We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

THE SHANNON SCHEME. - MOTION BY THE MINISTER FOR INDUSTRY AND COMMERCE—RESUMED DEBATE.

Contributions 113–240 of 240. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Deputy Johnson has given the figures.

Comment on this

Is my explanation right or not?

Comment on this

I want to find out whether this figure of 3.46 or whether Deputy Hewat's figure of 1.1, or whatever his figure is, is equivalent to the figure dealt with in the expert's report?

Comment on this

The figure dealt with in the expert's report is the figure represented by 1.5, I presume—that is delivery to the transforming station.

Comment on this

I think there is another point. I think the figure given in the expert's report is for the year ending March, 1923. We have some later returns which are more favourable to the Corporation by reason of the fact that they are almost exhausting the kilowatt capacity. In addition, they have got customers from the townships. There has been a remarkable increase in the number of units sold this year over last year. It is something like 2,000,000 units, I think.

Comment on this

Of course, that is a point which must be considered in connection with the increased consumption. The Corporation have, I believe, given a supplementary supply to Pembroke and a supplementary supply to Rathmines. The Port and Docks Board have shut down their station and are taking current from the Corporation. The Great Northern Railway Company have also shut down their power station and are now taking their power from the Corporation. The question of how far development in the production of electricity can be counted on, is a very important factor in connection with the whole scheme based on the development of the Shannon. This is a question which can be looked at from two points. I think that the members of this House largely take the view, the very enthusiastic view—and I do not say it is a wrong view—that the development of the Shannon on the lines of the report will be of national importance and that on that basis, even if the thing worked out that current in some cases might be generated more cheaply than it could be provided by the national scheme, still the national scheme would be of advantage to the country. I do not dispute that, but let us be clear on the issue as between the two. Either you deal with the matter purely as an economic proposition or you bring into view the bigger issue of how far this development of the central station can supply current all over the country to the benefit of the country as a whole.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

There are very few points at the present time, within the area of the Free State, where there is likely to be, within a period of six years, a development that would mean an economic working of the extension to that district. If that is so, the whole basis of the calculations that are laid down for this scheme must be revised. If it is not so, the figures given are reliable and can be counted on. On that point who are the best judges? Men who have been engaged in the distribution and the manufacture of electricity all their lives, know local conditions perfectly well, and if they have expressed the opinion that it would take a great deal longer time to develop the consumption of electricity on these lines to make it a paying proposition, I think their opinion, at all events, ought to carry some weight with us. The first step according to the Minister is going to be a high tension cable to Cork from Limerick or to Cork and Dublin, and the radiating lines are to follow in due course.

As an economic proposition, leaving out everything else, does any Deputy in this House imagine that to generate current in Limerick, solely for the consumption of Dublin, is a proposition that any person would be likely to put a lot of money in, if it were his own money? I imagine not, any more than I would imagine that it would enter into anybody's mind to send current from Dublin to Limerick. It is a long line. It is a long way to Limerick, and the experts themselves say that if it were confined to Dublin alone, the Liffey scheme would be the one to go on with. I do not express any opinion between the two, one way or another, but clearly at the present stage, when I think the country is suffering from over-taxation an expenditure of five millions in capital money with the possibility of that four or five million carrying with it a charge on the country, at all events calls for the fullest possible investigation of the whole question. That is I think all that is asked for. That is what I stand as asking for. I also stand as asking that the opinions of the men who have given an opinion on this matter, and who, I think, are capable of giving an unbiassed opinion, should not be treated as if they were of no account at all. In our enthusiasm we seem likely to consider it as a small matter to enter into this expenditure, a very large expenditure at the present time.

I imagine that it will not be quite as easy to raise £5,000,000 in the country at present as we would wish. True, the expenditure will not be immediate; a proportion of it will only be required immediately. True, one great benefit that will arise from the expenditure will be the minimising of the suffering caused by unemployment. If the money spent relieves unemployment nobody is going to object. But is it unfair to ask that a scheme of this magnitude, submitted so recently as a fortnight ago, should get every opportunity to be examined in the light of the economic position and of the development that it is going to attain? Will it not have greater force behind it after that has been done than if it were pushed forward in a hurried way, without even giving the consideration to it that one would give to a private undertaking of a similar nature?

It is difficult to speak on this subject. I recognise the enthusiasm all round for the development of this scheme. The claim that is made for a full examination is not unreasonable. It has been put forward by several bodies, not to retard the scheme, but to make sure that the calculations are reasonably likely to materialise when the scheme is in operation.

Comment on this

I must confess that I approach this subject, even at this late stage of the debate, with a considerable amount of trepidation, almost, I might say, bordering on bewilderment. This, indeed, is a great and gigantic proposal. It is one that if properly executed might revolutionise the whole economic state of our country, and, more than that, it might even impart an uplifting to the general body of our people in more than a material or economic sense. It is great both from a national, economic and financial point of view, and I desire at the very outset to congratulate the Government, and especially their spokesman, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, upon the courage that both they and he have displayed in the step that they have taken in the direction of progress, instead of having, as well they might, rested upon their oars. The Government have thought fit to bring forward a proposal of such magnitude and such vast potentialities that they deserve credit for the risk they have taken even in bringing it forward.

Speaking as one who is interested in this proposal from an entirely disinterested point of view, if I might say so, I desire to say that I am in favour of the proposal. I am in favour of a scheme for the utilisation of the waters of the Shannon for the purpose of providing power for the lighting, heating and industry of the country. To my mind, the Liffey scheme is out of the question. Even though it does concern Dublin, it is a mere local matter. As was said by Deputy O'Sullivan last night, the Liffey scheme could never have been expanded so as to be of any use to the rest of the country. The Shannon scheme may not, at the outset, provide for all parts of the country, but it must be, according to the reports presented to us, in future available for all the requirements of the country. I think that is greatly in its favour. Therefore, my position is this: I am in favour of a Shannon scheme. From what I can gather, this scheme seems to have been carefully considered and thought out, and undoubtedly it has been drawn up by one of, if not the greatest, electrical firms in the world.

I am in favour, on the report we have received, of putting this scheme into effect, and the only complaint that I have is, not as to this magnificent conception, but rather as to the means and methods of its execution. It would have been far better, when this great German firm approached us, and when we had arranged with them to draw up the scheme, if we had further arranged, the scheme having been settled, that we should be in a position to say to them: "Very well; thanks very much for your scheme, we are sure that it will succeed and that it is sound, now we will allow you, along with all the other great firms of the world, to enter into open competition to put that scheme into effect." I am sorry that that has not been done. It would have been better, from our own business point of view, if that were done, and it would have been better also from the point of view of our political relations throughout the world. However that may be, perhaps it is rather an ex post facto argument now, because, from what I understand, this resolution commits us to Siemens-Schuckert and this scheme.

I would like to point out, if it has not occurred to Deputies already, what is the effect of this resolution that we are now discussing. The effect of the resolution itself is nil. It has no legal effect. It will be necessary to introduce a Bill and that Bill will have to go through all stages the same as any other Bill. I must confess that I cannot see what the necessity was for the introduction of this resolution at all, except perhaps this. The Minister said that previous to proposing this resolution he had given a pledge that he would incur—I think this is a paraphrase of his words at any rate—no expense in regard to this matter. He then went on to say that when this resolution has been passed he would consider himself absolved from that pledge. I think it only right to ask the Minister, and I am sure he will do me the courtesy of replying when his time comes, what exactly he means by that? Does he mean after the passage of this resolution that he will be at liberty to enter into any contractual obligations with this firm? Does he mean that he will be able to say to this firm that now they have the contract, because if that is so he certainly will be acting without the authority of the Dáil? This contract with this firm will require legislation passed through this House and the Seanad. I think before that Bill is produced, and certainly before it is passed, the Minister, or the Executive Council, should not take it upon themselves to enter into any contractual relations with this firm in this matter.

The course that the debate has taken has been one rather of detailed criticism than of general objection to the scheme as a whole. I, for one, am not going to venture into the realm of criticism on a subject which I do not profess to know anything about, and, indeed, with all respect to most of the Deputies. I do not think they would be in a very much better position themselves if anyone of expert knowledge were to speak to them on the subject. That being so, I must confess I cannot see what great use there would be in referring this question to a committee composed of members of this House. I do not see what very much more could be discussed, or what more information could be obtained by individual Deputies sitting upon a committee, with the knowledge then at their disposal, which, I presume, would not be very much in advance of the knowledge they possess to-day.

This is largely a matter of trust, and indeed a matter of speculation. I admire the Government for their speculation, but I am rather chary of their trust. I think it would have been wiser if they could have had at their disposal, along with the four experts whose qualifications I am not going to question, someone from these countries —if possible someone from Ireland— some competent engineer whom they could have turned to, who, with knowledge of the country and its conditions as well as professional knowledge, would be able to help and assist them in coming to conclusions, or indeed in understanding the propositions put up to them by the experts and by Siemens-Schuckert. I am sorry they did not see their way to adopt that course. The proposal that the contract should be given of necessity to this firm is, I think, an unbusinesslike one. Those are the two principal grounds of complaint I have against the Government in their conduct of this subject.

I must say that for my part, at any rate, I am as optimistic as any member of the Government about the question of demand in the future. I am confident that when the supply is there there will be demand. The whole success of this project depends upon whether the demand shall be forthcoming, when we have brought into being the necessary supply. It is true, it may be said, that cheap power is not everything, and cheap power, to a certain extent, means very little in the conduct of certain industries. But, at any rate, cheap power will do one thing. It will remove one of the most cogent arguments against the setting up in this country of industries by people from across the water or elsewhere. It will not be able to be said, "We cannot go here and we cannot go there in Ireland because of the lack of power or of the cheapness of power." I think that this is a great step. I think it is a most progressive step. I think it is a step most highly commendable for a young Government in what we now call a young State. I think it is a step that is taken with considerable risk. There must be risk about it. There can be nothing in the way of certainty, but what we must be certain about is that the scheme which we are debating, according to the experts, at any rate, is a sound one, and that that sound scheme can be set up in a sound way, upon sound, economic lines.

I regret, therefore, that more care was not taken and more opportunity not given to others than the actual firm who are about to be engaged upon the work. Perhaps even at this stage it would not be too late for the Government to take into their counsels those experts, and there are some, on this matter, who know the conditions, and the state of the country in which this great experiment is going to be made. I am not, as I said before, going to take up the time of the Dail at this stage. But I do think that this debate has been a profitable one. I think it has been good from the point of view of the public and from the point of the Government itself. It has shown the deep interest that is taken in all quarters in this scheme. It has shown that the criticism of the scheme is mainly constructive and helpful. It has shown that there is no hostility to the scheme per se; it has shown that the Deputies, from all quarters, are anxious that the scheme should go forward, but they are also anxious that it should go forward on proper lines, and under proper care and proper control. That being so, if I may be permitted to do so, with all due respect to the members of the Farmers' Party, might I suggest to them that having done this much good by bringing forward this amendment, it would be a gracious act upon their part if they were to withdraw the amendment now, having elicited opinions from the various parts of the Dáil, and that they would allow the resolution now to pass.

Comment on this

As one of the Deputies from the constituency of Limerick, I wish to give my thanks to, and to express my appreciation of, the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the noble stand he has taken in producing this enormous scheme. Since I was a boy I have always been taught that there was as much power in the Shannon as would supply Ireland for all her industries. When I first heard this I never thought that I should see it realised or that I should see it accomplished. I hope it is going to be accomplished now. The first place I ever heard that was in the Christian Brothers' Schools in Limerick. The only people I ever knew to object to the promotion of a Shannon scheme were people who had vested interests in foreign countries. Those were the people who individually wanted to keep close to their own interests, and to neglect the interests of our country. We all know that industry is a thing that must be promoted, cherished and nursed. It must be nursed very carefully. The Minister says that he is quite satisfied that the power will be there for those outside of industry. I was glad to hear that, but the Shannon scheme in the future will develop industries. It will nurse industries. Industries that are in existence will be put on their feet, and the possibilities are that the scheme will enable new industries to start, industries that can go into competition with any in Europe. In the River Shannon from Limerick city down to Loop Head I know that there is as much material as would supply Europe with cement, and the possibilities are that in the very near future, and I daresay in the building of these canals, dams, and everything else, some company will be formed to take up this project. There were experts examining that matter twenty-five years ago, and they pronounced that the material was equal to any cement material that could be got in any part of Europe. All Limerick city and county are looking forward to the scheme going through, and not alone Limerick, but Clare and Tipperary. It will relieve unemployment; that is the first thing; and the industries that will spring up in the near future will be able to extend and to keep employment going. That is the main object of the project. I have great pleasure, on my own behalf and on behalf of other Limerick Deputies, in expressing these views, and the hope that the Dáil will pass the motion.

Comment on this

I do not intend to delay the House very long, but I do not wish to give a silent vote on this matter. This debate has had a fascination for me, and I thank God that I have lived to see the day when our own Government can make a gesture that has such promise for our country. I was born within earshot of a water-wheel, and ever since then I have not been far removed from one. I have been engaged in Irish industries all my life, and I was sent here to represent Irish industry. Someone might say that I have not cut much ice or made much noise in the Dáil since I came. One of the reasons why I have not done so so far is, that, in my opinion, up to this the Government had the protection of the tinker's wife. Now that a change has taken place and the first phase of the situation is over, I think the time has come when we are right into the second, which is the economic phase. In the first place I think it right to say that, in my opinion, no men could have done better, and I welcome this gesture in the hope that the Government has taken its courage in both hands, and that it means to prosecute this endeavour to a successful issue. There are great possibilities in this scheme in the encouragement and the stimulus it will give to our people, and it was never more needed than now. I have an intimate knowledge of many industries in this country, and to-day they are at a very low ebb. They are decaying. Something is wanted. If Ministers, having now broken the ice in this matter, put their shoulders to the wheel and encourage and protect the industries that we have got, they will have my support, and, I believe, the support of the bulk of the people. But if they show any weakness and heed the croaking pessimists who are sometimes to be heard here, and very often outside, the country will see to it that they will do their duty by the country.

Comment on this

We are jaded members of a jaded House. The conclusion is a foregone conclusion. Deputy Redmond, with prophetic foresight, has already indicated it. The amendment will be withdrawn and victory is ready with her laurels to crown the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I feel that were it not for the encouragement of Deputy Johnson's remarks yesterday evening to intervene now would be indefensible, as merely delaying the final stage. But Deputy Johnson said that there had been so much propaganda against this scheme that it is highly desirable that something by way of propaganda in its favour should be inaugurated, and the great value of this debate, as has already been said by our colleague here, is that it has begun that great work.

Yesterday evening I was seething with excitement, dreading the hour of ordeal when it should be my turn to speak, and in the tension of that hour of strain I made a verbatim note of all the speeches that were delivered. Do not be alarmed, sir, I do not propose to read them all. On studying to-day the speech of the proposer of the amendment to the resolution, I became convinced that sufficient justice had not been done to him. There is a story told of a man of letters, that he claimed he had written the best comedies that had ever been conceived, and when it was pointed out to him as rather an extraordinary thing that they had not been acted, he retorted that that was the very proof of their success; they were so exceedingly witty and humorous that the actors themselves could not restrain their laughter, so that it was impossible to have them played. Deputy Connor Hogan's speech had so much of humour, so much of subtle charm, that we attended rather to the language he employed than to the ideas that the language expressed. Consequently the full weight of his speech was not felt. It was not a speech in support of the amendment as formulated, but a speech which summarised practically all the points that had been made, whether in newspaper articles or in letters to the editors, for quite a long time past. I would like the Deputy to believe me that I do not accuse him of plagiarising these; on the contrary, I believe that those letters indicate a frame of mind and a line of thought that are natural to those for whom the Deputy has been able to speak here.

He has put his case more dexterously than they. He asks us to be wise in time, to display caution, not to go too fast. I was tempted to translate the Latin equivalent of his caution, Festina Lente, as an encouragement to the Minister, if-differently interpreted, “Make haste in Lent.” With caution incarnate Deputy Hogan warned the Minister and the Executive Council to go slowly. That is not exactly how the newspaper articles put it. They say that there is a decided intention on the part of the Government to stampede the country. I have an article here from a very weighty organ of very weighty opinions, in every sense of the word. “The Government is suspected, not unjustly, of an effort to rush the Siemens-Schuckert scheme over the nation's head. We shall oppose any such tactics of hustle.” Deputy Hogan and the party of which he is the spokesman have opposed these alleged tactics of hustle. What does the amendment propose? “That the proposals should be further examined by other experts of international reputation.” It was said of a very distinguished Irishman that his mind was like a clock—the works functioned only when the pendulum wagged. Deputy Hogan has the habit, the possession of which I envy him, of thinking while he talks and because he is talking. The rest of us are unfortunately subject to the limitation of having to think first and talk afterwards. Deputy Hogan modified his proposal into, “We accept a Commission of the Oireachtas.” He is afraid, incidentally, that without such further inquiry we shall have, as he said, a white elephant on our hands. It is to save the nation from that awkward predicament that a further inquiry has to be instituted. That is not unlike one of the processes of the British law courts which suffers a man indicted for murder to be tried three times in a case where there has been a disagreement of the jury, but, suppose the disagreement was on the first trial and the second jury agreed to find him guilty, the matter is at an end and there is no further prosecution. Similarly, I dare say, if the Farmers' Party could get a committee not necessarily of experts, to decide unfavourably on these proposals, then the matter would be declared ended and the nation would be exhorted not to go on with this tomfoolery. Yet the Deputy who recommended this further inquiry realises that, in effect, there should be no end to it.

Deputy O'Sullivan has pointed out very clearly what was the precise relation of those experts employed by the Government. The experts, or rather, the inexperts, whom the Farmers' Party would recommend, whom, on second thoughts, the Deputy recommends— what have they to inquire into? To what end is this cross-examination that the Farmers' Party desires? The problem is a three-fold one. As pointed out in the report, it is first of all, technically a problem for engineers; secondly, it is an economic problem. It is essentially an economic problem, but what the experts have not pointed out, it is likewise a problem of public policy, and that is a matter that concerns us quite as much as the economic aspect of it. Is the Government trying to rush the country, to stampede the country into a policy that is wrong? With your permission I will read a little further from the article. "Finally Parliament must not overlook the effect of its decision on the great neighbour who buys 95 per cent. of the Free State exports. It is true that English shipping companies have given contracts to German yards, but only after they failed to get equal terms at home. Now, the Free State Government propose to give a monopoly to Germany at the expense of the Irish farmers' essential customer. Will this be good business? The Oireachtas will be lacking in its duty to the people if it refuses to probe all the momentous issues which are involved in the Government plan." The casual reader might be foolish enough to interpret that as a threat and look on those as menacing words, but, knowing the organ in which it appears, I realise it is merely a warning of the same type as appears in a pamphlet circulated to most, if not all, of the Deputies some time ago with the name of a very distinguished engineer on the cover, Sir John Griffith. The hand is the hand of Esau, but the voice is the voice of Jacob. Now, I am not dealing for the moment with the inaccuracy of the statement that a monopoly is being given to Germany. I am dealing rather with the suggested history. We have had such a lot of these histories in connection with the suggestion of stampede that even at the risk of being more than usually tedious I would like to dwell on them. This is a letter from a well-known Irish engineer, Mr. Arthur E. Porte. It is written as if to illustrate the wisdom of the proverb, "Let the cobbler stick to his last." When an engineer becomes a historian he loses a great deal of his authority. "We are forced," he says, "therefore, to inquire why Dublin is offered current by Siemens at one halfpenny per unit. The answer surely is simple. Siemens arrived in the field too late to propose a monopoly of the Liffey. Other groups had already developed Liffey schemes in great detail and at great expense. No Liffey amendment, with large propagandist possibilities, could be moved. Consequently we are now offered a scheme the financial essence of which is that Dublin—because the Liffey schemes were available to supply it with current at three-farthings a unit, while the rest of the country makes up the loss in paying excessive prices. I challenge any competent person who is familiar with the history and financial details of the Siemens' scheme to gainsay this general conclusion."

I accept that challenge. I happen to know the precise date at which this distinguished Irish graduate in the employment of Messrs. Siemens first approached the President of the Dáil. It was not because that it was too late an hour to make approaches for a Liffey scheme, but it was because that engineer, as patriotic Irishman, had his interests centred upon the economic development of his own country, and, finding himself in the employment of a firm whose operations were world-wide, he set himself to interest his employers in the exploitation of the Shannon water power, and, instead of their going out to give their experience and ability to China, they were, very happily for us, persuaded by him to turn their attention to Ireland. The fact that Messrs. Siemens came to Ireland at all, and were willing to divert their energies from other centres of operation, was due to the case that Dr. McLaughlin was able to make for the possibilities of the Shannon. Now we are asked to believe that Messrs. Siemens and these employed to scrutinise with vigilance every detail of Messrs. Siemens' plan, did this thing hurriedly. Why, if it were only a priori, would not one come to the conclusion that a firm accustomed to the operations of the magnitude that Messrs. Siemens engage in would not undertake a project of the kind in a hurry? Every single record of the height of the Shannon at every period of the year in the last 100 years was carefully studied in Germany. Every ordnance survey map, and the reports of all the Commissions that ever sat under the British regime to investigate water power in Ireland, were carefully studied before they came on the ground to inspect the actual territory. That is not a case of hurry. It is not a case of superficial investigation. Everyone knows, to take a small example, how anyone expert in a particular department can with extreme and almost incredible rapidity form a decision which would occupy the inexperienced man for months, and leave him still in vacillating doubt. That is the difference between acquired dexterity and the ordinary amateur mind.

Now, who are those experts whom we employed? Are they men who are accustomed to slur business, to do things in a half-hearted way, and in incomplete measures? The Government had the advantage of being lent the greatest men in the electrical world in Sweden. Everyone knows, as regards civil engineering applied to water power, that Switzerland stands foremost. There are great men in Germany, and there are great men in America, but Switzerland is the pioneer in this, and was the pioneer in all those almost magical undertakings in the making of roads, the construction of mounbridges, and the construction of mountain railways. Switzerland has the same pre-eminence in those affairs as Ireland has in linen, whiskey, or shipbuilding. We have a careful report of these experts, two of them from Switzerland, who have devoted themselves to the civil engineering elements of the problem, and two others, Swedish and Norwegian, to the aspects of the case in which Ireland more resembled their own country. We have had an extraordinary number of geographical discoveries in the course of this debate.

Deputy Darrell Figgis, who has some distinction as a novelist, for example, has exercised his imagination with regard to the comparison of other countries. I took a note of his speech, and I find that a great deal of it was devoted to unnecessary repudiation of a charge of interestedness financially, but a great deal of what he had to say I had already read in that pamphlet which was published under the name of Sir John Griffith. With regard to the repudiation I thought at the time of the famous epitaph on Craggs, which one may read in Westminster Abbey from the pen of Pope:—

"Statesman, yet friend of truth, of soul sincere;

In action faithful, and in honour clear;

Who broke no promise, served no private end,

Who gained no title, and who lost no friend."

He has pointed out, and some of the members of the Farmers' Party likewise, that you have local centres of electrical production in Switzerland. Anyone who will compare the map of the two countries, not to speak of comparing the countries actually as regards their physical contours, will realise that we have a tremendous advantage over Switzerland, and in fact over those other countries, in the possession of the Shannon. That is a paradoxical remark, no doubt, to make, because it is notorious always that while Ireland has plenty of water she has very little water power, and when I made that remark to two of the chief men of Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert their answer to me was that that was perfectly true until 1920, since when things had altered in the way of capacity for engineering to develop energy, even in the absence of a natural head of water, or fall. It is very interesting in that connection to notice what the experts have said, and I dwell upon it because there is a natural assumption that on account of the flatness of the land energy is not forthcoming from our water sources. Someone said about the Irish rivers that they were like the Irish people, so lazy that they refused to flow out of the country. That, of course, is not true of the Liffey. The remark I wanted to dwell on is at page 4:—

"The exploitation of water power depends on two factors—(1) The relation, in time and quantity, of the flow of water to the demand for energy, and (2) the available fall or head. In the case of the first factor, the conditions in Ireland are very favourable as compared with most continental countries—the greatest flow occurs in winter, when the demand for energy is greatest. Excess winter energy can possibly be used for seasonal industries for which labour employed in summer on the farms should be available. On the other hand, the conditions as regards head of water are unfavourable in this country, being in the main a flat country, and consequently capable of developing only a limited amount of water power."

This is important, I think, in connection with the criticisms of Deputy Figgis. The alternative would be to have a number of local stations as in Switzerland, each a centre of power development, or to have the one central station. Now that brings me immediately by an easy step to the questions who are Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert and why the date 1920? Anyone who will look at an industrial map of Bavaria will see that in comparatively recent years there were various centres of production, some by water power, some by coal and steam. All those have been utilised as transforming stations in connection with one big central energy producer. Messrs. Siemens executed that work. They executed a similar work in Pomeroy. Therefore they are no ordinary contracting firm looking for business and such in their character and operations that no firm can be got to tender against them in profitable competition. There has been a great deal of criticism here this afternoon and yesterday evening. I must not forget my friend, Deputy Gorey, who was so keen about the chastity of his honour and the honour of his country that he felt if he voted for the Minister's resolution that he would have done something for which he would be punished here and hereafter. A great deal was spoken of giving this contract to be tendered for by others in open competition. Let us not forget the history. Generation after generation it had been reported that there was plenty of water and no water power. Even Mr. Challoner Smith, whose excellent data were utilised by Messrs. Siemens, and to whom a great tribute has been paid by them, was quoted, and rightly quoted, by Deputy Figgis yesterday evening as speaking as a result of all his investigation of "the Shannon myth." When our Irish engineers, who according to the measure of their opportunity, are, no doubt, as great as any other land produces, turned their minds in consonance with the movement everywhere to be witnessed of seeking to develop water power into electrical energy, it was to the Liffey they devoted their time and attention. You had at one and the same moment three different competing schemes for the utilisation of the Liffey, and it was generally accepted that the Shannon was no use in comparison. This firm, prompted by an Irish engineer's brain and patriotism, was able to show to the satisfaction of four of the greatest experts in the world in those particular matters that the Shannon power could be exploited advantageously. Then, what are we asked to do? Give their plans, give their brains, give their results to anyone who comes along to tender. That is really what this demand for competition reduces itself to when put into plain language—give a free present, gratis, of all the detailed plans of Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert to any other firm that comes along. Is that national equity? I ask is it good business? I said we had to consider this in its three-fold aspect as an engineering problem, an economic question and public policy. Is this going to be a land that will attract the brains and enterprise and long experience of men in other countries to help us in the development of our natural resources? Is this to be our history that the first time that a marvellous possibility opened itself out to the men who had the genius to perceive it, we utilised all that they could give us, and then in the name of the supposed—it is purely supposition—saving of some pounds in the matter we turned them down.

We have been told that German machinery is inferior. If it is, it is a very extraordinary thing that Great Britain, as the "Daily Mail" articles are continually showing, is sending its orders to Germany. Japan sends its orders to Germany. I suppose that is because the products of the German factories are notoriously inferior. The article that I quoted from, after telling us to think of the effect upon our great neighbour, the farmer's best customer, goes on to say:—

"It is true that English shipping companies have given contracts to German yards, but only after they failed to get equal terms at home."

Surely if that is a defence for English firms giving their orders to German contractors, it is good enough for us. They could not get equal terms at home. Could we have got equal terms at home? If we had waited for terms at home we should have a Liffey scheme and no Shannon scheme.

There is more misrepresentation current. The critics of the Government's position are very much like the star performers of a certain type in English music-halls, described as quick-change artists. The Minister for Industry and Commerce yesterday, in recommending this proposal on the economic side, and in showing that consumption will probably be forthcoming to meet all the requirements of the case, repeated what is dwelt upon in the experts' report at page 56:

"To the experts it appears to be a self-evident matter that the quantity of energy produced on the Shannon scheme, in the first place, must be assumed to find its application in the general electric supply services, i.e., lighting, household and industry."

The Minister laid great stress upon the fact that for the consumption of the energy to be supplied, he was not counting upon any new extensions of industrial enterprises; that he was really building upon domestic consumption. Observe how that can be tortured into something quite other:

"Mr. McGilligan has, both in the Seanad and in the Dáil, emphasised that he is not relying upon the starting of new industries."

That is quite true.

"Therefore, while we may have no new industries in any one of the twenty-six counties, as a result of the proposed electrification, we incur risk to one important existing industry——"

That, I take it, is a reference to the substitution of electric eels for salmon—

and by his admission that no new industries can be reckoned, Mr. McGilligan takes from his scheme the strongest argument that would have commended it to the country—in fact, the one argument that made the Siemens' plan welcome to many when it was first outlined.

Everything that the Minister said is within the recollection of the House. He never declared that no new industries can be reckoned on. He simply said that he was not reckoning on new industries as a factor in his calculations. I was rather surprised to find so accurate and so scholarly a critic as my friend, Deputy Thrift, falling into a mistake similar to that which the journalist whom I have just quoted fell into. Deputy Thrift boasted, in an aside, that he had "got one in for education." I think those were his words. And the "one" that he "got in" was: "It is disappointing to find that the electric current will not be used for the electro-chemical industry." That was due, I dare say, to reading a paragraph at the top of page 56 by itself, instead of reading it as a continuation of something at the bottom of page 55:

For heating purposes, the Siemens-Schuckert scheme assumes a consumption at the partial development of 40 and at the full development of 60 million k.w.h. per year. For electro-chemistry it is suggested that 135 million k.w.h. in the partial development and 188 in the further development might be used. The experts consider a reduction necessary in the estimated consumption of heating current but think that about half the amount mentioned in the project will be used if available at low prices.

This is the remark at the top of the succeeding page:

As for the electro-chemistry, the experts find it doubtful whether the power resources available should really be used for that purpose.

This is criticism on partial development and that is not a declaration that there is no current available. It is an expression of opinion that, under the partial development scheme, it is doubtful whether the power resources available should really be used for that purpose.

In order to form an opinion on this question it is necessary to examine in its whole extent the production capacity of the Shannon scheme, relative to the requirements in the district in which its energy is intended to be sold, i.e., in the entire Irish Free State. To the experts it appears to be a self-evident matter that the quantity of energy produced under the Shannon scheme, in the first place, must be assumed to find its application in the general electric supply services....

There was another respect in which those experts anticipated the verdict of the Farmers' Party. Deputy Hogan and Deputy Baxter were both very emphatic in their statement that the farmers would not utilise electricity. The experts make a somewhat similar statement:—

"The experts are aware that in Ireland it is thought that the rural population would be unwilling to introduce the use of electricity to an extent worth mentioning.... The experts are not inclined to the opinion, however, that this condition, which, no doubt, represents the present situation, will continue to exist for any great length of time."

This is the passage in connection with which Deputy Figgis—I am sorry he is not here—attempted to mislead the House—I say that deliberately—by misreading. I drew his attention at the time he was reading it to the omission of commas:

"In Ireland the amount (of dairying) is four times greater... Where electricity is availed of in the dairies of Norway now"—there is a comma there, introducing the parenthesis—"practically everywhere refrigerators are also used."

I draw attention to that because it is stated in some of those articles and letters to the editors that there is no use in the dairy industry for electrical energy, but that what is wanted there is steam. That is one of the contributions to this subject refuted by the statistics mentioned here in the report that I have quoted. Deputy Connor Hogan finds himself supported by one of these engineers in another particular. This time I do not refer to the experts. The Deputy said that probably very few in the House are able to understand these documents. His words were: "No individual could enter into the stupendous calculations," and he made a plea to have them condensed. I know that when I was a law student and obliged to learn equity, the great difficulty I had was that I could not get hold of a book big enough. Students generally began their study of that complex and intricate subject with a compendium, and the result was that it was a case of getting off by heart without understanding, or going without altogether, and the bigger the book the better the chance was of understanding. However, different people have different tastes. Deputy Connor Hogan does not think that this is of very great value. Here is what an engineer writing to the "Irish Times" says: "Both documents"—that is the Siemens' document and the experts' report—"may be useful for propaganda purposes. They are of small technical value."

"They are of small technical value?" The product of the finest brains and the richest experience in this special department have no technical value. They are useful for propaganda, yet they are unintelligible to so highly intelligent a Deputy as Deputy Connor Hogan, so that the Deputy's colleague, Deputy Heffernan, does not require to go to special committees on Private Bills in order to hear the experts contradict each other. One thing, however, that emerges and is hopeful from all the debate is, that the Farmers' Party are not opposing. Deputy Gorey, Deputy Heffernan, Deputy Baxter and Deputy Connor Hogan have all assured us that the Farmers' Party are not opposing. True, Deputy Baxter's non-opposition was of a somewhat fierce character. He struck me as willing to wound, but yet afraid to strike. Yet the Farmers' Party will hardly adopt Deputy Baxter's criticism in the main, and try to make it appear that this is a measure that was intended for the benefit of cities and towns, and that the credit of the country, which is an agricultural country, will be pledged therefor. I hope I am not doing an injustice to his statement. What is in the minds of all these Deputies is what is in the mind of Deputy Thrift—Can the Government give us an assurance that this is going to turn out profitable?—Deputy Thrift asks can we be absolutely certain that it will be a commercial success. I ask myself, is that the test that is applied by a great nation going to war? Countries have taken the great risk of declaring war without knowing that they were going to win; they had courage in themselves, in their own capacity and their own resources, and they counted upon winning through. This policy of caution that is recommended to us is very good in small commercial enterprises, but as the experts have warned us, this is not to be viewed as merely a commercial enterprise.

The electrification of Ireland must not be regarded as a purely business affair, but as a great national economic question. When the question of financing the national electrification scheme arises, the State will naturally find the greatest measure of economic independence involved therein a factor of vital importance to itself.

The people who used to assure us that we had plenty of water, but no water power, were the people who have coal to sell to us. A few years ago an Irish-Canadian friend of mine wrote me a long memo which he asked me to submit to President de Valera and his Cabinet. It was to the effect that what six millions of British coal was able to do for Ireland, he and his associates in Mexican oil could do for two million pounds' worth of oil. I pointed out to him that if all the industrial resources of Ireland were dependent on power produced by oil arriving in tanks the moment that England engaged in her next great war, these would be paralysed, and therefore it was essential that we should have the source of our power inside our own area.

Now, even if coal became cheap, as cheap almost as dirt, it would still be worth while for us to develop our water power for the sake of our national independence, to be self-supporting and not dependent upon some other country. Deputy Hogan invited those of us who believe in that, and believe in the scheme, to show the measure of our belief by financing it ourselves, and he added, without interest. Surely that is not a proper test to apply: to finance it without interest. It would be a fair test of one's sincerity, of one's convictions, and of one's faith in the future to say: "Will you finance it yourself?" That is precisely what we are proposing to do. Now, Messrs. Siemens want to finance this. They not only want the contract, but they want to carry out all the work, and they want also to supply the capital and control it. If we had advocated that what answer could we make to those who spoke about peaceful penetration, and spoke of putting ourselves in the economic grasp of foreigners. Why, obviously, as a question of public policy there should be either no Shannon scheme or it should be worked by our own capital. Messrs. Siemens could get at any moment millions to finance this from capitalists in America. I have no doubt that the very fact that Messrs. Siemens are to carry out this contract will secure for us a loan for the purpose at a most favourable rate. That is another of the excellencies of the scheme. There is where the world-wide reputation of these people counts as an asset in our interest. How long have we been waiting with caution for our independence to govern ourselves? No one ever said: "Be cautious about risking the friendly feeling of the great neighbour that rules you by asking for power and liberty to rule yourself." Well, now that we have achieved our independence we are to become delicate and careful about the sensitiveness of some firms in England lest they should be hurt in their delicate susceptibilities so that we are to be under a worse thraldom in the name of achieved liberty than we were in when, obviously and in fact, we were under alien rule. That is the most extraordinary proposition that I have ever heard of, and that is called wisdom. I call that timidity and pusillanimity, as it was called by other Deputies. I want to show confidence in ourselves and in our own capacity to make good. This, I take, as a real testing of the capacity of Irishmen.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

As the Ceann Comhairle stated earlier in the evening, it is only by leave of the House that I am permitted to speak a second time on this amendment of mine. I am perfectly willing to withdraw the amendment, for I think it has achieved its purpose. It has achieved its objective, and that was to get the Shannon scheme thoroughly and very well debated. It has done so. I put down this amendment not in hostility to the measure, but to show that while not prepared to go all the way, not to swing into the flood of enthusiasm aroused through the country, at the same time I felt that the good points of the scheme should be brought out and debated. And I feel that the debate has served, in that respect, a very useful purpose. Personally I was not prepared to embrace the scheme whole heartedly. Neither was I prepared to take the risk of standing up and voting against it. I wanted to find another outlet, and I put down this amendment to refer it to a Committee of experts or, alternately, to a Committee of the House.

There are some few points now that have arisen in the discussion that I would like to deal with. Of course, the House is fatigued, and the Minister has to make his summing up, which will necessarily take him, if he is to answer all the points raised, quite a considerable time. There are a few points that I would like to deal with as directed to myself. Deputy Egan said that the Farmers' Party were simply holding up the proposals. Yes, possibly. But not perhaps quite in the sense that the Deputy conveyed. We were deferring the question, not holding up the proposal, and I submit that there is an essential difference between the two. We take up this stand on the side of business. I put a query to Deputy Egan whether on a question involving privately a large sum of money he would not think twice about it, or whether he would go at once and make an immediate acceptance. Of course, the Deputy would not do so. But Deputy Egan was prepared, on this great public question, not to adopt the same rule as he would apply in his private affairs. It was to go forward without consideration, to be rushed and moved forward without regard to those elementary business principles that he would advocate in other walks of life.

Deputy Professor O'Sullivan made some points with which I should like to deal. He spoke of the timidity of mind that would not come forward on this matter, that was prepared to dillydally, revolving it in every aspect. After all, is that not just? Is there anything improper in it? Must not every great question be debated for a season before a final decision is taken? The Deputy in his speech wanted to cast an aspersion on me, if I may say so, by saying that I had no right to refer to the credit of the nation, and that I voted against the Land Bonds Bill. It is quite true I voted against the Land Bonds Bill. But the Deputy inferentially gave his own case away. He was prepared to stand by the independence of Ireland, but he was prepared to accept a guarantee of Great Britain for his Land Bonds Bill. That is an extraordinary thing to me; it is an anomaly. I cannot understand such unique inconsistency. However, the thing is only a minor detail.

There was a document put into my hands this afternoon to which, I think, some attention should be given. The Minister yesterday spoke of Mr. Kettle's estimates of an increase of 15 per cent. per annum in the consumption of electricity in Dublin. This document deals with some evidence Mr. Kettle gave before the Committee of the Oireachtas inquiring into the Liffey Bills, and Mr. Kettle definitely stated that "The average development to be expected for the Dublin Corporation supply over the next 10 years is 10 per cent., and for the tramways about 2 per cent. The figure given by the Minister as Mr. Kettle's figure is, therefore, 50 per cent. higher than the increase as given by Mr. Kettle." And the document goes on to state: "The actual average increase for Dublin Corporation over the last twenty years was about 700,000 units per annum, so that Mr. Kettle's figure of 10 per cent., which would now mean about 2,000,000 units per annum at the transformer sub-station, seems to be a quite optimistic figure. It is quite true that last year the increase in the number of units was greater than this 2,000,000, but this was not on account of ordinary development work, portion of the increase being merely a transfer of units from one generating station to another. Messrs. Siemens report figure as the consumption for Dublin, including the tramways partial development say at the end of six years was 63½ millions, whereas Mr. Kettle's figure for the same time is 59½ million units. Messrs. Siemens figure for the full development of Dublin is 85¼ million units as against Mr. Kettle's figure of 58½ million units. The figures in question are of importance in as much as the Minister stated that the Shannon scheme partial development would pay its way even if only the 100,000 volt line was run, supplying only Dublin, Cork and Limerick. Evidently the consumption for these cities at the end of the partial development would not exceed 60 million units which at ½d. per unit would mean only £125,000. To obtain the £315,000 required it would be necessary to charge Dublin, Cork and Limerick 1¼d. per unit, which is considerably higher than the present unit cost of generating by steam."

Comment on this
Kevin Christopher O'Higgins MINISTER for JUSTICE (Mr. Kevin O'Higgins) Cumann na nGaedheal

Is it in order to ask the Deputy what he is quoting from?

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

It is a statement which has been given to me by a Deputy of this House.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

As it is a question of the name, it is that of a certain man pre-eminent in his profession, and he had, I think, an expert of international reputation behind him —Herr Buchi.

Comment on this

Where is Deputy Herr Buchi?

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Herr Buchi I say. This statement was given to me by a Deputy of the House.

Comment on this

He should not have done it.

Comment on this

Whose statement is it?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Could he not make his own speech?

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I am just bringing forward this thing and I am asking the Minister to deal with it, because if it is part of the propaganda that is going on against the Shannon scheme I think it is well that it should be nipped in the bud here and now by the Minister. I offer no opinion on it, and I make no comment. All I ask is that the Minister, when he is replying, should deal with the question as it has been put. I will not comment on it.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

It was simply with a view to reference that I was anxious to know whether the Deputy was quoting from any published work or what the statement is which he is reading.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

It has been referred to by two Deputies in this House already, to my knowledge.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

What has?

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

The statement which I have just read.

Comment on this

Whose is it?

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

It is Mr. Kettle's statement.

Comment on this

He is not a Deputy of the House.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I have not suggested that he is a Deputy, but the Minister in his speech yesterday quoted certain figures to show that for the consumption of electricity, that is the progressive increase for a number of years, the estimate was 15 per cent. on the Minister's figures. In this statement from Mr. Kettle, he denies giving any such estimate. He says it is only 10 per cent. I would ask the Minister to deal with that point, and perhaps the Minister might, in some respects, pray for some of his friends, with the solitary exception of Deputy Magennis, who put the question, in a most excellent manner, on the transcendental question of national policy. I am prepared to stand over that word, transcendental.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

It is a good word.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Many of the other Deputies went on pious aspirations simply. They contributed nothing to the debate. They gave nothing in substance as to what their enthusiasm for this scheme amounted to. Deputy Magennis stands unique. He stood out apart. He has given food to them to reflect, and I appreciate the very fine speech indeed that he delivered. I am willing, as I say, to withdraw my amendment, and perhaps under the influence of his speech I am not quite so much opposed to the Shannon scheme. I am even perhaps beginning to feel a little of the glow of enthusiasm burning for it.

Comment on this

Yesterday two statements were made by Deputy Figgis, one to the effect that he had an interview with me in May, 1923. He goes on to state that a minute was kept of these conferences. As the report runs, it states:—"A minute was made that day and checked over by all the persons on our side who were present at this conference." Those were the exact words. I kept no minute of that conference and no minute of the conference was given to me, but it transpired that Deputy Figgis inferred that he was invited to go on with the scheme. At the time it was within the knowledge of the Government that there were two companies promoting Liffey schemes, and it was more than possible that the Corporation might enter the list. So it is unlikely then, most unlikely, and I challenge it, that we invited any particular person to go on with a scheme, knowing that only one could succeed. Apparently somebody has got the idea that some compensation is due to them by reason of their activities on that particular occasion and from the date of initiation of the schemes. The second statement made by Deputy Figgis—I think it was on the first occasion he alleged a lack of good faith—was to the effect that he had a letter from the Government dated the 12th December, and he wanted to make out that negotiations were in progress with Siemens-Schuckert at that time.

I had the records of my office looked up, and I find on the 27th December, 1923, that I had an interview with Professor Magennis. I kept no minute of that interview, and I presume from the entry on the next day that it was with a view to asking me to receive Dr. McLaughlin and himself, because on the next day, the 28th December, there also appears on the diary "Professor Magennis and Dr. McLaughlin." On that day I turned down, on my own responsibility, a proposal for the development of the Shannon put up by Dr. McLaughlin. I find that the next entry that appears of Dr. McLaughlin's name in the diary, is on the 26th January, 1924. There appears "Dr. McLaughlin, Mr. J. McGrath, Mr. Blythe, and Mr. Kennedy, Attorney-General." The next entry appears on the 8th February, 1924: "Dr. McLaughlin, Messrs. McGrath, Blythe, and Kennedy." The item of the 8th February is referred to in the White Paper.

It is obvious from these entries that there were no negotiations going on at the time Deputy Figgis alleged, although he appeared to be satisfied that the statement I made that there were no negotiations was quite right. However, I thought it was due to the House that I should disclose these particulars. There is only one other comment I would make. In his report or his statement of the interview of the 3rd May he mixed up the President of the Executive Council and the Government. If a Minister gives an expression of opinion in his office that is not an expression of view from the Executive Council. Deputy Figgis knew quite sufficient about the Constitution to know that if he wanted an expression of view from the Executive Council he should approach the Secretary of the Executive Council in that connection.

I should have prefaced my remarks by saying that in common with everybody else who has spoken, I feel very great pleasure in congratulating the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the very able statement he has made in connection with the Shannon scheme.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Deputy Connor Hogan, I gather, has withdrawn his amendment.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Yes.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy takes credit to himself for having initiated a debate which has thrown considerable light on the Shannon proposals, and he apparently believes that debate would not have taken place on the simple terms of the resolution which I proposed. He can take that credit to himself if he pleases. He has introduced a letter which, at the end of his reading, he reveals as having come from the City Engineer. In that, the City Engineer states that my statement regarding his estimate of 15 per cent. of increased consumption is inaccurate, and that his estimate would now be somewhere in the region of 10 per cent. My estimates on which I based an opinion yesterday are, therefore, out to the extent of 50 per cent., and any conclusions founded upon them must be false. I have, in my possession, a letter from Mr. Kettle, dated the 31st July, 1924. It was written to me personally. In it he replied to questions which I had sent to him through the medium of the Ministry of Local Government and Commissioner Hernon. The answer to one of the questions is that he estimates the normal increase of consumption at 15 per cent. per annum. If that is not sufficient, Mr. Kettle was examined before a Private Bill Committee on December 3rd, 1924, in connection with Liffey schemes. He was asked there with regard to mass units consumed, and his estimate as to the future. He states this: "That would give a total for the year of 35 million units. That is as regards present requirements. For future requirements I estimate that the Corporation, Rathmines and Pembroke would, in about seven years' time, need 35½ million units, and the Tramway Company 16 million units, making a total of 51½ million units". Now, somebody else can do the calculation to check this. I assert that the increase estimated by him on that number of years —from 35 millions to 51½ millions— represents an increase of 15 per cent. at compound interest. I know that Mr. Kettle wrote me a letter in which he definitely states 15 per cent. I have had that corroborated by the evidence he gave, when he was promoting a Private Bill for the harnessing of the Liffey. Apparently you can count on 15 per cent. at compound interest when you want a load factor for Liffey development, but when it is a question of Shannon development you reduce the figure to 10 per cent.

I looked for certain results from the setting down of this resolution, and while I believe I have some, I am disappointed in regard to others. Deputy Magennis has alluded to a quotation from one of the two daily papers in this country. It passes my comprehension how, after what I said yesterday, I should be misinterpreted into saying that there is no hope for new industries under this scheme. I made a clear and positive statement that we do not count on new industry for the consumption that is necessary to make this scheme economic, and that is turned into: "There is no hope for new industries," and one of the things that would have fascinated most people about this scheme has now been taken away by me. Later on, in the ordinary account in the same newspaper— the ordinary account of the debate— a statement of mine is given the honour of leaded type. It is where I was speaking about drainage, and I made use of this remark: "that under the regulation of the lake necessary in the partial development, no possible flooding could occur by reason of the protection of embankments." That phrase is given the honour of leaded type, and the "no" was omitted. I am made to say that flooding could possibly occur by reason of the regulation of the river.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

resumed the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I had hoped that in the course of the debate that has arisen on this resolution, we might have cleared away any doubt with regard to navigation and with regard to drainage, and that by the implications of this proposal of mine, implications which, I hope, to make explicit to you shortly, we would have cleared away all the interested criticism and all the criticism which depends upon the furtherance of British contracting firms in this country, and that having cleared away that by a certain vote, we would have a period of from four to six weeks, before legislation comes to be discussed, in which we might have had decent criticism, criticism intended for the betterment of the scheme, and that would help us to have the scheme made as sound as it would be possible to make it from the engineering point of view.

With regard to the general tenor of Deputy Hogan's amendment, I feel to a certain degree sorry for him, because, I think, Deputy Gorey let him down badly last night. We have the amendment of Deputy Hogan to the effect: "that the aforesaid proposals should be further examined by other experts of international reputation with reference to the feasibility of the commercial hydro-electric exploitation of the River Shannon, with further reference to drainage, utilisation of existing roads and bridges, navigation and fisheries." Deputy Gorey categorically stated that he was satisfied about navigation, about drainage, that the roads and bridges were such a small item they did not matter, and that as for fisheries, his final judgment was they should not be allowed to interfere with power requirements. That leaves the amendment at this point: that we have to get other experts of international reputation to advise on the feasibility of the scheme. That is to say, I presume, the economics of the scheme, a thing which, I think, this House is as competent to decide as any experts, or any international experts. Deputy Gorey, as the leader of the party which has put down what I was going to describe as a dilatory amendment, has expressed himself satisfied with regard to drainage and navigation; the question of fisheries must await further investigation. It must await examination that will not be concluded until after the scheme is built up.

There are two other points that arise from the comments in to-day's Press in connection with the debate here yesterday. A meeting of the Irish Electrical Engineers was held last night, and a gentleman, who was not an electrical engineer, delivered himself of a prophecy that the scheme was going to cost £20,000,000. We may have that £20,000,000 sooner or later, with the Shannon fully developed, and the Erne and the Liffey linked to it; but the only scheme that is under consideration at the moment is the scheme entailing a cost of £5,200,000. Nobody can question that is the amount which we are considering, because for that we have binding estimates, if we care to accept tenders here and now, with the exception of the item referred to by Deputy Thrift, on page 80, limited to civil constructional costs. The prices are absolutely fixed and binding. They are maximum prices from Siemens-Schuckert point of view. They are not the minimum from our point of view. We have checks and controls by which, if we find a reputable firm in any other part of the world that would do any part of this work at less than Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert, then we can beat them down to that, or give the contracts on those parts to other firms.

The Irish Electrical Engineers think that we should go slowly with this. Now, Irish engineers in general, and their relation to this scheme, must be touched upon in brief. It seems to me that the engineers have suffered through those who pretend to represent them in their letter-writing to the Press on this matter. If I thought that those people who have written letters to the newspapers in connection with this Shannon Scheme really represented the engineering profession in this country, then I would despair of the engineering profession in the country. But I have talked to members of the engineering profession, and I know well they are not properly represented by what has been said. I think it is an unwholesome thing that certain people, by their speed in rushing into print, should have almost got the engineering profession here into the state in which this scheme must either be broken or the engineers in Ireland think that their dignity has suffered. That is quite unwholesome. It is not fair to the engineers of this country that that should be the state, and I do not believe it represents any considerable fraction of the engineering opinion in the country.

Certain arguments have been advanced here clarifying details of the scheme, and certain criticism passed against some details. I do not intend to deal with Deputy Figgis and his relation to Liffey projects, and to what extent he, thinking there was a guarantee, invested the savings of his lifetime in a certain project. That is no matter for this debate. If Deputy Figgis even had a guarantee, if any Liffey Bill project had a guarantee, that is no reason why an inferior Liffey project should be given superiority over a very much better Shannon project.

The term "binding contract" has been used, and Deputy Figgis produced a minute made by him of what he alleged to be my words on a certain occasion. That very point was raised on the 19th December by Deputy Johnson, and I made it quite clear that, as far as the Dáil was concerned, the White Paper did not represent a contract between the Dáil and the German firm. The Deputy also used the term "binding contract" as signifying the relations between the Executive Council and the promoters of the Liffey project. If that is to be examined in detail, some other occasion can be taken for doing it. In the absence of Deputy Figgis, I do not intend to go into it. Deputy Figgis stressed one remark of mine, and no doubt we shall see it stressed in some of the English Sunday newspapers. I said that if electricity was not going to be sold through the country, then there would not be any necessity to complete the 35 and 10 K.V. lines. I am sure there is going to be founded on that the conclusion that I do not believe there is going to be any sale for electricity in the country. Now, I was merely taking a pessimistic view-point, and pointing out that if, after embarking on the construction, one discovered that no sale of electricity was possible in the country, then you would be thrown back on the consumption in the three main cities. I drew a certain conclusion from that and went into certain figures. I want to reiterate, as it is likely to be taken up wrongly, that that was merely looking at the thing in the light of the almost impossible contingency of no electricity being sold, after the scheme was built out, to any place in the country except Dublin, Limerick, and Cork.

Deputy Figgis challenged contradiction on one point. He said that the actual consumption in the Free State at the moment had been over-estimated and he challenged contradiction when he said that the consumption was not more than 40 millions for the whole Free State. The actual figures published, which Deputy Figgis can get as well as any Deputy, for Dublin, Cork, and Limerick, including in Dublin, Rathmines and Pembroke, show that in these three places alone in 1923 41½ millions were consumed. So that when Deputy Figgis says that the consumption is only 40 millions, he can be immediately proved wrong by the figures of these three cities.

The Deputy also spoke of his friend in Leeson street who would not engage in an expenditure of £35 to instal electricity in his house, and he used that in connection with the estimate of costs to consumers around Mallow, and said that, to the price to consumers around Mallow of almost 7d. quoted in the Siemens' report, you would have to add the cost of installation. Presumably the inference was, that as £35 was prohibitive in Dublin, farmers down the country would find it prohibitive to instal electricity in their houses, even when the wire was passing alongside the door. Dun Laoghaire is at present being equipped with electrical plant and connections are being made daily at a not higher rate than £2 10s. If anybody were to estimate what would be the cost, say, in this district of Mallow, which we have taken for the sake of an example, of actually bringing electricity into the houses from the wires laid, at the cost of 6.8d. finally to the consumer, I do not believe that any likely consumer would incur a greater charge than £2.

Deputy Figgis was amusing in one point. He asked if this great firm of Siemens-Schuckert could finance this scheme which they brought forward. This is a question that has been urged in the newspapers, and the answer is, yes. The firm are prepared to finance it. It is amusing to have the question put by Deputy Figgis who wrote, when the scheme first appeared, that it meant that the scheme was definitely going to go into the hands of the Germans, and that it meant German grip and German control of all the industrial development in this country. Deputy Figgis now asks why they cannot finance it, and he also said it would be no good for industry, although previously the argument was: "Do not let them get it, and do not let them finance it, as otherwise they will get control of industrial development in the country."

Deputy Johnson wished that the public should be reassured with regard to the strength of embankments and of the constructional work that is to be undertaken. As far as I can foresee, the likely course of events, once this resolution is passed, the Government will have to employ engineers to go in detail into the Siemens' scheme, as modified by the experts' report, or to put it the other way, into the experts' report having the Siemens' scheme as reference to it. All these questions as to whether extra borings have to be taken out, whether impermeable matter is to be found at a certain spot, or how far one must go to get it, and how far material dredged will be sufficient to withstand the pressure of water—all that remains for the engineers employed by the Government under the scheme to test, and to assure themselves and the public that any constructional work undertaken will be definitely safe.

Deputy Johnson asked for certain information to be given to the Dáil in that regard. We can examine into these things. We can have engineers to see that all these matters are looked to. I cannot, however, give a promise to the Deputy, for instance, with regard to the matter dealt with in page 20—the mixture of sand and clay. I do not suppose the Deputy wants any. Nor can I pledge myself to give him, at different dates, what the Government engineers have decided as to, say, a proper mixture of sand and clay in the embankments. The Deputy, I believe, wishes to be satisfied that that matter will be taken in hands and that where the experts have pointed out that further borings are necessary, or that borings have revealed a certain state of affairs which requires great caution and care, then further borings will be made and caution and care will be given.

The suggestion which Deputy Johnson also made as to State policy in connection with this scheme, namely, that we should simply charge to the consumer a price which would cover the cost of the construction and the cost of the maintenance and repair of that constructional work, leaving out all charges for interest and amortisa tion, leaving these to be borne by the State, is a matter that can be raised when we come to the Shannon Organisation Bill.

The Deputy's warning that having got this resolution the Government should proceed to do the same for the scheme as the opponents of the scheme are doing against it, is one which we certainly shall keep in mind. I had not power to employ anybody on account of the pledge I gave here in December. With this resolution through, certain administrative expenses can be incurred by my Department, and we shall certainly see that the public gets as much information as possible with regard to the details of the scheme.

Deputy Gorey raised for the first time the question why not make this Bill go through the same procedure as Private Bill procedure, and let its terms be submitted to the searching examination which Private Bill procedure entails? That is a comparison that should be taken. The Shannon scheme has so far gone on different lines from the procedure set down for the promoters of Private Bills. I think there are three points in which comparison can be made. The Shannon scheme has been presented, not merely presented by Siemens-Schuckert and the experts, but has been presented in the abridged document before the Dáil in greater detail than any Private Bill is ever presented. Actually, as presented to the Government, it takes the form of a tender with binding estimates. What has Private Bill procedure entailed? Summaries of costs, general and vague statements, as to what this may cost, and as to what something else might cost, but no actual tenders, no contractors' tenders as this has. Without disrespect to members of this or the other House, who have been appointed to examine the various Liffey projects, I say that this scheme has stood the test of four international experts brought over to act as judges, while on a Private Bill Committee you have a certain number of laymen who are assisted or rather confused by expert witnesses. It seems to me peculiar that An Dáil, which would have no hesitation in passing a Bill to take away the rights of private property for the benefit of other private promoters, after it has passed through a certain type of procedure, should grudge the State, represented by the Government, the passage of a scheme after it has been presented in great detail, with binding estimates and checked and examined by four expert judges.

Deputy Gorey also raised, and was the first to do so, the question of how prices here would be controlled. This question was raised in the Seanad, and to the Senator who raised it I put a question as to whether he was so innocent of engineering practice as to imagine that there was only one way of checking the prices, and that that was by the form of open tenders. He gave a negative reply to that. Deputy Gorey seems to imagine, and I think Deputy Good agrees with him, that possibly, if not the only form, the best form and the most usual form for checking prices is by way of competitive tenders.

Comment on this

It is the only way you can get the lowest price.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is what I mean by checking prices. I make bold to assert that very few great engineering schemes in the last five years have gone by the method of open tenders. There is a hydro-electric project in North Wales. I take three examples from a number on which I have information. There is the Kenya Colony railway extension and the Anglo-Spanish railway construction schemes. These are three examples from a great number—I can give the House these in detail at a later stage.

Comment on this

Singapore.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

In not one of these three cases was there any open tender.

Comment on this

I can give an equal number on the other side, if not more.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

All I seek to prove is that the method of doing without open tender is usual.

Comment on this

No, it is sometimes adopted.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is quite usual. We have in paragraphs 11 and 12 all the possible checks that any Government could desire in order to check prices. I put it again in that simple form that Siemens-Schuckert have intimated that with the exception of what was referred to in page 80 of the experts' report the costs are absolutely fixed. They are maximum. They are the maximum prices Siemens-Schuckert can get, but they are not the minimum they may be forced to take. We can make them lessen their charge.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We would require to satisfy ourselves that the firm would supply material at prices not higher than those at which similar material of first grade quality could be obtained from a reputable firm in any part of the world. We would require to satisfy ourselves that the prices quoted by Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert were not higher than those by which the work could be performed by any other reputable firm.

Comment on this

Will the Minister forgive me if I point out that work consists of labour and material. The clauses he has read only deal with material. I am talking about prices for work.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We will take the division of labour and material. Deputy Good's fear apparently is that wages have not been fixed sufficiently low.

Comment on this

I have not said so.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We can raise them apparently.

Comment on this

I should not be surprised.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I have heard the other criticism very often put forward: how did German contractors and foreign experts know the price at which labour was to be obtained in this country?—the inference being there that labour was so high in this country that they would naturally tender on a German, Swiss or Swedish basis, and that our prices would be altogether fallacious. In that they had the guidance of my own Department.

Comment on this

Why can we not see these prices? Why have they not been disclosed?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Because Deputy Good has not been appointed by this House as the judge either of labour costs or of material costs.

Comment on this

Appointed by the country?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Government has been appointed by the country, and the Government chose four experts and is going to put in other engineers to check every detail of the costings. Deputy Gorey raised one point about islands in the Shannon. I do not know if he was serious, but I think the statement I made about the actual regulation of the river will answer him. If the river height is not to be increased from what it is at the moment, obviously islands not submerged at the moment will not in future be submerged. When we come to the fuller development, islands may have to suffer. Deputy Hogan hoped there would be sufficient checks to prevent the control of power by outside firms. There cannot possibly be any control of power by outside firms, and the Deputy may rest quite assured that such would not be allowed. Once Siemens-Schuckert have built out this plant and it is in working order, the contract, whatever contract there be with Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert, must then lapse. What other hold there could be by Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert over future production of power in the country I cannot see. But since the Deputy asked for an assurance, I can only take it from what is my own intention, or what I forecast and foresee in regard to the following out of the scheme, and in that I cannot see how there is any possibility of any outside country controlling the price of power here. Deputy Hogan further asked: "Why should we stop at small villages?" And here I bring forward the example of Mallow. This question of Mallow and the price to be charged there has been very much canvassed, and it is supposed to reveal one of the many weaknesses of the scheme. It is estimated that current can be delivered to consumers in the area of the rural district around Mallow at a price which is about 6.8d. Let it be understood what that means; it means that for the sake of giving a clear example of the results of the scheme Siemens-Schuckert went into certain further particulars; they took the transforming station at Mallow and they estimated the cost of running wires to every house, farm-house and every other type of house, in an area of about four hundred square miles, an area that is, roughly, bounded by the towns of Drumcollogher and Charleville on the north, and Banteer and Mallow on the south.

Comment on this

I think it might be of interest to the Minister if I pointed out that the network plan provides current feeders to 1,350 out of 3,000 houses.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I over-stated it in saying every house. If you could give a supply to every house in the district the cost for that particular 3,000 would be less than to the 1,300. What I should have said, and that tells more against the cost, was that they took a certain number over that area. They took certainly those furthest removed from the transformer station, and they estimated what would be the cost of bringing further lines, radiating out from the transformer station, and they so that a certain number of houses could be supplied with power. They estimated that the wiring to that number of houses would cost £50,000 to £60,000, and they took the cost at the 2.1d. rate, on page 104 of the report, and to that they added the division over all this number of people of the extra money required for the wiring, and they made out that that would cost to each of these people 3.8d. If you take that with the 2.1d. with certain additions for the loss in transforming, making it up to 3d., you get a price of 6.8d. If you take the table given on page 103, where you have a figure of .8d. for current, that is to say, if you go on the system of a flat rate all over the country for the sale of all your units, then the individual farmhouse in the area around Mallow can get supplies at a price of 3.8d., plus .8d.—4½d., that is to say, a farmer at Mallow can have it delivered outside his door, requiring an additional expenditure of about £2 or £2 5s. for bringing it inside his house, at 4½d., while in Dublin up to two days ago, consumers were paying 8d., and at the moment they are paying 7d. We do not stop at the small village. We estimate that the £5,200,000 will provide money sufficient to bring current along the 100, 35 and 10 k.v. lines, the result being that places of 500 inhabitants and upwards will have current supplied to them. We go further, and say that if the demand be there, if that area spoken of, bounded by these four towns, desires power the additional costings have been made out, and if the one flat rate price is to be charged for current they can have it at 4½d. In the other event, they can have current at almost 7d.

Deputy Egan raised one point in connection with which I must enter a slight warning. I have said that not one penny is being asked from riparian owners for the amelioration of their land. That was indicating an intention which has yet to be accepted by this House. What I should have said was this, that on the income side of the scheme no reliance is put upon getting any money from riparian owners for the amelioration of their land. But when certain Bills come before this House it may seem good to the Oireachtas to decide that these people should pay something, and if they do there will be an additional income to the scheme. But the scheme can be made economic without a single penny being charged to riparian owners. Deputy Egan also raised the point with regard to providing loans to farmers for the cost of installation. That cost of installation is a matter that ought to be worked out, and on which I would like to see some of the critics, in newspapers and elsewhere, giving us the benefit of their advice.

Deputy Figgis talks about a £35 installation, and apparently wants that to be taken as a sort of flat rate all over the country. I told the House definitely of £2 10s. for connections in Dun Laoghaire, and I say that it will be possible to get connected up, as in the Mallow district, for about £2. But even on that small sum the House may again see fit, when the Bill comes before it, to make provision for loans to farmers, so as to cover the cost of installation where farmers like to instal. Deputy Egan also raised the point, and it was afterwards raised by Deputy Myles, as to what would be the position of existing undertakings and as to what would be the procedure as to sale, and one or other of the two Deputies mentioned the question of compensation to existing undertakings. Certain Electricity Orders have been passed since the Shannon scheme made its appearance, even as a White Paper, and a clause in these has always been insisted upon by my Department. That clause has received the sanction of the Oireachtas in at least four Orders, and in the Seanad on one occasion when a Senator believed that the clause was left out he made an attempt to have it inserted. This was the clause:

In the event of a central power station being established and that the supply of electricity in bulk is thereby made available to the undertakers at a rate of charge equal to or less than the cost of generation in the generating station of the undertakers, the undertakers shall take such supply from the central power station.

That seems to me entirely reasonable, and it has received the approval of the Oireachtas in several cases already. If we can supply to an existing undertaking current at the same as, or at a less price than, they can themselves generate and to which they can themselves add their own overhead charges they are not prejudiced in any respect. I think that is a reasonable thing to ask, that where you have set out to provide a national supply, existing undertakings should take current from you on the condition that you provide it at the same cost as, or at a lesser cost than, that at which they can generate themselves.

Deputy O'Sullivan drew attention to a point to which I referred earlier, that we want to-night from An Dáil a clear expression of opinion on one thing. And that is if the Shannon scheme in the main, as put forward by Siemens-Schuckert, be approved of, then Siemens-Schuckert are to be the contractors under the Government. That is really the big point that is to be decided to-night. If the Shannon scheme of Siemens-Schuckert is not approved of, if it fails for some technical detail from some defect which emerges later before we proceed to the actual contract with them, then the matter is clear. But if Siemens-Schuckert are not employed as contractors, remember the Government has no Shannon scheme. The only Shannon scheme which the Government has to offer to this country is, at the moment, the Siemens-Schuckert scheme. Tonight's resolution, as far as I am concerned, means mainly this—that subject to the checks and controls which we have in paragraphs 11 and 12 of the White Paper, there is an indication given here to-night that if the scheme be accepted Siemens-Schuckert are to be the contractors for it. That expression of opinion is required to-night. It is required as early as possible, and, if it be given, and if the conflicting interests, English and others, who are seeking to make inroads on this scheme, see that they have no chance of doing that, I believe we will emerge from what I have called the region of interested criticism to the better region of criticism intended to be helpful and to build up a sound scheme.

Deputy O'Sullivan also called attention to one very important point, and that is this—criticism has been passed as to the setting out of the Shannon scheme on top of the Liffey schemes. To a certain extent this contention depends on what Deputy Figgis had raised earlier as to how far the Liffey promoters were encouraged. My only feeling, looking back on it, is a feeling of relief that the Siemens-Schuckert proposals came along early enough to prevent this country making the gross blunder of committing itself to the Liffey project, which would, for a generation, have precluded all possibility of a decent national supply. Deputy Heffernan agrees with Deputy Figgis that the passing of this resolution to-night binds us to the full development, and as Deputy Heffernan is not prepared to ask the riparian owners to pay the £200,000 set down as an item of income under the full development, he is not prepared to accept the resolution to-night.

The resolution is carefully drafted to cover only partial development, as recommended by the experts, and as somewhat modified by them. Deputy Good spoke of three types of contract —a lump sum contract; a contract based on the schedule of prices; and a contract based on a percentage of the costs. This is a contract based on the schedule of prices.

Comment on this

Where is the schedule?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We have it.

Comment on this

We were told that this contract was based on clauses 11 and 12 of the White Paper. That does not make any reference to any schedule.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It falls within clauses 11 and 12, and it is based on the schedule of prices; and these prices are fixed and binding, except in one respect, and in that respect not even Deputy Good can get an engineering contractor to make an absolutely fixed and binding estimate. Certain items depend upon quantity. The unit price is fixed there. But nobody can tell, until the quantity of material is removed, how much the amount of material actually is. To that extent there is a variation, subject to this, that as far as you can judge for the length and breadth of the canal how much material is to be removed, it is not possible to estimate beyond a shadow of doubt how much of that material is earth and how much is rock.

Comment on this

That is only a question of quantity, but on the question of prices you say you have a schedule of prices. What steps have been taken to ascertain that these are the lowest prices?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The experts have reported that the prices are reasonable, and the Government engineers to be appointed under this scheme will see that the prices are not merely reasonable, but that they are the best we can get. With the exception of the quantities and the allowance for variation in that respect, Deputy Good admits that that is quite ordinary and only reasonable——

Comment on this

Yes, but the experts know nothing about current prices in this country.

Comment on this

They have been told.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I would not like these experts to go and search about for the current prices of turbines of the type we are to instal in this country, because there have never been any turbines of that type in this country before.

Comment on this

There are 10 miles of dam. There are no turbines in that. What about the labour cost for that?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The labour costs have been fixed in conjunction with the officials of my Department. Material is a matter that can be checked by experts from any country. Beyond all that is this, that we must assure ourselves by the engineers appointed under this scheme, that the prices are as low as we could get from a reputable firm anywhere else. I do not know what other safeguards could possibly be required.

Comment on this

Competitive tenders.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Deputy Good apparently contends, or at least I take it to be his contention in one part of his argument, that we should expose all these prices. He complains that he has not got the schedule of prices. Apparently, he contends he should have them, and then having got them, and when they had been revealed to the public and revealed to the contracting firms, we should ask them to tender. I wonder would Deputy Good like to have his contracts thrown open in that way?

Comment on this

Where schedules are prepared, there is a custom and practice. That practice has not been adopted.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If we bring in a good Shannon scheme, I would be satisfied, but if, in addition to that, we get brought in to this country a somewhat better method of business than has hitherto been adopted, that would be an additional reason for encouraging this scheme. It has been asked why did we not bring in these experts beforehand— why should experts not have been asked to see whether there was a Shannon scheme possible, and then call for tenders and ask the Siemens-Schuckert firm to tender with the rest? That is what it would mean. This dates back to the end of 1923 or the beginning of 1924, at the time when this was described as the great Shannon myth. Six months later, a Deputy interested in a Liffey Bill promotion and assisted by engineers, wrote in to say that the scheme was demonstrably impracticable. Yet the Government, faced with the great Shannon myth, were to call in engineering experts, and ask them to pass their judgment upon the possibilities of a scheme. They could not have called in Irish experts, because Irish experts, in so far as they were vocal, had condemned it beforehand. If they went elsewhere there would be an ordinary charge of 2½ per cent. to be paid for work of this type, and the Government would have to embark upon a 2½ per cent. commission on an unknown amount before they could have got any scheme.

Actually, if the scheme did appear, and if it were the same scheme as this, amounting to about £5,000,000, there would have to be a preliminary payment of £125,000. I can imagine Deputy Good's indignation with the unfortunate Minister when he came to this House and asked leave to spend the sum of £125,000 for that purpose. The Deputy also holds that the districts should be canvassed to see what demand there is before you provide the supply. Leaving out of account the fact that Siemens-Schuckert's representative in Ireland did go round nearly every town and large village in the country, and that the experts later visited a considerable number of them, is that, I wonder, the way in which brave captains of industry in this country operate when they engage in some new enterprise? My idea of bravery with regard to industry was that a man embarking on private enterprise was like a man casting himself on an uncharted sea and taking risks. Apparently that is not so in this country, and production here must be based on the orders received before there is anything ready to supply such orders, and, on the consideration of the orders received, they will build the plant afterwards. That does not operate anywhere else. I spent a certain amount of money on myself in a certain period in order to enter a certain profession. Was I to delay my progress to the Bar until such time as I was assured that a certain number of clients were ready to fee me when I got there? Would the medical student ever become qualified if he had to wait until the patients were there ready for him? There is one big advantage to be looked to in proceeding immediately with the national supply scheme, and that is to secure, at the earliest possible date, a uniform system of supply. There are, at least, five towns which have been anxious to have electricity undertakings, but which have been held up or have restrained themselves, until they saw whether a national supply was possible. If we adopted what is recommended by some critics outside, that we should allow the country to develop its small power plants until the full demand presents itself before proceeding with the Shannon scheme, we might find ourselves on a relatively similar scale to the position in which England is at present. There are so many points of difference in the systems of supply in England that the British Parliament has almost passed a grant of £10,000,000 not to centralise supply, but as the first step to doing so, i.e., to secure uniformity of supply. If we are to allow ourselves to develop by means of small power plants with all their divergencies we should almost certainly preclude any chance of having an early development nationally. Deputy Good also dealt with the figures in Dublin, and he has adopted here a casual line of argument which, again, is not fitted to a business man. He said that in Dublin, current was produced at less than one penny. The evidence of Mr. Kettle before the Private Bill Committee was that it was produced at 1.13d., minus capital charges, and if you take a moderate estimate from the accounts of the Dublin Corporation last year you come to a minimum of 1.6d.

Comment on this

Including a certain amount of distribution?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

1.6, including no distribution.

Comment on this

Current can be produced at less than one penny in Dublin.

Comment on this

Who has it?

Comment on this

Out of the Shannon scheme it can be produced in Limerick and brought to Dublin at .52d.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Therefore, that is how current can be produced in Dublin for less than one penny. The Deputy argued that it could be produced here at less than one penny, and by taking advantage of the Shannon scheme it would be .52d., and he said it would be something between one halfpenny and one penny. I worked out the figure to be compared with .52d., and I found that it was 1.6d. in Dublin. Instead of from one halfpenny to one penny, I could say from three halfpence to threepence, if we were to argue in that way. The .52d. is set out in detail in the schedule and can be examined, and the 1.6d. can be examined according to Mr. Kettle's published accounts. Mr. Kettle mentioned 1.3d., exclusive of capital costs and distribution, yet Deputy Good says, even if you add the capital costs, you can produce at less than one penny. Mr. Kettle, the City Engineer, says 1.3d., exclusive of capital costs. The Deputy also says that our method of going about this was definitely putting the cart before the horse. He gave his system and outlined his method of procedure, that is the calling in of the experts first, and he asked why was this not done, and why was the horse not put before the cart. Sinn Fein tried to back many horses into the cart of the Shannon scheme, and no Irish engineer could be found to say that it was likely to be a success, but now, when we have got this scheme properly put forward and properly established by a German firm, Irish engineers are anxious to engage in it, and Irish engineers are rather wondering why they had not previously been called into consultation, so that they could have got the scheme in motion. If I may proceed further with the metaphor of the horse and cart—I shall not go to a lesser species of animal for the Irish engineers than a pony—it seems to me that we are being asked to back a pony into a motor car when the motor car is already cranked up and ready to start. The Deputy wants to know why this material was not in the hands of Deputies earlier. He said: "We have been pressing for months to get the report." Does he make any allegation that the report was not published at the earliest possible date?

Comment on this

I said that the report was in the hands of Deputies only for a fortnight, and we are asked to approve of it now.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is quite correct, but I thought it led to the imputation contained in the other statement.

Comment on this

Questions were asked as to when the report was to be issued.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I had invariably to reply "as soon as possible," and it was issued as soon as possible.

Comment on this

A fortnight is the important feature.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I will deal with that later. The Deputy went on to speak, almost in the same breath, of a second matter, and I think it was the backwash of the second phrase that made me think there was an imputation in the first. He said that if we proceeded in a certain way the whole scheme would be above suspicion. What suspicion has the Deputy about this scheme? This is the atmosphere which Deputy Good and Deputy Heffernan have managed to generate around the scheme. What does it mean? There is certainly unusual procedure, but does the Deputy allege that there is anything else? He says that there are no plans and no estimates. There are plans and there are estimates.

Comment on this

They have not been disclosed.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I will come back to it again. Are we to disclose the contractors' estimates, and then ask for tenders in open competition? Deputy Professor Thrift made what, I think, was the best adverse criticism of the scheme. His criticism is a type that we hope to get increasingly in the next four or six weeks. He gave certain calculations which he had made himself, and he asked that these be reconciled with certain calculations I had either made, or hinted at, yesterday. He raised the question of what energy you would be sure of getting in a dry year. I do not know if this will sufficiently satisfy the Deputy: if you take that estimate of 153 million units generated—I am speaking merely of what can be got constantly in a particular year, so that I am for the moment neglecting losses in transmission which will occur relatively in any transmission—if the Deputy's question means 153 million units produced in a dry year, and 1905 was the driest year of the period, and if he asks me in any month of that year would you have one-twelfth of 153 million units, the answer is, of course, you would not. Neither would you have a demand of one-twelfth of 153 million units, and the advantage this country has, as opposed to the disadvantages in Norway, Switzerland, and Sweden, is that your requirement curve varies pretty well as your flow of current curve varies, so that to that extent we are in favourably placed circumstances, having our greatest volume of water, and greatest number of generated units in the months in which you have your greatest demand for power. The Deputy has made certain calculations, and I do not intend to follow them just to the full, but it did emerge at the end that the Deputy thought, speaking of the full development, that there could be produced only 260 million units.

Comment on this

For certain?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes.

Comment on this

But you could count on that only in a particular year.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes. Deputy Professor Thrift is the only person in the Dáil who has calculated on his own account. I am sure he will admit that his calculations could not have been carried out to the same degree of accuracy with regard to storage conditions and so forth, as the experts have done. If Deputy Thrift turns to page 26 he will find that he is pretty much in agreement with the experts. There it is said:—

"Final development. Storage space, 827 million cubic metres. Without the aid of steam-power on the basis of a proportional increase in the experts' requirement curves there can be produced 275 million k.w.h."

So that actually in his calculation, which is not so accurate, as the Deputy admits, as that of the experts, he is pretty much in agreement with them. The Deputy took this question of my 15 per cent. increase, and he used the figure in another way. He gets a different result to what I got, but one equally satisfying to me. I use the 15 per cent. increased consumption mainly for this purpose—I take the chapter dealing with the estimate of consumption at a certain time for the three main cities, and Herr Borgquist has estimated that it must be something around a named figure to make the scheme economical. He estimated that in about 1931 or 1932 a consumption could be counted on in Dublin, Limerick and Cork of 115 units per head of the population. That argument, I still hold, is good, and it is still good for the three cities, and that is all I used it for at the time. It is further corroborated by the extract I have read from Mr. Kettle's evidence before the Liffey Bill Committee. If you take that estimate and get it to the year 1932 you will find that this figure is not 115 units per head of the population, but it is about 136.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister did he turn that 115 per head of the population into the total number of units per year? It will obviously only be about 57 million, whereas about 115 million units is what he wants to sell.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That, I think, is where the Deputy and I are at variance. The Deputy has taken 115 all over the country. He took it on the basis of 50 million units, which he works out to be the consumption at present in the whole country.

Comment on this

I take it you want to sell 115 million units in the year as a total?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes. As I understand the Deputy's argument, it runs this way. He took 50 million units, and 15 per cent. of that for a certain number of years, and in 1932 arrived at 90 million, when I said I must get 115 million.

Comment on this

There is confusion about the 115. The 115 number turns up twice; once per head of the population, and it comes up again as 115 millions required every year. My argument was that there were 50 million at present in demand. I divided that into 30 million for ordinary purposes, and 20 million for travel and power purposes. I applied the 15 per cent. increase to the 30, and it produced about 70, which I added to the 20 as constant for the Tramway Company, giving me 90.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am afraid I must have confused the Deputy on this 115 million units. My use of the 15 per cent. was confined to the three cities.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that Mr. Kettle denies the 15 per cent., and says that should be 10 per cent.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I said I had a letter from Mr. Kettle, dated the 31st July, 1924, in reply to questions which I sent him through the medium of the Local Government Ministry, and Commissioner Hernon. That letter said that his estimated increased consumption was 15 per cent. In addition, I take the evidence given by him before the Private Bill Committee in December, 1924. He there said that in 1923 the total for the year was 35 millions, and the Deputy can read it for himself. He estimates that in 1931 there will be a total of 51½ million units. If the Deputy works that out he will find that it is an increase at the rate of 15 per cent. compound interest. We have Mr. Kettle's repudiation of the 15 per cent. given twice, and I want twice to repudiate his repudiations, by his own plain statement to me in the letter of July, 1924, and the evidence given by Mr. Kettle when under examination in connection with the Liffey scheme.

To come back to Deputy Professor Thrift's argument, I used the 15 per cent. only for the purpose of the three cities. I took it at that, and said on the basis of Herr Borgquist's calculation, that the consumption per head of the inhabitants of these three cities of 115 was moderate. Mr. Kettle would actually make it to be somewhere between 136 and 140 units per head. Deputy Thrift takes it the other way, and I want to follow him. He takes the 50, and he divides it into 30 and 20. Twenty for tramways and power, and 30 for ordinary consumption. If he recollects that there are only two cities with tramways, I think he will admit that it is a rather unfair proportion to take. Even if he takes his 50, and estimates at the 15 per cent., he arrives at the mass unit consumption in 1931 of 90 millions.

Now, in 1932, to make the scheme economic, on the basis which Deputy Thrift has taken, we must arrive at a sale of 115 millions. Therefore, at the same date we are 25 short. Deputy Thrift forgets that our 115 are divided this way: 90 million at the .5d., or whatever the rate may be all over the country, and 20 million units which we have given over for heating at a cost of about .25. Even on the Deputy's argument, following out that rate over the whole country, which I believe to be unfair, we arrive at the year in which we should make ends meet on the scheme, short about the 20 millions which we said we had for heating at a certain amount. Even that basis—a much more conservative basis than Mr. Kettle's, and a somewhat more conservative basis than the experts'—I hold, is founded on two great fallacies—one, that you are only to have the same rate of consumption in cities and towns which are entering for the first time on the use of electricity as you have in Dublin, already partially supplied, and, secondly, that the division of thirty and twenty over the whole amount is fair. Those are items which will form the subject of discussion for days to come. They will probably lead to elucidation of the good and bad points of the scheme, and, as such, they are welcome. The Deputy says, however, that we are bound to the engineering details of the scheme, and he quoted certain pages.

Comment on this

What I wished to convey to the Minister was that it seemed to me the effect of this resolution would be, if you pass it, that you would be giving adherence to this scheme in its engineering details, that you would be agreeing to support that scheme, and that the Government would be bound to bring in a Bill on the lines of that scheme. I am anxious that the Minister should make that point clear.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That preamble referred to pages 16, 17, and 20. Page 17 says: "The choice of the spot for dredging is one for particular care and will require further borings." Let the Deputy have no further apprehension. I am not going to carry out the scheme. I am completely inexpert in the matter, and I have no trust in myself for that purpose. There is no use in my looking at the matter and saying that dredging entails a great deal of trouble, that I have not the time to give to it, and, consequently, that I will not bother about the dredging, but that I will proceed as things are. This scheme has to be handed over to competent engineers, and they will have before them the warnings the experts have given as to things that have to be further inquired into. Those engineers will have to do their work thoroughly. If we got incompetent engineers, even with that very good scheme and that very good report, the scheme could prove a failure.

Comment on this

Would it be possible to modify the scheme in its engineering details, if we agree to it as it stands?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We are not agreeing to anything as it stands. We are agreeing to the Siemens-Schuckert scheme. There is a modification here which states that it will require further borings. If Deputy Thrift wishes to bring me down to details, we can agree to page 17, and we can agree that it will require further borings.

Comment on this

Supposing some other point arises that requires modification on which the experts have not reported, what then?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If it seems reasonable, and if the engineers insist on it, it will have to be done. The Deputy made that an introduction to the further argument that the costs of the scheme might be changed. I interrupted him to answer that later on. In page 80, it is stated: "it permits of a judgment of the probable costs within a margin of about 10 per cent." That appears on page 80, after the experts themselves have warned us that certain things will require to be done. Having done that, and bearing in mind this question of quantities, which might vary, they say that undoubtedly there may be room there for variation in costs, and they sit down to estimate what is the probable variation. Their expert view is that ten per cent. variation in the cost of the civil engineering construction side is sufficient. They themselves—the men who gave the warnings—were surely not likely to forget those warnings when they came to estimate the costs.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Minister has not answered my point. This resolution mentions in the "whereas" part:

"The experts appointed by the Government to examine the proposals of Siemens-Schuckert for the hydro-electric exploitation of the River Shannon have reported in favour of the adoption, with modifications, of the partial development scheme."

That is to say, we are really asked to approve to-night of the partial development scheme with the modifications mentioned by the experts. Suppose that further engineering investigation reveals other points which may require modification and which may be quite important points, we would have approved of the scheme as it stands. Would it be possible then for us to make those necessary alterations?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not like to say that that will be in the Bill, because there may be too much founded on the Bill and people may be disappointed when they see the actual terms of the measure. Obviously, if something else cropped up through the course of the construction work, and if the engineers we had appointed decided that a change they thought of was necessary, and recommended that change, that change would be effected. If it were a question of money and that money would go beyond the ten per cent., the Bill would provide for that.

Comment on this

It is not a question of money: it is a question of procedure. We shall have sanctioned, by this resolution, the introduction of a Bill to carry into effect this scheme, with its present modifications. Supposing further modifications become necessary, would it be in the power of the Executive Council, without permission from the Dáil, to bring in a Bill to provide for the modified scheme? If you like, it is a technical point of procedure, but I think it is an important point of procedure.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If it is an important and technical point of procedure, it can be met by a difference in the wording of the legislation. When we bring in the Bill, we can attend to it. The Deputy has not been committed to the Siemens-Schuckert scheme with only the modifications recommended by the experts. He is committed to a sound partial development scheme. Siemens believe the scheme to be sound and the experts have recommended that scheme with modifications. If other modifications are necessary, we are not going to have an unsound scheme merely because of a point of procedure.

The Deputy was the only one who raised a point about drainage. I feel this is an important point and, although the hour be late, I want to clear away any further difficulty about drainage. He raised the point that up to date you have the land draining into the river. In actual practice, if he visits Portumna, he will find that the position is the reverse. But this was his idea— that the land drains into the river and that if we erect embankments we will prevent draining into the river and bring about a new condition in which, the level being raised at some points, the river will drain into the land. He wants to know how that is to be met. There are side drains and, if there are side drains there of a certain type, then the present condition is preserved. If those drains are on a certain level and if the levels can be regulated by electric pumps, surely the same position is preserved—that of the land being drained into something. From that "something" the water will be brought back into the river by a certain process.

The Deputy seems surprised and disappointed that the electro-chemical industry was "turned down." This point was, I think, dealt with by Deputy Magennis. The electro-chemical industry was not turned down. It was turned down at a price of .35d. If the Deputy would read the part of the experts' report to which Deputy Magennis referred him, he would find that the experts believe that even on their modest estimate of consumption in 1932, there will be in the ordinary year about 100,000,000 units that you can give away at next to nothing. They put in a price of .15d., and an electro-chemical industry at that price should certainly pay. Taking both things—that it would not pay at .35d. and that there would be units to give away at .15d., which would seem to indicate that an electro-chemical industry would be a success—they, notwithstanding that, turned the proposal down for this reason: that they believe the consumption will be such in 1932 that there will be no surplus units of energy to be given away.

Comment on this

That is exactly the point I made. I did not say they turned it down. I said their report was unfavourable to the electro-chemical industry, as it suggested this further development in other directions.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Does the Deputy not see the further chance the electro-chemical industry has? If the estimates of consumption are exceeded, and if these surplus units are not there to give away, surely the next step is to proceed to the second stage of partial development set out in the report.

Comment on this

This applies to the full scheme.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Either we can have an electro-chemical industry if the experts' conservative estimate is just met, or we cannot have an electro-chemical industry if their estimate is exceeded. But if their estimate is exceeded, we can have no possible doubt with regard to the scheme, as a whole, being a success. We are in the happy position of having either a second partial development scheme or an electro-chemical industry under this partial development scheme.

Comment on this

I do not wish to stress the point, but the paragraph I quoted referred to the full development scheme, and is to be found on page 56.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is quite true, but if the Deputy will turn to page 111 he will find there an estimate of surplus energy which, it is assumed, we will be able to sell at a very low price—say, .15d. per unit—for electro-chemical industries or others. Deputy Baxter advanced a peculiar argument —that if this scheme went through, we would be involved in further protective measures, because Protection would be necessary for the industries which themselves would be necessary to make the scheme economic. I think the argument cuts the other way. If you do not have a scheme of this kind, you are going to have imposed upon you further measures to protect industries in this country, as against industries in other countries which are benefited by electricity. Deputy Baxter asked if a precis of arguments were made out could we get the experts submitted to cross-examination on them. If we get definite arguments, which seem to have substance in them, these arguments will be submitted to the engineers whom we will appoint to make the necessary preparations in connection with the scheme. If they are found to be of greater substance than these engineers can deal with, we will certainly refer them to the experts for their opinion. The Deputy ended his query with the phrase "and in this way stop all criticism." I have no hope that the particular type of criticism which I quoted is going to be stopped by merely referring points to experts.

Deputy Myles was the first to raise the question of the experts and their qualifications. He asked how did we come to select them. He wanted to know if there was any engineer advising me. If I were to go into the details of the various suggestions which I put before the Executive Council from time to time with regard to experts, and into the history of the entire dealings—how we decided from what countries experts were to be drawn, and then decided further who were the experts required for the scheme from these countries—it would be a long story. There was no special engineering advice tendered to me. But we had very good advice on the whole question, and inasmuch as there was a World Power Conference taking place at that time, which an official of my Department attended, it was very easy to discover what were the countries from which experts should be chosen. Once the countries were chosen, the four men almost chose themselves. I have already given to the newspapers the qualifications of those experts, and I do not intend to go into that matter here.

I have already replied to another Deputy as to how it is proposed to deal with existing electricity undertakings. Deputy Myles put two further questions to me. He asked: are there any figures in the larger report, which are material to the issue, held back? I have dealt pretty fully with that matter in reply to Deputy Good, but I can answer Deputy Myles that, as far as I believe, there are no figures material to the issue at present before the House held back. The second question is: is the basic price to consumers dependent upon the limitation of power used? The answer to that again is, "No." There is no limitation as to use with regard to the partial scheme. The Deputy also spoke of German machines, and seemed to decry German machinery. He asked how were new parts to be supplied. If you do get one German firm to instal machinery, it does not follow that you have always to go to the same firm for your repairs. But if it is asserted that it is unsound to get foreign machinery brought in here, because the getting of spare parts may cause delay, I can only refer again to the City Engineer. The Pigeon House has had for the last 15 years mainly Swiss plant installed, and why there should be any objection to doing on a national scheme what has already been done in the Pigeon House, without any great inconvenience being caused, I do not understand. The Deputy also said that the arrangement of pumps, syphons and side-drains required more examination. That examination, of course, they are going to get. Again, I must refer to the engineers likely to be appointed, if this resolution is passed. The engineers appointed to supervise the carrying out of this scheme will look into all these points. The whole question will be considered, at their leisure, by competent engineers appointed to carry out this scheme.

Deputy Redmond got back to the question of open competition. If, as seems to be the case, Deputy Redmond and Deputy Good want open competition for open competition's sake, then they are not going to get it in this case. If what is sought is open competition for the country's good and for the purpose of getting the best out of the scheme for the country, then I refer again to Clauses 11 and 12, which provide every possible check that anybody can want in order to secure the greatest advantage for the country. The Deputy referred to the redemption of a pledge I gave here on the 19th December, and asked does the resolution mean that I can enter into contractual relations with this firm. What I want mainly is leave to incur certain administrative expenses in connection with getting the scheme better known to the public and getting engineers appointed, so that the preliminaries may be worked up to the point of the making of the contract.

The Deputy himself, I am sure, knows that a contract for £5,200,000 cannot be entered into on the basis of a resolution of this sort. There is no money resolution with it, and there is no Governor-General's message, and those people who have been so critical of the rush and of the hurry about this debate might have recollected that there was no binding in that sense— binding us to any great expenditure of money without a money resolution and without the Governor-General's message. In what has happened here my main purpose has been served. The reports have been handed out. There was not much time to have them read, but I had the feeling that if I came before the House six weeks hence and initiated a debate, I would have been met by the same objection that nobody had time to read the reports, and that there had been no chance given for a consideration of them.

I think that we have stirred people up now to a realisation of certain details and certain virtues of the scheme. The resolution means two things, as far as I am concerned, and I want to repeat this before we go to a vote. It means a redemption of the pledge that I gave here on the 19th December that no expenditure would be incurred. I have now come forward and stated that if this resolution is passed, certain administrative expenses will be incurred, and, further, I want this to be understood: that a vote for this motion to-night does mean—it is very necessary that this should be clearly known, so that interested criticism should be swept away—that we are going to accept at a later stage, unless some defect occurs, the Siemens-Schuckert scheme, and if we accept that it is definitely going to be with Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert as the contractors.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Deputy Connor Hogan's amendment has been withdrawn, and the main question is now before the Dáil—that is the motion on the Order Paper in the name of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I am now putting the motion.

The motion having been put,

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I think the motion is carried.

Comment on this

challenged a division.

The Deputies having assembled for a division, the Ceann Comhairle asked if there were any tellers against the motion, whereupon Deputies Johnson and Nagle rose in their places.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I do not think that a division ought to be taken, with only Deputies Johnson and Nagle against the motion. If they like, I will have their names recorded against the motion without a division.

Comment on this

On a point of order and procedure, I want to know if there is any method whereby a vote on a motion can be recorded when a question has been debated for two days. The advocates of one point of view have. I submit, the right to have their names recorded as having been either present or absent, or at least those of a particular point of view should have the opportunity to have their names recorded as having taken part in a division. I submit that it is within the power of a Deputy in the House to challenge a division with a view to finding out whether there are any Deputies willing to go into the Division Lobby to support contentions that they have been advocating during the two days' debate, and to make it quite clear and have it on record that certain Deputies have decided to vote in the Lobby that conforms to their convictions, and that other Deputies have refrained from voting, if they do refrain from voting. I submit that an opportunity should be given to have a record made.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

If the Deputy desires to have a record made, I shall have the roll called.

Comment on this

That will be perfectly satisfactory.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Clerk will now call the roll.

The roll having been called, the Ceann Comhairle declared the motion carried unanimously, the following Deputies being present:—

Earnán de Blaghd.Séamus Breathnach.Seán Búitléir.Seoirse de Bhulbh.Próinsias Bulfin.John Daly.Máighréad Ní Choileáin BeanUí Dhrisceóil.Patrick J. Egan.Desmond Fitzgerald.David Hall.Thomas Hennessy.Patrick Leonard.Donnchadh Mac Con Uladh.Liam Mac Cosgair.Séamus Mac Cosgair.Maolmhuire Mac Eochadha.Tomás Mac Eoin.Pádraig Mac Fadáin.Risteárd Mac Fheorais.Pádraig Mac Fhlannchadha.Patrick McGilligan.Eoin Mac Néill.Seoirse Mac Niocaill.Liam Mac Sioghaird.Liam Mag Aonghusa.Pádraig Mag Ualghairg.Patrick J. Mulvany.Martin M. Nally.Tomás de Nógla. | John T. Nolan.Michael K. Noonan.Peadar O hAodha.Mícheál O hAonghusa.Criostóir O Broin.Seán O Bruadair.Risteárd O Conaill.Tomás O Conaill.Partholán O Conchubhair.Máirtín O Conalláin.Eoghan O Dochartaigh.Séamus O Dóláin.Eamon O Dubhghaill.Peadar O Dubhghaill.Pádraig O Dubthaigh.Eamon O Dúgáin.Aindriú O Láimhín.Séamus O Leadáin.Pádraic O Máille.Risteárd O Maolchatha.Pádraig O hOgáin (An Clár).Pádraig O hOgáin (Gaillimh).Máirtín O Rodaigh.Seán O Súilleabháin.Andrew O'Shaughnessy.Mícheál O Tighearnaigh.Caoimhghín O hUigín.William A. Redmond.Patrick W. Shaw.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

A record will be made that, there being no Deputies to vote against the motion, no division was taken, but that a record was taken of the Deputies present. The House agreed to that course.

Comment on this