We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

School Transport and Special Education: Discussion

Summary

School transport cost €479 million in 2025, with the Comptroller and Auditor General attributing the overspend to underfunded estimates and calling for clearer reporting of special-education spending. The Department said rising demand, particularly for pupils with special educational needs, drove costs, and that the structural funding shortfall had been addressed; it is implementing a review intended to expand access and improve integration with public transport. Members raised concerns about eligibility rules, unused seats, poor communication and delays in special-needs support, while the Department cited substantial growth in special classes, staff and school places. Ticket charges are due to return to 2021–22 levels for 2027–28, while most costs remain publicly subsidised.

Contributions 399–604 of 604. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I get that, but I am worried about the here and now, the cost to the taxpayer and the Exchequer, and, obviously, about whether it is the best fit for the pupil. From my experience speaking to families and kids, they want to be in the local area. It is the failure of successive Governments over many years to put those localised educational requirements-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We are doing it now and I know the Cathaoirleach accepts that.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

You are doing it.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The other thing is that the parents notify system allows parents to apply to switch.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Regarding the case we were talking about, with the 330 km round trip, is there a transport escort?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

I assume so. I will have to check that but I presume there is.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

We do not provide the escort, so we would have to check that.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There may not be. Individual children have very different needs. A bus escort is only used when it is required.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Regarding that particular case, how much does it cost to provide that taxi service? Do we have that figure?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

That is a very specific service. It costs in excess of €109,000 per year.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay, and possibly the cost of an escort on top of that. The witnesses can see the concerns there, both in terms of the failure to the student, and also the huge financial cost to the taxpayer. It is quite concerning.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

To answer the Cathaoirleach’s previous question, Bus Éireann’s figures for 2025 show that 27% of our total costs for school transport related to taxis.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Do we have an overall cost for the transport escorts or bus escorts?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We do.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

What is the overall cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

It is just north of €80 million for 2026 and projected to be €90 million for 2027.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That is more than 5,700 bus escorts. Of 24,400 children who were on special educational transport, more than 5,000 had a bus escort.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Does the Department feel that is an efficient use of resources? I hear what the witnesses are saying in terms of what is going in now, but does the Department view that as an efficient use of badly-needed resources?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

First and foremost, our responsibility is to meet the constitutional rights of children to an education. Giving children access to education is our responsibility. After that, we absolutely want to do it in the best, most efficient way possible. Are those costs acceptable? No. That is why we are doing so much. The Deputies have acknowledged what has been done. We have doubled the number of special classes since 2020. There are 20 new special schools. We are working to change the situation but, as I said, some of it is going to take time to work through. We will reduce those costs.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Correct me if I am wrong but it seems Ms McNally is saying there has been, and reading between the lines there has been, extensive analysis carried out on providing adequate special classes, which is, and has to be, paramount. There is huge demand there. I am conscious of many parents not able to get a place for their child in any class who are forced into situations such as this. That certainly fails everybody. What analysis has been conducted on how providing adequate special classes in local areas could reduce the need for private taxis and costs?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That is the whole objective. It is absolutely the objective.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Has there been a stand-alone analysis carried out on it?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

What we are looking at is – Ms Mannion might want to come in on this - what the special education prevalence is and how it is growing. We were down at one point something percent and grew to 2%. We were at 3.2% and we are now at 3.5% or 3.6% and it could go to 5%. Mr. Loftus and Ms Mannion work really closely to increase special provision. Approximately 75% of post-primary schools have special classes, with more planned. We have 1,300 very small primary schools and we cannot say we will have a special class in every single one of them within the next couple of years but we are targeting every primary school with eight classes or more. A huge amount of work has been done to plan to have as much specialist provision locally as can be delivered. Ms Mannion may wish to come in on this.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

We actually spent a considerable period of time in 2022 looking at how to provide the scale of special education provision. Ms McNally spoke about moving up to 3.6%. Internationally, approximately 5% of provision is in specialist placements, so we are trying to increase the provision all the time. When we looked at this, we were able to see not just on a national level - we actually broke it down by school planning area because there are variations across the country - whether families prefer special classes over special schools. We have tried to be more targeted in our response. Our circulars and information sent out to schools in recent years talked about targeting those schools with eight classes or more which have no special classes. That is because those are large areas where the children live. In other times, there would have been smaller schools, perhaps outside the town, that offered to open a special class. We went back to those and that is how we massively increased the numbers. If we look at a school with eight classes or more, that is where the children are in those towns. If we open the class in that school in the town, we ensure those children get local provision.

The parents notify information has been hugely valuable. We have opened 71 inclusive special classes for children already in those schools, which meant those children did not need to leave the school to go to an alternative provision and thus it avoided incurring special education school transport costs. We are coming at this not just at a national level, but at a local school planning area level. Those 71 inclusive classes this year have been very important.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Finally before I allow my colleagues back in, we are talking about children who have been lucky enough, if that is the right word, to get a place. We know some parents are forced to take legal cases against the Department to vindicate their right for their children to receive appropriate education, something they are legally entitled to. In June, we got correspondence provided by the Department that showed that €2.043 million had been spent since 2022 on legal costs and court settlements in cases involving families seeking appropriate school places for their children. That included €567,000 in 2022, €399,000 in 2023, €661,000 in 2024, €251,000 in 2025, and up to that point in 2026 it was €165,000. We were told there were 17 pre-litigation cases in 2022. In 2025 that jumped to 163. Can we get updated figures in relation to pre-litigation and-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will ask Ms Mannion to come in but before she comes in I really have to send a strong message to parents that we are absolutely committed to making special class places available for children. Ms Mannion will come in with the numbers but, honestly, cases do not progress because we resolve them and we are able to show parents that there are places. We have 800 places in special classes available at the moment. We are meeting the need. When it is identified, we are meeting the need. Some parents - and I have absolute empathy and sympathy for them - take a case because they are really worried. What I would say to them is that we have doubled the numbers. The committee has heard all of this. I would ask them to please talk to their local SENO.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

They would say the only reason it is resolved is because they have taken legal action.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

And I would say that is not the case.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

We have been very clear with parents but we have also been very clear in our defence in these cases before the courts.

That is 100% not the case. On the delivery of the provision, we talked about the planning a little earlier. That is what is giving the number of places. There are 800 vacancies across the country as of today. In answer to the Cathaoirleach's specific questions-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Can we get the figures?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

Yes. The legal costs paid to date in 2026 come to €333,000 and there are 98 pre-litigation matters on hand. These are a mixture of matters relating to school places and other special education litigation matters. To repeat, none of those cases have proceeding to a hearing. We have worked with the families to resolve them. There are places available. You do not need to take a court case to get a place.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

How many cases have been initiated that specifically relate to the September 2026 enrolment?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

There are 65 judicial review cases that relate to school places.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is for 2026.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

Yes, there are currently 65.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Ms Mannion for that.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

I am just saying that places are available. We are trying to work with those families to support them into those existing places.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Unfortunately, it is the experience of many families that the only way they see to vindicate their rights is to take-----

Comment on this
Ms Martina Mannion

The vacancies are there.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That is why I would encourage families to talk to their local SENO as early as possible. The places are there.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I propose to again open up the discussion to my colleagues for a shorter round of supplementary questions if that is okay with all of our witnesses. I call Deputy Bennett, who has five minutes.

Comment on this

I will go back to what Ms McNally said about every child having a constitutional right to education. Will she explain that to me? I do not think I got it. On the eligibility criteria, why would somebody not be eligible?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Every child has a constitutional right to an education. That is a fact. The school transport scheme is a slightly separate matter. This scheme is operated. There is no constitutional right to a school transport scheme. It was deemed that it had to be within reason. Back then, it was decided that 3.2 km for a primary school child and 4.8 km for a post-primary school child would be the eligibility rules. It also had to be the nearest school.

Comment on this

I know people in Monaghan who live outside the parameters of this 4.8 km. They actually live further away than that. Why are they not eligible?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

If they live further away than that, they are eligible.

Comment on this

They had their money returned. They paid for the tickets before the date and-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It may be the case that they are not going to their nearest school. It must be that their nearest school has places.

Comment on this

How many applications have been refused in Monaghan? How many of those who applied for tickets did not get one?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I will check whether Bus Éireann has that number but, to be clear, it is only non-eligible children who have not got a seat. Non-eligible children can apply and pay their money.

Comment on this

These children were eligible and then got a response and had their money refunded. I am just wondering why that happened.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Would Ms Mulhall like to come in on that?

Comment on this
Ms Barbara Mulhall

Where there is capacity and where there are vehicles, all eligible children have a place on a school transport vehicle. We will certainly look into any cases the Deputy has on hand, but there-----

Comment on this

That is okay. Is it Ms Mulhall I should come back to on that? I will email her details of the cases.

Comment on this
Ms Barbara Mulhall

Yes, it is. However, we can categorically say that all eligible children have a space, where capacity is available.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Could this relate to the rule about there being fewer than ten children?

Comment on this
Ms Barbara Mulhall

There must be more than ten in a distinct locality before a service can be established.

Comment on this

If a bus is already full, is another bus put on?

Comment on this
Ms Barbara Mulhall

If there are eligible children, all eligible children are facilitated first.

Comment on this

I will bring Ms Mulhall details of the case. On the distance, how far from a school will a bus go? What is the biggest distance?

Comment on this
Ms Barbara Mulhall

Bus Éireann might be able to assist with that question. The mainstream buses may go to more than one school. They would have certain pick-up points along the route. A bus could go to a primary and a post-primary centre that facilitates a number of schools. We might not have details of the distance travelled. I do not know. Does Ms Flynn have any detail on that?

Comment on this
Ms Miriam Flynn

With regard to mainstream transport in particular, the routes are planned based on the number of eligible pupils presenting. There are clearly defined guidelines issued by the Department. Where possible, we try to ensure that people get services within a certain distance of a pick-up point. As I have said, the routes are primarily designed around eligible pupils. They do vary. On Ms Mulhall's point, where possible, we try to ensure our vehicles operate both a primary and post-primary service. That is to try to ensure we optimise the use of the resources we have. The distances can vary. It is quite difficult to give a unified answer.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

To be clear, the remote area grant is available to some families if there is no service.

Comment on this

I am sorry. What was that called?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It is the remote area grant. It applies where there is no service. This is a result of the rules. Again, there has to be ten children in an area to be serviced by a route. If we cannot provide a service but a child is eligible, the family can get a remote area grant.

Comment on this

Will you get a remote area grant if there are no buses in the area? How much of a grant do you get?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It is a daily rate with a maximum per week.

Comment on this

What do the families use that for if there are no buses or public transport?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It can be used to cover parental costs or some other arrangements they make.

Comment on this

I will move on from those questions. Can I have clarity on the total income that Bus Éireann receives from the Department?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There are two elements. Again, Bus Éireann may come in on this. There is the administrative charge and then there is the charge for its services. The administrative charge in 2025 was €15.2 million.

Comment on this

It was €15.2 million. What was the charge for the school transport service?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

It was approximately €457 million.

Comment on this

It was €457 million but that is going up to €641 million this year. Am I correct in that?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

That was in 2025.

Comment on this

That was in 2025. What is going up to in 2027?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

It will be €557 million.

Comment on this

It will be €557 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

To be clear, that is based on Bus Éireann's numbers.

Comment on this

Am I correct that the total income will be €641 million?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The total transport budget for the Department and Bus Éireann in 2027 is currently €687 million.

Comment on this

How much income does Bus Éireann take in outside of the school transport scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

Our total revenue for this year will be just under €900 million.

Comment on this

It therefore takes in two thirds more.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

It is €457 million out of €900 million. It is basically half the figure, so about two thirds.

Comment on this

Two thirds of Bus Éireann's income comes from school transport.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

I think we are mixing up the years.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

I am referring to this year. This year, 2026, our turnover should be in the region of just under €900 million.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

In 2026, our whole budget is €641 million. Bus Éireann only gets some of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

I apologise to the Deputy. If I may clarify, our revenue in 2025 was about €770 million, of which €457 million related to school transport. I am sorry. I was crossing three different years in addressing the question.

Comment on this

The school transport scheme still accounts for two thirds of Bus Éireann's income, however. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

If you were to get into it, you could say it is two thirds of our gross funding. However, we are obviously not completely funded. We have some-----

Comment on this

If Bus Éireann lost that contract, it would be gone.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

To be clear, 91% of it goes to subcontractors, as we talked about earlier.

Comment on this

Two thirds of Bus Éireann's income comes from the Department, however.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Delaney

As the Deputy says it, yes.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It is probably important to say that Bus Éireann provides this service for us on a cost-recovery basis only. It is not for profit. The other arm of its business has a different commercial arrangement.

Comment on this

I mentioned salaries in Bus Éireann earlier on. There seems to be great salaries in Bus Éireann. I am again bringing it back to the fact that the Department is paying two thirds of the salaries in Bus Éireann. We would also have travel-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

As I mentioned earlier, we have an apportionment. It is agreed under the accounting arrangements we have in place. The proportion of Bus Éireann's other costs we pay was independently and externally decided. We pay an independently agreed proportion of other costs.

Comment on this

That is fine. I have noticed that, in her package, Ms O'Sullivan also got an electric car valued at €65,000. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I do not think it is valued at €65,000. It is one of the fleet cars used by the whole business. I have the same car as the supervisors.

Comment on this

It is the same car used by all of Bus Éireann.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

Anybody who needs a fleet car in Bus Éireann, for example, supervisors and other members, because they are out on the road with-----

Comment on this

How many fleet cars are on the road?

Comment on this
Ms. Jean O'Sullivan

Between our supervisors, mechanics and vehicles, I am not quite sure.

Comment on this

Does Bus Éireann supply all of those employees with cars?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

If they need a car for work. I refer, for example, to a supervisor who needs to be on the road supervising. In schools, for example, our supervisors would have fleet vehicles. They have to be able to meet all of the 11,500 contractors around the country to evaluate who is on the bus, whether the bus-----

Comment on this

Where are those cars parked? Do the employees, including Ms O'Sullivan, keep the car at home?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I keep my car and I pay benefit-in-kind on it. The other cars are fleet cars. They are typically parked up-----

Comment on this

Could Ms O'Sullivan remind me of the number of fleet cars?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

The fleet cars are work cars. They are used for work business. My car-----

Comment on this

I know they are fleet cars, but two thirds of Bus Éireann's income comes from the Department.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

Two thirds or 91% of Bus Éireann's income is paid out by Bus Éireann. It does not come to Bus Éireann. It is a mechanism to administer the payment to other people. We do not receive that payment. The payment that we receive is the €15 million. We are a conduit for the other payments to be procured in tender processes. Some 91% of that figure does not reside within Bus Éireann. It resides within a mechanism for us to pay the contractors to deliver the backbone of the service we spoke about earlier. It is not our funding.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Ms O'Sullivan might provide details of the size of the fleet and a breakdown of electric vehicles versus normal petrol or diesel cars.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

Yes.

Comment on this

I thank all the witnesses for staying with us. I am going to go back to the school transport review of 2024 because I did not get enough time on it earlier. Ms McNally said implementation is somewhere around 40%-plus in terms of that review. How many recommendations were made in the review?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There were 27 recommendations. A few of them did not require action because they were recommendations to maintain the status quo, as such. There were about 24 recommendations that required action. All of those are advancing, and 42% are complete.

Comment on this

Could Ms McNally provide the headline in terms of what the completed ones involve?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

They are broken down, for example, around eligibility, rules, integration, special educational need and data. Under eligibility, there were 25 pilots. We did 11 pilots in the first year and 14 in the second. The 25 pilots are advancing. They have been maintained for the 2026-27 school year. They are testing the distance rules other Deputies spoke about, including the nearest school rule, integration and so on. They are testing a number of the concepts and the recommendations.

Comment on this

Is it mainly on a pilot basis?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

They are being done on a pilot basis. We feel that is the prudent way to do it. It is also because if we have to build capacity and so on, it is a way of testing the market. Colleagues have referred to the fact that it is highlighting problems. For example, in one of them, the demand in Rochfortbridge went through the roof. There was a 500% increase. Children and young people who had other alternatives sought to move from them onto this route, so it raised issues about supply, not just affordability, but also of vehicles and drivers.

Comment on this

Just to clarify, when Ms McNally says 42% of the recommendations are complete, is she saying that the pilots have been completed?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

No, they would not be complete. I will give the Deputy an example of something that might be complete or that is very nearly there, namely the application form. We want to put the application online for families applying for their child who has special educational needs, to make it easier for them and better for us for data collection. That is nearly over the line.

Comment on this

Are the pilot schemes not considered complete?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

No.

Comment on this

They are a work in progress.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

They are leading towards the integration.

Comment on this

In terms of what remains, Ms McNally mentioned integration as one of the key recommendations. What are the other key recommendations that have yet be to be fully implemented?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The data utilisation. We have done a lot of work. We have tested other systems but we now have to decide on the system that we are going to use in order that we will have live data that we will be able to use and plan routes accordingly. That is very much a work in progress.

Comment on this

I apologise if I missed it because I had to attend another committee meeting. How is the under-utilisation of spaces that are taken up but not used being addressed?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I explained that at the moment, for safety purposes, we have one seat per ticket. We are addressing it in a few different ways. We are progressing the utilisation data. We need those IT systems. The reintroduction of the fees back to the 2021-22 levels is a way to encourage parents who were not really using the ticket to only apply for it if they are going to use it. I have gone blank now.

Comment on this

Ms McNally touched on it. I apologise if I missed it, but do we have a clear picture on the data collection of the under-utilisation of spaces?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

No, we do not.

Comment on this

Is the vacancy rate 20% or 30%?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We just do not have accurate enough data to say. It varies from day to day.

Comment on this

Surely Bus Éireann is in a position to relay that information back in terms of areas.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Bus Éireann can come in on this, but because the service is outsourced and it is procuring private contractors, it is very difficult to get reliable data. Bus Éireann might come in on that.

Comment on this

To be fair to Bus Éireann, it is the Department that is paying for the service.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

Absolutely, yes.

Comment on this

It is the Department's responsibility to ensure that the information comes back to it, as the service provider.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

What I am saying is that some data have been shared. Mr. Clohessy will come in on this. Bus Éireann never suggested that it was adequate but there is not enough reliable data, so we need the utilisation and the technology.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

In the couple of instances where we have run them, they have been really insightful and helpful. What we have found is that it is much more nuanced than whether a child is using a space or not. They are using it at different times. They might be using it in the morning or in the afternoon. Sometimes they cannot use it because of after-school activities-----

Comment on this

Yes, sporadically.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Clohessy

-----and more sporadically. That is why the technology requirement is there; it is to really get into the issue and give a proper insight into it.

Comment on this

If we take the example of a child who has a ticket and a seat and who may use it 30% of the time, because the parents may not be able to drive them on certain days of the week and then they use the bus, is that appropriate when there is another child who would use the place five days of the week and does not have a seat?

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will let the Comptroller and Auditor General in before Ms McNally replies if that is okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

We undertook a special report, which, I think, we published in 2017. We were looking at data that was available from 2015. We included a reference to a survey the Department asked CIÉ to carry out. It looked at 34 primary routes and 11 post-primary routes. The key finding was that at primary level 61% of tickets issued were being used in the morning and 70% in the afternoon. At post-primary level, morning and afternoon ticket usage was 75% and 72%. I am just referencing it because, obviously, it is a methodology. It is not perfect, but if there was a selection of representative routes at least we would have some angle on the utilisation. It is not a substitute for proper ticketing.

Comment on this

Based on that, it is somewhere in the region of 30% plus of seats that are not used.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

Correct. Obviously, there might be a different pattern for each child but, on average, the utilisation on buses was between 60% and 70%.

Comment on this

It seems a high amount of wastage, in terms of the service that is being provided, if 30% of the seats are not filled. That is one of the frustrations for parents when their child cannot get a seat and they report back to us, as public representatives, and we know there are empty seats on the bus every day.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

It is a difficult policy to grapple with.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

The safety of the children has to come first. As Mr. Clohessy said, occupancy can be very sporadic. We also know from another policy area in the Department about attendance that the attendance of children in school has dropped. It is improving again but 20% of children are absent for more than 20 days a year. Between attendance issues, medical issues and extracurricular activities it is quite difficult.

Comment on this

I understand that it is complex. We cannot take the roll call every day to see who is on the bus.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We could have a policy of use it or lose it, as has been said.

Comment on this

In terms of a certain amount of use anyway.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

That may be where we are going.

Comment on this

How that is recorded is another issue. How do we capture that information? I understand it requires a lot of forensic analysis, but the Comptroller and Auditor General's report was published in 2017; it is now 2026.

It does appear that there is a lot of work needed in this area to try to improve the levels of vacancy and waste in the system.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We are definitely not where we want to be on the utilisation data. We would like to be ahead of where we are with the technology.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I have a number of concluding questions. Regarding school building projects, especially in terms of special education, a couple of terms were used earlier on. Ms McNally talked about really strong forward planning. Robust forward planning was also mentioned.

I want to give an example where that has failed and failed dismally. It relates to a school community in my constituency, namely, Kilcoole Primary School, which has been fighting over many years to do away with prefabricated buildings on the school grounds. There have been prefabricated buildings there since 2011. There has been extensive planning engagement and, thankfully, it has moved to the construction of the new school and the refurbishment of another premises. Unfortunately, the school principal and teachers have been told now, at this stage, there are going to be four prefabricated buildings put on site, even though the refurbishment work is ongoing. The school community thought they had seen the end of prefabricated buildings, but here we are back to this situation. That robust planning has failed and failed dismally.

Correspondence has been circulated that cites that in the case of Kilcoole Primary School the requirement of two special needs classes was identified well into the process. Why was there such a dismal failure that has led to a situation where parents and teachers are saying they fear segregation is now going to take between children with additional educational requirements and every other child in the school? Why was there such a failure in this situation?

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

As this relates to an individual school, I will ask Mr. Loftus to come in on this.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Generally, I do not accept that the Department has had a dismal failure in terms of its forward planning. We do a huge amount of forward planning. In the constituency itself more generally, we have invested almost €250 million since 2021, completing a very significant number of projects. Over 40% of the schools in the constituency have had additional capacity or improvements made to them, which is reflective of the forward planning being done.

In terms of the school referenced, Kilcoole Primary School is one of the projects we currently have on site. It is a 24-classroom school building that will be there. The school currently has 23 classroom teachers. We are looking at how we might add additional capacity. In terms of modular accommodation, which is one of our delivery mechanisms for permanent accommodation, that is the mechanism we are looking at in that context. In making that judgment, we considered, from a value-for-money perspective, what is the most appropriate method for adding additional capacity at the school itself. It also adds a bit of flexibility because primary pupil projections for Kilcoole, as part of our forward planning, are at or near peak and will ultimately start to reduce. That gives us a bit of flexibility in how we manage it.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The robust forward planning should surely have captured that to ensure there was no necessity for prefabricated buildings. Mr. Loftus cites all the different metrics and all the positives, but I would argue all day that the school community still sees these prefabricated buildings as temporary, substandard and not as high standard as a permanent build. This is something ongoing and on-site as we speak here, and there is correspondence from the Department that said it was laid out in the process that this additional need was identified. That is a failure of forward planning.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

There is a world of difference between what historical prefabricated buildings were, even when I went to school, compared with the modular accommodation which is one of our permanent solutions. I put a lot of work into that piece. I would also make the general point that the school will ultimately have 24 classrooms as part of the project. We are looking at adding capacity there too. It currently has 23 classroom teachers.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Why was that additional need not identified in the robust forward planning process, which you have alluded to consistently?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

That project has been in our pipeline for quite a while.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is it the delays that have led to this serious failure, that, in my view and the view of teachers, pupils and parents in Kilcoole, is going to lead to a substandard build? Is it the delays that have led to this?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

I do not accept that.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is what you have said. This has been an ongoing, lengthy process and in that process this additional need was identified.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

It is an ongoing process and, yes, that project had to work its way through the pipeline to construction, and that is where it is. Ultimately, it is a 24-classroom building between the two amalgamations of schools there. They currently have 23 classroom teachers. The extra modular accommodation, which is a permanent solution and a world of a difference compared with historical prefabricated-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

To conclude on this, at this point is the Department not prepared to move to a permanent build, away from the current model in which-----

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

The modular is a permanent solution. There is flexibility in how they are used.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

What is the lifespan on these?

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

For any project we deliver, regardless of the delivery mechanism, our technical guidance is based on a 60-year lifespan. Obviously, that lifespan then adjusts-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

So, those prefabricated buildings are going to last 60 years. That is not permanent.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

Any of our buildings have a technical span of 60 years. However, that gets extended through maintenance, and we always send a strong message on preventative maintenance. That is a strong aspect of our national development plan going forward.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I want to conclude on this topic, but I urge and call on the Department to look at this particular case again. The community has been failed. The Department's system, according to Mr. Loftus's own words, through the length of time it has taken to get from stage 1 right the way through, has failed the community of Kilcoole. I am sure that is replicated in many towns and villages right across the State, with failure and delays in progressing essential builds.

Comment on this
Mr. Hubert Loftus

To make a final point, we ultimately make those decisions in regard to what we consider the most value-for-money solution to achieve that.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

We have to be fair and objective here. There has been a huge amount of delivery across the school building programme and the statistics and the facts are there. There has been massive delivery in terms of new builds, brand new schools and extensions to schools. The volume and scale are huge, and the quality is generally really high as well.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I want to return to Bus Éireann. I welcome its representatives are here today and I am conscious that Bus Éireann is here on a voluntary basis and is not audited by the C and AG, and therefore we do not have a role in scrutinising its books. That is a major failure, not of the representatives' doing, but of Government. I think that needs to change, not just as regards Bus Éireann, but also other commercial semi-State bodies. However, I welcome the fact Bus Éireann is here.

It would be a missed opportunity for me not to raise a number of local constituency failures by Bus Éireann on routes other than the school transport routes it provides. In County Wicklow we have a number of routes, including the 131, 132 and 133. I continually get complaints about all of those routes. Can I ask a more general question first? What is the most complained-about route Bus Éireann operates in the State?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I would say the most complained-about route is in Cork.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am conscious that in 2018 and 2019 the 133 that runs between Wicklow town and the city centre was the most complained-about route. There were 899 complaints about that route. If the volume of complaints I get from constituents on a daily and weekly basis is sent on to Bus Éireann, I am sure the 133 is up there as one of the most complained-about routes in the State. Would I be right in saying that?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I am not sure, to be honest. As the Chair knows, there is an infrastructure piece we are all building on. One aspect is that we have an ageing fleet and we are getting newer fleet all the time, and we very much welcome the investment from the National Transport Authority. We also have a capacity issue. The complaints we are currently getting relate to capacity issues in terms of the vehicles running on those routes and the fact that they are an ageing fleet. That is just a timing thing, because the new fleet is coming into the country.

We are now working on considerable EV projects to utilise the new EV vehicles that are also coming on board. All I can say is our commitment-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

In the new fleet coming into the country, I think there are 60 buses. That is expected between now and the end of 2027. That does not give much hope to my constituents who use the 132 between Bunclody and Connolly Station. It runs through Baltinglass and Wicklow. For many days over the past weeks there has been no service because one of the limited buses that serves the route has been undergoing maintenance because it is consistently breaking down. Are we serious here that we do not have additional buses to put on to ensure a critical service for a rural community can have continuity of service? Is Ms O'Sullivan telling us that they potentially have to wait until the end of 2027 before the 60 buses come on stream?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

We are getting a delivery of new buses as early as the beginning of next year. They are diesel buses. We are also getting EV buses as they cascade around the country. There are a number of vehicles, including school buses, entering the system next year. We feel that some of it is an infrastructure timeline issue where the newer vehicles will reduce the maintenance issues we are having. We are having significant maintenance issues with older vehicles, but we are replacing them as quickly as we can on a regular basis. That is a commitment of the State.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I turn to the 133 and the 131. Again, they are critical services with ongoing and regular issues in terms of capacity. Students and people going to work are waiting for buses. A bus coming from Wicklow town is driving by them in Newtownmountkennedy or Kilpedder because it is at capacity. Despite repeated requests for additional services to be put on to cater for the huge demand there because it is a fast growing area, the service has not really changed significantly over the past number of years to reflect the huge increase in population and demand. What can Ms O'Sullivan tell people who are being passed by Bus Éireann buses daily in places like Kilpedder?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

We have our allocation of vehicles and the schedules we work on with the NTA. We are in an ongoing engagement with the NTA to deliver additional capacity along numerous routes, including these routes. We are hoping that in this budget funding will be put forward by the NTA across nationally-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

They are hoping, so those-----

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

No, the budget allocation has been made but what routes are going to benefit from it is the piece we are waiting for.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I ask specifically about the 133. An issue I have raised consistently is a park-and-ride facility at Fassaroe in Bray. The facility is built. It cost €11 million in taxpayers' money. The failure by the NTA to forward plan has again resulted in a situation where that facility is locked up under private security because there are no buses to serve it. It has been locked up now for the guts of a year. We have been told by the NTA that the plan was, and is, to increase the capacity of the 133 and put more buses on the route. Where are those negotiations at and when does Bus Éireann expect it will have buses going in to that badly needed park-and-ride facility that is currently locked up?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I do not know the answer to that.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Ms O'Sullivan does not know.

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I do not know the answer to the NTA's approval on opening up the park-and-ride. I can ask the authority and find that out, but I currently do not know the answer.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Has there been any engagement with Bus Éireann over the past year in advance of this park-and-ride facility? It was due to open many months ago. What engagement took place at that stage?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

I do not know. Our operational team would be able to answer that, but they are not here. We are only here with the school transport team, but I can get the answer for the Deputy.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Can Ms O'Sullivan get me a comprehensive answer?

Comment on this
Ms Jean O'Sullivan

No problem.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

More importantly, when is it going to open? That is what people want to hear. There is €11 million of taxpayers' money sitting idle and there is a failure to forward plan. The witnesses can argue with me all day. There is a chronic failure of robust forward planning in the Department of Education and Youth. It is the same with the NTA. I would appreciate a comprehensive report on that, and specifically on when it is going to open and what additional services will be on that critical 133 route between Wicklow town and Dublin city centre.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There is massive forward planning. There is evidence of it and there is evidence of success. We do not always get it right in every case, but the evidence is there and we are happy to provide a report on the evidence of forward planning.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Ms McNally might do that. There may be forward planning, but by the time it goes through that comprehensive, timely, lengthy and cumbersome planning process that forward planning is outdated by the time contracts and contractors move-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

There are also-----

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

This was the case in Kilcoole.

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

No.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank that is reflected in the correspondence that has been given to the school community. This additional capacity was identified late in the lengthy process, and that is the experience-----

Comment on this
Ms Bernie McNally

I have to point out to the Cathaoirleach that we also have budgetary parameters. I am not saying there are not individual circumstances that are delayed but, broadly, the forward planning has delivered. I have to put that on the record.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That concludes our engagement for today. I thank the Secretary General and her officials from the Department of Education and Youth for attending. I also thank the officials from Bus Éireann, the Department of Transport and the C and AG's office for their attendance. Is it agreed that the clerk will seek any follow-up information and carry out any agreed actions arising from the meeting? Agreed. The committee will meet again on Thursday, 12 November 2026 with officials from Greyhound Racing Ireland.

Comment on this