TREATY (CONFIRMATION OF AMENDING AGREEMENT) BILL, 1925.
Contributions 1–200 of 390. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 51 of 1925 ›
I desire to move that the Dáil gives permission for the introduction of the Treaty (Confirmation of Amending Agreement) Bill, 1925, a Bill to confirm a certain Agreement amending and supplementing the Treaty of 1921, and to amend accordingly the references to the Treaty of 1921, contained in the Constitution of the Irish Free State (Saorstát Eireann) Act, 1922, and the Constitution. The agreement, I think, has been published in a White Paper. I accordingly move.
Comment on this
I do not know if I am in order, but I shall have to oppose the motion for the adjournment. I intend to move, when that motion is disposed of, for the suspension of Standing Orders in order to enable the Second Reading of this Bill to be taken to-day and to be dealt with to-day.
Comment on this
On a point of order the President moved that the House do sit to conclude the business on the Order Paper. There is one principal item on the Order Paper. The second item on the Order Paper is the adjournment of the Dáil. Is it in order to move additional motions?
Comment on this
I understood the President's motion was that the Dáil to sit later than 8.30 p.m. That was the order made.
Comment on this
On a point of order, it was quite distinctly stated by the President that his intention was to conclude the business on the Order Paper. That was why the question was not discussed.
Comment on this
The question put was that the Dáil sit later than 8.30 p.m. The President stated his object was to conclude the business on the Order Paper. The motion that the Dáil do now adjourn is in order; I am accepting it.
Comment on this
I move:
That the provision of Standing Order 79, as to the giving of notice for the Second Stage of a Bill, be suspended to enable the Second Stage of the Treaty (Confirmation of Amending Agreement) Bill, 1925, to be taken at this day's sitting.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Standing Order under which the President is moving for the suspension of Standing Orders leaves the onus upon you, a Chinn Chomhairle, to say whether this is a case of urgent necessity. I submit it is necessary, before this motion can be accepted by you, that reasons for the urgency and the necessity for it should be stated by the mover. You and the House ought to be convinced of the necessity for suspending Standing Orders to take a motion of this kind, a motion in relation to the Second Reading of a Bill which has only been put into our hands, and which, as far as we know, has no urgency behind it. I urge that it is necessary to have some reasons stated for the urgency.
Comment on this
It is necessary for the President to state his reasons.
Comment on this
The reasons are not far to seek. During the last fortnight this matter has been under our consideration here. Not the least voluble amongst the people who have asked us for our policy with regard to this matter has been the Deputy who raises this objection.
Comment on this
I think the President should address himself to me on the question of urgent necessity.
Comment on this
On that question I think it is well known to you, sir, as you were present during the debates on this matter, that a Boundary Commission was sitting and the publication of its report was imminent. You are aware that we had several discussions here dealing with a report issued by two people, neither of whom was nominated by this Government. That report issued by them contemplated a very serious situation in this country, a situation which, during at least one sitting here, was dealt with by several Deputies representing the constituency that was vitally affected. That it was a situation fraught with grave danger is well known to every Deputy in this House. That was the danger upon which the Government was asked to state its policy here. The Government was asked to produce its policy at a moment's notice. Here is our policy. Here it is.
Comment on this
The President ought to show some of the restraint that he is appealing to the people to show.
Comment on this
This is not a matter of policy, nor is it a matter of debate; it is a matter for a decision by me on a simple question, and into it there is no necessity to bring any heat whatever. (Deputies: Hear, hear.) There is no necessity, even heatedly, to approve of my own view of this question. The matter is one that requires calm. I want the President to state, as calmly as he can, for me and for the House—for me in the first instance—why it is urgently necessary that a motion should be made to-day for the suspension of Standing Orders in order to take the Second Reading of this Bill. If the President will confine himself to that, and if Deputies will allow the President to address me without interruption, the matter could be decided, and, when it is decided, Deputies will have every opportunity for debate or otherwise.
Comment on this
It is unnecessary for me to elaborate to any great extent the feeling—the very grave feeling— of nervousness, to put it in its mildest form, which was apparent here during the discussion that took place. Now I tell you that the published report of the Boundary Commission was promised for issue to-day. This measure which is introduced here revokes that power, suspends that authority, and offers an immediate—and necessarily immediate—method of settling the matter in a peaceful, orderly and satisfactory manner for the vast majority of the people of this country. That is my reason for the urgency of this matter.
Comment on this
Might I ask the President a question? Had he or the Vice-President any authority from the Dáil to negotiate on this Northern question?
Comment on this
I fear that the President has not given any reasons why the Standing Orders should be suspended for the purpose of taking the Second Reading of a Bill which has only within the last quarter of an hour been placed in our hands. It is obvious to everybody that the Bill cannot become law to-night, so the matter of urgency does not arise. Surely, it is absolutely necessary that the Standing Orders can only be suspended in a matter of such grave importance, after due consideration of the Bill which has just been placed in our hands. The President has spoken of the gravity of the situation. Undoubtedly it is grave. It is grave, because it is touching the very Constitution of the State, and we ought to have time to consider the Bill which has been placed in our hands. If only from the point of view of the proper regulation of the business of the Oireachtas, we should not be asked, on ten minutes consideration, to take the Second Reading of a measure which proposes to uproot the Treaty that was made in 1921. I submit that the urgency has not been proved.
Comment on this
I would like to add, to what Deputy Johnson has said, that when the Dáil adjourned on Thursday night last, it was understood that we would be called here on Monday, if necessary, to hear a statement from the President. There was no indication whatsoever, then or since, until we met here to-day, that we would be asked to take the Second Reading of the Bill. We came to hear a statement from the President, possibly, but certainly not to agree to take the Second Reading and consider a Bill which was put into our hands only a few minutes ago. I think it would be treating the Dáil very unfairly, in view of the understanding that was present in the minds of the Deputies on Thursday evening last, when we separated, to ask us to take this Bill now. The understanding was that we should assemble, if necessary, to hear a statement from the President on the course of the negotiations in London.
Comment on this
I submit to you, sir, respectfully, that the President has not addressed himself to the real question. He has shown no reason why hurried legislation of this sort is necessary. He has shown, whether he intended to do so or not, what is made very obvious, that he himself has been stampeded into a state of panic, and that is the explanation of the hurry on his part. He has not shown why we should be stampeded into legislation without giving that proper measure of thought and consideration needed for a Bill of so much importance. The Dáil last Thursday adjourned under the impression that it was to hear an account of the matured policy which the breathing time that the Dáil agreed to allow to the Executive Council would provide for. Now, at this sitting, it is demanded that we should proceed to alter the Constitution, to tear up the Treaty. I use the very words——
Comment on this
The Deputy is addressing himself to the argument and not to the point of order put to me. I cannot allow speeches to be made on the question.
Comment on this
I deprecated the use of arguments of that particular kind by the President. If I should decide to allow this motion to be made, an opportunity will be given to the Dáil to decide whether or not the Dáil will agree to the motion; but on the point of order put to me we cannot have speeches made which are relevant to the question which would arise if the Bill were allowed to be discussed.
Comment on this
When the Dáil adjourned on Thursday it was adjourned for the purpose of waiting until the President would make a statement. The President has not seen fit to make his statement on the introduction of the First Reading of this Bill. We have come here to hear that statement now. I, for one, am of opinion that we ought to give the President an opportunity of making that statement, and when he has made the statement that the Dáil should adjourn to consider it. I am prepared to go any length to have the President's statement, to meet the fire if there is going to be fire. For that, reason I am prepared to support anything that is put forward to enable us to hear the President's statement.
Comment on this
There are just two points I want to put before you. I have frequently joined with Deputy Johnson in protesting against legislation being taken too quickly. I do not remember that on any occasion—certainly not on more than one occasion—that I have had the support and advocacy of Deputy Professor Magennis.
There are two relevant facts in this matter. First, that the Bill is a very short one and a very simple one. The important part of the Bill is the Schedule, and that Schedule was in every paper on Friday morning. It was circulated to Deputies. I got my copy on Saturday morning. It was actually in the Press on Friday morning. On Friday afternoon the Labour Party issued a statement condemning it in detail. They have had time to condemn it, but they had not time to consider it.
The second point is that there has been considerable anxiety in the country. That anxiety and uncertainty should not be unduly prolonged. It is not in the public interest. It is bad for finance, it is bad for trade, and it is bad for employment. The sooner this question is settled the better. Therefore, I trust that you will see that it is a matter of urgency.
Comment on this
I, as one member of the Dáil, have not been handed a copy of the Bill. I find a difficulty in supporting a motion that we are to take a Second Reading, seeing that I have not been given a copy of the Bill. I opposed the motion made by Deputy Johnson, because I felt that the President had a right to make a statement here; but, as I have not received my copy, I do not see why it should be taken now.
Comment on this
I also oppose Deputy Johnson's motion, and I do so in order to allow the President to make his statement. I did not think that we were going to get this legislation forced on us in this manner by way of a Bill. I was of opinion, when the Dáil adjourned on Thursday last, that the President was to make a statement as to why legislation should be introduced in order to amend the Treaty of 1921. Surely, the least we could expect is that the signatories to that agreement, which was arrived at in London to alter the Treaty, would be prepared to make statements now before they ask us to pass this legislation. I would also like to know whether the Dáil will allow the 47 Deputies outside, who have not taken their seats, to come in in order to voice their opinions as to whether this agreement should be accepted or not.
Comment on this
Perhaps it might be agreeable to the House if it would be possible, or agreeable to you, sir, that you should suggest to the Government that they should proceed with the Second Reading now, that the President should make his statement on Second Reading, and that the House should then adjourn. That, I think, might meet the wishes expressed from various quarters of the House.
Comment on this
We want the Second Reading of this Bill to-day for the reasons I have stated—for the important, weighty, and grave reasons I have brought before you. There was never an occasion, in my opinion, when it was more necessary to have a clear and unmistakable expression of opinion from this House, either in favour of or the rejection of the measure which we have brought forward for acceptance.
Comment on this
I am astonished to think that the President suggests that the Dáil should decide to-day to pass the Second Reading of this Bill. If Deputies are going to be given an opportunity of expressing their views on this it will not be passed to-day or tomorrow, even if we were to sit all the time and it would be better for the President to recognise that. It would be better for him to accept what Deputy Johnson and other Deputies suggest. Let the President make his statement and we will consider it.
Comment on this
It appears to me that Deputy Baxter has given very good reasons for the early commencement of the Second Reading of this Bill. If, as he suggests or threatens, two or three days consideration of this Bill will be necessary, it seems the more necessary to start to-day. I did not follow or approve of Deputy Johnson's point, that because the Bill cannot become law this evening there is no urgency. It seems to me that the longer the interval between this and the time the Bill becomes law, if it does become law, the more necessary it is to commence consideration of the principle of the Bill, which is a short Bill, simply asking the approval of the Dáil to the Scheduled Agreement. I would like to stress and endorse the aspect presented by Deputy Cooper and the President. There has been a very grave political crisis. That crisis has had its reactions on business, and its reactions, naturally and necessarily, on the money markets, and an early decision, favourable or adverse, on this proposed agreement is a matter of the first importance. As befits a Government, we come to the Dáil with a policy, but as befits responsible representatives of the people, the Dáil must come to a decision on that policy without undue or unnecessary delay. The agreement which is scheduled to the Bill has been before the public for three days. Deputies and parties were not slow to pronounce upon it, and the pretence now that Second Reading cannot commence because Deputies require further time is not sound. I hesitate to use the word dishonest, but I say it is hypocritical.
Comment on this
The point before us now is whether there is sufficient urgent necessity proved to allow a motion to be made to suspend Standing Orders.
Comment on this
The Bill is short, so are the Ten Commandments. I do not know that you can hurriedly construct or consider them. The Bill may be short, but time is required to consider it. It is of very great importance to the future of Ireland. There is a very great difference between undue delay and undue haste. There is a happy medium by which those sent here by their constituents to represent them can give calm consideration to the Bill brought forward by the Executive Council. I say it is not a question of haste, but a question of giving the Bill necessary time, and Deputy Johnson's motion provides that when he asks the President to make a statement so that the House could then adjourn and the representatives of the various constituencies would have time to give calm consideration to the question of what is best to be done in the particular circumstances.
Comment on this
I also protest against the motion of the President. I submit, as other Deputies have submitted, that he has not shown that there is urgency in the matter. I think a very important point has been made by Deputy Esmonde. He is in the House, and he has stated that he has not yet received a copy of the Bill. There are Deputies who are not in the House at all, and I take it if Deputy Esmonde has not got it they also have not. I am wondering whether it is in order to proceed with a measure a copy of which has not been placed in the hands of every Deputy. When we adjourned on Thursday, as some Deputies have pointed out, we were told that if we came here to-day we could expect a statement by the President. It was pointed out by some Deputies who lived in remote constituencies, such as those in the West of Ireland, that it would be impossible for them to get here. I think when that statement was made the Minister for Industry and Commerce inferred, at any rate, that no business of any importance would be done other than hearing the President's statement. That was the feeling prevailing all over the House. It is all very well to talk about the question being one of gravity, but hasty legislation, such as we are called on to enact to-day, may contribute to a far greater state of gravity than that in which we find ourselves to-day. I think the House ought to consider the state of the country, and consider what hasty legislation might lead to. God knows we are bad enough.
Comment on this
I take it that the necessity for passing this Bill here is no greater than the necessity that would arise in connection with other parties to the Bill. I have information that in the North this Bill will not be put before the legislature there until Wednesday. For that reason I cannot understand why, in the Free State, Monday is to be the all-important day, while in the North the Bill can wait until Wednesday. Furthermore, I object to the suspension of Standing Orders. They are there to protect minorities, and we will not be a party to giving away whatever protection these Standing Orders afford.
Comment on this
On a further point of order, on the question as to the urgent necessity for the suspension of Standing Orders, I would like to know whether it is the intention of the Government to conclude the Second Reading, if this motion is passed?
Comment on this
The President stated the necessity not only for the commencement of the debate but also for the passing of the Second Reading. The Vice-President made a very good case for proceeding with the Second Reading, but I notice that he did not mention the question of concluding, and before any vote shall be taken as to the suspension of this Standing Order, I think the House should know definitely whether it is the intention of the Government that a Bill of this gravity and importance should be put through all stages within a few hours from now. After all, no less than eighty-one members of the House took part in the division that has just taken place, and is it suggested that these eighty-one members are not to be given ample time for consideration and discussion of the Bill, and that it is to be rushed through the Second Reading to-night?
Comment on this
That is not the point I am called upon to decide now.
Comment on this
No, but the urgency and necessity for giving permission to move that a particular Standing Order should be suspended. That is the question.
Comment on this
I submit that the urgency and necessity for doing so are as great to-day under circumstances in which we meet as for the long and careful consideration of the Treaty, of which this is part. President Cosgrave is anxious that the Bill should be passed its Second Reading to-night regardless of the time. If every member of the House has a right, if he desires, to give expression to his views on this, it is impossible to conclude to-night. I submit the President has given no reason why he should move this particular motion, and he should give a reason for repudiating the agreement come to last Thursday when we adjourned, and when everybody agreed we should meet to-day for the purpose of hearing his statement.
Comment on this
I am anxious that the President should let us know whether he intends the debate should finish to-night. If he intends that it should I can promise him he will only do so by the aid of the closure, and that he will have an empty house so far as these Benches are concerned.
Comment on this
Many questions have been raised, under the guise of points of order, which have no relevance to the point I am now called upon to decide. Standing Order 123 reads:—
"By unanimous leave of the House, or, in cases of urgent necessity, of which the Ceann Comhairle shall be the judge, any Standing Order or Orders of the Dáil may be suspended for the day's sitting, and for a specified purpose on motion duly made with or without notice: Provided that when it is proposed without notice to move that any Standing Order relating to the taking of any stage of a Bill be suspended such motion shall not be received by the Ceann Comhairle unless the request to receive it shall have the support of not less than half the Teachtai who have taken their seats according to law. Teachtai shall indicate their support by rising in their places."
What I am called upon to decide, therefore, is whether a case has been made of urgent necessity for allowing the President to discover whether more than half the Deputies who have taken their seats according to law are in favour of the suspension of the Standing Order in order to allow a motion to be made that this Bill be now read a second time, that is in order that the discussion on the Second Reading shall begin to-day. I am not now deciding, nor am I asked to decide, any question with regard to whether the discussion on the Second Reading, if it were taken, should end to-day or not. That is a different matter to what I am now called upon to decide, but I do think that in this matter there is a case for allowing a particular motion to be made and received under Standing Order 123, in order to find whether the Second Stage of this Bill can be moved to-day. If I were asked, as a matter of urgent necessity, to allow the suspension of Standing Orders to take all stages of the Bill to-day, I certainly would refuse. What I am asked is to allow an effort to be made to take the motion for the Second Reading of this Bill to-day, and I think a case has been made for my giving that permission. I rule accordingly.
Comment on this
I move the suspension of the Standing Orders to enable the Second Reading of this Bill to be taken to-day.
Comment on this
The motion that the President proposes to move is the suspension of Standing Order 79 as to the giving of notice of the Second Reading of a Bill to enable the Second Reading of the Treaty (Confirmation of Amending Agreement) Bill, 1925, to be taken to-day. Before I can receive that motion, under the Standing Order it must have the support of not less than half the Deputies who have taken their seats according to law. Deputies in favour of the motion being received will therefore rise in their places.
Deputies having risen,
Comment on this
The request has the support of 59 Deputies who have risen. The motion can, therefore, be made. The question is: "That Standing Order 79 be suspended to enable the Second Reading Stage to be taken to-day."
Comment on this
I oppose this motion. There are Deputies who have taken their seats in the House who have not had this Bill placed in their hands, who have not had an opportunity of reading the Bill, and who, therefore, have not had any opportunity of exercising their rights as Deputies. The Second Stage of a Bill is defined as a stage for allowing the principles of the Bill to be discussed and decided. When we are dealing with a matter of such importance surely it is due to every single Deputy that he should have had notice according to the Standing Orders that the Second Stage of such a Bill was to be taken and proceeded with. As has been pointed out, we adjourned on Thursday last on the understanding that we would hear a statement on behalf of the Executive Council in respect of the negotiations, or in respect of matters arising out of the Boundary Commission. We have not had that statement, but we were presented with a motion to take the First Reading of a Bill. It has been customary on occasions of importance of this kind for Ministers to avail of the First Reading to explain the purport of and the reason for the introduction of the Bill. The President refused that to the Dáil. So far as I know, no one was treated with the courtesy that Deputies should be treated with by being informed as to what course it was intended to take.
Comment on this
I do not intend Deputy Johnson to get away with it that one has to ask to be treated with courtesy. If Deputy Johnson had asked me the moment we came in what was the course of business he would have had a very exact and liberal interpretation of what the course would be.
Comment on this
I am not talking about rights now. I am talking about courtesies. To conduct the business of a Parliament it is known that there are certain courtesies developed to allow consideration of proposals. Here we are faced with the proposal to take the First Reading of a Bill. We had circulated officially by the Clerk of the House an Order Paper stating that the First Reading would be taken. Until after the First Reading had been taken no one had any information that the Second Reading was to be taken immediately. The Dáil was not informed by the President on taking the First Reading what were the reasons for introducing the Bill. That at least was due to the Dáil.
Then the question arises as to the necessity for suspending Standing Orders. As has been pointed out, Standing Orders were devised for the purpose of protecting a single Deputy, and a minority of Deputies against possible overbearing action on the part of the majority. This matter was up for discussion once before, and it was recognised that events might occur which would require that Bills would need to be passed without the usual notice. The device was, therefore, formulated that a majority of the Deputies would have to assent before even the motion could be discussed. That assent has been given. I think it now requires to be proved to the satisfaction of the Dáil that it is necessary to suspend Standing Orders, in order to allow the Second Reading of this Bill to be taken to-day.
The Bill is one of the utmost importance, and it raises questions of constitutional right as well as questions of privilege. They may have to be discussed later. Urgency has not been proved. Deputies have assented to the discussion of the motion being taken. I urge upon Deputies that they should be convinced by argument that there is urgency in this matter, and that it is necessary that the Second Reading of a Bill of this kind should be taken this afternoon. The President has told us that not only is he going to introduce the Bill—he does not merely want the right to explain its provision and explain its urgency —but he wants to compel the Dáil to take a division upon it, thereby depriving absent Deputies of the right that they have in this matter. I say that is a brow-beating of Deputies. It is over-riding the rights of the individual Deputy who has not had a chance to come here and speak his own mind or the mind of his constituents.
At present there are Deputies in the country seeking the minds of their constituents on this issue. There are also constituents in the country endeavouring to reach and convey their views to Deputies. The Minister contends that the Dáil should decide upon the merits of the Bill to-day. I submit that that is a flagrant disregard of all Constitutional rights. It is over-riding all the privileges and functions of Deputies. They are deprived of rights that the Standing Orders and the Constitution itself gives them. They are deprived of the right of deciding a matter of the utmost importance, as to whether the Constitution under which they have been living, and which they have supported, is to be torn in two. If the Dáil is going to give facilities so that the Second Reading of this Bill may be taken under these circumstances, then I say the Dáil is prepared to do anything.
Comment on this
I think the Dáil should not give permission to suspend Standing Orders in order to allow the Second Reading of this Bill to be taken now. I agree with Deputy Johnson when he stated that there are a number of Deputies not present who are seeking the views of their constituents on this question. Deputies were told on Thursday last that no business would be taken to-day, except the President's statement on the negotiations with regard to the agreement arrived at in London. The agreement had not been arrived at on last Thursday, and I agreed then to an adjournment in order to have statements to-day from the President, the Vice-President, and the Minister for Finance on the boundary negotiations. I agreed to the adjournment so that a statement would be given to the public before any legislation was introduced. The Dáil is asked to-day to agree to the Second Reading of a Bill, the contents of which are not known to Deputies. That is not treating Deputies with courtesy. In saying that I do not mean that I am completely against this agreement. In fact, I might say that eighty per cent. of the people I represent are in favour of it. At the same time I think it is not right for the Government to introduce legislation, and practically force it down the throats of Deputies without giving them an opportunity of considering it. I put it to the Ministry that if they expect this legislation to be passed, the least they can do is to agree to an adjournment of the Second Reading, so that Deputies may have an opportunity of considering the Bill. Wednesday is time enough for the Northern Government to introduce legislation.
Comment on this
Well, the same thing applies to the British Government and they will not deal with it until Tuesday. Sir James Craig, who really benefits under this agreement, will not have to force legislation on the Northern Parliament, but President Cosgrave, of the Saorstát Parliament, who went away to London without any authority from this Dáil and without any mandate from the Irish people——
Comment on this
The Deputy will have an opportunity of making this speech on the Second Reading.
Comment on this
I protest again—I hope I am in order this time —against the effort, which is part and parcel of the Government policy of late, to set aside all the principles of representative government and to introduce autocracy in its place. We set up a Constitution, in which responsible government was the essential feature, and here we are supposed to do our duty to the country on a very important measure like this in the space of a few hours; in that time we are expected to debate this measure, to digest it and to come to a mature decision upon every point that it contains.
We are told that it is only a short Bill. I can state a thesis in a few words and it will take the ablest men of the world centuries to debate it and to arrive at a conclusion. We are all familiar, in the history of thought, with simple thesis of that sort. Men who wish to force a measure of this sort upon the people, no doubt, are anxious to burk discussion. Why this indecent haste? For fear there should be time given to the country to rise up in protest. It is for fear the people in the country, notwithstanding how they have been doped by inspired paragraphs in the newspapers, may awaken at last to the truth of what all this portends to them and that they may call upon their representatives in this House to resign or vote against a measure of this type. But an opportunity is not to be given. In other words, representative government is to be killed outright by this proposed step. What is the haste? If there were any real cause of haste, why should we not see it exhibited in the Six-County Parliament? Are they in such a panic with regard to their border-line that they must throttle discussion, that they must close down deliberation and rush a settlement, as it is facetiously called, through their House? The country really has not had time to recover from the staggering blow it received or from the consternation that blow caused, that men in their name should undertake to commit them—for that is what it means—to a bargain of this sort. I say that we are entitled, not in our personal character, but because of the fact that we stand for the people, to have the fullest measure of discussion that the importance of the matter requires. So far as tactics are concerned, so far as regards strategic advantage in the matter is concerned, it is best for us who oppose this Treaty No. 2 that the Government should exercise the force of its numbers in the present Dáil to rush the proposals through. If there were one thing better calculated than another to impress the public with the opinion that they are afraid of public criticism, it is just this pressure on their part to take the Second Reading now.
The President, in his opening remarks, tried, with that dexterity which is peculiarly his, to confuse the issues. He tried, as he has done in his message to the people, to make his audience believe that because he was in a panic, because he and his colleagues were in a hurry, that we, too, must follow the evil example and be in a hurry to come to an irrevocable decision. That is not the way, I submit, of constitutionally-minded members of a Government or members of a representative assembly. If this is not a deliberative assembly, it is a fraud upon the people. I say deliberately and advisedly it is a fraud upon the people to call together a House and describe it as a Parliament and then proceed to take just such steps as will deprive it of its character as a deliberative assembly. What is the real issue in this? Are we a recording body to be called here suddenly and without preparation, merely to record approval of that whereof we do not know? There is, of course, always the tame follower, and, along with the tame follower, there is the practised wire-puller, the prestidigitator of politics. The Irish people are to be terrified by the fact that we are all hurrying to take the Second Reading. This measure is deliberately calculated to-day to enforce the impression, already made upon the public, that there is a danger from which they must be saved, that that danger menaces them now, and that this is the only defence that can be put up. That is a lie.
Comment on this
That is not a question for me. The President is displaying some more of his political conjuring. I am not a card to be played with. "Under which thimble is the pea?" That may do very well in other assemblies, but it will not answer in this.
Comment on this
The President is trying to put me off my point. He ought to know by this that he cannot rattle me.
Comment on this
I always submit to the ruling of the Chair, but not to amateur and self-constituted chairmen. The impression has been made upon a certain section of the public, fortunately not upon all the public, that the only alternative to the danger that we are told threatens us is to allow Ministers to defy the Constitution; to flout this Dáil and to set it at naught. In other words, the danger is so great that to avert it we must undo all that we have gained in the way of self-government. I insist upon this: there is no point I am more anxious the public should be alive to than this, that what the Government are really doing is not merely setting their hands to Treaty No. 2 but that they are also at the same time dealing a fatal blow at representative institutions and representative methods of government. The proposal here that we should rush through this Second Reading is really a move for anarchy. What I mean by that, sir, if you will permit me to explain, is this: The President and his colleagues seek to terrify the people with the bogey of anarchy. We have always been told that there is no alternative Government, and that if there was an alternative Government it was that dreadful thing Republicanism. There is another kind of anarchy not so palpable but quite as terrible—social confusion and the destruction of public order. There is anarchy—I describe it accurately and, I submit, technically—the anarchy of those who ought to be the champions of the institutions of which they are the personal embodiment: of those who use their position not to discharge the natural functions of that office but to undermine it.
Not a single member of the Executive Council is clothed with any authority except what the Constitution and this House give him, and when now as parliamentary leaders in the Dáil, they, backed by a majority, try to use that majority to stifle discussion on a matter which will have to be debated and is a matter of principle, on Second Reading, they are really, I submit, once more trying to take away from those present their rights, and, inasmuch as there are members who are not here and have not received notice of the highly important matter to be dealt with here and now with such haste, their rights as representatives of the people are taken from them. If the members of this majority and their leaders were so much in love with liberty as they profess to be—if they were such careful guardians of the public well-being as they profess— would they not welcome the fullest amount of analysis and criticism. What are they afraid of? They are afraid to let in the light upon their proceedings; they are afraid to state their reasons. They simply say: we have the might and we will use it. When there is a general election what will the Irish people say?
Comment on this
I am not afraid, at any rate, to face that ordeal. My hands are clean and my record is unstained, and I hope it will remain unstained and untarnished as long as I am a member of this House. I have heard of these phrases before, but never so specifically as they have been made now. Now you have the revelation—the threat. It is all intimidation. All this contention of special urgency, what is it but intimidation? The whole conception of it is to prevent a full expression of opinion on the part of a full House as to what the constituencies wish to have said. Has there been any public meeting held? Was there any opportunity for the holding of a public meeting at which the issue could be submitted?
I have always held that we should be mindful in this House that we are in a representative character. When a member of the House is interviewed by the Press on some important proposal that is submitted to him for the first time he may be tempted, as I have been tempted, to express his own individual opinion. I dare say that is within the range of the liberties allowed to a member, but when he comes here to record his vote he ought to be allowed an opportunity to know what his constituents think and feel in the matter.
I say that if our constituents are not permitted time in which to consider this matter, and to have all the bearings of it put before them by their representatives and others who are in a position to guide their thought, then there is a blow struck at liberty. That could not be done in the time allowed here. What was the time allowed? We were all deceived as to what was about to happen. I am willing to admit that I am not such an experienced politician —politician I mean when I say politician—as the President. I did not know that when a promise was made the promise would not be kept, and that I ought to take measures accordingly. I was one of those dreamers, if dreamers they are to be called, who believed that when responsible Ministers asked to stay our hands from criticism so that they might have time to come to a decision on their policy, that they meant it. I was one of those weak fools in politics who imagined that if we gave the members of the Executive Council the time they asked for that they would utilise it for the purpose for which they asked it. Instead, they spring a proposal of this enormous importance upon us. They rush it here. We walk into the House and an usher distributes amongst the majority of the members copies of the Bill, and then the enormous assumption is made that we are such supermen that by merely glancing at an elaborate instrument—not merely an Act of Parliament but in effect a Treaty between the high contracting parties—that in that glance this wonderful vision of ours enables us to see all its implications, its future consequences, its effect upon the country, and its effect upon the spirit of the country, and how it will be taken by those who are approximately affected by it. I refuse to pay that compliment either to myself or to my colleagues here. We have not these superb gifts of intelligence. We have not that divine insight that enables us at a glance to read out all the implications of a measure, however short, which is complex in its character, and we ought to be allowed—even if it were only for the sake of pretence on the part of the Executive Council that they have some regard for representative institutions even yet—time for deliberation.
No meeting has been held on the part of those who have supported the original Treaty; there has been no time. True there has been, I understand, a meeting of parties or groups belonging to this House, but so far as I am aware, judging from the reports in the daily newspapers, there has been no meeting throughout the various constituencies. Would the President introduce a Bill for the suppression of dog fights and rush it through the House at the same rate as he proposes to rush this through? No. We have had unimportant measures here before, comparatively unimportant, and weeks and weeks have been spent in deliberation upon them.
Comment on this
I find it easier to name the important measures, as I could enumerate them on the fingers of one hand, but not the multitudinous Acts we passed as a sort of penny-in-the-slot agency. I would not undertake to name them.
We have our rights here, as representatives, and if they are to be filched from us by a majority vote, at any rate, we shall act under duress, and the world will know it. We shall be at pains to let our fellow-countrymen, north and south, realise that we are not lost to all sense of national honour, that we are willing to give our time, and all the thought of which we are capable, to the working out of a proper solution of the difficulty which the incompetence of the Executive Council has created.
This is a Bill, the latter stages of which will be brief, because, as I take it, inasmuch as there must be identical legislation between the three Parliaments, no amendments will be possible. I take it this is the intention of the Ministers. Consequently, there is ample time allowed through curtailment at that end of the process, without very considerably enlarging the time to be devoted to this measure.
I challenge the Ministers, before the bar of public opinion in Ireland, to justify what they have done, to justify it by expounding the reasons that validate what they have done, and what they now want to make us particeps criminis with regard to. The idea is that we should hurriedly, before we have time to reflect, give our assent to these propositions, and clothe them after the deed with authority that they full well know they have not, and which they usurped. The reason for all this haste, as I have explained, is to stampede the country, and along with the people we represent, and, consequently, to give us a sense of the utter futility of contesting this matter against their phalanxes. Do the Ministers suppose that because by this show of force they get a majority vote, in favour of suspending Standing Orders, that we will retire from the unequal combat of numbers? Their calculation is utterly mistaken. In the exercise of the closure, the powers of which they do not possess, but that I am quite sure would not be a stumbling-block to Ministers, who usurped authority on other occasions which they did not possess——
Comment on this
By saying the Ministers could usurp authority to allow the closure to be put into effect. What does he mean by that?
Comment on this
I am glad you drew my attention to this matter. Speaking impromptu, I have not got, perhaps, clearly before me what the regulations are to which we are subject. I apologise. I should have remembered, with you before me, that no power which is yours as custodian of this House, will be permitted to be usurped. What I had in my mind was that they would attempt it, as they are attempting it now. They are filching from the Irish people the right to express their views upon a matter which is theirs and which concerns them vitally. We must be allowed the opportunity to know what the Irish people are thinking about this thing, and the Irish people must have an opportunity of knowing what their representatives are saying here. That is my third point. Unless there is time in the country to read the reports of the debates in this House people will not be aware of what is being said on their behalf. They are entitled to know that and to take it into consideration and to form their own views. The Ministry's proposal is to confront the country, outside of these walls, with the accomplished fact, make us, in Hindoo fashion, put up our arms and say "kismet"—"it is written, the fates have decreed. It is useless for us to represent any further."
Comment on this
I do not take the same view as Deputy D'Alton or Deputy Magennis upon this question. We want the President's statement, and the Second Reading will give him that opportunity. Or is he going to shirk it? For that reason I want the Second Reading. It is the statement we want and not the consideration of this Bill in the country, or of the schedule to the Bill. We can form a fairly intelligent opinion upon the three sections of the Bill and also upon the schedule. We have read them. What we want and what the country wants is the statement.
If Deputy Magennis says the country wants to discuss the Bill, I tell him on behalf of the country it is the President's statement they want to hear. The Cumann na nGaedheal Party has had an opportunity of hearing everything the President told them or choose to tell them.
Comment on this
I am making none of these assertions at all. We, on these benches, are not animated with any prejudice whatever on the matter. We want to hear what the President has to say, and we want the country to consider it, together with the Bill and the sechedules. Let us have both together. Let us have the Second Reading statement now and let the Dáil have time to consider it until to-morrow. Is the President prepared to accept that?
Comment on this
I should like to support Deputy Gorey in the suggestion that he has made. On the point of order previously, I made identically the same suggestion. If the President would now make the statement which we are all anxious to hear as Deputy Gorey says, and if he would having made the statement, give both the Dáil and the country some time at least to consider it, not an undue amount of time, but some reasonable time, by adjourning, say, this debate until to-morrow and concluding it at a not far distant time, I think that that would meet with the views of all reasonable Deputies and people outside. I think that the proposal, in the first place, that the Bill should be taken by way of Second Reading at all to-day is rather a drastic one, but what I gathered from the few words that fell from the President. Which he has not seen fit to contradict, that we should conclude the debate this evening, is a little bit too far-fetched. After all, this is probably the most serious measure that has come before the Dáil since this Constitution was made, and it is certainly treating the Dáil, to put it mildly, rather lightly to suggest that in the space of a few hours, without giving any intermediate time for consideration, Deputies should be asked there and then to record their votes one way or the other. I do not think that it is an unreasonable request I am making, supported as I now am, I am glad to say, by Deputy Gorey, that the President should make a statement now upon the Second Reading, that he should give an assurance that he would not move the closure to-night, or in the alternative, that having made the statement the House should adjourn and we should meet to-morrow and conclude the business at a later stage.
Comment on this
I want to say that I feel this is the most momentous question that has come before the Dáil since the ratification of the original Treaty. In view of the statement made by the President, that he wants the Second Reading passed to-night, I must take strong exception to the suspension of the Standing Orders for the purpose of so doing. This is a matter on which Deputies have had no opportunity of consulting their constituents, and it is my opinion that we have no right or authority to cast a vote on a matter of this kind to-day without first finding out what the considered opinions of our constituents are. We all came here to-day for the purpose of hearing a statement made by the President. That was the distinct understanding given to us by the Minister for Industry and Commerce when discussing this matter on Thursday. We had no indication whatever, until the Bill was handed to us to-day, that we would have to deal with the Second Reading of this important matter. There are Deputies amongst all Parties, certainly there are Deputies of the Farmers' Party and of the Labour Party, who have had no opportunity of knowing that the Second Reading of this Bill would be taken to-day. It is my opinion that the attitude which we take with regard to this Bill, and the vote which we give on it, will be matters which will be discussed and which we will have to account for for many years to come. I believe that a decision of this kind should not be forced upon the Dáil without giving the people of the country an opportunity to discuss it.
I do not agree with Deputy Redmond that we should have a discussion on the Second Reading to-day and that the discussion should end then, or be adjourned possibly until to-morrow. I think that the least time the people of the country should get to discuss this matter is a week—that there should be at least a week's lapse between the time when the Second Reading is introduced and the time when a final decision is taken. I am going to consider this matter with an open mind; I am going to consider the Articles of Agreement which are placed before us by the Government in the light of the statement which will be made by the President on these Articles. We have here simply the bare bones of the Articles; we hope and expect that these Articles will be elaborated and explained, and we feel that possibly our point of view and the point of view of our constituents may be changed by the statement which will be made by the President. But we want to give our constituents a chance of reading the President's statement and of knowing what the other speakers here will say on this Bill. For my part, all I can say is that if the President insists upon taking this Bill to-day and if he insists, apart from his words, on having the closure put on it, on that point alone I will be forced to vote against the Second Reading.
Comment on this
The President cannot insist upon the vote being taken to-day. The President can claim to move: "That the question be now put," at any particular time. His motion may or may not be accepted by the Chair.
Comment on this
Do I understand from your remarks that if the President does ask for the closure you will not grant it?
Comment on this
I did not say that. I simply wanted to explain to Deputy Heffernan that the President could not get permission to move the closure without the assent of the Chair, that the motion he was making was not an infringement of the rights of the minority. Deputy Heffernan has got that protection. As to Deputy Redmond's point, I would rather decide each point as it arises.
Comment on this
We have decided to sit late. Obviously we decided that in the light of the circumstance that we were going to do some business. Why should I be asked simply to make my statement? Why could the debate not be gone on with? Why could the Bill not be discussed? What reason is there?
Comment on this
It will be very simple; it will lend itself to examination by anybody. Deputies are complaining that they have not had time to make up their minds after trying to stampede the country themselves already; somehow or another it has not come off. I am prepared, and I have always been prepared, to give every possible consideration to any reasonable application made from any part of the House.
Comment on this
What does the President mean by sitting late? Does he mean sitting until the Second Reading is passed?
Comment on this
It was originally the intention to have a decision on the Second Reading to-day, but as so many Deputies intend to speak obviously that is not possible.
Comment on this
There is one point that evidently Ministers forget, that the country through their action has been lulled into a false position as regards this whole question of the Boundary; the country having been misled through the action of their representative, who, as some people said, was either asleep or in a comatose condition. He evidently did not act as he was expected to act on that Commission. Certainly the Executive cannot be held free of responsibility in that matter owing to want of careful thought on their part in looking forward. I think the country has not seen the mistake that evidently has been made. The Government's method of strategy may be very good in trying to relieve themselves of the position in which they placed themselves. Still the country is entitled to pause very carefully when you find Ministers going on public platforms—even an extern Minister—and telling the people that the Boundary report is going to be all right, and when the President gets up in the Dáil and tells us that he has unbounded confidence in the members of the Commission. Evidently the Executive Council were misled, and, I say, if they were misled, we are in duty bound to see that the country gets time to consider the matter.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy is misled as to what the motion is. The motion is for the suspension of a Standing Order to allow Deputy D'Alton to make this kind of speech later on this evening.
Comment on this
I do not see why the Standing Orders should be set aside to enable the Executive Council or the President to use their position to rush a matter of such vital importance as this is on the country. The question is to be finished to-night or to-morrow, without giving the people the fullest opportunity of considering what is the wisest or the best course. Evidently the agreement cannot stand scrutiny; by showing undue haste they doubt the opinion of the country.
Comment on this
It is quite obvious that there is a strong opposition to the motion. As far as I can gather from the statements made by the Deputies, the real opposition is to asking the Dáil to make a decision on the Second Reading to-night.
Comment on this
I am not clear what the position is from the remarks the President made, but I take it that he is prepared to move the adjournment of the House at the hour of 10 or 10.30, as is usual when we sit late, and if the debate is not concluded he will go on with the discussion without moving any closure or having any decision taken on the matter.
Comment on this
Is the President prepared to say definitely that if the debate is not concluded to-night he is prepared to move the adjournment of the Dáil?
Comment on this
Then we have it that the President is prepared to move the adjournment of the Dáil not later than 10.30, and if the debate is not then concluded it is not his proposal to get a decision on the matter to-night.
Comment on this
The President cannot insist on getting a decision to-day. Having settled that, the President's position now is that the debate will continue until the usual hour when we have agreed to sit late, that is 10.30. If the debate is then concluded the question will be put, but if any Deputy then desires to speak, the question will not be put. Does that clarify the matter?
Comment on this
This is about to-day. I cannot answer Deputy Heffernan about to-morrow. We go on not later than 10.30. If no Deputy offers to continue the debate, then the question will be put. If any Deputy wishes to speak, then the President will not claim to move a motion that the question be put.
Comment on this
When I asked the President whether there was a time limit, he said "no." If he said "yes" then this discussion would not take place.
Comment on this
I want to raise a point of order. This Bill is designated:
"A Bill to confirm a certain Agreement amending and supplementing the Treaty of 1921 and to amend accordingly the references to the Treaty of 1921 contained in the Constitution of the Irish Free State (Saorstát Eireann) Act, 1922, and the Constitution."
The Constitution Act entitled "The Constitution of the Irish Free State (Saorstát Eireann) Act, No. 1 of 1922" contains this provision:
"The said Constitution shall be construed with reference to the Articles of Agreement for a Treaty between Great Britain and Ireland set forth in the Second Schedule hereto annexed (hereinafter referred to as the 'Scheduled Treaty') which are hereby given force of law, and if any provision of the said Constitution or of any amendment thereof or of any law made thereunder is in any respect repugnant to any of the provisions of the Scheduled Treaty, it shall, to the extent of such repugnancy, be absolutely void and inoperative."
My contention is that if there is to be a Bill amending the Constitution, then, according to precedent, we are bound to designate that Bill "Amendment to Constitution No. so-and-so." We have had an amendment to a Constitution Act, and we have numbered it because we wanted to avoid a difficulty that had been foreseen, which was raised in the law courts whereby a certain Article of the Constitution, which says that within a given number of years the Constitution may be amended by way of ordinary legislation, there is a possibility that that phrase in the Constitution would be taken to mean that any ordinary legislation which contravened the provisions of the Constitution might be taken by the Courts to be an amendment of the Constitution. So the Oireachtas decided by precedent that any amendment to the Constitution would be designated such in the title. Now this Bill obviously is intended not to amend the Constitution by the title, but it is to amend a Treaty, according to which every reading of the Constitution must be decided. No law enacted under the Constitution must contravene or be repugnant to the Scheduled Treaty. Now, the Scheduled Treaty is as we have know it since 1921. This is a Bill to amend the Scheduled Treaty. It is a Bill to provide by ordinary legislation an Act repugnant to the Treaty. Therefore, unless we are to treat this as a Bill amending the Constitution, and, if so, we must designate it as such, I submit this Bill is not in order, and should not be received by the Dáil.
Comment on this
This does not seem to be a question of order for me. It seems to me a point on which I could not make a decision. It is that a Bill which has not got a particular kind of title in accordance with alleged precedent should not be received by me. That is not a valid point of order at all, and apart altogether from that, the long title of this does say that it amends the Constitution. The long title is:—
"A Bill to confirm a certain Agreement amending and supplementing the Treaty of 1921, and to amend accordingly the references to the Treaty of 1921 contained in the Constitution of the Irish Free State (Saorstát Eireann) Act, 1922, and the Constitution."
In any event the point is not a point of order, and is not one that would prevent the introduction of the Bill.
Comment on this
Do you rule that the Bill may be dealt with and treated as though it were a Bill to amend the Constitution?
Comment on this
I am ruling that this Bill can be dealt with now, not as anything in particular, except what it may be deemed to be from its face. I could not undertake anything else.
Comment on this
I move the Second Reading of the Bill to confirm the Agreement amending and supplementing the Treaty of 1921 which was signed on Thursday last by representatives of the British Government, by representatives of the Government of Northern Ireland and by the Minister for Justice, the Minister for Finance and myself on behalf of this State. The text of that Agreement was circulated to Deputies in a White Paper issued on the day following its signature. The last Article of the Agreement provides that it shall be subject to Confirmation by the British Parliament and by the Oireachtas, and the Bill which I now propose for your consideration is the Confirmation of the Agreement in so far as the Oireachtas is concerned.
Yesterday was the fourth anniversary of the signing of that historic instrument on which our Constitution is founded. You are, all of you, familiar with the circumstances and with the atmosphere in which it was negotiated and signed. A period of truce had for the moment silenced the sound of the gun and quenched the torch of destruction. But our country was still an armed camp. On both sides the guns were in oil and the torch awaited rekindling. The passions and heat of battle had not died; they had only suffered a temporary suppression. Out of that atmosphere there emerged a Treaty of Peace which will remain an everlasting monument to the genius, the courage and the statesmanship of those who made it. Times have changed. To-day the gun is silent, the soothing hand of Time has calmed the passions of war; the old cloud of hatred and suspicion has blown away. A new atmosphere of friendship and brotherhood has been created; and it is this new atmosphere which has enabled us to bring you to-day a solution of problems which four years ago were, as events have proved, impossible of solution.
No one, even in 1921, regarded the formula in Article 12 of the Treaty as an ideal solution of the problem with which it was intended to deal; no one looked to it to do more than relieve the situation of some of its difficulties. With the best will in the world the Boundary Commission could not satisfy everybody; we might have hoped—we did hope—that it would have dealt with the problem in so far as a large area adjoining our borders was concerned, but we knew and everybody knew that even if our highest hopes in it had been realised, it would bring no relief to a considerable body of people whose abodes were situated in areas which under no conceivable circumstances could be transferred from the jurisdiction of the Northern Government. Nor were we so sanguine as to imagine that the transfer of people and territory from one jurisdiction to the other could be effected without certain heart-burnings and certain discontent. There was, however, no alternative. Michael Collins and Sir James Craig— both men of vision—sought in vain for an alternative, but it could not be found. Their conferences were barren of result. The time had not come— the confidence and mutual trust necessary to crown their labours with success had yet to manifest themselves.
After much delay the Boundary Commission was at last set up. It was not set up in the manner originally contemplated. Instead of one representative of North and South, with a Chairman of British selection, it was composed of our representative and of two representatives selected by the British Government, one of whom was the Chairman. There is no need here to go into the reason for that change in personnel. It is a matter of common knowledge. I make no apology for the part that my colleagues and I took in insisting that the Commission should be set up and should function. No apology is called for. That was our policy—it was the policy of this House. There was no alternative policy. As events happened, the Commission from our point of view failed utterly to achieve the results for which it was constituted. The forecast of its award, published a month ago, gave rise to feelings of dismay and anger. There was every likelihood that the old hatreds which were dying would revive and that the old passions which had been allayed would be rekindled. The menace of disorder again loomed black on the horizon.
The position was not of our creation. We omitted nothing—we overlooked nothing to ensure that the Commission should be fully cognisant of our claims and should be in complete possession of all the requisite information. The minority in the North on whose behalf we spoke, co-operated in the most loyal and thorough fashion. They came forward and gave evidence before the Commission, and made clear in and their aspects, without facts of their without heat them every assist-case our power—we created a special bureau to help in the preparation and presentation of their testimony, and I may say in passing that no more hard-working nor more loyal, nor more efficient staff than the staff of the North-Eastern Boundary Bureau has even been given a more difficult task to do or has done it more thoroughly.
And lest we might pass judgment on others, unmindful of the solemn warning of Holy Writ, let us not blind ourselves to the difficulties and magnitude of the task with which the members of the Boundary Cmmission were presented. We may as well be honest with ourselves. For two generations—ever since the national consciousness first manifested itself in the demand for self-government, the problem of the NorthEast was a constant menace. On every occasion when it appeared as if the nation's aspirations were on the threshold of realisation the powerful forces at the disposal of the opponents of self-government were invoked and the door was slammed fast. When our representatives met in 1921 with the representatives of the British Government to discuss terms of peace they found themselves confronted with that problem. They faced it and endeavoured to solve it. They realised that peace could not be secured by coercion, and they accordingly inserted in the instrument of Agreement alternative courses either of which the minority in that corner of Ireland might elect to follow. They were given the choice of throwing in their lot with their fellow-countrymen in the South or, if they preferred, they could retain their existing relation with the Parliament of Great Britain. This was the origin— the genesis of Article 12. It was a formula designed in the event of the latter alternative being acted upon, to prevent the coercion of a minority within that minority.
The situation was complicated by the fact that there was in existence a boundary line already four years old. There were divergent and irreconcilable interests to be considered. There were those whose desire to be transferred to our jurisdiction did not conflict with their economic interests or their geographical position. There were those who for those very reasons could not have effect given to their wishes. The transfer of the former so far from improving the lot of the latter would aggravate it. There were individuals and communities whose economic balance would be upset by a change as well as those who would benefit from an alteration. Finally, there was the strong sentiment of partisans not personally affected by the Boundary who looked to and expected the Commission to provide a line which to them would be politically satisfactory. In a word, the Commission were called upon to effect by human agency a divine settlement of a problem which had baffled the ingenuity of statesmen for half a century. This is not a time for recrimination nor for logic-chopping. When Dr. MacNeill, our representative on the Commission, severed his connection with that body 18 days ago we in the Executive Council were faced with a situation perhaps the most serious of the many situations with which the present Government have had to deal. An award of the Boundary Commission was imminent —an award which, if the published forecast were even approximately correct—instead of promoting peace and harmony between Irishmen, would, if it had become effective, have sown the seeds of distrust and hate and disorder. Not alone would it fail to bring relief to the minority in the NorthEast, but it would have bankrupted our Northern outpost, the historic country of Donegal. It would have handed over to Northern Ireland a large slice of its richest territory and would have transferred from our jurisdiction thousands of unwilling citizens. The withdrawal of our representative did not, it is claimed, invalidate the Commission. The two remaining members—neither of them nominated by an Irish Government— were legally competent to continue their deliberations and to issue their award. The award once issued was legal and binding. Faced with the legal position we had two alternatives. One was to put it into effect by withdrawing our administrative machinery from those areas transferred to Northern Ireland and moving into those areas ceded to us. The other was to fly in the face of law and constitution and to resort to the arbitration of force. Either alternative pointed straight to disaster and chaos. The second was clearly unthinkable—the former would rive the country asunder. There would be an outcry from our people, hostile feelings would be aroused, the Treaty position would be challenged and the security, aye, the very existence of our nation, would be shaken.
This was the situation with which we were faced when on last Tuesday I told you that the Executive Council were giving the matter the gravest consideration. It was one which gave rise to the gloomiest forebodings, and I want to say to those who have now rushed in to criticise and disparage, that at that time when we would have welcomed a constructive suggestion, a helpful word of advice, none was forthcoming—nor did we receive any assistance since, either directly or indirectly, from any of them.
Comment on this
My office was open. It is not by discussion here that you can come to anything on these things.
Comment on this
Above all the contributions I have listened to I think that absolutely the one breathing the least sanity or with any possible conception of representative responsibility is that from the Deputy who I suppose has now somersaulted out of our party. Nor did we receive any assistance, either directly or indirectly, from any of them. This was not a party question; it was a question of the nation. That fact was fully and clearly and generously recognised in this House.
Comment on this
One thing and one thing only was perfectly clear, and that was the publication of an award by the remaining members of the Commission would be a national calamity. Whatever legal flaws we might possibly discover in it, whatever line of appeal might possibly lie from its terms, it spelt immediate discontent and disorder. What was the way out? Peace—a lasting and secure peace—if it could be found under such unfavourable circumstances. Nor was this peace a necessity to us alone. It was none the less desirable to those for whom Sir James Craig speaks and to the British Government and people. In this spirit we met in conference Sir James Craig and representatives of the British Government. We went to meet them realising that the situation was one which called for all the statesmanship that we collectively possessed— that only in mutual understanding, by mutual co-operation, in an appreciation of one another's difficulties, and in an atmosphere of friendship and good will could a basis for peace be found. We were met, I am glad to say, in the same spirit, and thanks to the united efforts of the representatives of the three Governments the basis of peace was found. That basis is the agreement scheduled to the present Bill.
The first Article of the Agreement provides for the revocation of the powers conferred by the Treaty on the Boundary Commission, and for the retention of the existing Boundary. This arrangement abrogates the proviso to Article 12 of the Treaty, but in doing so follows in reality the spirit of the Treaty in the altered circumstances and in the new conditions which exist. The Treaty never contemplated that the Boundary should be changed unless Northern Ireland cut itself off from the rest of the country. In the tragic period which followed, Northern Ireland chose to take that course. But at the recent Conference in London there was a new spirit of cordial co-operation and friendship which, although political separation is an accomplished fact, was a manifestation of a genuine desire for united effort for the common good. That united effort—in itself a form of union—may, and I hope will, in time lead to the voluntary acceptance of closer and more tangible bonds of union, and will, I am confident, justify our decision to put this barren question of the Boundary behind us once and for all, and turn our faces towards new methods and new developments. This is surely a course more in harmony with the intentions of the Treaty than the perpetuation of a fruitless wrangle as to where a boundary between Irishmen is to be drawn.
The Agreement contains no reference to the important question of the position of the Northern Nationalists, which was our first consideration in the negotiations, and one which we discussed at great length and in all its aspects. I want to make our position in relation to the minority in Northern Ireland perfectly clear. At the time the Treaty was made that minority had already been placed under the jurisdiction of the Northern Government. Certain provisions were made in their interests by those who negotiated that instrument. How these provisions would have worked out in the unexpected events which have since happened, the signatories could not possibly have foreseen. We faithfully carried out those provisions, and it was not until everybody concerned had become fully aware that the Boundary Commission was not going to prove the anticipated instrument of salvation for the minority that we made any move towards other solutions of their problem.
The question as to how a minority should be protected has been very often asked. I believe that there is only one real security for minorities, and that is the good will and neighbourly feeling of the people among whom they live. Next to this written guarantees are scraps of paper, and sometimes irritating scraps of paper which kill in spirit what they profess to secure in words. There are no such written guarantees in the Agreement, because those present at the negotiations were resolved that the minority should have the only real security, which is, as I have said, to be sought only in neighbourly feeling.
Had the Boundary Commission produced a result which would have satisfied the hopes of the Nationalists, a minority would still have been left unprovided for, and in the estrangement between North and South which such a result would have produced, they would have found themselves more isolated than before. Minorities suffer most in times of political strain. When there is peace and accord they come by their own. I know it is difficult for the border Nationalists, whose daily lives are immediately affected, to take what I believe is the wider view. I believe that the organised and dignified statement of their case before the Commission was one of the factors which made the recent Agreement possible. I believe a new understanding is growing up, and that such an understanding is, as I have said, more valuable than written guarantees. I believe the time will come when those who presented their case to the Commission will say that their efforts have been crowned with greater success than if they had been rewarded by an immediate decision of the Commission in their favour.
We have arranged that for the purpose of dealing with certain matters of common concern the two Cabinets should meet together. These meetings must inevitably tend to remove prejudices and allay anxieties and to promote better understanding. Every step in this direction between North and South will react through the development of a better spirit in a favourable manner upon the position of the Nationalists in the North, and the Nationalists of the Six Counties can assist in this development by becoming a connecting link instead of a wall of partition between Dublin and Belfast.
Article 2 of the Agreement releases the Irish Free State from its obligations under Article 5 of the Treaty. The question of carrying out this Article had been raised by the British Government some months ago, but its settlement had been postponed pending the decision of the Boundary Commission. When the recent crisis made a reconsideration of certain Treaty provisions necessary, it was inevitable that this question should arise in the discussions.
Article 5 provided that the Irish Free State should assume liability for a proportion of the service of the public debt of the United Kingdom and war pensions, as existing at the date of the Treaty, due regard being had to any just claims on the part of the Irish Free State by way of set-off or counter-claim. If agreement as to the amount of the liability could not be reached, the matter was to be submitted to arbitration. Now the amount of the British National Debt at the time of the signing of the Treaty stood at the enormous figure of £7,000 odd millions. As long as our liability remained undetermined this Article hung over us as a menace to our credit, a hindrance to borrowing for development, a deterrent to our business expansion and a not unlikely cause of friction between the two countries.
I would hesitate to make any forecast as to the amount of what our ascertained liability would be, if our case and the case of the British Government had been laid before an arbitrator in cold figures, an arbitrator who was bound to interpret those figures and those claims in the strict and rigid atmosphere of international finance. Suffice it to say that others who have entered into the realm of prophecy on this subject have arrived at figures varying from an annual payment of £5,000,000 to a claim for an annual tribute of £19,000,000.
Comment on this
What are the President's own figures? What are the figures of the Executive Council? That is what we want to get at.
Comment on this
Perhaps the President would tell us what were the figures in his mind when he was signing the document?
Comment on this
What were the figures in the President's mind when he was signing the document in London? There is no use in talking about any propaganda that was going on outside.
Comment on this
I had only one figure in my mind and that was a huge nought. That was the figure I strove to get, and I got it.
Comment on this
If the question were what figure the Executive Council was prepared to accept, I would say the Executive Council had not any figure before them. We had the other thing before us—that is, the charge.
Comment on this
May I ask this question now of the President? Had the Minister for Finance the figures on him showing what the British claim was, or was likely to be, and what the Irish set-off was calculated to be?
Comment on this
I desire to raise a point, and it is of the utmost importance, not warranting a reply of the kind that the President has given to Deputy Magennis. On Thursday I asked the Ministers of the Executive Council who were present what was the amount of the claim, if any, which had been sent in by the British Government, and what was the amount of the counter-claim sent in, if any, by the Irish Government. Neither Minister could answer that off-hand, which was a thing I did not mind. I gave notice that the question would be put later. It is essential to a discussion on this matter. I hoped it would have been answered to-day either in question form or otherwise. Deputy Heffernan also wanted to put a question on private notice to-day, and you, A Chinn Comhairle, thought it was almost certain to be answered by the President in the course of this discussion. Surely we can invite an answer to a question of that kind which is so germane to the subject?
Comment on this
The figures, if any, will be dealt with by the Minister for Finance. I have not gone any further in my statement than to say that the British Government had taken up this matter with us. I did not go any further than that, and I am not going to go any further. The British Government had written to us concerning this matter.
Comment on this
How could the President be able to make an authoritative statement in regard to our financial position if he knew nothing about the figures?
Comment on this
Perhaps the President will be allowed to continue, and then Deputies can make their points in subsequent speeches.
Comment on this
I submit that the President's statement is absolutely worthless if he does not give us figures to show what was in his mind. He must have had figures in his mind. It is his duty to answer the Dáil on this matter and place the Dáil in the possession of all the information he has on the matter.
Comment on this
I am giving the facts as I have them. I have told the Dáil that the British Government took up this matter with us some months ago. I told the Dáil—I am certain I did—that we had not yet replied, that we had not furnished our side of the case.
Comment on this
That is question for the Minister for Finance. It was to his Department that the letter went.
Comment on this
I usually like, in matters of this kind, particularly to be exact. I am certainly not going to hazard a prophecy, particularly when other people are so wild in the prophecies they make in regard to these claims.
Comment on this
Could the Minister for Finance assist the President in this matter? The President has moved a motion which deals specifically with this thing.
Comment on this
If I might say so, it is open to Deputies to ask those questions during the course of the discussion.
Comment on this
Are we to take it that this Agreement was practically arrived at in the absence of the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Does the President say that the agreement was arrived at without he having any knowledge of what the figures were?
Comment on this
The President is making a speech to his motion. When he has made that speech, Deputies will have opportunities of making their own speeches. I think that is the best procedure to adopt. I allowed one question to be asked. If Deputies are dissatisfied with the President's answer, they can express their dissatisfaction in a variety of ways. The President should be allowed to continue his speech without interruption.
Comment on this
As I was saying, there are certain people who said our liability in respect to Article V. varied from £5,000,000 annually to £19,000,000. There is nothing so detrimental to financial prosperity as impending unascertained liabilities. It is essential for conditions of ordered finance that we should know the amount of our debt for good or for ill. This question of our liability was, I am bound to say, approached by the representatives of the British Government with a friendliness of feeling and the broad outlook of real statesmanship. They were not out to haggle over petty details or minor considerations. They were prepared to take the bold course, and to make a generous contribution towards cementing the good relations which have grown up between the two countries since the signing of the Treaty. They agreed to close all outstanding questions of controversy with us, and wrote off whatever sum they might have secured under this Article. We, on our part, undertook to assume liability for damage to property within the Irish Free State area since 21st January, 1919. The arrangement in these two Articles is a most advantageous settlement of outstanding financial matters. We have exchanged a perennial burthen of unknown magnitude in respect of an external debt for the liability to pay a sum amounting approximately to £5,000,000 for compensation for damage suffered by our own people.
The fourth provision of the Agreement is for increasing compensation under the Damage to Property Compensation Act, 1923, in respect of malicious injury to property done in the area of the Irish Free State between the 11th day of July, 1921, and the 12th day of May, 1923. Every Deputy in this House is aware of the complaint which has been made that the measure of compensation for post-Truce damage compares unfavourably with the awards for damage suffered pre-Truce.
We are satisfied that in fact there are grounds for this contention. The complaints were not confined to any one class. Our own supporters complained. They were, perhaps, not as loud in their complaints as a certain section who are commonly designated as the Southern Loyalists. These complaints were a source of embarrassment both to us and to the British Government. We thought fit to wipe out the cause of these complaints. We regarded an increase of ten per cent. all round as fair and equitable, and we believed that at a time when all parties were united in an effort to remove every cause of friction, this cause should be removed by the introduction of this provision in the Agreement.
Article 5 of the Agreement transfers the powers of the Council of Ireland to the Parliament and Government of Northern Ireland. In agreeing to this, we have been accused of cutting the one connecting link between North and South. In fact, we have done the very reverse. Under the Treaty the powers of the Council of Ireland, which were chiefly the control of railways, fisheries, and the diseases of animals, were restricted in their exercise to Northern Ireland. On the Council half the representatives would have been drawn from the Free State, and Northern Ireland could not have looked on its operation as anything but irritating interference. No real unification, even of the services under its control, could have been achieved in this way. We made the arrangement contained in the Agreement with the intention, which actuated all parties, of removing every outstanding cause of difference, in order to allow for the development, in future, of the best relations. In abandoning the Council of Ireland, the Free State will lose nothing. It will gain goodwill.
This then, is the Agreement which has been signed and to which the force of law must be given if it is to become operative. I believe, if it is accepted in good faith by all parties in Ireland, it will mark a turning point in Irish history. It will be recorded as one of the happiest pledges of these good and friendly relations which have been developing between our people and the people of Great Britain. It removes with one sweep the main outstanding sources of dispute between the two countries. It stabilises our financial position. It secures that we are deprived of none of our citizens. It is the best agreement which we were able to make and it is a good agreement.
It is now for the Dáil to accept it or reject it. It is open to the Dáil to take either course. We strongly and confidently recommend you to accept it, to accept it in the spirit in which it was made, to accept it in the interests of prosperity and peace.
Some Deputies have already indicated in no uncertain terms their determination to oppose its acceptance. Let us be clear as to the position which its rejection would create. Let us be clear that the Boundary Commission is still in existence—that its existence will be terminated only when the present legislation has been passed both here and in London. Its report is ready for presentation. Do those who oppose this agreement want that report? If they do, and if they can persuade a majority in this House to agree with them, then they can have the report. Will it do them any good? Will it confer on the minority in Ulster any benefit?
Article 5 is not yet gone. It will only go when this Agreement becomes operative. Reject this Agreement and you retain Article 5 with its unascertained financial burthens, its negotiations and its arbitration. If a majority of the House desires the responsibility of wiping out the results achieved by this Government's labours for the past fortnight, they can do so; they can get back to the position where we stood on the 22nd November. If, and when they do, I hope that those who take the lead in advising that course will recognise that they will not be able to evade their responsibilities. It will then be for them to do what they have hitherto failed to do, namely, make some constructive contribution to the solution of the problem which they will thus have created. I hope they will bear in mind that problems of this nature are not solved by platitudes, however profound, or by abstractions divorced from reality. Neither are they solved by the exercise of a capacity for thwarting effort. They are solved by facing facts as they are, and not as they might be in a Utopian world.
Comment on this
I oppose this Bill, and, in doing so, I am conscious that I labour under very serious disabilities. The President has read a carefully prepared statement in which he was assisted by the work, not merely of his colleagues in the Ministry, but by secretaries and the secretaries of secretaries; whereas we, by these rushed tactics of the President, are obliged to deal with the case as presented to us here and now. The President recited the history of the Boundary Commission. I will follow him therefore, as far as my memory will serve me, in the order of the statement of his case. He said that it was a problem not of to-day or yesterday, and the solution of it had baffled the statesmanship of various generations. He then disclaimed, on behalf of his Government, any responsibility whatever for the position, or the condition, into which that problem had been brought in recent days.
I am not a factionist in this matter, nor am I seeking to score dialectical points off the Minister. I pay no attention to those cheap sneers and jibes with which I am so familiar, that because I am a professor of philosophy and a barrister, and accustomed, therefore, all my life to exact thinking, and that, as a professor with exact thought and precise expression, I am disqualified from the consideration of documents and instruments of government such as this. The man in the street, apparently, who can run his eye over a document and make up what he is pleased to call his mind is, according to President Cosgrave, a better judge of this. No wonder he wants to rush, lest the man in the street should be invited by his representatives here to stay a while and think the matter out and consider its bearings. As I say, I am not speaking as a factionist, I am quite willing as one who is a member of his party—not only that, but I think he will admit I was one of the party most appreciative of him and his efforts in the past—to say that it is no pleasure to me to stand here differing as I do so fundamentally from the position he has now taken up.
Up to a certain moment in the conduct of the Boundary Commission the Executive Council is absolutely without blame, in my opinion. This Dáil admitted, when the elaborate correspondence from London with the Irish Government was submitted to it, that there was nothing revealed in that which at all reflected upon either the patriotic zeal or the ability of any member of the Executive Council in the handling of our case, but there came a moment when that wisdom ceased to inspire the Executive Council. A member of the Party, when we had suspended operations a few evenings ago in order to allow the Ministry sufficient time to consider the difficult position into which they had brought themselves, said to me: "Do you think that those men would be guilty of anything that is unpatriotic?"
Now I put the question here in public that I may have the advantage of giving my answer in public. I answer now, as I answered then, "Patriotism is a matter of the feelings. Right decisions are a matter of trained intelligence, and there may be no contact between these two." I am not challenging the patriotism—I have no concern with that of either the President or either of his colleagues—but I am challenging their capacity and confidence and their negligence, of which I accuse them in this matter.
The President says, by way of easy escape, that had someone come to his office he would have received suggestions as to how to meet the difficulty. Would he? Is that the experience of members of this Dáil with regard to the head of the Executive Council? I think I am entitled now, as the President spoke of me of taking up an insane position, to reveal a little history in connection with the Boundary Commission. There was no necessity to pass identical legislation here with regard to the proposal to alter Treaty No. 1. As advised by the Privy Council, the British Government were quite competent, by passing an Act in their own legislature, to appoint a Commissioner in room of the Commissioner who was to have been nominated by the Northern Government. Why did they press for identical legislation on our part? They were astute enough to seek to bind us beforehand to a position that would preclude us from saying: "We cannot accept the award of a Commission so constituted. It is not constituted in accordance with the Treaty for one of the three members was to have been appointed by the Ulster Government whereas two, other than ours, have been appointed by Great Britain." There is the first blunder made by the Executive Council. They passed identical legislation. I will correct what I said. The first blunder was not absolutely in the identical legislation by itself but in passing it without its being accompanied by any declaration of our mind in the matter.
Now, the President complains that a member of the Dáil does not approach him to put whatever he knows or thinks at his disposal. These lions cannot realise that even a mouse, on occasions, can be of use to them. I had the temerity to propose to the Executive Council a resolution which would have declared our minds. What reception did it receive? It was returned to me ignominiously. Fortunately it was, because I have the document. I should not have it, had not that fate befallen it. I proposed to the Executive Council, through the President, that we should, on the occasion of the Second Reading of that Bill for identical legislation amending the Treaty, pass a resolution to this effect:— That whereas certain British signatories to the Treaty have declared that the mind in which they signed the Treaty was so and so—to save the time of the House I will not go into details, but the details are in my memory—we declare on our part that the Irish delegation, the signatories to the Treaty had declared repeatedly, both at the time and afterwards, that the meaning and effect of Clause 12 to them was wholly opposite to that declared now by the British signatories; that it was in view of the interpretation given to Clause 12 by the Irish signatories that the Treaty was accepted and endorsed by the Irish people, and that we, as one of the high contracting parties in the Treaty, were as much entitled to declare the spirit in which the Treaty was signed as any British statesman. Not only that, but that the interpretation of the terms of reference created by the Treaty and within the scope of which the award was to be made by the Commissioners should now be declared by us.
I was quite willing to agree that on the question of international amenities, and even also on the question of strict legality, it might not be in the best of taste on our part to begin by a declaration of our interpretation of Clause 12, but that, in as much as the British signatories to the Treaty and the British Press had tried to poison the public mind with these partisan, ex parte statements, it had become a necessity on our part to declare our minds, that we were not the offending parties.
I submit, and I submit it to the people outside this House, if my words can reach them, that in the rejection of a proposal such as that the Minister sinned grievously against the light. Had that resolution gone out with the passing of the Act which modified the Treaty, the whole question of the exact terms of reference would have been pushed to the front at once, instead of at a later date, when it became so highly complicated that it terrified the President out of his ordinary balance of mind. Now he tells us a lot about the possibility of the Feetham award. We are to be frightened now by the Feetham award into forgetting all about the responsibility of the Executive Council in regard to the possibility of there being such a thing as the Feetham award. Is the country going to permit the ex-Minister for Education to be made a scapegoat for the Executive Council?
Comment on this
I have not authorised any Deputy to make use of my personal position to draw it in anyway across the considerations of the facts before the House.
Comment on this
That is quite so. It is unnecessary for Dr. MacNeill to say he has not authorised me, but that does not affect in the least my right to draw the attention of the public to the fact, and the fact is that Dr. MacNeill undertook a very difficult and thankless task. He knew, as we know, and the President has stated it to-night, and I have said frequently in language that would appear irreverent that God, in his omnipotence, could not settle the Boundary question to the satisfaction of everyone, for the simple reason that there should be no boundary line at all, a point upon which the extreme Unionists and we are in agreement. With full consciousness of that before his mind, Dr. MacNeill undertook that task. Now not only are our fellow-Nationalists in the North to be thrown to the wolves, but he is to be thrown with them. The Executive Council has asked us to forget everything by adopting the artifice of the cuttle-fish, which can darken the water by its sepia so that its evolution are invisible.
Comment on this
I protest against this use of my position by the Deputy—this pretence of rhetorical nonsense—about being thrown to the wolves.
Comment on this
I regret very much that Deputy Dr. MacNeill and I are not of one mind, because I have such a profound respect for his high character, but he must take the responsibility and consequence of entering public life. Any man who puts his hand upon public matters, or enters upon public activities, must be prepared to be criticised in any way that is legitimate. I am not, I can assure the Deputy, trying to appear to make a case for him, or trying to use him in any way. I think he knows me well enough to acquit me of any such intention. I would use the fact even if it were not the case of a life-long friend or a man for whom I have regard. If the Deputy wishes I will refer to him as A B to show that I am not intruding his personality in the least. I say that a member of the Executive Council was chosen for this difficult and well-nigh impossible position. I charge that the Executive Council retained him as a member of the Executive Council. They have law advisers who would have told them what their legal position was. They must have known long before last week, or the week before last week, that the Boundary Commission was a court of award, that the Commissioners were arbitrators. They must have known that it had not the powers of a supreme court, which could go wrong, and that the only remedy was to appeal to a higher court, if there was a higher court. If they did not know it was because they did not consult, so that the award would have to be given within the terms of reference.
Deputy Dr. MacNeill, according to the statement he made here, became a political Melchisedech, without generation, and without friends or kindred. The members of the Executive Council, his colleagues, knew nothing of what he was doing, were told nothing, they asked nothing, and yet in this House we have been continually reminded of the collective responsibility of the members of the Executive Council. How did they hope to divest themselves of the responsibility for what is done by one of their number? I am waiting to hear—and I count confidently on hearing it at a later stage—that under an Article of the Constitution the Executive Council are entitled to transact all the business of the Executive Council, and that consequently the President, Vice-President, or any other member who chooses to go over instead of the Minister whose business it was, the Minister for External Affairs, were qualified to transact all the business of his Department. That we will deal with later on in its own place. The plea that will invalidate that is collective responsibility. They cannot have it both ways. They have, and the country must see to it that they have, collective responsibility for whatever collapse, breakdown, threat, or menace of catastrophe was involved in the Feetham Commission.
The Minister for Finance, with the President, went to Emyvale on a certain Sunday. Though the Executive Council required time to make up its mind on its policy, this member of the Executive Council required only 24 hours, for he made what appears to be to everyone an authoritative deliverance on the Feetham Commission, and he told his audience that the Executive Council knew nothing about Mr. Feetham. I do not want to hold him strictly to words used on a platform. We are told by Deputy Good that it is one thing when a Deputy addresses members of his constituency, and that it is another thing when he addresses members of the Dáil where there are official reporters to record all his utterances. I do not wish to hold the Minister for Finance too closely to his words. Would he say now in the Dáil that the Executive Council knew nothing about Mr. Feetham? Anyone who cares to turn to the official reports for June, 1924, will discover the record of President Cosgrave reading a message sent to him by the British Government announcing the appointment of Mr. Feetham as Chairman of the Boundary Commission, together with an account of his services to the British Government, and his status in the Empire. They knew that much about him.
There was further a discussion about Mr. Feetham in the debate on a motion by Deputy Milroy in regard to the Boundary Commission. Surely they knew that? It will be said, of course, that Deputy Magennis made a speech, and consequently they did not know, and they could not be expected to read or to listen to that. Very good; then their ignorance is culpable and wilful, and in that ignorance they allowed an Executive Minister to go on until there was no way out. The President—I hope I am not misrepresenting what he said, because it is very difficult sometimes to hear him here—gave me the impression that he first knew of the situation through the disclosure in the Morning Post. Therefore, the Executive Council were in a fool's paradise, and would have remained in a fool's paradise, presumably, unless Deputy Dr. MacNeill resigned and disclosed to us, or disclosed to us without resigning, the position of affairs.
I hold that there is no getting away from the fact that, under the Constitution, the Executive Council are absolutely as much responsible as the Commissioner whom they appointed. It was the Executive Council, not the Dáil, who appointed him. The Dáil was not consulted on the matter. I make no complaint about that, but I note the fact as going farther to fix responsibility on the Executive Council. The Executive Council went asleep on this whole matter, notwithstanding their collective responsibility. Occasionally, the President talked in his sleep and assured the public that all was well—that all was going well in this, the best of all possible worlds. Other Ministers repeated the same assurance, until the country was also lulled to sleep on the matter exactly as the President——
Comment on this
I admit I cannot give the dates. I am now speaking extempore. The time has been forced upon me. I am adducing arguments and facts——
Comment on this
I am still asleep as far as this matter is concerned, and I would like to know what are the occasions Deputy Magennis refers to. If he cannot give them now, I would like to have them at another time.
Comment on this
Somebody else will give them during the debate. I have no secretary. I did my day's work before I came here. I have done the work for which I receive my salary. I come here to try to do my duty, and every difficulty is placed in my way by the "rush" tactics of the Executive Council. Does the President deny that members of the Ministry have, from time to time, assured the country that the result of the Boundary Commission would be satisfactory to the Saorstát?
Comment on this
Deputy D'Alton and Deputy Magennis—the latter in a more general way—have accused me of making a statement in connection with the Boundary Commission. A certain statement to that effect appeared in the Press, but I wish to deny the accuracy of that statement.
Comment on this
If I did the Minister for Local Government any injustice, I withdraw any remark that seems to include him. If every other Minister will get up now disowning it —we had the President and an Extern Minister—it would be a delight to the country. If each of the other Ministers who spoke to this effect would now disown his statement, and throw the blame on the newspaper reporter——
Comment on this
I want it to be understood that I am not denying the whole statement. I am denying the accuracy of the statement.
Comment on this
I am withdrawing the statement altogether as referring to the Minister for Local Government. It is quite enough for my purpose that the President talked in his sleep.