Update on Committee's Report on Vote 20: An Garda Síochána - 2023
The Comptroller and Auditor General reported €2.5 billion in Garda expenditure in 2025, alongside a capital underspend and €13 million in non-compliant procurement. Reviews found that poor accommodation planning for the 2024 Europa League final wasted €248,500, while camera errors led to 2,785 penalty notices being cancelled and €445,600 in potential fines being lost. The Commissioner said most recommendations on major-event planning had been implemented and outlined strengthened procurement controls; he also expressed confidence in the protected disclosures unit while reviewing its arrangements. Members raised concerns about Garda staffing, rural electric-vehicle suitability, training and financial oversight, with the Commissioner agreeing to provide further information and examine the vehicle issue.
Contributions 489–736 of 736. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
As a legal person, the Commissioner might talk us through it. For example, what is the largest deposit currently being held by An Garda Síochána?
Comment on this
There could be individual deposits of millions. For example-----
Comment on this
No. If I was to give a hypothetical example of a case that people would see in the media, if the Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau seizes €10 million worth of cocaine and €1 million in cash, we take that in and it is logged. It is counted first. We have money-counting machines now as a result of the amount of cash we now coming across in the context of drugs. We obviously have to have two people counting and a supervisor in order to get the numbers right. Then, it is secretly stored away until the trial comes around. During the trial or even before it, the defence can look to see that exhibit. They can say that they want to see and go through it. It might have to be forensically examined, fingerprinted or whatever. To answer the question, when it comes to the court case, we would usually bring all the exhibits to the courts. If it was several million in cash, we would not do that unless it was absolutely necessary. We would keep it in secure storage. Sometimes-----
Comment on this
It may be needed. The reality is that if a defence team,a judge or a jury say that they want to see an exhibit - it does not matter if they want to see the gun, the drugs or the cash-----
Comment on this
The Commissioner might come back to us on this. The example of CAB was given. I hear what the Commissioner is saying in terms of evidence, etc. He also spoke about the security arrangements around money when it is being held. Previously, information has been given to the committee regarding money going missing from Garda stations. There was considerable concern around the relevant procedures and the number of cases that were or that are currently being investigated. Will the witnesses update the committee as to the number of investigations that are currently taking place with regard to money going missing from Garda stations?
Comment on this
I do not have the number with me, but I will be happy to provide it. What was originally given to the committee in writing related to the number of cases which did not necessarily involve An Garda Síochána. That was clarified. I am happy to give an update.
Comment on this
It would be good to get an update.
We have been following the issue relating to deportation flights closely. Some clarity was provided regarding the rationale for the number of gardaí on each of the flights. However, this is a matter of concern. On a flight to South Africa in February, 133 gardaí accompanied 63 returnees. There was another flight to Poland. I do not have the figure for that. Considerable numbers of gardaí have been involved with these flights. The Commissioner that these officers are primarily from the Garda National Immigration Bureau. How many gardaí work within the bureau?
Comment on this
I do not have the total number involved. Some of the gardaí from immigration would be there on overtime. In the context of the number on the flight to South Africa to which the Cathaoirleach referred, the ratio was roughly 2:1.
Comment on this
I understand that. Can the Commissioner provide the number of gardaí working within the Garda National Immigration Bureau?
Comment on this
No, but I can certainly get that quite easily.
Comment on this
In 2020, the number was 115. In 2025, it was down to 99. Is it lower than that currently?
Comment on this
No, I do not think so. The other thing that we would certainly do with some of those flights would be to augment them with other detectives.
Comment on this
Primarily it is, but sometimes we have to augment it with other people.
Comment on this
The Commissioner might provide a breakdown on all of the charter flights in respect of which there is information and on the number of gardaí from the Garda National Immigration Bureau involved.
The Commissioner mentioned overtime. I am sure sending a garda to South Africa on overtime involves a considerable cost. On a number of occasions I asked for a breakdown of the costs involved. I know some of these are picked up as financial costs at European level, but we do not have figures as to the security costs involved per flight. How much did the flight to South Africa cost in policing terms?
Comment on this
It is actually quite difficult to break down per cost. We have provided the amount over the course of a year, which is €1.6 million. That was with respect to the flights themselves. Certainly, we can go back and if there is a specific flight, we can try to break it down. We will have to go through everything.
Comment on this
If it could be broken down, that would be good. There is a value-for-money aspect. I get that there are security costs. No one is questioning that. My interest is in whether we are getting value for money. With 133 gardaí on a flight to South Africa, we need to get a breakdown on the number who were working overtime. Were they all working overtime? What are the costs involved? Many of the flights involved are charter flights, and gardaí come back on some of these flights. Will Dr. Coxon provide a breakdown on how long they spend in the countries to which they travel and , the arrangements that apply when they are in those countries. On some occasions, charter flight flights are not used and other arrangements are put in place. The explanation given in this regard is that it is done for security reasons. Will Dr. Coxon outline what kind of security reasons would lead to a garda not coming back on one of those charter flights returning to Ireland regardless?
Comment on this
I can give an example. When we were in Lagos, in the context of the idea of having more than 100 gardaí there and trying to find their way back, it just made sense from a risk perspective when everything was evaluated. I want to be clear that cost is one of the things that is looked at. Determinations are made on a case-by-case basis as to whether it makes sense to do it by means of a charter flight versus another method.
As a way of being helpful, please know that we work with Frontex. We sit on the Frontex management board. I do not know if members are aware of the background to this, but there is a specific formulation around how these charter flights are done across Europe. What we are doing is not inconsistent with what occurs across Europe with respect to removals. In fact, the 111th meeting of the Frontex management board just occurred in Dublin in September. With regard to what we are doing with respect to the 2:1 ratio - if somebody is particularly high risk, it can go up as far as 4:1 in terms of the number of gardaí on the flight - the methodology used in assessing the risks and making the determination on the numbers is consistent with what is happening across Europe. We are not outliers in this regard. Our formulation is based on our work with Frontex in this regard. As the Commissioner noted, we have an overall officer in charge of the operation, an escort leader, a back-up team leader and a back-up property team leader. We also have medics, interpreters and human rights moderators.
Comment on this
That is excellent.
The other thing that is important to note, without getting into details of operations from a policing perspective, is that we have to ensure that everything is kept secure and as calm as possible on these flights. Gardaí who are on the flights cannot ask for back-up. What you have is what you get when you are in the air. We have had times when that has been a challenge. Certain types of use of force cannot be used in the air. Unfortunately, in terms of how this operates across Europe, the number of gardaí is impacted with respect to considering all of these things.
Comment on this
On some flights, there are children aboard. It is really important, therefore, that we maintain order on them. Earlier in my career, I was on some of these flights. On one flight, a Swiss police officer badly assaulted. To be blunt about it, a considerable chunk of his face was bitten off. That has absolutely firmed up my belief that in the context of anything we do around this, we have to be make sure that we see to the welfare of the men and women we are sending abroad. The other aspect is that rest periods and all sorts of other things need to be taken into account. I know the Cathaoirleach did not say it, but these flights certainly are not jollies by any means. I assure him of that. It is difficult work that those involved are doing.
Comment on this
I am over time. I thank the witnesses. I do not think anyone is questioning the need for deportation flights or for the gardaí to be on them. It is incumbent on the Committee of Public Accounts to question the value, the cost, etc, of these flights. We are not questioning the necessity for them.
Comment on this
We can certainly pick one of them out, maybe the South African one, break down all the details and supply them to the committee, including who was on the flight, where they were from and the overtime and subsistence rates involved. We can provide all that.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. With the agreement of the witnesses, I will allow members to come back in for a short supplementary round.
Comment on this
Sorry, I will allow Deputy Neville in and then we will open it up to a second round.
Comment on this
At least the Chair is not being paid time and a half or double time every time he goes over time.
Comment on this
I noticed that Deputy Kenny got a good bit of time as well.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. It is because of a serious matter that they are before the Committee of Public Accounts today. I totally understand that they are professional people running a professional organisation.
My first question is general in nature. Has the Garda Commissioner been in post less than 12 months?
Comment on this
It has been a year. I will not tell the Deputy what it feels like, but timewise, it has been year.
Comment on this
As long as he does not age in the US presidential manner, he might be okay. How does the Commissioner feel about the state of morale among gardaí?
Comment on this
Any garda who is listening will be happy hear the Commissioner say that it is excellent. He is not going to qualify his comments whatsoever.
Comment on this
No, I certainly will. We have a workforce heading for 19,000. I will not say that every person is delighted. That would be unreasonable. I have travelled extensively around the country during the past year. I have met thousands of gardaí, particularly at all the big events. I am really happy with the level of engagement that has taken place and with a lot of the work that has been done. Most of the people we have are really engaged. We have done surveys of our workers. We see that the majority of our people have a real sense of purpose about the work they do. That is why I say it is excellent. I think it is really good.
Comment on this
That is fine. How does the Commissioner think they feel about the use of phones and how they go about their daily jobs being recorded? Are any of those things having an impact on how they do the job or how they feel about it?
Comment on this
Yes, when I say morale is very good, it is obvious that gardaí sometimes operate in very difficult circumstances and have to deal with a lot of things that I and the other senior gardaí did not have to deal with when we were younger. They have to deal with social media, phones and intimidation, as we saw in particular during the fuel blockades. There are a lot of tough things for gardaí to deal with now, but it is my job to try to make sure that they have all the tools they need to do their job and to support them.
Comment on this
Is the Commissioner happy that the court system, legislation and the rules and regulations that apply are helping them to do their job or are these holding them back to any degree? If so, in what areas are is this happening? I refer specifically to pursuit or any other that methods they might employ in their work. Do the laws of the land fully back them up or should something be changed?
Comment on this
As I referenced earlier, it is certainly my belief that the legislation around drivers in An Garda Síochána is not where it should be. Ten gardaí are currently the subject of prosecution for driving offences while at work. My view is - and I have said this on a number of occasions - that the standard applied to gardaí when they are doing their duty should not be the same as that applied to normal people. They deal with really difficult circumstances and we expect them to respond, to come quickly and to help us out. Then, if something happens, they are prosecuted. Certainly, I do not think it is adequate as it is.
As I said earlier-----
Comment on this
It is in agreement with me. As I said earlier, I have spoken to the Ministers for justice and Transport. We corresponded with the Department of justice, which sent that correspondence on to the Department of Transport. We suggested changes to legislation, which I hope will be moved on.
Comment on this
Is the GRA happy with the training its members have received?
Comment on this
It is probably not for me to comment on how the GRA feels, but I think everyone in the room knows the position. It has articulated its position well publicly to the effect that it is not happy about it. Again-----
Comment on this
Does the Commissioner agree with the GRA?
Comment on this
No, again, everything is not absolutely adequate, but, as I said a few minutes ago, my job as Commissioner is to try to do everything I can to improve things. One of the things is training. We are certainly trying to improve driver training. I went through it in quite a lot of detail earlier. Is everything perfect? Of course, it is not, but we are working on it, putting resources and money into it and I hope the GRA would acknowledge the amount of effort we are putting into it.
Comment on this
That is fair.
I will change tack. An Garda Síochána is an Irish organisation that is primarily land-based, but we also have helicopters, aircraft and everything else. What is going on there? What is the situation with the aircraft?
Comment on this
We have had these for 25 years. We have a Garda air support unit.
Comment on this
Has An Garda Síochána bought new aircraft or is it looking to do so?
Comment on this
We have three aircraft. We recently purchased a new fixed-wing aeroplane, which cost approximately €14 million. It went through procurement. We were supported by the Government, so we have it in place. It is an absolutely excellent-----
Comment on this
What does An Garda Síochána use it for?
Comment on this
We use it for a number of things. Primarily, it is a surveillance platform.
Comment on this
I am reluctant to go into it in detail at an open forum like this, but it is primarily for surveillance.
Comment on this
It is for surveillance of many types of crime. The other thing is that it has quite a decent capacity, so it allows us to move gardaí, for example, an armed intervention team, around the country if we need to do that quickly. If there is a barricade incident or something, we can move people down from Dublin quickly or we can move specialists in roads policing or whatever it might be if we need to.
Comment on this
We have bought two helicopters but have not received them. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Yes, that is correct. We are in the process of replacing two of the helicopters we have.
Comment on this
I hope they are not like our electric buses, namely sitting in a shed somewhere.
Comment on this
No, absolutely not. The standard of these machines is exceptional. They are the top European standard.
Comment on this
Why do we not have them if we have bought them?
Comment on this
I will go through that now. They are Airbus H145s. They go through a rigorous process of testing and certification. People may not know this, but the military fly our aircraft, so we deal with it a lot about certification. They have to go through a number of agencies, but we hope to have one quite soon and maybe-----
Comment on this
There are drawdowns at different times. Mr. O'Connor will probably be able to give a bit of detail about it.
Comment on this
Approximately 24 months ago, but that was the initial stage, as the Commissioner said.
Comment on this
The first payment was made two years ago.
Comment on this
There are two helicopters, so they have different dates of first payment. I have given the longest period.
Comment on this
However, that is standard in the acquisition of aircraft.
Comment on this
I am not saying it is not.
We have an issue in Kildare. We have a significantly growing population and we do not have enough gardaí. If I ask the Minister for justice about it in the Chamber, I am told it is an operational decision made by the Commissioner. What can we do to ensure north Kildare gets more gardaí? We have issues with antisocial behaviour, be it in Clane, where we have had significant local events, or in housing estates in Celbridge, where we have continual events. I work closely with the superintendent and the community gardaí. We have some of the best people, but, to a man, they will all say that they need more support. How can we ensure we get more gardaí in north Kildare especially, considering the growth, development and increase in population?
Comment on this
I am glad to tell the Deputy that this October we will be allocating an additional 12 gardaí to Kildare.
Comment on this
Twelve gardaí. Will we lose any or is that 12 new gardaí?
Comment on this
Yes. Since I took over as Commissioner, 78 additional gardaí have gone into Kildare.
Comment on this
Seventy-eight, but we need more and we need to be able to get them.
Comment on this
Again, communities all around the country want to see more gardaí. The Deputy is absolutely right.
Comment on this
Kildare has some of the lowest numbers per head of population. It is one of those areas where we probably do not have the big Garda stations because we do not have those populations in the villages. Maynooth, even with having a university, does not have a full-time Garda station. Celbridge does not have one. These towns have populations of between 18,000 and 23,000, which is significant and will only grow in one way.
Comment on this
As I say, 12 out of the October intake is quite a significant number. We take a number of factors into account when allocating people. I do not disagree with the Deputy. I do understand that Kildare has a big population, there are challenges and it is a growth area. I take the point made by the Deputy.
Comment on this
I will go back to one remark made at the start when the Deputy asked me about morale, and I said it was excellent. I certainly do not want to come across as glib or anything when I said that.
Comment on this
To put some context on that, around President Trump's visit, I visited a load of the gardaí working in Doonbeg, and in Dublin Airport and Shannon Airport. Everyone, to the man and woman that I met, were absolutely fantastic, very proactive and delighted to be involved in it, were in really good form and very happy with a lot of the things we provided for them. It is in that context and that was my very recent interaction. I certainly did not mean to come across as glib.
Comment on this
No. I asked the question because I come from a Garda family so I have seen the changes and know the changes at first hand. I know the difficulties of being a garda and that it has transformed compared to the way it was 30 years ago. I am very conscious of that. Obviously, there are the pay deals, be it the transformation from the initial pay deal to the 1995 pay deal, and then on to the guys from 2011 to 2013, who are some of my friends and lads I know. I do know the difficulties and challenges faced by gardaí. People join the Garda now and you hear that they leave. When I was growing up that was not something; you joined the Garda and stayed. That has changed and I am very conscious of that. What we need to do here is to hear that and know that. It is easy for me to know it because I have lived with those people who are my family. The Commissioner has an opportunity to say it here and that is why I wanted to ask that question. I did not mean it in a negative way either.
Comment on this
Yes, as the Deputy said, I wanted to put context on it. Like I say, it is absolutely a tough job.
Comment on this
It will not be taken out of context either.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Neville. Are the witnesses okay to hang on for a few minutes to open it up to a second round of questions? I will try to limit members to five minutes or thereabouts.
Comment on this
There are two north Kildare TDs here and they have been well-served. They have got 12 gardaí in the last hour. Fair play to Deputy Joe Neville in procuring that. It would be remiss of me not to confirm that there are new gardaí being added to Ringsend, Irishtown and the Donnybrook policing districts as well. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Yes, absolutely. We certainly have a number of challenges in those areas and we are trying to really work hard with those communities. There have been a number of high-profile things, for example, when playgrounds were damaged in the area. Also in that area, we have a number of events that take place at the Aviva Stadium. We are conscious that we have to put extra gardaí in. In October, again at the next out-take of new gardaí, there will be additional gardaí going to Donnybrook.
Comment on this
I thank the Commissioner. I wish to return to a few issues. If I understood it correctly, Deputy Commissioner Coxon gave the example that around 119 gardaí would arrive in Lagos on a chartered plane. While I do not want to put words in her mouth, she said it would not be appropriate to leave 119 gardaí in Lagos where presumably hotels and different flights would need to be hired. From both the perspectives of cost and safety, all of those gardaí were put back on the charter flight on the way back. Is that how those operational decisions are made?
Comment on this
I do not want to get into specifics. I am happy to drill down further and present a written submission. What I am saying is, even aside from that scenario, everything is looked at in the round, as the Commissioner mentioned, including what kind of rest period is required. Sometimes people have travelled for 20 hours, working, etc., and it is about the location that they land in and what is available. I know there are discussions with the Department about what that looks like. It is a contextualised decision to be made.
Comment on this
We got a list of which deportation flights gardaí came back on the chartered flight-----
Comment on this
-----and which ones gardaí did not come back on the chartered flight. Commissioner Kelly clearly presented the security risks and the reason for that number of gardaí. From the perspective of the Committee of Public Accounts, we just want to know whether it was right to spend money on a chartered plane to go back. Would it have been cheaper for gardaí to return on a commercial flight with an overnight hotel, overtime, etc.? Are those the kind of things the Garda Síochána considers when making those decisions?
Comment on this
Yes. That is all part of the decision-making process.
Comment on this
Is it a value-for-money decision as well as a security decision?
Comment on this
When that material is provided we will be able to examine that closer.
Comment on this
If I can add, in any of these considerations with these flights, and I know because I have interacted extensively on this with Detective Chief Superintendent Minnock who is in charge of immigration, we try and do the best value for money and the shortest time they are away. Obviously, we do not want gardaí out of the country for any more time than is necessary.
Comment on this
They probably do not want to be doing it either.
Comment on this
It is not exactly a glamorous gig to be going on a plane and flying back again.
Comment on this
Again, we have lots of difficulties and some really challenging ones, where we even had flights where there was a medical emergency and planes were diverted. I do not want to name the countries but we have been diverted to some really challenging places where we have had gardaí ending up going to hospital with people and it was really challenging. I can tell members that I certainly would not like to do some of those duties that they have had to do. It is difficult. To go back to the point in the Deputy's question, we certainly try and do it for best value for money whatever the combination of flights are. We are more than happy to supply the details from our point of view.
Comment on this
Obviously, more people are being deported now both on chartered flights and on commercial flights than previously.
Comment on this
It also appears in the budget there is more money being assigned for this.
Comment on this
From a policing standpoint, how does that work operationally? If an ordinary garda comes across an individual, in whatever circumstance, and he or she identifies that that individual is subject to a deportation order but has not left the country, does that person get detained immediately? How are the persons selected for these types of involuntary deportations?
Comment on this
The deportation process is quite complex. If there is an order in place, An Garda Síochána has to make sure that people are good to go and they have been through every part of that process.
Comment on this
If gardaí ran into somebody on the street, in that random scenario, does that person get detained? This is if gardaí are looking into them, and they have not committed a crime but the gardaí know that they are subject to a deportation order.
Comment on this
Most of the deportation orders that we have are planned deportation orders. They are ones where we select a group of people. We make sure that they have gone through everything - all the judicial process, any appeals or anything. Everything is done and they are selected. We then move them to a location beforehand and then we move to the flight.
Comment on this
When does the Commissioner anticipate that An Garda Síochána will publish the code of conduct for CCTV? As I understand it, that is the final piece in the jigsaw. There is a commencement of a particular piece of legislation. A lot of laws have been passed recently that deal with the whole area of CCTV. A lot of communities want to see more CCTV in their areas. Will the code of conduct be published soon? When it is published, does the Commissioner envisage that An Garda Síochána will install more Garda-operated CCTV cameras in communities, particularly in the Dublin area, which is an area that I am interested in?
Comment on this
I will hand over that question to Deputy Commissioner Cleary.
Comment on this
On CCTV, we are at 99% completion on the code of practice. It is at the ministerial approval stage at the moment so I would expect to see that shortly.
Comment on this
Does the deputy commissioner envisage more Garda-operated CCTV cameras being installed in Dublin after the publication of the code of conduct?
Comment on this
Yes, that is the plan. I do not have details of locations or anything like that.
Comment on this
On the issue of CCTV, am I right in saying that at the moment both local authorities and the Garda Síochána do not have a capital fund they can draw on for the replacement or installation of new CCTV? Is that correct?
Comment on this
An Garda Síochána has a modest fund of €2 million. We have asked for more. I think the Department also has a fund.
Comment on this
A fund of €2 million would not go very far.
Comment on this
Ballymun, for example, has the largest CCTV scheme. It is 25 years old.
It has almost 50 cameras. A sum of €2 million would not get you a handful-----
Comment on this
To be fair to An Garda Síochána and the Department, we sought additional money. We will have to recalibrate it once we look at-----
Comment on this
I raise it because more should be available to the Commissioner. I support that and it needs to be communicated to the Department for the future. It makes a difference on the ground.
Comment on this
We had a difficult start to the year in Finglas with the tragic death of Grace Lynch. I know the Commissioner has met her parents as have many other members of An Garda Síochána. Scramblers have been a prevalent issue for some time in our community and there was a frustration. I was asked by a journalist if I was calling for the Commissioner to resign. I said I was not, but if it was not dealt with in six months that I would be. That led to the headline saying the Garda Commissioner should resign. That is not my view. I compliment him. There has been a marked step in attempts at senior level, including him, to engage with senior political people to look for solutions including changes in legislation. That has never happened with any previous Commissioner. I compliment him on that. There was a blame game for a long time between the law needing to be changed, resources, stuff happening on the ground and directions or no directions. There was all of that stuff. The clarity has helped. This will be an ongoing battle as with all policing.
Quarter 1 of this year saw a significant improvement in seizures. It was almost 1,000 e-scooters and scramblers in quarter 1, which I think was the equivalent of the entire previous year. How are we doing in quarters 2 and 3 for seizures of e-scooters and scramblers?
Comment on this
I have the numbers for the first half of the year from January to June. We had 1,865 in total. That is the full range of e-bikes, e-scooters, quads and scramblers. Specifically, we had 180 scramblers and 1,412 e-scooters. It is a significant number. We have had a number of days of action. We have a special operation, Operation Meacán, in relation to this. These days of action have been particularly successful. We have tried to publicise those. As the Deputy rightly said, this will have to be continued work. We just have to keep our foot on the pedal on this.
Comment on this
The failure to police this had a significant eroding effect on people's confidence. People could see a bike going up and down the main street. They were saying that if the Garda could not do anything about that, it could not do anything about other issues. I ask the Commissioner to continue doing that for people's safety, for confidence in the Garda and all of the other reasons.
Pursuit training is important but I agree that pursuit is not always the solution. That is why section 109A was brought into the Road Traffic Act. It was to allow seizure at the place of storage. At our safety forum meeting we had a discussion about seizures under section 109A versus more general seizures where the Garda would also take firearms, drugs and other things. There seems to have been some discussion on the power to destroy or the requirement to go the High Court. In section 109A, it is clear that people have to go to the District Court to have the bike released and the Garda also has the power ultimately to destroy it. It was not clear that it would have the same powers under section 40. Will Mr. Kelly give some clarity on that? Does the Garda have the power to destroy if it is seized under another section? Is there still the requirement for them to go to the District Court?
Comment on this
As the Deputy rightly pointed out, it is complicated because there are different sections involved depending on what we seize them on. If we seize them, the person it is seized from has the opportunity to go to the District Court and make an application to get them back. Every case is different, but my understanding is that in most of those cases they are not returned, which in my view is positive.
Comment on this
Can Mr. Kelly provide us with the number of people who made those applications? I imagine it is small.
Comment on this
It might be difficult to do because the Courts Service has the numbers. On our internal portal, where we put out instructions and information, we have set out specific guidelines for gardaí on the front line. These include what their powers are to seize and how they can dispose of them. Our preference is that we seize them and get them destroyed. We are doing that with lots of them. We put this out on social media. We are trying to get the message across when some of these expensive vehicles are seized. When it goes to District Court we obviously challenge those.
Comment on this
If you go to the Garda stations with responsibility for this, the backyards of those Garda stations are full of seized vehicles.
Comment on this
I imagine storing them will become a problem. The next frontier in that issue is the sale of e-scooters and scramblers. I ask that having had some success on one side the Garda turns its attention to those areas where shops and online presences are selling. Some of the retailers have responsibilities too. I thank the Commissioner.
Comment on this
My first question is about the stay of a chief superintendent in a Dublin hotel during Joe Biden's visit. That was investigated by the anti-corruption unit. I am asking the Commissioner to ask each of his current deputy and assistant commissioners if any one of them stayed in a five-star hotel during that visit and to confirm in writing to the committee the outcome for any of them if they did so.
Comment on this
I am sorry. Why does the Deputy want that?
Comment on this
I asked at the time about people who were promoted. I am unaware as to whether or not the Commissioner promoted any individuals who may have been under investigation at the time by the anti-corruption unit.
Comment on this
Maybe we could get this in writing to bring some clarity to it. The Deputy wants me to ask all the members of my senior leadership team if they stayed in a hotel during the Biden visit. Is there an allegation around this against one of them?
Comment on this
There is no allegation at all, but I asked the Commissioner at the time, while the investigation was ongoing, not to promote anybody considering that some of them may be under investigation through the anti-corruption unit. However, promotions did take place. For all we know as a committee, someone was promoted to a position within An Garda Síochána while they were under investigation by the anti-corruption unit. I can absolutely provide it in writing and, through the Chair, propose that the committee discuss that we would provide it in writing. If not, I can personally provide that as a Member of the Dáil.
Is it Garda procedure to acknowledge every protected disclosure?
Comment on this
The assistant commissioner has probably outlined the policy position in relation to it.
Comment on this
I will state that if a protected disclosure comes into the protected disclosures unit, and the means by which it comes in means it is known as a protected disclosure, then yes, there is engagement with the protected disclosures unit-----
Comment on this
Can I just finish my sentence? You do not have to explicitly state that you are making a protected disclosure. In that, as I stated, there are a number of alleged wrongdoings but you do not, with the legislation, have to explicitly state that you are making a protected disclosure.
Comment on this
That is on the individual. The protected disclosures unit receives a protected disclosure. As Ms Gunne said, it does not have to say protected disclosure. Is there acknowledgement of that from the protected disclosures unit to the person who sent in the correspondence?
Comment on this
Where you have gone through the structure where it is known it is a protected disclosure, a follow-on form is filled out that it is a protected disclosure and it is known explicitly that it is a protected disclosure.
Comment on this
Yes, where it is known that it is explicitly a protected disclosure, and you are engaging. The whole part of the remit of the protected disclosures unit is that follow-on and engagement with the protected disclosures unit.
Comment on this
Per the RTÉ documentary, why was acknowledgement not sent to Dr. Donal Corcoran?
Comment on this
Chair, we are not going into this. We are precluded in relation to any details that would touch it. I would be doing injustice to various arenas where you have adjudications or processes ongoing and I would ask such a question.
Comment on this
It is just to put it on the record.
Comment on this
To be clear for the record, every protected disclosure sent to the protected disclosures unit is acknowledged by the protected disclosures unit.
Is that correct? Yes or no?
Comment on this
Deputy Kenny's question is very pointed on a particular area and I am not-----
Comment on this
I am asking about a very basic question about procedure.
Comment on this
I think it is a fair question in the general sense. Is it the policy that every protected disclosure-----
Comment on this
In a general sense, when it is known and you are engaged in the process of a PD1, the formal process of making a protected disclosure, you will be advancing into filling out a form and there will be engagement with a protected disclosures unit.
Comment on this
Okay. Again, regarding protected disclosure procedure, are all case closures independently reviewed or quality assured before the closures?
Comment on this
On a protected disclosure, what I stated previously is that when the reporting person comes forward, their perception of wrongdoing does not necessarily mean that wrongdoing will be found or will be proven. To clarify for the committee, there is an independent process in relation to the protected disclosure manager. They appoint an examiner or an investigator to look into the matter. I have spoken today about the nine areas of wrongdoing. One of those is you have to be an employee, and that employee list has expanded to cover volunteers of An Garda Síochána, consultants, contractors and trainee applicants. A protected disclosure can be closed for the fact that you do not reach the definition of a protected disclosure, for instance, you do not come in under that remit. A protected disclosure will be closed where a file has been sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions, the investigation has concluded and the matter has then been referred for conduct or discipline, it has been dealt with and has been transferred to Fiosrú for investigation, or it is dealt with by lessons learned or policy. The reporting person is advised of the closure and then they have a number of days to look for a review. A review will be from a person of a higher rank. In the past, an examiner or an investigator was at chief or principal officer level. That review will be conducted by an assistant commissioner and will be carried out.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for letting me back in. I have two very different topics to raise. First, I ask about the impact of social media on crime and how it is changing the world around it, for example, young people involved in behaviours they should not be. I am obviously speaking to happenings in Athy initially but also to more local issues where there is antisocial behaviour for dares and things can be videoed. We all see clips of videos from Snapchat and screenshots that are shared on WhatsApp. We have all seen terrible things. Especially where you see it with younger people and they may be challenged or part of a ring, what has the Commissioner seen there with that behaviour and what can we do to make our community safer around that? I am speaking as a public representative who is a parent of teenage boys, a coach of underage teams and who knows lads. What can we do to help them and assist them in any way possible, not to mind that these things can be used against people too in other ways?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Neville. I completely agree with him. It really is a huge problem in contemporary societies for all those reasons he has spoken about. There are a load of different things on the policing front that we are challenged by with social media. I will go through a few examples of it. We have people who go on social media to call out other groups for fights and arrange these on social media. We have all sorts of intimidation of and shaming done towards young people. Then we have the phenomena of driving the wrong way and lots of generated imagery around child sexual abuse. There are many areas that are really challenging.
Comment on this
Would Mr. Kelly recommend a ban? As Commissioner, what would he like to see? Would he like to see social media banned for under-16s? Would he restrict it? What is his own view, as someone in a very responsible position?
Comment on this
I can certainly give my views but it is probably outside my area of competency. We have Coimisiún na Meán in place. I would certainly say some of the outright bans are often difficult to police in effect, and we have seen the experience of that in other countries. For me, the solution is education and parental involvement. We do a lot of work on this ourselves. We do extensive work in schools programmes. We give lots of advice. There are different agencies providing advice to parents of young children on the use of devices, the access to them and the amount that the children are on them. There is definitely a big education piece. It is not a law enforcement piece on its own. Law enforcement is only one part of it.
Comment on this
Yes, but is it being seen in the day-to-day work of An Garda Síochána?
Comment on this
I am just going to change lanes, specifically vehicle lanes, to talk about OSCAM. Is that the group which overseas the operation of traffic and speed cameras, etc? Is that correct?
Comment on this
Apologies, it is that group GoSafe which oversees it.
Comment on this
OSCAM is the system. How much is GoSafe paid every year, or how does that work?
Comment on this
It is a multi-annual contract. I will ask Mr. O'Connor, who will have the details of it, to bring the Deputy through it.
Comment on this
The contract was signed in November of last year. It is for €200 million.
Comment on this
I think it goes as far as 2031 but I will confirm that later.
Comment on this
On average, it is about €50 million a year then, is it?
Comment on this
Okay. How do we get our money back? Obviously, it is through the speed fines. Is it cost neutral, or how does it work?
Comment on this
As set out in the C and AG's report this year, you would assume it would be cost neutral. This year we had to pay slightly more owing to the issue that the C and AG identified, but ordinarily for every €100 collected, An Garda Síochána keeps roughly €60 for its cost of running it. We then refund the Department of Finance 40%. It might be 60:30, actually.
Comment on this
It might be 60:30. How much is a typical fine?
Comment on this
It is €160. How much does An Garda Síochána get to keep?
Comment on this
This year we are at about €23 million and we repatriated €10 million.
Comment on this
Of that €160, An Garda Síochána keeps €60, is it?
Comment on this
Those are the percentages we work out of, roughly.
Comment on this
About €100, give or take, and then €60 goes to the Department. Speaking to the issue then, was the issue the cancellation of some of the fines?
Comment on this
Was it 2,500 fines that were cancelled? Is that right?
Comment on this
There were two incidents called out by the C and AG. In one case we did not, and in the other case our contract did not have a reclaim clause. The new contract has a reclaim clause.
Comment on this
So the company messed up. From what I have seen the company did not have the right-----
Comment on this
In one case I think the C and AG might have said that it was An Garda Síochána's issue and the other it was not An Garda Síochána's issue.
Comment on this
Let us talk about the one where it was not An Garda Síochána's issue. Were the guns not working or what was the situation?
Comment on this
If I may, it was that all the cameras have to a location data thing built into them so when you get the fine it tells you where you were stopped. The location data in this particular camera was incorrect. That was the problem with it.
Comment on this
So you cancelled 2,500 fines, but at the same time, how much was the cost to the State? What was the loss of revenue to the State on that?
Comment on this
I do not think it is quite correct to describe it as a revenue of the State. It is a fine. It is an amount collected. I do not think either that I would describe it as having cost us €480,000.
Comment on this
So how much is it? Was the number €445,000?
Comment on this
Why did the company not have to pay us? If we are paying it €50 million a year and it made a mistake, I would have thought surely it would have to pay us.
Comment on this
The full €445,000 includes two incidents. I think the figure for the GoSafe problem was €299,000. That was basically-----
Comment on this
------motorists who were detected speeding and where a fine was issued, but then it was realised that they could not collect on that.
Comment on this
It was the company's mistake and obviously that money was forgone. I want to check why. Under the terms of the agreement, it should have had to pay the State or the Garda.
Comment on this
There was not a provision in the contract for that.
Comment on this
Will there be a provision in the future?
Comment on this
There is in the one we signed in November.
Comment on this
There is an acknowledgement that it was an oversight or that it has been rectified.
Comment on this
I am sorry for keeping the witnesses here. I will try to be brief. Going back to the point I made earlier about public service and value for money, in terms of the service the public is actually getting, I took from what the Commissioner said that he broadly agrees that Garda stations should be accessible where possible and phone numbers of Garda stations should be accessible and available to the public. In our local area, senior gardaí are advising members of the public to dial 999 when they need to call the Garda, even in non-emergency situations. Is that appropriate, in the Commissioner's view?
Comment on this
It is correct to an extent. If there is a call for service, where someone needs to call the Garda to come and do something, for example, if they see someone in their back garden, there has been a traffic accident or whatever, we need people to ring 999. That is the message we have been trying to get out. What we have seen happening over years is that people ring their local station, but with the system we have in place, the local station must then pass it on to a communications centre. It just delays it. We certainly have been messaging out. We have done it all ourselves, actually. If you have a call for service, if you need the Garda, you need to ring 999.
Comment on this
There are situation where people might just want to pass on information.
Comment on this
They can ring their Garda station or call in.
Comment on this
That is the point I am making. They cannot ring their Garda station. This is the reality on the ground. Even district headquarters are not answering the phone because they are busy, obviously, and I understand that. The system needs to be examined. The public service is not available to the public unless it is an emergency where they dial 999. People have a serious hesitation about dialling 999 because we are taught it is for emergency situations. I urge the Commissioner to try to ensure there is better accessibility to the Garda for the public. The old system of community policing seems to be turned on its head now because gardaí are simply not available to the public.
Comment on this
The Deputy's points are well made, particularly his first one on gardaí not answering the phone. This is something that we have spoken about in the reforms we are trying to do on first contact. The call for service is a separate thing and I have described that. The other thing is that, when someone rings a Garda station and wants to talk to a garda, whatever the issue is, if they just want some advice, of course the gardaí should answer the phone. The Deputy is right that the reality of it is that gardaí can be very busy in stations. We do not have a dedicated person who is sitting there to answer a phone. One of the things we are looking at, and we have made some moves towards it, is having a dedicated person who is front of house when a member of the public comes to the station, a member of Garda staff to do some of this work for us. I do not disagree with the Deputy. We need to improve what we are doing in that area.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. If I can refer to the Cork angle in terms of allocations, something that has been discussed very often is what we would regard as an underallocation of Garda members to the Cork city division in particular. We got a large number of November 2025, with 36 gardaí allocated. The Garda Representative Association estimates that there is a shortage of 75 gardaí in Cork. I have to make that case to the Commissioner in terms of future allocations. I ask him to consider Cork and Cork city. While we have seen improvements in visibility, that has been a city centre issue. It has not spread out to the suburbs, to the areas I represent in Cork South-Central. I am not necessarily asking for an answer today but just to make that point.
I submitted a parliamentary question on the use of electric bikes by An Garda Síochána. In August 2023 there were eight bikes deployed, as I understand it, on a pilot basis. Three years later, it is still on a pilot basis and no bikes have been added. As the Commissioner knows full well, that is a tool that can be used in high-visibility policing. It ensures gardaí can get around communities much faster and in a more visible way. Why are there not more electric bikes?
Comment on this
Ms Toale may be aware of the detail on that.
Comment on this
I saw the parliamentary question and have followed up with my transport colleagues, as the Commissioner alluded to, just to understand if there is a possibility of minor use of e-bikes. It was not actually being captured in our own details about fleets. It is not being captured and will be captured going forward.
Comment on this
I would appreciate if the Garda could look at that. Gardaí on the ground are telling me it is something they would welcome. As a public representative, I would welcome it. It would enable them to police greenways, areas through estates and so on more readily. Going back to the UEFA Europa League match in May 2024, I understand the policing cost of that was €7.8 million. That was entirely funded by the State. There was no element considered a private event.
Comment on this
I think there would have been non-public-----
Comment on this
It would have been fully owned by the State, by the Vote.
Comment on this
In terms of the changes that were alluded to earlier in respect of non-public duty events, would a similar event now be considered such that the Garda would not be charging for its services?
Comment on this
We would have to work through the model. It is commercial but at the same time we understand that the State would want this to happen. As the Commissioner said, there are three buckets and it might be parallel with two of them. That is one of the issues we are looking at when we are doing the policy. The policy is being looked at.
Comment on this
In terms of the accommodation issue around that match, there was approximately €248,000 wasted, in effect, on accommodation that was not used. What assurances can the Garda give us that there are better systems in place now, to ensure that does not happen again?
Comment on this
As I said earlier, we have certainly taken the lessons from that. There were a number of reports around it. By norm now, gardaí source their own accommodation. We certainly do not do it to the extent that we previously did. In exceptional cases, or if there are particular units, we will provide it. There now has to be a name attached to a room, so we have to have the name of a particular garda who is going to stay in the room. If they are told they are given a room, they have to take it. If for some reason they do not take it, they are certainly not paid a subsistence allowance for that night. We have a structure in place around the governance where it is only at quite a senior level that we will authorise the rooms. For example, in the recent presidential visit, we had rooms authorised but the controls around them were certainly far different from what we would have seen in that operation.
Comment on this
I want to raise two final issues. The first relates to the Garda station in Greystones in my constituency of Wicklow. The substandard nature of the station is an issue I have been following up with the OPW, the Department and at every level possible. It has impacted provision of safe and appropriate policing within the area. I have spoken extensively to the superintendent. She has said quite clearly that it is inhibiting the level of policing that can be provided in the area in terms of the ability to provide additional resources within the fast-growing population of the Greystones area. I do not expect the witnesses to have an up-to-date position on it now but there has been a shifting timeline in respect of the necessary upgrades to the station, which concern accessibility, toilets and basic facilities that should be available to both gardaí and members of the public. Will the witnesses follow up to see exactly where that is at? There have been repeated announcements by local members of the Government, namely, the Tánaiste.
He announced two years ago that it was imminent but I am being told it has not even moved to tender stage, so maybe you will be able to get an update on that.
Comment on this
There is one last issue I want to raise. I was asked to specifically raise this with you, Commissioner, by the family of a young man from my home town of Bray, County Wicklow. The young man had been homeless and was known to homeless support services. Tragically, he was found dead in July 2025. I knew this young man personally. I grew up with him. I know his family and I spoke to them in advance of this. They gave me their consent to speak about him but I am not going to name him for obvious reasons. I want to make it clear there are no suspicious circumstances around his sad passing and neither I nor the family are suggesting anyone was responsible for it, but there are serious questions about what happened afterwards.
He was found dead in an industrial estate in Dublin. On his person he had a number of belongings, including his public services card, his phone and other items. On the face of it that should have assisted in identifying him very quickly. He remained in the Dublin City Mortuary until January 2026, nearly six months after his death. A death notice appeared on rip.ie that named him without giving any more information and he was subsequently buried in a pauper's grave in Dublin. He was buried on his own, not surrounded by family or anyone else, because his family were not notified of the situation. Tragically, it was only in May of this year that the family, trying to find out where their loved one was, stumbled across that death notice on rip.ie. That is how they found out their loved one was dead and had been buried. They did not know about it. No one from An Garda Síochána contacted the family to notify them that their son, their loved one, their brother, was dead and that he was lying in the city mortuary and subsequently that he had been buried. This is despite the fact he had been identified. His public services card, which had his PPS number, could quite quickly have allowed his identity to have been established. He had been known to the Garda. Gardaí had been at the family home on a number of occasions. Medical records, summonses, etc., were still coming to the family home but there was no attempt to contact the family. I am not looking for answers here because there are a lot of questions and answers needed here. I have spoken to the Minister about this and I am asking Commissioner if he will agree to meet the family. This has been a saga that has been hurtful.
Fortunately, there has been some small movement. A licence was issued by the city coroner and the man was exhumed yesterday from that pauper's grave and he is going to get a proper funeral now. Those arrangements are being made so he can get a proper funeral service surrounded by his family, who should have been there in the first instance, and loved ones. Commissioner, will you agree to meet the family? There are so many failings here. Tragically, I do not think this is an individual case because there have been other high-profile cases in which homeless people have died and there have been serious, systemic failures in contacting families and identifying individuals. Tragically, this case highlights serious failures that have let down citizens, families and loved ones. I do not want you to get into the specifics because I appreciate you do not have the answers, but how could a situation like that possibly arise where someone is found dead with identification on them in the form of a public services card and there is a failure to notify loved ones?
Comment on this
I am not familiar with the details of the case but I will take the facts on face value as you have presented them. First, my condolences to you, Chair, and to the family. From what you have said that is absolutely and completely unacceptable. We will certainly make contact with the family. The assistant commissioner down there is Paula Hilman. I will get her to meet the family in the next week if they are available and we will try to do whatever we can now to rectify the situation and bring whatever comfort we can to the family. As I said I am not familiar with the detail of it, but from what you have said it sounds completely unacceptable. We will do everything we can to help the family now and to rectify the situation as best we can, but you have hit the nail on the head in that we need to look at whether this is a systemic issue with people who are homeless. We had another case in the Phoenix Park that I had concerns about as well. Thank you, Chair, for bringing it to my attention.
Comment on this
I will talk to you outside the meeting. There are other issues there. A family liaison officer was never appointed even after that contact was made by the family in May, so there have been real failures here. Even stuff that could be of some comfort to the family, like the personal belongings that were found with the individual, have never been returned to the family, even though they know the contents because the city coroner told them what the individual was found with. There have been so many failures. I will follow up with the Commissioner. It would be helpful. The family are not looking for heads on a plate or anything like that. They just want answers and, more importantly, to ensure something like this never happens again, so a follow-up meeting would be appreciated.
Comment on this
Thank you. Unless there are any other questions that concludes our engagement for today. I thank the Commissioner and his officials for attending. I also thank the officials from the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration and the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation as well as the Comptroller and Auditor General. Is it agreed the clerk will seek any follow-up information and carry out any agreed action arising from the meeting? It is. Our next meeting will be with officials from Uisce Éireann.