We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Committee on Budgetary Oversight

Implementation of Section 481 Report Recommendations: Discussion

Summary

SIPTU and Irish Equity said section 481’s cap and regional uplift recommendations had been implemented, but worker-focused recommendations remained outstanding. They called for fast-track dispute resolution, stronger enforcement of collective agreements, and audited compliance with employment and copyright obligations as a condition of tax relief. Irish Equity argued that buy-out contracts deny performers fair residual payments and that workers fear raising complaints because of possible blacklisting. Deputies urged the Government to use section 481 funding to improve job quality and security; no decision was taken.

I will explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the House as regards reference witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. Witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentations they make to the committee. This means that they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction. Some of today's witnesses are giving evidence remotely from a place outside of the parliamentary precincts and, as such, may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness physically present would. Those witnesses have already been advised of this and may think it appropriate to take legal advice on this matter.

Members are advised of the constitutional requirement that a member must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex to participate in public meetings. In this regard, I ask any members participating via MS Teams to confirm that they are on the grounds of the Leinster House campus prior to making their contribution to the meeting. Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity either by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Today's engagement forms part of the committee's follow-up examination of its previous report on the film tax credit section 481. In particular, members will examine the process of implementing the recommendations on section 481 as made by the committee. Today's session is split in two. For the first part, I welcome from Irish Equity, Mr. Gerry O'Brien, president, and Ms Jessica Freed, vice president. From SIPTU, I welcome Mr. Robbie Purfield, sector organiser. The committee welcomes the opportunity to engage with the witnesses and I thank them for being here today. I invite Mr. Purfield to make his opening remarks.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

On behalf of our members working in the film industry, SIPTU welcomes the opportunity to discuss implementation of the section 481 recommendations with the Committee on Budgetary Oversight. SIPTU, directly and through its affiliate Irish Equity, represents a substantial number of members working in film and television production on both sides of the camera, leaving us uniquely placed to comment on the report.

While we note that the recommendations on the section 481 cap and regional uplift have been implemented, it is greatly disappointing that those which would materially benefit workers have not. As previously discussed with this committee, the short-term nature of employment means issues arising during a production are often not resolved while the designated activity company, DAC, remains in operation. While we welcome these recommendations, we believe they should have gone further by recommending a bespoke dispute resolution process for the film industry.

There is currently a significant wait for an employee complaint to be heard by the Workplace Relations Commission, WRC, often exceeding a year. Extending the six-month time limit to submit a case to the WRC would therefore still not work. Instead, we call for a dedicated panel of adjudicators ready to hear disputes on a fast-track basis. A comparable process already operates in the construction industry and could be replicated in film and television. It would address concerns in the recommendation about how long a DAC remains open and delays in dispute resolution.

We also believe the recommendations do not go far enough in giving teeth to the enforcement of collective agreements. As it currently stands, SIPTU are signatories to agreements covering crew, construction crew in film and television and, through Irish Equity, agreements for television drama and film, although it should be noted that these agreements are in need of updating. Materially, there is a requirement on productions to comply with requirements under good-quality employment. However, we believe this should have been extended to include full and audited compliance with collective agreements.

If collective bargaining is Government policy, then compliance with collective agreements should form part of the quality-employment test for productions receiving public support under section 481. This would be fully in line with the Government’s obligations under the adequate minimum wage directive to promote collective bargaining in the industry. This would be especially pertinent in an industry in receipt of public funding in this manner. It should be noted that while many producers are members of Screen Producers Ireland, SPI, who we negotiate agreements with, many are not and choose to avoid collective agreements. This increase in enforcement would ensure a level playing field of quality employment across the board.

It should also be noted that our members in Irish Equity are in a further unique position due to their rights under SI 567 of 2021. While our agreements do deal with payments for their entitlements here, they are outdated and in need of renegotiation to better fit the current reality of the industry. We are currently discussing an indigenous low-budget agreement with SPI, however, we will need to also expand and update the agreements we are currently signatories of.

As previously raised by Irish Equity the last time it met with this committee, the real value for our members who are performers is in the copyright attached to their performance. This would need to be enforced in a way that sees agreements and subsequent payments broadly in line with agreements in other jurisdictions. Film and television production is by its nature an international endeavour which crosses borders. Our members should not be left worse off than colleagues from other countries who may have better contracts. Again, this is where we believe that full adherence to the Copyright and Related Acts 2000 and SI 567 of 2021 should be an audited requirement to avail of section 481 funding.

As it stands, there is an inconsistent approach to obligations under these Acts in some instances, with our members not receiving full entitlements.

As I have outlined, while elements of the report have been implemented, it is disappointing the aspects that enhance workers' position have not been. A further recommendation in line with what I have outlined would help give security to workers in the industry while also underpinning both the legislative requirements and the Government's obligation regarding collective bargaining.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here today. Mr. Purfield stated that recommendations relating to the section 481 cap and regional uplift have been implemented but the recommendations that would materially benefit workers have not. Which outstanding recommendations should the Government prioritise and why have they not been implemented to date?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

There are quite a few recommendations. One recommendation is to extend the six-month time limit in relation to referrals to the Workplace Relations Commission, which I referenced. Where an individual has an employment rights case, there is generally a six-month time limit for referral. The failure to implement an extension to that limit should be looked at and addressed. The project-based nature of the work people in the industry undertake means they will have moved on to other productions after six months.

The term "quality employment and training" has not been defined. We would welcome such a definition. As I referenced, we could look at auditing and putting a bit of strength into the requirements. I would be interested to know whether there was follow-up on the successive use of fixed-term contracts in terms of writing to the EU. I understand that would have been a matter for the committee. That is also a very important issue because, again, the nature of the industry on both sides of the camera is that employment is short term or fixed term. This is something that needs clarity.

Without meaning to digress or hold things up, the issue in many of these cases is that employment law, as it stands in this country, is geared towards people going into a factory or other workplace at 18 years of age and potentially coming out of it at a retirement age of 65 or 66. That does not fit the short-term nature of this industry, with people having multiple producers or employers over the course of a year. While I understand the committee is looking to implement the recommendations, and any type of improvement is welcome, they do not go far enough.

Comment on this

Will SIPTU provide the committee with figures on the number of disputes, alleged breaches of collective agreements or causes of performers being unpaid in the past five years? It would be good to get an idea of the true scale of the problem.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

I do not have those details to hand but I certainly can send them to the committee in the next few days, if that works.

Comment on this

That is grand. From cases he has seen, does Mr. Purfield think freelance workers may be afraid to apply their rights or raise complaints because of the fear that doing so could affect their chances of securing work in the future?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

In short, yes, that is very much the case. Without wishing to speak for Mr. O'Brien, the previous time we were before the committee, he spoke about people's fear and concern around the whole concept of "sign or else". That is the nature of the industry. As I said, workers in long-term employment and who are not going anywhere, for want of a better phrase, are more likely to stand up for themselves, whereas there is always a concern among workers in this industry that they will not get the next job if they ask a question.

Comment on this

I want to delve further into the issue of delays in WRC hearings. While film companies have closed in the meantime, the WRC, naturally, must have the resources to deal with complaints within an efficient timeframe. What else can be done to ensure workers can pursue complaints and receive a remedy as efficiently as possible?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

That is a wider question. In general, adjudication going to the WRC is currently taking a number of months to be heard. The service is, in effect, under-resourced as a whole, but the situation is even more acute for workers in this industry. A film production might last for only four to six weeks and a television production could be anything up to six months. That does not sit well or work properly for the WRC. As I said, we need a bespoke fast-track approach to dispute resolution at a very high and basic level, whereby disputes are responded to locally within a set number of days and, where they are not resolved, it is a matter of referring them to a panel of adjudicators in a quicker timeframe than currently applies under the WRC process.

Comment on this

Mr. Purfield referred to copyright entitlements and inconsistences in the application of those rights. What changes to section 481 would ensure producers comply with the copyright Act?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

I will defer to Mr. O'Brien on that question.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

The situation for performers is very different in the film industry because we are covered by two pieces of legislation. The Organisation of Working Time Act applies when we turn up on set to do our job. We are covered by protections for our image and performance under the Copyright and Related Rights Act 2000 and the European directive. When it comes to actors choosing to complain about anything, I have anecdotal stories about what happens. They do not follow through on complaints because there is an existential threat in doing so. That is not just confined to Ireland. I am currently attending the conference in France of the International Federation of Actors, FIA, which is the federation of all the English-speaking unions and all the European unions. All actors have this fear that if they stand up for their rights, having signed a contract that may transgress those rights, they will be blacklisted. It is a very real fear and there have been cases of that happening, as documented by FIA.

The other point is that performers cannot have quality employment when part of the value of their very existence is stripped away within their contract and they do not receive the residual payments they should receive. The legislation states that we should receive fair, proportionate and adequate remuneration. The contract adjustment provision states that this should be proportionate to the revenues generated, not just whatever figure comes out of somebody's accounting practices. We must have a situation where the residuals reflect the economic success of the production. We are currently working under a 2016 agreement, which, regrettably, is no longer fit for purpose under the alterations to and implementation of SI 567. Apparently, it is not a buy-out but it is a licence for ten years providing for unlimited use across all platforms, media and territories. For ten years, the lump-sum fee that is calculated at the point of production is all the performer will get.

If that lump-sum fee is disproportionately low, it is very difficult for performers to challenge the producer because they will have to present all the proof that the figure is disproportionately low, which means understanding the economics of distribution, where the revenues are, and knowing where the programme was sold and how much it was sold for, where the contact allows for that. When there is a buy-out contact, it is not possible to future-proof it for the performer. If all of that is calculated at the point the contract is signed, then the producer, the distributor and everybody down the line knows exactly how much should go to the actor or performer and a collecting society can then collect it and pay it to the performer. Without those structures in place, there cannot be quality employment and there is a failure on that basic tenet of the 481 relief that quality employment be created and provided and that you will also-----

Comment on this

I am sorry, Mr. O'Brien. There are other members who wish to ask questions. He will have other opportunities to speak.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

Sorry. That is basically what I wanted to say.

Comment on this

I welcome Mr. O'Brien, Ms Freed and Mr. Purfield. A lot of people probably do not fully understand the industry. Some of us have been through this and others do not understand. The point Mr. O'Brien is making is that people get paid for being on set on the days they are there, but much, if not most, of the revenue generated by the production is generated downstream. There is no revenue generated on the set.

It is generated because it is sold on, performed and so on. Will Mr. O'Brien explain the buy-out contract? Would it be a fair characterisation to say that actors are told they have to sign away their right to the future revenues that the producer will get from the performance of that production and if they do not sign, they would fear, and they might be right to fear, that they will not work again for that film producer or possibly any film producer? They would be fearful of blacklisting because they questioned the buy-out contract.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

Yes. We signed an agreement in 2016 that had that element in it. It had a licensing agreement for ten years of unlimited use, which means that for ten years, there would be no further payments. The existential threat exists across Europe, but there is a line now that is appearing in the casting advice note, CAN, which states that it is a policy of the company in question that no artist shall be allowed to render services unless they have signed this contract. That means the contract will arrive with a lot of verbiage in it. It will be a 22-page document. A lot the verbiage will not be in the document. Unless the artist agrees to sign that, they are not allowed on set. It is problematic as regards how these contracts are implemented. I find a problem with them, so I have to say that when I examine them. Yes, it is a buy-out. That is the definition of a buy-out.

Comment on this

What can the Government do about this and what the committee can recommend? That is the question here. We are giving money to these film producers to provide quality employment and training. The Government could clarify to the producer that presenting people with buy-out contracts that force them to sign away their right to future royalties, or residuals as they are known, is just not allowed anymore and they will not get the section 481 tax credit if they force people to sign buy-out contracts. Would that resolve the matter?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

The State could do that. It is within the remit of the State to do that and enact amendments that could beef up the legislation. There were two fundamental flaws in the legislation, the Act and the directive, in that they did not state that a lump sum was outlawed. It stated that the buy-out contract must be the exception rather than the rule, but how do you find the rule and which is the exception? Even in the Copyright and Related Rights Act, there was still a buy-out. If the contract is worded cleverly enough, then people sign a buy-out contract. The Departments must be aware of what constitutes fair, equitable and proportionate remuneration and what structure of contract will allow for the revenues, rather than the artists' fee, to dictate what the residuals will be. Then is a matter of making sure there is a collecting agent, collecting mechanism or administrative structure to collect those from the revenue streams globally and bring them back into the country. If the artist does not get the residuals, I am afraid Revenue does not get to tax them. They will be lost Revenue.

Comment on this

The State is losing out. It is putting money in, but the State itself, as well as the actors and performers, are losing out. Most of the revenue is probably going to the United States from Europe. Would that be fair to say? I think I have seen figures on that. Is that true?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

I am actually here talking to the Screen Actors Guild and Equity UK. I provided some of the figures from some of the collecting agents. I forgot to put up one, which was for performers, and they are collecting $1.6 billion globally. SAG has paid out about $2 billion. Equity UK, our nearest neighbour and one we should look to which has a very robust industry, has paid out something like £100 million since 2015. That is collected from some of the smaller rights that performers have around the world. That is built into their contract, so they are able to do that. The UK broadcasters have agreements that allow for repeat fees. If their distribution services sell around the world, the actors will receive further payments.

Comment on this

Will Mr. O'Brien elaborate on that point for people? In Ireland, currently, with the type of contracts that actors and performers are being essentially forced to sign, there is very little coming back in residuals. In other jurisdictions, however, there is a mechanism and a structure and there are contracts that ensure actors and performers do get a fair and equitable share of downstream revenues. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

That is correct.

Comment on this

If we had something similar to the sort of mechanisms and contracts that existed in Britain or other jurisdictions - I have seen stuff about Scandinavian countries and other European countries - these buy-out contracts where actors and performers are robbed of future revenues would not happen. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

I have to be careful on what words I agree to. Yes, they close us off from that residual pool that exists globally. There is a revenue stream around the world. The 2016 agreement creates a dam that prevents those who sign it to get access to that. It is very difficult for people to get access to that.

Comment on this

For below-the-line workers, that is, the crew, the people who are not in front of the camera, is it the case that for a lot of them, even though they might be working across multiple productions for the same producer, the producers are essentially denying that they have responsibility, as employers, for the crew and hiding behind the DAC structure so that they can deny that they have an employment relationship with the workers?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

The difficulty of it lands in terms of the short-term nature of the DACs. I will go back to what I said earlier. It gives an imbalance. It is probably not the same employer-employee relationship. I am an industrial relations practitioner. I am not into company law. I would not be fully read up on why the structure has to be DACs. That short-term nature creates an imbalance. That is something that has to be examined and addressed in some way, shape or form in the industry.

Comment on this

I am conscious that today a broadcasting Bill will be taken in the Dáil. That legislation will require that 25% of all the money that goes to RTÉ will now go to what are called independent producers who are also recipients of the section 481 tax credit. Might that be a useful comparison? SIPTU was involved in that and it has expressed concern. Previous jobs done by crew, which would have been an actual job with pension entitlements, are now going to be replaced by people working on an episodic basis for independent producers getting the section 481 tax credit. They will have no rights as employees.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

That is something that should be addressed through the processes we have. As I said in relation to having a process in place, we could look to having a speedy dispute resolution or a register of the collective agreements we have. That might bring a bit of balance back in terms of supporting the workers and giving them a bit of security within the industry. People need to be mindful that we may be trying to put a square peg into a round hole in terms of applying employment law and so on that would suit longer term workers to an industry where that just does not happen.

Comment on this

That has been the problem if we look at employment law more generally. Unfortunately, legislation and regulation are playing catch-up when you look at the atomisation and fragmentation of the traditional employment model. The vast majority of our suite of employment laws are geared toward addressing the issues that will have arisen over many decades, since the foundation of the State and longer, in terms of the traditional employment relationship and people's rights and entitlements in that regard. The film and TV industry is not unique in that regard. The situation is very acute there, however, because we all know that it is, by and large, a project-by-project industry and people are engaged on that basis.

Mr. Purfield made a point about DACs. It is often the case that people work for short periods for a particular production under a certain DAC but the same people involved in another DAC are employing them again very shortly after that, and there is often a relationship between the same people within the industry, but, unfortunately, that continuity of rights and entitlements does not follow people.

He also made an interesting point the dispute resolution process. There is an unarguable case for a discrete customised dispute resolution mechanism to be introduced in the sector. The analogy of the construction industry is a good one, it is well-drawn and people will understand that. We know that it is there for a good reason. It works, by and large. I am not saying that there are not issues but it works. The difference is that there has been a tradition of collective agreements in the construction industry. While I would be the first person to be critical of bad employers in the sector, or anywhere, it tends to work because employers understand that they would not have a successful industry without the skills and talents of their employees. They know that when disputes arise that organised workers can decide to create disruption legitimately to projects. The issue is, as Mr. O'Brien and Mr. Purfield said, that for people who are working in this sector, by definition, it is short-term, insecure and uncertain work. It is a small industry. It is quite incestuous and if a person develops a reputation of putting his or her head above the parapet, he or she may not work again. Not only is it a small industry in Ireland, it is globally interconnected, and this is the problem.

Mr. Purfield and I, and others, have sought over countless finance Bill processes to legislate, for example, to protect the copyright piece and ensure that there is no cash without conditions. There is a very significant State investment here in terms of tax expenditure. It is crazy that we have decided, broadly speaking as a Legislature, and that the Executive has decided, that we should not use the tools available to us to drive progressive change in an industry that is important to Ireland. Ministers and so on also decide to showcase and promote Ireland internationally but the experience of the people working in the sector, to put it diplomatically, is far from ideal.

Has a dispute resolution proposition been put to the industry? Has that model of the construction industry process gained any traction with it?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Yes, we are working through it at the minute. In terms of the crew and construction crew, we are in the process of negotiating a new agreement for both groups. We have broadly touched on the issue of dispute resolution. There is a process within the shooting crew agreement but, to be frank, it is too long for what it is. We have discussed it with Screen Producers Ireland. I believe in replicating that construction process where there are defined periods and access to adjudication. The problem on the face of it is that it would need to be resourced by the State. I appreciate that the Workplace Relations Commission and the adjudication service is under pressure as it is but by resourcing it, and having a panel of people who understand the industry, we would have a system that works through our issues.

I wish to raise another issue that SIPTU has flagged in terms of the crew and construction crew agreements. It would be useful to have some form of registration of the agreements. The agreements go past the parameters of an special exemption order, SEO, as it stands currently, which is difficult, and there are bits in it that we do not want to lose. If there was some form of an enforcement of registration to the Labour Court or whatever, that would be extremely useful for everyone.

Comment on this

Interestingly, it does not have the status of an registered employment agreement, REA, and it goes beyond. I drafted legislation for sectoral employment orders. At the time it was pioneering but these things are never meant to stand still. That was 12 years ago. There is also basic provision in the SEOs for things like travel, time, pensions arrangements, etc. Some of those agreements do go beyond that but the SEOs should be a floor beneath which nobody is allowed to fall. It should not be the extent of anybody's ambition but sometimes some employers only see it as a ceiling. That is a really good point and Mr. Purfield is absolutely right.

We, as a State, are spending significant amounts supporting this industry and it should not be beyond the State. If this is an important industry to the State and if the film industry, and everybody who works in it, are as important to us, as I feel it is and should be, and if it is as culturally important to us as we say, then the State should resource a dispute resolution process. The film industry, as far back as the pioneering work of Michael D. Higgins, has become a really important part of our proposition as a country. It should not be beyond the State to resource adjudication and a discrete, customised and tailored solution for the needs of an industry if it is as important as it says it is.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Purfield for his opening statement. He mentioned the long wait for WRC hearings. Is it the same for all non film-related companies? Does SIPTU seek a fast-track system for its employees?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

The short answer is "Yes". In terms of the sector that SIPTU represents, we cover a broad range of employers. We represent workers not just in film and television but across the likes of cinemas, print and the whole lot. I will give a practical example of wait times. Last March, I referred a payment of wages case for a group of workers in another industry. I lodged the case in time, followed all of the procedures and I still have not got a date for that. I followed up the case in the last couple of weeks and I still await a date.

Comment on this

Is that a problem within the WRC because it is not fully resourced?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Yes, and that is the point I have made. As the Deputy asked, it is a wider issue. It is not just related to film and television. Any employee in any industry will have this problem.

Comment on this

Does SIPTU seek a fast-track system for the film industry because of the unique circumstances due to the short-term nature of the jobs?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Yes, exactly. Let us take the example I have cited. These people are not going anywhere, and I mean that in the nicest possible way, and the issue will be heard. The issue we are having in the film industry is that the production is finished and everyone moves on to the next one, be it six weeks or six months. Either way, it is not enough time to have the issue resolved in a timely fashion.

Comment on this

I wish to make the general point, and we had it with RTÉ, that there are people going into work every day, working 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., yet they are on contracts. Are they not deemed employees by the Revenue Commissioners because of the nature of their work in the film industry?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

In short, some of them are. It is complicated and my explanation would take up the rest of the Deputy's time. In short, depending on what people do within the industry, some people might be hired as what is called "loan-out companies". It is a limited company that is engaged by the production. Some people are PAYE workers. My understanding is that processes are applied by Revenue that determine that.

Comment on this

Has SIPTU had cases with the WRC where people sought to be deemed employees and were successful or unsuccessful?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

No, I have not.

Comment on this

In 2023, this committee produced a report, which was before my time. Has anything changed for the better since then?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

In terms of employment rights, and like I said at the outset, no. The recommendations have not been put in place. It has certainly got busier. There are plenty of people in work. Within crew, in particular, it is very hard for productions to get people in. A lot of productions either bring in people from Northern Ireland or the UK because it is so busy, which speaks to the level of funding being given to people. A lot of imbalances still exist which were discussed at the least hearing.

Comment on this

Had there been any movement towards greater employment security?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Things are still as they were with the previous committee. To be quite frank, employment still has a short-term nature.

Comment on this

Has nothing changed in three years?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Effectively, yes.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Purfield give us one big ticket item? I know that is a loaded question. Is there anything that should be focused on to get one thing right?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Yes. The Deputy might need to split his question into two pieces. I agree with what Mr. O'Brien said about properly implementing copyright across the board and having agreements that mirror what is done in other countries so our members are not disadvantaged.

Equally, it harks back to dispute resolution because that gives people the security within the short-term job and it gives the easiest fix on it.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Purfield.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. On the copyright-related Acts and the buyout of contracts, what exactly needs to happen? Is it the case that something needs to be done to ban buyout contracts or is it the case that it should be as in SIPTU’s opening statement “full adherence to the Copyright and Related Acts 2000 and SI 567 of 2021 should be an audited requirement to avail of section 481” relief. Is that the mechanism to ban this or stop this?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Yes. We have spoken among ourselves about having agreements that would mirror the likes of the Pact Equity agreement in the UK. We need to have those agreements in place and enforceable, and have a shorter timeframe. The biggest problem we have at the moment is the fact that the buyout at the start is ten years. There is very little revenue at the back end after ten years so we need to have those fit for purpose. Having an agreement done collectively in place that mirrors what is best in class in other jurisdictions would resolve that.

Comment on this

Therefore does SIPTU think the best way is to get a collective agreement in place in the industry?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Yes.

Comment on this

In addition, do we need to make audit a requirement of availing of section 481?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

It is kind of both. I have not seen one but the section 481 application contains a question on whether the production company is adhering to local collective agreements. My understanding is it is the same as when people read the terms and conditions on a website when they are trying to get through to something: they just scroll down to the bottom and tick a box. It needs to be something that is audited. We need the correct agreements to be in place as step one and step two is that it is enforceable that if a production company is not adhering to the collective agreements we have in place, they do not get section 481 funding until that issue is rectified.

Comment on this

Should that not be a requirement regardless of collective agreements?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Possibly, yes but-----

Comment on this

Does Mr. Purfield think it cannot be done? I am just trying to understand this.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

The difficulty is that, as it stands with collective agreements, certain things will be above a legislative minimum. Deputy Nash spoke earlier about the floor and ceiling. It can be ensured that something is in line with a legislative minimum. In theory, everyone could be on a minimum wage. That is not something that we would want to see. By having collective agreements in place, we ensure quality employment and that they are enforced and people get the terms and conditions that reflect the work they do.

Comment on this

Since employment law is not fit for purpose in terms of the short-term nature of the sector, does this require a full rewrite of employment legislation? What is the way to tackle it? The witnesses talked about the fast-tracked dispute resolution. That would obviously help the situation but beyond that what sort of measures are needed to improve employment law for people in the sector?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

That is a big question. You are potentially looking at knock-on effects in every other industry then. I will sound like I am repeating myself but it does come down to speedy resolution and equally adequate resourcing within the relevant government bodies to ensure that things are done in a timely fashion.

Comment on this

That is the key thing really. While the employment law in the sector could be improved and would have knock-on effects for other industries if we could get the fast-track dispute resolution resourced by the State that would make a massive difference.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Yes.

Comment on this

Has there been any indication to date in any of the work the union has done over the years that there is any potential buy-in for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

From the State, I am not sure; there might be from the producers. I would like to think there was since they come and discuss collective agreements with us but I really could not answer in terms of the State.

Comment on this

Therefore it is really a case of us needing to make the case that considering the huge investment the State is making through section 481 and the tax relief, we should be creating an industry with good quality jobs and not the current situation. The industry has been valued in having been given the prominence but it is not being valued in having good quality jobs and security.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

A lot of work is being done to improve the good quality aspect but we are not where we need to be. As I said in the opening statement, the Government has obligations under the adequate minimum wage directive as well. By putting these processes in place in terms of auditing the collective agreements and strengthening dispute resolution would help towards that process in this industry. It is about ensuring taxpayers are getting value for money. There was €544 million invested across 2025 according to Screen Ireland so you can extrapolate from that what the section 481 funding would have been. With that level of taxpayer money going out there should be proper conditions in place for people working in the industry.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Purfield.

Comment on this

I have a few questions. I am in construction. In my company, I have employees and I also have subcontractors. My subcontractors come in as I need them and they go as I do not need them. They come in with their own costing, they provide their own insurance and they adhere to whatever on-site rules we have. There are sections around that who would be deemed as employees if they were there for a certain amount of time without providing any materials. They would be coming into that criterion. My subbies come in for three or four weeks and do a particular job and they are gone. They have employees who work under their limited companies. That is the way I work.

What we have here is performers, actors, crew and roadies – that is what I call them on the road – who go in and do a production for three or four weeks. Are some of them directly employed by the film industry as employees and others brought in like subcontractors like what I am talking about for the term of that three- or four-week contract or is the film industry trying to get into a situation where it they are going to be in for three or four weeks, they will say “Give me a crew under your contract” and they come in and under a subcontractor?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

There is probably a slight difference, as ourselves and Deputy Boyd Barret mentioned earlier, in that the DACs are employing people and equally within that, from a crew point of view, it is the case that some people provide equipment to productions as limited companies. Let us take a sound engineer. The heads of department in sound would have a lot of expensive equipment and it makes more sense for them to be a limited company whereas the boom operator underneath them might be only PAYE. That person would be hired by the DAC. There would not necessarily be a subcontracting element to it.

Comment on this

They would be brought on as a PAYE employment for the term of that production.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Yes. It could be for three or six weeks. Performers, in terms of actors, would be even less. Generally with co-productions and so on, it will be performers coming in. I can think of a pretty big name recently, which I will not name, which ran for eight months and the headliners would have been coming in from America. A lot of the day actors or day players would potentially be Irish and coming from here. Mr. O’Brien might want to speak about the difference.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

We are now caught under the Karshan ruling, which means everyone is going through payroll whether they are in for the day or not.

On what we bring in, it sounds like we are going into that strange airy-fairy world of talent. We leave behind an asset to the company when we are finished after that day, three days or five weeks. We are told we are employees even if we go in for a day, yet we have to provide all the expertise and all the instrumental things that give the performance to the company, which then exploits it and continues to exploit it.

We have always maintained that we are freelance, by the nature of our industry. If we were going into a three-month contract, we would probably fall into the area of being employed and have our work go through payroll, but normally, we are freelance.

Comment on this

I am looking at this from my own perspective as an employer. If I had somebody coming in for one day with a particular set of skills as an actor might, they would be paid a premium fee for that time. If they had come in, done one job for me and then said that they wanted some royalties from my margin at the end of it, it would have to be different. Due to the nature of the film industry, there has to be a different set-up for the rules. One law will not fix this. If that law was brought in, it would have catastrophic effects on all different kinds of employment across the country. There needs to be a particular law brought in for the film industry, which is what I am looking at here. It would not work in my industry, unless you were using the likes of a subcontractor and were taking on employees. If you were lucky enough to get a skilled employee in the construction industry now, you would take them on because they are not there. However, what the witnesses are looking for does not suit every industry. Are we looking for a particular law on funding under section 481 for the film industry alone? If we changed to this, it would not fit other industries. Maybe that is what the witnesses need to have a look at that.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

I will defer to Mr. O'Brien again.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

I am in agreement with the Chair because we are covered by two separate sets of legislation. When we are on set, we are covered by the employment laws and the operation of the working time Act. However, when we leave the set, what we leave behind is covered by the copyright Act and the European copyright directive in the digital Single Market for the ongoing exploitation of that work. There are two laws, but perhaps there needs to be a bridging law that says this has to happen with regard to the implementation of the copyright element and the protection of intellectual property.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. O'Brien. Before Deputy Devine starts, this meeting has to conclude by 4.15 p.m., as we have other witnesses outside to come in.

Comment on this

I had flagged that we were coming in.

Comment on this

That is fine; I have no problem with that. I know Deputy Ó Murchú wanted to come in.

Comment on this

Deputy Ó Murchú was before me, so he should go next.

Comment on this

I have no problem with that, but we have about 11 minutes between all of us here to speak.

Comment on this

I have just two questions-----

Comment on this

Deputy Devine can go ahead. I was late.

Comment on this

-----and I will save the rest for later. I thank the witnesses for their presentations. I want to ask about the regional uplift, which was at some percentage and did have some impact on escaping from the east coast - Wicklow, Dublin and wherever - to the west. There have been fantastic movies and documentaries - the works - made out there.

Do the witnesses believe that the extension of the regional uplift with the higher rate of 8% would have a significant effect on allowing that industry within the west and other parts of the country, apart from the east coast to thrive? Normally, the stuff that takes place around the Dublin area is the city, the grime, the dirt, the "Love/Hate" and all that sort of stuff, while the west seems to have a prettier picture, even though the underbelly is often shown in good movies as well. That was one of the questions.

As to section 481 relief, do the witnesses believe it should be tied to specific asks like sustainable employment? Should that be put into a contract or whatever we want to call it? Would this then bring greater use of Irish composers and other elements that would and perhaps should come to encourage the industry and our indigenous artists under the section 481 relief? Those are my two questions. I hope I was quick enough.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

I will try to be brief in my response. As regards the regional uplift, my experience is that there is more and more happening outside what I would call - I stress that this is my own terminology for it - the Dublin-Wicklow bubble. However, the issue or restriction you will find is that of facilities for people. There is some great scenery and outdoor stuff - this point is outside my employment rights remit - but I find from talking to crew and actors that studio space outside the Dublin-Wicklow area is an issue. Studio space in general is an issue, but I am aware that Troy Studios is availing of the uplift for unscripted productions at the minute. There is quite a bit that goes on over in Galway now and west Cork, but there is a lack of studio space, which is an issue.

I stress that this next is not necessarily an industrial relations employment rights matter, but anecdotally from talking to crew and when we meet producers before they start a production to make sure that things are in order, productions down the country, so to speak, generally struggle to get skilled crew. It goes back to the Cathaoirleach's point that if you find someone skilled, you hang onto them. Naturally, most of the crews have gravitated towards Dublin because that is where the bulk of the work is. Having adequate crew elsewhere seems to be a problem.

The Deputy also asked about tying the funding to specific asks. That should definitely happen, particularly in much of what I have outlined. I see Mr. O'Brien's hand is up and he might say the same thing when he comes in. The Scéal uplift is extremely tenuous at times in terms of what can actually be used. It might just be an Irish composer and that could be the only thing. You would need to be extremely careful to ensure that it is not just the case that the visual effects or post-production is done here and suddenly it is considered an Irish production and is availing of more than it should.

Comment on this

Does Mr. O'Brien want to come in?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

I will be very quick. Regarding the uplift, we would be in support of it. I have seen the effect of a film company arriving into a regional area in the off-season, through January, February and March and in the lead up to Christmas. I have worked there and seen the economic benefit of it. I would support the uplift. It is where we are in lock-step with our producer friends.

The word "sustainability" is difficult for an actor because it can only exist if we have access to fair and adequate remuneration, based on the success we helped to create along with our composers, writers and directors, who also have the same problem with buy-out contracts. If that were happening, then we would have sustainability.

Comment on this

In fairness, the idea of buy-out contracts and the issue that exists with Irish Equity is something that we have all dealt with previously. It just needs to be brought to a conclusion. It is about the wider issue of the power differential between producers to whom we are providing State money and those who work in all aspects of the film industry.

I might ask Mr. Purfield about the shooting crew agreement. We have all heard the stories of those who have been blackballed. We know the issues regarding people who have raised where they were not particularly happy with conditions. We have also had court cases where, at the end of the day, producers take no responsibility as employers and instead fight from the point of view of the DACs being the producers for the period. How do we ever hold a DAC to account when it disappears?

Many have said, and Mr. Purfield can make his own arguments on this, that the shooting crew agreement has therefore not delivered rights beforehand because that is between SIPTU and SPI.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Yes, that is correct.

Comment on this

I have heard from many people - I am sure Deputy Boyd Barrett has, too - who have said that they would have no hope for a future agreement. Even from its own point of view, what powers does SIPTU have to investigate and enforce on set if it is told of an instance? I would think they are very limited. Given that the State puts money into this, we need to find a way of enforcement that provides SIPTU with better powers to deliver on this.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

In relation to the crew agreement, it was negotiated during Covid and there are gaps in it. Like any agreement that any industrial official in any union has ever worked on, there will be gaps and issues, but we are currently working to improve it. I know that there is a narrative among some people out there that it is between us and Screen Producers Ireland, and not necessarily the production companies, but Screen Producers Ireland is effectively an employers' group.

Comment on this

Is this not a mechanism that is used by the producers? SIPTU does a deal with them, but they say that they are not really the employers. Who is SIPTU actually doing the deal with?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

That was the point that I was coming to. Screen Producers Ireland is effectively an employers' group. It is no different to SIPTU's construction sector going into the Construction Industry Federation, CIF, or our security industry sector going into the security industry federation. It is an employers' body, and all of the major production companies are involved in it. Having looked at what goes on in other industries, I certainly do not buy the narrative that it has no teeth.

Going back to what I said at the start, if we had some sort of registration, which I referred to when I was responding to Deputy Nash, be it a registered agreement, a sectoral employment order, SEO, or whatever it needed to be, it would give it more teeth in terms of enforcement. However, in terms of us investigating issues, part of the agreement gives us access to a set with 24-hour notice if there is an issue, so we are able to go out and meet people, which we do regularly. That is a useful tool to have in terms of resolving matters.

Comment on this

Deputy Ó Murchú is getting somewhere with it, so he can take my time. It should not be guillotined.

Comment on this

I get what Mr. Purfield is saying. Registration is something that would give SIPTU a greater level of power.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Yes.

Comment on this

What else does it need provided in that case? I am not looking for a bun fight with SIPTU around this, but my feeling is that, like Mr. Purfield said, this will not necessarily provide the framework that can deliver the rights for the people who work in the industry. What do we need to do to make it work?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Like I said to Deputy O'Callaghan, it comes back to an element of proper auditing within the section 481 system. One thing that a producer would be extremely afraid of is not getting its section 418 funding. That would be a significant cost.

Comment on this

Is there a bigger piece of work that needs to be done by the Government, which we have all spoken about previously, from the point of view of ensuring that section 481 funding is only provided when good practice is being followed?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

In short, yes.

Comment on this

So, there is a wider conversation that SIPTU needs to have with the Government before we even have a shooting crew agreement.

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

We currently have an agreement, but we are looking to give it more teeth in terms of the new agreement. Some form of auditing and proper compliance with the agreement as part of a company's section 481 application would be key.

Comment on this

That is a major thing. A number of us were previously promised that if he did not see an improvement in this, the Tánaiste would look at it when he became Minister for Finance, as much as he did not always believe it should be done through the Department of Finance, but that is what every Minister says. We will have to look at some sort of mechanism to make this work. I appreciate the responses.

Comment on this

It is impossible to come in on a meeting for two or three minutes, so I kind of see this as pointless, but this matter is something that was really looked at by the previous budgetary oversight committee. Deputy Boyd Barrett and I were members of that. We discussed it over weeks rather than having a guillotined thing over such a short period of time. We put huge work into the committee report. I have less than a minute, so is there anything in particular-----

Comment on this

Deputy Farrell has four and a half minutes.

Comment on this

Okay. The screen reads "4.15 p.m." What, in terms of effort, has actually been done to address the issues since the committee published that report? It was worked on for months and was championed by Deputy Boyd Barrett. What efforts do the witnesses feel have been made in addressing those issues since?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

I have been in this particular role about a year and a half. That is when I took over from my predecessor, so I was not around at the time of the last set of hearings and the recommendations being issued. However, when I knew I was coming over, I read through them and had a quick flick through the minutes. The report certainly looks substantial. That is always welcome, and I give the previous committee credit for it.

I know that the Deputy missed my opening statement, but as I said, certain aspects within the recommendations that were for the employer, for want of a better phrase, have been actioned. The recommendations made within the report for the employee have not been, and that is the disappointing piece. The report makes reference to a stakeholder forum. As far as I am aware, there has not been a meeting of the stakeholder forum. We would certainly welcome that. Regular communication in any walk of life when we are doing industrial relations is key, and we would certainly welcome having a regular forum. I spoke about certain things being put in place, but even where the committee did make recommendations, such as extending the six-month limit in the WRC and extending the life of DACs, none of that has been implemented. It is still pretty much as it was at the start.

Comment on this

For this committee, it is now a case of taking on that report again and seeing whether we can push through what SIPTU thinks are the specific things that we need to at this stage.

I have another few questions, although they may have been dealt with. Unfortunately, I was chairing another committee and missed an awful lot of this. In relation to the UK's PACT-Equity agreement and it being seen as a model to follow, there appears to be reluctance in some quarters that this agreement could be implemented here. Will one of the witnesses speak on the effectiveness of the PACT-Equity agreement and whether it is applicable to here?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

I will let Mr. O'Brien take that question.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

It is being used here. There are a number of co-productions that are using it in this jurisdiction and everybody is quite happy with it. The objection mainly comes to an issue around the working time Act, which can be amended with an addendum to say that when the PACT-Equity agreement is used here, the working time Act should apply over the contractual option that is available around rest periods and so on, but the rest of it is very detailed and protects the performer and the typically atypical nature of actors' performances on the set. It is very detailed and has an extremely robust back-end deal, both for television and film, that allows for proportionality based on the revenues generated. There are a couple of things that may have to go, such as the use of net profit. Net profit is very difficult to calculate in the film industry and may not exist, and it is not a figure that is directly associated with the revenues. That is about it.

Comment on this

Does Irish Equity think that we can harmonise upwards in terms of performers' rights across the island of Ireland and that the agreement could be used for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

Yes. We work very closely with our colleagues in Northern Ireland, so, yes, it does work here. I had a phone call from an agent just before I came over for this meeting and they were delighted that there was a production that they had people on that was using the PACT-Equity television agreement. They said that they went through it bit by bit to make sure that there had been no alterations. They are quite happy with that.

At the same time, though, the buy-out contract is working alongside that. One company is penalised for actually doing something that is favourable to the actor because it is going to pay them residuals while the other company is using a buy-out for ten years.

I think that it is the perfect model and that it would provide a huge structural safety net for immigrant investors because they need a certainty that they are compliant with legislation when they work in a European territory, and it is good for this jurisdiction.

Comment on this

Screen Producers Ireland has called for a regional uplift to be established based on previous uplifts, but at an increased rate of 8% across the State. Does Irish Equity support that kind of proposal?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

Yes, if it is welcomed by our colleagues in Northern Ireland. Harmonising across the island with those agreements is good. As I said earlier, I have seen the effect on a rural district when a production is filming around there for a couple of months in an off-peak season. It helps to boost the local economy. However, it would have to be measured and made sure that it was worthwhile. In that area, we are in lock-step with our colleagues. We have a robust adversarial relationship regarding residuals.

Comment on this

Are the contracts that are being given to actors and performers in breach of the copyright directive? If the Government ensured that those contracts were compliant, could we move towards resolving the issue?

The witnesses have said that people would be fearful and have reason to fear if they decided to say that they were not happy with these contracts, that they would potentially be blacklisted. Have the witnesses anything to say to us given that the producers who might blacklist people are getting public money? To me, that is shocking. It is shocking that we are giving €177 million to producers who we are being told will blacklist people if they assert their rights.

Will Mr. Purfield comment on the debate about the fixed term workers Act because, as I understand it, the Act is designed to deal with episodic employment? It states that somebody in that sort of episodic employment should have rights that are no less favourable than somebody in full-time employment. What we appear to be hearing from the film producers is that the fixed-term workers Act cannot apply in the film industry. Will Mr. Purfield comment on that because that seems unacceptable?

Comment on this
Mr. Robbie Purfield

Again, this comes down to the fact that this legislation is not designed for film and TV production. One member mentioned RTÉ. We would have a level of people on fixed-term contracts in RTÉ. When they get to that four-year anniversary, they are made permanent. That is what the Act is designed for. The problem we have is that we are effectively trying to put a square peg in a round hole. I do not think the nature of the industry allows for it. I get what the Deputy is driving at and I get that people need the security of it, but when people drafted that legislation, it was geared more towards an industry where someone comes in at 18 and potentially goes out at 65, not one where he or she is bouncing from employer to employer over the course of six or 12 months.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry O'Brien

I would not use the word "illegal" given that I am outside the parameters. Wonderfully crafted documents are presented to people who may not fully understand the nature of what they are signing, particularly young actors. Without collective agreements, it is filled with too much fresh air in that there are areas that are then filled out with special stipulations that may not have been put before the members for ratification. It is a very grey area but if we look at these contracts contract by contract and line by line, a much more skilful legal mind than mine, and I am not a solicitor, may find issue with the way they are drafted.

Comment on this

That concludes this session. I thank the witnesses for attending this meeting. We will suspend for a few minutes while we allow the other witnesses to join us for the next public session.

Comment on this

I call the meeting to order and advise members that we are now in public session. I ask everyone to turn off their mobile phones or put them on silent. Before we begin, I will explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regard reference witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. Witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation they make to the committee. This means that they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Members are advised of the constitutional requirement that a member must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex to participate in public meetings. In this regard, I ask any members participating via MS Teams to confirm that they are on the grounds of Leinster House prior to making their contribution to the meeting. Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity either by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Today's session marks the second follow-up engagement of the committee on section 481. From the Irish Film Workers Association, I welcome Mr. John Arkins, general secretary, and Ms Liz Murray. The committee welcomes the opportunity to engage with them and I thank them for being here today. I now invite Ms Murray to make her opening statement.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee for the opportunity to address them for a second time on behalf of film crew. Our members predominantly work in the construction grades. Appearing before the committee in 2023, we said that section 481 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997, as amended and currently structured, does not work for the workers nor does it work for the taxpayer. Nothing has changed. It fails to deliver the objectives of the reliefs, which are clearly set out in the Film Regulations, SI 119 of 2019.

I am an employment rights and industrial relations advocate. I represent the members of the association, which is a properly registered trade union, in respect of their employment rights and related matters. I can say that ours is the only trade union that was prepared to take on the fight for employment rights for film production crew and it has cost our members both financially and professionally. My colleague, John Arkins, is general secretary of the Irish Film Workers Association. Until 2018, when he was blacklisted for raising issues relating to employment rights before an Oireachtas committee, he was a senior supervising stagehand in the industry with nearly 30 years' experience. He has not worked a single day since. He was blacklisted by every production company in Ireland. Mr. Arkins and I can speak to our continuing efforts to secure employment rights for our members at the WRC, the Labour Court and the High Court.

All those matters are on the public record. We can detail for the committee the roadblocks we have faced at every turn in the past seven years. We have been pursuing our cases, and we can speak to the difficulties faced because of the failure to implement the recommendations of this committee. Mr. Arkins can give lived testimony to support our contention that the requirements of section 481 and the film regulations, which require the film producer company to meet two criteria - an industry development test and a culture test - are not being met by the producer companies. This, we suggest, is driven by a light-touch regime, where governance and compliance are left in the hands of the industry and where State agencies appear to be more interested in the end goal only, that is, accolades, gongs, and statuettes. Publicity around such industry affairs offers a means to justify the continuation of section 481 despite the fact that the regulations are not being met.

Ireland has experienced and award-winning crews, actors, writers, directors, and musicians. The reliefs are given so that they may enjoy quality employment and training. We should value those workers. Instead, rights which apply universally to each and every other worker in other sectors and industries throughout the country, including the gig economy, do not appear to apply to film production crew and talent. The system is clear on any plain reading of the regulations. However, the requirement to have a qualifying company is being used as a shield to distance producer companies from their obligations. If the Government had implemented recommendation 5 of the Committee on Budgetary Oversight, this practice would be forced to cease. I remind members of recommendation 5:

...that it is clearly established that producer companies who receive Section 481 on condition of creating quality employment and meeting the industry development test must take responsibility for employees and acknowledge their employment relationship with film crew across different productions and recognise the accumulated service of all such employees as a condition of receiving Section 481.

The fact that the industry is allowed to police itself in the areas of employment and employment rights needs to be stopped. Compliance and governance of the reliefs is a matter for the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment and the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport. Currently, the Revenue Commissioners alone have oversight. The film regulations are clear and unambiguous. The producer company must meet both an industry development test and a culture test in order to claim its reliefs. It is our submission to this committee that neither of those tests are met, nor will they be met unless radical amendments are made to the film regulations to at least take account of the committee recommendations. However, we suggest that they need to go even further and impose penalties if there are breaches of the regulations.

We can also speak to the fact that the producer companies generally do not see their having an ongoing employment relationship, as defined in the framework agreement on fixed-term work, which has been further strengthened by EU Directive 2019/1153. The committee further recommended at 6:

The Committee commits to writing to the EU Commission requesting examination of the use of successive Fixed Term Contracts for film crew across multiple productions, where such crew never acquire Contracts of Indefinite Duration or any acknowledgement of their service, and whether this amounts to a breach of EU Directives in terms of both the Fixed Term Workers Directive and EU directives relating to state aid for the Audio-visual sector.

That was published in the report of the committee. That question has subsequently been addressed by the WRC, which found in favour of the workers and that the workers' rights had been breached by the failure of the employers to issue contracts of indefinite duration or to adhere other legislation derived from EU directives. Because of recent decisions relating to employment breaches, our members are now reporting increasing instances of get-around, and I do not know what other word to call it, where more and more members are encouraged to become registered companies as an avoidance mechanism. Had the Government moved to implement recommendation 6, workers would have been protected. Instead, the industry employers are increasingly moving to have workers become a registered business and engage those businesses rather than PAYE workers. That presents a very significant difficulty for the continuation of section 481, as this relief is payable for the provision of quality employment and training, which we understand to mean those employed on contracts of service.

Rates of pay and other terms and conditions of employment are set out in collective agreements between workers and trade unions. Self-employed people cannot engage in collective bargaining. That is a breach of the Competition Act. However, it is our understanding from our members that even those who did set up as limited companies are being offered the collectively agreed rates of pay. These workers agreed to become limited companies, and they have now contracted themselves out of all their rights to the protections of employment legislation and any other benefits employees have as a right. We believe urgent action is required by the Government, but having been here before, we do not hold out much hope of meaningful change any time soon.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Murray and Mr. Arkins for carrying on the campaign to have the rights of workers and film crew, in particular, vindicated in the film industry. It is terrible that we are still here where we were all those years ago. For the benefit of the committee, the first time I met Mr. Arkins he took me to a set in the Dublin Mountains. He was working as the stagehand for "Ripper Street", I think, was it?

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

"Badlands".

Comment on this

"Badlands". Since he raised the issue back then at the culture committee of people not having their rights vindicated, he has not worked in the industry he had worked in for 30 years up to then, which is absolutely outrageous as far as I am concerned. For the benefit of those who maybe are not as familiar, maybe he could just explain whether it is the case that all of this turns on the question of recognition of service in the industry. I was just reading about the company that employed Mr. Arkins for that film. Last year, it got €50 million. To put that in perspective, €177 million was given out in section 481 tax relief last year, and one of those companies got €50 million of that, which was the company that Mr. Arkins used to work for across multiple productions for several decades. However, it does not want to recognise the fact that it employed him for all of those years and hides behind the DACs, which are set up from each production. Is that a fair-----

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

That is correct. That is exactly what they say, and it is not us saying that. When I came here in 2018 to the Oireachtas joint committee, this is what we told then. Our story has not changed. I lost my job, my livelihood. I have lost 50% of what is left of my working life. I work in construction; I build sets. It takes a harder toll on the body. I have about five years of working left in me before I start getting knees and hips replaced. When we came in here, we were told by the Government to go to the WRC and the Labour Court. I went to the WRC and so did the 24 men behind me. I went to the Labour Court and all the way to the High Court, and the High Court told me and my colleagues that the Labour Court trampled on all of our constitutional rights, that it stopped the investigation where it should have started. The reason I say that is because it is quite simple. This is a cross-departmental issue. It is not left for one Department. I have been seeking meetings with my local TDs since 2018. I met one in my local area, the Sinn Féin TD. I and Ms Murray have been raising these issues. I have a title of general secretary.

I am a supervising stagehand. That is what I am. I spent 30 years at it. We came forward to represent ourselves because we were not getting representation anywhere else. I worked under five different union officials in the union for which I was a shop steward for 20 years. No one has ever raised these issues. When we asked for our service to be recognised and for an end to be put to this, that is when I lost my job. I have 28 years of holiday credits coming to me. That is how many years I worked without getting annual paid leave. They give you holiday credits. I have 28 years' worth coming to me. That is what the Irish taxpayer is paying for, the abuse of people like me.

People look at me and say, "He's a big strong lad. He doesn't need anyone to take things up for him", but we are talking about trainees coming in from college. I defended trainees coming in with qualifications from good colleges that are recognised everywhere in the world except in the Irish film industry. You can have a qualification from college but it is put in the bin and you are classed as a trainee. These poor kids work 60 to 70 hours a week just to get in the door. They are burned out after two years. They are gone. I raised these issues and negotiated with the employers. At the start of the day and at the end, there is "prep" and "wrap". These kids are expected to work for nothing just to get in the door. I have sat in rooms face to face with these producers and I will tell the committee members which of them did this. That is why I am here. I am here to give living testimony as a worker in the industry. After more than €5 billion has been given to build a film industry in Ireland, we do not have an industry. I have affidavits from two of the biggest production companies in the land, one of which got the €50 million. In these High Court affidavits, they said this has nothing to do with them because they do not employ anyone. They say that, while they own the 30 companies the man involved worked for, they have nothing to do with him.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

Mr. Arkins says these companies have no employees. That is what they are telling third parties.

Comment on this

Let us clarify this because the issue came up but was not fully addressed in the last session. The Chair asked about contracts of indefinite duration and the criteria to be met. How many workers in the film industry have benefited from the fixed-term workers Act by way of getting contracts of indefinite duration?

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

Not one single worker has.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

Supervising stagehand is a general operative grade. Every organisation and building has GOs. Even the Dáil does. They are the porters, the cleaners and so on. No organisation does not have GOs. They would be the first to get contracts of indefinite duration, CIDs. They are the ones who do all of the pushing, carrying, lifting and shoving. Since the protection of fixed-term workers Act was implemented in Irish law, not one single worker in the Irish film industry, which has received €5 billion in funding so far, has received a contract of indefinite duration. That is why we took the case.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

The crucial aspect of all of this is the reason for the legislation. It was changed by the Minister for Finance in 2018. The Department put in an undertaking and set out clearly the legislation that should apply. The undertaking said that employers must have particular regard to section 9(2) of the Protection of Employees (Fixed-Term Work) Act 2003. The defence put forward by the industry and the producer companies when they are taken to tribunals is that people were employed by a once-off qualifying company. A colleague of mine was let go from a production three weeks ago. He was taken back on under another contract with a new DAC but on a week-one basis. All of the other eight months this person worked on the other production do not count. Nothing counts because of this "qualifying company" provision. The Department of Finance introduced those undertakings but there seems to be a dichotomy between certain people's understandings of the relationship between a DAC, a qualifying company, and the producer company. They are set up by the same person. There is an employment relationship. Mr. Arkins has an employment relationship.

Comment on this

I have to allow other people to get questions in. Each Deputy gets seven minutes.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

I am sorry.

Comment on this

We will allow flexibility because we have flexible time. I call on Deputy Devine.

Comment on this

May I just apologise to our guests? I have to go to a debate on the Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill, where related issues are being discussed.

Comment on this

Give them hell.

Comment on this

I will time Deputy Boyd Barrett.

Comment on this

Gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe. I am kind of new to all of this. I have relied on Deputy Ó Snodaigh to guide me a little bit. I am absolutely gobsmacked by what the witnesses have said. I have a union background in nursing and I take it for granted that we all have continuation of employment and the rights that go with it, which we fought for. However, the witnesses are saying that the film sector is the very poor relation. It is a race to the bottom writ large and only the witnesses' association is trying to halt it. The production companies are making money on this and leaving the association's members behind. Given that we are in a period of industrial unrest, it is fitting that we are discussing this. Despite what Deputy Micheál Martin has said and his goading of public service workers, that is going ahead tomorrow. The witnesses have made it really clear that there is not sufficient oversight over the section 481 tax relief to ensure quality employment is delivered as required under the industrial development test. The way in which DACs, rather than the production companies themselves, receive funding makes it impossible for workers to vindicate their rights. That has come across loud and clear. I have two questions. What measures are necessary to change this and to deliver an effective oversight regime and the means for workers to secure their rights? How should section 481 be restructured to support the indigenous film sector, leading to local jobs rather than funding overseas investment?

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

I would love to be able to tell the Deputy what needs to be done. As I have said, the Government tried to do something. It tried to set out clearly that section 9(2) of the fixed-term workers Act has to be taken into account. If you acquire the length of service set out in the legislation, you are entitled to a contract of indefinite duration. What is muddying the water is the question of DACs. This is just a qualifying company that is set up. The employers are saying that, when that qualifying company is closed and the producer company moves on to something else, the relationship is broken. That is the only thing that breaks the relationship. Collective agreements have been in the industry for over 30 years. Those agreements travel from one job to the next but workers' rights do not. That is the key thing that came up in the Workplace Relations Commission.

We won those cases based on the fact that the Act does apply and the producer company is the employer of the crews. I do not think the spirit and intent of the legislation meant that you could just give anything from €5 million to €30 million for a film, 32% of the budget of the film, to somebody who is really a pop-up shop.

Comment on this

It is almost like a shell company.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

It is a subsidiary. It is recognised as a subsidiary. There is a relationship between the companies but that is where the problem occurs. That is where the problem is.

Comment on this

It is unfathomable that it is not working. The legislation allows for it but there are loopholes. There is avoidance.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

The film production companies' defence is that a worker such my colleague Mr. Arkins would have a contractual relationship with the DAC. The producer company gets the money and transfers it into the DAC to protect the money from the parent company and from anything that is not associated with the film. He has a contractual relationship. The producer companies do not recognise that there are two relationships. There is an employment relationship, a contractual relationship or both. They do not recognise the employment relationship.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

I do not know how to fix it.

Comment on this

Somebody somewhere must know.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

The way it is, it is explained. We asked a fairly simple question in 2018. It is the simplest question but no one seems to want to answer it or to be able to do so. Are the people who get the money responsible for building the Irish film industry that they are supposed to be building? We do not ask what they do when they get the money. The Irish producer company gets the money. The fact a DAC is set up is irrelevant because the DAC does not exist until the producer sets it up. He or she is the only constant in the whole thing. I have had 30 fixed-term contracts from the one company. I worked on TV shows such as "Love/Hate" for four or five years in a row and got a fixed-term contract year after year. I was told they were five different companies. If you go to buy the box set of "Love/Hate", it is in the one box. Everything comes back to the main Irish producer company.

The simple question we asked, and that no one wants to answer, was, "Are the producers responsible for us as crew?" No one wants to answer that question.

Comment on this

Nobody wants to answer that.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

No one does. People have alluded to it. They might say they are responsible and tell us we have all these employment rights like everyone else. However, we have gone through the system. It took me seven years. We went to the WRC and after an investigation, it stated that it believed we were right and have those rights. The Labour Court then said we did not have those rights.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

It did not say why.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

It did not explain to me why that was the case. It did not take the ruling from the adjudicator and say, "This is the reason why you do not have those rights, Mr. Arkins." It did none of that. It just said no.

Comment on this

I will follow up on the point. I thank Mr. Arkins and Ms Murray for their statements and presence here. Mr. Arkins has described the temporary nature of setting up these companies and then closing them when the episode has been made. It is done over a short period. How does that compare with what regularly happens in the construction industry? Many developers set up companies just to build a housing estate and close them afterwards. What are the workers' entitlements in that circumstance? Are those workers in as precarious or unstable a position? I would have thought they were in a better position. Can Mr. Arkins and workers like him get to that stage? They are not that different.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

The construction industry is a good example. If I work for the builder, building houses this year, and then he or she finishes that gig, he or she is always looking for the next gig. Producers are the same. They are always looking for the next gig or the next hand-out from the State. Builders would tell me that they are finishing this row of houses this week but that in two weeks' time they will be starting on the site nearby. In that case, your service and entitlements, including holiday entitlements, travel with you. Everything travels with you. This is the only industry funded directly by the Irish Government and the Irish taxpayer to create quality employment.

Comment on this

The nature of the construction industry that Mr. Arkins just described is no different-----

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

It is no different.

Comment on this

-----as far as employees are concerned.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

However, construction workers get their rights and entitlements.

Comment on this

That happens at the end of every contract.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

They get their rights unless they are contractors. I know lads, including scaffolders, who get all their rights. They get their holidays, like everyone else. They get paid. They get everything else. They are in the pension schemes.

Comment on this

How can Mr. Arkins reach that position?

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

As far as I am concerned, we have reached it. We are entitled to it.

Comment on this

It is not being recognised by the employers.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

It would be like a big building company turning around and saying it has done one specific job and while it is also doing another job somewhere else, it is not really the same company. It would be like it telling its employees that they start from scratch on a Monday on the other site. I look at that and say, "You are the same builder." It is the same company.

Comment on this

It is the same parent company. The company sets up subsidiaries, which are 100% owned. It is the same shareholders and directors.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

That was the case we put forward in the Labour Court.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

In the contracts Mr. Arkins worked on, 58 subsidiary companies were set up and dissolved because they only have to be set up 21 days before the start of the film's production.

Comment on this

What is the purpose of them being set up on a temporary basis? I can understand from a limited liability company point of view why separate companies for building sites could be set up to protect a parent company.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

It is a Revenue requirement.

Comment on this

All those different subsidiaries that are being set up-----

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

It is a Revenue requirement.

Comment on this

Is it to lessen the workers' rights or is it-----

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

No, absolutely not.

Comment on this

They have to set them up.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

They have to maintain them. It is a Revenue requirement. For each film that is made, you get 32% of your budget for eligible expenditure and to pay wages. That is what you are getting it for. To ensure you are spending it for the project for which you claimed it, Revenue requires-----

Comment on this

It is to ring-fence it.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

-----it to be ring-fenced.

The Deputy asked how we secure these rights. The answer is that there is only one way to secure them, and that is what we are doing. We are in the High Court. We were in there on our own because we do not take money from anybody to represent them. Mr. Arkins has given his time and I give my time. We won the cases and then we found that we were going a bit further. We had to put together a few bob to get legal representation because we were up against senior counsel, junior counsel, tax experts and-----

Comment on this

They have deep pockets.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

They do. That is just a statement. They had deep pockets and we did not. Mr. Arkins went in and represented himself and won his case. Really and truly, that is the only way-----

Comment on this

Was that case in the courts or the WRC?

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

It was in the High Court.

Comment on this

For the protection of the witnesses, bearing in mind that they will have court cases, going forward, I ask them to protect themselves. This meeting is being broadcast live. For their protection, I ask them to ensure that whatever they say will not come back against them in the courts because they said something publicly. That is for the protection of the witnesses. I want to make sure they are protected.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

The case was won at the WRC. There was then a place in between where the decision was overturned without explanation. The adjudication officer's decision was overturned without explanation.

Comment on this

By whom was it overturned? Was it by the WRC?

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

It was the Labour Court.

Comment on this

You can appeal from the WRC to the Labour Court.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

Yes. We do not know the reason because it never gave us an explanation. We went off to the High Court. Those cases have been before the High Court. Decisions were issued and other cases are pending. I will leave it at that.

Comment on this

Has anything improved in the past few years? This committee, prior to my joining it, did a report in 2023. Has anything improved at all or is the position still exactly the same?

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

It has absolutely disimproved.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

It has got worse for workers. I will tell the Deputy what happened in the meantime. When we came to this committee and got this thing done, we were trying to get some traction. Members who came forward were told to go through the scope section in the Department of Social Protection. A couple of people went through the Department. This is another issue that has arisen within the film industry. When people went in and put their case forward to scope - I am probably not getting the name right but I know it as scope - it ruled that the workers were bogusly self-employed. Scope ruled in their favour and the company appealed the ruling. The matter went to a full hearing, which found in the workers' favour that, yes, the workers were bogusly self-employed. As some of these workers had worked for 18 or 20-odd years, they had to go back to the same Irish production company. It then said it had nothing to do with it, the company had been dissolved and "Here is my accountant". It is not that the workers argued and won their point once; they had to go back every year. They worked for the same company on different productions but they were then polished off. People were shaking their heads and saying this was absolutely crazy. This is another way workers in the film industry are treated completely different from everyone else. If I work on a building site and I say Murphy's building contractors was on site and I worked for it when I was bogusly self-employed, one ruling will be made against Murphy's construction. That is what is done.

Comment on this

I ask Deputy Timmins to take the Chair.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming before the committee. As with the last time they were here, what they have said is so powerful. That is what has created so much interest in this topic in the committee. As the witnesses will remember, we dealt with this issue at length in the previous committee and really delved into it. I think that is due to the witnesses' very strong contributions.

On what Mr. Arkins said about the WRC and the Labour Court and touched on regarding the construction sector compared with the film sector, do these mechanisms work for the film industry? How can they be changed? What I am hearing is that they are just not fit for purpose for the film industry. Maybe the witnesses could speak about that. They have outlined their own experiences. It is important that we get actionable things we can do to help.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

I am not familiar with the construction industry per se-----

Comment on this

I am referring to the film industry and the witnesses' experiences with the WRC, the Labour Court and all of that. They outlined how everything worked for them in relation to dispute resolution mechanisms and then the failings with respect to their own experiences. Are the dispute resolution mechanisms we have fit for purpose for the film industry, given its complexity? I will put it that way.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

The dispute resolution mechanisms and the adjudication service are for employment rights. They work; there is no way two ways about it. The one difficulty we have is that there is no explanation from the Labour Court. If someone goes to the High Court with a case, they will get a judge's ruling. It will be pages long and will set out its reasons in detail. With the Labour Court, you do not get that. By the way, we were before four divisions of the court because we have 23 or 24 of these cases. We got a different ruling from each division of the court. However, it all amounted to the same thing - "You have got the wrong legal entity". We are going back to 2019. The WRC adjudication officer said that we needed to change, take out the name of the production company and put in the name of the DAC. We refused because the production company, according to the regulations, is responsible. It gets the money. It is the one that gets the shillings and it can go off and do what it likes with them.

That particular section did not work on this occasion. I am sure it works for other workers but it just did not work for this. It is not complex. Let us say you rock up to the Labour Court with a senior counsel, junior counsel, an expert witness on taxation, which is not an employment matter, by the way, and you have two or three accountants willing to give evidence, as they see section 481. The problem is taking out or finding some other mechanism. The Deputy was a member of the committee at the time we spoke here. What was set out in five of the committee's recommendations was to find a mechanism that did not muddy the waters. We were in a hearing for hours where we had, as I said, a senior counsel, junior counsel and a whole myriad of people who were allowed to give evidence on a matter that is not proper to the Labour Court. The Labour Court rules on employment matters, but the way it was framed and the way debate happened around taxation just muddied the waters. The basic point that was made that it was the DAC, the qualifying company. The irony is that it was the producer company that appeared before the Workplace Relations Commission and instructed counsel. The directors of the production company appeared before the WRC and the Labour Court and they are the people who appeared before the High Court, so there has to be some relationship. Why would you spend all of that money trying to say it has nothing to do with you when it clearly has? The evidence of the film regulations did not find favour with the piece in the middle. It found favour with the first and third pieces but not with the piece in the middle, for some reason.

Comment on this

That is interesting. Much of this was dealt with in the previous Dáil term-----

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

That is correct.

Comment on this

-----and the previous Committee on Budgetary Oversight but what has actually changed?

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

Nothing.

Comment on this

That is the issue.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

It is worse.

Comment on this

I think it is great that our fantastic Chair has brought this matter back for discussion. We now need to look at how we can now exert pressure to get this report looked at. A huge amount of work was put into it and it should not be a case that something like that is then left on a shelf. The witnesses have bared their souls at this committee and told us exactly how it was. It was not easy. That should not be the case, and I do not think the committee should stand for it. I am sorry the witnesses have had to come here again. Ms Murray said this is her third time at the committee. I think it is beneficial. We now need to look at how we get that report implemented.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Farrell. As I said at the start of the meeting, I am in construction and I am an employer. The more I listen to the evidence, the more I believe this will not change under the current legislation and laws around the film industry.

I believe there needs to be a different regulation for the film industry because of the process.

I am a building contractor and have a limited company. I employ employees but I also employ subcontractors. The subcontractors that work with me might be here for a couple of weeks and then they are gone. They get a premium cost for being subcontractors, so they look after their own tax affairs and everything else. If they are with me over a long term, however, they can be then deemed employees at a certain time. With my employees, when I go from one contract to another, everything carries over because they are employees. Nothing carries over for a subcontractor. I have listened to everything Mr. Arkins said, including that he has signed 30 contracts, but I have also listened to what he has been saying about the film industry itself. As I recall it, every time a main company starts a film, it sets up another company. At the end of the filming and the end of the tax year, that company is dissolved and the main company then opens up another company. I presume this is done for the protection of the main company because it might have ten, 12 or 15 films going on at the same time and if something happens over here, it could affect the main company. I understand all that but the only way the witnesses are going to change this - and the witnesses will be back here again - is by having a certain policy and regulation around the film industry.

I would not be allowed to set up a new company because you go on a register saying you have so many companies. It takes so long to set up a company and by the time you dissolve a company, it takes a long time. From what I am hearing and from my own experience, and I am no legal expert, if the companies that the main companies are using, over a 12-month cycle or whatever it is, are dissolved, that then takes away all the different rights the workers have because they cannot take them from one company to another company that has been set up for another film as it will be a separate entity and will probably have a separate tax number. Everything has been set up differently. I am trying to look at where the Government could intervene. In that purpose alone, there has to be rights of contract carried over. Mr. Arkins said he has done 30 contracts with the same company on different film sets. To me, that then is a carryover from the point of view of long-term employment under the same company, but there are 30 contracts with 30 different companies in their eyes.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

Yes.

Comment on this

That is where the problem lies. If it is the same main company and it has all these sub-companies or shelf companies that it opens up and closes down, this is where the regulation needs to be tightened up. While the main company has to be protected, the rights of workers in the film industry must be protected when one company carries over into another one. That is where the regulation and policies should change. There should be a different policy for the film industry. What Mr. Arkins is talking about would not work for me in my industry and there are other industries where it would not work. If we are using the same regulation and laws for one sector that is completely different from mine, 99% of them will probably work in mine but there is a percentage of them that will not work in the other.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

The regulation for the film industry - SI 119/2019 - has always operated under its own stand-alone film regulations since SI 357. I always remember the Magnum 357. This is going back a considerable number of years. In 2015 or 2016, it was changed from an investor industry to a production-based industry and the difficulties have arisen from that time. My colleague Mr. Arkins should not have had contracts. When he started in the film industry in 1999, he should have been on an open-ended contract. The Protection of Employees (Fixed-Term Work) Act was in place in 1999 and would have had direct effect from then but it was not transposed here until 2003. However, it would have had direct effect from 1999, so Mr. Arkins should have been considered an open-ended worker but he was not. The industry started issuing fixed-term contracts and they just went on and on. After two-----

Comment on this

On a fixed-term contract, and again I go back to the construction industry with which I am most familiar, someone sets a premium for the fixed-price contract if they are coming in as a specialised contractor, regardless of what sector they come from. They charge a premium for that contract. Did Mr. Arkins's contract come under a basic pay scale?

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

No. It is a fixed-term contract under the Protection of Employees (Fixed-Term Work) Act. After two contracts and four years, one is entitled to a contract of indefinite duration. However, because the companies are saying, "Hold on a second, that wasn't me, your honour. It was-----

Comment on this

It was the other company.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

They are saying it was them but they were-----

Comment on this

A sub-company.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

Yes. The Minister for Finance and the Department of Finance made it clear in the undertaking that was added in 2018 that the Protection of Employees (Fixed-Term Work) Act and all other EU employment law, EU law, all other directives and all social and employment law must apply to the film industry. The film industry will come in here and tell the committee it does apply it, but it is for the period that the workers are on the gig. The other things, such as the framework directive and the new directive on transparent work, do not apply because the worker does not have the service.

Comment on this

The crux of this is that if the main film companies are applying and they have sub-companies, those sub-companies are listed to the same main companies. If they are sub-companies of a main company, the witnesses are looking for this to be recognised under workers' rights. The witnesses are looking for these sub-companies to be recognised as sub-companies, even if they are dissolved, and that there should be something on employment rights.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

Yes. As the committee recommended in its 2023 report, the producer company should be responsible-----

Comment on this

-----for the sub-companies.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

-----because its people are the ones who get the money.

Comment on this

I understand.

Comment on this

We should not be in these circumstances. We have spoken many times before. Let us be clear. Anybody who has spoken about instances of people not having rights within the film industry and anyone who puts their head above the parapet have been blacklisted. Mr. Arkins has seen it happen to him. We could go round and round the garden on this. The fact is that the employer is the producer and the producer draws down the money from section 481. It is as simple as that. Producers get the benefit of it and create the DAC because it is a necessity to create it to produce one film. When the DAC disintegrates having served its purpose, what remain are the rights to that film which belong to the producer-----

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

Correct.

Comment on this

It still has the end results. What is going to happen in court is going to happen in court but the fact is there has been an attempt by the entity that is the employer to basically persuade us that it is not the employer and that this particular device is the employer. That is all it is. It is a financial device.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

Where a contract for a service is provided to, for example, Disney or any of those big companies, it retains the right to the content.

Comment on this

That is my whole point. It owns what is produced.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

However, it does not want Mr. Pesky Employee.

Comment on this

The issue I brought up with Robbie Purfield from SIPTU is the idea that the shooting crew agreement is not fit for purpose. He told me that it does not have enough teeth but it is a deal that is being done with Screen Producers Ireland, the representative body of the producers. They are the employers but they state they are not the employers-----

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

They are fully funded by the State.

Comment on this

I agree 100%.

There is only one way this can work so people have their rights vindicated. The difference between this industry and every other industry is that it receives huge State payments through section 481. It was said earlier that what needs to happen is some sort of registration or auditing scenario and even something beyond that, whereby if a company draws down that money and there are instances of it not delivering on workers' rights or any other rights, then that is a black mark against it and therefore section 481 payments will not be made. I suppose that is the failing. In fairness, the speakers said it is back in Government. It is probably not back under the Department of Finance but under the Department of media. However, that is what we need. We need the Government to set up a mechanism that ensures section 481 funding is only paid to those companies that vindicate the rights of their employees and follow proper procedures. That is what we need to have set up.

Comment on this

We have to finish up for a vote.

Comment on this
Mr. John Arkins

After seven years of the other men and I going through this scenario to come back with the evidence to prove this, the problem is that we cannot tell the committee why the Labour Court ruled the way it did. We cannot tell it because the Labour Court did not tell us. Even the High Court judge said that the Labour Court failed and breached our constitutional rights.

The Deputy spoke about regulations in the film industry. The legislation is there and is quite clear for associated companies. All these companies are associated under the film group. We just want an explanation from the court to tell us why that does not apply to the film industry. If we know why it does not apply to the film industry, then the committee can do something about it. The fact remains the same. Every single Government Minister stood up in the Dáil and said there are no exemptions under any legislation. That is what they have said. However, according to the Labour Court, we have the wrong legal entity. It did not tell us why we had the wrong legal entity. It did not go through and give us a detailed explanation. That is the reason.

Comment on this

It cannot be fixed if there is no disclosure.

Comment on this

Can anything be done by this committee to find that information? That has failed miserably. Beyond that, we need a mechanism that holds producers to account on the basis. We can do it because the State is providing them with money, so they need to adhere to rules. If we need legislative change, we need to make that change, whether we are talking about the fixed-term workers Act or something else.

Comment on this
Ms Liz Murray

The then Minister for Finance, Paschal Donohoe, wrote to us. He said that if the legislation was not being adhered to, he would-----

Comment on this

We also got a promise from the Tánaiste that if this had not been dealt with, that it would be looked at.

Comment on this

We have to vote.

Comment on this

We all have to follow through on it.

Comment on this

This concludes the session. I thank the witnesses for attending the meeting.

Comment on this