Business of Committee
The Comptroller and Auditor General reported clear audit opinions on the accounts presented, while noting some procurement issues and EU fines, including one for late transposition of a directive. The committee agreed to examine local authority funding and oversight, seek further details on departmental Revenue settlements and troubled rail IT projects, and pursue lessons for government IT oversight. It will request the RTÉ funding agreement and press for legislation enabling the Comptroller and Auditor General to audit RTÉ.
I welcome everyone to the meeting. Before we proceed, I have a few housekeeping matters to go through. Members are reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 226 that the committee shall refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies. Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. I also remind members of the constitutional requirements that in order to participate in public meetings, they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex or precincts.
The agenda for today's public session is as follows: minutes; accounts and statements; and correspondence and upcoming meetings. We will then suspend and begin the engagement with the officials from An Garda Síochána at 10.30 a.m. The minutes of the meetings of 1 October 2026 have been agreed and will be published on the committee's webpage.
I welcome the Comptroller and Auditor General. A total of 52 sets of accounts and financial statements were laid between 28 September and 2 October 2026, which are due to be considered today. I now invite the Comptroller and Auditor General to present these to the committee.
Comment on this
First, we have the financial statements of the Kerry Education and Training Board for 2025. They received a clear audit opinion.
No. 2 is the financial statements of the National Oil Reserves Agency DAC for 2025, which received a clear audit opinion.
I will not go through Nos. 3 to 48 individually. They are the appropriation accounts of the Votes for Departments and offices for 2025. They received clear audit opinions in all cases. It is my opinion that the accounts properly present the transactions and financial position of the various Votes. For a number of the accounts, certain matters are brought to attention, including non-compliant procurement. In a couple of cases, EU fines were incurred. There are other matters linked to chapters in the Report on the Accounts of the Public Services for 2025.
No. 49 is the financial statements of the Medical Council for 2025. These received a clear audit opinion.
No. 50 is the financial statements of Coimisiún na Meán for 2025, which received a clear audit opinion. Related to that and managed by Coimisiún na Meán is No. 51, the Broadcasting Fund. The financial statements for 2025 have been presented and they received a clear audit opinion.
No. 52 is the financial statements of Teilifís na Gaeilge for 2025, which received a clear audit opinion.
No. 53 is the financial statements of the Local Government Fund for 2025, which received a clear audit opinion.
No. 54 is the financial statements of the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission for 2025, which received a clear audit opinion.
Comment on this
I would like to ask about No. 48. Did the Comptroller and Auditor general mention something about European accounts?
Comment on this
No, it was fines levied as a result of actions taken by the EU Commission. There are a couple of accounts where I am drawing attention to fines being paid.
Comment on this
In general they relate to non-transposition of EU directives or late transposition of them.
Comment on this
That would be when the government has not reached targets it is supposed to.
Comment on this
Yes. Typically when an EU directive is adopted member states are allowed about two years to transpose it into national law to give effect to the directive. If that does not happen, then after the two years has expired the Commission may initiate legal proceedings. If it continues not to be transposed, the Commission may go to the EU Court of Justice where a fine can be imposed. There was just one case of that in 2025. It was payment of a fine by Vote 40 - Children, Disability and Equality to the EU Commission due to the late transposition of a directive.
Comment on this
I think it was on rights of parents and children. I do not have the detail. One of the chapters presented this year is on the accounting for EU transactions. We have a number of suggestions about how that could be made clearer. In that I give a background to the fines that have arisen between 2020 and 2025. There were a number of cases in 2024 as well.
Comment on this
While we are on that, is there a directive coming down that the Government is not going to meet environmental targets by 2030? Will there be a huge fine for that?
Comment on this
That would I think arise from non-achievement of targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. I have reported previously on that. It is out there as a possibility. It may not be in the form of fines as it may be more automatic. There is an obligation to try to buy credits for non-achievement of targets by us.
Comment on this
We have no indication of what that fine will be if do not meet the targets.
Comment on this
I reported previously on that. It is quite a big figure but there is a very wide margin of estimation involved in that.
Comment on this
What does Mr. McCarthy mean by a big figure?
Comment on this
I would have to check the figures we reported. A chapter in last year's annual report deals with the matter.
Comment on this
From what I have heard there might not even be any issue with us having to buy carbon credits because other countries might not do it or might not have done the same, so it might not even be something that comes down the line at all. It is a completely open question.
Comment on this
They may not have surpluses to sell to us.
Comment on this
So there might be nothing in it. It might be a nothingburger in the finish.
Comment on this
Except for the planet.
Comment on this
Just get rid of the planet.
Comment on this
It could be a cost or it might not be a cost. Nobody knows. It is as at that level.
The question I had was on the Local Government Fund. It is something people would typically fly by. Obviously the local property tax is an element of it. What exactly is in the financial statements the Comptroller and Auditor General looks at? Does he look at the allocations from the State to the individual local authorities and how those are calculated? Is that part of his remit? I mean the methodology behind it. Or is it just the accounting and monitoring of how the funds transfer?
Comment on this
Principally it is the accounting. The method of allocation and the choice of how the funding is allocated is dictated by legislation to a certain extent but thereafter it is a matter for the Department. Allocation of funding would be generally regarded by us as a policy matter and therefore not something we would comment on. The choice of allocation is for the Minister and the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
Yes, I am thinking of the methodology of whether it is by population and so on. I think it is broken out so that some of it is by population and some of it by area.
Comment on this
It is a complex formula and it is certainly something that, if the committee was minded to, it could ask the Department-----
Comment on this
I would like to do that. The Chair is probably in the same wheelhouse as me. He is in a county with a growing population and a growing need for services. Deputy Farrell knows this too. There are local authorities with significantly growing populations which may have lower funding. We can look at statistics like the number of local authority staff members per head of population. Countes like Kildare and I assume Wicklow and Meath, as well as Galway, do not have cities but have significant populations and they are almost at risk of being underserved by local government funding. I would like the opportunity to bring someone in so we could discuss that and really go through the methodology. Ultimately, the counties with a growing population are probably more in need of services than an area with a more static population and I would like the opportunity to go through that here.
Comment on this
On that point, there is a chapter in the Comptroller and Auditor General's annual report on the funding of local authorities. It is an area numerous members here have expressed concern about for a number of different reasons. I have spoken to the clerk to the committee and I propose that next week we scope this out. There are potentially a series of engagements to do with funding of local authorities. We can bring in the Department but also other agencies that fall under the remit, be that the LDA or NOAC. I am proposing we scope this out to see what potential engagements there are. To follow up on the theme of accountability and oversight, there is a big piece there in terms of the lack of oversight, especially for us and the Comptroller and Auditor General when it comes to the funding and accounting for of the funding to local authorities. We will scope that out. I agree it is an area we need to have a look at.
Comment on this
I was going to raise the Local Government Fund as well and ask what exactly is being audited there. It is €1.3 billion but as was explained, it is about the methodology as well. I totally agree with Deputy Neville on probing that further. As a new enough member, it is unsatisfactory we are not able to bring in local authorities. Can we be the public accounts committee that tries to start a process to ensure local authorities can come before us? What needs to happen in order for us to do that? We audit the Local Government Fund yet we cannot assess the performance efficiency of local authorities. It is wholly unsatisfactory. I do not know what needs to happen for us to be able to do that. The Comptroller and Auditor General is given the Local Government Fund to audit and bring before us yet our hands are in effect tied behind our back when it comes to local authorities and their performance. There are 31 of them across the country. It is a sizeable amount of public expenditure but they are beyond the reach of the public accounts committee. We need to do what we can and to start the process on that.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be aware that we have set up our working group looking at the remit of the Comptroller and Auditor General and the public accounts committee. There is potentially a difference of opinion on how we arrive at bringing accountability for the funding of local government. Certainly there is a substantial piece of work ongoing by this committee on that and I hope we will make considerable progress with regard to that not just when it comes to local authorities but other agencies and bodies that remain outside the scope of the public accounts committee and the Comptroller and Auditor General, and more importantly what needs to be done to come under that oversight.
Comment on this
The appropriation accounts are presented to us and we will probably use our work plan to plan out some of those. There is an item I want to ask Mr. McCarthy about. Vote 34 - Housing, Local Government and Heritage included a €4.9 million PAYE settlement with Revenue but the details of it seem quite minimal. Now the accounts are laid before and published could we write to the Department and ask it to provide more detail. I think a prepayment has been made in advance of a final determination but something on the scale of €4.9 million is very significant. Not all the details appear to be there, probably because it is a live issue with Revenue, but we should be getting more detail. I would like us to write to the Department.
Comment on this
There were four Votes where there were references to settlements with Revenue: Vote 13 - Office of Public Works; Vote 18 - National Shared Services Office; Vote 30 - Agriculture Food and the Marine; and Vote 34 - Housing, Local Government and Heritage. Some of them we have touched on previously when the National Shared Services Office financial statements were presented last year. The resolution of all outstanding matters with Revenue had not been concluded even at the end of 2025. The committee should ask them all for an update of those matters and for further details.
Comment on this
Is Mr. McCarthy aware whether the issue with housing relates to a small number of individuals with large outstanding amounts, or is this a whole category of workers?
Comment on this
We could write to all of the Departments as suggested but I would like us to get more details specifically on housing.
Comment on this
Could that be related to the amnesty Revenue introduced last year about the regularisation of employment status and the bogus self-employment issue?
Comment on this
If the Chair will leave it with me, I can check and come back shortly.
Comment on this
If we write in advance, it will give us more ammunition. That is the wrong word. It will give us more information ahead of making a decision whether to call people.
Comment on this
We move to correspondence. There are a number of B items of correspondence to consider today. These have been received from Departments and public bodies, and we will start with the three deferred items from last week’s meeting.
No. R2026/0498 is correspondence received from the Health Service Executive in response to the committee's request for further information regarding Autism Initiatives Ireland, dated 24 September 2026. This item was flagged by Deputy Farrelly and me.
Comment on this
I have followed up and queried that, and I am happy.
Comment on this
I am happy too. There is reference to an external review carried out in 2019 with regard to the body. PKF-FPM carried out that external review. We will ask for sight of that. They also touch on the €100,000 value improvement contribution being made by Autism Initiatives Ireland in 2019. We will ask for clarification of what that was for. Unless other members wish to contribute, is it agreed to note and publish the item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0499 is correspondence received from the Secretary General of the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation in response to the committee’s request for information in respect of the Office of the Government Chief Information Officer, OGCIO, and ICT, dated 24 September 2026. Is it agreed to note and publish that item?
Comment on this
I will flag one issue in that case it passed members by. A different approach seems to have been taken by the NTA and Irish Rail on different IT projects. This correspondence specifically states clearly that the OGCIO was never asked to get involved in the project that ended up getting significant financial writedown, whereas in the next generation ticketing project the OGCIO was very much involved. Can we seek assurances from the NTA as to why it would approve one project for peer support by the OGCIO for information and help, whereas the other one did not?
Comment on this
At one of our meetings in January, I raised the point about the circular. The train control centre was designated a capital project. Therefore, it fell outside the circular and was not an IT project. This correspondence goes into detail. The project is categorised on its main purpose but because it is a commercial State entity it falls outside the circular. When I asked Mr. Creegan what other governance mechanism was there, he gave a vague answer that they do something similar along the lines of the circular. It did not give much confidence. That is the reason. There is not anything wrong. It is a point I have raised here. When we look at IT projects more generally there are a number that are not included or categorised as IT projects because they were not the main purpose of the capital investment. They were an element of it.
Comment on this
It is important correspondence, but it raises considerable alarm bells in my mind. We need to feed this into our report on the failings and learnings that need to come from ICT projects. The OGCIO should be playing a major role, but it is particularly concerning when it says it is not proactive in going out to bodies and asking about IT projects and where failings are. It is more reactive. It waits for bodies to notify it. That is not good practice, particularly when you see major IT failings across the board. I also agree on the train management system. That is a major failing. The IT part of that project was significant and multiple millions of euro in value, and failings came from that. We need to write back to the OGCIO to ask what learnings have been taken from that. Is that something it is still willing to stand over? There was a miscategorisation in its role when it comes to IT projects of that scale. Going forward, there need to be changes to ensure there is proper oversight where something is deemed infrastructural and not IT, but where the IT part makes up a considerable percentage of the overall contract. We need to write back to get further clarification of what learnings have been made. Is that okay with members?
Comment on this
It is broadly to get confidence that all learnings from IT projects are being fed back to the OGCIO whether or not they are commercial State entities. We need the centre to be learning from all of these failings , putting out better guidance circulars, and making sure there are better governance structures in place.
Comment on this
Is it agreed to note and publish the item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0501 is correspondence received from the Secretary General of the Department of Finance, regarding the late laying of the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman 2024 financial accounts, dated 24 September 2026. Is it agreed to note and publish the item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0503 is correspondence received from the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation, regarding the appointment of Ms Catherine Pierse as Accounting Officer for the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, dated 29 September 2026. Is it agreed to note and publish the item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0502 is correspondence received from the Secretary General of the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation responding to the committee’s request for information regarding the Irish Rail traffic management system, dated 25 September 2026. This item was flagged by Deputy Farrelly and me.
Comment on this
Can we seek further clarification specifically on the projects flagged red in the traffic light system being employed by the Department to understand where they are at and where they have fallen down? What is the delay and the project overrun? Can we get a detailed note on each of those projects? It would be useful in our work.
Comment on this
I agree with that. It is quite concerning. One of them was the next generation ticketing. On the Department’s traffic light system, it is given RAG status. It improved from red to yellow for them under the subsequent review, but it outlined some of the issues there. There are four other major projects.
We do not really have an oversight as to the overall cost of them, what the delays are, what the challenges are, the cost overruns or details of any interventions for these five projects that have been identified by the Department. We need to see what interventions have taken place, what delays, as they say, why they are on this amber light or are being given a red-light status, the cost overruns and the delivery challenges. We have done a comprehensive piece of work on our IT projects. One is possibly contained within our database that we have amassed. I spoke to the clerk before the meeting and he will check but a number of them, potentially, are not listed by ourselves and we have not captured them in the scoping exercise we carried out. Maybe we need to go back and have a look at that. I know there was a specific timeline in terms of the questioning we put out to the Departments and bodies. There may be a slight overlap there where we potentially miss some of these. We will just double-check that. There are projects here with significant concerns, in my view.
Comment on this
Are they all IT projects? Maybe that is something for us to clarify. In terms of next generation ticketing, I specifically asked the NTA both at this committee and the transport committee whether there were any issues with it or any missed deadlines. I followed this up with parliamentary questions. The answer I am getting back and the answer it gave this committee was that everything was in order, there were no missed deadlines and there were no issues. It is concerning for the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation to now be telling us it was red-flagged and now has moved to yellow. That is certainly not what it told this committee or the transport committee.
Comment on this
From recollection, I think there was a report that there were staffing issues that had been resolved. I agree it is quite concerning, given Indra is the company responsible for delivery of this and the fallout from the train management system. There are other issues also in terms of the Ernst and Young report, and what engagement is taking place between Indra and Irish Rail in the compilation of that report. While we are looking at one small section here there are bigger issues at play outside of that as well. I agree absolutely.
Comment on this
The NTA very much painted the train control centre as a project that was progressing well, which was in stark contrast to how Irish Rail was interpreting it. I am very conscious that this cannot happen again. I am now concerned, given what they told this committee versus what we are seeing here. Are they doing the same thing again?
Comment on this
Unless there are any other comments, is it agreed to note and publish this item? Agreed.
I will move on to the work programme. On 15 October, the committee will examine the 2025 financial statements of Uisce Éireann. On 22 October, we will examine chapter 26, the procurement of hot school meals, with the Department of Social Protection. The Department of Education and Youth will attend in a representative capacity. On 5 November, we will look at examining the provision of school transport with the Department of Education and Youth. We will also invite the Department of Transport along with Bus Éireann to attend in a representative capacity.
With regard to any other business, we had discussed earlier in our private session the issue of RTÉ, the ongoing issues around funding and the oversight of the reform programme within RTÉ. We had a comprehensive discussion on it. There are considerable concerns here. A number of members spoke extensively on the issue. It has been agreed to write to the Department and to the director general of RTÉ, and to have an engagement with those parties after the October break. We will schedule an engagement. Deputy Geoghegan spoke in our private session.
Comment on this
Irrespective of what we are reading about in our papers today, and hearing from Mr. Bakhurst, hopefully, moneys will be found and maybe that issue will be resolved. Over the long term, this is illustrative of issues we identified at this Committee of Public Accounts, which relate to who is ultimately accountable for the delivery of the RTÉ strategy. When the Department officials were here they said it was not their job to oversee the delivery of the strategy. When RTÉ were here they said that NewERA, which formed part of the NTMA, had some particular role. The Chair might recall that we were asking, and I was particularly asking, a lot of questions about this 400 headcount voluntary exit programme RTÉ were to get to as part of its target. It was nowhere near that target. That is the reality. It was said to us that it was not all about headcount and it was about personnel-related operating costs, but after our last hearing with RTÉ the annual accounts were published for 2025 and its personnel-related operating costs, at least at the end of 2025, were still at about 50%. The target is to get to 45%. Mr. Bakhurst subsequently in an email that was published said that in the middle of 2026 it is now at about 48% as it relates to personnel-related operating costs.
The bottom line is that as part of its strategy it was provided with €50 million, according to RTÉ's own documents, to fund a voluntary exit programme of 400 people. I heard Mr. Bakhurst yesterday on the radio saying that it has already secured 100. Unless there are new numbers we know this is not correct. There were 67 provided in terms of the voluntary exit programme and the balance to that 100 figure Mr. Bakhurst referred to were suppressions. The State has given RTÉ money to carry out a voluntary exit programme. The State has given it money to carry out a whole series of other measures, including providing high-quality content. To be fair to Mr. Bakhurst, we can see a lot of evidence of the improvement of content in current affairs and sport that he has overseen. At the end of the day, what we are concerned about here is the spending of public money. We know that RTÉ will become subject to audit of the Comptroller and Auditor General but we need to hear from the Secretary General of the Department as to what control mechanisms are being put in place so we do not arrive at the situation we are currently in, where on the one hand we have one side saying the strategy is not being delivered, the other side saying the strategy is being delivered, and we actually do not know where the truth lies. We need to get to the bottom of it.
Comment on this
To build on the points Deputy Geoghegan has made, ultimately it is regrettable to see such a public fallout from this on both sides. It is no way to professionally manage a situation like this. From our work perspective, I would like to see the detail of what is being reported on as a written agreement between the Department and RTÉ because the accusation is now that the Department is reneging on the commitment it put in writing for 2027. It would be prudent of us to request sight of that to see if we can ask further questions. It would be important for us to see that level of funding adjustment, which is essentially a cut to the RTÉ's budget next year. As it is being reported, to only learn about this a couple of hours before the budget was announced potentially has massive ramifications for what RTÉ can achieve next year. I believe that much more will play out over this in the next couple of days and weeks. From my perspective, I would like to see what is being discussed as a written and signed agreement between both parties.
Comment on this
I agree that is key. It is an objective question. RTÉ says it has a written agreement and it is in line with the written agreement, whereas the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, says that RTÉ is in breach of it. It is an objective question that can be determined. It is not an opinion. In order for us to make an objective determination, we need to see that document and then be able to see what progress has been achieved. It seems to me pretty incredible that this is foisted upon RTÉ and public sector broadcasting workers at the eleventh, and further, hour with no notice and so on. We could help to get to the bottom of this by getting the document.
Comment on this
Reflecting on the discussion we had earlier, it is important we have the Department before us. I say that because we do not want the Committee of Public Accounts to be a place where agencies that require funding and Departments have a public spat with each other. What is different in this case is that in July 2024, following issues that arose at this committee and other committees, there was a decision of the Government to expose or commit the State to multi-annual funding.
That was done on the basis of an agreement between the Department and RTÉ. The questions for the committee, in terms of protecting public money, are whether this agreement has been enforced and whether the funding provided has delivered what was hoped in the agreement. I agree that this should be objective.
I also do not want to undermine the Department's ability to be able to withhold funding at any time if it does not feel like it is getting progress. We have seen in areas in the sporting world where withholding money can ensure greater delivery or enforcement of an agreement. The key thing is that it is about the mechanisms. What are the mechanisms in the agreement which allowed the Department to withhold or delay money? Is it a matter of withholding or delaying money or is it a matter that money is now no longer available? These are two very different things. It is very clear that this is not a budgetary discussion. It is a discussion about the exposure of the State and public money, an agreement which was signed and the enforcement of that agreement. The committee has a remit for that and this is the place where we should be holding Accounting Officers to account.
Comment on this
To add to that, I want to make the point that the public spat taking place at the moment is quite unedifying, to be perfectly frank about it, but we do have a duty to probe the agreement that was made. The Minister is effectively saying a lack of performance and a lack of transformation are taking place in RTÉ and RTÉ disputes this. We need to interrogate the document and see what the terms and conditions of it are. The public back-and-forth is certainly no way to do business and it is very unedifying to see.
Comment on this
It is regrettable that this has become public in the way it has on our airwaves and in the media at the moment. If there is an agreement and the Department is contending that the terms for the funding are not being met and that it is going to cut funding, then we really do need to drill down into its case.
Comment on this
We will certainly ask those questions and ask for a copy of the agreement. We will make provision in our work programme for engagement. We should also follow up with the Department because there is pending legislation to ensure RTÉ comes under the remit of the Comptroller and Auditor General and, therefore, we will be able to provide proper fiscal oversight of the organisation. I must say it is concerning that the enabling legislation still has not been passed. I know the Comptroller and Auditor General said previously there had been some limited engagement with RTÉ on preliminary works to go in and start the auditing process of RTÉ. Will the Comptroller and Auditor General tell us where we are with that? How prohibitive to commencing the work is not having the legislation?
Comment on this
As I have explained before to the committee, we are awaiting the legislation. We are trying to take the work forward on the basis that it has been indicated that we will be responsible for the audit. We have tried to bring it forward as much as we can but we are going to be under significant pressure if we have to take responsibility for a financial audit of RTÉ for 2026. Really, it is over to the Oireachtas to pass the legislation and allow us to engage fully.
Comment on this
At what point does it create severe difficulties, where the Comptroller and Auditor General will not be in a position to be able to do the auditing for 2026?
Comment on this
In the normal way, we would already be undertaking interim audit work for 2026 at this stage, had we responsibility for the audit for 2026. There will be a limit to what we can do in the time that will be available if RTÉ is to report with an audit certificate from me for 2026 by, let us say, March or April 2027.
Comment on this
With the agreement of members we will write to the Department to express our concern and frustration with the delay, the slow movement of the legislation and the potential impact it will have in ensuring there is proper fiscal oversight, which is a key component of reform and accountability in the RTÉ organisation. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Is there any issue under any other business?
Comment on this
Very quickly, to come back to the Revenue settlement on Vote 34, this was in relation to PAYE compliance covering the tax years from 2021 to 2025. I do not have the full details of it but it relates to matters like benefit-in-kind, employees paid as if self-employed, travel and subsistence claims and contracts of, or for, service. The total amount paid to Revenue was €4.9 million and this included interest and penalties of €788,000.
Comment on this
The committee should explore that further when we have more time. Mr. McCarthy may not know from the audited note but does this relate to a small group of people with very high benefit-in-kind settlements or was it a larger category of workers with smaller amounts? Maybe we will get these details from the Departments.
Comment on this
It is probably best to ask them for that level of detail.
Comment on this
Am I right in saying that the scale of €5 million is significant?
Comment on this
It is €5 million but it is over four or five years. Typically, benefit-in-kind would be relatively small amounts, and I understand some of it includes matters such as professional subscriptions, but then there are other cases where I understand it involves the private use of vehicles or the provision of accommodation and these could be more substantial figures. The Department will be able to provide better feedback.
Comment on this
I may be probing too far into what the Department should be answering but does Mr. McCarthy think it is likely to involve staff members of the Department?
Comment on this
Yes, people on the Department's payroll.
Comment on this
It is an issue we need further information on. Having given considerable time and engagement to the issue of bogus self-employment, we are hearing that a proportion of this relates to misclassification of PAYE workers. We need further information around how many people were, essentially, bogusly categorised as self-employed in local authorities. What other settlements have there been? This settlement was made to Revenue. Obviously, when someone is categorised as self-employed when they should be an employee they are denied other workers' rights, such as sick pay, maternity pay or pension provision. We need further clarification and information as to whether other payments have been made retrospectively to these individuals to rectify the issues there as well. I am not sure whether this would be captured in any of the accounts.
Comment on this
I do not have that level of detail. I understand the payment to Revenue was in the early part of this year so I would imagine that if there are any related adjustments to be made they will probably be hitting in 2026 or later years.
Comment on this
We will follow up and try to get further information from Revenue with regard to this. Do members wish to raise anything else? As there are no other items which members wish to raise, this concludes the session and we will now suspend for a couple of minutes before our engagement with An Garda Síochána.