We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

School Transport and Special Education: Discussion

Summary

School transport cost €479 million in 2025, with the Comptroller and Auditor General attributing the overspend to underfunded estimates and calling for clearer reporting of special-education spending. The Department said rising demand, particularly for pupils with special educational needs, drove costs, and that the structural funding shortfall had been addressed; it is implementing a review intended to expand access and improve integration with public transport. Members raised concerns about eligibility rules, unused seats, poor communication and delays in special-needs support, while the Department cited substantial growth in special classes, staff and school places. Ticket charges are due to return to 2021–22 levels for 2027–28, while most costs remain publicly subsidised.

Contributions 1–197 of 604. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

This morning we will engage with the Department of Education and Youth. The agenda of the meeting is to discuss the provision of school transport and special education. On behalf of the committee, from the Department of Education and Youth, I welcome Ms Bernie McNally, the Secretary General, Mr. Hubert Loftus, Ms Martina Manion, Mr. DaltonTatton and Mr. Martin Clohessy, who are assistant secretaries general and Ms Barbara Mulhall, principal officer. We are also joined by officials from Bus Éireann, Ms Jean O’Sullivan, chief executive officer, Ms Miriam Flynn, chief school officer, and Mr. Tom Delaney, chief financial officer. Mr. Eamonn Murtagh, assistant secretary general from the Department of Transport is also attending in a representative capacity.

We are joined by officials from the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General including Mr. Seamus McCarthy, Comptroller and Auditor General, who is a permanent witness to the Committee, and Mr. Shane Carton, deputy director of audit. They are all very welcome.

Before we begin, I wish to explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards references you may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected, pursuant to both the Constitution and statute, by absolute privilege. This means that they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege, and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Witnesses are also reminded of the longstanding parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity, by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity.

I will now call on the Comptroller and Auditor General to deliver his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

The Department of Education and Youth funds the provision of transport services to and from primary and post-primary schools for children who live beyond a set distance from the nearest school that is suitable to their needs. The Department also funds the provision of school transport for children with special educational needs and for children from Ukraine or living in international protection accommodation centres.

Bus Éireann manages the delivery of school transport services on behalf of the Department. The related functions undertaken by the company include planning and scheduling of transport routes, subcontracting private operators, vetting drivers and monitoring contractor performance.

The cost to the Department of providing school transport services for around 181,000 pupils in 2025 was €479 million. This was down from €512 million spent in 2024. The original school transport subhead provision in the Vote 26 estimate for 2025 was €383 million. The outturn of €479 million was 25% more than provided. The explanation for the overrun presented in the appropriation account was underfunding in the estimate relative to what was required to meet the demand for school transport under established access policies.

The unit cost of providing transport for over 24,000 pupils with special education needs was significantly higher than for mainstream services, due to the need for bespoke and sometimes individual transport arrangements.

The number of children within the schooling system with special educational needs has risen substantially over recent years. For the 2025-26 school year, over 30,500 students with more complex needs are enrolled in special schools, or in special classes within mainstream schools, an increase of around 70% since 2020.

Meeting the increased demand for special education services has necessitated opening new special schools, growing the number of special classes in mainstream schools, and increasing the numbers of special education teachers and special needs assistants.

Subhead A.6 provides for payments of salaries, wages and allowances of special needs assistants in primary and post-primary schools. The estimate provision for 2025 was €915 million. The outturn was €1,051 million which was an overrun of 14.9%. The appropriation account explains that funding provision of €46 million intended for additional special needs assistants had incorrectly been allocated to other payroll subheads. A further €90 million of the overrun was attributed to funding underprovision.

Other costs associated with special education provision are currently spread throughout the Department’s Vote. There are plans to change the layout of Vote 26 in the future to allow for greater visibility of capital and current expenditure on special education.

A comparable issue of lack of transparency around funding for education and training boards was dealt with by inclusion in the annual appropriation account of an appendix listing such expenditure by subhead. A similar approach for special needs expenditure in the 2026 appropriation account could be a useful interim step pending reform of the Vote.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the Comptroller and Auditor General. I will now ask the Secretary General to deliver the opening statement on behalf of the Department of Education and Youth. As set out in the letter of invitation, Ms McNally has five minutes.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I thank the committee for the invitation to attend here today to discuss school transport and special education. I am joined by a number of colleagues at assistant secretary level who the Chair has introduced already and Barbara Mulhall, principal officer in the school transport unit. The Chair has also welcomed colleagues from the Department of Transport and Bus Éireann. I hope the briefing we provided in advance has been of assistance.

The Department is responsible for funding and setting the rules for the provision of a school transport scheme for eligible students. Bus Éireann manages the operation of that scheme on our behalf.

The Department's expenditure on school transport in 2025 was €479 million, which included a supplementary provision of €96 million. The supplementary budget was required to meet the demand forecast by the Department. The allocation for 2026 is €641 million, and the Department is on profile to live within that budget. Budget 2027 contains an allocation of €687 million. The Department is satisfied that the structural deficit that existed in recent years has been addressed. We will continue to work closely with the Department of public expenditure and reform to monitor the scheme's budget and performance.

Reduced fares were introduced as a temporary cost-of-living measure in recent years. As part of budget 2027, the Minister announced on 7 October that for the 2027-28 school year, ticket charges will be restored to 2021-22 levels. The cost of school transport is heavily subsidised by the State. With the restored ticket prices, 93% and 75% of the cost of the primary and post-primary school services, respectively, will continue to be met by the Exchequer. Very importantly, almost 46,000 children, over 25%, will access the service free of charge in 2027 due to having a significant special educational need or being in receipt of a medical card.

Committee members are very familiar with the 3.2 km and 4.8 km distance rules and the fact that students must attend their nearest school by language or ethos to be eligible. The rules are also clear that only after all eligible pupils are accommodated can non-eligible children be considered. Where services are not available, remote area grants are offered to eligible pupils.

Over 181,000 children, including 24,400 children with special educational needs, availed of the service in the last school year. Since 2020, there has been an increase of 58% in the number of students travelling on the scheme.

While successful for the vast majority of families eligible for it, the scheme faces significant challenges. These include the following. There are many non-eligible students and families wishing to avail of the service. A one-seat, one-ticket safety rule restricts the number of tickets issued. Under-utilisation of the service is a feature as many ticket holders do not use it on a full-time basis. Reliable and timely utilisation data is not currently available to support a policy change to this rule. There are substantial inflationary cost pressures, and we have experienced challenges in sourcing contractors and drivers. Full roll-out of the school transport review to enable a significant increase in the numbers of children accessing the service will rely on integration with public service transport. Technology improvements and other logistical, timing and funding challenges will have to be resolved. We are working intensively with stakeholders to build and safeguard services into the future, and implementation of the school transport review recommendations are well under way.

I turn now to special education and, more particularly, inclusive education, which is at the core of the Department's mission. Our education system is underpinned by a much-valued and committed workforce of teachers and special needs assistants, SNAs. In the 2027-28 school year, there will be approximately 52,000 special education teachers and SNAs ring-fenced in our schools to support children with special educational needs. Budget 2027 provides the largest ever funding allocation to special education of €3.8 billion. This will fund an additional 1,353 special education teachers in mainstream and specialist settings, bringing the total number of special education teachers to 24,000, the highest ever allocation, representing a 35% increase since 2020. Over 21,000 of these teachers will work in mainstream schools, ensuring that support is provided in the most inclusive setting possible. Funding for 2,339 additional SNAs was also provided for September 2027, increasing the total number of SNAs to over 28,000, an increase of 65% since 2020. Additionally, budget 2027 provided for extra professional learning and training, essential to ensure that staff can support the complex needs of children in our school system.

This year, the Department and the National Council for Special Education worked closely with all education stakeholders to deliver 587 new special classes, bringing the total to over 4,300, double what we had five years ago. Four new special schools are also being established in 2026.

The Department is committed to continuing to develop more inclusive practice and to be inspired by the leadership of school communities all across the country. The introduction of 70 inclusive special classes this year demonstrates this commitment.

Work to plan for the provision of special education places for the 2027-28 school year and beyond is well advanced.

I thank the Chairman and the committee again for the opportunity to attend here. I look forward, with my colleagues, to answering members' questions.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Ms McNally. I now ask the chief executive officer to deliver the opening statement on behalf of Bus Éireann. As set out in the letter of invitation, Ms O'Sullivan has five minutes.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I thank the Cathaoirleach and the members of the committee. I will not repeat a lot of what the Department has said because some of our opening statement is similar.

We welcome the opportunity to discuss school transport today and, particularly, the opportunity to outline the scale and governance arrangements supporting the scheme and, most importantly, to look ahead as to how we develop the scheme in partnership with the Department of Education and Youth.

As Ireland's national bus company, Bus Éireann operates the most extensive public transport network in the country, serving communities in every region. For over 57 years, we have operated the school transport scheme on behalf of the Department of Education and Youth, working in close partnership with the Department in support of its policy objectives and the provision of this really important national service.

The scale of school transport, as the Department has outlined, has been significant in recent years, particularly since 2020. The growth represents a significant and complex operational undertaking and highlights the need for enhanced supports around vetting, safety, effective planning and, most importantly, to ensure that the market has the readiness to be able to support the future growth. It will also require continuous investment in technology, fleet and new ways of working as well as introduction, potentially, of different administration opportunities, particularly around AI.

Our relationship is supported very much by well-established governance and accountability arrangements, including a clearly defined service level agreement, regular operational meetings to review performance and quarterly strategic meetings to consider longer term priorities and developments.

Bus Éireann directly operates 6% of the mainstream routes. In 2025 we worked with 1,448 contractors, which helped us deliver 11,241 routes. That is a significant undertaking in the number of routes we deliver daily. As part of that, we thank the contractors that support us. They are really the backbone of the delivery of school transport across the country. We really welcome their support and we engage with them regularly in order to be able to make sure that we can progress the system and support them in their delivery. We also support families through the application process and handle 42,000 calls and an additional 21,000 web chats from families availing of the scheme every year.

It is also important to note that we engage in structured planning, funding and forecasting processes. We provide the Department with an annual funding requirement in advance of the following year. Updated forecasts are also presented to our audit and risk committee and the Bus Éireann board.

Bus Éireann's statutory accounts and year-end financial reporting are independently audited, as are the accounting arrangements specific to the school transport scheme. Our procurement processes operate in accordance with the utilities directive and applicable procurement legislation, with tenders assessed against robust qualitative and financial criteria. This is essential as the scheme has grown now to the number of contractors we procure annually. These arrangements provide a strong framework for transparency, financial oversight and accountability as well as an important foundation on which we can continue to develop the governance and administration of the scheme.

Looking ahead, we fully support the ambition of the school transport 2030 review, which was published in 2024, to expand school transport provision, to streamline application processes and to progress more integrated transport solutions, in partnership with the National Transport Authority, in a safe and reliable manner. We believe that this is a significant opportunity to build on the experience, expertise and infrastructure that currently exist within Ireland's transport assets. We recognise that meeting future demand and expectations will require proactive planning, innovation and transformation, and we are delighted to be working in partnership with the Department of Education and Youth to progress those areas.

Sustainability is also a central part of our future development. Bus Éireann is committed to advocating for and supporting more sustainable school transport, including transition towards lower emission and zero-emission vehicles, contributing to the Government's wider climate action ambitions.

We believe that by combining the Department's policy direction and oversight with Bus Éireann's operational experience and delivery capability, we can work together to enhance the numbers accessing the school transport scheme to meet the needs of future generations and the growing population.

I would like to acknowledge the continued partnership with the Department of Education and Youth, along with our schools, the Department of Transport, the National Transport Authority, NTA, our private contractors and operators, including our own Bus Éireann employees and the many elected representatives who engage with the scheme on a daily basis. I also recognise the students and families for whom we provide transport - up to 181,000 pupils a day. We look forward to any questions that might be presented by members.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Ms O'Sullivan. We will suspend our meeting at about 12.30 p.m. for a 15-minute break and then we will resume shortly afterwards. The lead speaker today is Deputy Daly, who has 15 minutes. All other members have ten minutes. If time permits, on the conclusion of that we will allow members back in for a short round of supplementary questions. I note that our timers are down so I will indicate when members have one minute left to give people advance warning.

Comment on this

I thank all the witnesses for coming here today. I recognise the massive logistical operation it is to get 181,000 children and young people, including those with special and additional needs, to education. When we see that the State is investing 92% of the cost of getting young people to national school and 75% of the cost of getting people to second level, the figures are very considerable. They have grown from €220 million in 2020 to €512 million in 2024 and an estimated €640 million this year. These are significant sums of money. There are a lot of moving parts. The State has a right to know that the investment is being managed properly and that it is fit for purpose and carrying out the required function of getting young people to school, reducing the number of car journeys and ensuring that children with special and additional needs have access to mainstream and special education.

I am not an accountant, but one of the things that caught my eye here is that expenditure from 2020 until 2026 shows a huge variance in excess expenditure over projected expenditure in each of those years. There was a €96 million overspend in 2025, a €131 million overspend in 2024, a €99 million overspend in 2023 and a €69 million overspend in 2022. These are very significant overspends. I cannot really find an explanation for that type of variance.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I thank the Deputy for the question and for acknowledging the volume and complexity of the scheme. We are very clear that this is a demand-led scheme. None of the Deputies will have heard us say there are only enough places for 160,000 children and then there will be no more after that. It is a demand-led scheme and with that comes variation year on year. Each time in the Estimates we estimate the need for the next year and we negotiate with the Department of public expenditure and reform. Sometimes the Department of public expenditure and reform has questions as regards whether those numbers will truly materialise. On occasion, it may have said it is going to hold back and it is not necessarily going to give us everything that we have looked for but it will look at it again and see if the need materalised.

It is also important to say that over the years there has been a lot of spending that could not have been predicted. With Covid, a particular type of spending was required. With Ukraine, 18,000 children and young people arrived into the system. More than 6,000 of them needed school transport that we could not have planned for in late 2021 when we were looking at the 2022 budget, and again the next year. A lot of the growth in spending on the scheme is down to special education. We spend 60% of the budget for 13% of the children. While the average mainstream child costs about €1,480 for the year, on average, the cost for a child with special educational needs is €14,000. The growth in that area does justify a lot of the additional expenditure.

Comment on this

I can accept some of that but I would still say that we continue to blame Covid for a lot of things. In 2022, we were out of Covid. Let us park Covid. It is responsible for a lot of things but not for these types of estimates. I accept it is a demand-led scheme but, again, the variance seems to be very significant. If we are saying that 60% of the cost goes to 13% of pupils – I have no argument with that - the students have special and additional needs but in the review of the School Transport 2030 report, what emphasis has been given to look in detail at how children with special and additional needs are transported to school?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There has been a lot of work. One of the colleagues here-----

Comment on this

I am sorry to interrupt Ms McNally, but I was in Castlerea visiting a special school and we had children being transported from the south of Sligo, who are closer to a special school in Sligo. That demands planning between the Department of education, Bus Éireann and the other stakeholders. I wonder about how much detail the Department goes into on some of these costs.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Traditionally, children were travelling long distances because we did not have special classes and special schools in their local community but the Deputy will know that we have doubled the number of special classes since 2020 and we have 20 new special schools. Over time, children are going to be travelling much shorter journeys. Some of those children started in a special class a couple of years ago which was quite a distance away, and even though there are now special classes more locally, obviously they want to stay where they started and it is going to take a few years for some of those children to work through the system so that children are travelling shorter journeys. Eventually, that will save us money but we do respect that if a family and a child have made a connection with a school that is a wee bit further away, we are not going to pull them out of there. That is a little bit of it but that will change things profoundly. I am not sure if Deputy Daly saw the maps that were included in the briefing pack but we had to amend them because there were so many dots and some of the maps were all green, or whatever it was. There are now so many – 4,300 – special classes around the country that they are beginning to be in every community. They are not in every school yet but we are making specialist places more accessible.

Comment on this

Who decides? Who makes the assessment that a child needs to go by taxi, for example, rather than on a bus? I can understand that some children have to go by taxi with one-on-one supervision. Who makes that assessment? This is 60% of the budget.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The Department of education works with the National Council for Special Education. The special educational needs organisers have a role. They know the child's needs. They also know the local school. They then work with Bus Éireann, which has a duty in that regard. If there is a route or service that is available, we will put an extra child on that, wherever we can. Bus Éireann works very hard to avoid having a one-to-one situation. If there is a service there already, we will put more children on it but on a number of occasions there is not and we do provide one-to-one services as well.

Comment on this

I know that under the school travel scheme there is a prescribed distance from school for primary school and secondary school. I have a situation, for example, in my constituency in Ballinasloe, where there is significant deprivation, intergenerational unemployment and very significant social issues. That has been shown by Pobal and there have been other studies in regard to this. Does the Department look at situations where, for example, people have no access to cars in a community like that? Clonfert College is almost 2 km out the road. We have written to Local Link to see if it could provide a service. Teachers tell us that children are not going to school simply because they cannot get there and they cannot afford to get a private taxi.

Some of them are using a private taxi service. Is there any look at areas of special deprivation where there are extreme social circumstances, such as in Ballinasloe?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I think the Deputy is saying where children do not meet those distance criteria of 3.2 km and 4.8 km.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The school transport review we published in 2024 that we are implementing, and on which good progress has been made, looks to reduce the distance criteria. Now, it is for everybody at the moment.

Comment on this

I notice in the report there is a view to move towards integrating public transport with school transport. In that town in particular, starting at Creagh, which would be on the east side of the town, one Local Link bus at 8 a.m. linking up to Clonfert College and coming back at 4 p.m. would solve that problem. We can get no one to engage with us on that issue. It is a serious issue because there are children who are already starting behind the curve, who do not start school until they are six, do not go to preschool because of their circumstances and go to school hungry. All the stories are there from all the social enterprises. The data is there. We have it, if the Secretary General needs it.

That would also solve other problems because there is a capacity issue in that town in terms of national school places. You have children now who cannot get from Creagh - these are children with resources - and have to get into Ballinasloe town to go to Clontuskert, which is five miles outside the town. I am just suggesting simple solutions but we cannot get anyone to engage anywhere.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

What the Deputy is saying is very reasonable. Our Ministers and Ministers with responsibility for transport have talked about the absolute need for us to do more work in this regard on integration. We have some integration pilot schemes already happening. What the Deputy suggests about maybe looking at areas of particular disadvantage for prioritisation around more pilot schemes to look at issues like that is something we can look at doing. We have a small amount of money in budget 2027 for further pilots and that work with the Department of Transport and Local Link. We are committed to advancing that.

Comment on this

The other issue, and I think I speak for many public representatives on this, is that in August and September our phones were hopping. Many of the issues around tickets were resolved eventually, but I have one case where someone with the resources measured their distance to the school and had a dispute with Bus Éireann over the measuring. Bus Éireann was including a loop beyond their house in the country and that put them outside, so that it was Roscommon-Strokestown. I could get no engagement as a public representative with Bus Éireann and made phone calls. Eventually, my secretary was told that the person who dealt with them was on holidays in August, which they are well-entitled to, but an organisation that size should have had someone covering it at such a critical time of the year. He is in an appeal process three months down the road. He is a person with resources. How would it be for someone who does not have resources who is not enabled to deal with such a system that does not respond to their needs?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Bus Éireann is here and might want to speak to this. I know that they try very hard. They are very committed to responding to customers. They have a call centre to try and deal with volumes of calls. On that route measurement, Bus Éireann tries to take a practical and fair approach.

Comment on this

But we need communication. Communication is required there. That is the point I am making. I am not trying to in any way pre-empt the outcome of that appeal, and it is going to an appeal, but communication would be important for such a simple issue.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The CEO of Bus Éireann is here. Ms O'Sullivan might-----

Comment on this

Sorry, I will direct that question to the CEO then. I apologise.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

Apologies, if that has been the situation for this particular family. We use geographic information system, GIS, mapping, which comes from a standard process that we use right across Government in terms of measuring the routes to and from school - from the home of the individual to the school - and if there is an appeal in relation to that.

The one thing I would say about the school transport team is that it is very seldom that any of them take holidays in the summer period. They are so committed. One of the things I found fascinating when I joined Bus Éireann is that school transport members do not take summer holidays. I am surprised that there was somebody on leave, but I totally accept the fact that the communication in that particular case has failed. We understand that the volume of queries that come in on the customer piece come in in the summer when we are trying to also build out the routes and the mapping. It is unfortunate they overlap at the same time. If the Deputy wants to give me and Ms Flynn, the chief schools officer, the details, we will look into it individually.

Comment on this

I thank Ms O'Sullivan for her answer.

In relation to special education, I pay tribute to the Department and to Deputy Michael Moynihan, the Minister of State for special education, for the huge amount of work that has been done to expand special education places in mainstream schools, in particular, but also in special schools. Of course, we have a lot to do yet. Is there a difficulty around flexibility of special needs assistants, SNAs? We have more SNAs than ever in the system, yet we have situations emerging where there is a lack of responsiveness to individual schools which have defined needs or changing needs that are backed up by their special educational needs organisers, SENOs, in those areas. Is there an issue around that? The point I am trying to make is that different schools have changing needs for SNAs. That is the way I would put it. If that need changes and that resource is not required any more, can the resource of an SNA be moved to a school where that resource is required?

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Apologies, the Deputy has less than a minute left.

Comment on this

That is my last question so.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will answer that question. Briefly, the system is built to have some flexibility in it. Schools can contact the National Council for Special Education, NCSE, and ask for a review. At the moment, there are approximately 130 schools which have asked for a review. The fact others have not might suggest that they might be - I am not saying they are - doing okay. When they request a review, the NCSE can go out to look and see if more is needed and there is a resource. We have a resource available to look where there is particular need.

Comment on this

I accept that. I want to make this point. St. Ronan's school, in Taughmaconnell, in County Roscommon, which has 109 children, five mainstream teachers, 1.7 special education teachers, six level 3 students and nine level 2 students, put in an application, supported by the SENO, last May for additional SNA support. Eventually, it got declined in August. They are appealing now with the NCSE. They still have not got an answer. They were promised an answer last week. They have children with flight risk. They have had a changing need. It is well demonstrated. They are struggling. We have special education teachers, SETs, covering SNA lunches, and that becomes an issue if there are courses that they have to attend. I really would like to make that point about St. Ronan's in Taughmaconnell in Ballinasloe.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We will take that case up with the NCSE to see where it is. There are almost 26,000 SNAs now across the system. Clearly, a SENO went out there and may have believed. SENOs themselves are former teachers. Some of them are therapists. Some of them might be very experienced SNAs. When they go out, they try to look objectively at whether the resource that is there is being used to best effect, but we will bring that case back to them.

Comment on this

I also accept that the Ministers involved have increased the SNA numbers to the highest level ever, that there is the highest level of special education teachers ever and there are expanding places. We have to say that an awful lot has been done and huge investment has been made. I thank the Secretary General.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I thank the Deputy for acknowledging the Ministers' roles.

Comment on this

I welcome everybody in today and thank them for coming before us in the public accounts committee.

It is disturbing when I hear that some children are not eligible for school transport. The Department's mission statement is "to ensure that all children and young people have access to a positive learning experience and to facilitate them, through learning to realise their .. potential and contribute to Ireland’s social, economic ... development." As part of this, the Department funds the provision of services to and from post-primary schools for children who live a distance from their nearest school. I believe it is the Department's job to ensure children get to school. It is awful to say "children that need to get education". All children need to get an education. How could there be any ineligible students, especially in rural communities? Where I come from, we do not have a public bus system. We do not live in a city where there is public transportation. That does not happen. It is disheartening.

Maybe I will start with Ms O'Sullivan, who is very welcome here today. I refer to one of the recommendations from the published document on the school transport scheme. That document went out, I suppose, from Ms McNally's Department in 2019. There was a review asked for at that time and it did not commence until 2021.

I know Ms McNally was not there at the time. It was finally published in February 2024. We are still seven years out from the review of the school transport scheme but everything within that school transport scheme has not been implemented as yet. As far as I am aware, the reduction in distances from 4.8 km has not happened. Maybe somebody can explain why.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Maybe I will answer those questions because I think both points the Deputy made are on the policy side, but if anyone from Bus Éireann wants to come in, they can do so. I will start with the Deputy's earlier comments about the non-eligible people. This is a scheme and while I talked earlier about it being demand led, it is demand led within a certain rule. There have to be rules to every scheme. Otherwise, we could not estimate costs in any manner. About 18% of children are using the scheme at the moment. Were we to make it available to everyone, it would either cost significantly more or we could integrate-----

Comment on this

There should be no cost for education. It should be a priority of the Department of education to ensure every child gets educated.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The school transport review, which we are introducing, looks at reducing the eligibility criteria, but it recognises that if we do that, we could see a massive increase. One of the pilots - Rochfortbridge - showed a 500% increase in demand because we reduced the distance criteria. That is not really affordable for the State, possibly, unless we do more on the integration. That is why we are working really hard on the integration.

From a policy perspective, it was a rural initiative initially. Those criteria of 3.2 km and 4.8 km were an initial part of the scheme.

Comment on this

I will go back to the review that said the Department was going to reduce it to 2 km. How does Ms McNally expect children 4.8 km away to get to school if they are in a rural community? Does she want them to walk along roads that are very dangerous because there are no footpaths or other infrastructure in place? I am just wondering what way the Department is thinking this out. Children need to get education.

I will come back to Ms McNally on another point. Every child should receive a school transport ticket. I do not understand at this stage of the game why there are not scanners on buses to see that if a child is not using the ticket, they do not need it. I hear all the time from people who have contacted me this year who could not get school transportation. In my eyes, there is a very easy solution to the problem. Scan the tickets and if children are not using them, then there are free seats on the buses. Buses are going to schools with loads of free seats on them, yet I am being told that the buses are full to capacity, which is not the situation. I am just wondering why nobody is scanning the tickets to see if the tickets are being used.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We all want a technology solution and we have piloted-----

Comment on this

Why has it not happened then? It has been seven years and-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We would like to be further on. We have piloted different mechanisms and there have been challenges with would-be solutions. However, we are advancing this. There is intensive work happening between the Department and Bus Éireann to progress this.

Regarding the capacity on buses, every seat on every bus has a child's name and a ticket associated with it-----

Comment on this

They are not on them.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

-----but we do not have the technology. We all know that in families, children are sick, doing football after school, etc. Therefore, there is never going to be 100% utilisation unless we change policy.

Comment on this

How does a parent who has applied for a ticket before the cut-off deadline and paid the money then get a letter just before September to say his or her child is not eligible for it?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will answer that from a policy perspective as well. We know that every child who is eligible for a mainstream ticket has got a ticket now. The children who have-----

Comment on this

I can tell Ms McNally they have not. I have emails on my phone. The parents of children had their money refunded and were told they were non-eligible even though they had applied before the deadline.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We allow non-eligible people to apply. Non-eligibles are allowed to apply and they pay, and if there is then a seat left on the bus after all the eligible children-----

Comment on this

How can any child be non-eligible?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It is because the scheme-----

Comment on this

I just do not get what the Department is saying. It has got-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The scheme has eligibility criteria. To be eligible, people must-----

Comment on this

I actually think it would go to a court of law that Ms McNally is saying children are not eligible for school bus tickets. They live in a rural community. They have no other way to get to school. Ms McNally is saying they are non-eligible. It just does not come home to me.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The scheme was created several decades ago. There are those distance criteria and children also must be going to their nearest school. If they meet those distance criteria, they are eligible. If they apply on time and pay on time, they get a ticket. We want to use every seat on the bus, so we encourage non-eligibles to also apply, but they will only get a seat if there are spaces left on the bus after the eligible children have been dealt with.

Comment on this

Whose bright idea was it last year to increase the tickets to double the amount they were the year before?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The Minister announced this year that tickets were going to go back to what-----

Comment on this

They went up last year as well.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Last year, they went up as well. I think that-----

Comment on this

Are they going to go up again?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Yes, that has been announced. That is going to be-----

Comment on this

They went from €50 to €100 and now they are going up to €200.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That is still, even with the higher amount-----

Comment on this

Will Ms McNally confirm that it is going to go up to €200 for a school bus ticket where children cannot get a school? Ms McNally cannot confirm to me that every child in the country is going to get a school bus ticket in a rural community, but the Department is increasing the prices by €200. Is that correct?

Comment on this

Every eligible child who applied-----

Comment on this

Is going to have their bus ticket increased to €200.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

-----has got a seat on the bus now. Every eligible child on the mainstream service who has applied and paid-----

Comment on this

How can the Department decipher between eligible and non-eligible? It is very unfair because there are people in rural communities who I believe are living beyond the distance of 4.8 km. They are eligible but the Department is saying that they are not. Is it a lottery system? How does the Department decipher if somebody is eligible or non-eligible?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The rules of the scheme are very clear. It is those distance criteria and it is the nearest school. However, the school transport review does propose that we change those rules, so we are working towards changing those eligibility-----

Comment on this

The school review has been going for seven years.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It was published in 2024 and we have about 40% of the actions in it completed.

Comment on this

However, it has been going on for seven years.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Yes. Since it was published in 2024, we have about 40% completed and we are on the way. We are progressing it.

Comment on this

Who made the decision that the bus tickets were going to increase to €200 next year? Is that what Ms McNally said?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There are different prices. There is €100-----

Comment on this

Who decided that?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That was a budgetary decision as part of budget 2027.

Comment on this

A budgetary decision through the Minister and the Department.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The Department. Ultimately, it was a whole-of-government decision.

Comment on this

Okay.

In relation to that, when Ms O'Sullivan came into her role in Bus Éireann, I understand her salary increased from €210,000. Is that correct?

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

This is the last minute, Deputy.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I thank the Deputy. I have worked in the public sector for 30 years, so I understand absolutely the scrutiny that comes to the public purse, particularly in relation to CEO salaries.

Comment on this

What is Ms O'Sullivan's salary working for Bus Éireann?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I applied for a role in Bus Éireann as CEO through a robust open competition, after which I was appointed to that salary of €260,000, and for transparency-----

Comment on this

However, the role before that was €210,000. Am I correct in saying that?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

The previous CEO's role was €210,000, which had been fixed for seven years.

Comment on this

Okay, but Bus Éireann actually sought to pay €280,000 to Ms O'Sullivan. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

It was €260,000.

Comment on this

However, Ms O'Sullivan wanted €280,000 at the start.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I have no idea about that.

Comment on this

Ms O'Sullivan does not. I find it amazing that, to get children to school to get their education, their bus tickets are going to be increased, but the CEO's salary went up, just in case Ms O'Sullivan does not know, from €210,000 to €260,000 when she came into the position. That is correct.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

Yes. That is the position I applied for.

Comment on this

Yet we cannot get children on school buses to school. It beggars belief. What is this Government at?

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Deputy Bennett. I call Deputy McAuliffe.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here today. I do not have too many questions on school transport, being a Dublin TD. I certainly do not get the same level of queries as some of my colleagues. However, as a member of my parliamentary party, I would reiterate that it is a consistent issue that appears each year. When something comes up like that at the same time each year for the same reason and so on, it points to a structural issue. Part of it is, as the witnesses said, the question of eligibility. I would point to the fact that there certainly are a lot of issues around communication. I think some of the frustration Deputy Daly had earlier speaks to that. I will leave it at that.

Obviously, we have children in special education availing of school transport. In my area, we have had a very significant expansion of the number of both special classes and special schools.

That has greatly assisted the reduction in the requirement for transport. Nobody wants to see their child sitting on a bus when they do not have to.

I want to speak to that issue of special education. When you look at the numbers in regard to the expansion, it has been very significant. A concern I have is that during any period of significant expansion, you always ask yourself whether value for money is being adhered to. The budget for the NCSE went from €20 million to €40 million between 2020 and 2025. The number of SNAs increased from 17,000 to 25,000. The number of special class teachers increased from 2,000 to 4,300. The number of students enrolled in special classes or special schools went from 18,000 to 31,000. There is no doubt that there has been a significantly increased level of service delivery.

My question relates to the construction projects that often come alongside that. What steps has the Department taken to ensure there is value for money in the provision of additional school buildings, specifically for special education? Principals relate to me that in year 1 or 2 of the emergency response to this, a lot more funds were available. This year, and maybe last year a little bit as well, there is much tighter scrutiny of the finances around additional accommodation for special education classes. How is the Department ensuring value for money, and what is the impact of that on service delivery?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I thank the Deputy and others for their recognition of the work the Minister, Deputy Naughton, and the Minister of State, Deputy Moynihan, have done to respond to need. The Deputy talked about the level of need and we know that it is expanding.

Zoning in on the building programme, the Deputy knows that we have €7.5 billion over five years, with €1.6 billion this year. We do a huge amount of activity to get value for money in that, honestly. I could spend a lot of time on that but I will not. We have about 26 frameworks in place. We follow procurement fairly ruthlessly but we also have frameworks so that we have different options. We target large, tier 1 and small and medium providers. We target a number of different contractors, etc., to be available to do the work.

In regard to value for money, we have everything pre-designed. We have technical specifications, layouts, etc., organised. We have very little change orders on our contracts because everything is designed upfront to minimise the amount of change that comes later. We research that and I can talk about that further. A huge amount of work has been done.

One of the big things we have had to do this year is utilise existing capacity. That €1.6 billion we have is a lot of money and as much as we all love it, we have had to reutilise existing capacity so we give the schools €30,000 in grants or €80,000 in grants.

Comment on this

Is that where the Department is asking schools to repurpose existing classrooms rather than the provision of-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Exactly. Where it is appropriate. We know that this year, for example, a couple of hundred schools have just taken the €30,000 grant. Another 240 or thereabouts have looked for the €80,000 grant to do refurbishment. Out of those 587 extra classes we have done this year, 500 are in existing accommodation with some grant assistance to make them work. Then there are about 87 where we have had to have new builds or modular.

Comment on this

For those new builds or modular, does the Department have a figure for a price per classroom that it is able to bring in?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We do, and my colleague Hubert can come in here. We have a very close idea of what we expect to pay.

Comment on this

Has that decreased over the last number of years?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask my colleague Hubert to come in on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I thank the Deputy for the question. In the wider sense, it is across the construction sector. The construction sector environment is challenging enough. We have been in periods of elevated inflation due to wider concerns. As our Secretary General has indicated, the vast bulk of our needs, whether it is special classes or the new special schools we have established, the focus and first port of call is to repurpose existing accommodation and maximise. That is the most efficient way to get timely delivery and it is also very cost-effective.

Comment on this

How much does a modular or external class cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

For a standard classroom, you are probably looking at around €370,000 excluding VAT as a base for the actual modular unit. Then you can have various scenarios. As for the additional site costs relating to that, it depends on the particular sites involved and all of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

That is around €370,000 for the actual unit.

Comment on this

It is €370,000 for the unit itself and then you have site costs. Could site costs be in the region of €100,000 or could they exceed the €300,000 figure for the unit itself?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

No, they would not exceed it. There would be a proportion of it as a percentage but that would vary depending on the particular sites involved.

Comment on this

What is the lifetime of some of those units?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We have a very strong emphasis on quality-----

Comment on this

I should call it a construction unit as opposed to a unit as a class. I know that is not the correct term.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Yes, and I call the modular "permanent accommodation" because that is what it is. It is just one of the variety of delivery mechanisms that we use. The lifespan we use with regard to assessing modular accommodation, no more than any other, is our standard, typical lifespan of 60 years but, obviously, with a good maintenance regime and a stronger emphasis on that as part of the national development plan, NDP, roll-out, that lifespan gets expanded-----

Comment on this

There has been discussion around the rental of modular accommodation. Am I correct in saying that, certainly in my constituency, the construction modular units that have been put in have largely been purchased as opposed to rented. Is the Department using rental of modular accommodation for the provision of special classes?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

The standard approach for us is to purchase modular accommodation. It is a permanent solution.

Comment on this

How many schools are using rental?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We are doing a rental review for the public accounts committee. It will probably be completed primarily by quarter 1 of 2027. In regard to rentals, when I look at the budget I have to manage - €1.6 billion - the rentals in any given year are about 2% of that, and that is a static or falling figure. It is more a legacy of the past rather than where we are for the future.

Comment on this

The Secretary General spoke about the issue of frameworks and so on. We all know that people can make a tender on one basis but then the reality of delivery can sometimes be different. Has the Department identified, let us say, contractors with consistent issues? Anecdotally, groups like Education Equality and others are starting to notice that particular suppliers or project managers have more delivery issues than others. That is a voluntary group doing it anecdotally. What measures is the Department taking to ensure those issues do not arise?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We have a robust governance process for our school building programme. In the school sector, it is very much about standardised layouts and design. Whether I go into a school in Dublin, Cork, Kerry or Donegal, it is pretty much the same inside. It might vary a bit outside depending on the local circumstances of the site, planning conditions, etc., but it is very much standardised once it is in the classroom.

Comment on this

Are some contractors better at design, management and delivery than others?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

There are always elements of that but, as part of our overall procurement strategy, our approach is to look at which of the contractors, and the scale of them, are best suited to the larger, more complex projects-----

Comment on this

Is there a systematic approach to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Absolutely. We have a procurement unit that manages some of that for us and we have a lot of expertise in that.

Comment on this

How does that procurement unit engage with, for example, a school principal who might have very practical examples of what has gone right or wrong? The Department and I have dealt with each other in regard to schools in my area. Mr. Loftus talked earlier about the defined profile or design. Under one planning process, I would have said some very basic questions were not included in the planning application, around green roofs and so on. Those are the things tha cause delays and result in parents not getting a place. The quality of the contractor and those kinds of things need to be managed better.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It is always an evolving picture and environment. There is a challenging construction sector, with evolving requirements in regard to regulations, the sustainability and climate agendas, and all of that.

Comment on this

Is the Department bringing the experience of the school principal into the procurement unit to review contractors?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Absolutely. Our teams are out there supporting schools. We have buildings officers and all of that. That feeds back and we have a team that continually looks at our designs and how we evolve and improve them. There are always learnings in this job, and that is just the way of life.

Comment on this

I thank everyone for attending. My first question is about the spend on transport in the education system. Deputy Daly alluded to variances. What caught my attention were the ups and downs during the years. It was €225 million in 2020, €512 million in 2024, €479 in 2025 and €640 million for 2026 or 2027. That is bouncing around. We or anyone involved in accounting are used to seeing budgets going like this. Obviously, there might be a drop for a good reason, but what we see here is a rapid increase, then it goes down, then up and then there is another rapid increase. I am not blaming the witnesses. I am potentially questioning what the politicians are doing. Are the witnesses just having to respond to decisions being made, things being said and platitudes being offered? Why is the Department of education budget bouncing around to such a degree?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It is moving because of need and circumstances. For example, some of the change-----

Comment on this

I genuinely do not buy that, because need is need. The need was probably always there. If you change the criteria, need will go with what happens. Ms McNally said earlier that it is demand led. I get what she is saying, but I almost do not buy that either. If you keep changing the criteria, demand will reach it.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Ukraine was not predicted. It caused a spike. Some 18,000 children came into the country, and 6,200 of them were on the scheme. There were 5,000 the following year-----

Comment on this

We changed the criteria to match that need.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That is one thing.

Comment on this

Ms McNally is using it as an example of criteria.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The cost of living is another. In different years, the Government provided extra money for school transport to make fees more affordable. In 2022-23, fees were reduced completely------

Comment on this

They were reduced to zero.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Exactly.

Comment on this

Did that make sense?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That was a huge affordability measure.

Comment on this

Did it make sense to do it?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It was a cost-of-living measure that made school transport-----

Comment on this

Did it make sense to do that?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There was a strong justification for it-----

Comment on this

And Ms McNally agreed with that.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

-----but it did increase. We saw an increase of 26,000 in the number of applications. It was a cost-of-living measure that was extremely popular. It was really warmly welcomed.

Comment on this

We are not talking about being popular; we are talking about doing what is right. That is why I am wondering what the Department’s role in it is. Politicians will always try to make popular decisions. However, from the perspective of governance and the management of costs, are they pushing back on that?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The Government and our Ministers have said that in normal circumstances a fee is appropriate. The school transport review has said that it is desirable-----

Comment on this

Then why was that done? Did Ms McNally disagree in 2023?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There were particular circumstances after Covid and with Ukraine. The cost of living was high. There were particular circumstances at the time that merited it. However, we are introducing and restoring fees again.

Comment on this

Was it a mistake to do it in 2023? What I am getting at here is that this is the PAC. Ultimately, we are here to ask how much is being spent and if it is being spent right. I will not say that I am against school transport, just as last week I did not say I am against school meals. Anyone who is against those would be wrong in the eyes of the public. At the same time, we have a job to do to ensure that serious questions are asked. Last week, we could see where €50 million in funding was being wasted on school meals. The total budget for school meals five years ago was €50 million. We see all these costs going up, but I am asking whether the Department of education pushes back when it needs to and says that something is wrong and that it does not agree with it. Does it just say that something is all right and then waits to see what storm it brings? Bus Éireann then has to try to get the buses to deal with that.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Ministers and the Government have made the decision to restore fees to the level they were at in 2021-22, which will still be 92% subsidised for primary and 75% subsidised for post-primary. That is probably a solution that will support the sustainability of this scheme and, as other Deputies have said, allow us to expand it and possibly reduce distance criteria, etc. The evidence does support charging a heavily subsidised fee, and that has been the decision of Ministers and the Government in recent times.

Comment on this

That is important. It is where the Department has to ask hard questions, because we are seeing variances and cost escalations all over the place. How much of the €640 million relates to is taxis?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will get the exact number, but I think it is approximately €143 million. Those taxis are predominantly used for children who have very customised special educational needs.

Comment on this

I am not even going to question that. What is the highest paid taxi operator?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I do not know if I have that information. I do not know if Bus Éireann has it.

Comment on this

I want to get a feel for it.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

It is an annual payment of €71,500.

Comment on this

Somebody gets paid €71,500 to drive-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

Let me correct that. It is €73,300.

Comment on this

I do not want to talk about the individual involved. At the same time, it is important that information comes out of the PAC. A taxi driver is being paid €73,000 to bring somebody to school.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

To clarify for the Deputy, that is a rate of €1.78 per kilometre. That service is-----

Comment on this

Once again, I am not going to question that service because, I am sure the person needs it. At the same time, it is important to identify, because we are seeing that as an issue.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There could be a number of children involved. It could be a seven-seater vehicle. There are a good number of children on these transports.

Comment on this

Once again, I want to get a feel for it. Are we happy with that in all the individual areas? This is what I want to clarify. Tenders are put out in the area overseen by Kildare and Wicklow Education and Training Board,, KWETB, for example. That is the area Deputy Farrelly and I are most familiar with. Does the tender for the buses come through the schools or is it through the like of the KWETB?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

We run the tenders. Just to give a flavour-----

Comment on this

Is that the Department of Bus Éireann?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

Bus Éireann.

Comment on this

Bus Éireann runs the individual tenders, but the tender process for out-of-school use, like driving to and from school, bus services for matches and all that, is separate. That is also what I want to clarify. Bus Éireann controls every element of it. Does it do the taxis as well?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

Yes.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

They are also procured.

Comment on this

The company goes through all of that. Is it happy that there is a competitive procurement process for each of those taxis?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

When we talk about taxis, it is important to state that we have approximately 3,000 of them in the system. As Ms McNally said, they support children with additional special needs. Some 740 of those taxis offer a one-to-one service. I think we should be proud that the State provides that service.

Comment on this

That is what I was saying-----

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I know the Deputy is saying that too.

Comment on this

That is not what-----

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I get that.

Comment on this

I am trying to move the discussion away from the point where there is a risk of it becoming emotive.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

Okay.

Comment on this

I just want to go through the numbers, because that is our job today. It is not for Ms O'Sullivan to tell me that kids need a chance, and no more so than everybody needing school meals.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

No. I am saying that even when we are looking at it, we say that there is a cost that we manage robustly within a procurement framework. There is then a cost that comes to the value of what is needed for the child. It is expensive.

Comment on this

Absolutely. From a special education perspective, what will teachers be asked to do for people entering primary schools? What role are they being given? What are we changing?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Is the Deputy talking about the role teachers in primary schools are being given to serve children with special educational needs?

Comment on this

Who gets to decide the designation and information that comes into them?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The system is based on whether a parent believes their child has particular special educational needs that require specialist provision. The Deputy should remember that most children are supported in mainstream classes with access to all those special education teachers we have. For every three or four mainstream teachers we have, we have one special education resource teacher helping those children in mainstream classes. If a parent believes that level of support and all the SNAs in mainstream are not enough and want a special class or special class or school, under the existing scheme they have to get a professional assessment. It might be a psychologist or someone who says-----

Comment on this

I will be quick. I am conscious of time and I know it is an open-ended question. Will individual teachers now have more of an influence?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We want to do the right thing for children. We find that their having to get this professional assessment with a diagnosis is blocking some children from advancing through the system.

Comment on this

I get that, but my fear is that teachers are being asked to do something which, realistically, they are not really in a position of wanting to do. That is what I want to clarify.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We have increased the number of teachers in the system. We are now going to have-----

Comment on this

We are also asking a lot more of the teachers and we have to be conscious of that as well.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That is why we are putting in all those resource teachers and why we have doubled the number of special classes.

Comment on this

We have not doubled the number of teachers.

From a construction perspective, we have given extra classrooms. I look at St. Anne's in Ardclough. It is a new school and was given an extra class. At the same time, are we comfortable and happy with the level of funding that is being made available for these schools, not to mind that I have also seen the need for a three-school campus in Kildare where St. Raphael's is a special school as well? Are we happy that we have the resources from a capital perspective to ensure, first of all, that when we say we are going to do it, we deliver it, which we have not done in time in Celbridge? There is then the situation in Ardclough where we have given the support to the principal and the school to deliver what was promised to the parents and students who potentially are coming in

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

In terms of that Ardclough case, we met with the school and design team recently in relation to guidance and advice around their project. Some of our team went out and visited that school as well and provided them with good advice. They key thing there is making sure that the proposed works being done are cost-effective and work within the parameters of our scheme. That is the direction of travel we want to see there.

More generally, we have a €7.5 billion NDP envelope that gives us good clarity and certainty for the period form 2026 to 2030. Our job in the planning and building unit is to work through that, prioritise the needs and special needs-----

Comment on this

With St. Raphael's and the three-school campus element of it too, we have a school with a specific set of needs. They have been promised it for many years but it is not being delivered. Those students require that service and building but they are not getting it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

We are aware of that campus. It is an important project for us. It includes a special school, but there was also a history to that site issue outside the direct control of the Department that we had to manage through our work. That is now on a pathway forward and is certainly now a project that is in the latter stages of our design and ultimately will get considered like our other projects going forward for our next prioritisation approach that we will be doing.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. I know I bounced from topic to topic, but I thank them for their time.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here this morning. I will start off on the school transport element. Like other members, I acknowledge the huge increase in the scale of the operation and the budget. In 2026, it is €641 million, which has come from just over €200 million a short number of years ago. It is a huge operation to manage and that is fully understood. In many cases, it provides a great service. It is important to say that too, but it is fair to say that every year the summer is the one time of the year that many public representatives dread when it comes around because we get contacted by families in a state of desperation where, for one reason or another, it is not working out for them. One family member may have a school bus place and another does not, or the local school does not have a place and therefore they no longer qualify for the service, and there are other operational issues as well. In some cases, family members previously had tickets but do not for the coming year. A wide range of issues present themselves and we, as public representatives, try to assist and engage with people. It is acknowledged that there are significant operational issues. Where are we with the 2024 review in terms of implementation? Can the witnesses give us a quick update on where things stand?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I thank the Deputy for acknowledging the scale and what has been delivered. We absolutely empathise with Deputies. We know that summers can be very difficult. Again, as I said at the beginning, when we look at it and analyse it, the dissatisfaction is mostly with the non-eligibles and the concessionary. They have an expectation. They have applied and paid on time, and they really hope that they are going to get it. Sometimes they get it and sometimes they do not because to use the money that has been voted to us for this purpose, we have to live within the rules of the scheme.

Regarding the review, as I said, we are progressing every action that has to be progressed in it and we are about 40% complete. The biggest thing that will help what the Deputy is describing-----

Comment on this