We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Update on Committee's Report on Vote 20: An Garda Síochána - 2023

Summary

The Comptroller and Auditor General reported €2.5 billion in Garda expenditure in 2025, alongside a capital underspend and €13 million in non-compliant procurement. Reviews found that poor accommodation planning for the 2024 Europa League final wasted €248,500, while camera errors led to 2,785 penalty notices being cancelled and €445,600 in potential fines being lost. The Commissioner said most recommendations on major-event planning had been implemented and outlined strengthened procurement controls; he also expressed confidence in the protected disclosures unit while reviewing its arrangements. Members raised concerns about Garda staffing, rural electric-vehicle suitability, training and financial oversight, with the Commissioner agreeing to provide further information and examine the vehicle issue.

Contributions 1–240 of 736. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

This morning we will engage with An Garda Síochána. The agenda for the meeting is to discuss Vote 20 of the 2025 appropriation accounts; chapter 13, on the cancellation of fixed-charge penalty notices due to error on the 2025 report on the accounts of the public services; chapter 8, on accommodation cost for the policing of the UEFA Europa League final in the 2024 report on the accounts of the public services; and the committee report on the 2024 appropriation accounts, Vote 20 - An Garda Síochána.

On behalf of the committee, I welcome officials from An Garda Síochána: the Commissioner, Mr. Justin Kelly; Ms Siobhán Toale, chief corporate officer; Mr. Aonghus O'Connor, executive director of finance; Dr. Shawna Coxon, deputy commissioner, policing operations; Mr. Paul Cleary, deputy commissioner, security, strategy and governance; and Ms Catharina Gunne, assistant commissioner, governance and accountability. We are also joined by officials from the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration, who are attending in a representative capacity: Ms Eileen O'Reilly, principal officer; and Mr. Nicholas Murphy, principal officer. From the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation, also attending in a representative capacity, I welcome Ms Jenny Connors, principal officer. Finally, we are joined by officials from the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General, including Mr. Seamus McCarthy, the Comptroller and Auditor General, who is a permanent witness to the committee; and Ms Mairead Leyden, audit manager. You are all very welcome.

I wish to explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards references witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected, pursuant to both the Constitution and statute, by absolute privilege. This means witnesses have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege, and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction. Witnesses are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity.

I now call on the Comptroller and Auditor General to deliver his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

The 2025 appropriation account for Vote 20, An Garda Síochána, records gross expenditure of €2.5 billion. This represents an increase of €128 million, or 5.3%, on the previous year.

Other large Votes are presented using programmes of expenditure based on key outputs or service areas. In contrast, Vote 20 is presented mainly in terms of expenditure by resource input classifications. Because of this budgeting and accounting approach, the account does not disclose the cost of individual Garda outputs and deliverables, such as community policing, traffic policing, crime or cybercrime investigation, or other specialist functions. Garda output targets presented in the Vote Estimate are not linked to the related expenditure. In the past, I have also reported on weaknesses in Garda accounting for the costs of individual non-public events, even though cost recovery is the general policy.

The Vote expenditure is accounted for under a single programme which encompasses all of An Garda Síochána's activities. The largest component of expenditure continues to be pay. Salaries, wages and allowances amounted to €1.59 billion in 2025. An Garda Síochána spent a further €454 million on pension and gratuity payments to retired gardaí. These two areas account for around 80% of total expenditure in the period.

An Garda Síochána's capital building programme is a significant area of expenditure each year. A total of €71 million was available for 2025, but expenditure was significantly lower, at just under €40 million. The underspend was attributed to project delays in 2025, and €17.3 million of unspent capital funding was carried over to 2026. A similar underspend pattern occurred in 2024.

In addition to the building programme, An Garda Síochána is investing significantly in its operational fleet, with the addition of a new €21 million fixed-wing aircraft that was delivered in late 2025 and became operational in 2026. The purchase of two new helicopters at a cost of almost €30 million is also progressing, with delivery expected this year.

The account also records expenditure of just over €42 million on other transport. This was €9.8 million higher than the original Estimate, mainly due to accelerated purchase of vehicles required in preparation for Ireland's current Presidency of the EU Council.

After carryover of capital funding, the amount liable for surrender at the end of the year was €9.5 million.

The committee may wish to note the Accounting Officer's disclosure in the statement on internal financial control that An Garda Síochána incurred non-compliant procurement of €13 million worth of goods and services in 2025.

The reports before the committee relate to two specific matters that arose from the audits of the 2024 and 2025 appropriation accounts.

The first report examines the management of accommodation provided for by An Garda Síochána linked to policing of the UEFA Europa League final, which took place in the Aviva Stadium, in Dublin, in May 2024. The total policing costs for that event were estimated at €7.8 million, all of which was borne by the State. An Garda Síochána spent nearly €590,000 on accommodation for use by gardaí who were policing the game. However, just over 40% of that expenditure, or €248,500, related to accommodation that was not actually used by Garda personnel. The examination identified weaknesses in the planning for and management of accommodation needs for Garda members for the event. A public procurement process was not conducted prior to acquiring hotel accommodation for the event. Rooms were booked in bulk before the full accommodation requirements of Garda members had been established, and were not cancelled on time. In addition, the use of manual spreadsheets to allocate rooms resulted in instances where members were assigned multiple rooms, either within the same hotel or in different hotels.

Over 250 cases of potential overpayments of travel and subsistence claims were identified, totalling approximately €35,000.

These arose, in part, from a failure to adequately cross-reference claims submitted by Garda members against accommodation and meals provided and paid for by An Garda Síochána. Due to limitations in the data available, the amounts identified are likely to represent the minimum overpayment level. The report made a number of recommendations aimed at addressing the weaknesses identified. The Accounting Officer accepted the recommendations and outlined actions to implement them.

The second report relates to the cancellation of fixed-charge penalty notices in 2025 arising from errors in the operation of two static speed detection cameras at separate locations on the N17 in County Mayo and on the N25 in County Kilkenny. The camera on the N17 route was operating effectively but did not have a valid calibration certification. Between the camera becoming operational in December 2024 and the error being identified in February 2025, 1,871 speeding fixed-charge notices had been issued by An Garda Síochána. These notices were subsequently revoked. In the second case, An Garda Síochána had recorded incorrect townland details in the fixed-charge penalty notice processing system for the N25 camera. This resulted in 914 notices being issued with an invalid offence location, all of which were subsequently revoked. The cancellation of these notices resulted in potential fine receipts of €445,600 being foregone. In addition, the related penalty points were either cancelled or were not applied to the licences of the motorists concerned.

The examination found that the contract with GoSafe in place at the time of these errors did not contain a provision for the recovery of losses arising from failures by the service provider. The current contract, which took effect in November 2025, includes a provision allowing amounts to be withheld where the service provider fails to deliver services in accordance with the contract terms. However, An Garda Síochána stated that the costs related to the operation of the N17 camera during the affected period were recovered from GoSafe. In the N25 case, the error was on the Garda side of the operation, so cost recovery from the service provider would not have been appropriate. While An Garda Síochána has since strengthened its arrangements for monitoring calibration certificates and validating camera locations, the examination found that there was scope to formalise procedures governing the introduction of new camera locations on the fixed-charge penalty notice processing system. The Accounting Officer has stated that the revised procedures are at an advanced stage of development.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the C and AG.

I ask the Commissioner to deliver the opening statement on behalf of An Garda Síochána. As set out in the letter of invitation, Mr. Kelly has five minutes to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee for the invitation to be here today.

An Garda Síochána is committed to ensuring that the significant public resources entrusted to us are managed appropriately, that they provide value for money, and most importantly that they support our core mission of keeping people safe. The budget provided to An Garda Síochána continues to increase with an allocation of more than €2.3 billion net for 2025. As always, the Vote has been managed by offsetting some savings across subheads as the end of the financial year approached and required a net Supplementary Estimate of €20.4 million, which is about 0.87% of the total allocation in 2025. This Supplementary Estimate comprises a gross expenditure requirement of €60 million offset by a surplus in appropriations-in-aid receipts of €39.6 million, resulting in a net added requirement of €20.4 million for the Vote. The expenditure supported An Garda Síochána in responding to significant operational demands in 2025, including increased protest activity and the major policing and security operation associated with the visit of President Zelenskyy in December. It also supported continued investment in our people, equipment, technology and operational capability.

Increasing Garda numbers and our visibility in communities remains a key priority. A total of 618 new gardaí were attested in 2025, marking the highest number of new allocations in seven years. For the first time, two Garda trainee recruitment campaigns were held in a single year, attracting more than 11,000 applications. At the end of 2025, our overall strength stood at 18,405 personnel, comprising 14,425 gardaí, 308 reserves and 3,672 Garda staff. We have continued to increase Garda numbers during 2026, and I am looking forward to the next group of approximately 200 Garda trainees passing out later this month, which should see us have the highest number of gardaí in the history of the State. We are highly ambitious in this regard and want to meet and exceed the Government target of recruiting 5,000 gardaí by 2030.

We also continue to invest in the resources available to front-line gardaí. During 2025, 407 vehicles were allocated, bringing the fleet to 3,650 vehicles, which is the highest in the history of the organisation, including approximately 300 electric vehicles. Further investment was also made in specialist vehicles designed to enhance operational capacity across a number of policing functions. We have invested in a new aeroplane, helicopters, an armoured vehicle for our emergency and armed response units, equipment for public order units and rigid hull inflatable boats for our water unit. Significant investment across the Garda estate continued throughout 2025 with the completion of a new facility for An Garda Síochána's fleet management section and the continuation of construction on the redevelopment of Portlaoise divisional headquarters in County Laois; the new divisional property and exhibits management system, PEMS, store at Drogheda Garda station; and the development of a new Garda station at Bailieborough in County Cavan. Further investment was also made across Garda regions in minor refurbishments and upgrades of existing Garda stations and welfare facilities nationwide. Three significant projects for the southern region commenced in 2025, including a new Garda station in Newcastle West in County Limerick, the new Clonmel Garda station in County Tipperary and the new divisional headquarters in Macroom, County Cork.

This continued investment in our people, resources and operational capability was important as we prepared for Ireland’s Presidency of the Council of the European Union in the second half of 2026 and the significant international events that accompany it. As the scale and complexity of our operations continue to grow, it is equally important that we continue to strengthen how those operations are planned, resourced and financially managed. The policing operation for the 2024 UEFA Europa League final provided important organisational learnings in this regard. The subsequent reviews undertaken by Forvis Mazars and Deloitte identified opportunities to strengthen our planning, governance, resourcing, financial management and organisational learning for major and extraordinary events. The majority of the resulting recommendations have now been implemented or otherwise closed, with work continuing on the remaining recommendations.

That work has resulted in a number of changes to how major events are managed. We have strengthened the organisational framework governing their planning and command, and we have introduced improved technology to support resource and duty planning. Now, following chapter 8 of the Report on the Accounts of the Public Services 2024, where organisational booking of accommodation is required, this will operate on an exceptional basis and be subject to senior-level approval, documented justification, oversight and controls. We have also developed an event-costing template to strengthen financial planning for major events, while work continues to further strengthen our approach to debriefing and organisational learning. These changes form part of a wider programme of work to strengthen financial governance and controls across An Garda Síochána. Since the committee’s previous examination of Vote 20, updated procurement policies and procedures have been introduced. These updated procurement policies and procedures were introduced in 2026, supported by a centralised contracts register, enhanced monitoring of expenditure against contracts and improved processes for identifying and reporting non-compliant procurement. We have also increased the use of Office of Government Procurement frameworks where possible or practical.

The scale and complexity of policing mean that An Garda Síochána is entrusted with very significant public resources. With that comes a responsibility to ensure those resources are managed carefully, transparently and in a manner that delivers value for the public. As Accounting Officer, I am committed to continuing to strengthen our financial governance and controls, to learning where improvements are required and to ensuring that the significant public investment in An Garda Síochána supports our people in delivering a professional policing service and keeping people safe.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the Commissioner for that. We will suspend our meeting at 12 noon for a short 15-minute break before resuming shortly afterwards. Today's lead speaker is Deputy Geoghegan, who has 15 minutes. All other members will have ten minutes. If time permits, when all speakers have concluded on their first round, we will open it up to a shorter second round of supplementary questions.

Comment on this

I thank our witnesses. Does the Commissioner have confidence in the protected disclosures unit of An Garda Síochána?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Yes, I certainly do. We have done considerable work in strengthening our protected disclosures unit over the last number of years. Of course, legislation requires us to put a policy in place. We have done that. Our last policy was published in 2021 and we recently updated our policies. Those policies are available externally on the Garda website and internally on our own portal. We have significantly strengthened that unit in personnel. We now have a full-time protected disclosures manager in that unit. All the members of the unit have undertaken training with Maynooth University. In addition, we have interacted extensively with Transparency International Ireland. We have trained 166 senior officers with that organisation and we plan to train a similar number before the end of this year. We have certainly done a lot of work on protected disclosures. As Garda Commissioner, I want to make it clear that we want workers in our organisation to come forward if they have concerns or if they have identified wrongdoing. I am content that we have the processes, policies and structures in place to support that.

Comment on this

Yesterday, the Minister for justice stated in the Dáil that An Garda Síochána received 46 protected disclosures in the period from 2022 to date in 2026. Does that tally with the Commissioner's own figures?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Before me today, I have the figures for 2025 and, in relation to today's meeting, for 2023. Assistant Commissioner Gunne has responsibility for governance and accountability. She may have the full figures.

Comment on this
Ms Catharina Gunne

Yes, I can answer that. In 2021, there were 20 protected disclosures. We had 15 in 2022. In 2023, we had 26. We had 12 in 2024 and 23 in 2025. To date, we have had 17 this year.

Comment on this

I thank Assistant Commissioner Gunne. Yesterday, the Minister for justice also stated in the Dáil that he had examined the files on what had happened prior to his arrival in the Department and that, in his view, his predecessor, Deputy McEntee, behaved in an entirely appropriate manner and followed departmental advice in respect of issues to which the Deputy asking the question was referring. Does an analogous situation arise in the Commissioner's case? Did he review files from the previous Commissioner's time relating to protected disclosures when he became Commissioner?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

The Garda Commissioner actually has a very limited role in dealing with protected disclosures. Since taking up my current role on 1 September, I have not reviewed any protected disclosure files.

Comment on this

Is the Commissioner in a position to say whether he is satisfied that his predecessor acted in an entirely appropriate way, as the current Minister for justice has said about his predecessor?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I worked with the previous Commissioner, Drew Harris, for seven years and he had an absolutely impeccable career both in Northern Ireland and here. In all my dealings with him, he was an officer of the utmost standing and integrity. I have absolutely no concerns regarding any decisions the previous Commissioner made. As I said, I have full confidence in him, particularly around any issues of integrity. One of the key things he did upon taking up his role was setting up units such as the anti-corruption unit. As the Deputy will know, he made significant inroads in that area, particularly in respect of discipline and criminal behaviour among members of An Garda Síochána. One of his key achievements in his term was that he sent out and reinforced the message that none of that behaviour was welcome in An Garda Síochána. I hope that is helpful.

Comment on this

For the avoidance of doubt, nothing has come into the public domain, recently or otherwise, that has caused the Commissioner, if he has a function or role, to examine how protected disclosures are carried out in his organisation. It is not an analogous situation to that of the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, who reviewed files relating to his predecessor. The Department does not really have a function in processing protected disclosures made against An Garda Síochána but it has a role in determining where they go. Is the Commissioner saying it is not an analogous situation and that there was no trigger for him to review protected disclosures or how they were addressed when he became Commissioner?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

All I can talk about is what I have done since taking over as Commissioner on 1 September. I certainly have not been involved in anything like that. I will say that with what has happened in the last number of weeks, I have met with my executive and senior leadership teams and we have looked at what we are doing in this area, particularly following the RTÉ programme. Only earlier this week, I met the chief executive of Transparency International Ireland and his team. While, as I said a few minutes ago, I am content with our policies and structures, it would be remiss of me not to relook at that to make sure that everything we have is absolutely rock solid. That is what I am in the process of doing at the moment.

Comment on this

To briefly go back to Mr. Kelly's predecessor, the previous Garda Commissioner, Mr. Kelly may have seen that, in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report on the annual accounts, it is noted that disclosures were made by the OPW in respect of people living on OPW premises in the Phoenix Park. The office had to make voluntary disclosures to Revenue as a result of undisclosed benefit-in-kind. It was previously disclosed that the previous Garda Commissioner lived in a property in the Phoenix Park for a short period of time. Is the Commissioner aware of any issues with Revenue arising from that?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Not that I am aware of, but I might pass that question over to the chief corporate officer, who would be more familiar with members of An Garda Síochána more widely who are living in OPW properties. There are about 77 in that situation. The Deputy is obviously particularly interested in the case of the former Garda Commissioner. I will ask Ms Toale to address that. Our executive director of finance, Aonghus O'Connor, may also be able to shed some light on it.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

In terms of the former Commissioner, Drew Harris, there were absolutely no irregularities whatsoever relating to his accommodation in the Phoenix Park. The arrangements were put in place with the Department of justice and the OPW. In fact, I had the opportunity to review a range of materials relating to that year so I can absolutely confirm that. The Commissioner has introduced another topic. We do have current members in a range of OPW-owned properties across our estate. We are currently working with the OPW to ensure that any matters in relation to Revenue and benefit-in-kind are dealt with through a structured process. Some of those properties have not been rent reviewed for a considerable period of time. There are matters for us to attend to in that regard, but there are absolutely no matters outstanding or any irregularities at all with regard to the former Commissioner, Drew Harris.

Comment on this

Ms Toale says there are matters to attend to. Will she clarify how many people and residences are involved?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

We have fewer than 80 properties, about 77, in which Garda members are living. In previous generations, Garda members would have lived quite close to Garda properties in order to better perform their duties.

That is no longer a requirement for us, or is certainly a requirement that is moving away quite rapidly. We have people in properties where the rent has not been reviewed upwards in a number of years. These properties are owned by the OPW and in the first instance we are working with the OPW to make sure a rental market evaluation is carried out, so we can understand the scope and scale of any matters that need to be attended to.

Comment on this

When Ms Toale refers to matters to attend to, what does she mean?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

Taxation and Revenue matters.

Comment on this

Revenue matters. The Garda may have to make a voluntary disclosure to the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

We did make a voluntary disclosure to Revenue in 2023. We are still in the process of closing out those Revenue matters. We are in the final stages of engagement with Revenue on that. In that regard, we did make a disclosure in relation to those properties that I just mentioned.

Comment on this

All of those properties.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

Most of those properties. From memory, 50-odd of those properties, and a settlement was made at that time.

Comment on this

How much was the settlement?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

The settlement was in the order of €800,000 for two years.

Comment on this

Okay. Are there outstanding amounts on which the Garda may have to make further declarations?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

There may be. We are in discussion with Revenue around a range of matters relating to that disclosure. There is a range of engagements going on. There is further audit testing to be done in the next number of weeks, in fact, in relation to the Revenue disclosure. We anticipate that we will close matters with Revenue probably before the end of the year.

Comment on this

How is it that every garda resident of an OPW-owned property, other than the Commissioner, resulted in some kind of Revenue disclosure? How come the former Commissioner living in an OPW-owned property did not give rise to a Revenue issue?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

The Commissioner paid benefit-in-kind in that regard. That is disclosed in the accounts. It is quite visible.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

It is, yes.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

You can see it.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

From memory, An Garda Síochána was paying a rent in respect of the property and the value of that rent was charged and taxed as benefit-in-kind for the Commissioner.

Comment on this

Obviously, it is not a great situation for the Garda to be in, not to be paying Revenue what it is supposed to be paying. We have seen Government Departments in similar situations. The Department of Social Protection had to make a Revenue disclosure. What was the underlying cause of this? How did it arise that An Garda Síochána was not paying tax that it should have been paying on these properties?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

To explain, members are renting property at a particular market rate. The issue arises because there is a view from Revenue that the rent the members are paying is not at the market rate that it should be. Those rates have not been reviewed upwards. It is a complex enough matter because-----

Comment on this

Who found this out? Did the Garda make the disclosure or did someone from Revenue contact the Garda? Who discovered it? What was the governance control mechanism that resulted in the Garda saying there was an issue and that it should have been paying more tax than it was.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

There were matters going back to 2022 and 2023 where, following an internal audit on our part, matters were discovered. Deputy Commissioner Coxon at the time engaged external experts to further review the situation. There was an external partner brought on board. The organisation, under the leadership of Commissioner Drew Harris, made the unprompted Revenue disclosure in 2023.

Comment on this

I have only limited time left and I have a question for Commissioner Kelly. Deportation flights are a significant operational issue for An Garda Síochána, at least in terms of the numbers we are familiar with. How many Garda personnel in 2025, or even to date, were or are involved in deportation flights, on both charter and ordinary flights?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I do not have those exact numbers with me. We can certainly try and get them and get a note to the Deputy. They vary between the flights. Each one of them is risk assessed. There is a risk assessment done on the flights and they vary depending on who is on the flights and the location they are going to. There is a number of factors around them. We can certainly get the Deputy a note on the numbers.

Comment on this

How does it work operationally? The Department has a role in all this, as distinct from just the Commissioner, which is Mr. Kelly's role. How does that relationship play out? When does the Department say it has a bit of money for a plane the Garda can use to deport people who are subject to deportation orders? Does it say there are prisoners who it feels should not finish their custody here and should be deported to the countries from which they came within the European Union? How does that interplay operate? Does it impact the Commissioner at an operational level in terms of how many gardaí he has on the beat?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

No, to answer the Deputy's last question, it certainly does not. We have a dedicated bureau, the Garda National Immigration Bureau, which deals with the majority of the flights the Deputy is talking about. There is a number of different categories of people whom we remove from the country, depending on what orders are in place, such as deportation orders, EU removal orders, or whatever that might be. We interact very closely with the Department, which funds the expenditure around the flights. There are people from the Department here who will be able to provide detail around that. Our part of it is getting the people for the flights and then getting the personnel onto the flights that go abroad. That is our part of it, in the main.

There are lots of rules and regulations around the flights and how many people are on them, and how many officers go with each individual person being deported. For example, the general number is 2:1, so we will have two gardaí for every one person. With some particular individuals, depending on the risk, it can be up to four people at times. On these flights as well, we have to have lots of different precautions in place. For example, we need medical people on the flights and a human rights adviser. There is lots and lots of planning that goes into all of these flights. For sure, they are heavy on resourcing but it is very important work. We certainly see it as a very important role that we have in An Garda Síochána, particularly around removing people from the country who have committed offences, particularly sexual offences. We have a whole operation, Operation Moonridge, which focuses on people whom we can remove from the country who have committed sexual offences and are near the end of their prison sentence. We certainly see it as a core piece of our work. As I said at the start, every single one of those flights is different in how we approach them.

Comment on this

The witnesses are very welcome, as are the officials from their respective Departments. The Commissioner speaks about potentially reaching the highest number of gardaí in the history of the State next year, with two recruitment campaigns in 2025 attracting 11,000 applicants and 618 new recruits in 2025. In that same period in 2025, how many people left the organisation?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

The numbers are relatively low. Less than 1.5% of the organisation will leave in any year. Our retention rate is actually very good. When we compare that to many other police forces in the UK and Europe, it is actually excellent. It is a really good rate. As the Deputy probably knows, we get many members of our organisation who have done 30 years in the Garda and are 50 years of age who have the option to retire. We certainly see that about 75% of people who reach that category decide to stay. Even though they can leave with their full pension, they do not.

Comment on this

In respect of 2025, what is the number of people who left?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

It would be around 200. Does Ms Toale have that number?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

I do indeed. In 2025, we had 218 people who retired. We had 208 people who voluntarily retired, which the Commissioner just mentioned, who are those who can retire on full pension when they have reached 30 years' service. We had ten at compulsory retirement and 202 who resigned. This refers to the Commissioner's data in terms of less than 1.47% turnover. We lost people to death; a very small number of members died. Some people retired on grounds of ill health but the number is probably five or six.

Comment on this

Is there a capacity issue then in terms of what was essentially a big year of recruitment, whereby the new graduates essentially just replaced those who had left for a variety of reasons. That looks like operating just to stay in a similar position. Is there a capacity issue with Templemore and with the organisation's ability to match the appetite of 11,000 people who want to join when, ultimately, the number recruited just offsets the number who have left?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

No, absolutely not. For example, between 2015 and 2025, our total personnel increased by 16%. As I said earlier, we are very close to reaching the maximum number of sworn members of An Garda Síochána we have ever had in the history of the organisation. That is really positive. Very shortly, we are going to hit the 15,000 mark, which is obviously a big threshold for us to reach. The Government has funded us for 5,000 over five years and we are working really hard towards that. The way that will pan out, obviously, is that every year people leave. At the end of that five-year period, we forecast that we will have about 16,500. Obviously, we will have more people joining, but we will have some people leaving.

At the end of this year, we will have about one garda for every 370 citizens. Our aim is to get that to one for every 342 by 2030. Various studies have been done around Europe and in the UK on the ratio of the number of police officers to population. That would bring us roughly in line with Police Scotland. Police Scotland is a comparator that we often use as Scotland has a similar-sized population. That is what we are aiming for.

This year, we will have just short of 1,000 new gardaí coming into our organisation, again the biggest number we have pushed through. There is a lot of positivity around recruitment. Despite what is sometimes said or the narrative, I actually think we have a really good news story around recruitment, with 11,000 people wanting to join An Garda Síochána.

On the capacity issues at the college, we have been supported by the Department around improving our facilities, improving numbers in classes, etc. Again, that is really positive. This year, we are going to have five recruit classes going through the college.

Comment on this

Has there ever been a business case to enhance Templemore to increase capacity, or is there a business case currently before the Department to consider that?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

We have already done that and the Department has supported us. Building works are ongoing in the Garda College. We have done a number of things around improving classroom facilities and sizes, and we have put quite a considerable number of new staff into the college to train recruits.

Obviously, 5,000 over five years is 1,000 a year. We are just short of that this year, just short of it. Obviously, next year we want to get to it, if not exceed it.

Comment on this

I will ask the Commissioner about those new recruits. It emerged this morning that Kildare essentially has the lowest number of gardaí per capita. It has the fourth-highest population in the country, yet it has the lowest number of gardaí per capita. What is the formula or decision-making process for allocating those resources? To me, those statistics would not add up, given that Kildare has a population of a quarter of a million, the fourth-highest population, yet the lowest number of gardaí per capita in the country. How does that work?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Since I took over as Commissioner, we have put 78 new gardaí into the Carlow–Kildare division. To answer the Deputy's question as to how we deploy, obviously we look at population size and particular demands. Every division has different demands on it. We look at crime rates. There are a number of factors that go into deciding how many people we put into a particular division.

Comment on this

Is there weighting in those criteria? Is population weighted?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

There certainly is. The reality of this is, in some ways, very positive for An Garda Síochána in that everybody wants to see more gardaí in his or her own particular area. Everywhere I go and every politician I meet wants to see more gardaí in the area. It is not the same in every country.

Comment on this

It is every community, not every politician. We are just representing what the communities are saying. It is the communities that are trying to understand that-----

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Absolutely. That is a very fair point. My point is that it is a very positive thing for An Garda Síochána that people want to see more of us.

Comment on this

People want to see the evidence stack up. They cannot understand how an area with the fourth-highest population has the lowest number of gardaí per capita. Perhaps the Commissioner could share a note with the committee as to how those criteria are weighted.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Yes. I will give a small example. Consider an area that is very heavy on events, such as the north inner city. There will be protest activity, matches, etc. Such an area will have more gardaí. It is weighted in that way. There are a lot of factors that go into it. Let me assure the Deputy that we think very carefully about allocations and how we do that.

Our head of human resources does a lot of work around this. We have personnel demand meetings that I actually chair, at which we go through and try to work out where we are going to put the people. There is actually quite a lot of work that goes into this. I know the reality is that it is very hard to keep every community satisfied, but, as I have said, the good news is that we are getting more gardaí in, so obviously there are more-----

Comment on this

Can I move on because I am running out of time?

Speaking about events, what was the total revenue that the organisation took in from non-public duty events in 2025?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I might ask Mr. O'Connor to give that figure to the Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

It was €7 million in total.

Comment on this

Has that 2025 figure been fully recouped or are there outstanding payments?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

There will be outstanding payments, but they are on the smaller side. The debt outstanding at the moment is €1.6 million. When I was here last year, it was probably €3.2 million, so we have significantly reduced it. We have a number of payment plans in place with people who have had difficulty paying what was invoiced and we are working through that with them.

Comment on this

These will all be concerts, sporting events, etc., where it is essentially gardaí who are-----

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

There is a myriad of events. There are concerts and events, and there are-----

Comment on this

Are they licensed events?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

There is the ploughing show.

Comment on this

The ploughing, okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

Practically everything that happens in the State could attract-----

Comment on this

Is the ploughing, for example, fully paid up for its non-public duty events?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

I would be 99% sure it is. If it has been invoiced within the past month, possibly not, but there is nothing old that is of significance. The old cases at the moment have to do with entities that are dissolved.

Comment on this

So the €1.6 million is not just from last year. It is an accumulation over a number of years.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

Yes. The vast bulk of it is historical at this stage. Everything that could be collected in the last year has been collected, as far as we are concerned. That is why we have payment plans in place. We are working with people who are in a position to pay us in order to close things down.

Comment on this

Is there any legal case where an entity is challenging the fee or refusing to pay it?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

Not a legal challenge. As the Deputy would expect, there is a bit of dialogue as to what should be in an invoice. We have worked through that. We have issued credit notes where we thought that was appropriate. That process continues.

Comment on this

When was the last time the fee was revised?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

I think it was 2023. As the Commissioner said earlier, the executive leadership team and senior leadership team have discussed this on a number of occasions over the past year. We have signalled to the marketplace that there will be an increase, starting, I think, in February of next year. It has been communicated to the wider community.

Comment on this

Percentage-wise, what increase is being considered?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

For a normal weekday event, it will go from €45 to €55. The weekend rate will have a more substantial increase, up to €75, and the rate for reserves will go from zero to €25. As the Comptroller and Auditor General's report asked us to do, we have basically looked at this and put in tiers. The tiers are based on An Garda Síochána membership but also weekend rates versus midweek rates. We have done what the Comptroller and Auditor General has asked us to do while, at the same time, balancing that against the community requirements.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

Good morning to everyone. I thank them for being with us.

I thank An Garda Síochána for its continued work in publishing its purchase orders online. One issue to flag is that, for quarter 2 of 2026, the link on the website does not work.

I ask that it be double-checked, and then we will be able to see all that spending.

I want to flag one question from the opening statement. The Commissioner said that this year a centralised contracts register had been brought in. How did that come about and what has been achieved off the back of it?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I will hand over to Mr. O'Connor because he has done a lot of work for us on this. We have about 145 procurements in total, and a value of about €29 million. I ask him to bring the Deputy through what we have done in this area.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

It came from a report of the Comptroller and Auditor General as well. It stated, and we accepted this, that our procurement process was not the most robust. I said that we had a journey last year, and we are travelling through that journey. We first moved it to an Excel system. When we were speaking this time last year, it would have been on Excel. We have now moved it to an electronic system that gives us more adaptability. The big enhancement that has come out of that for us is that we are now actually able to see what procurements are rolling off in six, nine and 12 months. The Deputy will know a lot of this. We are able to get ahead of the curve. We are probably a bit challenged this year, because the EU presidency has taken up so much of our time, in getting procurement out the door.

Comment on this

Has the centralised procurement register allowed An Garda Síochána an opportunity to better evaluate non-compliant procurement within the organisation? The Accounting Officer had disclosed in the statement of internal financial control that non-compliant procurement represented 69 contracts and represented a total value of €13 million in 2025. What journey is An Garda Síochána on to try and reduce that?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

It came down €1 million from the previous year. When we look at the numbers, they have also come down. More importantly, the dynamic within that has changed completely. Our big driver in 2024 was ICT. Out of the €14 million, it would have accounted for €5 million, and now it is accounting for about €2.3 million. We have more non-compliance on the facility side, and we are working through that. Another focus has been on the doctors and medical side, and we are working through that too.

Comment on this

Does Mr. O'Connor believe that it would be possible to link the purchase order reports and those payments back to the original contracts? Does he believe that is possible in the current accounting system?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

In our current accounting system, we would be extremely challenged to do that. We are moving to a new accounting system with the National Shared Services Office, NSSO. Again, I would have alluded to it last year. It is slightly delayed.

Comment on this

Which tranche is An Garda Síochána in for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

We are in tranche three now.

Comment on this

When is it anticipated the Garda will move to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

It will be in June of next year, all going well.

Comment on this

Does Mr. O'Connor believe that it will be possible for An Garda Síochána to link back to the original contracts?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

The NSSO system is far better on procurement than our current system, but I would not be able to tell the Deputy the honest answer today.

Comment on this

I ask purely because I think there is an opportunity there for An Garda Síochána. It has now put in its centralised procurement register, and that is great. The next step, though, is going to be for the Garda to have as much real-time information as possible on contract performance and spending as it is happening. That will, again, tip the scales in its favour. It will be able to go back and use that ability as a downward price pressure when the force renegotiates or retenders, and actually just have the knowledge around what is happening there as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

We fully accept that, and I suppose statespend.ie actually gets us there reasonably quickly, believe it or not. We are able to see spending across the system and are able to reach out to the recipients of other Votes that have spent with the same vendors. We have started one or two discussions on that basis.

Comment on this

Do not rely on statespend.ie anyway.

Following on from that, a very topical issue this year has been around Garda pursuits. I refer to the estimate for training and development in 2025. Now, I do not know if the figure of €1,000 was per garda. Was it? What was the estimate for training and development in 2025?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

It was about €10 million.

Comment on this

Was it about €10 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

The cost for the college itself is about €40 million, of which core training would be about €10 million.

Comment on this

Taking existing gardaí, what is the figure for upskilling, training and development?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

That goes through the college as well.

Comment on this

The training goes through the college.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

A lot of it goes through the college. The college is the sole arbiter as regards training.

Comment on this

How much then did An Garda Síochána actually spend on the training and development of gardaí?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

In the whole college, it is in excess of €40 million.

Comment on this

I am inquiring because members of An Garda Síochána have recently expressed concern about the lack of pursuit training. I just want to find out whether there has been any progress on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

Additional funding was asked for in the Budget Statement, and my understanding is that it has been granted.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I can certainly bring maybe a bit of clarity about the pursuit training. Obviously, this has been really topical in the past number of months. One thing I should be really clear about is that any pursuit is a really risky endeavour for members of An Garda Síochána and the public. I emphasise that it is any type of pursuit. At the moment, pursuit is authorised within An Garda Síochána. We can do that. It is controlled by our Garda communication centres, and they are the ultimate arbiters of whether a pursuit can continue or not. About 80% of them are continued and about 20% are discontinued.

Comment on this

I understand. I am just wondering when it is envisaged that members of An Garda Síochána will be provided with the required pursuit training.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

We have two Garda training schools for driving. For the instructors in those, we have a relationship with a police force in the UK that provides us with very specialised instructing. We do not pay for that, other than for the cost of sending our officers there. We sent a number of instructors there from our training schools and they are getting trained over there. When they come back, we will then have a train the trainer approach. Those newly-trained instructors will come back and they will be able to deliver training here. We do not need to bring officers from abroad here. That is in the process of just being completed. We are hoping to have the first members of An Garda Síochána trained in pursuit training in December. That will be the start of it. We will then roll it out further in 2027. We will obviously roll it out, in particular, in the areas where most pursuits are.

Comment on this

I just want to go back to the figures for a second. For 2024 and 2025, in note 3 on the Vote expenditure relating to the analysis of administration expenditure in programme A, there were the salaries, wages and allowances, travel and subsistence, and then training and development. It lists €1.5 billion for salaries and €21 million for travel and subsistence but for training and development there was just a figure of €1. That was the estimate, but for the outturn, nothing was spent on it. Did An Garda Síochána spend nothing on training and development?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Absolutely not, but I will ask Mr. O'Connor to clarify it.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

What the Deputy might be looking at there is the fact that training, unusually in An Garda Síochána, has two heads. There is the administration head, which is very academic training, if I can call it that, and then there is the Garda College, which I think is A13 or A14.

Comment on this

I just wanted to check that it was not the case that gardaí were not being upskilled or trained, given there is a budget for it.

The last issue I want to bring to the Commissioner’s attention that was raised with me is towing contracts. I know it is an area where historically procurement was not always in place. The concern brought to my attention was that people being towed were being charged and, subsequently, the Garda were also being charged for the same service. Is that what is allowed for in the contracts with the towing companies? Is An Garda Síochána willing to undertake a review of its towing contracts nationally to ascertain whether that is something that is happening that should not be happening?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I will hand over to Mr. O'Connor on the detail. Regarding some of the towing we do, for example, where we stop a vehicle, it has insurance and we seize it and bring it in, we are allowed under legislation to charge for the storage and removal of the vehicle. I think that is probably what the Deputy is talking about in the main. I ask Mr. O'Connor to bring us through the detail of how the contracts work.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

About €16 million is spent on towing. It is an area of focus for us at the moment because it is very diverse. We have a multitude of suppliers, and we are looking at that. We are aware of some market observations in that regard, and we are looking at that ourselves as regards what we can do.

Comment on this

I am glad An Garda Síochána is aware of it. This was brought to my attention privately, and it was something I was concerned about. I had seen an invoice from one company to an individual, and then the same invoice, with add-ons that had not been verified, had been sent to the Garda.

That was a matter of some concern. I suspect that was not what was provided for in the contract. This is just something I wanted to flag to the witnesses-----

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

We share the Deputy's concerns. We are working through it.

Comment on this

That is perfect.

Comment on this

I want to pay tribute to the Garda Síochána, which plays a huge role in our security, community policing and the enforcement of the law and of immigration policy. Without it, we would be left naked. I also pay tribute to the bravery of individual gardaí who are always a moment away from putting their lives in danger in order to protect us in our State. I wanted to get that out the way first.

I want to offer the caveat in advance that anything I say will be either a matter of public knowledge, something I have obtained consent to say or is not currently a matter of litigation. If there is anything does arise in that regard, the Cathaoirleach can interrupt me.

Regarding the Garda fleet management, I am from a place called Ballygar in County Galway. I am going to tell a story. It will sound parochial but it is not; it is emblematic of a transport issue in rural areas. We have an exemplar of a guard in Ballygar by the name of Pat Regan. I have his consent to use his name. He operates in the community on the basis of discretion and gaining the confidence of its members. He is never short of intelligence. He has set up youth clubs. He trains football teams. He is always there managing traffic when a funeral or a wedding is taking place. He gives way more than what is required. He is, as I said, an exemplar of a community guard. He is based in Ballygar. It is east Galway that he has to cover at night-time. He has to travel ten miles to Mountbellew to collect an electric vehicle. A one-hour charge gives 4% on the battery. The car is needed 24-7, so there is no time to charge it. Giving the car a full charge takes 25 hours. He has got it down to a fine art. He needs a 7% charge to get from Ballygar to Mountbellew and 17% to get to Ballinasloe.

Garda Regan was called to a serious incident at a place called Clonbern. I will not go into any more detail than that. The car was charged to 22%. When the charge depleted by 11%, he decided to pull over because he would have been stranded if he had continued. He hitched the last three miles to Clonbern. A passer-by picked him and brought him to the scene. He drove back to Ballygar after the incident was dealt with. A tow truck had to be called to bring the car away because there is no charging Ballygar and inadequate charging in Mountbellew. He has been waiting four years for a car, so I am putting out an appeal for him. He could do with a car and a charging point in Ballygar.

There have been a number of incidents in the Roscommon-Galway area, which is my constituency, where guards have been in pursuit of serious criminals and have run out of juice. That leaves the organisation open to ridicule. It is a Keystone cops situation, and that is most unfair on the individual guard.

I am all in favour of sustainable energy and of moving to electric vehicles, but we live in a rural area. What sort of evaluation was carried out and led to members being left with such inadequate kit?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

First of all, I am glad to hear the very positive commentary about Garda Regan. It is fantastic to hear. That is the whole ethos that we want for our organisation, namely the community policing and all the extra stuff that many of our guards do all over the country supporting youth and clubs.

To the substantive issue, it is obviously very concerning to hear the detail the Deputy has put to me. We will certainly have a look at it. Obviously, I do not know the detail-----

Comment on this

That is fine. I accept that.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

-----but we will certainly look at it.

As I said earlier, we have the largest fleet in the history of the organisation of 3,650 vehicles, including 300 electric vehicles. Electric vehicles are a challenge for us. Of course, we share exactly what the Deputy said around sustainability. We have targets, etc., that we have to meet. However, electric vehicles have been problematic for us for some of the reasons that the Deputy outlined, but also in the context of charging and our ability to get fast charges at stations. Some of this is outside An Garda Síochána's control. We have other dependencies, including those relating to the OPW, electricity suppliers, etc.

I have come to a bit of a solution. I met with the head of fleet management a few weeks ago. We had a discussion around electric vehicles. My view on electric vehicles, and I think it is shared by some of my senior colleagues, is that they are more suitable for the urban environment-----

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

-----and that is certainly something that I have asked our fleet management team to look at. They will be used in urban environments. In rural environments, because of some of the distances involved, there are some challenges around range. Vehicle range is increasing all the time, so this may be a problem that will time out.

As I said, we will look into the incident in question. My overall view is that I agree with the Deputy that these vehicles are not suitable for areas where there are large distances to be covered.

Comment on this

I would appreciate it if the Commissioner would look at the Roscommon and east Galway area in terms of that. I also ask him to consider giving Garda Pat Regan in Ballygar a car. I am running out of time. I accept the Commissioner's assurances on that.

On the protected disclosures unit, in a general sense, does the Commissioner think that a unit within a particular organisation should be used to investigate that organisation? I will give an example. HIQA goes into hospitals and nursing homes. We could probably do with an independent safeguarding authority for people who are in public or private care in any part of the State. I do not want the Commissioner to go into any detail, but does he think that, as a concept, there should be an independent protected disclosures unit?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

It is important to note that, under legislation, we are required to have a protected disclosure structure and an internal process. There are options for people to make protected disclosures outside An Garda Síochána. Protected disclosures can be made to one of our oversight bodies, Fiosrú, the Office of the Police Ombudsman. Such disclosures are certainly made to Fiosrú. There is that avenue available if people are not comfortable with An Garda Síochána. One of the first things that we advise people to do when a protected disclosure is made to us is to speak to Transparency International Ireland. The latter will go through their options for them in order that they are fully informed.

Comment on this

My final question relates to compensation. The figure in that regard seems low. I have to reflect on the comments the Commissioner made about his predecessor's diligence in terms of discipline within An Garda Síochána. I had a constituent, Detective Garda Cunnane, who was egregiously treated by An Garda Síochána. That is a matter of record. The matter has been completed. There was an investigation and a court case. Of course, we also had a situation in Limerick. They are two of the most obvious ones. I am not going to comment any further on that, other than to ask the following question. Do compensation payments come from the State indemnity scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

There are a number of ways that compensation can be paid. Obviously, if a member is injured on duty, there is compensation paid in that situation. Maybe in examples like the Deputy is talking about, there can sometimes be High Court actions or actions with the State Claims Agency. It is sort of a combination of all three. The Deputy will see from the figures that our outlay on compensation has increased. That has happened because there is a new system in place that is actually more efficient.

Comment on this

Does the Commissioner have an actuarial number for outstanding compensation claims that may be in the system?

For example, the State indemnity scheme deals with the HSE. It knows the potential, which is €5 billion. It pays out €1.2 billion per year. I am not suggesting that the Garda has claims of that order, but does the Commissioner have any idea of the outstanding-----

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

There is a significant backlog. Mr. O'Connor might be able to throw some light on the issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

We have an indicative figure from the State Claims Agency. The figure did not have to be published in the commitments note because the State Claims Agency is working through it, but we are aware of it.

Comment on this

I reiterate what I said about Detective Garda Cunnane. His family suffered grievously at that time. I want that on the record.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses from An Garda Síochána and thank them for all the work they do in keeping us safe.

I go back to Deputy Daly's question about electric cars. I have seen an issue in County Monaghan whereby electric cars are charging at petrol stations. Am I correct that not all Garda stations have the infrastructure in place for charging points?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

We have a combination of ways of charging the vehicles. Sometimes we do it at stations. We also provide a facility whereby we can charge at public points or, as in the example the Deputy gave, at commercial facilities. Not all Garda stations have charging infrastructure. As I said earlier, there are dependencies of which we are not in control. Obviously, the OPW owns all the properties that we have. We certainly want to increase our infrastructure in that regard. Our chief corporate officer, CCO, has done some work in this area, but, in fact, I will pass to Mr. O'Connor.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

We have approximately 580 Garda stations. Some 216 of those have electric vehicle, EV, chargers. There are 318 chargers across that estate of 216 stations. The bulk are at the lower end but we have a programme with OPW, as the Commissioner indicated, to install 50 kW direct current, DC, chargers at ten stations and 25 kW DC chargers at six stations. That has all been agreed with the OPW. We have a pipeline of 20 and 30 stations, respectively, to be rolled out in the coming years. As the Commissioner says, we are dependent on the OPW in the first instance and ESB Networks in the second instance.

Comment on this

Who is going to pay for all that infrastructure at each Garda station? Will it be the OPW?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

The way the Garda capital budget works is that we are given an allocation and we work through that allocation. The OPW will also have some funds that it will put towards the project. In the majority of cases, it will be paid by us. In some cases, it will be paid by the OPW.

Comment on this

How much is it going to cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

I cannot say offhand. I will come back with a note.

Comment on this

Perhaps Mr. O'Connor would come back to me. I would also like to know how much the changeover has cost so far. I do find it strange that electric cars would be acquired for Garda stations that do not have chargers. Did anybody think this out? We get electric cars but we do not have chargers in place.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Obviously, the strategy is that they go to stations that have chargers in place.

Comment on this

In Monaghan, why are they charging-----

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Like I said, I do not know about that individual case. We can certainly come back to the Deputy. Obviously, the strategy is to put those stations in places with chargers. We obviously want to improve the infrastructure and improve the speed of the chargers that we have in place.

Comment on this

How many EVs did Mr. Kelly say the Garda has at present?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

We have 300 cars.

Comment on this

They are spread across stations. What would Mr. Kelly hope to increase that number to?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Mr. O'Connor might have numbers for that.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

We have taken the learning internally that the next fleet purchase, which is due later this year, will be biased towards conventional cars, if I can call them that, until such time-----

Comment on this

The Garda is going back to conventional cars.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

We are not going back. We remain committed to EVs, but we have to wait for the infrastructure to meet our appetite.

Comment on this

Before the electric cars were purchased, was there not an assurance that there would be electric chargers?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

There was, but, as the Commissioner alluded to, we are dependent on other State actors. They may have had other challenges that made them delay their roll-out and. We are pausing our roll-out to allow them to catch up with our appetite in that area.

Comment on this

I like to put the following question to most witnesses who come before the committee. Does the Garda have an IT system? Is it the PULSE system that is operating? What does that system cost yearly?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

One of our largest expenditures is on ICT. PULSE is just one of a number of systems we have. I will ask the CCO to bring the Deputy through some of that. As the committee will have seen, some of our biggest contracts are around ICT.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

The cost of running the ICT function is approximately €180 million per annum.

Comment on this

The cost is €180 million per annum.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

Approximately €20 million of that relates to our own staff and payroll costs. The remaining €160 million is split between operational expenditure, including the cost of maintaining systems and upgrading systems, with the other €80 million going to capital costs. I do not have the specific expenditure for PULSE with me but I am sure I can get it for the Deputy.

Comment on this

That would be great.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

There is no difficulty with that.

Comment on this

The Garda is spending €180 million on an IT system. That amount is paid every year.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

For the cost of running the IT function, €20 million is spent on payroll.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

That is paying staff.

Comment on this

What does the Garda get for €180 million? We are here to ensure that taxpayers get the very best value for money, and €180 million seems like an extraordinary amount of money to pay for IT.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Toale

It is.

Comment on this

It is astounding. The Garda is not the only organisation in this regard. Every organisation that comes before the Committee of Public Accounts admits that an extraordinary amount of money is being spent on ICT. Would the Garda not be better putting officers on the streets as opposed to having IT systems? What do these IT systems do to protect people?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I completely agree that €180 million is obviously a huge amount.

Comment on this

That is the cost every year.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

It is a huge amount of taxpayers' money, but I would actually like to spend more than €180 million. We have looked for more than that from the Government. In this day and age, policing in the modern world is hugely dependent on ICT. There are a range of different systems that support not just the gardaí on the front line but also our specialists and units that deal with victims of sexual crime.

Comment on this

I hear from the general public that they want to see gardaí on the street. That is not happening. There are not that many gardaí on the street. We hear now that we are spending €180 million yearly on ICT. Is that value for the taxpayer?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

It absolutely is. We go through rigorous procurement processes around our ICT. We have various governance boards around it so I can assure the committee it is good value for money.

To give an example, ICT is not something sitting in the background. It is connected to the front line. For example, body-worn cameras, which we are bringing in now, have been successful in our trial. The cost of body-worn cameras is approximately €86 million. This technology is expensive but it is important that we give it to our front-line officers in order that they have everything they need. For example, through the mobility devices that all gardaí have in their possession, they are able to check vehicles. They can see if there are warrants. They can see all those sorts of things at the touch of their fingers. That type of technology is the envy of many forces in Europe. We are doing well when it comes to technology. We have also invested heavily in our new communication system, the 999 system.

As I say, ICT is intrinsically linked to modern policing. One of our biggest concerns relates to any type of attack on our systems. If we were to lose any of those systems, it would really affect front-line policing. I cannot overemphasise the importance of it.

Comment on this

The Commissioner emphasises that ICT is important and that the taxpayer gets great value for money.

Will he talk about the overspend of €20 million on digital capital investment and IT expenses? Again, it is about getting value for taxpayers' money. How did that overspend occur?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

My colleague Mr. O'Connor might answer that question.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

Basically, as the Commissioner alluded to, body-worn cameras would be one element that-----

Comment on this

There was an overspend of €20 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

In ICT, yes.

Comment on this

I am being told we are getting great value for money. I do not consider an overspend of €20 million to be good value.

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

We would have underspends on other lines.

Comment on this

I am just wondering about these ICT projects. Is there one company involved in all of them across the board? Perhaps this is something at which the C and AG could look. The ICT companies seem to be making a lot of money right across every Department. That is coming to our attention every week. I would like to see whether there is a recurring theme and if the ICT projects being run across all Departments are similar. There seems to be a trend of an awful lot of money being spent on ICT. Mr. Kelly said the cost was €180 million in one year, which would amount to €1.8 billion over ten years. It is an incredible amount of money to be spending when what taxpayers would like to see is more gardaí on the streets.

I have asked all my questions. I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will allow Deputy McAuliffe in before we take a short break as he is under a time constraint.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Cathaoirleach's assistance. I said to the Tusla representatives last week that there is huge respect for the work of An Garda Síochána, just as there is for many of the agencies that appear before us. The nature of this committee is that we often end up focusing on the things that go wrong from a financial and governance perspective. I take this opportunity to acknowledge some of the good work that is being done. Nearly 50 extra gardaí have been allocated to Ballymun and Finglas this year alone. The work gardaí have done at an international level in respect of the Kinahans and so on will have an impact in terms of the supply of drugs, etc. My own district has two great superintendents, Emer Curran and Donncha Maguire. They are newly appointed and I met them only this week at a local community safety partnership meeting. I have confidence that while they continue to fight for resources, they will do their very best with what they have.

Mr. Kelly's predecessor, in a fairly jaw-dropping moment, revealed to this committee that he had on hand €40 million of cash in Garda storage. I understand that was an unprecedented level of physical cash for any State body or agency. There were concerns about that and there was correspondence relating to it. Does the Commissioner wish to update the committee, first, on how much cash is currently on hand and, second, what measures are being taken to seek to secure a proper interest rate for that cash so that it does not lose value? Will he also comment on the security concerns regarding the money? I understand there were 40 investigations relating to it.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I am going to hand over to Deputy Commissioner Coxon, who has done a lot of work in the cash area. Before doing so, there are a couple of points that are important to make. To be clear, the cash we hold does not actually belong to An Garda Síochána. We have received very clear legal advice that we cannot lodge the money into a bank account to gain interest. The reality of this is-----

Comment on this

That is different from how the Criminal Assets Bureau, CAB, holds money. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

It very well may be but the-----

Comment on this

It is a significant point because if CAB holds cash in a different way, whereby it holds its value, and that is equally evidenced from CAB's perspective, surely the same procedure should apply for An Garda Síochána.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I do not know what arrangements CAB has in place but we certainly can look at that. I assure the Deputy that we have put significant time into this matter. We have legal advice around it. A lot of the money we have is related to prosecutions and court cases. As I said, we have very firm advice that we cannot lodge it with a bank to gain interest. If we could, we certainly would do so. If there were a gain for the State from doing that and we could do it, we would, of course, do it.

The other point about CAB is that it operates on a different burden of proof from that applying to An Garda Síochána. We deal with criminal prosecutions, which require a criminal burden of proof, while CAB operates on a civil burden of proof, which is completely different.

On the point around the security of the cash, that certainly is a concern for us. I know the Deputy raised that point last summer. Deputy Commissioner Coxon has done a considerable amount of work on this and will be able to give him some of the updated figures.

Comment on this
Dr. Shawna Coxon

The Commissioner has covered most of it. Currently, we have €45.9 million in custody as evidence. That cannot be converted in the same way that we cannot sell a car we seize, which must be physically brought to court. It is the same with a physical bill. We have written to the committee extensively to explain the position on this. We have looked into it yet again, because we also have issues and concerns, but there is no-----

Comment on this

From whom did An Garda Síochána seek the legal advice to which the Commissioner referred? Has there been consultation with the Department of public expenditure, for example, in terms of the value of that evidence?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

We have our own legal section and I would have sought advice from our executive director for legal and compliance. I would have to check back on the papers but there usually would be extensive engagement with other agencies and with senior counsel. As I said, we have not done this once-----

Comment on this

To clarify, was the advice the Commissioner sought external to An Garda Síochána?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Like I said, I do not have the papers in front of me and would have to check them. Most of the advices we receive would be a combination of internal and external.

Comment on this
Dr. Shawna Coxon

It is important to say that the Director of Public Prosecutions, DPP, was, of course, consulted because the evidence we bring to court is what that office will be presenting there.

Comment on this

Since this issue was raised at this committee last year, An Garda Síochána has consulted the DPP about it. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Dr. Shawna Coxon

Yes, and we did so before we were here last year as well, which is why my position has not changed.

Comment on this

What changes and improvements have been made in terms of security?

Comment on this
Dr. Shawna Coxon

There is ongoing work in this area. Our property and evidence management system, PEMS, tracks every piece of evidence we have, including cash. We have physical systems. PEMS is about tracking what we have. Since we last met, there have been updates. As the Deputy will recall, we had challenges around the figure. It is an estimation figure because if money is counterfeit or sent in a different way, there might be challenges in terms of what that euro figure is. There has been an upgrade to the-----

Comment on this

Has there been any assessment of that €45 million in terms of what element of it is counterfeit cash and what element is real cash?

Comment on this
Dr. Shawna Coxon

We are in the process of doing that. It is very time consuming because everything has to be physically looked at. What has happened initially is that we have upgraded PEMS to be able to determine what is cash and what is other forms of monetary value or other pieces of evidence. That is one thing that has been done. The other thing is we are looking-----

Comment on this

Does that mean the €45 million figure is not accurate?

Comment on this
Dr. Shawna Coxon

I am saying it is the best estimate we have with the systems we currently have in place.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

To clarify, counterfeit would not make up a large amount of that figure. The reality is we do not come across a lot of counterfeit money.

Comment on this

Okay. I might return to this later. We have not made enough progress in this area. As a member of the committee, I am not satisfied that enough has been done, perhaps outside of An Garda Síochána, to ensure the value of that cash is safeguarded. Am I correct that, ultimately, a significant portion of it comes back to the State?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Yes, absolutely.

Comment on this

It was announced last week that €250,000 would be provided from the proceeds of crime fund for different justice projects in my constituency. This is money that makes a real difference on the ground. Are we talking about bundles of cash on shelves? Are we talking about loose notes? What form does this money take?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

It is a combination of all of that. As the Deputy rightly said, a lot of the money that comes into An Garda Síochána, at the end of the core processes, is returned to the State. That is what happens to the majority of the money we seize.

If we seize from criminals or drug dealers, we wait until the court process is over. As soon as it is over and absolutely as soon as we can, we go through the process in the court and get it back to the State. The State, as the Deputy says, can use that for some really good purposes.

Comment on this

Deputy Dolan raised the issue of non-compliant procurement in last year's accounts. The RTÉ programme raised a number of issues around stock management and procurement. I will ask a few questions for Mr. Kelly to answer in whatever time he has; he might come back to me in writing if he cannot answer now. Was the procurement of the holsters a compliant procurement? What was the value of it?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Yes, it was. There were 2,575 holsters procured between 2013 and 2020 and the value was €89,061.60.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Kelly give me the same details for the ammunition?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I think there were 500,000 rounds. I do not have that value with me but we can certainly get it.

Comment on this

What was the value of the contract for destruction?

Comment on this
Mr. Aonghus O'Connor

Some €140,000 was paid for the destruction but the destruction covered a lot more than the 500,000 rounds the Commissioner-----

Comment on this

Are the witnesses satisfied the procurement processes regarding the purchase of the holsters, the purchase of the ammunition and the destruction of the ammunition - and, I suppose, the destruction of the holsters as well - were all compliant?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Yes, absolutely. There was no cost for the destruction of the holsters once they were removed.

Comment on this

What was done with them?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

It was within an existing contract, so there was no additional cost.

Comment on this

Given that we got those in evidence, the witnesses might provide a written note on those amounts they gave us, if that is okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I thank everybody for being here this morning. At the outset, I want to put on the record my great respect for members of An Garda Síochána for the work they do, day in and day out. It is one of those jobs where you do not know what you are going to face when you go into work on any given day, and that is extremely challenging. I have great respect, so anything I say is in my role as a member of the Committee of Public Accounts to try to question some issues.

The first topic I want to ask about is the Garda Reserve. In 2025, there was €1.4 million allocated but only €342,000 drawn down. I note the opening statement mentioned there are currently 308 Garda Reserve members. Is that particular model dead in the water at this stage?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Reserve members are very important for me as Garda Commissioner and I certainly see them as part of our organisation going forward. The numbers we have at the moment are absolutely nowhere near where they need to be. Only in recent months I had a number of meetings around moving on our Reserve members. In the last year or year and a half, our full focus has been on getting sworn members into the organisation and the committee heard some of the things I spoke about regarding that. For us, it is the same people who are dealing with Reserve members and full members in terms of getting them through the vetting system, the competitions and all that. However, we are now turning our focus to Reserve members.

Comment on this

Do we have a target? We have targets in relation to sworn members.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

I do not have a target number to present yet because we are still working through it. However, there are a couple of things we have already decided we are going to do. With Reserve members, we are going to do targeted reserving, meaning advertising per area and particular areas.

Comment on this

I am caught for time. Is Mr. Kelly saying it is a focus and that he is not happy with the level he has and wants to increase that?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Yes.

Comment on this

I recently had a parliamentary question on the topic of body-worn cameras. In 2024, there were 600 body-worn cameras deployed, as I understand, across five Garda stations, and in 2027 the Commissioner wants to roll that out further. When does he estimate the full force will have body-worn cameras?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Everything that has been rolled out so far has been on a pilot basis. We have pilots in a number of different areas. We have now moved to the procurement stage and we are going to roll out into next year. Deputy Commissioner Cleary has led out on the project, so I will ask him to give Deputy McGrath some more information.

Comment on this

How much is it estimated to cost for the full roll-out? Can I have a timeline and the cost, please?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Cleary

The Commissioner has already mentioned a figure of €86 million. Regarding the timeline, the proof of concept has been ongoing and we will be ready to go to tender in the middle of January, with roll-out starting in the middle of July. It will be a phased roll-out and will be incremental, based on network capability, demand, and assignment in the different stations. It is moving well. We are on target in the project. We are going to try to bring forward the awarding of a contract to before Christmas if we can, but we have-----

Comment on this

In terms of the quantum of the contract if it is phased, approximately when will the 15,000 members have cameras? Are we talking about two or three years?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Cleary

I would say it will be three years at best.

Comment on this

Were the cameras considered effective? Did the pilot work?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Cleary

Yes. There are some areas outside of our control with networking in older buildings.

Comment on this

I want to move on to the issue of Garda pursuits. This is something I want to clarify because it is something the public are very concerned about. According to public commentary, as few as six members of the force are to be trained before the end of the year. As it stands now, are there members of the force qualified to carry out pursuits?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

At the moment we have a number of different levels of training. We never had dedicated pursuit training in the organisation before. This is the first time we ever did training for pursuit.

Comment on this

Does that mean members are able to pursue?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin Kelly

Members are now able to do that. It depends on their level of training, but they are trained using vehicles with blue lights and sirens, going through junctions etc. There is training around that and, at the moment, they are allowed to do it. We have policy in place which allows them to do it. As I said earlier, all the pursuits are now controlled by our control centres where we have people who are specially trained to manage pursuits.

Comment on this