We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

PUBLIC BUSINESS. - SCHOOL ATTENDANCE BILL, 1925—REPORT STAGE.

Contributions 1–123 of 241. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill School Attendance Bill, 1925
Enacted

No. 48 of 1925 ›

Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

In connection with the amendments, there was some misunderstanding to the effect that the amendments to the Schedule, dealing with the insertion of certain words, would all be automatically repeated. That was incorrect. Deputy D'Alton has given notice to move amendments about Clonmel and Tipperary, and other Deputies desire to oppose an amendment that was on the Paper before dealing with the Borough of Kilkenny.

Comment on this
Prof. John Marcus O'Sullivan MINISTER for EDUCATION (Professor O'Sullivan) Cumann na nGaedheal

I move Amendment 1:—

In page 3, Section 2, line 2, after the word "means" to insert the words "and includes," and in line 3 after the word "years" to add the words "and every other child to whom this Act is for the time being applied by virtue of an order made by the Ministry under the power in that behalf hereinafter conferred on him."

This amendment is really necessitated by the new Section 23 which was introduced at a rather late stage on the last Committee Stage of the Bill. It is purely a drafting amendment to make provision that this Act shall apply not merely to children from the age of 6 to 14, but also in the case of other children over the age of 14 who, by order of the Minister, will come within the Act under this new section. I think Amendment 2 is designed to meet the same purpose.

Comment on this

One of the weaknesses of this amendment is that it is quite indefinite as to when it will be put into operation. Of course it is recognised that it will be possible to put this provision into operation much earlier in some areas than in others. It is desirable that, wherever possible, it should be put into force at the earliest moment. It would be well, I think, if we had an assurance from the Minister as to the course that is likely to be followed by the Department in connection with this matter.

Comment on this

What the Deputy says is perfectly true, that it may be possible to put this into operation much earlier in some districts than in others. There are some areas in which we may have to wait for a very long period before it can be put into operation. A certain number of inquiries will have to be made as to the state of affairs in different areas. I can assure the Deputy that, wherever possible, there will be no unavoidable delay in exercising the powers conferred by the section.

Comment on this

I move Amendment 3:

In page 3, section 4 (2), paragraph (a), to delete all from the word "or" in line 19 to the end of the paragraph, and at the end of the sub-section to add a new paragraph as follows:—

"(d) That the child has been prevented from attending school by some other sufficient cause."

Comment on this

The only explanation I can give about this amendment is that it is the best we could do to meet the wishes of the House as expressed the last day.

Comment on this

It is certainly an improvement on the original.

Comment on this

If any Deputy thinks that there is a better way, I should like him to put forward his views, and I can assure him they will be sympathetically considered.

Comment on this

I suppose the District Justice will be the judge in this matter?

Comment on this

I am afraid we must depend on the District Justice. I do not see how we can get out of that in the administration of any provision of this kind.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

As I raised the matter on the last day, I desire to say that I believe the Minister has got about the best form of words that could be got to meet the particular case. So far as I am concerned, I am satisfied. As Deputy Good has said, it is an improvement on the original.

Comment on this

I move Amendments 4 and 8, as they deal with the same matter.

4.—In page 3, Section 4 (3), line 29, to insert before the word "The" the words "Until the year 1936."

8.—In page 3, Section 4 (4), line 36, to insert before the word "The" the words "Until the year 1936."

This may not be considered a very practical proposition, but the amendments are put forward simply as a matter of principle. I dislike the proviso in these sub-sections, and the amendments are moved to indicate in the Bill that we are yielding to the force of circumstances in allowing the proviso to stand. I understand that the amendments are not likely to be opposed from the benches that opposed on the last day the removal of the whole proviso. I do not press the amendments strongly, but I bring them forward as a matter of principle.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

As one who does not wish to see sub-sections (3) or (4) in the Bill. I support Deputy Thrift's amendments. If we cannot get rid of them altogether, the best we can possibly hope for is to get rid of them in ten years' time.

Comment on this

I support the amendment, as it mitigates the evil.

Comment on this

I support the amendment because the section, as it stands at present, invites people in different parts of the country, where no necessity for keeping children at home exists, to keep them at home. Some note introduced into the clause that will suggest in some way that it is really objectionable and that we hope to overcome that objectionable position within a certain time, will be very valuable not only in bringing the conditions to an end at that particular period of time, but in restricting the possible bad effects of the section at present.

Comment on this

I was waiting for some light from the benches that spoke so eloquently on this matter on the last occasion. They have been referred to; they have been almost invited by Deputy Thrift to give the amendment their support. I agree with Deputy Thrift that it is not a very practical amendment from the point of view of legislation at the present time. The Deputy said it was a matter of principle. It seems to me as if we were ashamed of what we did last time and were trying now to get out of it. I want to explain that if I leave this amendment to the House I am not a bit ashamed of what we did the last time. I do not think there is any necessity for this amendment. Personally, I would prefer to let the year 1935 legislate for the year 1936 and that we should not legislate for it now. Beyond the dislike that I have to legislating ten years ahead and, if I might so put it, pretending to be somewhat better than we are, I have no insuperable objection to the amendment. If the Dáil desires to accept it, I shall not put any obstacles in its way, but, so far as most of us are concerned, it is like the man who plants the seedling of the oak.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

The amendment serves the purpose mentioned by Deputy Mulcahy. It shows that, in putting in this section, we are merely making a concession to existing circumstances.

Comment on this

That was the best argument put forward.

Comment on this

I wonder would it be possible to be a little more precise and to say "in deference to wishes expressed by certain Deputies on the Farmers' Benches."

Comment on this

Would Deputy Thrift put into the amendment "the 1st January, 1936"?

Comment on this

I had that written originally, but, when I looked into the Bill, I found that the clause only operates in April and October.

Comment on this

I move Amendment 5:

In page 3, Section 4 (3), line 31, to delete the words "1st day of April" and substitute the words "17th day of March."

Comment on this

Deputies may remember that there was considerable discussion on this matter on the last occasion. The view was put forward from the Benches that I am now looking at and by some of the Deputies that were then there, that some effort should be made to meet the agricultural needs of the country in this connection. Various suggestions were made, and I promised to consider them. I definitely stated that though I promised to consider them, I could not promise that that consideration would lead to acceptance of the suggestion put forward—that we should extend the period at both ends, so to speak, or that we should take power to provide different periods for different parts of the country. I considered that matter very fully, and I came to the conclusion that it was impossible to meet, as I desired to meet, the views put forward by the various Deputies. That was so, for a variety of reasons. The too-great extension of the period would lead to difficulty in the enforcing of the Act by the enforcing authority. From the school point of view, it would be objectionable also. It did not seem to me that the alternative suggestion—to have different periods in different parts of the country—would work out well in practice. After due consideration, I came to the conclusion that the real economic argument was for exemption at the beginning. That is where the necessity comes in, especially in connection with the utilization of the fine weather in the spring to put down potatoes. In considering that, it became apparent that the date actually mentioned in the Bill, however it might suit County Cavan, for which Deputy Baxter spoke, would not suit other portions of the country, and that an earlier date was advisable for other portions of the country, owing to the urgency of getting the potato crop in when favourable weather would occur. That is the reason why I would like the Dáil to adopt the suggestion of the 17th March as the date on which the first of these periods shall begin. That is as far as I can reasonably go to meet what I consider the very plausible and reasonable views put forward by the Deputies representing farming interests and other Deputies on the last occasion.

Comment on this

Deputy Baxter made a very strong case as regards County Cavan. I dare say the same conditions exist in other counties of the Saorstát. That was the reason I, for one, urged that a difference should be made between those counties where child labour is largely employed and counties where it is employed to a very small extent. I think the Minister has met the point very fairly in fixing the 17th of March as the first of these dates. That would provide for the potato-planting period.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I have a general objection to the lengthening of this period, as I argued on the last day, but if the Minister is satisfied that it is necessary and that it meets a substantial claim advanced from the Farmers' benches, I will not press my opposition to the amendment.

Comment on this

The argument was put forward that children might be useful in thinning the turnips at a later period. Two things helped me to come to a decision on that. First, the small farmer, whom we had particularly in mind, would be very little affected by that, and then, at the later period of the year, the evenings are long and there is not the same urgency that there would be about the harvest at the later portion of the season or about the setting of the potatoes at the other period.

Comment on this

It was more in the interests of labour that I made that suggestion. This is the time that children could earn a considerable sum of money ("No"). It would be in the interests of the farmers, but it would be more in the interest of the parents of the children that they should earn money at that time, as they can earn it in my part of the country.

Comment on this

I am afraid Deputy Conlan misunderstands the Bill somewhat and misunderstands the "No" which greeted his suggestion. Under the Bill, it is not possible for children to earn money as he suggests.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I move Amendment 6:

In page 3, Section 4, sub-sections (3) and (4), lines 32, 34, 39 and 41, to delete the word "child" and substitute therefor the word "boy."

This amendment has been put down following a close study of the arguments used during the debate that took place when we moved to delete sub-section (3) and sub-section (4). In effect, these clauses, which have been retained in the Bill, give power to keep children at home to do light agricultural work during certain periods of the year. One Deputy after another who spoke in favour of the retention of the clauses referred to the usefulness of a young lad of 12 or 13 years of age in putting down potatoes or in helping to gather the crops. I want to secure, by this amendment, that these clauses will apply only to the young lads of 12 or 13 years and that they will not affect the girls of that age—in other words, that young girls of 12 or 13 years will not be exempted from attendance in order to engage in light agricultural work. I do not think there will be many Deputies who will advocate that young girls of 12 or 13 years should engage in light agricultural work. I, therefore, feel certain that there will be no difficulty in accepting this amendment.

Comment on this

I cannot quite agree with Deputy O'Connell, and I am afraid I cannot accept the amendment. He says a young lad might be very useful. A young lass might be quite as useful. I am not going to attack this problem from the point of view that it contravenes the Constitution in regard to sex distinction. I presume it does not. I will leave that aside and attack it from another point of view. Personally, I am not sure that it is not more desirable to have a girl of from 12 to 14 years engaged in light operations of this kind than to have her at school or even studying. I think it is a more natural and a more healthy thing that at that period of her life she should be relieved from going to school. I certainly would prefer that girls at that age should get a little more manual work than that boys should, from the mere health point of view. From the economic point of view, I do not think it would be fair that the small farmer who happens to be blessed with a number of daughters and who does not happen to be afflicted with any sons should be penalised as compared with his neighbour. I hope Deputy O'Connell, when he considers the arguments I have advanced, will not find it necessary to press his amendment.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I am rather amazed at this new theory advanced by the Minister as to what contributes to the health of children at the age of 12 years or thereabouts. It is the first time that I heard such a theory advanced. I would like to know whether this theory is a theory of the Minister's own or whether it is based on experience or medical reports or anything of that kind. I never heard the theory advanced before.

Comment on this

It is the result of vague discussions with medical men.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

The theory is quite new to me. As Deputy Corish reminds me, it has not been suggested even from the Farmers' benches.

Comment on this

They would never think of such a thing.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

They would not be so ingenious as to think of an argument of that kind. I can fancy parents quoting that in every District Court all over the country when they are brought up for having their girls running about the roads instead of being at school. The Minister for Education, they will say, thinks they would be better off from a health point of view, and health is the chief necessity. I hope he will tell us that he is not serious in putting forward that argument. I would be sorry if I thought he were, but I do not believe that he is. Of course, it can be said that a girl should be useful about the house at this time. I personally would not like to contemplate the general keeping at home of young girls and the putting of them to work on a farm at that particular time of the year. I do not think it is the right thing to do. I think they would be better off at school. I may point out that there is this advantage: Special attention might be given to the particular subject girls have to learn at school over and above what the boys learn. Girls have to do one extra subject, that is needlework. If, during this particular time of the year, boys were at home —and the vast majority of our schools are mixed schools—special attention could be paid to needlework. The Convention of Geneva says that it is only on the basis of vocational instruction that you could defend keeping them at home at all. I think it is not proposed or suggested that our women when they grow up should be engaged in actual farming operations as a vocation. I do not think, therefore, it could be said that if they are engaged in putting down potatoes in the spring they are engaged in vocational instruction. I think the amendment is a reasonable one, and, in all the circumstances, the Minister ought to accept it.

Comment on this

There is one aspect of this that I would like to refer to. I think we have to discuss this apart altogether from the question as to whether it is reasonable or not to keep young people of 12 or 14 years of age at home to do light agricultural work. Personally I think there would be very grave objections to differentiating between boys and girls in the matter of light agricultural work of that kind. Some of us have had opportunities in very poor parts of the country of seeing the conditions of persons on small holdings. One thing that struck us very much is that the difference between a fair measure of comfort on a small holding and very poor and straitened circumstances depends upon the whole outlook of the woman on the holding. If you have a woman of the house with an interest in the work of the holding, you have a comfortable home and a fairly comfortable living, whereas if the woman has not that interest you have neither comfort nor any kind of a fair living. I think it would be a great mistake to differentiate between boys and girls in the matter of engaging in agricultural work between 12 and 14, if you are going to have them engaging in it at all. On the matter of needlework I think that the danger of making this differentiation would be increased if you are going to make it for the purpose of teaching the lady of the house needlework. Training in needlework is very essential, but I think that ordinary and proper provision for it should be made in the ordinary course of the school year, without reference to the fact that girls should do it when the boys are putting down potatoes.

Comment on this

There is just one point that occurred to me in connection with this section and possibly it might be useful for the House to consider it. It has been pointed out on several occasions by those who are in touch with juvenile employment and those who register at the Exchanges for employment as juveniles, that there is a very much larger percentage of illiterates amongst the girls than amongst the boys. I do not know whether the Minister is aware of that, but that is a fact. That being so, it appears to me that it is essential that a protection in a Bill like this should be put in in favour of girls. The section says that they are only to be exempted from attendance at school while engaged in light agricultural work. What one is afraid of is that advantage will be taken of this section to keep these girls at home, and that instead of putting them at agricultural work which, as the Minister points out in certain circumstances, from a health point of view might be advantageous, it will possibly be found that the larger number of them will be employed at domestic work. I think that is an aspect of the question that ought to be considered, and I think on the whole, when one comes to consider it, that possibly the solution put forward by Deputy O'Connell has a good deal to commend it. It is very undesirable, I think, that parents should have the opportunity of making claims on the school time of children at the period when school time is of very great importance, and I would urge on the Minister that in view of the experience of those connected with juvenile employment all over the Saorstát—it is not confined to any particular area— that parents will try to keep the girls at home, because they are more useful at minding the younger children, and as I said, we must take steps to protect these girls against the inroads on the part of their parents.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will not give way on this amendment. I do not see why discrimination should be made between boys and girls. I do not believe that the statement as to the percentage of illiteracy being higher in the case of girls than in the case of boys applies to the areas occupied by small holders. I believe it would be more applicable to towns and cities than to these places. Deputy O'Connell talked also about girls being employed at domestic work. I think that cannot possibly be the case because domestic work in the rural areas is very slight in comparison with agricultural work, and girls of that age are just as useful at agricultural work as boys are. Apart from that, I think it should be very useful from the health point of view, if they are allowed to participate in hay-making work at that particular time of the year. I believe it is very suitable and will be very useful for them.

Comment on this

As regards the point raised by Deputy Good, it might be that in some of the towns there are more illiterates amongst girls than amongst boys, but I hope it is not suggested that by giving an extension that amounts to twenty days in the year, we are going to make an illiterate of a person that otherwise would not be an illiterate. I suggest that the most obvious explanation of illiteracy is the fact that people do not attend school. At least I hope that is the explanation. I think the education of the girls is not lower than the education of boys. On the whole it is rather the contrary; they reach a higher standard of proficiency than the boys in these matters. The argument that was stressed on the last day and that I have already referred to on an earlier amendment was the necessity of getting in the potato crop. That is the reason that I propose putting back the date from 1st April to 17th March, because the girls in that matter are quite as useful and as necessary as the boys. I think that Deputy O'Connell can scarcely combat that point of view. I am not quite sure exactly what Deputy O'Connell's picture of a small farmer's house in the country is.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I was reared in one.

Comment on this

The suggestion that women are not engaged in agricultural work may be true of one particular portion of the country, but it certainly is not so all over the country; they take a pretty considerable share in the work. The farmer's wife and the farmer's daughters play a very considerable part in the work, especially at these critical periods in the agricultural history of the year— the spring or the harvest. On the whole, I am afraid that we must keep to what is in the Bill, in this particular matter. Deputy Mulcahy has very clearly pointed out the necessity, so far as a number of people are concerned, for this.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I move:—

In page 3, Section 4, sub-sections (3) and (4), lines 35 and 42, to delete the words "for his parent" and substitute therefor in each case the words "on or about his parents' farm or holding."

This amendment is one that I will press much more strongly on the Minister, because I think it is one that is very necessary. It is proposed in this exemption clause that the reason for keeping the child at home should be that he is engaged in light agricultural work for his parent. I am proposing to substitute "for his parent""on or about his parent's farm or holding." This amendment more clearly and definitely expresses what was in the mind of the framers of this clause. I have gone to some trouble to examine somewhat similar legislation in other countries and I have never come across the phrase "for his parent," while phrases somewhat like the one I propose are used in legislation in most of the Canadian provinces and in the United States, where they do give such exemptions. There is no need to argue in favour of the amendment. The reasons for its acceptance seem to be self-evident. "For his parent" is very indefinite, and in my view does not meet the object which the framers of the clause had in mind. Neither does it fit in with the arguments used on the last occasion when it was carried. The whole argument then was that the parent should have the help of his child at this particular time, but putting in "for his parent" may mean quite a different thing, something that neither the framers nor supporters of the clause had in mind. This is a very reasonable amendment and I hope it will be accepted.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will accept this amendment. I do not think it can be said that it is unnecessary. There is a possible interpretation of the words "for his parent" which I do not think was intended. It does not seem to me that this proposed change really affects the substance, but it makes very much more clear and definite what is intended.

Comment on this

May I ask what is the interpretation?

Comment on this

I think it is quite open to say that the child is kept at home to work for his parent if his parent really lends him to work for someone else, for nothing if you like, but it may be for a consideration given otherwise.

Comment on this

If it were for a consideration given otherwise, that undoubtedly would be employment of that child by the other person.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

It would be impossible to establish that there was employment. That is my whole point. The child might be kept from school and sent by his parent to work somewhere else, and there would be consideration in kind. Some work might be done in return or a horse might be lent—there would be some consideration for the employment of the child. It would be impossible for anyone to establish satisfactorily that there was consideration given in that way or that there would be employment in such a case. On the other hand, if the amendment is accepted, if the child is engaged somewhere else it will be known at once that he was not complying with the law, as he would not be engaged about his parent's farm. It could be clearly established in that case that he was not complying with the law, whereas if you leave in "for his parent," no matter where the child is engaged when away from school, you are not in a position to say that he was not in fact "engaged in light agricultural work for his parent," because even if his parent sends him to work somewhere else he is engaged for his parent.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Connell must be aware that it is the custom all over the country for farmers to help one another at certain seasons, such as in the spring, and in the autumn at the threshing. If people were precluded from helping their neighbours in that way it would make matters difficult for them.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy argue that the words in the Bill "engaged in light agricultural work for his parent" would permit of the child being sent to work for a neighbour? That is the real danger.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

That is what I want to prevent.

Comment on this

That is the interpretation put on the clause by a Deputy on the Farmers' benches.

Comment on this

Deputy Baxter, when he brought forward this matter made it clear that it was absolutely necessary for small farmers who were not in a position to employ labour to have their children to help them at certain periods of the year. It was not his intention to allow children to be sent out for remuneration or consideration of one sort or another. What was clearly in the Deputy's mind was that these small farmers should be able to keep their children at home to help them because they were not in a position to employ labour at certain periods of the year. Therefore, I hope the Minister will accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I find myself somewhat in a difficulty, because I should have thought the words in the Bill in some respects were more satisfactory than those proposed in the amendment. In another connection I remember we had some other difficulty about the word "holding." It is exceedingly difficult, for instance, when a man lets land to another for eleven months to decide whose farm it is. I know we had that difficulty in connection with the Drainage Bill, and I think we deliberately avoided the word "holding." If we did not avoid it, I know it was a source of considerable difficulty as to how it should be interpreted. I must say that I would prefer the form of words in the Bill. However, as there will be a Report Stage I shall give consideration to the matter before then.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Will there be another stage?

Comment on this

As the Bill has been recommitted we will have to have a Report Stage. The only question is whether we shall take that stage to-morrow or later.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I thought we might take it this evening.

Comment on this

In that case, I do not feel inclined to accept the amendment at present.

Comment on this

The Minister believes that the intention of the words proposed is the same as those in the Bill. I take it that is his attitude, but that from a legal point of view he prefers the words in the Bill.

Comment on this

That was my main contention, but a point has been raised by Deputy Conlan. I had not considered whether there is a custom in the country such as he refers to. If there is a widespread custom of that type, I should like to have time to consider how far that should be recognised until this particular year—1936. It is not an aspect of the case that I have considered. My objection at the start undoubtedly was that I thought the words in the Bill were preferable to the words put forward by Deputy O'Connell, but now that another point has been raised by Deputy Conlan I should like to give it fuller consideration. I will confess that that also is in my mind as well as the other interpretation.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

It was to guard against this very kind of thing that I put down the amendment. There may be a custom of this kind in a few places, but it is the kind of custom that is responsible for the irregular attendance we have in the rural areas and it is a custom that, if recognised at all, would be open to very great abuse. Any child, whether he is required on his father's farm or not, could claim to be absent during those twenty days and plead this custom, and it would be very difficult for any District Justice to convict in a case like that. The parent might say: "I lent my boy to a neighbour to do some work." It is these very things that the amendment was put down to guard against and I would urge the Minister not to give any consideration to that matter. The plea originally made was that the small farmer would want the help of his children at certain periods of the year. That was the whole argument on which this claim was based, and that was the argument that was accepted by the Dáil, as Deputy D'Alton has rightly said. It was on that ground that this clause was retained. As Deputy Conlan has shown, the words "for his parent" might be interpreted as meaning working for a neighbour. We know that it would be impossible to establish employment in such a case, although it might be well known that there was a consideration given of one kind or another for the services of the child. That was the very reason that this amendment was put down, because it limits the employment of the child to the parent's farm. I do not think there will be any difficulty about these words. No claim can arise about land as under the Drainage Act. All the Justice will have to say is whether the child was engaged on his father's holding or not. If there was any doubt about the ownership of the particular field where he was working I am sure any sensible District Justice would not convict. I do hope the Minister will see that this amendment really expresses more clearly the intention of those who argued in favour of the retention of this clause and supported it on the last occasion than the words in the Bill, which are open to a very wide interpretation indeed.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Connell need not be apprehensive that there will be what he calls a lending out of the child. These exchanges of labour only occur between near neighbours, and, in fact, they only occur at all because the work cannot be effectively carried out except through a combination amongst small farmers for particular kinds of work at particular seasons of the year.

Comment on this

Can Deputy Conlan say that when help like that is exchanged in different parts of the country children under 14 are included as portion of the help?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

In the particular agricultural industry that we are acquainted with in the Northern area, the flax industry, a special class of weather is required and children do the work. It is work eminently suited to children, who would need to be available on any day that would be found suitable. Usually people engaged on this work find that they require the assistance of more children than their own and they procure the assistance of the neighbour's children. Similarly they would send their children to assist their neighbours. Work in connection with the flax industry is very important work. The interests of the agricultural community are served by having children engaged in the work and I do not think that for the matter of a day or two the interests of the children would be, to any great extent, affected. When engaged on the flax industry the children are training their hands and feet, and they require to train their hands and feet just as much as their brains. I think there is too little attention given to the training of the hands and feet and there is rather too much being hammered into the children's heads.

Comment on this

Deputy McGoldrick is adopting an attitude of frank opposition. It is an argument against the Bill as a whole.

Comment on this

Deputies who heard him speaking before and who have heard his speech now will realise that he is adopting an attitude of opposition to the Bill. The question now is one of whether we are going to encourage the hiring-out of children, let the hiringout be for money or for kind. I hope the House will agree that it is undesirable that parents should lend their children to do agricultural work, even in the districts Deputy McGoldrick speaks of, in defiance of the general purposes of the section as originally proposed. In the course of the discussion not one word was used in favour of this section except what implied that the work of the children was to be done on their parents' holding. Every argument used was in favour of that proposition. Now we find the idea germinating—and the Minister is giving some kind of encouragement to it—that the work should not be confined to the parents' holding, that the children should be lent about, transferred from one holding to another, and that the fullest advantage should be taken of the ten or twenty days' exemption.

There was a reasonable possibility that the twenty days mentioned in the Bill would not be needed, that only two, three or four days would be utilised, and there was a maximum period of ten days in spring and ten in autumn allowed. Now we are making it possible—even probable—that as between one farm and another the whole twenty days of abstention will be used because the children will be occupied in working for their parents and the friends of their parents. I hope the Minister will see that the argument for the section was an argument in favour of children working only on their parents' land. The object of the amendment is to make it quite clear that that purpose should be embodied in the Bill.

The contributions to this discussion show it is the desire of the opponents of the Bill and of those who are anxious for child labour on the land that children should be given as much exemption as possible. I hope the Minister will be firm in this matter and will not hesitate to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I should not like it to be understood that I am an opponent of the measure. I am in hearty accord with its object; there is nothing more needed than a Bill of this sort. At the same time, I would like to see sound legislation. I do not want legislation to be so watertight as to make it possible that the economic interests of the country and the physical requirements of the child might be overlooked. Such legislation would not serve the cause we all have at heart. That cause would be better served if we legislated in such a way as would tend towards the better development of the physical, economic and educational interests of the community.

Comment on this

It is not fair that Deputy Johnson should characterise the Deputies who took part in this discussion as opponents of the Bill. If he so alluded to me, I may say that I have not adopted an attitude of opposition.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

He did not mention that.

Comment on this

A very valuable point has been brought out by the putting down of this amendment. The discussion that took place in Committee on this Bill was on the basis that this work was for the parent. Having heard the discussion, a number of Deputies were influenced to vote for it, feeling that there was a pretty considerable possibility that the whole of the ten days in the spring and the ten days in the autumn would not be used up. If we are going to have the scope of the Bill widened to include people for whom the children can work, we are going to drift into a position in which the whole of the twenty days will be used up and the effect of that on the school work will be very great. If, from the 17th March to the 15th May, every child in the school, on varying days, is going to be absent for ten days, it will create a state of chaos for the teacher. If the scope over which the child can be employed under this section is going to be widened from what was understood in the original discussion, you open the whole question again.

Comment on this

It has been generally recognised, not only here but in the country, that this Bill was necessary because of the poor attendance at schools. The House, in its wisdom, has decided that there are to be certain days in the spring and autumn on which a child may be absent for the purpose of working for its parents. It must be understood generally that one of the causes of bad attendance at school has been this lending about of children from place to place. It is the children we have to consider; we must look to their future, and surely it is not in their interests to allow such a loophole as is provided in this section in the Bill? I hope the Minister will consider the amendment sympathetically. We all have the interests of the children at heart, and I think it would be very unfair to let this section stand as it is. I think it would be open to grave abuse. It might be very much abused and the very thing we want to prevent—bad attendance in the schools—would be increased or, at least, would not be improved in the slightest degree.

Comment on this

I confess I am more or less in the position I occupied when I last stood up to speak. A point has been raised that I have not given full consideration to. Deputy Conlan's point of view appears to be similar to the point of view stressed by Deputy McGoldrick. There are certain crops which, unless you get them in quickly at certain periods of the year, will stand little chance of being saved and great damage will thereby be done. I understand it is the custom for neighbours to help one another in the particular way suggested—by allowing their children to work. One man allows his children to work for his neighbour and the help is reciprocated. I would like to give fuller consideration to this matter and view it in all its bearings. I suggest that Deputy O'Connell could bring the matter forward again, when I will be in a position to deal with it more definitely. I cannot accept the amendment as it stands.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I am satisfied to bring it forward again if I am given an assurance that there will be an opportunity. Of course I accept the Minister's word.

Comment on this

It was understood that the Report Stage would not be completed to-day; therefore there would be sufficient time in which to consider this amendment.

Comment on this

There are other amendments down that may have to be reconsidered. Deputies will remember that quite a number of amendments were got through hurriedly on the last day. We would require some time to consider the Bill as it has been amended. Probably the Bill may stand as it is, but it is quite possible that there may be alterations elsewhere.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

On those conditions I am quite prepared to withdraw the amendment. I hope the Minister will not place any undue weight on this lending-out system that he has heard of. Crops may want to be saved at a certain time; but if all the crops have to be saved together where will be the advantage of transferring helpers? Deputy Conlan speaks of threshing. That is one of the things I never anticipated children would be engaged at.

Comment on this

Children are very useful there.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

They are very useful at a great many things. The intention of the House was not to allow children to remain from school for the purpose of engaging in such operations and they would be better out of them.

Comment on this

It is no place for them.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

That shows what dangers lie in leaving the section as it is. As Deputy Mulcahy rightly pointed out, there is danger in encouraging this lending about. As regards the anxiety to get in a crop, I would be sorry to think it would depend almost entirely on the labours of the children. The people who have passed the school age are the people who give most help on those occasions. I hope the Minister will see his way to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I think we began this discussion with the Minister believing that the actual legal force of the words as passed in Committee, taken in conjunction with other sections, was that the work must be for the parent at his own home. I hope he will bear that in mind.

Comment on this

I assure the Deputy I will bear that in mind. That was the impression I began with.

Comment on this

I do not know how the Minister is going to get all this information within the short space of two or three days. As Deputy McGoldrick, who seems to have impressed the Minister, may not be here when this matter comes before us again, I would like to say that the conditions in Donegal regarding the employment of child labour are notorious. The Minister should not allow himself to be impressed easily by the statements made in regard to Donegal. In many parts of Donegal children are hired out as early as the age of eight, and evidence was given that some were hired out even at a younger age. They are hired out and remain away for six months from their homes at work, such as herding cattle, for the sake of £3.

Comment on this

I do not agree with the statement that Donegal in regard to child labour is in any way exceptional as compared with the rest of the Saorstát.

Comment on this

Thank God it is.

Comment on this

Donegal has to stand a great deal of abuse from people who are only casually acquainted with the conditions there. These people who speak as if they knew all about the conditions there should be careful about making statements of that character. The people there have as great a love for education as those in any other county in Ireland, and probably have a great deal more than those in many cities and towns. I think it is wise to make special provision in order to allow these children to participate in work that is suitable to them and that has to be done at certain periods of the year.

Comment on this

On this point I would like to refer the Minister to the admissions of Deputy White, who is from Donegal, on the last occasion on which this subject was discussed here.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 3, Section 4 (4), line 36, to insert before the word "The" the words "Until the year 1936."

Comment on this

I move:—

In pace 3, Section 4 (5) (a), page 3, lines 47 and 48, to delete the words "along the shortest public road or path from the child's residence" and substitute the words "from the child's residence along the shortest way lawfully and conveniently available for him," and in line 50 to delete the words "from the child's residence."

Comment on this

This is to meet an amendment previously moved by Deputy Heffernan. I think, upon consideration, that this is the best way in which the situation would be met. I think that Deputy O'Connell had some objection to Deputy Heffernan's views on the matter. The amendment will, I think, meet Deputy Heffernan's views and also Deputy O'Connell's objection. It will also meet what we want to achieve in this particular section.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

What is the force of the word "conveniently"?

Comment on this

What is the trouble?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

The trouble is that it might be argued that it was a convenient way, if a boy had to cross a rough stile.

Comment on this

From many points of view a way might be inconvenient and might be extremely difficult. A short way, for instance, might be over a mountain. That might be within the requisite two miles, but it could hardly be said that a person was bound to measure the distance from the house to the school by a way leading over a steep mountain.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 4, Section 6 (2), line 22, after the word "writing," to insert the words "or in person."

Comment on this

This amendment is to meet the case of those people to whom Deputy Good is continually referring, namely, illiterates— those who are not able to write, or who have difficulty in writing.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 4, Section 6, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"(4) The parent of a child to whom this Act applies may transfer the child from one national school to another national school at any time either with the consent of the Minister or when the transfer is made because of a change of the ordinary residence of a child, but in any other case a child to whom this Act applies shall only be transferred from one national school to another national school on one of the following days, that is to say, the 1st day of January, the 1st day of April, the 1st day of July, or the 1st day of October."

Comment on this

This is a re-drafting of an amendment, the principle of which I accepted, from Deputy O'Connell on the last occasion.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

There is a matter that struck me since that, and perhaps the Minister might give it some thought. The amendment states that the child shall only be transferred from one national school to another national school on certain days. What happens if the school is not open on one of these particular days?

Comment on this

The transfer of the pupil takes place on that day.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

It may be argued that if a child is not transferred, say, on the 1st January, when there is no school, the teacher could not admit him afterwards. Perhaps something could be put in so as to indicate that what is intended is the first day on which the school is open.

Comment on this

I will consider that further between this and the next stage. The 1st April, for instance, may fall on a Sunday or some other day on which there is no school.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 4, Section 7 (3), lines 48 to 51, to delete all from the words "This section," line 48, to the words "apply to or" in line 51, and substitute the words "Regulations made under this section shall not prevent any child who immediately before the commencement of this Act is in lawful employment from continuing in such employment or."

Comment on this

This amendment is intended to meet the stylistic objections which Deputy Thrift raised the other day.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 4, Section 7, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"(4) Every regulation made under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made, and if a resolution is passed by either such House within the next subsequent twentyone days on which that House has sat annulling such regulation such regulation shall be annulled accordingly but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under such regulation."

Comment on this

This is to meet Deputy Mulcahy's point.

Comment on this

I move:—

In pages 5 and 6, Section 10, to delete sub-sections (2) to (6) and substitute seven new sub-sections as follows:—

"(2) In every school attendance area in the said county boroughs and urban districts there shall be a school attendance committee and the first school attendance committee in each of the said school attendance areas shall consist of the persons who immediately before the commencement of this Act were members of the school attendance committee appointed under the Irish Education Act, 1892, for that area and such persons shall hold office as members of the said first school attendance committee until the time prescribed by the Minister under this section for the commencement of the term of office of their successors.

(3) The members of each school attendance committee in the said school attendance areas (other than the members of the first school attendance committee and members appointed to fill casual vacancies) shall be appointed triennially at such times as shall be prescribed by the Minister under this section and shall (unless they previously die or resign) hold office for three years from the time prescribed by the Minister under this section for the commencement of their term of office.

(4) Every school attendance committee (other than the first school attendance committee) in each of the said school attendance areas shall, if a Juvenile Advisory Committee established by or under the control of the Minister for Industry and Commerce exists in the school attendance area at the time of a triennial appointment of members, consist of eleven members during the succeeding triennial period, and shall, if no such Juvenile Advisory Committee exists in the area at the time of such triennial appointment, consist of ten members during the succeeding triennial period.

(5) Of the members of a school attendance committee appointed under this section, each one of five members shall, so far as such persons are available, be either a manager or a patron of a national or other suitable school in the school attendance area, and one other member shall be a teacher in a national or other suitable school in the school attendance area, and, when the committee consists of eleven members, one other member shall be a member of the Juvenile Advisory Committee in the school attendance area.

(6) Five members of every school attendance committee appointed under this section shall be appointed by the Minister, and at least one of the members so appointed shall be a teacher in a national or other suitable school in the school attendance area.

(7) When a school attendance committee appointed under this section consists of ten members, five of such members shall be appointed by the council of the county borough or urban district in which the school attendance area is situated, of which five members one at least shall be a manager or a patron of a national or other suitable school in the school attendance area, and when the school attendance committee consists of eleven members six of such members shall be appointed by the said council, of which six members one at least shall be such manager or patron as aforesaid and one other shall be a member of the Juvenile Advisory Committee in the school attendance area.

(8) The Minister, after consultation with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, may by order prescribe the times and mode of appointment of members of school attendance committees by the councils of the said county boroughs and urban districts and by the Minister respectively, the time of commencement of the period of office of the members of such committees, the time and mode of filling casual vacancies in such committees and the period of office of persons appointed to fill such vacancies, and the times of meeting, quorum, conduct of business, and keeping of accounts of such committees.

Comment on this

This is an effort to introduce a slight change in the section in order to meet the point raised by Deputy O'Connell on the last day. I suggested that at least one teacher should be appointed by the local authority, and he said: "Why not by the Minister?" I have accepted that particular point of view. This is a rather long and complicated amendment, and as we were changing as regards that particular point of view I thought it well to make other changes. As we know definitely, at least I hope we do, what school attendance committees are to continue in force, I thought it well to define that the normal number of a committee would be ten, and in order to provide for a member of the new body to which we are giving representation, namely, the Juvenile Advisory Committee, I have increased the number to eleven in those districts where there is such a Juvenile Advisory Committee.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

The amendment refers to the teacher of a national "or other suitable" school. I do not think that there is any necessity to put in that. "Other suitable school" in this connection would, I take it, be something in the nature of a private school. The number of these schools is very few. I do not know that the people who conduct such schools will be particularly interested in this matter, and I do not think that there is any case for including such schools in this particular connection.

Comment on this

That is actually in the Bill so far as compulsory school attendance is concerned, and it applies to such schools as well as to others. There is in reality no reason for excluding them.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 6, Section 11, to delete sub-section (2) and substitute a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) For the purposes of Part IV. of the Local Government Act, 1925 (No. 5 of 1925) (which relates to the superannuation of the officers of a local body), every school attendance committee shall be deemed to be a committee of a local authority and to be a local body within the meaning of the said Part IV. of the said Act, and the provisions of the said Part IV. shall in so far as the same are applicable apply to a school attendance committee and their officers in like manner as they apply to a committee of a local authority and their officers subject to the following modifications, that is to say:

(a) the grant by a school attendance committee of any allowance or gratuity shall be subject to the approval of the council of the county borough or urban district by which the expenses of such school attendance committee are defrayed; and

(b) in the case of an officer of a school attendance committee appointed under the Irish Education Act, 1892, who becomes an officer of a school attendance committee under this Act, such officer's service under the former committee shall be reckoned as service under the latter committee."

Comment on this

The Dáil may remember that after a certain amount of debate on the last occasion the principle of superannuation was accepted for the officers of such school attendance committees as remain in force after the passing of the Act. I accepted the principle and promised to bring forward at this stage a redraft of the amendment put forward by Deputy Doyle. This amendment is the redrafted form.

Comment on this

In the absence of Deputy Good I move:—

In page 6, Section 12, before the word "every," line 48, to insert the words "subject to the approval of the council of the county borough or urban district and with the sanction of the Minister."

Comment on this

I suggest to the Minister that this is a necessary amendment, and that having definitely given school attendance officers pensionable rights and having rightly done so, the local authority should have some say in the question of the appointment of school attendance officers. I think that was put forward by the Minister himself when he said that the acceptance of Deputy Doyle's amendment was conditional upon the assumption that school attendance officers were to be appointed in the future on certain conditions as to age limits and qualifications. The amendment, so far as I understand it, requires that the approval of the local authority should be given to the appointment of school attendance officers.

Comment on this

The officers of school attendance committees are pensionable and the only change that this particular amendment proposes to make is that the school attendance committee can turn their secretary, who is an officer, into a school attendance officer, but both the officer and the school attendance officer are pensionable. A secretary, for instance, would be pensionable. I think the school attendance officer and the secretary would be normal officers. Whether there is any necessity for preventing a school attendance committee transforming their secretary into a school attendance officer, or whether it is necessary to get the sanction of the local council or the Minister, is a matter for debate, and I would like to have the views of Deputies upon it.

Comment on this

My view is that it is desirable that the school attendance committee should be under some control by the council. It is an organ of the local authority and up to the present the local authority has been strongly represented on it. I think the amendment which we have just accepted, and rightly accepted, will rather reduce the representation of the local authority. I think that the proceedings of the school attendance committee should be liable to be reviewed and approved by the local authority. It only refers to a comparatively small number of cases in which the committees continue. I think it is desirable that the link with the local authority should be close, and by giving this form of control which Deputy Good proposes the proceedings would be liable to their approval. I would like the Minister to consider the matter.

Comment on this

This amendment as it stands would give the committee power to appoint a person to a pensionable position. It seems to me, if a person is to be appointed to a pensionable position, whether under a local authority or otherwise, that the authority of the local body, or the Minister, for such appointment is desirable.

Comment on this

I, too, support the proposition in the amendment, because I see that the committee is to consist of one half nominees of the local council and one half to be appointed by the Minister. Officers of that committee should be, especially if they are to become a charge at all upon the local authority, sanctioned by the local authority, which is the elected body, and not by the appointed body. I think that that is a reasonable claim to make on behalf of the elected local authority.

Comment on this

I am sorry that Deputy Good is not here to support his own amendment. I know that he is a very enthusiastic and hard-working member of an urban council, and I think his views might be expressed by saying that the urban council, or the local body, being the payers, are responsible largely for the money, and that they should have some say in the control. There is nothing very deep in the amendment beyond the argument put forward that the local authorities should be consulted in connection with these appointments.

Comment on this

And the Minister.

Comment on this

And the Minister.

Comment on this

I have really no objection to the amendment, but I cannot follow the argument about the pensionability, if I might coin the word. The section as it stands does not give power to the committee to appoint anybody they like as school attendance officer. It gives them power to appoint one of their officers as an attendance officer, and that officer is already a pensionable officer.

Comment on this