DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924 (THIRD STAGE) RESUMED.
Contributions 115–222 of 222. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 18 of 1924 ›
This section deals with making compulsory notification of certain diseases in the country that are at the present time only adopted. Some counties make notification compulsorily, and others need not, and it is obvious that if this section is to be effective at all it should be in force all over the country. The Acts, that the section is intended to enforce, deal with the notification of the spread of disease, the inspection of dairies and cowsheds, and with various other sanitary matters. It might be well to give a short summary of the effect of the Acts that this Bill proposes to put into force.
The following Acts are made compulsory by this section:—
(1) The Infectious Diseases (Notification) Act, 1889. This required heads of families and medical practitioners to notify cases of infectious diseases to the medical officer of health. At present it only applies in urban, rural or port sanitary districts where it has been adopted by the local authority of such district by resolution after advertisement, notice to the Minister, and fourteen days' notice to each member.
(2) The Infectious Diseases (Prevention) Act, 1890, provides for inspection of dairies, cleansing and disinfection of premises, detention in hospitals of infected persons without proper lodging, burial, etc. It only applies to sanitary districts after a resolution as in (1).
(3) Public Health Acts Amendment Act, 1890 (Part III.). This contains sanitary and other provisions dealing with sewers and drains, public sanitary conveniences, building on unclean ground, sanitary bye-laws, foodstuffs sold, slaughter houses, dwelling houses, streets, etc. It applies at present in urban and rural districts after adoption by the sanitary authority by resolution after one month's notice.
(4) Public Health Acts Amendment Act, 1907, Part IV. This contains provisions for preventing the spread of infectious diseases, and prevents persons suffering therefrom from carrying on occupations except such as do not involve risk of spreading the disease. It also deals with the supply of milk, infected clothes, infected children, library books, hospital expenses, nursing, cleansing and disinfecting, and may be applied at present to any district by order of the Minister made on the application of the local authority, who must advertise their intention to make such application for at least a fortnight.
(5) The Tuberculosis Prevention (Ireland) Act, 1908, Part I., provides for the notification of prescribed forms of tuberculosis which, by reason of infective discharges, are liable to communicate the disease. The notification is to be by medical practitioners. It applies at present in sanitary districts after a resolution of the sanitary authority made after fourteen days' notice and approved by the county council. These sections make the Minister's duties in relation to general health clear. They empower him to set up bodies of experts whose advice he can obtain when necessary.
The diseases that are compulsorily notifiable under the First Act, the Prevention of Diseases (Notification) Act, 1889, are the following:—Smallpox, cholera, diphtheria, membranous croup, erysipelas, scarlet fever, typhus fever, enteric fever, relapsing fever, and puerperal fever. It will be noticed that there was a special Act for the compulsory notification of tuberculosis. Tuberculosis is in some respects a disease per se. There is considerable conflict of professional opinion as to how infectious tuberculosis is, but the general idea is that it is not a highly infectious disease, and that people are only liable to infection after being exposed to it for a long period and under conditions of malnutrition, overcrowding, etc. For that reason it has been considered desirable to draft a special Bill to apply to tuberculosis and not to make regulations with respect to this disease as stringent as in respect to highly infectious diseases like smallpox. Accordingly the Act making tuberculosis compulsorily notifiable is a very mild Act. It only applies in cases where the disease is specially contagious or infectious notified as being dangerous by the medical practitioner. The disease is notified by the patient's medical practitioner, and the local authority does not intervene unless at the patient's special request. The medical practitioner who hands in the certificate has to state on the certificate whether the patient desires such attention from the local authority or not, and if not, the local authority does not intervene. The greatest care is taken that no publicity will be given to the diseases and there is no power under the Act for the removal of a patient compulsorily.
I make this statement with regard to tuberculosis, because some people are afraid that by applying this Act compulsorily, tuberculous patients may be subject to hard treatment because people suffering from this disease, and their relations, are naturally sensitive about it. I desire to make it perfectly clear that the application of this Act will not submit them to any humiliating investigation or anything of that kind. It is clearly desirable that the Act should be put into force, because without notification it is impossible to give patients the facilities for curing and treating the disease properly. It is impossible to compile suitable statistics and to provide proper methods for stamping out this disease otherwise. As a matter of fact, since notification was adopted in 1910 there has been a very considerable decline in the number of deaths from tuberculosis. In 1910 the deaths were 1.57 in the thousand, and in 1921, when the last statistics were available, the proportion was 2.3, so that notification on the whole has proved very beneficial in this respect, and it would be a great pity not to enforce this regulation throughout the country.
Comment on this
There is one Act which I do not see mentioned in this schedule, and I would like to know something about it; that is the Public Health (Medical Inspection of Schoolchildren) Act, 1919. I am not sure what will be the position of that Act when this Bill passes. There does not seem to be any reference to it in the Bill, although I understand that it is the law of the land, and applies in some parts of the country.
Comment on this
That Act is applied at present, but the difficulty is that we have no means of enforcing it. Until the county medical officer is appointed under this Bill we will have no means of putting that Act into operation.
Comment on this
Do I take it that once you have the machinery in this Bill set up you will be in a position to apply that measure throughout the country?
Comment on this
Like Deputy Lyons, I am seeking information. I would like to ask the Minister if this Bill will provide procedure by which the owners of houses in towns can be compelled to provide proper sanitary accommodation. I am aware that urban councils have great difficulty at present in enforcing orders owing to the complex provisions of these Acts.
Comment on this
I think it is good to have an extension through the whole country of the provisions of these Acts regarding notification, etc., which have hitherto only applied to certain areas. I would like to have more evidence from the Minister as to the value of the provisions of those Acts in some areas where they have been applied, and to what extent the medical profession, and other persons in duty bound to notify, have complied with the provisions of these Acts in their particular areas. There is a question also which, perhaps, the Minister would answer, as to whether the application of these Acts, referred to in the Fourth Schedule, to the whole country would make any difference respecting the powers of urban authorities in respect to country dairies where infection may exist. I refer to such a case as, say, scarlet fever, in a district from which milk comes to town, and I would like to know whether the town authorities will have any added powers under this section in respect to the notification and, perhaps, to the supervision over and authority to control the milk supply coming from such an area. I have quoted scarlet fever, but that, perhaps, may not be the most pertinent from the point of view of infection in respect to milk, but I will say in reference to any infectious disease which may be conveyed through the milk supply. I know that the matter is giving rise to some difficulty in some places and I wonder whether there are any added powers or changes in the law in such matters embodied in this section.
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson has asked for some more detailed information in regard to the incidence of diseases of the kind specified in these various Acts and the effect of notification on them. Unfortunately, owing to the fire in the Customs House, the statistics in my Department are lacking and it is only general statistics that I can give at this moment.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say, in general terms, that the medical profession have heartily endeavoured to comply with the Act in respect of notification in these areas where they are bound to notify?
Comment on this
Yes. With regard to the inspection of dairies under the section dealing with the appointment of a whole-time county medical officer, that will be provided for. There is a section, Section 4, in the Infectious Diseases Prevention Act touching on the same point. It states that where a medical officer of health is in possession of evidence that any person in the district suffers from an infectious disease attributable to the milk supply in that area from any dairy within or without that district or that the consumption of milk from such dairy is liable to cause infectious disease, in such district, he shall, at the order of a justice having jurisdiction in the area where the dairy is situated, have power to visit such dairy if accompanied by a qualified veterinary surgeon for the purpose of inspecting the animals therein, and if after such inspection he is of opinion that such disease is caused or is likely to be caused by the consumption of milk from that dairy he shall report to the local authority, and the local authority may give notice to the dairyman to appear before them in not less than twenty-four hours.
Comment on this
I move to delete the section. The object of this amendment is to find out the intention of the section. The section says that it shall be the duty of the Minister in the exercise and performance of his powers and duties to take all such steps as may be desirable and so forth. The powers and duties of the Minister are already defined in the Ministers and Secretaries Act. My desire is to find out whether this section adds anything to the powers of the Minister, for, if so, I want to suggest that those additional powers should be more clearly defined. If, as I suspect, it does not add any powers to the Minister, it is unnecessary. If I may be so rash, I will say that the section reminds me of a resolution of, say, a trades' union congress or a farmers' union, or some other public body which is propagandist in its nature. It rather suggests in a general way what the powers and duties of the Minister should be. As I say the Minister's powers have been defined in the Ministers and Secretaries Acts, and I do not think that this adds anything to these powers, and therefore the section is unnecessary. That is why I asked for its deletion, but I may be wrong in that assumption. It may conceal within its ten or twelve lines something to add to the powers of the Minister. If that is the case, I want these added powers much more clearly defined than they are in the section.
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson is more or less correct in his surmise that this is a publicity section to some extent.
Comment on this
It does not add anything to the powers of the Minister. This section has been inserted at the wish of the medical profession throughout the country. I have got no interest in it apart from that. There is, however, this point about it. If there was a spread of infectious disease in this country, or, suppose our food products in England were suffering from any handicap there, and if medical opinion in England became aroused and said that there was no machinery here to enforce regulations regarding the prevention and spread of diseases of that kind, it would be well to be able to point out that there was a Minister who has functions with regard to these matters. That is the principal idea of having that section in the Bill.
Comment on this
Instead of deleting the section, I expected Deputy Johnson would be adding something to it. I am rather surprised he did not put down an amendment to add to the duties of the Minister the duty of looking after or initiating medical inspection of school children, which Deputy Johnson and I have very much at heart. There is nothing said about this duty in that particular section, so the Minister may evade it if he wishes.
Comment on this
I still have the view that it is quite unnecessary. I am not going to press the matter. The Minister has told us that it does not add to his powers, and is merely a declaratory statement. I would suggest the possibility, though, that if the Minister does not exercise all these duties, and take all such steps as may be desirable, he may be impeached. Perhaps, therefore, it had better be left in! I beg to withdraw the amendment, if I may.
Comment on this
I move:—
"In line 24, after the word ‘including,' to insert the following: ‘the strict segregation in all public institutions of persons suffering from all forms of venereal disease and.'"
This amendment is put down, in part, to draw from the Minister some statement of his policy on this question. It is such a disagreeable subject that it is very often passed over without discussion, and because of that, perhaps, things are not as we would wish them to be in some of our public institutions. The state of affairs in a certain public institution in my county was brought under my notice about twelve months ago by a clergyman. I admit it was a revelation to me. Since then I have made some inquiries of members of the committee of the county board of health, and what I said was a revelation to them. I do not know what the conditions may be in other counties, but I do know, in one or two counties, at least, that there are in the men's wards of the institutions men suffering from this horrible disease, and in the same ward, in beds side by side with them, other individuals, some infirm, and the same conveniences are used by all these people in that same ward. A similar state of affairs prevails in the women's ward in these institutions. I think it is really appalling that that should be permitted in any institution. Both from a health point of view, and from the moral point of view, there is everything to be said against it, and a change ought to be effected as soon as possible.
A subject like this is not likely to get the discussion by our boards of health that its importance demands. I fear it has been passed over, and is passed over up and down the country, and unless the Ministry takes some action things cannot be expected to improve, because, generally speaking, the representatives on the boards will pass over this matter as quietly as possible. While I agree that, perhaps, in the public hospitals in Dublin conditions are different, and the wording of my amendment might not be exactly acceptable to those who know more than I do about the conditions in those institutions, I feel that in our county hospitals arrangements ought to be made that when people go in suffering from these diseases they ought, wherever possible, to be separated from those other unfortunate people who enter, because of infirmity or old age. They should be kept apart from those infirm and old poor people, who often have to be compelled to live in a ward, and use all the conveniences these other people use. I want to hear from the Minister what is the policy in this matter, and if there is any intention to take steps to have things altered as soon as possible.
Comment on this
In reading the amendment, I took it in general terms to mean the strict segregation in all the public institutions of persons suffering from all forms of venereal diseases. I took that to mean that all such persons should be segregated in public institutions. However, Deputy Baxter tells me that is not his intention, and that the intention in the amendment is to see where people have been admitted to public institutions suffering from venereal disease that these people shall be segregated or kept in a ward by themselves. Let me say a word or two on the general question: first, as far as the treatment of these diseases is concerned, 95 per cent. of them can be quite safely and well treated outdoor, and are treated outdoor at present. Only about 5 per cent. require hospital or intern treatment on account of complications that arise. If there be any attempt made, as I thought at first this amendment suggested, to segregate these people in institutions who are capable of going about their ordinary occupations, the knowledge of the existence of these diseases would cease, and there would be a cessation of the people who at present are presenting themselves for this outdoor treatment in the hospitals with the most splendid results. At the same time, I will take Deputy Baxter's point of view. These diseases are contagious, but not infectious in the ordinary way; that is to say, that the germs that produce them are carried by some means from persons to persons, and it is quite true, and must be admitted, that if vessels are in contact with persons suffering from these contagious diseases, and if these vessels are brought into contact with healthy persons, in that way the disease might be carried to those other persons.
If any carelessness exists with regard to this, then I think it most advisable that some rule should be adopted by the Local Government Department. I do not know whether they have such a rule as far as institutions as a whole are concerned, because the Local Government Department have no control over hospitals supported by voluntary subscriptions. But in public institutions supported by the rates I think there should be a rule devised by the Local Government Department insisting that where people suffering from venereal disease have been admitted to those institutions they should be kept apart, and the greatest care exercised as regards instruments or anything that is used in eating, such as knives, forks, plates, and other utensils. The utmost care should be taken that articles used by diseased people should not be used by healthy people in the ward. Deputy Baxter suggests that that is not being done, that no care is taken, that people are lying in bed suffering from this disease side by side with others, and that it is possible that the same utensils are used by both classes of patients. That is a great danger. If Deputy Baxter wants anything carried in the nature of an amendment he must modify his proposal by inserting the following words, "strict segregation in all public institutions, supported by the rates, of persons who have been admitted therein and are suffering from venereal disease." I do not think it is necessary that this amendment should be passed. I think the Local Government Department should have a rule that those cases be kept apart.
Comment on this
If he refers to county homes, I would point out that venereal diseases are not treated in county homes, and that nobody is allowed in the county homes except the old and infirm. No able-bodied man or woman is allowed into a county home. Again, if he refers to hospitals, I think he has a very poor opinion of doctors if he thinks they would allow such a state of affairs in any hospital.
Comment on this
Deputy Myles may call it what he likes. I am stating the conditions as I have found them on investigation of a county home.
Comment on this
Has such a thing been known definitely, because I think it is a terrible state of affairs?
Comment on this
Unfortunately it is true and I regret to have to bring it forward here. It was a revelation to myself and only it was brought to my notice by a clergyman I would not know of it. When it was brought by me to the notice of the committee they had no knowledge of it.
Comment on this
I do not think this amendment would fit in with this declaratory resolution and add to its value. I suggest there is a little misunderstanding. As I understand, Deputy Baxter is referring not primarily to people treated for venereal disease but to people who may be brought into hospital suffering from other diseases, and yet who may be suffering from that disease.
Comment on this
The Deputy has raised a point that is rather difficult to deal with. I thought first of all he was referring to cases in county hospitals that were being treated for this disease. I do not know what action can be taken in a county home, because in the ordinary course of events such a patient should not be in there but should be in a county hospital. Treatment of the disease is difficult, because the term "venereal disease" is a comprehensive one, and the effects of the discase are manifold. There are very few diseases but may have had their origin in some venereal affection, or may have predisposed the patient to the disease. You may get a patient suffering from bone disease or rheumatism, or something of that kind, that may have had a venereal origin. In some cases the disease is infectious, in others it is not. Sometimes it may be latent and it may break out at different periods. It might inflict serious hardship on individuals to have them segregated in the way mentioned. It may prevent them seeking treatment. At the present time many women are suffering from the disease who do not know it. If they knew they were to be segregated and branded with the stigma of this disease they might not go in for treatment at all. It is a big question to go into.
At the present time the Government is being very much exercised by it, and my solution of the problem is to appoint a consultative council under the provisions of the next section to inquire into the whole matter regarding the spread of venereal disease. In the first instance, the duty is on the medical officer of a hospital to see that this or any other infectious disease does not spread, and he would be guilty of neglect amounting to criminal neglect if he allowed a person to contract a disease of this kind owing to not having his patients properly isolated when suffering from a malignant form of the disease. I am afraid, in the first instance, that this will have to be left to the discretion of the medical officer. It would be impossible to devise rules and regulations from our point of view that would be capable of having the effect that Deputy Baxter seeks, without at the same time inflicting grave hardships on people who may be suffering from the conseqence of the disease which they may have contracted innocently. A surgeon may acquire this disease in performing an operation, or it may be congenital. On the whole, it is a matter that could not be dealt with in this rough-and-ready way. It is a delicate matter, and we can only devise means of dealing with it after consultation with those people who can give us expert advice. I cannot accept the amendment, but I think it is a good thing to raise the matter here to allow us to get the views of the Dáil on it. I was not aware of the fact that cases, such as Deputy Baxter mentioned, were to be found in county homes, and I am very sorry to hear it. In the ordinary course of events, such things could not occur.
Comment on this
Before we confer on the Minister those powers formally, I want to impeach him. Deputy Johnson foresaw the possibility. Among the powers given to the Minister we have (b) the treatment of physical and mental defects, including the treatment and care of the blind. It will be within the memory of Deputies that when the Old Age Pensions Act was passing through the Dáil considerable opposition was manifested to the reduction in the pensions of the blind. While Deputy Johnson found me unsympathetic on other matters, I agreed with him on this. We obtained a pledge from the Minister for Finance that if the responsible Minister would put up a scheme for ameliorating the condition of the blind by training or otherwise he would divide up for that purpose the money saved by not having the blind pensions. As far as I know, the Minister has not put up any scheme, and before I agree to confer on him those powers, I want to get a promise from him that he will consider this matter and put forward a workable scheme. The Minister for Finance cannot get away from his pledge. It only remains for the Minister for Public Health or his Department to take up the matter. I earnestly hope that when he replies he will tell us the scheme is already in being and only requires pressure created in the Dáil to put it in force.
Comment on this
We provide a grant of £6,500 for the blind, and it is open to the local authority to propose schemes. We are willing to adopt them if they do and to provide for the relief of the blind in institutions such as Deputy Cooper suggests. At the moment I have not devised any particular scheme for relief in general. It has not been brought home to me in any way that it is imperatively necessary at the moment.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister realise that it is a very unusual situation for the Minister for Finance to leave money waiting for a Minister and not to have that money used. His attention being drawn to the matter now, will he consider it?
Comment on this
May I also add that if this section is carried it will not be enough for him to wait until the local authorities present schemes. It will be his duty, if this section means anything, to take all steps that are necessary to secure the treatment of physical and mental defects, including the treatment and care of the blind, and the training of persons for such services. I did not think that it added anything to the powers, duties and functions connected with public health which had been given to the Minister already. I am beginning to think that there is a good deal to be said for this section and that the Minister will not be able any longer to say that the local bodies had failed to initiate schemes and that therefore he could not act. If this is carried, we shall be able at any time to say it is his duty, notwithstanding the failure of the local authority to take the necessary steps to secure the prevention and cure of disease. If this money that has been taken from the blind pensioners is available for schemes of treatment and the care of the blind, then as soon as this becomes law we shall look to the Minister to find a way of spending those moneys economically and effectively.
Comment on this
My impeachment in this matter has been carried out in a very perfunctory way. I am afraid that Deputy Cooper had not his brief prepared. He should have brought forward evidence to substantiate his charge. The onus of proof is on him, for the present at all events. So far as I am aware, I have not been negligent in my treatment of the blind. I am glad that the Minister for Finance is available, if we find it necessary to call upon him. So far there has been no case of hardship brought to my notice on account of there not being sufficient funds available for the blind. We spend every year £6,500 for the blind, and, as far as I am aware, that is adequate. If Deputy Cooper is prepared to bring forward evidence that the blind are suffering as a result of my administration, I will be happy to carry out his views.
Comment on this
I rise to a point of order on Section 17. Are we in order in proceeding with a section which proposes to vote money, with no member of the Executive Council present. If the Minister for Finance had just gone out, I would not call attention to it, but he has now gone out for over a quarter of an hour. We have a right to have a member of the Executive Council here, and certainly in a debate on a financial matter a member of the Executive Council should be present. Would I be in order in moving to report progress?
Comment on this
The Seanad is meeting to-day, and I know that certain members of the Executive Council are busily engaged over there. Perhaps the Minister's presence is required over there for a few minutes.
Comment on this
The Minister has been in the Dáil all the time, but I believe the Seanad rose more than half-an-hour ago. If it will convenience the Minister, I will not move to report progress, but I suggest that you should adjourn for half-an-hour to enable a member of the Executive Council to be present.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
To delete the section and to substitute a new section as follows:
(1) For the purpose of giving advice and assistance to the Minister in connection with the exercise and performance of his powers and duties in matters affecting or incidental to the health of the people there shall be established a public health council.
(2) The public health council shall consist of the following persons:—Eight persons representing boards of health, appointed by the Minister after consultation with such boards or a representative association thereof: Four persons representing councils of county boroughs, appointed by the Minister after consultation with such councils: Three persons being registered medical practitioners, appointed by the Minister after consultation with organisations of such practitioners, at least two of such persons being registered on the medical register in respect of a diploma in sanitary science, public health, or State medicine: One person being a registered dentist, appointed by the Minister so as to represent such dentists after consultation with any association thereof: One person being a registered veterinary surgeon, appointed by the Minister so as to represent such surgeons after consultation with any association thereof: Two persons representing registered nurses, appointed by the Minister after consultation with association thereof: Two persons representing certified midwives, appointed by the Minister after consultation with associations thereof.
(3) The Minister may make regulations for the purpose of increasing the membership of the public health council so as to provide for the representation of insured persons or of approved societies under the National Health Insurance Acts, 1911 to 1924, or any Act amending those Acts.
(4) The public health council shall meet at least twice in every year for the purpose of considering matters of public interest in connection with the health of the people and giving such advice to the Minister thereon as he shall think fit.
(5) The Minister may make general regulations for regulating the proceedings and quorum of the public health council, and the council shall act in accordance with those regulations.
(6) The Minister shall be ex officio a member of the public health council, but shall not, save as hereinafter provided, vote at any meeting of the council.
(7) The Minister may take the chair at any meeting of the public health council and in such case shall have a casting vote.
(8) In the absence of the Minister, an officer of the Minister appointed by him may attend a meeting of the public health council.
(9) The Minister may require any of his officers to act as secretary or other officer of the public health council.
(10) The public health council may appoint committees consisting of members of the council or of members and other persons for the purpose of considering matters referred to such committees by the council.
(11) Payments may be made by the Minister, out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas, to members of the public health council and committees thereof, to such extent as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance, in respect of the following matters, that is to say:—
(a) repayment of travelling expenses.
(b) payment of subsistence allowance.
(c) reasonable compensation for loss of remunerative time.
Section 17 gives power to the Minister to establish consultative councils in connection with such matters affecting, or incidental to, the health of the people as may be specified in the order. Every consultative council established under this section consists of persons having practical experience as to the matter in respect of which they are to give advice or assistance. A few moments ago the Minister indicated what he meant when he asked for power to establish consultative councils. A specific evil is present and he wishes to establish a consultative council to advise him with respect to that specific evil. That is very good, but I do not think that the Minister, when proposing to get these powers, is meeting the requirements of the case to any appreciable degree. The proposal is that the Minister may appoint such a council to deal with specific subjects, to be constituted in any way he pleases. It is not intended that these councils should have initiative. They shall not be required to consider subjects for suggestion or submission to the Minister. It is presumably intended that a council should be formed ad hoc to deal with specific matters referred to them by the Minister. The Public Health Council that was set up some years ago made a report which was, I think, a very valuable one in many respects. That body reported in favour of the establishment of a health council to advise the Ministry generally respecting all matters affecting public health. The recommendation was: “The formation within the Ministry of a health council composed of representatives of public and professional interests, to which will be entrusted the general direction of policy in regard to the administration of medical and health services in Ireland.” The body that made that recommendation was a body of very experienced and responsible persons. It included the Medical Commissioner of the Local Government Board, Dr. Coey Biggar, Sir Henry Robinson, Sir Joseph Glynn, Dr. Maguire, Mrs. Dickie, Dr. Rowlette, and several others, and it was a very carefully considered and well thought out report. In one or two respects it is out of date, inasmuch as we have now a definite Ministry of Public Health, but there is still required a body such as a public health council, which will be permanently in existence to advise generally and inspire, if I might say so, the public health side of the Minister's work.
We must bear in mind that the Minister is a Minister not only of public health. His functions are very much wider than the mere consideration of public health and medical affairs, and it was believed by that council, and I believe that it would add very greatly to the prestige and authority of his Department, on the public health side, if there was in existence a council of the kind that is proposed in the amendment. Within that council, or from that council, there may well be selected consultative committees to deal with specific matters that may be referred to them by the Minister, such as are touched upon in this section. But much more than that is needed. There was some difference of opinion on the part of this committee that made its report in 1920 respecting the internal organisation of the Ministry of Public Health, but there was no difference of opinion amongst these fifteen or twenty persons, of long experience and a good deal of responsibility, in respect to the necessity for a health council, and giving that council considerable powers, not, let me say, depriving the Minister of his powers and his responsibility, but a council advisory and fitting in with the scheme of government which we have adopted, and yet a body which might be looked upon by the Minister as capable of giving him authoritative advice and expert direction.
The proposals in the amendment are that such council shall be somewhat different from the proposals in the report of the Public Health Council, set up in 1920. The proposals in the amendment follow the plan somewhat of the late Council of Agriculture, and the composition is somewhat different from the composition recommended by the Public Health Council, or as represented by Deputy Sir James Craig. We make provision for eight representatives of the boards of health, four representatives of the county boroughs which are outside the county health districts, three of them to be representatives of the medical profession, one of the dental profession, one of the veterinary surgeons, one of the nurses, perhaps one of the midwives, and leaving open the question of the representation of health insurance societies, inasmuch as there is sitting a committee which presumably will report upon the relations of the health insurance societies to the Ministry of Health. It may be desirable that there should be representatives of the health insurance societies upon any public health council.
There is not at present anybody or any authority, except the Minister himself, which might be said to be a unifying, co-relating, or stimulating authority in matters of public health. As I said, the Minister has very much wider responsibilities than the supervision of public health. No doubt he has expert advisers, but the expert advisers are unknown to the public; they cannot speak with the same authority as an advisory council of the kind that is referred to in the amendment, and they cannot stimulate or educate public opinion in the same way that such a council would. I would suggest for the consideration of the Minister and the House that is a very important part indeed of the work of public health administration, the interesting of the public in matters of public health and getting the consent, approval and co-operation of the public in the administration of public health laws. When a proposal comes out from the Minister on the advice of his expert representatives, who may or may not be known to the public — in the main are not known to the public — it will not have the same force as a proposal of the kind would if it were backed by a council of this kind. If there is a council representative of all the interests whose business it is to promote public health, to prevent disease, advising the Minister, stimulating public action, creating public opinion — and shall I say?—directing public policy in respect of health affairs, the hope of general co-operation will be very much the greater and it will more likely be realised than if there is no such council. If there is any fear that the creation of a council of this kind will cut across Ministerial responsibilities I think that fear may be dispelled.
The proposal in the amendment would not at all deprive the Minister of his powers and responsibility, but the council would be empowered to consider proposals, schemes and plans on their own initiative, and make those proposals to the Minister. If he thought well to incorporate them into administrative action or into legislation he would have immensely more authority, both with the public and the legislature, than he could have without such a body. The intention of the amendment is that such a council shall meet twice a year at least, and that the Minister would preside at such conferences. I think that the proposal is one which will add very greatly to the Bill and give a good deal more confidence in public health administration in the future, and will inspire the public, I think, with a desire to assist in that administration and co-operate in the general work of public health. I commend this proposal to the Dáil as a better one than the proposal in the Bill, one which would not necessarily cost more money, perhaps would cost less money, if there are to be many consultative councils set up. I would say that the extra cost, if there is to be such, would be very well repaid in value received. Consultative councils or consultative committees, as I have said already, for specific purposes, can still be appointed, and are likely to be much more satisfactory if appointed from or by this council than by the manner set out in the section. I would ask the Dáil to give fair consideration to the proposal, and eventually, I hope, to embody it in the Bill.
Comment on this
If Deputy Johnson chooses to move his amendment in the absence of an Executive Council Minister, I am willing that he should do so——
Comment on this
But I am not willing that we should proceed with its consideration, and I ask you, sir, whether you will take a motion to report progress. The Seanad is not sitting; I have been over there and the place is in darkness. There are three Executive Ministers in the precincts of the Dáil having tea. If they can have tea, why should we not have tea? Will you take a motion to report progress? Standing Order 83 says: "In considering a Bill a Special Committee may at any time, adjourn, and the Dáil sitting in Committee may, at any time, report progress, provided that a motion to this effect has been carried. Any such motion which is deemed by the Chairman to be dilatory or obstructive shall not be accepted." This is not a dilatory or obstructive motion. It is the assertion of a constitutional principle that where the Dáil is asked to consider matters involving expenditure of public money not merely an External Minister but an Executive Minister who is responsible for the expenditure of money shall be here. I move to report progress, if you will accept the motion.
Comment on this
I think so long as a substantive resolution is not under discussion there is no necessity to have a member of the Executive Council present. The Minister for Finance remained here while the substantive resolution was under discussion, but he said that he had an important interview and could not spend time here while an amendment was being discussed.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance is necessary. As a matter of fact no amendment can be moved until the section is under discussion and comes under consideration. But apart from that the Minister for Finance is not the only Minister. Where is the Minister for External Affairs? Has he been so exhausted by three hours' work in the Seanad, if he has been there? I understood that the Seanad has been discussing a Bill in which the Minister for Agriculture was interested. I think it is treating the Dáil farcically that no Executive Minister should be here.
Comment on this
Before you put the motion, might I draw attention to the rights and privileges of Deputies? There is an unwritten rule that no Deputy would draw attention to the absence of Deputies during tea time. After all, I think we agreed some time ago that we would do our best to keep a quorum between the hours of 6 and 7, and as it is now 10 minutes to seven, I do not think we ought to adopt the drastic step that Deputy Cooper has proposed.
I only rise to remind the Dáil that we agreed not to draw any attention to the want of a quorum between the hours of 6 o'clock and 7 o'clock. The Ministers who are gone to tea are entitled to a little relief, and they are entitled to get away during the hours upon which we agreed.
Comment on this
Under the Standing Orders I do not think it is necessary to have a quorum when on the Committee Stage, between either the hours of 6 o'clock and 7 o'clock, or any other hours for that matter.
Comment on this
I see that the Minister has now arrived, and I suggest that we should now proceed with the business. I am really anxious to deal with this matter, and now that the Minister is here, I think that Deputy Cooper might withdraw his proposal.
Comment on this
If the Minister is going to stay, and does not intend to come in and go out again, I am quite willing to withdraw.
Comment on this
I am not sure that I perfectly understand the situation.
Comment on this
I may, however, say this: If a Minister is not allowed to have his tea without Deputies coming out to spy and count heads and then come back here and report that a Minister is having certain sustenance, then the Dáil has got to a very peculiar pitch. I require to be fed just as well as anybody else, and I think it is for myself to choose, when I please, the time when I shall eat. I do not think it is the rule of this House, nor do I regard it as an essential, that a Minister should be in the Dáil when a clause in the Bill, which covers the same ground as the Financial Resolution previously moved, is under consideration. I regard it really as very derogatory to the dignity of the House that any Deputy should indulge in the statements that I understand Deputy Cooper has indulged in.
Comment on this
As a matter of personal explanation, I would like to inform the Minister that the only reason why I tried to see if there were Ministers available, was because the Minister for Local Government and Public Health had stated that several Ministers were engaged in the Seanad. Nobody, of course, would desire to prevent any Minister from having tea, but Ministers should arrange to relieve each other so that there should be some Executive Minister responsible to the Dáil always here. Even if we had Private Members' business under consideration, we should always have the guidance of a member of the Executive Council. That is a constitutional principle which I assert and which the Dáil should assert. I am accused of having spied. If I did so, I apologise, and I hope the Minister will accept my apology. I am rather heated in this matter and I may have acted wrongly. If so, I hope the Minister will accept my apology.
Comment on this
If I may again intervene, I do not think that this matter has gone to the point of having an apology made or accepted. The Deputy has vehemently asserted the point of view he holds. I want, with equal vehemence, to repudiate that. I do not at all accept that as a principle. Is it suggested that the Minister responsible to the Dáil is not competent to carry on the business of his own Department in the Dáil? I think he is quite competent, and it is quite in accordance with the dignity of the House, when other Ministers are entirely occupied with their business, that one Minister would be left here to handle affairs on his own.
Comment on this
If I may say so, I think that the question of how many Ministers should be present, when a matter of great importance like this Local Government Bill is under discussion, may be said to be for the discretion of the Ministers themselves. But it does suggest itself to me that where very important matters — and in this case, matters which involve payment of moneys out of the Exchequer are under consideration—the Minister in charge of the Bill should not be left entirely unsupported, even on the Benches behind him, as frequently has been the case. Apart from that, I think there is a good deal of point in Deputy Cooper's complaint that in this Bill, to a degree noticeable, the Minister in charge has been left alone to deal with any criticism. The Minister appears not to have had the support of the other Ministers in piloting the Bill through. I think the constitutional point is not so great as Deputy Cooper has suggested. I think the question is between Ministers, though the point may be considered quite a considerable one.
Comment on this
I want to support, in the very strongest manner, the amendment that has been proposed by Deputy Johnson, which is more or less the same as the amendment which stands in my name and which follows on the amendment Paper. There were two things that I have been interested in ever since I first tried to impress upon the Dáil the necessity for some improvement in the public health service of the country. One was the appointment of a fully qualified fulltime county medical officer, who would devote all his attention to his work, and be responsible eventually to the Minister; the other was that there should be a public health advisory council that would be able to initiate matters and give advice to the Minister. The first of these is provided for in the Bill. The second is not provided for in anything like the way I would like to see it provided for. I called attention, during the Second Reading, to the fact that I had the greatest possible objection to the appointment of consultative committees that may be appointed by the Minister, that he may never call to his aid, that can only discuss with him matters he himself lays before them for discussion, and that cannot initiate matters of public utility and public benefit. Deputy Johnson has alluded to the public health council, that was appointed by the Ministry for Health Act, 1919. In addition to the public health council, that Act appointed at the same time the Chief Secretary as Minister for Health.
In appointing this public health council, the preamble stated that it was appointed for the purpose of giving advice and assistance and making proposals to the Minister for Health. It will be seen from this that that council was clearly empowered to make proposals on its own initiative. As Deputy Johnson said, this public council sat for many months. They were a very important and well-informed body in regard to public health, and in 1920 they eventually issued a report, that has also been referred to. They made certain proposals, which included an Irish Public Health Bill. This Bill was to improve the public health service in the country. That public health council was appointed under the Act of 1919, and it has been allowed to expire. Deputy Johnson's amendment is an attempt to resuscitate this very important council. As Deputy Johnson said, the council made certain recommendations. They recommended the appointment of a ministry of health. The Government have met us half way in that; they have called the Minister for Local Government also the Minister for Public Health. They objected to a separate minister for health, and I agreed with the Government then, that perhaps the expenditure would be too great. I pointed out then, and I would point out still, with all due respect to the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, that he knows nothing about public health, and that it would be a great advantage to the Dáil if, when a separate minister for public health was not appointed, that a parliamentary secretary would be appointed who would be able to give information to the Dáil, more direct information than the Minister could, who is not quite in touch with public health matters. Another recommendation was the formation of a public health council. The Deputy and I put down amendments. I have copied exactly the personnel of the council selected by this public health council. Deputy Johnson has enlarged upon it. Perhaps if I were to find fault with his amendment it would be that the committee he has suggested is too large. As far as I remember, there are fifteen members on the committee suggested by the council. I think Deputy Johnson has suggested something like twenty-one members on his public health council.
In the recommendations that a public council should be formed, it was to be composed of representatives of public and professional interests to which should be entrusted the general direction of policy in regard to the administration of medical and health services in Ireland. So far we have settled the county unit as the area of local administration, and by means of the committees that I am sure will be appointed by the public health boards, we have linked up, as far as my estimation is concerned, the districts with the central local authorities, namely, the county councils through the public health boards. But what we have not done, and what the Bill does not do anything like sufficiently, is to connect the local rating authority and the public health authority in the country with the central authority here. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health is the central figure here. He is the head of the central health authority, and as he will tell us the Bill provides for the formation of certain consultative committees. These are not sufficient. This central health council that Deputy Johnson is proposing, or advisory board, as I have called it, is absolutely necessary. This will bring the local rating authorities into close connection with the central health administration. It would get the support of the medical profession in the country, because there is a provision made that the medical profession should be represented on this council as well. Finally, there are the voluntary nursing associations working in the country, and, in my opinion, it will be extremely advisable that these people working down in the country should be able, by sitting on an advisory council, to give advice as to the matters I have referred to before — that is, as to the medical inspection and treatment of school children. The people who are engaged in that work, I believe, should be in touch with the Minister so as to give him advice to work out a policy and suggest the changes that might be made. It would create a far greater interest in the public health of the country if they thought they were in touch with the central authority here. The object aimed at by setting up this council and advisory board is that the local bodies would be in a position to have their needs and interests inquired into, and, secondly, the Minister will be kept fully in touch, and will be more likely to have the support of the public and the profession generally.
Deputy Johnson has touched upon another point that I think is of importance. Although the provision in the Bill suggests that these consultative committees should be some way qualified to deal with matters that would crop up, Deputy Johnson wisely said that his proposal does not interfere with the adoption of committees that would deal ad hoc with certain matters. That does not interfere with the formation of the health council. What I have been pressing for on the Second Reading was that we should have specified the qualifications of the people who were going to serve on those committees. That is to say, there are certain representatives in the local rating authorities who should get their interest represented, and that the medical profession, the veterinary profession, the dental profession, and the nursing profession should be represented. I think it is absolutely necessary that these qualifications should be specified in regard to the personnel of the council. I have stated before, and I state again, that I feel with regard to the proposal in the Bill that the Minister may appoint anybody he likes, whom he may consider has qualifications for the post. But he may not be capable of judging whether they have these qualifications or not. In the second place, as I have said before, there is nothing obligatory either to call these people together or ask their advice. If the Minister does call them together he can lay before them whatever he likes and not allow them to discuss any matters which would initiate a public health policy on their part. I therefore support in the strongest way the amendment proposed by Deputy Johnson.
Comment on this
I was not surprised to see Deputy Sir James Craig bringing forward an amendment of this kind. It was at least similar to what Deputy Johnson has moved. Deputy Sir James Craig is a distinguished representative in the Dáil of an eminent profession. It is only natural that he should take upon himself the duty of looking after the interests of that profession in every possible way. I consider that the proposal of consultative councils, constituted as suggested, would probably be to the interests of the people interested, such as nurses, doctors, veterinary surgeons, etc. But I cannot see so clearly why Deputy Johnson is so interested in this matter, because I think that if such a body were set up, it would amount to a serious hampering and a serious interference with the rights and prerogatives of the Dáil. The suggestion for an advisory board of this type appears in paragraph 27 of the report of the first public health council. This paragraph recommends that the general policy and the principles of administration of public health and medical service, should be subject to the general control and direction of the health council, constituted on the lines set out in the amendments. The central authority recommended in paragraph 26 (a) and (b) was the Chief Secretary. The Chief Secretary in those times had very little time to devote to public health matters. His hands were, for the most part, preoccupied with political measures, measures for enforcing law and order as understood in those days. He had very little time to deal with public health matters. He came over here a stranger in the country. As a general rule he was only left here for a short time, too short a time to learn the peculiar conditions that prevailed in the country. He came over here and was asked to administer laws passed in Great Britain and applicable to English conditions, and which would only be made applicable to conditions in Ireland by a liberal use of scissors and paste. Such an officer coming over to Ireland to administer laws that were not in the first instance made for Ireland was placed in a very peculiar position. Without the assistance of a council, composed of representatives of the profession interested in public health and local authorities, it would be practically impossible that such an officer could carry on, and it was undoubtedly a proper thing at that time to set up a council or body such as is recommended in Deputy Sir James Craig's and Deputy Johnson's amendment, with some differences.
I oppose the two amendments on the same grounds. We are in a totally different position now. Our legislation is passed by an Irish Parliament, and Irish conditions are present to our minds all the time when we are legislating. The law is to be administered by an Irish Minister, not by an English Chief Secretary. Any advice I require in this matter I much prefer to get from this Dáil, which is the most representative assembly in the country, and a totally disinterested assembly, rather than from a body such as that proposed by Deputy Johnson, which, I say, without meaning any offence to the people interested in it, would, to the extent of two-thirds, be more interested in the particular professions they represent than the interests of the nation as a whole.
Comment on this
I will make the Deputy a present of that. Even if it was only to the extent of 10 per cent.——
Comment on this
Would the Minister say in what way my profession would benefit by serving on a public health council?
Comment on this
I mean that naturally an advisory council of that kind would have the interests of the profession at heart, and would be continually prompting me as to what is the best thing for the profession and suggesting that I should adopt this measure or that measure, oftentimes regardless of whether it was to the interest of the ratepayers or not. They would have in mind more the interest of their own professions than they would that of the general public. I prefer in matters of general policy to be guided rather by the Dáil than by an advisory council of that kind. The type of council I need in this matter is a council that would give me expert advice in case of any sudden emergency, of any difficulty with which my Department is not in a position to cope. If there was a serious outbreak of influenza of an abnormal kind, an advisory council consisting of nurses, veterinary surgeons and ordinary country practitioners would be of very little assistance to me. If the plague or some unusual disease of that kind broke out, it would be necessary for me to be in a position, if necessary, to go to Vienna to get experts to deal with that particular problem. That is the object I had in view.
Deputy Sir James Craig, of course, throws doubt on my capacity to deal with problems of this kind, and says that perhaps the medical men would be in a better position to deal with public health matters. But, as a matter of fact, when the Ministry of Health was set up in England, on the first occasion they appointed a medical officer as Minister of Health. For some reason, that has not been stated, that officer was never subsequently appointed.
Comment on this
Ministers have been appointed since, and on each occasion they have been laymen. I do not want to press that point further. As I say, a council of this kind would be of very little assistance to me. The other consultative council would be of very great assistance, and under no circumstances would I agree to drop it. If I were to have the two councils of the type suggested by Deputies Sir James Craig and Johnson, as well as this council, it would be necessary to seek another grant from the Ministry of Finance, as there is not sufficient provision made in the Bill. I could not approve of the setting up of such a council under any circumstances. I go even further and say that if such a body were in existence when this Ministry was set up, it would be the duty of the Minister to dissolve it. In doing so I would be acting on precedent. We had the analogy of the Congested Districts Board and of the Commissioners of National Education. There was no necessity for the Commissioners of National Education after a Ministry of Education was set up, and after we had a national assembly to legislate for Ireland and to guide the Minister in the administration of his Department.
Comment on this
We have now the mind of the Minister revealed. He was appointed as Minister to look after local government, public health, housing, poor law, road administration, elections, registration of voters old age pensions, and several other things, but he does not need advice in the administration of these Departments, or any of them, except the advice that he can get from the Dáil. I want to know whether it is his conception of the business of the Dáil that it is to be an administrative authority. Is it our business to help him in the administration of his Department? If it is, then I suggest he should take a method which has not yet been taken, and that is, to ask for the appointment of a committee of the Dáil to assist him. Quite a reasonable proposition; one which may eventually have to be adopted, but one which has not yet been considered by the Dáil, or embodied in the Constitution. Apart from that, how is the Minister going to receive directions as to policy in matters of public health from the Dáil? In a broad and general way it might be possible occasionally in the course of a Session for the Dáil to pass resolutions respecting matters of public health. But, does anybody suggest that it is within the competence of the Dáil to deal in any efficient way with the policy of administration for the prevention and cure of disease? Nobody would pretend it. We can raise questions, we can discuss methods, we can criticise the administration, but who will pretend that the Dáil is competent to bring forward concrete proposals, to initiate detailed administrative methods to the Minister in matters of public health? The Minister knows that is impracticable. He really wants to have all the power in this matter in his hands, and that he should act not on the advice of any body who has the ear of the public, and help thereby to educate the public, but on the advice of his administrative officers against whom I have not a word to say. I know nothing of their competence, and I assume that they are the most competent people in the country.
The Minister says that he, as Minister, is quite capable without the assistance of any such body as is adumbrated in these proposals, to administer the affairs of public health in this country, in addition to affairs relating to housing, poor law, local government, registration, elections and all the other matters that come under his Department. He says that while it may have been necessary to have such a body when there was only a Chief Secretary to administer laws which were passed in England it is now no longer necessary. If we rule the Dáil out in matters of detail respecting administration what is the difference between his Department of Public Health and the Department of Public Health that existed before 1921? Apparently the Minister thinks that it is a good enough answer to the very serious and carefully-thought-out suggestion of Deputy Sir James Craig and the amendment that I have moved, to suggest that the medical profession in backing any proposal is only thinking of its own interests. The medical profession will thank him for that. If any public purpose is to be served by his administration of public health he will have to secure the co-operation of the medical profession. He starts off by saying that in any proposal of this kind to associate the medical profession with administration they will be only looking after their own interests. I wish there were more doctors in the Dáil. I think the Minister has not done himself justice in this. He suggested that two-thirds of the members of the council would be professional people looking after their own interests. The proposal is that there shall be twelve representatives of the elected councils who are locally responsible for administration, and nine others representative of the various elements professionally affected, not only in the cure but in the prevention of disease.
I wonder does the Minister realise that the new view, shall I say the modern view, respecting the functions of the medical profession has been prevention rather than the cure of disease. I wonder have such views ever reached him. If they have, and if he accepts it as part of the business of the medical profession, does he not see that if they were perfectly successful in preventing disease, or as widely successful as it is humanly possible to be, they would be killing their professional interests, and yet, does he deny that they do seek to prevent disease? If the people who have expert knowledge of the causes of disease, the means of curing disease, and more particularly the precautions necessary to prevent disease, are not to be called in to assist and give active co-operation in the direction of policy, then we have to say good-bye to any commonsense, let alone any good-will, as between the Ministry and the persons concerned. The Minister, in taking up the very rigid position he has taken in this matter, reveals, as I said, the mind behind the whole Bill.
While Deputy Sir James Craig has generally supported provisions relating to public health embodied in the Bill, because he believed they were going to benefit public health administration, I think he will see now that there was more in the opposition to local autonomy in other matters than he saw before. We now find that the idea of bureaucracy is firmly implanted in the Minister's mind. He wants to centralise in officialdom all power or authority, and that they shall not even accept advice, except on special occasions, for special purposes, from persons who may be said to be interested in public affairs. I regret that the Minister has taken this stand. I thought he would have seen how valuable an assistance this would be to the administration of his Department. I hope he will either withdraw his references to the medical profession, or that the medical profession will let him know what they think of him.
Comment on this
I am sorry to have to differ with such an eminent authority as Deputy Sir James Craig is on a matter of this kind. It appears to me that the difference between the amendment and the original Bill is a very marked one. The Minister proposes in the original Bill that he shall have the right to set up an advisory committee, should occasion require it. The proposal in the amendment is that a permanent advisory committee shall be set up which shall meet twice every year. That permanent advisory committee is not to have any executive powers. The amendment states that its duties are to be as follows:—
"Considering matters of public in connection with the health of the people, and giving such advice to the Minister thereon as it shall think fit."
Whether the advice is necessary, or whether it is useful, we are to have this permanent committee set up to meet twice a year at considerable public expense to tender that advice.
What is the position under the Bill, looking at it as practical men? We have twenty-six counties in the Free State, and under the Bill, I take it, we will have twenty-six boards of health. That is to say, we will have twenty-six boards of health advising the Ministry, and on top of that it is proposed to attach another advisory board. We will have something to say later on about the expense that is going to be incurred under another section of the Bill. There is a growing feeling, for which there is a good deal of substance outside this Dáil, that we already have too many officials in connection with the Government of the Free State. I look upon this proposition as an ordinary citizen, not possessing any special skill, and I am inclined to come to the conclusion that twenty-six boards of health, each advising the Ministry in connection with the matters that come under their jurisdiction, would certainly be adequate, if not too much. As far as I am concerned, I am not prepared to support any proposal that will add a further unnecessary number of officials to the government of the country, or a further unnecessary number of advisory people who are to meet at least twice a year at the expense of the State.
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson, who has been most anxious all through the discussion of this Bill to set up committees, which, as far as I can see, will have very few duties to perform, stated that what he had in his mind was something similar to the committees that existed under the Department of Agriculture and Technical Instruction. May I carry Deputy Johnson's mind back to the duties performed by these committees to show that there is practically no analogy at all between their duties and the duties which it is proposed the committees to be set up under this Bill should perform.
Comment on this
All I said in that respect was that the form of the committee, the form of election and representation, was based upon the form constituting the Council of Agriculture.
Comment on this
I quite accept what Deputy Johnson states, but I think he also had in his mind that the duties possibly were somewhat similar. If he did not say so, let me remind the Dáil, at all events, that those committees had very different duties to perform to what will be the duties of the advisory committee which it is proposed to set up under this amendment. Some of those who had the privilege of sitting on the committees constituted in connection with technical instruction — I presume the same procedure was followed with regard to agriculture — will remember that very large and important schemes, embodying a large expenditure of money, had to come before, and be approved by, these advisory committees. They had very important powers.
Comment on this
I agree. But my point is this, that no useful purpose will be served by setting up another committee in addition to the twenty-six committees provided for under the Bill. We have come to a point in this country when the expenses of officials and of government are becoming a tremendous burthen on trade. This expense is hampering industry and is causing unemployment. I will want to see the necessity for adding to that expense before I will vote for an amendment of this character which proposes to set up an additional committee.
Comment on this
I suppose that Deputy Good, if he wants to be consistent, must vote against the section as well as against the amendment; because, if we were to substitute Deputy Johnson's amendment for the section, we should still have one committee. This section gives the Minister power to establish an unlimited number of committees and to pay their expenses.
Comment on this
But, under the section the Minister takes the power to set up committees. The power is there expressed in the section, and the Minister does not even have to come to the Dáil for the power to do that. The section gives him power to create an unlimited number of committees and to pay their expenses. He may not intend to exercise that power. I dare say he does not. But surely, taking Deputy Good's view, it is utterly illogical to give him that power.
Comment on this
I pointed out in my opening remarks that the difference between the two proposals was this: That under the Bill temporary consultative bodies were to be set up if the Minister desired them for a specific purpose, but for a specific purpose only. Under the amendment it is proposed to set up a permanent Advisory Board which is to meet at least twice a year. In my opinion this Board will have practically no duties at all to perform.
Comment on this
It is lamentable to hear a gentleman in the position of Deputy Good reiterate what another Deputy stated in a previous Dáil, namely, that he knew as much about public health, and, indeed, a great deal more, than I did, and certainly a great deal more than the young men I was turning out from Trinity College. Deputy Good suggests that the elected county councillors on the twenty-six boards of health are going to give advice on public health matters to the Minister. Now, I never heard any argument brought up in such a foolish manner as that. Deputy Good is willing to say that because he sat on a technical education committee, the members of it were able to give advice on matters relating to technical education. But because the Deputy knows nothing about public health and does not realise that the country is in a most lamentable condition for the want of improvement in public health, he is going to oppose the expenditure of a little money that perhaps would save thousands of lives and provide for the treatment of many forms of disease. It makes me, as I say, blush, sometimes, when I find people in the position of Deputy Good and others, who think that they know a great deal about these matters. The amendment proposed by Deputy Johnson suggests that there should be people representing the ratepayers on these committees. Deputy Johnson also suggests that certain doctors should also be put on because of their special knowledge of public health matters and in order to give advice. I maintain that that is absolutely necessary if the schemes proposed for the country are going to be effective. I am sorry that the Minister for Local Government took occasion to make the remarks he did about the medical profession. I want to say here and now that this Bill has been discussed by committees of the medical profession, representing the entire profession in the country, and I may say that I am voicing the opinion of these men. It is suggested that these men only want an advisory committee set up because they want something done for themselves. Now, I repudiate that entirely, and I think that the medical profession can stand up with a very clear conscience and say that the majority of them are endeavouring to prevent disease, the occurrence of which and the continuance of which would put money in their own pockets. I think that any suggestion that we make, any advice that is given on matters of public health policy by the profession should be gladly adopted by the Minister. The Minister alluded to the fact that Dr. Addison, the first Minister for Health in England, had been replaced by a non-medical man afterwards. Everybody knows that Dr. Addison came to grief through political influences, and not from the fact that he was not able, because he was a doctor, to carry on the Ministry of Health.
Comment on this
I rise, not necessarily because of the attitude of Deputy Good on this matter, but because I might be permitted to say a few words on a subject which I think Deputy Sir James Craig will say I know nothing about. I think that Deputy Good is right in saying that these committees formed in this way are not an improvement on what is laid down in the Bill. I say that with regret, because I quite agree I ought to support Deputy Johnson in this, because I have been preaching, as far as in me lies, the danger of bureaucratic control in the legislation that comes before us. We see indications of it and it is creeping in rather rapidly, and on this ground if I could support Deputy Johnson I would very willingly do so. But analysing the committee proposed to be formed by this amendment, I cannot really say that a body formed in this way, of a more or less permanent character, should be set up. I do not see there is any step in the Bill except in so far as elected representatives are concerned to change the constitution of the rest of the boards at all. But let us assume that such a committee was accepted by the Dáil and was in operation. It is semi-professional as regards the section that deals with doctors, veterinary surgeons, dentists, and as many more professions as may be added on. If Deputy Sir James Craig advocated and pressed for a board or body or committee composed entirely of professional men it would appeal to me more than this hybrid committee that in essence has the seeds of dissension in itself and is collectively almost certain to clash with the Minister and his Department. Humanly speaking, it appears to me that the formation of this committee on the lines laid down gives an opportunity for a body of men to meet periodically, more than twice a year, putting that down as a minimum, to discuss matters that may come up from different standpoints altogether, and to have vast differences of opinion within themselves, and who, I think, in their decisions would be inclined to send forward resolutions to the Minister of Health that I do not think his Department could accept in the spirit in which these resolutions were passed.
On these grounds, and not with any depreciation of the value of the medical advice which the Minister ought to have at his disposal, I venture to say the amendment is not an improvement on the Bill. As Deputy Good has said, it is going to be an expensive body. It is going to add to the expensive administration at a time when I say that the urgent need of the country is to reduce expenditure so as to get our taxation within reasonable limits which the country can bear. The committee which it is proposed to set up is, in my opinion, a committee that would do nothing like the work that Deputy Johnson expects it to do. I cannot believe that a committee, as constituted by that amendment, would be of the slightest assistance to the Ministry, nor do I think it would be in the interests of the harmonious working of the public health administration of the country.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Hewat say whether there is any other form or constitution of such a committee that would meet with his acceptance?
Comment on this
Is it the principle or the form of the committee he objects to? That is what I desire to know.
Comment on this
I am afraid I have to say that, in my opinion, the body proposed to be set up would not do what Deputy Johnson expects it to do, and would not be an advisable body to set up. Deputy Johnson asks would I suggest any other body. I believe that the Minister has taken power to set up an advisory board.
Comment on this
If anything more is required it is not very apparent on the face of it at the present time.
Comment on this
I do not rise to intervene directly upon the general question which has been debated, but the Minister for Local Government used one argument which provoked me too far. I understood him to say that the results of the abolition of the boards called the Commissioners of National Education and the Intermediate Education Board were such that he was unable to accept this proposal. All I wish to remark in that connection is that if that argument was on a par with his other arguments I do not think he has made much of a case. I ask the Minister has he any real idea of what the position of education in the country is? Does he really think that it has improved since these two boards were abolished? I can hardly believe that even the Minister with his mind drawn off from such matters altogether by the consideration of an important Bill like this, is unaware of how unsatisfactory the position of national education is and that secondary education is still awaiting the scheme promised so long. If the Minister has no better argument to adduce than that the abolition of boards such as these which have done good work in the past and whose abolition has been followed by a steady disimprovement in the state of education in the country, compels him to reject this proposal, I think his case is a very bad one.
Comment on this
I did not intend the analogy to be pursued in that direction. I am not aware of the facts stated by Deputy Thrift, and they do not concern the discussion one way or another. I am sorry that the Minister for Education is not here to deal with the question in a proper manner. I may have put what I wanted to say about the medical profession in a way that gave some offence to Deputy Sir James Craig; there is nobody who has a higher conception of the way the medical profession carry out their duties than I have. I have daily evidence of how disinterested they are and how they throw their heart and soul into their professions, not from any mercenary motives. What I meant was that the medical profession, like others, sometimes look at a matter from an idealistic point of view and try to attain the maximum result from their own point of view, and they do not take into consideration all the practical difficulties in my Department. In my Department we have to look at it from the practical point of view, and if any grandiose scheme is put up for dealing with disease we have to take into consideration what that will cost and other matters of that kind, and where we are to get officers to carry it out.
I know if a committee of this kind is set up it would mean continual wrangling with my Department, and eventually probably we would succeed in winning this or that committee over to our view, but it would mean a considerable loss of time debating these points, and it would take up much of the time of my Department in long consultations. The Bill, as it stands, makes ample provision for setting up councils where necessary, or if any sudden emergency should arise, or if any matter such as State medical service has to be dealt with, requiring special consideration by people competent to express expert opinion on it, then I have power to set up such a committee. The idea of keeping a body in cold storage, paying their expenses, a body that will feel called upon to come together and give advice on matters that have not been considered very deeply, is not, I think, advisable, and for that reason I cannot agree to the amendment.
Comment on this
I am sorry I had not the advantage of hearing all the discussion on this question, but it seems to me that the point at issue is, whether the Minister takes up this position or not, that he and his Department alone are the people who will know all about what the country needs in the matter of public health. If he does not take up that position, then he will want advice, and who is in the best position to give this advice? I have no doubt whatever that even now, and it has always been the case, it is the people who are actually engaged in public health service who are in the best position to give advice as to public health. Everybody knows it is those who are engaged in these services mentioned in the amendment who take a foremost part in calling the attention of the public to the necessity of what is required to improve the public health. Unless, as I say, the Minister takes up the position that he requires no advice, or that his Department requires no advice, I cannot see for the life of me what the objection is to adopting the amendment and setting up an advisory council. The necessity arises in connection with practically all ministries who have advisory committees. Mention was made, I understand, of the Education Ministry, and I understand the point was made—I gathered so from Deputy Thrift's speech — that it was an advantage to abolish the Intermediate and National Boards. I maintain that there is no analogy, inasmuch as these Boards were not representative boards or were not chosen because of their representative capacity.
I think the Minister might have consulted with the Minister for Education and asked him what his intentions were with regard to the setting up of an Advisory Board of Education, and I think he will find that the Minister, at least, has not the same objection to receiving advice from people qualified to give advice, as the Minister for Local Government appears to have. The Minister talks of these consultative councils and says that he will set them up when necessary when the emergency arises. That, again, is a case of the Department knowing what ought to be done without any advice. Possibly if he had advisory boards the emergency to set up such boards would not arise. Deputy Good spoke of the expense compared with the object which is sought to be achieved, and which would undoubtedly be achieved. The expense would be simply nothing worth speaking about. What is it? The calling of something like twenty or twenty-one members together twice a year and paying their expenses. That is the expense about which Deputy Good complains, where such a vital necessity as public health is concerned. The very fact of these councils being established and meeting would create an interest in public health matters, and I cannot see what possible objection the Minister could have in refusing to set up this advisory body in connection with his Ministry.
Comment on this
I think it is something of a disgrace that some Deputies should treat such an important question as this in the flippant manner in which they have treated it. Of course we can quite understand, from the speeches made by Deputy Good and Deputy Hewat, that the real objection to the amendment is that it is going to cost so much. It does not matter, apparently, to them what good may be effected by the amendment with regard to the health of the country. The whole question is what it is going to cost, and, as Deputy O'Connell has pointed out, the cost would be comparatively little. The Minister takes up the attitude that he does not want anybody to advise him, that he and his officials know all about the public health requirements in the country. The argument has been put forward by Deputy Good that the Minister has twenty-six boards of health.
I would like to ask Deputy Good what the average member of a board of health knows about public health, or would Deputy Good say that the members of a board of health would be able to deal with questions of public health with such knowledge and authority as the people who are suggested in the amendment. It is said by Deputy Hewat that the reason he is going to vote against the amendment is because the people who are mentioned in it to form the advisory council would not be able to achieve the object which Deputy Johnson has in mind in his amendment. If that body will not achieve what Deputy Johnson has in mind, surely twenty-six county boards of health, or any one of them, will not achieve it. From what I know of the personnel of some county boards of health, I am perfectly sure they would not be able to give the Minister any assistance. They may be able to give him assistance to a certain extent, as they might know as much about public health as the Minister or his officials know. I dare say they do. I believe that there is a real necessity for putting on advisory councils, persons like doctors and nurses, persons who know public health questions from the proper point of view. I do not profess to know very much about them any more than the ordinary man, but perhaps I know as much about them as the average member of a county board of health or Deputy Good or Deputy Hewat.
Comment on this
I want to remove what I consider a misunderstanding. Deputy Good referred to 26 county boards of health, but there are 26 medical officers of health to be set up under this Bill, each of whom is supposed to be an authority on public health matters, and if 26 medical officers of health are not sufficient to guide the Minister in whatever measures he requires for the health of this country, then I say we are a very sickly population indeed.
The point made by Deputy Hewat is a very good one. You are going to have men representing the ratepayers on the one hand, and the professional element on the other. One says we want this, and the other says we have no money, and the result will be that meetings will become debating societies, and no results will be achieved. You will have the expense in and out of season of this body, who will be called together every six months, or at more frequent intervals, debating subjects on which the Minister is well informed by his 26 medical officers of health. It would be a superabundant board, and I think it would be foolish at present for us to agree to it.
Comment on this
Deputy Wilson has reminded the Dáil that the 26 boards of health will have 26 medical officers. I was privileged to be a member of a public health committee for 10 years. A medical officer instructed the committee on matters in connection with tuberculosis, and informed them that the tubercular bacilli did not travel through the blood vessels of the body. An able layman said that they did travel through the blood vessels, which, of course, they did not. That shows how a layman can set himself up as an authority on a medical matter over the medical officer.
Comment on this
Deputy Wilson submits that there are 26 medical officers of health, and that these officers of health will form the advisory body, which is to advise the Minister in relation to public health policy. Will the Minister say that that is a fact?
Comment on this
There is nothing provided in the Bill that these medical officers of health shall meet together to discuss maters of public health affecting the country as a whole, and that they shall form an advisory council to suggest a health policy to the Ministry. There is no suggestion of that kind in the Bill, and there is no intention in the Bill that that shall be so. Would Deputy Wilson say to the Minister for Lands and Agriculture that the county instructors are quite efficient to advise them in regard to the milk supply, cow-testing associations, bulls, breeding schemes, and any of those other schemes brought forward? County instructors are available, but it has never been suggested that they should form an advisory committee to the Minister, although the Deputies on the Farmers' Benches had the opportunity to make this point in the previous debates on agricultural questions. But, of course, the health of the people is a small matter to the farmers. I quite agree that if they were thinking consistently, and according to any political principle, they would support this proposition, as they supported the other proposition as to advisory councils to the Minister. I wonder if it is not true to say, in fact I assert it without any hesitation, that the Minister is intending in matters relating to the health of the people, not only matters of immediate administration but public health policy, having an eye on the future, to rely on the advice he receives from his departmental officers.
In the Estimates for this year I find a total of ten medical inspectors. So far as they are denoted as being medical inspectors, they have a variety of duties. Will the Minister tell us how many of these inspectors have a Diploma of Public Health, and will the Minister say that it is sufficient to rely upon the advice of two or three of these medical inspectors who may be competent, to carry with him in any public health scheme the medical profession and the public? I hope the Deputies will bear in mind that this is a very important part of the proposal — to carry the public and the medical profession with you in any proposal of public health policy. I say that it is not enough for the Minister to rely solely upon the hidden officers of his department, some of whom may be competent and qualified, but none of whom is in daily practice, and in regular touch with the public and public necessities, and are only able to judge by reports that come in writing. The case for expert advice, and for continued consultation with people specially interested has been made and accepted in nearly every country in the world. The Minister for Agriculture, like a wise man, acknowledged the value of consulting the people concerned who have special knowledge, and invited conferences and continued support for any schemes that are being put forward. But the Minister for Local Government is above these petty things. The experiences of other countries do not matter to him. He is going to concentrate all power in his Department, and to keep down costs to satisfy Deputy Hewat and Deputy Good. He is going to say: "If there is any knowledge outside my Department in matters relating to public health, then it is no knowledge and is not worth consideration."
The Minister thinks only of calling together expert committees when emergencies arise. I suggest that it would be much more to the point, and certainly infinitely more economical, if the Minister would have the advice of people interested in matters of public health before the emergency arises, so as to prevent the occasion for calling the consultative committee together when an emergency arises. Deputy Hewat laid stress upon the constitution of the proposed council. I am not laying stress upon it. If that is the only objection it is easy to arrive at an accommodation. But no; continued reading of reports from public health committees will be an efficient substitute for the proposed council. Deputy Good suggests that, having twenty-six boards of health, there is no necessity for any advice from any expert authority, but I think that Deputy Good does not really believe anything of the kind. He knows that the boards of public health are not, and cannot be an efficient substitute for any expert advisory body.
Comment on this
I quite understand that Deputy Good is satisfied about those powers and hopes they will never be exercised, because they will cost money. On the other hand, I believe that it is desirable to look ahead in matters relating to public health policy, and to get together frequently people appointed by the Minister from associations, bodies and boards, who are known to be keenly interested in matters of public health and to endeavour to arrive at common agreement if possible. In any case, even by their discussion of specific questions, you will educate the public. If, then, the Minister approves of their recommendations, when he brings forward any proposal to the Dáil or issues any of the innumerable Orders he is empowered to issue, the fact that he has behind the Order which he may issue, the authority of a council of this kind, will make the co-operation of the public more likely and the assistance of the medical profession much more certain.
The Minister spoke about taking the advice of the Dáil. In every Bill he and his predecessors have put forward in relation to public health affairs and local administration, they have provided for legislation by Orders in Council and by Orders of the Minister. But henceforth we are going to have a change. We are going to have no more legislation by Order. We are going to have the advice of the Dáil before any such Order is issued. I think I see him doing it. I ask the Dáil to support the principle of this amendment. It may be subject to modification if the constitution laid down is not generally acceptable, but I would ask the Dáil to support the principle of having a public health council to assist the Minister in the administration of public health affairs. The motion would be to delete paragraphs 1 and 3 of Section 17, and to substitute paragraphs 1 to 10 in the amendment on the paper.
Comment on this
The effect of the amendment would be the same as the amendment on the Paper, because Sub-section (11) of the proposed new sub-section is identical with Sub-section (2) of Section 17 as in the Bill.
Comment on this
I have amendments down which deal with the same matter, and I do not think there would be any useful purpose served in going over again any of the arguments I used or in inducing Deputy Johnson to go over any of his arguments. If I thought it would be of any educational value to the Government or to my friend, Deputies Hewat and Wilson, I would continue to argue the matter; but as I think there is no prospect I would ask the House to allow me to withdraw my amendments.