We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Financial Statements 2025: Uisce Éireann

Summary

Uisce Éireann reported 2025 revenue of about €1.8 billion and capital investment of €1.43 billion, with profits reinvested in infrastructure; the Comptroller and Auditor General issued a clean audit opinion. The CRU’s €31 million reduction in future allowed revenue for missed leakage and non-domestic collection targets was accepted by the utility, which said it would deliver efficiencies to absorb the impact. Uisce Éireann outlined a €12.2 billion investment programme focused on network upgrades and housing capacity, while acknowledging ongoing service and communication challenges. Committee members also questioned executive pay and performance awards, the funding model, procurement transparency and the pace of local projects.

Contributions 866–1,084 of 1,084. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 5 parts.

-----so I am really looking forward to seeing now next year when we have Uisce Éireann back in here that "absolutely" it spent that money in the right manner and "absolutely" it was well-spent, including for the taxpayer.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I beg the Deputy's pardon. That is one of my "isms", and I apologise for that. I am sure we all have them.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

The reality here is that we are very much on track to deliver our capital budget this year.

We are also on track to deliver within our operational expenditure budget and that has been a very difficult-----

Comment on this

On the capital budget, going back to housing delivery and planning, in 2024 it was 52,000. Is that correct? In 2025 it was 32,000. What is the figure for 2026 predicted to be?

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

For 2026, I can give figures for the year-to-date. The 2026 connection offers year-to-date, up to the end of August, were associated with 31,000 housing units.

Comment on this

What did Uisce Éireann finish at last year?

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

We finished last year at 41,903 connection offers. Sorry, I was rounding up.

Comment on this

It was 41,000. Again, I want to make sure the taxpayer knows they are getting value for money.

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

Just on connection offer numbers, we are responding in that regard to applications from developers so-----

Comment on this

But still we are down. From 2024 there were 52,000. In 2025-----

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

We measure our performance here in terms of-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

In 2024, we had the refunds programme-----

Comment on this

However, Uisce Éireann had 52,000 in 2024. In 2025, it had 41,000 and in 2026, it estimates 31,000 now.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

No. We are 31,000 to August so that is not an estimate.

Comment on this

By year end, then?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Say 50,000.

Comment on this

Oh my God. That is amazing. Uisce Éireann is going to do-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Some 48,000.

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

Our performance is measured in our response rate to developers because ultimately we cannot-----

Comment on this

But that is 19,000 Uisce Éireann is going to do now in two months?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Deputy-----

Comment on this

That is amazing.

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

I am sorry, Deputy-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Deputy, we are responding to the market. Developers come to us and say they would like-----

Comment on this

I am just wondering what the taxpayer is getting value for money here. In 2024, €119 million was spent on wages but in 2025, €222 million was spent on wages. That was an increase of €90 million in one year.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We explained the wages in relation to people coming over.

Comment on this

It was an increase in staff of about 900. Wages also increased by 3% in that everybody automatically gets an increase, which I remind everyone sounds like a very two-tiered system compared to everybody else in the public sector. They do not get a 3% raise every year. I just want to remind the witnesses of that. On top of all the additionality in relation to staff and performance bonuses, we also have hospitality. Maybe the witnesses can just tell me how much they spent on hospitality that year? Was it €170,000?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Yes.

Comment on this

How would you spend €170,000 on hospitality?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It is about €57 per staff member so it is a relatively small figure.

Comment on this

Relatively small.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Yes.

Comment on this

A total of €170,000 on hospitality is relatively small.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It is, yes.

Comment on this

Mr. Gleeson is definitely living in a two-tiered system.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

A total of €57 per staff member is a relatively small figure.

Comment on this

How many staff are there in total?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It was 3,200 when it was-----

Comment on this

Will Mr. Gleeson remind the public again that every single one of those got performance-related bonus except for 18 of them?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The vast majority did, yes.

Comment on this

There were only 18 people who did not get it.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We have a very good, dedicated workforce. The vast majority-----

Comment on this

The whole country has a dedicated workforce but they do not get a performance-related bonus, they do not get a 3% hike and they do not get hospitality. Mr. Gleeson is just taking things for granted. The Government is funding, Uisce Éireann, as Mr. Gleeson said, by €2.2 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Billion.

Comment on this

Some €2.2 billion in 2026. There has to be something for the public to see transparency here. Mr. Gleeson thinks this is all easy come, easy go. I can tell him it is not. People work long and hard and have to pay taxes to make sure that Uisce Éireann has this money.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

My staff work long and hard to deliver the services that we deliver. We have an excellent staff and we have a very good pay model that involves PRA-----

Comment on this

Will Mr. Gleeson tell me again about Uisce Éireann's performance-related bonuses? Nobody has to do anything. Nobody has to meet targets-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

They set their targets.

Comment on this

They do not set the targets.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The line manager sets the targets. The staff meet their targets. That is what we have. We have a very dedicated, hard-working workforce. They work very well. A small percentage fail. That is the reality.

Comment on this

That is the 18 people who did not get-----

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It is 8% who are behind the curve, to be fair. I said that earlier.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The people who are behind the curve do not get the full amount but they get something.

Comment on this

That is nice.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

That is the model.

Comment on this

For not performing you get something anyway.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

No, sorry-----

Comment on this

That is what Mr. Gleeson is after telling me.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Maybe the person did not get all their objectives. We measure people based on how they performed.

Comment on this

In a real world, you do not get compensated for not working.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I am sorry; there is no question that they are not working.

Comment on this

There is something going on if they are not meeting their targets and Mr. Gleeson is telling me that 18-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

A portion of their target was not met so they get penalised because of that. That is the reality.

Comment on this

What percentage was it again? Mr. Gleeson said everyone else in the company gets how many percent?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Eight percent did not get it.

Comment on this

Eight percent did not get it.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Eight percent were behind.

Comment on this

We will just put that on the record

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

And that 8% is aligned to a normal market-based model that is used to-----

Comment on this

It is not normal. I can tell Mr. McCarthy that in any way it is not normal.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

If we turn up-----

Comment on this

When you see all the teachers and nurses and everybody out on the picket lines yesterday, it is not normal.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We are a performance-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We will go to Deputy Boland next.

Comment on this

I want to focus on the negative revenue adjustments. There was a €31 million negative revenue adjustment. One of the reasons for this was Uisce Éireann was not meeting the benchmarks for collecting revenue from commercial or non-domestic customers. What are we talking about here in terms of money? How much in bad debts did this finding relate to?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I will ask Mr. McCarthy to come in on that one.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

The calculation is taking our bad debt provision as a percentage of our total revenue. That is around 9% or 9.5%. That was the €32 million, which was our bad debt provision, over our total revenue of €333 million, so nearly 10%. That is taking an example for last year. The target the regulator has set for us is that our bad debt provision would be no more than 5%. We are very conscious that we have a long legacy of under-payers and poor payers that need to be cleansed and we are in the process of cleansing that book. Our proposal back to the regulator – and the discussions are very much ongoing – is that we would move that from a provision. A provision is highlighting a concern over the collection. It is not saying that we will not be able to collect-----

Comment on this

I appreciate that but let us actually look at the figures.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I will talk about the figures now.

Comment on this

We are just running out of time so if we could focus on the figures I would appreciate that.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

In terms of where we are right now, we are targeting close on 95% collection rate over billed revenue. The Deputy might say that should be the same thing but the reality is we have billing cycles that are legacy billing cycles. Some of them are annual, some of them are half-year so we have a big percentage of our revenue unbilled at a point in time. What is very positive is that we are doing close to that 95% but we want to make sure the regulator will work with us on that. We are discussing that.

Comment on this

I appreciate that on the percentage but what is Uisce Éireann’s total bad debt figure today and what is the figure of those outstanding for more than 90 days?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

In the accounts, the Deputy can see our ageing debts. We wrote off €16 million and it is called out in the accounts. That is on page-----

Comment on this

Can we just focus on the figures?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We have an exercise to do. We have still a sizeable very old book, but what we want to do is do it forensically, cleanse it and make sure that we know who the customer is so that they can-----

Comment on this

I appreciate all that and I agree with all that but I am trying to get a better understanding of the figures. Some €16 million was written off. That would be written off because it had been outstanding for how long?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

As to the exact details, it could have been outstanding for seven, eight or ten years.

Comment on this

Where are we with outstanding debts for greater than 90 days?

Comment on this
Ms Colette Drinan

Note 11 of the accounts, on page 117, has a table that sets the aged debts out.

Comment on this

Is it trending up or down? The reason I am focusing on this is I want to know is Uisce Éireann actually carrying a liability for another penalty, another negative revenue adjustment in this cycle?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We are trending upwards.

Our non-domestic revenue increased significantly between 2024 and 2025. That also went up by €60 million, but we still have that old debt we have to cleanse. The reality of this is that we have spoken to the regulator and we know we will not be able to deliver this incentive in its current form until we can get all of that existing legacy debt cleansed.

Comment on this

What is the obstacle to getting that existing legacy debt cleansed?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It is essentially time, inspections and getting out there and spending money on cleansing it.

Comment on this

Are these customers being charged?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

They are being charged. They are getting invoices. They are continuing to use it, but what we are finding in some cases is that they may not be the same customer. It might be going to a building or a premise but the business has changed or the company name has changed. The most important thing for us on the debt situation is that we cleanse the book once and manage it thereafter.

Comment on this

When will we have cleansed the book?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

To be fair, it is going to take a number of years before we will have fully cleansed that book, without putting significant energy into it.

Comment on this

Could Mr. McCarthy give me a target? It is really important. I am not trying to be difficult but we need to track the money and the value for money. Telling us it could take a number of years is just not good enough for this committee. Could he give us a date?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

All I can say is that it will take a number of years unless we put significant money into it and it might not be able to pay for itself.

Comment on this

I appreciate Mr. McCarthy's position but I it is important for Uisce Éireann to set out a timeline for cleansing this book.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I take that on board.

Comment on this

It is not good enough to come into the Committee of Public Accounts and say that it is going to take a number of years; we need to see a plan and a timeline as to when we expect the book to be cleansed.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We are working with the CRU on this.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We have worked very closely with our board as well on this particular point. That is why we are seeing the trend on increasing our collectability to get from 90% to 95% in terms of collection rates.

Comment on this

What is the target date for achieving a 95% rate?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We are hoping, from a cash-collection basis, that we will be there, ideally, this year but definitely next year, but we have to make sure the regulator moves with us in terms of the definition. We are working on that.

Comment on this

I have a feeling we might be having this conversation again.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Hopefully we will not.

Comment on this

Hopefully it will be more positive but when Uisce Éireann comes back in to us next year we will need to see a plan on this.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I appreciate that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

That is fine, yes.

Comment on this

Otherwise we are going to end up repeating these conversations. We need to see progress.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I understand that.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for staying on. Back in July when he was looking at Uisce Éireann's accounts, the Comptroller and Auditor General highlighted that, further to what Deputy Boland was talking about, the Commission for Regulation of Utilities proposed a €31 million penalty in the form of future revenue adjustment. The CRU considered that in the period 2024, Uisce Éireann underperformed in achieving key targets for water-leak reduction and the collection of non-domestic revenue. What did that penalty end up being?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It ended up being €31 million in terms of the actual determination.

Comment on this

It did finalise at €31 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It is a revenue reduction over the next five years.

Comment on this

I take the point that the performance-related pay model in Uisce Éireann is benchmarked - I think that was the phrase used - against a normal private market model.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Also, the semi-State market and the utilities.

Comment on this

Can the witnesses understand how it is seen by the public watching? For example, the Comptroller and Auditor General also said that it is very unusual for performance-related pay to exist in the bodies that he audits. That is for obvious reasons and it relates to Uisce Éireann's establishment. The body that regulates Uisce Éireann has said the company has not been meeting water-leakage targets for a number of years and proposed to fine it €31 million. At the same time, Uisce Éireann is paying the full level of performance-related pay to its employees. Can Mr. Gleeson understand how that is viewed by people watching, notwithstanding what he said about the market model, and that they might find it difficult to understand?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The economic regulator is one portion of our business. In that area, we hit 20 of the 24 targets. We barely missed two of the others and the revenue reduction was put in place for the two that we missed. We also report to the Environmental Protection Agency, which sets targets for us. It checks us every year. We have internal targets. We have health and safety targets. We have the cultural integration of all the local authority staff coming in. There is a lot of work going on in the business that is not covered by the CRU.

Comment on this

Yes, but Uisce Éireann is being fined to the tune of €31 million for not meeting leakage targets during a specified period, while at the same time all of its employees are receiving the full performance-related pay. Can Mr. Gleeson understand how the public watching would feel that there is a mismatch?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Again, just-----

Comment on this

Could Mr. Gleeson just answer that question? The public watching feel there is a mismatch. Can he understand why that would be the impression that the public would have?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

No, because I do not see that there is a mismatch. Everybody in the organisation took a hit because the leakage rates were not hit. Everyone lost probably 3% to 4% off their PRA because of the leakage rates, which was the corporate target. The corporate target was not met and we had a percentage-----

Comment on this

That impacted the performance-related pay.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Everybody took a hit because we did not meet the leakage rates but in lots of other areas we hit the targets. That is the model that we have.

Comment on this

When Mr. Gleeson tells us that the performance-related pay is exactly the same as in the semi-State companies, the challenge we have on this side of the desk is that the Comptroller and Auditor General does not audit the other commercial semi-State companies. We have no visibility over the other commercial semi-State companies. I take Mr. Gleeson's word in terms of what he says. Is there anything that he could give this committee to support, by way of evidence, the statement he has made?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We have already committed to Deputy McAuliffe that we would come back with a benchmark against an increment model, the public sector model and our own model to demonstrate that it is-----

Comment on this

This is a different question. Mr. McCarthy is saying that 97% performance is typical across the commercial semi-State sector. I think he extended it further and said the private-market model.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

No, I am sorry. I am not saying the 97% performance-----

Comment on this

That was my question.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I am saying that the awards-----

Comment on this

Does Mr. McCarthy think Uisce Éireann is an outlier in terms of performance-related pay?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

No. I would not think so.

Comment on this

Where does he stand? Does he have visibility over the other semi-State sector companies and can he give an answer to the committee?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

In terms of their outturn on an annual basis, from just a simple comparison in the external market, we would consider that, based across our objectives, 90% or 92% or 93% would be good. It is important. We would consider ourselves to be in that range. However, it is important to point out on the leakage-----

Comment on this

I just want to ask a very clear question. I was under the impression that Mr. McCarthy had told me that the amount of performace-related pay that Uisce Éireann is paying its employees was comparable, in percentage terms, to other commercial semi-State agencies in the State. Is he now saying that is not the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I cannot say for definite that the amount we paid is comparable but what I can say is that-----

Comment on this

Could Mr. McCarthy please answer the question? What can he say - relative to the other commercial semi-State agencies in the State - in respect of Uisce Éireann's percentage share of performance-related pay? I am only interested in what he can say.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Our model is quite-----

Comment on this

I do not want to hear about Uisce Éireann's model. Mr. McCarthy knows the question. He has heard it a few times. What can he say?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

All I can say is other semi-State organisations use-----

Comment on this

So Mr. McCarthy does not know. If his answer is "I have no visibility and I cannot tell you, Deputy Geoghegan", could he please say that? What can he say?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

What I can say is that I know other semi-State organisations are using a variable or pay-----

Comment on this

Whether by intention or design, Mr. McCarthy left the impression on this committee earlier that the percentage of performance-related pay his organisation was paying out was comparable to every other commercial semi-State company in this State. He is now saying something very different. Which is it? It is a really simple question. Does he have any information? Does he regret lending that impression to the committee that it was comparable?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

No, we do have information. In some cases semi-State organisations are paying more and in some agencies may be paying less.

Comment on this

Paying more percentage of performance-related pay.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Some may be paying a higher percentage and some might pay less. It is about linking it back to performance.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

What Mr. McCarthy was saying is that it is the same model. They are all applying the same model.

Comment on this

I understand the model. I was not challenging the model.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The individual percentages and the bands are going to vary from one company to another.

Comment on this

The point we are making is that Uisce Éireann paid all of its employees the full amount, or 8% less, and 18 people got no performance-related pay.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

What I can say on that from a normal distribution curve, we are very much curved. A normal distribution curve in the semi-State market and in the public market is exactly the same. We are curved to that.

Comment on this

Could Mr. McCarthy give the committee anything on the specific question I am asking, in addition to the questions Deputy McAuliffe asked? Could he provide the committee with an evidence basis that demonstrates Uisce Éireann is typical across the commercial semi-State sector as regards the percentage of performance-related pay?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We will get that information.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We will get that information for Deputy Geoghegan. We will bring it in as part of the overall study.

Comment on this

With the indulgence of the Chair, I have a question for Mr. Laffey. The last time Irish Water was before us I raised a local issue about the Ailesbury pump station and the effluent that was going onto Sandymount Strand. To give credit to Irish Water, it met with the residents' association. While they may not have been very happy with some of the responses given at the meeting, the residents were appreciative of the fact that Irish Water met them. Does Mr. Laffey have an update in respect of that issue and any temporary solutions that could be imposed?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We have a contractor looking at putting in a mechanism to capture the debris that might come out when the pump station is overflowing. We have also got a contractor in who is working with CCTV and modelling the network in the whole area with a view to coming up with a long-term solution. What will be centre stage is that given the area and the congestion in the area, etc., the long-term solution will probably be working with Dublin City Council to remove storm water from the network because that is causing the problems. However, we are actively working on it, absolutely.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Laffey.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Deputy Geoghegan. I have a number of concluding questions. I want to return to the issue of the European Commission referring Ireland to the European Court of Justice for significant failures. A figure was given of €16,000 per day in potential fines. That is at the lower band. The upper band would be nearly €100,000 per day. Would I be right in saying that? What way is that structured?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Yes, and even talking to the Department, nobody can predict what the court will hand down because it is-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

No, absolutely, but to say the potential is €16,000-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

The potential is that, yes, and-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

-----but it could potentially be up to €36 million per year.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

It could, and what I would like to add to my last reply is that, essentially, all the issues with the treatment plants will be fixed by the end of this year. The outstanding issues, which are still causing us problems, relate to networks. One of the main issues is that the network for the city of Cork is non-compliant with the urban wastewater treatment directive.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mr. Laffey is saying that even at the end of this year and going forward, there is no easy fix. We are potentially still going to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We are looking at roughly €2 billion to fix the network in Cork city today and we are looking at probably digging up 50 km or 60 km of very busy streets in the centre of town.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is the intention to fight this in the European Court of Justice?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We are working with our parent Department to put forward a phased basis for remediation conditions in court. We are actively working with that. Ultimately, we will have to tackle the network in Cork but we are just asking for time.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

However, will the decision to fight the case in the European Court of Justice be on the basis that there will be a phased approach to the-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We probably lost the fight in about 2019 when we made the final representations to the court. What is happening now is we are just trying to mitigate any impact that we might have. We are also working with the court to perhaps say we are not going to fix all of Cork, but if we start looking at integrated drainage plans and working with Cork city and we do it on a phased basis, would they give us extra time.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay, so, potential fines of up to €36 million per year-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

It could be, yes.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

-----and that will be retrospective back to 2019.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Yes.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

What provision, if any, has been made within the Uisce Éireann accounts for those significant liabilities and potential liabilities?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We have not made anything at the moment, I believe, because, ultimately, we have to-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I presume it would be liable-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Would it?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It would not be our liability. It is the State's liability.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Therefore, within the Department's overall-----

Comment on this
Mr. Brían Munnelly

No, there is currently no provision. Again, the Voted system is an annual system, so we would not make any kind of provisions or long-term provisions. There is no provision at the moment.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay. That is of ongoing significant concern. The witnesses might keep us updated in relation to that.

I want to return to the issue of the meter in the Meta data centre that was not working. Mr. Laffey might remind me, was that identified in 2021?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

I did not say that the meter was not working in Meta. I said there were meters in data centres across the country that were not working.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay, but was there one that was not working, which had significant usage within that data centre?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

No, I think that at the time, we had captured all of the main users in the greater Dublin area. Ultimately, we had to spread out across the country to find where the other data centres were. Some of them were unmetered in some respect and some of them actually had meters that were either under-recording or not recording at all. All of that has been fixed.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay. I want to turn to a couple of local issues, one of which relates to a developer provided infrastructure, DPI. It is an old private wastewater system treatment plant in the Kilpedder area of my constituency of Wicklow. It is 40 years old and, unfortunately, despite money being allocated at a national level to decommission this system and rectify significant issues there - funds over €1.2 million were allocated to Wicklow County Council back in 2020 - there is still no clarity as to when that significant issue will be rectified, when the plant will be decommissioned and when the required works will actually commence. I do not know whether anyone is in a position to provide any information in relation to that.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

No, I would not be in a position to provide that but I will look into it. I know that in a couple of other local authorities, the money has essentially been turned down by the local authority and it has said it is up to Uisce Éireann to fix it. We have actually accepted those DPIs back into our main programme, so I will-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mr. Laffey might come back to us on that because there is significant concern. There is slight movement there in terms of it going to tender and with land access and so on from the council but the fact that is that it has had money for the last six years and there has still not been significant progress. Mr. Laffey might clarify whether there are any other issues within Uisce Éireann's remit that are potentially delaying it or what responsibility there actually is.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Does the Cathaoirleach have the name of the estate?

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is Garden Village in Kilpedder in County Wicklow. More importantly, we need a clear timeline as to when it will actually be rectified and put right.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We will contact Wicklow.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

This is the final issue, and I raised this previously. There are significant issues with odour at the Wicklow town wastewater treatment plant. There have been a number of investigations carried out. It has been established that a new updated odour abatement system is required within that facility due to very significant, serious foul odours above and beyond what would be expected at a wastewater treatment plant. It is on the Murrough, which has European environmental importance; it is a special area of conservation. There are serious issues there. It is an area widely used by members of the public for recreation and amenity, but during the summertime people simply could not use the area. Investigations have been carried out. Surveys have been carried out. I have been told that it was going to be put on the capital programme for this year. I have not been able to get any clarity. Again, I am not sure whether Mr. Laffey would be in a position to provide any information here.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

I will get it-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

If Mr. Laffey could.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

I will reply directly to the Cathaoirleach.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Perfect. That is great. That is it from my end. Does Deputy Geoghegan have any other issues? No. Deputy McGrath wishes to come in.

Comment on this

I will be very brief. I do not want to hold up the meeting. I will make two quick points, if I may. I am sorry; I had other issues to which I had to attend.

I am sure the whole area of communication has come up during the course of discussion. Number one is communication to the public. I was speaking to an Uisce Éireann employee this morning on the way to Leinster House and they referred a case to me where, we will say, there was planned work or a planned outage of the water supply, but many of the householders impacted were not aware of it. Back in the day, they would have put up local signage, for example. That practice no longer happens. Apparently, people were told it would all be on the website and they would be able to see it on the website. There is an issue there in terms of alerting. We have plenty of unplanned outages. the witnesses cannot do much about that. I understand that. However, when there is a planned outage, surely, we have an onus to be better at communicating-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

When there is an outage, people should get a letter.

Comment on this

They should get-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

That is the process, so that is an error or mistake on our part. We can look into that.

Comment on this

Okay. In this case, that did not happen and according to this individual, that is the practice, by and large, in terms of households not getting-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

If it is less than four hours-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

-----we may not do a letter drop, but if it is any longer than that, we should. We would have to look at the particular circumstances.

Comment on this

I would appreciate it if Mr. Gleeson could look into the practice there and make sure there is consistency around the country because he will appreciate that when there is a planned outage and someone suddenly realises there is a disruption to supply-----

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

I understand where that is happening, it could be an error on our system. Getting that feedback is really vital then because we are able to look into it and correct our records and then realise that actual area is connected into this supply, so-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Again, we would encourage the Deputy's constituents to sign up to the tech system. It is simple. People put in their eircode and mobile number and they get texts related to any works that are going on.

Comment on this

I am on that myself. It is a busy text system.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I can imagine that.

Comment on this

There are a lot of texts coming in.

I have another two quick points, Chair, if I may, in relation to crews on the ground. I made this point the last time. I am aware of certain individuals working inhumane hours in terms of covering areas and responding to calls, breaks, disruptions and so on where there is nobody else to come out and deal with them. Uisce Éireann really is threadbare on the ground in terms of the workforce and individuals who will respond to these issues. It seems to be heavily reliant on a small number and that is something it has to address. I appreciate it is budgetary and all that in terms of additional staff, but it is an issue, and it is unfair to be relying on a small number who are continually responding.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I would not think we have budgetary restraints. Because of this transition, we may have shortfalls in crews in certain areas. Ms Attridge might comment on that issue.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

We have tried to stream our teams so we can provide specialist support to the front-line teams. There are specialised teams building that local knowledge so that they can have an impact and take some work away from local teams. If there is, for example, a pump fault in Carrigaline, the guys on the front line do not have to try to fix it themselves any more. They can call on the front-line team. If they have a process issue with a treatment plant, they can call on a specialist team to provide support. They do not have to be able to fix everything.

We are getting there. We are improving. We know we have a lot to do. It was such a busy summer for a lot of the front-line work.

Comment on this

Yes, it was. The local knowledge is critical. Bringing in others is fine but local knowledge is important. That is why the individual who serves an area is very often essential.

On communication with us as public representatives, there has been some improvement, to be fair. You will always get replies and so on, but it is the effectiveness or quality of some of those replies that is an issue. The replies do not always give you the information you need. There is still more work to be done in that regard. We have in the past raised the need for dedicated people to whom we can go as public representatives. We could build up a certain relationship with them and establish familiarity. That would be a good model. Perhaps the witnesses would consider that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We have taken that feedback. I have looked at the responses and some of them are generic. We are going to try to improve the quality of the responses. We are looking at some kind of regional team that would facilitate Oireachtas Members. We are bringing that to our board this month, and I hope we will get something to the Minister in the next couple of months. That will be something that Members could critique.

Comment on this

That would be good. I appreciate that. I am sorry for holding everyone up.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That concludes our engagement for today. I thank the chief executive officer from Uisce Éireann and his officials for attending. I also thank the officials from the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage and those from the C and AG's office for their attendance. Is it agreed that the clerk to the committee will seek any follow-up information and carry out any agreed actions arising from the meeting? Agreed.

The committee will next meet on Thursday, 22 October 2026, with officials from the Department of Social Protection.

Comment on this