OIREACHTAS LIBRARY. - SCHOOL ATTENDANCE BILL, 1925—THIRD STAGE.
Contributions 137–277 of 277. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 48 of 1925 ›
The small farmer cannot be used in this argument. The small farmer will not have so much turnips, beet or mangolds that it will be necessary to employ children to do the thinning. It is in the interests of the big farmer in this case, and I certainly think it would be wrong, and we would be forgetting the arguments used on the previous occasion, if it were now extended to another class of people. I think the Minister will find, if he looks into this matter, that it will be quite impossible to make regulations applying this at different times to different areas. I do think we have gone quite far enough—too far in my opinion—in fixing the period within the time mentioned in the Bill, and I think it should be left at that.
Comment on this
In regard to Amendment 14a, I might say that this was put down as a consequential amendment to my first amendment raising the age from fourteen to sixteen. I could not move it at this stage until I see what will be done in the new section which the Minister has promised to introduce.
Comment on this
I beg to move:
In sub-section (3), line 33, to delete the word "ten" and substitute "twelve."
I think all the arguments used on the general question apply with increased force to the special point dealt with in this amendment. The Minister indeed foreshadowed that, in what he said and seemed disposed to look on this amendment with so much favour that I do not think I need repeat or dish up again the arguments used. I think the age of ten is undoubtedly too young an age to allow children to be kept away from school for the purpose of doing even light work. I therefore propose that the age should be raised to twelve.
Comment on this
I think it is hardly necessary for me to say that I am strongly in favour of this amendment. Seeing that we could not keep this section out of the Bill altogether, this is some consolation. I think there is hardly anybody in the Dáil but will agree that the age of ten is too young altogether. Even in countries where exemptions are granted—there are exemptions given in some countries in Acts passed many years ago—exemption is not given so early as at the age of ten. In no country is the exemption granted at a lower age than twelve even where exemptions are given in legislation passed several years ago, and I think it is altogether reactionary, altogether contrary to the spirit of the times that we should say in our legislation that a child of ten years should be so engaged. I hope the Minister, as he foreshadowed in the previous discussion, will accept the amendment of Deputy Thrift, and I am sure Deputies on the Farmers' benches will recognise that whatever argument may be put up in the case of a lad of twelve, ten years is altogether too early an age to grant exemption. At that time the child will be only in the Fourth Standard or so. I think there is no necessity to labour the point any further.
Comment on this
It is all right to suggest that the age should be raised to twelve years and that only a child of twelve years should be permitted to remain at home for those ten days. However, when we come down to hard facts, if we accept it at all that a child is to be of value at home to do certain work, we must recognise that the parent will only keep a child at home to do such agricultural work as he is capable of doing. While parents may get a reputation for treating their children perhaps rather severely and for not showing sufficient consideration for their physical ability to do certain work, I hold that the majority of parents will only ask children to do work that the children are able to do. I want to tell the Dáil that children are capable of doing agricultural work at ten years. I have done it myself at ten years, and I got children to do it at ten years in my county.
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson asks is it a desirable thing. It would be a desirable thing if we could send every child in the country to a University. I agree that that would be grand, but I want to tell Deputy Johnson—take Germany if you like as an instance— that all the students at the German Universities go home to the plucking of their vines at certain periods of the year.
Comment on this
Exactly, but they do not go to the University in order that they may make a livelihood in the vine-yards. They are getting a vocational training, but the people in that progressive country know that, if they are to be kept at the University, there are certain other things that must be done at the farmhouse and around it. I want to point out that there is certain work to be done to-day on the farm, and that it is very difficult to do it at present. I suggest that when you seek to insert an amendment such as this, you are not helping education, and I feel that the Minister should not agree to such an alteration in the Bill. The Dáil has already decided that this age of ten should be left in the Bill. I suggest that no parent will engage a child to work in the fields if the child is not able for the work. The majority of parents in rural districts will be sufficiently considerate not to make their children do work which they are not able to do, and if they are able to do what the parents want, you are taking away a concession with one hand that you have given them with the other by accepting this amendment.
Comment on this
There are hundreds of poor women in this city and in my own constituency who would be very glad if I put in a plea that they should be allowed to keep their children at home so that they may go out to work. There are many of those women with two or three children, and any child of ten years of age is well able to look after a child of five years or three years. The mother may say: "I must go out and earn my livelihood; I must feed my children; I will sell oranges at the street corner; at least I will do something." That argument can be used just as effectively as the argument that Deputy Baxter is using. The same argument was used hundreds of times in Belfast.
Comment on this
Let it be ten days or only one day, if the Deputy likes. There are plenty of people in this city who would be pleased if I and those acting with me would put up an argument that there should be certain exemptions in their cases because of economic necessity. We have, however, hardened our hearts against the poor because we believe the education of the children is of greater importance. We recognise there is going to be hardship. People will find they are obliged to strain the law and, if they are allowed, they will break the law; they will risk breaking the law and they will blame us for supporting a law which will impose on them rigid supervision over their children and the necessity of seeing that their children go to school. All this must strain loyalty on the part of constituents, people whom we might be expected to plead on behalf of because they are poor, because they may be widows, because they may be people who are out of work, and so on. That argument can be applied with equal cogency.
We believe, however, that it is essential for the future of the children, for the future manhood and womanhood of the country, urban as well as agricultural, that the habit of regular attendance should be imposed upon the children. It is necessary that discipline should be imposed, even though parents may have to feel some little loss. The pleas of poverty and hard conditions are pleas that must make an appeal to the heart of every Deputy, but, if we are looking ahead, and if we are considering the future of the people of the country, we must insist that education and the discipline which this particular kind of education entails, is of paramount importance.
The difference between ten and twelve years is very considerable. I am not going to go into the merits of the issue we have decided, but, as between ten and twelve years, there is an immense difference in the life of the child. I am sorry that the plea has been put forward in this House that a child of ten years ought to be free to stay at home to do light agricultural work. There is a case for a child of twelve years as against a child of ten. Up to a few years ago—perhaps up to this moment—many thousands of children did not go to school after twelve years of age.
I have been reminded that the school attendance in County Cavan, the county that Deputy Baxter speaks for, is the worst in Ireland, except perhaps part of County Mayo. We want to improve that. There may have been, and there may be even to-day, economic factors that led up to that state of affairs. I am not sure whether County Cavan is the worst in respect to economic conditions; it is the worst in respect to attendance in school, and we are endeavouring to improve its reputation. I would urge strongly that Deputy Thrift's amendment should be carried by a big majority, if it is not adopted unanimously.
Comment on this
I was inclined, at the beginning of the debate on this amendment, to support what Deputy Baxter said, and to produce a few arguments in support of it from my own experience of things. I have been greatly strengthened in that determination after hearing what Deputy Johnson has put before the House. I do not agree with Deputy Johnson that if it is possible for a man or a woman to be kept from starvation by sacrificing ten days of a child's attendance at school, the man or woman should be allowed to remain in starvation. That is an inhuman doctrine. I am inclined to think that the attitude of Deputy Johnson and Deputy O'Connell has a little touch of inhumanity and unreality. They seem to entertain the belief that you can reform the whole life of the country by adding twenty days to the period of time during which a child attends school. I do not quite see eye to eye with them, and I have some experience of the educational life of the country.
I was going to add to Deputy Baxter's argument a point that does not seem to have struck anybody. The whole argument against keeping children away from school was based upon the assumption that when children are kept at home they are used for all kinds of heavy manual labour, work for which, perhaps, agricultural labourers should be employed. The argument, more or less, is that there is child-labour at the age of ten years. Anybody who has been brought up in a country house knows that there are millions of things that a child of ten years could do for its mother.
Comment on this
Exactly. As I say, there are millions of things that a child who has attained any physical strength could do for its mother. In the summer months particularly the mother needs the child's assistance very badly. I was reared in a country house, and my education was as well looked after as anybody else's education. I was sent to school regularly, and whenever an occasion arose on which I could help, I was kept at home. That happened now and again, particularly at times when the men and women were too busy to look after the hundred and one little matters that needed attention.
In a Bill like this, which is liable to meet with a certain amount of opposition in any case and which is liable to be a bit irksome in its application, if you go in for tightening down everything in the most rigid strait-jacket fashion, you will be bringing about a feeling of opposition to it. I am sorry Deputy Baxter's last amendment was not accepted. If you can get a ninety per cent. attendance for six or seven months of the year, you will be doing a very good thing. There will be just as good value secured in the end as if you put into operation Cromwellian methods and force the children to attend school during the remaining months.
Comment on this
I believe that as a result of this Bill you will get between an eighty-five and a ninety per cent. attendance. I am sorry the suggestion to spread the time over which abstention from school would be allowed was not accepted. It must be remembered that you are not passing a measure instituting education in Ireland for the first time. At the most this Bill does not affect more than a small percentage of the people; it affects people who habitually abstain from sending their children to school.
Comment on this
Allowance is being made only for necessary abstention. Deputy O'Connell seems to look at this matter from the point of view of setting up machinery that was never in existence before, and he seems to consider that we are going to deal with whole masses of people and that school life will be affected to an enormous extent. As against that, this Bill is not likely to affect more than six or seven per cent. of the people.
I am rather astonished at the attitude of the Labour Party towards this question of compulsion. I remember the first occasion on which I spoke in this House. It was at the end of the debate on the Treason Bill. Deputy Johnson on that occasion was very much opposed to compelling people to do certain things. He was terribly opposed on high moral grounds to compelling people to obey the ordinary laws of society.
Comment on this
I am speaking in regard to the general matter raised by the strait-laced doctrine put forward by Deputy O'Connell. The argument was wrong.
Comment on this
I do not think a compulsory School Attendance Bill is a good thing, but when you are compelled by circumstances to have a compulsory School Attendance Bill, you ought to be very careful, in the first place, that you do not make it unjust, and in the second place, you ought to be careful that you do not tighten it up so as to defeat your own ends by the methods you adopt to put it into operation.
Comment on this
The arguments of Deputy Baxter and Deputy Professor Tierney were expressed so eloquently that there is a danger of the Dáil not realising that they are not only arguments against the amendment but are arguments against the Bill. If all Deputy Baxter and Deputy Professor Tierney stated is true, there is no need for this Bill. If we are going to assume that all parents thoroughly understand the child's welfare, there is no need for compulsory attendance. This is a Bill intended to deal with the bad parent. I am not suggesting that the agricultural parent is a bad parent, and that the town parent is a good parent.
Comment on this
There are good agricultural parents and there are bad agricultural parents. There are agricultural parents who do not realise the value of education—Deputy Baxter knows that as well as I do—and there are agricultural parents who will make every excuse to keep children at home. Deputy Professor Tierney's argument is an argument against compulsion. He talked about compulsion of the strait-jacket type. These are the advocates of compulsory Irish.
Comment on this
There is an argument against excessive compulsion, which is a very different thing from compulsion. I said the principle of compulsion in itself is bad, but there are circumstances where compulsion is necessary. I was arguing against tightening compulsion too much.
Comment on this
There is a refinement in that doctrine that savours of Deputy Magennis. It is a philosophical point which, I am afraid, my rather uneducated brain is incapable of appreciating. The Deputy has talked about the restrictions of the strait-jacket. Has he ever thought of applying that doctrine to the Statistics Bill, which is a Bill full of the most drastic penalties? I did not hear the Deputy complaining about strait-jacket methods in that connection. If the Deputy supported the Second Reading of this Bill, I do not think he can say that the alteration from ten to twelve years—an alteration that will prevent a boy from being taken away from school when his brain is most susceptible and when he is most capable of learning—is unreasonable.
Comment on this
Twenty days, in addition to the holidays and Saturdays. It is a considerable period. I do not think the Deputy was in his place when we discussed the main question. What really counts is the interruption of the course of study, and it is undesirable, I submit, that children of ten years should have their course of study interrupted. At twelve years they begin to think things out for themselves. I earnestly hope that the Minister will accept the amendment, and if he does not I hope Deputy Thrift will divide on it.
Comment on this
We do not hear Deputy Tierney very often in this House. I am sorry we do not hear him oftener. If there is one question one would expect to hear him on, it is on a question of this kind. As an educationist, as a man who, as he says himself, has climbed all the rungs of the educational ladder, we would naturally expect to hear him on a matter of this kind. But we would expect that, speaking as an educationist, he would not give voice to the views that he has given voice to on this occasion. He comes forward now and charges Deputy Johnson and myself with what— inhumanity. To stand up here in the interest of the children and their protection—that is the inhumanity that Deputy Tierney speaks of; that is his conception of inhumanity. To seek to protect and to stand up for the interests of the most helpless portion of the community—that is inhumanity according to this new educationist, representing a constituency which has the very worst school attendance record in Ireland. If he speaks as Deputy Tierney, representing North Mayo, I can understand him. If he speaks as an educationist, I fail to understand why he should take up an attitude like that.
Deputy Cooper has already pointed out that the Deputy's speech was a Second Reading speech against the whole principle of the Bill. He did not believe in compulsion; the majority of the people did not want compulsion. We are introducing compulsion because it is necessary to prevent those who do not recognise their duty to their children not only from interfering with the education of their own children, but with the education of other children who are sent to school regularly. Deputy Tierney—the humanist, the man who cannot be charged with inhumanity—stands up to advocate that children of ten years should be kept at home from school at certain periods to do work on the farms. I am surprised at Deputy Tierney.
Comment on this
I desire very strongly to support this amendment. It has been said that this is only a matter of twenty days in the year. It is much more than that, if you look at the matter from the point of view of the teacher and the carrying out of his year's work. As the Bill stands at present, it means that during the months of April, May and June—July, for some particular reason, is left out—and during August, September, and half of October—that is, nearly over six months of the year—fifty per cent. of the pupils will be able to absent themselves for 20 days at any rate. The teacher's work, I take it, must fall within a period of one year. There must be a beginning and an end to it, and the arrangement that has been suggested would mean a weak beginning and a weak end, for, perhaps, the most important section of the school—that is, the senior pupils. Even if you restrict the period during which this is possible to 45 days in the spring and 75 days in the autumn, you will hinder the teacher in dealing effectively with his yearly course. It is very important, in my opinion, that you should restrict the number of pupils to which this would apply by extending the age to twelve years. That will enable a teacher to arrange the particular periods during which he will emphasise the beginning and the ending of the work of the year for his senior students. But, if you put the teacher in the position that he is going to have a bad attendance of children from 10 years upwards at the beginning and the end of his year, you are going to confuse things very much for him.
Comment on this
This is an amendment to which we should give a good deal of consideration. Deputy O'Connell has reiterated over and over again the necessity for continuity in education. That is apparent to all of us. I, for one, believe that the less the civil law is brought into effect in dealing with this and other matters, where really the moral law should come in, the better. Unfortunately, there is a necessity for this Bill. The question is, how we are going to secure the regular attendance of children at school in order to make them better citizens and more useful elements of the community without doing an injury to any section of the community. Deputy Baxter referred to the necessity for a certain amount of child labour on small farms of ten acres or so which are worked by one man. I cannot understand why such farmers cannot get that labour without lessening the hours of attendance for the children at school. Why should we follow the school holidays that have come to us from across the water—the regulation holidays at Christmas and Easter? Farmers and other people only get two or three days off at Christmas. Why should not the school holidays at Christmas and Easter be reduced and holidays be given at the period when the children can do work at home, which Deputy Baxter thinks is so important? I put that suggestion to the Minister and the Dáil for careful consideration. We are not tied down to any regulation holiday. Why should the children get a fortnight at Christmas and at Easter? Why not give them three or four days at Christmas and at Easter, and let the longer holidays coincide with the time when they are wanted to do this light work? That is the way to meet the matter, and have no division about it.
Comment on this
I understand that in my absence Deputy O'Connell made some reference to child labour in Tirconaill. I have not gathered quite clearly what he did say.
Comment on this
One thing I am satisfied about is, that when the Bill is passed there will be neither sufficient schools nor teachers in Tirconaill to cope with the increased attendance.
Comment on this
Child labour is very largely availed of in that county, and we have got an unfortunate system in existence there—the hiring system— under which a very large number of children of tender years are sent out to earn money for their parents. That is an absolute necessity if they are to keep their homes together. My opinion is that a reasonable measure of compulsion is necessary in order that the children may get some education.
Comment on this
While I did not favour Deputy O'Connell's amendment, I am very strongly in favour of this amendment. Although I admitted the necessity for children helping small farmers at certain periods, I do think that children of ten years should not be used for that purpose. Very extravagant terms were used by Deputy Johnson, who spoke of slavery and other things. At the same time, I think that a boy of from ten to twelve years of age is of very little use on a farm except for very slight duties. Such a boy would get very tired after a short time of application, and for that reason I am ready to support the amendment. The statement made by Deputy White has made me feel even more strongly on this matter. If, as he says, children of tender years are being hired out to regular farm work all the year round, that is a very different proposition from children helping their parents on twenty days of the year, and for that reason I hope the amendment will be adopted.
Comment on this
Personally I am rather in favour of the age of twelve, but I will leave the matter to what is euphemistically called a free vote of the House, which means that our Party will be divided and the other parties will vote solidly.
Comment on this
In as much as arguments are going to decide this issue, it is well, perhaps, that there should be at least one argument adduced to counteract the influence of Deputy Tierney. The Bill before us contains Section 4, and those who were present on the occasion will remember that I endeavoured to make this particular provision less rigid than that which the Minister, whom Deputy Tierney follows, put into the Bill. The Bill is one to make attendance at school obligatory and to make parents responsible for their children's attendance. It is a Bill that was promised by the predecessor of the present Minister, and it is being brought forward in response to what we believe to be a general demand, and we understand it has the backing of the party to which Deputy Tierney belongs. It is a Bill to impose compulsion on parents in respect to the attendance at school of their children. Deputy Tierney is against obligatory attendance at school. He explains that he has gone through the whole gamut of education. He was brought up in an agricultural district and he gives credit to his parents for insisting that he should attend school fairly regularly. His parents also kept him away from school pretty often. We have, however, a result which is quite satisfactory. Deputy Tierney has gone through the whole gamut of education; ergo why send children to school, why oblige them to go to school, why not keep them at home to do the hundred-and-one things required about a farm-house? That is the logic of Deputy Tierney's argument.
As Deputy Mulcahy pointed out, the effect of this irregularity of attendance for even these twenty days is not merely bad on the ten or fifteen bad attendants, but it is also bad on the 80 or 85 per cent. To allege that this rigidity, this uniformity of attendance, is bad is to say that we ought to be careless, not merely about the few who do not attend, but also about the remainder who do attend. The fact is we are dealing, not with the education of one individual or individuals, but we are dealing with classes. There is one social and economic fact on the other side which I ask Deputy Baxter and other Deputies to take into account. From the educational point of view we are faced with the fact that we can only supply one teacher for forty pupils. Boys and girls at school are not dealt with as singles but as classes, and if a class is going to be irregular in attendance, the education of the whole class is damaged by the absence of ten or fifteen per cent. of the pupils.
The plea has been urged that it is only the agricultural community that is affected by this particular discussion. That may be true, but let me remind the House that it is in many agricultural areas that the attendance is most unsatisfactory, and in so far as the attendance is good and regular the whole Bill will not need to be passed. It is a Bill to effect the better attendance of those who are bad attendants at present. If anybody is in favour of obliging children to attend school regularly he ought surely be in favour of making the obligation apply to children under twelve and not make an exemption which would allow children to be kept at home to do one hundred and one things under the guise of being called upon to do agricultural work.
Comment on this
I do not desire to allow Deputy Johnson to carry the House with him in his sympathy. My attitude is that I desire to have moderation observed. The only thing which I want the House to bear in mind is that it may be possible to have too much compulsory education. I admit heartily, and I have long thought, that it is necessary to have some system of compulsory education to deal with those parents who will not send their children to school regularly. While doing that, however, you should not apply compulsion to people who send their children regularly to school but who may occasionally want to keep them at home. In this Bill you are compelling everybody, good parents as well as bad, and you refuse to exempt anyone, whether good or bad, from the terms of the Bill except, at certain periods, children at the age of twelve. You are therefore inflicting a certain amount of hardship, and you are doing a little to incommode any parents who send their children regularly to school but who want occasionally to keep them at home for a short period. I think much of the attitude of Deputy Johnson and Deputy O'Connell towards this Bill is that of——
Comment on this
Yes, a Cromwell. What I meant when I referred to them as being inhuman was that they failed to take human nature into account in their attitude towards this Bill.
Comment on this
By that amendment the Deputy will see that we on these benches are desirous of relaxing the obligations where there is a reasonable excuse.
Comment on this
I am prepared to admit that Deputies on the other side have their moments of humanity, but from what I have heard this evening I think that those Deputies, particularly Deputy O'Connell, are inspired by a tendency to compel people to do everything. I am against that universal tendency. I do not think that we are going to gain a great deal by tightening the age limit from ten to twelve years. I think you will cause a good deal of inconvenience to many harmless people. You will not get rid of any terrible abuses or punish any terrible criminals, but you will incommode many good parents who send their children to school regularly.
Comment on this
I do not think that there can be a great deal of inconvenience involved in this amendment. The argument has been put up that, as a general rule, decent parents would not send out children of ten years of age to do ten days' light agricultural work on their farms. I admit they would not, but what you have to consider in regard to particular legislation is whether it will leave loopholes for abuse. If you do not put in an amendment of this kind in the Bill you will leave a loophole for abuse. I think it would be wrong for the Dáil to pass a Bill which formally sanctioned the sending out of children of ten years of age to do ten days' agricultural work. As Deputy Johnson wisely pointed out, there is a big difference between a child at the age of ten and a child at the age of twelve. A child of ten is not much more than a baby. Sending out a child of ten years to do agricultural work seems to me to be inhuman. I find it hard to speak mildly about this matter. If you calculate the number of school days, leaving out Saturdays and Sundays, between the 1st April and 15th October, you will find that the number is something like 136, and with the holidays it means 100 days out of 136. As the Minister says, there is nothing extravagant in the proposal.
Comment on this
I would like to emphasise the question that is raised on this amendment. I do that because Deputy Tierney insists on making Second Reading speeches at this stage. The point at issue is whether, or not, the exemptions which are put in should apply to children at the age of ten or at the age of twelve years. Deputy Thrift moves an amendment to the effect that they should apply not earlier than at the age of twelve years. If the amendment is not carried we will be the only State, as far as I can discover, in which exemptions of this kind apply to children of ten. I have made an exhaustive search through the school legislation of all the countries in Europe and in America, and I can find no place in which these exemptions for agricultural work are given at such an early age. Deputy Baxter draws a picture of the conditions in Cavan. I do not suppose they are very much different from the conditions in Fermanagh, across the Border, and in portions of Tyrone. There there are no exemptions at the age of ten. Permission is given in a very much more limited extent than under this Bill for the employment of children in certain circumstances at twelve years of age, but there are no exemptions whatever under the age of twelve in Northern Ireland. I pointed out yesterday that they had given exemptions in England, but that these exemptions were removed up to the age of fourteen. Are we to be pointed out as the only State in which it is deliberately and formally set down that exemptions should be given to a child at the age of ten years to remain at home to engage in light agricultural work? That is a question that the Dáil will be asked to decide on this amendment.
The question of compulsion is not involved. It is a question as to at what age this exemption should be given, and making a plea for the quiet, decent parent—the parent that Deputy Tierney talked about does not carry us very far—the quiet, decent parent will send his children to school, and will not need this exemption at ten, or twelve, or at any age. These are not the people who have caused this Bill to be brought in. The people who have done that are the people who are indifferent, particularly in the areas represented by Deputy Baxter and Deputy Tierney. These are the people, who have made the Bill necessary. I was thinking of suggesting that it might be possible to have the bell rung now to bring in all the Deputies to hear the arguments, seeing that on this occasion at least it will not be a question of asking the Whips, "How are we to vote?" I do hope that the Dáil voting freely, even in the manner indicated by the Minister, will—
Comment on this
——follow the Minister and will not reject this amendment, so that, as I say, we will not leave ourselves in the position of being pointed to as the only State that has put into its school legislation permission for a child of ten years of age to absent himself from school to engage in agricultural work.
Comment on this
I do not know that Deputy O'Connell would think it right that because the people in Spain or Italy or England or Scotland or America do a certain thing——
Comment on this
Or Fermanagh—that accordingly his conscience would direct him that that was right and that he would follow their example. I suggest to Deputy O'Connell that there are very many occasions when, if such a proposition were put up to him, he would ask himself where it would lead him, and he would decide that he would turn down the example that was given to him by some of these countries as to what he should do in the conduct of his affairs. It is no argument that because certain things are done in certain countries, where conditions are different, it is right for us to do the same. I am amazed at Deputy O'Connell suggesting that we should follow such a course. I am not surprised that Deputy Thrift has moved this amendment. Deputy Thrift does not understand the conditions in rural Ireland as we understand them. Deputy O'Connell, from the educational point of view, and particularly from the point of view of the organisation he is representing, feels that it is better, and easier for the teachers to conduct their work successfully, if there is no break at all from the day the child first goes to school until it leaves at the age of fourteen. I agree that from a certain point of view the advantage to the teacher in his work would be very great under such circumstances.
Deputy Johnson looks at it from another point of view. I can understand his point of view, and he, I suggest, would be prepared to keep a great many of the people at school until the age of twenty, and he might perhaps think that to a certain extent that would solve the unemployment problem. It might, but it would not be a solution from the point of view of the economic difficulties that the country is facing. Let us examine the position. If we have conceded and if the Dáil has already decided that there may be a ten days' respite from attendance at school at certain periods of the year, let us take the parent who during the holidays has his child engaged on certain farm work, the child being perfectly capable of doing it, physically fit and sufficiently intelligent for the work. Let us imagine the position that that child and parent will be in because of this Bill. The day after the school opens the parent cannot keep the child from school to do the same work that the child did the previous day. I cannot understand that reasoning at all. The physical ability of the child is no argument, because I suggest, with all respect to those who have argued to the contrary, that parents will not put upon their children a physical strain that they are not capable of bearing. They do not do it, and the light agricultural work that some people seem to question the ability of the child to do is being done by children of ten years and under. I have done it myself under ten years, and I have had a child with me doing it, putting in the potato crop, and it is done over a very great portion of the country. I can see no reason whatever for permitting the child to do that work during the holidays and preventing him doing so if its parents require him the day after the opening of the school. I can understand that from the point of view of a Deputy looking down on the country from the heights of a University. I can even understand it from Deputy Johnson, but it is rather difficult to understand it from Deputy O'Connell, who has a comparatively good knowledge of conditions in the country.
I do say, regardless of what may be argued about the necessity for compulsory attendance, that this additional ten days' attendance by children from ten years to twelve at two periods in the year will not improve very considerably the standard of education during that period, and I doubt if it will make any difference at all to the child with ordinary intelligence. These ten days will not always be taken, but there will be occasions when it will be necessary to take them, and it will make little difference over a period of four years. I would prefer to have seen the Minister stand on the original proposal. He seems to be partly of two minds. I hope he is not drifting over to the other side, that seems to be so very badly informed as to the conditions in the country. I believe it would be better to leave the Bill as it is. If the experience gained in the working of the measure will show that certain improvements are necessary I think we could approach them much better then than at present, and I repeat that there is every possibility that in this we will step out too far and that there may be a desire to retreat. This would make the administration of the Bill very difficult and if it is passed you will find that there will be a very general desire later to amend the Act, because experience will show that you have stepped out too far and too soon.
Comment on this
I want to repudiate most emphatically Deputy Baxter's suggestion that I am looking upon this particular amendment, or any portion of the Bill, from the point of view of employment, or labour, or wages, or anything to do with the working classes as wage earners. I am looking at the amendment and at the whole Bill purely from the point of view of what I believe to be an educational necessity.
Comment on this
I would like to say, by way of personal explanation, that any of the arguments I have used in this connection were not used in the interests of the organisation that I happen to serve elsewhere, and were not used because of any advantage this would bring to the people whom I serve in that organisation. This would be of no advantage to the teacher. The teacher will have to do his work whether these children are at school or not. It was not in their interests that I spoke but in the interests of the children.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell and Deputy Johnson have practically said what I want to say. I always listen to Deputy Baxter with great interest, and he speaks with knowledge of farming life that I, unfortunately, largely lack. So I listen to him and very often look to him for guidance. But I think in this he is wrong; he does not see the gravamen of the argument in favour of the amendment. We do not support it because we believe that there is a tendency to undermine the physical health of the children, that parents in Ireland, as a rule, overwork their children and put burdens on them that physically they are not able to bear. I do not believe there are many parents in Ireland who would do that, and if there are there are other ways of dealing with them. This Bill has been introduced in the interests of the child and of his education. If there is any principle at all involved it is: Do we believe that education is a good thing? I remember Deputy Baxter practically telling us that the salvation of the country depended on education. If it is a good thing, let us give the child as much of it as we can. The parent who can exercise self-denial will not find this Bill oppressive. It is the parent who will not think of his child who will find the Bill rather harsh at first. I believe in setting a rather high standard, and I assure Deputy Baxter that from the educational point of view interruption in study is most detrimental. It lowers the effective teaching standard of the school for the term. Unless a man has actually been teaching he cannot realise how interruptions of this sort can destroy the term's work. I appeal to the House to support this amendment, and I congratulate the Minister on his boldness—I expected nothing else from him—in leaving it to an open vote.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will retain the original clause in the Bill. The law is supposed to be for the greater convenience of the greater number. In the West they are all small farmers and they cannot get on with their work expeditiously except they have the aid of their children. It is all spade-work. Deputy Johnson and Deputy Thrift seem to be under the impression that the work the children do is equivalent to slavery. It is the lightest work possible. I do not know whether Deputy Johnson or Deputy Thrift knows what a "slit" is. But everybody in the West knows. A slit is a potato cut into different portions. Each portion has an eye. A child of from ten to twelve years has a small quantity of these potatoes in a box. He throws the "slits" on to the ground, already prepared with manure for them. The father, or sometimes the mother, of the child turns the clay over the potatoes, and thus the work goes on. That is the lightest kind of work that a child could possibly do. But if the child did not aid the father, it would take three or four times longer to do the work. Deputy Johnson is exercised about the attendance at school. I, too, am exercised about the attendance of the children. The average attendance at present in the national schools in the rural districts is about 80 per cent.
Comment on this
I wish it were. The official figure for the Free State is 72 per cent.
Comment on this
This Bill makes attendance compulsory on 180 days, taking off these ten-day periods. The children must go to school for 180 days and that is a very considerable advance. Deputy Johnson and Deputy Thrift should look at the matter in a reasonable light. The people should be convenienced as far as possible. In that way, you will make the community satisfied. If they are not satisfied, it may not be possible to enforce the law. There are a large number of Statutes which it has been found in practice impossible to enforce. As regards Geneva, I have no love for Geneva. I believe the paragraphs read out by Deputy O'Connell were drawn up by some philanthropist who knows nothing at all about the actual facts.
Comment on this
I move Amendment 19:—
In sub-section (4), line 40, to delete the word `ten" and substitute "twelve."
Comment on this
I move Amendment 21:—
To delete sub-section (5) and substitute the following sub-section:—
"A school shall be deemed to be accessible to a child for the purposes of this section if it shall appear to a Justice of the District Court that it is possible for the child to attend the school daily without undue fatigue if the child shall walk, and if it be impossible for the child to walk that there is a suitable means of conveyance to the school from a point within a reasonable distance from the child's residence at a cost which shall not be excessive having regard to the means of the parent."
I do so for the purpose of getting the Minister's views on it. Throughout the section our main endeavour has been to find a suitable formula, and I suggest to the Minister that the formula laid down in this new section is, to some extent, an improvement on the formula laid down in the Bill. I hope that I shall have the support of Deputy Tierney, because the amendment tends to make a more elastic formula and to avoid construction and a strait-jacket. The Minister's proposal lays down different ages and distances. The question whether a school is accessible or not will be regarded in reference to these ages and distances. I do not believe you can lay down a hard and fast line in the matter Some children of under ten years are stronger and more fitted to walk long distances than other children over ten. I have two boys aged 11 and 9. I would back the boy of 9 to walk the other off his feet. The District Justice, under my amendment, will be allowed to take points like these into consideration. Again, some roads are longer than other, even though the distance is the same. That may be a "bull," but it is a statement of fact. A hilly, muddy road, or a footpath across wet, heavy fields would certainly be more fatiguing to a child than a hard metalled road. That is a point that could be taken into consideration under my amendment. The District Justice would be in a position to say whether a child suffered undue fatigue or not. My amendment would allow the District Justice to take into consideration all relevant facts, such as the physical health of the child, as distinct from illness, the state of the roads, etc.
There is an appendix to the amendment as regards the point where there is a suitable means of conveyance. The Bill lays down that if a suitable means of conveyance exists it must be used, whatever the cost. It may frequently happen that a man may have two children attending a school, and that one of the 'buses on the new motor 'bus services we have growing up in the country passes the door of the school. If the distance from the home of the children to the school is more than two miles it is quite conceivable that the fare for each child on the single journey may be threepence. I do not think children are taken on these 'buses at half price. That would mean that for the two children of this man their 'bus fare to and from the school would be a shilling a day, or five shillings a week. Assuming that he is an agricultural labourer earning twenty-six shillings a week, the 'bus fare for his children to school would prove to be a very severe tax on him. These are points that I put before the Minister for his consideration. I am not passionately enamoured of the form of words I have used in the amendment, but I do think that something a little more elastic than the two miles or three miles for under ten or over ten is needed.
We have been repeatedly told that hard cases make bad law. I hold that quotation is a misquotation so far as the law is concerned. It refers to the law courts, and not to the legislature. If a judge was to let himself be guided, not by the law and not by decided cases that reflect and assign the limits of statute law, but by his sympathies and his feelings, then, indeed, you do get bad law. I think the point for the legislature—the body that makes laws but does not administer them—is to consider all the hard cases beforehand. Make your law such that if possible hard cases will not arise. I urge on the Minister to accept, if not this amendment, at least the principle embodied in it, and not to insist on sub-section (5) in the Bill.
Comment on this
What I feel about the amendment is that it tends to a loosening of the Bill. I feel it might be used as a method for getting out of the provisions of the Act. I approach it with the same objection that I had for some amendments moved earlier to this particular section. One point does strike me in connection with what Deputy Cooper has said and that is the question of fares. I do think even where there is a suitable means of conveyance, that that might be read by the District Justice without reference to the fares in paragraph (b) of sub-section (5). It is an interpretation to which these particular words are open. On the whole, I am not inclined to accept the amendment as it stands for the reason that I have stated. I do not like, where excuses of this kind are mentioned, to have too great looseness. I will undertake to look into the point, if the Deputy is satisfied, to see whether something could not be done to meet the special point about reasonable cost.
Comment on this
I accept the Minister's undertaking. In looking into the matter I would ask him to consider one more fact, namely, the definite stipulation as to so many miles. This, I think, will almost certainly lead to interminable disputes. Who is to decide how many miles a child's home is from the school? You are not likely, I think, to find milestones adjacent to every school house. Is it the members of the Civic Guard who are to measure the distance? I can imagine the child's parent coming along and saying: "Not at all; I am three miles and more from that particular place. The distance was always regarded as more than three Irish miles." That is a point that I think ought to be given consideration. I admit that the Minister has not had much time to think over this or any other measure, but I would ask him to give his mind to this in the interval and consider how it will work out. As far as I can see, the onus in this case, though in no other case, will rest on the Civic Guards or the prosecuting authorities. How the miles are to be determined, whether off the ordnance map or in what other way, will, it seems to me, give rise to a serious administrative problem.
Comment on this
I recognise the spirit in which this amendment is drafted, and think it is one that should get some attention. I am rather in favour, however, of the practical working out of what is in the Bill than of what is suggested in the Deputy's amendment. The Deputy stated that this question of distance would lead to interminable disputes. I do not think so. That, in my opinion, would be a much easier question to settle than, say, the question whether the child had suffered undue fatigue in walking to school. I think we need not worry very much over this matter of distance, because, with the exception of a few areas, the great majority of children would not have to walk considerable distances. The point, I think, is covered already, because it is open to the District Justice to decide whether or not the child has a reasonable excuse, and, of course, he will take all these things into account. If the parent is able to prove that the attendance of the child at the school does, in fact, put too much of a strain on him, and if he is able to produce a medical certificate in support of his statement, of course he would not be convicted. I think it would be better to leave in the definite two or three miles so that the parent would have an idea, generally speaking, of what he is expected to do. Otherwise, in the case of children who would not in reality suffer undue fatigue, it might be urged by parents anxious to keep them at home for other reasons, that it would entail undue fatigue on them. For that reason I prefer what is in the Bill. I agree with Deputy Cooper on the point he made as to the question of fares. I think that is one that might be looked into. I think what was in the minds of the framers of the Bill as regards suitable conveyances was that this referred only to those places in which conveyances were got up specially for bringing the children to school. This point that Deputy Cooper has mentioned about 'buses and fares is one that might be looked into.
Comment on this
I am as anxious as Deputy O'Connell that there should be no loop-holes left in the Bill. I had thought, in the case of a child absent from school and that the father urged the child suffered from physical fatigue, it would have been sufficient for the prosecution to prove that the child had been planting potatoes with him all day. The father can now get up and say that he has it on the authority of an eminent Deputy in the Dáil that planting potatoes is less fatiguing than walking to school. I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 23, which stands in the name of Deputy Heffernan:—
In sub-section (5) (a), line 47, after the word "path" to insert the words "which path is a public right of way."
I think there is a good reason for this amendment. We know that it is customary for school children to go across fields and also over paths, which may not be public paths, to school. If you establish, say, that the distance from a child's house to the school is two miles by a certain route, the route being over a path which is not a public path, and that a disagreement, as we know often happens, arises between the neighbours as to the use of this path, it may mean that the children will have to change their course and thereby add a half a mile to the distance that they are obliged to travel. In a case such as that, the question would arise as to what was the real distance from the house to the school. I think if this amendment is inserted it will get over the possibility of the uncertainty likely to arise if the section is left as it is.
Comment on this
I am afraid it would be inadvisable to accept this amendment. I see Deputy Baxter's point, but there is another thing to be considered. The section speaks of the distance being measured to the nearest public road or public path.
Comment on this
I think that it was intended to mean that Deputy Baxter is right. Otherwise there would be no point in the amendment.
Comment on this
There would. Even then the wording of the amendment would be wrong. I assumed that it meant public path. There might be public paths over which there are not rights of way. I will give an instance. I went to school by a path across fields, but there was no public right of way. That was definitely established. If I had to go by the public road the distance would be multiplied by three miles. Take an individual case where a parent might say: "I will not send my child to school." That person might be within a half mile of the school by sending the child along a path over which there was no right of way. He might argue that the school was inaccessible if the child had to travel three miles over the public roads. Although his neighbour's children travelled that way, and while there was no objection to them doing so, still, if Deputy Baxter's wording was put in, and if there was no public right of way over the path, a parent might argue that he was not within accessible distance of the school. I think if the words "public path" were put in, without mentioning the right of way, it would meet Deputy Baxter's point. For instance, if a parent is summoned for not sending a child to school, and if he can show that his child is not at liberty to travel by the path, and if he goes by another route he has to travel over the specified distance, I do not see how he could be convicted. I do not think there is any necessity for altering the language. To put in the words "over which there is a right of way" would immediately give rise to all sorts of disputes, possibly as to rights of way, where such a question has never been raised. There are numerous instances where children travel to school across fields over which there is no right of way. If these words are put in, if a parent wants to keep a child at home, they will be inclined to take advantage of it.
Comment on this
I am not quite sure if there is a distinction in law between public path and a path over which the public has a right of way.
Comment on this
Is there? Really the situation is that if you put in this amendment it may be pleaded that the path is not a public right-of-way, and the onus would be on the Gárdaí to prove that it was a public right-of-way. That might be a very difficult thing, and in nineteen out of twenty cases might not really affect the merits of the case. I think the question might be left to the good sense of the Gárdaí on the one hand and the District Justice on the other. If the child did not use a particular path I do not see how a District Justice could entertain the case or convict where the school was not within two miles distance. This is a question that must be left to the discretion and good sense of the enforcing authorities on the one hand and the District Justice on the other.
Comment on this
I want to point out that if you leave the section as it is, to measure what is the shortest road or path, you would give a definite direction to the justice. While the section is so worded, it is what the justice must act on in law. Difficulties exist in the country, and the children of neighbours who might be on good terms to-day might not go the same way to school to-morrow. That must be recognised.
Comment on this
That is a point that did not strike me before. It is not a question as to the road the child may choose, but as to how the distance may be measured. If the word "available" was put in——
Comment on this
The point in the amendment is that while a parent may have a well-founded objection to sending a child to a particular school he might send him to another school. There might be such reasons, some of which were mentioned yesterday.
Comment on this
I think there is a slight misconception on the part of the Deputy who put down the amendment. This section does not deal with the school that the child is to attend. It deals with the school attendance area in which the child lives and with the officer who has to look after the child. A child may live in one school attendance area and go to school in another.
Comment on this
I am glad the Minister made that plain as there was a misconception about the section. It was thought that there was some intention to define the school rather than the school area. Of course there is no such intention in the Bill as to take from the parent the undoubted right he has to send the child to any school he chooses. I think the misconception has arisen by putting what is contained in Section 6 before Section 9. Section 9 deals with the school attendance area. I think it is well to make it plain that there is nothing in the Bill which would take away from the parent the right to send a child to any school he chooses.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider the desirability of putting in some words referring to Section 9?
Comment on this
In some cases it might be easier for a parent to give notice personally to the teacher or the school attendance officer other than in writing. That is the reason for the amendment.
Comment on this
I understand the difficulty about the clause as it stands. The parent might not be able to write. That will turn up again in connection with another amendment from Deputy O'Connell. He is proposing that the teacher shall be notified. Here it is somewhat different. I think it would fulfil the condition if the parent went into the Gárdaí barracks. Remember there are forms there which the Gárdaí will fill in. It is an ordinary legal requirement that the matter should be in writing. `Or otherwise" might be too vague.
Comment on this
I will consider whether some words as "in writing or in person "might meet the situation. It would not do for some one to go into the Gárdaí barracks and say: "We have changed. We are now in another attendance area." I will consider some phraseology which will make an attempt to cover it.
Comment on this
If the Deputy departs from writing there will be trouble in the future. Only by writing can you have a proper record. I grant that there may be occasions where writing may be a difficulty. At present that difficulty exists and assistance might be given in such cases at the barracks.
Comment on this
Perhaps if the "in writing" were left out it might meet the situation. I can quite conceive a case where a man, instead of writing, might drop into the Gárdaí station and say: "We have left this area."
Comment on this
I move:—
To add a new sub-section after sub-section (3) as follows—
(4) Except in case of change of residence or with the special consent of the Minister a parent desiring to transfer a child to whom this Act applies from one national school to another national school may do so only at the beginning of the quarter commencing the 1st day of January, the 1st day of April, the 1st day of July, or the 1st day of October.
This amendment was put down to meet a difficulty peculiar to the city areas. It provides where changes are made from one school to another, they should only be made within a specific time— that is, at the beginning of each quarter. Of course, where there is a change of residence there is special provision made. It would not apply in such a case. I have even protected the interests of the parent to a further extent where there might be special reasons why a parent should move his child from one school to another. I have said: "except in cases of change of residence or with the special consent of the Minister, a parent desiring to transfer a child from one national school to another may do so only at the beginning of the quarter commencing the first day of January, the first day of April, the first day of July, or the first day of October."
I have received many complaints, from teachers in Dublin especially, and to some extent from teachers in Cork, and from school attendance officers too. of the habit of some children shifting about, two or three times within a quarter, from one school to another. Often this is a dodge to evade compulsory attendance, because it takes the school attendance officer some time to trace the school to which the child has gone. The school the child has left has no notification where the child has gone to and because of that fact many school days are lost. It is a matter of convenience which will not inflict injustice on anyone, and it will make for a smoother working of the Attendance Act.
Comment on this
I have no objection to accepting this amendment. I think there is much to be said for it. I will consider the drafting, however.
Comment on this
In the absence of Deputy Heffernan I move "to delete section 7." The section deals with the restriction on the employment of children. It seems to me to be a very wide power to confer on a Minister that he could prohibit the employment of children, and, in particular, that he may, in furtherance of that object by regulations, prohibit or restrict the employment of such children in particular occupations. I should like to get from the Minister some justification for the inclusion of this section in the Bill. I should also like to know whether or not it is not possible for some future Minister for Education, such as Deputy O'Connell in the Labour Government, to prohibit the employment of children even during the ten days' grace we have in Section 4 during agricultural operations. The Minister could exercise wide and unlimited powers under the principle we have adopted in Section 4, and I should like the Minister to give some justification for its inclusion in this section at this stage.
Comment on this
If the child does not attend during the school hours, in the years which he is, by this Act, expected to attend in, he commits a breach of the law. The parent is guilty. The employer is an accomplice and is guilty also. The accomplice is getting some value out of it, and I do not see why the accomplice should not be punished as well as the parent. It refers only to the time at which the child was bound to attend school, not to any other period. Because this is a Compulsory School Attendance Bill, that is sufficient ground to justify a provision of this kind. There are two guilty; one is the parent and the other is the employer. Both are equally guilty. Why let off the employer who commits a breach of the law and punish the other party? If the Deputy considers it for a moment he will see there is plenty of justification for the insertion, in this Bill, of this section. It is put in not as a regulation of employment, but as a corollary of our school attendance regulations and nothing else. It is as an effort to remove the temptation to avoid attendance at school that this section is inserted.
Comment on this
Sub-section (2) says "any person who employs a child in contravention of a resolution made under this section shall be guilty of an offence under this section." Does not that mean that you more or less insist that the employer shall ascertain the age of the child?
Comment on this
I find it very hard to agree with the principle of this section. The child may look older than its years. A child may be thirteen and may be easily taken to be sixteen years of age. Are the employers to go to a registry office to get a birth certificate or are they to insist upon the production of a certificate from the child? If the appearance of the child is such as to warrant a person regarding the child as older and above the school age I do not see why such a person should be subject to the infliction of a penalty.
Comment on this
There is no substance in the argument of Deputy Connor Hogan. I think it is proper that in this Bill the same facilities should be available for obtaining information by the employer as in the case of employers in regard to the National Health Insurance and Unemployment Insurance. I think that if people exploit child labour for any purpose they should be penalised.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will not accept this amendment, because there are many employments which are profitable to parents and into which they could send their children under the age which might escape observation if not carefully gone into. I think the Minister should have the power to look into matters like the employment of children in pantomime and cinema shows and places of that description. Many children are employed in pantomimes at a particular period of the year and in cinemas at any time. These are two classes of employment into which parents might send their children for the purpose of making a certain amount of money, greatly to the detriment of the children if the matter was not seen into. I see the Minister has power under this section to inquire into this sort of thing and do away with any irregularity if such exists, and I hope he will hold by Section 7 as it stands.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I beg to move Amendment 28:—
In sub-section (2), line 47, after the word "pounds" to add the words "in respect of each day or part of a day on which the child is so employed."
I look upon the offence with which this amendment deals as a serious one, and I think we ought to treat it as something serious, and we ought to look upon it as a thing that is not merely accidental. If the child is employed, and if there is a continuous employment, every day of such employment should be treated as a separate offence.
Comment on this
I am not quite sure whether the fines laid down here are in accordance with those for breaches of the Factory Act, which are of a kindred character. But it would seem unwise to have a breach for an offence under one Act dealt with more heavily than a breach under another Act. Before the Minister determines what penalty should be laid down I suggest that some inquiry should be made.
Comment on this
I feel that the punishments under the Bill are quite drastic enough. I think it would be unreasonable, for instance, in the case of an employer, employing a child for five days, to fine him £25. It would seem to be altogether out of proportion to the offence. I am quite willing that the employer should be fined and punished for such an offence, but there should be a certain proportion between the offence committed and the punishment inflicted.
Comment on this
My whole point is that employment on successive days should not be treated as one offence, but that employment on each day, or part of each day, should be treated as a separate offence.
Comment on this
I think that would be met by the case coming before the magistrate. If he continues the offence he could be prosecuted a second time, but I think he should be prosecuted each time for each offence. The same point arises in connection with Deputy Johnson's amendment in regard to the attendance at school—not quite the same point, perhaps—but he has an amendment down to delete the fourteen days' grace.
Comment on this
I beg to move Amendment 29:—
In sub-section (3) to delete all words from "any child," line 48, to the words "apply to," line 51, inclusive.
The section would then read: "This section shall not apply to or prevent the exercise of manual labour by a child lawfully detained in a certified industrial or reformatory school," etc. The amendment seeks to delete the exemption of children now employed, although under the age of twelve years. We are all agreed, I think, that even children that are at present employed at that age should be required to attend school, and while there might be a good defence that would satisfy the magistrate that no penalty, or severe penalty, should be inflicted, nevertheless, it should be treated as an offence, and the proper kind of discipline enforced on the parents as well as upon employers of children of tender age.
Comment on this
I strongly support the amendment, because, owing to the laxity of the laws up to the present many children left school at a very early age and went into employment. Section 2 of the Act of 1892 lays it down that a person shall not take into his employment in any place to which the section applies any child, except for the setting and planting of potatoes, hay-making, and harvesting, under 11 years of age, who has not got the necessary certificate. That plainly only prevents employers taking into employment children under 11 years of age, but even if it can be urged that the child is employed for hire or gain for the purpose of setting or planting potatoes or harvesting, there is no limitation to the age so far as I can see. In that Act there is no limitation of age. A child could be taken into employment at any age so far as it could be said he is taken into employment for the purpose of planting and setting potatoes or for harvesting. The Dáil has decided that up to the age of 12 years there will be no exemption from school, but if this sub-section is passed in the form in which it is, all those children who may have left school at any age up to 12—and, as we know, numerous children did and were taken into employment—will possibly, seeing this Act coming along, try to get employment, and will be deprived of the advantages the Bill will confer if they are allowed to remain in employment instead of being sent back to school. The amendment is very important, and I hope the Minister will accept it. We should not neglect these unfortunate children who have been taken away from school at such early ages and sent to employment. There will be many children over the ages of 14 years or 16 years who can be employed to fill their places, and no hardship will be done in sending the children back to school.
Comment on this
I am not sure the Deputy is reading this particular section correctly. As I understand the section, it only refers to children to whom a special order is made. Sub-section (1) of Section 7 states that "The Minister may by order make regulations for prohibiting the employment of children to whom this Act applies, at such times or places, or in such manner as to prevent or interfere with their attendance at school." It is to that particular section I take it that this exemption refers. Supposing the Minister makes a general order in connection with the children in any area, and that some children in that area have been already employed for a couple of years, would it not be very undesirable that they should have to leave that employment? I do not know exactly what the nature of the order made under this would be. It might be an order affecting children up to 16 years of age. There is no age mentioned in Section 7, and I might as well argue that the order under Section 7 would apply up to 16 years of age. Assuming an order was made that no children should be employed under 16 years of age, would it not be exceedingly undesirable that a child at that age who had been in employment for four years, or, say, apprenticed——
Comment on this
It might, because at the moment the Bill is very lax, and this might be an order made after the bringing into force of this Bill, and in that way we might do a very serious injury in connection with this proposal. There is certainly no limitation to 12 years of age. The age has to be fixed under Section 7.
Comment on this
There is an aspect of this I overlooked in speaking. The Minister is empowered to make regulations which may at some future time reach the age of 16 years. Those regulations may have to deal with the attendance at continuation or technical schools, and they may allow for the employment of children in such circumstances, provided they attend some course of tuition. But if those children are in employment at present no regulations that the Minister may make in the future can be held to apply to them. In a year's time, say, if the Minister desired to make certain regulations regarding the attendance of children in certain districts up to the age of 15 years he could not make any such regulation applicable to any boy or girl who is in employment now. I think that is the effect of sub-section (3), because the regulations he is empowered to make cannot apply to any child who, before the commencement of the Act, has been in lawful employment as long as he continues in that employment.
Comment on this
Until we see the new Section 4 I think it is impossible to reply to Deputy Johnson, but the intention with regard to Section 4 was that where it could be done children of the age of 14 years who were in employment were to continue in employment until they reached the age of 16 years, but they were also to continue such courses as the Minister would decide on. Section 7 only deals with special regulations which it may be desirable to make by reason of some occupation, or of something in the district. The Minister may think it desirable to make a special order, but that would not affect the ordinary force of the new Section 4 in my opinion.
Comment on this
There is one aspect of this that I am rather surprised that neither Deputy Good nor Deputy Johnson referred to owing to their general position on these matters and also owing to certain things that occurred within the last couple of days. This is really retrospective legislation. I understood it was a very serious thing to have anything of the kind except for the gravest possible reason. Here is an existing contract, and if you make this retrospective——
Comment on this
The amendment. The amendment would have the effect of making the Bill, if retrospective, affect existing contracts. Undoubtedly it breaks existing contracts. It makes them illegal. I did not think that Deputy Good would be in favour of that.
Comment on this
I was surprised that this aspect of the matter had not dawned on Deputy Good with all his respect for the sanctity of contracts. I think it is a bad thing to break contracts already in existence. These contracts are in existence if the child is in employment. If the child goes out of that employment and goes into the employment of another, then the clause will refer to that child. There cannot be a new contract, but the existing sub-section only guards the existing contract. If the Deputy considers the matter he will find that it will not affect very many cases, and year by year these cases will grow less —less from the growth of the children on the one hand and less from the ceasing of the particular employment in which the child is engaged. I do not think there is sufficient reason to so amend this Bill that it will have the effect of retrospective legislation so far as existing contracts are concerned.
Comment on this
I must say that I am not able to appreciate the point about retrospective legislation. If the child is employed to-day, we are not saying that he is not employed. We are simply saying that for the future he must attend school.
Comment on this
I do not think there is any contract at all in the case of children under fourteen years of age, beyond a week. It is only from week to week. I do not think that this is quite so important as perhaps Deputy O'Connell thinks. I do not think that it is going to affect any great number of children for any great length of time, but I do press the point that I made, notwithstanding Deputy Good's doubts. Sub-section (1) said that the Minister may make regulations affecting the employment of children to whom this Bill applies. Now the Bill may apply to children in certain circumstances up to the age of sixteen, and I would hope that before very long you would have embodied in the law or regulations some provision which would say that a child would be at school or in some occupation, and, if in some occupation, that at least in some part of his weekly career he will be receiving some instruction. Now, assuming that as a future development, which is to be brought about by Regulation or Order——
Comment on this
Under the coming new section, whatever it may be. I imagine it is going to be quite loose. The Minister is being empowered in this section to make Orders and Regulations respecting the employment of children. If he conceives of making an Order which shall affect children who are at present in employment, he will be prohibited under this sub-section (3) from making any Order affecting those children. I ask the Minister to think over that point before the next stage, but I will not press the amendment.
Comment on this
This section refers to the Minister and Regulations, but I do not think it refers to a child at all. I would ask the Minister to consider also whether such a Regulation should not apply to children.
Comment on this
This section gives power to the Minister to make Orders which will practically create offences, and it might be well to consider whether the Bill could not contain a provision by which such Order would be laid before the House for the statutory period.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy has anticipated what I was going to say. I believe that an Order under this section should be laid on the Table of the House and that an amendment is necessary to that effect. I believe also that in sub-section (2) the phrase "any person who employs a child in contravention of a regulation made under this section," would be improved by inserting the word "knowingly." The section would then read: "Any person who knowingly employs a child in contravention of a regulation made under this section." Notwithstanding the superior wisdom of Deputy Murphy, I am still of opinion that this thing can lead to abuse and that an employer quite unconsciously, as he believes he is acting in a right spirit, can be penalised because he has not gone to extreme steps to verify the age of a child. I feel, too, that when we are giving very wide and very extensive powers to some future Minister of Education, who need not necessarily be a member of the Executive Council, regulations which he makes under this section may be in conflict with the policy of the Executive Council as directed by its Minister for Industry and Commerce and that there is a cogent reason that every regulation made by the Minister should be laid on the Table of each House of the Oireachtas for its approval. I would ask the Minister to consider that.
Comment on this
I do not know whether it is desirable to tie the hands of the Minister too tightly on these matters. Of course we can err in that direction also, because it may happen that an Order may be necessary and the House may not be sitting. If that Order were not put into force until the House sat and approved of it, other difficulties might arise.
Comment on this
I did not mean to suggest that. The Order can come into effect at once but the matter can be raised in connection with that Order inside the usual period.
Comment on this
I will consider Deputy Mulcahy's point. In regard to the point raised by Deputy Connor Hogan, he should know that if a person goes into a public house during illegal hours—when I was learning law I learned that, and I suppose he knows it now—it is no defence for the publican to say that he did not know the people were in the house.