We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

BEET SUGAR (SUBSIDY) BILL, 1925.—SECOND STAGE (resumed).

Contributions 1–141 of 272. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Beet Sugar (Subsidy) Bill, 1925
Enacted

No. 30 of 1925 ›

When my speech on the Second Reading of this Bill was interrupted by the adjournment on the last occasion I was discussing the question of the relative prices of mangolds and sugar-beet. I find on reference to the Official Report that I stated: "From my experience of farming I consider a fair average yield for mangolds is about 20/- a ton per statute acre." It is obvious that I expressed myself in rather a clumsy fashion. What I meant to say was that I considered from my experience of farming that a fair average yield would be 20 tons per statute acre at 20/- per ton. That brings us to £20 as a fair average value in my opinion, for a statute acre of mangolds. I had originally worked out sugar beet at 10 tons per statute acre, but as a result of the discussion here I prefer to rely on about 8 tons per acre, because in discussing a matter of this sort it is better to err on the conservative side, and I think Deputy Gorey, on the last occasion, accepted a figure of 8 tons per statute acre as the yield for sugar-beets. That means that the money value of an acre of sugar-beet of eight tons to the acre at 54/- would be £21 12s. as against £20. You may really call it the same thing if you wish. Then, in addition to that, there is the value of the pulp, which the farmer can buy, according to the Minister's statement, at about half price, and that would be equal approximately to 30/- per acre. That is to say, he has the right to buy one-half of the yield of dried pulp, and that figures out at 30/- per acre. In addition, there is the food value of the tops of the sugar beet plants. I am not in a position to give mathematical expression of what that is worth, but I think it is generally estimated that the tops of mangolds are of very little food value; I think the usual custom is to let them remain on land for manuring the ground; whereas the sugar beet crop contains very valuable food and is largely and entirely used as such. In addition to that and making a further comparison of sugar beet with mangolds there are these facts, that the succeeding corn crops yield from 10 to 15 per cent more, and in that connection I find that in Germany, with the ten years average rotation, including a beet crop, that the increase in yield worked out as follows:—For wheat the increase was 15.3, for rye an increase of 5.8, for barley an increase of 28.9, for oats an increase of 40.7, for rape 18.6, and for potatoes an increase of 6.5 per cent. It will be a simple matter for each one to work out for himself the effect of these increases and credit them to the value of sugar beet as against mangolds. But the real value of sugar beet cultivation, as opposed to mangolds, is that it is a new crop, you have a guaranteed price over a period of years, and that you cannot say for any other crop. That, to my mind, is a very considerable thing in favour of sugar beet. Deputy Cooper stated, I think, that the guarantee of price was only for one year. If he refers to the Bill he will see that a guarantee can be given for three years from the year 1928, I think it is.

Comment on this

It can be given. Is there any compulsion on the company to give it?

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

Well, the compulsion will be this, that when the factory is erected it must in the first place get the beet. If they get down to a very low price for beet, of course, the beet will not be cultivated and their factory will remain idle. There is one price for three years and another for one year, and I interpret that in the year 1928 the farmer will be entitled to get a three years' guarantee at 54/- a ton.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy make quite sure that that is correct? The schedule says: "Beets grown in the years 1926, 1927 and 1928, price per ton, 50/- for one year's contract; 54/- for three years' contract." I take it that means that the three years' contract would have to be entered into for the years 1926, 1927 and 1928.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

That is not my interpretation; I may be wrong, and if so perhaps the Minister will correct me later, but I infer that to mean that in the year 1928 the farmer will be entitled to get 54/- for three years from then.

Comment on this

I apologise for interrupting again, but will the Deputy elaborate the word "entitled"? Will the farmer have any legal, any statutory claim? "Entitled" is rather a vague word.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

I understand that part of the contract with the Lippens' group is that they are to guarantee 54/- to the farmers for a three years' contract. Perhaps I put it wrongly. The question of the necessity for a supply of farmyard manure has, I think, cropped up in this discussion, and one thing about the growing of sugar beet is that very large quantities of it are grown on the Continent, in Belgium certainly, altogether from artificial manure. That I think is a point that ought to be taken into account. Deputy Gorey compared the yield of an acre of sugar beet with the yield of an acre of potatoes, and of course it is quite obvious, looking at it at first sight, that the potatoes would give a very much higher return. But then it altogether depends on the price of potatoes, and it will be within the recollection of Deputy Gorey, and of other farmers, that a couple of years ago potatoes became absolutely unsaleable. There again I want to emphasise the fact that for the sugar beet cultivation there is a guaranteed market and a guaranteed price, but that does not apply to any other crop grown, and I think it is to the credit of the sugar beet cultivation.

Comment on this

When I gave figures with regard to potatoes, I meant potatoes grown in the neighbourhood of the city of Dublin by market gardeners in the months of June and July.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Minister for Lands and Agriculture) Cumann na nGaedheal

In what year?

Comment on this

Last year, this year. When I dealt with the main crop I am afraid I expressed myself very badly, or at least not sufficiently. I said: "On the main crop I have given my values on a much reduced basis for July." That is either misreported or I have stated it very badly, but I think it is misreported. What I should have said was: "On the main crop I must give my values on a very much reduced basis from July." In other words, from £5 10s. to £6 10s. or £7 per ton would be as much as potatoes could fetch as a main crop.

Comment on this

I think also that the Deputy was referring to Irish acres. However, I do not want to dwell particularly on that point, except again to emphasise the fact that potatoes are not always saleable, and no matter what price you get for an article, if there is not a ready sale for it it is not much use. Before I leave the question of the yield of sugar beet I may say that, personally, I am rather more optimistic about the yield than even the Minister. Of course I am aware that I have already accepted the eight tons, but it is well to know that in England for the year 1923 the average is stated to be from eight to twelve tons per statute acre, and as high as from fourteen to eighteen tons per statute acre in certain districts— Norfolk and the Fen country, I think.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say what exactly an average of from eight to twelve tons means?

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

It puzzled me also, but I take it that an average of from eight to twelve means ten.

Comment on this

Mr. Wood reported, I think, nine tons per acre average of the factory areas for last year.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

Then the average for the three years, 1911, 1912 and 1913 on the small plots cultivated in Ireland shows twelve tons per statute acre. Of course I am perfectly well aware that you cannot expect on a larger commercial scale to get the same results as you will on smaller plots which probably receive greater care and attention. Personally I am not so much afraid that the yield of sugar beet in Ireland will not be well up to the standard as that the sugar percentage may fall rather low, and of course we have not got sufficient information before us at present to form a very definite opinion on that point. I would like here to correct a reply which I made to Deputy Johnson. He asked me could I say what was the average sugar percentage of the beet. I replied, I think, that it was in or about 15 per cent. I looked it up afterwards and I discovered that that referred to one factory for one particular period. I have gone more closely into the matter since and I find that from the year 1912 to 1914 the average of the Cantley factory works out at 16.5 per cent. sugar on a total beet crop of 367,000 tons. I think that that is a fair period over which to take an average. There are, I suppose, considerable variations according to the season; wet seasons bring it down and fine seasons bring it up, but at any rate I think that that figure can be accepted as a reasonable and fair average.

Now, one of the criticisms that has been made, as well as I recollect, is in the foot-note to a document which Deputy Johnson circulated the other day and is that the benefit to be gained in connection with this industry is really concentrated in the farmers in one particular area. That is to say, it is not widespread all over the country, That kind of criticism can be applied to many enterprises. For instance, the drainage of the Barrow only affects the people in the neighbourhood of the Barrow. Also remember the Shannon scheme will leave a great many people untouched. The fact of the matter is that it is quite impossible to devise any big scheme that is going to reach into every hole and corner and benefit everybody and even if we accept the criticism that the benefits only accrue to one area, even then it is better than doing nothing. We are relieving unable employment in that area, and I hope we will be getting extra land under tillage in that area. The criticism has been made also that the subsidy is too costly. Having listened to the Minister for Agriculture's explanation of the various negotiations I think it is perfectly clear that he made the best bargain he could. That is to say, if he gave any lesser subsidy the people would not come here to develop the sugar-beet industry and certainly would not pay farmers the price of 54/- One of the reasons why I took such an interest in this scheme from the very beginning is that I was hopeful it would employ many people. Undoubtedly the greatest evil we have in the country to-day is unemployment, and holding that view I cordially welcome any scheme that appears to me to go even a short distance towards remedying that evil.

Deputy Gorey said, with probably a great deal of truth, that this is largely an experimental venture. That is to say that this first factory is to be looked upon largely from the educational or experimental point of view. There is a good deal in that, but I contend if it proves a success the same as has been proved in other countries that the relief to unemployment will be a considerable matter at a later stage as soon as other factories can be set going because it is to be remembered that one factory will only supply the requirements of one-sixth of the population of Ireland and consequently other factories will be built later on if this proves a success. The building of the factory alone will cost a couple of hundred thousand pounds, so there will be a good deal of employment given in the actual building. With regard to the number of people employed in a factory of this size I have read a good deal of different estimates and literature dealing with the sugar beet industry in various countries. Roughly speaking, a factory working at full power will employ 250 skilled hands for the three months of the active portion. In addition to that there will be a demand for an amount of unskilled labour which will vary so much that I do not care to put any figure down.

Comment on this
Darrell Figgis Mr. DARRELL FIGGIS Independent

Will the Deputy say if he has prepared any estimate of the amount of wages likely to be expended in employment?

Comment on this

No; I have not, because it depends altogether on the rate of wages ruling in the district. Whether that has been settled or not I cannot tell you.

Comment on this

Or the number of men likely to be employed per acre.

Comment on this

Yes, I have gone into that matter. It is stated that for every ten acres of beet cultivated there will be one man employed. That is to say as distinct from the factory. I speak of agricultural labour and handling of the beet in various stages. That will mean that 5,000 acres of beet will employ, constantly, 500 men.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean that one labourer will attend to ten acres or there will be one extra?

Comment on this

It is estimated that for every ten acres applied to beet cultivation one man will be employed.

Comment on this

Does it mean one man extra or one man altogether?

Comment on this

You may have it both ways.

Comment on this

That is very important. We ought to know the extra number of hands people employ. When I hear of one man attending to ten acres of beet I think it is too ridiculous.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Minister for Lands and Agriculture) Cumann na nGaedheal

Will five do fifty?

Comment on this

Will the Minister say there is no extra labour required at all, that one man can do 10 acres or 5 do 50?

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey is entitled to his figures. I have given figures which I have taken from responsible journals. The statistics are there.

Comment on this

I think the Minister for Agriculture has stated one extra man for every ten acres.

Comment on this
Darrell Figgis Mr. DARRELL FIGGIS Independent

Extra for what?

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

We are talking at cross purposes. What I mean is that if they put down ten acres of beet there will be required one extra man.

Comment on this

Over and above the potato crop or the regular rotation?

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

Yes.

Comment on this

Before the Deputy passes on I think it would be helpful if he tells us the authority from which those figures are taken, particularly those regarding the increase in the yield of succeeding crops.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

I have not the exact title at present. It is a pamphlet produced by the Sugar Beet Growers' Association. I think that was the name, and that I can find it out for him. The Minister for Agriculture said that in his opinion this factory will not bring any extra land under tillage. I daresay he is correct as far as the first year is concerned, but I would be very sorry to think that it would be correct when the factory is going at full power, because, in my opinion it would be exceedingly difficult to get 5,000 acres devoted to beet without an increase in the tillage area. However, that is a matter of speculation and a matter of opinion. Certainly, for my part, I would not have the enthusiasm I had for the beet-growing industry if I did not think it would not bring, at a later stage at all events, some extra land under tillage.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Minister for Lands and Agriculture) Cumann na nGaedheal

May I explain? I said it does not matter twopence in my opinion whether the factory brings one or two acres, or any number of acres, extra under tillage. What does matter is whether the factory proves, in fact, that sugar beet is a profitable crop in this country, so that later we may have, not one, but twenty factories, and not 5,000, but maybe 50,000 or 100,000 acres of tillage. So far as this factory is concerned, it is not for the purpose of increasing tillage, in my opinion, but of proving whether beet sugar is a profitable crop in this country. If it is profitable, then we can have factories run on commercial lines afterwards, which will bring a far bigger acreage under tillage.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

Deputy Figgis the other evening referred to the fact that he thought it would be desirable that, as the State are putting up the subsidy, they should have representation on the board of this company. I am inclined to agree with him. I think it is a perfectly fair proposition, that if the State are going to put up a sum which may run into £200,000 per year that they should have somebody to look after their interests. I observe in Section 3 of the Bill that the company which receives the subsidy is to publish balance sheets and accounts, and that these are to be circulated amongst Deputies. It appears to me that it would be very desirable that the State should have a representative director on the board of the company.

Comment on this

It would be interesting to hear Deputy Johnson's views on that.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Why?

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

Deputy Johnson has plenty of opportunities of expressing his views on that. Deputy Figgis went on to say, however, that if this company are going to make considerable profits, or any profits, that the State should share in them. At first sight that seems a very plausible statement, but you have to go a little further. There are plenty of people in the world who are perfectly willing to share profits, but I have met very few in my experience who had the same opinion about sharing losses. There is no doubt that, although very fine paper profits can be shown, paper profits do not always materialise. I am not at all convinced that it would be desirable that the State should commit themselves to the extent of sharing both losses and profits. Very often we have seen in our business experience prospectuses of companies that promise all kinds of wonderful results, but these results do not always materialise, and I do not think it would be right that the State should enter into any obligation to share the financial losses of the working of this company. Although they can put up a very strong prima facie case for making good profits, there is an element of risk in it. There is, first of all, the uncertainty that the quantity of beet is going to be grown. They have to take that risk. I wish to emphasise what I have already stated, that it would be necessary for very considerable propaganda work to be carried out in order to educate and persuade farmers into growing beet, because if the quantity of beet is not produced the whole concern fails, and I am afraid there will be a definite end to the sugar beet industry for some time.

There is a good deal of discussion as to where the site of this factory is going to be. I have been asked, on various occasions, where it is going to be, and I think Deputy Gorey expressed some curiosity also on that matter. I have made one answer to any people who have come to me on this question of the site of the factory. I said that, in my opinion, the first district that puts up a definite guarantee of a definite number of acres of beet in a given area provided that it has fairly good rail and water accommodation, is the one where the factory will be established.

Comment on this

Is that the position to-day?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

As far as I can hear, at all events, the site of the factory has not been decided upon yet?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

No.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

It rests with the people in the different districts to get going, and to make out the best case they can to have the factory built in the middle of their area. It is not at all clear that the farmers in the different districts are taking this matter seriously enough. It is the duty of the farmers, if they have any enterprise, to try and prepare statistics for the people who are going to build the factory, and I would like to see them a little more alive to it. I can quite follow that there are a great many matters upon which they wish to be instructed before they can decide finally whether beet growing will pay them or not. I would suggest to the Minister that in the very near future he should send some of his experts down to the possible districts where beet may be cultivated and give the farmers in these districts some information.

One of the things that appears to be exercising the minds of a great many farmers is the question of freight. Personally I hold the view that the great bulk of the beet will have to be carted on the farmers' carts. I think when it comes to paying freights over long distances that a good deal of the milk will be out of the cocoanut for the farmer. These are questions which a good many farmers are asking themselves. That is to say, that they want a little information as to what their expenses are likely to be.

There has been a suggestion — I suppose I am in order in referring to it — about this matter being referred to a select committee. To my mind, this policy of hastening slowly is a very questionable one. I have always regarded festina lente as the magnificent inspiration of a lazy man. It is a magnificent excuse for letting things drift and doing nothing.

Comment on this
Darrell Figgis Mr. DARRELL FIGGIS Independent

I should be very loath to interpose merely on the point of order that the matter is not before the Dáil, but if Deputy Egan is going to refer to a matter that is not before the Dail, I think he ought to read the terms of the motion, and ask himself whether the whole Dáil is likely to report as early as the date set down in this motion.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it not a fact, well within our recollection, that Deputy Figgis is the very Deputy who introduced this topic in his speech on the Second Reading—a proposition for a Committee? Is it out of order for another Deputy to reply?

Comment on this
Darrell Figgis Mr. DARRELL FIGGIS Independent

I am not questioning that. All I am saying is that Deputy Egan was not speaking so much about a Committee as about delay. There will be no delay according to the terms of the motion.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

In any case, I do not want to develop this matter very much further, except to say that I do not believe in this policy of delay. There is quite sufficient evidence available to enable us to make up our minds whether to go on or not with this project. I have in my recollection the results of a good many Government commissions. It is an exceedingly rare thing for any action whatever to be taken as a result of a Government commission or committee. The longest one I can remember is the Childers Commission, a great number of years ago, which found that Ireland was overtaxed to the tune, I think, of three-and-a-half millions. There was a whole series of commissions in the intermediate years. Then we had our own Canal and Waterways Commission, the report of which is still lying in a pigeon-hole. I think Deputy Figgis agrees with me there. Apart from this, I do not see in what way a commission or committee could help in this matter. This is a matter that requires a certain amount of technical knowledge and a good deal of deep study, and I maintain that has all been done already. If you appoint a Committee of the Dáil, or of both Houses, you will have an amiable discussion round a table, and nobody will be convinced.

For my part, I have no hesitation in saying that I welcome this Bill. I believe that this project contains wonderful possibilities for the future development of the country. I believe in it mainly for the reason that I have always held that it is our duty, in our economic development, to proceed along the lines of least resistance. For that reason, I consider that in developing agriculture, or any of the industries associated with agriculture, we are taking the best possible course to help to build up this country.

Comment on this

I have kept an open mind on this matter all along, and I must say, from what I have heard, that I have not yet made up my mind on the question of the sugar-beet industry. I took it for granted that the Government had decided that a sugar-beet industry was to be established, and that when established it could be run on an economic basis. I find now that its establishment is to be experimental, and that the Government, apparently, has no fixed ideas as to whether the experiment is to be successful or not. I approve of experiments of this kind in connection with agricultural industries, but I suggest that an experiment involving £2,000,000 is a very dear one for this country. There are other experiments with possibilities that would not involve the country in such large expenditure, which might be carried out before finally embarking on this scheme.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

What are they?

Comment on this

I might suggest to the Minister that the experiments that have been made were made on specially-selected plots in a certain number of counties, and that the results cannot be regarded in any sense as final. We know something of the system on which these experimental plots are carried out. We know that particular farms are selected, and that the crop is grown under the most favourable conditions. No reliance can really be placed on such experiments, as to the acreage and the percentage of the yield of sugar from beet, grown under average conditions. If the Minister wants a real test I would suggest, as an experiment, that portion of the country might be reasonably set aside for sugar-beet growing as a commercial proposition. That would involve a loss, perhaps, of several thousand pounds, but the crop would be grown under ordinary farming conditions and not in specially-selected plots. The people would then be able to see what the results per acre would be and what the yield of sugar would be from the beet.

In the Dáil we have been confronted from time to time with projects of this kind as accomplished facts. Deputies have had no real chance of inquiring into the details of these schemes. We have had the Shannon scheme. It appears that the Cabinet comes to a definite decision and says: "This is our decision after having the advice of our experts, and the Dáil has got to accept it." I think Deputies have a right to insist that they shall be quite sure that any scheme for which their support is asked is financially sound. I am not prepared to give my support to this scheme, simply because the Minister for Agriculture, or any other Minister, states that his experts say the scheme is a sound one.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I did not say anything of the kind.

Comment on this

I believe that the Minister for Agriculture did not say that, but I understand that the Minister for Finance did say it. The Minister for Agriculture says that this proposal is an experimental one. I say if it is experimental a question that has to be seriously considered is, whether the country is able to afford an expenditure of £2,000,000 upon it. There are possible alternatives upon which the money might be spent, and that might be of greater advantage to agriculture, and give more employment. I am not condemning the scheme, and, on the other hand, I am not giving it my support. I am not in a position to condemn the scheme, nor am I in a position to give it my full support. I would like to be in a position to support it, because it is stated that the scheme is going to improve the condition of agriculture, of the industry generally, and give employment. Anything which would have that effect certainly deserves the support of Deputies, provided it is within the financial capacity of the country to bear the expense.

There are many questions in connection with the growing of sugar beet that have to be taken into account. I maintain that these questions have not been adequately dealt with. That is the reason I am in favour of a committee being set up. I have not come to that conclusion after reading Deputy Figgis's motion. I intended to make such a suggestion myself. This is a scheme which might be adequately dealt with by a committee, which would have an opportunity of examining witnesses, seeing documents and papers, making all possible enquiries, and satisfying themselves that it was a sound one. As far as I can gather, the Inter - Departmental Committee had nothing to do with the question of the policy of the establishment of a beet factory. They were simply told: "We have decided a sugar-beet factory is to be established in this country, and your duty is to find out what is the best means of establishing it. Get estimates and find out what is the best tender. When you have done that we will accept your findings." The type of committee I would suggest is one that would go into the whole question of the growing of sugar beet, and that would take into account the different conditions that exist in this country compared to other countries, where the sugar-beet industry is established. It would take into account things that adversely affect the growing of sugar-beet and the difference in climate. We have a wetter climate in Ireland than other countries in which the crop is grown.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

What harm is that?

Comment on this

I only suggested that it might be a harm. I do not know. I maintain that the matter has not been sufficiently investigated and that it cannot be investigated without the establishment of a factory.

Comment on this

Norfolk, 1922!

Comment on this

I know that that was a wet year. Do they have a wet year, year after year? How does the rainfall in the other countries compare with Ireland? Does it fall in large quantities at a time or in continual showers daily? That would have an effect on the industry. If the rain falls in large quantities at one time, that would not prevent work proceeding in the fields, as the land dries after a while, when fine weather ensues. In Ireland, for the past two or three years, we have had continual rain week after week, with the result that it would be difficult to put men out on the fields to work at the cultivation of beet. It is well known that if beet is to be properly cultivated you must have men working at it all the time. Another effect of the climate we have is that in wet weather you would have a most luxuriant growth of weeds. On that account it will be necessary to keep more men working on the land, tilling the beet, and thereby increasing the cost of production. I have not noticed that these matters have been gone into. I maintain that they ought to be gone into. There is another matter which might be considered. There is the question of freight charges, the question of the cost of carrying the beet to market. If it is found that we cannot get a sufficiently concentrated area from which to get the beet to market, the area will have to be extended and, thereby the cost of carting the beet to the factory will be very much increased. I have been informed that the cost of carrying one ton of beet ten miles by rail is five shillings a ton. The Minister for Agriculture told us that the radius of the circle within which beet would be brought to the market would be twenty miles.

Comment on this

Where did the Deputy get that quotation of five shillings for ten miles? Is it from a railway company or a transport company?

Comment on this

It does not matter where I got it.

Comment on this

It is important.

Comment on this

That is roughly what it is, five shillings for ten miles. I am sure it is not much lower than that.

Comment on this

I would be surprised to know that that is a quotation from the existing classifications on Irish railways.

Comment on this

My quotation is not for Irish railways, as beet has not been carried on the railways here. This is probably a continental quotation. I think I got it from one of Mr. Woods's publications, and it may be taken to be approximately correct. Five shillings for ten miles would be ten shillings for twenty miles. That would come off the price of the sugar-beet. It must necessarily come off the price of the sugar-beet sold by the farmer. Deputy Egan talks about road haulage. If you haul beet by road, I ask Deputy Egan what the profit will be? If Deputy Egan loads one ton of sugar beet on a cart and hauls it twenty or even only ten miles, it is a day's work for a man and a horse.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

There are hundreds of thousands of tons of barley hauled considerably over ten miles every year.

Comment on this

Barley is a much more valuable substance in proportion to its weight than sugar-beet. Sugar-beet is a comparatively light substance, and the cost of haulage in proportion to its value would be greater. Deputy Magennis gave us a very interesting lecture on the question of sugar-beet. He is a very ardent advocate of the necessity of establishing a sugar-beet factory or factories. I would rather suggest that he almost over-argued his case. I would certainly have been more convinced if he had not gone so far to prove the necessity or the advisability of establishing one or even three beet factories. He also told us that one of the advantages of the establishment of a sugar-beet factory would be the increase in the yield of milk by forty-five or fifty per cent. He says that these were the official figures given in a British observer's report to the British Government. I ask the Dáil seriously if they think it is possible to increase the yield of milk in milch-cows by forty-five or fifty per cent. by feeding them on beet-pulp?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy challenge my veracity or is it the figures he is challenging?

Comment on this

I am challenging the figures in the Deputy's statement.

Comment on this

Does he challenge my veracity? I think I am entitled to an answer. I gave the Deputy the source of my information. If he disputes the accuracy of the figures which a British official gave to his Government I have nothing to do with that. The language which the Deputy uses now imputes to me the statement of something that is not true.

Comment on this

I will quote the Deputy's words in his speech on Tuesday last:—"Experiments both in Government research schools and in the actual practice of dairy farming show enormous increase in the yield of milk in the case of cows fed upon this pulp. Between forty-five and sixty per cent. increase are the official figures given in an English observer's report to the British Government — a man sent out to make a report on agriculture in Germany." I say that that is what Deputy Magennis said. I do not believe that. In fact, I know that such a thing is altogether impossible. At that point in the Deputy's speech Deputy Johnson interjected and asked: "Had selection anything to do with that? Professor Magennis — In what sense? Mr. Johnson — Selection as regards the milking qualities of the cattle. Professor Magennis — Certainly it had." That changes the whole aspect of the case.

Comment on this

Read the next sentence.

Comment on this

"It was all part and parcel of scientifically conducted farming and dairying." I acknowledge that, but Deputy Magennis was arguing that sugar-beet would increase the production of milk. Then unquestionably, he combined with that the fact that selection will increase the production of milk. We know that selection, apart from feeding, will vastly increase the production of milk. I read from his argument, and I suggest that anyone would read from his argument, if Deputy Johnson had not interjected, the idea that sugar-beet slices fed to cattle would give an increase of from forty-five to fifty per cent. in the milk yield. Probably a number of Deputies received this booklet written by Mr. Alfred Woods, about whom we have heard so much. He gives some results of experiments as regards the feeding of milch cows with sugar beet. I would refer the Deputy to page 6.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to me?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Deputy is not particularly referring to Deputy Magennis.

Comment on this

I thought that the Deputy who was speaking said that he would refer me to this publication. It is a Van Rossum publication. I have read it more than once.

Comment on this

As regards experiments it says: "Lot 2 in the first period had neither roots nor slices, and in the second period had 20 lbs. of roots per day, and 5.8 lbs. dried beet slices, besides the three parts of pulp to fourteen in the grain mixture. In this trial the milk produced on the ration with slices was 22½ lbs. more per cow as a weekly average." I calculate that to be an increase of sixteen per cent., a very satisfactory increase.

Comment on this

In England?

Comment on this

No, in Michigan. The following paragraph deals with another experiment which shows an increase of 6.18 per cent. There is evidently an increase in milk production to be gained by feeding with beet slices, in addition to other feeding, but I suggest it could not be increased by forty-five per cent., as Deputy Magennis suggested.

Comment on this

Again I ask your protection, sir. I quoted from a particular document, with regard to a particular country, as observed by a particular official of the British Government. The Deputy insists in believing that I generalised, and that all over the world in the Sierras, the Rocky Mountains, the Argentine, and the Alps, and under any circumstances whatever, the dried pulp residue of beet-sugar production would give a milk yield of from 45 per cent. to 50 per cent. The thing is nonsensical.

Comment on this

I am within my rights. I say that Deputy Magennis's statement does not specify any particular English observer. He does not give the English observer's name, or on what occasion he reported to the British Government, or where we are to get a copy of the statements which the observer made.

Comment on this

Or where the milk was going to.

Comment on this

That is all very fine, but these are the words that are used, and we have them before us. That kind of argument is a type of special pleading, or propaganda, calculated to do more harm than good, as regards the establishment of an industry of this kind. We want solid, hard facts. If an increased milk yield of 16 per cent. can be got good work will be done, and we would appreciate that, but it is not right to mislead the farmers.

Comment on this

Again, I ask is it right to suggest that I am misleading the farmers?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

I do not think the Deputy should use an expression conveying the suggestion that the Deputy is misleading the farmers.

Comment on this

I say that while Deputy Professor Magennis has no intention of deliberately misleading the farmers, the farmers reading the statement may be misled.

Comment on this

One of them has been.

Comment on this

It is not advisable that they should be misled, or that they should read propaganda or exaggerated statements about the possible advantages of the beet root industry. We should rather try and get down to the real hard facts, and get a grip of them, so that we should know what sort of industry we are embarking on. That is why I suggest that there ought to be a committee of inquiry of the Dáil or the Oireachtas set up. That committee would have the opportunity of hearing evidence. That evidence would be published in the papers, and people would have a chance of reading and discussing it, so that the whole thing could be thoroughly thrashed out. As it is, it has been handed to us as a scheme which has been decided upon by the Government, and we are asked to accept or reject it. Deputy Professor Magennis is very fond of passing slights, if I might say so, on the farmers' representatives, if not on the farmers themselves. He referred to the agricultural grant, and he said that the new agricultural grant might be usefully diverted to the establishment of beet factories. I will read his words, as I do not wish to draw his ire upon me by not giving his exact statement. He said: "If you want to know where to get the money — well, instead of that £600,000 given as a grant-in-aid of agricultural rates, which is only a relief — a species of outdoor relief — give the money in the form of subsidies that will create not one but at least three factories in each of the provinces at present under the jurisdiction of the Saorstát, and create something with a permanent yield." We will not acknowledge that the agricultural grant given to us this year is a form of outdoor relief. We state that that grant is simply putting a matter right that should have been put right long ago, and that agricultural land has been bearing for years, and is still bearing, an undue proportion of the rates for the upkeep of local services. Therefore this agricultural grant has nothing to do with a subsidy or outdoor relief. It is merely righting a wrong that has existed for years, and that has already been righted in England and in Northern Ireland. Deputy Professor Magennis referred to an assured market. He says: "Farmers will have the advantage of an assured market." They will, but will they have the advantage of assured prices. Under the Bill the price is guaranteed to the farmers only for three years. The price is fixed at 54/- for that period, and after that the price is left to the free play of supply and demand. That is, in other words, that the factories can pay the lowest possible price at which they can get beet root. It is an excellent thing to have an assured market.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, I have not read the report myself yet, but I think if the Deputy reads on he will find that I was recommending Van Rossum's offer, and I pointed out that it included something like a guaranteed fixed price for ten years. It is three years in the Bill, and that is why I was speaking in recommendation of that particular offer.

Comment on this

I cannot refer the House to this particular quotation. I understood Deputy Professor Magennis was referring to the general statement, but if he did refer to the Van Rossum's project, and pointed out that it guaranteed a price for ten years, I would say that the Deputy was right, that that scheme did guarantee an assured market. That is an important matter, and should have been considered by the Executive Council in deciding to what company they would give the subsidy in connection with the establishment of this particular industry. In my opinion, another very important reason why this matter should be considered by a Committee of the House, is that many statements have been made with regard to alternative schemes, or schemes which might be established at the same time. We have heard about the Skoda factory scheme, and Deputy Professor Magennis has spoken about the Van Rossum scheme, regarding which he has given a great many figures. We have the statement of the Minister for Finance that these schemes were not acceptable, and were not as good as the scheme put before the Ministry by the Belgian firm. Many statements have been made on this subject, and letters have appeared in the Press. I am not in a position to say whether they are correct. There may be something in them, and there is the possibility that if plans put forward by other people had been accepted a considerable saving might be made for the State in connection with the establishment of this industry. I maintain that before the Dáil passes this Bill it has a right to know what these schemes are.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Minister for Lands and Agriculture) Cumann na nGaedheal

The Dáil has got all the details in connection with the scheme.

Comment on this

I think the details given were not sufficient to enable the House to form a judgment. I would ask the Minister himself if he were faced with the question of choosing between three factories to be established in the country, and if he had to judge by a bare outline given in a hurry in the House, would he be in a position to make up his mind in a quarter of an hour as to which was correct?

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Minister for Lands and Agriculture) Cumann na nGaedheal

It has been going on for three days.

Comment on this

The Minister was not speaking for three days. There are possibilities that a considerable saving might have been made if one of the other schemes had been accepted. It is stated to-day in a letter in the Press that a considerable saving might have been made if the Skoda scheme had been accepted.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not like to interrupt the Deputy, but there is one consideration that ought to appeal to him as a farmer. Under the Skoda scheme the farmer was to get 42/- per ton for beet, while under the other scheme he is guaranteed 54/-.

Comment on this

I am quite aware of that, but that argument is not going to make me change my point of view—

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I did not think it would.

Comment on this

It is stated in this letter that the Skoda people put forward a scheme; that while other firms got chances of making other offers and suggestions the Skoda people got no such opportunity and that, without any such opportunity, they were informed that their scheme was not considered satisfactory. It is quite possible that arrangements might have been made with the Skoda people whereby, with a slight increase in the subsidy, they might guarantee the same price to the farmer as under the scheme which has been accepted. Judging by the statement in the paper it would appear that undue favour was shown to certain schemes when the promoters got an opportunity of revising their original estimates that the other promoters did not get.

Deputy Magennis suggested that there was another company which was in a position to establish a factory — the Van Rossum Company. He gave us certain figures with regard to that syndicate. The figures are given in the statement made to the Dáil but not in tabular form, which would permit one to judge effectively, by comparison with the other schemes, as to whether it is sound or otherwise. But it should have been considered as an alternative scheme, and if a saving could be made to the nation it ought to have been accepted. The promoters of these schemes should be given opportunity to meet the representatives of the Government and to vary their schemes, if they are prepared to do so, in order to meet the requirements of the State.

I would suggest that if there is any suspicion that there has been any favour shown, and that some firms did not get the opportunity that the others got, it is only right that the Dáil should understand by means of a Committee if things are as they should be, and if the best offer from the soundest firm has been accepted. As regards the statements made that this scheme is a subsidy for the farmer as against a subsidy for the factory owner, I maintain that by far the greater benefit will eventually result to the factory rather than to the farmer. The factory gets a subsidy of approximately £2,000,000. The Minister for Finance states that the factory is expected to produce 86,000 tons of sugar in ten years. If seven tons of sugar beet will yield one ton of sugar, it would require 602,000 tons of beet to produce these 86,000 tons of sugar. Taking this at an average price of 40/-, that is equal to £1,200,000 for the period. Taking the free market value of beet at 30/- per ton, that is £903,000. That would be the figure if there was no subsidy for beet. These are only estimates. I understand that the market value of beet on the Continent is something like 35/- per ton. If from £1,200,000 you subtract £903,000, that leaves a sum of £297,000. I maintain that that is what the farmer gets out of the £2,000,000, and that the balance goes to the factory. Now, with regard to employment, I think the amount of employment given in connection with this industry has, to a certain extent, been exaggerated. The actual employment given in the factory is nothing extraordinary. I think it was Deputy Egan to-day who stated that it would employ up to 250 people.

Comment on this

500 people.

Comment on this

That is very much larger than the figure with which I was supplied by an official of the Department of Agriculture. But I will take that figure as being correct. That is not a great deal of employment. The question of employment will depend largely on the amount of extra employment on the land. And the extra employment on the land depends, in my opinion, on whether beet will be grown as an addition to, rather than as a substitute for, the present green crops. I do not think anybody can state at present to what extent beet will be grown as an addition to rather than as a substitute for the present green crops. If we take it that beet is to be grown as an addition, it will certainly have the effect of increasing employment in country districts. My view of it is that where the farmer at present grows, say, an acre of green crops on a 25-acre farm that is probably about the average of green crops grown — if he grows an additional acre of beet he will, in my opinion double his area under cultivation. Where formerly he had four acres under cultivation under a four-course rotation, he will now have eight acres under cultivation. It will double his root crop, and double his grain crop and double his new grass crop also. It will have the effect of increasing employment in such cases. That, of course, will also affect the carrying capacity of his land. The question arises whether he will be able to carry as many cattle under this system as under the old system, where he had more grass and less cultivation. It involves the question whether it will pay the farmer to grow grain to sell. It will double the acreage of land under oats or barley, and there will undoubtedly be a surplus for sale. If there is not a good price paid for the grain crop, the farmer will lose something on the grain crop which he has to sow as a result of the cultivation of beet.

I only put these matters forward tentatively. I maintain that these are things that should be considered by a committee. The ultimate effect they would have on agriculture should be considered, so that when we would be voting on the scheme we would have a fairly reasonable idea as to the general effect on the agricultural industry. We have not had an opportunity of considering that. We have not had an adequate opportunity of visualising the changes which it is likely to bring about in the agricultural industry. To put a Bill of this kind hastily through the House, placing a lot of undigested figures before Deputies, is not the way that a scheme involving the expediture of £2,000,000 should be dealt with. The expenditure is likely to be more than that, because I understand from the speech from the Minister for Finance that it is probable that this subsidy will not cease at the end of ten years. In all probability a reduced subsidy will have to be given at the end of that period. If this factory is found to be a success, and if other factories are established, they will have to be subsidised also. That means that the State will have to embark on a large scheme of subsidies, entailing a considerable expenditure of money. As Deputy Magennis said, it will mean dipping very deeply into the pockets of the taxpayer in the future. The question for the House to decide, in my opinion, is: Is it worth while? Will the money to be spent on the sugar factory be spent to the best advantage? Are there not possibilities of spending £2,000,000 in other ways, which would benefit agriculture to a greater extent, benefit industry to a greater extent, and give an equal, if not greater amount of employment. If there are possibilities of that kind — and I would suggest that there are possibilities——

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Would the Deputy indicate some of them?

Comment on this

I will walk into the trap, as the Minister desires it. I will indicate a couple of possibilities for the improvement of agriculture. There is a very insufficient sum included in the Agricultural Vote for agricultural education. There is an insufficient sum being spent on cow-testing associations. I only give those as examples of how money might be usefully expended, which would result in increased production and increased employment.

Comment on this

Would these schemes give increased employment?

Comment on this

Increased agricultural production is bound to give increased employment. All increases in production along the lines that the Ministry is following at the present time — dairy produce, poultry products, cattle feeding in the winter, and matters of that kind, for the purpose of providing food — is bound to increase employment. Agricultural education is starved at the present time. Not nearly enough money is spent on it, having regard to the value of the agricultural industry to this country. Statements were made by Ministers here which I find it difficult to reconcile. We should have an opportunity of finding out what exactly was meant when these statements were made. The Minister for Finance states that coal in the sugar beet factory would represent 50 per cent. of the cost of manufacture. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture states that the percentage for coal would amount to between 14 and 25 per cent.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Would the Deputy turn to the end of the Official Report and read the Minister's correction of the figure which he gave.

Comment on this

I have read the Minister's correction, but it is not sufficiently clear. I am not saying that an incorrect statement was made, but I believe that Ministers ought to be given the opportunity of reconciling these statements.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

They have been reconciled.

Comment on this

They have not been reconciled to my satisfaction.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I did not suggest that.

Comment on this

An opportunity should be given to have these figures reconciled, and we should be quite satisfied that these statements are not made loosely, but that there is definite information behind them. We have had figures given with regard to cost of production and it is very hard to reconcile them. The Minister for Finance said that 50 per cent. of the cost of manufactured sugar would be represented by coal. Deputy Egan said that one ton of coal would manufacture one ton of sugar. According to statements made in this House, the cost of production is only £32,000 for an 8,000 ton factory. The Minister for Agriculture says from £90,000 to £140,000. There seems to be something loose in those calculations, if we take the statement by Deputy Egan that a ton of coal will manufacture a ton of sugar. There have been conflicting statements made, too, with regard to the subsidy. The Minister for Finance said, in making comparisons between the British subsidy and the Irish subsidy, that the British subsidy was 15/8½ per cwt. of sugar, plus 10d. for molasses. We know that the Irish subsidy is 23/-. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture worked out the British subsidy at 19/9, plus 2/1. Those are statements which require to be explained. If the Minister for Lands and Agriculture is right, the Minister for Finance cannot be right. If this scheme is to be adopted, I would suggest that the idea promulgated by other Deputies should be carried out — that the Government should have a right when they invest £2,000,000 in this industry to have some voice in its control. They should have some representation on the board of directors. In the other schemes put before the Government they would have representation on the board of directors.

Comment on this

What good would that be?

Comment on this

It might be minority representation, but minority representation is sometimes useful.

Comment on this

What for—to create friction?

Comment on this

It is a matter of opinion what the effect would be, but it might not necessarily be friction. It might be very useful from the point of view of criticism and from the point of view of seeing that the factory was being run as it ought be run and that the farmers' interests were not being neglected by the board of directors. In the scheme submitted to the Government by Van Rossum, they would have representation of two out of five. I think that that should be an argument in favour of the acceptance of such a scheme.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Is that in the Van Rossum scheme?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is not in the Van Rossum scheme. It is in the Skoda scheme.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is the 42/- scheme.

Comment on this

I am not advocating the 42/- price to the farmer. That was a nice point for the Minister to make, but I maintain that the promoters of that scheme should have had an opportunity of having it examined.

They should have an opportunity of rectifying the scheme in regard to prices for farmers, and other matters, if they were willing to do so. I believe undoubtedly that if they do not rectify the scheme in that regard it will be a fatal objection, and it will tend to prevent the acceptance of the scheme. If we are to believe statements that we see in the papers, they did not get an opportunity doing so. Now, the success of this scheme will depend finally upon the farmers; it will depend upon whether the farmers will be prepared to undertake the growing of this beet in sufficient quantities to warrant the establishment of a factory. They are going to get a guaranteed price for certain number of years — for three years. I would suggest that if the factory people are going to get a subsidy of ten years, there is no reason why the farmers should not get a guaranteed price for ten years.

Comment on this

They are getting it for six years, at all events.

Comment on this

No, for three years. The Bill says that the farmers are to get a guaranteed price for three years. I do not know how the Deputy makes it six years.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is right, but there are other factors.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That is perfectly correct.

Comment on this

The success of the scheme depends upon whether the farmers will enter into it wholeheartedly and will take a keen interest in it. If the idea of establishing a sugar factory is a sound idea, there is no reason why it should be a contentious matter. If it is supported by the Government, and if, eventually, it is decided that a sugar factory is required, I believe the House should unanimously support the project. An effort should then be made to encourage the farmers to engage in the production of sugar-beet, and in the better cultivation of land. But we should give the farmers every opportunity of understanding what they are to do, and what the effect will be on the industry. The farmers should have some opportunity of knowing whether this is the best paying game if they embark on it. The question is not a sentimental one; it must and will be a financial question, for the most part, amongst the farmers. The whole point for the farmer is whether cultivating sugar beet will pay better than the present system of farming. We have different conditions here from those that exist in Norfolk. Norfolk is a county with tillage traditions; it is suited to tillage and not to grazing. It is much easier to get farmers in a county like that to engage in the growing of beet than it would be in this country, where we have few areas devoted to tillage in the sense in which Norfolk is devoted to tillage.

The growing of beet may involve the breaking up of large areas of grass land. The farmer will have to be assured that it will pay him to break up this land, good quality grazing land, before he will undertake the cultivation of beet. He should have a reasonable assurance that there is profit in beet-growing and that there will be an advantage from the point of view of succeeding crops. If that can be made clear to the farmers, I believe they will take up beet-growing. It would not be right to face the farmer with a scheme which the Government may think is a sound one and will be for the eventual benefit of the country, without explaining fully its immediate effects and the results likely to be achieved in the course of a number of years.

It is possible that if the farmer embarks on this scheme, in five or six years he may find himself, having all his land tilled and his system of farming changed, faced with the attitude of a factory which has the monopoly, which may give whatever price it likes, and over which the Government have no control, as it would have no representation on the Board of Directors. That would be an unsatisfactory position for the farmers. I contend that we have not got sufficient information. Until we get more information, until we know that the best scheme—the scheme more suited to this country— has been adopted by the Government, until we know the possibilities of this scheme in its application to Ireland, until the Dáil is convinced that it is a feasible scheme, and that the establishment of the factory will tend to improve agricultural industry and increase the wealth of the country, we should not proceed with any undue haste. We should like to have more information in regard to the promised improved financial and social conditions under this scheme for the establishment of a sugar beet factory.

Comment on this

Rather than interrupt the Deputy. I delayed until he had finished. Perhaps I will be permitted, on a point of explanation, to clear the Deputy's mind in regard to a matter on which his mind was obscured by reading the report of my speech. I read to the House a balance sheet submitted to the Government by the Van Rossum group. In that balance sheet it was computed that for 5,000 acres under beet tillage there would be 50,000 tons of beets and 5,000 tons of sugar; for each ton of sugar, a ton of coal and a half-ton of limestone. Now, the Deputy seems to be under the impression that the computation of one ton of coal for one ton of sugar is very imaginative, or that it was an illusory thing that Deputies on these Benches had devised out of their own heads. Those are the figures of a firm engaged in the production of sugar from sugar-beet in Holland—one of the greatest firms in Europe. I think the Deputy is certainly misreading the report if he is under the impression that I invented the figures. That is not one of my propensities.

Comment on this

I thought that was what the Deputy had read.

Comment on this

Either it is in the report of my speech or it is not. The Deputy purported to read from my speech. He referred a few moments ago to what he called a statement of mine which did not set out detailed figures. I read the balance sheet, every figure in the balance sheet, and the Deputy is probably unaware that Deputy Johnson circulated afterwards a sheet of figures based upon a combination of those figures and the figures of the Minister.

Comment on this

May I explain that I was aware of the fact that the Deputy had read out what was part of the balance sheet of the company. I maintain that as the statement was not set out in tabular form, and was interlarded between other matters in the debate, it is not possible to understand it.

Comment on this

But Deputies understood it.

Comment on this

I would like to call Deputy Magennis's attention to the fact that his statement quotes the price of sugar at 50/- per cwt., which is altogether in excess of the price at the present time.

Comment on this

I expressly stated that the date of the letter was the 19th January, and that some of the figures in it, for example, the price of sugar and coal, would necessarily require revision. These are the exact words I used.

Comment on this
Darrell Figgis Mr. DARRELL FIGGIS Independent

I would like to ask one question, as this matter is rather confusing. Are the figures under reference now, and the figures read by Deputy Magennis, the figures of the Van Rossum group or the Lippens group, in the Bill?

Comment on this

They are the Van Rossum figures.

Comment on this

With so many authorities and so many experts on the sugar-beet industry in the Dáil, a Deputy such as I am feels very timid entering into the discussion. However, I would like to say that I regard this Bill as a further big effort on the part of our Government to develop the Saorstát industrially and economically with, of course——

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for AGRICULTURE (Mr. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

And agriculturally.

Comment on this
Mr. HENNESSY

And, I was going to say, with the eagle eye of the Minister for Agriculture on the need of developing the agricultural industry. I therefore beg to support the measure. Less than twelve months ago the matter of establishing a sugar-beet industry in this country was not before the people as a practical proposition. In the early autumn of last year a number of practical farmers — I wish to lay emphasis on these two words—and practical business men in County Cork met and formed an association called the North Cork Industrial Development Association.

Comment on this

The North Cork Militia.

Comment on this

Their successors.

Comment on this
Mr. HENNESSY

Amongst this number there were, as I say, practical farmers, men who had experimented for a number of years on the growth of sugar-beet, its sugar content, its high food value, its manurial value and all that. By a series of lectures and public meetings and so on, they focussed the attention of the people of Ireland and they focussed the attention of the Government on the importance of establishing a sugar beet industry in the Saorstát. I have no doubt that the Dáil and the country appreciate the work of that Association, and will mark such appreciation in a practical way by assisting our new industry, by co-operating with the Government and the people in making this industry a success. I understand there are certain essentials for the success of the sugar-beet industry in the Saorstát. First of all, there is the question of transport facilities. The factory must be built within easy reach of rail or water transport facilities. Then there is the question of the quality of the soil. I understand that the soil must be rich, loamy soil, that it must be deeply tilled and enriched, and that you must have a good water supply. Of course, a matter of great importance is the co-operation of the farming community. That is very important, because in the first years of operating or working such a factory, we must have within reach of the factory or within the area in which it is established, I understand, 5,000 acres of land under cultivation for beet.

I say without any hesitation that in Cork County you have all these essentials available. I do not put that forward with the object of establishing a prior right for Cork beyond any other part of the Saorstát. I do say with such an assurance from a very large number of Cork farmers and business people — in North, South, East and West Cork and all the parts of the county which I have travelled during the last twelve months—that you have there the main essentials. I think that the firm whose offer the Government have now accepted, Messrs. Lippens of Belgium, with the co-operation of the Government, particularly the Minister for Agriculture, who has the records and statistics at his disposal, should give such a place, where there are such assurances, some consideration and I leave it at that.

The establishment of this industry will be a big fillip to the agricultural industry. We have, first of all, an extra 5,000 acres to be tilled. We must have deeper tillage and we must have richer tillage. The grower of this crop is assured a guaranteed price at the factory for three years, at all events. This gives him a net profit, in the first instance, of at least anything up to £11 per acre. We must not stop there; there are other calculations to be taken into consideration. We have the dried slices, which are sold back to the farmer for a few shillings per cwt.; I might say for a few shillings per ton, because I am informed by an expert authority that a few cwts. of these slices yield a ton of pulp when soaked in water. This ton of pulp has a very high food value and a very high fattening value for cattle. As other Deputies have already pointed out, it has also a very high milk producing value. The land, I am informed, is of such a rich state after this crop that the cereal crops put in afterwards will give a very much greater yield. The leaves from this beet crop have a very high manurial value. The crop is pulled in the autumn, and the leaves are left on the field generally and ploughed in. These give very good results to the crops sown afterwards.

We have also got to consider the question of how this matter affects the problem of unemployment. It has been mentioned by other Deputies before. Surely we must agree that an industry of this nature must, in the ordinary course of its operations, absorb a large number of our unemployed. We have, first of all, a large acreage of tillage, which must necessarily carry with it a large number of men to work it. In all its stages—first the planting, the thinning, the cleaning and the pulling—a number of men will be required. There will be the building of the factory which will cost something about £3,000,000. Surely that will give employment to a large number of men. Afterwards you will have to employ people to operate all the machinery. From that point of view this question deserves the serious consideration of the Dáil. There is on the Order Paper to-day a motion in the name of Deputy Figgis, the effect of which is that this Bill should be held up for some indefinite period.

Comment on this

That is not so. Read the motion.

Comment on this

The date is fixed as the 25th June.

Comment on this
Mr. HENNESSY

When we get to the 25th June we will probably have reached the date for the adjournment of the Dáil for a period of three months, and goodness knows where we will find our factory when we come back. I submit that if the Dáil were to agree to appoint the committee suggested, it would come back with a report assuring us of what we have been told already by the Minister for Agriculture, and of what the Departmental Committee, appointed by the Government, reported on. That committee, after going exhaustively and minutely into the matter, reported that the offer of M. Lippens was the very best proposition that could be put forward. I do not think that the Dáil could accede to the request to hang up this Bill in view of the fact that we have 50,000 unemployed in our midst.

We all know from the views expressed from the Farmers' benches that agriculture needs a fillip. We know, too, that large numbers of our young people are compelled to emigrate to America week after week to the extent of about 25,000 a year. In view of these facts, I do not think that we should hold up a great constructive measure of this kind. From the conclusions arrived at by the Departmental Committee, which examined this question in all its aspects, I think we should proceed at once with the scheme outlined. We have had the experiences gained by other countries in this matter of beet cultivation put before us. We have learned of the great wealth which they have derived from the carrying on of this industry, and, therefore, I say we should not proceed slowly in this matter.

The experience of Great Britain has been quoted for us. We have seen how the Government of that country hunted over the world to get the best men and the most reputable firms for the purpose of establishing more factories, of the kind we are discussing, over there. That ought to be a sufficient encouragement for us to go on with this scheme. I trust, therefore, that the Dáil will urge on the Government to proceed as quickly as possible with this scheme, and, further, that it will press on the Executive Council to grant not merely a licence to the firm of M. Lippens for the setting up of one factory, but that if other reputable firms can be secured, it will grant similar licences to them. In my opinion, we have room in the Saorstát for a second factory of this kind. I have no doubt myself that this is a kind of industry which will receive the co-operation of all classes of people in the country, and that it can be made a great success.

Comment on this