DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924 (THIRD STAGE) RESUMED.
Contributions 1–114 of 222. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 18 of 1924 ›
I do not suppose there is anybody in the Dáil, from the Minister down to the latest elected Deputy, who would not vote for this amendment, if he thought that it would improve the condition of the poor. The amendment is a long one, but I think it could be boiled down to inserting the word "shall" instead of the word "may," in order to make the board of health do certain things in regard to committees. We will presume that the board of health, being elected democratically, are sensible men and would not be likely to choose representatives on these committees without seeing that they more or less represent the different districts of the county. Perhaps I may be classed as laudato temporis acti. Looking back upon the systems I have known for thirty years, I do not know that any of them have been an improvement on the old boards of guardians. So far as they were concerned, they were most democratic bodies. One never heard in those days complaint about the condition of the poor, or anything of that kind. They had nothing to do with districts, or anything of that sort. Their whole time was taken up dealing with poor law relief and practically nothing else. They had nothing to do with the administration of roads. They were democratic bodies. Whatever may be said about the old grand juries, nothing can be said against the old boards of guardians. It was the fault of the people if they were not democratic, and I think their work was extremely well done. The Minister has said that he has an open mind on this matter and proposes to introduce a Bill later on to deal with it and improve on it.
It would be a mistake, I think, therefore, to bind down the board of health — which will probably be altered — to do certain things. My opinion is that there are many matters in regard to poor law relief that can be suggested. That would not be possible if we bind them down and force them to create committees. It may not be necessary to create committees. Other arrangements may be better. It is for this body, that the Minister proposes to set up, to inquire into the matter thoroughly, and to devise the best means by which the interests of the poor shall be seen to. I am not for binding down the Board of Health to any particular scheme in regard to committees until we have the report of the body that is to be set up by the Minister.
Comment on this
I go part of the way in support of the amendment, but instead of forming a committee of three in each rural area, and electing them, I would allow the county council to nominate three. In an average county you would have four against nine on the board of health. They would not have the power or privilege of voting. For that reason I maintain we get a better selection of people altogether on the board of health. In the first place you get people who would not go for election, and in the second place people who would not go if they were burdened with voting power. Under a board of health there will be voting for positions from the charwoman to the chaplain. In the different counties you have charitable people who are prepared to devote their time to such work, but who would not go for election.
Comment on this
I do not think there can be any magic in the number 9. I think 3 is too small. The Minister should reconsider the matter, and enlarge the number to one-third of the county council. A board of health of nine for a whole county is altogether too small. I also think that we should introduce the nominated element. I would not give power to vote, as that should be restricted to direct representatives of the people.
Comment on this
Deputy Wolfe i afraid to insert in this Bill a provision which would make it mandatory upon the board of health to appoint local committees. He is afraid that it might prejudice the decision of a Committee or Commission which is about to be set up, and which is to report at some future date, and in some future Parliament perhaps a new Act will be passed. I would point out to Deputy Wolfe that nothing that is embodied in this Bill will prevent any future Parliament enacting in any way, even to repeal a provision which we put into this Bill. Nothing that we put into this Bill now will prevent a future Minister proposing an alteration.
We are concerned about the period between now and the enactment which is to follow a report of a committee which is to be appointed. Everything that Deputy Wolfe said about the old boards of guardians shows how valuable a provision this is — that there should be some local persons interested in the administration of home assistance in addition to the officer. Again I suggest that the arguments of Deputy Wolfe go far to support the proposal in the amendment.
Deputy Hogan pleads for some sort of committee which is not elected, but the amendment provides in sub-section 2 that it
"shall consist of not less than three members and may be composed either wholly of members of the board of health, or partly of such members, and partly of other persons."
These committees are to be appointed by the board of health, so that Deputy Heffernan's desire is satisfied by the provision of the amendment. In addition to those I claimed last night, I claim the support of Deputy Wolfe and of Deputy Hogan, as the amendment will fulfil exactly the requirements that both Deputies argued for this afternoon.
Comment on this
The Bill provides that local committees may be set up and the amendment wants to force the board of health to appoint those committees. I want to speak from experience and to learn from it something to guide us in the future. Those local committees were set up in some districts, with the result that while they were very lavish in dispensing home help, the amount required for their activities could not be obtained from the rates. It is preferable to leave the Bill as it is and give the power to the board to appoint a sub-committee if they like, but not to force them to appoint what in their best experience may be wrong.
There is nothing in the amendment to provide for cases where the sub-committee abuses its powers. I know of a case where a Labour organiser was appointed a member of a sub-committee. He merely used the ratepayers' money to get people to join his organisation, thereby gaining a subsidy every week from the relieved person. I do not say that will happen again, but there should have been provision made for the removal from the sub-committee of persons who are not doing their duty.
Comment on this
The principle is there, anyway. It can be done by the Bill, and there is no necessity to force the board of health which, I assume, would be composed of commonsense people, to do what they think may not be right or proper. In some areas it might be a good thing to have the sub-committees, and in others it might not. As I have stated already, there is provision in the Bill for the appointment of sub-committees and hence, this amendment is not required and I am going to vote against it.
Comment on this
I am sorry I did not make myself clear. Judging from Deputy Johnson's remarks, I did not, but my contention is that nine is too small a number to administer board of health services in a county. I would enlarge the board by a nominated element of three from every rural area. The amendment seeks to have an executive committee of three, but my contention is for a nominated element of three from each rural area in the county to act with the nine members of the board of health. I would not propose to give the nominated element voting powers. From my experience, I believe it would be easy to get a number of charitable men and women, who have time to spare, to act as a nominated element on the board of health. If they had to go up for election and were given the privilege of voting for the different appointments that would occur under the board of health, they would not take the position, but I am certain you would get a lot of people who would allow themselves to be nominated as members of the board for the special purpose of doing charitable work.
Comment on this
Deputy Wilson referred to a Labour organiser being a member of the commitee. I fail to see why a Labour organiser should be objected to when we have farmers' organizers on these committees. I know cases of organisers employed by Deputy Wilson's party who were members of these committees. They did very useful work with their colleagues from the Labour Party. I hold it is necessary that we should have these sub-committees. I have more experience of public boards than Deputy Wilson, and I know it is a physical impossibility for a home help officer to look after distress in very large rural areas. He must be assisted and guided by the different local sub-committees unless it is the Government's wish to leave full power in the hands of these home help officers. I may say that I believe that is the wish of the Government from letters I have seen at different public boards. The idea of the Government apparently is to give these home help officers the exercise of a certain kind of prerogative and to place them more or less in the same position as commissioners are placed in in the case of dissolved public boards. If that is the Government's intention, I believe it will mean that large numbers of people who are entitled to receive home help, and who are in a state of distress, will be left to starve. Deputy Wilson may laugh and smile at the fact that people who are entitled to receive home help will not receive it. He may think that it is to these people's interests that they should not receive it, but I can assure him that I for one have realised my responsibility here. I say if that is the intention of the Government, backed up by Deputy Wilson's party, then I am not going to be a party to it and I will take other measures in my own area to see that the people I represent will not be allowed to die of hunger.
Comment on this
I am a little disturbed with regard to this matter. I am quite satisfied that the board of health can appoint sufficient committees, and I would be perfectly satisfied with that if I knew that the committees were going to be appointed, but permissive legislation for Ireland in the past has been a disastrous failure. I certainly feel in the matter that if the boards of health do not appoint these committees it would be a very serious matter to the country. Therefore, I am inclined to vote for the amendment unless I have some assurance from the Government that the health boards will appoint those committees. I think I made myself clear that I would be perfectly satisfied with the committees that are empowered under the Bill to be appointed by the health boards and if I knew that that would be done, I would be satisfied, but Deputy Johnson suggests that it will not be done.
Comment on this
Well, I am a believing sort of person and am inclined to believe that if permission is given to these boards, that they will not take it upon themselves to try to do all the work but will certainly appoint the committees and committees representative of the various districts. But what is sticking in my mind is the word "may." I would like to feel assured that these committees would be appointed, and I would like the Minister to give some assurance that the committees will be appointed, and if not I would be in favour of the amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Wilson told us that committees previously appointed to administer home assistance increased the expenditure several hundred per cent. Will he tell us what percentage of increase was there in distress over the time he was considering, from the starting point to the point where the increase of 200 per cent. was reached? Had not the distress increased proportionately, or is it his point that in order to prevent the committee doing justice to people in distress, even if there was an increase of 200 or 300 per cent. necessary to meet that distress, that the committees who recognise their duties should be scrapped so that this distress should not be met; and that instead of those committees you should have officers to whittle down the demands of those people rather than committees who should be allowed to do justice? Is that Deputy Wilson's point?
Comment on this
My point is that from the experience of some districts in the past the tendency was for the local committees to be more lavish in the expenditure of public money than they would have been if they were paying the money out of their own pockets. These local committees having the public purse at their disposal and being compelled, more or less, to fall in with local feelings, are not likely to refuse a neighbour and so forth. They began to apply the public purse in such a lavish manner that it was utterly impossible for the ratepayers to carry on. That has been the experience in one district at any rate, to my knowledge, and the result was that public officials had to be appointed to see that people in distress would not be allowed to remain in distress; that their cases would be seen to and that everything should be done that could be done to see that hungry people who ought to be fed should be fed, but that public money would not be used for the purpose of furthering the interest of any class of the community.
Comment on this
The constitution of the committee provides that representatives will be got through the county councils and through the boards of health, or through any other channel. What is to prevent those paying rates getting representation upon those committees? I suggest it is up to Deputy Wilson and others to safeguard themselves by getting representatives on these committees who will look after their interests.
Comment on this
I beg to move the following amendment:—
"In Sub-section (1), line 1, after the word ‘time,' to insert the words ‘request the county council.'"
I think that Section 12 gives too much power to a nominated body, and the only supervision that the county council has over the board of health is over the estimates. The county council will have to supply the money, but that is the only control it has over the board of health, which is empowered under this Bill to appoint any committee it may think fit. If the Minister accepts this amendment, so that the board of health may from time to time request the county council to appoint such committee as it may think fit, it will be giving the county councils some little control over such committees. The county councils consist of elected representatives of the people. Nine members of the county board of health are representatives of the people but they are nominated by the county council. I think that by giving the county councils the option of appointing such committees you will be holding a certain lever over the board of health. I think that is desirable not alone from the point of view of effecting a great saving but also from the point of view that the proper people will be appointed by the county council, people who, in the opinion of the county council, are capable and suitable to act on such committees. I fail to see why any nominated body should have power to nominate another body, neither of which may contain elected representatives of the people. I have put down the amendment on the instructions of a large number of ratepayers in my constituency and I ask the Minister to accept it, as there is nothing in it to upset the section of the Bill as it stands.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy has in the back of his mind by moving this amendment. The county board of health is to be established for a particular purpose, dealing with public health matters and sanitation and all matters with which the county council have nothing to do. There is no reason why the county council should be allowed to interfere in this manner with the work of the board of health, as that body is in the best position to judge as to what action it is best to take in a particular case. The county council has very considerable control over the board of health in all its duties. It has complete financial control not only over estimates but over all expenditure of the board of health, which is composed exclusively of members of the county council. If at any time two-thirds of the county council wish to have a member of the board of health removed they can do so. I can see no sense in this amendment whatever.
Comment on this
The sense of the amendment is to give the county council better control over committees appointed by the board of health, which is a nominated body appointed by the county council and which has full authority to appoint such committees as it thinks fit. I want the Minister to have the county council appoint these committees. The Minister says that the county council has full control over the board of health. The county council supplies the money to the board of health, but that is really all the control it has over it. I quite agree that two-thirds of the county council can at any time remove a member of the board of health. I think the Minister should accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Like the Minister, I do not see what this amendment proposes to do. On the other hand, I think that it will prevent progress So far as the board of health is concerned, occasion may arise during the progress of a meeting when it may be absolutely necessary for the board of health to appoint a committee. In view of the fact that county council meetings in many counties are very irregular, I do not think it would suit to have the county council appoint these committees. I am opposed to the amendment, and I think that Deputy Lyons, on consideration, will see that it would not work at all in practice.
Comment on this
I propose the following amendment:—
"In Sub-section (3), line 14, to insert after the word ‘three' the words ‘and not more than twelve.'"
The sub-section of the Bill says that every committee appointed under the section shall consist of not less than three members, but I want the Minister to say definitely in the Bill what the maximum number of members would be. I want to insert the words "not more than twelve" so that the board of health when appointing such committees will not appoint everybody in the whole county on them. It is a well-known fact that committees have been appointed consisting of sixteen, twenty or twenty-four members of which probably eight form a quorum, and it is impossible often to get a meeting held.
Comment on this
I cannot accept this amendment. It would be giving me a power that I prefer not to exercise, that is, forcing these boards of health to restrict the number of the members of their committees. In initiating legislation of this kind it is very hard to know how it will work out in practice. In many respects it may often happen that in a particular county there may be occasion to have large committees, and I cannot say at this stage to what number the members should be restricted. I should say myself that twelve would be a small number, but at any rate at present I would not be prepared to fix any number. It should be left to the discretion of the county board of health, and if members of the board have not sufficient sense to know how many members to appoint on the committees, I do not think that I could help them by trying to force my ideas down their throats.
Comment on this
If the county board of health appointed an advisory committee consisting of sixteen or twenty members, would the Minister sanction that number? According to the section they can appoint 300 members if they like. I think that the Minister should specify the maximum number of such committees. Surely it is not giving too much power to the Minister to authorise him to say how many members can be appointed on the committees. I am not one of those who agree with giving too much power to any Minister, and I am sure I would not be giving too much power by this amendment. I think that the Minister should give an undertaking that he would consider the matter, and in that hope I withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move:—
"In Sub-section (3), line 16, to insert after the word ‘persons' the words ‘but shall be composed of the elected representative of such districts the committees are appointed for, and all such committees shall be granted the travelling expenses, as mentioned in the Schedule of this Act.'"
I am afraid I will have to stand firmer on this amendment than on the other two, and I will have to force the hands of Deputies in order that they may show to their constituents whether they wish the administration of local affairs to be placed in the hands of people who are not elected. What I want is that where committees are appointed they will consist of elected representatives of the county councils for such districts as they are appointed for. My object in putting forward the amendment is to safeguard the moneys subscribed by the ratepayers, and to see that the proper people will have control over the administration of local affairs. For that purpose I want to place the full responsibility on the elected representatives of the county councils in whatever districts such committees are appointed by the county board of health.
It is not too much to ask that the members of such committees shall be paid such travelling expenses as are allowed in the Schedule of the Bill. If you want representatives to act in a proper manner, and to attend to the business they are appointed to look after, it is necessary that they should be paid travelling expenses, the same as members of the county council. I think the Minister should give this amendment a little better consideration than he has given to my other amendments. It is essential that the people should have a person whom they have elected to look after their interests. Only such elected representatives should be on those committees in order to safeguard the funds of the ratepayers, to look after the welfare of the poor, and, above all things, to look after the interests of the workers. A person who is simply nominated, and who, if he went forward for election, would not get twenty votes in that constituency, is not a suitable person to be appointed on such a committee. The proper people for such committees, as I have already explained, are the elected representatives who, in addition to looking after the interests of the poor, would see that the estimates are not increased unnecessarily, and generally would have a greater sense of responsibility. I am a member of several nominated committees, and we can seldom get a quorum to attend these meetings. In one particular division in the County of Westmeath there has not been a meeting for probably eight months. These are appointed on committees.
If those men were elected representatives they would certainly turn up. The four elected representatives on the committee are at every meeting, but they have to go away because there is no quorum. On account of that and for the purpose of safeguarding the ratepayers, I ask the committee to accept this amendment.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister not to accept this amendment. As far as I understand the amendment, what the Deputy aims at is that no person who is not a member of a county or of an urban council should be appointed on one of those committees. I think the Deputy should know, and the other Deputies do know, that some of the most useful people you can get on these committees—the people who will take a real interest in the work — will perhaps not be members of a county council or of an urban council. The class of people I would like to see on these committees would be those who take a genuine interest in the welfare of the poor — the people who work voluntarily in the Public Health services and in the relief of destitution. As the Deputy's amendment might prevent people of that class being appointed on those committees, I would ask the Minister not to accept it.
Comment on this
This amendment does not prevent people being nominated on such committees, but it does specify that the persons elected as representatives of the district must be members of that committee. They may have a committee of eight and they could then appoint three or four outsiders, in addition to the members of the county council. I only ask that the elected representatives on the county council in districts where committees are appointed should be members of those committees. I am not going, as Deputy Morrissey has said, to exclude people who may have a knowledge of this work.
Comment on this
What the Deputy means to do is not exactly what the amendment will do if it is carried.
Comment on this
It depends on the number of the committee. If the committee consists of only three members, you cannot have any outsiders on it. If the number of elected representatives in that district be six and the number of the committee appointed by the county board be twelve, then you will have six elected representatives on the committee. Surely that is sufficient scope to give people who will not stand for election or who might not be elected if they stood. I think Deputy Morrissey took a wrong view of the amendment. If the number of members of the committee is larger than the number of representatives there is nothing in the amendment to prevent the county board of health appointing outsiders on the committee.
Comment on this
Like Deputy Morrissey, I ask the Minister not to accept this amendment. I do so especially in view of the fact that the Dáil has decided by vote to abolish the rural district councils. There may be a principle underlying the amendment, but the amendment in its present form does not carry it out. You are going to disfranchise the whole rural area by this amendment and for that reason I am opposing it.
Comment on this
If Deputy Lyons' amendment bears the interpretation he put on it when introducing it, Deputy Morrissey answered him effectively. If it bears the interpretation he put on it on the last occasion, there is no necessity for it, because that is provided for in the Bill as it stands. In neither case could I accept it. Regarding the proviso as to travelling expenses, if the Deputy would take the trouble to read Section 65 of the Bill, I think he would find it covers the situation perfectly.
Comment on this
I quite agree. I read that, but I thought it would be well to have provision here too so as to make sure. Deputy Corish asked the Minister to reject this amendment, as the district councils had already been abolished. But surely that is all the more reason why we should have some committee in these districts. I am trying to form little district councils in each district.
Comment on this
I would like to ask Deputy Lyons where he is going to get elected representatives in the rural areas, since the district councils have been abolished.
Comment on this
The elected representatives of the district on the county council should act. I am not at all convinced by the arguments of Deputy Morrissey or of the Minister. I think this amendment should stand. I want to see the people catered for in a proper manner, and in my opinion nobody can look after the people as well as their elected representatives. On those committees on which there are no elected representatives the work is not carried out to the satisfaction of the local people. The Minister replied and said that the section provided what I desired. I agree that it says that the committees may be composed wholly or partly of elected representatives, but I want that made mandatory. I want to have elected representatives of the districts, members of those committees. I want to place a certain responsibility on the county boards of health that when electing those committees they will put on them members of the county council, apart from those who may be members of the county board of health. The amendment does not prevent the nomination of outsiders. Any Deputy who opposes the amendment I certainly think is not acting honestly and according to his conscience, but purely owing to personal considerations.
Comment on this
The section, if amended by the acceptance of Deputy Lyons' proposal, would read:—
Every committee appointed under this section shall consist of not less than three members and may be composed wholly of members of the board of health or partly of such members and partly of other persons, but shall be composed of the elected representatives of such districts as the committees are appointed for, and all such committees shall be granted the travelling expenses as mentioned in the Schedule to this Act.
I do not think anybody could vote for that amendment. I do not think five per cent. of the people would understand it if it were embodied in the Bill, and it would give plenty of work to lawyers. I imagine that at the back of Deputy Lyons' mind there is a purpose which is quite commendable. These committees which are to be appointed under this section may be local committees or they may be committees to do any special work, local or general, as decided by the board of health. According to the section, such a committee may be composed either wholly of members of the board of health or partly of such members. There may be one person appointed upon the committee who is a member of the board and two or more others who are not members of the board, and none of them, as a matter of fact, need be a member of the county council. I think there is some point in Deputy Lyons' attempted explanation of his proposal which is not met by the section.
I doubt the wisdom of having a committee of the board of health doing, perhaps, very important work, when not a single person on that committee need necessarily be a member of the county council. That is a defect. The board of health appointed by the county council will consist of a certain number of members of the county council and a certain number of other persons outside the county council. That board of health is to be empowered to appoint a committee for local or general purposes, and under the section such a committee may be composed of five, seven or ten persons, all of whom may be non-elected. The defect there should be remedied by the insertion of a proviso which would embody what is at the back of Deputy Lyons' mind but which is not embodied in his amendment. I would ask the Minister to consider that point between now and the Report Stage, because there is a certain importance attaching to it. It might even mean that very important work would be transferred by the board of health to a committee of that board, of which not a single person was elected by the people.
Comment on this
There is possibly a point in Deputy Johnson's suggestion. The intention of the section is that there should be an elected member of the board of health on the committee, but it might possibly bear the interpretation put upon it, if regarded from a lawyer's point of view. I would be open to strengthening the section somewhat on the Report Stage. These local committees have no control over finance whatsoever, and, therefore, the matter is not so material as it might appear. However, I will consider the point on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I will be quite satisfied if the Minister will insert a proviso in sub-section (3) to meet my point. I want some elected representatives to be members of these committees. There is nothing in the section directing the county board of health to appoint such members on the committees, and they might solely appoint outside persons who have not been elected. I would urge the Minister to provide that a certain percentage of the representation should be reserved for elected persons.
Comment on this
I move Amendment 10:—
To insert after sub-section (3) a new sub-section as follows:
"Existing officers of district councils shall where eligible and able to perform the duties get first preferences of appointments as officials of such committees."
The obvious effect of this amendment would be to reduce the number of those likely to receive pensions. I do not think it is necessary to dwell upon that point. We all think that there are too many of these pensionable officers and we would like to keep the number as small as possible.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. I think it is very important that appointments to be made by the board of health should be made wherever possible from eligible officers of the late district councils. We have cases of new appointments by the boards of health, while at the same time we have suitable men who acted as clerks of district councils and boards of guardians going out on pension. These men are young enough and capable of performing the duties of the offices, but new men are coming in and getting these positions under the boards of health. It is only right that these ex-officials should get the preference when they are eligible and suitable for these positions. It should be mandatory on these boards to appoint these pensionable officers.
Comment on this
I am sure that this amendment is unnecessary. If Deputies considered carefully Section 65 they would see that all the officers of the present rural district councils will automatically become officers of the county council and they can be transferred to the county board of health. So far as I am concerned, all along I have insisted — and under this Act I will have much more authority for insisting than formerly — that existing officers should get the preference in all these appointments. I am certainly not going to be placed in the position of pensioning officers who are better qualified to do the work than new officers. I think the Deputies who followed the course of events, so far as my Department is concerned, will say that I have given good earnest of my intention in that matter. Only a very short time ago, I was forced to the very serious step of having to close down West Cork County Board of Health because they refused to appoint one of the many officers who formerly belonged to the abolished unions and insisted on appointing a person who was not at all well qualified for the position. That has been my attitude all along. It will be my attitude under this Bill also, but my hands will be strengthened under this Bill owing to the fact that Section 65 has been inserted, whereby all these existing officers automatically become officers of the county council.
Comment on this
We have no doubt about the Minister's intentions, but it might happen that for some reason the Minister would send in his resignation hereafter and his successor might not have the same good intentions. Consequently I would like a provision inserted in the Bill.
Comment on this
I am not quite satisfied with the Minister's explanation. I think his intention is perfectly clear, but I am not quite satisfied that Section 65 covers this matter. I do not want to press the matter too far, because I know the Minister has good intentions in regard to it. It says that any existing officer may be transferred by the county council to the board of health. I think that might be made stronger, to state that he shall be transferred if a suitable position arises in connection with the board of health, and if there is no work in the county council. I only make that suggestion, that it might be made stronger.
Comment on this
I think the Minister might accept something of this nature, because when we come to look at Section 65, we see that although there is a provision by which the officer may be transferred to the county council, still when we come to sub-clause (3) we read: "That if any existing officer of a rural district council is removed from office in consequence of change affected by or under this Act the cost of any compensation granted to such officer for such loss of office shall be charged on the area of the county"— shall fall on the local rates. I think the Minister might insert something by which it would be made obligatory upon the county council to try to get work at all events for these existing officers and not to superannuate them.
Comment on this
I think that what the Deputies are looking for is completely covered by Section 65. It says:—
Where the business of any council or committee is transferred by this Act to any county council the existing officers of that council or committee employed in that business shall...
It does not say "may."
...from and after the appointed day become the officers of such county council in like manner, subject to the provisions of this section as if they had been appointed by such county council, and any such officer may be transferred by such county council to the board of health of any county health district in such county."
It says it shall be the business of the county council, but if a county council cannot utilise him they may transfer him to the board of health, and it means that he shall be retained in the service. However, I think the most suitable place to discuss this matter would be under Section 65. If Deputies are not satisfied, then I would be willing to put in any other safeguards they would like.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister if in a case of that kind the officer would be secured from loss of income. If he has served a long time, and if he is transferred from the county council to the board of health, will his emoluments remain as they were?
Comment on this
The better way would be to postpone discussion on this matter until we reach Section 65. Will Deputy Cole take this amendment now or postpone it to Section 65?
Comment on this
I will accept an amendment to Section 65 on this matter.
Comment on this
We had a great deal of discussion on the principle of this section. We discussed it on the Second Reading and on the section dealing with the abolition of the rural district councils. We have had it running all through the course of the debate. Therefore, I would just like to say a few words on the matter. Briefly the section enables two kinds of committees to be set up. First of all, you have local committees, and, secondly, you have got committees for special purposes set up for the whole county health area. I have thought that members elected for each electoral area — there are so many members of a county council returned for each electoral area, I think the average is about 7 —would form a suitable nucleus for a general purposes committee in each electoral area, and I think that is the most likely shape these committees will take. There is nothing in the Bill to compel these committees to take that shape. We are allowing the utmost elasticity in that matter, because it is quite possible there may be several districts in an area that may have very conflicting interests. One may be a watering place that would require particular attention from the point of view of developing it as a resort and another might be an agricultural area and so on.
In practice, committees appointed on the basis of the electoral area might not be in every case a success. I think in the beginning it will probably be wise to have these members who are elected for each electoral area come together as a committee, and afterwards committees will naturally spring up in the various districts where a want for them makes itself felt. The committee for the county health area will be a much larger and more important affair. Say that a lighting scheme was decided on for the whole county health area. Then a committee would be appointed by the board of health to inquire into the best methods for providing a lighting supply for that area, and it would be a much more important committee. It might require the services of a paid secretary, and it might require an office, and the officers of the board of health would be able to deal with the work of such committee. Local committees, on the other hand, would require practically no staff. It would be a case of formal meetings in each other's houses, and it would entail no expense at all. I am very anxious that these committees should spring up through the country. It is the custom on the Continent for committees of this kind to spring up in every hamlet and parish, and I think that the line which will be probably followed will be something on the principle of the French communal system. I think it would be a great improvement on the old district council system, which did not provide at all adequately for the wants of the district that it was intended to serve.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say whether a lighting scheme would be under the jurisdiction of the county council or the board of health?
Comment on this
Would the Minister say what would be under the jurisdiction of the county council, apart from the board of health?
Comment on this
So that the point is apparently that the roads which were intended to be administered by a central authority will be the only work of the county council, which is the elected body, and I take it, in a general way, that this work would be finished at the first annual meeting when it has passed the estimates. It may appoint a road sub-committee, I have no doubt. The board of health will be then practically as independent an institution in relation to the county council as the old board of guardians was to the county council, having almost complete freedom from supervision, except, once a year, financial control. I confess that the scheme does not seem to me to be satisfactory from the point of view of the electorate. It is practically relegating to the county council the functions of an appointing body on the one hand, and on the other hand a registering body with respect to finances, the budget presented by the board of health, and the collection of rates. I hope it will be more satisfactory than it promises, to my mind.
Comment on this
I am surprised that the Minister did not insert in the Bill a provision making the county board of health an elected body and the county council a body nominated by the county board of health. It would have been much better to do that than to have it as it is at present. I was rather surprised to hear the Minister's reply to Deputy Corish, that the county board of health was the proper authority. If a lighting scheme was started in the district, the county board of health cannot find the money; they have no authority to strike a rate; they have no authority to collect money. The money is supplied by the county council, but it appears to me that it does not matter who works the county board of health, the county council has to pay the piper. I think it would be much better if the Minister, when abolishing district councils, also abolished county councils, had no elected representatives for any part of Ireland, but sent down commissioners. That would probably suit him much better than allowing anyone to have decent representation. I am against this section.
The Minister has not accepted any amendments to improve it as required by Deputies. It gives too much control to a nominated body. It is making them the supreme body over the county council. The only authority the county council will have is that when the county board of health demands a certain sum, say £34,000, the county council will have to find that money. That is what they are there for, to find money, hand it over to the county board of health and let them spend it; hand it over to a body which is only a nominated body. I think that is not a section that will meet with any satisfaction. It may satisfy a few people who wish to become members of a county board of health for the simple purpose of getting their sons or daughters into positions, but will not meet with the approval of any honest representatives who are really out for the good of the people. The county council will have no control over anything, doctors, midwives, infirmaries, waterworks or lighting schemes; all they will have control over will be the throwing of a few shovels of sand on the roads. I think the Minister, on the Report Stage, ought to delete the county council as an elected body, substitute the county board of health, and have them that they shall appoint the county councils. I think it would be more honest if they did. I will call for a division on this section.
Comment on this
Does the question of the county councils arise under this section?
Comment on this
Is this not a question of the county board of health appointing committees?
Comment on this
Yes, but there is the further question that if the county boards are appointed by the county councils the county boards will have more authority in the counties than those who appointed them.
Comment on this
Does the county board get this authority under the section?
Comment on this
You will have to keep to the question of county councils and county boards of health.
Comment on this
A good deal has been said about the board of health being only a nominated body. Deputies might just as well say that we are only a nominated body. We are only a Committee of the Dáil, just as these will be committees.
Comment on this
If Deputies will read Section 13 they will see that the county council has complete financial control over the board of health. It is not merely a case of passing its estimates; they have control over actions that the board of health takes in connection with finance. After all, that is the main item to be considered.
Comment on this
I made a statement a little while ago which I find was not wholly correct, and I want to amend it. I said that any of the committees appointed under this section might consist wholly of persons who were not elected. That is wrong. There must be at least one person on a sub-committee who has been elected to a county council, inasmuch as the board of health will consist, in the first place, of persons who are members of the county councils and therefore are elected. But quite easily any such committee might consist of only one person who has been elected by the ratepayers to the county council, and might consist, in addition to that one, of any number who are not elected. Any such committee may have granted to it any powers as the board of health as a whole has been given, and in that way you may have a committee consisting of ten persons having the supervision — shall I say? — of the lighting of all the areas in the district. One person on that committee will be a member of the county council, but the rest will be, or may be, non-members of the county council. It will be that committee which will have a detailed knowledge of the requirements of the district, or will be supposed to have it. That committee would prepare the estimate which will be presented to the county council from the board of health. The county council will have the power, as the Minister points out, to refuse to accept that estimate, refuse to strike a rate to cover it, and of course it will have the same sort of ultimate authority as the county councils had in the past over the boards of guardians. But in practical working what was the effectiveness of that authority? Very little, after the vote had been given.
Comment on this
Once a rate had been struck in the old days it was the board of guardians, and in the new days it will be the committee which will have the administration of those moneys, so that we are likely to have the experience that the practical working of the administration will be in the hands of the board of health and its sub-committees, mainly its sub-committees. The board of health will consist of nine persons, and it will appoint, perhaps, nine sub-committees, one member of the board of health on each sub-committee.
Comment on this
"May appoint." The argument that succeeded against our amendment with respect to one particular function was that the boards of health appoint themselves. But let us assume that they do not appoint themselves, in deference to the wishes of Deputy Wilson. The board of health of nine persons is to do the whole of the administration of all the services of the county council except the management of the roads. Then the prophecy that the board of health will meet three days a week for every week in the quarter will likely be realised. But, on the other hand, let us take the other view, that the board of health, having the power to appoint committees, will exercise that power. It is the board of health, consisting of nine members, and it appoints nine sub-committees. One member of the board of health who has been elected to the county council will act upon the committee, and he will have five, six, or seven other persons, none of whom will be elected. So that we are to have the whole administration of the county council carried out by persons who have not been elected to the county councils, who have not been elected to any other body, in fact.
That may satisfy what the Minister for Justice spoke of two or three weeks ago as being essentially democratic, and the equivalent of representation in the Dáil — that a body concerned would be answerable directly to the people through its representatives. I suggest that under this scheme it is going to be very far from being directly responsible; it is going to be very indirectly responsible and at a very great distance from the ordinary processes of election and responsibility to the ratepayers; there will be final responsibility, no doubt, as the financial control will be in the county council. Unless that county council is likely to be in constant touch with the administration—and it will not be under this scheme — the financial control is only a pretence. The people that will be in actual control will be the sub-committees, who will present estimates to the county council from the board of health. The sub-committees are to consist of persons, some members of the board of health, and some non-members of the board of health.
Possibly — and I am putting this as a possibility, not as an inevitable consequence of the Bill, and I think we have got to guard against possibilities in a measure of this kind — the sub-committees, whether local or general, whether administering the functions in an area or the general functions of the whole district, may consist of one person who has been elected by the ratepayers, and five, six or ten other persons who are only answerable to the board of health, having been nominated by the board of health. If that can be defended, anything can be defended. It is a complete negation of the system either of the Parliamentary representation or the Local Government which we have taken over. If we would say frankly that we intend to abolish the system of representation through election, and responsibility to the ratepayers by means of an electoral system, let us say so at once; but do not let us pretend to retain that system, and then embody in an enactment proposals that are a negation of that system. That is what Section 12 proposes to do.
Comment on this
I cannot see the drift of Deputy Johnson's remarks. If he read sub-section (4) of this section he would see that those sub-committees have only advisory powers, subject to confirmation by the board of health, unless the board of health confers additional powers on them with the consent of the Minister. All the time you have the elected representatives of the people in absolute control. If they wish to give away that control in any set of circumstances, that is their own business. There is no obligation on them to do it. They can have these committees appointed and leave them purely advisory committees. There is no necessity to give them any more powers.
Comment on this
Question: "That Section 12 stand part of the Bill"— put.
Do you agree with this result?
I beg to move the following amendment:—
At the end of sub-section (1) to add the following words: "The county council may with the consent of the Minister define the limits of expenditure by the board of health, and such limits shall not be exceeded except with the consent of the Minister."
I am not quite clear that the Minister in this section has definitely laid down that a county council may place a definite limit on the amount of money to be spent by the board of health. Some of us who are not very closely acquainted with the working of Local Government are only gradually beginning to visualise what is going to happen when this Bill comes into force. We had it explained by Deputy Johnson that the county council is simply going to be a nominating body, performing, as its first duty, the nomination of the board of health. Another duty it will have is that of looking after the rates in the country, and the control of the budget supplied by the board of health. The question is whether the budget will not be supplied in the same manner as that in which the budgets of the old boards of guardians were supplied to the county council. They put in an estimate at the beginning of the financial year, and to all intents and purposes the county council had no real control over the amount of that estimate; they simply were a sanctioning body.
I am not quite clear whether the Minister intends this section to mean that the county council will have the power to restrict the expenditure of the board of health. Does it mean that the county council can say: "You will only be allowed to spend £5,000 on such and such a service," referring, say, to the home help service or some other service over which they may have control, such as the hospital service? Further, does it mean that the board of health may not have power to exceed that amount without the sanction of the Minister for Local Government? The intention, we are told, is to keep a strict control over the purse and to see that the money of the ratepayers will not be wasted. It is well known the expenditure on local government has gone up by leaps and bounds, and that the rates now paid are something like three or four or five hundred per cent. higher than in 1914. Such a rate cannot be borne by the people, and there should be some stringent control exercised.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I would like the Deputy to mention in what county the rates are three or four hundred per cent. higher than in 1914.
Comment on this
That statement, I think, can be proved. I know a case where the rates this year are 6/6 in the £ as compared with 1/8 somewhere about 1914. Those rates are four times greater than they were in that period. That is in the district where I am living. I am not perfectly certain about the former year, but probably it was 1913 or 1914. That being the case, I believe that a strong hand must be kept over the finances of the country. You have this nominated board of health with its nominated committees and sub-committees, and these committees may have power to expend money. You have this expenditure by the board of health and its committees handed over as a demand on the county council. The county council may have no option but to say, "We have to pay." When the ratepayers kick up a row, the county council simply say, "We cannot help it; we got this demand from the board of health and had no option but to meet it." I want to know if the intention of the section is to give power to the county council to ration the board of health. If it does not, my amendment aims at giving that power.
Comment on this
This amendment, I think, is not necessary. Even if accepted, it would not achieve anything like what will be achieved by the section as it stands. If the amendment were accepted in its present form I do not know how it will read into the section.
Comment on this
Even at the end it will not read very well. To my mind it does not give the county council any greater control over the board of health than is provided for in the section. I do not think it will ensure what the Deputy has in his mind. As to Deputy Heffernan's statement, that in some counties the rates have gone up 300 or 400 per cent. over what they were ten or twelve years ago, I would like to know the district where that happened. If the Deputy said 30 or 40 per cent. it might be nearer to the facts.
Comment on this
I have given a definite statement. It is a district council. I will supply the Deputy with the exact figures if he wishes.
Comment on this
Deputy Heffernan is probably labouring under a misapprehension. Probably what he has in mind is the time when we had electoral division rating for poor law purposes. These rates varied considerably. From my experience, I do not believe there was a rural district in Ireland in 1914 with a 1/6 rate. I know there were rates of from 10d. to 2/- for poor law purposes. I cannot find anything in the amendment very much different from what is contained in Sub-section (1). The amendment aims practically at the same thing and would only make the Section unwieldy. The Deputy should remember what the value of money was in 1914 as compared with now. He should take into account what has to be paid now in wages and salaries, and should know that it is not possible to carry on now at the same rate as in 1914.
Comment on this
I do not see any necessity for the amendment. The Deputy does not seem to be fully aware of the position of the board of health. I am afraid he has no knowledge of the work or of the jurisdiction of the board of health. He evidently thinks that the members of the county council are not elected by the people and that they put on the board of health men who are not elected representatives. The board of health consists of members of the county council elected by the people. They are responsible to the county council in the first instance, and the Local Government Department checks everything that is done by the board of health. The amount of money expended under the poor law system has been very considerably decreased in the Riding from which Deputy Heffernan comes. At the same time, I might remind Deputy Johnson of the fact that there has been practically no complaint from those out of work and who are entitled to home help.
The board of health is a body that is absolutely bound down. If it is not bound down in any county then there is something wrong. Let us hope that other boards of health are managed as well as the board of which I happen to be chairman. There is absolutely nothing done in our county that is not under the control of the Ministry. Practically all of the members are farmers and there is very rarely a complaint. If anything is wrong the Ministry will not approve of it. Any expenditure incurred has got to go before the county council. Up to the present it was not possible to send in an estimate of the probable expenditure for the 12 months, which Deputy Johnson refers to. That would be absolutely impossible, as these boards are only a very short time in existence and the work was new to some of the members. The amalgamation schemes made a very great change. From what I have seen these boards have done their work well. I know that the members of these boards recognise that they are responsible to the county council, and both the board of health and the county council are under the control of the Local Government Department as regards every item of expenditure. I see no reason for the amendment, because any expenditure incurred by the board of health will have to go, not alone before the Local Government Department, but before the county council, where every item will be criticised and no undue expenditure will be allowed.
Comment on this
I want to support Deputy Heffernan's amendment. An ideal state of things appears to exist in Tipperary and perhaps there is reason for it. Deputy D'Alton has given a reason why conditions are ideal there; still I think there is something in Deputy Heffernan's argument, and that things may not always be so well, even in Tipperary, as they are at present. There is every reason to think that a future board of health in Tipperary may be composed not of farmers but of people who may be less careful about spending public money. I think there ought to be one authority in every county really responsible for finding the money that has to be spent, and that the county council should be that authority. If they have to find the money they ought also be in the position of allocating how the money should be spent.
It is all right to say that boards of health are under the authority of the county councils. I do not know what the conditions are in Tipperary, but they do not generally obtain. As far as I know, in other counties these boards are entirely independent of the county council. The county council does not interfere, nor has it any right to interfere, as to the amount of money boards of health should spend. It seems to me that it should be within the jurisdiction of the county council when estimates are being considered to say how much is to go to the board of health. That power should be in the hands of the county council, as they are the real responsible body for raising and spending money.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey says that is provided for in the Bill, but I do not think it is provided for in the shape Deputy Heffernan intends. If Deputy Morrissey, Deputy D'Alton or the Minister can show us that the county council would have jurisdiction to the extent of saying to the county board of health how much they can spend, we will be satisfied that it meets Deputy Heffernan's point. Otherwise we will not.
Comment on this
I am in favour of the amendment. I think this amendment would at least give some control to the county council which raises the money. Sub-section 2 of Section 13 says:—
The money required to meet the expenses of a board of health in the exercise and performance of their powers and duties under this Act shall be supplied by the county council to the board of health on an annual estimate and demand by the board of health, and shall be estimated, demanded, and paid in the same manner as the expenses of a rural district council have been heretofore estimated, demanded, and paid, or in such other manner as may be prescribed.
That is, if the county board of health demands £60,000 the county council has no alternative but to grant it.
Comment on this
If the estimate is £60,000 the county council have no power to reduce it. Deputy D'Alton has told us about how well the workers of Tipperary are treated by the county board of health. I am very pleased to know that the people are so well looked after by the board of health there. It is not so in every other county. Section 13 of this Bill compels the county council to raise money and to hand it over to the county board of health. The least we can expect is that the county council should have some control over that money. As Deputy D'Alton stated, it is all under the control of the Minister for Local Government. The general complaint with all public bodies under the old regime was that there was too much red-tapeism, and that there was too much of the iron hand kept on local authorities by the then Local Government Board. The same thing applies now. If a man is employed by the county council the sanction of the Minister for Local Government has to be obtained. There is too much control — I do not say on the part of the Minister himself, but by the officials of his Department. Of course, the county council have not so far been asked to submit to the Department the names of the road workers for sanction.
Deputy D'Alton is quite correct in saying that the expenditure of the money is under the supervision of the Local Government Department, so that if the county board of health do anything wrong the Department, as the Bill provides, can cause such an inquiry as they may think fit to be held. That is not sufficient to safeguard the county council. The people who are elected to the position of county councillors should, in my opinion, have some control over the money expended by the county board of health. When the latter body sends in an estimate the county council should be in a position to say whether they would sanction the full amount asked for, or reduce it, if they thought well. In my opinion, the county council should be given that authority, so that they might be enabled to save the money of the ratepayers. A lot has been said about increases in the estimates of public bodies. Some Deputies have put down the increase at from 200 to 300 per cent. I can speak with authority of two counties in the Twenty-Six that comprise the Free State. In these counties the rates have been reduced by 1/8 and 1/10 in the pound, while, at any time, the rate was never more than 7/10 in the pound. The cost of home help has increased, no doubt, but that is not the fault of the unfortunate people who have to make application for assistance.
I suggest the fault is due to the employers in this country who will not invest their money in industries and thus provide employment for the people. In my opinion, members of the board of health, even though they be not members of the county council, should be given power, in cases of distress or hardship which come to their notice in their own districts, to afford relief to the sufferers. I agree with the amendment of Deputy Heffernan, because I see that it proposes to give the county council some authority. It was stated that the county council were the masters as far as the estimates are concerned, but in my opinion, they have not the control in that respect that they should have. It is true, of course, that the county council has control over a load of sand that may be spread on the roads, or over the man engaged rolling a wheel-barrow on the roads,: but I think that is all the control they have. The Minister, in his reply, stated that the county council has full control over the finances of the county. I can say that they have no control over the county board of health, and that they do not know in what manner the money they raise is expended by that board. I think the Minister should accept this amendment for the reason that it proposes to give the county council some little control.
Comment on this
I desire to assure my fellow-Deputy from the County Tipperary that when I was speaking on this matter I had not the Tipperary county board of health in view at all. I was speaking on the matter from the general point of view of the whole country. Statements have been made to the effect that the rates have not been increased by amounts like two, three or four hundred per cent. There are, however, definite cases in which the rates have been increased, and I can produce facts to show that they have been increased by the amounts stated. Deputy Hughes, while acknowledging that the rates have increased to a large extent, states that the value of money has decreased. I would like to remind him that while the rates have increased the value of money to the ratepayers has decreased. The amount of money which the ratepayers get for their produce has not increased by even fifty per cent. I would be perfectly satisfied if the increase in the rates bore some relation to the increase in the value of the produce which we sell. But it does not. It was stated that sub-section (1) of this section covers the matter that I am endeavouring to cover by my amendment. I do not agree. Sub-section (1) of the section states that "The board of health shall be subject to such conditions and restrictions in respect to expenditure as the county council may impose with the consent of the Minister." That does not say that the county council shall be definitely limited or rationed as to the amount which they may expend.
Comment on this
The amendment says they "may." I put in the word "may," as Deputy D'Alton pointed out that the Board of Health is only in existence for a very short time. Therefore, the amount of money which the county board of health will require to expend will be very problematical for some time, and it would not be right or fair to ask the county council to place a limit on the amount at the present time. To limit the amount would be a very arbitrary procedure to adopt at present. In my opinion, when the county boards of health have been in vogue for four or five years, the county council should then place a limit on their expenditure, and tell the Boards: "This is your limit, and beyond that you cannot go. If you do, you will be surcharged."
Comment on this
I was glad to hear from Deputy Heffernan that his remarks about the increase in rates by three or four hundred per cent. did not apply to counties, but to rural districts. I am not going to accept any responsibility for the expenditure of rural district councils. I have taken a very effective way of getting rid of that, and I am surprised that when Deputy Heffernan put forward such a good argument in favour of their abolition, that he did not vote for their abolition, but voted the other way. With regard to Deputy D'Alton and Deputy Baxter, they seem to be at cross purposes as regards the relation of the board of health to the county council. As a matter of fact, there is a difference in the constitution of Deputy Baxter's board of health to the one in operation in Deputy D'Alton's constituency. Deputy Baxter's board of health was elected by the rural district council and the urban council. That system was changed subsequently, and the board of health was elected by the county council. Deputy D'Alton's board of health happens to be one of those that was last set up, and it is responsible to the county council. At the present time there is no very effective control over the boards of health by the county councils, but sub-section (1) of this section gives complete control. That sub-section embodies everything that is in Deputy Heffernan's amendment. Indeed, it includes a great deal more. Deputy Heffernan's amendment would add nothing to the sub-section. The only possible effect it might have is that a judge, in construing the section along with the amendment, might possibly look upon the amendment as a limitation of the section, and some of the powers that the county council have under the section as it stands might be taken from it if this amendment were inserted, and for that reason I am opposed to it. If I thought that the amendment would increase the authority of the county council over the board of health, I would accept it, but if it were to do anything at all it would, I think, be the other way about.
Comment on this
If the Minister would give me a clear understanding that there is power under the Bill as it stands for a county council to limit the expenditure of a board of health, I am willing to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Heffernan's amendment enabled us to discuss the principle of this section fairly elaborately, but there is just one point in it that I desire to call attention to. The Bill provides for the usual contributory places for special expenses provided for under the Public Health (Ireland) Act of 1878, with this addition, that the area of rural district councils is added. That is necessary because, on the appointed day, the expenses of the rural district council will be charged on the area of the rural district, and for that reason the area of the rural district will have to continue to be the area on which special rates are charged for some time to come. It is advisable to retain this as a special area of charge for the future. For example, supposing at the present time, or on the appointed day, a rural district council has erected a waterworks in respect of which there is a loan outstanding, that loan would be charged on the area of the rural district, and if, on a subsequent appointed day, or at any future date, an improvement were made in the waterworks, obviously the area on which to charge the expenses incurred in respect of that addition or improvement would be the area of the rural district. For that reason, it is necessary to add it to the other areas on which special expenses are charged.
Comment on this
This section deals with the abolition of special committees, that is, committees dealing with quasisanitary functions and that were committees of the county council. As long as the county council was in control of functions that were partly sanitary it was necessary that they should have the power to appoint these committees, but now that all the public health functions of the county are centred in the Board of Public Health it is only right that these functions should be taken under control by the board of health. In the case of the Tuberculosis Committee under this Bill, if that Committee were not abolished you would have some functions dealing with tuberculosis performed by the county board of health, and other functions dealing with the curative side of the disease performed by the Tuberculosis Committee, and it is better that all these functions should be performed by one body — the county board of health. If it is necessary to appoint a sub-committee to deal with these matters that committee should be appointed by the board of health and not by the county council, as it is the board of health that will have to deal with all matters in connection with health.
Comment on this
Will the appointment of the Agricultural and Technical Instruction Committee be made by the board of health, or will they be appointed by the county council and remain under the supervision of the county council?
Comment on this
Will the county councils appoint the management of the district hospitals and the county infirmaries or will the committees of the county infirmaries be transferred?
Comment on this
What have county committees of agriculture or mental hospitals to do with this section?
Comment on this
I am looking for information. The section shows the different committees that were appointed.