We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

DÁIL IN COMMITTEE. - FINANCE BILL, 1925—THIRD STAGE.

Contributions 1–153 of 313. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1925
Enacted

No. 27 of 1925 ›

Ernest Blythe MINISTER for FINANCE (Mr. Blythe) Cumann na nGaedheal

Section 1 does not call for any observation. It simply imposes income tax and super tax, and provides for the continuance of statutory provisions hitherto in force.

Comment on this

This is to implement a reciprocal arrangement whereby our charities are exempted from British income tax, in return for our exempting British charities. As a matter of fact, we lose very little income tax by this; the British lose more. It is not a permanent arrangement, but it has been in existence for a couple of years, and it was felt that two or three years more must elapse before a term could actually be put to this exemption. It is felt that a period of three years should suffice to enable charities here holding investments in Great Britain to dispose of those investments. If during that period of three years it has not been done, the charities will not be able to blame us if we decline to continue the arrangement any further, and if they find themselves liable to income tax in Great Britain.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give us any further information than he has already given on the subject of a better arrangement for the charging of income tax as between the British Government and the Saorstát Government? He explained to us, when the subject was under consideration previously, that he would endeavour to have an arrangement arrived at between the two Governments at an early date that would do away with a great deal of the trouble that exists at present.

Comment on this

I have no further information to give, except to say that I have been in correspondence with the Chancellor of the Exchequer on the subject, and that officials representing both Governments are examining the matter. It is too soon yet for any result.

Comment on this

This Section in part covers something that has been done in practice. We have not yet actually charged income tax on the gratuities or demobilisation pay of ex-officers and men of the National Army. Sub-section 2 was designed to get rid of an anomaly. By an adaptation of the British Act of 1919 pensions granted to ex-members of the National Army are exempt, but pensions granted under the same Act to ex-members of the Irish Volunteers and Citizen Army had not the benefit of exemption. We felt this to be anomalous and the section is introduced to cure it. The third sub-section simply provides for repayments where necessary.

Comment on this

This section is self-explanatory. The amount of duty involved is trifling and a certain amount of work will be saved in the investigation of these cases.

Comment on this

Could the Minister tell us whether the fact that an agricultural society employs a band at one of its shows will exclude it from the benefit of this section? It has been held, I believe, in the past, that the employment of a band rendered it necessary to charge entertainment tax. As is well known, the Royal Dublin Society and a great many other agricultural societies do employ bands or orchestras to add to the attraction of their shows. I should like to have an assurance on that point, if the Minister can give one.

Comment on this

That, of course, deals with entertainment tax and the matter is difficult. The disposition would be to ignore the presence of the band in connection with entertainment tax, if there was only one band, and if it was a subsidiary feature, and the show was the real entertainment. We feel that it would be dangerous to make any change in the law in regard to entertainment tax. You might have entertainments given with a few animals shown, just to cause exemption from the tax. The disposition has been, if the band is a very minor feature of the whole performance, to ignore it.

Comment on this

I take it from the Minister's reply that he will judge the matter very largely by the prize money and the number of exhibits, and if the show is a bona fide one he will not stress the presence of a band, either for entertainment tax or for the purpose of this section?

Comment on this

That is really the position.

Comment on this

This is to remedy an injustice that might arise in certain cases of persons having income from foreign possessions. I will just illustrate it by an example. Assuming that a person acquired shares in an Australian company in April, 1925, having previously had no income from abroad, and that he got dividends as follows:— 1925-26, £800; 1926-27, £1,000; 1927-28 was a bad year, and he got £50. As the law stands at present, in respect of the year 1925-26 he would be charged on the first year's income, amounting to £800. In 1926-27 he would be charged on the income of the preceding year. In 1927-28 he would be charged on the average of the two preceding years, or on £900. That would give a total of £2,500 on which he would pay income tax, although the dividends actually received in the three years would only amount to £1,850. It is felt that there is a definite hardship there, and that a person should not have to pay in excess of the income, but on the actual amount earned in the three years.

Comment on this

This is a matter I have already explained on the Resolution. It will bring certain people who would otherwise not be liable to be charged tax during absence from Saorstát Eireann into the same position as the majority of the citizens. For instance, if Deputy Cooper or Deputy Johnson were to go abroad for the purpose of occasional residence, he would not escape income tax. On the other hand, if a Belgian who had become, under the Constitution, a citizen of the country, went abroad, and a certain portion of his income did not arise here, he might escape tax altogether. This will bring the whole body of citizens into the same position.

Comment on this

We might have a little more information on this, especially as Rule 3 of the General Rules is not available for consultation in the library. As I understand it, this is the adoption of the British procedure with regard to temporary residence out of the country. Is it going to be worked in the same spirit as the British work their provisions? I do go abroad for some temporary residence occasionally, and have not attempted to escape Saorstát income tax, but have attempted with some success to escape British income tax. I find the British Government asked me to specify every single occasion on which I have been resident in Great Britain or Northern Ireland, even for a night. I have finally persuaded them that various stays of one or two nights, not exceeding two months in all, is sufficient return. It is possible for a resident in South Africa or Australia to be able to specify his visits to Great Britain, because he possibly only makes one, and that of considerable duration, but I do not believe even the Minister, looking back eighteen months, could give exact details of every time he visited Northern Ireland in that period. It is almost impossible, when the countries are as close as they are, and when crossing the border is so easy, to keep over eighteen months or two years—unless you are one of those people who keep a careful and accurate diary—exact information as to every visit paid out of the country. I would suggest that the Minister would be wise in this matter, where there are people who come here occasionally, even members of the Seanad, who are resident out of the Saorstát and come here for the meetings of the Seanad, to allow a general return. He should have enough information at his disposal to discover whether that return is accurate. It is fairly easy to discover whether a man when he comes over resides temporarily in a hotel or a club, or whether he has a residence of some kind. I do not know if the Minister could invoke the aid of the postal authorities or the Gárda, but there must be machinery by which he can discover this. If you are going to ask people to return every single visit, though it might only be an odd visit for a race meeting, you are going to set up an inquisition which will cost a great deal more than it brings in.

Comment on this

It will only arise in the case of a person with ordinary residence. The position is clear about anybody who has acquired citizenship under the Constitution, and by virtue of the Constitution merely. The change, for instance, will have no effect on Deputy Cooper. But if a Frenchman, or a Belgian, or a Russian was ordinarily resident here and went abroad temporarily, and if portion of his income tax arises abroad, and we are not deducting at the source or anything like that, this will prevent him escaping liability for income tax by an occasional residence abroad. But they are not liable unless they are ordinarily resident here.

Comment on this

Sections 7, 8 and 9 hang together, more or less. They really represent the fulfilment of an undertaking that I gave in the course of the debate last year to Deputy Good.

At present the time limits existing are, in the case of additional assessments and surcharges, three years from the end of the year to which the assessment or surcharge relates; in the case of repayment claims for ordinary statutory allowances, personal allowances, relief in respect of children and so forth, three years from the end of the year of assessment for which relief was claimed; in the case of penalties, three years from the date of the offence. You have a similar time limit in all cases. It is now proposed to extend the time limit in all three cases to six years, that being the period prescribed by the Statute of Limitations in the case of ordinary contract debts. It is not proposed that the extension would affect any case prior to the year 1922-23, when we took over control. Section 7 contains provisions with regard to additional assessments, and it follows the lines of Section 29 of the British Finance Act of 1923, except in regard to the matter of the period of operation. The British section was given effect to as from the year 1920-21. We propose the year 1922-23. This particular section, which was enacted in Great Britain, carried out one of the recommendations of the 1920 Royal Commission on income tax.

Sub-section (1) extends the time limit for making additional assessments to six years. Sub-section (2) extends the time limit for surcharges. This provision was put in the British Act, and it may be of more importance there than it is here. Here it is very rarely necessary to resort to the method of surcharge, because the additional assessment is normally the most effective and convenient method. There are certain differences in the arrangements in England, whereby they have additional Commissioners who are local men and the work is not done by the inspectors, so there is a certain reason for it. It may be convenient for us to put it in; it has been inserted because in certain cases it may be convenient. Sub-section (3) extends the time limit for making an assessment or an additional assessment in respect of super tax, to six years. Sub-section (4) limits the period in which the executors of a deceased person may be assessed in respect of the income of the deceased before his death, for a period of three years after the end of the year of assessment in which the death took place. For example, if a person died on the 1st April, 1924, and the inspector discovered in March, 1927, that he had not disclosed in his returns certain British dividends an assessment can be made for the years 1922-23, and 1923-24, on his executors.

Comment on this

Even though the estate has been wound up?

Comment on this

If the discovery was not made until the 6th April no assessment in respect of his income for any year can be made.

Comment on this

Supposing the estate had been closed, would it be open to the Minister, through his officers, to make a charge on that estate?

Comment on this

Substantially there is no difference in time as compared with the present arrangement. In the previous sub-section we extend our powers of recovery from 3 to 6 years. In this particular sub-section we do not extend it to 6 years; we make the period 3 years, which is approximately the time that is available at present for recovery. I do not know the course to be adopted when the estate has been wound up, and the duty is not recoverable.

Comment on this

Supposing the assets are distributed, what will be the position of the executors? They have dis-discharged their duty, and they are released from their bond. Can the Minister still come down and make a further surcharge? They have distributed the assets, and, I take it, in that case they would be personally liable.

Comment on this

Fundamentally it is the duty of the executors to discover liability. In any case, we are not extending the period of recovery here. In this case the period is dealt with in sub-section (4), and it corresponds roughly to the period available at present.

Comment on this

Under what section could the income tax authorities recover death duties in regard to a man who died in March, 1918? Arrangements were then made between the representatives of the deceased and the Government authorities whereby certain duties were paid. Subsequently, when the Free State Government came into power, that arrangement was set aside, and a valuer was sent down. Another assessment, independent of the first one, was then made. Under what section was that procedure adopted? It has not taken effect yet, and I hope it never will. I think the Minister knows the case I am referring to.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey handed me particulars of a case, but I have not the papers by me at the moment. There is no section in the present Finance Bill dealing with death duties. I think it would be better if the Deputy put down a question on the subject.

Comment on this

Or perhaps it would be still better to raise it on the adjournment?

Comment on this

If the Deputy would give me due notice, he could do that.

Comment on this

I take it from the Minister this is a new section that is in the Bill, and it has not been incorporated in any previous Finance Act. Am I correct in so understanding the Minister?

Comment on this

No, sir. There is power of recovery at the present time and this does not extend that power. In the case of certain things, additional assessments and so forth, we are extending our period of recovery from three to six years; but in other cases, such as income tax or supertax due by the estate of any deceased persons, we do not extend the period. We except that subject from the extension.

Comment on this

If this provision were not in the previous Finance Act, would it not appear to the ordinary person that there was some doubt about it, and that in order to clear up that doubt the section was inserted in this Bill? This provision did not exist in any previous Act. This raises a most serious question in regard to the liability of executors. It leaves it open, after the estate has been closed and the moneys of the deceased distributed in accordance with his wishes, for a further claim to be made. There still exists, with regard to the executors, a liability under this particular section. If it should be subsequently found out that certain moneys should have been paid to the income tax authorities that had not been paid, even though the assets were distributed and the estate closed, it would still be open to the Minister to make an assessment the executors who, if no funds were available to meet the charge, would become personally liable. That is a most serious position for executors.

Comment on this

I explained to the Deputy that this is a section dealing with time. The first three sub-sections of this section specifically extend the time for doing certain things from 3 to 6 years. In the fourth sub-section we say that in the case of a particular estate those things shall not be done over a period of 6 years, and can only be done for a period of 3 years. The existing law in the General Rules applicable to Schedules A, B, C, D, and E sets out: "Where any person dies without having delivered a statement of all his profits or accounts chargeable to tax with a view to an assessment thereon, in due course an assessment in respect of the profits or accounts which arose or accrued to him before his death may be made at any time within the year of assessment, or within three years after the expiration thereof, upon his executors or administrators, and the amount of the tax thereon shall be a duty due from and payable out of his estate." That is how the law stands in regard to a deceased person. We are extending the time for doing certain things in the section generally. In the fourth sub-section we say that the time shall not be extended in respect of the estate of the deceased person.

Comment on this

I am not at all sure, on the particular case that the Minister has cited, that if the estate has been closed, the assets distributed, and the executors have discharged their liability, that any further liability still continues. I am rather inclined to think that, under the particular case mentioned, the charge must be made against the estate before the assets have been distributed and the estate wound up. As I have said many times, I am not a lawyer, but it is common sense that once an estate is wound up and the executors have discharged their duty, they should not be held personally liable for further liabilities in connection with income-tax and things of that nature. If that point is not clear, it ought to be made clear. It ought to be made incumbent on the authorities that charges of this kind must be inquired into and made on the estate before the assets are distributed; otherwise an impossible position will be created for the executors. None of us would like to be placed in the position —and of course we all like to help our friends—of accepting an honorary appointment as executor if we are going to have a serious responsibility placed upon us in which we may incur liabilities that in many cases we might not be able to discharge, unless at the expense of our own families.

Comment on this

Would not sub-section (4) clear that point?

Comment on this

The Deputy raised a point which does not really arise out of this section. The law as it stands simply says that the new powers for recovery that we take in regard to additional assessments and assessments of supertax and the question of surcharges shall not apply to the estate of a deceased person. We retain the old limit of three years; we do no more. It is a case that very seldom arises. This particular provision is one that was enacted in Great Britain the year before last. There is nothing new or original in this sub-section. The general matter is one that might be argued, but I do not think we are touching on it at the present time.

Comment on this

I am interpreting sub-section (4) exactly in accordance with the Minister's explanation. He followed that up by quoting from the law as it existed prior to the incorporation of this section. Though its substance really applied to previous Acts, the section as we now find it did not exist in any previous Finance Act as regards this particular country. I do not know that it exists under the British Finance Act. Certainly, the custom may be in force but I have no recollection of the particular clause in its present form appearing there.

Comment on this

I can only read the Rule again (Rule quoted).

Comment on this

I think the last clause is the governing clause there. It says "out of the estate." It does not provide for the liability of the executors themselves. If that is carried on, I suppose it would be read by the Ministry that if the estate was distributed the amount in question would be regarded as a bad debt.

Comment on this

The sub-section does not alter it. The sub-section deals with time only. It does not introduce anything new.

Comment on this

I would be glad if the Minister would inquire into it, because even though it has been the custom, it is quite obvious it has not been understood by those who accepted the responsibility of executors. If they understood their position and that this liability continued for a period of three years, I am sure the result would be that none of them would close the estate until after the three years had expired. That would be very undesirable in connection with estates, and it is obviously a matter that should have inquiry and attention at the hands of the Minister.

Comment on this

As far as I can gather, this is a matter that very rarely arises, because anything there was there to be discovered would be discovered in connection with the fixing of the amount of estate duty due. The sources of income and so forth would be disclosed, and any discovery the Revenue Authorities might make would normally be made in connection with the payment of estate duty. It would be a rare thing for anything to be discovered at a later stage than that.

Comment on this

If they had been lax in their duties it is quite obvious the liability would still continue.

Comment on this

I move Section 10. It is practically identical with the section embodied in the British Finance Act of 1924. I dealt with this matter when the Finance Resolutions were before the House in the first instance, and when they were before the House on Report. This section was introduced in Great Britain because, although no case had been decided, a judge, in hearing a case, had expressed certain doubts as to the legality of the practice which this section is designed to put beyond doubt and which had always obtained. This is a question that only arises in the case of a change in the rate of duty and the payment of dividends by companies showing on the warrants a deduction of tax on a composite rate. In certain cases in a year of change, tax deducted might be shown at 4/3, 4/6 or 4/9, and it becomes always very difficult to explain to the taxpayer at what rate he should be entitled to his allowance. Even if it be a fact that there is no necessity for this section, it will put the matter beyond doubt from the point of view of the taxpayer. It simply means that the man is entitled to his allowance at the rate of the year. That is the practice that has always been carried out.

Comment on this

I move this section, which deals with such a case as I will mention. A person who is charged in Case IV. of Schedule D, in respect of income from foreign securities, or in Case V., Schedule D, in respect of income from stocks, shares or rents outside Saorstát Eireann, is normally assessed with reference to the full income arising, but where such a person satisfies the Revenue Commissioners that he is not domiciled in Saorstát Eireann, or that, being a citizen of Saorstát Eireann, he is not ordinarily resident in Saorstát Eireann, he is entitled to have the assessment made with reference to the amount of remittances of such income into Saorstát Eireann. Where a banker has deducted Saorstát Eireann tax from income derived from securities of a foreign State, and the beneficial owner proves to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that he is not resident in Saorstát Eireann, repayment is made under the provisions of the Rules of Schedule C. Similar repayment falls to be made in similar circumstances where tax is deducted under No. 7 of the Miscellaneous Rules applicable to Schedule D in respect of interest and dividend of foreign and colonial companies, taxed by deduction by Saorstát bankers. The position at present is that the Revenue Commissioners have no satisfactory means of getting the necessary evidence to enable them to decide these questions of "domicile,""ordinary residence," and "residence." The section enables the taxpayer who is dissatisfied with the decision to have the case heard before the Special Commissioners, in the same manner as they would hear an appeal against an assessment. The Special Commissioners can then be required, either by the taxpayer or by the Revenue, to state a case on a point of law for the decision of the High Court. The real position is at the moment that the Revenue Commissioners have to decide these questions of "domicile,""ordinary residence," and "residence," possibly without having evidence adduced, and it is felt that it is desirable to have an appeal to the Special Commissioners open to the taxpayer. It is thought desirable that he should have the opportunity of having his case heard and the matter decided by the Special Commissioners as regards facts. On a question of law there would, of course be an appeal to the courts.

Comment on this

As the Minister knows, this question of the refund of income tax is a very difficult one at the moment. It is further complicated by the fact that in some instances, where refunds of income tax are claimed from Great Britain, the Revenue authorities there refuse to consider the claim until the applicant has furnished a full statement of his income from all sources. I would like to know whether cases of that kind have been brought before the Minister, and when applications are made by residents of Great Britain to the Revenue authorities on this side for a refund of income tax, if a similar custom is adopted here. This question of getting refunds of income tax is quite difficult enough, without the necessity of giving this additional information, and having to answer the immense number of questions which arises out of this additional information. I am sure this matter has been before the Minister, and possibly he has had some correspondence with the Revenue authorities on the other side. I would be glad if he would give us some information on this particular aspect of the question.

Comment on this

I am afraid I am not in a position to give the Deputy the information he has asked. We find that it is impossible to simplify the procedure that exists at present, except by a very radical change in the entire system so far as double income tax is concerned. We are certainly prepared to agree to any reasonable scheme that will safeguard our Revenue. We cannot afford to lose half a million pounds or to lose any substantial sum in revenue. Subject to our revenue being safeguarded, we are prepared to agree to any reasonable scheme to simplify the present arrangement, which we are satisfied can never be other than an arrangement that will cause a great deal of delay and irritation. The whole matter of double-taxation relief is, as I am sure Deputy Good is aware, a very complex one. I certainly would not be able to stand cross-examination on it. It would not require an expert in income tax law to puzzle me in connection with it, and if Deputy Good wants to ask questions in connection with double income tax relief, he will have to put them on paper.

Comment on this

I have no desire whatever to put any difficult problems to the Minister or to add to his troubles. But these are questions that are arising every day. The particular matter which I have just mentioned was brought to the attention of the Minister's Department. The reply of his Department was, when this full statement of income was demanded by the British authorities, that they should not give it as they are not entitled to it. As soon as that information was sent to the British authorities, they replied: "We are sorry we cannot comply with your request for refund of income tax until we get the full statement." This is a very material matter in connection with refund of income tax and there ought to be some understanding between the two Governments as to what information is necessary. If this information is not demanded by the Free State Government and is demanded by the British Government, surely that ought to be the subject of discussion between the two Governments as to whether it is a fair or unfair claim to make. This matter has been going on for a number of years. It is not a thing that was introduced this week or last week. It has been in existence some four years and these problems, instead of becoming less, seem to me to be becoming greater. If some real attempt is not made to assist those who live in the Free State and have investments outside the Free State, the result will be that they will be driven outside the Free State. It is all very well for the Minister to say: "Let them take the money out of investments elsewhere and invest it in the Free State." We have had an enlightening discussion here this afternoon with regard to investments in railway securities in the Free State. That is a question I have not touched, but if pressure of that kind is brought to bear on those who have capital, I think you will find, in nine cases out of ten, that the individual will come before the money will move. In the interests of the Free State, I would urge that every step that can be taken to simplify this matter should be taken.

Comment on this

So far as anything we could do ourselves is concerned, I think it will be generally admitted that the arrangements we have made have been less inconvenient to taxpayers than the arrangements the British have made. As to entering into correspondence with the British Government with regard to something they do in respect of claims upon them for repayment of income tax, that is hardly feasible. After all, Great Britain is not a subject State of the Saorstát, and I do not think we can dictate to them as to what their arrangements should be. We have been continually in correspondence on this subject and a joint investigation of the matter is at present going on. We realise the importance of assisting our people here in getting what is due to them in the matter of repayment of income tax and relieving them of worry and irritation, but the British Government equally has a right to take the steps it thinks proper to safeguard its revenue. We certainly cannot call upon them simply to have regard to our wishes or the wishes of our citizens. So far as making any give-and-take arrangement is concerned, we are willing to do our part, but we cannot do more.

Comment on this

Section 12 is designed to meet the case of companies which declare their dividends free of tax. In cases such as that, taxpayers frequently have difficulty in computing the amount of the tax for the purpose of rendering claims to the Revenue Authorities. This was a reform which was urged by various witnesses before the Royal Commission on Income Tax in 1920, and it was unanimously recommended by the Commission.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister the meaning of the words "in writing," in line 50. Would that exclude typewriting or printing, because very often these dividend warrants are either typewritten or printed? Would it not be sufficient to say: "accompanied by a statement showing—" omitting the words "in writing." Perhaps the Minister would consider that before the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Certainly, but I think any printed or typewritten matter would do.

Comment on this

It might be verbal.

Comment on this

It is the customary form.

Comment on this

This is to amend a section of the Act of last year. Certain difficulties arose in connection with the payment of remuneration to bankers, owing to the form in which last year's section was drafted. Remuneration is paid to bankers for deduction of tax. It is also paid for furnishing particulars, but not deducting under the arrangements that exist in connection with double taxation relief. Now the bankers have a great deal more trouble in furnishing particulars than in actually deducting. We thought last year that the section passed enabled us to fix different rates, one a rate for deduction, another a rate for furnishing particulars. It was found, however, that that was not possible, and we had to resort to a very cumbersome procedure whereby we ascertained the amount of each sort of work done by each banker and fixed the composite rate to cover what would have been the amount received by the bank if it had been paid a customary rate for the deduction and the new rate for the furnishing of particulars.

Comment on this

This practically only applies to banks.

Comment on this

Only to banks.

Comment on this

This is a declaratory section. When the section in the Local Government Act was drafted and passed, perhaps there had not been sufficient advertence to the wording and the form of the Income Tax Acts. The result has been, on examination, that the Revenue Commissioners are afraid that the section in the Local Government Act, although intended only to affect the valuation for the purpose of local rates, might also affect it for income tax purposes. That was not intended, and it is felt that the only satisfactory arrangement is to actually make clear the effect of the section by a section in the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

While there is a remission of rates there is no remission of income tax.

Comment on this

I move amendment 1:—

In sub-section (1), lines 44-45, to delete the words "personal clothing and wearing apparel" and substitute the words "overcoats, coats, waistcoats, trousers, knickerbockers, costumes, blouses, skirts, stockings, socks, underclothing, shirts, collars, ties, corsets, caps or velour hats, handkerchiefs, and umbrellas."

There is a slight verbal error in this amendment. One word has been omitted. The correct reading of the amendment is as in Amendment 2: "caps, felt or velour hats, handkerchiefs, and umbrellas." The word "felt" has been accidentally omitted.

I have put down this amendment with the object of making these duties on wearing apparel more clearly defined in the Bill. It merely says "personal clothing or wearing apparel." This is a very wide and loose term. I have defined it more clearly. If I had a free hand I should prefer to limit the duties more closely. I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce made a very strong case with regard to the duty on ready-made clothing. I think a strong case could be made with regard to the duty on hosiery. Personally I should have preferred that he stopped at this, and when we had our customers trained to this to extend it. But the Minister is prepared to go the whole hog straight off. I have extended the duties to all these articles because the Minister might find that he could not be expected to accept any amendment that would involve a large sacrifice of revenue. Therefore, I drafted an amendment which covers every article likely to be manufactured in this country, and which also covers all the most expensive articles that are likely to bring him in revenue. It leaves out certain border-line articles; for instance, it leaves out gloves. Gloves are a very debatable question. At the present moment they are not manufactured in the Saorstát, though I believe some time ago they were manufactured in Tipperary. But gloves cover not only ordinary gloves, but, as Deputy Dr. Hennessy reminded us yesterday, rubber surgical gloves, and they cover, as I reminded the Dáil some time ago, boxing-gloves. They are not articles of any great value on which any large duty would be obtained, while they would require a certain amount of skill and a certain amount of machinery for their manufacture. So I omitted gloves. I also omitted clothing of very young children, except in so far as they are covered by underclothing.

I think the desire of the Dáil is to relieve the father of a large family of this burden so far as it can. With these exceptions, broadly speaking, I have tried to cover the bulk of the articles included in "personal clothing or wearing apparel." Of course there will be border-line cases, but I think by the more explicit definition you will have fewer border-line cases. If the Minister accepts this amendment it would be impossible for the officials to do as they did the other day, to place this duty on absolutely unmade-up silk which was intended for covering purposes, and not wearing apparel. Because it was silk it was held to be wearing apparel. I have no doubt whatever that a refund of that duty will be obtained. I have no doubt that it was a bona fide mistake, but if the description had been made more detailed as it is in this amendment, it would not be possible to tax these people on silk. I therefore ask the Minister to accept this amendment and the consequential amendments that follow.

Comment on this

Deputy Cooper's amendment, I think, illustrates immediately the great difficulty of dealing with this particular matter by way of schedule. For instance, he suggested that the amendment covers all the articles that reasonably could be taxed, with certain exceptions which he mentioned. Now the amendment would not allow us to tax articles like wool mufflers, which could be made here. It would not allow us to tax jumpers, cardigans, dressing-gowns, night-wear, pyjamas and a variety of other things which could be suggested. I believe myself it is undesirable to attempt to deal with the matter by way of schedule. The difficulties of the border-line cases would increase. The more you had a schedule the greater the difficulties you would have of deciding cases which might be neither one nor the other. If you altered the words in relation to caps and hats and brought in tweed hats there might be a question regarding the tam-o'-shanter, as to whether it was a cap or a hat, or neither. We deliberately put in the words "personal clothing or wearing apparel" feeling that practically all the articles could be made here, or if they could not be made here, as in the case of certain articles of millinery, at any rate, they could be, as it were, assembled here. We believe that all this type of industry is a type which is related and which is suitable to the country. It is not the heavy type of industry in which I suppose this country could never compete. It is a type of industry which might well be carried on here. It is not the type of industry that requires very expensive machinery or huge capital to have it carried on. From all points of view we think that the whole range of clothing or wearing apparel is rightly included in this particular duty. We see no possibility of satisfactorily working the tax by excluding sections of wear. It would be very difficult, for instance, to exclude children's wear. The question of where the border-line was going to be would be difficult and it would give rise to a great number of disputes and a great deal of trouble in actually working it out.

I feel that, while for instance children's clothing has not been made in this country to any great extent, there is no reason why it should not be made, and the object of the tariff is not merely to encourage production and development in the particular lines that have actually been made here, but to induce people to take up new lines, in the feeling that after a very little time organisation will be created, the skill will be acquired or purchased and that the articles may be made here in the future as well as elsewhere.

Comment on this

I am sure what the Minister says is possible with regard to certain of these articles, but it will take some little time to organise these industries and to get them working. Pending that time the great mass of these goods will have to be imported. I have drawn the attention of the Minister on many occasions to the incapacity of his Department to deal with this new problem. Delays of from fourteen to thirty days are taking place in the Customs. I have pointed out to the Minister where his arrangements are hopelessly inadequate. I mentioned a case where duty had been assessed when the goods had been found after a very considerable amount of difficulty in the very unsuitable stores that are used at the moment at the North Wall. When the goods had been found the people concerned were sent a mile away to Beresford Place, where they had to stand in a queue in a hopelessly understaffed office and wait a considerable portion of the day in order to make their payment. They then had to bring their receipt back to the North Wall and get their goods. While the Minister may blame business people for want of capacity in connection with organisation arising out of these duties, I think he might very well consider whether there is not in his own Department an amount of laxity that should be inquired into. As I pointed out on a previous occasion, these particular goods are seasonable goods. While the hot weather is with us light goods are in urgent demand; wires are sent across to get replenishments of stock. Stocks arrive and they are held up in the Customs for fourteen days, three weeks, or a month. by the end of which time we will probably have normal conditions as regards the weather; the demand for these light fabries will have disappeared, and these stocks which have been ordered to meet the demand existing at the moment will be left on the hands of these people.

Comment on this

The heated atmosphere will have disappeared.

Comment on this

Yes. When the Minister interferes with trade he should ensure in the interests of the State that the interference is of the least possible injury to trade. No steps have been taken in order to remedy these matters that have been a constant source of complaint on the part of traders, and I really must press the Minister, in view of the promises that he made, to see that some steps are taken to inquire into these complaints. I can give him particulars after particulars. I have one case before me which only reached me this morning, concerning an article that was sent, not through the Minister's Department, but by registered post. It left the other side on the 27th May; this is the 10th June, and it has not arrived yet. That is the responsibility of another Minister; I think that the Finance Minister has quite enough to look into at the moment.

His Department is causing very serious injury to trade, and we want to get an assurance from him that every precaution will be taken to reduce the interference with trade to the minimum. The Minister, as I said, has promised that these matters would be inquired into. I want to know what the result of that inquiry has been, because it would appear from the complaints that reach me that the methods of doing business to-day are no different from those of six or eight weeks ago, when the duty was first enforced. This is a serious matter for traders, and we want some assurance that the Minister has taken steps, and if the steps he has taken have not met the situation, that further steps will be taken in order to mitigate the trouble.

Comment on this
Darrell Figgis Mr. DARRELL FIGGIS Independent

I support the amendment not only for the reasons which Deputy Cooper advanced, but for those that have been mentioned by Deputy Good. I think that a great deal of the delay that has occurred, that is occurring, and must necessarily occur in connection with new duties of this kind is very largely due to the fact that the officers administering it are not quite clear as to whether a particular article is within the dutiable area or not. I have had cases brought before me, and I will give one example; I could give three or four. A considerable amount of delay has occurred and a great deal of exasperation and loss has been caused in the case of a particular trader who got in artificial flowers. He heard nothing about their arrival until he made his own particular inquiries. He wrote to London; he heard from London that the goods had been sent on a certain date. It was then about ten days or a fortnight afterwards. He sent down to the docks and found that the goods were there. He took the matter up with the proper authorities, and they wanted to know whether the goods were artificial flowers for wear or not for wear, whether they were within the range of the duty or not. This particular trader was somewhat amused at the inquiry because he said that any person who understood the matter, who had any technical knowledge, would know that no lady would use these flowers in wearing apparel; they were obviously unsuited for it. When he gave that assurance they asked him whether he would give a written undertaking that these appliances would not be worn, and he replied: "I can give no written undertaking that the flowers will not be worn; I can give no undertaking that when I have finished with them for the purpose of decorating my shop and they are discarded that some person will not get a hold of them who will think that they are suitable for wearing." He said that he was not going to pay for the goods, that he would leave them there, and that the trader on the other side could make recovery. That is only one particular case. The delay in this particular case occurred because the authorities were not clear as to whether the goods were or were not within the dutiable area.

I think a great deal of the delay of which Deputy Good has complained, and of which many Deputies must have had numerous cases brought to their attention, is very largely owing to the fact that there is not a clear schedule for the guidance of the officers who are discharging this new duty. I urged this on the Committee Stage of the Finance Resolutions. I return to it now, and I join with Deputy Cooper in urging that a list should be set up, that we should not merely say that a duty will be charged upon some general commodity, and that the officials collecting that duty should then be left to discover for themselves, or by reference to their superior officers, whether different commodities are or are not within the dutiable area; that we should set down quite clearly, and as definitely as possible on which goods the duty is to be levied, and on which goods the duty need not be levied. The Minister for Finance, in criticising the terms of this amendment, I think, in quoting the various items, war referring to some list that he had seen or that was before him. I imagine that some kind of list must have been available. I cannot understand his reluctance in making that list, if there be such a list, a definite schedule for purposes of legislation. I cannot appreciate to the full his reluctance in doing that, but I think it would be a good way of starting with this matter, even though it might prove that certain items would be discovered in the course of working to be quite within the dutiable areas, although not set down in the schedule. If that were so, the schedule could be changed, amplified, and made clear so as to include such items. But let us at least expedite the administration of these new duties by letting the officials, and the public have before them some definite statutory list to which reference could be made to determine whether articles are strictly dutiable or are not strictly dutiable. There will always be a border line. I think when the Minister was referring to the border line I heard Deputy Redmond suggest that there would have to be a new Boundary Commission in regard to these border-line cases, but the publication of a schedule would not make it any more difficult or any less difficult in regard to these cases that are doubtfully within the area. It would at least give a certain amount of certainty, a certain amount of information in the first instance, to the public that will be affected, and in the second instance to the officials administering the duties.

Comment on this

Deputy Figgis' instance about artificial flowers is a very strong confirmation of the necessity for an amendment of this kind, because the Minister spoke of these articles of wearing apparel that we could not produce ourselves, but in which we might have an assembling trade. I think that those were his words. Amongst such articles, I presume, are ladies' hats. Surely artificial flowers would be the raw material of that assembling trade. Why should they be taxed? Shapes, I think, are exempted from taxation, but why should artificial flowers be taxed if we are trying to build up an assembling trade here? That helps to show that the thing has not been properly thought out, that a general formula has been adopted without any regard to its working with reference to the general public. There is a dislike on the part of the Minister, or his Department, to have any specific schedule in any detail. On the pier at Dun Laoghaire there is posted up in an obscure place a schedule of taxable articles. It is dated October, 1924, and the unfortunate Customs official has to interpret the duties that we imposed a month ago with the help of a schedule dated October, 1924, which any irritated traveller may invoke against him. I wonder is there any more recent schedule that gives in detail a list of the taxable goods to guide the officials. I hope the Minister will answer that question.

With regard to the omissions that the Minister noted, I deliberately left out cardigans and jumpers, because I see no means by which you could tax them without taxing the jersey of the little boy playing in the street. One definition would cover them all. I would sooner let the cardigan or jumper escape than tax the jersey that the small boy from 5 to 8 years of age wears. Secondly, he quoted woollen mufflers. What are woollen mufflers? They are the consolation of the poor girl who is unable to buy furs. They are comparatively inexpensive. You would really think that when we are taxing so much we need hardly come down to the very poor and tax the thing that keeps them warm in the cold weather. What is the other exception? Nightwear—pyjamas, dressing gowns, and so on, I left out. All our days are taxed, and for Heaven's sake let us have our nights in peace. These are the exceptions that I did not include. They were not inadvertent; they were intentional.

What it comes to is this: the Minister refuses this amendment, because he says we may, at some future date, be able to build up industries in the things I have left out. I have gone a very long way to meet him in this amendment. I have specified twenty articles that may be taxed. I have specified I think, every article we are producing here at present. I have given protection to the twenty men employed in the hat trade: to the thirty-five people in the umbrella trade. I have given protection to every Irish industry operating at present, and, in addition, I am giving protection to every big industry, to the big things such as men's suits, women's costumes, overcoats. All these things will receive protection under the amendment. The Minister says: "That is not enough. We must go the whole hog this year. This year I expect such a development that we will not only manufacture all the things mentioned in Deputy Cooper's amendment, but all the things he has left out." Do we not all know that these things will not be manufactured in the Saorstát this year on any scale that will meet the requirements of the people? What does it come to, then? By a tax on every single one of these items you increase the cost of living. I say concentrate on two or three things, or even on twenty things—I would prefer fewer if I had a free hand—but concentrate on the big things, on the things that will give employment and that give the bulk of the revenue, the things of large value, and let the little things go.

Comment on this

Deputy Cooper's appeal that we should leave our nights untaxed does not appeal to me. I do not know that there is anything I can say further in reply to Deputy Cooper. I presume that he regards this whole tax as undesirable. He regards it as making the best of a bad case to limit the tax in any way that he thinks the Dáil would agree to. I take the opposite view. I think that we desire to have the range as wide as possible in regard to wearing apparel; that we should not unduly restrict the operations of this tax. We deliberately framed a certain policy. We decided to include a certain range of goods in our operations. We estimated that we would get in the circumstances that exist a certain revenue for them. We fixed our remissions of taxation having regard to that revenue, and I do not feel inclined to depart from the general policy that we have already adopted, and which is embodied in this Bill.

With regard to the points raised by Deputy Good. We are trying to remedy the matters complained of. Delays have undoubtedly arisen. I did not see any way, when we decided on having these taxes, of avoiding some delays, and we took the best steps we could to provide additional staff. We are providing a further staff for the Revenue Department, not of a Customs character, but on the clerical side, and so far as we can do it, we are taking every possible step to clear away any accumulation of goods that exists. We cannot take somebody off the street and make a Customs Officer of him. No matter whom you bring in, there is going to be some time when his use will be rather limited. An intelligent man can be made some use of from the beginning, but the assistance he can give for some time is limited.

Comment on this

Is not that an argument for limiting the tax?

Comment on this

No, because you simply will raise new questions. Deputy Figgis talked about artificial flowers. I do not want to have a whole series of questions raised. I mentioned the case of an article like a tam-o' shanter. Great difficulties could be raised in regard to that. If you tax shirts and do not tax pyjamas, there is a type of American shirt which looks very like a pyjama jacket. You will have a great deal of dispute as to whether it is taxable or not. By limiting in this way, and cutting through the tariff, you simply raise new complications, which are the things that are difficult to deal with, things that will cause delays when you have a certain number of comparatively inexperienced officials dealing with them.

Delays are not all due to the Customs. There are, for instance, delays due to lack of accommodation. To some extent, so far as lack of accommodation is concerned, we may put the blame on the carrying companies, who have not been very ready to extend the transit shed accommodation that is required. One company, I think, is not accepting any parcels of dutiable goods at present. The shed where their ships discharge is absolutely choked up. Goods cannot be found; there is a pile of things thrown on top of one another. Once that state of confusion has been created, it is difficult to clear it away. As I say, no goods are now coming in, and that particular pile is being cleared up. We are doing all we can, having regard to the facilities that exist, and the experienced staff that we can use.

The trouble about artificial flowers is that you are always bound to have doubtful cases, and you cannot adopt any course other than such a course as has been adopted. Deputy Cooper seemed to indicate that the delay was entirely due to the Customs. It is not the duty of the Custom authorities to inform importers when goods arrive. Their duties are to see that the revenue is collected, and that goods are not cleared until the duty has been paid. It is not their duty to see that things are presented for payment of duty and for clearance.

Comment on this

Are the dutiable articles not placed in bond?

Comment on this

They are placed in bond by the importers, not by the Customs Officers. Ordinarily, they are placed in a transit shed, which is technically regarded as being part of the ship, by the shipping company; and they cannot be taken away from there, except they are being removed to bond, without the payment of the Customs duty. Strictly speaking, the Customs people could refuse to allow any article off the ship until a full entry had been made and duty had been paid, but of course they do not do that. The custom is to regard the transit shed as being part of the ship, and to allow the goods to be put into the shed. Then they are cleared from the transit shed.

A good portion of the delay, both at present and when our own separate Customs system was first set up—when there was a great deal worse confusion than there is now—was caused through lack of space. When the Customs system was first set up here great piles of goods accumulated in the transit sheds, and those which arrived first were those which were last out. In one case at any rate, I have had reports that that occurred recently. I am informed that difficulty has been overcome. It has not been just overcome yet, but it is being dealt with, and I hope that in a very short time the business of the ports will be going on normally again.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that one carrying company has offered to place additional space at the disposal of his department at the North Wall, and has he made any reply to that offer?

Comment on this

I have not heard of it personally.

Comment on this

I will give details of it later.

Comment on this
Darrell Figgis Mr. DARRELL FIGGIS Independent

I do not want to press the case with regard to artificial flowers too far, because I recognise the difficulties attached to it. I only repeat it now because I think some kind of definition with regard to that would assist not merely the importer, but the department itself, if one were to take that instance as an example. The question I now put to the Minister with a view to getting some kind of ruling is: Is it intended to levy duties upon what may be strictly regarded as the raw material of manufacture in this country? When the Financial Resolutions were before the Dáil, I gathered, and I think the majority of Deputies gathered, the impression that the purpose was to levy this ad valorem duty on articles that came into this country in a manufactured state, in order that their manufacture here might be encouraged. I urged then that a duty might be levied on the importation of foreign cloth, and the Minister replied, and justified his case quite fully, that that would be a two-tier duty, and it was not the intention to do that. If you are going to charge this duty, not on the completed article, which might be a hat, but on what is the raw material for a finished product, as it would be in the case of artificial flowers, and a number of other things, then you are going to get exactly the result that the Minister deprecated on the Financial Resolution: you are going to get a two-tier duty and are not going to encourage the manufacture of the finished product in this country. I give that as an instance, and ask the Minister in regard to that particular example if it is the intention to levy this duty on artificial flowers, simply because artificial flowers may be used in the manufacture of hats, and, if so, would then, but not until then, become portion of the wearing apparel.

Comment on this

We have been giving consideration to the question of feathers and artificial flowers, and we have not really completed consideration of that matter. It might be possible that I would, on the Report Stage, agree to exempt one or other, or both, of these particular articles from the duty, but in our discussion with the people interested in the trade, we have only felt that a good case was really put up for unblocked hat-shapes, and we put a sub-section in exempting the unblocked hat-shapes. Artificial flowers are articles that might be made here. We are certainly not imposing a two-tier duty. It may be that, through taxing components, we are not likely to get all the effect that the duty might otherwise have in the manufacture of hats. I think, however, that there has been a great deal of the putting-together of hats done here. There has not been such a tremendous importation of fully-trimmed and assembled hats as the Deputy seems to believe. On the other hand, for things like feathers, which are not manufactured, but which are only treated, there seems to be a somewhat better case. It is one of the matters that we are investigating with a view to seeing whether or not any further exemptions ought to be given. We feel that the only sound case that was put up by these people was on the one point of unblocked hat-shapes.

Comment on this

With regard to the question of complaints as to delays at the North Wall, the Minister has informed us that he has been doing all he can to remedy that matter, but he has a difficulty in getting suitable officials. Might I suggest to the Minister that he could select some confidential official in his Department to whom he could say: "Here is a real difficulty that has arisen and that ought to be removed?" Let that official see exactly how this problem could be dealt with; leave him on that work until it is dealt with. If it is a question of accommodation, surely the Minister has power to deal with that. These complaints are continuing from day to day, trade is being lost, and nothing is being done to remedy matters. The time has arrived when the Minister ought to take up this task seriously. He should appoint some official who will report from day to day the steps he is taking, and how far the difficulties that have arisen are being dealt with. I would urge on the Minister that in the interests of trade it is necessary to take drastic and immediate action. Complaints have been made for months, and I hope the Minister will take up the matter seriously and have it remedied.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I desire to support Deputy Good in the plea he made for a more prompt clearance of dutiable articles at the North Wall. I have been informed that seasonable goods particularly, like drapery, fabrics, etc., are being held up for as long as thirty days. By the time they are delivered the goods are practically unsaleable, as the demand has ceased. That is altogether wrong, and the Minister, having regard to the business of the country and the protection of the revenue, should insist upon getting a more prompt clearance. It appears to me that forty-eight hours, and certainly not longer than seventy-two hours, should be ample time in which to get the goods cleared. The Minister stated that confusion existed on the setting up of the Customs barrier more than two years ago. I wonder he did not make provision to obviate a similar difficulty when the new tariffs were set up. There was an absolute lack of provision. That was not good enough. It should be obvious to the Revenue authorities and the Department of Finance that the imposition of a tax would necessarily create delays; yet nothing was done, as far as we can learn, to facilitate the handling of goods, and officials are moving very slowly at present in surmounting existing difficulties. If some remedy is not immediately found, it will diminish the sale of certain goods and extinguish trade to a large extent. In any case, prices will have to be raised if you are not to diminish the profits amongst the distributing houses. The essence of the trade is a quick sale. If the goods are too long on hands the traders will require a higher margin of profit to indemnify themselves. If the trade declines, you automatically lower profits for the traders, and, incidentally, you are lowering your own income tax yield. Further, you are helping to create unemployment. Large numbers of people, as the Minister is aware, are employed in the distributing trade in Dublin. Is it in the interest of those people, or of business generally, to have long delays at the quays? I do not think it is. The Minister should insist on a prompt despatch and clearance of goods at the frontiers.

Comment on this

There was one question put by Deputy Cooper to which I did not find an answer in the Minister's reply. Have the Customs officers any kind of schedule as a working instrument? It seems to me absolutely essential that they should have in order to expendite the handling of goods. The Minister admitted how difficult it was to decide whether artificial flowers or feathers could be described as accessories of wearing apparel.

Comment on this

The real point was whether we should decide to exempt them. At the moment they are liable to tax.

Comment on this

There are many border-line cases that will come up from day to day and it is rather hard to expect an official summarily to decide these matters and endeavour to interpret the Act for himself. Would it not be a more reasonable thing to give him some kind of a working schedule?

Comment on this

The Customs officers have full instructions. They have the official import lists which set out the number of articles and the type of articles that are dutiable. Those lists set out overcoats, mackintoshes, men's and boys' suits, vests and trousers, women's and girls' fabrics, mantels and cloaks, aprons and overcoats, under-garments, coats, collars and cuffs, feathers, haberdashery, millinery, braces, suspenders, gloves, hats, caps, bonnets, and other head gear. Those are some of the items in the official import list. Then the officers are given certain instructions following the imposition of a tax and the passing of resolutions. As different points are raised and difficulties are experienced, supplementary instructions are issued, so that the officers have the fullest possible instructions that could be given. Doubtful points arise from time to time, and you are bound to have questions arising that were not fully thrashed out before. Whenever the need occurs, Customs officers are further circularised.

Comment on this

I desire to thank the Minister for the explanation he has given. Many people were perplexed over that matter.

Comment on this

I also desire to thank the Minister for making my case. We should really define those articles ourselves, and not leave it to the Revenue authorities and the Customs officers to interpret what articles are or are not dutiable. We are the people who should indicate what is to be taxed and what is not to be taxed, and not the Revenue Commissioners. Therefore, I must press my amendment.

Comment on this

Of course, the courts ultimately decide. If people feel that the Revenue Commissioners are not interpreting the section properly, they have their remedy. It is not a question of the Revenue Commissioners supplementing, altering or twisting anything in the Bill or the resolution. The resolutions are subject to the interpretation of the courts, just the same as any law. With reference to the provision of accommodation, we have no powers to enforce the provision of accommodation except to stand strictly on our rights and refuse to allow any shipping company to land its goods until full entry has been made.

Comment on this

If you are satisfied in the interests of the trade that the stores into which goods are to be transferred are suitable for the purpose, why not allow them in?

Comment on this

It is really a choice of evils. There was one port at which we met with absolute resistance when we wanted accommodation provided, and it was only when we threatened to close the port that the people concerned climbed down and provided the accommodation. One does not desire to take drastic action unless other means have failed.

Comment on this

On a point of personal explanation, I have not accused the Revenue Commissioners of twisting or perverting their duties in any way. I suggest we are placing on their shoulders a responsibility that belongs to us and not to them.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider the suggestion I made about appointing a responsible officer from his Department and entrusting him with the task of investigating these delays? Let him see the difficulties, consult with the Department, and deal with them. This problem has continued for months, and it means serious injury to the trade. The Minister, as we all recognise, is an exceedingly busy person. Why cannot he select one confidential person and say to him: "I want this difficulty dealt with; I put the responsibility on you, and I will give you any assistance necessary." That is the way we business men would deal with it.

Comment on this

It is being dealt with in that way. An inquiry has been conducted on my behalf in regard to delays alleged to have taken place at Fowler Hall. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was accused in that respect, but it is really my responsibility. Investigations are proceeding, and all the steps that can be taken are being taken to remedy matters. But when you have new duties, and when you have difficulties that the new duties necessarily create, it is no easy matter to deal with them. Heretofore the people were not accustomed to having transactions on dutiable goods. You have the difficulties of getting particulars and evidence that would enable you to charge ad valorem duties, and they are always troublesome to work. You have a staff fresh on those duties, you have a greater volume of duties and a shortage of space. Certain members of the staff are comparatively new and they cannot deal with those problems as rapidly as a more experienced staff could. It is really a matter of time. It is a matter of clearing away the initial confusion, getting the staffs better trained, having the public taught to comply promptly and fully with the Customs' requirements, and having officers experienced in dealing with those new duties. We have given all the staff that is really necessary. We cannot give an experienced staff, because that does not exist. We have also given the Revenue Authorities a staff for purely clerical duties. The whole situation is being met in that way, and it is now a matter of investigating particular duties and remedying them as rapidly as they can be remedied.

I would, if I had finished with this Bill, give a certain amount more personal attention to it, but I have given a good deal, and I have had numerous conferences with responsible officers with a view to getting rid of any difficulties. I simply say that the imposition of a considerable number of new duties, which bring people into contact with Customs and Customs formalities who were never in contact with them before, must necessarily result in a certain amount of confusion. We can only try to get over the difficulties as rapidly as possible.

Comment on this
Darrell Figgis Mr. DARRELL FIGGIS Independent

I am moved by the Minister's touching appeal to hurry on with the Bill, in order that he should have more time to deal with this matter. Having regard to the number of complaints that have come my way, and to the number of complaints I have heard of, would the Minister consider this definite suggestion: If goods such as I have mentioned, in respect of which a definite decision has not been taken, cross the border-line, will he, pending a definite decision, let the goods go through?

Comment on this

No, sir. I would have to consult the Revenue Solicitor, and if he was in doubt I should have to take the advice of the Attorney-General, and act on his advice.

Comment on this
Darrell Figgis Mr. DARRELL FIGGIS Independent

God help the importer!

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 16
·
Níl 35
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 4:—

In sub-section (1), lines 27 and 28, to delete the words "furniture (other than bedsteads)" and substitute the words "tables, chairs, sofas, stools, desks, benches, wardrobes, cupboards, cabinets, chests of drawers, wash-hand stands and dressers."

I need not take very long in arguing this amendment, because the principle is the same as the principle of the last amendment. It is, briefly, that we should say what we are taxing in detail, instead of dismissing it by a general term such as "furniture." I venture to think that when, by Resolution, we imposed this tax on furniture, we did not know it included every routine article that could possibly be used in a house or office or shop, or even school—though I am not quite certain on the last point. We did not realise that it would cover the wood in the handle of a broom and things of that kind. We thought of "furniture" in the terms in which I have expressed it in the amendment— tables, chairs, cupboards, and so on. These are articles in which we could possibly build up an industry. There are a certain number of firms manufacturing them now, and there may be more firms manufacturing them in future. I do not think that it was contemplated that the tax would apply to such insignificant things as the handle of a hammer or the wooden part of a sieve. I understand that all these articles come under the definition adopted by the Revenue Commissioners—anything that is normally used in a house. I think children's toys come under it, too. I do not think we had any idea, when imposing the duty, that articles of that kind would be included. If we had that idea, I am not at all sure that we would have passed the resolution. I have defined in this amendment all the larger articles of furniture, the making of which would be likely to give employment here or to yield any substantial amount of revenue to the Minister. The duties on these small articles are hardly worth collecting. They cause trouble, annoyance and expense in collection, and that, in itself, condemns them. I, therefore, ask the Committee to accept this amendment rather than adhere to the general term "furniture," which is being stretched to cover a great many more articles than we ever imagined.

Comment on this

The word "furniture" is one that has the advantage, for the purpose of legislation, of having been litigated about a good deal. It has frequently happened that people in their wills have left their furniture to somebody and there has been a dispute as to which of the articles in the house were "furniture" and which were not. So much litigation has taken place in regard to this matter that you can find legal decisions dealing with almost any question that would arise in regard to what was furniture and what was not. While to the layman there might be difficulty in deciding some such questions, there is not, from the legal point of view, any great difficulty in such cases. I would put it to Deputy Cooper that there are many wooden articles of furniture which are excluded from his list which might as well be included as the things he has mentioned. Coal scuttles, shelves, music stands, fire screens, curtain poles, hall stands, umbrella stands, book cases, settees, sideboards, presses, towel racks, and all sorts of other articles would come quite as well within even the narrow view of the meaning of the word "furniture" as the things he has mentioned.

There might be certain classes of articles that would be taxed furniture which it would be thought desirable to exempt. In certain cases we have provided exemptions. We provided exemptions in the case of picture frames and we propose to provide another exemption in the case of vacuum cleaners. I think that the general term "furniture" is one that serves. I do not know that the members of the Dáil in general were in any way mistaken as to its meaning. There is just one class of article that is included in the term furniture which members of the Dáil did not realise would be classed as furniture: that is brushes used in houses. I do not think that is one that we should move to exclude. It is an article that has been manufactured here for a very long time and it has been manufactured in a satisfactory way. Brushmaking is an old industry here, and I do not feel inclined to move for the exclusion of that particular class of article from the definition "furniture."

In regard to the other things that were included I think they mostly are articles that anybody would have anticipated as being likely to be included in the term "furniture."

Comment on this

Will street brushes come under the word "brushes?"

Comment on this

Not if they are street brushes.

Comment on this

Would tools come under the definition?

Comment on this

No, for instance, a hammer handle.

Comment on this

Is crockery ware furniture?

Comment on this

Wooden furniture.

Comment on this

What about clothes pegs. They have been defined as furniture.

Comment on this

I think they have been defined as furniture.

Comment on this

The principle of Deputy Cooper's amendment is to let the public know what they have to pay on. The Minister, in replying to Deputy Cooper, stated that the Commissioners have under consideration, or have adopted certain exemptions.

Comment on this

One exemption appears in the section; another appears amongst the amendments that are on the Paper.

Comment on this

I think the Minister did indicate that the Commissioners have the power to vary——

Comment on this

No, the Commissioners are bound, when any doubt arises, to take the advice of their solicitor; they might feel that it would be well to have the advice of the Attorney-General on it. When they get that advice they act on it, unless the matter is decided otherwise in the courts, or until the matter is decided otherwise in the courts. But they must strictly carry out the law as laid down.

Comment on this

The Minister has not answered me. He quoted articles as being left out, but some of them are made of metal. Coal scuttles are usually made of metal; so are umbrella stands. A side-board would be defined as a table and cupboard, and it would probably come under one or other of these terms. I do not know what meaning the law places on the word furniture. I do not know whether shelves and curtain poles would be included in it. I think if a person takes an unfurnished house he usually gets shelves and curtain poles in it.

Comment on this

You did not go into any of the new houses.

Comment on this

I know that I bought a house unfurnished, and there were both shelves and curtain poles in it. I would rather the shelves had not been in it. But those are minor points. If the principle of this amendment were adopted, there is nothing to prevent the Minister putting in the whole schedule from which he has obviously quoted, on Report. I suggest that we are doing wrong both in this and on the last amendment in transferring to the Revenue Commissioners and to the Attorney-General a duty which it is for us to discharge. It is for us to say what articles are to be taxed and what articles are covered by that general description "furniture." I am not convinced by the Minister's arguments.

Comment on this

Deputy Hewat has appealed on behalf of the public. I would appeal on behalf of the Customs officers, because they find great difficulty in deciding whether items are taxable or not. The result is that articles coming in at the beginning of the year will not be cleared until Christmas. I heard of a case from Sligo where an importer purchased a lot of goods. The Customs officers charged him a certain amount. He wrote a cheque for the amount, but the Customs officers thought that perhaps there might be an overcharge and until the matter was decided they would not give him the goods. He was willing to pay and to get a refund afterwards if there was an overcharge, but the Customs officers would not allow the goods through until the thing was finally decided. If the matter was decided on the lines of the amendment I think it would be a great advantage both to the Customs officers and to the public.

Comment on this

Of course instructions are being given to cover all the points that have been raised. They may not all have occurred to people in the first instance and supplementary instructions are issued. It is not necessary in every case that we should consult the Revenue Commissioners or the Law officer. If the Revenue Commissioners have any doubt as to the position they can take legal advice. In the case of individual officers, they find difficulty in deciding whether an article is dutiable or not. Somebody complained to me that in one place an officer had insisted on charging duty on a bedspread on the ground that it was part of a bed. I rather think it was a false allegation. Some difficulties will arise, but these are only initial difficulties. From time to time, instructions will be issued that will cover every possible point that can be raised. I should say that even now there are very few articles coming under the notice of Customs officers that they will not be able to decide promptly whether they are dutiable or not.

Comment on this

I think the Minister is under a misapprehension with regard to the bedspread case. It was I who mentioned it to him. It occurred with regard to Messrs. Arnott, Dublin. It is a genuine case and no fabrication. It is really necessary, in the interests of the Customs and of the trading public, that there should be some sort of technical education, some sort of continuation school, provided for those who are to carry on the very difficult duties we are imposing on them. In all good faith the Customs official was under the impression that a bedspread was part of a bedstead, and therefore a wooden article. It had to be explained, after considerable difficulty, that it was in the nature of a quilt. He knew what a quilt was and the difficulty was surmounted. Similarly, when the duty was first put on musical instruments, a case arose where it was only after considerable discussion and wrangling that a Customs officer was convinced that a piano-stool was not a musical instrument.

Deputy Cooper is legally, technically, and historically correct in his claim that his catalogue includes sideboards, because a sideboard is literally a side-table, and all sideboards, as he is well aware, were originally tables merely. The cupboard arrangement was a separate entity altogether, which, in the latter part of the eighteenth century was added, and made a component part of it. Now it would come under the category of a cupboard, and it would be hit in either case. There is one article of furniture which is in very general use, and which more than Deputy Cooper would be likely to expect to find as one of the appurtenances of the house he has rented, and would be disappointed, namely, spring rollers for blinds. These are only made in America. An English firm attempted to rival the American producer in their manufacture. They invested a considerable amount of capital and secured skilled labour, but they could not produce this article at a fraction of the cost of the American article. We are protecting nothing by putting a duty on these. They cost a remarkably small sum. You could not buy in Ireland the timber that is contained in one of them for the price of the total contraption, its spring interior, and all the adjustments, and putting on a duty on such an article is really only making things costly for the generality of people, especially poor people, while the revenue to be gained from it is comparatively trifling. It does seem to be a sound principle that the public should know what they are to be charged for and what they are expected to pay upon. As a general warning, the word "furniture," no doubt, is good enough and, if it is intended merely as a sort of prohibitory notice, to prevent the public from importing things in the category of furniture, it is well and good. But, after all, we are supposed to safeguard the interests of the trading community, and to be concerned about commerce, and undoubtedly the want of a detailed and specific list will militate against the swiftness of the clearing of stuff that accumulates in the Customs. We all know the difficulty of the railway porter who, trying to charge for a parrot and some other things, consulted his list and interpreted "cats is dogs, porpoises is insects." You may no doubt create a similar difficulty here. I suggest if, in addition to this collateral advantage of having a detailed list in a schedule, you also had some sort of technical after-hours school provided, you would get over a great many of the difficulties.

Comment on this

I am very glad to have Deputy Magennis's advocacy. I hope, if the curtain pole is not excluded, its associate and neighbour, the spring blind, will be. I think in the main he has made a case. The appeal I really want to make to the Minister is to make these instructions and regulations accessible to the members of the Oireachtas, by placing them in the reading room or in some other way. I do not know how they are issued, but we have no access to them. The result is that we are continually getting questions from constituents as to whether it is right that such an article should be taxed. We have no way of replying without going to the Revenue Commissioners. I think it would save his own Department a considerable amount of correspondence and trouble if he would make these things accessible. At any rate, we would feel that if a mistake had been made we could call attention to the matter by question or by some other means.

Comment on this

I would undertake to let Deputies have, and also to make available for the public in the ordinary way, a document giving the most complete list possible, so that very little doubt could remain in anybody's mind as to what was included in the term "furniture." But there still would be something left out.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (2), line 34, after the word "levied" to insert the letter "(a)" and in line 37 after the word "frame" to insert the words

"or

(b) on any apparatus made, wholly or partly of wood and adapted to be used for the purpose of household cleaning by means of suction or on any component part of any such apparatus."

The amendment is introduced because of the fact that the relative value of the wood in instruments of the kind is so very small that the tax would not be worth the cost of collection.

Comment on this

Has the Minister considered that this is, in fact, a brush? It is an apparatus described as a cleaner, worked either by a pump or by electricity actuating a pump. It really takes the place of a brush, and brushes are some of its components. One of the oldest established businesses in Dublin is brush-making in all its varieties, and if this experiment in the way of a protective tariff is to be successful, and if tooth brushes, shaving brushes and so on, are to be put aside and sweeping brushes and brushes for cleaning ranges are to be regarded, and rightly regarded, as furniture, it will mean that this piece of furniture will really be a substitute for many of these brushes. In any house where a suction cleaner is used it takes the place of certain brushes that formerly would be supplied by the Dublin industry. It seems to me, therefore, that although we are benefiting the adoption of modern methods and helping domestic economy in this case, there is a certain amount of cross-purposes. Anything that discharges the function of a brush should be, for the purpose of this Bill, a brush.

Comment on this

I understood up to now that Deputy Magennis favoured the development of electricity. He did enthusiastically support the Shannon proposal because he believed it would aid brightness and comfort, and relieve unnecessary labour in certain departments of social life. He is not proposing in the interests of the candle-making industry to prevent the development of oil lamps, gas or electricity, but he is proposing for the benefit of the brush-making industry that you should prevent the development of suction for the purpose of removing dust and dirt. I am at one with him in desiring to see the brush-making industry retained as far as it is reasonably possible, but I am not so far advanced in the protectionist dogma as to say that you must restrain the development of scientific apparatus in the interests of the old-fashioned brush-making. If I had that view, I would certainly not support any proposal that would come into competition with the old-established industry of candle-making.

Comment on this

There is another point also. Certain classes of vacuum cleaners contain no wood, and they would escape the tax. It simply would mean that these would be competing with others that contained a small proportion of wood.

Comment on this

I merely spoke to draw attention to a fact that perhaps has been overlooked, that circumstances sometimes arise in medical practice that the treatment which would cure a patient suffering from one ailment will expedite the removal of a patient suffering from another. On the question of tariffs we need to gang warily. That was the sole purpose I had in view.

Comment on this

took the Chair.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister if he has been able to meet the point that I brought up on Second Reading about what are called charity clothes, clothes sent from outside the Saorstát to some charitable agency, and further, if it is possible to do anything to meet the even harder case of people of reduced means who receive clothes from relations or friends living in Great Britain or in the Six Counties? These people are often very poor and they are also very proud; they do not like it to be known that they are in receipt of charity, and at the same time these part-worn clothes are a god-send to them, enabling them to make a respectable appearance in the eyes of the world. I realise that it would be very difficult to make arrangements to meet the case of these people without defeating the objects of the tax, because tailors might arrange with agents to get clothes in under that guise, but if it is possible to do something, I hope that the Minister will do so to meet a case which is really a genuinely hard case. I hope he will be able to tell us what proposals he has in view with regard to charitable societies like the Sick and Indigent Roomkeepers' Society.

Comment on this

I desire to draw the Minister's attention to another matter. I consider that this section imposes a certain amount of hardship on those people whose furniture was destroyed by the Irregulars or otherwise, and who got an award, probably two years ago, with the construction order for their premises. Many of these construction orders could not be carried out up to this, or are not finished, and of the furniture award much of the money is still lying there and the furniture has not been bought. This section imposes a 33 1-3 duty on imported furniture. The Minister may say that this furniture can be procured at home, but I hold that furniture similar to that which most people lost, cannot be produced locally. You may get kitchen chairs and similar articles made here, but if you buy the high-class furniture made in this country the award would not be sufficient, and it is, therefore, incumbent on these people to buy imported or second-hand furniture. The Minister may think lightly of it, but it would come home to him if he had got an award of £1,000 for furniture that he could not buy for £1,300 or £1,400, and he would not think so lightly of it. There are many people in this predicament, and I think the Minister should do something for them on the Report Stage. I would like to hear his views on the matter, and to know if he considers that the imposition of this tax will mean that one-third of what he gave with one hand he is taking away with the other.

Comment on this

Deputy Doyle talks about people who got awards, say, a couple of years ago, and have not yet been able to buy the furniture for which the award was made——

Comment on this

They have not had their houses reconstructed.

Comment on this

Quite. It is a fact that during the past couple of years furniture has slumped very considerably, and probably even with the tax on these people will be able to buy about as much furniture as they would have been able to buy if they had bought before there was a reduction in prices. At any rate, if that does not cover the difference, it covers it in part. I do not think it is possible to meet cases like that, any more than it would be possible to meet the case of a person, say, who may have got money from an insurance company. Any change in a system of taxation will occasionally bear hardly on people.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

It is an extraordinarily big change. A thousand pounds would buy a couple of years ago what would now be worth only £630, on the basis of prices at that time.

Comment on this

There are quite a number of kinds of furniture of which there will be no substantial change in price as a result of this tax. There were classes of furniture made on competing terms in this country before the tariff was put on at all. They were not perhaps made in sufficient quantities to meet the market, but in those particular grades of furniture I think competition will be stimulated, and as far as they are concerned, a person who has an award will be able to buy at approximately the same price as before the tax was imposed. There are other cases where, no doubt, an additional price will have to be paid as a result of the tariff, but, as I said before, that is, to some extent at any rate, neutralised by the fall that has taken place in prices during the past couple of years. I do not know that the difficulty is one that any reasonable machinery could be devised to meet.

We have examined the matter of clothing imported for charitable purposes. It would be possible to exempt clothing imported by charitable organisations, but it would not be possible to do in the case of clothing imported by individuals, and, as Deputy Cooper rightly said, in many cases individuals desiring to import second-hand clothing would have a better case than a charitable organisation. In any case I am not frightfully keen on encouraging charitable organisations to gather old clothes in other countries for distribution here. From the administrative point of view it would be practicable to deal with the importations of organisations such as the Sick and Indigent Roomkeepers' Society, or bodies of that sort, by way of exemption, but that is only part of the problem, and no machinery could be devised for dealing with individuals. It does not really seem equitable to deal with one and not with the other. On the whole, I feel that it is not desirable to do so.

Comment on this

I am sorry that the Minister is not more sympathetic towards the charity clothing, because while it may be possible in time to get old clothes in this country, it will take some time to organise it, and in the meantime the poor will suffer. I cannot help thinking that this is one of the cases where administrative convenience should come second to the welfare of the people. With regard to Deputy Doyle's point, I do not think that the Minister has made his case at all. His case, which he also made to me some time ago, is, firstly, that furniture ought to be procurable in this country, and so the tax will not have to be paid, and secondly, that furniture has fallen in price in the last two years. I do not know if he will accept the Board of Works as an authority on furniture, but I find that the Chairman of the Board of Works, in evidence before the Committee of Public Accounts on the 18th June of last year, said: "It may be that members of the Committee do not fully realise how expensive furniture is. It is one of the things that have become most expensive." That was a year ago. Since then I have examined the Board of Works' Estimate for furniture, and I find that it has fallen very slightly, less than 2 per cent. of their Estimate of last year, so that this marked slump in the price of furniture is not borne out by the figures and the statements made on behalf of the Department for which the Minister is responsible.

The Minister's second point is that the furniture is obtainable in this country. I had a letter this morning from a gentleman who is not a constituent of mine, but who said that he wrote to me because one of his representatives was a Minister, and therefore he did not think he would take the matter up. He informed me that he wrote to the principal furniture dealers in Dublin, Messrs. Millar and Beatty, and they informed him that furniture of the class he required was not manufactured in the Saorstát, and he would have to get it manufactured elsewhere, from which I infer there is no reasonable possibility that it will be manufactured in the Saorstát in the near future. I know that firm, and I fancy other firms are in great difficulties, that they cannot get the skilled labour required to manufacture furniture of this class. It seems to me altogether unfair to say to a person who has been put to the loss of his own furniture, put to grave and serious inconvenience as the result of the burning of his house, "You will be able to buy furniture cheaper than when it was burned." He did not buy the furniture when it was burned. He may have bought it 20 years ago. Account has been taken of that in the settling of the claim, and to say to him, "You will have to pay thirty-three and a third per cent. more than you were allowed as compensation for your furniture," will cause a hardship. If that is the result those taxes are bad, because taxes that produce injustice are bad taxes.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say is a test tube, provided with a cork, a bottle?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy complaining that test tubes have been taxed?

Comment on this

No, I am asking for information.

Comment on this

They are not bottles in the view of the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

If they are not, are they jars?

Comment on this

The Minister does not specify test tubes as bottles?

Comment on this

No, they are not regarded as bottles.

Comment on this

I put down this amendment with a view to getting a statement from the Minister as to the progress that has been made in the bottle industry as a result of the imposition of this duty. It will be remembered that when discussing the Resolutions, nearly a month ago, we put to the Minister the case of certain industries in the Saorstát, in particular the manufacture of ink, which were going to be seriously penalised by this duty. A great many of the industries that were being penalised, such as the soda-water bottling trade and similar trades, had their case met by the introduction of an amendment by Deputy Duggan taxing all bottles that contain dutiable goods. Ink is not dutiable. When we put it to the Minister that these industries will suffer as the result of cross-Channel ink coming in in untaxed bottles, whereas Irish ink has to be put into taxed bottles, the only consolation we could get was that the Minister said they would urge the Irish bottlemakers to supply the necessary bottles for the ink and certain other trades—chemists and so on—with as little delay as possible, and in another connection the Minister suggested that the Irish bottle trade hopes to be able to meet the new demand by the beginning of June.

We are now one-third of the way through June. I should like to ask how far the trade has been able to meet these demands. I am informed that the manufacturers of ink in County Wicklow have approached the Irish bottlemakers and have been told that they cannot hope to supply the demands before the end of July. If they cannot supply the demands before the end of July, they might as well not supply at all, because the trade is going. The cross-Channel ink-makers, having their bottles free of duty, are capturing the whole market of the Irish ink manufacturers. So that in order to stimulate a comparatively small industry, which could be stimulated in other ways, we are destroying another small industry. I hardly think that is a satisfactory state of affairs. I suggest that we should be wise to adopt this amendment. It is not a perfect one, but then, at any rate, manufacturers of articles in the Saorstát will say they have got fair play and they have not had to pay more for the bottles in which they put their goods than do their competitors across the water and in the Six Counties.

Comment on this

I do not exactly at the moment know how well the bottle manufacturers have got on. I do know that it was necessary for them to engage in a certain financial reconstruction, and that occupied more time than was anticipated. But I am informed that the progress that was made with that was satisfactory, and that there probably will be a junction of the two companies that exist, and that the anticipations that were held out in regard to the supply of bottles will be fully realised. There has been, I think, a certain amount of delay that was not anticipated, but I understand from the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who is more closely in touch with that particular aspect of the matter than I am, that the matter is going ahead, and that there is no reason to anticipate that they will not be able to supply the bottles required. There will, no doubt, be grave inconvenience if there is any long interval—if the manufacturers of ink have to pay duty on bottles and find themselves unable to get the other bottles for any length of time. But I do not think that we can as a remedy adopt the suggestion—I do not know whether it is in order as an amendment —put forward by Deputy Cooper that we should tax bottles imported as containers, no matter what they contain. The Deputy has already complained at considerable length about delays and Customs difficulties, and I have already suggested that one of the principal reasons for these delays was lack of space. If we have a whole series of articles, that at present are not dutiable, brought into the category of dutiable goods through the containers, we will have further delays and congestion. I do not think that with the staff and the accommodation available at present, we really could afford to take on these new things and to incur the delays that would result.

Comment on this

I am the last person to suggest that a Deputy should be ruled out of order, but I would suggest that this amendment, as it stands, is out of order coming from the Deputy. The effect of it is to impose new duties. By deleting the word "dutiable," of course the word "commodity" becomes enlarged, and therefore a new duty would have to be imposed. The only means whereby this amendment, I submit, could be accepted would be if it were moved by the Government.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Redmond is right. The amendment has served my object. It has extracted from the Minister a statement of the situation. The Minister is too honest for his present job. When he has got a bad case he shows it. I think he showed pretty clearly that he had a bad case on this occasion. In spite of his anticipations, not a single additional bottle has been made up to the present time, though we are in the middle of June, and we were promised that these factories would be in full blast in the beginning of June. I venture to say that as a result of that admission we shall respect the Minister as a man, but we shall in future distrust him as a prophet. I will either be ruled out of order, or ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
ACTING-CHAIRMAN

The amendment is out of order.

Comment on this

I beg to move:

To add to the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"Any article liable to the duty imposed by this section which is re-imported into Saorstát Eireann after exportation therefrom shall be exempt from the said duty if it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that the article had been first imported on or after the 9th May, 1925, and the duty imposed by this section had been duly paid thereon."

I move this amendment in response to the invitation thrown out by the Minister for Finance upon the occasion of the Second Reading, when I raised a question as to the propriety and the advisability of imposing a duty more than once upon what are known as containers, as distinct from empty bottles. I desire to direct attention to the wording of this amendment, which is in identical terms with sub-section (3) (d) of Section 18 in regard to empty bottles. The provision in regard to empty bottles is, that though empty bottles have to pay a duty once, that duty will not be reimposed upon the same bottles. I should like to impress upon the Dáil the distinction that is here made between the imposition of the tax as regards empty bottles, on the one hand, and full bottles or containers, upon the other. I should like to find out the reason for this distinction.

I do not know whether in the meantime the Minister has had an opportunity of further investigating this matter. If he has, I hope that he may be able to say that he has come to the conclusion that full bottles or containers should be treated in the same way as empty ones. I submit that the same argument applies to both as regards the imposition of the tax, in regard to the method of payment and the number of times it should be paid, as far as the empty and the full bottles are concerned. I want it to be clearly understood—it was not quite clearly understood on the last occasion, unfortunately, probably owing to my own fault—that I am not saying that there should be no tax upon full bottles. What I do say is: when a provision has been made, once the tax has been paid upon empty bottles that it will not be levied again upon the same empty bottles, that the provision should also apply to full bottles. When the tax has been once imposed upon full bottles, it should not again be imposed upon the same full bottles. I do not think that is in any way an extravagant demand.

The arguments, of course, in favour of the one levy as against several impositions are very strong. Take the case of the importation of a motor car or anything else. Is it to be said that 33 per cent. has to be paid on a motor car the first time it comes in and, if that motor car is sent out of the country—has to be sent out, perhaps, for repairs—when it comes back again the 33 per cent. shall be paid once more? No, it is not. That is not the case. That is not asked for. The motor car does not pay two duties; it only pays one. That provision has been made with regard to empty bottles, and I am only asking that the same provision should be made in regard to full bottles.

The arguments against this amendment in relation to full bottles, it may be said, are precisely the same arguments as could be used against the provision in Section 18 in regard to empty bottles. It is perfectly true that there is great difficulty in identification. The Minister informed us how to get over that difficulty, to some extent at any rate, in regard to empty bottles. I cannot see why he should not get over it in the same way in regard to full bottles. If an empty bottle comes into the country, pays duty, is exported full and then re-imported empty, and can be identified, and if the tax can only be imposed once on that, I do not see why a full bottle exported empty and re-imported full should not be treated in the same way. I would suggest there are other means besides the one adopted by the Minister in this regard. Say that a trader in Dublin imported 10,000 bottles of a certain mineral water into Dublin and got a receipt from the Customs authorities for having paid duty on the 10,000 full bottles. If he wanted to export the empty ones he goes back to the Customs authorities, brings his receipt for the 10,000 full bottles—he may not have the whole 10,000 empty ones to return, but he would have a large proportion of them—and he will be given credit in respect of the duty he has already paid. When he has to re-import the bottles he will be given due credit in respect of the 10,000 that he had paid duty for. I am only throwing that out as a suggestion.

I do not want to depart from the Minister's own suggestion and the line that he has adopted in regard to empty bottles. But why would he not pursue the same policy in regard to full bottles? It is not a matter that is going to interfere with the bottling industry, which we are anxious to see thriving and flourishing, but in regard to which, unfortunately, the Minister is not yet in a position to tell us how it has succeeded. It will not interfere with that under existing conditions, we may be told. I hold that it will be the contrary, because if these bottles which are imported full are to be exported empty, then re-imported full and another duty made payable on them, it will, perhaps, be more to the advantage of the trader to retain the empty bottles here and sell them here, to the disadvantage of the bottling industry in Ireland. I know, as a matter of fact, that already bottles have been sold, and they have been sold under the price at which they could be made here in Dublin.

Comment on this

Are they branded?

Comment on this

They are not branded. I think, from the point of view of injuring the bottling industry, the boot is upon the other foot. I think if the inducement of sending the empty bottles out of the country is taken away, if there is no inducement in that direction, the effect of a large quantity of empty bottles remaining here will certainly do no good, and may possibly do a considerable amount of harm in that industry which we are endeavouring to start and which we hope will thrive in Dublin.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

They would not be the right measurement.

Comment on this

They would be, say, for soda water. Take baby 'Pollys, for instance; they are very suitable for baby O'Briens. Perhaps the Deputy is acquainted with both those commodities. One is soda water and the other is a natural mineral-water bottled at the springs in Germany. If the mineral-water manufacturer in Dublin wants to get bottles, he will probably be able to buy the bottles cheaper from those who have them in Dublin and who do not want to export them than he would from the Dublin Bottlemaking Company, where, to my knowledge, they have not attempted to make anything in the nature of that bottle. That is my view, at all events, as far as the bottling industry is concerned. Consider what is the object of differentiating between the full and the empty bottle. It has been suggested—I do not think seriously, because I do not think it could be—that people might actually import full bottles into the country, that full bottles should be imported in large quantities, in order to evade the tax on empty bottles. That does not touch the point at all. I am not dealing with a tax on full and empty bottles; I am dealing entirely with the question as to whether the tax should be paid once by empty bottles and a dozen times by full bottles. I am not objecting to the tax on full and empty bottles. My whole contention is that what you have done in Section 18 in regard to empty bottles should, in all fairness, be done in regard to full bottles, and the new section that I propose, after Section 19, covers that ground. I do not think I need trouble the House to read the section. It is identically the same as Section 18 (3) (d). I trust the Minister will be able to meet me some way in that regard.

Comment on this

What we have done in regard to bottles exported full is, that we have really stretched the law and departed from the ordinary practice in order to facilitate people engaged in an Irish industry, and who are exporting their goods here. Normally, we should insist on absolute identification of bottles which are being readmitted free, and a comparison with the bottles which were exported. Following the ordinary practice in regard to Customs matters, we ought to be sure that the bottles imported were the identical bottles exported. We do not insist on that. We simply seek that they are similar bottles to the exported bottles. We operate the exemption contained in the previous section, and which existed last year. We operate on a sort of running account which we keep with the trader. We do a thing which we are barely entitled to do. We assume an identification which is not really established. We assume they are identical bottles, although we do not take the steps we should take to establish that identity. We stretch the law for the purpose of enabling the people manufacturing mineral-waters here to carry on their trade without any handicap. It is a different matter altogether when we are asked to do it in favour of foreign manufacturers, producers of mineral or table waters sold here. There is no reason why we should strain the law and depart from the ordinary practice for the purpose of facilitating outside competitors. That is the reason why, under Section 19, we do not make provisions that are in the Bill under the previous section.

If we adopted the Deputy's amendment and carried it out strictly, and insisted on absolute identification, which I think we ought not to do, because, after all, we have no interest in facilitating the trade of foreign competitors of our manufacturers here, it would be practically, if not entirely, inoperative. I suggest there is not really any point in the suggestion the Deputy put forward, that if some concession such as this is not given, bottles will be retained, left here, and therefore fresh bottles will be used for each consignment of foreign mineral or table waters imported. If it pays the people carrying on this trade to take the bottles out of the country now, as I believe it does, it will pay them with the tax on. The tax will make no difference in that way. We assume that if the bottles went out in the past, they will go out in the future. I think that is pretty obvious. Bottles in the past were imported free. They had no duty to pay, and it was cheaper to take the bottle out of here than to buy a new bottle. If there is to be a duty on the importation of bottles, then it will be a question of whether it is cheaper to collect the bottles here and take them away, or purchase a new bottle and not bother with the collection.

Comment on this

And sell the old bottles here?

Comment on this

It really makes no change as regards the practice. It will depend on which system pays. I think that is the whole matter. We make a special point to meet our own manufacturers. We do not see why we should make a special point to meet their competitors, especially as making that special point does involve assuming identification without taking the steps we ought to take to establish identity.

Comment on this

I notice the Minister says that this differentiation between the full and the empty bottles was really to protect the mineral-water manufacturers. I am glad to hear that, because that is what was always at the back of my mind—that this was not a tax on bottles, but on mineral waters. It is a tax for the benefit of mineral-water manufacturers in this country, a tax which the Minister and his Government are perfectly entitled to impose. But I do not think they are entitled to impose it in the way that they have done. I do think it would be fairer and squarer if they came forward and said: "We are going to place an extra tax on mineral-waters." Instead of that they proceed to do it in this exceedingly roundabout and cloaked fashion, and they place a tax upon one class of bottles and another class of bottles, and then get up at the eleventh hour and declare that this is not a tax on bottles, but is for the protection of mineral-water manufacturers.

If, as the Minister says, it is a question of competition from outside, if he thinks that we in this country can produce natural springs such as Apollinaris, Apenta, Vichy, and so forth, he is welcome to his opinion, but, unfortunately, I cannot agree with him. I would point out to him that we do manufacture soda water in this country, and very good soda water, too. Is he aware that, under his proposals soda water can be imported, and is being imported, in syphons, and that there is no tax whatever on the syphons? Would it not have been far better, from the point of view of the soda water manufacturers of Ireland, of which there are many, to protect industries which do exist and not to protect visionary industries, dependent on natural springs, which do not exist here? Would it not have been better to have placed a tax upon syphons than to have placed a tax upon full bottles? If the tax had been put upon syphons, there would have been some protection for Irish soda water manufacturers, but, instead of that, a tax is placed on what is known as "containers," which contain all sorts and kinds of table and mineral waters, which we cannot, and do not, produce in this country. This tax, I submit, with all due deference, will be no benefit whatever to Irish soda water manufacturers or to the glass-bottle manufacturers. This section being supposed to deal with protection of glass bottles, most people would understand it to be for the benefit of the glass-bottle industry. Now we are told that it is not that class of tax at all, that it is an extra tax on mineral-water for the benefit of the Irish mineral-water manufacturers. I think it would have been better if the tax had been struck otherwise.

I admit it is a tax on all classes of mineral-water. It means that the mineral-water coming in here at present, which pays 8d. per gallon duty already, will have to pay a further duty now upon the vessel which contains it. That vessel will come in here. It will vary in size from the "Baby 'Polli," which, by the way, was the foster-mother of the "Baby O'Brien," to champagne bottles which, I admit, are not of much use once they have been used. But you would have all kinds and descriptions of bottles which it would not be worth while to export and re-import, with the new duty on them, each time. They will be inevitably dumped here and that will be to the disadvantage of the bottle industry. I put that very strongly to the Minister and I would suggest that if it is not possible for him to accept my amendment, as it stands, he should consider the matter between this and the Report Stage and see if he could not mitigate to some degree the extent of the tax that is imposed. Threepence per dozen is to be placed upon bottles under 5 ounces, and 6d. per dozen is to be placed upon bottles over 5 ounces. That is not an ad valorem duty at all. I do not know how it is arrived at. A champagne bottle will pay only about as much as an ordinary split soda water bottle. In that regard, something might be done to make the tax more fair. If the Minister would consider between this and the Report Stage the whole question in its different aspects, he might see that there was something to be said from the point of view of similar treatment, in the first place, for empty and full bottles, no matter whether they can be identified or not; in the second place he might discover the possibility of future injury to the new bottle industry, and in the third place he might see the possibility of mitigating to some degree the extent of the new imposition which, I respectfully submit, has been reached in an arbitary manner and not upon any basis that is apparent on the paper, as it is before us.

Comment on this

This duty was imposed solely with reference to the bottle industry. It was imposed because we found that people would import large quantities of soda, mineral or other waters for the purpose of getting the bottles free of tax, as they would have been able to do if there had been no tax on the bottles. Immediately after the first resolution was passed, we heard of people who actually ordered large quantities of mineral water from outside the State, not because they would have preferred that mineral water to mineral water they could have got here, but because they got the bottles in free of duty. It was with reference to that it was imposed and not as an extra tax on mineral waters. We are asked to make concessions in regard to the operation of this tax and we are asked to make those concessions really for the benefit of people who send in mineral or natural waters here which compete with mineral-waters made here. I do not see any reason why we should make that special concession. There was a reason to make it in regard to bottles exported full because we had to prevent our own industry from being handicapped. If I had any belief that such an amendment as Deputy Redmond suggests was necessary in the interests of the bottle industry, I would certainly consider it very carefully but, so far as I have been able to go into it, I do not see that there is going to be any danger in that respect. I think the bottles which have been customarily collected and exported will be collected and exported in the future, independent of any change.

Comment on this

In regard to what the Minister has said about the importation of full bottles, that has not got anything to do with the question, because I am not opposing the tax at all as proposed for both full and empty bottles. I am in favour of both. What I am opposing is the differentiation in the imposition of the tax as between one case and the other. In one case, the tax is imposed once and in the other case it is imposed every time. In regard to the suggestion that quantities of full bottles would be imported as a means of providing empty bottles——

Comment on this

That was without the tax on bottles.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that the freight that would have to be paid on those full bottles would not be considerably more than the tax that would have to be paid? Is he aware of the fact that empty bottles cost much less not only in weight but in the comparative charge for carriage on the railways? They cost very much less in freight than full bottles and any trader who would import bottles full of liquid— whether water or any other liquid— and pay in respect of the extra weight and extra freight in order to avoid the duty, would be out of his mind.

Comment on this

I wonder did the Deputy ever hear of the town of Dundalk? The freight from the Border would not be very considerable.

Comment on this

I see the Minister's point now. I am always forgetting the Border. Really, that point does not affect the case. As I said before, I am not against the tax but against the difference in the imposition of the tax—the number of times it is being imposed on one as compared with the other. In regard to the Minister's suggestion, that the amendment would be for the benefit of outside competitors, I venture to say that it would be nothing of the kind. It is not my intention that it should be so. A great many of these waters are beneficial from the medicinal and table water point of view. They are waters that cannot be made in this country, and their distribution has given considerable employment here. For some time, at all events, you will not be able to have sufficient bottles manufactured here, and you will not be able to have the wonderful Connemara baths developed in order to replace the amount of distributive employment that is given at present. However, the Minister seems to have made up his mind, and he is now about to impose, by this section, an extra duty upon mineral waters. I congratulate him upon the manner in which he has done it, but I hope the next time he proposes a new duty it will not seem to be upon one article when, in reality, it is upon the other.

Comment on this

I rather gathered from Deputy Redmond's last remarks that he is not pressing his amendment. I would like to say in regard to this question that I think the Minister has got rather into difficulties over this bottle question. In this particular case referred to in the amendment the bottles travelled backwards and forwards, and on the present method they will pay a tax in the first instance and pay a tax on every other occasion on which they come in. I look on it in this way: that obviously the people who are sending in this stuff will consider their own interests entirely. If it suits them to leave the bottles here they will leave them here, and if it suits them to take away the bottles, and pay the duty again on reimportation, they will do it. The one thing I would like to emphasise to the Minister is that it will come out of the pocket of the consumer. Deputy Redmond has made the point that these special bottled waters he refers to are not produced here. Then, obviously, they do not come directly into competition with any local product, so that the tax is a tax that does not protect any Irish industry, and it is going to be paid, I presume, if one understands the ordinary economic laws, by the people who wish to use these particular waters.

Comment on this