PUBLIC BUSINESS. - SCHOOL ATTENDANCE BILL, 1925—REPORT STAGE.
Contributions 124–241 of 241. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 48 of 1925 ›
That depends. But in that connection he would be combining the positions of, say, secretary and school attendance officer and get pay for both. That is certainly a consideration. I have no objection to the amendment. Subject to having it redrafted, I am quite ready to accept it.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not think that it would be very undesirable for an officer of a council to get an appointment outside without consulting the council?
Comment on this
I might point out that Section 11 provides that the school attendance committee may, subject to the approval of the council of the county borough or urban district, make general appointments. We are only dealing with the case where the attendance committee may appoint one of its officers to be a school attendance officer, and in effect that is really another appointment. I think to make it run with Section 11 that the Minister might put that in.
Comment on this
I have no objection whatsover to accepting the amendment, especially after the point of view urged by Deputy Thrift. If it is withdrawn, I will bring it on again on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 6, Section 13 (1), line 67, to delete the words "poor rate" and substitute the words "like rate as that out of which the expenses of a school attendance committee appointed under the Irish Education Act, 1892, were defrayed under section 74 of the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1898."
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 7, Section 14, before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(2) Whenever the Minister could under the foregoing sub-section dissolve a school attendance committee he may, in lieu of dissolving such committee and making the consequential provisions mentioned in the foregoing sub-section, by order remove from such committee all or any of the members thereof, and whenever any such order is made the vacancies on such committee caused by such removal shall be deemed to be casual vacancies and shall be filled accordingly."
Comment on this
I move:—
In pages 7 and 8, Section 14 (3), to delete paragraph (c) and substitute two new paragraphs as follows:
"(c) the officers of the dissolved committee or removed supervisor (as the case may be) shall be deemed to have been removed by virtue of such order from office and the council to whom the moneys of such dissolved committee or removed supervisor are transferred:—
(i) shall have in respect of the pensionable officers of such dissolved committee or removed supervisor the like powers of superannuation as are conferred by this Act on a school attendance committee, in respect of the officers of such committee, and
(ii) shall pay to the non-pensionable officers of such dissolved committee or removed supervisor compensation in accordance with a scale to be fixed by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health after consultation with the Minister for Education, but not exceeding in any case one year's salary at the rate of the salary of which the officer was in receipt at the time of the dissolution of the committee or removal of the supervisor (as the case may be);
"(d) all expenses incurred by a council in pursuance of this sub-section shall be defrayed out of the rate or fund out of which the expenses of a school attendance committee are to be defrayed under this Act."
Comment on this
On the question of procedure I do not know how this will be dealt with. I might point out that there is another amendment later, No. 27, dealing with this matter. This is a generous provision in comparison with what is to be found in, say, the Civil Service on similar occasions. If we propose to make any modification in connection with No. 27, I suppose a similar modification would apply here. The only question is whether we should discuss it on this or on Amendment No. 27.
Comment on this
This is only a matter of procedure. Would it be possible to discuss No. 27 at this stage? I do not know that it would, but I think that if we do pass No. 19 we should do so only on the understanding that whatever decision is come to on Amendment No. 27 will apply to this.
Comment on this
And also, I suggest, No. 28. I think as it is in order—I cannot quote the Standing Order at the moment—to postpone the consideration of any particular portion of a Bill until some other portion has been considered, that we should postpone consideration of Amendment 19 until Amendments 27 and 28 have been considered.
Amendment 19 postponed.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 8, Section 14, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"(4) Whenever a school attendance committee appointed under the Irish Education Act, 1892, which should under this Act become the first school attendance committee of a school attendance area is at the commencement of this Act either not in existence or not properly constituted, such first school attendance committee shall for the purposes of this section be deemed to have come into existence under this Act and may be deemed by the Minister at any time after the passing of this Act not to be discharging its duties under this Act duly and effectually and may be dissolved under this section accordingly."
Comment on this
The purpose of this is quite clear from its wording, I trust. Where there is not a school attendance committee, as there is not, for instance, in the scheduled areas that we have in the Bill—the City of Limerick is one of them—there is no provision in the Bill to deal with the situation. The Gárda Síochána are not in a position to take over the administration of the School Attendance Bill in that particular area. The alternative for that was to schedule it, and then the position would be that there would be a school attendance committee there. If that did not work satisfactorily it could be dissolved and a supervisor appointed in its place. It did seem absurd, as there was clear evidence that Limerick was not a place in which to establish a school attendance committee, to set up a committee there in order to dissolve it and to put a supervisor in its place. Consequently the amendment is introduced to meet that situation.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 8, before Section 16 to insert a new section as follows:—
"Whenever a child to whom this Act applies is for the time being attending a national or other suitable school in accordance with this Act but is absent from such school on any day or days on which he should under this Act attend such school, his parent shall as soon as possible and in any event not later than the third day after the day or the first of the days (as the case may be) of such absence communicate in writing or in person to the principal teacher of such school the cause of such absence."
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 8, Section 16, at the end of sub-section (1), to add a new paragraph as follows:—
"and
(c) informing him that if within three months after such proceedings he again fails to comply with this Act further proceedings may be instituted against him without previous warning."
Comment on this
Is not three months rather a long period? Perhaps the Minister would say something about that.
Comment on this
Deputy Thrift proposed that there should be no limitation whatsoever, and I thought that three months was reasonable, that is, if a parent was guilty of an offence and if within three months he is again guilty it would be unnecessary to warn him a second time. Does Deputy Mulcahy suggest that a warning should be given the second time within three months?
Comment on this
No, but if a parent is proceeded against and he takes no notice of the order, it would be rather unfair to the child that no further steps should be taken for three months.
Comment on this
That is not it. No further warning would be given to the parent that he will be proceeded against. It was really to secure quickness of execution that Deputy Thrift put down his amendment, so that the step of giving the parent warning a second time would be eliminated. I think that Deputy Thrift and Deputy Mulcahy are quite at one on the point.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 8, Section 16, before sub-section (3) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(3) Whenever a parent within three months after being convicted of an offence under this section, fails without reasonable excuse to cause his child in respect of whom he was so convicted to attend school in accordance with this Act, such parent shall, unless the child has ceased to be a child to whom this Act applies, be guilty of an offence under this section (which shall for the purposes of this section be deemed to be a second offence under this section) and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding forty shillings."
Comment on this
I think that this is more or less consequential on Deputy Thrift's amendment. Deputies will remember that we excluded the clause the last time for a certain purpose, and I think we excluded more than we intended to exclude. Deputy Thrift's amendment was confined to telling the parent that no further notice will be given. We will now have to proceed without further notice.
Comment on this
I am very glad to see that the Minister has put down this amendment. It is quite true that it is necessary to supplement mine.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 9, Section 17, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"(6) A prosecution for an offence under this Act may in a school attendance area situate in a county borough or urban district mentioned in the Schedule to this Act, be prosecuted at the suit of any school attendance officer in the area as prosecutor, and may in any other school attendance area, be prosecuted at the suit of the enforcing authority of the area as prosecutor."
Comment on this
It was proposed on the last occasion by Deputy Connor Hogan, on behalf of Deputy Heffernan, that the school attendance officer, or the enforcing authority, should have power to appear and conduct the prosecution—that is, that a solicitor need not be employed. The amendment is put down with that end in view. It seems quite reasonable.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 10, Section 18 (2), lines 7 and 8, to delete the words "such fee as shall be fixed by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health" and substitute the words "a fee of sixpence."
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Good I move:—
In page 11, Section 23, to add at end of sub-section (2) a new paragraph as follows:—
(f) appoint Advisory Committees in such places and for such periods as the Minister may think necessary."
This is a purely permissive amendment. It allows the Minister to appoint advisory committees if and when he thinks fit. He need not appoint them if he does not think fit. It can do no harm and may be useful.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Cooper tell me what he means by an advisory committee? For what purpose?
Comment on this
I am afraid that the Minister will have to wait for Deputy Good's return. But in view of the fact that this is not compulsory, but that it will give him power to appoint them if he thinks fit, that he can then analyse the nature of these advisory committees and discover their purpose, I think he might accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Is there not a point in this that the Minister would like to be advised in regard to the desirability of using his powers regarding extending the age, and so on? Possibly that is intended, and I think it might be a desirable thing.
Comment on this
I am quite sure that Deputy Good recognises the willingness of the Minister always to take advice in providing the machinery for him to get that advice from a good source.
Comment on this
If I was not aware that Deputy Good had down another amendment on the last stage that was very different in its scope so far as words went, but the purpose of which, possibly, was quite the same as this and the purpose of which was quite outside the scope of the Bill, I might look at this more favourably. As Deputy Good has now returned, perhaps he could explain what he means. We are in the difficulty, Deputy Good, that Deputy Cooper, in your absence, moved your amendment, but was unable to tell us what you meant by it.
Comment on this
I was anxious that those in the different areas should be consulted on matters affecting their areas. It was pointed out earlier, in discussions on the Bill, that conditions are not identical in all areas. In order that the Minister might be made aware of the circumstances in the various areas, I am anxious that he should have this power of calling advisory committees into existence for such periods as he may consider necessary. It is not essential, I think, that these committees should have anything of a permanent character about them, except that in some areas the Minister came to the conclusion it would be well to have them made permanent.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy indicate on what matters the Minister should seek the advice of these committees?
Comment on this
In connection with some of the proposals that we have had under consideration in relation to this Bill it may be desirable, in certain circumstances, to have advisory committees set up. This evening, for instance, we discussed the employment of child labour. That is a matter, for instance, that might come before an Advisory Committee, especially in certain areas where a distinction may be finely drawn as to whether it is an agricultural or industrial area. If it is the former, the section would operate, and if an industrial area the section would not operate. That is a matter, I think, on which it would be well to consult local interests. I am afraid that one of the weaknesses in this measure is that it possibly puts too much into the hands of the Minister, and too little on the particular areas. My experience of the working of the Technical Instruction Act was this: that one of the outstanding advantages of that Act over our Education Act, which applied to primary education, was that under it you had consultations with the areas concerned. The Minister in that instance derived considerable assistance from the local people as to the various problems that arose from time to time.
Comment on this
I think there is a good deal in this amendment by Deputy Good that is worthy of consideration. It might be a useful amendment to adopt, especially as there is to be no compulsion on the Minister to appoint advisory committees. I take it that the intention of Deputy Good is that these advisory committees should be set up principally in regard to the powers conferred on the Minister under the new Section 23.
Comment on this
That section gives power to the Minister to apply the Act in certain places and at certain times, and to a certain extent within the limit of fourteen to sixteen years of age. In connection with that, I can conceive quite a number of things on which it might be well for the Minister to get the advice of local committees. There would, for instance, be such questions as the accommodation available, how best to make use of it, staff arrangements and so on. I think if these advisory committees were set up that very useful work might be found for them. They might serve, if I might put it so, as a kind of useful buffer for the Minister. If they made recommendations it might be useful for the Minister to be able to fall back on them, rather than to be put in the position of bearing all the odium of doing a thing himself. It might be well for the Minister to have local bodies to consult before putting into operation all the powers given to him under this new Section 23.
Comment on this
I desire to support, very strongly, the amendment moved by Deputy Good. If the amendment did nothing more than make local areas recognise their responsibilities in connection with education, it would, in my opinion, have served a very useful purpose. In educational matters there is a big difference as to the systems that obtain here and on the other side of the water. Here the Minister and his Department exercise a more or less bureaucratic control over education, whereas on the other side the local authorities, to the extent of very considerable contributions, take a great interest in their schools and in the educational problems of their district. If Deputy Good's amendment did nothing more than create a local interest in education, then it would have done a very good work.
Comment on this
Apart from Deputy Hewat's reasons I am afraid I cannot accept this amendment. Either this Advisory Committee is for the purpose of this particular Bill, that is, securing the attendance of the children where the Bill operates, or it is for some other purpose. Having listened to a number of speeches, I should say it may be for the purpose of helping the attendance of children at school, but it is much more likely to be for some other purpose outside the scope of this particular Bill. If the amendment is meant to deal with school attendance, which is the purpose of this Bill, then you are up against the proposition that was discussed for a short time on the last occasion, of divided authority as between the Civic Guard and the School Advisory Committee. If you are to have an Advisory Committee under this Bill, its principal purpose, I take it, would be to enforce the Act and to give advice on that. You would, therefore, have the Civic Guard as an enforcing authority on the one hand, and this advisory body, perhaps running counter to the actions of the Civic Guard, on the other hand. I think that would make for maladministration of the Act, and therefore if the amendment is meant to achieve something that is within the scope of the Bill, I think it is objectionable from the point of view I have urged. If it is meant to achieve something altogether outside the scope of the Bill, then I feel I must reject it. As regards the point made about the exercise of the powers given to the Minister under the new Section 23, I think it would be less cumbersome and would lead to less trouble to get all the local information required indirectly, instead of directly through an Advisory Committee, seeing that the Minister himself will be the person to appoint this particular committee. I am sorry I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I would like to point out to the Minister that the powers given in the new Section 23 are brought into existence by reason of the extension of Section 2. The difficulties that arose under Section 2 whereby we extended the school age from 14 to 16 were of such a character that certain powers had to be given to the Minister. The Minister pointed out, and we all agreed, that for obvious reasons it would be inadvisable to put these powers into force immediately. That, of course, would have happened if we had incorporated the amendment as originally proposed in the Bill. When the matter was under consideration the question of school buildings was discussed, whether the schools were capable of extension and the number of scholars that they could accommodate. It occurred to me that the question of encouraging employment in a particular area by exemption, say, from attendance at schools of certain boys and girls who were in employment, and the arrangement, say, of continuation classes in the evening, were all matters that might engage the attention of local committees. There is no reason, simply because you set up an Advisory Committee in one area, that you should set it up in every area. I suggest to the Minister that he is more likely to achieve good results in the matter of education by co-operating with the local people. He is acting apart from them altogether through his Department. There is nothing mandatory at all in this amendment. It is only where it is thought desirable that advisory committees are to be set up.
The Minister stated that if these committees were set up they would be brought into conflict with the Civic Guard. There would be no question of that at all, because the Civic Guard have certain duties to discharge and there would be no clashing between them and the local committees. The amendment suggests, in connection with the extensions under Section 2, that before they can be put into full operation the local committees should be consulted. These are matters that cannot affect the Civic Guard. If there was any danger of a clashing between the local advisory committees and the Civic Guard the Minister would have the power to say to the local committee that he was very much obliged to them for the assistance they had given, that he had the information he wanted, and that their duties were at an end. I think the Minister has taken a different view altogether of the functions of these advisory committees to that which I hold. I do not see any possibility of a conflict between them and the Civic Guard.
Comment on this
The first part of the Minister's argument was without any force in respect of this amendment and without any application to it. Deputy Good has already disposed of that. As I understand, the object of these advisory committees would not be to secure attendance at school. You have the enforcing authority, as set out in the Bill, to do that. It might be necessary to relate definitely the advisory committee to Section 23. But I do say that such local inquiries as the Minister can make through his inspectors or officers will not meet the position fully, because it will not bring together the conflicting interests in a particular area. The object of Section 23 is to bring the children between 14 years and 16 years into school and to give them a particular type of education. It may not, and I hope will not, be confined to the national school programme. There may be different types of schools in the locality. You may have a technical school or an agricultural school, or it may be necessary to set up in some central area, where there are facilities, schools with higher "tops." It may be necessary to set up a school in a central area which will be entirely confined to children of these ages, and I foresee that all this will lead to conflicting interests. If there were any way by which you could bring together these conflicting interests, it would be helpful. If an inspector goes into an area to make inquiries, he may find that the authorities in charge of one school do not want this departure at all, because it is going to upset their particular arrangements. The teachers of a particular area may not want it, because it is going to draw children over 14, who are attending their school, away to some other school. They will object to it, and the inspector will be confronted with difficulties of all kinds. We know how difficult it is to make changes. We all naturally want to go along as we have been going, because we do not know what danger there is in new arrangements or how it will affect our own case. There will be all kinds of difficulties.
I believe it would be extremely helpful to the Minister if he could set up, under this amendment, a committee which would give representation to all the interests that he thought ought to be represented—that would bring together all those interested in education in the area. The value of such an arrangement would be that it would bring all those interested in education face to face in one room. The Minister's representative could say: "Here is a problem which we have to settle in your own area; could you give me any idea as to how it should be met?" That would be the value of that arrangement, as against the sending in of an officer to make inquiries. He may make inquiries from different people and get different views from practically everybody. One man will have one objection and another man will have another objection. It is only when all are brought together that you will arrive at the common denominator of the objections. I think it would be possible to get a working arrangement in that way which you would not be able to get by the sending of an officer into an area to make inquiries.
Comment on this
Many inquiries can be undoubtedly made by the Minister. If there is any question as to seeking further information of the kind suggested by Deputies Good and O'Connell—to what extent and with what modifications Clause 23 might be made operative in a certain district—there is nothing to prevent the Minister appointing a Commission ad hoc. But if you definitely state in the Act that there is to be an advisory committee, even with the saving clause "for such purposes as the Minister may think necessary," you are undoubtedly setting up a body that will ultimately claim to be more than an advisory body. Human nature being what it is, this advisory committee will not confine itself to the special purpose for which it is set up. If it is found necessary to consult local opinion— not merely local opinion sectionally but local opinion collectively—there is nothing to prevent the Minister setting up a local commission ad hoc and asking them to investigate the matter. From that point of view, the amendment gives no more power to the Minister than he has already, and it has, from my point of view, very objectionable features.
Comment on this
I am sorry the Minister cannot see his way to accept this amendment. I feel so strongly about the matter that I shall have to press for a division.
Comment on this
I move Amendment 27:
In page 11, section 25, sub-section (4), line 49, to delete all the words after the word "Act" and substitute therefor the words "as compensation a sum equal to in the case of any particular officer one-sixth of the annual salary and emoluments of which he was in receipt on the first day of November, 1925, for each completed year of service."
This amendment, I submit, makes a very moderate demand on behalf of the officers. It only proposes to give them bare justice. As Deputies will notice, it provides for one-sixth of the annual salary and emoluments for each year of completed service. The arguments in favour of it are perfectly obvious. I have in mind some officers who have given many years' service, and it is suggested in the section that they are to be disposed of with some amount, not exceeding in any case one year's salary. That point should be emphasised. In my amendment it is proposed to give them one-sixth of one year's salary for each year's service. I think that is a reasonable proposal and one that the Minister cannot advance any argument against.
Comment on this
We put down the provision in the Bill because we were under the impression, taking similar officers, for instance, in Government employment who had non-pensionable positions, that, on the whole, it was a generous provision. I have made inquiries as to the procedure and practice, for instance, in the case of a servant of the Government who had an office that did not carry a pension, and I was told that, roughly speaking, the average treatment when the office was abolished, was to give one week's salary for each year's service. Therefore, if a person had served, say, 30 years, which is, I think, the limit for any of the officers we are now considering, 30 weeks' salary—not one year's salary—would be the compensation given the officer.
Deputies will remember that we were dealing with another matter, the question of pensions for officers of School Attendance Committees, and that the argument I laid most stress on —I will not say it was the only argument I used—was the advantage, from the point of view of education, of having a pensionable officer. This would save a tender-hearted Committee from the temptation of keeping on a man long beyond the usual period. We would also remove the temptation from the individual school attendance officer to seek other employment, and to eke out the salary he was getting which, in itself, would not make provision for his old age. There is another consideration that, I think, might be borne in mind, and that is, that in the particular case referred to we were dealing with a position in which the school attendance officers, practically, made it their sole source of revenue. In the case of officers referred to by Deputy Hogan, I wonder if their sole source of revenue is derived from the salaries they get as school attendance officers.
Comment on this
That is, simply, they have their ordinary means of livelihood, and, as a kind of side avocation, they attend to school attendance. A paper was circulated some time ago about the accuracy of the returns given here. For the accuracy of the returns I can accept no responsibility. Probably, on the whole, they were correct. They were supplied by the various School Attendance Committees. Some are part-time and some are whole-time officers. For part-time officers the salary varies. Sometimes it is £6, and even lower. Sometimes it is as high as £52 per year. There are whole-time officers enjoying a salary of £35 yearly. I wonder was it seriously contended that that would be the sole source of revenue of these particular people? I think most of the arguments that apply in the case of compensation or superannuation for attendance officers that remain in the scheduled areas will not apply in this particular case. As to what the actual cost would be, if you take the whole country, seeing the extent of it, perhaps it would not be very exorbitant. It might not appear very exorbitant, if you give them, say, one in every fifteen years. Taking that as a basis, you can calculate it by multiplying any sum required by 2½ or 3. For whole-time officers appointed under the Education Act, if you give them compensation of one year's salary for every fifteen years service, in a town like Carlow it would be £63; Drogheda, £116; Dundalk, £166; and Tralee, £203. The total for whole-time officers of the urban areas would be £953 on that scale. In the rural areas it would be £2,118, making a total for whole-time officers of £3,000. If you calculate for the part-time officers in the urban areas, giving one year's salary for every fifteen years' service, the figures would be £700, and in the rural areas £1,400. If you add these together, whole-time and part-time officers in urban and rural areas outside the scheduled districts, giving one year's salary for every fifteen years' service, the total would be about £5,000. I had hoped that Deputies would have expressed their views on this. Deputy Hogan is the only Deputy who has spoken on the question so far. I would like to hear the views of other Deputies. I have given them certain facts from which perhaps they may be able to form a conclusion as to what, on the whole, is just. As I said, we put down one year's salary in the Bill because, making comparison for their services, that seemed not altogether unreasonable. In no case were we anxious to add to the burdens of the local authorities at this particular time.
Comment on this
I think the amendment is reasonable, considering the duties those officers had to perform in the past. I know officers in my own county to have given good service in the cause of education, and I think one-sixth of the yearly salary is not too much as compensation. That would mean every school attendance officer having six years' service would get one year's salary on the abolition of his office.
Comment on this
I should like to use some of the Minister's own arguments in support of my amendment. He tells us we are not to assume these officers are whole-time officers and are entirely dependent on their salaries for their living. That is exactly what a good many of them are. The Minister makes a comparison between those officers with small salaries and other officers, but he does not tell us the salaries of the other officers to whom the same terms are given. He made a comparison with officers in other departments who are not pensionable, and he says "we propose to treat school attendance officers on the same basis." I will take the Minister's own figures. He stated fifty-two in one and six in another case. Let us strike an average and say twenty-nine. I suggest that is a fair comparison with the salaries the other people get? He has made a comparison without any reference whatsoever to their salaries. He submits five thousand pounds to be the cost.
Comment on this
Not on the Deputy's proposal. It will be the cost of his proposal multiplied by two and a half at all events.
Comment on this
He suggested that is an exorbitant sum. That reminds me of the old lady who saw Niagara for the first time and who, turning to her husband, said: "Oh, I remember, I left the tap turned on at home." If that is the fashion in which the Minister deals with men who gave valuable service to the State, I think it is a niggardly way to deal with the matter, inasmuch as thousands have been given in other cases where less valuable services were given.
Comment on this
Although those officers are not whole-time officers, still a great many of them had given very long service, and I think in the case of some women who were attendance officers, the service in their case has been practically whole-time. The country cannot afford to give pensions all round. Still, when an office is taken compulsorily away, I think the people from whom these offices are taken should be treated as fairly as we can afford. As the amount concerned is not very large, I suggest to the Minister he should consider giving one year for every ten years' service. Some of them have served thirty years. It is a sort of compromise between one year for every fifteen and one for every six, and would not make a very great difference.
Comment on this
I expected some assistance from the House. When local government matters are considered here, we get a great deal of assistance. Up to the present I have got no view except that six times the salary ought to be granted. Deputy Hogan says: "What about a comparison of the salaries people, whom I mentioned, enjoyed." They were whole-time officers. The six pounds represents not a very considerable part of their means of livelihood. In the case I referred to it represented a person's sole means of livelihood. If the House is agreeable, I have no objection to saying one year in every twelve.
Comment on this
That would be three years' salary, and in the case of some of the towns mentioned, I think the burden might come on them.
Comment on this
Deputy Hogan is right in one point. It does not follow that everyone whose position is abolished will get the maximum even as it stood. The idea was that it would range, according to the number of years' service, from one years' salary to three months' salary. If the Deputy would accept the one in twelve I should be quite ready to consider it. I will consider, between now and the Report Stage, whether it shall be one in ten or one in twelve.
Comment on this
I believe there is a good deal of equity in Deputy Hogan's amendment because, after all, a few days ago we made the office pensionable for the whole-time officers. They are not losing their positions as the officers from the rural districts and the urban districts of the country are. I say that there is a good deal of equity in this, considering the action of the Dáil the other day, by which the whole-time officers who are retaining their positions are to have pensions.
Comment on this
I ask the leave of the Dáil to withdraw the amendment. I am doing so on the Minister's promise.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In page 11, section 25 (4), line 52, to delete all words after the words "Minister for Education."
I could not support Deputy Hogan's amendment, because it seems to me too detailed. My amendment is intended to give very much wider discretion to the Minister for Local Government and to the Minister for Education than they have in the Bill at present, by removing the limit of one year's salary. I see no reason why we should tie the Minister down in this way. They should have regard to the circumstances of the case. The Minister told us that there are some people who are doing this work for a nominal salary. I more or less inferred that it was a hobby with them and that they took the small amount to pay for shoe leather. But there is no doubt but this fixed maximum would work unfairly now. There are two cases in my own constituency. In Balbriggan there is a whole-time officer who is secretary of the school attendance committee also. He, or, it may be, she has been twenty-four and a half years doing the job. The maximum amount that that officer could get is £55. On the other hand, in South Dublin there is a secretary of a school attendance committee who also acts as a whole-time school attendance officer. He has occupied the position four months, and yet that officer can get £100.
Comment on this
I am talking about the Bill as it stands, and not on the improvements the Minister is borrowing from the Labour Party. I am talking about the Bill as drafted and introduced. Under that Bill the officer who occupies the position for four months gets £100, and another officer who has occupied the position for 24½ years gets £55. I do not say that is a thing that would happen. I hope the Ministers would use their discretion to some extent, but it proves that cut and dried administration of this sort is not desirable. It penalises the employees of one committee, that is to say in the case of a committee that has paid lower salaries and have kept the expenses down. In the case of people who had their heart in the work and who were because of that satisfied to accept smaller salaries, the amount to be given would be definitely smaller than that given to persons employed by committees who were prepared to spend money lavishly. My amendment simply removes the fixed limit of one year's salary. It does not necessarily involve any extra demand on the ratepayers at all. The pension would be fixed by consultation between the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Education. But it does make it possible to take into consideration the local circumstances and the local differences that would make it in some cases desirable to give a slightly larger amount than this fixed one of one year's salary.
Comment on this
I confess that I see a danger, or rather a difficulty, in this amendment as against the amendment suggested by Deputy Hogan. I feel that it would be more satisfactory from the point of view certainly of the Minister, if there were a definite scale put into the Bill, because if you do not put in a scale you will have all kinds of arguments put up and all kinds of pressure used and all kinds of circumstances urged as to why a particular person in a particular case should get one sum, and a particular person in another case should get another sum. I think it would be better for all concerned if it were possible, in accordance with the suggestion made by Deputy Hogan, to put a definite scale into the Bill, so that they would all know what they were entitled to normally. Of course, there would be a discretion still left to the Minister, but normally that is what they would be entitled to. I think it would be far better from the Minister's point of view, and possibly from the point of view, too, of Deputies who might be asked to make representation to the Minister. That kind of thing has been sometimes done, but if there was, in the Bill to be passed now, a scale on which the Minister would be expected to act, this would be avoided. That is what Deputy Hogan's amendment suggests. I suggest to Deputy Cooper that if the Minister accepts the suggestion of Deputy Hogan, modified as he practically promised to modify it, it will be a better arrangement than as it stands at present or as it is in this amendment.
Comment on this
I am inclined to agree with Deputy O'Connell that it would be very objectionable if there was not a scale. The difference between Deputy Hogan's amendment and the amendment moved by Deputy Cooper, so far as that is concerned, is whether the scale would be fixed here, or fixed by the two Ministers in individual cases. The Bill as it stands provides for a scale to be fixed. Of course, one of the first things that would be considered would be the number of years' service. If a scale were fixed I would suggest that the man who has 24½ years' service would not be in the same part of the scale as the man with four months' service. That is quite obvious. Assume that the section asks the Ministers to fix the scale, and then assume, if the Dáil can make such an assumption, that they had a minimum of commonsense, they would hardly put the man with four months' service on the same level as the man with 24½ years' service. Deputy O'Connell said there was danger, and I do not know whether he changed the word afterwards and said there was a possibility that the maximum would be one year's service. I can understand a certain anxiety on the part of Deputy O'Connell to put in some higher maximum than one year, knowing well that the maximum put in will be actually the maximum that will operate. If we fixed three years or two years maximum, the man with the longest service would practically get that amount of pension going out, and the others would be graded from him downwards. I confess I cannot see any great virtues in this, except an immense amount of trouble that would be given to the Ministers and Deputies by the loose arrangement that seems to be suggested by Deputy Cooper's amendment, but that in reality is not suggested by Deputy Cooper's amendment.
Comment on this
It is suggested and suggested definitely—an absolute principle. I am utterly opposed to all this trying to supply moral courage by putting restrictions in statutes. Deputies and Ministers ought summon up their moral courage and turn down indefensible demands. As it is we continually find that local authorities and Ministers and pensions boards are all hedging themselves in and saying: "You have an excellent case but it does not come within the four corners of the Act; it does not come within the provisions laid down in the statute." I think that is all wrong. We ought to begin at the top in this case. In this case it is only Deputies and Ministers who will be troubled. We ought to face that trouble and to face the very disagreeable necessity occasionally of turning down our constituents, but the evil goes the whole way through. In the Local Government Bill various provisions were put in because local authorities could not be trusted not to vote away the ratepayers' money in large sums. They have got to face the responsibility and face the ratepayers. All these artificial safeguards are like the precautions with which a doctor surrounds a sick man, and we should be recovering the health of the body corporate sufficiently to be able to get over them. All I have heard from Deputy O'Connell and the Minister convinces me all the more that I was right in putting down this amendment. I framed that amendment not from the point of view of saving Ministers trouble, which I sometimes try to do, not from the point of view of saving my mail bag from being overloaded with letters, but from the point of view that we have got to face these things out and face this responsibility and not protect ourselves by inserting restrictive clauses in statutes.
Comment on this
Deputy Cooper has propounded a most extraordinary doctrine. We have been discussing supplementary estimates to-day. Why? Because it was necessary, and Deputy Cooper should know, that there should be some restriction on the expenditure of Ministers, that their moral courage was not enough restriction, that there should be some legal and statutory restriction on their power to spend money. I thought Deputy Cooper was one of the strongest exponents of that doctrine. Now I gather one of the securities the people should have is the moral courage of Ministers, Ministers who are variable. The moral courage of X to-day is of a higher grade than that of Y to-morrow or next year, and the allowances and the scales that are granted are going to vary according to the moral courage of Ministers. I was doubtful until Deputy Cooper made his last statement as to whether there was not something in his case, but now I am convinced that he is on the wrong track entirely and that there must be some check on expenditure besides the moral courage of Deputies or Ministers.
Comment on this
With regard to Amendment 19, whatever provision is put in—that is as to the one in twelve—the amendment under Section 25 will naturally also come into the proposed section we were discussing.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In page 11, Section 25, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"(5) All expenses incurred by a council or body in the execution of this section shall be defrayed out of the like rate or fund as that out of which the expenses of the school attendance committee were defrayed by such council or body."
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 11, to delete from the Schedule, the words "the County Borough of Limerick" and "the County Borough of Waterford."
I am moving to delete these areas from the Schedule in response to demands which I have got from both of these areas and which I consider to be representative demands, in the case of Limerick especially. I understand—as a matter of fact I think the Minister said it himself a few minutes ago—that there is no school attendance committee operating in Limerick at the moment, effectively operating at any rate. I have been informed on very good authority that the Juvenile Advisory Committee which exists in Limerick has passed a resolution asking that the area should be deleted from the Schedule and that the Gárda Síochána should be the enforcing authority in Limerick. If that is the case I can see only one possible reason, which was indicated by the Minister, for the inclusion of Limerick in this Schedule. That is that the Guards are not in a position to take up this duty. Candidly I cannot conceive that that would be the position.
I do not think it will throw on the Gárda Síochána in Limerick such a very onerous duty that they would not be in a position to discharge it. I would be surprised if that were the case, and I would require very strong evidence indeed to convince me that they are not in a position in Limerick to act as enforcing authority under this Bill. As I say, that could be the only possible argument, so far as my information goes, especially in Limerick; and the same thing practically applies to Waterford, perhaps though not to the same extent, because I think there is a Committee functioning in a small way in Waterford. My information is to the effect, however, that it is felt there that the Act will not be a success unless it is administered by the Gárda. I do hope, therefore, that the Minister, in view of the facts which have come to my notice and which possibly are correct, with regard to the position of the school attendance committees especially in Limerick, will explain to us why he has excluded Waterford and Limerick from the jurisdiction of the Gárda Síochána.
Comment on this
I think I have on more than one occasion put forward what my position is in this matter —on the first occasion in answer to Deputy Morrissey. Our idea was to have, without any reference, as I pointed out before, as to whether in any areas, committees were good committees, indifferent committees, or bad committees, the Act administered everywhere by the Gárda. At first the Gárda thought they would not be able to undertake the administration of the Act anywhere, but then they consented to undertake the administration of the Act in most of the country. They definitely excluded areas in which they could not at present undertake the administration of the Act—what I may call the Dublin, Waterford and Limerick areas. I put it up again to them to give it their full consideration, and they gave it very full consideration and endeavoured to see whether they could not undertake the administration of the Act in these two places. Again they were quite definite that they could not at present, at all events, undertake the administration of the Act there. That being so, there is no choice but to keep to the proposition in the Bill. That was the reason why I could not table an amendment to exclude Limerick and Waterford, however much I might desire to exclude both of these cities. It was especially desirable in the case of Limerick, where there is no committee in existence, and where there is no prospect, as I know, of getting a good committee. As the Dáil knows, I have already provided measures to deal with that case. There will be no necessity to call a committee into existence there. We will be able to deal with Limerick as we would with the scheduled areas where we have to abolish committees and appoint a supervisor. In Waterford the case is not so strong. There is one reason why we cannot exclude Waterford and Limerick from the schedule, but that is a sufficient reason so far as I am concerned why we cannot thrust that over on the Gárda at present.
Comment on this
Is it possible for the Minister to state the reason why the Gárda cannot administer the Act?
Comment on this
I am afraid that I could not state it. There is a strain on the Gárda, and it was definitely put up to them, and they decided it was outside their resources at the moment.
They were very clear on the point. There was no hesitation. They considered it again at my suggestion—carefully and sympathetically considered it— and made every effort to see if they could administer the Act in those two places. Again the answer was that they could not. The situation at present did not allow them to undertake the administration in those places. If the Committee in Waterford does not administer the Act properly we have the same remedy that we have in the case of Limerick. I suggest that Deputy O'Connell might be satisfied with that explanation.
I am not by any means sorry that the Deputy moved this amendment, apart from the fact that I am unable to accept it, because whatever may be said about the possibility or the advisability of not having the Gárdaí administer the Act in Waterford or Limerick, there can be no excuse for extending the areas which are not to be administered by the Gárdaí as suggested in other amendments. Our idea is, wherever the Gárdaí are willing to undertake it, to have this Act administered by them. As I said already, there is no slur on any of the committees who are at present doing excellent work. There is no suggestion that these committees are not hard-working, but for a variety of reasons, especially for the sake of uniformity, we should prefer to have the administration through the Gárdaí. That is what we are aiming to achieve; that is what we have achieved in the country outside the scheduled areas.
Comment on this
If the Minister takes up the position that he has put it definitely to the Gárdaí to take on the work and they say that they are not in a position to do it, it would be quite impossible to force the matter on them. Though it might be done, it would be quite inadvisable to do it, because if they were forced to undertake it against their will, they would not have very much heart in their work. But I must honestly express surprise that that is the state of affairs. I am quite prepared to accept it, but I am not very strongly convinced on the matter. However, I do hope that the matter will not be lost sight of, and that in the near future it will be put up to them again whether it would not be possible for them to undertake the duties in those two areas especially. I suppose there is nothing to be done in these circumstances except to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I wish Deputies to realise that the Gárdaí at first were under the impression that they could not undertake the administration of the Act anywhere. They have now gone very far to meet us, and I think that should be recognised— that we should bear in mind not so much what, for the moment, they are unable to do, but what they have undertaken to do willingly, because they saw the necessity of it, although they recognised the drain that it will be on their resources.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy ought to recognise that in densely populated areas the imposition of a duty such as this would necessitate the employment of a much larger number of men than are available at present. The demands on the Gárdaí are very considerable, even in the rural areas, and this does place a large additional burden on them. I think it was explained here last year that one of the reasons for the delay in connection with the introduction of this Bill was this difficulty of having it administered. It is hardly necessary to point out that modern conditions have imposed a very considerable strain on the Gárdaí. In the city of Dublin fifteen years ago there was one policeman on point duty; at present there are 150. To get men to do this extra work would mean either taking men away from the duties they are employed at at present, or increasing the numbers. So that it is not that they are unwilling to take on the duty, but rather that it would be difficult to expect them to take it on in addition to the other duties in a densely populated area.
Comment on this
I should like to say that I recognise the benefit it would be, so far as the enforcement of the Act is concerned, if the Gárdaí undertook to enforce it. It is because I am thoroughly convinced of the beneficial effects of their administration of it in the country that I am so anxious to have those benefits extended to other areas. I quite recognise the force of the case that has been made by the President and the Minister, but I should like to say that if the Gárdaí undertook the administration in densely populated areas I believe the effect would be even greater than in the rural areas. For that reason I was wondering whether it was too late even now to put something into the Bill which would give a certain discretion to the Gárdaí, in those areas where the Act is not administered by them, to question any child found about the streets who is obviously of school-age with the object of finding out why he was not at school. Anybody who goes about our cities encounters children who should undoubtedly be at school. The school attendance officer cannot possibly deal with all of them in densely populated areas. If it were felt that the Gárdaí had power to inquire why they were not at school it might have a very beneficial effect. The Gárdaí could do very useful work in that way by reporting to the school attendance officer. I throw out that suggestion, which may be worth consideration even now.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 11 to add to the Schedule the words "Dalkey Urban District."
First of all, it is necessary for me to make the conventional case that the School Attendance Committee in Dalkey is an efficient one and that it is the desire of the local authority that it should be continued. School attendence in Dalkey last November varied from 84 to 88 per cent. I asked the Minister for figures with regard to some other counties, and I find that in Wexford it was 70 per cent., and in Mayo and Cavan about 68 per cent. But I realise that the Minister stated there are many efficient School Attendance Committees all over the Saorstát, and that that in itself is not a sufficient reason. The reason I move this amendment is that he has himself in the schedule exempted the urban districts of Dun Laoghaire and Blackrock which adjoin Dalkey and are absolutely similar in character to it. I find it hard to believe that the Gárdaí cannot enforce the School Attendance Act in Dun Laoghaire, but that they can enforce it in Dalkey. The townships are actually very closely connected educationally. A number of boys from Dalkey go to Dun Laoghaire every day to school and a number of girls from Dun Laoghaire go to school at the Convent in Dalkey.
It seems to me very difficult to enforce the Act when one urban district is under one system of enforcement and the other is under another system. It is very difficult from the point of view of the Gárdaí themselves. The headquarters of the Gárdaí are actually in Dun Laoghaire, and the Superintendent of the F Division in Dun Laoghaire will be enforcing with the Gárdaí one law in Dalkey and a different system altogether in Dun Laoghaire and Blackrock. Officers will be liable to be transferred from time to time and you will have officers from Dun Laoghaire coming to Dalkey who know nothing of the enforcement of this Act and who will be asked suddenly to take it up. Dalkey and Killiney will be the only parts of what is called the Metropolitan District in which the Gárdaí are called upon to enforce it and I do see great administrative difficulties from that point of view.
Another argument I should like to put very briefly is that it is very possible that in future Dalkey will be amalgamated with Dun Laoghaire and Blackrock in a coast borough. I do not want to forestall the report of the Greater Dublin Commission, but I know that a case has been made for that amalgamation and that actually a Private Bill has been deposited in the Private Bill Office to bring about that amalgamation. Surely the Minister will admit that it will be anomalous if you have a borough with one system of school attendance in one end and a different system in the remaining two-thirds.
I do not expect the Minister to accept this amendment. I have given up expecting Ministers ever to accept amendments, but I would ask the Minister if he will have a further conference with the Gárdaí on the subject with regard to the points I put forward as to enforcing from Dun Laoghaire a special system in Dalkey that is not in force in Dun Laoghaire. I think administratively there are serious difficulties in the way and I shall be glad if the Minister will examine them.
Comment on this
I am always rather nervous about opposing Deputy Cooper's amendments, because in nine cases out of ten I find the arguments I use can only convince him all the more steadily of the rightness of his position. He will easily understand why I am a bit nervous about opposing him on this occasion. Still, oppose him I must. I explained my position very clearly: that where the Gárdaí were willing to take over the administration we were anxious they should take it over. They are willing to take it over in Killiney, Ballybrack and Dalkey and incidentally, I may remark, in various other places that an attempt is being made by other amendments to get included. For that reason, because it is the most satisfactory way of administering the Act, we see no reason for including any extra place in the schedule. It seems to be unreasonable to include, say, Dalkey, Killiney, North Dublin and Clonmel if we do not include a place like Kilkenny. It would be unreasonable to include Kilkenny if you do not include Galway. It would be unreasonable to include various towns if we do not include some other places. In many cases there is the efficiency of the school attendance committee to be urged, judged by the average attendance on the rolls, and there is also the desire of the local authority. These, as Deputy Cooper mentioned, are the conventional reasons.
Deputy Cooper also urged that in the future Dalkey and Killiney may be amalgamated with a greater Dublin. Personally, my hope is that before any such thing occurs there will be an amalgamation also in the other direction: that the administration of the Act in districts convenient to Dalkey within the Metropolitan area will be taken over by the Gárdaí and I hope that amalgamation will take place before the possibly distant date that is contemplated by Deputy Cooper. We realise there is nothing very anomalous in the fact that simply because you have one such big authority, there should be different authorities under the School Attendance Bill. You have that to a certain extent in the city of Dublin. At the present moment you have several distinct committees, each responsible for its own district.
Comment on this
Enforcing the same Act. I may remark that the difficulty about going from one school attendance area into another applies there quite as much as it would apply to Dalkey and Dun Laoghaire. There is no possibility of this amendment being accepted. I might add—and I do not suggest this with a view to stopping or shortening discussion in any way— that there is no possibility of any of the other amendments dealing with this particular schedule being accepted.
Comment on this
The Minister has made the position very clear. He is trying it on the dog, and Dalkey is the dog. If he succeeds in the case of Dalkey—I do not think he will—then he will be able to persuade the Dáil in regard to Dun Laoghaire and Blackrock. We will suffer that the Minister may achieve his ends.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
Amendment 32 reads: "In page 11 to add to the schedule the words `North Dublin Rural District."' The Minister said that the merits of all these amendments are equal. He is quite wrong. The merits of this amendment are not as strong as the merits of the last amendment.
Comment on this
When I drafted the amendments I tried to observe some principle in the schedule. One principle I could see was that urban districts should not come under the Gárdaí. Now I see that is not to be the case at all, and it is to be a question of the limit of the gullibility of the Gárdaí and the limit of their accessibility to persuasion—persuasion on the part of the Minister. That being so, no purpose will be served in moving the amendment.
Comment on this
I did not suggest that all the amendments were of equal merit. My hope was that they all would have the same fate. As regards the question of principle, I have no doubt that Deputy Bolger and Deputy D'Alton are also moving on matters of principle.
Comment on this
Amendment 33 reads: "In page 11 to add to the schedule the words `Killiney and Ballybrack Urban District."' That amendment was put in in order to be consistent. Nobody in Killiney or Ballybrack takes the slightest interest in this.
Comment on this
I am afraid it looks like a forlorn hope to bring this amendment before the Dáil:—
"In page 11, to add to the schedule the words `The Borough of Clonmel."'
Deputy O'Connell's amendment was to delete the county boroughs of Limerick and Waterford. His idea was that the Gárdaí should take charge there because the school attendance committees were not doing their duty.
Comment on this
I believe, according to the Minister, there are not sufficient Gárdaí available for the work. That applies especially as regards Clonmel and Tipperary. The Gárdaí in both places are very limited in number. In Clonmel the school attendance committee has charge of local services, including school dentistry, child welfare, etc.; all these things are controlled by the one committee. The reports of all those boards come before this committee. The school attendance in Clonmel has reached a 95 per cent. standard. In Clonmel and Tipperary school attendance is good because the school attendance committees are interested in the work and there is no occasion for the Gárdaí.
This Bill was brought in for the purpose of ensuring the attendance of children at school. Where you have a school attendance committee such as in Clonmel, the schools are visited every school day. There is no possibility of any child being absent. If a child is absent, members of the committee go to its home and ascertain why it has not been sent to school. You are now going to take this work out of the hands of Catholic and Protestant clergymen, important drapers, members of local authorities and fathers of families who are interested in this work. They have done good work and they have brought up the school attendance from 50 per cent. to 95 per cent. of the full school roll. I do not think it is good to bring in a civil power where it is not necessary. You are now going to bring in the Gárdaí where they are not required.
If the school attendance committees are not doing their duty, it should be open to the Minister to take immediate steps to have the Act administered as he may think fit. Why take the work from those who do it usefully and voluntarily? The members of those school attendance committees are usually connected with other activities and they are daily in contact with the schools and the homes of the people. I move the amendment and I hope it will be supported. If the Minister wishes to place it in the same category as Dalkey, Killiney and Ballybrack, he will have to explain his reason for so doing.
Comment on this
The main argument put up by Deputy D'Alton is that the committee in Clonmel that has charge of a lot of things, including child welfare, school attendance, meals for children, etc., has been doing its work excellently. I submit that the members of that committee will have a wider field now. The duty of getting the children into the school will be handed over to the Gárdaí, and the members of the committee will have a wider field in which to expend their very useful energies. I am glad there is one place in Ireland where an interest of the kind the Deputy speaks of is taken in school life.
Comment on this
If onerous, difficult work is taken from me I will hand it over very gladly. I would like to check the figures the Deputy gave before I accept them absolutely. He talked of an increased attendance from 50 to 95 per cent. I would like to know the period over which those figures extend and the manner in which they were made up. While accepting the Deputy's statement that there is a Committee there which takes an interest in its work, I suggest that in looking after school buildings, child welfare, meals for necessitous children, medical inspection and finding employment for such children as have passed the school age, the Committee will be very fully employed and can well afford to leave this other work to the Gárda Síochána.
Comment on this
I have not the slightest doubt that the tribute that has been paid by Deputy D'Alton to the Clonmel School Attendance Committee is well deserved. I am not quite sure about his figures. I do not say my figures are more correct, but there may be a slight divergence as to the actual percentages. The figures for 1924 show that 84 per cent. of the children on the rolls attended in Clonmel Urban District. According to the Census of 1911 the number of children between the ages of five and fifteen was 1,745. Of that number, 1,600 would be what I might term available children. The number on the rolls is 1,043 and the average attendance was 84 per cent. There are other places. The attendance in Deputy Cooper's Dalkey is 86.6; in Drogheda it is 86.5; Dundalk, 85; Fermoy, 89, and Wicklow, 85.5. From the point of view of effectiveness under this Act, I think Deputy D'Alton will recognise that in regard to other places as good a case can be made out as for Clonmel. It comes to this, that I could see no reason for taking on a place like Clonmel or Tipperary or Kilkenny. I am sorry I cannot accept this particular amendment.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I think the agreement was that that disposes of Amendment 35 as well. Deputies Doyle and Bolger are interested in an amendment referring to the Borough of Kilkenny.
Amendment 35—"In page 11 to add to the Schedule the words "Tipperary Urban District" (Louis J. D'Alton)— not moved.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 11 to add to the Schedule the words "the Borough of Kilkenny."
There is an important and effective committee in connection with school attendance in Kilkenny. It has been doing very good work for the past twenty-six years, and it is the wish of the committee to be retained in the position in which it has been carrying on for such a long period. I think that the arguments of Deputy D'Alton with regard to Clonmel have even a stronger force in regard to Kilkenny, where they have brought the attendance at schools during the year 1925 to the very high figure of 85 per cent.
Comment on this
I had an amendment down to the Schedule in the Committee Stage and it was by accident that I did not put it down for the Report Stage. In supporting the amendment of Deputy Bolger I wish to say that in the annual report dealing with primary schools, of which there are eleven in Kilkenny, it is stated that the percentage of attendance in 1923 was 85 per cent., and in 1924 it was 84 per cent. That was rather a disturbed time, a time when everybody was a law unto himself. The school attendance committee there have worked very hard and have done excellently by keeping the attendance as it is. I would not support this amendment if I thought it would, in any way, retard the progress of school attendance, as I desire to have it at the highest point possible. In the City of Kilkenny there is a population of 11,000, and in my opinion where there is such a large number of people the Gárda Síochána will have a difficult task to perform in regard to school attendance. The local committee should be allowed to co-operate with them and the borough should be included in the Schedule.
Comment on this
I feel impelled to move an amendment to insert Killarney and Tralee in the Schedule. The percentage there is 81 per cent. and the number on the roll between the ages of five and fifteen, according to the Census of 1911, is just 100 short of that in Galway. As a Minister, I would oppose such an amendment, but as a Deputy for Kerry I would be inclined to put down an amendment in favour of the inclusion of Killarney and Tralee. I will admit that there is very good work being done in Kilkenny by the local school attendance committee. The school-going population between the aged of 5 and 15 is 2,240, and the number on the roll is 2,027, which, in itself, is rather unique. I pay that tribute to Kilkenny, but on general principles we must rule out Kilkenny. I do not think, moreover, that there is full unanimity even in Kilkenny itself as to whether this school attendance committee should be kept on.
Comment on this
If the Minister has any doubt about unanimity amongst the representatives of Kilkenny, I may say that they are unanimous that the committee should be kept on, but, of course, I do not know what the President's opinion is.
Comment on this
I would. Why should Kilkenny be placed on a level with all these little provincial towns we are hearing about? We feel insulted that it should be compared with places like Tralee and Killarney. I do not think that it is fair to penalise Kilkenny in order, perhaps, to do the right thing in the case of Galway.
Comment on this
I have not heard any dissentient voice with regard to this amendment from the people of Kilkenny.
Comment on this
I recognise that I am up against a stone wall and that the policy of the Minister is going to prevail, but, perhaps, the President would tell us what his view is.
Comment on this
I looked upon this question, not as a representative of Kilkenny, but as a person responsible for doing what is fair and just to the whole country. Having looked at Kilkenny, I approached the next largest borough, which is Galway, and I found that Galway is out. There is this danger in urging a smaller place to be inserted and a larger place to be excluded, namely, that a very popular Deputy, if he were so inclined, might canvass and induce a large number of his friends to have his town included. That would be bad law and would reduce the character of the Dáil. As such, I am not satisfied that there is a case for the inclusion of Kilkenny. I am going to supplement what the Minister has said. I have heard objections from people in Kilkenny to the inclusion of the borough. I have also heard a case from Kilkenny to have it included, but, having considered all the circumstances, I am satisfied that I would not be justified, as a national representative in the Dáil, in putting in Kilkenny and keeping out Galway.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
The question now would be: "That the Bill, as amended, be received for final consideration." Does the Minister mean to take that now?
Comment on this
No, we will postpone it until the first day the House meets after to-morrow; that is, possibly Tuesday week.