We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - ESTIMATES FOR PUBLIC SERVICES.—VOTE 48 (DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE).—RESUMED.

Contributions 131–268 of 268. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

How are you going to have responsibility if you have no brand?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

A brand on the eggs?

Comment on this

Yes. How are you to deal with unsound eggs?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

This is the argument on the Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Act all over again. If the Deputy has decided views on that point in connection with the branding of eggs, I would be glad to have them fully considered. The regulations have not yet been prepared, and there is no decision one way or the other in regard to that, though the Act will be in operation in August.

Comment on this

I have very decided views, and these views are reinforced by the volume of opinion I have been able to ascertain. If the Minister is prepared to consider that matter, it meets my view, and we are prepared to put up a recommendation.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Certainly.

Comment on this

If the Minister would look at the Official Reports he would see that we put up amendments when the Bill was going through. He will find there sufficient reasons for accepting this point of view.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That is the point I have just made, that this was all argued.

Comment on this

Yes, pretty exhaustively.

Comment on this

I want to deal with the question of the appointment of the inspectors provided for under this sub-head. I notice, not alone in this case, but in every case where an appointment to the public service is to be made, that the advertisement states that ex-members of the National Army will get a preference, and that the appointments will be made by a selection board appointed by the Civil Service Commission. I take, and have always taken, the view that no citizen has any more right than another to an appointment in the public service where the taxpayers' money is being spent, and I do question very seriously if one citizen, whether he has been in the National Army or not, has higher qualifications than any other man when it comes to questions of appointments of this or of any other kind. We all know perfectly well that whatever service was rendered, and there was good service rendered by the men who joined the National Army, whether individuals joined for patriotic or for other motives——

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

What other motives?

Comment on this

I was coming to the point, if the Minister would refrain for a moment from interrupting me, that they were well paid for the services, whatever they were, that they rendered. The Estimates that have been passed here are the best indication of that. If such a thing should ever have existed, the time has now arrived at any rate when that bogey should be dropped. The same kind of thing was put up after the European war by Mr. Lloyd George and his friends, that the men who fought and won the Great War for England were the men who should get work and positions which were in the privilege of Ministers of the State and the Government to give.

With regard to the Selection Board, I have read a speech made by the Minister for Finance at some dinner in the City of Dublin, where he said that neither he nor any of his colleagues have power to appoint even a shorthand-typist. I question that very much indeed, because I have discovered, and I think it should be within the knowledge of Deputies, that the men who compose the Selection Board appointed by the Civil Service Commissioners, are generally the heads of Departments of the State, or very highly-placed officials. We all know that these men, whoever they may be, are very largely under the thumb of the Ministry, and for that reason appointments made in cases of this kind must have some bearing on the minds of the Ministers in regard to individuals who have made application. I am making no accusation against the Minister for Lands and Agriculture at all, but against other Ministers.

Comment on this

You are just making the sort of speech that is typical of you. The Deputy always avails of the privilege here to throw slander at people outside.

Comment on this

That is just typical of the kind of mud that the Minister is capable of throwing at Deputies.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Deputy cannot discuss these matters on this Vote.

Comment on this

I am raising the question of the right of people to appointments on merit, apart from political influence and service in the Army.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Would the Deputy explain "political influence" in connection with this? I have clearly got his point about National Army men; I understand what it means, but I want to understand what he means about "political influence."

Comment on this

I have made a statement, and the Minister is quite capable of understanding it, that the Selection Board, as far as one can understand, select men for positions of this kind in accordance very largely with the wishes and views of the heads of Departments of State. Is that so or not?

Comment on this

What has that got to do with it?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Deputy Davin is of the opinion that ex-National Army men should not get a preference; I am of opinion that they should. I am quite clear that they should. I will not enter into the question of why these men joined the Army. Deputy Davin thinks they joined the Army for pay; so do a great many others. I have my own views about that. That does not arise. I am clearly of opinion that ex-members of the National Army should get a preference.

Comment on this

To what extent?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am clearly of that opinion, and it is the view of the Government, and I believe of the majority of Deputies that ex-members of the National Army should get a preference, and they will get a preference. Deputy Davin has the opposite opinion. He has a right to hold it.

Comment on this

I want to say to the Minister for Finance that this is an honest opinion and is, I hope, as honest as his opinion is on many matters.

Comment on this

I believe it.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I do not know why the Deputy flaunts his honesty.

Comment on this

The mud-slinging Minister for Finance doubts it.

Comment on this

I do, frankly.

Comment on this

Thanks for nothing.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

On the question of the Selection Board, Deputy Davin, of course, thinks that everyone can be got at. I cannot help that; I cannot persuade him that they cannot. I am merely stating that there are people who do think otherwise, and that really everyone has not got his price, whether it be money or political influence. That is all that is in it.

Comment on this

I did not say that at all.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Deputy Davin thinks that most people can be got at. He will learn when he gets a little older that there are people who cannot be got at, and I am absolutely satisfied, and I have good reason to be satisfied of this, because a good many appointments have to be made in connection with my Department, that I would not for one dare to attempt to influence any Selection Board set up by the Civil Service Commission. I know what would happen if I did. The Civil Service Commissioners and the selection boards cannot be got at by a Minister with influence of any kind. The heads of the Civil Service are men of character and reputation, and the fact that a senior officer, let us say, of the Ministry of Local Government or of Defence, or of Finance, is on the selection board to make an appointment, say, in the Land Commission does not mean that I can go to him and get at him. That is not done. We have our own responsibilities, number one, which would prevent us attempting it, and the particular officer in question, who is usually a high official, who is usually put there because he has some special knowledge, cannot be got at. Therefore, from both points of view it is out of the question.

Comment on this

The Minister has made a statement which raises a certain doubt in my mind. He stated that the Civil Service Selection Board might be composed of the heads of Departments, as, for instance——

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I said senior officers.

Comment on this

Of the Local Government Department, in the case of the selection of Land Commission officials. If we take it that the Committee appointed to select Land Commission officials consists of one of the high officials of the Local Government Department, one of the Department of Finance, and so on, it seems to me that such a committee is quite incapable of selecting men to do Land Commission work, or to select the right men to carry out inspections under the Land Act.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Supposing there is an appointment which requires a certain amount of technical knowledge, administrative knowledge, and a good general education, and that this appointment cannot be made by examination, the proper selection board would be composed of somebody who has a technical knowledge of the particular work, say, the inspection of land, creameries, or anything else, and somebody else who would be a fair judge of general education, who would have to make up his own mind in conjunction with the man who would have the special technical knowledge of the general education and of the administrative ability of a particular applicant. That is all that there is in it. I picked out at random a couple of Departments, the Ministry of Defence and the Ministry of Local Government, and spoke of appoinments in the Land Commission. These were, of course, picked out at random. I am merely pointing out that for every appointment that cannot be made by examination, and which requires a certain amount of technical knowledge, a certain amount of administrative ability, and a certain amount of general education, you must have a selection board made up of different kinds of people, people who have the requisite technical knowledge, the requisite administrative experience, and who are fair judges of what standard of education is necessary for the appointment. That is all.

Comment on this

In connection with 0.2 (E) "Educational work in connection with the Act," would the Minister say if any money was spent on similar work in last year's Estimate? Would that include any of the work that would be done by the College of Science, such as "Creamery course at Cork University College," and "Equipment for creamery course"? I would like to know if the sum that was spent under another head, last year, say, has been turned over to this, if there is a corresponding reduction in another part of the Estimate compared with last year, and if it is brought in here under this head now.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Practically the same sort of work was done last year at Cork University, but we expect more students and we provided somewhat more money for that purpose this year. There are certain courses at University College, Cork, for creamery managers. The scholarship amounts to free tuition and a maintenance allowance. I forget for the moment what the maintenance allowance is. There is also provision for the practical training of buttermakers, and perhaps creamery managers, at creameries, and the scholarship amounts to a maintenance allowance of 15/- per week, and a small fee to the creamery. That was provided for last year under a different sub-head, but it is increased by a small amount this year.

Comment on this

Am I to understand that there is a sum in any other part of the Estimate with this to cover similar work?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

In any part of this year's Estimate?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am not quite sure about that.

Comment on this

We have here £1,134 for the administration of this Act. Does that sum include a certain sum to be spent on educational work in connection with creamery training this year, a portion of which sum was also spent, or some similar work done, last year?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I think last year was the first time we gave any special courses in University College, Cork.

Comment on this

But is there an endowment in connection with the work of the College of Science?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

There is.

Comment on this

Apart from this altogether, is there a sum set aside for creamery work in the College of Science?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Certainly, in connection with the Munster Institute.

Comment on this

The point that Deputy Baxter is trying to make has not been answered. I maintain that this sum of £2,400 is not properly placed in this Vote at all. We will be told by the Minister that the administration of the Dairy Produce Act costs so much, and he includes this sum for the training of creamery workers.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That is arguable. It is a question for consideration whether estimates for educational work should not be brought all together. This educational work was undoubtedly done in connection with the Act last year for the first time — deliberately done. The Deputy may fairly state that we might abstract that from the total. It does not amount to so much.

Comment on this

Comparisons have been made with regard to the amount spent by the Government and the farmers for the working of this and other Acts. It is rather important that no amount should be included which would make it appear that the Government is spending on the Act more than it is spending.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

No.

Comment on this

As to the particular headings under which these Estimates should appear, we had last year an agreement that certain items might better appear under other headings. This year these items continue under the same heading, notwithstanding that agreement.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Is the Deputy referring to this Vote?

Comment on this

I am not referring particularly to this Department.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Then it does not arise.

Comment on this

We are discussing educational matters, and the Minister has agreed that it would be more appropriate that all educational matters should appear under one Vote.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I said it was arguable.

Comment on this

The Minister agrees it is arguable. Whose duty is it to regulate these different Votes and the order in which they appear.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The sub-heads are changed this year, and much simplified, and I think the Public Accounts Committee agreed with the reorganisation.

Comment on this

Whose duty is it to regulate the order in which the Estimates appear before us?

Comment on this

The Department of Finance, but it must, in making any changes, consult the Public Accounts Committee.

Comment on this

Is it only the recommendations of that Committee that will be considered by the Department of Finance, or will recommendations be made by the Department of Finance and put before the Committee?

Comment on this

Normally the Department of Finance would move first.

Comment on this

The suggestion will have to be considered by the Department for Finance as to whether these educational estimates should not more properly be grouped under one head.

Comment on this

In this case the matter under discussion is special educational work in connection with the Act, and to treat this as a sub-head that would be the basis of future Estimates is rather unwise, unless we are assuming that the education work in connection with the Act will be a perpetual procedure. I take it this is special work in connection with the initiation of the Act.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It is.

Comment on this

And will not appear again.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I said it was arguable, and that is as far as I can go. I have often considered the Estimates from the point of view of whether certain items should not be transferred from one sub-head to another. There are good reasons for and against. I am not saying that my personal opinion even would be that this should be transferred back to some educational sub-head, especially in view of the fact, as Deputy Johnson has pointed out, that this particular educational work is done in connection with the Act. Of course we might argue whether it is in connection with the Act or not, but was done because of the Act, and in connection with the policy which the Act is also trying to further. One might argue that that would apply to the courses in the Munster Institute. On the other hand, this expenditure would not be incurred but for the Act. It was to meet the want that we felt would be there when we were looking for good officials at the beginning. It is a very big question, which you cannot argue on a sub-head, as to whether the whole organisation of the Estimates might be changed. There is a lot to be said on that point.

Comment on this

This is really not an educational grant at all, as it includes maintenance allowance to pupils. I presume any educational vote is not going to be based upon providing maintenance for pupils. For instance, part of this is for the training of butter-makers. There must be something exceptional about that. As a State we are going to train buttermakers?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

We are doing it.

Comment on this

If we are going to adopt that course we are going to interfere with the normal course of events.

Comment on this

We voted money last year for the same purpose.

Comment on this

Last year, I presume, was also a special year. I presume that is not going to be a continuing policy— at least I hope not.

Comment on this

It has been going on for years.

Comment on this

I presume buttermaking is going to be a highly lucrative employment in which the people themselves and those who employ them will see that they are properly qualified. In this particular ease, I should say it was in the nature of a special course, and that the main bulk of it would disappear in a short time.

Comment on this

This particular sum is justified because it is required to make the Dairy Produce Act a success by having special training. I do not see why it should come under the heading of education. I know of no vote that is so necessary. Farmer Deputies, like Deputy Hogan, who have knowledge of what is being done in preparation in order to make the Act a success, will appreciate the necessity for this particular education.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

As to the scholarships, supposing we agree to give a scholarship of £49 per year, we either hand that over to the student or we can tell him to go to Cork University and that we will pay 15s. per week for maintenance and £10 fees. That would come to £49. That is all there is in it.

Comment on this

I quite agree with the principle of maintenance being included in scholarships. In fact they would be no use without it. The ordinary observer outside the Dáil sees in the estimates that we spend so much on education. That is not a correct figure, because we find that, in addition to the sums that appear under education, large sums for educational purposes are administered under the agricultural Vote. So that the sum put down in our estimates for education does not represent the money actually spent on education. From that point of view it is desirable, and the opinion has been expressed outside and conveyed to the Minister for Finance, that our accounts might be made much more simple and definite. All the steps that can be taken in that direction would be desirable, not only for Deputies but the public.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Following out his argument, does Deputy Good suggest that the Minister for Education should be responsible for the expenditure of this money?

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

Then there will be difficulty in making a distinction and putting it under the education Vote.

Comment on this

It could be put under a sub-head of the education Vote, and we would then know what is the total amount that is being paid for education. I do not know whether Deputy O'Connell knows what is being paid. Certainly I do not.

Comment on this

On sub-head (o) (3) I should like to ask for some information. How many areas have we scheduled as black scab areas?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Two.

Comment on this

What is the extent of these areas? How long have they been scheduled? What are the possibilities of wiping out the disease? How far has the work of the propagation of specially selected seed proceeded, and what are the possibilities of the success of that seed in those areas, so that part of this Vote might be eliminated?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It is, in fact, being eliminated gradually. The Vote for 1923-24 was £3,664. That was a special grant for the propagation of immune varieties of seed. There are two of these areas scheduled. They are small areas, but I could not give details as to the size. The fact that black scab has only appeared in two areas has justified the policy of isolating the areas.

Comment on this

How long is it since they were scheduled?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Certainly before I became Minister for Agriculture. They are scheduled three or four years— one of them at least. The policy of the Department is to schedule the area to prevent export or import except under stringent conditions and to make arrangements for the propagation and distribution of immune varieties of seed. I would not like to say how long they will remain scheduled. We are very lucky that black scab has spread only to this very small extent. It would be a very serious thing to take off the ban until we are abundantly satisfied that there is no danger. Our investigations in regard to immune varieties of seed, and in regard to the disease in general, have not given any results that would justify the holding out of a hope that these particular areas will be made free areas within any short time. I do not think there is any possibility at present of removing the limitations they suffer under. On the other hand, we have spent a considerable amount of money in propagating and distributing immune varieties of seed, and for that reason we are able to reduce the sum under that particular sub-head.

Comment on this

With regard to (o) (4), I would like to get some information from the Minister. The other day a statement was made, I think by the Minister, that the Weeds Act was again going to be enforced. I would like to know if proper investigation has been made into the question of spreading weeds in the country. I know an intelligent farmer who maintains that thistles are not spread by the blowing of seeds, that they are spread by roots. To all intents and purposes seeds do not cause any great spread of thistles. That may seem a rather ridiculous statement to make, but I have known where thistles have been cut year after year and they still persist in growing.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Cut after seeding?

Comment on this

No; they are cut twice a year. I know that sometimes they are cut after seeding, but in the case I speak of they are cut before seeding, and there are farmers who maintain that, to a certain extent, it is a waste of public money to enforce this Act. I am not saying that that is correct, but I think it is a subject for investigation. The enforcing of the Act means the employment of a number of inspectors, and a great deal of worrying to farmers. I would like to be satisfied that we are fully justified in voting the amount required for such an item of expense.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

My opinion is that thistles are propagated by seed and that is the opinion of the Department of Agriculture. Supposing the Deputy were satisfied on that I would like to have his opinion as to whether the Act should be administered.

Comment on this

If that is so I say yes.

Comment on this

With regard to sub-head (o) (5), I do not really know what the conditions are, but the question Deputy Roddy put down would indicate that some quantities of foreign bacon, however small, are coming into this country, and the possibility of that stuff being re-sold, or re-exported, as Irish bacon, is something I would like to have information on. There is a considerable consensus of opinion that sufficient attention is not being given to this question of looking after our exports and seeing that products of no other country are being sold as products of this country, and that our products are not being misrepresented. I have been told that it is customary for even business men in our own country to make people believe that the bacon they are selling is Irish bacon, whereas it may be Canadian or Danish, and not alone bacon, but many other commodities as well. I am not satisfied that two inspectors are sufficient to look after all this, through the length and breadth of the country. I think two are not nearly sufficient to do it. I do not know what the position was in other days, but I think a considerably larger number of inspectors were engaged on this work. I do suggest to the Minister, if the function of these inspectors is to see that none of the products of the Irish farmer is being misrepresented by having stuff from other countries sold here in the name of Irish agricultural products, that two men are not enough to do that work. If it is worth the money spent on the salaries of two men it is worth while doing it right.

Comment on this

On the other hand, I am informed that during the strike in Denmark recently a very considerable quantity of Irish butter was exported in kegs, and, of course, that means that it was sold in England as Danish butter, and it was sold when the market was against Irish butter to the extent of 20/- a cwt.

Comment on this

That is a matter for the English inspectors.

Comment on this

It is the other side of the question. We are selling Irish butter, and it is sold in England as Danish butter. If the extra price went to the farmer I would be satisfied, but it does not go to the farmer. I do not know whether the Minister's long arm could reach such a case. If he can by any means get us the price that is paid for Danish butter, we will not object so long as we get the money.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister if he has any information that Canadian hay came into the port of Dublin.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That is a different point. There was no allegation that Canadian hay was sold as Irish hay. Canadian hay is coming in in very small quantities.

These two inspectors are engaged mostly in investigating the question of whether butter contains margarine, or whether margarine is sold as butter. That is their main work. I am not contending that these inspectors are sufficient to deal with questions arising in England, especially as to whether foreign produce is being sold as Irish produce. They would be, of course, utterly inadequate for that. We have not yet made final arrangements for inspectors of that sort in England. The reason is we are not quite sure of the number that will be required, and whether they should be part-time men or officials appointed by the High Commissioner or whether we should make use of certain people, perhaps in trade in England, for that purpose. All these questions are being considered, and we will be in a better position to judge whether Siberian butter is being sold as Irish butter, or Chinese eggs as Irish eggs, when we have the Dairy Produce Act and the Eggs Act some little time in operation. These two inspectors, as I say, were mainly employed in taking samples of butter. Of course they had to take samples in every case reported to them. There are a few inspectors at present in England controlled by the High Commissioner and provided for in this Vote.

With regard to the case mentioned of foreign pigs coming into Sligo and being exported to England, there is an allegation that they were sold in England as Irish bacon. We are investigating that at the moment. We have not got any information that it is so It may be, but it will be investigated to the end. We will be able to trace the bacon undoubtedly. We will be able, I think, to make sure whether that was in fact sold as Irish bacon or not, and we can take steps accordingly; but we have not succeeded in getting that information as yet. I said there were two cases; but, I think, that was the only case that was brought to my notice.

Comment on this

The Minister has pointed out that the inspectors that are referred to here have as a duty mainly the testing of whether butter as sold retail contains margarine or whether margarine is being sold as butter. I wonder whether there is a duplication of responsibility in this matter between the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Justice. Chicory sold as coffee is another instance of adulteration. Are we to take it that only in respect of the adulteration of butter, or the misdescription of butter, is the Department of Agriculture responsible? It seems to me the time has come for the proper allocation of duties in respect of the sale of impure food or the detection of adulteration. I cannot see why this particular police function should be the function of the Department of Agriculture, when all other similar functions in respect of the adulteration of food is under a different Department. I would suggest to the Minister that he should have this matter discussed with the Minister for Justice and arrange for the bringing together in one Department of all the police functions in respect of misdescription, false description and adulteration of food.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I agree that the co-ordination of all these services is undoubtedly a question for consideration, not only here, but in England. It is a big question. It is bound up also with our trading in other countries, and with the whole question of appointing trade agents. Having the right sort of agents makes the question a big one.

Comment on this

I think there is a distinct difference between the question of the responsibilities of the Department of Agriculture acting on behalf of producers in respect of the sale of produce in other countries, and the question I have raised. They would not initiate or be responsible for a prosecution in another country. As regards goods sold in this country to the detriment of the consumer, that is a matter which surely should be the business of the Department of Justice, rather than the Department that represents the producer. That is where I make a distinction. I think it is quite clear.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I do not think that that was the point of view behind the provision of this particular service. They inspect creameries and factories more than shops. I think it was from the point of view of the producer that this particular service was instituted.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean creameries mixing margarine with butter?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

And factories.

Comment on this

Would the adulteration of foodstuffs referred to by Deputy Johnson not come under the duties of the local authority?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Yes. Of course, Deputy Johnson's point is that there should be co-ordination of these services. I agree.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister if there is any general inspection under this heading, and if there are any discoveries that there is adulteration being carried on, and prosecutions, because there is complaint now and again that this matter is not being attended to by the Department of Agriculture. A number of inspectors were previously engaged on this work who are not engaged on it now, and a good deal of stuff has been sold as Irish agricultural produce that is not Irish produce.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It is not quite as bad as it looks, because they generally get information. It is not a question of scouring the country or of rushing into this shop or that. They generally get information, one way or the other, as to cases of adulteration, and they can so deal with specific cases. I am aware that since the year 1922 there were not more than two inspectors on that work under the Department of Agriculture. I can vouch for that. I do not know what happened before that. There have been prosecutions; there were a good many prosecutions last year.

Comment on this

In regard to sub-head (o) (6) perhaps the Minister will explain why the "Allowance to Chief Agricultural Analyst" is indicated as "nil." The foot-note is, "In abeyance at present." This office has to do with the Fertilizers and Feeding Stuffs Acts. In years gone by, at any rate, the duties carried out by the agricultural analyst under this Act were, I am aware, very valuable. They were taken advantage of largely in connection with manures and feeding stuffs. I would like to know whether there is any other Department doing the work that was hitherto done by the chief agricultural analyst, or whether it is undone. If it is undone, it would be well if we had some information as to the reason. There is no doubt that impurity and uselessness are very prevalent in regard to many manures and feeding stuffs from a chemical-analysis point of view. A great many of these articles are marketed, and this Act, if I remember rightly, imposed upon the seller of an article the responsibility of stating the analysis. There surely must be some check as to whether that analysis has been maintained in respect of the article sold. If there is no officer on whom the responsibility lies of testing submitted samples, it means that the Act is in abeyance. If the Act is in abeyance, probably many people are being defrauded because of the sale of useless manures, and unsatisfactory feeding stuffs.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It would be extremely serious if that service were dropped, or even left in abeyance. The allowance is not there, but the office and the service are there. The reason for that is that, as a matter of general policy, it has been decided that all the analysis shall be done in one Department by the Chief State Chemist. Officials in other Departments who have been doing that work have been transferred to the Department of the Chief State Chemist. He is now doing the analysis for this Department and for every other Department, with special officers, of course, for special work. The inspection of manures, fertilisers, and feeding stuffs, is done by all the instructors and inspectors of the Department, except the veterinary inspectors. There is no falling-off whatever in that regard. The inspection is taking place, and is being carried out at least as energetically as ever it was. We all realise the necessity for that service. No Department of Agriculture could do without a Department which would make analysis available to the farmer to show whether or not fertilisers or manures were up to standard. That is being done at present by the Chief State Chemist, who has a special staff for that purpose.

Comment on this

If this sub-head is to be kept in the same form in the Estimates of next year, I hope there will be a footnote stating that the work is being done by another Department. As it is, the footnote is misleading.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It is misleading.

Comment on this

Who is responsible as regards the prosecution of those who are selling foodstuffs that are not up to the analysis made two or three years ago? Is there any way of proving that that food or manure is up to the standard which it reached when put on the market some years ago? Is there any analysis in cases where this stuff is not what it pretends to be? Is the Department to which these functions have been transferred taking steps to protect purchasers against those who are using their position to sell manures and feeding stuffs to the public which are not up to the standard?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The Chief State Chemist merely analyses. The other functions are carried out by the Department of Agriculture. The Chief Chemist has nothing to do except analyse and produce a certificate.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say whether there have been any prosecutions recently under this Act?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

There were prosecutions last year. So far as the experience of the instructors goes, there is no deterioration in the quality of manures, seeds, or fertilisers.

Comment on this

Under sub-head (p) (Appropriations-in-Aid), I want to put a few questions. I see in the fourth line, "Receipts from students' fees, sale of livestock, farm produce, rents, etc.," with particulars of the receipts from the different colleges. On the next page, I see "Receipts from sale of dairy bulls at reduced prices, fees for leasing of such bulls, and registration fees, £1,250." I want to know why these two items are not treated as one. Are the receipts in the second case in respect of bulls that are purchased at shows and then sold to farmers at reduced prices? I see, also, another item, "Dairy Produce Act, 1924 — Receipts from fees for registration, etc., £2,800." That seems to me to be a very low estimate of receipts from fees. I would like to know from the Minister at what rate he has calculated them and what quantity of butter exported he has calculated.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

With regard to the second question, I take it the point is whether we decided on 2d. per cwt. or 4d. per cwt. That point does not arise, because the export part of the Dairy Produce Act will come into operation only next year. Part I. and the general provisions only come into operation this year. The question of export will not, therefore, arise until next year. With regard to receipts from the sale of dairy bulls at reduced prices, that refers to an item in (g) (2)—"Purchase and insurance of dairy bulls for leasing or re-sale at reduced prices— £3,000." There was always provision made in the Endowment Fund for that purpose. You may buy a bull for £200 and sell him at £60. That has been going on for a long time, and this year we calculate that we will get about £1,250 in connection with these sales. What we will get from the purchaser will be, of course, considerably less than we pay for the bull.

Comment on this

I quite understand that.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

With regard to leasing, that seldom occurs. We occasionally lease a bull to a cow-testing association.

Comment on this

Would the Minister please explain what are the necessary qualifications to get one of these cheap bulls? Is it a case of making a "poor mouth"?

Comment on this

Deputy Wilson forestalled me. I was about to put the same question.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am surprised at Deputy Wilson putting that question. He ought to know the practice. Cow-testing associations from various parts of the country make representation and prove that they have no premium bull within their area. They may, perhaps, prove that though they had a premium bull they had a bit of bad luck, and he died. We have to make up our minds as to the most suitable centres where a few valuable bulls might be placed. Some district might, perhaps, have very valuable pedigree cows. But these bulls cost a lot of money, and farmers could hardly be expected to buy a stock bull which would be up to the pedigree of the cows. It would be of great advantage to them if, instead of asking them to spend £200 or £300 on a bull to mate with their particularly good cows, we bought a bull and leased it to them. The following year we would lease it to another district, and so on like that. A small farmer might have three or four pedigree cows. He might have bred them himself or come by them cheaply. It would be hard to expect him to pay £300 or £400 for a stock bull. We would lease him that bull and lease it to the other farmers next year. In the ordinary way, that man, who might have very valuable cows, would be only able to give about £50 for a bull. It would be very valuable for him, or for a cow-testing association, to get one of these bulls for a year.

Comment on this

What about the sale of the bulls?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

They are sold in the congested districts mainly—the poor districts — to cow-testing associations.

Comment on this

What is the fee for leasing bulls to the small farmers?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Five pounds a year, as a rule. It covers insurance.

Comment on this

Does the Minister consider the holder of, say, a hundred acres, with a fairly big stock of cows, a fit applicant for one of these bulls?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

With a fairly good stock of cows—certainly.

Comment on this

Would you consider his application reasonable?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

In certain circumstances.

Comment on this

In the event of a farmer buying a bull under this system, or leasing a bull, is there any stipulation that he must give service of that bull for his neighbour's cows?

Comment on this

If the Minister is considering Deputy Doyle's point with regard to a farmer of 100 acres, would he take into consideration the suggestion that heifer calves, which are the progeny of that bull, when the farmer has a fine herd of cows, should not be exported from the country?

Comment on this

Calves by these bulls are generally ear-marked by the Department.

Comment on this