Update on Committee's Report on Vote 20: An Garda Síochána - 2023
The Comptroller and Auditor General reported €2.5 billion in Garda expenditure in 2025, alongside a capital underspend and €13 million in non-compliant procurement. Reviews found that poor accommodation planning for the 2024 Europa League final wasted €248,500, while camera errors led to 2,785 penalty notices being cancelled and €445,600 in potential fines being lost. The Commissioner said most recommendations on major-event planning had been implemented and outlined strengthened procurement controls; he also expressed confidence in the protected disclosures unit while reviewing its arrangements. Members raised concerns about Garda staffing, rural electric-vehicle suitability, training and financial oversight, with the Commissioner agreeing to provide further information and examine the vehicle issue.
Contributions 241–488 of 736. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
There is confusion on this. What number of Garda members who have done the driving course and the training are in a position to pursue criminals on motorways, national roads and so on?
Comment on this
We have a very basic level of training which is called competency-based driving 1, or CBD1. That level is really very introductory. At that level a member cannot pursue. If they are trained to CBD2 they certainly can. We have several thousand people across the whole organisation trained in that.
Comment on this
So there is not a free pass to criminals? Are gardaí able to pursue criminals?
Comment on this
No, there absolutely is not. As I said earlier, in about 80% of pursuits we give permission for them to continue.
Comment on this
What is the extra training in connection with if we have thousands of members who can pursue criminals? Is this extra training to do with people driving the wrong way on motorways?
Comment on this
Yes, absolutely. As I said at the start, pursuit can often be a very dangerous thing. We saw our two colleagues from Cleveland Police in the UK, who were two highly trained police officers, and they were killed. I should be very clear that training is not the panacea to stop this problem. For the recent M9 incident, there were lots of gardaí in that area. It was not an issue around resourcing, pursuit, cars-----
Comment on this
Was that an operational decision taken at the time?
Comment on this
Yes. That was not the issue. Our preference is to not pursue. Our preference is to use things like stinger devices, which stop cars, and to put them at different junctions. That is exactly what we were trying to do that night, using things like air support.
Comment on this
I presume there is a record of instances when gardaí are told to back off.
Comment on this
In 20% of them. So, 80% of them go ahead and 20% do not. To give context of that 20%, if gardaí are pursuing a vehicle and the vehicle went the wrong way down a motorway, the control centre will tell the gardaí they need to stop and that they are terminating the pursuit because it is too dangerous. If it was a pursuit in the middle of the day around the time schools were emptying out and was passing through a highly urban area, that could be one where the decision could be made. It is taken out of the hands of the driver.
Comment on this
We saw the roll-out of high visibility policing in Cork city, which is very welcome. In terms of public service, in the constituency I represent we have Garda stations that are effectively ghost Garda stations. They are not accessible to the public. You cannot phone them and have it answered. In terms of public service, is it the view of the Commissioner that the people should be able to walk into a Garda station during normal operating hours?
Comment on this
Yes, but with the caveat that we have over 500 stations. Of course, we can never have every single station open 24 hours a day. That is not practical. Of course, no police service does that anywhere in the world. For us, we have a combination of different setups. The largest stations are open 24 hours a day and people can go in any time. We have certain ones that close at 9 p.m. and we have certain ones that are not staffed.
Comment on this
I note the recent approach, which is called "First Touch", around the 60 Garda stations the Commissioner has outlined he wants to improve, and that is very welcome. Does he accept there is a lot of work needed on this? I live in a town with 20,000 people and the Garda station is effectively not accessible to them. It is there and gardaí work out of it, but people cannot walk into it and cannot phone that Garda station and get an answer. That is not good enough.
Comment on this
As the Deputy said, we have started a programme of improving many of our stations and the services we provide in them. One of the things I have said since I took over as Commissioner is that first contact with the community is really important to us. We have certainly done a lot of work to try to improve that. One of the results of the high visibility piece the Deputy referenced earlier is that we certainly know that people are happier with the presence and that there is a deterrent factor in it.
One result of that is we know people are happier around the presence. There is a deterrent factor in that and we have seen various crimes reduced in areas where we have those HVPs.
Comment on this
I just need to move on, but I thank the Commissioner for that. On policing and non-public duty events, the C and AG made a number of recommendations. Are all those recommendations now implemented?
Comment on this
There were four in total. Two are fully implemented, one is 90% complete and, for the final one, we are waiting for the migration to the NSSO financial platform in quarter 2 of next year, at which stage-----
Comment on this
Mr. O'Connor might have mentioned this earlier, but how much was collected in 2025?
Comment on this
Does Mr. O'Connor think that is a fair reflection of the draw from Garda resources for non-public duty events?
Comment on this
I would not be best placed to answer that.
Comment on this
It seems this is a very subjective system in terms of what is and is not a public duty. For example, we had President Trump in Doonbeg recently for the Irish Open. Was that considered a public duty or non-public duty event?
Comment on this
The Deputy is right, and we have looked at all of this again relatively recently. With the new system, we are going to have events that are fully commercial and non-commercial, such as charities, fun runs and all of that, and then we will have State events. The visit of a US president, UK monarch, President Zelenskyy or whatever, are State events.
Comment on this
Can I clarify whether the Irish Open in Doonbeg was entirely publicly funded?
Comment on this
Yes, absolutely. We were not down there to police the golfing event. We were down there to protect the President of the United States.
Comment on this
How much did that operation cost?
Comment on this
We have not got the final figures yet. Obviously, it finished relatively recently. We estimated it would be around €30 million for the full cost of that.
Comment on this
Is that the entire visit or that particular event?
Comment on this
Yes, the entire event. There were a number elements to it. There was Dublin and Doonbeg, so there were several different elements.
Comment on this
Regarding the uncollected money, how far back does some of that go? Are we talking just in the past 12 months, two years or three years? How much is uncollected and how far back does it go?
Comment on this
Approximately €1.6 million remains outstanding today. If you look at it, there are three points at €500,000 each. That would be very current, as in maybe the past 20 days, then our legal advice is that €500,000 would be statute-barred, and the other €500,000 would be for a vendor that has gone insolvent or has been-----
Comment on this
Some of that will be written off then.
Comment on this
We are in the process of working through that with our colleagues in the Department of public expenditure to write it off.
Comment on this
That total debt might go back about ten years. I think the statute-barred kicks in at six or ten years. Very little of it-----
Comment on this
I might just clarify one thing for the Deputy. Our forecast for the US presidential visit was approximately €30 million. We think we are going to come in under that forecast but we are still waiting on some claims, particularly for overtime and subsistence.
Comment on this
I thank the Commissioner for that.
Comment on this
The witnesses are very welcome. Sticking with events, I want to focus on the commercial events. We focused on this in the committee last year with the previous Commissioner, and I think there was in and around a €45 flat rate being applied at the time. What is the new system and is it consistent? In particular, I am looking at large commercial events and making sure the Garda is recouping what it needs. What percentage of the Garda's costs is the target to recoup?
Comment on this
As the Deputy has rightly said, we have re-looked at the costs. Previously, we had a flat fee which did not take into account Sundays, Saturdays and bank holidays. We have now moved from that €45 flat fee to Monday to Friday being €57, which is an increase, and then on Sundays and bank holidays we have moved from the flat €45 to €75.
As Mr. O'Connor mentioned earlier, we never charged for Reserve members and now we are moving to €25 per hour for them. As the Deputy may recall, the previous Commissioner spoke about public and non-public. In the commercial events the Deputy is talking about, say for example it is a concert or a match, any policing that is within the grounds or the concert venue is fully non-public. We charge 100% for that. We charge every piece of that. For outside, and I think the then Commissioner Harris went through this in some detail last summer, we certainly have a responsibility around policing, so it is a 50% charge outside. I hope that clarifies things.
Comment on this
Does that 100% cover overtime, say Monday to Friday where it is at night or overtime, PRSI, accommodation or subsistence? Is the Garda charging 100% of that to the commercial entity?
Comment on this
And the Garda is comfortable that the €57, €75 and €25 figures capture that outside element?
Comment on this
Yes. We intend for this to come in February, and we are obviously in the process of notifying all the event organisers that this is what we are moving towards. I will double-check with Mr. O'Connor that I am correct with the figures.
Comment on this
Yes. It is our best estimate of a fully bundled cost.
Comment on this
Good. Will this new financial accounting system help us to identify these costs more easily and will the Garda have a separate programme? It is difficult for the C and AG to follow and it is difficult for us to examine. I am sure that is not the intention of An Garda Síochána, but it would be very helpful if it was broken out into separate programmes where we could follow the costs more easily.
Comment on this
We can provide whatever information the Deputy requires, as we now have it tracked. The advantage of moving to the NSSO is that the C and AG's recommendation was that this should not be on Excel spreadsheets, which we fully accept. We will have an accounts receivable module in the new NSSO so we will be able to check it. In essence, everything is currently there in Excel, but Excel has its weaknesses.
Comment on this
I want to turn to training, specifically training for domestic, sexual and gender-based violence. There was an Garda Síochána Inspectorate report recently that found there was an inconsistent response across the country and it recommended things like trauma-informed training. How many Garda members have completed specialist training for domestic, sexual and gender-based violence?
Comment on this
Everybody who comes out of the Garda College - all our new trainees - receive an extensive training programme around domestic violence and there are a number of different elements to that, so we certainly have that.
Comment on this
That is for new trainees, so what about-----.
Comment on this
That is all new people coming in. For example, there are roughly 1,000 new people this year who will have had that training.
Comment on this
That is great, but what about the current cohort?
Comment on this
Currently, all our protective services units are specialists in this area. They are all highly trained. They have a very extensive training programme they go through when they are assigned to those units, so they have that. We have also provided online resources.
Regarding the recommendations of the report, we have implemented many of the recommendations, which were welcome. I might turn to our deputy commissioner on operations, Ms Coxon, who deals extensively with this area and has done a lot of work around domestic violence.
Comment on this
The deputy commissioner might also tell me the percentage of front-line gardaí who have been trained in this area. We know it is one of the most persistent issues across the country.
Comment on this
I apologise because I do not have the figure in front of me, but I am happy to follow up with the Deputy on that. It is very important and we have done a lot of work in this area.
Comment on this
Absolutely. We all have to appreciate that a huge factor in how a victim feels and whether they will pursue prosecution is the first garda they meet, so it is essential all front-line gardaí are trained. I would like to know what percentage have been trained, what the timeline is to make sure they are all trained and what continuous training will be given, especially regarding trauma-informed training.
Comment on this
We have reported on this with the Policing Authority, which is also very interested in the trauma-informed approach. I can assure the Deputy it is taking place. We will get back to her in writing with the specifics of that.
Comment on this
Does the training programme include being able to identify coercive control when they are called out?
Comment on this
Yes. We have a risk assessment tool that is used by every member of An Garda Síochána who deals with somebody where there is a concern around domestic violence, including coercive control. That risk assessment tool is done in every single case and is able to be looked at not just by the particular garda who filled it out but by others as well to ensure we are identifying risks early on and are able to act on that. We are continuing to roll out more and more work with respect to the risk assessment tool in terms of standardising the approach.
We know that this is an area that is important to the Commissioner, and we are doing what we can to improve that approach.
Comment on this
It is absolutely essential in addressing the epidemic of violence in our communities. Do we have a percentage of the complaints to Garda responses? Do we know the number of complaints over the past couple of years from victims who have raised issues with the response they received?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean people who were unhappy?
Comment on this
I do not have any figures like that to hand. The reality-----
Comment on this
No. The reality is that many of them go to Fiosrú rather than An Garda Síochána. I wish to address something the Deputy said. When I took over back in September, domestic violence was one the key things I spoke about. We have done a lot of work in this area. The Deputy referenced a report that had some concerning findings in it, and there was also a second report. I assure the Deputy that those two reports were discussed at our senior leadership team meeting in a lot of detail the very week they came out. Dr. Coxon has rightly said that, at nearly every meeting with the Policing Authority, we discuss domestic violence and what we are doing in that regard. Obviously, the Policing Authority measures our performance and the metrics we have in this area. Domestic violence is central to all our policing plans. We have dedicated inspectors in every division dealing with it. With regard to the volume of it, we are getting about 63,000 calls per year in this area. It is absolutely terrible. We are absolutely determined that we are going to do everything we can in this area. I only say all that to reassure the Deputy that, certainly at the leadership level, we are determined that we are going to work really hard on this.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. Are all the divisional protective services units, DPSUs, fully staffed? I know there are a number of them.
Comment on this
There could be a couple of them that are down a couple of members. That is just the natural flow of people being transferred from-----
Comment on this
No, absolutely not. If any of them are down, they come before our demand meetings and we assign extra people to them. Certainly, we know they do lots of work. One of the things is capacity around those units. We have put extra people into some of them. They are working hard. Some of our finest officers are in that area. They are doing difficult work.
Comment on this
Dr. Coxon has reminded me that we did a review of the DPSUs, including the capacity and number in them. Definitely, we want to keep them fully staffed.
Comment on this
The Commissioner might to write to us with a follow-up, letting us know where the training is at and the percentages, etc.
Comment on this
I have less than a minute left. I want to briefly ask about overtime. We have spoken about this issue before as it pertains to my area. A lot of gardaí are being pulled in different directions, particularly with the EU Presidency. I commend the work of the various serving members in Fingal. I know that a lot of them are having to work several days in a row, do overtime, etc., to try to meet the day-to-day demands as well as the demand of the EU Presidency. I acknowledge and thank them for that. More broadly, I am wondering whether there is a percentage target of overtime. There will always be a need for some level of overtime, but is there an optimum percentage or figure? When will we have sufficient front-line resources to reduce that overtime level, or is there a need to reduce it?
Comment on this
The situation with overtime is costing the State a lot of money. We want to make sure that we are only authorising overtime that is absolutely necessary. Given the dynamic nature of policing, I do not think there is any police force in the world that does not operate like this. Sometimes, we have to use overtime. For example, we were faced with some unprecedented events in recent years. Look at the fuel protest this year and the significant cost of that to us. This is work on top of the daily work. We are never going to have resources in place 24 hours a day to deal with some of these big things. We have to bring overtime into it. To answer the Deputy’s question, there is no percentage we aim towards.
Comment on this
One of the things we want to do is have good controls around what we authorise to make sure we are only authorising what is necessary.
Comment on this
If we reach the 15,000 level and things are business as usual, should we see overtime come down provided there are no extraordinary events?
Comment on this
At 15,000, maybe not. It may be the case if we reach 16,500 at the end of the five years.
Comment on this
I want to focus mostly on the issue of roads policing. Obviously, we are seeing a worrying trend of road deaths increasing year on year, basically, since 2021. Unfortunately, this year looks set to be no exception. That goes against the grain of what is happening in most European countries. What stands in stark relief to that increase of fatalities is the significant decrease in the number of gardaí allocated to roads policing units. Compared with 2009, we are down about 45%. The witnesses might correct me if that has changed, but the most recent figures I saw detailed 645 gardaí allocated compared with about 1,050 in 2009. Why are we so far down? Why does An Garda Síochána seem to have such difficulty getting that number back up again?
Comment on this
As the Deputy rightly said, fatalities are up this year, tragically. We have had 134 fatalities, an increase of 13 from 2025. They occurred in 123 different collisions. It would be remiss of me not to say that every one of those is a terrible tragedy and my condolences go to all the families involved in those incidents. To answer the Deputy’s question around the numbers, we have 660 people in total working on roads policing. This is the biggest area of any one specialist area in our whole organisation. There is more in roads policing than there is in organised crime or our sexual crime units. It is the biggest single block of people. It is bigger than immigration. It is important to note that.
The other thing to note is that the vast majority of our detections are not detected by roads policing units. Rather, they are detected by front-line gardaí. For example, the majority of drunk driving arrests are made by front-line gardaí. One of the things I want to do is ensure we are getting the most out of the people we have in roads policing. They must be productive and efficient. We have made a number of changes to the structures of roads policing. In her previous role as assistant commissioner in charge of roads policing, Ms Catharina Gunne undertook a review of the structures and management. We have put more management in place. The numbers are quite instructive in that area. For example, there has been a 27% increase in drug-driving incidents. Our checkpoints are roughly in line with last year. There is no drop in any of those. Many of our lifesaver offences detections are all up and while-----
Comment on this
They would not just be by roads policing. The majority would actually be------
Comment on this
They are a combination. While deaths on our roads are up, tragically, we actually compare favourably across Europe around the numbers. That is another thing to note.
Comment on this
To clarify, is the Commissioner saying that the low numbers allocated to roads policing is not really a problem?
Comment on this
No. It is one factor. Of course, I read the report on every single one of these fatalities. Unfortunately, and tragically, in some of the cases, it would not even have mattered if gardaí had been there. The accident was going to happen. I will provide one example in this regard. A segment of those fatalities relates to people who had health issues. For example, someone had a heart attack, crashed their car and died. It is not all about policing. Some of this is around-----
Comment on this
Does the Commissioner accept that we have too few gardaí allocated to roads policing?
Comment on this
He does not accept that.
Comment on this
I will continue to ask the questions, if that is okay.
Comment on this
Former Garda Commissioner, Mr. Drew Harris, made a commitment back in 2024 at the transport committee that there would be an extra 75 personnel in 2024 and a further 75 in 2025. That did not transpire. The Commissioner is not making any such commitment as to whether we going to see an increase in the number of gardaí allocated to roads policing.
Comment on this
Will the Commissioner provide any numbers?
Comment on this
I can provide some numbers. How it works is that when we have new gardaí going out from the college, it gives us the ability to move other gardaí around.
Our next out-take is in October. At that October uptake, what I am doing is bolstering roads policing in one of our regions that is particularly low, which is the north-western region of the country. Donegal is an area where we have seen a number of fatalities. We will have an uplift in there-----
Comment on this
Can Mr. Kelly tell me a total number? Are we going to get to-----
Comment on this
The promise of 150 is gone.
Comment on this
There has to be an incremental approach to this. Like I said-----
Comment on this
We were promised previously. I know it was Mr. Kelly's predecessor, but we were promised 150. Now, Mr. Kelly is not even promising the 150 in the next year and a half.
Comment on this
It is important to talk about what the figure of 150 was predicated on. The former Commissioner was very clear that it would be based on incremental increases in the overall number of gardaí, which is what the Commissioner is explaining in terms of what we will get to in time. It was this number based on the overall number going up. That is something we are working toward. The overall figure keeps getting quoted out of context.
Comment on this
Mr. Kelly will not give me a figure now of how many extra gardaí in roads policing we will have, say, by the end of 2027.
Comment on this
I am not in a position to do that. I can certainly say that in the coming months and years the Deputy will see more people going into roads policing. For example, in October, that north-western region will see a significant uplift in its numbers. We looked at all the regions, at the numbers and the statistics. We have chosen to give a significant uplift into that area.
Comment on this
In April 2024, former Commissioner Harris directed every garda to do 30 minutes road policing a day. Was that ever implemented?
Comment on this
Is it still being implemented?
Comment on this
Every garda is doing 30 minutes road policing a day.
Comment on this
Yes, they are directed to do so. We track it. We have a tracking system in place. We are in the process of putting together a mobile app which would help us with more robust tracking of that. That has been in train for a long time. I mention that because the other thing that is important to talk about with respect to numbers in roads policing is the use of technology. Our enforcement numbers are up and it is because of a whole-of-organisation approach around it.
Comment on this
Let us say these numbers - I think it was said there were 660 in the roads policing unit at the moment - are people who are full time on roads policing. They are not drawn into other activities.
Comment on this
No, but roads policing has quite a wide area of responsibility. They do lots of different things. For example, I think people think that roads policing just does speeding or whatever. There are lots of different things that they do but all of it is focused on the roads.
Comment on this
Would they ever be requisitioned into going to a football match, a concert or something like that?
Comment on this
No, but they sometimes do escort duties. Again, the Deputy will see whatever that is. An ambulance has to be rushed to hospital with a Garda bike. The road traffic people would do it.
Comment on this
Mr. Kelly is telling me gardaí from the roads policing unit would never be requisitioned to a football match.
Comment on this
I would be loath to say never, but that is not their sole focus. Their sole focus is on roads policing. I would not say never, but it would be quite unlikely that this would happen. It would be the same as-----
Comment on this
I understand that it has happened. For example, for a match between Bohemian FC and Shamrock Rovers on 27 February 2026, six members of the roads policing unit were sent to do it. They were requisitioned last year on the day of the budget. Presumably, when we get the figures about 660, that does not state 660 but minus. They are still marked as doing roads policing when actually they are not.
Comment on this
I need to see the context on that. They could have been there on overtime, for example, which would have been an extra duty to what they were doing. While they could be requisitioned to work on the budget, they could be doing roads policing on the budget, as in managing traffic. It is hard to comment on that without seeing the full context around it. It would not be the norm that roads policing officers are doing front-line policing. That is not the norm.
Comment on this
I will raise the Crowe review, some of which was pretty shocking. It found a lot of gardaí were doing good work in terms of roads policing and so on, but it found "a significant cohort of officers who are disinterested", have a "poor work ethic", are "deliberately ignoring offences" and "whose productivity is comparatively low". It illustrated a significant cultural issue among a minority of officers. Is Mr. Kelly confident that those issues have been addressed?
Comment on this
We have done a lot of work around that. One of the key areas is around supervision and management. As I said earlier, Assistant Commissioner Catharina Gunne has led out on this for me. One of the things that we have done is put in extra layers of management there and supervisors. I thank the Deputy for saying that. It must be acknowledged this is a small minority of people in roads policing. I think the majority of our people in roads policing do a good job for us. Again, relatively recently, we lost a colleague, Garda Kevin Flatley, who was killed on roads policing duties. The vast majority of people do really good work for us on roads policing, but I do agree with the Deputy. Some of what was reported was absolutely shocking.
Comment on this
There were particular points around An Garda Síochána's ANPR equipment, which seemed to be unreliable and not working. A small cohort effectively did not care that they were not working. Are those issues in terms of equipment sorted?
Comment on this
We have the Crowe report. There is a whole series of recommendations in it. We have implemented most of them. We put together a team to do that. I am confident that a lot of the problems unearthed with the Crowe report have either been resolved or are in the process of being resolved.
Comment on this
The Minister for justice told Deputy Mark Ward that An Garda Síochána has been allocated €125 million for EU Presidency-related costs. Is that what the Commissioner considers the total cost of policing all EU Presidency-related events will be?
Comment on this
Does Mr. Kelly have a particular cost or estimate for how much the AI summit next Wednesday will be?
Comment on this
I do not have them broken down per event. I will check with my colleagues. I do not have them broken down by event.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being with us today and sticking through the lengthy session. I also want to come back to pursuit training. I am a member of the media committee. We recently had social media companies before us discussing the TikTok challenges that we all are aware of, which lead to youths driving the wrong way down motorways and, tragically, deaths and serious injuries. The first question is in relation to the EU Presidency and some comments made to the justice committee around the timing of training. Just to be clear, is assigning Garda resources to EU Presidency duties stopping gardaí from receiving the necessary pursuit training they need?
Comment on this
Before the EU Presidency came up, we were cognisant of the demands that were going to be on us through the whole Presidency. The reality of it was we made a decision at strategic level that there were some things during the EU Presidency we were not going to be able to do. We obviously had to maintain front-line policing, but some things like optional training had to be put back until the new year and after the Presidency. That makes complete sense. I think I said at a transport committee meeting that we would do pursuit training in 2027 because of the EU Presidency. In the interim, with everything that has happened with the M9, we have decided that we are going to accelerate that and get us started.
Comment on this
That is what I was going to ask. Is pursuit training now categorised within An Garda Síochána as optional training, or is it necessary training? I presume by his later comment-----
Comment on this
It is necessary training. We will start it this December.
Comment on this
I want to go through the timeline of that. Mr. Kelly said instructors have been sent to the UK, which is a free-of-charge training exercise because of the relationship. How many have gone?
Comment on this
I think 12 instructors have gone. The idea is they go over, are trained and they can come back and deliver the training.
Comment on this
It is self-sufficient then because they are trained. Is there a review taken of those instructors when they come back before they implement the training to front-line or rank-and-file gardaí? Do they just come back and go straight into it?
Comment on this
All this type of activity is worked through our Garda College. There is a whole series of things around learning platforms, the syllabus and lots and lots of work that goes on behind this. A lot of work would have been done to decide on who it would go to. Even sometimes when you go to other countries for training in whatever area it is, you still have to tweak it slightly for the Irish context. It can be slightly different. That is generally around training. My understanding is, when they come back, they will be ready to go to start training.
Comment on this
There is no additional cost in reviewing their training before they can-----
Comment on this
No. When I say no cost, there is obviously a cost in that we have to send people abroad.
Comment on this
I understand that but there is no additional review cost or anything like that.
Comment on this
The intention is members of An Garda Síochána will receive some of this training from those instructors by the end of this year. The figure that has been put out is six.
Comment on this
I do not have the number. We can get that for the Deputy. To be realistic, this is intensive personal training. It is not something one instructor delivers to 50 people. They are in the vehicle with someone. Usually it is one instructor with perhaps two students. To get any big numbers through that will take a while. The numbers at the start will appear relatively modest but we will have to gain momentum next year.
Comment on this
How many drivers are in An Garda Síochána?
Comment on this
If the Deputy will give us a minute, Ms Toale might have the number. There are several thousand at different levels.
Comment on this
That is what I am trying to get to the crux of - how many drivers An Garda Síochána has. I presume the majority if not all have CBD 1, the basic driving course.
Comment on this
I understand it is intensive training but the wait behind it matters to those who need it, in particular the families watching on who have suffered a loss. I am trying to figure out how long it will take to get a sufficient number passing CBD 2 or pursuit training that will serve the nation in the way we need it. That is what I am trying to get at. The Commissioner can come back on that in a minute because I have other questions he might answer in the meantime. Will pursuit training be mandatory for all drivers or selective?
Comment on this
Will that be a geographical spread or in areas with a history of incidents?
Comment on this
Both. Just to clarify, it is not our intention nor would it be practical, nor is it done anywhere else, to train every single driver in pursuit training.
Comment on this
I understand that. Is that pursuit training specifically designed for cars? The motorway incidents are obviously a huge challenge. Does it factor in scramblers as well, which are a massive blight on communities around this nation, or does it just focus on cars?
Comment on this
I will have to come back to the Deputy. I do not have the details of what the training includes. We will come back with a note on it.
Comment on this
I would appreciate that. I am surprised the Commissioner does not have that detail considering the number of justice committee meetings he has sat in in recent times and having met families who have lost loved ones due to the scrambler issue. It is crucially important that if this training is done, and time is invested and money invested in some sense - it will tie into the college training aspect - that we get what is needed from it, it is fit for purpose, it is not a wasted exercise or a wasted spend, and it tackles the core roots of the blight on our communities. Scramblers are a huge part of that, as are e-scooters and e-bikes.
Comment on this
It certainly will not be wasted. As I said earlier, it is not a panacea for this problem.
Comment on this
I am glad the Commissioner brought that up. I realise it is not a panacea for the problem, it is not the preference and there are other mitigating factors, but the lack of this training is having a huge impact on rank-and-file gardaí. I have spoken to gardaí in my area who are resistant to pursuing anything related to pursuit training for fear of not being able to deliver a successful outcome for all involved or the personal ramifications it might have for them. Garda Sean Shields lost his personal licence and got a road ban for trying to tackle a scrambler, as I alluded to. There is also the risk to their own life because they do not feel adequately resourced. I know the GRA and Association of Garda Sergeants and Inspectors have been calling vociferously for this training to be delivered to their members. The Commissioner is saying it is not a panacea, which I respect, but this is what his members are calling for and what they say is needed to be able to protect and serve the communities they are based in. That needs to be taken on board as well. While it might not be the go-to, gardaí across the country have to be sufficiently resourced to protect their communities. I did not mean to dwell on that as much as I did.
Comment on this
I am in lockstep with the two associations on this issue. They have been looking for this for many years. After I took over as Commissioner, at the first GRA conference I attended I announced we would do this. We have started to do it. The other thing is protections for gardaí. The Deputy may have heard me speak about this publicly on a number of occasions. I am doing everything I can to try to get protections for gardaí in those situations. We have sent a significant paper to the Department of justice with recommendations around legislative changes. I am glad to see the two Ministers involved in transport and justice are supportive. I hope to see that as soon as possible so gardaí going out to do their very best every day and night have the protections they need. I do not disagree with anything the Deputy has said.
Comment on this
There is a Garda fleet of 3,650 vehicles - I have taken that figure from the opening statement - 300 of which are electric. Are the vehicles suitable for pursuit training or will further investment be needed to deliver the training?
Comment on this
They are suitable. I am sure many of the members will have seen around the roads that the standard of our vehicles has hugely improved - not just in numbers but the standard. The standard patrol car we are moving towards now is a Skoda Octavia estate. We have spent a significant amount of money upgrading those vehicles when we get them. They are really good quality. On top of that, we have invested quite heavily in our roads policing vehicles. We have some particularly high-performance vehicles out on the roads to deal with issues on motorways, etc. The vehicles are of the standard we need. We need to continue to do that and improve them. As I said earlier, I met the head of transport and we discussed all of this at length.
Comment on this
The Commissioner does not see a need for further investment to modify or adapt the vehicles for pursuit training.
Comment on this
I mean for the specific stock at the moment to be able to deliver pursuit training.
Comment on this
I am out of time. If I may, Chair, did we get the figure for how many drivers there are?
Comment on this
I do not have the total number of drivers but to give the committee some comfort, in 2024, 2025 and 2026 a total of 2,933 gardaí received driver training. We can give the full number in writing afterwards. That is just over the past three years.
Comment on this
Is that the basic driving training, CBD 1?
Comment on this
It is all together. In addition, by mid-November we will have four gardaí who are fully trained as driving instructors. There are three different types of training around pursuit training to be able to deliver it. A further 11 will be done by the end of this year, so there are 15 in total.
Comment on this
Will the witnesses provide the committee with a breakdown of the full number of drivers in An Garda Síochána, including how many are trained in CBD 1 and CBD 2, and a projected timeline for the number for pursuit training?
Comment on this
I welcome our witnesses and thank members of An Garda Síochána across the country for their very hard work, particularly in my hometown of Mallow and across my constituency, Cork North-Central. I will keep my questions firmly within the committee's remit in relation to public expenditure, governance, internal controls, systems and procedures used by An Garda Síochána, in particular around protected disclosures and the Garda Vote. I will not seek to determine the merits of any individual allegation or criminal investigation.
I wish to start with an issue I raised with Mr. Harris, when Mr. Kelly was at this committee, in relation to the stay of a chief superintendent and his wife at a five-star hotel in Dublin during Joe Biden's visit to Ireland. I am fully aware of the anti-corruption unit. I spoke to Garda Gary Walsh on two occasions in relation to the anti-corruption unit investigation into this matter. We received acknowledgment that €664,000 was spent on hotels during this visit, but a conclusion has not been arrived at on whether or not a chief superintendent based in Dublin stayed in one of the hotels with his wife. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Did that investigation produce anything in relation to spouses or partners receiving publicly funded accommodation during this time?
Comment on this
So the investigation did not look into that or it came to a conclusion that it did not exist.
Comment on this
When we were here at the meeting on 26 June, the Deputy raised the issue around the senior officers. As the Deputy rightly says, it was assigned to our anti-corruption unit, led by Detective Chief Superintendent Gary Walsh whom the Deputy met. They conducted a thorough investigation into this under the auspices of Deputy Commissioner Cleary. We were not able to find any evidence of the allegation that the Deputy brought forward.
Comment on this
Okay. In relation to the €664,000, did all of that money comply with Garda rules?
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows, there have been issues, particularly in Operation Argillite, which was the operation I spoke about earlier around the Europa League final. We certainly have had inadequacies around our controls around hotel rooms. Since that, we have put a lot of changes in place, for example in some of the recent events we have had. We have now moved towards a practice whereby members who require accommodation will now source it themselves and then it is refunded through their subsistence overnight rate. However, in exceptional circumstances, we provide hotel rooms, particularly for specialist units that need to move as a group, for example, a water unit, a technical bureau unit or something like that.
Comment on this
They have to be authorised at quite a high level. We have done a lot of work around that.
Comment on this
During that time, I wrote to the Commissioner as well in relation to the promotion of individuals while the investigation was ongoing. Considering that we have had significant promotions within An Garda Síochána since the Commissioner's appointment, following this meeting could he establish as the Commissioner whether any current deputy or assistant commissioners were among those who were accommodated at Garda expense during this time and furnish the committee with the outcome of those inquiries? Would the Commissioner be willing to do that?
Comment on this
Has the Deputy some additional information that he wants to report?
Comment on this
I have no additional information. I spoke with Chief Superintendent Gary Walsh at the time. Considering that there have been significant promotions in that time, would Mr. Kelly, as Garda Commissioner, now ask all of his deputy and assistant commissioners whether they were one of the people, and whether they stayed in a hotel during that time, if possible?
Comment on this
I do not quite grasp the point that the Deputy is trying to make.
Comment on this
I just want to get an understanding of whether one of those deputy or assistant commissioners was under investigation at the time while the Garda Commissioner promoted them.
Comment on this
At the time, the Deputy brought up an issue that a chief superintendent and his wife stayed in a room without paying for it at public expense. As I say, we conducted a detailed and thorough investigation into it. There is no evidence of that. I know-----
Comment on this
Does Mr. Kelly have an understanding as Commissioner that any of the people he promoted during that time were under investigation by the anti-corruption unit?
Comment on this
I would be very reluctant to speak about individual people in this forum in that context. I certainly do not think it is appropriate, Chair. I will go back to what I said: the anti-corruption unit, ACU, is one of our foremost units around investigation. It has investigated many allegations - criminal and discipline - which have led to prosecutions of gardaí. As the Deputy will know, unfortunately we have had a number of gardaí investigated by the ACU. They have been prosecuted and convicted in courts. Only recently, unfortunately, we had one. As the Deputy knows, this was tasked to ACU to do. It did a thorough investigation. There is no evidence into the allegation the Deputy made.
As I said, and I think this was said to the Deputy, if he has any further evidence to support his allegation, of course we will look at it again. If the Deputy or the committee want to write back to us and say that the Deputy has something additional, of course we will consider it. Of course we will.
Comment on this
Okay, I will write to the Commissioner.
The day after the RTÉ programme aired, I listened to the Claire Byrne Newstalk programme. Deputy Commissioner Cleary, speaking on the programme at the time, stated that the former Commissioner objected to the protected disclosure office appointing Mr. Ray Lane as an expert witness and that another witness was subsequently appointed. The Commissioner can correct me if I am wrong on that; I do not have the specific quote. If the Commissioner had been Commissioner at the time, would he have intervened at that stage?
Comment on this
On the latter part of the Deputy's question, it is difficult to put me into a position to suppose what I would have done. Maybe stepping away from the specific instance the Deputy is talking about, what I would say generally is that in a whole range of things in investigations when we bring in specialists from the outside - when we bring in experts or whatever it the case - there can often be lots of discussion around who is the appropriate expert. The cost of it is really important to us.
Comment on this
I suppose the question I would have is this: what authority would the Garda Commissioner have in appointing somebody, considering that the protected disclosures manager and those working as head of the protected disclosures unit made a decision that Mr. Ray Lane should be appointed but the Garda Commissioner objected to that, intervened and appointed someone?
Comment on this
Maybe be careful about naming people, particularly if it is not in the public domain. I am not quite sure.
Comment on this
That is very much in the public domain. It was covered in the RTÉ programme and covered on Newstalk that morning.
Comment on this
While it may have been, the reality of what the Deputy is bringing up today is that there are outstanding investigations by An Garda Síochána and external bodies. There are also a number of court cases related to the area that the Deputy is talking about so I am limited in what I can say around that area for obvious reasons.
Comment on this
Okay. I want to speak specifically in relation to Dr. Donal Corcoran. Dr. Corcoran appeared in the RTÉ programme and is a Garda whistleblower. I do not want to speak about whether Dr. Corcoran is satisfied with the outcome of his investigation. What I am asking is whether there was an outcome, and if there was, what was it and how was it reached?
Deputy Commissioner Cleary also publicly stated that the protected disclosures referenced in the RTÉ programme had been "investigated comprehensively" and that the investigators "went to the nth degree". Does An Garda Síochána stand over that statement in relation to Dr. Corcoran's protected disclosure, which was made to Yvonne Cook on 21 August 2024 and later followed up in October? My understanding is Dr. Corcoran received no acknowledgement at all of that protected disclosure. Would the Commissioner consider that going to the nth degree and being "investigated comprehensively"?
Comment on this
What I need to say at the outset is there was obviously a number of people in that RTÉ programme. Three of them are serving; one of them is no longer in the organisation. Obviously, on a personal level, I certainly sympathise with them. It is a very difficult situation for them to be in. I certainly do. Particularly, some of them have been in the organisation for a long time. One of the things we have done from a welfare point of view is we have certainly reached out to all those people, even following that programme.
Comment on this
If I may, would the Commissioner say that is going "to the nth degree", considering that someone made a protected disclosure and received no acknowledgement at all-----
Comment on this
-----and has since received still no acknowledgement?
Comment on this
-----for reasons that are readily understood by this committee, I cannot make any comment on the question that the Deputy has asked.
Comment on this
I am not asking about the specifics of the case itself. I am asking in relation to the procedure of a protected disclosure - a protected disclosure was made - and the specific person who made the disclosure.
Comment on this
I am certainly happy to talk, and I have earlier, about the structures, the policies-----
Comment on this
But the structure is that he received no acknowledgement.
Comment on this
I am certainly happy to talk about them in general but the question that the Deputy has asked me is tangentially linked to a number of proceedings.
Comment on this
Okay. In general, does the Commissioner believe it is appropriate that if a Garda member makes a protected disclosure they will receive absolutely no acknowledgement of that protected disclosure investigation?
Comment on this
We have a whole policy in place that outlines the contact that we should have with people who make protected disclosures. We have a policy in place in relation to that.
Comment on this
So how can the Commissioner stand over no communication being made?
Comment on this
I cannot speak in relation to the individual case. Like I say, there are outstanding-----
Comment on this
Why not? Is there something specific?
Comment on this
Chair, I would seek your advice on this because I think I have been very clear. In the area that the Deputy is going towards, there are a number of outstanding matters. It puts me in quite a difficult position.
Comment on this
That is fair enough, for reasons that have been outlined previously and that are in the public domain.
Comment on this
I am specifically asking about the procedure of acknowledgement of a protected disclosure and the investigative work that is going on.
Comment on this
If I hand over to the assistant commissioner in charge of this area of governance and accountability, she might bring the Deputy through the policy around how we interact with people who make protected disclosures. I am sure Ms Gunne will be able to provide that detail.
Comment on this
In relation to our operations and our structures, we have a protected disclosure unit that sits under governance and accountability. On 6 January 2025, it transferred. The unit had oversight from the executive director of human resources and people development, and that was the managing of protected disclosures, but the policy sat under the executive director of legal. As to what the Commissioner has said to date, the last time we looked at our policy was in 2021. Then we had the introduction of the new Protected Disclosures (Amendment) Act 2022, which amended the 2014 Act. Since we have taken over that, it now sits in governance and accountability. We have streamlined processes in relation to that. Prior to its coming across to governance and accountability, there were a number of protected disclosure managers. The resourcing now sits with a dedicated principal officer, our protected disclosure manager. We also have sergeants and an inspector in that office. When a report is received, a report is made, and that can be done by post, by email, by telephone or in person. As regards the reporting person who makes that - the Commissioner has referred to this today - it is just the independence of that. They are made aware of Transparency International Ireland in the first instance and they receive independent advice. Also, what is very different with the introduction of the Policing, Security and Community Safety Act is that when you have a protected disclosure which is a criminal offence or is under the offence where you believe it has been committed, that now must be reported. We are obliged under the Act to report it externally to Fiosrú.
The Act refers to a number of wrongdoings as regards a protected disclosure. I refer to the relevant information. The reporting person states that there has been wrongdoing. They have information such that they have reasonable grounds to believe there has been wrongdoing, and the Act covers-----
Comment on this
Does An Garda Síochána acknowledge the protected disclosure when it comes in? Does the Garda send an acknowledgement back to the person who made it?
Comment on this
There are nine areas of wrongdoing, but a reporting person's perception of wrongdoing does not necessarily mean that wrongdoing will actually be found or proven. When a report comes in, as to what I have said about Transparency International Ireland, that individual advice too will be for self-incrimination, for going through that assessment phase, whether or not it is a protected disclosure. Then my unit, under the protected disclosure unit, will engage with the reporting person. However, it is very important to underline that a protected disclosure has all those relevant wrongdoings, but the Act does not have to be prescriptive that those headings are an offence. Failure to comply with legal obligations, health and safety, environmental damage - there are nine of them. However, it does not have to be prescriptive that you say to me in the course of your work that you are making a protected disclosure. Sometimes there is a difficulty in identifying where the person is actually making a protected disclosure.
Comment on this
Thank you, Deputy. You will have an opportunity to come back in again.
I have a number of questions. I will return to the issue of the residential properties owned by the OPW and used by An Garda Síochána. I think the figure of 77 was given. How many of them are unoccupied at this moment?
Comment on this
We are in the process of auditing all those properties, Chair. We could certainly come back to you. Ms Toale, could you give an indication if-----
Comment on this
As regards the 77 properties, Mr. O'Connor's team is doing a full audit of all An Garda Síochána properties at the moment, and the outcome of that audit will be discussed with the OPW in terms of what our future strategies and plans are. We have a very close working partnership with the OPW-----
Comment on this
The 77 figure I mentioned is where we have Garda members occupying residential properties that would be proximate to Garda stations. That is the figure I mentioned in the context of the Revenue disclosure.
Comment on this
Are there other properties that are not proximate to Garda stations owned by the OPW and used by the Garda, namely the Phoenix Park and other places?
Comment on this
No. There are a small number of properties at the entrance to the Phoenix Park which are under discussion with the OPW, but there are no Garda members in those properties. We have a huge Garda estate, and I think some of your colleagues, a Chathaoirligh, pointed to the fact that some of them are manned, partially manned or whatever. We are doing a full audit of that in that context.
Comment on this
You are saying that a rental market evaluation is now taking place, and that comes three years after voluntary disclosure for benefit-in-kind to Revenue. Why is that taking place only now?
Comment on this
We have been working with the OPW, which is strapped for resources, no more than ourselves, and it has not been able until now to support it. We are working together with it - these are its properties - to see how we can support it to conduct that rental evaluation.
Comment on this
Are rents payable within those properties paid to the Garda or the OPW, or who manages-----
Comment on this
You might give us an example. What is the lowest rent currently being paid on one of those properties?
Comment on this
I will come back to you in writing on that, Deputy.
Comment on this
I do not have that breakdown because that is part of the ongoing discussions.
Comment on this
As regards some of those arrangements, you might give us a breakdown, a timeline, as to how long they have been in place, when they were last reviewed, etc., because it is quite concerning. I want-----
Comment on this
Just to be clear, a Chathaoirligh, they are OPW properties. That is not diminishing An Garda Síochána's role in them, but they are OPW properties.
Comment on this
I want to move on to the cash being held as evidence. It is up to €45.9 million. We got some information there about the legal information that has been provided to the Garda. Who provided that legal advice?
Comment on this
Our own executive director of legal team would have provided it following consultation. I would have to check the papers, as I said, Chair. It is probably external advice. As Dr. Coxon pointed out, we would have consulted the DPP as well because a lot of these involved prosecutions.
Comment on this
If you do not mind, Chair, if I might take that away, I can certainly talk to legal about it. I think it is certainly straightforward around prosecutions.
It is very straightforward in the context of prosecutions. If there is a physical exhibit around disposal or that before the trial, it is very straightforward. We do not have any leeway.