DÁIL IN COMMITTEE. - FINANCE BILL, 1925—THIRD STAGE.
Contributions 154–313 of 313. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 27 of 1925 ›
I move amendment No. 9:—
In sub-section (1), line 55, to delete the word "and" and in the same line, after the word "tobacco," to insert the words "spirits, and any article on which a duty is imposed by Section 25 of this Act."
The effect of the amendment is to exempt spirits from the operation of the section and to make the wording of the section consistent with the wording of Section 7 of the Finance Act of 1901.
Comment on this
I might say that sweetened spirits are charged on their sugar content. As they are charged spirit duty on the proof gallon and on the bulk gallon, the section would be extremely difficult if they were to be charged, as they would be, sugar duty on the bulk gallon, while the spirit duty is charged on the proof gallon. They will continue to be charged on the sugar content.
Comment on this
I move amendment 10:—
In sub-section (2), page 10, lines 5 and 6, to delete the words "contained in or," and in line 8 to delete the words "contained in or."
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 11:—
Before sub-section (3) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"Whenever the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that any motor car or motor car part imported into Saorstát Eireann is for the use of a poor law medical officer they shall, subject to compliance with such conditions as they think fit to impose, exempt such motor car or motor car part from payment of the duty on motor cars and motor car parts imposed by this section."
In moving my amendment, I may, at the outset, suggest to the Minister that for the purposes of the amendment he could give relief under two heads— firstly, in import taxes, and, secondly, in licence duties. Whilst I should be glad if the Minister would see his way to give relief to all members of the medical profession, I would confine the amendment to giving relief to those in the Poor Law Medical Service. The average doctor uses his motor car not as a luxury, but as part of his equipment. He brings speedy relief to his patients, and it cannot be said, in any sense, that it increases either the number of his patients or his income. The justification for increased motor taxation is mainly based on the fact that the tax goes to the upkeep of trunk roads, or main roads. The mileage of the dispensary doctor's district is about 100.
Comment on this
I may point out that none of the Customs duties collected on motor cars goes to the upkeep of trunk roads. They go into the Exchequer.
Comment on this
That makes it all the worse, because I have no doubt that out of every hundred miles there were only ten miles of trunk roads. In fact, there was very little money put into the repair of the roads, with the result that they do fearful damage to the doctors' cars. The net result is that the average life of the dispensary doctor's car is two years. That means that every other year he will have to pay an import tax and a licence tax, about £40 in alternate years. This would be an intolerable taxation on a man whose salary averages about £400 a year, and that £400 a year is not net. At least half of it goes to travelling expenses. I would ask the Minister to make some allowance in the case of these doctors. They feel that since the establishment of the Free State Government they have not got very good treatment; they have got less than concessions. They feel that they have not got justice. We would be satisfied, even if the Minister said that he would give us the same consideration and the same treatment as hackney cars. I think the Minister could well afford to do this, because on a recent occasion he found it necessary to withdraw a certain grant in the administration of the National Health Insurance. This grant was used for medical certification. The result was that when the doctors were paid from other moneys their remuneration was reduced by something like £10,000 a year, which was quite a considerable sum to men already badly paid. I leave it at that. I think the Minister will see the justice of the case I make. These men, as I said before, are very badly paid. Relief has been given to others who find themselves in distressful conditions owing to the times, and I know no men harder hit than the average dispensary doctor. He was at one time able to keep his children in a boarding-school. The average dispensary doctor nowadays has to withdraw them from the public schools and give them whatever education he can locally, with the result that he is very badly able to equip them. At least he cannot equip them as well as he was equipped himself, for their future life.
Comment on this
I wish to support the amendment. I know something about dispensary doctors in my district. I know that they would not be able to carry out their work properly without the aid of motor cars. I think Deputy Dr. Hennessy was very moderate in his demand. He only asked for equal treatment with the hackney cars. I know of a case in my own district where a serious accident occurred, and not alone did the dispensary doctor use his car for his own purposes, but on finding that an immediate operation was necessary he gave the patient the benefit of his car and drove him away immediately to the infirmary. Dispensary doctors have to go long distances both day and night. They have to visit the poor. They have not very big salaries, and the least they might get is the treatment that Deputy Hennessy asks for them, that is to put them on a par as regards taxation with the hackney car people. I do not think that there is anything unreasonable in his demand.
Comment on this
Deputy Hennessy seems to be under some misapprehension. A hackney car pays the ordinary Customs duty on coming in, and I do not see, if you want to make distinctions between individuals, how you can do so in respect of Customs duties. You might as well say that a doctor should be allowed to import during the year so many lbs. of sugar free of duty, or so much clothing. You cannot really distinguish between one individual and another when you are dealing with Customs duties. It would be practicable to do so if you were dealing with the road tax. I do not say that I would favour that, but the working out of the thing would be possible. It would not be possible in this case, because there would be nothing to prevent a doctor from bona fide importing a car for his own use, and when it ceased to please him selling it and importing another for his own use. You would have the possibility of abuse arising in that way. Some dispensary doctor might decide that he wanted his car no longer; you could not compel him to keep a car when he has got it, and the same difficulty would arise in regard to the parts. I do not think that this is a concession that could possibly be administered, and in any case I think it is entirely the wrong way of approaching the matter. We should be giving concessions to certain classes of public servants, shall I call them. If they are insufficiently paid the way to attack it is to put them on a higher basis of pay, but we should not unnecessarily introduce the giving of concessions and privileges to individuals. That always complicates the law, and it creates new grievances and new discontents. It is a most unsatisfactory way of dealing with things. If public servants are insufficiently paid the matter should be examined and their pay adjusted, but I do not think they should get special concessions. In saying that I am thinking more of the road tax. You might allow a doctor to pay less road tax or you might make arrangements to issue him the licence free of duty, but this proposal to allow his motor car or his motor parts in free of duty could not be administered without opening the way to very grave abuses.
Comment on this
I would remind the Minister that the case of the dispensary doctor is not on a level with that of other officials. It is well known that he is paid no salary; he does not even get his travelling expenses, and he performs services for which he receives no pay, such as the issuing of death certificates for which the State pays him nothing. I think a concession of this kind would help to make matters smoother for dispensary doctors. They cannot very well go on strike, and the Government has certain powers when it comes to fixing their salaries. It could increase their salaries, but it has always declined to do so. It appears to rely on the fact that the doctors cannot go on strike and that anything they are given is enough. Another matter to which I would like to draw the Minister's attention, although it might more properly come under another Ministry, is that there are a number of people who receive medical treatment free under the Medical Charities Acts who are not entitled to it legally or morally. The Government has continued simply to exploit the doctors in the treatment of these people, and now when they ask for some small recognition they are told that they should be put on a level with other officials.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister for some information with regard to the Committee which he promised to set up to consider the question of motor parts and whether he would possibly let in smaller motor parts free of duty. Has any progress been made in setting up that Committee? Can the Minister tell us who its members will be and what will be its terms of reference, or if it has not got to that point can he give us any information as to what associations and organisations he has approached with regard to the nomination of members of the Committee?
Comment on this
It has got to the point that the terms of reference have been drawn up. The terms of reference suggested are as follows:—
To consider and report as to the causes of delays in the clearance on importation of component parts of motor cars and motor cycles whether on first importation or on re-importation after repair, and as to what alterations, if any, should be made in the regulations governing the clearance of such goods.
It is proposed to have a couple of people on the Committee representing the motor trade, a couple of officials, and a chairman. I am not yet in a position to announce the names of members.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider putting on a representative of the motoring public, representing the Automobile Club or some such body?
Comment on this
And possibly add another official as well if he were afraid that there were too many against him.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 11, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"The duty imposed by this section shall not be charged or levied in respect of sugar or molasses made from beet grown in Saorstát Eireann, and the provisions of Section 6 (except sub-section (1) thereof) of the Finance Act, 1922, as adapted under the Adaptation of Enactments Act, 1922 (No. 2 of 1922), shall apply and have effect subject to the following modifications, that is to say:—
(a) the word "non-dutiable" shall mean exempted by this sub-section from the duty imposed by this section, and
(b) the expression "Saorstát Eireann" shall be substituted for the expression "Great Britain or Ireland."
Section 6 of the Finance Act, 1922, provided that Excise duties on sugar and molasses made from home-grown material were to cease. The object of the amendment is to make it clear that these duties are not being reimposed in the provisions of the present Bill and to remove any doubt that may arise on the construction of the section. It simply means that the law in that respect remains as it is.
Comment on this
The need for the existence of an Excise duty at all is that glucose may be made and that is liable for sugar duty on a certain basis. Glucose is to a considerable extent used in certain classes of cheap confectionery and jams.
Comment on this
Yes, but I cannot help but relate this to the discussion last night, and I think it is inevitable that we must consider the proposal to remit excess duty on sugar in relation to the general question of beet sugar. I do not think that this has any relation to anything except sugar made from beet grown in Saorstát Eireann.
Comment on this
The position is that the amendment is proposed in anticipation of the establishment of a beet sugar industry in the Saorstát, I was going to say during the period of this financial year, but presumably once this is passed it would require a special repeal to be enacted, so that apparently what is anticipated is that there would be no Excise duty on sugar made from beet grown in the Saorstát. I say we cannot help but relate that to the proposal of the Beet Sugar Subsidy Bill. In effect, if we pass this amendment it will mean an additional subsidy of £9 6s. 8d. per ton. That did not appear from the Minister's speech last night. There was in comparative British legislation in the first place a remission of Excise duty; that was the subsidy the beet sugar industry obtained in Great Britain. The proposal over there now is that beet sugar will pay a regular Excise duty equal to the import duty, but that it shall receive a subsidy. It now appears that we are proposing to pay a subsidy of 24/6 per cwt., with an additional subsidy in the form of a protective duty on imports, or shall I put it the other way, a remission of Excise duty of 9/4. I take the opportunity that this amendment affords of showing what it will mean with respect to the proposed beet sugar industry. Deputy Magennis provided us with some estimates of costs which laid the foundation from which we could draw some conclusions. On the basis of 6,000 tons production from 50,000 tons of beet as an average per year of the first three years, which is the basis upon which the Minister is putting forward his scheme, we have the following balance sheet:—There will be paid to the farmers per year for beets, £135,000. The cost of turning that beet into sugar, according to Deputy Magennis's figures, would be £90,900. On the other side we should have a subsidy of 24s. 6d., £147,000, and the sale of pulps, £12,500, and assuming the price of 20s. per cwt. of sugar, £120,000 for sugar. That would show a net profit of £53,600, to which it is now proposed to add £56,000, that is, a net profit of £109,600 upon a capital of £300,000.
Comment on this
That is the figure Deputy Magennis gave when he was trying to show the small return. But the figure of the Minister was £300,000, which the Minister for Agriculture tried to correct by saying £200,000. I am taking the £300,000 figure, and assuming the costs will be ‘omewhat equivalent to those in Deputy Magennis's scheme, we have a return of £110,000, or thereabouts, per year for the first three years, assuming that this amendment is passed, and the Bill also becomes law in its present form. If the Bill does not become law, the amendment, whether it is passed or not, does not matter, because there will be no beet sugar industry without a subsidy. So that obviously the amendment is intended to fit in with the Bill. I wonder are we to understand that part of the bargain with M. Lippens is that there should be a remission of duty on sugar made from home-grown beet. That was not stated last night, but it is surely a central fact, because it will mean an additional charge upon the Exchequer of £56,000 per year. If the figures have been given and the estimate has been made with this remission of duty, then I think the case that I endeavoured to make last night, on the figures that were then available, was not so serious as it appeared, but if we are to add £56,000 to the subsidy, which this amendment would entail, then I say that we are entirely too extravagant, that we are making too big a present to the shareholders in the proposed company, and imposing altogether too great a burden upon the State for the benefit to agriculture. If we are going to spend this amount of money, we must examine very closely whether the establishment of the beet sugar industry is the best way to expend that money. The proposal is confined in this first factory to probably 800 to 1,000 farmers, and it would mean £200 per year to that number for, say, ten years.
I do not want to argue the case of the Bill again, but one cannot but relate this amendment to the Bill, and consider the effect upon the Bill of the amendment. I would say, in any case, that as there is not likely to be any beet sugar produced before the next Budget statement in April next, we ought not to tie ourselves by passing this amendment, because, whether there has been any agreement or not, if this becomes law, it will be assumed by the promoters of the company that they are to have a remission of duty, in addition to their subsidy. Once we enter upon that, we shall be bound, on pain of breach of faith, to continue this remission. It is very serious I think, that we should have discussed the Bill last night without having an understanding that it is also proposed to remit 9/4 per cwt. upon all sugar produced in the Saorstát.
Comment on this
I have not been able, perhaps, to follow Deputy Johnson's arguments entirely, but I may say that this amendment is proposed more for the purpose of making sure that we have not inadvertently repealed the exemption of beet sugar from Excise duty which has heretofore existed. At present, apart from the effect that the Resolutions may have, there is no Excise duty chargeable on this sugar. We did not intend to repeal that provision of the law, but since this Bill has been drafted, it has been suggested that the form of the section may perhaps repeal it. To ensure that it will not repeal it, we propose to put in the amendment specifically declaring the exemption of beet sugar from Excise duty to be in force.
Comment on this
No, on the contrary. I do not want to discuss the Beet Sugar Bill now, but the Bill was drawn up on the basis of there being no Excise duty on beet sugar produced here. The various figures at different periods are the net subsidy that they will have. Of course there will be deducted from that the amount of the Customs duty on sugar at any particular time. That is the net advantage that those manufacturing beet sugar here will have over competitors—the average of 23/-.
Comment on this
Will the Minister explain what is meant by the comparison with the British subsidy, which is to continue for the next two or three years?
Comment on this
That was adjusted to give the corresponding figures. The British figures were net figures, too. The figures were strictly comparable. We give the net advantage that the manufacturer has. That average of 23/- over ten years gives the net advantage that the manufacturer here gets over his competitors. The British figures that we gave were corresponding figures. If we impose an Excise duty on sugar, and charge it to the manufacturer here, we should have to add the amount we charge in Excise duty to our subsidy. We do not wish to impose an Excise duty here, because it seems to be absurd to charge a person duty and to give him that duty back with some more as subsidy. In Great Britain they have an Excise duty, possibly because, theoretically, they hold themselves out to be a Free Trade country, or for some such reason. That in fact is the only reason there could be for charging an Excise duty and paying people to whom we charge the duty a greater sum in subsidy. You have two transactions instead of one.
There is not the slightest possibility I should say, in our time that sugar manufactured here can afford to pay a net amount in taxation. That is, that it can afford to pay more than it would get in subsidy. Certainly, one can say that for 20 years it will not be able to do such a thing. I do not think there is any country in the world where sugar can pay a net amount in taxation. Consequently, we regard it as absurd to impose an Excise duty. We do not wish to alter the existing provisions of the law which exempt beet sugar from Excise duty. The figures that we have in the Bill are the net figures of the advantage that the beet sugar will have here. They are figures, of course, that are reducible in the actual amount paid by the amount of the Customs duty on sugar which might prevail at any particular time.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In sub-section (2), line 29, after the word "handball" to insert the words "gymnastic displays."
I do not think this amendment modifies in principle the section as drafted, but it makes verbal additions which really complete the category that is provided. In sub-section (2) the Minister recognises that certain athletic games are often played indoors, and by referring to badminton and handball as being excluded from the entertainments tax, along with other games, he showed that he approved of a similar remission applying to them. I do not think his list is complete, and this amendment proposes to add gymnastic displays, which would be, as athletic performances, quite on a par, I should think, with the games of badminton and handball. I do not think there is any real principle involved, and I have every hope that the Minister will be prepared to accept the amendment. I have two amendments in which the same principle is involved, but I am simply referring to gymnastic displays in the first instance.
Comment on this
I am prepared to accept the principle of both this amendment and the next amendment, but I should like the draftsman to have a look at the phraseology.
Comment on this
There is one point I should like to raise on this section, and it is one that the Minister would probably be inclined to meet, that is that entertainments tax is charged on exhibitions given by artists who exhibit their pictures for sale. I do not think it could have been intended that that particular form of exhibition should be taxed, and it is causing a considerable amount of hardship.
These exhibitions are not held in the same way as ordinary entertainments. They are merely held in order that the artist might be able to put his wares before prospective purchasers. A small charge is made for entering into these exhibitions, merely for the purpose of keeping all and sundry out who might take advantage of the opportunity offered and flock out to the place. I believe that happened in a large number of cases. I know it to be the case from my own experience. Whenever I have gone to one of these exhibitions I have not paid because, I suppose, I was considered to be a prospective purchaser. I believe that in a large number of cases friends and others who go are not charged. Charges are only made in some cases and they are not levied in other cases. It would be just as much an absurdity to charge an entrance fee to a grocer's shop in respect to the people who go there to buy commodities the grocer has to sell, as to charge entertainment tax on a person going to see certain things that he might purchase. That is the only way the artist has to exhibit his wares to prospective purchasers. This might be met by way of administration. All the Minister might do is to undertake an entertainment tax will not be looked for in cases of that kind. I think the case is equally fair and just.
Comment on this
I was not aware that entertainment tax was chargeable in such cases until very recently when the matter was brought to my notice. I have been considering it and I will promise to go fully into it before the Report Stage. I think it is a case in which we could agree to have the payment exempt from entertainment duty. I will promise to consider it further.
Comment on this
In the event of the Minister exempting these exhibitions from entertainment tax, will there be a refund?
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
To insert before Section 28 a new section as follows:—
(1) There shall, in respect of beer brewed in Saorstát Eireann on or after the twenty-second day of April, nineteen hundred and twenty-five, be allowed the following rebate from the excise duty payable in respect thereof, that is to say—
In the case of beer brewed by a brewer of beer for sale, for every thirty-six gallons of beer of whatever original gravity, charged with duty and delivered from the brewery, a rebate of one pound, or where the duty payable in respect of thirty-six gallons of any beer so charged and delivered is less than two pounds and four shillings, a rebate equal to the amount by which that duty exceeds the sum of one pound and four shillings;
and so in proportion for any difference in quantity.
(2) The excise drawback payable on the exportation of any beer, or on the deposit thereof in a warehouse for exportation, from Saorstát Eireann as merchandise or for use as ship's stores, shall, unless it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that no rebate has been allowed in respect of that beer under this section, be reduced by an amount equal to the amount of the rebate allowable under this section in respect thereof.
This sub-section shall be deemed to have had effect as from the twenty-second day of April, nineteen hundred and twenty-five.
(3) The Revenue Commissioners may make such regulations as they consider necessary for the purpose of carrying this section into effect, and in particular for the purpose of facilitating and controlling the calculation of the amount of the rebate to be allowed under this section and with respect to the method of computing the quantity of the beer in respect of which rebate is to be allowed.
(4) If any person acts in contravention of or fails to comply with any regulations made under this section, he shall, for each offence, be liable at the election of the Revenue Commissioners, either to an excise penalty equal to three times the amount of the rebate, which through the commission of the offence has been, or might have been improperly obtained.
This amendment is rather a long-winded one, but I will endeavour to condense it. At present the tax on stout is £5 per standard barrel, and if you reduce that by £1, and if the brewer gives 4s., the same as they did in England, it will reduce the price of stout by one penny per pint. I do not think the brewers should have any trouble in giving another £1 off the barrel, considering their shares are running up miles high, so to speak, every day. They are giving big dividends to the shareholders. I hold that the real shareholders are the people who drink the stout; they are the people who put up the shares. Those are the people for whom I now claim a bonus, just the same as others are getting this year. If £1 were taken off the tax, then perhaps we could agitate against Messrs. Guinness and other brewers. By so doing we would reduce the price of Guinness to 8d., and the price of other stout in another side of the country—stout just as good— to 6d.
I am not here speaking on behalf of the public. It is very hard, I am sure, to disabuse your minds on that point. I am speaking this time from the point of view that it is recognised that stout is a food. That has been recognised by the Ministry. I am not quite sure if it was the Ministry; but when a question was raised about regulating the size of bottles Deputies Johnson and Sir James Craig pointed out that the matter came before them at the Food Commission. There the size of stout bottles was questioned, and they did not think there was enough going into the poor man, who was using stout for food. I hold that stout is a good food. There are some foods you eat—you must eat them, because you cannot get better—and you can hardly digest them without having a bottle or a pint of stout. The pint of stout is essential in the every-day food of the working man. If you reduce it by £1 in the barrel, and if the brewer gives 4/-, you will bring the price of Guinness down to 8d. in my side of the country, where they sell it for 9d., and you will bring other good stout down to 6d. The workmen would appreciate that. The weather favours me in moving this amendment. I think a few pints will be necessary for the hay-saving very soon.
Comment on this
An arrangement was made in the British Finance Act of 1923 whereby there was a rebate of 20/- per bulk barrel, and whereby there were certain reductions by the brewers. That was for two purposes. It was for the purpose of reducing the price of the pint and for encouraging the consumption of lighter beers. For instance, if a brewer made a bulk barrel at a gravity of 50, he got only one rebate of 20/-; if he made two barrels with a gravity of 25, he got two rebates of 20/-. There was definite advantage in the brewing of light ales. I do not think it would have much effect in that direction in this country. The number of bulk barrels consumed in the Saorstát annually is about 900,000. If we gave a rebate of 20/- a barrel on that it would mean an immediate loss to the revenue of £900,000 per annum. If, in addition, beer were to be brewed at a lower gravity than is usual here, as the duty is charged on the standard barrel there would be a smaller amount of duty collected, while the same amount —£900,000—of a rebate would be given. In consequence, we might lose considerably more than £900,000 per annum by this. By adopting Deputy Daly's amendment, it would mean a minimum loss to the revenue of £900,000. The amendment cannot be accepted.
Comment on this
Out of stout alone the revenue gets four and a half millions annually, and they are trying to shut down half the public-houses.
Comment on this
Considering that you will have £3,600,000 out of stout, this is not much to grant to the people. You are hardly entitled to it at all. It was a war tax and it is still kept on. Now it is a teetotal tax, and you will be grumbling by and by if you are asked to pay a big price for the licensed houses when they are deprived of their licences. We are paying beforehand for that.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
Deputy Redmond is not here, and I formally move the amendment standing in his name:—
Before Section 30 to insert the following section:—
"The duties of Excise chargeable under Section 5 of the Finance (New Duties) Act, 1916, on cider and perry shall cease to be chargeable or leviable as on and from the 6th May, 1925, and no duty of Excise shall be chargeable or leviable on cider or perry which is sold or kept for sale in Saorstát Eireann on or after that date."
This will give the Minister an opportunity, as the President would say, to show his form, if he wants to do it.
Comment on this
As I explained to the Dáil already, there is, practically speaking, no money in this. We are charging duty not only on beer and spirits but also on mineral-waters, and it does not seem consistent that one form of drink should be selected for exemption from taxation. There is this to be said in favour of the amendment: that, owing particularly to the reduction in the sugar duty, mineral-waters do enjoy a measure of protection. That is, at any rate, sweetened mineral-waters; cider does not. I was inclined to meet Deputy Redmond to this extent, that there is one form of dutiable liquor which is made to a very small extent here, perry. There is a charge of 2d. per gallon, and I was inclined to meet him by agreeing to halve the present duty on cider.
Comment on this
There is an Excise duty of 4d. per gallon on sweetened waters and, in addition, they use certain dutiable essences.
Comment on this
Do I understand in respect of this amendment that on Report the Minister will be introducing an amendment halving the duty on cider?
Comment on this
I move amendment 18, which is as follows:—Before Section 34 to insert a new section as follows:—
The Stamp Duty on Customs entry forms chargeable under Section 22 of the Finance Act, 1924 (No. 27 of 1924) shall cease to be chargeable or leviable as on, and from, the 1st day of July, 1925, and no Stamp Duty on Customs entry forms shall be chargeable or leviable on or after that date.
The effect of this amendment will be to repeal the Statistical Tax that we imposed last year. When we were discussing the Statistical Tax and its brother-in-arms, the sixpenny postal tax on parcels, I adduced many arguments against this tax. I think the lapse of time has not weakened the arguments, and the Minister's statement, in introducing the Budget, indicated, I think, that the Government, to a certain extent, have an open mind on the matter. The Minister said then that they did not propose to remove this tax until they had had a little more experience of its working. So far as experience of its working has gone, the general trend of evidence is to show that it has caused a considerable amount of inconvenience to the private individual and also to the merchant, and that it has not achieved the object which was intended—reducing the number of small parcels imported. That is inevitable. It was inevitable as a result of the protective duties we imposed last year. It will become even more inevitable—if that be possible— as a result of the duties we are imposing now. We are going to tax a large number of diversified articles of comparatively small value. There will be a far greater importation of small, individual parcels than there would be if you were merely taxing staple commodities like sugar, tea and tobacco. A shop is not likely to have to send to England for a lb. of tea to meet the wish of one special customer, but it is quite likely to have to send to England for half-a-dozen handkerchiefs or one pair of shoes or something of that kind.
I do not know whether the Minister thought this was an original tax, or whether he knew there was a precedent for it, and that he, sixty odd years after, was following in the footsteps of Mr. Gladstone. In the year 1860 Mr. Gladstone imposed a similar tax— a statistical tax—on what was then the United Kingdom. I think it was levied at the more moderate rate of 1d. per entry, instead of 6d. Then everything was much cheaper than now. Income tax, I think, was about 4d. in the £. One penny then was about the equivalent of 4d. now. The levying of that tax produced serious complaints. After it had been in operation about two years, a Select Committee of the House of Commons was set up to consider its operation. That Select Committee, all things considered was a strong committee. It had amongst its members Mr. Cobden, then in the last years of his life; a future Chancellor of the Exchequer in Mr. Robert Lowe, and a young member in Mr. William Edward Foster, who did not know then that, twenty years hence, posterity would connect his name with the word "Buckshot." But it was a fairly strong committee of the House of Commons, and Mr. Gladstone gave evidence before it. He admitted that petitions had been received against this tax from most of the principal ports of the United Kingdom. He gave a list of the principal ports of the United Kingdom. He gave Dublin first place; then Glasgow, Belfast, Cork, Derry and Wexford. I wish some of the Deputies for Wexford were here. I wish Deputy Corish was here. It is obvious that a good deal of the exception taken to this duty was taken in Ireland.
Comment on this
I apologise. I had hoped Deputy Corish would be here, because he is peculiarly identified with the port of Wexford. I think Deputy Doyle is more connected with the port of Rosslare, which Mr. Gladstone had not foreshadowed. Mr. Gladstone said:
I frankly admit that we cannot justify, for the sake of the 1d. which it produces, the permanent imposition of a charge which involves so much labour and delay and cost upon the community over and above what it brings into the Exchequer.
I believe that to be true of this tax, though it is a 6d. instead of a 1d. tax. Mr. Gladstone also said:
The tax was originally imposed for statistical purposes, but also because we wanted the money.
I have no doubt the Minister would also plead that justification here. Mr. Gladstone proceeded:
I am afraid it causes a good deal of trouble, and, through trouble, cost to the mercantile community.
That is my case; that this tax is one that causes an altogether excessive amount of trouble and cost to the mercantile community—excessive both in regard to the revenue it brings in and to its intended purpose in relation to statistics. The committee reported— and their report was unanimous—
As to the operation of these charges on the trade and commerce of the country, mercantile witnesses were unanimous in describing them as obstructive, vexatious, expensive and unequal.
I believe that is as true to-day as it was in 1862. This tax produces an amount of revenue altogether insignificant, when compared with the trouble, annoyance, and obstruction caused by its collection.
The Commitee's report proceeds:—
The evidence which has been obtained fully sustains the acknowledged principle of sound taxation, that the tax shall produce the revenue required with as little annoyance to the payer as possible.
I sometimes think that that sound principle is overlooked in the Ministry of Finance. I should like to have it emblazoned on the walls in letters of gold.
Mr. DARRELL FIGGIS: Not gold.
Comment on this
Then, if gold is obsolete, in letters of paper. Finally, the Committee reported:—
Your Committee are of opinion that these small charges on commerce are unwise and inexpedient and recommend their abolition.
Mr. Gladstone acted on the report of the Committee, and in the following year, in proposing the repeal of the tax, he said:—
It was believed that this tax was capable of being framed with great simplicity and of being levied without entailing any delay or hindrance in the course of trade. I am bound to admit that this expectation could not be realised.
I believe that precedent, 60 odd years old as it is, is a sound precedent. I believe that if the Minister and the Government have, as has been suggested, an open mind but that they do not see their way to accept this amendment, they should see their way to set up either a committee of the Dáil or an outside committee to consider the operation of this tax and also the 6d. charge levied on parcels. They are at present not taking up any position because the tax has not been in operation for a year. Will they set up a committee of this kind when the tax will have been in operation for a year— that is, next September? Will they allow merchants interested, Chambers of Commerce, and others to give evidence before such a committee? If so, I believe we shall, next year, give the matter fairer consideration and approach it from a juster standpoint. I do not want to weary the Dáil and I do not want to read to them all the matter I have here from Chambers of Commerce and smaller bodies. If the Minister will agree to set up this committee, it will not be necesary for me to do so. The Chambers of Commerce and others can come forward and make their case. If the Minister will indicate that he is prepared to take that step, to have this tax and the 6d. parcels tax examined by a commercial committee, then I shall not press this amendment. Otherwise, I fear I must press it, because I do believe that this tax causes enormous inconvenience not merely to the trader but to the general public as well.
Comment on this
I could not agree to set up a Committee such as has been suggested by Deputy Cooper. I did indicate in my Budget statement that, so far, the tax did not seem to be lessening the number of small parcels imported, which was one of the purposes we had in imposing it. However, a very short period has really elapsed. It is difficult for people to take up a new course in regard to their dealings in goods and it may be that, before the end of the present financial year, it will show results such as it has not shown heretofore. At any rate, we feel that we are not going to take any action or even consider the tax on trial for its life until a further period has elapsed. If, by the end of the financial year, it is not proving successful in diverting this stream of small parcels, then we may decide to abolish it. However, the tax has not had anything like a fair chance yet and I would not propose to set up any committee to inquire into it.
I would like to say, moreover, that the 6d. charge on postal parcels is on quite a different basis. We do not see any reason at all for abolishing that charge. That particular tax has been successful. It has reduced the number of postal parcels very considerably. We have considered it from every point of view and there is a cast-iron case for the maintenance of the postal parcels charge. Where we have doubts is in regard to the Customs entry duty. There is this further point, that the tax will produce a revenue of £40,000 a year. We have budgeted on the basis of obtaining that revenue and that is an additional reason for declining, at this stage, to agree to abolition of the duty.
Comment on this
I am sorry the Minister has not received this amendment more favourably. Deputy Cooper asked him to set up a Committe of Inquiry if the tax was not successful at the end of 12 months—that is, next September. He has not conceded that. The Minister has a very small idea of the amount of inconvenience this tax causes. It does not hinder the large wholesaler as much as it does the small country grocer. The ordinary country shop has to send out orders for all sorts of goods— jams, paints and so on. They are charged 6d. each in respect of these parcels. That is really a very heavy tax on the ordinary grocer along the Border who, at the present time, is finding it very difficult to carry on. In addition to the actual cost, the inconvenience is extremely annoying and I would join with Deputy Cooper in asking that the Minister should give this matter reconsideration.
Comment on this
I want to give formal support to Deputy Cooper's amendment and to press on the Minister the advisability of considering the removal of this tax. I think I was the first member of the Dáil to object to this tax and I have steadily held the opinion that it was unnecessary. I also said, on the occasion of the introduction of the tax, that it would cause inconvenience, and that, still more, it would cause irritation. My forecast in that regard has been fulfilled. It has caused a great deal of inconvenience and it has caused a great deal of irritation. It hampers trade and anything that hampers trade should not be encouraged by the Minister. It has not succeeded in its object. The parcels are coming in in as great numbers as before the tax was imposed and I think the tax has not been justified. It has not succeeded in causing distributing stores to be set up in this country for the purpose of getting the goods in in large quantities and disposing of them to the buyers here. Apparently, the articles required vary so much in type that it is not possible for any distributor in this country to get in a sufficient stock to work the business on a paying basis. I think Deputy Cooper's idea of setting up a small Committee is an excellent one and I feel that the Minister is not really adamant in regard to it. I think he is inclined to consider the question and I would press upon him, if he does not set up the Committee, at least to give the question of the removal of the tax his most careful consideration between now and the introduction of the next Budget.
Comment on this
The actual distance between the Minister and Deputy Cooper is not really very considerable. I would like to urge the Minister to consider if he could not diminish it further. The Minister has said that there are doubts in his mind as to whether this tax is justified. He urges that another year's working will be sufficient to show whether these duties are justified or whether the tax is justified. Deputy Cooper has urged that a committee should be set up to examine into the matter with a view to making recommendations for a change, if such a change be considered necessary, next year. The Minister, if I understood him correctly, has already intimated that the matter will remain in doubt between now and this time twelve months in view of the prospective change. Deputy Cooper suggests that there may be certain matters of doubt in which the Dáil as a whole may care to enter with a view to seeing whether there should be any change at the end of twelve months. I urge on the Minister to let the committee be appointed and have access to the information that will be available to himself and his staff in order that he and the Dáil through that committee of the Dáil, appointed either by himself or by the sessional committee of selection, should co-operate in coming to that decision.
Surely that is not a very far-fetched conception to urge upon his convenience. If there be that doubt in his mind, and if there be a doubt in the mind of the Dáil, why not let the committee be established? Let the amendment be withdrawn, and let the committee be established in order that all the information that will be present to the Minister's mind in coming to his decision in twelve months' time, and that will be present to the mind of his advisers, should be available to the committee also.
Comment on this
The Minister refuses to divide his responsibility. I admire his courage, but I deplore his tactics. I am afraid I must inflict on the Dáil one, at any rate, of these documents which expresses the opinion of an important section of the country on this duty. The following is a copy of a resolution passed by the Sligo Chamber of Commerce:—
Resolved: That this meeting of the Council of the Sligo Chamber of Commerce, having discussed the question of the new Customs entry duty (or statistical tax) strongly approve of the statement issued by the Dublin Chamber of Commerce on the subject.
I might remind the Dáil that the statement of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce at that time was a condemnation of the tax:
We urge upon the Government the necessity for an amended classification of the import list. In its present form it very often amounts to a heavy tax on a small consignment. For example, a member of this Chamber recently got in a consignment of groceries, weighing about 2 cwt., by steamer from Liverpool, and according to the present import list he had to pay 10/6 entry duty. This we consider is an imposition that should be rectified immediately in the interests of the trade of the Free State.
Copies of this resolution to be sent to our local T.D.'s.
Where are they? Deputy Dolan is there, and the others will be here for the division. It was also ordered that a copy of the resolution be sent to myself. That is the view of the Sligo Chamber of Commerce, and there is no doubt that so far as this duty is concerned, the views of commerce as a whole have been pronouncedly hostile. It is felt to be an impediment on business, and it deserves all the epithets which Mr. Gladstone was forced to apply to a duty of his own sixty-five years ago. As regards the 6d. parcels tax, the Minister said that he regarded it as an admirable tax, and that it was well justified. We have heard of a reduction in the number of parcels, but we have never yet heard of any increase in the book post. No figures have been given as regards that, but I am aware that a considerable proportion of parcels have been transferred to the book post. The Minister and his Department are satisfied that this is a good tax. In that they stand alone. The tax has been condemned on every side. The Minister has probably seen the figures of the Dublin Mercantile Association, in which, by ten to one, the retail traders, the wholesale traders and the manufacturers of the country have condemned it. I do not know whether the Minister for Finance ever reads the "Cork Examiner." The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs does, which matters more. Once a week the "Cork Examiner" has a leader condemning this tax. I regard the "Cork Examiner" as one of the most important and influential papers in the country.
Comment on this
Deputy Daly expresses the opinion of the average man in the country, and condemns the tax. I do suggest that there is a case for more inqiury as regards this. This is not a thing that should be settled in the secrecy of the office and brought down as an ultimatum to the Dáil. This is a case in which there should be an inquiry, and if there is to be no inquiry then this amendment goes to a division.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 19:—
Before Section 34 to insert a new section as follows:—
The minimum charge of 2/6 on goods liable to any Customs duty chargeable under Section 25 of the Finance Act, 1924 (No. 27 of 1924), shall cease to be chargeable or leviable, as on, and from, the 1st day of July, 1925, and all goods liable to any Customs duty shall, on and after that date, be charged and levied such duty without regard to any minimum charge.
This amendment is intended to repeal the minimum Customs duty. Last year we decided that whatever the Customs duty might be, if it was less than half a crown, it should be levied at the rate of half a crown, so that even if the Customs duty was only threepence the person receiving any parcel or packet on which it was leviable would have to pay half a crown. It might be much more than the value of the packet, but still the duty would have to be paid. That provision was intended to facilitate the operation of the Revenue Commissioners, and it would have been a reasonable provision, as long as the Customs duties were only imposed on a small number of articles imported in bulk, such as tobacco, wine, spirit, tea, and sugar, because these are all things that are dealt in by wholesalers, and there were practically no small parcels or packets of these kind of things. Then what were called the McKenna duties were imposed, and there would be again a number of small parcels: one small parcel containing a part for the repair of a motor car, one small musical instrument; but in these circumstances there would be no gross anomaly in imposing the duties. In imposing these duties now we have completely altered the basis of our fiscal system; we are putting on duties on all manner of articles of comparatively insignificant value. The result is that on a birthday, or an anniversary, when a present is sent to one by post with a single handkerchief, one has to pay a minimum Customs duty of half a crown, in addition to the sixpenny statistical duties tax. That is not equity. It is not right to tax one single article one hundred or one hundred and fifty per cent. of its value. Yet so long as we maintain this provision in the Finance Bill we are bound to have that charge. If the provision was intended to lessen the work of the Customs officials it might mean something, but we have, by our own Act, enormously increased the work of the Customs officials. By imposing a duty on various articles of wearing apparel and on furniture, the work of the officials has increased to an enormous extent without even mentioning the duty on bottles and blankets and rugs.
There is no justification, therefore, for continuing this duty. There might be a justification if the duty was imposed on a small number of things and we wanted them dealt with in bulk, but it is impossible to deal with two hundred or three hundred types of wearing apparel in bulk. Fashion is capricious. A new pattern of scarf, a new type of stocking comes into vogue and there is a desire and a demand extending through the whole country to a degree that some of us would have thought impossible fifteen or twenty years ago. I was in the West of Ireland last week and I had been accustomed to see girls going about barefooted. I still thought I saw girls going about barefooted, but instead of that they were going about with the latest style of silk stocking so that their legs were not as bare as I supposed them to be, and they were wearing shoes. The levelling up of ranks, and the diffusion of fashion throughout the whole country has reached such a pitch that every retailer, even in the small towns, and in Ennis, Sligo, and Enniscorthy has to keep the best, and he has to import these things quickly, very often from across the Channel. The result is this tax is a crippling charge on trade and industry and I suggest, therefore, that it should no longer be continued.
Comment on this
I wish to support this amendment again. I also took exception to this on the last Budget statement. I think Deputy Major Cooper has covered the ground fairly fully. It is a tax that will cause still greater inconvenience now that there are a greater number of articles covered by the new Customs tariff, and it affects a great many smaller articles that may be sent as presents, such as handkerchiefs, stockings, and small articles of that kind, which are not at all valued for the amount of money, or which would not warrant the imposition of 2/6 as the actual tax to be placed on them. I am not as much in touch with merchants as Deputy Cooper, but I have heard of one or two extreme cases. I have heard of one case in which a small article valued for about 9d.—it was, I think, a motor cycle part —upon which 2/6 had to be paid as well as the 6d. statistical tax. There you have somebody being frightfully annoyed having to pay 3/3 on an article worth 9d. and which had to be sent for to England because it was not obtainable here. Now that machinery has been set up for collecting Customs tariffs, I see no reason why these articles should not be charged the actual tariff which they are bound to pay in accordance with their actual value.
Comment on this
I would like to support this amendment for the same reasons as I supported a similar one last year. Last year I took the case of a chemist in a Border town in the Free State and tried to compare his case with that of one across the Border. I tried to show the inconvenience that arose. I dealt first with the case of a prescription being made up in two towns, one situated on this side of the Border and the other on the other side. The cost of the prescription here was a great deal more than that on the other side, and I pointed out that that tended to decrease trade in the Border counties. The inconvenience is also considerable. Drugs are not like anything else, and cannot be kept at full stock. It is a great drawback for chemists to have to meet this extra tax.
Comment on this
The tax might not be necessary if it were not that we have here a new State set up, that previously from an economic point of view we were joined to another country, and if the channels of trade to a large extent remained the same as they were, and were intended to remain so, so that this country was not an economic entity and that there were no Customs of our own here. It is really a tax aimed at ending the trade across the Customs frontier in small parcels of trifling value. As I explained before, that involves a large cost to the State in keeping statistics. It involves extra work and extra costs in Customs administration. Without this tax, and before this particular minimum was put into force, it often happened that a fairly highly paid Customs officer worked the whole day dealing with dutiable goods on which he collected, perhaps, 3/- duty. One effect of the minimum is that an officer can do in half an hour work which previously would have taken a day. The actual removal of the minimum at present would lead to further delay and congestion and would lead to the necessity of further cost in the administration of the Customs. Once, I think, this country has its own Customs system and is trying to develop its own economic policy, we must try to arrive at conditions that are normal between countries economically separate, where trade, broadly speaking, flows in important channels, where you have wholesale or substantial dealing across the Border, and where you have not single handkerchiefs, for instance, to be assessed separately and to have inserted in documents the duty to be charged on them. If we got a reduction in this terrible flood of parcels of trifling value it might be possible for us to modify this tax and let the small number of parcels come in, but until we have got trade into channels that are normal we should, and must, maintain this tax. There is no reason that I can see why a chemist on this side of the Border should not deal with a Dublin wholesaler.
Comment on this
I do not know about that particular article, but, generally speaking, that is his remedy. There is no doubt, where you have a country an entity from the point of view of Customs, you must check this expensive and troublesome system of trading across the frontier in small packets of very little value.
Comment on this
I think the Minister's argument cuts both ways. His argument is, that inasmuch as we have just cut away politically and are cutting away economically our connection with another State, it is desirable to have taxes like these, that shall more completely set us on our own legs in regard to business matters. So far so good. But the connection that has remained until now has had another effect. I suggest that it is this other effect which is most injuriously hit by the imposition of a minimum tax, and that is that there have been family friendships and connections of many sorts set up as between one country and another, and, whatever may be the case in regard to chemicals to which Deputy Cole has referred, I venture to suggest that the majority of small parcels on which this minimum charge would be levied, are parcels not sent in the way of business, but in the way of friendship, of association, and as birthday tokens. I would like very much to see exactly how many items at 2/6 each are charged as duty in respect of (a) on parcels sent to traders for traders to sell; and (b) from private individuals to private individuals.
Comment on this
It would be very interesting, and I venture to say that the second would greatly outweigh the first. Complaints are being received from people here on this side, and they will be far worse now than in the past if, on small parcels sent to people here containing dutiable goods, the value of which is trifling, there is, nevertheless, 2/6 to pay. That was the case in the past, but now that we are including wearing apparel, handkerchiefs, ties, and so forth, these half-crowns are going to be collected on a much larger scale in future, and an amount of inconvenience will be created which will have no compensation in the creation of a greater amount of business. If any person in Great Britain or Belfast desires to send a present to anybody in Dublin, it is in his own locality that that purchase will have to be made, as it cannot be made in the Free State, but it is the person in the Free State who will pay dearly for having such parcels sent to him.
Comment on this
I think the Minister has made no case for the continuation of this tax. There is no justification for it whatever in my judgment. The Minister says that for sentimental reasons we must cut off the connection.
Comment on this
However, there is one class of people that have not been taken into consideration and that is the unfortunate public. This grand-motherly legislation tends to make this charge intolerable. In my judgment it is bad finance and bad administration. I do not think that outside the House or outside the Government benches you will find many people to stand by this tax as a reasonable tax.
Comment on this
I suppose income tax, especially the man who has not to pay any of it. I do not think the Minister says it is a tax at all.
Comment on this
It is not a tax; it is really a minimum charge, for whatever taxes are imposed by the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
The whole basis of his argument is to stop traffic, to make this island, or our portion of it, a very little island.
Comment on this
I say yes. In reply to the Minister's statement I say the whole trend of this legislation is to curtail trade with the outside world. Whether the Minister agrees with me or not, it is tending towards isolating us while as far as the people in the country are concerned it is giving the maximum of irritation for a very small return. The Minister talked about the expense to the Customs and Excise being curtailed. I do not think that if he would analyse the amount that is charged to the State for the collecting of the half-crown, he would find that it is justified.
Comment on this
There are two grounds on which the tax is opposed. One is that it causes great irritation to a great number of people and that it interferes with the sending of presents, birthday presents, and other articles of endearment, I suppose. From the business man's point of view, examining this particular traffic, the question that the Minister for Finance has got to ask himself is: is it an economic proposition to handle something like 39,000 articles in a month, as the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs told us come by post containing these articles, assess the value of them, put a value on them and collect the tax in turn from every person to whom the articles are delivered? I do not think anybody, viewing the thing from a business point of view, could stand for the extra expense that would be inevitable from the examination of such a large number of parcels.
Take the case of people in trade here having a house of one sort or another paying rates, taxes, and rent and keeping up staffs and running their business, if we are to take it from the Chamber of Commerce, on sound business lines. These people doing business on sound business lines, continue getting small parcels of half a dozen handkerchiefs or some other small quantity of goods to satisfy one or two particular customers. I would like to know if that is the modern method of doing business on sound business lines? It does not appear to me to be so. I think business houses should make an effort to get in goods in fairly large quantities and that they should not be making use of what is really a convenience for the public, a public service, and imposing enormous trouble and considerable expense of time on the Custom authorities and throwing a charge on the State which it cannot bear.
I would like to know if any business man was charged with this particular duty of handling so many articles as are brought in here in parcels, would he say: "Certainly I will examine every one of them and I will charge every person only the exact proportions of the duty that he is responsible for. I think it is an excellent method of doing business between one country and another, and that it is a popular business. Because of the fact that here are so many people engaged in it, and the fact that it is popular, whether it is economic or not it should be the duty of the Government even at a large expense to maintain a staff for the purpose of examining these parcels." I do not think any business man would approach the matter from that point of view. If we are satisfied that this particular traffic imposes a heavy burden on the State, even at the expense of antagonising some of our constituents, it is our duty to the still larger number of constituents who do not use that traffic, to see that they shall not be called on to pay taxes, which will enable the smaller number to benefit by an immediate delivery of goods, in consequence of that very expensive method of doing business. Even though there is a large number of people inconvenienced, even though there is a large number who object to the extra burden of two and sixpence, even though there are business houses getting in small parcels of half a dozen, you could not expect the Government to carry out a work that will impose a heavy cost on the whole community. You must look at this matter from the broad, general view of the State. If Deputy Cooper, Deputy Hewat, Deputy Heffernan and Deputy Cole were the managing directors of the State would they count this as a legitimate, well-balanced, sound proposition—to handle such a large number of small parcels and assess the tax on each commodity in accordance with the value of each article?
Comment on this
The President has really pronounced an extremely eloquent condemnation of the whole Finance Bill. He has appealed from those of our constituents who are inconvenienced to those who are not. In other words, he appeals from those who wear imported clothes to those who do not. Apparently the majority of his constituents do not wear any of these imported articles.
Comment on this
I have worn apparel for many years and I have never paid the tax on it. I have no intention of paying it.
Comment on this
I must visit Kilkenny. The President has not paid any tax for the past two months, but I am sure that he will pay it unconsciously in the future. Sometimes when he thinks he is buying Irish goods he is buying what Irish retailers buy outside.
Comment on this
We are not all so free from being gulled as the President. He has the unique experience of not alone being in the Dáil for some years, but he has also been in the Dublin Corporation. I am not going to accuse the Minister for Finance of being sentimental. We were told by the British Chancellor of the Exchequer that he was a wise and determined man. Of the latter I have no doubt whatever. I have put up too many amendments in my time, and have had them turned down to have any doubts about the Minister's determination. I regret to-night that determination is so prominent and wisdom so much in the background. He has told us that he is trying by this 2/6 minimum tax to alter the channels of trade. That is a very dangerous and a very difficult thing to do. If the Minister for Industry and Commerce were here he would agree that the alteration of the channels of trade is a thing that must be carried out on scientific lines, that you must not indulge in any rash or any haphazard efforts to control it. I suggest that a flat rate of 2/6 is an indiscriminate and haphazard method of dealing with it. It is true that all sorts of links of trade have grown up in the past, and that is inevitable in a small country.
Deputy Cole instanced the case of chemists. It is a fact that no Dublin chemist, no wholesaler, can stock the whole range of drugs required in the modern pharmacopoeia, because drugs will not keep. Some drugs might not be asked for once in two or three years, by which time they would have lost their value. No firm is rich enough to sink capital in a venture of that kind. Precisely the same thing applies here, because demand varies with the caprices of fashion. There is no wholesaler in the Free State, and I have been in touch with some of the biggest of them, who can carry such a stock as the wholesaler in London or Manchester. It means locking up capital for a period of months, probably for a period of years, without a prospect of return. There has to be a considerable amount of overseas trade, and, what is more, overborder trade. The President could not be thinking possibly of any shopkeeper getting half a dozen handkerchiefs. I agree in the case of the Dublin shopkeeper, but what about the shopkeeper in Newbliss or Glenfarne? Will he not get half a dozen handkerchiefs from a shopkeeper at Enniskillen?
Comment on this
Where is he to get them? He is a long way from Sligo, and there is no place but Enniskillen where there are big shops that can supply them. By the time he pays freight, if he gets them by train, or pays postage, he will probably find that he might have got supplies cheaper. He is accustomed to dealing with certain wholesalers long before the border came into being. Tirconaill is accustomed to dealing with Derry, and the border has not broken all these bonds of trade communication. It would be the greatest misfortune if we did anything here to make the border more permanent. I am afraid that is one of the effects of a minimum half-crown duty, making us more self-contained. I would be more inclined to put the case on sentimental grounds rather than accuse the Minister of being sentimental. I think that is one of the serious indictments of this duty. The President's argument is really not an argument in favour of the minimum duty. It is an argument against taxing an enormous number of articles of infinite variety and comparatively small price. That is the reaction of his argument. I would agree in every word if he is dealing with wine, porter, spirits, and tobacco. There a man might say: "Why not take the whiskey I have in stock; why insist on other whiskey?" In the case of tobacco he might say: "Is not the tobacco I have good enough; why do you insist on something else?" But when you deal with women and the ramifications of women's apparel you will find that reason fails, that argument fails, and I do not believe that even the President would convince them that they ought to get what they do not want.
Comment on this
I knew that once the President got going he would fairly get away. I have been watching him for two or three hours, and I knew that when he did come in, from my experience of him, he would have a real good innings. With regard to large parts of the country, the President was fairly correct in saying that shopkeepers would not be bringing in goods in small parcels, thereby increasing this higher percentage duty. Let that be so. What about the other end of it, of which I spoke at the beginning? I think the President was trying to suggest that I had an excessive number of birthdays, or that someone had an excessive number of birthdays.
Comment on this
There is the fact to which I referred before, and that is that a great deal of irritation is undoubtedly being caused to people who receive parcels that are sent to them for purely sentimental reasons, and by way of friendship, on which they have to pay a duty that is probably half as much again as the value of what they receive. It is not as if that could be corrected by the giver of the present. That cannot be done, obviously. The only person penalised is the person who receives the goods. It is on the ground of irritation in this way, without any benefit whatever to the Irish shopkeeper or the Irish trader, that I urge that this minimum tax of 2/6 should be abolished.
Comment on this
I am afraid the President has not strengthened his position by the interesting statement he has made to-night. As I understand his case, he is anxious to alter the present channels of trade. If he is so anxious to alter the present channels of trade why not stop these parcels coming in altogether, instead of putting on this irritating tax of 2/6? If he is really determined in his proposal that is the proper line to adopt, if he wants to effect the change. I am afraid that in attempting to attack trade to-night the President with all respect has shown want of knowledge of trade. We have been dealing with new taxes this year largely put on apparel and commodities of that kind. This parcels tax largely affects commodities of the kind. If the Minister had any knowledge of that particular trade in apparel he would come to the immediate conclusion that it was one of the trades in which mass production was impossible. If he were to consult—and I am sure he will as a result of tonight's discussion—some of his lady friends he would find that mass production would be the last thing ladies in this country would desire. If two ladies happened to be at a function wearing similar dresses I know that the people who sold these dresses would hear about it for years.
Comment on this
If I know anything of ladies' fashions it is one of the things that seem to irritate them more than anything else. If they buy a dress in a particular place they understand it is the only dress of that kind that will be sold by that particular firm.
Comment on this
That is quite right, but what I am coming at is this: the President's argument was, why not order 20, 30 or 50 dresses of that particular pattern? If he will consult any of the people interested in that particular trade he will be told by them, as I tell him, that is impossible, that it would ruin their custom if they sold even two costumes of the same pattern. When you are talking about trade in apparel and trade in motor cars you are talking of two different commodities. What is possible, and is the custom, in one is impossible in the other. If the President wants to alter the methods of these trades, as it seems he is determined on doing, and have our girls out in the same dress, and our ladies in the same shoes, stockings and umbrellas manufactured by the million, and all alike, he will want to alter the fashions and to alter the views of these people. I assure him that if he starts on that problem he will find it is a big task.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy has misunderstood what I said. I do not think I mentioned alteration in the channels of trade—good, bad or indifferent. I said this was a particular method of traffic which was costing the State too much money, and that with this tax of 2/6 the ladies interested in models will get off very cheap, for they will get off with 2/6 for an article on which they would pay £3 or £4.
Comment on this
I centre on the one thing. If Deputy Good, Deputy Hewat, Deputy Cooper, Deputy Heffernan, and Deputy Cole were seated here with the responsibility of this service superimposed on them, as the Minister for Finance has said, and they found that is was a costly service inasmuch as it took up so much time and so many officials, and that the tax in respect of this immense number of parcels of 33? per cent. would be insufficient to pay for this service, then they would have to do exactly as we are doing or lose their reputation as business men.
Comment on this
I have been listening to Deputy Good with some interest, especially when he suggested that mass production in the matter of clothing was out of the question. I wonder does he ever see the London dailies of great circulation with illustrations of dresses of all kinds, and does he not realise that those are almost daily produced under mass production conditions, with occasional little alterations, and that, in any case, the particular kind of article that is in question would not have to pay the tax, for it would be already paid in the larger sum. The Deputy's chief point seems to be that there was no basis for the allegation that there was this uniformity in clothing, and that infinite variety was the vogue. He was not speaking solely of ladies' dresses, and I venture to suggest that if it happened the Deputy were in the neighbourhood of this building about this time to-morrow night and he looked around he would see that there is a very great deal of uniformity about articles of clothing. It so happens that a certain event which is to take place to-morrow night is confined to those who are prepared to wear uniforms, and this tendency to uniformity has a considerable effect upon the clothing trade. Mass production and uniformity go together, and I suppose if we could all be induced to wear uniforms for social functions the next step would be to get them all made on one model out of one particular firm's production.
Comment on this
And possibly of one size with the aid of pneumatic blowers. The possibilities of cutting down or adding to the garments would be the means of encouraging a certain amount of local industry. There is no doubt that there is a great deal of mass production in the clothing trade, and that has forced everybody connected with the trade in this country to look favourably on these proposals which limit, to whatever degree, the introduction of clothing produced under mass production conditions. I think the effect of this minimum duty will be, if it has not already been, to limit the importation of single articles produced under mass production conditions, and which are advertised so largely in the daily and weekly press. I hope the Ministry will stand by this tax for at least a sufficiently long time to prove that it has an effect upon import trade of this kind. So far as luxury trades are concerned, the effect of this duty on the smaller articles is really very little, that is, as regards the consumer, but it may affect the trader to some degree. The consumer is attracted by the design, colour and the fashion rather than by its inherent cost, and the tax of 2/6 on these articles has hardly any influence on the retail price of any of the articles sold of a luxury character.
Comment on this
I hardly expected to hear this tax defended on the grounds of uniformity, to have it put forward that it will enable you, A Leas-Chinn Chomhairle and Deputy Thrift, to occupy the same clothes as well as the same chair. I do not know if that is a consummation devoutly to be desired. I would tell Deputy Johnson that it is precisely in regard to this matter of clothing which he calls uniform that there is the greatest divergence of cut, the greatest expense and the least mass production. It is precisely in regard to clothes, at ceremonies, worn in the evening, that the greatest pains are taken to make certain differentiations of shape, cut, outline and material, and at great cost these differentiations are obtained.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Deputy whether those particularly well-cut garments, when going through the post, are subject to the two-and-six duty?
Comment on this
Apart from all that, we have got off the subject of the amendment altogether. I want to put the case that a level flat minimum rate of duty is untenable and penalises people who cannot afford to be penalised, people who get old clothes from relations or, from want of a better word, from patrons or former employers or people of that kind. It creates a sense of injury and injustice in the mind of the recipient and therefore I suggest the Dáil ought not to continue it.
Comment on this
I move:—
Before sub-section (3) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"The dog duty in respect of any dog aged one year and upwards shall be paid by the person keeping the dog on or before the 1st day of January in each year, and the duty in respect of any dog aged less than one year and more than one month, shall be paid within one month of such dog attaining the age of one month."
I am glad to have come to an end of controversy. After the fighting we can now come to the dogs. This amendment relates to the Excise duty on dogs.
The amendment may be advocated on two grounds. First, from the farmers' point of view from the 1st of January to the 1st Ápril there are any amount of cur dogs going through the country in the lambing season, chasing, worrying and destroying sheep. Those same dogs are hunting birds when they are making their nests, chasing rabbits and hares. They are a general nuisance. If a dog is to pay duty he should not be given a loose period of two or three months during which time he is not to pay duty. It is not a good thing for the dog himself. When the duty is payable there are hosts of dogs either turned out by their masters or else drowned and got rid of. I think the country is in favour of a change of this kind and of having it done at an earlier date.
Comment on this
I think, if the Minister will remember, he practically gave me a promise that he would change the date on which this duty would be levied on the introduction of the Budget. I suggested to him, for the very reasons given by Deputy Cooper, that it would be desirable that this duty should be charged on the 1st January rather than on the 1st April. The reason is the one given by the last Deputy who spoke, that those dogs, unlicensed mongrel curs, were loose at the very worst time of the year and that they killed lambs. Sometimes they form into packs and scour the country at night. I have seen packs of those dogs. Some of them may be licensed, but usually they are not, because people who license dogs go to some trouble to keep the dogs around their premises. Serious damage has accrued to many farmers. Sometimes the dogs kill sheep as well as lambs. With regard to the latter part of the amendment, I do not quite understand what the intention of the Deputy is, except that he wants not to have those mongrels exist at all. People will be obliged to destroy them and not to allow them to grow up to be a year old. I think it is a good idea, and I have pleasure in supporting the amendment.
Comment on this
I think it was Deputy Wolfe who made the appeal that the ordinary licence duty which used to be levied in March should be changed to December or January. I quite agree that that would be a very wise and necessary thing to do. There is no doubt of the hardship and the harm that is done by dogs wandering in that particular season of the year. Just then we have the lambing season. The months of February and March are the months of the lambing season, and more harm is done at that time to sheep than at any other season of the year. The Deputy talks about dogs worrying large flocks of sheep. I have seen thirty or forty sheep being attacked at one time by half a dozen dogs. That is no uncommon thing in the country in the case of anyone who has kept sheep. It is only in exceptional cases that the owners have been traced and connected with this damage. The result generally is that the unfortunate people to whom damage is done have no redress in any court or otherwise. If the date is changed to December and you have registration by the first of the New Year it would be very beneficial. With regard to the latter part of the amendment, to make dogs of one month or upwards be licensed, that is ridiculous. Let there be a particular date, and let all dogs over a month old on that day be registered. I hope the Minister will have this changed and brought up to an earlier date. The country wants it. It would save a considerable amount of damage to sheep. Another thing is within recent years, when there was very little law in the country, packs of mongrels have been allowed to exist and they have done considerable damage. Last year the law was not enforced as it should be, and a lot of those dogs are living still. I know the law will be enforced this year. The machinery is there to enforce it. There are huge numbers of unnecessary dogs in the country. I do not know where they find food; certainly they do not find it in their own kennels.
I will support the first part of this amendment, but not the second. There is no necessity for a second licensing day varying from month to month and week to week. That would be ridiculous. There is another thing, too; it is not in this, but it is almost up to the time when we might seriously suggest all dogs should be kept under control, at least by night. It does not arise under any section here, but it is something that will have to be considered in the near future, I think.
Comment on this
The second part, the part that you object to. It would save an amount of trouble to the Gárda Sióchána if that were done.
Comment on this
When I was supporting this resolution I did not support two licensing days. I said that the licensing days should be changed from March to December. I do not suggest two licensing days at all. No one could tell the age of a dog.
Comment on this
I would like to support Deputy Cooper's amendment as far as having the dogs licensed in December or January is concerned. I think it would be a very good thing. Personally I would prefer the 1st of December to the 1st January, but I think January will meet the case best for most farmers. I am sure there will be a general claim for the licensing day to be as early as possible in the year, so that dogs will be paid for at that particular time. I agree with everything that Deputy Gorey has said about these dogs roaming about the country and the damage they do. People turn them out to save themselves the trouble and expense of feeding them, and they let them roam about the country in packs. It is a quite common thing to see this happen about the country. At the present moment it is going on largely. Every night I hear packs of dogs barking about the place. They are looking for food, and are not fed by their owners. As regards the age of the dog. I entirely agree with what Deputy Gorey says. I think this part of the amendment is extremely vague. It is not satisfactory as far as I understand it. I think the age of the dog should be fixed at from three to six months on the 1st January, and after the 1st of January, when the dog attains a fixed age, the dog should be paid for.
Comment on this
Perhaps I might, with regard to the second part of the amendment, enlighten Deputy Gorey and Deputy Wolfe as to my intention. My view is, that every dog over a month old should have a licence, and it is quite fair and an easy thing to tell the difference between a month-old puppy and an eleven months old dog.
Comment on this
I am putting it as the difference between a month old dog and an 11 months old dog. Under this amendment every dog should be entitled to get his licence after it is one month old. I cannot agree that a man who had a dog born should be allowed to keep it until it was 11 months without getting a licence for it. The next thing we shall hear is that Deputy Gorey will be winning the Waterloo Cup with an unlicensed dog.
Comment on this
Unfortunately the Deputy has had too many amendments to have any dinner at all. If you fix the 1st of January as the time for taking out a licence you will have the position that some dogs will not be licensed until they are 10 or 11 months old, and other dogs will have to be licensed as soon as they are a month old. However, I am glad that the principle of the amendment finds favour. If the Minister thinks the latter part of it is unacceptable I am prepared to allow it to be altered.
Comment on this
I accept the principle of the amendment. As regards the second part of it, I do not think it is necessary, because the section already says it shall be the duty of every person who keeps a dog aged one month or upwards to produce on demand by the Gárda Síochána a licence under this Act. So that the second part of the amendment is unnecessary. With regard to the first, I agree wholly, and I would be prepared to accept it by changing the period from the financial year to the calendar year. There is one little difficulty that prevents me from accepting the amendment. Licences are paid at present up to the 31st March next. We will have to provide some sort of transfer period so that the people would not have to be paying again for the three months from January to March. As soon as I think out a clause to cover that part I will bring it in.
Comment on this
Before Section 34 is put I wish to draw attention to the custom that prevailed in the past by which owners of kennels were enabled to register dogs by giving a description of the lot. It is the custom in kennels to keep two, or sometimes more, packs of foxhounds. They are all of one colour, and having to fill a separate form for each is vexatious, unnecessary and serves no useful purpose. The whole lot could be described, and have been described, on one sheet or form. I do not know that the harrier packs that are very useful could not be done in the same way. I do not know at what number you would fix the kennel or packs that would come under this. It would be very handy, especially if it were put down at ten or twelve; where the dogs are all of one breed they are easily dealt with. If the old system were reverted to it would be very simple, and it would be very welcome to the people of the country who have large packs of dogs.
Comment on this
The system that Deputy Gorey desires will be reverted to. That has been considered and there is no difficulty in the matter.
Comment on this
I beg to propose amendment No. 21 which stands in my name and of which I have given notice. It reads:—
21. To insert before Section 35 a new section as follows:—
"The duties of Customs and Excise chargeable or leviable on twist plug tobacco shall on and after the 9th day of June, 1925, be chargeable or leviable at rates amounting to four shillings per pounds less than the duties chargeable or leviable previous to the 9th day of June, 1925."
Of all the increases of taxation in recent years none has imposed greater hardship on the poor than the extra duty on tobacco. The labourers and the small farmers who a few years ago got an ounce of tobacco for 2d. or 2½d. have to pay now 8½d. or 9d. I submit in all seriousness that there is no justification for continuing this oppressive and cruel tax. The victims in my opinion are in need of relief. We are told by some expert economists that tobacco is a luxury and that the poor people can very well do without it. We might as well say that tea is a luxury, and yet you have, I am glad to say, given relief to the poor householders from the tax on tea. To most of the labourers and small farmers that I know the occasional smoke is an absolute necessity. I know many to whom the deprivation of a meal would be far less disconcerting than that of their usual smoke. Why inflict, or continue to inflict, this great hardship on the poorest section of the community while you are giving substantial relief to those who, like ourselves, have incomes up to the taxation mark? If you can possibly draw the distinction between the poor man's twist and luxurious Havana and select mixtures puffed by the well-to-do by all means do so. But whether or not you make such a distinction, I ask you in all sincerity to relieve the poor man of at least half this duty on tobacco, and that is all I am asking you to do.
Comment on this
I seem to have struck a very favourable portion of the amendment sheet, because these amendments, one after the other, are meeting with my approval. I support the amendment because I think the idea in it is a good one. I do not know if it is financially feasible; I cannot tell what loss it would involve to the Customs, but I certainly think that an excessive duty on plug and twist tobacco is a hardship on people—I might say the poor, because the people who use this kind of tobacco are mostly poor. I remember when they were able to get their ounce of tobacco for 3d. I think it now costs 8d.; I am not quite sure what the exact price is, because I do not smoke twist, but it is more than double the original price—three times the original price, Deputy Figgis tells me. It is really a necessity of life to these people. The working man, the farm labourer, is as fond of his clay pipe and of a smoke as he is of his food, and he would be more unhappy if he missed his smoke than if he missed his dinner.
Comment on this
They are not all like Deputy Gorey; most of them are smokers. Deputy Cosgrave is not asking to have this tax taken off cigars, cigarettes, or the luxury tobaccos, but to have it taken off the common twist. I would ask the Minister to consider the proposal, and if the amount suggested is too great he might possibly agree to a lesser amount. If he does not accept the amendment and it is not carried I would ask him to bear this particular aspect of the question in view when he is preparing his Budget next year.
Comment on this
I know from experience that poor men would rather do without their breakfast than without a smoke. This tobacco is not used altogether as a luxury; they regard it as a necessity. Half of them say that they would go mad if they had not their smoke. They would rather do without their dinner, and for that reason I support the proposal to reduce the tax on what the working man smokes, the common tobacco.
Comment on this
I also wish to support the amendment and to say a few words with regard to one class in particular, the old age pensioners. It is really hard on these poor people, of whom, I am sure, I would be safe in saying that 90 per cent smoke, who have only 7/- or 8/- or 9/- a week to exist upon and who have to pay 1/6 a week for a couple of ounces of tobacco. That leaves them a very slight margin to exist upon. I think that something should be done on the lines of Deputy Cosgrave's amendment, particularly for the benefit of this class of people, and also, I might say, for the working men.
Comment on this
As we were framing our Budget we had to decide what might be done with the amount available for remission of taxation. We gave that amount principally in the abolition of the tea duty and in the reduction of the sugar duty. We considered other things that might be done; we considered whether there might be a reduction in the beer duty or a reduction in the tobacco duty, and what we felt was that these other things were not at all so widely used. I do not know what proportion of the adult population of the country uses tobacco, but we have to remember that the great majority of women do not, and that children and young people do not, so that perhaps you have only one-fifth or one-sixth of the population who use it. You have a very much higher proportion using tea or sugar. We decided to give a reduction in the most widely used commodities. We had only a limited amount available for the reduction of taxation. If we were to pass the amendment the effect would be that the Customs duty would be reduced; there would be no reduction in Excise duty. At present we are charging on the tobacco as it comes in. There is a higher rate of duty on certain manufactured tobacco. We might reduce the Customs duty if we liked and thereby lead to the abolition of any manufacture of tobacco here. We charge duty on the leaf coming in. There is no means of distinguishing between twist and plug, or any other form of tobacco, when the leaf is coming in. If we were to try to distinguish between them it would mean an alteration of the whole system under which tobacco is manufactured; every tobacco factory would have to be a bonded factory, and all the work would have to be done under supervision, because if not we might have people cheating the Revenue to an almost unlimited extent. It would really be impracticable. All tobacco is charged as as it enters, and except it is to be manutured into Cavendish or Negro Head it passes out of the purview of the Customs altogether. Tobacco used for Cavendish or Negro Head is manufactured in a bonded factory under Customs supervision. If we were to try to distinguish between twist and plug and tobacco that is to be used for cigarettes or other things we would practically require to have all the tobacco manufactured in the country under supervision.
Even if it were possible to do that we could not afford it. It is difficult to estimate what this would cost, because we have not any firm figure of the amount of twist and plug used in the country, but it would probably cost anything in the neighbourhood of three-quarters of a million. On the other hand, if we were to take the line of reducing the duty from 8s. odd to 4s., the effect would be a much bigger loss in revenue—£1,600,000 or £1,700,000. It is obvious that we can do neither of these things. We cannot afford to lose three-quarters of a million, and we can even less afford to lose the bigger amount. Really, this is one of the things that might have been an alternative to the big reduction which we made in the sugar duty. Instead of the penny-three-farthings reduction in sugar, we might have given one-half-penny reduction, and done something like this. But there is not the money to do this, or anything like it, as things stand.
Comment on this
Do I understand the Minister to say that the effect of this amendment, if adopted, would mean a loss of three-quarters of a million?
Comment on this
I want to get the figure checked because I have here the Finance Account for the year 1923-24, where the net receipts from tobacco and snuff are entered at £3,719,000 odd. Even putting the whole question of snuff aside, and taking that figure as the total receipts of tobacco alone, it appears, then, from the Minister's figure that the amount of duty paid by those who consume twist and plug—that is to say the very poorest in the community—amounts to one-fifth of the whole of the tobacco receipts for the Saorstát. I think that that calculation is a justification of Deputy Cosgrave's argument, that on those grades of tobacco, consumed as they are only by the poor, a relief should be given, and that they should not be asked to pay duty which does amount, on the figures that I have shown, to one-fifth of the entire duty paid on tobacco in the Saorstát.
I recognise the difficulty that the Minister is in, especially at this late stage of the entire movement that one describes as the Budget. He has intimated to us before we went into Committee on the Finance Bill that there were certain limited moneys within which he had to move, and I can see that the adoption of this, at the moment, might not be a practical course for him to take. But, I do draw his attention to the fact that these poorer grades of tobacco, consumed by those who could not afford the other type of tobacco, amounting so largely as they do in the total receipts in respect of tobacco, ought to claim some special attention from him for the future.
Comment on this
I am sorry I cannot agree with this suggestion, especially as it has found some support on these benches. If there is going to be a reduction on any article of general use, let it be a further reduction on sugar that everybody consumes, and which is a necessity of life.
Comment on this
On a point of order, are we discussing sugar or tobacco?
Comment on this
The claim made on behalf of tobacco smokers, that they would sooner do without their breakfast than a smoke, does not appeal to me. If they did do with a little less tobacco and substituted food for it, they would be doing a good thing. It has been pointed out that a certain proportion of the population will benefit by a reduction in this tax. If there is going to be some reduction made to benefit the poorer section of the population let the reduction be made on some article of food that is used by all of that section of the population. A reduction in the tobacco duty would do no good to the community, as in many cases tobacco is used as a drug. People get into the habit of using a certain amount of that drug, and it is very difficult for them to give it up. If they could be induced not to use so much of it, they would be much better off. If it could be done, I would like to see no tobacco smoked. The people would then be much better off than they are to-day.
Comment on this
I wish to support the amendment, and to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that the present high duty on tobacco was imposed as a war tax. It is time for the Minister to consider a reduction in the taxes that were described as war taxes when they were being imposed at Westminster. The average workman in this country is severely handicapped by these war taxes. Even the price of stout and beer is higher here than in Northern Ireland by practically 24/- per barrel. In the Saorstát the Excise duty is £1 per barrel more on Guinness's porter than in Northern Ireland or Great Britain. I think the Minister for Defence, who is always seen with the pipe of peace in his mouth, would not like tobacco to be described as anything else but a necessity of life. I had expected to see him supporting this amendment.
Comment on this
As this tax was described as a war tax when imposed, it is time that the Minister should consider a reduction, and give those who use tobacco an opportunity of getting it at a reasonable price.