We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

School Transport and Special Education: Discussion

Summary

School transport cost €479 million in 2025, with the Comptroller and Auditor General attributing the overspend to underfunded estimates and calling for clearer reporting of special-education spending. The Department said rising demand, particularly for pupils with special educational needs, drove costs, and that the structural funding shortfall had been addressed; it is implementing a review intended to expand access and improve integration with public transport. Members raised concerns about eligibility rules, unused seats, poor communication and delays in special-needs support, while the Department cited substantial growth in special classes, staff and school places. Ticket charges are due to return to 2021–22 levels for 2027–28, while most costs remain publicly subsidised.

Contributions 198–398 of 604. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Sorry, I am just caught for time, so I need to be very specific.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

-----is the integration with public sector transport. That is the biggest thing.

Comment on this

Where are we with that issue?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We have had one particularly relevant pilot down in Shannon-Limerick, etc., where, integrated with public service routes, we were able to take seven school transport vehicles off the road and use public sector vehicles as well. That has been a very successful pilot. It was huge work with the Department of Transport and we are really grateful for the collaboration there. We hope to build on that this year. As I said, we have a little bit of money in the budget and we hope to build on that.

Comment on this

In terms of the remaining recommendations, Ms McNally says that 40-something per cent of them have been implemented, so we are 50-something-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Progress is being made with all of the rest of them. We mentioned data-----

Comment on this

What is the timeline for the full implementation of those recommendations? The report is two years old at this stage.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We will make a lot of progress on the ones that are totally within our control but the integration with the routes is a very big one. That will take a little bit more time but our respective Ministers are-----

Comment on this

Can we have an estimated timeline?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

-----really engaging.

Comment on this

Is there a targeted timeline?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I cannot really-----

Comment on this

The Department does not have a timeline.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I hope to see a lot of progress. Our Ministers in both Departments, senior Ministers and junior Ministers, are really engaging and we hope to see good progress there.

Comment on this

Anti-competitive practices were previously found in the area of school transport provision. The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission, CCPC, pursued the matter and five individuals were convicted, as I understand it. Are we confident that similar practices do not exist within the provision of the service at this point in time?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We aware of that work with the CCPC. Across a service of this scale, where we have 11,000 routes and over 8,000 vehicles, things like this can arise so procurement practice is really important. The Deputy might want to pull Bus Éireann in here, but it has very robust procurement practices.

Comment on this

What level of resource does Bus Éireann put into ensuring that there are no anti-competitive practices? Will one of its representatives give us a snapshot of what it does to ensure that these issues are not repeated?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

I will answer the Deputy's question. There are a couple of things. First of all, the people who were found guilty, all of their contracts were terminated - just so we are clear in terms of what we do when we know. The second thing is regarding procurement, roughly speaking, we did about 3,200 tenders in the last four to five months and we had 15,000 bids. Roughly 83% of the tenders we did had more than two bids. More than 65% had more than three bids, which is competition.

Comment on this

It is, but it could also be co-operation.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

Pardon?

Comment on this

On the face of it, it is competition, but it looked like there was competition before and there was co-operation between the providers.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

The Deputy is quite right. The second part of what we do is that we have developed over the last couple of years three internal metrics to look and see if it is value for money. I do not necessarily want to go into those unless the Deputy wants to.

Comment on this

No. Does Bus Éireann receive complaints that there are alleged anti-competitive practices?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

If we did, we would report them immediately.

Comment on this

Does Bus Éireann receive complaints?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

We had one which is what led to what happened.

Comment on this

Have any further complaints come through to Bus Éireann?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

Not yet.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. I want to raise the issue of school transport escorts. That is very often one of the reasons given for transport provision not being provided in special cases. How much of a difficulty is recruiting school escorts for the Department?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We have talked to this committee about whether it is difficult to get SNAs. We can fill SNA positions fairly easily across the country. Bus escorts can be a little bit more difficult. There definitely can be situations but to address that we increased the pay about two years ago and it is now aligned with public sector deals.

Comment on this

It is somewhere between €15 and €16 an hour, but they do not get paid until the point of pick-up, for example, so they can have travel costs. They may get two to three hours pay per day, for example, so on a weekly basis, it ultimately adds up to very little.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It is a part-time job and it-----

Comment on this

Is there any plan to review it further?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We are constantly looking at the bus escort service. It is a really important service for us. They are aligned now so as other pay levels go up, they will go up with it. We have provided an information pack. There is actually a review under way and my colleague, Mr. Clohessy, is further looking at this. They perform a really important role for us.

Comment on this

It is being looked at. I want to turn to special education and I again acknowledge the increase in all aspects of that in recent years. That is to be acknowledged and welcomed but it is still an area where a lot of work is needed. In terms of the Department of education as a whole, special education is very often cited as a reason for the project overrun for 2026. Is that a fair description?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

In 2026, we are going to come in on budget. There had been difficulties in previous years. A lot of them actually had to do with general payroll and requiring supplementaries for teachers and SNAs, but we would have worked with Department of public expenditure and reform and proven that the predictions we had around the number of teachers needed within the system were accurate and it would have given us supplementaries. I know that the C and AG has a chapter-----

Comment on this

To clarify, Ms McNally said they are coming in on budget. What year does the €600 million overrun apply to?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

In 2026, we are going to come within budget because earlier this year we got an additional €646 million. That has gone into the budget, so we will-----

Comment on this

You were €600 million short in the original budget.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Yes.

Comment on this

Let us be straight about that. Special education has often been cited as the reason for that overrun. Is that a fair description?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Yes. Most of that €646 million was payroll and some of it was school transport. Approximately €400 million was on payroll, school transport and addressing an existing structural deficit, but about €200 million was for the additional demand that emerged. The Deputy will recall the parent-notified process within the NCSE where we ask parents to notify us in advance. That identified a much more significant need for this September. Instead of the 400 special classes we had funding for, we needed funding for 587, for example. That dealt with that extra demand.

Comment on this

Many people would regard this as a failure of planning within the system. I will give an example from my own constituency. There is an emerging chronic shortage of secondary school places in the area I represent in Carrigaline, Passage West, Crosshaven and Douglas. What people cannot understand is those children were in primary level school, and the numbers were there and we know what is coming through, yet there is now an emerging chronic shortage of places for those children to go on to local secondary schools. How does that happen?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I might call in my colleague, Mr. Loftus, on this but there is strong forward planning. For example, at present, we have 10,000 more first year places than we have sixth class students. Mr. Loftus can go into more detail on that. We generally get our predictions right but there are pockets. Even though our demographics are going down there are areas, particularly urban areas, where there is growth. I will call Mr. Loftus in to add to that.

Comment on this

I appreciate Mr. Loftus may not have the detail for the area I highlighted in Cork South-Central, but this is certainly one of those pockets where, based on what I am getting from families, there is a major shortage of places. Again, I go back to my point that these children are coming from primary level education. How does the Department not foresee the difficulties and make provision on time for available places in the coming year? It is just difficult to understand.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I thank the Deputy. More generally, we have quite a robust forward-planning process and use technology, our geographic information system and all the engagement we have with local authorities. Planning requirements are ultimately linked to housing roll-out, managing all that and working that through. For Cork South-Central, the Deputy's constituency, there are seven school planning areas. Those have peaked at primary level and three have peaked at post-primary level. We have managed and worked through that provision. One of the biggest developments we are currently engaging in with the local authority is probably the big plan for the docklands area. Ultimately, there will be huge provision there of 25,000. We will have a lot of work there with school sites being reserved and provision being required. That is probably the biggest piece.

We have the same numbers in broad terms transitioning from primary to post-primary in recent years. The key thing there is managing capacity well at post-primary and maximising and optimising that. We work with a lot of school stakeholders to ensure that is achieved. Part of the challenge, in tandem with that more generally, is making sure solutions are being worked through around special needs and special needs provision in the mainstream schools.

Comment on this

I am out of time. Thank you for that.

Comment on this

The witnesses are very welcome. As someone who represents Fingal, one of the youngest areas in the country, special education is obviously a huge focus for me. I welcome the additional places in Balbriggan and the new school which will hopefully open in Loughshinny next year. However, as Deputy McGrath has said, we really need to see secondary school places.

Balbriggan, Skerries, Rush and Lusk are rapidly growing. I know it can be hard to model, but ready-made families with older children are moving into the area and secondary school places are a necessity. I have said before that Skerries has its own school district and has no special education secondary school places. It is essential we see that delivered next year in Skerries Community College and St. Joseph's Secondary School. It is very close to submitting its finalised 2b application, but it is absolutely essential we see work on that school and Gaelscoil Ros Eo in Rush, which is rapidly developing.

I am now going to turn to school transport. Obviously, we are delivering more school special education classrooms right around the country and we all see that. However, yet again, in the past week I had an email from a parent who lives in Rush and desperately wants their child to go to the new school in Loughshinny next year, but its enrolment has not opened yet because the school has not opened. She has been given a list of special schools to apply to, with the closest in Ballymun and the furthest in Rathfarnham. It makes no sense to send a child from Rush to Rathfarnham. Similarly, I know there is a child coming from Sandyford to the new special school in Balbriggan.

This is why the school transport has gone absolutely wild. It is not because parents want to send their kids from Sandyford to Balbriggan or Drogheda to Dublin city centre; it is because they have no choice. This is not about preferential schools. Is the Secretary General engaging with parents on an annual basis? Parents are saying if their child goes to school on the other side of the city, they cannot go to parent-teacher meetings or pick them up when they are sick, and will not be involved in the school community. I am not saying any parent or family wants their children to stay where they currently are. I fully appreciate that they might be embedded in their communities, but at the same time we have to bring children closer to their communities. We have to allow parents to be involved in the school communities. That should also help us with the school transport issue. Is the Department asking parents on an annual basis whether it would be possible if new school places were opening in their community, and there was another family who could swap, they would be open to bringing their child closer to their community?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask my colleague, Ms Mannion, to come in but I absolutely assure the Deputy we are in violent agreement with her and those parents, and we have demonstrated this. For 20 years, there were no extra special schools but in the past five or six years, we have had 20 extra special schools built after 20 years of none. Special classes have doubled in number. Our ambition, and we are delivering on this, is more special classes and more special schools in local communities. That is what we aspire to. We do not want families travelling long distances but, as I said, some that have started may want to continue, so it will take awhile.

The Deputy asked if they could swap and the answer is "Yes". That is why we have put more SENOs into the National Council for Special Education. At one stage, they were in the high 60s and now there are about 127. This is so they know the children in their area, the schools and parents, and they can have those conversations.

Comment on this

To confirm, are the SENOs having those conversations with parents on an annual basis?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

Yes, Deputy. We are delighted Balbriggan opened for 18 students last month. It is a huge start and we are delighted about that. There are 44 special schools in Dublin catering for over 2,700 students. Eight of the new schools are in Dublin-----

Comment on this

I am caught on time. I do not need to hear-----

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

The point of this is we have created massive additional capacity in Dublin. It is one of those areas where we know it is needed.

Comment on this

I agree. I made that point myself. Is the Department looking at trying to bring children in and telling families that even though they will have to apply to Sandyford or Rathfarnham, next year it can look and see if it can bring them closer to their communities?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

Part of the reason we have asked for the parent-notified process and for parents to engage with the NCSE is exactly for that purpose. The NCSE needs to know where those children are. Many of the children who applied for September 2027 places are people already in places who are looking for alternative places.

Comment on this

I will ask Ms Mannion a question. What percentage of those children this year have said they want to come closer to their community now that classrooms have opened in Balbriggan and Loughshinny?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

Of the 7,860 people across the country who applied for places for September 2026, there will be a small percentage of those who were already in a special placement looking for an alternative special placement. We would have seen that as a net result because it did not require additional capacity to be created. Once they had the letter of eligibility, the SENO could work with them to get a place in a local special school closer to them, which would then free up a place in the special school or class they were coming from. We see this as very important as we are creating additional provision. It is helping.

Comment on this

My understanding is that under the 2024 review, special education inclusion on mainstream public transport had a target of 20%.

What is the current status of that target?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Sorry, could the Deputy repeat that question?

Comment on this

Rather than having children with special educational needs travelling in taxis when they do not need to, they could go on mainstream school transport buses. My understanding was there was a target of 20% in that regard. What are we currently at?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That is a journey we have to go on. There are children on the mainstream-----

Comment on this

It would help me if I knew what the starting percentage point of that journey was.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Do we have the exact number, Ms Mulhall?

Comment on this

I find it very hard to meet a target if we do not know where we currently at.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We have some information. I know the number of bus escorts on mainstream transport. Do we have an accurate number of children, Ms Mulhall?

Comment on this
Ms Barbara Mulhall

Yes. There are around 80 to 100 on mainstream services at the moment.

Comment on this

Did the review not say we wanted to get 20%? Where we are we, percentage-wise?

Comment on this
Ms Barbara Mulhall

There are between 80 and 100 at the moment-----

Comment on this

That is the number of children but what does that equal in percentage terms? How is the Department tracking the progress on the review requirement if it does not know what the percentage is?

Comment on this
Ms Barbara Mulhall

The review requirement made a recommendation for parents who wish for their children to travel on mainstream transport, either with or without the assistance of an escort. That is actually in the application form. We try to facilitate that for parents who want their child to travel on mainstream transport. That is the ambition of the-----

Comment on this

I know, but I am struggling as regards how the Department is tracking whether it will deliver this if it does not know what the percentage is currently.

Comment on this
Ms Barbara Mulhall

There are currently 24,400 children with special educational needs on transport. Around 80 to 100 would be on mainstream services at the moment.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. McCarthy to give me that figure as a percentage.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

It is 3%.

Comment on this

First, I think it is essential the Department know where it is, percentage-wise, if it is to have any hope of delivering the target. Second, that is very poor.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It is complex, though.

Comment on this

I appreciate that but-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We are talking about the most specialist group. A child is not eligible unless they have particular needs, so moving them from a customised-----

Comment on this

That is not quite true. There are children going to reading schools, etc.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

They might not necessarily be eligible for specialist transport, just because they are going to a special school. It has to be that they have a need.

Comment on this

This is special education. It is not that they are all going to special schools. Some of them are going to special classes.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Yes.

Comment on this

I know from children I know in my constituency that not all of them are at the highly complex level.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Yes. Just because you are eligible for a special class or special school does not mean you are eligible for specialised school transport. The SENO has to determine there is a need, that this child cannot use mainstream transport. We are trying to get some of those children on to mainstream transport but they are children with more complex needs, some of whom might need bus escorts. There are about 50 bus escorts on mainstream-----

Comment on this

I am not advocating for children who are not able for it but if the review set a target of 20%, I just do not understand why the Department would accept that if it does not think it is achievable or if Ms McNally is telling me children are not appropriate for it.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We are working towards it. We have work to do. We have done a pilot with one school and it has been very useful to look at what the appetite is among parents towards this move. A significant number of parents said that, yes, they would be willing to consider it but they want reassurance that their child will be safe on the mainstream service.

Comment on this

Absolutely. If this is not a realistic goal, it needs to be revisited.

Comment on this
Ms Barbara Mulhall

That is why that pilot was done with the school in question. It was to see what is possible in the future. There are also people who may be attending special classes and mainstream classes and they are on the mainstream scheme but they apply through the mainstream scheme and do not disclose that they have a disability. We would not necessarily have sight of those because they do not want to disclose that information but, anecdotally-----

Comment on this

I am not interested in giving the Department a hard time about not reaching a goal that is unreachable, but if it is not reachable, the Department needs to very clearly state that. Starting with the percentage would help.

Has the Department modelled the cost of offering and providing free school transport for all children in this country? If so, how much would that cost?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask Mr. Clohessy to come in on that because the school transport review looked at this. There are cost implications-----

Comment on this

Absolutely. I just want to get a sense of-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

-----and there are driver and vehicle availability issues as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

Around the school transport review, there are a number of things we are testing, such as e-ticketing, which came up a little earlier, and having special education children on mainstream transport. The primary issue in the pilots that have taken place so far are reducing the distance criteria and waiving the nearest school requirement. The Secretary General has already outlined the particular instance on one particular route where demand increased by in excess of 500%. We have to be really careful about how we model this because while that will not present in a standard way right across the system, we need to get a full assessment of what that would look like across the system. At present, we simply would not have the buses or drivers, let alone the money, to be able to support a service of that nature. We will have to consider the 2 km limit and nearest school waiver in great depth. On providing it to every child, with parental choice and with a child who can go to perhaps the third or fourth nearest school, the number of variables becomes exponential and would significantly increase the spend-----

Comment on this

We are talking in the billions of euro if we are looking at this at the moment.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

That is fair to say.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The integration with public service transport is an essential part of making the scheme sustainable.

Comment on this

I will finish with the Secretary General on this point. I note the integration with public transport, which is great, particularly in rural areas. I have a real issue in that the route 33 bus in my area, serving Balbriggan, Rush and Skerries, does not bring school children to meet the secondary school times, in particular. If there is anything the Secretary General can do with the Minister for Transport and the NTA to make sure public transport is serving school communities, I would really appreciate it.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will pass that message on.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

As it is now after 12.30 p.m., we will take a short break.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I call our next questioner, Deputy Kenny.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses from the Department of education and Bus Éireann.

As the spokesperson for education for my party, I thank the Secretary General for the extraordinary amount of work that has been done within the education system. When good progress has been made, it should be recognised. Good progress has been made in all areas across education. There is a long way to go in ensuring that we have a perfect education system but I am confident that it is moving in the right direction.

I want to begin with the shortfall that was in the 2025 appropriation account. What was originally allocated towards school transport was €382.7 million and the expenditure eventually was €478.7 million. That was an additional €96 million, or 25%. I presume that was particularly towards transport for those with special educational needs. The Secretary General might give some sort of clarification in that regard.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask my school transport colleagues to come in, but I thank the Deputy for recognising the extraordinary work that has been done and thank him for the confidence. We acknowledge that a huge amount has been achieved and there has been massive work by schools all around the country. Parents have worked with us, as have advocacy organisations. It has been a lot of hard work. A lot of people, our Ministers, etc., have done a huge amount. We have an ambition and a vision and we want to continue to deliver for children. We are really grateful for all the money that the Government has made available.

Would Mr. Clohessy mind taking the question on the account?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

I thank the Deputy. The trajectory has been increasing with the number of children, particularly children with special needs, coming onto the service. Year on year, we have seen an increase in the number of special education learners but also the number of bus escorts, and there has obviously been an accompanying increase in fuel costs and inflation right the way across the system. Colleagues on the Bus Éireann side have indicated that there have been increases in costs. They are managing them proactively, but those costs are presenting. It is something that we are very conscious of to try to manage into the future.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. There have been overruns. Making accommodations has contributed to that, as has the soaring cost of fuel.

On the cost of providing the services, with expenditure approaching €600 million, what proportion goes directly to private transport operators, what proportion goes towards Bus Éireann - Bus Éireann's own vehicles and drivers - and what proportion is spent on administration?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I might again start that answer and my colleagues might come in.

Under the accounting arrangements that are in place, Bus Éireann cannot provide more than 10% of the routes, so it never does. We strictly follow that rule. We use Bus Éireann predominantly for areas where there might be market failure. The vast majority is procured from and provided by private contractors - well over 90%.

With regards to the charge that we pay Bus Éireann, there are rules on that going back many years under the 1975 accounting arrangements. Originally, those accounting arrangements said that Bus Éireann could charge 13% as an administrative overhead. At this point in time, it is charging approximately 2.5% because we changed that rule very significantly.

Last year, we gave Bus Éireann about €15 million for its administrative overhead, and we have very strict accounting arrangements in place for that. In 2018 and 2019, we brought in an external person to look at what costs it could charge to us, both direct and indirect. Ms Flynn, for example, works full time on school transport, so her salary might be invoiced to us. We then looked at what else across Bus Éireann could be partially apportioned to us. There is a strict methodology for that. We have gone out to tender for somebody to review it, and we hope to sign a contract in the next couple of weeks. We monitor this carefully to make sure that we are following the rules and that we are getting value for money for the Exchequer. We can provide more details.

Comment on this

I am happy with that. Our understanding is that eligible children receive their bus places and might use them for the first two or three weeks of the school year, and then suddenly no longer use it. Meanwhile, non-concessionary children who have looked for a bus place have not received one, because concessionary tickets have been given to children who then stop using them after the first two or three weeks. Can the Department come up with a mechanism, or is there already one in place, to identify children who have been given concessionary tickets but are no longer using them after the first couple of weeks of the school year and to take the tickets off them, though said in a nicer way than that, and give it to another child who was not concessionary to start with but maybe will use it?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It is our ambition to get to a stage where we will be able to do that. Some of that is happening already and we are taking action in that regard. For example, as another Deputy spoke of earlier, the reintroduction of the fees at 2021-22 levels will make parents think about whether they really want to pay for a ticket. When the tickets were cheaper, parents might have decided they would get that ticket just in case they needed it for a rainy day, but then did not use it. The reintroduction of the fees might reduce the number who were not using the service much. Some 25% of children will still travel free and for the others the service is heavily subsidised. We have also written to parents to say these tickets are quite precious and to please not apply for one and pay unless they are going to use it. We have issued communications in that regard.

Bus Éireann might answer this, but I think that if somebody wants to hand a ticket back, Bus Éireann will try to give the seat to somebody else. There is a lot of action, but the technological solution we are developing and the technology we have tried, tested and learned from will help us with that. Mr. Clohessy may want to add to that.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

That is fair. It is quite nuanced. We have run a couple of pilots, one in the Kells area, and we recently ran a pilot with U-TRAC devices on 44 separate routes. The information we have analysed is quite interesting, and we will publish it as part of the overall pilot evaluation. We find that utilisation rates vary from day to day, week to week and route to route, so it is more nuanced than a child simply not using the service. Some children might use it in the morning but not in the afternoon. At times, particularly at post-primary level, there are after-school activities. Those are the kinds of things we need to get into. As the Secretary General outlined, we need a technological solution to get to the bottom of it. The indicative information we are getting back from the pilot is useful and informative, and suggests that the situation is not as straightforward as it might seem, with people simply not using the service at all.

Comment on this

That is an important part of it and progress is being made. However, as TDs, we get calls saying people know other people down the road are not using their tickets, which they have been given, but their own child has not got a ticket because he is non-concessionary, but he would use the bus every day if he could get it.

I have two further questions, one on school transport and one other. I was reading a reply to a parliamentary question submitted by another TD. Bus Éireann refused to disclose the average contract cost by vehicle size, citing commercial sensitivity. Can it furnish the committee with the average contract cost per vehicle category?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

I will work off the latest figures we have, for 2026. These are what we call the daily rate per vehicle that we pay. The largest vehicle, a double-decker, costs €459-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

Per day. It then goes right down to taxis, at €246 per day. I can give the individual figures if the Deputy needs them.

Comment on this

A taxi carrying one child would get €246 per day.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

On average. That is the average across all of the more than 3,000 taxis operating in the Bus Éireann subcontracted fleet. I have figures for the other categories if the Deputy needs them, but I am giving the range-----

Comment on this

That is the range from the highest down to taxi level.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

Those figures are aggregated across all counties. They are not specific to any one county.

Comment on this

It is an average cost.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

It is an average of everything across Ireland.

Comment on this

This is a "Yes" or "No" question for Ms McNally and Mr. Delaney. Do they believe that is value for money?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

If I may come in here, special educational needs transport is very customised. For example, a child might want to go to a special school for the deaf even though it is a very long way away.

Comment on this

I have a cousin who is doing that.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Sometimes, there are long journeys and long hours because of the need. It is a door-to-door service, and sometimes it includes bus escorts. These are expensive services, but these are children who would not otherwise access an education, which is their legal right. It is costly. We have said publicly that while the average cost for a child in mainstream is about €1,480, for a child with special educational needs it is €14,000. That is the average. However, we are looking at this.

Comment on this

If the Chair indulges me for 30 seconds, I will ask Ms Mannion a quick question. We are all receiving emails about the assessment of needs category and how places will be allocated if the assessment of need criteria are removed. Will Ms Mannion take 30 seconds to speak on that?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

I think the Deputy is talking about removing diagnosis as a requirement for access to a specialist placement.

Comment on this

Or whether teachers would have to make that diagnosis.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

I am glad to clarify this. First, we are looking to remove all barriers to children accessing supports. No decision has been made about this. What we were looking to do was to trial, in a safe and secure way, with a small number of children and families who already have access to a special school or class placement, whether there was a better way that would remove the barriers and allow those children to access the placements if they did not have a diagnosis. This builds on something we have been doing since 2017. A diagnosis is no longer needed to access mainstream supports. It is not needed for the summer programme or for an SNA. The last cohort of children for whom a professional recommendation is required is children in special schools and classes.

We recognise the importance of a diagnosis for an individual parent and family and nothing we are doing here takes away from that. We are asking whether there is a better, fairer way, removing the barriers for children so that they can access those placements. We are genuinely not asking teachers to do anything at this point. We are asking stakeholders to work with us on a small-scale proof of concept that would allow us to see what might be involved in a better, safer way to meet the needs of children. That would show how long it might take, the resources and time it might take, and the impact on parents, schools and children. That is what we want to do. It is to remove any remaining barriers to children accessing places, alongside increasing provision.

Comment on this

I thank everyone for being here. I echo much of what my colleagues have said in support and encouragement of the work the witnesses are doing in their respective agencies and roles. Notwithstanding that, it has been noted already that there are significant structural challenges, specifically with school transport. As public representatives, we can nearly put into our work plans that, at this time of the year, just as there will be a trolley crisis in the winter, there will be a school transport crisis. That is what it feels like to the families affected. It is a crisis because the knock-on effects for what their normal day will look like, depending on whether they have a school bus ticket, are really significant. Is Ms McNally confident that the Department has received a budget allocation for 2027 that will not require Revised or Supplementary Estimates and that it has sufficient funding to deliver its work programme in 2027?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I am very hopeful that that is the case. We have received a significant budget across the whole Vote, including for special education and school transport, so we are hopeful. However, a lot of our services are demand-led. Most of it is entirely predictable.

Our forecasts over the years have proven to be really good. We are very good at forecasting. I can never say 100% that yes, we will be okay but we are hopeful.

Comment on this

We are unlikely to be here this time next year with a significant overspend or overrun in the same way as the last few years.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I would absolutely hope so but we cannot completely and utterly control that. On the special education side the NCSE is still working through the parent notify numbers that have come through so we do not have final numbers there yet. We are very grateful to the Government. We worked really collaboratively with the Department of public expenditure and reform and we got €3.8 billion for special education in 2027, which is very significant. On the school transport side we have €687 million next year, which is also very significant.

Comment on this

I want to get into the weeds a bit. Does the Department receive funding per academic year or per calendar year for the school transport? How does it work?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

We receive it per calendar year.

Comment on this

How much has the Department been allocated to run school transport for 2027?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

A sum of €687 million.

Comment on this

How much does the Department expect it will cost to run it?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

Based on current projections we feel that we will live within that allocation and we should be able to provide the services that are required based on the scheme that is in place for the €687 million.

Comment on this

What has changed then? In the past three or four years there have been significant overruns. Has the Department received a significant increase in funding? Has the Department finally acknowledged that this is what it costs or are we budgeting better? Why will we come in on target this year?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

There are a few elements. We have the parents notify now, which colleagues on the special education side have put in place, so we are getting earlier visibility of the numbers of special education children that are presenting. We are able to extrapolate from that how much it will cost in relation to special education transport. There are other bits too. The restoration of fees will help to manage particularly where people might have been getting a ticket but did not always need to use it. It will now be ring-fenced for the people who need it. We work very closely with colleagues on the Bus Éireann side around contractor costs to make sure we have good early visibility of what they look like. We acknowledge it is demand led. If circumstances were to change in some way that we cannot currently pre-empt, there may be some variation but from our perspective we are sufficiently well funded for 2027.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

If I could make an important clarification as a colleague has just reminded me. We hope we have enough funding next year. Clearly the pay talks are ongoing. A certain amount has been put into our budget for next year and if it is more than that we will require a supplementary.

Comment on this

Of course. I was not talking about that at all but I appreciate the clarification.

The Department has allocated €687 million to run the scheme. What percentage of that will Bus Éireann receive? Does it receive the full €687 million to administer the programme in 2027?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I will not be able to answer that question fully but I am happy to come back.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

We have budgeted for next year a figure of €557 million, which we have provided to the Department. That is with the fees as they are at the moment notwithstanding the comment from the Department of education. We have to budget everything as is.

Comment on this

How do we get from €687 million to €557 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

I will take that. We have other costs that we meet such as the cost of school bus escorts, the cost of grants to students where we are not in a position to put the services in place. While the substantial amount of the moneys that school transport costs goes to Bus Éireann, it is not 100%.

Comment on this

Fair enough. I thank Mr. Clohessy. Of the €557 million, what is the sum that goes directly to service providers?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

To answer for the year 2025, 91% of our cost for 2025 went to subcontractors. Roughly 4% to 5% was on delivery of our own services and, to the earlier comments by the Department, between 3% and 5% was on the administration of the scheme.

Comment on this

That is 3% to 5% for administration and the other 5%-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

We provide a certain amount of services ourselves.

Comment on this

Okay. What does the 3% to 5% of administrative costs look like in terms of human resources? How many people are on the school transport team for Bus Éireann?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

I will ask Ms Flynn to answer on the direct part of it.

Comment on this
Ms Miriam Flynn

In the region of 300 are fully deployed on school transport. That includes our drivers, supervisors and our clerical and executive teams that operate across 11 or 12 locations around the country. We also have 11 employees as part of the school transport management charge at different functional levels that are fully allocated to supporting the business. Based on the scale of procurement, a significant portion of that relates to the procurement of resources that we have dedicated in the area, which is extremely vast. We had about 40 that are full time equivalent from our indirect charge but they are really allocations of people who support the scheme in different capacities across the functions in the business.

Comment on this

Can we home in very specifically on people who deal with applications, front-facing communications either with families or public representatives or the logistical side of the tendering piece, which is to say nothing to do with the routes Bus Éireann runs? I imagine there is a school transport office. How many people look after the allocation of tickets and the customer service side of that?

Comment on this
Ms Miriam Flynn

We have in the region of 90 administration staff who work on those areas and we have a further 49 supervisors. They work very closely together. They work hand-in-hand in assessing applications, trying to determine what the optimum transport solution is and subsequently ensuring those tickets are allocated to people who are eligible under the scheme.

Comment on this

Let us round that up to 150. There is 90 and 49. Is that their full time, year-round, only job? They are not seconded for three months at a time and then they go back to previous roles. Their only focus is school transport.

Comment on this
Ms Miriam Flynn

That is correct.

Comment on this

Has it always been that way?

Comment on this
Ms Miriam Flynn

It absolutely has. We have 11 regional offices and they deal exclusively with school transport. For context, we start planning our school year now for next year. Our CFO has outlined the scale of our procurement. We are already looking at the routes that will need to go to tender next year. We are already starting planning for the routes that will go to procurement. We are looking at opening our portal in February. From February until May applications come in. This year we looked at making some improvements by offering one application and payment deadline but it was causing some confusion for customers originally. In conjunction with the Department, we found an improvement in mainstream applications in particular. Once it comes to May we are scheduling, assessing capacity on routes and trying to determine where we need additional capacity for pupils who are eligible under the scheme. Following from that, we have to procure the additional services as required. We are dealing with special educational needs programmes.

The other growth area we have seen in particular over the last couple of years is the summer programme for children with special educational needs. That has gone from 6,000 to over 11,000 children in the last couple of years. Again, that involves huge logistics and planning from the team to arrange that during the summer period in addition to working with over 6,500 new applications for special education needs. It really is an all round operation because every day we have to-----

Comment on this

That is really reassuring. I thank Ms Flynn.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Can I come in there? I was going to give the Deputy the breakdown of that number as well. It is something we look at on a monthly basis and we have meetings every six months to go into a huge amount of detail on that administrative overhead. It does get a huge amount of scrutiny.

Comment on this

If the Chair will allow me to squeeze in one more question, Kildare is not unique but there is a context in Kildare which I think will also affect Wicklow, Meath and any significant urban populations where there is significant population growth. Eligibility criteria mean that if I cannot get a place in my closest school I have to go to a school that is further away but which pushes me out of the eligibility criteria. There have been people in my area this year who have lost out on a school ticket because they were unable to get the closest school place to them.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The rules are the distance rule and then the nearest school but if your nearest school is full, if you have a letter that shows you applied and it is full you are then eligible for the next nearest school.

Comment on this

Is it the next nearest school or the school of one's choice after that?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

No, the next nearest school and if it is full, one can go to the next nearest and the next nearest so one remains eligible. If one has to go further and further, one remains eligible if those schools are full. It is not one's fault that those schools are full so one remains eligible, but there has to be some containment.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The school transport review says that we should drop the nearest or next nearest approach so it is policy that we should do that. Clearly if we do that, there will be increased demand. It is also more difficult for Mr. Loftus to do his job in terms of planning for local school need in the community if parents are going further afield all the time. It is harder to plan for provision but nonetheless-----

Comment on this

But not by choice. I do not think the demand piece will come because it is not an issue of choice. I completely accept if people choose to go to a school that is 40 minutes away-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

If the school is full, one is entitled to the next nearest school.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Every year, one can set one's watch and one's calendar by it. Come August and September, the e-mails and phone calls start coming in. Children apply and get tickets, either concessionary or non-concessionary, or are unsuccessful. Many get tickets only to find out that the route they were on during the previous year does not have a driver and the operator has pulled out, causing chaos and mayhem. How many children have received tickets for this year and their parents have paid, only to subsequently discover that there is no bus or the operator has pulled out at the start of the school year?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask Bus Éireann to come in on the specifics. All eligible children on mainstream who applied and paid on time have a service at the moment. At the beginning of the year, there were two routes in Wicklow where the children were eligible - they had paid and applied on time - but the routes were not available when schools opened. That is very regrettable but by the end of September they were available.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

So only two routes nationally-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Yes, at the beginning of September.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

And both of them were in Wicklow.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Special education is slightly different because in special education, we are still receiving 80 applications per week. There are some children in special education who are still waiting because genuinely, it does - not unreasonably - take Bus Éireann a few weeks.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

How many children in special education do we have figures on?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Of the children from last year who were known to us who were there last year, 33 do not yet have a service. That number is a few days old at this stage but Bus Éireann is working really hard on that.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is a real failure.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

As we talked about earlier, the special educational needs service is very customised. Bus Éireann tries really hard but there is not always driver or vehicle availability and it has to go through procurement. A total of 33 who had a service last year were delayed in accessing services.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I want to go back to the two routes in Wicklow. In previous years, it has been more widespread. I think the witnesses would have to acknowledge that. What is the reason for that? Why was there no bus operator for the routes this year?

Comment on this
Ms Miriam Flynn

It was actually one route in Wicklow. We had one route in Galway on the mainstream side. To clarify, the route in Galway was only off for about a day or two. We managed to get the service back up and running again within 24 hours. Unfortunately, on the Wicklow side, it was an operational issue that we were advised about at short notice with no driver. The local teams endeavoured to try to ensure they could get cover as soon as possible. We were very conscious that there were probably far more children last year at the start of the school year. We had 29 vehicles last year in mainstream where there was no service at the start of the school year. We have worked very hard with the Department in terms of our planning for mainstream applications. We have worked very hard in terms of our planning period and bringing it back to 8 May to allow us a bit more time to try to get those resources in place. All mainstream services are operating currently.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

So there are no pupils in receipt of an interim grant or any other form of-----

Comment on this
Ms Miriam Flynn

At present, no.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Obviously there is the ongoing issue of driver shortage across the board. How is that impacting the service and what measures are being taken? I know some interim measures have been taken to increase the age limit to 72 for smaller vehicles. Why is it only for smaller vehicles? Why has it not been increased for larger vehicles, where the age limit remains at 70? Correct me if I am wrong. What is the rationale for that?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will come in first and Bus Éireann might come in on the age limit of 70. For us, the shortage of drivers is not as bad as it was but it remains an issue. We are working very closely with the Department of Transport, which has launched a major initiative to attract more drivers. We have done some local work with our ETBs to encourage them to do more in the further education space. It is something that, nationally, the Department of Transport is working on. We have a couple of actions under its recently published action plan to assist with that. I will hand over to Ms O'Sullivan on the over-70s rule.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

The over-70s issue is something that comes up all of the time. In partnership with the Department of education, we agreed to have an independent survey done, which was commissioned by the Department of Transport via the RSA using Professor Desmond O'Neill, who is an expert on older people in terms of the risks related to driving. Our board had a good detailed account of that particular report. There are significant safety issues regarding-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

On that point, safety concerns have always been cited. Absolutely, children's safely has to be paramount. This metric or rule is being used for school buses. An operator can come into the same school that has stopped anyone over the age of 70 driving a larger vehicle, get the kids and bring them off to a swimming lesson or an excursion and that bus driver could be over 70. Safety risks are cited as a metric but those safety risks do not apply with the same operator or a different operator and a driver over the age of 70 who is obviously fit and able to come in, drive a larger bus and bring the kids off to a swimming lesson. What is the Department's view on that? Surely that makes no sense whatsoever.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Bus Éireann administers the scheme on our behalf and this is a rule it has representing that research evidence.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Surely that makes a mockery of that rule.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

Our policy is the Bus Éireann policy for school transport. We take it seriously with regard to the safety piece. It is informed by Professor O'Neill's views in terms of a published report that was previously given to this committee. On a pilot basis, the board and the executive have looked at over-70s up to the age of 72 on smaller vehicles. In the report-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Would it not make sense for that to be extended for anyone over the age of 70 for all vehicles once the person meets the criteria after an assessment and ability test every year? Would that not make sense?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

Not based on the evidence suggested in the report. Professor O'Neill has done considerable work in terms of talking to all of the experts within the field in determining that report. The issues that arise with over-70s in terms of driving a vehicle with children concern response rates. If something happens on that vehicle with children, the only other adult on the vehicle is the driver. There are serious concerns-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The same applies to the same driver possibly driving the same children to a swimming lesson.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I totally appreciate that but it is not under our policy.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will move on, but it is an issue for the Department along with the Department of Transport. I will move on to the issue of special needs pupils, specifically, the cost of taxis. A figure of €143 million was given for the provision of taxis in 2025. Am I right in saying that? What percentage of the overall school transport cost is that? Is it 20% or 22%? Do we have those figures? When the witnesses are getting that, they might be able to give us the figure for how many taxis were involved. I think a figure of 2,000 was given earlier.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

It is 3,000.

There are 3,000 taxis, of which 740 are for single-use.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Some 740 are single-use. Okay. What is the longest distance an SEN pupil is travelling in a taxi?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

There is a child with a lengthy journey whom we spoke about earlier.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

One is travelling more than 300 km. It is somewhere around 330 km per day.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

How many pupils are in that? One.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I do not know about the individual circumstance, so I could be wrong, but we know some of the very long distances are associated with the school for the deaf. These are circumstances where children and families choose to attend a very specialist place. Again, I do not know about that individual child; I am just speaking generally.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I do not want to get into individual circumstances or cases but I am interested. There is a round journey of more than 300 km and I am aware of one case where the pupil has to travel two hours in each direction. That could be the same case; I am not quite sure.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

As the Cathaoirleach knows, by us increasing the number of special schools and special classes, we are going to reduce that over time.

Comment on this