann's position, and it is Bus Éireann's position-----

Comment on this

Bus Éireann's position in any other realm would be ageist and discriminatory, and I am so surprised Ms McNally is continuing with this line even though there is international evidence contrary to the excuse Bus Éireann is giving to the Department. That is why we do not have proactive people. The officials do not seem to be able to exercise their own brains. They accept what they are told, contrary to the evidence for what they are doing. One hand in the Department of Transport does not know what the other hand is doing. That was not an answer. It was trying to justify the Department’s own inaction. We are without school buses because we do not have drivers, and that is why it is so ridiculous to tell me the same driver cannot take the children to school but can collect them from the school and bring them to Dublin on a school tour. I ask Ms McNally to please not let herself down and to use her brain. This is ridiculous stuff and the only people suffering are parents, who are under huge pressure to work to meet the cost of living, most of it inflicted by the Government, and Government TDs come to these committee meetings-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Deputy, we are not going to get into policy.

Comment on this

We were not going to get into policy until it was raised.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We can raise that in the Chamber.

Comment on this

Grand. The point is that the people suffering are the children, because their parents are having to leave them waiting while they finish work, sometimes at 5 o'clock, to collect them from school. It is causing huge antisocial behaviour problems and worry for parents.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I would say there are 7,400 vehicles on the road-----

Comment on this

I was not expecting Ms McNally to respond.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

-----and services are being provided to 163,000 children.

Comment on this