Gnó an Choiste - Business of Committee
The committee agreed to seek updates or further information on delayed financial statements, school-building audits, the National Museum redevelopment, NTA ticketing resources, IPAS contract litigation, Irish Rail’s train-management system, health-insurance recoveries and University of Limerick’s vacant property. Members raised concerns about RTÉ funding and recruitment, and agreed to follow up on executive pay and bonuses at Uisce Éireann, the children’s hospital schedule, alleged fraud at an education and training board, and public e-bikes being taken out of service. Next week’s agenda includes Greyhound Racing Ireland’s 2025 financial statements and officials from the Department of Agriculture.
I welcome everyone to today's meeting. Apologies have been received from Deputy Geoghegan.
Before we proceed, I will go through a few housekeeping matters. Members are reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 226 that the committee shall refrain from enquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government, a Minister of the Government, or the merits of the objectives of such policies. Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. I also remind members of the constitutional requirements that in order to participate in public meetings members must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex or precincts.
The agenda for today's public session is as follows: minutes, correspondence and upcoming meetings. We will then suspend and begin the engagement with officials from the Department of Education and Youth at 10.30 a.m. The minutes of the meetings of 15 and 22 October 2026 have been agreed and will be published on the committee's webpage.
No sets of accounts and financial statements have been laid since our previous meeting. I am informed that this is due to an issue with the IT system within the Oireachtas that has been going on for the past two weeks, which is particularly unfortunate. My understanding is that there is no resolution in sight.
That is tying the hands of the office of the C and AG and, in turn, tying the hands of this committee with regard to its ability to see what accounts have been presented. I propose we write to the Houses of the Oireachtas Service to get further information on this issue that is affecting this critical piece of work, to get a briefing note on what exactly is going on and, more importantly, when this issue will be resolved. Is that agreed? Agreed.
We will move to correspondence. There are a number of B items of correspondence to consider today. These have been received from Departments and public bodies.
No. R2026/0530 is correspondence, dated 16 October 2026, from the Secretary General at the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport, regarding the cell broadcast public warning system. Is it agreed to note and publish this item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0532 is correspondence, dated 16 October 2026, received from the Secretary General at the Department of Education and Youth, regarding the planning and building unit overview 2026. I have flagged this for discussion. There is a lot of critical information missing from this overview. Indeed, members cited a number of individual school buildings projects caught at different stages of development within their constituencies. It does not touch on any of those or what process is used to determine what school project should proceed, or any of those details. There are also follow-up questions. When we had the Department in previously, we were told that a condition audit being carried out on the school stock was ongoing. I propose we write to get an update on that critical and long-overdue piece of work to see where it is at and ask that we be furnished with the findings and full report. Is that agreed? Agreed. Is it agreed to note and publish the item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0533 is correspondence, dated 16 October 2026, received from the National Treasury Management Agency, NTMA, providing additional information including information on selected Ireland Strategic Investment Fund investments and the operation of prize bonds by the funding and debt management unit within the NTMA. That has been flagged by Deputy Murphy and me. I am happy to move on. Is it agreed to note and publish this item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0534 is correspondence received from RTÉ regarding League of Ireland negotiations. Is it agreed to note and publish the item subject to the redaction of any personal information? Agreed.
No. R2026/0535 is correspondence, dated 19 October 2026, received from the Chairperson of the Office of Public Works providing an update on the redevelopment of the National Museum of Ireland and the National Museum. Deputy McAuliffe has flagged this item. Does he wish to speak to it?
Comment on this
In private session, I suggested we write to the National Museum to ask for a more detailed breakdown of the overall more-than €3 million figure, but in particular the €1.3 million for investigative works and upfront design costs.
Comment on this
I agree. The correspondence does not get into specific information. There were issues previously with a stairwell within the premises, which is a fairly old premises. It has been said that additional work is needed. I am concerned that the museum has been closed since 2024. On the current expected timeframe, it is going to remain closed for up to ten years. We do not have an overall final cost. A sum of €3.6 million has been spent on the enabling and storage costs. This is an issue. I have concerns given the OPW is overseeing this and there is a potential for overspend and runaway costs. We need further sight of the expenditure to date and a more comprehensive breakdown as to the timeline. Having such an important museum closed until the early 2030s is quite concerning, while acknowledging that it does need work. We need a comprehensive breakdown. Is it agreed to note and publish this item, and write asking for further information? Agreed.
No. R2026/0536 is correspondence, dated 19 October 2026, received from the CEO of the National Transport Authority regarding the next generation ticketing project. I flagged this item for discussion. It goes into some detail on the identified resource constraints with regard to bringing forward this critical piece of work, namely, the next generation ticketing. However, it does not get into the specifics as to what the resource constraints are. They say they have been addressed but it is important we get an understanding as to what those constraints were. The correspondence states it will have no impact on the overall timeframe for the implementation or progression of this project, but we need more clarity on that. We also need more clarity on what the resolution is. Does it involves more outside bodies or consultants? We know how that ended up with the train management system, where there was an over-reliance on external additional resources. We know about the catastrophic failures to which that led. We need a clearer line of sight as to what additional resources have been put in. Are they in-house? Are they external? We need an overall comprehensive breakdown on that.
Comment on this
The end of the letter states that if any further details or clarifications are required to let the CEO know. We need to remind her we want a quarterly report on this. We should also tell the NTA that if this overall project status moves from green to amber or red, they should immediately notify us and give us details as to why the RAG status of the project has moved.
Comment on this
Is it agreed to follow that course of action? Is it agreed to note and publish the item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0538 is correspondence, dated 20 October 2026, received from the Secretary General at the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration regarding further details and ongoing legal proceedings relating to IPAS accommodation contracts. I have flagged this item for discussion. It is an issue we have touched on previously with regard to the pre-contract agreements and the litigation cases that had been taken by a number of parties. I think three of those have been concluded. We have not been given any specific figures. We know from the C and AG's report that there is a figure including these settlements and other issues totalling about €30 million. The Department points out that the overall value of these contracts was in the region of €100 million meaning, in essence, that was a saving for the State. However, again, this highlights serious failures that allowed pre-contract agreements to be put in place that exposed the taxpayer. We know there are still two more cases that are being discussed. Quite worryingly, there is another case now being taken by a prospective provider that has been initiated by them. That is quite concerning if it is a test case because we know there are many other providers there that did not have pre-contract agreements or arrangements in place. It is quite concerning that the taxpayer has been exposed to such high levels of financial litigation. We need to follow up on this and get further information. I also question the rationale for not giving the committee a full breakdown of the awards that have been made. We have a rough idea of the value of those. Suffice it to say, there are two other cases there. We need further information. Is it agreed to write back to get further information and to note and publish this item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0539 is correspondence, dated 20 October 2026, received from the chief executive, NTMA, regarding NewERA's ongoing engagement with RTÉ.
Is it agreed to note and publish? Agreed.
No. R2026/0540 is correspondence received from Maynooth University, regarding the president's accommodation at Maynooth University, dated 19 October 2026. We had a general discussion around this correspondence from Maynooth University. They have asked that the item would be subject to redactions. That is being questioned by members of the committee. It has been agreed that we write back to Maynooth University because there is a strong view held by committee members is that there is no sensitive or private information contained in that correspondence that would preclude it from being published. Unless any other members have any questions or points to raise, is it agreed that we write back to Maynooth University? Agreed.
No. R2026/0541 is correspondence received from the Secretary General at the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport, which is a response to requests for further information regarding the sports capital and related funding awarded to Longford Town Football Club and the Football Association of Ireland, dated 22 October 2026. Is it agreed to note and publish the item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0542 is correspondence received, dated 19 October 2026, from the chief executive officer at the Private Security Authority providing further information on the discovery in 2025 of fraudulent documentation in individual licence applications made to the authority. This has been flagged by Deputy Murphy. Does Deputy Bennet want to speak on that or we can defer it until next week?
Comment on this
If we can defer it, then that is fine.
Comment on this
We will defer this until next week when Deputy Murphy is here.
R2026/0543 is correspondence received from the CEO of the Mater Hospital regarding the hospital and private health insurers, dated 19 October 2026. That was flagged by me. This follows on from a line of questioning we had. It is also relevant to other correspondence we received from Children's Health Ireland, CHI. I may come back to it when we are dealing with the CHI correspondence because it gives us information with regard to a company that has been engaged to try get the some of the money back. The correspondence from the Mater Hospital states that this contract only started in March of this year, I believe. CHI get into more comprehensive information with regard to it so I will come back to that. Is it agreed to note and publish this item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0544 is correspondence dated 23 October received from the CEO of Bord Bia regarding non-compliant procurement. Is it agreed to note and publish this item? Agreed.
No. R2026/0545 is correspondence dated 23 October 2026, received from the CEO of Iarnród Éireann in response to the committee's request for further information. This has been flagged by me. I note that the 13-week termination process of the contract with Indra has now expired. Iarnród Éireann is saying it will not give us any further information at this point. Again, it is quite concerning that this appears to be heading down the legal route. It is something that we have to keep on top of. There is certainly more information that we need, particularly with regard to the train management system that was due to be put in place for the Cork line. The timeframe will not be met and in line with what was supposed to be in place by July next year. There will be financial considerations and penalties. The Iarnród Éireann CEO does not get into those issues. We need to write back and get further information. She says they are looking at the issue and they hope to have something in place but I do not think it is going to be in place until 2028, which is what she is saying in that. It is quite concerning and we need further information as to what are the potential fines and financial considerations. We need to get sight of that. Do any other members want to comment?
Comment on this
Irish Rail officials appeared before the transport committee recently. It transpired that they have also investigated the Indra issue internally and a third party is conducting a report on behalf of Iarnród Éireann as well as the NTA, which has instructed a third party. It is important that this committee sees that report. It is very important that any such reports are shared generally in terms of lessons learned. I just wanted my colleagues to know about that report.
Comment on this
There is one other issue I wanted to touch on . It has been indicated that a direct contract is going to be awarded to Siemens to bring forward a train management system. As a committee, we need to get further information on the cost of that contract, if it has been awarded, or what stage it is at. This will potentially be further costs on top of the €50 million that has been written off. We need a full line of sight on that. Is it agreed to note and publish this item of correspondence? Agreed.
No. R2026/0546 is correspondence dated 20 October 2026 received from the chief executive officer at CHI regarding private health insurers. Again, this has been flagged by me for discussion. I touched on the issue relating to correspondence from the Mater Hospital. CHI actually gets into more specific detail with regard to agencies that have been contracted to chase down some of the outstanding money from the private health insurers. Similar to the Mater, it has engaged with Dunraven Health Services, which provides assistance in the clinical appeal of unpaid health insurance claims referred by CHI. The CEO states that Dunraven Health Services charge 24% of whatever they take in, exclusive of VAT, which is a value of the incremental success reclaim. She gives a breakdown over 2024 and 2025. In 2024, CHI got €133,626, VAT inclusive. In 2025, it was €129,733. The Mater Hospital says that the contract was only awarded in March of this year and no invoices have been served yet. It is quite concerning that almost one quarter, or 24%, of the money that should be forthcoming, in this case to CHI, is going to a private entity for collecting the money that we should be getting. Again, the private sector is benefiting by chasing down money the private sector should be paying to the State. We need to get further clarity and more information on this right across the board. We have information with regard to the Mater Hospital but we need to get a complete overview of the health service, for all hospitals, on how much money is being paid to Dunraven Health Services, if it has been contracted for all hospitals across the State and if this is a general HSE contract. We need to follow up on this and it is of concern to the State at the very least. Do members wish to comment? No. Is it agreed to note and publish this item? Agreed.
R2026/0548 is correspondence received from the president of the University of Limerick regarding UL Student Life and the university's property at Honan's Quay dated 19 October 2026.
That has been flagged by myself in respect of the issue of the Dunnes Stores site, on which members of the previous committee had extensive engagement with UL. It is explicitly stated here that in respect of the site they paid €8 million for, with no proper valuation or due diligence being carried out, there is no intention of doing anything with that site, which largely remains vacant. It is quite concerning that an asset of such value is just lying there in the centre of Limerick. It calls into question the rationale for purchasing this site back in 2019. I had proposed previously that the committee consider bringing in UL. In the first instance, we need to write back and get more specific information with regard to the property on Honan's Quay, the former Dunnes Stores site, and we should ultimately look at bringing UL back in again. Is it agreed to note and publish the item with the suggested redactions with regard to student life? Agreed.
No. 0549 is correspondence received from the Secretary General at the Department of further education regarding the My SUSI ICT project; Aruba Erasmus and trip; higher education funding; and Carlow College, dated 27 October 2026. This has been flagged by Deputy Paul Murphy and myself. I am happy to defer it until next week in Deputy Murphy's absence.
No. 0550 is correspondence received from RTÉ regarding the agreement between the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport and RTÉ Radio on the implementation of its reform strategy, dated 28 October 2026. That has been flagged by myself. Does Deputy Bennett wish to speak on it?
Comment on this
I found this letter quite interesting. There are lots of key achievements and deliverables within the document. I am wondering if it is all fact or fiction. Has the Department of public expenditure or anybody investigated that anything happens? How do we know the reality? Does the Department of public expenditure conduct any stewardship in relation to the public finances that are being given here? With everything I have been hearing about RTÉ - yesterday we heard about Ger Gilroy, who was headhunted and given a salary of €191,000 and a wardrobe allowance of €5,000. Within RTÉ, does the Department of public expenditure or any Department go in and investigate? This is just an email. I would like to know if all the deliverables and key achievements are actually happening that are noted within the document. Do we just take that at face value? The Comptroller and Auditor General might shed some light on this.
Comment on this
I would say that it is probably for the Department of media in the first instance to question and follow up with RTÉ in relation to that. There is also the role of NewERA which will be looking at the finances of RTÉ. I am limited in what I can say about RTÉ until I become the auditor.
Comment on this
Why has that not happened yet? I thought it was in line to happen.
Comment on this
It is still not enacted. Does the Comptroller and Auditor General believe that the Department of public expenditure or any other Department goes in to investigate what the key achievements and deliveries are here?
Comment on this
No, I would not expect the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation to be down at that level of detail. Obviously the Department of communications would have a role.
Comment on this
No, I would not expect them to be going onsite.
Comment on this
I think they would be looking for assurance. I would imagine that NewERA would be looking into the detail, but not necessarily into the detail of an individual employee's contract.
Comment on this
That correspondence also includes the letter from the former Minister to the most senior level of management in RTÉ, which was a question many of us had after the 2027 budget allocation, reported to be €20 million less than what had been committed to. The letter shows very clearly, in black and white, that the former Minister had made that level of commitment via TV licence receipts and Exchequer funding. The question that naturally follows is how it is possible for a Department to renege on a level of funding already committed to, without anything being stated in that letter with regard to performance, outputs, outcomes or anything. It is a very clear black-and-white statement that this is what RTÉ would be provided with in 2025, 2026 and 2027, with no performance targets attached other than to continue to implement the strategic plan. A further query to the Department on the timeline of how that decision was made would be helpful. It is very clear that we want RTÉ to be able to plan in a multi-annual way. The confidence is probably shattered from that. Any further commitments now will be undermined by the fact that this one was withdrawn or certainly not adhered to. How can the Department renege on its own commitment? In the letter, it did not ask for any sort of performance-related achievements. There are questions to be asked about that in itself. Who was responsible for that and how? Ultimately, what is the outcome? Are we back to €260 million a year for 2027? Can that be confirmed? As TV licence receipts continue to fall, what is the next iteration of that two to three-year plan looking like for RTÉ?
Comment on this
Just to note we will have RTÉ and the Department in with us in a number of weeks, and members will have an opportunity to question all of that. I have similar concerns. It is apparent that there was no formal agreement linking the funding of €725 million over three years to any of the reforms within RTÉ. That is quite concerning. The only thing we have here is an email from the former Minister. Ultimately, it has led to the bizarre chain of events following on from budget 2027, when €20 million was going to be withheld and then quickly in the days afterwards it was quite clear that the money was going to be paid. It is unfortunate and has caused huge issues, not just in terms of the public view of RTÉ but also within the organisation itself. It is tying up the work of this committee. The enabling legislation is on Report Stage. The sooner that comes into effect the better, to ensure that the Comptroller and Auditor General can get under the bonnet of the finances within RTÉ.
Comment on this
On the legislation that is coming in, will it be enacted for all semi-State bodies?
Comment on this
Why would it not be right across the board when all these organisations are getting huge amounts of Government funding?
Comment on this
It is essentially a broadcasting (amendment) Bill. It will affect RTÉ and will actually also affect TG4, which should not be overlooked. There are other significant elements to that legislation apart from me being made the auditor of RTÉ.
Comment on this
RTÉ is not subject to the Committee of Public Accounts at present but it has been co-operating any time we have written to it. I think that is correct to say. Based on the session yesterday, there are certainly some unanswered questions around staffing arrangements and so on. The Ger Gilroy issue has been well aired. If they are due to come in to us in the coming weeks, it might be appropriate for us to look for additional information in advance in respect of that appointment, asking for the process that was followed to be set out very clearly. There are serious question marks about the staff reduction programme.
I think 68 members of staff took the first voluntary scheme. There were a further 30 positions suppressed, I think, but as we know, RTÉ needs to achieve just over 300 reductions over the coming years, which will prove very difficult. The key question that needs to be asked in light of the Ger Gilroy issue is how many other positions were recruited for over the last 12 months, say, within RTÉ. This one has been in the public domain but are there other examples of people recruited from outside RTÉ? That is a key question that needs to be asked.
Comment on this
Apologies, Chair. I am not trying to come in twice. I looked at the transcript of the last conversation between RTÉ and us specifically about recruitment. The way in which those questions were answered spoke so heavily about transparent expressions of interest and on some of the main recruitment that was not stuck to at all. That transcript was really interesting because it is at complete odds with what has come out in the last couple of days. If that is the way organisations are approaching their appearances here, I would be concerned.
Comment on this
Yes. I think I had a direct line of questioning in the transcript regarding how RTÉ does appointments, so it would be interesting. Deputy Farrelly obviously knows. He matched one against the other.
Comment on this
We will have RTÉ in and if there are questions members want to flag in advance with its officials to get information that will help the meeting run more smoothly and answer some questions in advance, members should send them to the clerk and we will ensure they are sent over. Is it agreed to note and publish this item with redactions of personal details? Agreed.
No. 0551, dated 28 October 2026, is correspondence received from the chairperson of the OPW regarding its event infrastructure framework. Is it agreed to note and publish this item? Agreed.
That concludes the B items for this meeting.
Next week the committee will examine the financial statements for 2025 of Greyhound Racing Ireland. We will also have officials here from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, who will attend in a representative capacity.
Are there items members wish to raise under any other business?
Comment on this
Two weeks ago at this committee, I asked about the committee that reviewed the posts with Uisce Éireann leading to the CEO getting a huge increase in his salary. We still have not received any correspondence on that senior post remuneration committee. I would like to write to it again. I asked at the time who is on the committee but I would also like to ask additional questions of all the organisations under its remit and if everybody got increases. The document is available for everybody to look at online. It sets out all the organisations the committee was assessing at the time. I would be interested to see whether all those organisations' CEOs received increases in their remuneration. I am sure most of them did because if one got it, I am sure they all got it. Within that we have Coillte, Horse Racing Ireland, the National Stud, EirGrid, the ESB, the Land Development Agency, RTÉ and DAA. A lot of different organisations were in that review and I would like to know how much the CEOs of each of those organisations got on foot of that review document. I would like the committee to write again to ask when that letter will be received.
I highlight again Niall Gleeson's huge salary, to which he received an increase of €118,000. I saw today the Environmental Protection Agency has released its statistics for the year. As I said at the time, Niall Gleeson is supposed to be doing an amazing job but here we are again with the EPA saying raw sewage has been discharged every day in 11 counties and villages around the country. Some 55% of wastewater treatment plants discharged wastewater that failed to meet the standards aimed at preventing pollution and protecting our environment. Wastewater in 13 towns and cities failed to meet EU standards. What does that say about Uisce Éireann, the work it is doing and its performance? I would like us to write to Uisce Éireann again and to Niall Gleeson to ask him why this is happening on this watch.
Comment on this
I agree with that.
On the children's hospital, we are due to get periodic updates. I had a quick word with the clerk earlier. I do not think we have an update to hand at present. I ask that we seek that update because the completion date of the hospital is becoming less clear by the day. It is appropriate that we specifically ask for a full written update from the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board and Children's Health Ireland on the hospital. We could agree to do that.
Comment on this
Yes.
I have a couple of items of my own. To follow up on Uisce Éireann, the report from the Environmental Protection Agency is quite concerning. You can put that side by side with the bonuses not just for Niall Gleeson, who got an extraordinarily massive pay hike, but also the fact that 95% of the staff in Uisce Éireann received bonuses despite having received a damning report from the EPA. It is an issue we are going to follow up on with Uisce Éireann. I certainly have specific questions about the different scales of bonuses paid to all staff within the organisation. They seem to be tiered such that the higher you are within the organisation, the higher percentage bonus you get. It is obviously linked to salary but we need additional information. It is concerning that there could be such a damning report as this and, at the same time, 95% of the staff within the organisation received bonuses.
I have a couple of other issues. I saw a report relating to the Mayo, Sligo and Leitrim Education and Training Board. Serious theft and fraud offences have been carried out within the organisation going back over a number of years. I propose that we write to the ETB to get further information on those offences.
The other issue I wish to raise is that public e-bikes, to the value of €1 million, are being taken off the road only a number of months after they were first put out. It is being suggested they are going to be put into storage by the NTA. We know the situation with the NTA and electric buses in storage, and the huge ongoing costs of that. We need further information on the e-bikes worth €1 million. Are they being put in the same storage as the electric buses? This beggars belief. I cannot fathom e-bikes worth €1 million being taken off the road and put into storage just months after they were put on the road. It is extraordinary and again raises serious concerns about forward planning within the NTA. I propose that we write to the authority to get a full explanation because, again, there is a serious concern regarding waste in the organisation and a failure to plan properly. Unless there are other matters members wish to raise under any other business, we will suspend the sitting.