We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Vote 26 - Office of Minister for Education

Contributions 400–604 of 604. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Do we have a shortage of buses?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We do in some instances.

Comment on this

Do we have a shortage of drivers?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We do in some instances.

Comment on this

Could Ms McNally accept and listen to what I am saying?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I am listening.

Comment on this

Does Ms McNally accept what I am saying?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There is other evidence. Bus Éireann bases its position on the Road Safety Authority, which is also familiar with that evidence.

Comment on this

Now Ms McNally is back to defending Bus Éireann. This is the same Department that has extended the medical requirement. Ms McNally's whole premise is that Bus Éireann has said medical evidence is what determines whether someone over the age of 70 is unsafe.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I talked about the context of 52 children and young people------

Comment on this

The Road Safety Authority is the body that recommended we remove the medical requirement. Ms McNally should not tell me to read research if she is not reading it herself. This is contrary evidence. In this Department, two reports seem to say conflicting things about the same issue, and Ms McNally is trying to justify this now in light of the Department’s own inaction. A total of 46 children in Kilmore and almost 50 between Gorey and Ferns have no mode of transport to school for next year. I ask Ms McNally to try to resolve that; it is her job.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I think that some of the children in Kilmore whom the Deputy is referring to had not applied for the school transport scheme, but I could be wrong.

Comment on this

That is because they were not eligible in the first instance. This is about why a bus was put on in Kilkenny for ineligible children at the drop of a hat because a party colleague of the Minister had asked for it. I have not got the answer from Ms Conduit today. Even though she knew I had made inquiries, she still does not know whether there are three buses on the route or two.

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

To clarify, three buses were approved for Callan. They were approved in October and it took until March to procure one of the buses, and a contractor stepped back. Now, for operational reasons, there are two buses - the Deputy is quite correct - because the demand has reduced for that route.

Comment on this

Ms Conduit is telling me, therefore, that we are able to accommodate on two buses the additional students who require there to be three buses. How or why would the demand have reduced? What would give rise to that?

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

I am sorry but I cannot say why. I just know demand has reduced.

Comment on this

How long was the third bus put on for?

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

I think it was put on and a contractor then withdrew its services, so there had to be another process to get the bus. I cannot answer the Deputy's question exactly.

Comment on this

I have contrary information to the effect it was a Bus Éireann bus and that after a week, all the children were accommodated on the empty seats of the two buses that were running. Does that sound correct?

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

That would be the normal course for concessionary children. Where there is additional capacity on a bus, they would be accommodated. There is nothing particularly unique about that-----

Comment on this

What is unique is that the same scenario arose in Kilmore last October but no bus was put on.

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

As far as I understand, and I know we have requested further information on this, those children had never applied for school transport.

Comment on this

Is Ms Conduit referring to the children in Kilmore?

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

The Deputy referenced Kilmore. We did go back seeking further information on whether it was Kilmore village or Kilmore Quay. As far as I know, most of those children had never applied for school transport-----

Comment on this

They did. What happened was there was a private operator who withdrew his services, and they were not-----

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

I am aware of that. That is very unfortunate for those families. I acknowledge that.

Comment on this

Of course it is very unfortunate, but these are all working parents.

I am not here to argue how unfortunate it is. I am wondering why it is one rule for one and it is not the same rule for everybody unless, it appears, you are a TD colleague of the same party as the Minister.

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

Can I just clarify-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is a political row that will have to be had.

Comment on this

That seems to be what is happening.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I ask the witnesses to clarify it briefly and we will then move to Deputy McAuliffe.

Comment on this

I have one more question because the Chair allowed Ms McNally in with no information.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Very briefly.

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

It is not unique. A large number of concessionary children are accommodated on school transport every year. There are eligible children, children under TAMs and children who would be under TAMs but the school may be full. A large number of concessionary children are accommodated.

Comment on this

I am concerned with the large number of children who are not being catered for and whose parents are working and contributing to the tax take of this country. There seems to be no understanding.

I have one other question.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It will have to be very brief.

Comment on this

On the accounts, I want to know what the prepayments were. There was an advance in 2021 and 2022 to Bus Éireann. In 2021, it was €8,990,000 and in 2022, it was €13,244,000. Why would we be making advance payments to Bus Éireann?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask Ms Conduit to come in on that. I assure the Deputy that we give Bus Éireann the amount of money that is deemed appropriate. Sometimes, there is a prepayment. It is an agreement that we prepay it but we look at the funding on a monthly basis and there is a very strong forensic process. It only gets the costs that it has incurred, and the Deputy knows that it operates on a cost-recovery basis only.

Comment on this

For school transport.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

School transport, yes.

Comment on this

So you prepay. Does Bus Éireann prepay the independent contractors that it hires?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I can check. Does Ms Conduit have that detail about the prepayment?

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

As far as I am aware, €6.1 million of that was for the waiver of fees that was introduced for that year, so that would have been prepaid upfront. As Ms McNally said, at the end of the year, any surplus is returned to the Department and to the Exchequer, so the prepayment may be in terms of providing for the fee waiver or for other matters, but it is not additional funding above and beyond the allocation.

Comment on this

What are the accrued expenses which doubled in the year 2021 to 2022 to just short of €8.5 million? What are the accrued expenses?

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

The €6.1 million relates to the fee waiver.

Comment on this

That is included in the other expenses. What are the accrued expenses at a rate of €8.5 million?

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

I am sorry, I do not understand the Deputy.

Comment on this

The accounts refer to Bus Éireann’s accrued expenses.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I understand Mr. Whelan has the figure to hand so he might deal with this briefly.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Whelan

I will go back to the prepayment first and then deal with the accrual. The prepayment is made up of two elements. A total of €7 million of it is due to the balance owing to the Department following the end of 2022. There is a schedule of payments that we pay to Bus Éireann. It is agreed for the year and those payments are paid out. At the end of the year, Bus Éireann has its accounts audited and we find out what the balancing payment is, and that can vary from year to year. When we have the final accounts, we know there is a prepayment after the year-end and we get that money back in the following year.

The reason the prepayment increased to €13 million in 2022 compared with 2021 was because, as a cost of living measure, a fuel contribution was made to the contractors for the increased costs. That was €6 million and it was approved by the Government to give that advance payment to Bus Éireann to pay the contractors.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Thank you. I call Deputy McAuliffe.

Comment on this

If I were to ask for an update on payslips, would that be enough of a question for me to get an answer before we got into a row about it?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We can give the Deputy an update. There is some positivity there. On several occasions, the committee has raised the fact the Department was still using paper payslips. That was because we were introducing a new IT payroll system that there had been problems with. We went out to tender and that tender failed. There was not sufficient interest and those that came forward did not meet the quality standards.

The good news is that we are availing of the Government's digital postbox and some 33,000 teachers and SNAs have signed up to receive payslips digitally. That was only introduced last year and we are seeing a couple of thousand teachers, SNAs and so on signing up every month for that. We will be continuing to promote it and there is a promotion campaign to encourage more teachers to do that. When we have the new scheme, that will be-----

Comment on this

It is an opt-in system at present.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Yes, it is at the moment. As the Deputy knows, to avail of the MyGovID digital postbox, people have to have a public services card. The Deputy is aware that it is not compulsory and you cannot force people to have a public services card, but many in the population are choosing to do so. At the moment, we are relying on that but it means people have the right to continue to have a paper payslip.

Comment on this

What was the cost of payslips for last year?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

We spent €2.9 million on payslips last year for the 3.35 million payslips that were posted. I will go back to some of the issues that the Deputy raised with the Secretary General. When we introduced the digital postbox in September 2023, 19,000 people availed of it; by the end of November, we had got that up to 25,713; and by the end of January, it was up to 27,547.

Comment on this

From what total payroll number of staff?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

There are 144,000 on the payroll.

Comment on this

We have a long way to go.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

We have a long way to go. I might add a couple of things. We are very conscious of the fact that, as the Secretary General mentioned, it is an opt-in piece. However, we are working intensively with the teacher unions and the Retired Teachers’ Association of Ireland to ensure that we promote this. We have information notes going out about signing up for these payslips. We provide details of this to people as they come on board, we provide training to new school staff, we are emailing the schools, we have updated our content on MyGovID and we are using the press office.

Comment on this

I take that on board. Essentially, we have a payslips bill of about €3 million per annum, which everybody in this room accepts is not an efficient use of public money, and there is more printing on top of that, as well as postage.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

The Department is not charged for printing, the cost of paper or the cost of envelopes for those payslips.

Comment on this

Who pays for that?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

Our payslips are printed and posted by the Revenue Commissioners printing service.

Comment on this

It is paid by the public purse. Let us not get into that, as it is a different area. My point is that there is a cost of €3 million. In 2020, a figure of €10 million was given for a multi-annual period and postage has increased over that time. This problem is only getting worse in terms of the postage costs.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We will phase it out. For example-----

Comment on this

To be fair, I have allowed the witnesses a lot of time to talk about this so let me respond. The figure went from 19,000 to 27,000 and the witnesses are now saying it is in the mid-30,000s. That is over the space of the last two or three years.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Just since last year. It was introduced last year.

Comment on this

It is an incredibly slow take-up. My understanding is that it involves the teacher first making an application for a public services card, which often involves them doing it on a day when they are not working because that is how it operates. Is anything being done with regard to the public services card in order for teachers to be able to access that service within the school?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

The Department of Social Protection intends to launch online registration for the public services card later this year. It is engaging with the Data Protection Commissioner and it has indicated to us that the online application process will, hopefully, be available in June. That will facilitate-----

Comment on this

How did the Department design a system that left it dependent on another Department to implement it?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There are a couple of things to say. We also operate the payroll for ETBs and all staff in the ETBs get their payslips via email. That is our intention. It is our vision that we move that type of system over to the rest of the payroll in non-ETB schools and that is what we will do. That is what we had planned to do a couple of years ago but the major procurement of the IT system failed. That is something that has happened elsewhere in government as well, so sometimes these big procurements for IT systems-----

Comment on this

When Ms McNally says “failed”, she means it was not possible to secure the solution that the Department wished.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We did not get a successful tenderer to introduce the system so we have to go out to the market again.

Comment on this

When it went to the market, no one applied.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We had a number of applications but, ultimately, none of them made their way to the final quality check. We would have been working very closely with the OGCIO and that was part of the peer review.

Comment on this

The prequalification elements excluded them through the process.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Through the process, they were eliminated. We had to make that decision.

Comment on this

This is not rocket science. Issuing electronic payslips happens in millions of organisations around the world. It is not rocket science.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

No, it is not. It was absolutely our intention to replace this a couple of years ago but, unfortunately, as I said, that system collapsed. As I mentioned, we have the biggest payroll in the country. The HSE might be about to bypass us shortly but, for the moment, we are the biggest payroll.

Comment on this

The biggest payroll and one of the last employers to come to electronic payslips.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

As I said, our ETB staff are getting their fortnightly payslips electronically.

Those 33,000-----

Comment on this

Why was it possible for ETB staff to transfer but not the staff of other patron body schools?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We have two systems. We have a system in Blanchardstown that is our ETB shared services and then we have our Athlone payroll for everyone else. The ETB shared services were ahead in their IT projects. The Athlone IT system was bigger and more arduous. There have been learnings. The OGP had a big tender like that fail as well. Many of the IT companies now want us to buy off-the-shelf products whereas we are looking for a customised product. We have teachers working in different schools and working different hours. There are many variations.

Comment on this

Have there been any discussions with the trade unions? They would welcome discussions. We have to stop wasting public money on postage right now, not next year.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We are encouraging the unions to encourage their staff to sign up for MyGovID. There are many other advantages offered by the latter. For example, it can be used to apply for a driving licence.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that the unions are blocking anything.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

They are not.

Comment on this

What I am saying is that the Department needs to do far more. There will be many interventions over the course of a year, such as in-service days, different things and so on. This is a major priority. Some €3 million could be spent on all of the other things we talked about.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That €3 million is diminishing.

Comment on this

Is postage not increasing?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The cost of postage has absolutely increased.

Comment on this

If the Department does not solve this, it will only get worse.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

First of all, when we get our new payroll system, there will be digital payslips. While we are awaiting that, we hope to have more and more sign up to-----

Comment on this

I have 18 seconds left. At one of my first meetings as a member of this committee, we dealt with the Department of Education. This was the issue that day. I have been here for five years and the Department has not solved the problem. Please deal with this matter before the Department of Education comes before the 34th Dáil. It is a major failure in the context of an issue that could be solved very simply.

Comment on this

I wish to come back to a couple of issues, one of which is capacity in schools. The Department builds new schools. It knows the areas that are growing and have expanding populations, yet the schools being built do not have additional capacity. The upshot will be that prefabs will be required after a school is built because perhaps there is not another site available and it takes so long to get through the process. That would have been the case with Greystones, which I mentioned, as well as Naas. What is the thinking in respect of that approach?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

On managing capacity, that is part of our overall forward planning and overall delivery and design. We are working that through.

Comment on this

Sorry, where is the forward planning when it is known that a school is fully subscribed and the Department is building a new school but not adding to the capacity even though the area is growing in population?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We are conscious of the roll-out of housing, which is a driver of school places. We align with that as best we can. There is a lead-in period with the delivery of projects. We have a structured stage approach to those. That is there for a good reason, which is to ensure they are well designed and well delivered.

Comment on this

There is no capacity for growth, however, even though the Department knows the areas are growing and have expanding populations. I refer to areas like Fingal, Kildare, Meath, south Dublin and Wicklow. It is not new that they are growing; rather, they have been growing and there has been a pattern of growth for decades now. Why would the Department not factor that in when looking at capacity?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We do. Looking at Kildare, we invest hugely in it as a place where there has been a great deal of growth in terms of the number of houses built. We added much capacity there with primary, post-primary and special schools. We are opening a new special school in September.

Comment on this

I will stop Mr. Loftus there. I know these things well. A site in Celbridge under the control of NAMA was identified in 2017. There is St. Raphael’s special school. These are the most vulnerable children. It is not a question of adding an extra classroom to an existing school; rather, this is one-to-one care. The school is falling down around the staff and pupils. St. Patrick’s primary school has been located on a GAA field since it was established. It is a full school that has been operating in prefabs since it was established. Celbridge Community School is also located on a temporary site. It is fully built, with not an inch of extra space available. As stated, the site was identified in 2017. There were problems with acquiring it. We do not even know when it will go to planning. The Department will be paying for temporary and substandard buildings in all of those cases. The most substandard temporary building is used for the children with the greatest need in terms of just how compromised they are. Is there joined-up thinking with regard to, for example, knowing in 2017 that there would be a problem with the site and it might need to be abandoned because it would not deliver in the timeframe? Is there any of that kind of thinking or does the Department stick with that one site and wait until it comes, irrespective of the need of the area or the amount it is paying out, for example, on prefabs?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We have a great deal of engagement with the local authorities in respect of looking ahead and forward planning for need. The projects and schools the Deputy referred to relate to the Celbridge campus development. That site has been particularly difficult to acquire. NAMA has been involved. It has not been straightforward. To be honest and to be clear, it is not for the want of trying to get that quickly from the Department of Education’s perspective. It has come over the line now. In tandem with that, we have that campus development as part of our delivery structures with the National Development Finance Agency, NDFA, which is a strong delivery partner for us. That will be working its way-----

Comment on this

I am sure it will be one of several examples, but in those situations, can the Department fast-forward through the design processes?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Yes, absolutely. We deliberately put that campus development, which is important - and the Deputy referenced St. Raphael’s Special School, which is important for us – into the NDFA programme, which is one of our strongest delivery programmes. The NDFA brings a great deal of professional expertise to that. We are confident in the trajectory of that project.

Comment on this

On the July or summer provision, the children of St. Raphael’s will not be able to go to summer camps. The application was made for July provision and it was refused because the minimum is two weeks and they could only provide a week. Surely something is better than nothing. It seems extraordinary that the Department states it is going after schools to try to get more schools involved and here is an example where-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask my colleague Ms Mannion to come in on this. The Deputy will appreciate that the summer programme can run for up to four weeks, and families and children feel they need the maximum amount of time. Two weeks is our very strong preference. We would much prefer that they do four weeks. There is work involved in arranging it for one week. We strongly encourage two weeks.

Comment on this

But the Department refused.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask Ms Mannion to come in on that. Perhaps she will do so now.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

The programme the Deputy referred to as July provision used to be a programme that was run for a month. Schools said they were struggling to find capacity to do it for a month and it is for that reason we brought it back to two weeks. We want schools to do it for two weeks because of the challenges in setting up the provision, getting the staff and getting it to work for one week. It is challenging for the children but also it does not provide the level of benefit required. If a school suggested that the challenges in running it for two weeks involved, for example, not being able to get staff, additional supports or anything like that, we had a portal supported by the Irish Primary Principals Network, IPPN, in conjunction with ourselves whereby we facilitated the registration of people other than the staff who worked in the school. We focused on, for example, student teachers, students in therapy care assistance and early childhood people. Some 1,500 people registered in that portal last year, which means schools have access to additional staff outside their own. We strongly encourage schools to do this for the minimum of two weeks. We would like them for do it for longer, but anything less than that represents a challenge for the children.

Comment on this

I do accept it was for a month and I can understand why.

How much of the increase in spending in 2022 on school buildings was due to the cost of inflation or to accelerated construction? Was it almost exclusively inflation?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

No, as I said earlier we have a very strong project roll-out. Obviously this comes at a cost. We are very conscious of the support of the Government and our colleagues in the Department of Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform in supporting this and in supporting these very needed projects.

If we look at the €300 million supplementary budget, we see €55 million of it was Ukraine related. The breakdown of the €245 million includes project roll-out. Obviously there is an inflation element and it is not easy to break it down clearly. For example, in 2021 and 2022 inflation levels were significantly higher. They were in the territory of 11%, 12% and 13%. Normal territory in school buildings is 5% or thereabouts. There is obviously an element of a premium. A strong element of the remainder is a very strong proactive project roll-out.

Comment on this

Every year where I live there is a scrap for school places. Sometimes schools are asked to accommodate additional students and prefabs can be put in at fairly short notice for them. Presumably there is some budget for this every year. Will the witnesses give us an indication of this particular aspect where each year the Department must provide at a late stage for the accommodation of students at primary and second levels? Will they give us a note on this so that we can see this type of last-minute piece?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

To make a general point, if we look at the capital budget the bulk of it relates to adding capacity to the system through large-scale projects, the additional accommodation scheme and modular projects. A lot of the engagement one might have in areas with significant enrolment pressures gets managed within existing capacity and maximising existing capacity. This is a responsibility on us and a responsibility of schools and we work it through. We are happy to provide a note to the committee also.

Comment on this

It has been said that Wicklow and Kildare are in a red zone. What other counties are in this red zone?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We can have different definitions-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Laois.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

-----of a red zone. If we look at issues such as oversubscription pressure and enrolment pressure, the trajectory at primary level, to take this as an example, is that enrolments have peaked nationally. Even in County Kildare and the area under pressure, if we look at it at county level enrolments have been relatively flat overall notwithstanding pressures in individual areas. If we look at post-primary level, we are at peak level for enrolments of new first years coming into the system. They are working their way through.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The question is whether the red zones are county wide or based in larger towns?

Comment on this

Where are the flashpoints?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Which is it and where are they? The number ten has been mentioned a number of times in the meeting.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

They are in particular school planning areas. Greystones was mentioned.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Will Mr. Loftus tell us where they are? One is Greystones.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

There is Greystones, some areas of Kildare, Fermoy in Cork-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Portlaoise?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

There are levels of redness.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will be coming to it in a few minutes.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We will be looking at these in the context that they are at a level that need significant engagement by the Department. Athenry is another area.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will revert to Portlaoise in a few minutes.

Comment on this

I want to return briefly to the subject of school transport and an issue highlighted in the special report in 2017. This is spare capacity in the fleet. There are people who have the bus ticket but use it a day a week because that is the day they do not have the car or somebody is off or whatever else it is. I am not aware of it from any of the bus routes that I know. Are people tracking this data usefully? Can we see how many kids are on the bus Monday morning, Tuesday morning or Wednesday morning? Is this fed in and do we analyse trends? Can we maximise our fleet capacity based on this data?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask my colleague, Ms Conduit, to speak on this. We do not have all of the data we would like to have. To know this we would need an e-ticketing system throughout the country and the entire scheme. Bus Éireann has piloted this but it has not been ruled out. Deputy Ó Cathasaigh knows that after eligible parents apply and pay there are reasons they do not use it all of the time but we cannot give their seat away to somebody else because we might end up with buses being oversubscribed. This causes a safety issue.

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

As the Secretary General said, we are piloting an e-ticketing programme and we will be looking to roll it out nationally. Unfortunately it will not be for the 2024-2025 school year. It will continue to be a pilot. It will give us real-time information on how many children use the service. Prior to a particularly tragic accident a number of years ago we overallocated tickets for the number of seats. Now we have seat belts on every bus and contracted bus and it is one child per seat. This has to be the case.

Comment on this

I can understand the challenge but the common frustration that we hear voiced is that the school bus passes those people who want a seat on it and they see empty seats.

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

There can be any number of reasons for this.

Comment on this

The kid could be sick or whatever it is.

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

They might attend after-school services or participate in other activities. We know there is rarely 100% occupancy of children on seats. Unfortunately we do not have sufficiently good, reliable evidence to develop policy in this area.

Comment on this

It is something that needs to be worked on.

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

Yes.

Comment on this

To change tack, I want to ask about the large number of children from Ukraine we are accommodating. It has been said that approximately 18,200 have been enrolled in primary and secondary schools. The Department probably has a good picture of mobility in terms of how often these children are moved from school to school. It probably has a reasonable line of sight on how many children are no longer in the jurisdiction. We know this is happening. My question is a little bit broader than this. Approximately 18,000 kids have joined our school system. Some of them are here for good and more of them are not. Doing a horribly rough calculation of dividing this figure by 25, which is the average pupil-teacher ratio, there are approximately 728 extra teachers in the system. I am sure it is more than this because of the specific needs. Are we forward modelling? If we have 1,000 teachers or more in the system due to the number of Ukrainian children who have come into it, do we have a plan to cope if a large number of these Ukrainian children leave? I recognise that the demographic bulge is passing through secondary school at present. Are we forward planning for this? We certainly do not want a situation where a large number of teachers are found to be superfluous.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We are working very closely with the Department of children and integration and the CSO. There is what is called "signs of life" that looks constantly at whether people are still in the jurisdiction. We have a good sense of it. This is why we can genuinely say that 95% of Ukrainian school-age children are in school at any one time. We have not seen a large amount of mobility to date. Some of them may go back. Deputy Ó Cathasaigh mentioned a class size of 25. I just want to correct him that we have reduced this to 23. Are we planning that some of these may be freed up? Yes, we have a statistician seconded to us from the Central Statistics Office who works with us on teacher supply and many other issues. This is absolutely a consideration. We are also considering a possible migration of other nationalities, such as Irish people coming back to have families here. There are other levels of migration. We try to factor this in. Clearly it is not an exact science and there is a lot of estimation.

Earlier Deputy Ó Cathasaigh mentioned special educational needs. We are planning for continued high needs in special education and prevalence rates.

We envisage that lots of teachers will be needed for the foreseeable future.

Comment on this

I want to ask a question on the disposal of assets of religious orders. I particularly want to ask about the Sacred Heart centre in Waterford, which is being transferred from the Sisters of Charity to the HSE. The legal title transfer is complete. What is the hold-up?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That is part of the 2002 indemnity agreement. Of the 128 properties that were promised, 125 have been received. Mounthawk in Tralee and the Sacred Heart in Waterford are the two outstanding. The Deputy knows that the State has use of it at the moment. I believe it is a conveyancing issue. I do not believe it is to do with the religious order. It is a boundary issue, but it has been going on a long time. We are told it is very close to being resolved.

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

We hope that will be resolved very shortly. As the Secretary General says, it is a conveyancing issue. Legal complexities have arisen with many of these properties and their disposal and transfer. Of the 2002 properties all of them are in the use of the State, which was the final intention.

Comment on this

It would be nice to see it done and dusted, rather than it dragging on.

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

Yes, of course

Comment on this

My last question is quite general. I have a real worry about casualisation of the profession, particularly at secondary level. Do the witnesses have detail such as can be supplied in the short amount of time available? It is a particular problem at secondary level but I know it is creeping into primary as well. I am referring to people who are full-time, permanent staff versus people who are temporary and part-time. I know it is really affecting young teachers. We are seeing a flight of teachers from the capital because they are being offered temporary part-time hours in schools and they cannot make ends meet on it. If we casualise the profession it will be a cause of real concern. One of the things that has propped up the education system in Ireland is the quality of the candidates we attract into the teaching profession. We do not want to undermine that. People are the basis of the education system. Will the witnesses give an outline of trends with temporary part-time contracts being offered to secondary school teachers?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I hear the Deputy's concern about casualisation and we have looked at the issue. We found a lot of data to counter some of what one hears in the media. There have been suggestions that there is a huge number of post-primary teachers who cannot get full-time hours. We have looked at some data on this and it reveals that the vast majority of teachers in post-primary schools, because they are assisting with other subjects, can get their full-time hours. For example, a teacher might be there to teach English and history. I probably picked two bad subjects by way of example. In any case, they might be teaching two subjects that do not give them full-time hours, but because we have put in other resources for SPHE or for English as an additional language, the school principal can draw the hours from elsewhere to give hours to the teachers.

Comment on this

This results in a lot of non-specialised teaching, though. Ms McNally has used SPHE as an example. Many young teachers are drafted in to fill out their timetable. That is not how any subject area should be treated. Similarly, teaching English as an additional language is something I have experience of myself. It is a skill in and of itself. It is not a case of, "In you come and take a crack at this". It undermines the profession, really. Guidance counselling is another area where specialist skills are required. It should be valued to the extent that people are put in but-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We do value it. For guidance counselling people have to be dual qualified. They have to be a qualified teacher and have a qualification in guidance counselling.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I want to revert back to red zones. Can you clarify whether Portlaoise is a red zone, yes or no?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It has a relative red zone in the context of the enrolment pressures. It has not been quite at the same level as some other areas. We are putting a lot of capacity in the Portlaoise area.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Over the last couple of weeks I have been trying to gather figures from different schools. My secretary has checked with nearly all the schools in the area at this stage. We have found that with the primary schools there is a question about people applying to a number of different schools which you termed dual or multiple applications. I spoke to a principal as late as yesterday evening about this. He told me that is not now happening, that there is a reference. Going by that, in the primary sector in the Portlaoise area, there is a need for between 190 and 200 places. Some of the children from my estate in Portlaoise town are going five, seven or ten miles to school on buses. They are going to places like Barnashrone, Timahoe and Mountrath, all over the place. The schools within the Catholic parish are Ratheniska and The Heath and they are full to capacity. Even with bussing children to a range of other schools, including Stradbally, there is still a shortfall of almost 200 places. I do not expect Mr. Loftus to speak for the Minister. However, she told me in the Dáil last year that there was no need for another primary school. I am saying that there is a huge need for another primary school in Portlaoise. I ask for this issue to be revisited. I know the Department is trying to deal with a lot of issues. With the intake into the schools we are falling short by a number of places. I acknowledge the new schools that have been built, but there is a huge need. At secondary level, there is a need for somewhere in the region of 120 to 150 places in the area, as far as I can ascertain. Again, in this case, children in the Portlaoise area are being bussed to secondary schools way outside of the area. There are now estates in Portlaoise with almost 900 dwellings in them. There are new estates. Maryborough village has roughly 300 houses. I canvassed it recently and it took a few goes to get it done. There are well in excess of 500 houses on it now. There are estates up roads all over the place. I ask the officials to revisit this because over the summer public representatives will be plagued by people who cannot get places for their children.

I spoke to Mr. Loftus recently on the phone about ASD units across the county and thank him for his help with the matter. This is coming from people including principals within the special education sector. As far as I can ascertain, somewhere in the region of 50 places are required at primary level and 60 at secondary level. In Rathdowney Errill, Mountmellick, Portlaoise, Portarlington and in the east of the county in Shanganamore and Barrowhouse there is a shortage of spaces. There is a huge need there. What I am impressing on Mr. Loftus is that I want him to come back to the committee with a detailed note. I do not expect him to have all those localised figures off the top his head, but what I do want is a comprehensive picture of what the Department's assessment is. The Minister has told me that there is no problem. Let me rephrase that because I do not want to misrepresent her, she has said that we do not need a new school. However, I am saying that I cannot see where these children are going to go. Do we start bussing them out of the county? At this stage, everything within a radius is full. The other problem arising in the area is that it is not just for the junior cycle. Families are moving in who have children in second, third, fourth and fifth classes. When these are counted up that is what is adding to that huge number at local level for primary schools, because they are up along the different years. The same applies at secondary level. There is a site at Coláiste Dhún Másc. It has 570 children. There is a plan for school for 1,000 pupils. That is stuck where it is.

The education and training board wants to move this on and its staff are anxious about it, as is, I am sure, the CEO. ETB staff have been diligent in trying to push it forward. I want the Department to take an interest in this project. It is essential that this second level school gets off the blocks because, whatever about the demographics of the county and across the State, the population of Portlaoise is going in one direction only. In 25 years, it has gone from 7,000 or 8,000 to 24,000 or 26,000 in the census in 2022. In terms of housing and everything else, we are talking about a population well in excess of 30,000. The estate I live in has increased in size by 50% in the last 12 months. There were 105 houses and there are now 169 houses. That is how quickly this is happening and we do not have the schools needed. I ask Mr. Loftus to respond.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Portlaoise is an area we are monitoring closely and it is an area-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mr. Loftus was not sure whether it was in the red zone or not. It needs to be put into the bright red zone.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It is relative. We are adding capacity at primary and post-primary level. The Chair mentioned Dunamase College. The Department of Education gave the green light for that project to go to stage 2B at the end of quarter 1. My understanding is that within a couple of weeks, the design team will lodge an application for planning permission for that project. The Department is dealing with capacity pressures and managing those. The Chair can rest assured that we will make sure short-term and long-term needs will be addressed.

This does not come as a surprise to the Department. We have our forward planning and child benefit data. We will liaise with the local authority.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Laois County Council will waste no time with this. The local authority is very on the ball with regard to this issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We engaged with Laois County Council and the ETB, including Mr. Joe Cunningham. We do a lot of engagement there as well.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Laois and Offaly Education and Training Board is a very strong ETB.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Absolutely, and we are conscious of that.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I want Mr. Loftus to come back to the committee with information on ASD units because-----

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Ms Mannion can clarify that but we are adding capacity in the ASDs.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

I can answer that question.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am asking about need in the county at primary and post-primary level.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

I can provide the Chair with up-to-date information from the NCSE. There are 60 special classes in County Laois already, of which 44 are at primary level and 16 at post-primary level. In County Offaly, which I know is in the Chair's constituency, there are 104 special classes, of which 76 are at primary level and 28 at post-primary level. For the 2023-24 school year, eight of those special classes in Laois were new classes, four at primary level and four at post-primary last year. There were seven new special classes in county Offaly, four at primary level and three at post-primary level. For 2024, ten new classes have already been sanctioned for County Laois.

The Chair spoke about Portlaoise. There are two new post-primary special classes going into Portlaoise and there are two new post-primary special classes going into Rathdowney. That will significantly increase capacity to meet the need at post-primary level. It is important to note that the Department of Education continues to see a big demand at primary level. That will be our focus and we will deliver the additional post-primary special classes at post-primary level and as children are moving in.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Will Ms Mannion assure me today that each child in County Laois who has been diagnosed as needing this and is now on the list for an ASD unit will have a place?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

What I can say is that for every child known to the NCSE who has a requirement for a special class or special school place, the Department is working with the NSCE to make sure all of those children get those special class places for September 2024. The special class may not be in the location the families wish-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I understand that.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

The additional SENOs on the ground will make a huge difference, as the Secretary General mentioned. There will be 120 SENOs across the country, including in every county, to make sure we are actually meeting those needs.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Ms Mannion. I ask for a list of those that have been approved.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

I will send that information to the committee.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will raise the conditions in the two ASD modular units at Barrowhouse National School in which the principal, teachers and other staff are working. The units were held up for years because the school was told to get a design team and do the work and preparation itself. That went on for years. Then the units were delayed and the Department of Education stepped in and told the school to hang on because it would do the project under the framework agreement it had. In other words, there was a company lined up that provides the work for so much per square metre or something like that. That is fine but the problem is that the project was held up for so long. The school is really struggling. What is the status of that project at Barrowhouse National School, Shanganamore?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Our team is liaising with that school currently. I am working with it and we have that project lined up to be delivered under our timber modular accommodation framework. It is of really high quality and really good.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is all right. I take that point.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

That is pretty imminent and we will liaise with the-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Will the principal, Ms Pauline Lawlor, and her staff have that project in place by September?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I am loth to give precise timelines given the nature of projects, but certainly-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Has the building started?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It is an important priority. The project is SEN-related and from the Department's perspective, we will leave no stone unturned to deliver it as quickly as possible.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I said a minute ago that the Department has a framework agreement with the company, so it sets the priorities for the company.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Absolutely.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am asking Mr. Loftus about this issue because the school has no physical extra space at the moment. The school has also applied for permanent classrooms which it also needs. The most chronic need is for two modular classrooms for the ASD classes. What is in place at the moment is totally unsuitable. I ask Mr. Loftus to give that project absolute priority.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We will-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Has he visited the school? Has he seen it?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

No, I have not.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mr. Loftus should read the architect's report on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Our team are there. I know the school was planning to put the modular unit at the front of the school. This is a high-quality timberframe modular unit that we see as meeting a good need. Our team sees the best place for that unit to be at the back of the school. We will liaise with the school on that.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Will Mr. Loftus send me a note on the project?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We will leave no stone unturned.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is really urgent that this project is done.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Absolutely.

Comment on this

Can I ask a quick question?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Yes. Go ahead.

Comment on this

We know Caranua was a finite organisation and it has completed its work. There are, however, still a small number of outstanding clients. There is one particular gentleman in Limerick who had a builder walk out of the site and it has been a building site for the past few years. Are there others like that? When do the witnesses expect to have in place the legislation needed to wind Caranua down?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I thank the Deputy for the question. I will come back to the case of the gentleman she referred to. The legislation is going through at the moment. It is going to Committee Stage so the Minister hopes it will be through in this term. That will result in Caranua ceasing officially to exist and the appropriate records being transferred and so on. Progress is being made on that.

With regard to the individual in question, we know there are no cases open, per se, but there is one individual - we will not discuss the details - for whom the Department, as distinct from Caranua, is trying to find a resolution. We are engaging with another agency on this issue to try to find a resolution. Something was recommended a few months ago and it was not to the individual's satisfaction, so we are still trying to work through the issue. Does Ms Conduit wish to comment?

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

There is strong intent and engagement with another Department and with local authorities and direct, frequent engagement with the gentleman in question.

Comment on this

Is that the only case?

Comment on this
Ms Aoife Conduit

Yes.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That brings the meeting to a conclusion. I thank the witnesses and staff of the Departments of Education and Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform for the work involved in preparing for today's meeting. As it is the first time some of them have been before the committee, I want to acknowledge that some of the questioning was a bit robust. I have to be fair to everybody and to ensure that witnesses have an opportunity to answer questions being put to them.

I also thank the Comptroller and Auditor General and his staff for attending and assisting the committee today. Is it agreed that the clerk will seek any follow-up information and carry out any agreed actions arising from today's meeting? Agreed. Is it also agreed that we note and publish the opening statements and briefing papers from today's meeting? Agreed.

I thank everybody again. We will suspend the meeting and resume briefly in private session before concluding in public session.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Chair, the briefing note we provided in advance contains a lot of information.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We have it.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

If members wish to revert to us at any stage, please do.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is always useful and it saved time today. I appreciate that.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I thank the Chair.

Comment on this