Gnó an Choiste - Business of Committee
All seven 2025 accounts received clear audit opinions, with no questions raised. Members criticized the Department of Public Expenditure’s response on the OPW’s financial commitment to the national children’s science centre and agreed to seek further engagement and meeting details. On hospital parking charges, the committee called for follow-up on implementing the 2018 review and requested the new review’s terms of reference and timeline.
I welcome everyone to today's meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts. Before proceeding, I will go through a few housekeeping matters.
Members are reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 226 that the committee shall refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies. Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
I also remind members of the constitutional requirement that in order to participate in public meetings, members must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex or precincts.
The agenda for the public session today is as follows: accounts and statements, correspondence and upcoming meetings. Then we will suspend and begin our engagement with officials from Uisce Éireann at approximately 10.30 a.m.
I welcome Ms Colette Drinan, secretary and director of audit, who is attending on behalf of the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General, who is a permanent witness to the committee. There are seven sets of accounts and financial statements laid between 5 and 9 October 2026 due to be considered today. I now invite Ms Drinan to address these before opening the floor to members.
Comment on this
As mentioned, there are seven sets of accounts, all for the financial year end December 2025. First, Citizens Information Board, certified on 30 July, received a clear audit opinion. The National Disability Authority, certified on 30 June, received a clear audit opinion. The Defence Forces canteen board, certified on 30 July, received a clear audit opinion. The motor tax account, certified on 16 September, received a clear audit opinion. Horse Racing Ireland, certified on 30 June, received a clear audit opinion. The Royal Irish Academy, certified on 22 July, received a clear audit opinion. Finally, the Land Development Agency, certified on 5 June, received a clear audit opinion.
Comment on this
Members do not wish to raise any issues or any questions in relation to any of those. We are happy to move on.
The are a number of B items of correspondence to consider today and these have been received from Departments and public bodies.
The first is No. 0508, correspondence received from the Department of Rural and Community Development and the Gaeltacht, in relation to the late laying of the annual report and financial statements of Údarás na Gaeltachta for 2024, dated 22 September 2026. Is it agreed to note and publish this item? Agreed.
The next is No. 0513, correspondence received from the deputy chief executive of Beaumont Hospital board, in response to the committee's request for information regarding income generated by a private company providing radiology services, dated 6 October 2026. Is it agreed to note and publish the item? Agreed.
The next is No. 0515, correspondence received from the Secretary General of the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation regarding the committee's interim report on the examination of the 2024 appropriation account for Vote 13 - Office of Public Works and chapter 5 of the C and AG's report on the accounts of public services 2024, dated 7 October 2026. I am sure members have read that correspondence with some interest. Before I open this up to members, it is deeply disappointing that the Department of public expenditure and reform seems to have completely washed its hands in any engagement on this, an issue to which this committee has given considerable concern and attention. It is deeply concerning. It is noted that the Minister of State, "Boxer" Moran, belatedly is now going to meet with ICML. Why that has not happened before now remains to be answered, but there are still considerable concerns. I read a newspaper report in The Irish Times this morning that the national children's science centre, on foot of our producing our interim report early in the year, has sought a number of engagements with the Department of public expenditure and reform and has not received any response. That is the essence of the problem here. It is the head-in-the-sand approach that is walking us into not only further financial limbo but also serious further financial consideration and concern for members of the public. I will open this up to members. I am sure everyone has had an opportunity to read the responses.
Comment on this
If ever there was an example of the siloed Civil Service, this is it. We all accept that the OPW made a mistake initially in agreeing to this contract and compounded its mistake in 2013 in agreeing to the arbitration, but for its parent Department to say that it has no responsibility - and, to me, it actually looks like they have even had very little engagement - is absolutely outrageous. This is a liability on the State, and for the Civil Service to play "Not my responsibility" is just not good enough. This needs to get resolved. We need all parties to engage proactively. The only way things get resolved is by dialogue, and that needs to happen here. We also need to see the national science museum proactively engage and be reasonable in its requests of the State.
Comment on this
Like Deputy Boland said, what we see is an entity being thrown under the bus in real time by the Department of public expenditure and reform. Nearly every second word in this correspondence reinforces the idea that this is the OPW's responsibility and not the Department's. The reason that concerns me is, ultimately, who funds the OPW but the Department of public expenditure and reform. Burying the head in the sand, like Deputy Boland said, and hoping this issue will go away has failed the State and the Exchequer over decades and is only going to be the wrong approach. As a committee we have called for many months for the people involved to get to the table. It is a very welcome step that the Minister of State will meet with the body to try to progress this. I note that in that correspondence, though, it is to either progress the project or to end the OPW's commitment to the project, whatever would be the most financially beneficial engagement with the State, with legal advice showing that that will be a costly measure in and of itself.
As a committee, we should reflect on the fact that we have done much to get this to this point. The next step is crucial, and I call on the Department of public expenditure and reform to be at that meeting with the Minister of State, Deputy Moran. There needs to be a representative from the Department at that meeting, and I ask that we issue correspondence to the Department calling for same. That will be a really important next step in this.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, time might not be with us. That meeting is imminent this week, either today or tomorrow, so I do not know whether that is feasible-----
Comment on this
As everybody else said, the Department of public expenditure and reform has the ultimate responsibility for funding or not funding this, but at this stage of the game, the taxpayer has lost a lot of money in relation to this issue and the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste need to be involved in this as well with the Minister of State. Something needs to happen. It is a complete waste of taxpayers' money. It has gone on for years, and somebody needs to step up to the mark and decide who is in charge here. Something needs to happen ASAP.
Comment on this
I welcome the intervention of the Minister of State in meeting with ICML. I agree with Deputy Boland that the siloed response from the Department of public expenditure is particularly disappointing for two reasons. Dealing with this specific case, we are essentially saying to it that there is a possibility of the State spending more money and that being a further waste of money and the Department of public expenditure and reform should be interested in that and should be intervening at this point. One of the recommendations made that very clear.
Second, the Department does not address the fact that the OPW made this commitment on behalf of the public without a business case and it does not seem to have any consequences for a body doing that. The Comptroller and Auditor General and other members here referred to that. If there are no consequences for committing the State to a contract without a business case, what is to stop any other body doing the same thing? It is just disappointing that the Department has not taken the more macro view of this and said, "This is an example of where things go wrong, the OPW made a commitment that it should not have made and, as a result, we have put these steps in place." It has not said that to us. It has effectively said this is a matter for the OPW, and that has been the problem from the beginning.
I am of the view that we should write back to the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation saying we acknowledge the response but we want them to come back on the systemic points raised regarding what is in place to stop similar projects occurring again.
Comment on this
I agree with the members' views. One of our recommendations said:
The committee considers that the matters identified during its examination are unlikely to be resolved through engagement between the parties alone and will require consideration at an appropriate level across Government.
I hear members' frustrations. I do not think it is solely on the civil servants. It is quite easy to blame the Civil Service for a lot of failures. This needs ministerial and Government intervention. That was the call right across the board. It needs intervention at appropriate Government levels. Unfortunately, that has not taken place here. There are other considerations here. We know through our examination of IPAS expenditure that the State has paid out considerable liabilities for pre-contract agreements with potential IPAS providers. That has put us on the hook for up to €20 million, if memory serves me right.
So, there is precedent there. I am not saying the State should seek to buy its way out of this, but on one hand the State is prepared to take measures to take issues to a head to try to save the State from further financial liability, but the approach here is not consistent with that. It is a case of continuing to walk us into further financial risk. We are two months out from the completion of that tender documentation preparation process, and the Minister is only meeting now. We know there are consultants working away on that tender preparation. What happens at the end of December? Do they advertise for tenders? What are the liabilities then if somebody prepares tender documents and submits them only to be told there is no money to fund this? Is that putting the State on the hook for further financial liabilities for the companies and businesses that tender for that, knowing that the project is going nowhere?
It needs to come to a head. We absolutely need to follow up with the Department of public expenditure. There is a huge abdication of responsibility there that is unfortunately exposing the taxpayer and State to further financial loss. We need to go back. Inevitably, we will have the OPW back before the committee at some stage, but I think the responsibility here lies at a higher level, and that is within the Department of public expenditure. We need to follow up with that Department and echo all the points, frustration and annoyance that have been aired here. We also need to follow up with the OPW. We know that meeting is going to take place. We need to find out what exactly is being discussed. We need to see what is on the agenda. We need to see a copy of the minutes from the meeting that takes place between the Minister of State, Deputy Moran, and ICML. Is that agreed? Agreed. Is it agreed to note and publish the item of correspondence? Agreed.
No. R2026/0516 is correspondence received from the Minister for Health regarding hospital car parking charges, dated 7 October 2026.
Comment on this
I have raised this issue on numerous occasions at this committee. It relates to car parking charges outside hospitals, which should not be happening when people are sick and going into hospitals. There was a review done in 2018 and then in 2019 on the outstanding issues. We are here today being told that after all that time, coming up on eight years, the outstanding issues are still in place and still have not been resolved, even though there has been report after report done. We are now told in this letter that there is going to be a process of establishing a national review, which is completely ridiculous. They just need to reduce the price to €10 as was called for in the review in 2018. It just seems to be an ongoing saga. It is complete delay tactics and complete deflection. They need to do it straight away. The Minister for Health needs to step up to the mark and ensure this happens, so sick people are not being charged the horrendous fees they are being charged in carparks right across the country in every hospital. I ask that the Minister goes back to the report that was done in 2018. There is no need to set up another national review. All we need to see is that people are charged no more than €10 a day in car parks.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Bennett for that. I agree with that. It is deeply concerning. Regarding the review of 2018, there is a line in the response from the Department in the covering letter from the Minister that says the Secretary General has now written to the HSE CEO asking that the HSE takes the necessary steps to give effect to the key outstanding recommendations of the 2018 hospital car parking review. Here we are, eight years later, and action is seemingly now being taken. It absolutely shows up what that review was in 2018. It was a box-ticking exercise with no implementation and no intent to actually follow through on it. It would not give members of the public much hope of anything successful coming from the letter that has been sent to the HSE CEO. I ask that we follow up and get a copy of the letter that has been sent to the CEO and also see what timeframe has been given to the hospitals to implement the content of the 2018 review. Regarding the new review that is due to take place, I think the Department is saying it will report by the end of quarter 1 of 2027. We need to see the full terms of reference for that review group and who is actually going to make up that review group. Is it agreed that we follow up on those points? Agreed. Is it agreed to note and publish this item of correspondence? Agreed.
That concludes the B items for today's meeting. We now move onto the work programme. Next week, the committee will examine chapter 26, procurement of hot school meals, with the Department of Social Protection. The Department of education will attend in a representative capacity. The committee has also agreed its work schedule for the remainder of the year and this will be posted on the website. We are making a few amendments to it but we hope to have it agreed for next week's meeting.
The committee also agreed its report on the temporary international protection and Ukraine. That will also be published next week.
The last item on the agenda is any other business. Are there any other items members wish to raise at this stage? No. That concludes our second session. We will suspend for a short time.