Financial Statements 2023: Health Service Executive
Contributions 196–402 of 402. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Rather than just getting the detail, I would ask that the Department fully review that situation. As I said, these were people who carried out what in my view was essential work. It was as risky as other types of work within the health services who fall under the scope of the scheme. These are employees who we need to continue to do very important work. I just have a fear that we could end up in a situation whereby resistance from the Department ends up costing us more than the payments would in the first instance. I just wanted to make that point through the Chair.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat, a Theachta. We will now take a short break. The meeting is suspended for ten minutes.
Comment on this
Beidh mise mar an chéad chainteoir eile. One issue that has annoyed me for some time, even previously in my role as a city councillor on Galway City Council, is that of agency spend. We have seen that it has gone from a spend of €350 million to €650 million in a four to five year period. If we look at that trend and the figures that we had up until August, it seems that if the trend up to August is maintained, that figure of €650 million will be exceeded. In fact, it looks as though a figure of €700 million will be exceeded with regard to agency spend. Does Mr. Mulvany concur with that figure? Does he think we will go higher than last year's figure and could it exceed €700 million?
Comment on this
The Deputy is right. Agency spend has increased substantially in the past five years. In 2019 it was €423 million and in 2022, it was closer to €720 million. Last year it was just over €780 million. It has increased substantially with the biggest part of the increase occurring before and during the pandemic. The key issue is that it has not reduced. There are efforts under way to reduce it. Our first target is to hold it steady this year against June to August levels of last year. I need the exact figure but we are 3% or 4% beyond that. We are above steady compared with last year but most of that can be accounted for in terms of price. The cost per hour of agency goes up as wages generally go up. Our overall aim is to reduce agency spend substantially. We have-----
Comment on this
I understand that is the aim but the reality is, when we look at the figures, they do not correspond to what the aim is.
Comment on this
The reality is we are holding it steady. We need to move now-----
Comment on this
The first thing we did as part of the pay and numbers strategy was to issue 500 positions to the regions and the services to convert agency two weeks ago. That will convert-----
Comment on this
Conversion takes about three months. The organisation saves 20% of the cost of everything.
Comment on this
It would be hard to see the impact on this year's accounts in a significant way. That is why the Deputy is right. We will either be close to or exceed last year's spend, because both of price increase and as the CFO said, we now hold steady. We will see a reduction in agency over the next 12 months, back to the level it was at before quarter 3 of last year.
Comment on this
Before quarter 3 of last year. When does Mr. Gloster expect it to be at 2019 levels or does he not see that at all?
Comment on this
I do not see it being at 2019 levels for some time.
Comment on this
For some time. I can see from the spend on the management and administration that the HSE has gone from €29 million to €86 million in those areas. One of the frustrations for people - and it is not always a frustration that is based on facts, it can be based on experience and we have heard quite powerfully from an Teachta Cannon his own experience of getting the piece of paper and going around – is that for administration and management, that seems like quite a lot within the HSE. Can Mr. Gloster confirm that has been the increase for management and administration?
Comment on this
Broadly speaking yes, there has been an increase in management and administration of the order the Deputy is talking about. Back in 2019 it was approximately €32 million.
Extrapolating for last year, it is approximately €80 million, so there has been a substantial increase. It comes down to what we mean by management and administration, who those people are and what they do.
Comment on this
Mr. Gloster stated that he had a staff of approximately 166,000. There is considerable frustration about agency spend in general, particularly given that there are many people who want to get good jobs in the HSE. This expenditure on agency and management and administration basically represents a trebling of the previous amount. Why has it increased to this level in such a short period?
Comment on this
The HSE also wants to recruit people permanently into directly employed jobs. That is our preference and is generally what we offer. We only use agency staff when we cannot get people for jobs or only need them for short-term filling. Some level of agency staffing – probably 3% or 4% in an organisation as large as ours – will always be necessary. There will always be short-term gaps that we cannot fill-----
Comment on this
When 7% of one’s total spend on pay is on agency staffing – in some services, it is even more – that is more of a problem. That is the over-reliance we are trying to reduce. The level increased during Covid in particular. Much of the additional processing during Covid, including around vaccinations, saw many administrative staff involved. The level has decreased by approximately 20% since the height of Covid. We would like to drive it down further.
Comment on this
-----but we are discussing a large amount of spending. I understand that the HSE has an aim, but it does not seem that the aim and what the HSE is doing correlate at all.
The Minister created a productivity and savings task force, which set a target of reduced spending. Who sits on that task force?
Comment on this
The task force is chaired by Mr. Gloster and Mr. Robert Watt, Secretary General of the Department. There is senior management from the Department’s management board and the HSE’s senior executive team. There is now a productivity unit within the HSE that is a national focal point for driving productivity. We published our review to the Minister. It is on the website. We also publish all of our minutes and agendas. The focus and priority-----
Comment on this
For me, the main question is who sits on that task force. At yesterday’s health committee meeting, Fórsa stated that there was also a representative of the consultancy firms sitting on it. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Heading up the productivity unit within the HSE is someone from a consultancy firm.
Comment on this
Does that not beggar belief? Would the consultancy firm in question – I do not need to know which one it is – have benefited from agency spend in terms of management fees?
Comment on this
As to whether the firm benefited from agency spend in a different job or during Covid, it potentially did. I do not know the answer for sure.
Comment on this
Surely that is the crux of the issue. If the productivity and savings task force is meant to reduce agency spend, does Ms McGirr not believe that it is a bit of a-----
Comment on this
The productivity task force covers much more than just agency spend. The savings-----
Comment on this
The measures to reduce agency spend include staffing, roster changes and agency conversion. Limits are now in place and there are targets for savings, which are the responsibility of the regional executive officers via Mr. Gloster, to be achieved. They are not related to the work being done on the productivity side of the task force. The reason for having external assistance on the productivity side is because we are considering matters like OPD, digitisation and other issues that were discussed earlier in terms of how to improve operating efficiencies.
Comment on this
We mentioned an external element while discussing procurement issues, but in most people’s heads, “external” means “independent”, in that there would be an independent external body examining matters. This raises a concern about-----
Comment on this
I might comment without going into who is providing the external consultancy.
Comment on this
I accept that. The external consultancy firms are not typically the providers of agency services. A different range of firms provide the bulk of our agency nurses, physios, administrators, etc. The equivalent of three external people on the seven-person unit in the productivity and savings task force are there for their external expertise, adding to the internal expertise of HSE staff. There is no conflict there. They are different. That is part of the overall effort the CEO has led to reduce our reliance on management consultancy. Where the specific type of management consultancy we are discussing is concerned, the target was to drop it by 30% against the quarter 1 2023 baseline and keep it reduced. We have hit that target. We got most of it done in 2023 and have hit it and maintained the decrease in 2024. While we are using a small amount of extra consultancy for the productivity and savings task force, it is part of dropping the overall reliance-----
Comment on this
We agree that agency spending is too high. There are targets to bring it down. The conversion that Mr. Gloster mentioned is one of the key ways. We have invested more than €50 million in safe staffing and nursing to reduce the agency cost of nursing in hospitals. The consultants’ contract, which is in the evenings and daytime, is there to reduce reliance on bringing people in outside the 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. schedule. In recent years, we have increased the workforce on the health side by just under 28,000, never mind the Department of Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth side. These are all measures that should reduce agency spending. We agree that there is an excessive reliance on agency staffing. This is the focus of the task force. There is no-----
Comment on this
The witnesses can appreciate that there would be a query when there is an increase in the spend. I take Mr. Gloster’s point about the 500 he says will change over from being agency staff. What professions are we talking about?
Comment on this
They are predominantly – 99%, I believe – front-line workers. There are a further 400 separate conversions in nursing for safe staffing, so there are 900 conversions in total. They are everything from temporary allied health professionals working on the front line to nursing staff. If there are agency administrative staff like receptionists in a health centre, we are talking about converting front-line workers.
Comment on this
I welcome more people being able to get jobs in the HSE. I did my leaving certificate in 2008 and most of my friends who studied health went abroad. They are coming back but find it impossible to get full-time permanent jobs. This has a major impact on being able to get a mortgage, move out of the family home, etc. The embargo impacted on them further.
Regarding private consultancy firms, we have heard that the unions have argued that the money spent in 2023 alone – €80 million – could have been used to recruit people to a significant number of posts in areas that were badly understaffed. Mr. Gloster hopes to get 500 conversions under way. When it appeared before the health committee yesterday, Fórsa stated that the 2023 spend would have funded 1,865 therapy posts, 2,354 medical secretary posts or 1,334 psychology posts. Most people will be concerned by this, given how many people looking for assistance are on waiting lists and the number of people who are not getting full-time permanent jobs.
As has already been said, when many people get into the system, it is fantastic and they could not ask for better. Is it an area of concern if unions like Fórsa are coming out and saying the HSE has €80 million? We would like to see people being hired to keep staff within the sector. What is Mr. Gloster's view?
Comment on this
To avoid confusion, there are three components. There is agency staffing, which is temporary staffing. If we look at the profile of our agency staffing, a substantial number do not want to be HSE employees because they like to be able to pick the hours they work, they work shorter time and some are people who have retired early and come back to do various pieces. We have to reduce our dependency on agency staffing. That is the first point.
On management consulting, I said when I came into this job that the HSE spend on management consultants, but more importantly its culture of dependency on management consultants, had outgrown any reasonable sense of what was needed. In essence, we were almost subsidising our workforce with it. We have reduced that by over 30%, as the CFO said, which is a very substantial reduction and saving. Any consulting we now take on is much more competitively priced, is for a much shorter time and much fewer people are linked to that expertise.
Fórsa has a job to do, which is to represent its members, and I do not for one minute propose to be disparaging about that. However, there is no connection between what we spend on management consulting and hiring health and social care professionals. My only issue with hiring health and social care professionals is that I cannot get enough of them. There are several hundred vacancies in physiotherapy, occupational therapy and speech and language therapy in disability services alone that I would fill today in a heartbeat if the people were there, but the supply is not there. There is no connection between what we spend on management consulting expertise in one part of the organisation and filling health and social care professional jobs in another. That is simply not the case.
I fully share Fórsa's overall concern about our reliance on management consulting. I hope Fórsa continues to co-operate with us and work with us when we take out that management consulting in different parts of the organisation, and that we can continue to ensure the work is done.
Comment on this
When the embargo happened, I was contacted not by a lot of people, given that not that many would contact me directly, but by a number of people, in particular young women who had worked in the healthcare profession and hoped to come back. Either they were in Britain and they were trying to come back, or they were living here and not on a full-time contract and were maybe working one or two days a week. This had a very serious knock-on impact on them. While I appreciate Mr. Gloster is telling me there are jobs available, at the same time, many people are finding it difficult to move home because they cannot be guaranteed they will get into a workplace. That age group of people, those in their 30s, want to have a full-time job so they can settle down.
Deputy Murphy raised the issue of the posts that were advertised on 31 December 2023 and then cancelled overnight. I understand there is a dispute about the figure. The unions are saying it is 2,000 posts and my colleague, Deputy David Cullinane, has tried to get a response from the Minister with regard to exactly how many it is. How many would Mr. Gloster say were there on 31 December and then, overnight, were no longer there? What figure would he put on that?
Comment on this
We have 147,000 full-time equivalent posts currently occupied by 165,000 individual people. Our turnover rate last year was 8% and if we break that down into quarters, we get 2% of the workforce per quarter. That is the type of number we are talking about. That is outside of new developments because we carry vacancies in new developments. However, in our core workforce, I would imagine that on any one day, we could be in the territory of 2,000 to 3,000.
Comment on this
Mr. Gloster knows there is a dispute about whether it was 2,000 posts that were cancelled overnight from 31 December to-----
Comment on this
That is what is said for nursing alone.
Comment on this
I would certainly say there is a dispute in relation to 2,000 nursing vacancies.
Comment on this
I would say that in the total organisation, not just nursing, it is probably somewhere between 2,000 and 3,000.
Comment on this
It is hard to know because the numbers have grown at such a rate. Our nursing numbers have never reduced.
Comment on this
I would be loath to say. I would have to try to get a better handle on it.
Comment on this
The Minister has not been able to respond to it either. We are just hearing this from the unions. That is what they are saying and we are then told there is a dispute about it. If we have a disputed figure-----
Comment on this
To be fair, I have tried to make this point to everybody who wants to discuss these figures. Despite the moratorium at the end of the last quarter of 2023, there were more resources in the HSE at the end of 2023 than there were at the start. There have been more nurses in the HSE every single year since the end of 2019.
Comment on this
To be fair, my question is specifically on that because there is a dispute. I would like to get to the bottom of what that figure is. It is a disputed figure, which is fair enough, but we cannot dispute a figure if there is no second alternative figure.
Comment on this
No, but we have to remember that, on 31 December, there were 4,000 posts in the organisation that were not funded and we got to keep those in the settlement.
Comment on this
That is not the question. It is a figure that has been disputed. What Mr. Gloster is saying is that he does not have the figure to hand.
Comment on this
What I would say is this. In 2023, 8,000 net extra people were recruited to the Irish health service over the course of the year and they were there on 31 December, so whatever vacancies were there were well mitigated in that context. That is the point.
Comment on this
Yes, there was a nurse missing in the community nursing unit in Limerick. Of course, there was. Yes, there was a social worker missing somewhere. Of course, there was. On any given day, that happens. However, that was overtaken by the fact we kept 4,000 jobs and we added 2,000 more jobs than we were funded to do last year and got to keep them. This year, we are again adding several thousand jobs.
Comment on this
That is not the question. If Mr. Gloster does not have the figures to hand, he might provide them. It is a disputed figure. It is something we are trying to get to the bottom of but we cannot get to the bottom of it if only one side is telling us an exact figure.
I am conscious of time because other members are offering. I want to ask a question in regard to primary care centres, in particular the Carraroe centre in County Galway. Carraroe is on the list to get a primary care centre. We want to make sure people are able to access healthcare locally, especially in a rural area like Connemara, from where it can take well over an hour to get to Galway city, even forgetting about the traffic issues. It is a long-standing demand to have a primary medical centre. At this point, does Mr. Gloster know what the estimated timeframe is for delivery of that and what costs are associated with it?
Comment on this
I will ask Ms Broderick to respond. It is not her area but she was attempting at the break to establish the position with regard to Carraroe.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat. It is an issue of great concern to local people to have local health services.
Comment on this
I got confirmation at the break from Tony Canavan, the regional officer. My understanding from him is that they are working to develop a business case to deliver a primary care centre in south Connemara, which will cover Carraroe as well. I do not have an indication of what indicative cost might be associated with developing a primary care centre.
Comment on this
I will come back to the committee on the timeframe. I did not ask that.
Comment on this
That is fine. If the timeframe could be given to us, that would be fantastic. I am aware it is not Ms Broderick's brief and I thank her for trying.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for attending. There are many different areas that we could focus on. One of the things that really jumps out at me is the climb in expenditure from 2019 to 2023. Obviously, that is taking Covid into account but it seems the expenditure has not dropped back. To give context to my comments, we are looking at the figures coming from south of €20 billion, at approximately €17 billion in 2019, and climbing to over €25 billion now.
One of the things I want to feed back to the witnesses, as somebody who has been elected to the Dáil for four and a half years in a rural constituency, is that we know that 1.6 million of Ireland's population are deemed to live in rural areas. The lack of access to GP services is extraordinarily bad and it is getting worse. Lack of access to out-of-hours services is at crisis level. I do not want to get too parochial but I can speak to my constituency because I know about it from meeting constituents. When people want to see a GP but perhaps cannot do so or they have to wait for a period, their health worsens. That potentially requires an emergency solution, with people going to an emergency department. The consequence is that they may end up on a hospital bed or on a trolley. This clogs up our hospital system.
I have raised this before. It is staggering that 25% of GPs are now over the age of 60, if I am not mistaken. What has Mr. Gloster done in the past years in his role to address this? Where are we with it? The expenditure in the HSE is climbing rapidly. We are lucky to live in a sound economy but I am fearful of what may happen if circumstances change internationally. Can we sustain paying Mr. Gloster's organisation such a sum of money annually?
Comment on this
There are two aspects to the GP matter and one specific to rural matters. My colleague, Dr. Colm Henry, might add to that because he plays quite a part in that. The fundamental structural change that we have made, which has commenced this year, is that we have increased the number of GP training places to 350, which is quite significant. The graduate numbers over the next four years will exceed the predicted retirements. The plan is to supplement that. One part of the world, South Africa, has a particularly skilled workforce of doctors, who have come to Ireland and under an arrangement with the Irish College of General Practitioners, they can do two years of supervised practice here and then register as GPs. We have tried to target those specifically where there is either deprivation in cities or rural access challenges. Dr. Henry might want to address GP development in rural Ireland.
Comment on this
As the CEO said, we have increased the number of trainees. We have a national level of GPs to population which is suboptimal, frankly. It is six or seven per 10,000 people. We need to get to about 11 per 10,000. As the Deputy pointed out, looking at a population level and even a regional level fails to address the particular exposure we have in rural, single-handed and isolated practices. I attended a conference of that group of general practitioners last weekend. Through the GP agreement in 2023, money has been set aside to support specific general practices which are stand-alone with locum support and linking them to a hub GP practice, in addition to the measures the CEO referenced, under which we have 121 international graduates supporting these kinds of practices. We hope to raise that to 250 per year right through to 2031 so we can go from our current suboptimal provision of GP cover, with, as the Deputy points out, an ageing GP workforce, to having the additional 350 trainees per year bring us to the ratio we would like to see, of 11 per 10,000 people. That special care needs to take place for those isolated, stand-alone, single-handed practices because of the particular vulnerability.
Comment on this
I refer to north Cork since this came up so much during the local elections. People cannot get in the door to see GPs in Mitchelstown and Fermoy. This is replicated in other parts of the country. I am not even going near the SouthDoc issue but it is extraordinarily worrying that even when people require a consultation with a doctor in an emergency or a call-out to a home that the service is collapsing. It comes back to people ending up in the hospital system. It is having a significant impact on costs. I come from a family of healthcare professionals. All my siblings are working in healthcare settings.
I look at the primary care system as a positive development. As Mr. Gloster knows, I have been working hard to try to get the primary care centre up and running in east Cork. I think it was granted conditional planning by the county council this morning. I am also interested in the ambulance training unit that is being built in Youghal in the south of the country, as set out in the 2024 capital plan. What is the timeframe for the roll-out of new ambulance training colleges and funding being made available to progress them? We have done these successfully in other parts of the country. I think there is one in Ballinasloe in the midlands. How quickly is that being done?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the opportunity to address that. I know the last time I was here, he was quite frustrated at our level of responsiveness. I know the team worked with him and others in the area. Three positive and exciting things are happening. There is planning permission for the primary care centre. There was a request from the local authority for additional information which has gone in and I do not envisage any major challenge to that. Planning permission for the community nursing unit has gone in and there is an additional information requirement for that. In the case of the ambulance training base, we need additional training capacity. We are planning to grow the number of paramedics in training every year. A feasibility study, which needs to be done first, is currently being done on the possibility of locating that in the St. Raphael's campus.
Comment on this
Regarding the other campuses that have been put in place, Ms Broderick has responsibility in this area, specifically the training colleges-----
Comment on this
How many employees are based in them? What scale is the facility in Ballinasloe? How many people are teaching there? How is it managed?
Comment on this
Is that with regard to staff teaching paramedics?
Comment on this
I do not have a specific number because the training is run out of the National Ambulance Service centre in Tallaght. There is a training centre in Tallaght and one in the midlands. I do not have the exact number. I would have to come back to the Deputy on it.
Comment on this
I ask Mr. Gloster to get that information if possible.
Comment on this
It operates, for want of a better word, like a third level college. There is a group of students, which could be 30, 40 or 50, and there is a group of tutors. The students go out on placement with ambulance crews on the road. It is a full cycle of training and has to operate like a full-time college.
Comment on this
We are 12 months on from Storm Babet, which took place in 2023. Enormous damage was done to Midleton. I was talking about this with the Office of Public Works earlier in the week. Midleton hospital experienced devastating flooding. The Owenacurra Centre there, which has been much-discussed over the current Dáil term, was damaged too. I want to get insight on where the HSE is with rolling out the new capital infrastructure both for psychiatric care in Midleton and the Midleton hospital development. That has been dragging on for a long time. I am more than concerned about it. Where are we with it?
Comment on this
I ask Dr. Andy Phillips, the regional executive officer, to speak on that.
Comment on this
I know there is a lot of community solidarity about the Owenacurra Centre. That centre was not fit for purpose. We are developing a much better facility for people on that side. As to the timescale, I apologise, because I will need to get back to the Deputy on that. Midleton hospital is a much-loved facility in the community. I know a number of things are happening there. We need to get back to the Deputy on the specifics of the timescales.
Comment on this
I would like to get correspondence from the HSE on that this week, if possible, to get a live update on where we are. There is concern locally about the pace of development. It feeds back into a wider issue with any capital development in the HSE, which is the length of time it takes.
Comment on this
I understand that. To be fair about Owenacurra, regarding the time to get it out of the ground, before I came, it was much disputed. I went there and met staff, some of the residents and the mental health service in Cork. After that visit, I made the formal decision that we would build on the same site so that the future users of those services would have access to the town and all of the support systems there. That decision has been made. I understand the design work has been well drafted. We will come back to the Deputy with a more definitive answer.
Comment on this
I ask for a progression timeline too.
Comment on this
I congratulate the Cathaoirleach on being the first woman appointed to chair the Committee of Public Accounts.
Comment on this
I thank both our Leas-Chathaoirleach and former Cathaoirleach for their inputs to the Committee on Public Accounts during my term. I thank the witnesses for their attendance. I will start with a quick question about capital infrastructure. What is the update on to the 97-bed block for Wexford General Hospital? Will Ms McGirr answer?
Comment on this
I will get the details and get back to the Deputy.
Comment on this
I thank Ms McGirr. I do not know who is responsible with regard to the home care support services but I am very concerned about the volume of calls I am getting whereby those in receipt of the care and their home carers are being informed they are no longer allowed to feed those they are supporting. While this has been sent out in the form of an email with the guidelines set down in a HSE document, the document pertains to 65-year-olds. I have the case of a mother who cares for two people, one of whom is a very seriously disabled and intellectually challenged individual as well as another son who has cerebral palsy and she cannot operate in an environment whereby the home care support worker does not feed her 22-year-old son, as an assistance to her. The reason I have been given is that when the client starts to choke that is something the home care support worker cannot cope with. Surely we are not sending in people who are not trained in this regard. Will Mr. Gloster look into that? I am not sure if this has been sanctioned at local level, constituency level or CHO 5 level but I certainly want a categoric answer because I know there are people who are seriously struggling with regard to this. I do not know if Mr. Gloster can answer this question now.
Comment on this
Certainly, before she became the regional executive officer for the mid-west, Ms Broderick was the national lead for older persons, including home care, so she might have some insight into this.
Comment on this
I am particularly discussing someone who has a 22-year-old dependent child who is intellectually and physically disabled and unable to feed himself.
Comment on this
We would need to have the individual details.
Comment on this
This might be around speech and language therapy advice because of dysphasia. It could be a choking risk, as described by the Deputy.
Comment on this
It might be a different type of carer that we need to get to this family. There are different types of care. There might be domiciliary care, or healthcare assistants.
Comment on this
We have sent the information. We will resend it. If it is that and there should be a reassessment, the HSE should not be writing to parents and putting the fear of God into them that this is no longer a part of the care that is provided because it is a very stressful environment already. I will take that up with Ms Broderick.
Comment on this
I know that and I appreciate that but it is very concerning and upsetting.
My other question might also be for Ms McGirr. Will she give an update on a medical centre for New Ross, County Wexford? The latest proposal was turned down as it was no longer viable, apparently. Can I have an update on that please?
I have a question for Mr. Mulvany. How much does it cost to keep a public patient in a public bed in a public hospital for one night?
Comment on this
It depends on the condition. The standard fee-----
Comment on this
The standard fee in the legislation, depending on the type of hospital, is approximately €1,000 but the actual cost depends on what the patient is.
Comment on this
We can give examples for a range of costs.
Comment on this
That would be a reasonable place to start.
Comment on this
If a 15-year-old was in a bed for 91 days with acute anorexia in a public hospital with no specialty department, would it raise a red flag for anybody? Would a question be asked either clinically or administratively?
Comment on this
It would, clinically. The only reason to have somebody there for that long is if that was viewed as the best place to have him or her, in the absence of any alternatives. The view would be that we would prefer if there were alternatives available but without knowing the specific case-----
Comment on this
The last time Mr. Mulvany appeared before the committee I put it to him that there had been a young girl with anorexia in University Hospital Waterford for 30 days. I was incorrect. I am stating on the record that it was actually 91 days. There was no clinical intervention that she should be moved until I got involved, and there was no administrative intervention to ask why she was there. The hospital neither had a paediatric dietician or any consultant come to see her. She moved out of the care of the CAMHS consultant into the care of the hospital consultant who failed to see her in the hospital, at her bedside, for 90 days until I got involved. Has that been investigated since Mr. Mulvany was last before the committee?
Comment on this
I am not aware of the specific case being investigated in that sense.
Comment on this
It is concerning. An eating disorder is particularly concerning.
Comment on this
I will come back to the eating disorder but we are talking about roughly €90,000 to €100,000 of money that actually went nowhere.
Comment on this
Eventually, the young girl was moved to an acute setting.
Comment on this
Yes, to deal with her disorder. She spent almost nine months there, during which time her father passed away. The tragedy is that when she left that setting she was referred back to CAMHS, which had neglected her in the first place. She is back to the same weight she was when she was admitted to the hospital in the first place. We are failing, and failing miserably. While the girl is back at school, her mother attends school every day to ensure she eats her lunch. In a year and a half, no inroads have been made in her mental healthcare except to put her back to where she started. There was no intervention in the 90 days she was in University Hospital Waterford. She lost more than 7 kg in weight and no questions were raised. That is failure and I do not care who is responsible but I want it to be addressed. I may never be back here again and I understand Mr. Gloster has a serious task on his hands. I watched his progress because I told him I would give him a chance. He is making progress but it is a mammoth task he has. For all the good we do, this child could have died but will spend her lifetime, if ever, trying to recover because we failed during the 90 days she was in a hospital for no reason with virtually no help.
We are failing our staff also because the hospital was not able to deal with it. The staff had no training. There was an adult dietician who clearly was doing her best but was out of her depth because this was a 15-year-old. I find it incredible that this has not been addressed even though Mr. Gloster was aware of it from the last day here. Not only that, the only provision she could be offered when she was released from the mental health setting that dealt with the anorexia in the first place was to put her back to a CAMHS service that was not fully staffed and did not provide fully for her care in the first place, which is how she ended up in hospital. It is value for money-----
Comment on this
The fact that the Deputy said to me that somebody spent 90 days in a hospital bed with no clinical intervention I will take up, examine and ensure it is inquired into. I find it nearly impossible to believe that could happen. I am not disputing the Deputy's advocacy.
Comment on this
I would like to say it is impossible but I sat in the hospital for a day with the patient. When it was discovered who I was, I was asked to leave. Not until then was there an intervention. Not until then did the psychologist come to the hospital and address the situation. Then it all had to happen as an emergency because the girl was in organ failure. This is crisis. For all the good work that has been undertaken, one death of this nature would be catastrophic for all of us. We still have failed because even though she is no longer at death's door, she is back to the very same position she was in the first place.
Comment on this
I cannot comment on the case but if the Deputy could get the details, I will certainly look into this.
Comment on this
No, I am still in the same position when it comes to eating disorders because we have not addressed the situation of either CAMHS units or CDNT units being staffed.
We have 817 vacant positions in CDNTs. We are servicing nobody. The situation with CAMHS is almost identical. I will have to come back in later because I am out of time Will Dr. Henry prepare an answer in the interim? CAMHS Wexford south, as it has to be identified - because if it is not, it discredits CAMHS north - has refused to take on hundreds of children on the basis that they may also have attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. We are really failing poorly.
Comment on this
I call Deputy Catherine Murphy. The Deputy will have five minutes now on foot of time issues.
Comment on this
Before Deputy Catherine Murphy comes in, I wish to address the Deputy Murphy from the south east. I have the update on the 97-bed block for her. The enabling works to clear the site are being done. There is also work towards finalising the design to get it out to tender. It will go out to tender in quarter 1 of next year. The commencement of works on site is scheduled for quarter 3 of next year.
Comment on this
The question is whether the money is available in the capital infrastructure plan. Has the money been sanctioned for the build?
Comment on this
My understanding is that it has, but I will confirm that.
Comment on this
I wish to pick up on the point my colleague Deputy Verona Murphy made on the CDNTs. This comes up repeatedly. I hear from people who had services when they were being looked after by Enable Ireland but who have no services now because they were switched to a CDNT. The vacancy rate in Kildare south is 16.7%. In Kildare north, it is 35.2%. In mid-Kildare it is 15.3%. Some 250,000 people live in Kildare. Looking at the demographics, it is one of the locations with the largest number of young people. This is a brass-plate service for most people. It just does not exist.
I spoke to one dad who described his home as a care home rather than a family home. When he did end up getting some sort of engagement with the CDNT, it was an absolute emergency situation. There would be quite a number of injuries in the house because one child has a particular behavioural problem. I am just using this as an example. The man in question was told he could go on a course. That is what he was offered. We are totally failing here.
Is the HSE making progress on the number of vacancies? I do not see it. Is CHO 7 different? Is it worse? Is this a problem right across the country?
Comment on this
It certainly is a problem right across the country. We appointed a senior HR professional to support recruitment into CDNTs. It remains an issue, and we need to make more progress. I am very conscious of the small number of children who are having their assessments and therapy within the appropriate time. It remains an issue we will need to work on, particularly as REOs.
Comment on this
There is just not a service for most people. It is the one area that is very out of control, from what I am hearing. It is repeatedly raised in the most tragic situations. We are talking about emergency situations, where you go with an emergency and are told to come back in 12 months. It is outrageous. I just wanted to highlight that as the kind of thing that really needs attention.
Mr. Gloster talked about a staff turnover rate of 8%. In addition to staff turnover, a huge number of women work in the health service. Some will have to take maternity leave and deal with other kinds of situations. In addition to the vacancies, do we know the numbers on maternity or sick leave?
Comment on this
We do have absenteeism. We have tracking in that regard. It can run anywhere between 5% and 6.5%, depending on the different discipline or speciality. I would have to check the position regarding maternity leave. The Deputy is quite right that maternity leave is a significant feature, hence the reference earlier, in reply to the Cathaoirleach, to the need to retain a certain number of agency staff.
Comment on this
We are talking about 8% turnover and possibly 6%.
Comment on this
I think that is a reasonable figure. I just would need to get specific-----
Comment on this
So the figure for the shortfall in staff is about 14%.
Comment on this
The 8% is over the course of a whole year. It is not all at one time. The 8% is not all gone on one day.
Comment on this
I know that, but it is a recurring 8%. It is not the same people, but it is a recurring 8%.
Comment on this
When you measure turnover, you measure it for the whole year. It is an amount on any one day. It is not 8% on the same day.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Gloster telling me that there are different numbers January, March and July? Is it generally 8% for the year?
Comment on this
We probably turn over about 2% in the quarter.
Comment on this
Mr. Gloster is talking about that being 8% over a year.
Comment on this
In the short time I have left, I will focus on one matter. We make recommendations to the HSE when we compile a report. One of those recommendations was that the reports from internal audits be published on the executive's website. Will the HSE be doing that? Does it see the internal audits and the reports from audits relating to the more than 60% of other publicly funded health agencies?
Comment on this
We publish all of the internal audit reports, whether they relate to the HSE's services or services that we fund. They are widely circulated within the HSE. We publish about a quarter in arrears.
Comment on this
I wish the Cathaoirleach well in her new role. I mark the fact she is the first female to serve in her position. I also thank Deputy Catherine Murphy for her work recently and throughout the term as Leas-Chathaoirleach.
Returning to the capital development side of things, I wish to ask another question. In the context of land relinquished during 2023 – this is a specific question – did the HSE do much community engagement with sports clubs or other organisations throughout 2023 where additional lands it may have had were given back to communities or made available for sale for community organisations?
Comment on this
I would be misleading the Deputy if I said that we did. The disposal of property follows a specific trajectory. We are obliged first to offer it to other Government agencies that may have an interest or requirement, particularly local authorities. It would not be unusual for us to dispose of a premises and for a local authority to take it for use. The second thing which has been an increasing feature over the past two years is we have offered certain premises - some of them very high profile, unfortunately, because they were torched – to the Department of integration to service the needs of international protection applicants. Regarding vacant land that is not built on, the primary focus of the dispersal of that or not is the Land Development Agency. It operates on behalf of the State and expresses an interest in our lands. Some we have transferred to it and some we are arguing to keep for our own future plans. With regard to dispensing with land to local communities, that would be very much on the margins. It might be where we actually own the ground and a soccer pitch might have been there for the past 30 years. We certainly would not be-----
Comment on this
It is interesting Mr. Gloster says that because I have one situation I wish to raise with him. I was trying to get a conversation without prejudice between a local GAA club and a facility where the HSE owned the ground but there was that instance where the field was used for GAA purposes. I was wondering about the mechanisms around that.
Comment on this
Without prejudice, we would not avoid having that conversation and being pragmatic in how we might consider it.
Comment on this
Mr. Gloster might just check that out with St. Raphael’s because I have requested that previously but I just want to get the ball rolling.
Comment on this
I will ask the REO, Dr. Phillips, to take it away and check it out. The Deputy is referring to St. Raphael's.
Comment on this
Yes. It is a huge site. There are vast lands with it.
I refer to the feasibility study on the ambulance training unit going into the old building in St. Raphael's. It is a beautiful building. It is almost like one of the old buildings you see in Trinity College but it has been left derelict and vacant for some time. It is sealed and contained. It is not as run down as some other empty derelict units would be.
I would encourage usage of older buildings where possible, particularly around an education campus. That will serve its purpose for decades if it were reinvested in rather than going through the hoops of trying to attain planning and trying to go down the road of a new greenfield site and all the trouble and hardship that can come with that. I know the witnesses will be coming back to me about the ambulance training college but on that feasibility study, there is a building sitting there.
Comment on this
We are not averse to using our old building stock. If you go to Monaghan, the former psychiatric hospital there is now probably one of the largest primary care centres in Ireland. It is a super facility. The St. Joseph's psychiatric hospital in Limerick is a multi-occupant site with a beautiful presentation of the old building, albeit for modern purposes. I would have no wish not to use them, but there is a practical point about the feasibility of doing the building if it is a protected structure or with regard to the energy rating and so on.
Comment on this
My ultimate message is that the HSE should please drive on with that. For the first time in 30 years, there is something happening in Youghal because of the State action. The town had lost 4,000 jobs in manufacturing and was utterly abandoned for years.
Comment on this
Our ambition there is for a major health campus.
Comment on this
That is good to hear. The primary care centre is moving along. I also ask about the chronic pain management suites the HSE is working on. Dr. Henry might know a little more about this but it is looking at locating some of them in primary care facilities around the country. I have another question about small injury units and to see what is involved in locating those within the new primary care settings being developed. I ask because there is obviously an ongoing development where I believe a contract has been given to Axis Healthcare group as the appointed contractor. I want to get feedback to see what is involved in securing a location.
Comment on this
Is that in relation to chronic pain units or local injury units?
Comment on this
Pain units tend to be located in hospital settings, but there are also some units in palliative care units like Marymount in Cork where we have a theatre. It tends to be a subset of anaesthetic care usually provided in a hospital setting but strongly linked to palliative care. Local injury units are located on specific sites such as Gurranabraher and elsewhere. They provide care from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. for defined clinical incidents up to a certain threshold. They have been quite successful in siphoning off cases that would otherwise present to emergency departments. Is the question related to primary care centres?
Comment on this
Correct, in primary care settings. I think they have done this in Dungarvan, County Waterford, with success. I want to see if it will be possible-----
Comment on this
We can maybe link up with the Deputy afterwards on that specific question.
Comment on this
The Cornmarket project in County Wexford is a support service for individuals with a history of addictions. A co-ordinator in the services has contacted me to say that the HSE is set to slash 26 front-line positions in social inclusion services at the end of this year. Twelve of those positions are specific to addiction-related services, and at a time when the demand for services is spiralling into a drugs crisis, this would be detrimental. There is a serious potential outcome if these positions are lost, and we are facing a public health emergency with regard to the current spate of drugs in villages and communities in County Wexford. Most recent figures show a massive increase of 23% in drug use across the south east between 2021 and 2023. It is an educated guess that that will go up in 2024 if this is to happen. We need investment in drug treatments and services to reduce wider costs to the taxpayer, and this is where we join the dots. The Cornmarket project believes that for every €1 spent, there is a €3 saving to the taxpayer across the sector. Will the witnesses clarify the current status of the 29 vacant positions across the south east? Because it feels like the south east is continuously being hit and discriminated against with regard to health supports. The HSE substance misuse services manager position has been vacant for more than 18 months in County Wexford. Will they please address that? We are in the throes of a drug misuse pandemic.
Comment on this
I am not familiar with Cornmarket. I will say two things to the Deputy. I was in Ashleigh House in Coolmine, Dublin, the other day where women recovering from addiction have their children with them during their residential treatment. I have seen the fantastic outcomes there, which will save thousands for each person into the future. My plan with respect to addiction services is certainly not to cut any spending. I only see it going one way, and that is up. I will have to come back on the specifics of what the Deputy is saying because I do not know-----
Comment on this
So Mr. Gloster is not aware of the intention to cut 12 positions within the services.
Comment on this
I have not authorised anyone to cut any front-line positions anywhere.
Comment on this
I would say it makes no sense at all given that every rural community in this country is facing an existential crisis with drugs. It is no longer the pastime of those who should be avoided. It is every village and community, and every young person I am acquainted with can tell me of friends or themselves being accosted and how it is being used in different environments. Now, this is not Mr. Gloster's fault, but this is most certainly not a time when we can take the eye off the ball. It ultimately leads to chronic-----
Comment on this
It is not my fault, but it is my responsibility-----
Comment on this
-----to deal with it when it comes to my attention. I am saying that I do not know the specific project or the structure of that agency but I have not required, requested, allowed or created the conditions in which anyone in 2024 or 2025 has to cut a front-line service.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear it and I hope he will come back to me. Should there be any instance where we are deciding that, it should be decided by a stakeholder engagement group, which includes gardaí, community liaison officers and politicians. It should be everybody.
Comment on this
That is what the drugs task force system was for, so I would expect that should happen.
Comment on this
Correct. That should happen well in advance of any cuts. I thank Mr. Gloster.
Comment on this
I turn to the Deputy's question on capital funding for Wexford. This year €2.2 million was allocated in the capital profile for it. I obviously do not have the capital plan for next year yet, but on the basis the €2.2 million was done, the enabling works and planning is going to happen. It is hard to see why it would not be in it. We are pressing ahead.
Comment on this
I think the planning has been granted, or if not, it is in the process. My issue is that is what the €2.2 million would probably be going towards but we need that capital infrastructure. Is there any update on the medical centre for New Ross? No. Dr. Henry was putting his hand up to me there.
Comment on this
Yes, it relates to the Deputy's question in the first round. The model of care for eating disorders is largely community based. Our plan is for 16 teams across the country. It is true that the Deputy's area is one of those not covered, but we are hopeful. There are 11 teams of the 16 in place. Eight are for adults and eight are for CAMHS. We have 11 in place, one recruiting, and we are hopeful for two more in the coming financial year, which will include coverage of Wexford and Waterford.
Comment on this
I do not want to take advantage, Chair, but I would appreciate a little latitude.
Comment on this
I turn to the reality of what is happening in our mental health services across the board. I do not know what kind of key performance indicators the HSE is using, but I can tell the witnesses of an adult who has been separated from her children for a couple of weeks, inflicted by her mother, who took her in because she is not coping mentally. She visited local mental health services where the doctor told her to go home and cop herself on. They are probably not the words, but they were to that effect, and he said that he would see her in three months when she had been away from her small children for two weeks. Her mother was with her and intervened, at which point he conceded that he would see her in a month. Where are we going, and what kind of monitoring are we doing? Another doctor told a woman he did not believe in menopause and took her off her medication. I could be here forever. I can tell you that I am proof menopause exists if anybody wants to drive at me, no problem at all. It is not something a doctor should use as a throwaway remark.
Comment on this
I take the spirit of what the Deputy is saying.
Comment on this
Will the witnesses clarify where on the HSE website the internal reports are? We will then close the meeting. Can that be clarified quickly?
Comment on this
Let us come back to the Deputy and tell her exactly where it is. It will be a link.
Comment on this
Whatever about the website, proactively every quarter-----
Comment on this
-----we release all the reports to the journalists under the blanket FOI provision. They are regularly published. We will check the-----
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses again. I thank the staff of the HSE and the Department of Health for the work involved in preparing for today's meeting. I thank the Comptroller and Auditor General and his staff for attending and assisting the committee today. Is it agreed that the clerk will seek any follow-up information and carry out any agreed action arising from the meeting? Agreed.
Comment on this
I would like to ensure I get an update on the medical centre in New Ross.