FINANCIAL RESOLUTIONS—RESUMED. - RESOLUTION No. 15.—GENERAL.
Contributions 143–286 of 286. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am sorry the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is not here, so that I might congratulate him personally on his oratorical lecture on protection. To me it brought amusement, because he envisaged that protection helped in efficiency. To get this country going, with its inefficient merchants and millers and weavers, you must enforce protection. That was his argument all through. I protest against his quotation of Arthur Griffith. He said that Griffith said that in order to induce this country to take its place in ordinary commercial life, you should enforce protection because the people are technically inefficient and because the merchants have no business methods. That is really what the Minister said. I have not the slightest doubt that he was correct in saying that the people had no technical ability and that the merchants had no proper trading ability. I do not object to his saying that in the least, because in so far as the master weavers of Cork are concerned, I have personal knowledge of their want of business methods. In other countries, the merchants seek their customers. They go round from wholesaler to wholesaler or from shop to shop and they try to secure orders. The man from South America or East Africa who wants to buy has to hunt up the weavers of Cork. I know that of my own knowledge. Instead of the weavers seeking out their customers, these people have to come and seek them out.
As far as the closing of the flour mills in Cork is concerned, I would like to be assured that it is not altogether camouflage or an effort to force the hands of the Minister for Finance. I do not doubt in the least that the flour millers in Cork or the flour millers in other parts of Ireland could produce as good flour as the Rankins and Spillers of Cardiff and Liverpool. But do they go to the trouble to do so? They do not. The Spillers and the Rankins take women from the West of Ireland, bring them over to their mills in England and set them making different combinations of flour, so that they will produce bread that will satisfy the people. The people want white bread—perfectly white bread—but the Irish millers will not go to the trouble to meet the tastes of the people. It is not many months ago since —I suppose more or less by chance— Odlums in the Midlands of Ireland produced a flour for which they were able to get orders as against Spillers and Bakers and every other firm. Why do not the millers try and meet the wishes of the people?
The same thing holds good in the clothing industry. They make very good cloth, but they never take the slightest trouble to meet the wishes of the customer. It is always a case of "take it or leave it." The same spirit seems to run through the commercial life of the country. In eating or weaving, there is no effort made to provide what the people want. It is said that the price of boots has not been increased. It has been increased by three shillings or four shillings. The people have paid it, but down the country they are continually growling about the prices they are paying for everything. I do not blame them in the least. The Minister says that the prices of the protected articles have not been increased. Who gets the thirty-three and a third per cent.? Either the manufacturer or the mechanic must get it, but I am sure it is not the mechanic gets it. There is a lot of nonsense talked about "dumping." What does "dumping" consist of? It consists of landing a manufactured article in a country at a price less than the cost of production. Does that occur in Ireland or is anyone able to prove that it occurs? So far as the technical knowledge of Irish manufacturers is concerned, such knowledge runs more or less in families. A man generally acquires a technical knowledge of the business in which his father, grandfather, and, perhaps, great-grandfather have been engaged. Do the Irish merchants make any attempt to instruct technically their children? Do they ever think that their sons should soil their hands while seated at a loom for a day or half a day? Do they ever think that they should soil their clothes as ordinary workmen in the mill? Do they ever consider the sending of their sons into the office to work as clerks, attending at the same hours and drawing the same pay at the end of the month? They do not. It is not so many years ago since I was invited, while going down the quays in Dublin, to have lunch aboard a ship there. I met on board a young chap of eighteen years. When that boy became twenty-one, he would be entitled, in his own right, to £250,000. That chap was covered with grease. What the people lack in this country is respect for labour. That lack of respect runs through the whole community. I could say a great deal about Protection, but I should like to have it proved that in any country where Protection was introduced it did not increase the cost of living. There is no analogy between this country and the United States. This country has a population of three millions or four millions. Between the different States of the United States there is free trade, and they have a population of 150,000,000. They do not manufacture in every State. Some of the States are absolutely agricultural, as the greater part of Ireland is. A lot that is said about Protection here is merely moonshine. What you have to teach the people in this country is respect for labour and care in small things. There is not a thing manufactured in Ireland at present that I know of that is not rejected, some time or other, on account of want of care in detail.
The Minister for Agriculture, some time ago, brought in a Bill for the protection of the egg industry. I suggest that he should bring in a Bill for the protection of the wool industry. The wool sent out of Ireland is absolutely scandalous. It is dirty, wet and badly put together. If a wool merchant here in Dublin or Belfast or Cork gets an order once from a Continental firm—it is only in special cases that he does get such an order—he will not get an order again, simply on account of the dirty, filthy and wet state of the wool. I do not want to say more as far as he is concerned.
I ask the Minister for Finance to reconsider the matter of the £1 licence duty. It is altogether too high, and, in a great measure, affects poor people. If it is at all possible I should be very glad if he could reduce it. In point of fact the licence duties put on lately are altogether too high. A £2 fishing-rod licence is altogether too high.
Comment on this
I am sorry I cannot congratulate the Minister for Finance on his Budget. Like the Farmers' Party, I got a little surprise. I was sure that, at least, the price of stout would have been reduced, and I will have to take my beating like Deputy Gorey. We were told that Ireland would be governed according to Irish ideas. The vast majority of the Irish people, at the present time, would welcome a reduction in the price of stout. I do not speak of whiskey. I am speaking for stout as the poor man's drink. It was described, and recognised, by one of our most eminent Deputies, Sir James Craig, as a food, and, I believe, as a digestive. I have said I am not sorry in respect of whiskey, although it would affect the trade that I partly represent here, but I am a man of many parts presently. I endorse a lot of what the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said here to-day. I would go a long way in putting a tariff upon any article that could be produced in Ireland without any increase in the cost of living—a difficult thing to achieve, of course. But it could be achieved in Cork. In Cork we are on top of everybody. Some speaker here—I think it was Deputy McBride—mentioned that flour could not be made in this country as good as it is made in England.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I misquoted the Deputy. I say if we had the same wheat coming in free to the country, flour could be manufactured in Ireland just as good as any coming from England. There would be only one difference, namely, that we would be paying for Irish labour instead of paying for English labour. Next to agriculture it is recognised that the flour milling industry half a century ago was one of the staple industries of this country. Now what do we find? Nothing in the mills but jackdaws roaming round the chimneys. There were three mills shut down in Cork within the last two or three years. Half-time is paid in a flour mill in East Cork, where I come from, and a whole lot of men are going two or three times a week to the unemployment office looking for money that they do not get as often as they should get —at least so they say.
I come back to the stout, and I say that it would be the most desirable and popular reduction of the whole lot. The most important bodies in Ireland, including the Cork Co. Council, have sent resolutions to the Minister for Finance —I do not know whether he got them all; I suppose if he did he threw them away—asking for a reduction in the tax on stout. I do not know if they gave me a mandate to use my influence with the Minister, but it was something to that effect.
I would also like to see a little tariff put upon tweeds and other things coming into the country. We have an example in Cork, where, owing to the tariff on boots, a factory has been enlarged to six times its former size and is paying a wage of £4,000 a month, whereas it was idle before the tariff. And not an increase of one penny has been made in the price of the boots. That is an example of what a tariff can do and of what Cork can do. The boots are just as good as any imported. Anything we have in this country does not seem to be good in the minds of some people, simply because it did not get a taste of salt water coming across. Tweeds, made in this country, by Irish tradesmen, should be good enough for the Irish people. If we were really patriotic, and meant what we said —we would try to make sacrifices to help the country. I think we would be as warm in Blarney tweeds as in any tweeds made in the North of England, and more so. Why do we not support these home productions? There is no use crawling to the Irish people to support them. I think we should force them to support them. This Budget is not forcing them to support them.
I do not know whether the Minister for Finance was a bit nervous or not, but I assure him that the unfortunate workmen throughout the country, half starved, and their families half starved, and with their fireless firesides, would welcome in the morning a tariff on flour and tweed coming into the country. I was coming up here a few days ago from Cork and I met Deputy Egan. He said: "There is another mill closed down," pointing to the Cork Spinning Company. I hope I may not have to apologise to the Cork Spinning Company, but I think it was that company he pointed out. There are a lot of Cork industries that could be revived if we only tried to do so. We are told we must wait until next year for a good Budget, for some reason or other, but we are not so forgetful, if we get some little concession this year not to remember it next year.
A tax has been put on wine. That is no harm, but I ask the Minister to reduce the tax on stout, and in doing so I am only carrying out the mandate given to me by the Cork County Council, the most august body in Ireland, including this. As I said, there is no use in singing "Sweet spirits, hear my prayer"—there is no use in my advocating the reduction of the tax on whiskey. I could not say that it was a food. I could only say that if you took five or six glasses going to bed you would have your breakfast in the morning cooked and all, because you could eat no breakfast. I must conclude by asking the Minister to reduce the price of stout to 6d. a pint, so that the poor, unfortunate workingman, who cannot do without it and who uses it as a food, will be able to give "two knocks for a bob," as they call it.
Comment on this
The introduction of the Budget is an annual stocktaking, and gives an opportunity of examining the country's position— what has been done and how it has been done, so that we may be able to do better in the future. In a normal country this annual stocktaking is of great importance, but it is of immeasurably greater importance to a new and experimental Government. We are a highly favoured people in many respects, possessed of natural intelligence of the first order. No one can contradict that. We have a beautifully fertile country with great natural resources which, if intelligently developed, would make it the most prosperous country in Europe. While the long debates were going on in January, 1922, I met one of the ablest bankers that this country has produced, and a good Irishman as well. He said to me: "What is all this prattle about in Dublin?" I said: "I do not know; I was up there during the week and returned last night, and I happened to be in the Dáil. It happened to be the session in which Document No. 2 first saw the light or was produced publicly, and I need not tell you that it was a rather electrical session.""If we could only take this Treaty," he said, "and operate it, we have all the resources to make this the most prosperous country in Europe." We did not take it without friction and disorder, but even now I hold that if we only could act together and have concord amongst the people, we could still make it one of the most prosperous countries in Europe.
The principal obstructions to our progress at the moment are (1) loss of national spirit; (2) the casual nature of a good proportion of our employment; (3) reduced industrial output owing to lack of demand thereby increasing the cost of production. As to (1): Some years ago we had a fine national spirit which, unfortunately, has almost entirely disappeared owing to circumstances that I need not now refer to. Instead of national spirit we now have apathy. Apathy consumes like rust. The two causes contributing to this condition are economic depression and disillusionment. The tide of fashion is a big factor in the country's economy and that seems to have gone against us for the moment. Is there any attempt to have our stability based on the operations of our own economic system? Has the Government a policy? If so, what is it? Has it ever been clearly stated? Scrappy flippancy is not the proper method of stating a national policy. The Minister for Finance wants more industries. He has stated so on public platforms. He wants people with money to start industries. In view of the condition of existing industries and the attitude of the Government towards them who would start industries here? He wants to produce more wealth—a very desirable thing— and have a larger population, but, as a matter of fact, his policy has driven and is driving out a good proportion of our population. Industry determines population and science is the handmaid of industry. The greatest asset possessed by any country is a healthy, active working population. The Government policy is well devised to reduce our population to a minimum. As to the result of tariffs: the West Britons and those opposed to Irish national freedom——
Comment on this
The remark and the force of it are lost on the man who makes it. The West Britons and those opposed to Irish national freedom are never tired of dwelling on the slight improvement in such industries as have got a tariff during the last year or two. Every intelligent man knows that the effects of a tariff are not immediate, but slow, steady and continuous. Some newspapers say that we have not produced another Northampton or Lancashire. Do we desire it? Those whose spiritual home is in England never desired an Irish Free State or any but a servile State. As to production and distribution: too much of the country's energy is absorbed in distribution and too little in production. Hence we give permanent employment to several thousand men and women in other countries by importing several million pounds worth of goods that could and ought to be made in this country, and give employment to our own people.
I wish to say a word as to the fallacy of tariffs increasing the cost of living in several instances. Bread is essential to our people. The price of flour is determined by the cost of production in the Irish mills. Let that be clearly understood. The price of flour is not determined by the dumpers. It is determined by the cost of flour at the Irish mills. Imported flour is sold in this country slightly under the price of Irish flour merely to effect a sale. The English mills produce 40 per cent. more than is required for English consumption. This country is the happy hunting ground for the surplus. I think it would be wise to enlighten some people here who were never in the firing line of industry. The miller in England has a huge output, and there are huge mills at the ports, the bulk of which have a capacity of 100 sacks per hour. He has a demand in his own country for 60 per cent., 65 per cent., or 70 per cent. of his output. The balance he sends away, and, while of course he is a business man and will get what he can for it, he is not in the same position when selling that surplus as he is when selling the bulk of his production, which, if sold at a profit, will keep his mills and his business going. It is better business for him to sell the surplus under cost rather than reduce the capacity of his mill. I am a flour miller and served my apprenticeship to it, and I challenge contradiction from anyone in the Dáil on this subject. It is better business for a miller to keep his mill going full capacity, because every time the modern roller mill is shut down and gets cold, it does poor work for a time after it is restarted. In addition, the miller has the full swing of his large business. The surplus quantity is sent to this country at whatever price it will fetch, and it is sold at 6d. or 1/- under what the Irish miller sells his flour at. It has been stated here that that flour is sold at the same price as it is sold in England. It is not. Quite recently it was sold at exactly the same price in Ireland as the miller sold it at his own door. Where does the freight and other charges come in? How can a man manufacturing flour in England, and who sells it in Dublin. Cork or anywhere else, say he sells it at the same price here, after paying all costs? That is dumping. Not only that, but that man is prepared to go a bit further, because if 1/- will not do he will give 2/- of a cut. The Irish miller has no dumping. The Irish miller must pay 20/- in the £ to carry on business; he must pay labour and all other expenses, and consequently he cannot afford to do things that the British miller can do with the surplus. I want that to be clearly understood.
Comment on this
As the Deputy has issued a challenge, may I ask if he is aware that the price of bread, made even with dumped flour, is from 1½d. to 6½d. per 41b. loaf dearer in Dublin than in any town in Great Britain or Northern Ireland? Can he give any figures as to the price of bread in Cork?
Comment on this
I am very glad Deputy Cooper has pat that question. The price that the Irish miller or that any other miller sells his flour at has no direct connection with the price of bread. You have to remember, in the case we are discussing, that flour is not the finished article. Bread is the finished article, and the intermediary— the baker—who produces the bread can effect the difference. I know exactly where the trouble lies but somehow I am very slow to state it.
Comment on this
We all need the mantle of charity now and again, and I am not so quick to throw stones as other Deputies.
Comment on this
My conscience is all right. There is nothing on it, thank God. In passing, I may say that I agree with Deputy Cooper that bread is altogether too dear. The price is too high for the loaf, and I say that it is entirely out of proportion to the cost of flour. That is as far as I will go. Another business that I know something about, and that I have recently paid well for knowing something about, is woollen manufactures. Before I come to deal with the woollen side of the business, I would like to say a word to Deputy McBride about his remarks. I do not know exactly where he comes from. It may be Achill Island, but he does not seem to know what is happening here. He must come from a very remote corner of this country and he has a very small opinion of his country and his countrymen. I do not share in that opinion, and I am sure the bulk of the Deputies do not share it. The whole burden of his theme, and it is the second time that I heard him repeating it—is like the Jews of old, "Can anything good come out of Nazareth"—can Irishmen turn out anything properly? He talked about Irish manufacturers not knowing their business, and of their sons not knowing their business. Well, I belong to the sixth or seventh generation of a family of millers. My sons have been trained. and well trained, and I have one of them in the gallery who is as well trained a man as there is in Ireland. He is not afraid to soil his hands or to dip into the grease. There are other people in the country who have done the same thing. It is a very cheap thing to say that everything made in Ireland is rubbish. It is very cheap but not justified. We have faults, but we have not them to that extent. Woollen mills are one of our oldest and most useful industries. We were all born naked and must have clothes, because we are not allowed to go in public without them for reasons of public decency, and the law forbids our doing so.
Comment on this
Some of us do, but it is in the interests of fashion and being up-to-date. This woollen industry survived the oppression and neglect of a foreign Government, and now under the fostering care of a native Government this industry is allowed to decay. It receives no help from the Government. When we talk about tariffs let us bear in mind that tariffs are not protection pure and simple. In protected countries tariffs are set up of from 50 to 100 per cent. and more, but we are talking of a wretched 15 per cent. or 20 per cent. merely to assist our industries and prevent them from decay over a period of depression. The capital invested in this industry amounts to one and a half million pounds for buildings, lands and machinery. The number employed is 4,500, and the possible output of those mills in the Free State is six million yards annually. Tariffs are something new to our people, as is also unfortunately the whole science of Government. As Lloyd George—I do not always agree with him, but I agree with him in this—when people were finding fault in England with our Irish Government, said: "Well, you cannot blame them very much; we never gave them an opportunity of practising. They are only starting out and you cannot expect wonderful things from them."
It should be clearly understood that tariffs, to be effective, must be general. If the woollen industry dies there will be so many less buyers of boots, and if the industry prospers it would be a helpful fillip to other industries in the country. These industries help each other, and if you let one die out it will be a loss to the rest. That is a point I want to drive home. Industries are interdependent. There is not an industry you establish anywhere in the country that does not help other industries. About it there are other industries that want one hundred and one things. It was with great regret I noticed the absence of sympathy for those who own industries and are employed in them. I am afraid that that absence of sympathy is due to want of knowledge. Somebody said that "Mischief is wrought by want of thought as well as want of heart." I am of opinion that it is for want of thought and not for want of heart that our Ministers have not done better on this occasion. There are men in this country who have put every shilling they possessed into Irish industry, and I happen to be one of them. Every shilling I ever possessed I put into Irish industries.
If a few years ago I did as most of my neighbours did and put my money in Imperial tobacco or British or other securities, I would be in a different position to what I am to-day. Is the man who puts his all in Irish industry to be let down? That is what our Government said to-day—that they are to be let down. Was this the policy of Arthur Griffith? I am afraid as regards some of the people in authority to-day that the policy of Griffith is a dead letter. However, I hope and believe that it will be revived to the country's advantage. There has been a lot of talk now and again about the revival of the soul of Ireland. I am one of those who subscribe to it, and am prepared to stand by it. I want to see the soul of Ireland revived, but I am not a spiritualist or a spook. I know well that a soul cannot be maintained without a body. If it is the policy of the Government to let the body die, to let the industries of this country that held out against great odds, maintained their position, served the country well by employing people and kept the ball rolling, die, then what cant it is to talk about the revival and preservation of the soul!
Comment on this
I hope it is quite clear that we are not attempting to collect more revenue than we intend to spend. On the contrary, we are deducting £650,000 from our estimated expenditure. We budgeted on that. I think that is quite clear, but I also think there is a doubt about it from the way Deputy Johnson treated it to-day. If we were not engaged in initiating new schemes as a result of legislation it would be quite simple to make up the estimates very accurately indeed, very close to what is exactly required. But remember our position. I speak about my own Department, because I happen to know it best, but I am in exactly the same case in that regard as almost every other Minister. We passed three or four new Acts— the Land Act, the Dairy Produce and Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Acts, the Live Stock Act, and we have schemes like the beet sugar. These are all new, and as there was no experience of these schemes it is quite impossible to say with any accuracy at what pace they will develop. There are one hundred and one considerations that might affect the matter. Take the Dairy Produce Act. As to how soon that will come into full operation depends upon a number of factors over which we have no control, and regarding which we have no experience. It depends on the condition in which we find the creameries, and how fast we can get them to do something they have not been asked to do before. It will depend on how soon we can recruit new officials for special and new work initiated under the new legislation. On the other hand, you are supposed to assume infallibility. That is supposed to be the correct pose in the Dáil. I cannot adopt it, and I cannot say that we can measure these considerations of which we and the country have no experience. Consequently I cannot say for certain whether parts two or four of this will be in operation during the coming year. I take that as one example, and I could apply it to every other piece of legislation I spoke about. I know, however, it is vital to put the Act into operation as soon as possible.
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain the position? Is he right in assuming that the estimate is above rather than below the actual expenditure that will come in view of these uncertainties?
Comment on this
The Minister has spoken of the uncertainties and the difficulties of looking ahead because of inexperience, but he is asking us to assume that the balance will be on the right side, that there is a certainty of 2½ per cent. and that the actual expenditure will be less than the estimated expenditure.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy let me come to that? That point arises, but I have got to develop it first. Take the Dairy Produce Act. I am just certain of one thing, that it is vital to put it into full operation as soon as possible. Everyone agrees with that, but I am not in a position to say and no one from whom I can seek advice is in a position to say, just how soon we can put the various stages into operation. Possibly I may be able to put the five parts into operation, and I estimate on that. I did the same in regard to the Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Act. I did the same in regard to the licensing of bulls, and the same in regard to the sugar beet project. I can be fairly certain as a matter of experience that I will not be able to live up to my programme in some respects. Perhaps the Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Act. the Improvement of Live Stock Act, or the Dairy Produce Act will fall short in some respects. I can be fairly certain, taking ordinary chances, that I will not be able to live up to the programme that I would like to, in regard to some matters, but in the beginning of the year I cannot say which and must therefore assume, especially as it is only margin of about 2½ per cent., that I hope to put these things into operation. While I have put the Eggs Act into full operation, in regard to the Dairy Produce Act I find other reasons because of which I cannot say at this stage that it might be exactly the other way about. That is the answer to the Deputy's question. These are the reasons why it is somewhat more difficult at this stage to estimate exactly our expenditure than it would be in five or six years' time when our schemes are in operation, when they are working automatically, and when you could estimate very closely just what you would require for the next year.
Deputy Gorey used the phrase that "expenditure must be based on assets." I suggest that we could all agree with him if he would say that policy must be based on assets. because policy controls expenditure. Here we are, two or three weeks after the discussion that took place on expenditure in the Dáil, in which we endeavoured to point out that expenditure depended almost exclusively on policy. We gave figures to show that. I showed just what increases there were in the agricultural services for the last three years and just exactly what those services were, and I pointed out that there was only one effective way of lessening the expenditure and that that was by dropping some of these new services.
Comment on this
Some of the new services vices. I pointed out there could be a very big decrease in taxation if we could get the Dáil to agree that these new services should be dropped.
Comment on this
I gave figures when I was speaking here on the last occasion showing that the new agricultural services had increased expenditure by £1,000,000, one way or another—the Agricultural Grant, the Sugar Beet, the Board of Works Loans, the administration of the Land Commission as a result of the 1923 Act, and of the Department of Agriculture as a result of the three Acts I referred to, and also as a result of the increased provisions for agricultural education in the universities. I pointed out that all these meant millions and that if Deputies were really serious that taxation ought to be reduced, there was only one way of doing it, and that was by dropping these services. I must remark that not a single Deputy on the Farmers' benches met that point. May I put it another way, that not a single Deputy who has been talking about high salaries met that point. The Minister for Finance yesterday gave simple figures, easily remembered. If, he said, there was a 20 per cent. cut in all the salaries, including bonus over £500, there would be a reduction of £180,000 odd, and if, in addition to that, there was a further 20 per cent. cut on all salaries, including bonus over £750, we would get a figure which, if added to the £180,000, would give something like £250,000. If you deduct the income tax from that you would get something like £180,000 or £190,000.
I want to know whether the optimists really contemplate any more drastic cuts in the salaries of officials than, say, 20 per cent. on every salary over £500, and a further additional 20 per cent. cut on every salary over £750, whether in common justice they contemplate that, and if they do, whether they are satisfied that the financial results of that cut are going to be worth the money. In any event, in talking of a saving of millions, I want to give up talking about a saving on salaries in view of these figures. Yet here we are to-day. On this debate the only contribution made in connection with the demand for a decrease in expenditure is the good old one that requires no thought, that is regarded as popular if you like, regarded as easy, so to speak—the expression "cut salaries." You are going to get £150,000 out of it. It does not matter about the equities. It does not matter that these civil servants, during the war, when the cost of living had increased 200 per cent. on the pre-war figure, had their salaries increased only by 50 per cent. They are now to be cut down to the pre-war level, because that is what this cut would do. All this is to be done in the interests of something like £180,000.
Comment on this
When I was giving the figures of the Minister for Finance I gave figures which referred to the Supply services as a whole, and not to the Department of Agriculture alone.
Comment on this
I will come to that. That of course is the last ditch. Why not make one man do the work of ten or eleven men? It is just as easy to say that as the other. There is no use in saying it except you can show you have some good reason for believing it could be done.
Comment on this
The Deputy is well aware that, as Deputy Duffy's colleague, I am trying to carry out his policy as well as I can.
Comment on this
In the interest of getting at results, we must make up our minds to it. If Deputies think that this country is overtaxed I cannot agree. I have the figures here. Com pared with other countries the taxation of the Saorstát is very much lower, taking local and State taxation. I need not give the figures now.
Comment on this
It would take too long. But you can take it as a fact that the taxation is lower here. I can supply the figures. If Deputies think that this country is heavily overtaxed, there must be a substantial reduction in expenditure, not a small reduction, but a substantial reduction of two or three millions. Then let us see what services are to be dropped. Let us take the responsibility of saying what services are to be dropped. It is not good enough to ride away by simply having a shot at the senior civil servants. I believe myself, and I always understood that in that I had the support of the Deputies from almost all parts of the House, that the principle of paying according to the work done is a sound one. On that principle, there is no doubt whatever about it, the lowest-paid officers of this State are the senior civil servants. But of course that principle, which Farmer Deputies and others will swear by when it suits their argument, will be discarded the very moment some other moral is to be drawn. But we cannot do business that way. I will ask Deputies who talk about big reductions are those services to be cut down—who are the servants to be cut down?
This is a most exacting country. It requires probably more social service by the State than any other country. Denmark has been quoted just like Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and other countries as an analogy. Well, these analogies are very often false. I do not like analogies, but I think that there is one point that could be made with justice with regard to Denmark, and the point that what has been done in Denmark might be done here. You have, for instance, control of the egg and poultry industry in Denmark. You have in Denmark control of the butter industry, and I think, of the bacon industry, but I am not sure about the latter. But as far as eggs, poultry and butter are concerned there is control in Denmark, but it is not by the State. Even though the taxation of Denmark is very high, higher than the taxation of this country, control has been not by the State but by the Farmers' Organisation, to whom the State gives a very small subsidy I was in Denmark, and I was rather careful to ask the number of the technical officers attached to the Agricultural Department in Denmark. I found the number extraordinarily few. I thought that rather strange, and I made further inquiries and what did I find? I found that there was practically the same number of technical agricultural officers in Denmark as in Ireland, but that at least 80 per cent. of them were attached to associations which were appointed and controlled by the Farmers' Organisation, and these organisations get comparatively small subsidies from the State. Obviously agriculture is administered more economically, but they have the same services in Denmark as here. I should say that if we had the same conditions here, if we had farmers' organisations here controlling their own produce, their butter, eggs and bacon, doing these things as only voluntary associations can do them, with the economy that voluntary associations can effect, then we would have all the advantages of that control at probably 30 per cent. or 40 per cent. less expense.
But that is out of the question. The State must do it here. Not only must the State carry out the services here in this exacting country which are carried out elsewhere by farmers' associations, but it must carry out a lot of other services which are never asked for in those other countries. At any rate, that is the position, and I must implore Deputies, in the name of decency, not to talk of reducing expenditure unless they are prepared to take the responsibility of coming forward and putting up the definite particular services which they require dropped.
I do not wish for a moment to imply that I would be prepared to agree that these services should be dropped. Not at all. I think, for instance, that the money expended in controlling the egg and poultry industry has absolutely justified itself even after a year, and I challenge anyone to deny it. It has absolutely justified itself. I do not like to make prophecies, but I say that at the end of this year, notwithstanding that we will not have every part of the Dairy Produce Act in operation, it will be abundantly clear that the Dairy Produce Act will have justified itself as it is now admitted that the Egg Act has justified itself. I think the money is well spent. I think the money expended on agricultural education is also well spent. I do not share the view that the Irish farmer is uneducated. That is wrong. I think the money spent on education is well spent. I think the money spent on these other services is well spent, and I am prepared to defend them, and to ask the Dáil to agree with me. What I am saying is this—that if there are people who differ with us let them come forward and state the services they want dropped, and let us have it out here, but do not talk of reductions of two or three or four million pounds in taxation, and then suggest, as a means for the purpose of reduction, a remedy which, even if applied in the most drastic way to the extent of 20 per cent. on salaries, and if even that cut were followed by another cut of 20 per cent., at the most you would only get £216,000.
I think, as I mentioned it, I had better quote the figures for taxation and expenditure in these countries. The figure for Denmark is, approximately, for State and local revenue, about £40,000,000.
Comment on this
Yes. For Holland I have the figures for 1923. Holland has a population of 6,000,000, and the taxation for that year was £204,000,000.
Comment on this
I am just meeting one point and drawing no conclusions. I know that conclusions that are very often drawn from statements of the revenue and expenditure of these various countries are often absolutely false, even though the statement of the revenue is correct. I am drawing no conclusion. I am dealing with the one point—that we are more highly taxed in the Saorstát than the people of Holland or Belgium or Denmark where we are told the taxation is lower. And then these people go on and say the same about Canada and New Zealand. I am not going to say that. The taxable capacity of a country depends a great deal upon the wealth of a country and the population; that is a complicated subject. Here I am meeting one point, namely, that we are more highly taxed than any other people in Europe.
Comment on this
It is quite simple to do that. The population of Denmark is not more than three and a half millions and the taxation is £40,000,000.
Comment on this
I am not quite sure of the year, but I think it is 1924. Holland, with a population of about six millions, had to meet a taxation of £204,000,000. Canada had to meet £143,000,000 in 1924, and the population there is about eight millions. New Zealand, with a population of one and a half millions, had a taxation in 1924 of £38,000,000. Norway, with a population higher than New Zealand but not higher than Canada, had a taxation in 1923 of £55,000,000.
Comment on this
I will not refer to Australia. The taxation is far and away higher than the taxation of Ireland, although there is not so much of a difference in the population; but it would be absurd to compare a continent with an island.
Comment on this
I would like to put the Minister a question with regard to taxation in Canada and other countries. Has the Minister made the Dáil aware of the fact that the taxation in Canada includes State services which do not exist here, such as State railways?
Comment on this
I thought I made it clear that I was meeting one point— the bald statement made here that our taxation was higher than the taxation of other countries.
Comment on this
Does the Minister for Lands and Agriculture consider that he has rebutted the charge that has been made?
Comment on this
If it is stated that the taxation of Canada is twenty millions, and if I can show that it is forty millions, I consider I have made my point.
Comment on this
The Deputy has referred to the same services. We will pursue that as far as he wishes; I do not know that the result will suit him. As far as Denmark is concerned, they do not have anything like the same services from the State. They get the service, but the State does not give it. I wonder have they control of the butter and egg industry in Canada?
Comment on this
If Deputies wish we can go into the services that are done by the State in other countries for the advantage of the citizens. If we touch upon that matter we will find that in regard to Denmark services are not as well done there as in the Saorstát; compared with Denmark we have to do far more services. Further, if Canada insists on giving services which we are not giving, that is one reason why taxation is so high there. That is my point. You can have these first-class services, social and otherwise, but you must be prepared to pay for them. The question for Farmer Deputies and others is: Are the services worth the money?
We are told that we must keep old officers and not recruit new ones. Farmer Deputies ought to know how much work the technical officers of the Department of Agriculture have to do; they ought to be some judges as to whether those officers are fully occupied. In the matter of dairy produce it means close and constant inspection, for long periods, of every creamery in the country. According to some of the proposals made here we are to turn to the agricultural instructors and the livestock officers and say: "In addition to your other work you are to do all this business."
Comment on this
I could give very many examples, but it all comes down to the same thing. We are told that there is a good case for not interfering with officers at present doing duty and we are asked not to recruit any new officers. If you are to have new services you must have new officers. It is not right to say that officers were dug in at the peak period during the war. They were not dug in at any time. They are dug in now at very much less than what they had then and the minute the cost of living falls their salaries will fall likewise. I will now refer to tariffs. We have a tariff on oatmeal and it is despised.
Comment on this
I think there is a lot in what Deputy MacBride said. We are inclined to despise small things in this country. In an agricultural country we should never despise small things. Watching the small things means a successful farmer. If there are good reasons for putting on a tariff on oatmeal, whether in the interests of the farmers or the mills, which are now to a very large extent attached to farmers' societies, then it should be done. If you want grandiose tariffs, such as were suggested by Deputy O'Shaughnessy, then advocate them and defend them. I am surprised at the attitude of Deputies who say that this is only a small matter. I remember that we had a discussion last year in connection with tariffs and much to my surprise I found Deputy Wilson advocating practically all-round tariffs on agricultural products. He was supported by Deputy Conlan and Deputy Connor Hogan, with some slight modifications. I distinctly remember that that attitude rather surprised me at the time. There was a very strong— almost a drastic—case put up for tariffs. It was not put up by one member of the Farmers' Party, but by several.
Comment on this
It was put up by Deputy Wilson, Deputy Conlan, and Deputy Connor Hogan, and others supported them. They endeavoured to show that from the farmers' point of view there was nothing in a tariff on flour. That is what I object to in the advocacy of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs in connection with flour. Let him advocate the tariff on flour from the point of view of flour millers or broad national policy, and there is something to be said for it from that point. There is something to be said for the growing of wheat; from the point of view of increasing the price which the farmer is to get for his wheat, there is nothing in it. In any case, a tariff was suggested by the farmers' Deputies—by Deputy Wilson, supported by others. They suggested a tariff on bacon, a tariff on oats and a tariff on barley. That was suggested by Deputy Conlan.
Comment on this
They suggested also a tariff on butter. Certain members of the Farmers' Party made it clear that they did not agree. But I do remember this distinctly, that we all agreed that the one thing that might be protected and that would confer some very slight benefit on a limited number of farmers, without doing any harm whatever to anybody else, was oatmeal. Even though it is a slight benefit I am ready to stand for it. If it is not a grandiose scheme, that does not matter. If there are twenty or thirty farmers' mills attached to these societies through the country that will be materially assisted by this tariff, why not give it to them? It is not doing any harm. Certainly no possible disadvantages of such a tariff would be big enough to counterbalance the advantages to these twenty or thirty societies. Hence we have agreed to it.
I suggest that you will have to approach tariffs from that point of view. I do not understand a man saying: "We must have a general tariff." I do not understand a man saying: "It would be possible to produce all our food in this country." It would. I think we could grow tea, provided there was a subsidy big enough to pay for greenhouses, heating, and so on, just as I think we could grow tobacco with a subsidy of about £116 an acre. These are, perhaps, extreme examples, but they show what I mean. It is not a question of whether we can produce the food we require. The question is: Can we produce it economically, or could the money we would spend on it be better spent otherwise? That is the whole question, and you cannot answer it by making a generalisation that applies to every item on the list. What applies to one item does not apply to another. There is no other way of examining this tariff question than by coming down to specific items, and hearing the pros and cons in each case. That is what is suggested when a Tariff Commission is talked about, and the great advantage is that these matters are to be heard in public. Might I say also that I do not like identifying tariff reform with patriotism. It is not good enough. There is something very like cant being talked on this question of tariff reform. I will say that, especially outside, there is something very like cant being talked on the free trade side, and I suppose that is the reason why there is something like cant on the tariff reform side. Tariff reform is not synonymous with patriotism, and you cannot take it as following inevitably that if A. B. announces that he is not prepared to have a tariff on flour, or on American bacon, he is inevitably a West Briton. That is what it is coming to; we might as well be frank about it, and I would like Deputies to realise that tariffs are often dictated by personal interests that are very far removed from patriotism. Tariffs are very often suggested by people who have interests in England, just as free trade is often preached by people who have personal interests in favour of free trade. I object to these sweeping denunciations, either of tariff reform or of free trade, and I object to this tendency to talk cant on the question, because that is just beginning to happen. It was suggested that there ought to be a tariff on oats. I would very much like to agree, if the House wants such a tariff. I would very much like the Minister for Finance to agree if the House wants it.
Comment on this
The majority. After all, we were twitted a short time ago that we were speaking with different voices and were told that there was apparently a certain amount of independence in the Government Party. You cannot have it both ways. If the House wants a tariff on oats, after hearing the arguments pro and con, let them have it. There is an import, I should say, of something over £250,000 worth of oats, of which I think about £80,000 worth is seed oats, and if Deputies think that it would be any great advantage to have seed oats, and also feeding oats, a little dearer they can have a tariff. I do not think so. I believe a tariff on oats would be purely a revenue tariff, because I believe that the Canadian oats comes in for a special reason, and will have to come in.
With regard to the point of view of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs I said before that I did not like analogies, and surely it is absurd to quote Australia, New Zealand and Canada as analogous with this country. I dare say that there is no emigration from Australia, except the return of immigrants to England for short periods, and I dare say in a continent like Australia with a present population of 5,000,000, and probably capable of finding work for ten, fifteen or twenty millions, as far as natural resources are concerned, there is not likely to be any great emigration from it. Canada is also a vast country, almost as big as the United States, a new country. undeveloped. It is no wonder that there is not emigration from these countries. New Zealand is in the same case though not quite to the same extent. Further, these countries grow wheat and are particularly suited for the growing of wheat. No tariff that we can put on would bring the Canadian climate or soil here, and these things count. It may be even though there are these differences in connection with soil, climate and natural conditions, that nevertheless the same tariff that applies in Australia would also suit here. But what I object to is simply the bald statement, without any examination of the factors, that because there is some tariff on flour in Australia, where vast areas of wheat are grown, there ought also to be a tariff here. Australia grows sugar cane and is very suitable for it. Why not say: "Australia has a big sugar cane industry; why should we not?"
In connection with flour there is just one point I wish to make. I do not want to go into this question from the point of view of the millers. I say this, with all deference to Deputy O'Shaughnessy: Obviously the first consideration that should be examined when considering whether a tariff on flour is necessary to keep the mills going, is whether the mills need it and, if so, how many of the mills. I know that there are some first-class flour millers who do not need and do not want it, notwithstanding the fact that their mills are not very well placed. Secondly, I think we ought to examine as to whether there are not some mills so badly run and with such out-of-date plant that they should not get protection, and after an examination of these things you could come to some conclusions as to whether a tariff is necessary to keep the mills going. What you do want is not patriotic appeals but this examination.
Comment on this
These have been examined, and the decision that has been come to is known, but let us pass from that. I do object to people making the case that a tariff on flour at the Mark Lane price for wheat is going to confer a benefit on the farmer. Supposing we did put a tariff on under that impression, and supposing, in fact, that the Irish farmers could not grow wheat at the Mark Lane price, what do you think the effect of that would be? Do you think it would make our farmers any more sweet on tariffs? I suggest to the tariff reformers who make these statements, without examining the matter, that they are doing their own case harm. I would like to ask, is the Mark Lane price going to get the Irish farmer to grow wheat? That is the question. I agree with the figures of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs that the price for best Irish wheat is about thirty shillings a barrel. Rather, I think I should say that the price is thirty shillings a barrel for best English wheat. Assume that the best Irish wheat is of the same quality as the best English wheat, which is a large assumption, then the price that is expected to induce the Irish farmer to grow wheat is thirty shillings a barrel. Will he do it? The farmer could get twelve shillings and thirteen shillings a cwt. for wheat all during 1925, which is a shilling more than the Mark Lane price for the best English wheat, and yet he did not increase his area under wheat, and the advantage to the Irish farmer to grow wheat is based on the Mark Lane figure. I will give the exact figures.
Comment on this
The Mark Lane prices for best English wheat in 1925 during the months of September, October and November were 11/11, 11/10, 11/5, 11/9, 11/9, 11/-, 10/6. For the same period on the Irish market the prices were 14/1, 13/5, 13/-, 12/7, 12/7, 12/-, 12/9. From these figures it will be seen that you had a difference of almost 1/6 a hundred in favour of the Irish market all that time, and yet we are told that the Mark Lane price is going to confer a benefit on the farmer. It will not. The price of thirty shillings a barrel for wheat is twelve shillings per cwt. Assume that a barrel of wheat is the same as a barrel of barley, I mean as regards weight, which of course it is not, then, for two cwts. of wheat the price at the figure I have given would be 24/-. Last year twenty shillings was paid for two cwts. of barley all the time.
Comment on this
I will assume that the price was twenty shillings for two cwts. of barley last year. Was there, I ask, terrific enthusiasm amongst the farmers to sell barley at that price? I want any farmer, I do not care what party he belongs to, to answer the question, whether he would rather be selling barley at twenty shillings or wheat at twenty-four. On which would he make the most profit? Obviously on barley, because there is more in the difference in the costings. There may be good reasons for this tariff on flour, but they have not been proved to me, and hence I would ask Deputies not to put this forward as conferring a benefit on the Irish farmer without having examined the question more fully.
I agree with the point of view that there must be a considered policy in regard to the wheat supplies of the country. That is a very big question. I daresay that there must be a considered policy so as to ensure that there would be sufficient mills in the country to deal with the wheat. That is something that must get attention because that would be necessary obviously in certain contingencies which are unlikely, but which are there. That policy has to be considered, and I am only quarrelling with the time.
Comment on this
This is not the time to consider it, and this is not the time to increase the price of bread if there is to be any increase as a result of these tariffs. I make that statement without any apologies to anybody. The best mills will not go, and with confidence I say that the well-run mills are not going, and are not depending on tariffs. We must also consider what inducements we can give to the farmer to grow wheat for his own use. Wheat can be grown on most lands with a little care and attention, but obviously that is a policy that can only be developed slowly. It would take a considerable time before, say, thirty or forty farmers could so change their economy and make arrangements to grow just the amount of wheat that they require for themselves, and that probably is the most healthy way in which you can extend wheat-growing. But that is a problem which can be helped partly by education and partly by other inducements.
I come now to the question of bacon. What is a tariff on bacon supposed to effect? First of all, there should be no necessity for a tariff on bacon. Bacon, so far as the farmer consuming it is concerned, is protected already. That is undoubted. It is undoubted that the farmer could produce bacon cheaper than he buys American bacon. There is no question about that.
Comment on this
Eighty-five shillings per cwt. is a high price for bacon, live weight. It is a peak price practically. The dead weight is 113/- per cwt., which is equal to a shilling a pound. After making all allowances for killing, for the head, feet, etc., it means for the Wiltshire cut, 1/1½d. per lb. at the very outside.
Comment on this
I said that I had made all allowances. The allowances I made included shrinkage, killing, and the low price for the head and feet. After making all these allowances, I am prepared to assert here that it amounts at the outside to 1/1½d. per lb. for Wiltshire cut. Shrinkage is only a very small factor. The difference between the weight of the dry-cured and the salt-cured is not great at all. I forget at the moment the exact percentage, but I examined it and worked it out when I was preparing these figures. The Deputy can take it from me that after making all allowances, first for killing, secondly, the low price for the head and feet, and thirdly for shrinkage, such as it is, and after adding all these together, the price for Wiltshire cut amounts to 1/1½d. per lb.
Comment on this
The Deputy says I am wrong. Will he say how much it is?
Comment on this
You are quoting the pork at a shilling per lb. Shrinkage will amount to one-sixth, so that five-sixths must be equal to a shilling per lb. and that surely is not 1/1½d.
Comment on this
I can only retort that the Deputy is wrong. Even Deputies who have not examined this problem technically can see it for themselves, —
Comment on this
I want Deputies who have examined the thing closely to realise this. I started at the peak price for pigs, eighty-five shillings. Seventy would be more like the average. Might I ask how many pence per lb. would the Deputy add for shrinkage?
Comment on this
About twopence a lb. The Deputy will agree that seventy shillings is a very good price.
Comment on this
Seventy shillings is ninety-four shillings dead-weight. Tenpence a lb. is about elevenpence after making all my allowances, and adding the twopence of Deputy Wilson, the price is 1/1d. That is a peak price, and American bacon is 1/3. Wiltshire cut is 1/3, and often 1/4. There is no doubt whatever that there should be no tariff required for American bacon so far as the farmers, who are large consumers, require it. I say that subject to certain reservations. On the contrary, there are farmers who must sell pigs. But very few farmers cannot so alter their economy as to enable them to keep an animal, worth with its fat £7, for six months. Further, I realise it is more difficult to cure in summertime than in winter: but the farmers who can do it merely cure in winter. Further, winter curing would reduce the imports of American bacon by half. You do not require protection for that. What is the protection going to do? If there is any Deputy who wants to advocate protection of bacon, I ask him when he is dealing with the question to let me know whether the following statement is not a fact. Protection to the tune of threepence per lb. as against American bacon would, in my opinion, merely mean that the fluctuation in the price of Irish pigs, live-weight, would be, not fifty shillings, which is the lowest price, but about fifty-two and not eighty-five, which is the highest, but about eighty-seven; in other words, protection to the tune of threepence a lb. on bacon would mean that the price would fluctuate over a slightly different scale; instead of having a fluctuation from a price of fifty to eighty-five, you might have a fluctuation from about fifty-two shillings a cwt., to about eighty-seven. What is that going to do for agriculture? What you want to do for bacon is to stabilise the price.
Comment on this
We can all agree that a particular increase of two shillings a cwt. on fifty in the market does not matter, or an increase of two shillings when the price is eighty-five. The real trouble with regard to the farmer is that instead of getting seventy shillings steadily the price drops to fifty, and then soars to eighty-five. I cannot see how the price is to be controlled. The root cause is that a sow litters anything from sixteen to twenty-two pigs in a year, and in America therefore, you have the number of pigs multiplied suddenly in one year by twenty. These mature in seven months, and multiply when it is worth while for the American farmer to breed pigs, when maize is cheap. Consequently I am unable to say how the fluctuations can be controlled. There are good reasons for keeping the mills in operation. There may be good reasons for wheat growing, but I do not want Deputies to go forward and hoodwink the Dáil by saying that any tariff on flour or bacon is going to improve the position of the farmer. It is not.
I have very little to say about roads. I do not like Deputies to say that roads are bad. Good and bad are comparative terms, and if you compare our roads with the rural parts of Scotland, for instance, ours are very good, and Scotchmen, who have been all over our roads, have said that. I know it myself, because I have been in both countries. If you compare the roads of this country with those of France they are, on the whole, better, I think, than the French roads. There is not doubt whatever that both main and by-roads are better on the whole than in 1914. Deputies talking about extravagance and high standards will have to apply the medicine to themselves. We have to cut our cloth according to our measure in respect to roads. I find from the figures that one thousand people are keeping up fifteen miles of roads in Ireland, whereas one thousand people are keeping up five miles in England. This is a country over-roaded; it has too many roads.
Comment on this
I do. It is inevitable. France is an agricultural country in which all the houses are in the villages, but you must remember the reasons and circumstances are such that we have a big number of roads and a long mileage, and we must realise that we must pay a little for the circumstances that gave that result and, if necessary, we must have worse roads than would be the case if we had a smaller mileage. In France it is much simpler to have good roads. The houses there are in the villages, whereas here they are dotted all over the country. Compared with any other agricultural country, we have a good standard of roads. There is no doubt the roads are good— better than they were pre-war—and they compare very favourably with the Scottish roads. That is not my own opinion only, but it is also the opinion of Scotchmen who have been here and who have experienced our roads. There are, of course, exceptions to every rule. I am ready to believe, if a Deputy stands up here and says that he knows a particular part of his county where the roads are very bad, that that may well be, but, on the whole, the roads are good enough, good enough for this country, and a lot better than those of other countries, such as France, and quite as good as those in Scotland. Whether we are farmers or not we must have main roads and we must agree that there is a distinction between main and by-roads. The fact that there is money spent on main roads is not a loss but a gain to farmers because these roads lead into every county in Ireland and farmers utilise them.
Comment on this
Some by-roads should be kept in a condition that suits the particular traffic on them, and it would undoubtedly be foolish to spend money on them from any other point of view. Some by-roads, for instance, are used for cartage while others must be kept in a better condition. I do not like the point of view that the rural community is not just as much interested as the urban community in seeing that the main roads are kept in first-class style. It is. If you admit that, you must concentrate on spending more money per mile on main roads.
Comment on this
That is a state of affairs that is likely to remedy itself in a very short time. We have to find money also to keep up the roads, and I object to the point of view that there is some difference between that and getting it through the rates. Some people say that there is greater advantage in finding the money by rates rather than by taxation, while others maintain the contrary view. If we increase taxation it means practically the same as increasing the rates. Remember that when we are asked to find more money for the Road Fund. Deputies also say that the licence duties for drivers are too high. If, however, you drop them to 10/- you will lose £30,000, and you will either have to do without that or find it otherwise. Other Deputies maintain that the tax on the car is too high. We can drop that, but where are you going to get the money? I only put forward these considerations to remind Deputies that they ought not to juggle as between rates and taxes. Certain money must be found to keep roads to a minimum standard, and every time that Deputies suggest, in the interests of motor owners or others, that either the road tax or the licence duties should be reduced, they should come forward and say in what other directions money should be found. With regard to lorries, I protest against the point of view of driving any lorries off the road. There is something fundamentally unsound in that. I heard a Deputy say that no lorries of over four tons laden weight should be allowed on the road. That would mean about a two-ton lorry maximum. Do Deputies realise what that means? What about the number of farmers' societies who have two-ton lorries which are able to perform many services for them, and which can take the produce from the stations far more cheaply? It is, apparently, put forward seriously from the Farmers' Benches that no lorry should be allowed over two tons on the road.
Comment on this
Yes; that means a two-ton lorry. I would be surprised if the farmers, as a whole, subscribe to that. It would hit them harder than anyone else as these lorries are used by farmers' societies and big farmers.
Comment on this
They are not. Do not trouble about farmers' societies or big farmers in that connection.
Comment on this
Supposing we assumed generally that no Deputy on the Farmers' Benches agrees with the Minister, perhaps, he might be allowed to proceed with his speech without interruption.
Comment on this
I think I speak on this matter for the farmers of the country generally, no matter what the Deputies on the Farmers' Benches may say, when I say that it would be a great injustice to drive the two-ton, or three-ton, lorry off the roads, as there is no reason for it. Any road policy that is based on that will have my active opposition and also, I believe, that of the majority of farmers. We are asked also why we do not take over the roads at present and centralise them, as well as centralise the road policy. The road policy has to some extent been centralised. I mean we have put forward a policy which aims at segregating the main roads and the by-roads, and spending a definite ascertainable amount of money on each for maintenance.
In addition, there is provision for the spending of £2,000,000 at the rate of £1,000,000 per year on the main roads. That policy may be right or wrong, but it is quite specific. With regard to the administration of this policy entirely centrally, Deputy Good, last night, asked: "Why set up authorities in each county to do this?" That is the point; we are not setting them up. They are there already. They have been doing this work for a long time. They have all the necessary requisites for doing it. They have the plant and machinery. If we were starting out anew, if we had a clear sheet and if we were evolving a road policy, without the necessity for considering the existing arrangements for repair and maintenance, we might perhaps take a different attitude, but we cannot approach the question from that point of view in the present circumstances. We must realise that the roads generally up to the present have been maintained, to a great extent, locally. The main roads, on the other hand have to some extent been maintained centrally. We have to recognise the position as it is. What we are doing now in no way prejudices future policy. It may be found, when administering this policy, that the correct method of dealing with the roads is to administer centrally. That raises some very large questions. I think you are almost advocating the abolition of the county councils, when you say the roads should be taken away entirely from the county councils.
Comment on this
That was Deputy Good's suggestion. It may be that time will show that the sound policy is to work the main roads centrally and the by-roads, or some proportion of the by-roads, locally. You can only find out those things gradually. We cannot simply do these things by a wave of the hand. It would be uneconomic and expensive to decide here and now, on insufficient data, to administer all the roads centrally. We can do that if the experience of the working of this road policy shows it would be useful, but there is no reason why we should come to that decision now.
Comment on this
Those are the views of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture.
Comment on this
That ought to be obvious. The Deputy has very often reminded me that I am responsible directly to the Dáil.
Comment on this
The Deputy was so insistent on the use of "we" that I thought he was speaking for the Department of Local Government.
Comment on this
I do not think I will run the risk of any further interruptions. I have nothing further to say on this roads question, and the Dáil, I am sure, will be delighted to hear that I have nothing further to say on any other question.
Comment on this
After the elaborate statement of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture, it seems presumptuous for a person like me to stand up to deal with the big question before the Dáil. I do so merely to make what I might call "a declaration of faith." I do not propose to go into any details in connection with the Budget proposals or in connection with the statement made by the Minister for Finance. I regret, however, that the tendency of the speeches delivered so far has been more or less to ridicule the idea of protection for the industries of the country. I suppose we must be thankful for small mercies, and we are offered a couple of concessions in the Budget. We have protection for oatmeal, to a very small extent, and we have protection for Ford motor cars. In addition, last year's tariffs are to be continued. Great stress was, however, laid on the statement that the tariffs already imposed are merely experimental. I submit that that statement, reiterated as it has been, prejudices the prospect of success of the industries that have been protected. Those who have capital will, naturally, not be inclined to indulge in experiments, whereas if they felt that the policy of the Government and the policy of future Governments would be to protect the industries of the country, they would be more inclined to invest their capital in native industries. Going as an ordinary individual through this city and through the country, I have observed that those who are opposed, generally speaking, to the imposition of tariffs consist of a huge army of agents for foreign manufacturers. They are spread throughout the length and breadth of the State, and naturally they are having effect. They are assisted by a huge army of distributors of foreign goods in the towns. The farmers who come in from the country districts, come into contact with those people who are interested in foreign goods, and, hearing the statement on every side that it would be a terrible thing to have tariffs and that it would increase prices, they come to the conclusion that a tariff policy would be bad for the country. On the other hand, who are those who are in favour of the imposition of tariffs? They are the people who for the past twenty years have conducted a fight to bring about the freedom of this country. They did that largely that they might get possession of the economic weapon and be enabled to protect the industries of the country, with the object of increasing its prosperity.
In addition to that there are people who have money invested in the industries of the country, and those that wish to invest their capital in these industries. The question comes to this: which of these two classes ought to be encouraged? I respectfully submit that the latter class are the class that ought to be encouraged, and I submit that that encouragement is not offered by the Ministers of our present Government to the extent which I, and others who have taken an interest in the country for years, would like to see. We all want to see the prosperity of the country. I do not see how we can have prosperity unless we have increased industry. Prosperity means increase in the population by the stemming of the flow of emigration, and by providing employment, and a decent living wage for the population.
This, of course, has been an agricultural country up to the present. But we cannot have an increased population, to my mind, and, consequently, we cannot have prosperity, on farming alone. If we are going to stem the tide of emigration, and if we want to have prosperity we must have industries. I submit we cannot increase our industries unless those industries which we possess at the moment are fostered and encouraged to such an extent that those who have capital will be encouraged to invest it.
Now the Minister for Agriculture has dealt particularly with the farmer and with a number of items connected with the farm. The tendency of his speech was that protection for any of those items would not improve the position of the farmer. I respectfully submit that the farmer in this country has to look upon the question from another aspect which has not been reviewed in its proper perspective by the Minister. The average family in this country is presumably five or six. I am not sure if there are any official figures at the moment, and I do not like to give figures myself because I have not the time or the facilities to deal with figures specifically. I know that in the constituency I represent the number of the family is very much higher than that figure. It goes up to twelve, and fourteen, and, sometimes, higher than that. Only one or two of the children can be provided for on the farm. The remainder must be exported the same as any other export, such as sheep and pigs raised on the farm, if there is no employment for them in this country. The farmer, therefore, has to look upon the subject from that point of view, as well as from the point of view put forward by the Minister. Unless the farmer is willing to bear a slight burden, for a short period, to encourage the industries of the country, he cannot succeed in keeping at home, in their own country, his boys and girls. I suppose it would not be easy to arrive at a figure, as to the value of this class of export. I do not suppose we could place a money value upon a boy or a girl of 18 years of age, although it has been done and written about in the past. However, if you put a money value on it I should think our adverse trade balance would be very appreciably affected. At the present time we are exporting this flesh and blood of our country, and unless industries are protected and that the policy of the existing Government of the country tends towards protection, I am afraid that exportation will have to be continued.
I submit that protection for this small nation is absolutely essential— protection, particularly against our neighbour—that big and prosperous country so near to us. It is a big and powerful nation with its large population and natural resources. It has a huge export trade, and consequently it is a free trade country, because free trade suits it. I submit that this small country needs protection as a policy as opposed to the policy that suits that other country. We are a small nation. We have been crippled for years by foreign rule, and we always wished we could have protection for our industries. We have advocated that for years, and have voluntarily given whatever protection we could to our industries. We always regretted we had not the power in our hands to give that protection to our industries that they really needed.
We have now obtained our economic freedom and we can only hope that before very long our policy, as a whole, will be protectionist. We have been described by some people as a baby State. I do not know whether that is a happy description, as we are one of the oldest nations in Europe. To those who believe in re-incarnation, I think the position can be more fittingly described by saying the soul of the nation has entered a new body, and a baby State has been evolved. That being so, the Government of this country should be regarded as the guardians or foster-parents of that baby. I do not know what we might think of the guardians and the parents of the baby who would deny to that baby the protection and nourishment needed for its existence. The life blood of the baby is flowing away. As far as the nation is concerned, the life blood is flowing out at Cobh. Unless something be done to stem the tide of emigration by fostering industries, I am afraid we must regard with pessimism the prospect of this country.
Now, I sincerely appeal to the farmers of this country not to be led away by the propaganda of those foreign agents and foreign distributors with whom they are coming in contact continually. In the interests of their own flesh and blood I appeal to them that they should become protectionists, because I believe protection is the only policy. I am not going to go into particulars, I am only dealing with general principles. I also appeal to the younger generation to advocate protection in their own interest, and to add to the clamour for protection of the industries of the country, so that future Governments may realise that it is essential for the interests of the country that industries should be protected and the nation saved from extinction.
Comment on this
There were a certain number of peculiar statements made in reply to what the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said in his speech—one of them, I think, was an anticipatory reply—which would lead one to draw most peculiar conclusions about the relative position of parties in the Dáil. It was insinuated by Deputy Cooper, and I think by Deputy Sir J. Craig, that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was actuated in what he said by his desire to win an election or by the fact that an election was coming off in the distant future. It seems to be always assumed in the Dáil that the party which sits on these Benches is waiting for an election and that the members of every other party seem to have been singled out by some supernatural agency to come in here and express their opinions. They are altogether free from any necessity to make any preparations or to have any consideration whatever for the likelihood of a general election. In discussing the economic conditions of the country, we ought to adopt the same attitude towards our economic conditions as the Minister for Finance has towards our finances in the Budget, when he talks about the state of the country's trade and industry. It seems to me that just as we distinguish in our finances between normal and abnormal expenditure, recurrent and non-recurrent expenditure, we should also distinguish, and keep the distinction carefully in our minds, between a depression which is common to this country and practically every other country in Europe at present—the normal depression following on the war and various other causes—and the kind of depression which is peculiar to this country and which may be said to be abnormal from that point of view. In discussing this Budget from the normal point of view, from the point of view of the ordinary depression which is common to this country and every other country, if you look at our trade and our industry from that point of view, it is a good Budget. It is a good ordinary civil service Budget, so to speak. But if you look at our position and consider the fact that we are just emerging from a hundred years of artificial economic depression, and that our whole industry, whether agricultural or manufacturing, and everything in our trade is conditioned by the results of that one hundred years, there is a great deal that might be said in criticism of the present Budget. We have to deal not only with the question of the increase in our expenditure since 1914, not only with the fluctuations of the market for our cattle or our other products, but we have to deal also with two or three big facts which make this country peculiar among practically all the countries in Europe. One big fact is the huge excess of our imports over our exports, and another is the huge yearly drain of emigration.
Looking at the Budget from the point of view of my own constituency, out of every parish of which, perhaps, a thousand people have to go every summer to another country in order to get sufficient employment to enable them to live in this country—the Budget offers very little prospect whatever to people of that kind. Their condition is not a passing condition; it is not due to the ordinary circumstances of the post-war period. It is a peculiar historical position, and not only this Government but the whole Dáil will be held responsible—and every other Dáil we have in this country in the future—for the continuance of conditions like that, until some body of people comes along and devises some means or other by which conditions like that can be remedied. In matters of that kind we have a big national task before us, and we are not doing very much at present to deal with the extraordinary depression all over the country, and particularly in the West. That depression exists in the cities just as well as in the country, and we are not doing very much to deal with that sort of depression at all. It is not going to do us any good every time we come here to discuss the economic condition of the country for the farmers to get up and announce that the industrialists are inefficient, and that the clamour for tariffs is only put forward by people——
Comment on this
I am not saying it is confined to the Farmers' Party. It is peculiar to every party in the Dáil. You have one type of person getting up and saying that our industrialists are incompetent and effete, and that their cry for protection is, to a certain extent, dishonest. You have another person getting up and saying perhaps the very same thing about the farmers, when the farmers' interests are being discussed. You have it said that the farmers are uneducated, and that before we can get any advance in agriculture in this country we must wait until some more or less supernatural agency comes along, and puts knowledge into their heads suddenly. You have both sides of the House exchanging recriminations of that kind, and, unfortunately, you have the Minister for Finance, to a certain extent, joining in.
Comment on this
In connection with what Deputy McBride, for instance, said about inefficiency, it seems to me that from the point of view of a person seeking work it is of great deal more value to get employment in a comparatively inefficiently conducted industry than it is not to get any employment at all, and that if you can encourage even our inefficient—if we have many inefficient employers—by any means whatever to improve their industries, if you can enable them to tide over, even with their inefficiency, a bad period of depression, you will do great good in comparison with the evil you will be doing by simply letting them die out. One hears a great deal of comparison between this country, with its small population, and countries with bigger populations. One hears a great deal about how difficult it is for us to impose tariffs in this country with only three millions of a population, whereas other countries have big populations and a big market in their own country for their products. One fact seems to be lost sight of in all these comparisons: that small and all as our population is we are losing part of it every year for want of anything to do at home because we will not take sufficiently active steps to see that we have something set up which will give employment at home. The position of the Executive Council in regard to the question of tariffs has always struck me as being a rather peculiar one. They adopt what may be called a tariff policy in a piece-meal sort of way and, having done so, they seem to find themselves in agreement with Deputy Cooper and to be very anxious and willing to give ammunition to the Deputy for use against themselves. The Minister for Finance has coined a phrase about the clamour that exists for tariffs. The Minister spoke about the clamour that there is from inefficient manufacturers for tariffs, and he said nothing at all about the clamour from editors and from newspapers—to whom it is not a bad compliment to say they are equally inefficient with the manufacturers—to take off the tariffs already imposed. There is an equal clamour from people who had other things to bark about as well as tariffs and whose other barks the Minister is not very willing to pay attention to.
I cannot understand why a policy should be adopted, and when it is adopted, an attitude of criticism and of depreciation towards that policy is taken up. We have the Minister for Finance, in his Budget statement, saying that he is going to remain within the limits of the pledge he made last year, and that he would not impose any more protection before the next election. One of the things that puzzles me is to know what actuated him in giving that pledge last year. I did not hear any great clamour from any party in the Dáil for such a pledge. The Minister seems to have adopted an attitude of tying his hands without being asked to do so. Such an attitude is only going to weaken the action the Government has taken on putting tariffs on certain industries. If they adopt an attitude of saying that all the cry for tariffs is from dishonest people, what are the public to say about the tariffs that have already been put on? Is it not open to the public to say that the cry for tariffs on bottles, for instance, was equally dishonest and came from equally incompetent people with the cry for tariffs on woollen goods? In setting up tariffs in this country it seems to me that it would have been better to have been bold and to have gone in, as Deputy O'Shaughnessy suggested, for a fairly general range of tariffs. I do not suggest tariffs on everything, but in particular on articles which are produced in large quantities in this country, and the production of which is closely allied to our greatest industry. The first care of the Government should have been to take into consideration the necessity of safeguarding this country in case we had a repetition of the Great European War, so that we would not be left in a worse position than on that occasion. We should consider first and foremost, a policy that would ensure a steady food supply for this country. Consideration of tariffs should be governed from the point of view not of helping this manufacturer or that manufacturer, but rather by how the imposition of tariffs would benefit the nation as a whole. Deputy Conlan talked about the position of the farmers in this respect. I am afraid that the Minister for Agriculture has an unfortunate tendency to treat farmers as if they were algebraic symbols. If every farmer was represented by .309 or something of that kind, disassociated from his family, and treated as an economic formula, forgetting that one farmer differs from other farmers, that farmers have families, and that the biggest of our economic problems is to find some means of existence, so to speak, for the surplus children of the farmers——
Comment on this
An attitude of that kind which would not discuss what possible profit a farmer, represented by a formula, would derive from a tariff, represented by another formula, which formula is cut as close to the wind as the Minister for Agriculture can cut it—like 3d. a pound on American bacon—does not seem to me to be a proper attitude. It seems to me that instead of treating both elements of your problem as algebraic symbols, it would be better to treat the question as a national question, and consider the interests of the nation as a whole, and whether a tariff would not be better for the country, even at the cost of a certain slight increase in the cost of living—whatever that may be. That seems to me to be another algebraic formula about which the ordinary human being finds it hard to have clear ideas. Almost everything that can be proposed seems to raise the cost of living in this country. Even if you have a slight increase in the cost of living it seems to me that a farmer with a large family should find it a benefit to have industries encouraged in neighbouring towns in which his children could get good employment. There is a woollen mill in Foxford, in my constituency—I suppose it is about the only industrial enterprise in it— and I am sure the farmers in that district, if they could get employment for their children, if we had tariffs on woollen goods, would not object to an increase in the cost of living.
Comment on this
About 300 hands. The factory in Foxford is an efficient and a well-run one. Any rise in the cost of living to farmers would surely be made up in that and a great many other ways. No matter what sort of clothes Deputies Gorey and Heffernan may wear the ordinary farmers do not buy imported readymade clothes to any great extent.
Comment on this
The Deputy is one of those who protested most violently against the rise in the cost of living. Even if the cost of clothing were put up, does not the farmer get back considerably more than that rise in the £600,000 which was given by way of relief of taxation last year? While we are on that £600,000, would it not be better for the country generally if some differentiation were made in taxation as between the farmer who tills his land and works it as it ought to be worked, and the farmer who does not till his land?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean as he thinks it can best be worked, or as somebody else, who does not own the land but manages it, thinks it ought to be worked, and who would have to pay for the loss, if any were incurred?
Comment on this
I suppose Deputy Baxter is in the same position as Deputy Heffernan, who wrote to the "Independent" a long letter, in which he pointed out that no matter what you did with a farm at present—no matter what you grew on it—there would be a loss on it. If that is the attitude of Deputy Baxter, the best thing we can do for farmers like him, and the best solution for our economic difficulties, is to export them as soon as possible to the Sahara, where they will have no land at all to trouble about.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I have been seriously considering acquiring a farm myself if I could afford to do it.
Comment on this
In so far as the Minister has agreed to the setting up of a tariff committee for the consideration of this question, I think he has done well. But—and it is a very big "but"—if the tariff committee is made up of free traders it will not give any more protection to anything, and if it is made up of people whose attitude is different towards this question, it will give more protection. There is no doubt about it that everything will depend on the composition of that committee.
Comment on this
I do not want it all protectionists. I only want to see people on it who will not fine down the conditions under which it will give protection to the narrowest possible point, who will not put all their weight on the one side when they are considering the question as to what they will or will not give protection. We have had a long discussion on the question of a tariff on flour. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture has pointed out that even if you put a tariff on flour you would not be able to give the farmer any great advantage over the Mark Lane prices of wheat in the present year. In my opinion, the problem is not one as regards giving the farmer a certain advance on the Mark Lane price in any one month, but it is a problem of securing a stable, steady market, and to have steady prices over a number of years in Ireland for Irish-grown wheat. The same thing applies to flour.
There, also, the problem is to do what you can to secure a stable market for home-made flour. It is not a question of taking a particular farmer at a particular time and seeing that he will make a profit, and it is not a question of securing a market at a particular time and seeing that you make a profit. If a tariff is imposed on these conditions the whole thing is rather immoral. That is rather strong language, but from the national point of view we should take the long view on that matter. Even at the cost of putting up the price of things on everybody, especially on the classes who can afford it for a time, I think it would be worth our while to see that a basis is given for industries which will always be necessary in this country, and will be particularly necessary if we ever have to face a European war again. It has often been said, but I think it is being said less frequently now than a couple of years ago, that wheat cannot be grown in Ireland. I suppose Deputy Heffernan, as one who appears to think that nothing can be grown in Ireland, will agree with that.
Comment on this
On this question of growing wheat it would not be a bad thing if some professor would investigate the history of wheat growing in Ireland, and establish that wheat has been grown in Ireland practically since the late Stone Age.
Comment on this
I do not see what that has to do with the question. The question is whether wheat can be grown in Ireland at the present time. It seems to be that nothing is considered economic that cannot compete with the heavily capitalised and organised English industries, and that nothing is efficient that cannot compete under those conditions. At that rate of going on we will find ourselves after 20 or 30 years with a very much reduced population composed of efficient people, and the inefficients gone away to America or elsewhere, if they are let in. What is economic in Ireland is what the people of Ireland want to make economic. I do not see why it should be regarded as the normal state of affairs for everything in this country to be competing with English conditions. There again we are getting back to the point of view I expressed at the beginning. In this country we have a very abnormal, ancient and historic problem, a problem of economic depression which is not due to any particular set of circumstances but to the fact that this country to a large extent has escaped industrial revolution, and we are now beginning to try and start an industrial revolution of our own. If we are going to start that industrial revolution with the Shannon scheme or without it, on the basis that everything in this country must at once be in a condition to compete with English trusts, we are not going to get very far with our industrial revolution. I was glad to hear the Minister for Lands and Agriculture speak favourably about encouraging the growth of wheat by farmers. It seems to me one way of encouraging the growth of wheat or anything else is by doing what I said —differentiating in your taxation or tax relief between the small farmer with 30 or 40 acres or less, and the big holder who, as a large holder said in the paper the other day, could not possibly make his holding economic if he tilled it.
We have the question of American bacon coming up again. There again I think the Minister for Lands and Agriculture said that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs should not have advocated the putting of a tariff on American bacon in the interests of the farmer, that it would not be of any benefit to the farmer. I think that that is what he said. I, for one, have been for a long time advocating a tariff on American bacon. I should be advocating a tariff on American bacon almost on moral grounds rather than on the grounds that it would mean a profit to our farmers. I consider that if we could possibly avoid these big importations of American bacon—take it from the point of view of ordinary taste—it would be desirable to try to get rid of them. I know the argument is put up that it is better stuff for greasing cabbage than Irish bacon. I have a long experience of both kinds of bacon and I am quite as good an authority on greasing cabbage as anybody else, whether he be a farmer or some other person, and I cannot see that there is any difference whatever between the two. In regard to the question of whether a tariff on American bacon would pay the farmer better, if he were to kill his own pigs, there is a big question involved which the Minister did not touch upon. It has been found profitable for this country to pay £250,000 per year for sixty years to England rather than pay over a sum of £5,000,000 in one lump. In the same manner the farmer may find it profitable to buy his bacon from week to week, and in that way he may find that he gains some little advantage by buying American bacon. I consider from the national point of view that it is a bad habit. It is a habit that as far as we can, we should eradicate. It is a habit the eradication of which would not cost us anything practically.
Comment on this
I do not see that it would cost anything at all.
Comment on this
I do not think so. If the people had the opportunity I think it could be easily arranged for them. Apart altogether from that, we could easily get over the increase in the price of bacon. It is a matter of habit very largely, just as you have the small farmers in Connemara who have gone on for the last ten years growing Champions and Up-to-date potatoes just because they were accustomed to do it, sooner than grow the new varieties they were advised to grow by the Department. The same is true in regard to American bacon, and when the Minister points out that the farmer would not get any profit by this arrangement the only thing I can think of—perhaps it shows my unfamiliarity with financial matters—is to ask where this £3,000,000 goes to? If we spend £3,000,000 per year on American bacon and if we can stop that £3,000,000 by putting a tariff on American bacon, where would the £3,000,000 go? I believe that there is a great deal more in this question of tariffs than a Budgetting matter pure and simple. I do think that the whole question of Irish industries is one which has not been taken up half seriously enough, since this State was set on its feet, by any party. We have sporadic speeches made, but we have no organised attempt whatever, apart from the question of tariffs, to do anything to benefit Irish industries.
I can give you an experience of my own which is a rather common experience. I go into a shop in Dublin and ask for shoes. I ask the assistant for Irish-made shoes. He is astonished at the question. Irish-made shoes are not procurable in one of the biggest shops in Dublin. It seems to me that there are organisations, trade union organisations and other organisations—I do not think the burden should be thrown on the shoulders of any one class in the community at all—the man in the shop who uses propaganda on behalf of English goods is very often a member of a trade union, the members of which would be benefited by making an organised attempt to carry out propaganda on behalf of Irish goods. I do not want to put the whole burden on the members of trades unions by any means. I think it is a movement, apart altogether from the question of tariffs, which should be of the greatest possible benefit to every member of the community if it is taken up with vigour and with an earnest desire and an earnest effort to use as much as possible of our own products in our own community. I think the Dáil, which, as I said, will be held responsible by the people of Ireland for what it should do to get rid of this age-long depression that we have in the country, could do a great deal by letting it go forth that its members will do what they can, individually and collectively, and in whatever organisations they belong to, to further the purchase of the products of Irish industry. Besides that, I think that if we had a little more elastic attitude on the part of the Ministry towards tariffs, and a little more consideration for our manufacturers, whether inefficient or not, we could in a very short time get a long way ahead in putting this country on its feet economically, and in such a way that no other class would benefit so much as the farmers.