We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

FINANCIAL RESOLUTIONS—RESUMED. - RESOLUTION No. 15.—GENERAL.

Contributions 1–142 of 286. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Ernest Blythe The MINISTER for FINANCE (Mr. Blythe) Cumann na nGaedheal

I move:—

That it is expedient to amend the law relating to Customs and Inland Revenue (including Excise) and to make further provision in connection with Finance.

Comment on this

I spent an hour or two during the morning endeavouring to draw up something in the nature of a summary of the figures presented to the Dáil in the Minister's speech yesterday. I regret to say that most of my efforts and many of the conclusions drawn from them, are vitiated by the presentation of the Table explanatory of the Budget that has now been distributed. For instance, I find that in the latter Table there is included a revenue for the coming year in respect of the wine tax of £80,000, whereas the Minister intimated that he did not expect any revenue from this tax in the current year. We learn also that there is an anticipated shortage in Income Tax collection owing to the Double Income Tax agreement of £200,000. Of course, that makes a very considerable change in respect of the coming year in the proposals of the Minister. I think I should draw the attention of the Dáil to an item on the other side of the account, the allowance deducted from the expenditure for supply services for over-estimation and savings, £650,000, and particularly to draw attention to the statement made by the Minister yesterday in defence of this method of budgeting.

It astonished me to hear from the Minister that it was justifiable to gamble on the possibility of savings out of the Estimates—that is to say, that less should be spent than we are asked to provide for—but that it was unthinkable to gamble on the prospect that revenue from taxes would be greater than those estimated for. The Minister argued that it is quite allowable, and that the Executive Council have considered it quite in order, and not a breach of any financial principle, that in estimating for the taxation for the year, the Minister has a right to assume there will be savings out of the Estimates. In this case we are asked to levy taxes upon the people deliberately and with our eyes open to the extent of £650,000 which will not be required. We are told the Minister dissents from that view, but the paper and his speech confirm, I think, my reading.

There is an estimation of probable expenditure on Supply and Central Fund services, after deducting abnormal items, of £24,207,658, and there is a deduction of £650,000 as an allowance for over-estimation, leaving a total normal expenditure of £23,557,658. We therefore begin to levy taxes to meet £23,557,000, and according to this paper we succeed in doing that with a balance of £7,000 in hands. I think that is a correct representation of this account, so that in fact we are to be asked in the course of future discussions of the Dáil in Committee on Finance to pass estimates for £650,000 more than we are required to provide money for, and the Minister justifies that as something quite in accord with just financial principles. It is astonishing to me that that should come from the Minister in view of recent history.

The Committee of Public Accounts a year ago made some references in its report to this question of over-estimating, and pointed out that there had been in the year then under review a considerable amount over-estimated for, and while the Committee then recognised the difficulties and the extraordinary conditions under which the budgeting for the year then in question had to be done, they deprecated this. The Minister for Finance concurred in that view, and went so far as to convey to the various departmental heads the view of the Committee of Public Accounts, and his own concurrence in that view, that there should be the closest possible estimating.

This practice of over-estimating has been deprecated, but now we find that the Minister comes along and practically invites the heads of departments in preparing their estimates to overestimate, and he says that in the round sum that is required we are prepared to recognise that say 2½ per cent. will be over-estimated for. When we remember that the Minister for Industry and Commerce only two or three weeks ago in this House, in defence of a certain position he was taking, told the House that there was to be recognised the difference in the amount that we were estimating for and the amount that would be likely to be spent, we find a curious state of mind on the Ministerial Benches as to the importance of close estimation. We have the view of the Minister for Finance that we have not a big national debt, and that, therefore, we need not have in mind the desirability of reducing that national debt, and that we may overestimate, not with the expectation that any sum saved in expenditure will inevitably fall in at the end of the year and go towards the reduction of any national debt, but that it could be discounted at the beginning of the year, leaving a sum in the hands of the departments over and above what they believe to be necessary for the carrying on, or for the requirements of their departments.

Appropriate to this point one has to remind the House of that feature to which Deputy Esmonde has on more than one occasion referred—I mean the Appropriations-in-Aid. While we are told that the amount required is a given number of millions to meet the certain expenditure, and we are going to provide money from taxation to meet that amount, we must bear in mind, if we want to get a proper view, that the Appropriations-in-Aid in this current year are estimated to amount to £1,000,000, roughly speaking, and that there has been a steady increase in the estimates in respect of the Appropriations-in-Aid, running from £535,000 to £628,000, £781,000 and £976,000. Those have been the estimates of the Appropriations-in-Aid, and for the two years for which we have accounts these estimates of Appropriations-in-Aid have been exceeded by 29 per cent. in one case and by 32 per cent. in another.

Apparently it is now the policy of the Minister to budget in accordance with the expectations that there is going to be a saving upon the Estimates and an increase in the Appropriations-in-Aid. I think that is not conducive to a proper care of the finances of the country. On the contrary, I believe it is asking the Dáil to agree to give very much more liberty to the departments in regard to expenditure than the Dáil should give. The Ministry of Finance, of course, will continue to keep a tight hold on the spending departments, but when we have this state of things presented to us as part of the policy of the Minister for Finance, we are tempted to assume that they are in league with the spending departments to hoodwink the Dáil to draw money from the country much in excess of the amount required to pay for the current expenditure under the various estimates. I think that is a matter of importance purely from the financial side, and that it is one the Dáil should take note of, and remember when we are discussing the Estimates we are invited in effect by this statement of the Minister—not knowingly or deliberately—but I think it might be taken as an open invitation to reduce every Vote by 2½ per cent., because of the Minister's expectation that there will be a general aggregate of 2½ per cent. saveable at the end of the year.

Let us assume that this £650,000 was really not required, and that we have reduced the Estimates by this amount in the course of our discussions during the next few weeks. We then find that the expenditure, which is estimated for, amounts to £23,810,000. We had from the Ministry yesterday an intimation that there had been a saving last year as compared with the previous year of. I think, £1,800,000. It is not a saving in the usually accepted sense, but the amount drawn by taxation from the country was less in 1925-26 by £1,800,000 as compared with the previous year, and the proposal for 1926-27 is that the sum of £2,300,000 less than was drawn in 1924-25, will be taken from the people in taxation. That is a very important figure. It is important because of the expectations that were held out to us a year ago. Then the Minister said: "It can hardly be doubted that a reduction in taxation will have on industry and commerce a stimulating effect not to be obtained otherwise."

I do not know whether it is the Minister's contention that the effect of these modifications of a year ago has been greatly to stimulate industrial and commercial activity. He did say in his speech yesterday that there were no evidences, or but slight evidences, of depression contained in the financial returns, such evidences as reduction in the consumption of intoxicating liquor and one or two items of that kind, but Deputy Good, Deputy Hewat, Deputy Heffernan, Deputy Baxter, and others have insisted—and I think their views are confirmed by other Deputies behind the Minister—that the state of industry and commerce is as greatly depressed to-day as it was a year ago. I am not able, with the knowledge at my command, to confirm or deny that proposition, but we are told on every hand that trade is very bad, that industry is greatly depressed and that there is little evidence of improvement at the moment. I was hopeful that we would have in his place when we were discussing the Budget, the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy for South Dublin.

Comment on this

He was here.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

He is not here now.

Comment on this

His evidence in this House was that nothing but bankruptey stared the country in the face. I would like to have from Ministers— the Minister for Industry and Commerce is probably in as good a position as anyone to do it—some indication of the present position of the country, industrially and commercially. Perhaps the Minister for Local Government could give him some assistance, but it is really of importance to have authoritative information on this matter, information of a kind which cannot be said to be drawn up with a view to proving a contention, but cold and clear evidence based upon such information as is available to Departments. The Minister for Finance, probably, could give us the information if he would be willing to disclose something even in a general way of the evidence of income tax returns. One might say in this regard that really it is very difficult to discuss Budget proposals, proposals relating to income tax, estate duty and super-tax, unless we have some evidence of the position of the country in regard to income tax and incomes. We are waiting now for several years for statistics in that regard and we have yet to wait a little longer, I believe, but it is important that we should know whether the contention of a year ago, that the reduction in the charge upon the country by £1,800,000 in the year just closed, has had a stimulating effect on industry and commerce.

I have a belief that it is not always true to say, and it is not wise to expect, that the mere leaving of incomes, by way of a reduction in taxation, in the hands of the income tax payers is inevitably going to benefit the economy of the country and to promote the prosperity of the country. I think, on the other hand, that the real result of leaving excessive sums in the hands of the income tax payers may well be to act deleteriously on the economy and the industry of the country, and that if we can provide for a wise expenditure of such moneys as we collect in taxation, we might be more effectively promoting the prosperity of the country than by leaving it in the hands of individuals who may just as well waste it as use it beneficially.

While I am not suggesting for a moment that the incomes of men should be collected by the State indiscriminately, I do suggest that there is an entirely wrong conclusion drawn by those who say that a reduction of taxation must inevitably increase the prosperity of the country. Alternatively I say that it may well be that a wise programme of productive expenditure is more conducive to the prosperity of the State and that the Government should raise taxes to enable that expenditure to be carried on. I would like therefore to have a little information of what is meant by this anticipated shortage of £200,000 arising from the modifications in the law relating to double income tax, because it seems to me from this figure that a further reduction in the taxes of income tax-payers, a reduction in the tax of super-tax payers, and a reduction in the corporation profits tax, may by no means have the effect of stimulating industry and increasing prosperity. I want to see some evidence of that. I hope Deputy Good will give us some evidence to show us that the reduction in taxation of last year has been effectual in increasing prosperity.

I want to repeat what I said last night in regard to the promise of the Minister to restore what was cut from the old age pensions. There is embodied in these Budget proposals a decrease in certain taxation of certain people in the country. There is a reduction in the super-tax of £115,000 and a reduction in the corporation profits tax of £85,000. The Minister says that the £200,000 represented by those two figures is not a real reduction in taxation, because a similar sum is being imposed upon the same people in the form of estate duty. Again it seems to me to be a rather curious doctrine coming from the Minister. One has heard time after time of the desirability of the simplification of taxation, and the unwisdom of complicating accounts in respect to taxation. But the Minister's suggestion is that he has gone to the trouble of wasting pen, ink and time, and to other trouble in cutting off from some people £200,000 in respect of two particular kinds of taxes, and imposing upon the same people the same sum under a different name. I think that that is a waste of time and a waste of energy and is simply tending to complicate matters and to make difficult of understanding this whole taxation scheme—if that were the fact. But I submit that the people who are being relieved of corporation profits tax and the people who are being relieved of the super-tax to the combined extent of £200,000 need not be the same people, and are not the same people as are being mulcted in this additional estate duty. If you are justified in adding to the estate duty, let us defend that on its merits. Do not defend it by simply saying that it is a change over from one pocket to another. Let us defend it on its merits. Having done that, if it can be done, we have to face the fact that there is a proposed reduction upon super-taxpayers and corporate bodies in their taxation of £200,000. That, I say, ought not to have been proposed here by the Minister who made the statement a year ago that there would not be any reduction of taxation until the old age pension cuts had been met. He said:

"If the situation is found to have improved at the end of the year some revision of the Old Age Pension Act of 1924 will have to be given precedence to any reduction of taxation however much required."

I submit that there is a direct and distinct breach of promise, a breach of faith to the old age pensioners in this proposal to reduce the taxes now paid by the richer super-taxpayers and the corporations who at present pay corporation profits tax.

The one considerable innovation in the Minister's proposals is the proposals relating to taxes upon betting and bookmakers. I have no doubt that there will be a considerable amount of interest shown by the public in these proposals. I think we ought to examine the proposals very carefully. I have no doubt that will be done in the course of the discussion of the Bill. The proposal to put a tax upon betting will not meet with my opposition. I think that the acceptable nature of this tax lies in the fact that it does tend to restrict the habit of betting, a habit which, unfortunately, is an obsession with very many people in this country and is doing an immense amount of harm. There is, however, a grave danger in the imposition of a tax of this kind. We are dependent to-day for something over eight million pounds of our revenue on the consumption of intoxicating liquor and the inevitable effect of that is to make a Minister for Finance very dubious about any legislative proposals that would have the effect of reducing his revenue. It must be a factor in his calculation, and in the calculation of any Minister for Finance, as to whether he ought not budget in the expectation that people will consume more intoxicants and to the extent to which we are dependent upon the traffic in intoxicating liquor, there is a defect in that form of taxation. By this betting tax we are adding one more to the number of taxes the revenue from which will depend upon the prevalence of a habit—when it becomes a habit—which is not desirable.

I am not taking the line that there is any great evil in a man putting a shilling or two or a pound or two upon the chances of a particular horse winning a race, a particular crop of wheat rising to a higher price, or a particular share rising or falling in the market. But when a practice of that kind becomes the main interest in life of so many people, as it does in this country, I think it is unfortunate that we should add to our dependence upon that kind of a practice for our national revenue. Therefore, I suggest to the House and to the Minister that, while it may be desirable to levy a duty upon betting, there should run concurrently with that proposal something which would have the effect, not of increasing the desire that betting should extend over a large number of people and over a greater number of bets, but that there should be something restrictive.

I throw out as a hint that a little check upon the publication of betting odds before races might be helpful in that regard. If newspapers, for instance, were discouraged from appealing to this obsession, this bad habit, of the people, and if a little check were placed upon their present methods of making a circulation by appealing to that racing passion, it might be useful and it might correct the danger—it would minimise the danger—of having future Ministers for Finance relying too much upon the extension of the practice of betting. I have no doubt that newspaper proprietors—I am not speaking of the men who do the business of their employers—would be very glad to fall in with any proposition of that kind. Irish newspapers, I know, feel acutely the competition of organs of opinion from the other side of the Channel which have made circulations by their appeals to the betting fraternity on this side. I am sure a relief from that kind of competition would be accepted with pleasure by Irish newspaper proprietors, and if there was any addition to the revenue of this country from any taxation upon betting news, I think their patriotic instincts would lead them to applaud any such proposal.

Comment on this

Has Deputy Johnson studied the racing news in the "Daily Herald"?

Comment on this

He has, of course.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

He does not make any exception.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared, following up the remark of Deputy Cooper, to ban even the "Daily Herald" if the same rule will apply to every other newspaper, from across the Channel, that prints betting news. There was a good deal of preliminary discussion last night on the effect of this taxation scheme upon the road policy of the Government. I think that the criticism was justified in two respects, at least. I think it is a right view to take that the heavy 'buses and chars-a-banc that are plying for passengers between the cities and the country are too heavy and too fast for the health and safety of the people or the economy of the county councils and the city councils. One has heard for years of the road hog, but we are now faced night by night and day by day with the hippopotamus in the shape of these tremendous instruments of fright that, carrying passengers, cut through the roads travelling at a very fast pace. I think it is true to say, as Deputy Myles said yesterday, that these vehicles are probably just as damaging —perhaps in many senses more damaging—as the heavy tractor or the heavy goods vehicle. I think there ought to be some check upon the size, apart from the weight, and particularly upon the speed of vehicles of that kind.

I think that the criticism that was levelled at the Government in regard to their failure to rise to a road policy is also justified. What we have foreshadowed seems to be a mere continuance of the present arrangements, with slight financial modifications. The President, and, I think, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, defended the proposals and the policy of the Executive Council in regard to this road question; but we did not hear from the Minister for Local Government and Public Health any defence of this policy. I think the Dáil, which has, I was going to say of malice aforethought, but of deliberation at any rate, appointed a Minister to be responsible for the administration of roads, has a right to look to that Minister for his views upon the road policy. We know that he is restricted in regard to finance, but, having now from the Minister for Finance some indication as to the amount of money that may be available for road expenditure, we ought to have from him the policy of his Department regarding the best method of administering and controlling the service of the roads. I think it is a pity that the hints we have had time and again regarding the views of the Minister for Local Government, the Minister responsible for the roads, of some general scheme of central control and administration of the main or trunk roads, have not been acceptable to his colleagues who are members of the Executive Council. But I venture to think that if he would come to the Dáil with his policy, explain it, and ask the Dáil for their approval, he would probably be surprised at the amount of support that he would get, and I think the effect inevitably would be that the Minister for Finance would be more generous in his view of the financial requirements. I welcome, as I might be expected to, the promise that a million pounds will be available this year for expenditure on the roads. I welcome that, even as a matter affecting roads and transportation, but I welcome it also because it will mean some considerable relief of the unemployment market, and that in that way it would do something, at any rate, to meet the situation. I hope, however, that there will be no continuation of the policy of making selections of places where wages are low and only making grants to county councils on the condition that low wages are paid. I think, also, the time is coming—I think the time has been passed for a considerable period—when the absolute preference that has been given up to now to men who served in the Army, even though they may be young and have no dependents, over men who have dependents, who are more needy, and very often better fitted to do the work, but because they did not serve in the National Army, for one reason or another, are deprived of the opportunity to get employment. I think the period during which that preference was justifiable is passed, and I hope we may hear the Minister announce that it is not intended to continue that any longer.

Comment on this

There is one point on which I think we must all be grateful to the Minister for Finance, and that is that he has supplied us most abundantly with the materials to enable us to judge and criticise his Budget. I do not think that in any previous year, here or in any other Parliament, has any Minister given fuller and more detailed particulars of every branch of his activities. The early issue of the Estimates, the circulation of the estimated revenue and expenditure, together with the very full and detailed statement that we heard yesterday, have all made the task of the critic immeasurably easier, and at the same time tended to disarm the critic. But one cannot allow an occasion of this character to pass without a certain amount of criticism. I hope it will be, to some extent, constructive criticism. I congratulate the Minister on having got through the year without either a deficit or a big loan. He ran things very fine last year. I do not know whether every Deputy realises how very small the margin was, but, thanks to increased revenue, thanks to a reduction in the Exchequer balances, the Minister got through. But I think that having gambled once, he is, like those addicts to whom Deputy Johnson referred, tempted to gamble again. I am not at all sure that a betting tax ought not to be levied on the Minister for Finance, because when he takes a deficit and says: "Oh, it is all right; that is over-estimating, and over-estimating will provide for the deficit," it is a somewhat hazardous proceeding. I suggest to the Minister that it would be better to check the over-estimating, to make his Department stronger to check it, and not be afraid of asking for a Supplementary Estimate. The Dáil has never been harsh in dealing with Supplementary Estimates, when any case at all can be put up, and I do suggest that it is the duty of the Department of Finance to bring home to other public Departments the fact that their estimates ought to be cut to the bone, and that no unnecessary taxation should be introduced.

There are two features in the Budget which I welcome without discussion. I welcome the agreement over double income tax, and I welcome the reduction of Corporation Profits tax. I think that the latter will stimulate industry and employment, and that is the answer to Deputy Johnson's criticisms. One point on which I had intended to criticise the Minister was that his speech yesterday did not give us a final balance sheet showing the results of the alterations in taxation and the results in revenue from the new taxes. He has rectified this error by this explanatory table we received to-day. There are two questions I want to put to him in regard to it. The first is: Why does that explanatory table not include the payments under the London Agreement?

Comment on this

They do not arise yet.

Comment on this

Will they not arise in the course of the financial year?

Comment on this

Not in the course of the next financial year?

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will elaborate that.

Comment on this

There are funds still due to us in the hands of the British Government which will be set off against the amount.

Comment on this

If the Bill had not passed would not these moneys come into the Exchequer here?

Comment on this

I presume the British Government would not pay.

Comment on this

In his speech yesterday the Minister said: "The quantities of wine taken from bond have been so large during the past seven or eight weeks that no appreciable increase of revenue is expected from the higher duties this year," but in this explanatory table we see additional revenue of £80,000 from wine.

Comment on this

I owe it to the Dáil to explain that. When I said that there would be no appreciable increase of revenue I was really acting on information which I got four or five days ago. We now know what was taken out of bond. There was not such a large quantity of wine taken out during the last few days as we expected.

Comment on this

Another gamble.

Comment on this

I thought the Minister would have an explanation and I have given him this opportunity of making it. There is an omission in the Budget which I welcome, and that is that with two comparatively small exceptions there are no new tariffs. There is a tariff on oatmeal, a comparatively small one, so small that it will not do the farmers much good——

Comment on this

It was never intended to.

Comment on this

So small that it will not do the consumer very much harm. Then again, there is the tariff on wireless. That, I think, is a bad mistake. I will elaborate my argument at a later stage, but I suggest that when you have a new service which is in the nature of a luxury, but which does yield revenue to the State, you should stimulate that service and not crush it. With those exceptions there are no new tariffs. The Minister spoke of the clamour for tariffs. I thank the Minister for teaching me that word. "Clamour" is exactly the right word, but the most intensified clamour came from the benches behind the Minister, even since the days when Deputy Milroy clamoured for tariffs, and when, perhaps, in a more restrained and dignified manner, Deputy Sears clamoured for tariffs. But the latest, most persistent, most continual and most clamant clamour came from the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. If I may offer, without offence, a frivolous comparison, the later utterances of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs on the subject of tariffs reminded me of nothing so much as a train entering a tunnel—there was a prolonged screech and then darkness. He even went so far in the darkness as to recommend people not to invest money in Irish industries unless they were protected. That was not entirely consistent with the speech of the Minister for Finance yesterday. The Minister for Posts, as an external Minister, has a perfect right to express his own opinions and has a duty to do so, but what I want to know is, what is the policy of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party on the subject of tariffs? On one point they are probably agreed—that is, to maintain the existing tariffs, and the Minister for Finance said yesterday that these tariffs ought to have a further experimental run of eight to ten years. Subject to certain reservations I agree to that.

I agree that where capital has been invested and employment given as the result of tariffs on any considerable scale, that you should not hastily or frivolously repeal these tariffs, but I make the reservation that the objects on which tariffs are levied should be defined much more carefully than they were defined in our Finance Act of last year, and that instead of a general duty on wearing apparel the articles of wearing apparel should be specified, and that instead of a general duty on furniture you should specify the articles of furniture which are giving employment and not apply an indiscriminate tariff on every sort and kind of article, many of which are not being and never will be produced in the Saorstát. Subject to that reservation, I agree to that policy which is, I think, the policy of the Minister, and the policy not merely of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party but of the Dáil.

Comment on this

Of the majority, Deputy Hewat being a minority of, I think, one. The second point in the Minister's speech was that it was undesirable to commit the country to a policy of all-round protection in advance of a General Election. Is that, also, the policy of the Chairman of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party?

Comment on this
James Joseph Walsh MINISTER for POSTS and TELEGRAPHS (Mr. Walsh) Cumann na nGaedheal

No, emphatically no.

Comment on this

When I said that, I was thinking of Deputy Sears, and I do not think it is the policy of Deputy Sears either. Now we have it that the policy of the Executive Council is not the policy of some of their most influential, most active and most energetic followers. The trumpet is giving a very uncertain sound, and how can they go to a General Election with any hope of victory?

Comment on this

It is a great thing to be a party of one. They can all agree.

Comment on this

It is, but even parties of one are sometimes inconsistent. I suggest that even if a party of one is to be any sort of a party whatever, if it is to have any force or influence in the country, it ought to make up its mind to sink its differences and, at any rate, present a united front to the world. However, I do not want to make a party speech, and I am going to suggest an alternative. I make party speeches at times, but sometimes they are Farmer Party speeches, sometimes Labour Party speeches, and sometimes even Government Party speeches, but I am going to suggest what, I think, to be a better way, and that is, to take this question of tariffs out of party politics. I believe that the Minister for Finance has taken the first step in that direction by proposing to set up a Tariff Commission. The only thing about that proposal is that I should like to know a little more about this Tariff Commission. The Government set up a Fiscal Commission about three years ago. That was not a permanent body. Its recommendations were largely sound, but they were completely ignored. I suggest that there is not the least use in setting up a Tariff Commission on these lines. I would like to know if the proposed Tariff Commission is to be a body similar to that of the Revenue Commissioners—a body of permanent paid officials—who will examine all proposals for tariffs, or is it to be a body similar to that set up under the British Safeguarding of Industries Act, so that if the woollen trade, for instance, asks for a tariff a special committee will be set up to go into that question, and if another trade asks for a tariff another committee will be set up to deal with that, and so on, the committee in each case being a small one composed of people believed to be experts? I do not want the Minister for Finance to answer me now on these points, but I hope that when he comes to reply generally he will give the Dáil an outline of the procedure, composition and methods of this Commission.

From that omission, which I am glad of, the omission of tariffs on manufactures, I turn to another omission which I regret and that is the failure of the Government to reduce the spirit duty. The Minister spoke yesterday as if this was purely a question of the revenue that he receives from spirits at present and of the revenue that he will receive from the same number of distilleries paying duty on the same quantity in future at a reduced rate. He ignored the existence of poteen and the fact that a reduction of the spirit duty might knock poteen manufacture out of existence altogether. I am going to give him a precedent. I am treating this from the purely revenue point of view, and I agree that the Minister could not sacrifice any considerable revenue in spirits. The precedent I am giving is taken from the United States. It is not taken from the United States recently. After the American civil war, as after all civil wars, the Government found themselves loaded with a considerable debt, and in order to pay it they imposed a duty of two dollars per proof gallon on all spirits, mainly whiskey. The result is expressed by Mr. D.A. Wells, who, when a very young man, was appointed a revenue commissioner at the suggestion of Abraham Lincoln, and who subsequently became Chairman of the United States Revenue Commission. This is what he says:

The tax of two dollars per proof gallon (amounting to more than 1,500 per cent. on the average cost of production) and the enormous profits contingent upon the evasion of the law, coupled with the abundant opportunity which the law through its imperfections and the vast territorial area of the country offered for evasion, created a temptation not to be resisted. This view was taken by the Revenue Commissioners in a report to Congress through the Secretary of the Treasury in February, 1866, and the Chairman of the Commission, after a thorough investigation of the subject and the collection and presentation of a large amount of evidence, expressed the opinion that the attempt to collect a two-dollar tax was utterly impracticable, and that the longer it was retained the less would be the revenue.

The result of that two-dollar tax imposed in 1866 was a revenue of twenty-nine million dollars. The following year the revenue had shrunk to twenty-eight million dollars, and by 1868 the Americans had applied that wonderful fund of resource which they have of evading any restrictions on the consumption of liquor imposed by the State, so that the production had shrunk to 6,700,000 gallons, and the revenue to thirteen million dollars. Then the Revenue Commissioners took action and the duty was reduced from two dollars to 50 cents. per proof gallon, the reduction being in the ratio of one to a quarter.

After that the position was fifty per cent. duty and then the duty was only a quarter. Instead of thirteen million dollars they got thirty-three million dollars, and for the next four years the average revenue received from the taxation of spirits was thirty-four million dollars. I am not saying that is a complete parallel to our situation, but I do say that I believe a considerable reduction in the duty on spirits would produce no loss in revenue, because the distiller of poteen would be put out of business if whiskey were cheap. You may oppose the reduction on social grounds, grounds of temperance and grounds of morality, but I am only discussing it from a financial and revenue point of view, and I believe it would be well worth while to reduce the duty to such a point that the poteen distiller would be put out of business.

From the Minister's sins of omission I shall now turn to his sins of commission. I am not discussing the motor question. I should have had time to compare in order to do that what has been done here with what was done elsewhere, but I have not had time to do it. I want to discuss, to some extent, the experiment of the tax on betting. I cannot help thinking it was an unwise thing to produce the tax on betting as a bolt from the blue. I think if there were ever a tax that required previous consultation and previous consideration with all the parties interested, it is this tax. There was not the danger of forestalling. A man would not go away and back a horse for the Derby yesterday or the day before because he thought there was to be a tax on betting. He would, at least, have to wait until the "Two Thousand Guineas," because he would not have the knowledge of the form of the horses. Following the British precedent of consideration by a Parliamentary Committee, consideration with people involved, bookmakers and racing authorities, should have preceded the announcement of the tax. However, the thing cannot be ever fully done. It will be no more possible to prohibit unlicensed betting than it was in the past to prohibit illegal betting, and the great bulk of betting has been illegal.

The Minister will not be able to prevent me from saying to another Deputy "I bet you a shilling Deputy Johnson will speak on this motion." I may say, "I should demand very long odds." He would not be able to prevent me or another Deputy saying: "I bet you six pounds that the Minister for Lands and Agriculture interrupts one of the Farmers' Deputies within a week." That would also be in the nature of a betting proposition. You will not eliminate that habit, and it will be impossible to check it completely. One point which I hope the Minister will elaborate is as to what is the position of people in connection with sweepstakes. I believe sweepstakes are illegal. They are also very common. Supposing we agree that we will each put sixpence in a hat and see who draws the winner, would that require a certified return and would it be necessary for a £10 licence to be taken out? Deputy Sir James Craig says "No." I want an assurance from the Minister. Also what will be the position with regard to smaller bets. On sums of ten shillings and over this tax of a shilling in the £ will work very easily, but I do not know if any of the present Ministers go to point-to-point races. I have seen pictures of the President at one, and if he ever gave a look—I suppose he did not give more than a look—in the direction of the bookmakers, he might have seen that betting at point-to-point meetings is done with small sums. A week ago I went to one and my total losses were three and sixpence.

Comment on this

What were the possible gains?

Comment on this

I think half-a-crown in one case and four shillings in the other. It was not a violent plunge, but how is it going to work out in bets of a shilling and multiples of a shilling under ten shillings? You cannot have one-twentieth of a shilling unless the Minister inserts it in the new Coinage Bill. Is there going to be a minimum rate of taxation? I think you will have to have it. It is logical and consistent to prohibit overseas betting. If we are to tax betting in this country, obviously the individual backer of a horse should not be in a position to evade the tax here by betting overseas. So far as that goes, I am with the Minister, but it is very bad from the point of view of the bookmaker. The bookmaker, if he is not to incur undue liability, is in the habit of hedging.

Comment on this

Laying off.

Comment on this

Deputy Wilson has a deeper knowledge of the technicalities of the matter than I have. If the bookmaker is not allowed to lay off then he will be placed in a difficult position. The bulk of the betting in this country is on cross-Channel races. There is a far greater volume of betting in Great Britain, and also in a great many Irish meetings the fields are so small that the odds are not attractive. It is very probable that for local reasons, from the fact that the jockey is an Irishman or that the horse is trained at the Curragh, or that the horse is an Irish-bred horse, he will be at false odds and that there will be more people desiring to back him here than in Great Britain. If the Irish bookmaker cannot lay off or hedge on that horse the horse will be at a false price in this country. In other words, there will be different prices in the Free State and in Great Britain and nothing will persuade a man betting on the horse that he has been treated fairly if he gets worse odds here than in England. He may blame the bookmaker, but more probably the Government, because it is a chronic habit to blame the Government here for anything that has gone wrong. I suggest the Government should either allow a person, who has taken out a licence or the two licences, to bet across Channel or stimulate them to form a sort of pool or clearing-house which will be as good as betting across-Channel. I am not technically acquainted with bookmaking. I know it from the point of view of a loser.

Comment on this

You know something about it.

Comment on this

I am not one of those who make money out of betting like some Deputies. As a result of this, you will have a great many people who have never taken an interest in politics taking an interest in politics now to the disadvantage of the Government. I think it is rather a corollary to this proposition that the Minister should repeal the Gaming Act. He cannot say to the bookmakers: "We recognise you and we recognise every transaction in which you engage to the extent of imposing a 5 per cent. tax, but, so far as the Gaming Act is concerned, you are outlaws."

Comment on this

What about the publican who supplies drink on credit?

Comment on this

Because a publican breaks the law and supplies drink on credit, and because the Minister for Justice cannot catch him, we are to intensify the situation. I suggest, if it is a bad thing, and I think it is a bad thing, that we should not equally put the bookmaker in the position of being winked at by lacking legal rights to enforce his transactions. The State taxes liquor, but it does not require a stamp or certified return of sale, whereas in the case of betting a stamp will be required by the Inland Revenue authorities. I do not see any harm in legalising betting. It would be assisting decent people and penalising the dishonest. I welcome the tax on betting, subject to my rather drastic criticism. It is an experiment in opening new avenues of taxation, and such experiments are badly needed. The most important section of the Minister's speech seems to have gone rather unnoticed amid the columns of detail. I refer to the passage in which he made it clear that the yield of taxation as a whole was steadily shrinking, and that all the arrears liable to be collected will have been collected within the next few years, so that the yield of taxation will be smaller and not greater, and thus the task of the Minister will be proportionately harder in future. Side by side with that shrinkage there is the tendency for the cost of administration to grow.

I hope that no Deputy has ever considered me a pessimist. I am constitutionally and by nature an optimist, but I confess I am somewhat alarmed at the prospect that the Minister's task next year will be harder than this year, and that whoever is Minister for Finance in 1928 will have even a more difficult task. I think it is the duty not only of the Executive Council but of the Dáil and of the country to look the situation in the face, as increased cost of administration with decreased yield in taxation, carried to an indefinite point, means ruin. What is to be done? The first thing to be done—and the Minister has made the first step towards it—is to try and increase the yield of taxation by encouraging to this country new taxpayers, by attracting back some of those who have left, and even some of those who never lived here, and also making the conditions of residence here such that they will create a desire among people to come and live here for good. We have great assets in our scenery, in our sport, and in other factors, and we ought to have capitalised them and made the most of them. I have heard a great deal about reviving our tourist traffic, but one resident is worth ten tourists, as he is here continuously, gives continuous employment, and pays taxes which the tourist does not— namely, direct taxes. Secondly, we should, if possible, find new sources of revenue. The betting tax is a beginning in that respect. I hope it is not an end, and I hope that the Minister will, in so far as protective tariffs do not yield revenue, try to see if there are any other sources. Thirdly, we must make greater economies than we have so far done.

About a month ago the Government turned down the idea of appointing a Geddes Committee. I regret it. I myself, however, appointed a Geddes Committee of one member with a quorum of one. That Committee in my person went through the Estimates to see where economies could be made. I have the results here in a series of amendments, which I am going to move when we consider the Estimates, amounting approximately to a saving of £660,000. That is not on the magnificent Monaghan scale. They seem to do things better in Monaghan than anywhere else. Where Wicklow, Dublin and Sligo have only foxes and weasles to kill their chickens, Monaghan has a bear. I hope that Monaghan will also put down amendments to the Estimates —I am not referring, of course, to the Minister for Finance. I say that a saving of £660,000 is a fairly sound economy at present.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

I hope you will not touch the agricultural grant.

Comment on this

No. I do not say that this economy can be obtained without sacrificing some services to which some Deputies will attach value. It can, however, be done, I think, without serious injury to the State. It will involve in some cases a postponement of services, but that must be done slowly, and it will involve in some cases a cutting in estimates which I believe to be over-estimated. It is, at all events, a serious attempt at economy, and I hope I shall have the support of all those who have demanded economy when I move my amendments.

Comment on this

While Deputy Cooper was speaking I think he made use of an expression which the Dáil did not hear. I think he said that he had not an experience of betting such as some Deputies had, and it reached some of our ears that one of these Deputies was, according to him, Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this

No, I did not mean you, but I will tell you who it was afterwards.

Comment on this

I am going on the assumption that I caught the Deputy correctly, and I want to dispel any illusion in regard to my betting transactions. I have not made a bet for two or three years—in Ireland. In discussing this Budget, or rather, this question of national expenditure, we cannot discuss the Budget without, at the same time, discussing the Estimates. The Budget signifies where the money comes from, and the Estimates give an idea where the most of that money goes to, perhaps where it all goes to. The Budget, taken together with the Estimates and the economic position as it exists at present, cannot be considered by the agricultural community to be a very happy Budget.

No effort has been made to cut down expenditure. The expenditure is slightly increased from last year, although the Minister tells us that the sources of revenue are visibly shrinking. While the sources of revenue are visibly shrinking, we have the mind of the salaried and wage-earning community forcibly expressed by Mr. Cooke in England in the words "Not a cent, not a second." What holds good in England should also hold good here. In the Civil Service and in every other department here we have the same mind and we have the same slogan—"Not a cent, not a second." If it is quite apparent that the sources of revenue are drying up, it is also apparent that our expenditure must be reduced and that all the people in the State must bear their share of the reduction. When we are told by the Minister that no item of expenditure can be reduced and when we hear this talk of "not a cent, not a second," we must recall that the present salaries are founded on the standard of the war period, and that that portion of the community which pays the salaries is not in the position it was in the war years. The sooner the Government makes up its mind to deal with the matter the better. The position at the moment reminds me very much of a certain type of individual whom I came in contact with many times. I have seen men about to die making their wills and bequeathing generous legacies to all the members of their families, while they had not a penny of their own, and were, as a matter of fact, in debt. Pretty much the same kind of gamble is being tried on here. Budgets and estimates must be founded on assets. If you are not going to trim your Budget and your estimates according to your assets, you are going to have bankruptcy. No matter what is said about agriculture—the staple industry of the country—no matter what boosting it gets in various quarters, the fact is that the agriculturist is in an extremely bad position and may be in a very much worse position two years hence. We have had figures showing what the prices are now compared with the prices in 1914, but no effort has been made to prove what the charges are now as compared with those of 1914. You cannot separate those two elements. To have a true picture you must include the two. Otherwise you will have only part of a picture. It has been claimed that if a Geddes Committee were appointed to review, not alone Civil Service affairs, but the whole question of public salaries, that enormous savings could be suggested. It might be found that three men would be able to do the work of five men. One thing we should make up our mind upon—that if we cannot get rid of the old officials, we ought, at least, stop recruiting for a considerable number of years. All these salaried officials, of one kind or other, have got into entrenched positions. They got into these positions at the peak points of the war years, and from those positions they are not willing to retreat. Judging from the attitude all round, they are prepared to let the heavens fall before they will yield a second or a cent.

There is one matter not contained in the Budget which I thought should have been dealt with, that is the question of the insane poor. I believe that this question of the insane poor should be made a national charge. That claim is only a fair one. I am quite confident that it would be more economical to deal with the insane poor, as a national charge, than to have institutions spread all over the country, with numerous staffs, and a lot of expense entailed that could be obviated if the control were national.

The question of most importance in connection with the life of the country, arising out of this Budget, is the question of road policy and the fuel problem. Deputy Good, I think said yesterday that he would favour a national authority with regard to trunk road construction. Anybody who has given the matter serious thought will admit that, as regards trunk roads, at least, a central authority is more effective and provides a better method of dealing with the problem. Otherwise the scheme should be made so uniform that the several local authorities will have a similar policy in regard to road construction. There is no use in having three or four different classes of road from here to Dun Laoghaire or different classes of roads in different counties. When you pass over the border of one county you sometimes get on to a piece of road in another county which it is impossible to travel. I can testify to that from experience. I certainly favour—and I think the party behind me favour—the maintenance of trunk roads by a national authority, or that the system should be so organised that the same policy will prevail under different authorities. We still hold the viewpoint that we held last year with regard to motor traffic. We still hold the view that the only method of dealing justly with this question is on a motor-fuel basis. The people who use the road ought to pay for the road. The people who use the road 365 days of the year ought to be made pay for the traffic on the 365 days. The lorry which is continuously using and breaking the roads should be made pay more than the lorry which only uses the road occasionally. The only way to deal with that is on the motor-fuel basis. I think Deputy Corish can bear me out in the example I am going to give in regard to heavy motor traffic. I have figures for twelve miles of a road in Wexford which show that the repairs this year cost £11,000. In the opinion of the county surveyor if the lorries on this road were reduced to four tons, including load, the amount of repairs would be reduced to £3,000. Next year the estimate for repairs instead of being £10,000 if the same class of lorries were run over the road would be £2,500.

Comment on this

Is that for repairs or reconstruction?

Comment on this

For repairs. It is an argument that very heavy lorries should not be allowed, at all, over certain roads in the country, Six-ton lorries are running over roads and bridges in the country which were never meant for them. The only cure is to put them off these roads altogether.

Comment on this

Is not this road that the Deputy refers to a main road, a trunk road?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

Yes, it is.

Comment on this

We have here the opinion of the engineer in whose charge this road is, that if the lorries running over it were reduced to four tons, including load, there would be a saving of £8,000 in the cost of repairs in one year. Do these heavy lorries counterbalance a saving of £8,000? Is that the Deputy's idea of justice?

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for AGRICULTURE (Mr. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

What would the Ideal Co-operative Creamery say to that?

Comment on this

I do not know. The Ideal Co-operative Creamery can procure lorries to suit their own requirements. The whole country cannot be expected to cater for the ideas of one little body.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am giving that as a specimen creamery.

Comment on this

It is these heavy lorries, beyond all question, that have made the railway position worse than it would be. The railway people themselves have largely contributed to that position by the high freights they charge and the staffs they have to maintain to suit the hours. That largely contributes to the position. The country is faced with the alternative of closing up the railways altogether, and with the loss of an essential national service, because whatever traffic is on the roads, whether it be of lorries, light or heavy, you have to keep the railways running as a national essential service. Cattle cannot be transported without the railways. The railways will have to be maintained even at a national loss. It is a question of economics whether you are going to deal with them in a same manner or not.

With regard to the spirit duty I have little to say. I will, in fact, say nothing at all except that seventeen millions have been spent upon drink, which is a very respectable sum. I will not say whether it is respectably spent or not. I say it is a very respectable sum. Some people think it ought to represent a mountain of money. If anything like value is given for this amount of money it would mean that a lake of liquid is being absorbed by the people of the country.

With regard to the betting tax, Deputy Cooper said something with which I quite agree. If you are going to recognise betting to the extent of collecting a tax from those who bet, I see no reason in the world why we should not make betting transactions legal. I see nothing immoral about it. If it is immoral to recognise betting as a legal transaction it is also immoral to take the earnings of that immoral transaction.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt, but that is really a different point from that made by Deputy Cooper which was whether a bookmaker should be allowed to go to a court of law and recover betting debts.

Comment on this

That is what I mean, too.

Comment on this

I will answer that.

Comment on this

I make the appeal that betting ought to be recognised as a legal transaction.

Comment on this

That is a different thing altogether.

Comment on this

That they should be allowed to go into a court of law and enforce payment.

Comment on this

That certainly would lead to the greatest possible abuse— such abuse that personally I would abandon the betting tax readily rather than agree. If betting debts were made recoverable you would have people induced, by all sorts of means, to enter into betting transactions, and it would be ruinous. The social effect of making gaming debts recoverable by law would be ruinous.

Comment on this

What does the Minister think of people who go to make bets? Does he think they are such simpletons as to allow themselves to be induced to make bets? There are very few bets made but are paid. Occasionally you hear of an individual who is a defaulter.

Comment on this

What about the ones you do not hear about?

Comment on this

And there is always the protection there.

Comment on this

I think this betting taxation is very welcome. It will prevent undesirables operating in our cities and on our race-courses. I hope we will hear less of the army of welchers coming round in future. I adhere to what I say, that betting ought to be recognised and ought to be made legal. I do not anticipate anything like the evils the Minister speaks of. I do not know where he gets his information.

Comment on this

If the Deputy thinks over the matter I think he will agree with me.

Comment on this

I made a few bets in my time, and I know a little about it.

Comment on this

Everybody is not as sensible as the Deputy.

Comment on this

It seems to me as if the Minister is trying to recover a tax on immoral earnings. He talks about the betting tax. In defending his refusal to put a fuel tax upon motor cars he talks about the difficulty of collection. What about the betting tax and the difficulty of collection and the possibility of evasion? These things seem to have no terrors for the Minister, and he has entered lightly upon his task, but he will find that what he thinks is a very clear proposition is really bristling with difficulties and obstacles. I think the Minister has gone very lightheartedly into the betting tax and the method of collecting it. I assure him he is dealing with people who know how to take care of themselves in this matter. Even with the assistance of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the Minister for Justice, I do not think he will succeed, and, taking the whole of them together, I think I can promise them a fifty per cent. failure.

With regard to the part of the Budget dealing with duties on motor cars, I heard a chorus of approval here yesterday about the departure in favour of the Ford car. It makes very little difference to the people of this country whether it is a Ford or any other car if it is not manufactured in this country, and it is very little difference to the people if it is not sold at a competitive price here, similar to what it is sold at in other countries. I understand the price here is very much in excess of the price in England, where, we are told, it is manufactured and assembled, and put together. It is very different from the price in America or Canada. I think we get too enthusiastic about anything, no matter what, manufactured in Ireland. I think an unfair discrimination is made in this case.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Deputy to say——

Comment on this

I forgot that there were a lot of Cork Deputies here.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Deputy to say that a considerable part of the Ford car as sold here is manufactured or assembled in England?

Comment on this

I understand that a considerable portion of the vehicle coming into the country is manufactured or assembled in Manchester. Perhaps the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs will explain the difference in prices.

Comment on this

I am not surprised at the Minister turning down the recommendations of the Tobacco Committee. I know the amount of money that foreign-grown tobacco contributes to the national revenue and I know how serious it would be to do anything that would interfere with that revenue. I think, however, the Minister indicated that those who had Irish grown tobacco on hands and had lost money would not be allowed to be at a loss.

Comment on this

Yes, we are prepared to consider cases.

Comment on this

There are two ways of considering the matter—considering it favourably, and considering it with the idea at the back of your head of doing nothing.

Comment on this

Considering it sympathetically.

Comment on this

Is that as much as we can get from the Minister?

Comment on this

You have got the whole thing.

Comment on this

That is an enigma.

Comment on this

Now I come to that great slice the agricultural community has got, that is to mean so much to them, and in return for which we are asked to sacrifice our whole position— that is the tariff on oatmeal.

Comment on this

A mess of pottage.

Comment on this

If there is anything to be said for that it can be called a millers' tariff.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for AGRICULTURE (Mr. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

Is the Deputy against it?

Comment on this

I do no care two pins whether it comes into force or not. It does not matter two pins to me or anybody else whether it is imposed or not. If that is all the Government are able to give by way of protection for the agricultural industry, it explodes for all time the theory that protection is going to benefit agriculture; it does away with the argument of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs anyhow.

Comment on this

The Deputy will think again.

Comment on this

One of the results of the tariff will be that it will make one of the essential calf foods a little dearer. I do not know whether that can be said to be a benefit to the agricultural community. It may be news to the Minister for Posts and Telegraps that oatmeal forms part of one of the most extensively used calf foods and this tariff is bound to make that a little dearer. It is such a small thing, however, that it is not worth considering.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Does the Deputy want it taken off?

Comment on this

Take it off if you like. It is not any good to us. Give it to somebody else.

Comment on this

What about the twelve thousand?

Comment on this

If farmers can get a fraction of a farthing apiece out of it, that is all I can see in it. I do not think it is worth referring to, except that it proves that no Government is able to do anything for the protection of agriculture considering where our market is.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want protection for agriculture?

Comment on this

I say to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs that neither he nor anybody else, even with the best will in the world, will be able to protect it by a tariff.

Comment on this

We shall see.

Comment on this

Even with all his resources and his great enterprise. I believe the Minister has tried very hard in the councils of the Cumann na nGaedheal to do something. Will the Minister tell us all about the million that we were told was going to be added to the Agricultural Grant but that they failed to secure? We heard reports about such an addition to the Agricultural Grant, but it did not come off. Is it kept over for the election Budget next year?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Now it is out.

Comment on this

Even Ministers on the front bench talked of the surprises that were in store for the agricultural community.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Who are they?

Comment on this

I am not going to mention names. I do not give away stable secrets like that. Are we to expect all these next year when the election is coming off?

Comment on this
Séamus Aloysius Bourke MINISTER for LOCAL GOVERNMENT and PUBLIC HEALTH (Mr. Burke) Cumann na nGaedheal

Expect what?

Comment on this

A Budget that will sweep us all off our feet; sweep us all into the Government net and give the Government three or four more years of office. As to the wireless receiving sets, the idea evidently is to make a distinction between the valve sets and the crystal sets. Evidently the intention is to make the owners of valve sets, who in present circumstances are largely rural residents, build up a fund for the development of broadcasting. The owners of valve sets have to pay a £1 tax while the crystal set users have only to pay 10s., in order to build up a fund for developing broadcasting. That is on a par with the Minister's methods of dealing with the rural population, because they live in the country away from the Minister's circle of civilization. If they are not good enough to live within that charmed circle, they are good enough to tax to procure facilities for the Minister's friends. I object to one section of the community being asked to build up a fund in order to provide entertainment for another section. If broadcasting is worth developing at all, it ought to be developed as a national charge. If we have a central station in Dublin set up at the national expense, why should not the whole scheme be developed at the national expense? There is too much of this discrimination. Ministers have got into the habit of thinking that sections of the community must be discriminated against—that one section do not deserve the same facilities as others. That is rather unjust. No one with any sense of justice could defend it. I am not surprised at the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs defending it. Perhaps I ought to congratulate the Minister for Finance as other Deputies have congratulated him. I congratulate him on one thing—that as far as national expenditure goes he is on the right side. The nation is not bankrupt so long as he can get the money, but the people who supply him with the money deserve a little consideration. The sooner people in a responsible position come to see that the nation is not able to bear taxation on the present basis the sooner we will have arrived at a sensible and sound position.

Comment on this

I have been taunted by Deputy Cooper with the fact that my constant advocacy of a change in the economic position in this country has come to nought in this Budget. I do not quite agree that it has come to nought. It is true it has not very largely materialised, but, in any case, I am prepared to make a present to the Minister for Finance, or anybody else in the Party of which I am a member, of the congratulations of Deputy Cooper and men who think like him on matters of this kind. His economic and national outlook and mine are as separate as the poles. There are, however, a couple of points in this Budget which to me are very acceptable. The treatment which the Ford car has secured will help not only to keep that industry in Cork, but, as a matter of fact, secures it there, and opens up for it a future as bright as any that the owners of that firm had envisaged. I am speaking with a knowledge of the feelings of those connected with the Ford firm with respect to this concession. The steps, though apparently limited, that have been taken to assist the distilling industry will go a long way towards restoring that industry to prosperity. These two sections in the Budget have, therefore, been a compensation to many of us, who had looked forward, not only to the salvation of decaying industries but their stimulation.

An important section in the Minister's speech is the setting up of a statutory body of Civil Servants to examine the various claims for the extension of tariffs. That is a step in the right direction. Personally I would have preferred that the Government had boldly grappled with at least some of the more pressing cases, and dealt with them on the spot. But, in the absence of that attitude on the part of the Government, I welcome the setting up of this Civil Service body.

Comment on this

Is it the Tariff Commission you are speaking of?

Comment on this

Yes. It has one weakness. In the event of a report which makes for the application of tariffs being recommended we can take it that the effect of the imposition of that tariff will be very largely nullified by forestalling. There may be difficulties in dealing with forestalling, but I put it to the Minister that in an event of that kind the industry concerned will be doomed at least to 12 months' complete inactivity. As has been suggested in a similar circumstance in another country, there is, to my view, no reason why legal steps could not be taken to see that nothing beyond the average import of the particular article should be permitted without retrospective taxation. This is not an unfair proposal. On the other hand, if this Committee proceeds to interpret the view, which may or may not be general, that the end of tariffs, before the general election, has been reached, and that its duty is merely to kill time, then, those of us who feel keenly on the tariff question will be called upon to review our position. I happen to be one of those who was attracted to political life by the teachings of Arthur Griffith. Through his years of toil he never ceased to dwell on two facts which he held were responsible for the slow but unceasing decay of the Irish nation. He pointed to the fact that in the '50's of the last century about 3½ million acres of land were under cultivation in this country. In 1914 tillage had dropped to the low level of 1,690,000 acres.

Comment on this

In what year was it 3 millions?

Comment on this

In 1851 the number of acres under tillage in Ireland was 3,509,000; in 1871 the number had dropped to 2,772,000; in 1891 to 1,975,000; 1911, to 1,697,000; 1914, to 1,690,000; 1925, to 1,571,000. There was a slow but constant decline. Side by side with this decline in tillage we have had the same steady flow of our people to other countries, such as America, which was guarded and protected by high tariffs. During the same period we found scores and scores of industries, which had been flourishing at the time of the Act of Union, declining steadily up to the introduction of free trade. One by one we found these industries passing away, and, in our time, dotting the hillsides of Ireland, as each and everyone must have seen with regret, with derelict mills.

Arthur Griffith told us that there was one cure for this combination of evils, and one cure only. He said, first of all secure the home market for the home producer, and where the home producer was unable to secure the market, to do that implied one very definite step—in the case of manufacturers—protection. He said in connection with protection that it was futile for a weak nation, a nation weak in capital and weak in technical resources, to think that it could at any time in the absence of protection stand up against its powerful foreign rivals. This was his one and main reason for advocating protection. Arthur Griffith believed, like the Minister for Finance yesterday, in stimulating production but, unlike the Minister for Finance, he showed us ways and means. He did not merely tell us that as regards the £18,000,000 adverse trade-balance which this unfortunate country is now suffering—£18,000,000 of money which is being dragged from a poor, hard-working people, and handed over to foreign nations, like an indemnity to a conqueror—that we should continue to suffer that loss without giving us ways and means of combating it. He told us to adopt protection. I have urged on my party, and I have preached to the country, the idea that there is only one salvation for the economic position of this nation as we now find it, and that that salvation is in protecting the country against the foreigner. I am glad to get the opportunity here of reiterating that expression, and any argument I can deduce, any influence I can use, during my connection with politics, will be used in the direction of protecting the weak man of Ireland against the highly-financed foreign dumper.

The big argument, the shibboleth of Adam Smith and Cobden, used against protection, the argument that undoubtedly has a certain amount of sway in the absence of counter-arguments throughout this country, is the one that by protection we are going to increase the cost of living. The counter-cry to that, or rather the stable companion cry, if I might use a sporting phrase for Deputy Gorey, is of course to produce as good and as cheaply. Unlike Deputy Cooper, and also unlike Deputy Gorey, I hope that I at least have some idea as to how the economic ills of the country may be rectified. I am not satisfied to confine myself to deploring them. I at least, and those who feel like me, whether our proposals, whether our remedies, are good or bad, can claim to have remedies, and we preach these remedies to the country. I say that protection does in some instances raise the cost of living, but there are a great many other things in the economic affairs of a nation that act in a like direction. Four millions have to be paid for education, for instance, and that increases the cost of living. The five millions we are spending on the Shannon scheme will increase the cost of living. Many things we do in the activities or functions of government also increase the cost of living, but we do these things with the sole object of increasing the opportunities for our people at home. Some tariffs would do likewise, at least tariffs that are not, for instance, associated with the basic industry of the country, will for a number of years have that effect. I can see that and I stand by it. There are, however, a great many industries closely associated with our life which can be protected without altering materially the cost of living. There is the woollen industry to mention one, and the flour industry to mention another. There are many others. It will be asked: "Will you name some of those industries that have been protected that have not raised the cost of living?" I certainly will. I have made inquiries regarding some of these industries that were established here already, and I have been informed without question that in the case of jam, confectionery, bedsteads, blankets, boots, candles, and tobacco, each and all of these are produced at present without any increased cost to the consumer.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs if he is supported in that statement by the Minister for Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this

I do not think that is a point of order. The Minister for Industry and Commerce will speak in due course. I have a communication which supports that statement from the secretry to the Dublin Industrial Association, and I have supporting statements from the manufacturers of blankets, bedsteads and candles. I know that in the case of tobacco there has been no increase. Nobody will challenge that. This morning I was informed by the managing director of Dwyer and Sons, Cork, that instead of their boots being sold at an increased price the price has decreased.

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell us whether he is referring to the price to the retailer or to the consumer?

Comment on this

The price to the retailer. The price as between the retailer and the consumer is not a matter the manufacturer has any control over, or can be held responsible for, and I am glad that interruption has been made. You have here a series of manufactured articles, each and every one of which has had its roots in the country, and the very small measure of protection which the Minister for Finance was good enough to extend to these industries has not only resulted in not increasing the prices but has resulted in the fact that the Irish market to-day is in their complete control, with the possible exception of boots. That surely is an encouraging fact for men like Mr. Sean Milroy who stood almost alone in those Benches in years gone by and appealed to the Government to come to the rescue of our workless and largely penniless working people. It is also a tribute to the enterprise of the people who were able in that short space of time, and with the uncertainty of the continuance of protection hanging over them, to accomplish that. What has been done here in these industries will happen in every protected industry in this State if these industries get a chance.

I appeal to the Government to come to the rescue of the woollen industry. Let me say at once that I appreciate the position of the Government in this matter. Their position is a peculiar one. The break up of those forces which were responsible for the establishment of this State and this Parliament, freed the field for all those elements which had little or nothing in common with progress. It freed the field for the importer and the rancher. and they have had for the last two or three years the fairs to themselves, and they have made good use of it. They have also been supported not only by their big financial resources and their business training, but by a Press largely dependent on foreign advertisements. They have made good use of their solidarity, but I think they can look forward to the downward current from this onward. Their size has been taken. The youth of Ireland is realising what the game is and to where it is leading. It is because of that realisation that I appeal to the Government to break away from its pledge that no further tariffs will be imposed in the intervening period. I have not appealed in vain I hope if this Committee should operate. I am particularly keen on seeing that our woollen mills should not be permitted to disappear.

When I left the Dáil last night I was accosted by a foolishly patriotic citizen who, three years ago, sold his property and, in addition to the money realised on it, got a considerable loan from the bank for the purpose of purchasing a woollen mill. He said: "I am ruined; the failure of the Government to come to the rescue of the woollen industry has ruined me. I have collected every penny that I possessed in the world and every penny that my friends could help me to realise and I have put it into a mill, not very far away, to the extent of £37,000. To-morrow I am prepared to sell that mill for £2,000; I am ruined; I am bankrupt. I was foolish enough to believe that I lived in a country working under a native Parliament which was prepared to stand by men who had the courage to stand by their country. I am deceived." Are there men in this House; are there Deputies in this House—

Comment on this

Who have no sympathy with that man? If the Minister for Justice has no sympathy with him, I for one certainly have. He is a ruined man because the Government has failed to come to his rescue. But he is only one example of the many who have gone by the roadside in helping to keep industries afloat. It is a matter of very great regret to me that these woollen mills should have been permitted to go down and out. Three of them in the city of Cork are already closed. A great number of their technical employees have been scattered to the four winds, and we here, at least, ought to realise that one of the greatest difficulties in building an industry is in providing trained hands. Let them be once scattered and it takes many years to replace them.

I am sorry also that nothing has been done in the case of the flour milling industry. In the city of Cork three mills have been already shut down and the fourth is on the point of disappearing. All over the country a similar tale is being told, and on the other side of the Channel, we read in the English newspapers, new combines with increased finances are being created to give our Irish milling the finishing stroke. Are you going to help that policy? Are there men in this Dáil who believe that neither the woollen nor the milling industry is of any concern to the nation? I hope, for the sake of the nation, that there are not and that at least these cases are worthy of sympathetic consideration, if not of immediate action. The milling industry at one time got some little encouragement from a Fiscal Committee that was set up here. That Fiscal Committee said: "The preservation of flour milling is important in the national interests." I presume the Fiscal Committee knew what it was talking about. That was not the particular Fiscal Committee to which Deputy Heffernan referred. I believe it was another.

Comment on this

A mysterious Fiscal Committee.

Comment on this

The Commission on Agriculture reported in regard to wheat growing that the national wellbeing would be served if a greater quantity of wheat were grown in Ireland and used in the mills and deprecated the importation of flour instead of wheat. Does anybody disagree with that?

Comment on this

What Committee was this?

Comment on this

Six months ago members of this party who felt as I feel. regarding some of these matters, waited on the flour millers with a view not only to save the flour milling industry, but to stop the importation, or at least to reduce the importation, of wheat, which is a heavy drain on the country. Last year we sent seven millions of money to foreign countries for wheat, and practically three millions for bacon. Ten millions from an impoverished country—from a so-called agricultural country. We made proposals. We discussed this matter of flour milling with flour millers, and they agreed that a tax of 2/6 per twenty stone on imported flour would be sufficient to save the industry.

Comment on this

We sent five millions out of the country for flour.

Comment on this

The millers guaranteed that, instead of increasing the cost of flour to the consumer, they would sell that flour without any extra cost.

Comment on this

Might I ask as a matter of explanation—this is important— where the Minister got the figures? Would the Minister tell us if this seven million pounds had not been sent out for flour, how much would be sent out for raw wheat?

Comment on this

The figure is about fifty-fifty.

Comment on this

Nonsense. If the figures of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs are no better than that, he should stop.

Comment on this

The Deputy persists in interrupting. It is not a matter for the Deputy to say when I am to stop. The Deputy ought permit others than himself to speak without interruption. If he wants these facts it is not necessary to cut in on my speech to secure them. They are available for everybody. Therefore I do not propose to give them.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Good man.

Comment on this

Now the Flour Millers' Association was satisfied that a tax of 2/6 per twenty stone sack would not only exclude imported flour which arrived here to the extent of nearly three and a half million pounds per year, but that no increase to the consumer would result. They gave that assurance as those other manufacturers to whom I previously referred gave it, that once the home market was at their disposal, with their increased output and their consequent lower overhead expenses the saving in this direction would be sufficient to give them a margin of profit without passing anything on to the consumer. In return for this concession which would bring about a re-opening of all our closed mills and a very great extension of employment, they were prepared to include in their home-made product any percentage of home-grown wheat which this Government would request them to include. They were prepared, in addition, to pay the Mark Lane prices prevailing at any one time for that wheat. The Mark Lane price for the four concluding months of last year was 28/- a barrel. The price for home-grown wheat during the same four months was 32s. 2¼d. per barrel. Farmers have assured me that 30/- a barrel would give them an ample margin of profit. As a matter of fact, I believe that they agreed that wheat growing last year was quite profitable.

Now, what the flour millers proposed in effect was this: that we proceed at once, with their co-operation and assistance, to take back or to hold back an increasing slice of this seven millions which we are handing over to foreign farmers. I venture to say that the farming community here who complain bitterly of the inadequate prices for grain would be very pleased indeed to see this Government give them a definite outlook in regard to one of these products. I wonder if that fact is questioned by any farmer Deputy in this House? It surely is of importance to this nation that some of the bread required for the support of its people ought to be produced at home. There was a time when this country produced all its own requirements in wheat. There was a time even when they exported the surplus. It is not unnatural to expect that in our day and in our circumstances, at least, a little of the home product would be sold to the home people. I doubt if it would do them much harm.

That is the proposal with regard to wheat. In many countries on the Continent of Europe people would be very glad to get home-grown wheat. They eat rye instead. Home-grown wheat is not good enough for the people of this country! And yet they grumble and talk about their impoverished position, and they talk about their unemployment, and talk about their taxation and about the tens of thousands of their people who are forced to flee to a foreign land; but they are prepared to ignore the fact that without any necessity whatever they send millions of money for wheat to the farmers of foreign lands—millions that could well be utilised for the farmers of Ireland. I stand for protection, for protection in general, not in particular. I do not stand for protection for every article in use, but I do say that there are a great many things, particularly those which did find general production in this country in the past, and which are essential in times of war, in times when external products are impossible to get—all those things which are essential to the lives of the people ought to be produced without any loss of time.

I suppose we will be told in later speeches that the farmer could not compete in his own market—that the prices of his products would be made prohibitive. I am not surprised at that. It is the kind of story that one would expect to hear. The same story was preached in Australia, New Zealand, Canada and Denmark, the countries that compete against this country in the same market. What do they do? Do they follow the role of depriving the nation of its second arm, depriving the urban population of a means of productive livelihood, and contribution to the national sustenance or taxation? They do not. In the case of the four countries we find a stiff tax—in some cases a tax reaching 90 per cent. We find in the four countries that textiles, woollen goods, are heavily taxed. The same applies to agricultural implements, boots and shoes, leather, tinned meats, confectionery and fish. We find that the system of taxation is almost too prohibitive in three of those countries in regard to the importation of flour, butter, milk and cheese.

In the case of Australia and New Zealand we find a tax on bacon. There is no doubt the Farmers' Union in New Zealand must have told the people that the imposition of these import duties would mean that they would be driven out of their only market. You had the Deputy Goreys and the Deputy Coopers and all the people who think like them in New Zealand, preaching the same doctrine. Fortunately for the people of New Zealand, that doctrine was discarded, and in their case, as in the case of the other three countries, protection was made a general rule; the exception is difficult to find.

We find each and every one of these countries hunting the non-protected country from the English market, a country that has advantages not only in its climate and its soil, but also in its proximity to that market. These are facts worth nothing. I observe that Deputy Cooper, when flatly turning down—boldly turning down—a communication of mine to a recent meeting in Cork, failed to deal with any of the statements I made. These four heavily-protected countries are beating our non-protected country at our own doors, in our own market, with our own weapons.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that New Zealand grants a preference in her tariffs to all goods produced in Great Britain, because Great Britain is her best market, and will he advocate that policy here?

Comment on this

We do.

Comment on this

That is what we do.

Comment on this

I am in every instance prepared to consider the claim of a good customer. That brings me to another point, which I will deal with later on, in respect of countries from which we get millions of pounds worth of goods and to which we send no goods. These four countries I have referred to are heavily protected. It must be obvious to those people who turned down protection in Ireland that these four countries are whipping us in the English market. That is what free trade has done for us. Not only are they beating us in the English market, but they are actually beating us in our own market. So much for free trade.

Is there any export of people from any of those countries? I have not heard of any. Is there any unemployment in these countries outside the temporary unemployment which lately capital has been made of in respect to Denmark? That was just a passing phase. Have any of these countries an adverse trade balance?

Comment on this

Will the Minister define the countries he refers to?

Comment on this

I have already done so.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned four countries. Will he tell me what they are?

Comment on this

Australia, Denmark—

Comment on this

Denmark has an adverse trade balance.

Comment on this

I have not completed my statement in regard to Denmark and I would be obliged if the Deputy gives me a chance to do so.

Comment on this

Denmark has an adverse trade balance.

Comment on this

In three of the four countries I have referred to they boast of a big surplus trade balance. They have a big and a growing surplus trade balance. Deputies, I am sure, have observed that in the last two days in the case of Canada, a week ago in the case of Australia and a couple of months ago in the case of New Zealand. In the case of Denmark it is true that, for the time being, things are not going as well as they might be going. There are many causes responsible for that. We know very well that in Denmark, for one thing, labourers' wages are at least twice what they are in Ireland. That may not be the cause for the adverse trade balance, but I just mention it as one of the items which can be touched upon and possibly amplified by other people. At any rate you have these four countries with no export of human beings, no export of money, no unemployed and all prospering.

The four countries are Australia, New Zealand, Canada and Denmark. These countries keep the home market to themselves; they insist on keeping one foot on dry land—one foot on solid soil—instead of looking like the fool to the ends of the earth for salvation. That is what protection has done for these countries. I am not referring to the United States, because there is no parallel. I am referring to countries that are purely agricultural, countries that, prior to the adoption of the Free State, were getting it rough. They have, since the introduction of protection, not only turned the corner but prospered.

I am not one of those who see the economic salvation of this country in a petty reduction of national taxation. Apart altogether from the fact that any considerable reduction is impossible and would be strenuously resisted, not from these Benches but, perhaps, from the Bench that resisted the reduction in the expenditure on Post Office Services, I am not satisfied that the reduction which at the utmost we might secure would make any material improvement in our economic outlook. I might remind the House that prior to the European War there was no question of heavy taxation, either local or national. There were people, certainly, who felt—we all felt it—that we were paying somewhat more than we ought to pay, but, on the whole, it was merely an academic question; there was no outcry about heavy taxation. But did our industries prosper? Will anybody in this House tell me that during his years of memory prior to the European War industries were started in Ireland in those heydays of low taxation? The only industries that I remember were ones that shot up but shot down at almost the same speed, that were wiped out by their opponents on the other side. I do not remember one industry, outside Fords, that was started in those days of low taxation and that has succeeded.

I have already said that in these same times our agricultural industry did not prosper. It declined. Therefore, as far as the prospects of increased industrial effort through any reduction of taxation that is possible at present are concerned I am not prepared to give it a moment's thought. It would be helpful; it would be an item; it would be well if it could be done, but as a real, live stimulant towards meeting the huge margin between imports and exports, which is bleeding this country dry at present, it is a bagatelle; it does not count. We have reached a break in the economic change in this country. We have reached a halt—I will not say a break. It is doubtful if this speech of mine would have been necessary had one-half of our people not decided to boycott a native Parliament. I put my country beyond any party, and I trust for the sake of these ideals that led me to pass through a living hell in securing, not political freedom alone—because that is only one item, the control of the Civil Service—but economic freedom, that the spirit that got these men to fight, in many cases to lose their lives, to establish a Parliament here will get a new impetus, with the assistance of those who now boycott this Parliament. I, for one, hope, in the interests of a nation which is struggling in a morass, which is being bled white by the export each year of anything from twelve millions to fifteen millions of its precious money, that the policy which has been lauded here to-day by Deputy Cooper and others will be short-lived. I see no hope for this country in the continuation of the policy which we inherited from the British. I see nothing but despair and disappointment for those with whom I was associated in the fight for freedom under that policy. Beyond expressing that hope, I am prepared confidently to leave the fortunes of this country with the awakening youth of Ireland.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

in the Chair.

Comment on this
Martin Roddy Mr. RODDY

I merely wish to say a few words on two or three aspects of the Budget. In the first place I would like to say that in my opinion anything that would have the effect of increasing the cost of living for the agricultural population of the country at the moment would be simply disastrous. As the old saying has it, "The last straw breaks the camel's back," and I think the utmost limit of endurance has already been reached. Anyone who studies the advertisement pages of the weekly papers will be amazed at the long lists of farms for sale each week. Actually during the last few months these sales have increased at an alarming rate, and I do think that if the Minister for Finance or the Executive Council did decide on going any further with their protectionist policy at the moment it would have the effect of driving quite a big number of small farmers out of business altogether. I agree, from the figures that have been supplied to us. as to the results of protection up to the moment, that quite a large number of people have been given employment, but we have not been told of the number of people who have actually been driven out of business altogether as a result of these tariffs.

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs quoted a long list of figures showing the imports, particularly of agricultural products. I am sorry I have not had an opportunity of looking into those figures and checking them, but I think after all the fact of there being such a huge import of agricultural products into this country during the past three or four years has been due to a variety of causes. In the first place, as a result of the huge demand made on the cattle trade during the European War, quite a number of farmers in this country got out of the tillage business altogether, and even when the war was over, and a slump came, the farmers still continued the store cattle and the fat cattle trade. Now I believe you will find that there will be a considerable revival in tillage and that our adverse balance will be reduced considerably. I know in my own county men, who have gone in for grazing for the last nine or ten years, are going back to tillage again, and Deputy Gorey will bear me out that the same thing is happening in his own county.

Comment on this

A little.

Comment on this
Martin Roddy Mr. RODDY

I think the Government are acting wisely in moving cautiously in this direction. After all we have no landmarks to guide us in a matter of this kind, and I think we should act with the utmost caution.

With regard to the tariff on oatmeal I am sorry that the Minister for Finance could not see his way to increase that tariff because I feel the small amount he has put on will be of very little inducement to the farmers of the country to increase their tillage area under oats. I am glad that the Minister has introduced a tax on lorries. The destruction of the roads as a result of the heavy lorry traffic during the past few years has been enormous and recently these lorries have taken to by-roads, particularly the lorries of shopkeepers who are using the by-roads for the purpose of distributing foodstuffs. If this thing were allowed to continue it would mean that in the course of a few years it would be impossible for the rate-payers of this country to maintain the roads in a condition fit for lorries to travel on. Deputy Gorey yesterday stated that the char-a-bancs were doing as much damage as the heavy lorries. My own impression is, that the 13-ton lorry, laden weight, on an ordinary steam-rolled road, would have as much effect as that of a char-a-banc running for a whole week. Still the char-a-bancs are getting off lightly. Personally I think that no lorry of 5 ton laden weight should be allowed to travel. We have got the railways, and I think all heavy traffic should be put on them. We have from Dublin to Mullingar three systems of transport running within a few miles of one another. I hold that all the heavy traffic should be sent by rail, and the other system of transport scrapped altogether.

With regard to the drivers' licences, I would be rather inclined to suggest to the Minister that he should find the extra money by putting an extra tax on the heavy lorry. In addition to that, I suggest that drivers should be made to undergo some sort of a test to show that they are efficient and capable of driving. I think in many countries, before giving a driver a licence, they require that test. It is quite reasonable to assume that there will be a considerable increase in the motor cars on our roads and for that reason the State should see to it that only efficient and reliable men should be given motor driver licences. I think considering all the circumstances that the Minister for Finance has done very well; the Budget has been framed on conservative lines and I think it will meet generally with the approval of people in the country.

Comment on this

I desire, at the outset, to congratulate the Minister for the Budget as a whole. The most interesting speech we have listened to has been that of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. He took me back to the days when I read Lord Macaulay's Lays of Ancient Rome:—

"Lars Porsena of Clusium

By the nine gods he swore

That the great House of Tarquin

Would suffer wrong no more.

By the nine Gods he swore it

And named a trysting day,

And bade his messengers ride forth

East and West, South and North.

To summon his array."

The position here is a little bit changed. There is an election coming on of which poor Ireland is to be the subject. I was rather surprised that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs showed so little wisdom, when ascertaining how the protection duties resulted, in going to the people interested in these tariffs. I had no doubt as regards the benefits to be derived from duties on soaps and other items, but I had grave doubt originally when the duty was placed on boots that it was going to do anything but bring an increased cost to the poor in providing boots and shoes for their children. I would like to ask the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs what diminution has taken place in the imports of boots during the last year? I do not care so much about the revenue produced, but I would like to know whether there is a tendency towards increased production in our boot factories. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs told us that the Cork people are supplying boots at a lower price now than before the tariff went on. In order to find out whether they were charging a lesser amount or not I would not go to those people, but rather to the persons who purchase the boots. It is hard to believe that a lower price is being charged for boots now than before the duty was put on.

I agree with the remarks of Deputy Roddy in regard to heavy lorry traffic and I would, in fact, go a step further and say that no char-a-banc should be allowed to carry more than twenty or twenty-five people, and also that no lorry be a greater weight unloaded than four tons. Our roads cannot stand this heavy traffic, and I agree with Deputy Roddy that such traffic should be left to the railways.

The railways need such traffic and I would forbid these huge lorries to use the roads. I have had experience myself as a motor driver, and I know no greater death trap than the presence of these lorries on the roads. From all directions complaints are being made that no attempt is being made to keep these vehicles on the proper side of the road, especially in going round corners, except where a policeman is present. I have found that out from my own experience. I would, therefore, suggest, if it were possible, that a licence should not be granted in the case of lorries carrying a heavier weight than eight, or, at the very outside, ten tons. With regard to drivers' licences, I think some modification of the new proposal ought to be made. I know a case in which the owner of a car has a family of five, all of whom are able to drive. It would be a serious impost in such a case if they had to pay £5 for the privilege of driving the car. In such cases I would reduce the amount where various members of a family are concerned, or else reduce the charge below the existing 10/-. I admit that there is a certain amount to be said for the standpoint of the Minister for Finance, namely, that by increasing the licence you will prevent a certain number of people from driving cars. I would urge the importance of ascertaining the ability of a person to drive a car before issuing him a licence. It is a very serious matter to allow a man with one leg, or one eye, or even two blind eyes, to drive a car. There should be some test applicable to men before they are given drivers' licences.

With regard to the tariff on oatmeal, I feel that it is not going to do much good, certainly not to the farmers, as there is nothing to prevent Canadian oats being brought in. It will probably mean eightpence a stone extra on the consumer. From the medical point of view, the medical profession has for years being endeavouring to supplant the use of the eternal teapot, which is kept sitting all day on the hob and from which children are occasionally given black tea or black tannin. The profession has endeavoured to get people to use more oatmeal and porridge. Some people say that porridge is not a food for decent people. One distinguished professor who could not digest porridge said it was not fit for men or horses, and the reply was that Scotchmen use it and English horses are fed on it, and where could better men or horses be found? In my opinion there should be a duty on Canadian oats in addition to the duty on oatmeal. This new tariff will probably stop a considerable amount of oatmeal coming from the Six Counties where tillage is carried out on a much larger scale than here. Strange to say I am in agreement with the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs in regard to his suggestion for a tariff on imported flour. I would, of course, allow foreign wheat to come in because we cannot compete with countries where wheat is grown under exceptional conditions, where it has only to be sown to be reaped, and where when it is cut it is ready for stacking. In those lands little labour is needed to collect and get it ready for the mill. By putting a tariff on imported flour we would not only give increased employment in the mills but we would also have the offal of the mills for use as cattle food.

I am sorry that the duty on wines has been increased. We know in the case of France, which depends almost entirely on the drinking of wines, that it is an extremely temperate country. One scarcely ever sees a case of drunkenness there. The poor man in hospital or in what corresponds to our workhouse is provided with a mug of ordinary wine and it does not encourage him to drunkenness. I think it would be better for us if there were an increase in the use of light wines here. Deputy Hennessy said that we were depending too much on the use of strong drink. I am not now going to deliver a lecture on the morality of drunkenness, such as Deputy Johnson delivered to-day on the morality of betting. I would have a good deal to say if I discussed the question of the price of stout and other things, but that is not the question at the moment. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs alluded to the fact that at one period Ireland was able to produce sufficient wheat to feed the country. I do not think that that could be proved up to the hilt. My knowledge of history leads me to believe that, at a certain period at all events, people generally depended on the growth of potatoes, and the Famine, with all its deplorable results, occurred because people lived entirely on them. I do not think that this country could be largely utilised for the growth of wheat. On the whole, I am satisfied with the Budget. The Minister for Finance has had to put on certain tariffs, and, perhaps, that on betting is the one that will create most criticism, but, on the whole, I think it is time we looked for other methods, and explored other avenues, of revenue than those upon which we have been dependent in the past.

Comment on this