We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

THE SHANNON SCHEME. - MOTION BY THE MINISTER FOR INDUSTRY AND COMMERCE—RESUMED DEBATE.

Contributions 1–112 of 240. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The debate was adjourned during the consideration of an amendment by Deputy Connor Hogan:—

To delete all words after the word "scheme" in the first paragraph of the preamble and substitute therefor:—

"Now therefore be it resolved that Dáil Eireann is of opinion that the aforesaid proposals should be further examined by other experts of international reputation with reference to the feasibility of the commercial hydro-electric exploitation of the River Shannon, with further reference to drainage, utilisation of existing roads and bridges, navigation, and fisheries, in the catchment area of the river, and the Dáil further considers that pending the production of a favourable report on the scheme by the second group of experts, no new work should be initiated or obligations, financial or otherwise incurred by the Executive Council."

Comment on this
Prof. Michael Tierney Professor TIERNEY

I intended at the beginning to say something against this amendment, but my own particular private reasons for speaking against the amendment have been somewhat lessened by the form it has since taken. I thought I could see a certain danger to this Dáil that nobody else perhaps has seen if the amendment in the form which Deputy Figgis proposed to put it had been allowed to go on. We have all seen the Experts' Report, and I for one must say that I found it a rather rugged document, and not very easy to understand. It is, of course, perfectly intelligible, and written in good English, but at the same time it is a translation from a German technical work, and it suffers from defects that must accompany such translation. The fear I had in my mind was, considering the rugged character of this report and the difficulty of understanding it, what would be the case if a Commission, including representatives of the Farmers' Union or the Farmers' Party in the Dáil, were to deal with this matter, and if Deputy Connor Hogan, who, I suppose, is that Party's chief expert on this subject, were entrusted with the task of writing another report.

I ask the Dáil to consider on its own behalf what would be the effect of this report if, already having passed through a translation from German into English, it had to go through the fiery furnace of a Commission, and in addition, have to go through Deputy Hogan's polysyllabic zeal, but, unfortunately for myself, that danger has been somewhat averted by the form the amendment has now taken, and I have to confine myself more to the definite business of the scheme itself. I think I can start off with a clear conscience by saying I know very little about electricity, and I think I run no risk of offending the dignity of the Dáil by saying it would be rather difficult to find more than half a dozen Deputies who could tell me or anybody what the difference is, if there is any difference, between volt, watt, and ampere, for instance. I say that not because I pretend to know anything about that myself but in order to raise a point which, I think, is the cardinal point in all this discussion. It is a point which has been already dealt with by Deputy Johnson. This House, before going into any detailed discussion of a scheme like this, should first of all make up its mind as to its competence to deal with a matter of this kind. This House has a certain competence in a matter of this kind which goes to a certain distance and no further. This House could and should see that any scheme of this sort brought forward should be submitted to people who are properly and thoroughly qualified to deal with it, people who are experts on it and who are capable of giving an expert opinion in every detail. This House should see that that report is brought before the House and that the House is assured that the experts have been given every opportunity to examine the scheme. Beyond that, I fail to see what the real competence—the competence from the point of view of knowledge—of the House is with regard to a scheme of this kind. I think once we have got the report of those four experts of high European reputation before us that our duty is to make up our minds whether that report, in fairly plain language, recommends or does not recommend the scheme. We cannot and should not take up our time by discussing all kinds of minor details in connection with a scheme which we are not really competent to discuss. The criticism that has been directed against the scheme, I think, might be said to fall under two heads. There is one kind of criticism which really might be said to be subterintelligent, might be said to be beneath the level of the average intelligence, and there is another kind of criticism which might be said to transcend the average intelligence. These two kinds practically exhaust all the criticism directed against this scheme. In the public Press in particular there has been scarcely a vestige of real intelligent criticism based on the motive of appealing definitely to reason and to the intelligence of the people. In this House there has been a considerable amount of both those kinds of criticisms as well.

The first kind of criticism is typified in particular by the amendment now before the House, and amendment which one has only to follow out to its conclusions in order to see its absurdity. It is proposed that we should postpone action on this scheme after having got this report from four European experts until the Farmers' Party in particular and the Dáil in general have been able to satisfy their intelligence on every detail, and until they are perfectly satisfied that they understand everything about it. I suggest that if we are going to wait until every single technical detail of this scheme has been explained and discussed by a public assembly like this or until Deputy Hogan or Deputy Heffernan have made up their minds and can prove to the public that they understand every detail of it, we are going to wait a long time. We are hardly ever likely to see the electrification of the Shannon proceeded with at all. I suggest that probably enough the Farmers' Party will be doubtful about the success of this scheme until they suddenly find their byres lighted with electricity, and then they will suddenly demand that the advantages of this scheme should be extended a great deal further. Then they will raise a cry that they have not been treated fairly in getting still more advantages from this scheme than they have got. The really troublesome sort of criticism, however, that has been directed against this scheme is not that kind of criticism that wants to put off the scheme because it cannot be understood by people who, by the nature of their profession and education, are not fit to understand it, including people like myself. The really dangerous criticism directed against this scheme is the criticism which is typified by Deputy Figgis, and still more by the campaign that is being conducted so sedulously in the public Press against this scheme. It is a kind of criticism which really transcends intelligence, that is to say, it is a criticism carried on to a large extent by intelligent people, but carried on with means that do not appeal to the intelligence, carried on for the specific purpose not of appealing to the intelligence, but to some emotion or other, to some prejudice or other, to some jealousy or other, appealing to some terror or other that can be aroused in the minds of ignorant people.

Making no reflection on the motives of anyone, looking at the matter from the point of view of literary analysis, if you take that criticism that appears in the Press and examine it you must come to the conclusion that the motives that lie beyond criticism of the kind that brings in the housing question in connection with this scheme, criticism of the kind that talks of the terrible danger to Limerick if the dam should burst, criticism of the kind that you had in one of the leading journals of Dublin this morning that misrepresented the statement made here yesterday by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that it was not necessary for the success of this scheme that it should provide power for industry at all, criticism that takes that statement and makes it mean that under this scheme you will not get any power, that this scheme is incapable of supplying power for industry—on the face of it criticism of that sort is based on motives which are themselves analogous to the motives they attempt to rouse in the minds of the public. When you find an intelligent man criticising a scheme like this and basing his criticism not on intelligent arguments, but on arguments deliberately calculated to raise all sorts of unreasonable prejudices and terrors against this scheme that man's convictions are something more than reasonable and intelligent convictions; they might be based on any one of the various emotions he is trying to arouse in the minds of the public, jealousy, for instance, terror, for instance, definite conviction for instance, or any one of those various motives, but I certainly think anyone who examines the great mass of that criticism must come to the conclusion that, whatever they are based on, they are not based upon reasoned conviction of that author's criticism, and do not care about reasoned conviction. They are making an appeal from their own prejudice to the prejudice of the people whose minds they are trying to arouse against this scheme.

We have heard a great deal of talk in all this matter about submitting this scheme to expert Irish opinion, to the opinion of expert Irish engineers. The Press has been full for several weeks past with criticism, purporting to come from eminent Irish engineers, from people expert in this particular subject. Looking at the matter from the point of view of the ordinary layman, it seems to me that the Minister and the Government have shown their perspicacity and good judgement in no matter more strongly than in this matter. They took this scheme, when submitted to them, out of Ireland altogether and submitted it to experts in other countries in Europe, where they knew they could get real experts, where they knew they could get people who would look at this proposal from the technical point of view and give them a real technical discussion on it, and make no attempt, in discussing it, to appeal to the emotion of jealousy or terror, as against any other emotion. Characteristically enough, the promoters of the criticism against the scheme try to make it appear that all the propaganda and all the publicity work is being done on the side of the Government and on the side of the scheme. In that connection, I might refer to what Deputy Figgis said yesterday about Dr. McLoughlin. Dr. McLoughlin cannot himself reply to any statements that are made about him in this House, and I think in justice as few statements as possible should be made about him. Deputy Figgis made some kind of vague accusation against him of having attempted, at some stage or another, to get hold of the Liffey scheme for Siemens-Schuckert. He based upon that accusation, which is substantiated only by his own word, another accusation— that Dr. McLoughlin was not acting in this matter purely from patriotic or disinterested motives. One thing I would like to say about Dr. McLoughlin and the promoters of this scheme in general is, that whatever they have done—and they have done a great deal of work in order to get this scheme brought before the country—they have not entered into a dishonest campaign in the public Press to "down" any other scheme that is a rival to this scheme. They have not fomented a correspondence in the public Press from every would-be expert and from practically every idiot in the country to "down" any other scheme which is a rival of theirs. In that respect, I think the promoters of the Siemens' scheme have a great deal more claim on the sympathy and support of intelligent people than the supporters of other schemes. The sooner this matter is raised above that level altogether, the sooner the methods of picture-house advertisement and theatrical advertisements are dropped in this matter of the electrification of Ireland, the better it will be for everybody. The sooner people begin to realise that you are not going to get away with any scheme by appealing to all sorts of terrors and foolish prejudices and by insinuating all sorts of lying statements, the sooner it is realised that any scheme that is put into force will be put into force on the advice of the experts and only after reasoned discussion, the better it will be for everybody.

Deputy Johnson yesterday, in discussing the possibilities this scheme opens up for the country, said practically everything I had in my mind to say on that point. But I would like to stress slightly one or two of the things he did say. He mentioned the possibilities that are in this scheme of opening up a different kind of life for people who live in the country and the possibility of redressing the balance in Ireland as between town and country. Justifiably and rightly, he used that point as an argument in favour of this scheme—provided this scheme is sound —as against any scheme for the development of any particular district in Ireland. I think that particular possibility is one that cannot be too strongly emphasised. It seems to me that, in this matter of electrification, we are entering upon a new age altogether in the history of Europe, if not in the history of the world. We are, to a large extent, coming out of the age of steam, gradually but surely. We are getting away from the influences which, for the last 150 years have been herding people in the huge towns, to become serfs around large factories worked on coal-driven machinery. We are reaching a stage where it will be possible, economically and on a sound business basis, to get small manufacturing enterprises carried on to a greater and greater extent all over the country. We are getting away from the concentration of industry into huge centres, and we are getting into a state of affairs where it will be possible to set back the hands of the clock, to go back—which we can do easily in this country—against that development which I personally believe has been the greatest disaster that England, to mention one country, has ever suffered: the development which has cleared her lands of inhabitants and driven her population to be serfs in her towns. I do not see that there is any prospect before this country brighter, in that way, than the prospect opened up for her by this scheme for the powerdevelopment of the Shannon. If it were only in consideration of the enormous advantages that this scheme might ultimately open up for the ordinary people of this country, it would be worth giving it a fair chance and honest, fair and intelligent criticism. The great problem for us in this country will be, if we are to develop industry: how are we going to develop it? Are we going to clear our lands just as the British did 100 years ago? Are we going to herd our people into towns or find, by some kind of modern development, an industry suitable for this country that can be carried on without the disastrous social consequences that have followed upon the development of industry in England? That is one of the points that should make us most careful to see that every chance is given to the Shannon scheme of development. It is a fine thing to see that the Labour Party in this country is prepared, on these grounds, to give a scheme like this a fair chance and to try and secure that it will have intelligent criticism and will not be snowed under by all sorts of appeals to mass prejudice or emotion or terror.

There are one or two little questions in connection with this matter of the supply of power that might perhaps be stressed also. It has been said very frequently recently that there is no use in supplying power, that the cost of power is only a very small part of the cost of industry. It has been almost urged that power is of no importance at all. There is one consideration in regard to that which is worth putting forward. Even admitting that power costs are only a small portion of the costs of industry generally, even admitting that you can run industries on coal nearly as cheaply as you can on electricity, I maintain that that statement is beside the point in considering this matter. The problem is not the dearness or cheapness of power; the problem is really the non-existence of power in this country. What you are faced with is the substitution of something which will provide native power in this country for power which you can only get from foreign materials. That seems to me to be a consideration which absolutely rules out all discussion about the price of power and all irrelevant details on that point which have been brought into this debate.

If we could get a supply of native power, whether it be cheap or dear, and particularly if we can get it in these conditions where it would be available almost for nothing, the value of that supply of power will, of course, be out of all proportion to the cost of power in any particular industry or even in the aggregate of industries worked in the whole country. Its value will lie, not so much in the amount of money it saves to any particular capitalist, but in the possibilities it opens up of an industry being started in every village in Ireland where there is material for an industry. In the large report of the scheme supplied by Messrs. Siemens you have at the end some information about the possibilities that exist in other countries for that sort of small industry, particularly about types of motors which seem to be very cheap and portable and capable of saving an enormous amount of labour. If we could get motors and devices of that kind into this country, and that as time goes on our farmers should avail of the opportunity of getting their work done by electricity, then we would have done for the country a work which would be enormously greater and more advantageous than the supply of cheap power for any particular concentrated industry in our big towns. I have read the report of the experts very carefully. I do not claim to have read it with absolute application to every detail, or that if I had, I would be competent to form an opinion on every detail. I do claim that, after a fair familiarity with written documents, I am competent to know whether or not a man, when he writes a book or a paper, knows what he is talking about. I am competent to know whether a man is an expert on the subject on which he says he is an expert. I am perfectly satisfied with the experts who, remember, were not called in to do propaganda on this matter, as someone said they were at a recent meeting of the Institute of Engineers. The experts were not called in to do that, or to take up the cudgels on behalf of Messrs. Siemens, but what they were called in for was to assist the members of the Executive Council in making up their minds about this matter. I am perfectly confident that these experts have not only given the scheme fair consideration, but that in a good many cases they have weighted the balance against the scheme, and have gone out of their way to overestimate the difficulties that will lie before the scheme, and to under-estimate the advantages of it.

I am fairly confident that, if the scheme gets a fair chance, before ten years have passed there will be a demand in Ireland not only for the electricity supplied by this scheme, but for electricity supplied by a big number of minor schemes. Before very long you will be faced again, I think, with the problem in this country of looking for other power besides electricity; and our difficulty will be not that we will have a supply of electric power for which we cannot find a market, but that we will have a demand for power which we cannot meet out of our own resources. I think, then, that when we have a scheme like this, and a report like this in our hands, there is a certain amount that we can do and a certain amount that we cannot do. We can decide whether, in our opinion, the experts who prepared this report were honest and capable, and from a study of the report it is possible to say whether they were or not. We can decide whether their report is a fair account of the possibilities of the Shannon scheme, but beyond that I do not see where we can go. I do not see what advantage is to be gained by entering into all sorts of details as to the effect of spade-cuts in the embankments and so on, or by entering into arguments as to the first neolithic ancestors of Deputy Figgis, and as to when he was presented with his first bow-and-arrow. That sort of argument is not going to lead us anywhere. What we can do, and what we ought to do, is to make up our minds definitely as to whether we think that the report of the experts put before us is a competent and an honest report, and whether we think that on that report the Executive Council can go forward, subject to the passing of a Bill, and put the scheme into operation. I have no doubt that the report is as competent and as clear and as definite a report as we are likely to get from any source, and that the county need have no fear if the Executive Council goes forward in taking up at once the preliminary work necessary for the execution of that scheme.

Comment on this

I rise to congratulate the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the courage and ability he displayed yesterday. I can assure him that I have good confidence in the course he adopted, and in the report that he has obtained. We are told that we should not have that confidence in that report and that we should have an appeal to a committee. Who would form the committee? I suppose engineers here at home, because nobody else is fit to sit on these committees; nobody else will be fit to contradict one of them, whatever might be said. I hold that these committees, if formed, could hardly in justice to themselves give an unprejudiced report, because let any one of us say to ourselves that we were overlooked for greater men, I hold that we would be in a small way jealous of one another and that we would try to get our own back. We have been told for years by every great man coming into the country, having a look round, especially if he was a Yankee, who would squeeze his nose:—"What a wonderful country this is if it were only developed! What splendid endowments by nature these people enjoy if they were only clever enough to put them into practice. They must be a lazy people, or they must be uneducated, or there must be nobody amongst them who can see what we can see. Waters are running waste that could be converted into oil, into coal and into horses if you like." What a great man the Minister for Industry and Commerce would be if he struck a rock and produced an oil well or a coal mine!

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

He would be a second Moses.

Comment on this

He would be an Irish Moses. But he did more. He struck the Shannon and has abolished the use almost of oil and coal if we only allow him to go ahead. And not alone will we allow him to go ahead, but it is the unanimous wish of the representatives of the Saorstát that we should push him ahead. People living in districts where they enjoy water supplies and are anxious to start industries would be in a position to do so and to give much needed employment in those districts if this scheme is passed.

We are told that this is going to be a very expensive scheme, but I hold that a whole lot of the money that is being spent weekly could be spent under the Shannon scheme productively instead of being given away for nothing, as some parties in this House complain. But now when the Minister for Industry and Commerce is making a bold bid to relieve that unemployment and do away with the dole in big measure, I think every man in this House should be behind him. By means of this electricity—I will venture into the field of engineering now, and I am sure I will not get far until I am bogged—I am sure we can get supplies of water where water previously could not be obtained. That would be a great advantage to the farmers. I hold that agriculture would be helped scientifically in a short time by the spread of a system of cheap electricity in the country. As some Deputy said yesterday, instead of candles, we will see the labourers' cottages beautifully lit by electricity. In short, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and the Executive Council will convert this island of fire-machines and candlesticks into an island of electricity and will have fitted this country, in my opinion, to take her place amongst the nations of the earth.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

took the Chair.

Comment on this

I would like to congratulate Deputy Professor Tierney on his well-reasoned maiden speech, and I should like to add that we, as Deputies, welcome individual expressions of opinion fromt he benches on which he sits. With regard to what has been said about criticism, and notwithstanding the risks that one may run in further criticising these proposals, I feel it is our duty as Deputies to carefully examine every detail of a proposal of this magnitude before we can give it our assent. If I might be permitted to do so, I would rather differ from what Deputy Professor Tierney said in discouraging criticism. I agree with the sensible remarks made yesterday by a Deputy who said he was glad to see the interest that was taken, throughout the country generally, in those proposals. He looked upon that, and I look upon that, as a healthy sign from the point of view of the country, and I hope that the desire of the Dáil will always be to encourage criticism of a useful character rather than to discourage it.

In the criticisms I have to offer I do not pretend to pose, as many Deputies here have posed, as an expert on the matter under consideration. I leave the technical details of this scheme to those who are much more qualified than I am to criticise them. But it is an extraordinary feature that all the criticisms of these experts, while not against the scheme in principle, have been against the scheme in detail. That is a point that should not be overlooked, because, condemn these experts as we may, there are men amongst them who are just as keenly interested for the welfare of this old country as any of the Deputies either on the Government or on the other benches in the House, and just as capable of coming to an independent opinion on the subject. But there are important aspects of this question, apart from the technical details, on which we, as laymen, can give a useful opinion. The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us yesterday that the contract for this scheme was really based on two clauses in the White Paper—Clauses 11 and 12. These are matters on which Deputies are capable of expressing a useful opinion, and they are very important matters in connection with the financial aspects of the scheme.

Let us consider for a moment the two clauses that the Minister told us yesterday were the basis of the contract for this proposal. The first is Clause 11, which reads as follows:—"If the report is approved and the Government decide to promote a scheme as a State enterprise"—that is practically what is conveyed in that resolution. "You propose"—that is Messrs. Siemens—"that your firm should have the contract for the supply of all material and for the construction of all works at market prices subject to the material being up to first-class specification." I would like to know exactly what market prices mean. Those of us who have experience of contracts in the carrying out of the work of local authorities, and other schemes, know that there are three forms in which we can obtain contracts. There are what are known as lump sum contracts—that is a fixed amount for carrying out a scheme in accordance with the plans prepared by the engineers. Then there are contracts based on a schedule of prices, and, again, there are contracts based on a percentage of cost. Those are the three forms of contract as we know them, in commercial circles, to-day.

But these proposals on which the contract is based are another matter. If we pass this resolution, these are the proposals which will form the contract, because on the one side you have the proposals put forward, and on the other side you have the acceptance put forward, so that that forms in itself a definite contract. Once we pass this resolution we are committed to that contract. Any further Bill that will be introduced can only embody what is contained in that contract. Therefore it is very essential, before we approve of this contract, that we should know exactly what it means. World market prices! I do not know exactly what that means. I do not know what it is that you would call a world market price for any commodity. You have a price at works, and you have a price on delivery. The delivery and the carriage in every country will be different. I am open to conviction on this point: I do not know what exactly is meant by world market prices in this contract. The President, who is experienced in the making of contracts on local bodies that he was connected with, will agree that contracts come under the three heads that I have mentioned. But I cannot bring this contract under any of the three heads. Clause 12 then goes on to state:—"The civil engineering constructional work is to be offered to the Siemens Bau Union at a minimum tender, the firm agreeing to employ to the fullest practical extent Irish labour and Irish contracting firms." Is that to be a competitive tender? If it is not to be a competitive tender, how are we going to know whether it is a minimum and a reasonable tender? The word "competitive" is not there. If we pass this resolution, as I have said, we are accepting this contract. It is in the vaguest terms. These are matters that should be explained, that should be thoroughly understood, before they are accepted.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Surely the Deputy is not going to leave Clause 11 and Clause 12 without reading the Government's answers to Siemens' proposals?

Comment on this

Where are they?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Just below Clause 11 and just below Clause 12.

Comment on this

Is there any other clause that the Minister wants me to read?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Clause 11, in so far as the Deputy has read it, gives the original Siemens' proposals to the Government, and the letter-press immediately below it gives the Government's return to that. The two are to be taken together.

Comment on this

Is it the following clause you want me to take? Is it the clause following Clause 12?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The six lines after Clause 11.

Comment on this

I will read that now:—"The Government would be prepared to give your firm the contract under the following conditions. It would reserve to itself the right of testing the quality and prices of the material to be supplied by your firm in such manner as the Government thought fit. The Government would require to satisfy itself that your firm would supply material at prices not higher than those at which similar material of first-grade quality could at any time be obtained from a reputable firm in any part of the world."

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

"At the time." I think the Deputy made the statement "at any time" unintentionally.

Comment on this

"At the time." That is quite right. Does that mean that this work will be offered for competition and tenders will be obtained, and that if Messrs. Siemens' tender be the lowest they will get the work? I want to know exactly what it does mean. If that is so, will the Minister kindly inform us?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I can only inform you by re-reading the second sentence:—"It would reserve to itself the right of testing the quality and prices of the material to be supplied by your firm in such manner as the Government thought fit."

Comment on this

Does that mean competitive tenders? Cannot the Minister now answer a straight question? Are we going to have competitive tenders in order that we may ensure that this work will be carried out at the lowest possible price?

Comment on this

Then that is one point clear. We are not going to have competitive tenders?

Comment on this

The work is going to be handed over to Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert and we are to pay whatever price they like to ask?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No.

Comment on this

If their price is not to be governed by competitive tenders, how are we to know whether it is the lowest price, the minimum price, or otherwise?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

You will know all about it.

Comment on this

There is a method. If you get the right to obtain competitive tenders you can always govern matters and tell whether a price is a reasonable, fair or a minimum price.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

And without competitive tenders you cannot?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Would the Deputy be surprised to know that the British Government has already ordered a constructional scheme in Wales in regard to which there was not competitive tender?

Comment on this

If the British Government make mistakes, I do not want the Free State Government to follow them.

Comment on this

Are there no mistakes made in the matter of competitive tenders?

Comment on this

Let me give you the idea that the experts formed after they had read some prices that are evidently not before the members of the Dáil. I do not know what schedule of prices was in the hands of the experts. I have examined all the documents that were handed to us, and I cannot find any prices on which to form an opinion as to whether the price would be reasonable or otherwise. Evidently prices were before the experts. Further, I would like to add that no plans, no specifications, are available in order that we may examine the scheme which we are asked to commit ourselves to by resolution this afternoon. What have the experts said on these prices which have been submitted to them and which we have not seen? On page 79 of the Experts' Report, it is stated:

"When the contract for the construction is drawn up the Government should make the contractors undertake to assume a reasonable share of the increases in wages. The experts were struck by the relatively high charge for building machinery shown in the estimates. On the other hand, there is no item in Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert's estimate for ‘unexpected costs' such as is usual in similar calculations and which amounts in hydraulic constructional works to about 10 per cent. of the total construction costs."

Then, further on, they proceed to say in the second paragraph, page 80:

"The plan handed to the experts does not show any detailed constructions. According to the rules of the Swiss Institute of Engineers and Architects, with regard to the drawing up of engineers' plans, three different kinds of prepared plans are distinguished, viz.:—(1) General plan with approximate estimate; (2) building plan with estimates; (3) detailed elaboration."

From the point of view of this differentiation Messrs. Siemens-Schuc-kert's plan must be considered as a "building plan." It permits of a judgment—this is the important point—"of probable costs," but it only permits of a judgment of probable costs "within a margin of about 10 per cent."

Comment on this

May I interrupt the Deputy for one moment? He left out—I am sure it was unintentionally— in quoting from page 79 the word "risk." The paragraph reads: "to assume a reasonable share of the risk of increases in wages." I think had he not stopped in the paragraph where he was reading he would have found some explanation of what he complained of, to my mind a rather reasonable explanation.

Comment on this

I do not want to take up the time of the House more than is necessary. I want to be quite fair in any criticism I offer and if I have left out anything I am sure the President will see that that omission of mine is put right. I would like an explanation from him of that last paragraph I have read, paragraph 2, on page 80. It states that the plans supplied to the experts only permit of a judgment of the probable costs within a margin of about 10 per cent.

Comment on this

I may be wrong, but I read that very much in conjunction with the previous paragraph in which they say it is usual to put in unexpected costs to the extent of 10 per cent. Then they go on to explain that what they have got in the nature of information permits of a judgment of the probable costs within a margin of about 10 per cent.

Comment on this

This is a matter on which I am glad to say I am capable of giving information, because it is a matter I have to deal with myself every other day. If the President will allow me to correct him I will show him the reason of the statement of the experts in the last portion of the clause if he reads the first portion which I read. The first portion of paragraph 2 is as follows:—

"The plan handed to the experts does not show any detailed constructions."

Without a detailed plan it is impossible to give a definite estimate. The plan supplied to them was only a general building plan without any details. On a general building plan it is impossible to prepare a definite estimate without details.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think the Deputy is using one word which may not express the precise meaning. The experts have divided the plans into three parts: (1) general plans with approximate estimate; (2) building plan with estimates, and (3) detailed elaboration. The Deputy now speaks of a general building plan. If he means the first, they have got more than that. He should refer to the second, as it is there.

Comment on this

I am referring to the reason why they say that, on the information supplied to them, it is not possible to give an estimate nearer than a margin of 10 per cent. The reason of that —and it is obvious to anyone who has experience in that particular industry— is that no details were forthcoming. Without the details it is not possible to give a definite estimate for a definite amount. That is why they say that the figures they put forward can only be accepted as accurate within a margin of 10 per cent. As I have said, there is a looseness and an indefiniteness, to put it mildly, about these proposals that will have to be cleared up, as far as I am concerned, at all events, before I will vote for the resolution.

If there is one thing more necessary than another in schemes of this magnitude, it is to see that the contract on which they are based is carefully and properly drawn. I need not tell any Deputy in this House what might follow from a very loosely drawn contract and the larger the amount the greater the liability. As I said, this is a subject on which I can speak with some authority, and having examined these proposals carefully and, I hope, reasonably, I have come to the definite conclusion, as the result of that examination, that the proposal before the House is one that I cannot subscribe to without further inquiry. I pass from that aspect of the question to another aspect. A great many criticisms have been offered and there seems to be a very considerable consensus of opinion among many who are entitled to form an opinion on this subject, that there is more than a doubt as to whether there will be a demand for the output of this scheme. I am sure that Ministers and Deputies have heard many criticisms on that point. Evidently the point was in the minds of the Government when they were considering the scheme. Those of you who have got it, will notice in the White Paper, in clause 3, the last clause on page 1, where it is mentioned: "You"—Messrs. Siemens —"propose to examine not only the existing market for power but to report on the future possibilities—industrial and other—that cheap power would promote." Messrs. Siemens reply to that: "We are dealing with a new country, and we have to base our estimate to a large extent on statistics from other countries."

That does not appear in the White Paper, but I have taken it from their report. The countries on which they base their statistics are—Norway, the Western States of North America, and Canada. From what one knows of these countries, and of our own country, I do not think there is much in common. If a prudent business firm were to embark on an expenditure of this character as a commercial enterprise, I am quite sure that they would not be satisfied to take the figures of any of these other countries, but that they would have the district which it was proposed to supply, if not in whole, certainly in part, canvassed to see what the probable demand was likely to be. If any body of directors were to embark shareholders' money in a scheme of this magnitude without taking that necessary precaution, I am afraid that when they came before their shareholders there would be a bad time in store for them. If you and I were shareholders and we found they had embarked on this expenditure without making any canvas of the area or forming any estimate based on that canvass, as to the likely demand for current in that area, we would be inclined to say that it was time we got other directors, that they were not looking after our interests. What do we do here? We are quite satisfied, apart from any canvass to take the figures from other countries and to apply them to our own. That is not sound. It is a method that would not be adopted by a commercial concern.

I would urge that something of that character be done before we are committed to this proposal. If the proposal be embarked on we all want to see it a success, but if the farming community are not behind these proposals where are we going to get the consumption for the current? The Minister yesterday put before us data based on Dublin, and said that in 1932 the demand would be so-and-so. Let me say on behalf of the cities that this scheme is not going to help the demand; it is not going to retard the demand in the cities. We can get current to-day practically as cheap in Dublin to within a decimal part of a penny, as we hope to get it under this scheme, provided it is a success. Current, as many Deputies know, and as the President can tell us, can be manufactured to-day in Dublin under a penny per unit at works.

Comment on this

I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy, but, as a matter of fact, on the last returns published— the accounts of the Dublin Corporation for the period ended 31st March—the cost per unit sold in 1924 is 69d. for coal, and for other expenditure of generation, distribution and management, 1.66 of a penny. I would like, furthermore, to direct the Deputy's attention to the fact that it is the most favourable year that could possibly be taken as far as the city of Dublin is concerned. The total maximum supplied was 11,054 out of 12,000 kilowatts.

Comment on this

I am obliged for the President's interruption. He talks of manufacture plus distribution. I talk of manufacture.

Comment on this

I said expenditure on generation, distribution and management. Coal was only 69d.

Comment on this

I do not think the Corporation is ideal, but I am sure the Corporation can do it. We can manufacture current to-day in Dublin for less than 1d. If there is any doubt on the point experts can come forward.

Comment on this

I must certainly express my grave doubt of that. I will admit it is possible if capital costs have been written down and huge sums provided for depreciation. You may arrive at it that way. I am taking these particular figures that lend themselves to exact examination on that point.

Comment on this

I have not the tramway returns and I have not examined them, I do not want to take up time by going into them now. I am satisfied that current can be manufactured to-day at 1d., or less than 1d., and I challenge the statement. What is it proposed under this scheme to supply current at in Dublin? It is something like .6 of a penny—something between ½d. and 1d. The advantage we are going to get in the city is something between .6 of a penny and a penny. That is assuming your scheme is an economic success, you can produce current at the rate set forth, and assuming that everything goes well and that you carry out the work within the estimate. Is that going to benefit the city? In an area that I am connected with we had in the last few months a reduction of 1d. a unit, not a decimal part of a penny, but 1d. a unit, and as a result of that reduction I do not see any queue of possible consumers waiting outside or asking for current. When you come to commerce, the cost of power, after all, is a small matter. It is not the cost of the power that is the real expense to commerce. It is the distribution and the installation of it. There are Deputies who have had some knowledge of the cost of production and distribution. In Dublin to-day the cost of production is in or about a penny—it may be something more. What is the charge for current? Eightpence. The cost of production is only one-eighth of that——

Comment on this

I am sorry to have to interrupt the Deputy, but it is scarcely fair to say that the cost is eightpence. The Deputy is leaving out of consideration the fact that actually more units are sold in the city for power and for heating than for lighting, and these units are certainly not sold at eightpence.

Comment on this

As the President knows, the profit in connection with a lighting station is not made on the powerunits sold. They only give in a power station what is known as a day rate, and what is necessary, in order to run the station economically. To get a consumption for that day rate, either by way of power or by way of heating, they are prepared to offer it practically at cost price.

Comment on this

Sometimes under it.

Comment on this

Sometimes under it. But the scheme is never made successful by the power price; they rely on the lighting price, and I notice that the experts have relied very largely on a large consumption of current for lighting, knowing that thereby the revenue will be considerably augmented. Deputy Egan touched the point yesterday when he said, and said rightly, that cheap current of itself will not be a very attractive thing, either for those in industry or for those who want power for private purposes. The difficulty is the cost of installation, and except some means is devised for getting over that difficulty I am afraid that the demand will be exceedingly poor. In connection with the different electricity systems in Dublin, I do not know whether or not the President is aware of the fact, but at their inception we had to provide means for getting over that difficulty. I do not know whether the President can call to mind the difficulties we had in connection with free wiring installation. I do not know whether that difficulty arose in the city, but we have had it in the townships, and it was a considerable difficulty. I mention that as a factor for which no consideration has been given or provision made. I am not in a position to form an idea as to what the cost of this installation will be, but I am quite satisfied that it will require a very considerable amount of money and, except as Deputy Egan very properly pointed out, something is done in that connection you will not get consumption for the current. As I have said, I am not satisfied regarding the basis of consumption. That is a matter, to my mind, that it is essential for the success of the scheme should be more thoroughly inquired into and put on a more definite basis before we are asked to accept the proposals. Next I would urge that a canvass should be made of a portion of the district in order that an estimate might be formed as to the probable requirements, because I think everybody will agree that there is no use in producing the current except there is a demand for it. Deputy O'Sullivan said, in reply to another Deputy, that in this scheme we are putting the cart before the horse.

Comment on this

Deputy Connor Hogan asked me why the experts were not first called in, that is, to examine the scheme practically before it existed. I said that that was not the usual practice.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I did not ask that.

Comment on this

I will go on with my argument and not have a discussion. If I let that in I would never finish it, and I must close the door. Why were the experts not called in? I do not know whether Deputy O'Sullivan has very much experience in matters of contracts and schemes. I would ask him if he can call to mind any scheme where experts were not called in in the first instance to prepare the scheme and plans, and having got them, they were then sent out to contractors in order to get estimates? That is the customary procedure. That is putting the horse before the cart. What is being done in this case? They have put the cart before the horse in going first to the contractors. This is a contractor's scheme, a contractor's estimate. After they had received it they sent it to the experts for their report. If that is not putting the cart before the horse I do not know what it is.

I do not want to go further into details. I would only like to say in conclusion that there is not that confidence on the part of the public behind this scheme that one would like to see. If this scheme is to be made a success that confidence is necessary. The only way that that confidence will be obtained is by opening the doors in connection with this scheme and giving the public and the citizens of the Saorstát full information in connection with it. What is the position? What is being done? After pressing in the Dáil for months for copies of the Experts' Report and of the original proposals of Messrs. Siemens we got them some two weeks ago. We had not seen the plans; we had not seen the detailed estimate, and before these details were very little over two weeks in our hands, a resolution comes along binding the Dáil, and binding this State to this particular proposal. That is not the way to carry confidence. We are a new Government; we want to carry the confidence of our people; we want to establish a method of doing things that will be above suspicion. Is that the way to do it? We have in the Dáil, as I said, men who are experienced in carrying out schemes of this kind in connection with local and other authorities. I ask them as a result of that experience to say if they have ever been parties to a scheme of this character? Is it any reason, therefore, why an amount of suspicion shrouds this scheme? I would urge upon the Government that the only way to get rid of that suspicion and to get that confidence behind this scheme which is essential to its success is to stop these rushing tactics, and give every information that is required. As a result of having that information then bring your scheme before the Dáil, and if approved, we will put it through.

The Dail adjourned at 1.40 p.m. and resumed at 2.30 p.m.,AN CEANN COMHAIRLE in the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE (Mr. P. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, when opening this debate, pointed out that we were debating the Shannon scheme and expressed shortly the hope that we would confine ourselves to the merits of that scheme. Deputy Figgis raised various points. He protested his own disinterestedness. He praised Dr. McLaughlin, and he discussed certain relations between the Government and the promoters of the Liffey schemes. These have absolutely nothing to do with the merits of the Shannon scheme, and whatever may or may not be the relations between the Government and the promoters of the Liffey schemes, these are other questions that will have to be settled at some other time. They can only be discussed now on the basis that some commitments in connection with the Liffey schemes shall prevent the Government from adopting the best scheme on its merits. That is the question here—what is the best scheme on its merits, and any commitments there may or may not be in connection with any other scheme is something that will have to be settled on some other occasion.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, in opening the debate, put the whole position very clearly. Let me quote some of his figures. He pointed out that the scheme will proceed by definite steps. There will be the canal, the power-house and the various distribution lines. First of all, there is the 100 k.w., then the 35 k.w., and then the 10 k.w. lines. The scheme will proceed in that way by various steps. He pointed out distinctly and clearly that the consumption of electricity for domestic purposes, that is, for heating and lighting, as distinct from power, will be sufficient to make this scheme a paying proposition. He made abundantly clear, I think, to anybody who was listening to him, that the scheme was not depending for its financial success on the consumption of electricity for power or that the real big argument in favour of the scheme was power. The Minister for Industry and Commerce gave certain figures, as I say. He pointed out that various tariffs could be imposed, that it was indeed extremely elastic, and that the particular rate here or there, whether it was to be a flat rate or whether it was to be a different rate for Dublin, a different rate for Cork, and a different rate for the small towns—one rate for big towns and another rate for the country—were questions which had to be decided later on, as a matter of policy, and on which the Dáil would have its say. These are questions which should be decided.

But he did give us samples of the various tariffs which could be adopted under the scheme. He pointed out that if there was no demand for current except from Dublin and Cork, that at a certain figure, namely, 52d., electricity could be supplied here at the end of the 100 k.w. lines to Dublin, Cork and Limerick—these are the termini of the chief lines—at .52d. in bulk and would pay for the whole scheme up to that point, provided there was increased consumption amounting to 15 per cent. per annum.

He made that abundantly clear to anybody who listened to him. He gave other alternatives; he said that if you want to adopt a flat rate you can supply current in bulk, assuming always a certain increase in consumption,. at .74d. at the end of the 100 and 35 k.w. lines, that is, to Dublin and the towns of over 5,000 inhabitants, assuming a consumption of fifty units per inhabitant. He went further: he pointed out that that would justify the scheme. That was your second step, that the scheme would be a paying proposition on these assumptions, first of all to Dublin, Cork and Limerick, next, at the ends of the 35 k.w. lines, and again at the end of the 10 k.w. lines, taking the flat rate of .82d., the same rate as for Loughrea and Kilkenny, and assuming a certain increase in consumption, twenty-six to thirty units per inhabitant, the scheme would again pay. These figures have not been challenged, and they cannot be challenged in any direction except one, that is the question as to whether you will get the increased consumption or not. This is a very complicated scheme, and it is not to be wondered at if laymen become a little confused on various matters arising out of it. But there are some things that should be clear, and it is clear, mathematically, provided you get the increased consumption which the Minister specifies, that at, let us say, .52d. at Dublin, Cork and Limerick the scheme pays, and so on at a flat rate of .72 for the second development, and .84 as a flat rate for the third development, the scheme will pay. These figures simply cannot be challenged; they are mathematically accurate, provided you get the increased consumption. Before dealing with that question of whether you will get the increased consumption or not, we ought to be as clear as we can be on certain other matters which I think are simply not debatable. We are not dealing here with the price of electricity to the consumer, the price to the householder; it was never intended that we should, though that question may arise; Deputy Johnson mentioned it. It may be, and I think that a time will come when the significance of this scheme, when all its reactions are realised, that there may be some demand in the Dáil some day that not only should the State control the production and distribution of electricity to the ends of the power lines, but should also control its distribution from the ends of the power lines to the householder.

That may be, but the question we are dealing with here is the production and distribution of electricity up to the end of the transformer stations, whether they be in Dublin, Limerick, Cork, Kilkenny, Tipperary, or any other place. That is the question. We are basing our scheme on the simple economic proposition that it is a sound scheme if we can show that we are doing that work—producing and distributing electricity to that extent at a rate which is from 100 to 400 per cent. cheaper than that at which that particular work is being done at present, or is being done by any other scheme, or by any scheme which is in contemplation as a rival to this. We ought to have that clear. I was a little surprised—the Minister for Industry and Commerce mentioned it—to hear the extraordinary doctrine that the cost of production and distribution up to a point did not matter. People who are absolutely sound, and who have the most respectable economic dogmas and beliefs, but who look upon the rest of us as theorists and a little dangerous in economics, sometimes enunciate doctrines which surprise me, and which would, I am sure, surprise Deputy Johnson. We have been told by Deputy Good that the cost of production from 200 to 400 per cent. does not matter. I sat here and listened to Deputy Good telling the Dáil that the cost of production varying from 200 to 400 per cent. did not matter, and did not enter into the economics of this scheme at all. I think he justified that extraordinary economic heresy by saying that the difference, as regards the cost of production and distribution to the transformer stations, or what correspond to transformer stations, and the cost to the factory or household is very small in one case, and very big in the other. That is the way he justified it. We could get the facts. These statistics are known, and we have not to depend on eminent European experts for them. They are here. I would like to know if Deputy Good, or any other Deputy, will contradict me when I say that the cost of production and distribution of electricity in towns in the country, outside Dublin and Cork, to what will correspond to transformer stations in this scheme, varies from about 2d. to 7d. I have a list before me in the "Electrical Times," and I can read it if necessary. The cost to the huseholder in these towns varies from about 6d. to 1/4, in other words just about double in some cases. In other words, in the country towns of Ireland, and I venture to say in those of most countries, the costs with which this scheme deals are just about half the total costs. Are these figures denied? I am sure that there are various Deputies here who are on electric light committees and who will be able to deal with these matters. These facts are undeniable, and yet we are told that the cost of production and distribution does not matter, and that the cost to the transformer stations to the end of the kilowatt line, the particular work which this scheme is doing, does not matter, notwithstanding that at present in practically every provincial town that cost amounts, roughly speaking, to between one-third and a little more than half the total cost. These figures can be checked, and I should be delighted to be shown where they are wrong. I know the figures for my own town. They have never been denied. I discussed this with men in various towns.

Deputy Tierney spoke of criticism, and I am surprised to hear that sort of criticism from Deputy Good, or, I should say, I am surprised a little bit, and perhaps satisfied. We may have differences on other economic matters with Deputy Good, and I am delighted that he has made me a present of this extraordinary statement. I am genuinely surprised that a business man would stand over such a statement. We know that small matters make all the difference in business. We know that in agriculture they make all the difference, and we know that counting the pence and the halfpence makes all the difference. This is a matter of 50 per cent. of the total cost, so far as the country towns are considered. I deliberately left out Dublin because the position of Dublin seems to be a bit debatable. I was surprised to hear Deputy Good say that electricity was produced at a penny for distribution to the citizens of Dublin. I have here a supplement to the "Electrical Times" for 1924 which was not prepared for the purposes of the Shannon scheme, or for the Liffey scheme, or for any other scheme, but for the purpose of a first-class paper giving accurate information of its own. I find the cost of production, at what corresponds to the transformer station in Dublin, is 2.42d. and the average cost to the citizens is 5.07d. That includes power. That means that the cost to the citizen for lighting and heating is probably more than 5.07d. but it does not affect the cost of production of 2.42d. The "Electrical Times" may, of course, be wrong. I am making a present of it to Deputy Good. I have discussed this with many people besides going to the obvious sources of information and this is the first time I heard that electricity was, in fact, produced and delivered in bulk in Dublin at less than one penny at what would correspond to the transformer station under the Shannon scheme. I venture to accept the figure of the "Electrical Times" as against that of Deputy Good. I have here the cost all over the country and every town in the country, and it is, I should say, between about an average of 6d., or, to be absolutely conservative, 4d., and I should say that the cost to the householder is between 6d. and 9d., going up to 1/- and 1/2. Dundalk is undoubtedly the best served of any provincial town in Ireland for various reasons, and it supplies a large quantity for power purposes. The cost of production and distribution is 2.64d. That is easily the best town in Ireland, and it is probably amongst the best in England or Scotland. Yet the cost is 2.64d. Apparently accurate figures do not matter unless they come from quarters that are recognised business quarters.

Comment on this

If we keep to the production costs I do not know that there will be much difference between us.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Deputy knows perfectly well that is like the flowers that bloom in the spring: it has nothing to do with the case. We are comparing what the Shannon scheme can do under present conditions against any other scheme, and we must compare figures with figures that are approximate. I am comparing the figures for the cost of power delivered in bulk to the transformer station here with the cost of the power delivered in bulk to the power house in Dublin. The Shannon scheme proposes to regulate electricity from production to distribution in bulk at the end of k.w. lines. That is undeniable. It is not proposed at present, but another day it may come, when the distribution of electricity from the end of the k.w. lines to the householder will be controlled. Let us compare things that are comparable. These are the figures from the most conservative paper. Anything is good enough to kick this scheme with, but nothing is conservative enough or statistically accurate enough to adduce in its favour. We are supposed to be hilarious Irishmen, scattered brained. We produce figures and facts from the sources where you go normally for these things, but they are all wrong, but matters of opinion, provided they come from the experts in this country, are quite all right. I leave that point. As lay men, as jury men, there are no two questions about it; we are forced to accept the facts as we find them. I am not saying that electricity cannot be produced by a power plant under certain conditions at ½d. perhaps less. I could probably do it myself at home if I set out to produce electricity at .5 by a power plant. I would buy a special sort of engine, and go into the whole case of producing, not exactly the amount of electricity I wanted for commercial purposes, but just to show that I could produce electricity at .5. But this is a commercial proposition, and I am pointing out that the Shannon scheme as proposed is a commercial proposition. It is not for Deputy Good to say that we should judge it on any other lines.

Comment on this

May I make the point clear? What I said was that the current could be produced in the city at 1d. The Minister does not doubt that. He tells us, what is not new, that current can be produced in bulk at 1d. It certainly can be produced in bulk at 1d. There is no doubt on the subject at all. Under the Shannon scheme it would be .52 of 1d. I say it will be produced in the city at 1d., and he says under the Shannon scheme it will be reduced to .52. There is the only advantage of the scheme, if it is an advantage at all to the city.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

I stated deliberately that I omitted the City of Dublin, because there was a difference of opinion between the figure there and the country. I had the authority merely of the "Electrical Times," but I may say I am entitled to take that as correct.

Comment on this

Do not put the responsibility on me.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

I say the figures for the production and distribution of electricity in the "Electrical Times" are in bulk 2.4. It is that figure that is to be compared with .5 of the Shannon scheme. I admit that you could produce electricity at .5 if you want to do it, but it is not being done, and there is no scheme that contemplates doing it for Dublin and the rest of the country. That is all I say. It is possible to misconstrue this in other directions. It may be said it is not proposed, in fact, to give electricity to a country town at .84. It was not proposed, or rather, I should say, that it is not decided yet. That is merely possible—it is merely a tariff—that is, a flat rate. For instance, it may be decided here later on to give electricity to Dublin at .03 I want to reduce it to absurdity, and for that reason to increase the price to the country, or at least, to come down to a business matter, it may be decided to give electricity to Dublin at one penny, which, according to the "Electrical Times," would be 100 per cent. less than it is given at present— that is, it would be one half less. In order to give power particularly cheap there are immense possibilities of variations. I pointed out that the only possibility of these figures being in error was the possibility that the consumption would not be increased. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, in opening this debate, told the Dáil the particular considerations on which he rested his belief—that the consumption would increase up to the point needed.

He gave certain figures for consumption in other countries. He took the case of Dublin, and he showed that the increase required from the present figure was from 42 to 80, bringing the consumption for power and other purposes to 118, and he compared that with the figures in other countries, Switzerland, Norway and Denmark. It was very much less than in other countries. He showed that the average for Norway was 400 to 800. Switzerland from 600 to 700, and that in Denmark, which is a country fairly comparable to ours, or at least with which our country is often compared, the consumption was considerably more than we were asking for or expected here, but he did not confine statistics, facts and comparisons, with other countries. I do not understand why it is necessary to attack this particular point by assuming that the Minister rested his case exclusively on foreign countries as Deputy Good did. He asked why should we incur all the expense, why should we undertake this scheme, solely by reference to conditions in other countries, and merely comparing our expectations with the conditions in other countries. He did not do anything of the kind. He pointed out that he was taking——

Comment on this

I was talking of the experts.

Comment on this
MINISTER for LANDS AND AGRICULTURE

He pointed out that he was taking the opinion not only of the continental experts, but of the City Engineer, Mr. Kettle. He pointed out that the City Engineer had stated professionally that he expected an increase of 15 per cent. per annum, and that that increase of 15 per cent. per annum would work out to more units per head of the population in Dublin than actually Messrs. Siemens require. Deputy Good will hardly deny that. Yet the statement is made that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is resting his case solely on foreign experts. The Minister for Industry and Commerce pointed out that the increase last year was 17 per cent. in Dublin. There was a comparable increase in Rathmines, and a very considerable increase in the various towns electrified in the country. He pointed out that per head of the population owing to the special circumstances, this country was not merely so well electrified as other countries, but that it was very far, indeed, from saturation point. Yet we are accused of resting our expectations of an increased consumption solely on the opinion of foreign experts. Supposing we did. Deputy Good suggested that there were very big differences between Norway and this country, that there were big differences also between Denmark and this country and between Sweden and this country from that point of view. It is not good enough merely to say that.

There are differences between Norway and this country, between Sweden and this country, and between Denmark and this country, but we must have more than the ipse dixit of Deputy Good to show that certain developments which took place in Denmark or Norway or countries like those are not going to take place here. We must have a little more than the theory of a double dose of original sin, or that nothing ever works out properly here. Deputy Good did not, of course, say that. I know conditions well in Denmark and Sweden, and I cannot see why there should not be some comparison between the conditions of Denmark and this country and Sweden and this country. I have not the slightest doubt that we shall show Denmark a thing or two in agriculture in a few years. We have done it already in some things, and I have not the slightest doubt but that our development in other directions will be as good as that of Denmark or any of those countries. I refuse utterly to reject the evidence which can be obtained by comparison with those countries, especially when that evidence is verified by the experience of at least one man who is in a peculiarly good position to judge, and by what has actually happened in the last two years, and what has actually happened notwithstanding the present hopeless conditions and the present price of electricity. The fact of the matter is that if we are not prepared to take a decision on the facts which we have before us in regard to consumption, then we do not believe in ourselves, and there is no use in arguing against anybody who refuses to accept the logical implication of those figures. We will not get any further by doing it. The position of the Government is that they are prepared. That is the one debatable point. The scheme is absolutely water-tight provided you accept that, and provided you accept the position that Messrs. Siemens are competent engineers for this work, and that the four experts who have examined it, not for the purpose of holding a brief for either side, are competent to judge the technical details of this scheme. It must work out. Let us assume—I know the assumption will shock some people—that it works out financially as has been projected; that is to say, that it works out successfully, as a result of the increased consumption of electricity for domestic purposes, that you have your 100, 30, or 35 kilowatt lines, distributed through the country; in other words, that you have your transformer stations all over the country, down to every village of 500 inhabitants. The price is whatever you like; it may be smaller in Dublin, and higher in other parts of the country, or bigger here. The scheme is paying interest, sinking fund, overhead expenses, and is paying that, as is contemplated, on the consumption of electricity for domestic purposes. The Minister pointed out that the production of electricity was based on the production in the driest year for thirty years, and that under normal circumstances you would have a big increase—nearly twice as much electricity produced at the bus bars in the centralisation in Limerick. He made it abundantly clear—this is the point which even the morning papers are unable to get—that he would have that electricity together with any other electricity not required for domestic consumption for practically giving away for power. There was no necessity to include in the price of that electricity any of the overhead or distribution expenses down to the end of the ten kilowatt line. Looking at it commercially, there is no necessity to charge any other expenses except the cost of distribution from the ten kilowatt line in the small village down in the country to any little business near it that wants electricity for power purposes—an infinitesimal cost, if you want to put it on a commercial basis, and only .00 something of one penny. There is no getting away from that, if you once admit that the scheme works out as intended. I merely insist on that to show what are the possibilities of this scheme. Assuming that it is sound, assuming the consumption for domestic purposes is what it is expected to be, assuming that you have, in fact, dotted transformer stations all over the country, power can, as a matter of national policy, be given away practically for nothing. For instance, I spoke a moment ago about the possibility of increasing the present figure of .5d. to 1d. for Dublin. That might very well be. That would certainly enable you to give away power for nothing. Or do what Deputy Professor O'Sullivan suggested when he pointed out that power available under this scheme was the most effective and efficient form of protection which the State could have at its disposal. There are simply immense possibilities, and there is no class in the country stands more to gain from the scheme than the farmers, not only from the social point of view, but from the strictly economic point of view as well. Deputy Good will agree that, in these matters, what makes the difference between success and failure is the having of all the requisites together. You may have your port, you may have fairly perfect transit arrangements, you may have your river, and you may have your raw materials, but you have not the power. What we have often seen happening in this country is that all the requisites are present except one. And that one makes all the difference. Here you can distribute power practically for nothing. There is no doubt about that.

If I were asked: what are the possibilities of this scheme for agriculture, from the economic point of view, I would not care to risk quoting concrete examples at the moment. But I do know that, as farmers get more educated, and as agriculture develops in this country, the industry will become more industrialised. It must, undoubtedly, prove a tremendous advantage in that event to agriculture to have cheap power distributed practically all over the country. I do not want to quote concrete examples. We are talking business, and a particular example, for a good many reasons, might not work out. It is obvious that if agriculture is to become industrialised at all—and it must become industrialised in a great many directions—that the possibility of having power not only in Dublin or in Limerick or in the twenty-thousand-inhabitant towns, but if necessary in the recesses of the country, is going to be a tremendous advantage.

We are urged to give this scheme very careful examination. We are told that it should be criticised in every detail. We are told that the whole future of the country, in one way or another, may depend upon it. We get that good advice from all quarters, and we agree with it. But, as Deputy Professor O'Sullivan pointed out yesterday, this scheme has got incomparably more criticism and incomparably superior criticism to any other scheme ever put before the Dáil. There is no doubt whatever about that. We all welcome criticism. Deputy Professor Tierney was, I think, a little misunderstood to-day. He, too, welcomes criticism. He made that quite clear. The extraordinary thing about this scheme is that the scheme has obviously got no attention and no examination of any kind from the wise men and the people of sense who were advising us to pause, to hesitate, and to give the scheme the most elaborate and careful criticism. I know a certain amount about the scheme as a layman, and I would be able to judge somewhat of the merits of particular points raised. But I must say that if I am to take seriously the criticism that this scheme has got in the Press and by the Press—criticism through letters, through reports from various organisations and criticism by the Press itself—then, I can only come to one conclusion, if I wish to be charitable—that is, that the people criticising this scheme have never paid it the compliment of examining it or examining the report of the experts. That is the only conclusion, if you wish to be charitable. You can come to other conclusions if you like, but the most charitable explanation of some of the criticism which I have seen of this report in the Press and by the Press is that the authors did not think it worth their while to read it, while at the same time impressing upon this "young and enthusiastic Government" the importance of Festina lente. Deputy Heffernan made the same point, that we should have this report examined carefully, and, as I say, I agree with him.

As I say, I agree with him. He suggested something like the procedure at a Private Bill Committee: that the experts should be cross-examined. The Deputy's suggestion was that these experts should be brought in and cross-examined by other experts on this scheme in the same way as experts are examined before a Private Bill Committee. I know what happens with these experts. They are briefed on each side. One side gets up and makes certain statements, and, of course, the experts on the other side contradict what has been said. That is what happens in every legal case, and that is exactly what we are saving Deputy Heffernan from. We asked the greatest firm of engineers in the world for this kind of work to put up a scheme. We then picked out four men of outstanding European reputation, not to defend the scheme, but to advise the Executive Council judicially as to the merits of the various points in the scheme. We will not get close to each other unless it is accepted that these experts were, first of all, men of outstanding reputation in their profession, and that they came into the scheme not to defend it or to condemn it, but to examine it judicially. That is the fact and that is what has happened.

While you can understand the point of view that experts—that point of view has been put up here in the Dáil —are always biassed, I suggest to Deputies that they ought to remember, when dealing with these particular gentlemen, that they are dealing with profound scholars and scientists, with men who have spent their lives not in commercial occupations but in the pursuit of pure knowledge for its own sake. That is their standing in the scientific world, and you must realise that. When you are criticising them, you must make up your mind as to whether these are the sort of men that should be brought before a special committee to be cross-examined by various parties holding various briefs. You have to ask yourself this: whether a firm like Messrs. Siemens, whether men of that sort of experience, men whose opinion is sought after in every centre of enlightenment in Europe, would forget, for instance, to consider the strength of the embankments or to go into a question like the nature of the subsoil, or that they would neglect to go into the various footy points that the ordinary engineer goes into when preparing a contract for, say, a body like Town Commissioners. That is really all I have to say.

Your best guarantee of the soundness of the scheme put forward is the reputation of the contractors who are undertaking the work and the reputation of the men who have given it their approval. That is the best guarantee you can have, and a delay in examination of the usual kind which we are used to, in connection with schemes in this country, would not give you anything comparable to, or anything that could be substituted for, that sort of guarantee. That is the position. In any event the Government are quite satisfied, and rightly satisfied, with these men, and they will have to be given some better reasons for delay than the argument that has been adduced up to the present. I am extremely glad indeed that this scheme is to be proceeded with immediately. I do think, if it were nothing else, this scheme will give this country an image and a picture of how great things are done by great countries. It will give the country something to think about besides the little sordid personalities and jealousies and so on that have been masquerading under all sorts of guises during the last two or three years here. It will be good for this country to see a firm like Messrs. Siemens in the centre of the country carrying out a big and a great undertaking and carrying it out in the way that things are done in great countries—in countries that have become great, and that have made a name for themselves, not only in their material but in their spiritual and mental work.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce invited Deputies to direct their discussion on this motion to the report, and to specific points in the report. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture has invited criticism, and, I believe, the Government, as a whole, invite fair criticism. I am anxious to give fair criticism, and I want to be fair—as fair as Deputy Good was—in every sense of the word. I regret that more Deputies in the Dáil did not accept the invitation of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. To my mind, much of this debate is taken, on one side, in support of the amendment of Deputy Connor Hogan, simply as a request for delay without giving reasons for it, and as a request for an appeal to more international experts. On the other side, there is a misapprehension of what I believe to be the position of the proposer and seconder of this amendment—namely. the imputation to them of opposition to the Shannon scheme. Now, I would like to make my own position in the matter perfectly plain from the very start, and then to proceed to justify it. I do not feel that I can support the amendment of Deputy Connor Hogan. I do not want more international experts brought into criticise the international experts we have had, and I am entirely in favour of the Shannon scheme. If Deputies remember the remarks I made after the Minister for Industry and Commerce introduced this scheme on the 19th December last, they will recollect, I think, that I am as much attracted by the glamour of the Shannon scheme as anyone. I am absolutely all out for development, and I say, let us have it. But we are asked to-day to go a little further, very much further: We are asked, not to say that we want the Shannon scheme, or to say that we want the Shannon scheme in preference to the Liffey scheme. If we were, I would say, let us have the Shannon scheme in preference to the Liffey scheme, and let us go over the whole country rather than over a section of it. What we are asked to say is, that we must take this particular Shannon scheme, with all its engineering specifications and details, and bind ourselves to it. The Minister will correct me if I am wrong, but what we are asked to do is to bind ourselves to this particular method of carrying out the Shannon scheme. It is there that I begin to find myself in difficulties.

I do not think I should be doing my duty in this House if I did not endeavour to put as much knowledge as I have at the absolute disposal of Deputies. I have no interests to serve in this matter at all. I am not an engineer, though I may have a good deal to do with the training of engineers. I can, therefore, claim to speak, to a certain extent, with some knowledge on a scheme of this kind, and I do not think I should be acting rightly if I did not acquaint the Dáil absolutely with the conclusions at which I have arrived after as much study as I could give to the scheme in the time at my disposal. I hope the House will bear with me while I try to put them in possession of the conclusions I have arrived at. I may become somewhat technical in the statement I have to make, but in doing this I am accepting the invitation of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and I therefore intend to go into certain details of the report. I want, in the first place, to see if I am correct myself, and if I am to put Deputies in possession of what the full scheme really means, and as to what possibilities of power it holds out to the country. In that connection, I desire, first of all, to draw the attention of Deputies to the table opposite page 102 in the experts' report, to which the Minister referred. I want to state what I understand from that table, and if I am not right the Minister will correct me. If I am right as to what the table means, then I want Deputies to understand it, too, because in this matter I cannot find myself in complete agreement with Deputy Johnson. We are not having this scheme put before us as a State scheme in so far as it is to be financed by State money.

We are having this put to us as a commercial proposition, and we have got to justify it as a commercial proposition. We have to see that there are in the scheme full possibilities, what those possibilities are, to what extent they can satisfy the demands of the country, and to what extent if the country will develop, as I hope it will, this scheme can pay for itself. We are not being asked to vote money for it from the State. In the request I am going to make to the Government I shall urge upon them that in the attempt to make this a commercial proposition, to make absolutely sure that the first step we take in the development of the country shall be a step forward and not a false step, and one which, if false, will retard the development of the country for a generation, they should be absolutely assured, as far as human beings can be, that the step they are taking will work out successfully for the development of the country. A few weeks spent more or less in satisfying themselves as to its soundness from the engineering point of view and the commercial point of view will not be waste time and will not expose them or those who ask for it to the imputation that they are throwing back this question for ten years or anything of that kind, but that it will simply let the people know, for one thing, that the Government is determined to take every step humanly speaking they can to satisfy themselves that the scheme is engineeringly and commercially sound before it asks for public support for it. Now, I wish in connection with these tables to draw Deputies' attention to what apparently is going to be promised by the Shannon scheme in a dry year, in a year of average rainfall, and in a wet year, and to ask Deputies to satisfy themselves that they fully understand what the proposed scheme means in the future.

Before I quote figures I think perhaps it is worth while spending a little time, I will not be long, on the technical point of view, in explaining how I approach this myself, and then asking Deputies to approach it that way. I take Mr. Chaloner Smith's figures. I take his rainfall for the last 30 years. I notice how the rainfall fluctuated. I took his calculations and I checked them as to the average total quantity of the flow that can be secured if we were able to completely store all the water that fell in a year, all the excess rain in a wet year, so as to set a balance against the fall occurring in a dry year. The upshot of that is that that average flow would amount to something between 8,000 and 9,000 cubic feet per second, and that if you were able to store all the water so that you could count on that, it would mean allowing, which is very nearly the case, fifty million units for every 1,000 cubic feet on a fall of 100 feet, very nearly four hundred and fifty million units per year if you were able to make use of the whole flow by storing up in the wet years and keeping that excess for the dry years. But, as Mr. Chaloner Smith himself points out in the discussion of this report before the civil engineers, to do that you would require eight million acre-feet of storage, and that would be equivalent to from 68 to 69 feet in depth over 136 square miles of lake and river surface in the Shannon above Killaloe. The Government, to get the average they count on of between four and five hundred million units, would have to be able to store up the whole losses, assuming no loss by evaporation, in a wet year to balance a dry year, and then they could count upon that for the average power— about 400 million units to the year. That 68 or 69 feet of rise in the river, at Lough Derg, is not a thing that we can regard as a possibility. It is not touched, or anything like it, in this scheme. I will give, in a moment, what the storage in this scheme really does. It practically does not affect that aspect of the question. It does not at all secure for you that in the average year you can count upon that average amount of electricity for a year, that is 400,000,000 units. It does not secure that for you at all. It practically means that in any particular year you could count upon the minimum.

You may have more, you may have an average amount, and you may have an excess amount. Moreover, what you are going to have you will not know until it comes, because it depends upon the rainfall. You can again have a minimum, and that minimum flow, instead of being a flow of between eight and nine thousand cubic feet per second, is a flow of about six thousand cubic feet per second. You can depend upon getting 260,000,000 units per year, and that is the utmost amount of electricity that you can count upon getting from this scheme if developed to the very fullest. You may count, if you can arrange for, the selling of 260,000,000 units; you may have more, but you will not know until you get it. But what chance will there be of selling it if it comes suddenly, and you do not know it is coming beforehand? It simply means that you will not know what to do with it, because there is not the customer handy to whom you can sell it. That is taking the matter up from the first point of view—namely, the average that you can count upon per year, but unfortunately that does not settle the question from the engineering point of view. You must take that flow, and consider how it is distributed throughout the year, and that is where the question of storage comes in as dealt with in this scheme. In this connection the engineers approached the matter from the point of view of what the demand for their output is likely to be, and they have found, favourably for us in that connection, that the demand in summer is very much less than in winter. That is very favourable for us, because, of course, our supply in summer is also much less than it would be in winter. But it is very much less, and in order to secure that there should be available in the summer the supply that would be required if the demand rose as the engineers hope it would rise they had to provide themselves with this additional storage so as to equalise the flow, and to get enough flow in the summer in order to meet the demand. I think I am right in understanding the remarks of the Minister in this connection, and my interpretation of them is rather different from the way that Deputy Johnson understood them, and I hope the Minister will check me if I am wrong. He used some words which, to my mind, indicated that he was going on the basis of the dry month in the dry year, but he did not at all indicate that the total number of units proposed to be supplied in the year was calculated for the whole year as a certain number of times the flow that would take place in the dry months of the dry year. What I understood him to mean was that he took the supply for the dry months as meeting the demand in the dry months, and that along with that he took the increased demand in the winter months, and matched that off with what he knew would be available—namely, the increased supply in the winter months. And, therefore, his estimate of 115,000,000 units as consumed in the year being based on a dry month as a start was quite right, but it did not at all mean that he took the total supply as determined by the amount that came down in the dry month in a dry year, because the supply fluctuated very much with the demand in that respect. Now, taking that does not even exhaust the extra supply that occurs in the wet months, and that is where this additional 50,000,000 units comes from that the Minister said would be available in the winter months, and which it is proposed to deal with in this report by means of seasonal industries.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The extra 50,000,000 units was for the wet months corresponding to 1905, and 50,000,000 units of the average was for 1905.

Comment on this

Quite true. That was the point I was coming to, but taking the average year you would have a total flow a great deal more than that in the minimum year. If you had a minimum flow you would have an excess, but if you had an average year, instead of a total flow of between five and six thousand feet you would get a total of between eight and nine thousand feet, which would give you a total maximum number of 260,000,000 units instead of 165,000,000 units to which the Minister referred. That is the point, I think the Minister wished to make. What do we understand as a matter of fact by this average year? Many of us, I think, would probably be ready to say that in an ordinary year you may expect that, and you will have that amount of electricity still. But it does not mean that at all. It means that making that mathematical calculation spread out over a certain number of years, adding up the whole flow and dividing by that number, you get that figure. If you take the whole rainfall over 30 years you will not find a single year in which the flow was that amount. In about half you will find it appreciably above and in the other half appreciably below. Taking the whole thirty years, you will find that about ten, or perhaps a little more— somewhere between ten, twelve and thirteen is my calculation—will bring you pretty close to the average. For a large number of years you might get the full excess, and then for a considerable number of years you would have a good deal less.

The average year in this report does not mean at all the year that you may expect. That is quite a different thing. The average year in this report means what you would get year in and year out. If you were able to check the full excess in a wet year, and then check it in a dry year, it would be different but you cannot do that. The total amount of electricity you can count on getting from this scheme is not 400 million units, as might be gathered from the statement. I do not think it was ever intended it should be. It will be more like 260 million units. You may have, quite unexpectedly, far and away more than that. You may have, perhaps, twice that output, and possibly more. But you will not know you have it until the period comes.

The object which I have set before myself in getting up is that I want to try to show that the scheme requires more investigation. The very report of the experts requires a certain amount of technical knowledge before it can be accurately understood. I understood the Minister to say—and I think I was right in so understanding him—that he himself had been hampered since last December by not being able to spend money on the investigation of this report. I quite appreciate that he must have been. I put this to the Dáil: we should set the Minister absolutely free; we should empower him to spend all the money that he pleases—I go so far as that—in testing this scheme in any way that the Government may think desirable. We should empower him to spend what money the Government pleases in getting any expert or other information that they like, in whatever way they like, whether they choose to get it tested by people here with technical knowledge—I do not call them experts —or in any other way. They should put the matter to the fullest test, and spend money in so doing, so that they could be completely satisfied as to the soundness of the scheme, and so that they shall be advised by those who do know whether the scheme is completely sound or not. I took up the report with a certain amount of knowledge, and I come across repeatedly—I do not know how often—statements, some of which have already been referred to in the Dáil.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Before Deputy Professor Thrift leaves the last argument, am I to take it that he is arguing that on the full development you can only look for a 175 million output?

Comment on this

Yes, for certain —the fullest development.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The fullest development?

Comment on this

Yes, for certain. I have not gone at all into the matter technically. I do not want to be too technical; in a debate of this kind one cannot be technical. The only way one can satisfactorily debate a thing of this kind is over a table when you would have figures and facts to go upon, and you could then debate it in a close way. As far as I can understand, I am convinced that you can count upon getting, with complete development, about 260 million units. You may be suddenly faced with having at your disposal over twice that quantity. In an average year you will be getting 400 million units instead of 260 million; but you do not know when the average year is about to come. You can, however, be certain on having 260 million units.

The full storage capacity, as proposed in the full scheme set forth here, is based by taking the demand curve, as it is called, considering what the demand will be in the summer and in the winter, and making up the total power required to meet it. That is balanced by means of your storage, and that is where the second average comes in. By this increased storage you can balance your flow throughout the year in such a way as to get over the great difficulty which occurs in the curve in summer, when the flow is very small. You can meet the demand in the summer and the increased demand in the winter by means of that storage; but when you do that, taking the experts' curve, it simply means that you are providing power which is produced on a flow of a little over four thousand feet instead of 5½ thousand feet, which occurs in the minimum year. What do the experts propose to do by means of this storage? Because of the fact that there is such a drop in flow in summer, they can only propose to meet with a comparatively small demand in summer, and that is the meaning of such a paragraph as you will find in the report.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Page 26?

Comment on this

Page 109—"The National Supply must not only limit, by suitable clauses in the contracts, the maximum power to be used by the large consumers, but they must also limit for every month of the year the amount of energy (units) which the consumers may use." It would not do if you had too great a demand in the summer. Even the storage proposed in the later scheme will only give a limited supply in the summer, because the flow is so small, and it will be found that the total power sold then with that storage does not correspond with the total flow that occurs in a dry year. It only corresponds with the flow of 4 thousand feet instead of the minimum flow of 5½ thousand cubic feet. The scheme does not propose to use, and it could not use, the whole flow unless you are able to utilise the storage to a far greater degree than is either commercially or engineeringly possible. I was about to put forward the reasons for which I claim, in specific points, that this report requires further consideration. I am prepared, as I say, to leave it absolutely to the Government as to how they will give it that further consideration. Let them satisfy themselves in any way they please, on the specific point, that the scheme is sound and will be a paying proposition. Let them not be hampered by any restrictions as to money. Give them a free hand.

I ask the Government not to ask us to-day to commit ourselves to agree to a scheme in which we are bound to engineering details, as I take it we will be doing if we agree to this scheme. If we pass this resolution that the Government asks us to pass, we are bound to engineering details and to the scheme put up by Siemens-Schuckert in that form. I say that you have only to read this report with some comparatively small technical knowledge and you will see—over and over again you will come across a place—where the experts in their report say they want further information. I say you should get that information. Go to further expense if necessary and let them satisfy themselves. The time that will be taken up in so doing will not be waste time. It will be time well spent, and quite possibly it may result in securing further support for the scheme.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Does the Deputy say that there is any part of the report in which the experts stated that further information is necessary before partial development could be proceeded with?

Comment on this

That is not quite clear. I will read one or two passages that I have in mind. "At all other places, when peat was at all present, it was in very small quantities. From this it follows that the construction of embankments on the Shannon river between Lough Derg and Lough Rea in all probability should cause no difficulties." That refers to later developments.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Apart from that, does it not refer to a point that will be attended to by engineers working out the scheme? It will not be laymen who will be working out the scheme.

Comment on this

True; but suppose the engineers, when they come to work out the scheme, find that the thing is a matter of very great difficulty, it will then be too late to mend your hand without landing yourself in enormous costs. You would want to know your costs before you undertake a scheme of this magnitude. It will not do to undertake the scheme believing that everything will be all right and that it is going to cost you, say, five millions or six millions, and then you find that it will cost you about twice as much.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Not twice as much. Ten per cent. of an addition is allowed on the costs of the civil constructional part.

Comment on this

In view of the engineering difficulties which arise in schemes of this kind, difficulties of a very serious character which may arise say in the foundations of your embankments, does the Minister really think the ten per cent. margin is sufficiently safe to meet the serious possibilities of that kind in a huge scheme of this sort?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I say simply this, that when the experts who discovered these difficulties say that a 10 per cent. addition to the cost is a reasonable addition, for such contingencies, I am prepared to accept that.

Comment on this

I do not think they have said that in this connection.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

See page 80.

Comment on this

You read on the very next page: "Thus the material for the embankment can be got by dredging, but the experts would nevertheless point out that the choice of the spot for dredging is one for particular care and will require further borings." It is just the kind of thing which you meet in an expert's report, when they want to be extremely careful lest things turn out differently from what they expect. It is not guaranteed by any means. It is a sort of danger signal in the report when you really read it carefully. I think Deputy Johnson already drew attention to one very important point. He drew attention, I think, to the end of page 20, where some of the experts have this very vague statement: "The material available does not appear unsuitable for embankments as it is water-tight. On the other hand, it is not resisting enough to withstand the attack of flowing waters." One would want something a great deal more definite than that before one binds oneself to a scheme of this kind.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Will the Deputy continue? Read on.

Comment on this

Certainly. I do not want to be unfair. I had better read the whole thing: "Therefore special protection is judged necessary for the bottom of the canal, as also for the slopes where they do not lie in rocks. This point will be further referred to in the constructional section." I do not think, however, it is completely dealt with in the constructional section; there is certainly nothing definite in that connection. I am only giving him my opinion.

Comment on this

The Deputy is misunderstanding the point I made. I referred to the paragraph which said that the materials are capable of resisting the pressure of the embankment. My point was that the materials referred to are capable of resisting the pressure of the embankments but that Sir John Griffith had raised the question and I thought for the purpose of reassuring a timid public that point should be made.

Comment on this

I did not quite understand that that was the reason that the Deputy raised this matter. I thought the Deputy was objecting, as I am, to the very vague way in which approval is given to these embankments. The sand appears to be somewhat too fine: that is a very vague statement, indeed.

Comment on this

It points out that the sand would not necessarily be used. There are clay, sand and gravel.

Comment on this

Quite. My point is simply this. I do want to go into technical matters, but going through the report it makes me come to the conclusion over and over again that the experts really wanted more time to consider this scheme, and is not that quite natural? You bring experts over from a country where conditions are completely different to those obtaining here. No matter how good they may be it is impossible for them to achieve the task you set them. In two months you expect them to familiarise themselves with the conditions, climatic engineering, and economic, and everything else over here. You expect them to familiarise themselves with all these conditions, to go into all the details of a huge scheme of this sort and to present their final report in two months. That is all you gave them. Is it reasonable? No matter what kind of men they may be, they could not do it. Can one wonder if one comes across in their report instances from which it is perfectly obvious that they have been pressed for time? Can one criticise them because, for example, in the case of Lough Rea, they made only four borings? Would any engineer guide himself by four borings for an area of that kind? One does not criticise the experts because they had not the time available.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is a construction which will not be likely for ten years.

Comment on this

I merely take that to illustrate it. There are several other points. I am quite ready to be convinced on them as I am on the whole matter. I am quite ready to be convinced, and, if I am satisfied, to give such support as I can to the scheme. I am merely taking up the attitude that I will not agree to the scheme, without further information. I am open to conviction, if you like to put it that way. I take both the Minister's remarks in this connection and the report in this connection. I am not quite satisfied that sufficient attention has been paid to drainage. The Minister's remarks on this point were very complete from one aspect: that is so far as sudden flooding is concerned, that will be avoided. That is perfectly right; it is completely satisfactory in that respect. The effect of any rise in the level by means of these embankments must be to diminish the sudden flooding, provided the embankments are quite strong enough and high enough. You will certainly do one thing by raising the level of the surface of the river—prevent sudden flooding. That is not the whole thing. I ask the members of the Dáil—I hope I am not too technical; I have tried not to be—they can all follow this—what is the effect of raising the level? It applies principally, I admit, when you come to the later development. It is really impossible to consider the partial development without an eye also to later development. Even to partial development it applies also. What have you got at present? You have got the lands on each side of the Shannon drained into the Shannon. They consist very largely of pear: that is prevented from becoming bog by the fact that the lands drain into the Shannon. You propose to raise your level so that instead of the drainage occurring from the land into the Shannon it will occur from the Shannon back into the land. You stop the sudden flooding at the expense of making the land lower than the river level, and instead of the lands draining into the river you have the river draining into the lands. Now, the report deals with that to a certain extent. It refers in a vague way to the use of pumps, and says that that will be avoided by pumps. No doubt wherever a pump is acting it will counteract all that, but then you will have a huge stretch of land affected by rainfall. You will have the gradual effect of the rainfall tending to produce a bog, instead of sudden flooding putting the land out of action altogether. Can anybody be completely convinced without investigation as to the way that big change in our topographical conditions—that big change by which you are setting the river to be drained into the land, instead of draining the land into the river—will not produce a complete change in the topography of that district? It requires a lot of investigation. At best, it will mean that the pumps, provided for by this scheme, will have to be supplemented, for each farm along the banks, by drains to get rid of the surface water on every farm adjoining the river. I say it has not been gone sufficiently into in this report. Even the Minister, in his very able speech, paid attention to the subject of sudden flooding, but I do not think he appreciated, when he was making that speech, this very serious change that is going to take place in the conditions of this district, due to the rainfall having nowhere to be drained, because the level of the Shannon is above what it was before.

One of the disappointing things, I must confess, about this report that struck me was the way in which it turned down the possibility of the application of this power scheme to electro-chemical industries. I had bright hopes that if we got the Shannon scheme going it would be likely to give that necessary impetus to the starting of electro-chemical industries which might have a very far-reaching effect on the prosperity of the country, particularly if the production of the power was backed up by the support that might be given by the Government to chemists and other scientists to enable them to carry out researches.

I must confess that I was disappointed by page 56 of the report:

The experts are, however, of opinion that the price for an electro-chemical industry laid down in the Siemens-Schuckert scheme of 0.35d. per unit could not at all be borne by that industry.

That looks very like—I do not say it is—saying that this scheme is not going to help the hydro-electric industry, unless the extra units can be more or less thrown in as a gift to that industry.

There are two or three other remarks made by the Minister to which I would like to draw attention. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture comes in in this connection to a certain extent, because he seemed to be perfectly satisfied with the Minister's figures, in which he tried to show that the supply would be met by the increased demand that would come in a few years on the assumption of normal progress, and also by the figures that the Minister gave of comparison between the Free State and a country like Denmark. I am afraid that the figures given by the Minister were not so satisfactory as the Minister for Lands and Agriculture thought. There is always a risk in dealing with figures from a mathematical point of view, particularly in averages, lest when you come to take the average of averages you get into a fallacy. I am rather disposed to think that the Minister's way of putting his calculation, namely, taking the number of units per head of the population, was rather leading him wrong. The proper way for him to put his calculation was on the basis of the total number of units used at present in the Free State, and the total number which might be expected in 1932, if normal progress took place. I think it would be a much safer basis of calculation. The Minister gave us figures of forty-one units per head of the population for ordinary purposes, and forty-two per head of the population for tramways. He applied to the forty-one fifteen per cent, increase, as mentioned by Mr. Kettle, and he left the tramways stationary. If you take fifteen per cent. for seven years at compound interest on the forty-one you more then double it. You bring it up to 100, and if you add the forty-two you get 142 per head of the population. He said what he wanted was something like 115 units per head of the population. Therefore, he said, we are perfectly safe, because 143 is far and away above the experts' estimate of 115. I am afraid that is very liable to be misleading.

I choose to take the total number of units at present. The total number is under fifty million units. I will take it in a less favourable way to myself. I will take thirty million for ordinary purposes and twenty million as applied to tramways. I apply to the thirty million the same increase as the Minister—fifteen per cent.—in which case it will more than double itself by 1932, and it will give you seventy million instead of thirty million. I add twenty million which is kept stationary for power, and I get ninety million units as the total, whereas there is wanted to be sold 153 million, I take it, at the power station, or 115 at the busbar, so that instead of that calculation putting you on the safe side, it leaves you rather under. It leaves you with only a demand for ninety million, whereas you have got 115 to sell. I think the difference arises from this, which, I say, also requires further investigation.

What does this scheme propose to do as regards population? At present in the three cities you have about half a million people more or less supplied. The scheme proposes to supply, if it can beat its competitors, that half million and also about another half million. That is, the total number of people in the Free State who will be able to draw on the electrical power, will be about one million people out of three and three-quarter millions in the Free State. That is all the scheme proposes in its widest extent. It will leave the power available to about one million people out of three and three-quarter millions. I say that is why this calculation on per head of the population is misleading.

I also fear it misleads the Minister when he comes to apply to the Free State any comparison with places like Denmark. I say we ought to know more before we can take Denmark as something with which to compare the Free State. We would want to know, what is the number of people in Denmark similarly situated with regard to, electrical supply that this million people will be in the Free State; whether the proportion who can draw on the electrical power in Denmark is like that which will be able to draw on it in the Free State if this scheme comes into being. If you can show that the conditions in that respect are really similar it will be a fair thing to say that you would actually have 55 per head of the population taking it in Denmark and 33 per head of the population in the Free State, if the whole 115 million units were distributed over the 3¾ millions. As a matter of fact, taking the people who are situate, so that they can draw on the supply if, they wanted it, you would have to divide 115 by one million, and not by three and three-quarter millions. That would mean you would want 115 units per head of the available population. That is really the figure required in making a comparison of this kind.

I am afraid I am tedious, but I do not want to do anything more than urge that there are details in this scheme which require real technical knowledge and technical investigation. The Minister seems to complain of being hampered. Let us remove that by all means and let us give the Executive Council a full and free hand to make every inquiry possible into the engineering details. Let them not say when we ask for that that we are really putting back the clock or trying to stop it. We are not. I contend strongly that we are only asking for what is a very small thing in connection with a very big scheme, a full and open public inquiry. When I say that I say it in a very general way. I am not asking for any public inquiry. I leave it to the Government to say how. Let us have a complete examination in some way of every point on which there is any doubt. I suggest there are points on which there is great doubt and that want further inquiry and investigation. Make use of the experts again if you like, but let us be satisfied about this fact, that it is going to be complete about this, that and the other. I think it is not going to increase the public confidence in the scheme if, after the Siemens-Schuckert Company's Report and the Experts' Report—even without any access to plans and maps—have been in the hands of some of us for about a fortnight, you should ask us definitely to commit ourselves to the scheme detailed in these reports.

Comment on this

Os rud é gur ceist í seo a mbéidh baint mhór aicí le séan na hEireann san am atá le teacht, sílim fhéin go mbadh cheart agus go mbadh chóir go ndéanfaidh cuid de-n chainnt i na thaobh as Gaedhilg. Táim go láidir ar thaobh na Tairisginte a chuir an t-Aire um Tionnsgail agus Tráchtáil ós ar gcomhair, mar táim cinnte go dtiocfaidh tairbhe mhór aistí don tír agus go mbéidh an tairbhe sin ag méadú agus ag leathnú fhad agus tá an t'am ag dul thart.

Nuair a bhí cuid againn óg, ag fóghluim tír-eolais dhúinn, bhíodh ríméad agus áthas orainn ag léigheadh faoi fhad agus leithead na Sionainne. Acht is ríméadaigh go mór a bhéas ag muinntir na h-Éireann as an abhainn leathain uasail sin, nuair a bhéas sí ag sgapadh soluis as fud na tíre. Shaoilfeá ó'n chainnt annseo san Dáil, agus ó'n méid atá ráidhte taobh amuigh di, go raibh féilméaraidhe, nó lucht tuaithe na tíre, i'n aghaidh aon dul ar aghaidh, gur daoine leisgeamhla, spadánta gan mhisneach gan mhaith, iad. Is mór an maslú é sin ar fhéilméaraidhe agus lucht tuaithe na h-Éireann agus níl maslú mar é tuillte aca i'n aon cor. Núair a chuir muinntir na h-Eireann gniomh rómpa a bhí níos mó ná an Tairisgint atá romhainn, úsáid a bhaint as uisge na Sionainne-sé sin, comhacht na Sasanach 'san tír seo, a bhriseadh— rinne na feilméaraidhe a gcionn féin san troid, agus thugadar a gcongnamh uatha go fonnmhar.

Tá daoine a chuirfeadh i gcéill gur ag lucht na mbailte mór a bhfuil intleacht na tíre uilig, agus nach fiú trumpa gan teangan baramhail mhuinntire na tuaithe. Is mór an dul amudha rud mar sin a rádh ná a cheapadh, mar is ins na gleanntaí uaigneacha, imeasg na gcnoc, atá le fághail na daoine is uaisle smaointe, agus is fearr inntleacht, i'n Eirinn. Tá na daoine seo ar thaobh na Tairisginte a chuir an t-Aire ó's ár gcomhair. Tuigeann siad nach bhfuil san tairisgint sin ach tús ar an bhfás atá ag tigheacht 'un cinn san náisiún Gaedhealach seo—fás nach dtiocfadh innti fhad a's bheadh lámh isteach ag an Sasanach i n-gnóthaigh na hEireann.

Comment on this

In the few words that I have to say in support of Deputy Connor Hogan's amendment, I want to make it perfectly clear that not a Deputy on these benches who has said anything in favour of the amendment has any thought of taking from the credit that is really due to the Executive Council for the work they have done in putting before the Dáil the scheme now under discussion. We have in mind also what we feel is the magnificent work of the Minister for Industry and Commerce both on this occasion and when he spoke of the scheme in the Dáil in December last. As far as possible, we want to remove the idea that some who are not now present tried to impress upon the Dáil, and probably the country, that Deputies on the Farmers' Benches were against the carrying of this scheme into effect. We are not. We are in sympathy with it, and I hope no body of men representing the farmers of this country in the Dáil at any time will ever stand up and, by act or word, say that they are against any scheme being carried into effect that will make for progress in this country. Accordingly what I have to say, while it may be accepted in one sense as being a criticism of the scheme and the policy, will not, I hope—and I have no desire that it should—be ever interpreted as opposition to the scheme. Whatever we may have said about this matter so far, or whatever action we have taken, we have no desire to be associated with certain people and certain criticism that is being applied to the scheme.

As to the point I wish to make, we have to consider, and I think at least it is our duty—whatever Deputy Egan's opinion may be about us as leader of the Farmers' Party on his side of the Dáil—to consider and express our point of view as to what the effect of the carrying out of the scheme will be on agriculture in Ireland I think we would not be discharging our duty to that industry if we did not take cognisance of the possible effect of the scheme on that industry. We must accept it, if the Shannon scheme is to be the declared policy of the Government, that the credit of this agricultural State will have to be pledged so that it may be put into operation. Very naturally the farmers of this country, in their present unfortunate condition, must ask what benefits will come to them through the operation of the Shannon scheme. They will ask also if the credit of the State at this period is to be pledged, and money obtained on the strength of it, can that money be used in any other way that will be more beneficial to the main industry of the State other than utilising it on the water-power of the Shannon? I would have liked to have had an opportunity of speaking before the Minister for Agriculture had his say, but I hope someone else on the Government benches will, if it is possible, make clear their policy with regard to agriculture and the possible effect of this scheme on our industry. I think we must expect it from reading the report and listening to the very able statement of the Minister that the power will be utilised in the principal towns, and our two or three cities. But the Minister at this stage holds out no hope, and rightly so, that the power obtained from the Shannon will be utilised, or can be utilised, by the farmers. I am sure we will be all in agreement with the Minister when he says that he hopes it will not be so for all time. But as far as we can see for the present, and for a good many years to come, it will not be possible for agriculture to avail of this power, except to a very limited degree, indeed. There is another point. We will be far away from the distributing stations. The cost of taking the power to our homes would, in almost every case, be prohibitive.

Deputy Johnson made the point that he rather chose to look on this scheme, or on the administration of this service, as he looks on the administration of the telegraph service. Exactly so. From my point of view, the Government managing this scheme, as it will be managed as a State administered concern, will manage it exactly as the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs runs the telegraph service. It is our complaint that this service, if it is not paying its way, calls upon us in common with the other taxpayers of the State, to bear the loss. We bear our proportion, perhaps an unfair proportion. Along with bearing what we consider an unfair proportion of the loss, if there is a loss in the running of this service, we have, if we utilise the service, and if we live a mile outside the town, to pay again, for the use of the service that is placed at the doors of the people in the towns and cities. It is our unfortunate fate to have to pay extra. I am inclined to the view that we would be perhaps in the same position when the time comes in this country that the farmer would desire to have the power of the Shannon made use of at his home. It is true that the Minister for Lands and Agriculture touched the very fringe of this. But all he was able to say was that he did not want to quote concrete examples of what use agriculture might make of it. Exactly. I am afraid he could not. I would like to have heard him make answers to the points I have made. We cannot forget, and I repeat it, if this resolution were passed and if the scheme operates, and the service is administered by the State, that beyond question it will be in the interests of the town and cities. I candidly admit that I cannot see at the moment what use or benefit may come to the farmers because of the fact that the waters of the Shannon have been harnessed. I do not want to make a point of that. But it seems to me to be the truth.

There is just another point. If it is to be a State administered service there must be the ambition that it shall pay its way. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs tries to cut down the postal service and to curtail it in order that it will pay running expenses. So it will be in the administration of this scheme. One way to ensure that the service will pay will be to extend it in directions where the power can be sold in bulk, where the cost of distribution will be small, and where there will be an encouragement to people to take it in. I can see that the administration of this service will, in the future, to a very considerable extent, dominate Government policy. I am inclined to think that it will drive the Government, perhaps, farther on the road towards protection. I am inclined to the view that in their ambition to make the service a success, commercially and otherwise, they will be inclined to see springing up here industries that will take their power in bulk in order that the service may pay. There is just one way of encouraging industries to spring up. That is being pursued to some extent at the moment, and that is a thing that we do not regard with any considerable pleasure. I mean those of us who sit on these benches do not regard with pleasure the methods that have to be adopted. The methods are to put on protective tariffs to enable these industries to be run here in a way that will make it possible for them to live and pay their way.

Is it not very likely that the administration of the service, to a certain extent, dominating Government policy here, will urge the Government further on the road to protection, and to protect certain industries that are not the main industries of the State? I know the Minister may argue that that will only come at the time when full development will be the accepted policy, when we will have power for sale that can be practically given away. It is something that we cannot shut out from our minds, recognising what the Government policy with regard to industries is at the moment. We have to take cognisance of it as to what may happen in the future. I would like to have some statement from the Minister on these two points that I have made. I have no desire to detain the Dáil, but the amendment that has been moved has given opportunities for debate and discussion that might not be otherwise afforded. I think, too, that there is a reason, and a very good reason, why the Government ought accede to the demand for a further inquiry. I said at the beginning that I, personally, and my colleagues, are not either in sympathy with or in agreement with the many critics, or with the criticism that has been offered on this scheme. Yet it is absolutely essential that you shall have the confidence of the country in your efforts to carry it through. The enthusiasm and the energy of the Ministry and the Executive Council are necessary. But where the credit of the State is to be called into operation as well, I feel that it is right that everyone who has anything to say to this scheme ought to be given an opportunity.

There is this report of the experts, and the statement has been made that there has been no opportunity of cross-examining the experts on the report they made. I am inclined to say to the Executive Council: "Throw open the doors. Let us bring the experts again, leave them to the people who have criticism to make, ask the people who are critics, and who have criticised this scheme in the Press and outside to put up a precis of the criticism that they have to offer."

If the Executive Council think that there is good reason and good ground for re-examination of the men who have made this report, it will not be misspent time. On the other hand, if there is not good weight and argument and reason in the points that these people make, as Deputy Connor Hogan has said, they will be confounded by the statements they make themselves. That is one way, from my point of view, to silence all this adverse criticism. Beyond doubt, rightly or wrongly, if an opportunity is not afforded those who are not satisfied with the project in many ways action can be taken that will be detrimental to the success of this scheme.

I do not think that in a project of such stupendous size as this any chances ought to be taken, and whatever the Government might be inclined to do we feel that as far as we could we have discharged our obligations. We have impressed on them the point of view that for the success of the scheme we are as desirous as any man on the Government benches. Give those who are not satisfied every opportunity to prove that the report is not sound, that the experts' conclusions have not been well founded. Give the country and all of us an opportunity to hear the pros and cons and to learn whether there is reason and sense in the statements that have been made. If we got an opportunity of coming to our own conclusions on the evidence that would be put before us we would be satisfied that everything possible had been done, that every possible precaution had been taken, and we could all stand behind the Ministry in the projection and carrying through of the scheme with confidence and faith, and could believe that it would be certain to be a success.

Comment on this

So much has been said in favour of this scheme that really I feel rather ashamed to rise in its support; it is like painting the lilyBut I do take the opportunity of saying something in support of it because I feel that it is such a wonderful gesture of faith on the part of the Government in the country's future that I think it should be made evident to the public that the Minister and the Ministry have the enthusiastic backing of this House for the scheme. Consequently I would like to add my voice to that volume of support which has made itself heard here for the Shannon scheme. I really am quite unable to understand the genesis of the opposition that has been shown and that is rising to a great volume outside this House, opposition which has manifested itself within the last few days. I cannot see why any men of goodwill, men whose only interest is the progress and the greatness of this country, can offer opposition to the scheme. The opposition in the House has been fading away as the debate went on. The Farmers' Deputies have been watering down their opposition until I think that Deputy Connor Hogan will soon be a general without an army. The opposition from other parts of the House has been timid, has not been strong, has being trying to damn the scheme with faint praise.

Deputy Professor O'Sullivan referred to what he very aptly termed the colonial mind in this country, the mind which has no faith in the future of Ireland, has no faith in her people, and in the strength and vision of our Government to see a scheme of this kind through, the mind which feels that we are not big enough to tackle big schemes, and that we are too lately out of leading-strings to mark out our own course in these matters. I do not think that to-day the country will give any backing to that type of mind in its opposition to this scheme, and I think it is unworthy at this hour of the day that men should be found to organise, as they evidently are organising, in the Press and outside this House a body of opinion to oppose what I consider the first step in the upward rise of the country to economic strength and greatness. I can understand the opposition that is represented by Deputy Figgis; they have in a measure a certain interest in this affair, and their opposition is quite understandable. They see the scheme only from one point of view, the point of view that is warped by the interests of the opposing scheme. But we cannot afford to allow any interests to stand in the way of national progress and consequently, though there may be a certain amount of hardship involved for the interests which are behind the other schemes, I think that we will have to disregard it and give the Minister a backing to go ahead with the greater scheme that will, in my opinion, revolutionise the whole face of the country.

Some suggestion has been made—I think it came from Deputy Egan—that these interests should be considered in the way of compensation. This must be looked at from a business point of view, and, while I admire the initiative and the courage of these people who are prepared to put money into the schemes that have been projected, I venture to think that they were not doing it altogether for their health sake, that they had, as all commercial concerns have, an eye to profits. All three of them cannot succeed; one only can succeed. If one succeeds it will be at the expense of the other two, so that in any event two-thirds of them were bound to lose whatever money they have put into the investigation or the undertaking. Consequently I do not see how any onus will lie on the Government to give consideration or compensation to these interests. If, as has been stated here—though I am far from convinced as to the truth of the statement—that encouragement was given to these people to proceed, it might be for the generosity of the Government to consider what might be done in the way of some set-off to those who might have gone ahead at a time when they misunderstood, from the correspondence that passed between the Government and themselves, the Government's future attitude. But I, for one, would say that it should be approached in a very limited way with regard to compensation.

The opposition, as I have heard it inside and outside the House, seems divided into two heads. A case is made against the capital expenditure. Surely a country like ours, where a section of the community could afford to amuse itself by the dissipation of millions' worth of property, and where the Government got backing and strength to deal with that destruction, that country will not now hesitate to back the Government in what I consider a very mild capital expenditure. That expenditure is really a gesture on the part of the Government, as I said in the beginning, of good faith in the country's future. It is a gesture which shows that the Government are taking the long view and the big view and that they have large and big ideas for the future of Ireland. It is a gesture which in another way is an indication of their appreciation of the measure of economic freedom which this country has secured under the Treaty. That capital expenditure is going to do something more than set the wheels of industry going in Ireland again. It is an expenditure which, by the very employment it would give and the activity it, would develop, would do a great deal to take the country out of the slough into which it has fallen. It will tend to the distribution of money and it will encourage others to follow the lead of the Government to invest their money in Irish undertakings.

I am not going to deal with the technical side of the scheme, because the Minister, in stating the case, has dealt ably and completely with the technical details, and it would be impossible for me to add anything to what he has said. I would like to deal with the side of it which appeals to those of us who are looking to see a revival of that hope and faith in the country which were shaken by the actions of those opposed to the Government. For years we thought and said that Ireland would do great things when she got her feedom. Now, at the very first step which our Government are taking we find organised opposition. I do not mind criticisms that are honest, decent and fair, but we find an organised and sinister opposition to this scheme making itself apparent in the Press, and apparent amongst the public in conversations which are heard in the streets and marts around the city. In this step the Government are doing something to start the country on the upward path. Yet we have this criticism which I call unfair, and which has been engineered and organised from some source or another, and I venture to think it has emanated from the colonial mind of which Deputy Professor O'Sullivan has spoken.

Deputy Figgis made a number of points, some of which were covered again in a very hesitating way by Deputy Professor Thrift. Deputy Figgis seemed to have his brief very well prepared. He spoke from it, and another Deputy read from the same text. He talked about the danger of the embankments from a spade thrust. I think of all the stupid criticism offered to the scheme that which appeared in the Press, and to which Deputy Figgis referred as a spade thrust destroying the embankments, was the most foolish and futile. A great deal has been said about the embankments. I think it has been pointed out here that these embankments, as projected, are the work of expert engineers, and that the formula to be used in their construction is one of more than twice the strength of that used in Switzerland, where the erection of such embankments is a matter of common practice.

The German formula, which is almost twice as strong as the Swiss, has been strengthened again. That is the strength of the embankments to be put up here. These embankments will fail if all modern technical experience fail, but if it stands these embankments here will also stand. I think that the attempt made to offer criticism of this scheme on the question of embankments is not honest or straight. Another point has been made about the danger of sabotage. I do not believe that we will have any sabotage in this country again for a very long time. Deputy Professor O'Sullivan dealt with that, and disposed of it completely, and I will say nothing further about it except that if we are to be assured about everything we do and have to get guarantees against such things as sabotage, and if every individual embarking on a commercial undertaking has to protect himself by having guarantees about such matters further than what ordinary wisdom and justice would indicate, I do not think there would be any progress and no big schemes would be undertaken in this or in any other country. It seems to me. from the type of opposition we have heard here in this House and outside it, that some men seem to have been missing their political kruschen and to have lost pep. They seem to be getting into a state of pessimism about the future. They talk about the poverty of this country, and it makes me feel almost anæmic to hear such talk. It is not a poor country. It is undeveloped, and its resources and riches are untapped. This is the first big step towards tapping them. To such pessimists I would say, let them take some tonic to give them hope in the future, and not to hold up their hands when schemes of this kind are projected which might commit the Government to an expenditure of more than a pound. Recently I came across a cutting from the "Philadelphia Public Ledger," and I find that Philadelphia is undertaking a scheme some— what similar to ours, and it will involve an expenditure of 52,000,000 dollars. It brings electric current right across the whole State of Pennsylvania, yet we hear dismal suggestions here about bringing power from the Shannon. It is no wonder that I speak about men missing their political kruschen. Another objection towards the scheme is based on the grounds of consumption. Surely no one thinks that there is a normal consumption of electricity in this country. Anybody who knows anything about the use of electricity in other countries knows that this country is abnormally low in its consumption, because in the small towns in the country there are not men of initiative and courage or of sufficient financial strength to put up the capital required for electrical schemes.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

took the chair.

Comment on this

If we had those throughout the country we would have electricity used where to day we have oil lamps and the penny dips. If electricity were available for the small towns and villages the consumption normally would be at least three times what it is. I have no patience whatever with the criticism delivered here of the calculations which the experts have made on the evidence of very expert people of the consumption for the current under this partial scheme. I believe we will be running the full peak load of this scheme long before the Minister anticipates, and that the demand on it will march concurrently with the carrying out of the lines to the various areas. We are not a backward people, and if we place at the disposal of the people anything in the way of modern development they will at once make use of the opportunity placed at their doors. I have figures here; they have been quoted perhaps in the Dáil before, to show the advance in the use of electricity that has taken place in other countries where opportunities have been offered to the people to take it. The calculations of the Minister are based entirely on domestic consumption, and he has taken no cognisance of, and does not include in his calculations, the possible demand that will be made from industry. I am not one of those who think that we should first have industries before we create a supply of power. I do not believe in that. I consider the criticism dishonest that has appeared in the Press recently as to the small percentage of power charges compared to overhead costs in any other undertaking. I believe that if the current is made available in the country you will find the small industries, at present unable to keep themselves going from lack of power, getting strength and extending, and new industries springing up, and that the demand will be not only from the domestic side, but advancing in proportion to the estimate made by the skilled engineers bringing the consumption up to the 110,000,000 units required, but that it will be doubled before 1932. I have not the faintest doubt of that, and I venture to prophesy that before that time. through the facilities that will be given to the people for the use of electricity, we will have more than doubled the demand that the Minister estimates as a minimum.

It is not to be assumed for a moment that the Government are going to wait on the mere natural increase. They will have to take steps to see that the advantages of the use of electricity are brought to the people's minds, and that by propaganda, personal canvass, and other means known to commerce of a progressive kind, the people will be induced to take advantage of the use of electricity, and that demand will be created, as it can be created, for all useful products of that kind. Drainage has been spoken of, and Deputy Professor Thrift made some point about the raising of the level of the river causing reverse action to take place, and that instead of the bog lands on the Shannon banks draining into the river the river will drain back on to the land. He suggests that this scheme requires more consideration because of this possible effect. I think if he refers to the experts' report he will find that it is they who have brought this possibility to light. They have taken cognisance, and have taken steps to secure against its occurrence; consequently it is only delaying action to hold up the scheme for examination on that point. It was raised by the experts and provided for by them in their report. When we consider the number of thousands of acres of land now flooded periodically or permanently that would be made available for cultivation by this scheme, I wonder that the Farmers' Party should offer any opposition to it. For this scheme provides a remedy for that flooding, and it will be automatically brought into effect through the carrying out of the scheme. Land would be drained and made available for agriculture. Deputy Egan referred to the saving that will be effected by getting power from the Shannon, by the reduction that will take place in the purchase of coal, and the effect that will have on our trade balance, for instead of sending money out of the country for coal we generate power from our waters, and that will be to the advantage of the whole commercial life of the country. I hope the opposition to this scheme will disappear, and that the Dáil will show its appreciation of the courage and the high purpose of the Executive Council in undertaking such a scheme; its appreciation of the very exhaustive way in which the Minister has gone into the details of the scheme, its possibilities and probabilities; and the extraordinary way he has kept together the whole threads of this vast undertaking, and in preparing the way for putting it into operation, immediately the House has given, as I know it will give, its endorsement of the scheme.

Comment on this

I welcome the introduction of this great Shannon scheme. I think it is a very great conception. It seems to me that it may realise what I have had as a sort of vision before me all my life, that is to say, a great number of industries re-established and established in Ireland, in addition to the staple industry of farming. "It is obvious, and always has been, that many industries could not be established here hitherto from the want of suitable coal. The development of electricity throughout the Free State will, to a great extent, free us from that incubus, and put us on a fair level with the great industrial countries of the world, so that we may deal on even terms with our neighbours.

As I know nothing whatever about the technical side of electricity, it really would be almost impertinent for me to talk on this subject at all, and I should not have thought of doing so but for the fact that in October, 1923, availing myself of an opportunity, I urged upon the Government to take up the Liffey scheme that was then being brought forward by three or four companies. I urged on the Government to take it out of their hands and make it a national scheme and to work it with a view to giving employment which was then much needed. I thought, too, that the Government would be more careful to preserve beauty spots, which are an asset to the country, than any private company would be which had nothing but private gain to consider. As between that scheme and this, there is no comparison. This is undoubtedly a great conception, and I am sure all the world are looking out to see what we shall do about it. I think we shall either rise to the highest point or fall to the lowest depths according as we act by this scheme.

It has been said that there has been no enthusiasm about the Shannon scheme in the country. I think that, considering its vastness, the criticism that has appeared is not at all unfavourable. Moreover, there have been resolutions passed by very important bodies approving of it. For instance, I read a resolution from Limerick the other day that expressed the most hearty approval of it in every way. As regards the other scheme that has been before the country, I do not think a single voice has been raised in its favour. The boards in the country have torn it to pieces. The riparian owners, with the exception, I think, of myself, did likewise. Of course, you must consider what may be the opinion of the people behind all these things. I said everyone was against it. But a man— I think he was a constituent of Deputy Wilson—came up to me at the fair at Naas and said: "When is the Government going to take up the Liffey scheme?" I said: "I do not think the Government are going to take up the Liffey scheme. There has been no enthusiasm shown by the country and no meetings have been held in favour of it. If they favour it, they should hold meetings and send resolutions to that effect to the Government." He said: "I attended meetings; I am strongly in favour of it, and I voted against anything being done." This man and many others voted against the scheme, and yet they were in favour of it. Such a mentality is difficult to understand.

There are several points of view which make me favour this scheme tremendously, and I am sure it appeals in the same way to the people of the country. When even the partial scheme is developed, it ought to give a vast amount of employment to the youths of the country who have no taste for farming. When these industries, which we hope will be re-established and established, come about, there will be a place for the restless spirits of the country who are not content with the monotony of farming. A lot of farmers' sons abominate farming, and those who hate farming emigrate or go about doing nothing. I hope in those industries there will be a place for such young men. For the farming industry I think there are vast vistas opened up by this scheme. I think even with partial development a vast improvement ought to be possible in the carrying out of farming work. Take, for instance, one thing—the drying of hay. What we suffer in a wet season everybody knows and the difficulty of getting one's hay in proper order at any time most farmers understand. If this electricity comes within a reasonable distance of any farmer who really takes an interest in his work, I think he will not be long in making use of it for this purpose and also for dairy work and other things. If we become to some extent an industrial country—I hope we will not become that altogether and that we will not kill our primary industry—I hope and believe that by the energy we show in taking up and working these additional industries and by the energy we show in establishing those works, we may offer an inducement to our hard-headed brethren in the North, who respect hard work and successful work, to come in. I think that is a thing worthy of being considered, and I am sure that the advantages that will accrue to us will weigh with those hard-headed people.

In the Shannon district itself there ought to be a great improvement brought about by this scheme. Drainage, which has been a very vexed question for many years, ought to be improved vastly even by the partial scheme. Shipping, as far as I can understand, will be facilitated considerably by the scheme, too. The only thing I see which has not been dealt with very fully so far is the fishing industry, and even that may not be so much affected by the scheme as one might imagine at the first glance. Even if it were, so great will be the advantage to the country of this scheme that the fishing industry, great as it is, will be as nothing in comparison with it. With respect to the dangers of the scheme, the bursting of embankments has been mentioned. It seems to me that the dangers in connection with the Shannon scheme are far less than the dangers in connection with the Liffey scheme. I know something about Poulaphouca, and I know pretty well that a dam there would want to be of very strong construction. Suppose a dam did burst—as happened in Italy— it would be a serious matter for Ballymore-Eustace, Newbridge, Kilcullen and Celbridge, as it would practically sweep them away. If the dam at Lough Derg burst, I do not think damage to that degree could be caused, since it is not proposed to raise the reservoir very much higher than the highest level it can presently reach.

I think, taking all those things into consideration, that the advantages to the country will be so great that there ought to be no delay in pushing forward with the utmost speed this scheme. I do not believe in the proposal to get together another committee of experts. We should be no further advanced after we got their report. We would be only more mixed up, and it would be a useless waste of money. I think the scheme ought to go forward at once. The Government have got the opinion of the best experts in the world—all from outside Germany—and I do not think, even if they did get more opinions, that there would be any great advantage derived from it. I hope the work will proceed as quickly as possible.

Deputy Connor Hogan has an amendment on the Paper. That amendment has only got behind it the desire, as far as I can see, to delay the scheme. To take a phrase out of Deputy Connor Hogan's dictionary, I refuse to be the vocal medium of the policy of procrastination. I desire that this scheme go forward without any further delay. I think that at last we have got to the time when there is some hope that the day long looked for is breaking for Ireland, and that before long a spirit of contentment will be shared by everybody in this old land of ours, so that we may settle down to work, and work energetically.

Comment on this
James Cosgrave Mr. JAMES COSGRAVE Independent

I am one of the few Deputies here who do not believe in speech-making. I believe more in work than I do in talk. But I do not wish to give a silent vote on this matter. The Minister, in his opening statement, referred to criticism of this scheme by people from Portumna. As the place mentioned happens to be in my constituency, I know the people to whom he referred. I can assure him that he need not be in the least annoyed by such critics, because they represent nobody in that district except the few remaining links of landlords and graziers in East Galway and North Tipperary. The poor people in East Galway, whom I have the honour to represent here, and whose lands are flooded for six months of the year, welcome this scheme. Why should they not? It will do away with floods, in my opinion, for all time. The Callow lands from Whitegate, in Country Clare, to Banagher, in King's County, and from Banagher to Ballinasloe, in East Galway, have been all flooded for the past twelve months, the result being that 99 per cent. of the hay crop was completely lost. Worse still, the green crops of the poor people were lost and forty families were routed out of their homes by floods. The people to whom I refer are to-day in miserable poverty. I reported this state of affairs to the Government, but nothing has been done up to the present. Now that something is about to be done, is the Government going to be prevented from putting the Shannon scheme into operation? In my humble opinion, it is the best scheme, so far as the poor people are concerned, that has ever been introduced in this country. It will drain the land, it will open up employment, and, by giving the people employment, it will take them from poverty and misery to prosperity and happiness. My advice to the Minister and to the Government is to hammer away at this scheme might and main, and to give no heed to the critics.

Comment on this

Even at the risk of being charged with possessing a "colonial mind," and various other things, I venture to take part in this debate, because it seems to be the fashion for everybody to speak on this subject. I would like to assure the Minister that I am not coming forward in any critical or obstructive mood. I want to put certain questions to him, to which I hope he will supply answers when he is winding up the debate. I would like to know who selected these experts and what information was available about their international reputation. I would take the case of a man who is about to have an operation performed. which may mean life or death. That man will naturally want the best surgeon available—a specialist in his job. Does he go to Tom, Dick or Harry and ask him for the surgeon's name, or does he go for information to a medical man who, he knows, ought to know? How did we come to put all our dependence upon these experts? We must assume that there were some engineers behind the Minister in this matter, but we have had no evidence of that so far.

I think the Minister is to be congratulated on the way he brought this scheme forward. At the same time, that is more a tribute to the Minister's ability in debate than it is to the merits of the scheme. I venture to say that if the Minister came here to-morrow to prove that black was white, he would pretty well succeed in doing so. One of the things mentioned about these experts was that they were over and above "the commercial mind," that they were men who had spent their lives in the pursuit of knowledge. I do not think that is the type of man whose advice we want. We want the man who has spent his life in the pursuit of money to advise us as to whether our scheme is going to be a financial success or not. Deputy Heffernan raised a point about the cross-examination of experts, and I thoroughly agree with him. You have had this scheme put before these experts. They were put in the position of judges. But they only heard one side of the case. Can their judgment be sound?

Practically no Deputy touched, to any extent, on the fishery question. I am not in a position to do so, and I regret very much that the Minister for Fisheries is not here, because his help on this occasion would be extremely useful. It is to be assumed that if the fisheries on the Shannon—a very valuable asset—are destroyed, that compensation will have to be paid to several parties. I do not for a moment suggest that the fishery question should hold up the development of the country. But we must take into account, amongst other things, the money that will have to be paid to people who have rights in these fisheries. The question of drainage has been largely discussed, and I only desire to point out that this arrangement of pumps and syphons and side-drains would require a tremendous amount of examination— much more than it has got from any Deputy who has spoken. As regards the experts' view on these fisheries, I would refer you to Page 46 of the report. I think that to anyone who knows even a little about fisheries, that is not a very good criterion of the experts' ability in this matter.

Another point I would like the Minister to deal with is the question of existing stations. How is it proposed that these stations should be dealt with? The Minister must be aware that there is a great deal of uncertainty all over the country, and that for the period of eight or ten years ahead there will be a tremendous amount of uncertainty. Numbers of small towns will be without light, because of uncertainty as to the methods to be adopted and uncertainty as to the effect of the Shannon scheme. On account of that uncertainty, it will be impossible to induce people to put their money into these undertakings. I think it would be well if the Minister cleared that point up.

Another point that struck me during the early portion of the debate was that there were certain prices to consumers which the Minister, in reply to Deputy Figgis, admitted were held back. He did not give, to my mind, a very satisfactory reason for holding them back. I would like to know whether there are any other figures in that large report held back also, and if they are material to the issue.

There was another thing in the arguments used about this enormous amount of current to be sold, and that was the limitation on the hours of use. That is a thing that should be very thoroughly explained, because I think it was the continental practice that was taken into account in the working out of these figures, and that is that at certain hours of the day current would not be available and that at certain hours of the day current would be available at a low figure. That was not to my mind brought out fully and clearly. That would, of course, enormously cheapen the general average all over and would give misleading figures. You could offer a man current on Sunday when everyone is at church at .001d., because then you have it going to waste, and it pays you to get anything for it. Arguments of that kind should not be brought in to lower the general average all round as to what current could be given for all the year round. I now come to a point which Deputy Good dealt with as to world prices for machinery. I hope the Minister will give us further information on that point. There is one thing that I would like to impress on the House, and it is this: the plant that would be employed, presuming that Messrs. Siemens take this job in hands, will be entirely of German manufacture. That places this country lock, stock and barrel in the hands of German engineers.

Comment on this

What is the alternative?

Comment on this

I hold no brief for any country's manufacturers, but I do know this much from my own experience and from the experience of a large number of people, that German manufacturers, on the whole, in the electrical industry are not on a par with those in a great many other countries. It is a well known fact, and I think it can be borne out by any engineer, that the factor of safety—for example, the factor of safety in German dynamoes and German motors—is very far short of what it is in American or English machines. Then you put yourselves in the hands practically of one firm, and the question of replacement arises. I came across the other day the case of a man who was foolish enough to send an order to Germany for some electrical fittings. He sent the order in June and did not get delivery until the following March. If that is a sample of the way this country is to be treated in the matter of trade, I do not think it is a good advertisement for Germany. There was one point that some Deputy mentioned about the Minister having a card up his sleeve, and I take it he had railways in mind. Somewhere in the report I have seen that the cost of coal in Switzerland, which was taken as a comparison, was £3 per ton, and that even then it was found cheaper to run the railways by coal than by electricity.

I have it from a very eminent engineer who has studied the subject, that if you had your electricity for nothing in a country where coal is sold at a reasonable figure, you would not be able to make it pay. There is one point that I would like to draw the Minister's attention to. When speaking yesterday he stated that Mr. Kettle had given an estimate of 15 per cent. per annum as a probable increase in the consumption of electricity for the Dublin Corporation supply. Now, Mr. Kettle informs me that that is not correct. Mr. Kettle, in his evidence in connection with the Liffey scheme, stated that the development to be expected in the Corporation supply over the next ten years is about 10 per cent., and for the tramways about 2 per cent. The figures given by the Minister, as Mr. Kettle's figures, are, therefore, 50 per cent. higher than the increase given by Mr. Kettle himself. As Mr. Kettle has been taken as an authority, and, I think, rightly so, and following out further Messrs. Siemens' report, the figure of consumption for Dublin, including the tramways, under the partial development scheme, at the end of six years, is given as 63½ million units. Messrs. Siemens' figure, under the full development scheme for Dublin, including the tramways, is 85¼ million units, while Mr. Kettle's figure is 58½ million units. These are corrections which, I think, it is only due to Mr. Kettle to bring to the Minister's notice, and I hope that when he comes to wind up the debate that as many of these points as possible will be cleared up.

Comment on this

There are just a few points that I would refer to. The ground in connection with this scheme has been travelled over very carefully, not only by supporters of it, but by critics in the House and outside of it. Deputy Major Myles has stated that the scheme requires more examination than has been given to it by the four experts. He wants to know also why these experts were chosen, and stated that they were men who devoted themselves more to the pursuit of knowledge than to the pursuit of commerce.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, I desire to say that I did not say that. I was following the Minister's statement.

Comment on this

I am afraid that the Deputy did not quite follow the Minister in his statement. The Minister made it quite plain that these experts were chosen because they had given this particular work a life study, and the Deputy's argument bears out the fact that the Government were absolutely right in selecting men with a worldwide reputation—men who would not be likely to propound or bring forward a scheme that would be faulty. There is no danger that they would risk their reputation in doing a thing like that. By way of example, Deputy Myles said that if someone had to undergo a serious operation he would not, as he said, go to Tom, Dick or Harry, and ask for advice as to the surgeon he would select to perform the operation. The patient, he said, would go to his medical adviser for advice on that matter. That is precisely what the Government have done in this case; they have gone to experts with a worldwide reputation for this class of work for advice. None of the critics of the scheme has told us where men more eminent than these experts could have been found. Some Deputies, I forget who, asked why not have the subscribers or the users of the power first before you introduced it. The suggestion they made was that the scheme should not be introduced until there was a sufficient number of subscribers to utilise the power made available. If you have your electrical scheme developed in this country, then you will have the possibility of promoting industry in it. In the average country town you have no power but gas or coal. The price of coal, I am afraid, is far higher than what Deputy Myles suggests. I think he said the price in this country was £3 a ton. In many districts that I know the price ranges from £3 to £5 per ton, and it is the high cost of coal that is preventing many people, who are anxious to develop new industries in the country and to re-open old ones, from doing so. The cost of coal is so prohibitive that they could not hope to carry on an industry with any hope of profit.

As regards creameries, the cost of coal for their engines and also the cost of cartage is so very great that the development of the existing industries —and the creameries are existing industries connected with our main agricultural industry is really prohibitive. The price of coal is a very serious factor. I believe that with the development of this scheme you will have an industrial revival in this country. It will, as Deputy Wolfe says, help the people in every part of the country. It will help those people who are doubtful as regards production, and as to the possibility of the people of Ireland competing with the people of other countries to see that capital available in different areas will be used, and will be an impetus to get the people of Ireland to do what they should do in developing the resources of the country quite as much in the towns as in the cities. The Minister has dealt with the technical points. The advantages of this scheme for the whole country are so great that any Deputy will see them. Even if there was no profit on the money invested on a scheme over a number of years, indirectly it will help the people of the country both now and in the future.

Comment on this

I think the House has very fully dealt with this matter, and I do not propose to take up the time of the House to any great extent in connection with it. There has been great enthusiasm for the scheme from all parts of the House. As far as I know there is no opposition to the Shannon as a source of power for the Free State being developed. All that has been asked is that the House should not be definitely committed to the particular scheme before us until there has been a further examination into the basis on which the calculations are made. I think Deputy Thrift was very fair in his suggestion that the matter need not be delayed in any way by giving the Minister all the power he requires to spend any money that is necessary. I emphasise in support of that that this scheme is the product of Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert through the medium of the White Paper.

The White Paper has met with a good deal of criticism. Messrs Siemens-Schuckert are a very eminent firm, and they were empowered to produce a scheme. They did so in due course, and it was submitted to the experts. When it came to the experts it was materially altered. I think it is recognised that the experts have gone into the matter very fully, and given a very elaborate and complete report, as far as the scheme is concerned. Surely under the circumstances it is not too much to ask that the putting into operation of this scheme should, before it is proceeded with, get every possible consideration. In connection with electricity it is a well-known fact that the cost of generating at the power station is not the largest cost in connection with the supply to the consumer. The distribution costs are, of course, very heavy, and are governed largely by the question of load factor and the conditions under which the power station is operating in supplying the current. This report that we have before us in no way deals with the question of the cost of distribution.

The Minister made the statement that, taking the high tension transmission on its own, and leaving aside altogether the question of distribution from the high tension cables, it would pay its way on the basis of supplying current in bulk to Dublin, Cork and Limerick. I think he mentioned the cost of that operation—I think also it is mentioned in the books—would be £315,000. That is on the basis of Dublin being the principal consumer. Of course, the whole scheme is based on Dublin. It is very hard to anticipate a greater increase in consumption over a period of six years than to bring it up to 60 million units for Dublin, Cork and Limerick. At a halfpenny a unit on 60 million units you would have £125,000, as against that cost of £315,000. If those figures are right, based on that calculation, the cost of supplying Dublin would be more than a penny a unit. The cost of generating electricity in Dublin—I refer to the statement of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture—is not two, decimal something of a penny. At the Corporation works it is, I think, in or about one penny. When transmitted to the transformer station in Fleet Street, I think it is somewhere about 1.5 of a penny, including the cost of capital on the connection between the Pigeon House and Fleet Street. The cost to the consumer is, of course, largely dependent on the conditions under which the current is being used.

Speaking on behalf of a body of men who have been very much abused in connection with the criticisms they have made on this question of the economical distribution of power in Dublin, through the medium of this high tension cable from Limerick, I think it is unanimously their opinion that as far as the larger area of distribution is concerned, governed by a net-work of communicating poles throughout the Free State, it will require a very considerable development and use of current to make the whole system work out on the lines of a very cheap electricity supply to the various parts of the country. They are not less enthusiastic on the question of utilising the Shannon for the development of power than any member of this House. All they ask, as far as I know, is that reasonable time and reasonable consideration should be given to the whole proposition before committing the country to the actual expenditure of the large sum of money estimated.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy will excuse me, and would allow me to ask whether we can clear up the point about the cost of production of electricity by the Dublin Corporation? I think if we did it might save some trouble afterwards. Different statements on the subject have certainly caused some confusion. As regards the Corporation, in the report of the Electricity Committee, dated March 31st, 1924. I read that the cost per unit sold was for coal .69 of a penny; other expenses, including generation, distribution and management, 1.66 of a penny; total, 2.35 of a penny. Then for interest there was 1.11 of a penny. The total cost per unit, exclusive of renewals and reserve, was 3.46. Now, that may be quite familiar to Deputy Hewat, and there may be some other points that he will be dealing with; but I think it would be important if we got that point cleared up at this stage.

Comment on this

I am not very conversant with the figures of the Corporation, but I will give them to you as far as I know them. First, the current is generated at the busbars of the Pigeon House Fort. That operation is a works cost, and it does not represent more than one penny a unit.

Comment on this

That is the point you are dealing with.

Comment on this

That is the point. That current is then conveyed to the transformer station at Fleet Street. Covering the interest on the capital, the sum engaged in the operation, I understand the cost there is 1.5. The figures Deputy Johnson gives are, as far as I know, the figures to the consumers.

Comment on this

It is the cost per unit sold.

Comment on this

That is per unit sold as delivered to the consumer.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

Is that allowing for everything?

Comment on this

I think it is allowing for everything, as far as I know. Of course the Minister knows all these figures better than I do, and he can correct me.

Comment on this