We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - ESTIMATES FOR PUBLIC SERVICES. VOTE 19—RELIEF SCHEMES (RESUMED).

Contributions 116–247 of 247. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Following the advertisement the acts——

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

What acts?

Comment on this

The acts that Deputy Baxter spoke of last night. The Minister was not present.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am waiting for them yet. I read the report, and I want to know what acts.

Comment on this

There is nothing in the reports unless the Minister read the Official Reports.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Let us have the acts that I have been asking for for the last three months.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

It would be better to hear Deputy Johnson. The Minister can then make any reply he thinks necessary.

Comment on this

No names were mentioned. That is a matter for Deputy Baxter's discretion. The statement was made that to his knowledge certain works were undertaken in respect to drainage affecting the lands of three persons who were supporters of the Government or who were expected to be supporters of the Government. The request of the fourth person, whose land was in a line with these, was refused because he was a declared opponent of the Government.

Comment on this

We got no names.

Comment on this

I am not making charges. I am reciting what Deputy Baxter explained to the Dáil.

Comment on this

I made the statement that the men who allocated the money to be spent in the different districts were members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Who were they?

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

He did not say who they were.

Comment on this

I am speaking of the points that Deputy Baxter made. He has repeated the second point. He made a number of others, but these were two definite statements which did not give names. I take these statements in conjunction with the advertisement, and I say that there is a prima facie case that has not been answered or met—not even by an offer from the Ministry of an inquiry into those charges made by a responsible party. No suggestion has been made except to throw it off as something jocular, something arising out of a heated election campaign. I suggest to the Ministry that a mere throwing off of a story like this is not going to do them, or their party, or the country, or their reputation for clean administration, any good.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Is this a point of order or what is it?

Comment on this

If the Minister wants to stick strictly to points of order I will sit down.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I want to finish.

Comment on this

I thought the Minister had finished long ago.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Minister is entitled to make a second speech.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am not making a second speech.

Comment on this

The Minister was sitting down waiting for the interjection.

Comment on this

The Minister is in the habit of throwing out taunts and asking for replies, and I thought he had finished.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am not complaining of Deputy Johnson's interruption, but it was rather a long interruption. That is why I intervened. I did sit down when he stood up in order to give him an opportunity of making the interruption. If he has anything to add, I am willing to give way.

Comment on this

I can only repeat that the case that Deputy Baxter has made, particularly the case following, as I say, that advertisement, gives me the impression, notwithstanding the kind of repudiation that has come from the Ministerial benches, that there was an atmosphere of public corruption in the Cavan election, and that unless some inquiry is made it will appear that the Government and the administration at the time of an election did use a political organisation to assist the candidature of their party, because of the promise of this special expenditure of funds in the interests of the party. That is the case, as it appears to me, that has to be met and is not being met, and I suggest to the Ministry that it is the kind of case that ought to be the subject of inquiry from Deputies representing the Independent Party, probably, in this House.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

All I have to say is that Deputy Johnson is exceedingly credulous. If it impresses him in that way it does not impress me one bit. I know he is a past master of the art of making up a stage case. He loves to do it. "Something behind the scenes!""People are getting suspicious !" The Farmers' Party are also good at it. We are constantly being adjured by Deputy Johnson and Deputy Baxter, who gets up and says that he does not believe we are such rogues as people are saying, but, in our own interests, we ought to have an inquiry. We are not children. We are not to be rushed by soft talk of that sort. Deputy Johnson believes that a prima facie case is made out. These are his facts. It is three months or more since the Cavan election, as Deputy Egan has pointed out. Serious general charges are made now without any specific charges. For that three months not one single specific charge was made. I am the Minister responsible for these two Departments. I discussed this matter a month ago and asked Deputy Baxter for concrete cases. I will say that I think he told me he had no concrete cases. In any case I never got one. Remember these are very serious charges. According to Deputy Johnson they involve corruption and all sorts of unspeakable things. You have Deputy Baxter and Deputy Johnson, who do not sleep at night thinking of the reputation of the Government, doing their best to see that the Government is kept in the absolutely straight and narrow way. Yet not a single inkling of a concrete case have I got that I could get my teeth into from Deputy Baxter for the three months. After three months he comes along and the Dáil has heard what he had to say. His first statement to-day was that a certain man, whose name he gave when pressed for it, who was not an official of the Land Commission, told him on the road that he was going round to pay the men. I ignore that. I think too much of the Land Commission to listen to balderdash of that sort when simply thrown across the House by a person when forced into a corner. The next is the advertisement. I do not care what Deputy Johnson's particular political standards are. All I know is that I do not give two pence what a Cumann na nGaedheal branch here or there happens to say. I am not responsible for what they think or say. As Minister for Lands and Agriculture my responsibility is to try and keep the Land Commission and my Department impersonal and non-political. I do that. If people choose to make foolish and silly statements which anyone could see are foolish and react upon themselves I cannot be going about contradicting them. I make no apology for it. There is the third case. We have got no names. It is a case where a bog was drained and something else should be done. On that flimsy superstructure one is asked to believe that a public inquiry should be held.

Comment on this

Your repudiation is not lightening the burden.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I would not make so little of myself or my party as to repudiate them. We will repudiate them if we get them in a concrete way. There is no use in Deputy Johnson doing the innocent and saying that in the month of June, 1925, he wants me to assure him that it is the Government and not Cumann na nGaedheal organisers that run the country. I am about tired of Deputy Baxter's constant, tearful, sorrowful and long-winded orations in the Dáil to the tune of: "We believe you are perfectly honest, but the country does not believe it and we would like you to hold an inquiry."

Comment on this

I am not begging an inquiry: I am challenging it.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

We were told about the Shannon scheme that people are going about wondering just what sort of corruption we are guilty of in connection with it. The Minister for Industry and Commerce was assured that there is terrible suspicion in the country about the Shannon scheme, and also that the sugar beet scheme is not above suspicion. We were assured by Deputies that that was so and that they were telling us in our own interests, that they wanted to stop the talk going on. Now it is the administration of the Land Commission. The day we begin to do things wrong we will begin to get nervous and begin to find it necessary to have fake inquiries of all sorts. We are not going to be rushed into inquiries over every flimsy charge made in a casual sort of way by Deputies. I ask the Dáil not to agree for a moment to this inquiry. There is no case for an inquiry, and I tell Deputy Baxter and Deputy Johnson that if at any time any official of the Department does anything wrong it is their duty to let the Minister know immediately and let him inquire into it. It would be fairer to the official, to the Dáil and the Minister to take that course rather than making general charges and without giving any facts or names.

Comment on this

As reference has been made to the Shannon scheme there was an insinuation that there was something corrupt about it. I would like to say that I never heard that. I would like to know who said that.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

We have been told by Deputy Good that people are suspicious about the scheme. That is all we have been told. It leaves us quite cold. Anyone who likes to be suspicious can be so.

Comment on this

I said that the action of the Government with regard to the Shannon scheme had created suspicion when they withheld the documents.

Comment on this

I had occasion to visit Cavan during the last election, and I would like to give what I consider an impartial opinion on the subject that is now before the Dáil. At one place, where I understand more of the Government money was spent on relief works than in any other part of Cavan, I addressed a large hostile crowd. There were a large number of interruptions, and respectable people, as well as the organiser, told me that these interrupters who would not allow me to speak, were men engaged on relief works, receiving the money provided by the Government. I made it my business to find out if that was true. I challenged the interrupters, and asked some of them that were pointed out: "Are you receiving Government money?" None of them denied it. They said the money was their own, and that they were only getting back what they paid in rates. As far as my experience goes, I say that supporters of the Irregular party were receiving more in that locality than the supporters of any other party, and that if the Cumann na nGaedheal representative was administering the money he was doing it very badly, because all the persons he engaged were active opponents of the Government.

Comment on this

I did not intend to take part in this discussion only that the Minister for Lands and Agriculture drew me into it. He said that only two parties in the county got anything done—the Farmers and Cumann na nGaedhael.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I said that is what they were saying.

Comment on this

I am afraid there was not enough discrimination made in connection with relief works. A certain amount of work was done. I did not get much done. I got a little done, but I would like to have more done. At the same time, certain by-ways and roads were made that were, I might say, unnecessary. I was with Deputy Baxter, and went around these rivers, and saw lands that were flooded. The crops had not been taken out, and the hay was lying in the fields. We were very anxious that something should be attempted in these parts, but unfortunately we have not succeeded up to the present. We are hopeful that with the assistance of Deputy O'Sullivan something will be done in the near future.

Comment on this

This has been a very interesting discussion. It is remarkable for the fact that evidently the Government do not think they have committed themselves in any way.

I do not think they have. This was not good enough, of course, to deceive Ministers. This policy was not good enough to deceive members of the House, but it was good enough to try on the Cavan folk. The methods adopted there were certainly good enough to convince anyone that they were the people who held the purse and who were able to deliver the goods. And they did it, too. Perhaps the average elector had not the high intelligence that is to be found here in the Dáil. Possibly their intelligence was no better than the intelligence of the Deputies on those benches. There is no doubt about it, it certainly is strange when you come to think of people coming up in lorries and waiting on Ministers—deputation after deputation. Those people were introduced by the organiser there, whom I am given to understand was a school teacher. He was not attending to his duties at the school at that time; he was probably lent to the Government, to the Cumann na nGaedheal party, for the purposes of the election. He was a gentleman named O'Rourke.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

He should not be in politics.

Comment on this

There would be nothing said in that case.

Comment on this
Prof. Michael Tierney Professor TIERNEY

Does Deputy Johnson make that part of his indictment against the Government—that school teachers should not act as organisers?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

What has that to do with Deputy Johnson?

Comment on this
Prof. Michael Tierney Professor TIERNEY

Does he agree with that part of the indictment against the Government?

Comment on this

Where is the necessity for that?

Comment on this

When I was in Cavan I heard all this about the school teacher who should have been on the active list and in his school. He was going around the county and, no doubt, he was getting good results. He was not in his school; I thought he should be there. I do not know what arrangements were made between the Minister for Education and the Director of Elections at the time, who I believe was also a Minister. I believe that this gentleman introduced several deputations, some of them to the Minister for Lands and Agriculture. To give that Minister credit, I believe, as a matter of fact, that he turned down all the representations made to him on various occasions there. I know he did.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

I could have easily stated that, but I did not think it worth my while.

Comment on this

The Minister knew it was all balderdash and had no foundation; but how was the average elector of Cavan to know that? It was pumped into him at every cross roads, on every platform, and in every publichouse in the county.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

By both sides.

Comment on this

The trouble is that we on those benches are only sucklings in this matter. We do not know how to get on.

Comment on this

You do not expect us to swallow that?

Comment on this

Now, this individual I speak of, on the Minister's admission, busied himself introducing deputation after deputation, saying that he had made promises——

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

No.

Comment on this

—— and, to the credit of the Minister, he turned all those down. Has the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs repudiated this action?

Comment on this

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was not director of elections.

Comment on this

He was director of organisation.

Comment on this

Then I do not know what you were. We, at least, heard the Minister described as the organiser of victory, the Carnot of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. Let those who know French pronounce the name after the French style. As Deputy Egan says, Ministers are not fools. I know that is quite right, and I know that the Ministers did not commit themselves up there. I am sure Deputy Egan did not, either. At the same time, they had those underlings going about, men who did not appear too much, men of little responsibility; but nevertheless, those men were good enough to get into touch with the electors and they were good enough to convince them. They were the men who did the work and the fellows who were not fools kept away. That is quite a good policy. It is quite what I expected and I can understand that Deputy Egan would not leave any tracks after him.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

And would not cry about it afterwards.

Comment on this

No, he would not cry about it. Deputies here stated that there were no concrete instances put up. I think there have been many concrete instances. I was in Cavan and I could see and hear many instances. I do not know the names of people there.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

You ought to have heard all I heard.

Comment on this

I thought when this gentleman was being referred to that he was a commissioner. I actually asked in Cavan if he was a member of the Land Commission and I heard he was not. From all I heard about him I imagined that he wielded great power and that he was actually a Land Commissioner. I think that he was mentioned as Commissioner O'Rourke, though I did not know any Commissioner O'Rourke who was employed by the Land Commission.

Comment on this

Perhaps he is a Secret Service man.

Comment on this

I could not imagine, and I cannot visualise, a more pointed appeal to the cupidity of the ordinary individual than happened in the case of Cavan. I cannot visualise such methods as were described here as being adopted in Cavan. I could not picture any methods appealing more to the cupidity and the baser passions of human nature than those that were adopted in Cavan. The whole thing was a credit to nobody. It almost reminds me of the tactics adopted by another political party in the country. They have gone around in election after election and appealed to men to vote for them. They said: "If you vote for us you will have to pay nothing; we will get you out of your debts and everything; we will get you land free, and we will get your debts wiped away; you can do what you like and you can adopt any means you like to get other people's property." That has been the practice in the country, and that is the way that elections have been fought in this country. I refer generally to the way the Irregular election propaganda has been carried out. I do not like to see the Government Party following other electioneering methods, if not to the full extent of 100 per cent., at least to the extent of 50 per cent. I know that in this country elections are not fought on a straight appeal to the electors, but on an appeal to the baser passions and to the brute nature in man. Deputies may smile at that. After all, I believe there is a brute nature in man, and the original strain is as near the head to-day, is as near the surface, as when Adam was rearing his family.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

Would that be the case if the farmers got the majority?

Comment on this

I believe that Commissioner or Organiser O'Rourke is now back at his job and is leading a useful life. I must congratulate the Minister for Education and the Minister for Organisation.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

Probably the farmers will get him the next time.

Comment on this

He looks like a winner, anyhow. I do believe, from what I have been told in Cavan, that the people whom this money was intended to benefit did not get it; it did not reach the people it was intended for.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

How is it that did not happen anywhere else?

Comment on this

Perhaps it did, but the necessity was greater there. I say that people who did not need employment were appointed as gangers. I have come in contact with one or two of them, and just to show the Minister that his people are not always right, one man happened to be a supporter of ours. By putting on a certain face he got appointed right off. He told us that if he did not do that he would not have the chance of a job.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

That was hitting below the belt.

Comment on this

This is not altogether a matter for laughing at, when you go among the people who are in grave want and who are very much in need of assistance. At that election and in such circumstances you have a party coming, blowing the trumpet, and advertising that "the President will do this and will be anxious to receive his loyal subjects and to hear representations from them in regard to drainage, etc." The people were told that they would be received. The money bags began to jingle, and it was shouted out, "We are the people who are ready to deliver the goods and who can do it." That does not reflect very much credit on the Government or on the people responsible, and it is putting our national character at a very low par. The sooner we start on a higher and better plane the better for the nation, and the better for anybody who claims that this nation is an honourable nation.

Comment on this

I thought that some day three months ago the Cavan election was over. I thought, too, that the verdict of the Cavan electors was given, and that a certain man was elected there. I find now, however, that some Deputies want to traverse all the ground traversed in the course of the election, and to have all the controversies associated with it stirred up again. I would like to know from the Deputies who are bringing this matter forward, did they ever state here in the Dáil that there was no destitution in Cavan? Did they ever state that that work was not required in Cavan, especially in that portion of the county known as West Cavan? Did they ever state that West Cavan was not in a state of utter destitution or utter want during that period and for some time before it? Did they ever state on public platforms that money was not wanted?

Comment on this

Nobody suggested that.

Comment on this

They went round to brag that they got the money to give these people, and what was the meaning of the brag if not to attract the electors? Was it not to secure their votes? But, because the Party that Deputy Baxter is a member of, did not get the spending of the money, the pique is on them because they lost the election. Deputy Baxter may laugh at the moment. He admits that he went about and tried to get certain works done. Because the Inspector of the Land Commission or the engineer sent down did not fall in with the views of Deputy Baxter, or had not the works done that Deputy Baxter thought to get done for his friends in a particular place, Deputy Baxter finds fault. I have been through Cavan a good deal. Deputy Baxter made statements here last night which no man—certainly no man in Cavan— could justify. He stated that works were done up to a certain point, but because the place of some supporter of another party intervened, the works stopped at that point, and were again commenced further on. I defy Deputy Baxter to give any idea of the way the people of Cavan voted, because, as sensible men, the majority of them kept their minds to themselves until the day of the election.

Deputy Baxter said that he knew of several instances where people would not get work because they were not of a certain political faith. I challenge him to give me the number. He said he knew of one individual case. I suppose there were thousands employed, and he said he knew of one instance. These charges of corruption are made here. I say here in this House—and I think Deputy Baxter will not contradict me—that I made it a particular point when travelling through the country to inquire whether the work done was work of a nature that was going to be reproductive, and whether the money was earned or not. I inquired from the clergymen and the leading men that I met all over the county. I am sure some of the clergymen were backing the candidate that Deputy Baxter was backing, and they told me that they never saw people in their lives who worked as well, that it was work that would last, and that it would be of material advantage to the people of the county.

Comment on this

Tell Deputy Beamish that.

Comment on this

Deputy Beamish did not know that.

Comment on this

I have myself been on the roads, bog roads that were made, and the clergymen told me that the people in that area—it was a very large bog—could never go into the bog with anything except a donkey and creels on his back, to take the turf down some miles to the county road, and that now because of the work that has been done the people are able to get a cart up there and take the turf out in the cart. These are the classes of work done. I have seen some of the drainage works done. I have seen some of them that were finished and they were a credit to the men who carried them out. I think Deputy Baxter will not deny that. The only point in the argument is that there was not enough money given to carry out the necessary work. I told the people in Cavan myself that money would be found to finish any work that was commenced, that it would not be left in a state in which it would not be reproductive. The Minister comes along now and states that any works that were not finished will be finished. It is very good propaganda perhaps to bring this matter up here, but when a very serious charge is brought forward it should be backed by facts and no facts have been adduced here to make this charge what we are supposed to believe it is. We got a general statement from Deputy Baxter. If Deputy Baxter had told the people in Cavan during the elections that they were not going to get any money spent in Cavan, that the Government refused to give any grant to Cavan, and if Deputy Baxter says that the people in Cavan, especially in West Cavan, where the bulk of the money was spent, did not want relief, I am sure it is not the question that is raised here now we would hear. Instead, the Government would have been impeached for a lack of foresight in not providing food and work for the people in that period. If the Government had waited until something serious had happened or until relief had come from America or Russia, or some place else, then the Government would have been impeached for not doing their duty, but because the Government have done their duty, and because they have sent money, in order that people would not starve at a time which everybody admits was a period of stress, owing to the failure of the turf and the potato crop, it is sought to indict them here. If the Government had not done this they would be impeached for a lack of duty and for not carrying out their responsibilities, which were to see that the people got work and that they were not allowed to starve. I hope we have heard the last of the Cavan Election, at least until the next election comes round. Let the Party who is making this noise take their beating manfully. If they do that they will not be the worse of it; they come up here crying ——

Comment on this

We are not crying.

Comment on this

Because their candidate was defeated. They fought the election; they did their best and the Cumann na nGaedheal did their best, and the Cumann na nGaedheal candidate won.

Comment on this

Where is the man who won? Why is he not here? Did he ever come here since?

Comment on this

If the Deputy was here for the past few weeks he would have seen him here every week since he was elected.

Comment on this

No, sir.

Comment on this

I challenge the Journals of the House to show that there has been any week in which he was not here since he was elected.

Comment on this

He may have been in Government Buildings, but he was not here.

Comment on this

It can be proved from the records. I am adamant on that, because I know it is a fact. As I say, I hope we have heard the last of the Cavan election. I have been through it, and I will say this about the people of Cavan. They are a hard-working, honest people. They knew the right thing to do, and they did it on the last occasion.

Comment on this

We may have heard the last of the Cavan elections, but we have not heard the last of the extraordinary constitutional doctrine the Minister has just propounded. The Minister for Defence says that he went through Cavan, and promised the people that the necessary money would be forthcoming to complete any useful works that had been begun, that they would not be useful unless the work was carried through to completion. I think that is a fair summary of what the Minister said.

Comment on this

What I did say I repeat, and I will not go back on it. The statement was put forward that there was not enough money to carry out the work when the works were begun. There was not enough money, it was alleged, to finish them, and the Farmers' Party told the people that there was not enough money, and that they were not going to get any more, in order to get their votes. They told them furthermore to get paid, because the Government had no money—not enough to pay them. It was to controvert that I made the statement.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I want to know if the Minister for Defence will substantiate the statement that the Farmers' Organisation told the people to get paid for the work done, to get payment every day. I ask him where was that stated.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Hewat will not contradict me when I say that.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Give a concrete instance.

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan was once and once only in Cavan, and he was there only for about three hours.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I was there four or five times.

Comment on this

You must have been asleep there.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

The Minister was probably asleep, but I was not.

Comment on this

I am glad that I have drawn the explanation from the Minister for Defence that he was acting under what he believed to be provocation, but he did, what seems to me, to be a very dangerous thing. I am sure the Minister for Finance is not used to being committed by his colleagues in the Ministry to find the money. As a member of the Executive Council, he may have a right to do that, but he had no right to bind an external Minister to anything. The Minister has no right to bind the Minister for Agriculture, an external Minister who is not subject to the Executive Council, and is not even subject to the Cumann na nGaedheal. He is subject to the Dáil as a whole. The Minister acted, perhaps, under provocation in the heat of the moment, but do not let that be accepted as a constitutional doctrine. Do not let the Minister go down and say: "I will see that the Minister for Lands and Agriculture, the Minister for Local Government, and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs shall give a guarantee that this work shall be done." He has no more right to do that than Deputy Johnson has a right to do it.

Comment on this

I never said that I would make any Minister do anything. I have not said it here, nor did I say it there.

Comment on this

The Minister has stated that he would guarantee that the work would be completed. How could it be completed if the Minister for Lands and Agriculture did not complete it?

Comment on this

The Minister has stated to-day that it will be completed.

Comment on this

I have established that the Minister for Defence knew some months ago what the Minister for Lands and Agriculture would say to-day as a justification for his conduct then?

Comment on this

Deputy Cooper will not put words into my mouth which I did not use. I said that the Minister for Lands and Agriculture stated that he was going to finish the work that he commenced, and I say it would be criminal not to finish the work, having started it. I wonder is it Deputy Cooper's doctrine to leave work that has been started half unfinished?

Comment on this

I certainly never suggested that. The Minister rebukes me for putting words into his mouth, but I venture to say that if I did so, he is falling into my bad example. I wish to make the point that members of the Executive Council cannot commit external Ministers in their conduct of the work of their Department. What would the Minister for Defence say if, for instance, the Minister for Lands and Agriculture were to go down to Kerry and say, "You need more soldiers here, and I will make the Minister for Defence send them."

Comment on this

I would tell him to mind his own business.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister for Lands would be entitled to tell the Minister for Defence to mind his own business.

Comment on this

Of course he would.

Comment on this

Then does not the Minister for Defence think that he misled the people of Cavan to whom he was talking when he gave the guarantee? The moral of this business is that the fewer pledges Ministers make in these material matters to individuals the better. The further they keep aloof from giving undertakings the better. This, as Deputy Gorey has said, is an appeal to the worst and not to the best of an elector, saying that a man will receive material advantages because he supports one party or another. I agree that the hands of all parties are not clean in this matter. The remarks of one member of the Farmers' Party, who is not here, undoubtedly suggested material advantages. Ministers should, however, remember that they occupy peculiar positions, that they are trustees of the nation, not merely of a party, and they must remember that always and not act merely as party leaders.

Comment on this

I feel the importance of this debate and I wish to point to one statement which Deputy Baxter made. He seemed to suggest that the whole Cumann na nGaedheal Party behind the Government are ready to use certain tactics in a particular constituency in support of the Government. As one Deputy I absolutely repudiate that. In my constituency there have been numbers of people looking for land and numbers looking after drainage. I have been informed by some of them that some other Deputy will see the Minister and he will use his influence with him as I had no desire to do so. That other Deputy is not Deputy Morrissey. Anybody who has come to me in connection with the division of estates has never been questioned by me as to whether he belonged to the Cumann na nGaedheal, the old Irish Party, or the Conservatives. With me it is a question of merit. I get a list of the workers entitled to certain portions of land in their neighbourhood, the uneconomic holders, and the evicted tenants. What I am saying on my own behalf applies also, I believe, to other Deputies on this side of the House. It is not a question for them to choose in these matters between those who are and those who are not followers of Cumann na nGaedheal. I do not think there is any Deputy on this side of the House so base as to do anything in connection with buildings or land for party purposes. I do not know what occurred in Cavan. I think it is a very great loss that owing to certain circumstances we saw the departure of Deputy Seán Milroy in that Division. His has been a great loss as, if for no other reason, it would have saved us from all the unpleasant matters which have come before us this evening, matters which should not have been brought forward at this time. They should have been brought forward by Deputy Baxter at the proper time instead of now, when they interfere with the business of the House. If Deputy Baxter had a serious charge to make it should be brought to the proper quarter, and if he has a charge to make again I hope he will make it at the proper time and at once. We are all aware that certain Deputies avail of their position here to inform their constituents what they have done. They ask questions in the House and the next thing you find is that the questions they have asked are in the local Press to show what they are doing on behalf of the farmers. You never see that done by Deputy Morrissey or myself, but you see two pages, perhaps, full of matters which certain members of the Farmers' Party have done for their constituents.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Would the Deputy name them?

Comment on this

Deputy Heffernan. Reference has been made in regard to Cavan, but I say that we do not descend to such tactics—neither Deputy Morrissey on the Labour benches nor myself on the Government benches. Deputies apparently can only retain their position in their constituencies by spreading such things broadcast and by showing what wonderful persons they are.

Comment on this
A DEPUTY

You hide your light under a bushel.

Comment on this

Yes, their light is so small it is a very small bushel that conceals it.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

On a point of order, I want to know if it is correct Parliamentary procedure for Deputy D'Alton to refer to Deputy Heffernan in the terms he has used, as hiding his light under a bushel?

Comment on this

I never referred to the fact that Deputy Heffernan made the smallest attempt to hide his light under a bushel.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Deputy D'Alton has not referred to Deputy Heffernan in an abusive manner.

Comment on this

No, but that he published all his good points and works the interests of the Farmers' Party. If you have people going to elections and doing things that should not be done those who object to those acts should at once make their protest, and not be bringing up charges three or four months after the event. If necessary they could bring legal pressure to bear to deal with corrupt offences, if they believed that the party had acted in a corrupt manner.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Deputy D'Alton has insinuated that Deputy Heffernan has taken steps to have questions asked here, and together with other matters relating to himself has them published in the local papers. Does the Deputy make that statement definitely? We know that newspapers publish all these questions. The insinuation is that Deputy Heffernan has all these matters published in the local papers for his own glorification.

Comment on this

I would remind the worthy Deputy that I have referred to the fact that Deputies use their position to have reported in the public Press what they have done in the House, so as to place themselves in a certain position of advantage with their constituents. The men in Cavan made a small effort to apply the same tactics.

Comment on this

The charge made by Deputy Baxter to-day was somewhat vague. I took a considerable part in the Cavan election in the interests of Deputy O'Reilly. What the Deputy has stated was not my experience at all, quite the contrary, that no undue favour was given to the supporters of the Government candidate. I found that every time I went to Cavan quite a litany of complaints was made to me, and I was besought to report to the Minister that all those who were controlling the relief work were opponents of the Government, and supporters of Deputy O'Reilly in Cavan felt they had a grievance on this account. I did not report the matter to the Minister, and I never went to Cavan during the election that complaint was not made to me from every centre in the constituency. It would cause me considerable consternation if any improper methods were used by the Party I was associated with in the election. I regret that Deputy Baxter did not take an earlier opportunity, as Deputy Egan said, of having this matter dealt with by the proper Minister. No doubt the enemies of the country will take advantage of the statements made by Deputy Baxter to blacken our reputation in the eyes of the world. As one who took part in the election, I found that not only was what Deputy Baxter said not true, but, as I have said before, and I want to emphasise it, I found the very contrary to be the case. With regard to the advertisement that shocked Deputy Baxter and Deputy Johnson, I suggest that advertisement should be read seriatim, paragraph by paragraph. I would ask those Deputies if there is anything in the paragraphs which could possibly uphold a charge of corruption against any member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party or the Government.

Comment on this

I make that charge.

Comment on this

You may, but you could not sustain it. I agree that the advertisement was somewhat unfortunately worded, and, perhaps, undue advantage was taken of that in Cavan on account of the presence of the President there. A plain backbencher like myself, who has had the misfortune to travel in company with a Minister, or anyone familiar with an election area knows perfectly well that advantage is taken of the presence of a Minister in the constituency by anyone who has a grievance, or thinks he has a grievance. Deputations of all sorts put before the Minister, when they have the opportunity of seeing him personally, their claims. I have no doubt that the presence of the President in Cavan was taken advantage of on that day. I do not think there is anything wrong in an organisation asking delegates to come forward so that their claims might be pressed on those of their own party at the Party Convention. I challenge any Deputy to say that there is anything wrong in that. The advertisement, though perhaps unfortunately worded, could not be construed by any honest Deputy as carrying a charge of corruption against members of the Government or members of the Government Party.

Comment on this

I wish to refer briefly to two remarks made in the course of this debate. One was by Deputy Cooper. What he said in effect was that the hands of no party in this matter are clean. It must be quite clear to Deputy Cooper that the Labour Party had no hand, act or part in the conduct of the Cavan election. Therefore they are free from any of the corruption that has been alleged against the Government Party in this matter. The other matter with which I wish to deal is the invitation of the Minister for Defence——

Comment on this

On a point of order, are we debating the relief grants vote?

Comment on this

It is about time the learned Professor should rise to a point of order.

Comment on this

He attempted to speak before on matters that were relevant, but was not permitted by reason of the fact that we are discussing everything under the sun in the Vote at issue.

Comment on this

The discussion that has taken place on this matter would remind one more of a board of guardians' meeting than of a representative body such as we are supposed to be. I hope the like of it will never occur again, and that we will not have to listen to discussions conducted on the lines of this debate. The Minister for Defence has made a statement here, and I invite him to prove it. I asked how many times had the victor of Cavan appeared in this House since elected, and the Minister said that if the division list was produced it would show——

Comment on this

I venture to say that is very wide of the subject matter of the discussion.

Comment on this

As the Minister for Finance knows, nearly everything discussed here was very wide of the issue raised by Deputy Johnson in his motion. With regard to the debate, it struck me, and I listened to most of the charges made by Deputy Baxter, that if there is any justification for any of the charges made against the Government, the Ministers, or the Party that supports them, it is the charge that lies in the advertisement issued in their name, and to which they are committed by being present at the meeting called by this advertisement. It is not an uncommon thing in the ordinary course of events in a by-election or a general election to ask candidates if they would agree to support such and such a thing if elected. But it is a different matter for deputations to be invited to attend on Ministers, who have the power and responsibility of administration, and ask them to dole out money for such and such an area in Cavan or elsewhere. The charge has been made that that has been done by every party. Deputations could not wait on members of the Farmers' Party, or members of the Republican Party, and ask them to do things the Government could do, for a member of these parties by winning the election in Cavan would not put his party in control of the administration of the country, or get into their possession the funds at the disposal of the Government to dole out for this and that area. The charge that has been thrown back at the Farmers' benches in this particular case is wrong. If deputations find it necessary at any time, even at the time of a by-election, to see people, Ministers or otherwise, who have money at their disposal to give away, such as grants for relief work, the Minister should see them in Government Buildings, and not down in Cavan or Mayo when they are going on a party mission. I think that the charge which we have heard has only met with a qualified repudiation from any Minister who has spoken in this debate.

Comment on this

I would like to say a few words before the question is put. I spoke in reference to Deputy Baxter's charges last night as if it were possible that a certain degree of seriousness might be attached to them. Hearing Deputy Baxter further to-day, and hearing especially the story of the man going out to pay the men, I must say, without any intention of being unfair or offensive to Deputy Baxter, that I can only regard the whole thing as a joke—simply a joke. With reference to the advertisement, it is not the sort of advertisement I would draft if I were issuing an advertisement. But so far as I can see, it was simply an advertisement inviting people to continue further the damnable habit of deputationising Ministers. There is nothing wastes more time or causes more annoyance to Ministers than people insisting on seeing them and telling them in interviews and speeches, lasting sometimes three or four hours, what they could tell them on two sheets of notepaper. Everybody down the country believes that nothing is done right except they come and see the Minister and make a speech to him. Apparently, owing to the election being on, the Ministers who went down to this constituency were going to be forced to listen at great length to everybody who liked to come along and tell their story of what was needed in their particular district.

Comment on this

Did they not agree to listen?

Comment on this

I have not the slightest idea. I was not there. But I suppose they did. In fact, you can never refuse to listen, though I have on a few occasions refused. It is difficult, however, to do that, whether the Minister be in Government Buildings or anywhere else. In a democratic country the people can get at the Minister. They can stop you in the street and deputationise you. And you cannot help it. You are at their mercy. There was no suggestion in this case that anything could be done on a political basis. The notice simply asked the people to come and put their case for their particular district, and state the areas in which destitution existed, before the Minister who was there. It is very undesirable to have an election coinciding with the carrying out of relief works in a district. I do not see how in such circumstances we can avoid the appeals to cupidity which were made. As Deputy Gorey said, there were appeals to cupidity made and apparently they were made on both sides. I have no doubt about that. I do not see how you can avoid that. No matter what Ministers do, the people who are hot in the election will, when the election fever gets up, use every argument they can to get votes. They will use this argument and make every sort of representation. I believe that happened in the Cavan election. As to anything wrong having been done, the more I have listened to this discussion yesterday and to-day, the more I have been satisfied that there was nothing wrong done.

Comment on this

I think I have a right to reply in a few words. No Minister, and no Deputy behind the Ministers, has met my charge or answered my question as to who allocated the money in the different districts. I say that it was the members of the Cumann na nGaedheal organisation. No Minister and nobody behind the Ministers contradicted that or can contradict it.

Comment on this

It is the purest nonsense.

Comment on this

Deputy Baxter knows as well as I do—and I know well—that the money was allocated by the inspectors and engineers of the Land Commission. No Cumann na nGaedheal official, or any other individual in the County Cavan, could allocate one penny until the engineer went there and was satisfied as to the work that was to be done and the amount of money that was to be spent. That is how the money was allocated and Deputy Baxter knows it.

Comment on this

I ask that a Committee of the House be set up to deal with the matter. I am not saying anything that I am not in a position to prove. All I ask is that a Committee of the House be set up to make inquiries and let it be proven whether my statements are correct or not.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 14
·
Níl 37
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?