RAILWAYS (EXISTING OFFICERS AND SERVANTS) BILL, 1926—SECOND STAGE (RESUMED).
Contributions 1–173 of 352. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1926 ›
A great deal has been said about this Bill, so I do not desire to say very much. In the first place, it appears to me that the Minister does not seem to know his own mind on the subject matter of the Bill. In connection with the retrospective clause which was discussed at great length yesterday, I think we are practically assured that this clause is a reflection of the mind of the Ministry. It is nonsense to say that the Minister is going to allow a free vote of the House on this particular clause. It is a peculiar thing to say that he is going to have a free vote of the House when, as a matter of fact, the House is not in a position to know what is the mind of the Party which sits immediately behind the Ministry. To my mind, anyone who gives a vote for the Second Reading of the Bill will agree with the principle of it. Retrospective legislation is very undesirable, especially in connection with a matter of this kind, because you have got to teach the people of this country to have respect for the law. If Bills are brought in dealing with matters retrospectively people will have very little respect for the work of the Dáil. When Deputy Gorev was speaking yesterday he said that the railway managers had to accept a certain position which prevented them from lowering freights. He said that anybody who goes into any office or goods store at a railway station will find too many men employed. So far as I know, the railway managers know their business very well and they will not keep on men other than those they want. It appears that if that is the case they are probably keeping them on because of a promise by the Minister that he will give them relief in the Bill now before us. These men are being kept on with a certain amount of procrastination so that they will not be dealt with as liberally as the men who have gone before them. The Minister in this Bill is trying to interfere with the Superannuation Fund. To my mind, he has no authority to do any such thing because according to my information, this Superannuation Fund is controlled in London and any employee, when he comes to a certain age, is entitled to draw superannuation out of it. It is not good enough and it is certainly extraordinary legislation if the railway company is allowed to take money out of this fund—out of the pockets of the workers—and to pay it out to them again, because that is really what the proposition means. It is an absurd piece of legislation. The whole Bill appears to be a very hurriedly thought-out thing—a Bill brought in almost in a fit of desperation in order to come to the relief of the shareholders of the Great Southern Company. The Minister yesterday quoted certain cases. He said that in at least three cases men who had been in receipt of £700 per year were, on amalgamation, after the arbitrator's award, drawing £900 per year. I have made inquiries since yesterday evening and I find that this is not the case— that nobody in touch with railway circles has any knowledge whatever of any such case or cases. It may be that some of the higher officials——
Comment on this
He can read it himself. Some of the higher officials may have had agreement with the railway directors, and such state of affairs may have been brought about. But the Minister mentioned these cases in order to blindfold the Dáil, so to speak, and lead them to believe that these were only one or two such cases, and that in the ordinary case the employees were in receipt of more money since they were declared redundant than they were prior to amalgamation. I do not think that is the proper way to treat the House. The Minister told us that he made a mistake, and that the Dáil and Seanad made a mistake in regard to the 1924 Bill. So far as I can see, he is making an earnest endeavour to get the Dáil to make another mistake.
Comment on this
It might, perhaps, rectify a mistake to some extent, but it would make another mistake. As I have said, the retrospective clause is very undesirable, and I would ask Deputy Gorey and his party to reconsider their decision and to vote against this Bill, because nobody knows what will happen between this and the next Stage, when the Minister proposes to allow a free vote upon this particular clause. To my mind, a vote for this Bill now will be a vote for the principle of retrospective legislation. I would ask the Dáil to vote in such a manner that this Bill will be thrown out and returned to the Department of Industry and Commerce, so that it can be redrafted.
The Minister challenged me to read a letter which I had received, and of which he has a copy. I propose to oblige him. This letter is written by the Secretary of the Irish Railway Clerks' Association to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and it is dated 29th April, 1926:—
A Chara,
Railways (Existing Officers and Servants) Bill, 1926.
You are reported in to-day's Press as having, in the debate yesterday on the Second Reading of this Bill, quoted an instance in which a railway servant, with 30 years' service, in receipt of 60/- per week before amalgamation, and reduced by 1/- per week after amalgamation, could claim and be awarded "a minimum payment of 30/- per week for life for the loss of 1/- per week."
I feel compelled in the interest of truth to characterise this as a very grave misrepresentation of fact, and one calculated to seriously mislead the Dáil. In such a case, what would happen would be this: the employee concerned could, under sub-sections 3 and 4 of the Third Schedule, claim that his wages had been reduced, and that he was, therefore, entitled to a lump sum allowance, based upon the value of the reduction in his pre-amalgamation wages. If no agreement was arrived at, the case would come before the arbitrator, who would ascertain the lump sum value of the reduction and award accordingly. In fact, already two such cases at least have come before the arbitrator, in one of which the man was reduced by 3/- per week, and placed in an inferior post. The arbitrator made an award for a lump sum of £200, and the employee concerned will now be compelled to work 3/- per week less for the remainder of his railway career, unless, as is very unlikely in the circumstances, he gets promotion to a higher post.
Moreover, in all such cases the company can always avoid paying any compensation, by restoring the pre-amalgamation wages or salary of the employee concerned, and when his position becomes vacant, make the new occupant work at the lower rate. Needless to say, reductions in wages effected as a result of Trade Union wage negotiations with the company, do not entitle the employee to compensation.
In view of these facts, I think it is only fair that the amazing misrepresentations contained in your statement should be made clear, and in case you may not feel disposed to do this personally, I am sending copy of this letter to certain Deputies for their information.
May I say also that your allegation that a certain redundant employee is drawing £200 per annum more now than when he was working is absolutely inaccurate, as no such case exists at the moment, except those of senior officers dealt with by the Directors (some of whom are better off than when they were working); whose cases are not covered by your Bill. The case you may have in mind is clearly a hypothetical one, which in all probability is as mythical as the case already dealt with in the preceding paragraphs.
Yours faithfully,
(Signed) J. T. O'FARRELL,
Irish Secretary.
These cases were quoted by the Minister in order to mislead the Dáil and it is pointed out now in that letter that these arrangements only apply to people with whom special agreements were made by the directors themselves.
Comment on this
I think the arguments against the Bill have been over-stressed. Notwithstanding the adjustments the Minister is prepared to include in the Bill, the opposition does not seem to be in the least mitigated. Now, in so far as the Bill has for its object the repeal of the anomaly of a man who at the time of amalgamation had £500 per year, and, as the result of arbitration afterwards, found himself in possession of £700 a year, I think the Bill is absolutely justifiable.
Comment on this
The Minister says that it is possible under the existing Act for a man who loses one shilling per week to be compensated to the extent of thirty shillings a week.
Comment on this
So far as the Bill has for its object the repeal of that anomaly also, I think it is justifiable.
Comment on this
It can happen, and anybody who reads the Schedule will easily see how it can happen.
Comment on this
I am quite anxious to see fair play done to the railway employees. They constitute a considerable proportion of my constituents, and I believe I had their support in my election. At the same time, I am not going to advocate anything which I believe to be iniquitous.
Comment on this
A great deal of fault has been found with this measure because of its retrospective character. There may be something in that. At the same time, if it is retrospective for the purpose of remedying the abuses I have just mentioned, I say that the retrospective section of the Bill is justifiable likewise. This is not the first time we have had retrospective legislation in the Dáil.
Comment on this
Before my time, there was an Act passed here, known as the Local Government Act, 1923. That Act was retrospective in so far as it affected certain officials. It repealed Section 8 of the Local Government Act, 1919, with the result that where men had been awarded pensions of £200 per year, which was only two-thirds of their existing salary, these awards were reduced by £100.
Comment on this
I do not, but I am surprised that that Act did not raise a storm at the time, as the present measure has done, because I look on that Act as far more unjust than the retrospective clause of the Bill now before us. I think the Minister is quite ready to meet every legitimate objection that has been put forward against this Bill, but we must remember the position of the railways. We must remember the widow and orphans who had the modest earnings of the late bread-winner invested in railway shares, and who are now without dividends. I think these people are also entitled to consideration. The State has interfered with those people, possibly for the national good, but at the same time it has inflicted a grievous injury on them. In this matter, instead of doing what is popular, we should be rigidly just.
Comment on this
The Minister, in his statement, promised several amendments to the Bill as introduced, and he has also practically guaranteed to the House that Section 6 will not come into operation. Most of the complaints which I, at least, have received from the railway people in County Wexford and elsewhere, stigmatised Section 6 as the chief objection to the Bill.
Comment on this
They did. That was the chief objection in every letter I received, and now that the Minister has promised and practically guaranteed that the section will be withdrawn or deleted from the Bill in Committee, I believe there is a different aspect put on the Bill entirely. Deputy Corish remarked that anyone who voted for the Second Reading voted for the principle of the Bill.
Comment on this
When I came into the House yesterday I firmly made up my mind to vote against the Bill as it stood, but to-day I have altered my mind and that is really due to the statement of the Minister. The Bill is not the same as introduced to the House. Considering the amendments that are to be brought in by the Minister and that the retrospective section is to be taken out, I have made up my mind that I will vote for the Second Reading. In doing so I do not think that I am doing an injustice.
Comment on this
I wish to register a protest against this Bill. The Minister, in speaking on the Bill yesterday, gave as one excuse the difference existing between railway officials and civil servants as regards pensions. He said that the civil servant is only entitled to a maximum pension based upon one-sixtieth of his income for each year of service, while the railway official is entitled to one-sixtieth as the minimum. He did not explain to the House that the civil servant accepted his pension while the railway official had to accept dismissal. He failed to tell the House that the civil servant was enjoying luxuries, and a good salary, at the time that the men, whom an Irish Government are attempting to rob now, were fighting for Irish liberty and refusing to carry munitions to kill our fellowmen. These men sacrificed in many instances their liberty, while civil servants were enjoying their comfortable salaries. These men had to face dismissal because of their activities and in return for that, as I mentioned yesterday, the Minister is attempting to legalise robbery, by preventing the men who paid into the superannuation fund from getting the benefits of the contributions to which they would be entitled. Probably he is encouraged in that by his partial success on the Shannon scheme. If I know the railway men aright, he will find that he will not be as successful in attempting to lower the standard of the railway workers of the Saorstát as he has been with the unfortunate unorganised men on the Shannon scheme.
We have heard about great losses on the railways. One would imagine that they were attributable to the workers, but we did not hear, even from the shareholders in this House, any reference to the mismanagement of the railways or about the want of proper facilities in many areas. I can give an instance. On the Sunday after Christmas, when many people in business in the city wanted to get back to business for the following day, there was no train from Wexford to Dublin. People who had to get into business by Monday morning had to take motors. On the following Sunday, when no one was travelling, there was an excursion for the first Sunday of the month. Probably the directors thought that they might have to pay a few men a few pounds extra if they gave a train on the Sunday after Christmas. To my own personal knowledge they lost hundreds of pounds owing to the fact that they had no trains to convey people to their different places of business on that Sunday. You have the shareholders, not saying one word in condemnation of the directors. Has it not come to the knowledge of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that thousands of pounds have been spent on the repairs of carriages, and that some of these carriages were put on the scrap heap at Inchicore? When some of the members had drawn the Minister's attention to the matter, the carriages were sent, I think, to Naas, in Deputy Wolfe's constituency. When some of the members interested found that the carriages would cost £2,000 for repairs, after their removal from the scrap heap down to Naas, they were transferred back again. I hear that the directors and some of the shareholders are inquiring what has become of them.
Comment on this
You have dog boxes there for the people. Deputy Gorey says that you have too many employees on the railways. He must be one of the privileged Deputies when he finds too many porters and too many clerks in the various stations he is privileged to go into. The fact that he is leader of the Farmers' Union probably accounts for that, but it is not my experience. We find many stationmasters doing the work of porters and doing the work of clerks, where they are in charge of goods stores, and although they are not paid for work on Sunday they are obliged very often to work on Sunday in order to get through the work that they should finish during the week. They are unable to cope with the work in numerous country districts. Deputy Gorey knows that even in the case of farmers who send milk to the stations, their men have to assist the porters to carry the milk to the carriages, owing to the fact that enough porters are not employed at the stations.
Comment on this
Two. I appeal to the Minister to withdraw this Bill. I can assure him that as far as the railwaymen in my constituency are concerned, they are not going to submit under any guise to being deprived of any of the rights that they are entitled to. I have changed the opinion I always held of Deputy Good after his speech last night, because he said nothing good in favour of the Bill at all. And seeing that Deputy Good has been very good on this occasion and opposed the Bill, I ask the Minister to accept his opinion of the Bill and withdraw it.
Comment on this
The debate has developed into comment on the management of the railways, comment which is quite out of order.
Comment on this
I do not intend to follow my colleague, Deputy Everett, into the question of the management of the railways, but I want to point out the position which has been somewhat clouded by the speeches made here. Remember there were three or four railways in this country, and by the arbitrary act of this Government they were forced into amalgamation.
Comment on this
Well, twenty-eight if you like. These railway companies were forced into amalgamation, and though they had not agreed to it, they were compelled by the law to accept amalgamation. In the working out of that amalgamation several anomalies have arisen, and surely it is the duty of the Government to rectify whatever wrongs they have done the railways by this amalgamation. Any reasonable Deputy in the Dáil will agree to that. We agree that whatever rights the railway officials have, they should have the equities, but they should not get more than their rights. I contend that in the cases made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce there are men getting more than their rights, and we will not stand for that.
Comment on this
It is the rectification of a wrong, and it is the duty of the Government to rectify that which is wrong.
Comment on this
We are much interested in the railways from the point of view of our own business, but we do not allow any interest of ours to clash with our sense of justice in a matter of this kind. We are quite satisfied that whatever rights the railway officials had, those rights should be secured to them, and that they should keep them; but we could not force the amalgamated company into a position where the right of dismissal of an official is refused on any ground whatsoever. We could not refuse them the rights they had before amalgamation, and we are not going to force them to pay £900 a year on retirement to an official who earned only £700 per year while at work. In the rectification of these wrongs we agree that the principle of retrospective legislation which is introduced into this Bill is wrong and we will not support it. We have already agreed that it is wrong in principle, and ought not be embodied in the Bill.
With regard to Deputy Everett's references to the national work of these men, I have to say that that was also dealt with last night. This is a business transaction and it ought to be settled on business lines. It is not right that railway stockholders should pay for national services. National services, if they are to be paid for, should be paid for by the State and I do not think that that argument has anything to do with this Bill. We will support the Bill subject to the promise given by the Minister.
Comment on this
Apparently it is to be recognised now that the ordinary charges which have been so current in people's mouths lately with regard to autocracy were never meant. I now find myself criticised not for having yielded to the representations made to me but for having refused to yield to the type of representations against which Deputy Cooper protested yesterday—the hectic flourishes of certain Senators in the newspapers, the waste of money in the duplication of telegrams to Deputies to try to sway their judgment in certain things, and the writing of letters which amount to nothing more or less than a statement that the voting power of certain folk is going to be used if this Bill is not withdrawn. I am glad that the Dáil has the courage to stand up to that sort of thing. I do not believe that outside the Labour Benches there is any lack of appreciation of what the suggested amendment that I have spoken of really amounts to. A certain number of details have been spoken of. Deputy Davin criticised this as being a second amending Bill to the Railways Act of 1924. He apparently thought that the fact that any amending legislation to the Act of 1924 was required was in itself bad. It must be within the memory of the Deputies that the first amending legislation with regard to the Railways Act of 1924 had Deputy Davin's approval.
Comment on this
Even though it was amending legislation, it had his approval, and in this he stood apart from the rest of his Party.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I want to say that I was careful enough to point out during the progress of the Railways Bill that I supported the very thing the Minister had to admit was justified by bringing in an amending Bill.
Comment on this
The only point is that Deputy Davin would support this amending legislation if he finds it to be what was asked for by him at the time that the 1924 Act was going through.
Comment on this
I justified and do justify, and will again justify, if necessary, my support of that particular amending Bill on the ground that I pointed out, an anomaly that apparently existed at the time that the Bill was going through the House, and the Minister refused to accept or listen to that point of view when it was put forward by me and other Deputies.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin supported that piece of amending legislation because it was in line with his own thoughts when the Bill was going through. I want to take this whole legislation on that basis. If it be proved that there is any injustice being done to men by reason of this Act—and that that injustice was something that was not in the minds of the Oireachtas when that Act of 1924 was going through—then I will let it be argued against me that the purpose of the Bill has been defeated.
However, I will get to that when I come to the two or three main points, and find out if certain people now stand for what we have now discovered to be in the 1924 Act. Can they reconcile with their thoughts what was their intention when the 1924 Act was going through? I have Deputy Davin's support for this amending legislation, if he discovers that the amending legislation in principle is favourable to Deputy Davin's views.
Comment on this
That is the usual debating society argument that we know the Minister is so accustomed to.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin is sent here because of his responsibilities to his constituents, and he is prepared to stand by his constituents. Does he now class himself as unworthy of his constituents' confidence in that respect?
Comment on this
If the Minister wishes to know the opinion my constituents hold of me, let him resign his seat and I will resign mine.
Comment on this
I am not going to put the Deputy to the point of dismissal prior to what he is really coming to. I just want him to think what his statement amounts to—the debating society argument. This is a democratic assembly intended to be a place where it is expected that we can argue things out. If the Deputy is so poor in argument that when a case is proved his only answer is that it is only debating society tactics, then I say he is not worthy to represent his constituents.
Comment on this
I might be able to impress that view down the country before long.
Comment on this
I challenged the Minister to come to Leix and Offaly during the election campaign, and he did not come.
Comment on this
There has been a tendency in the debate on this Bill not to allow the people who are in favour of the Bill to speak at all. I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce is entitled to make his speech——
Comment on this
I am stating my view that the Minister for Industry and Commerce must be allowed to make his speech, and it is my duty to so state my view. It is not the duty of Deputy Byrne to give me any advice.
Comment on this
I will try to answer them. I will give the Minister the same challenge as Deputy Davin.
Comment on this
We will leave it at that. Deputy Davin said that the unions had been forced to fight even on unsound cases and had to incur certain expenditure. I wonder would the Deputy like to have a comparison between the action of the unions here and in England—how far cases had been pressed in England to try and get a man both superannuation and compensation, or whether it is thought possible that such a case could be pressed in England; whether such a case as that would be considered one of the unsound cases which the railway company forced the unions to fight in order to incur expenditure. With regard to the question of costs, which a number of Deputies referred to, and as to which Deputy Norton said that in the amending Bill I should have amended defects in other regards, suppose we have that question looked into. It can be easily done, if some Deputy cares to move an amendment. But care must be taken that the amendment cuts both ways and that the union funds are made liable for costs given against a man where the union is fighting that man's case, and to find out whether the union will accept that. If they do there may be a compromise; there may be an accommodation on that point also. If the railway company are to be mulcted in costs when cases are given against them, so also should the union funds be made liable and the man made to give security for costs.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say that the private shareholders of the company will have to be made liable also for the risk that might be run?
Comment on this
If it is not considered that the railway funds are sufficient to meet the costs of any actions against them, if that can be proved to the arbitrator, I am sure the arbitrator will look about to find how the costs will be secured.
Comment on this
Will the principle apply that the limited liability of the company will be abolished and that the ultimate liability will fall on the shareholders individually?
Comment on this
When that point is raised in an amendment I will meet it.
Comment on this
The Minister may take it from me that the union funds are as safe as the funds of the party with which the Minister is associated.
Comment on this
Let me get some definition as to what is an interruption. We have had an excellent example of a proper interruption when Deputy Johnson asked the Minister if he agreed to something when the Minister was making a proposal. Then Deputy Davin said something which clearly would lead to trouble. There is no connection between the funds of the Minister's party and trade union funds.
Comment on this
There is no such question. I have always held that there must be a certain amount of interruptions, but there is a kind of interruption that is of no use. I put it to Deputies in all calmness that that kind of interruption will not get us any further.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin alluded to a particular case in continuing his argument—at least it was in the same context; I do not know whether we are to take it as continuing his argument or not about unsound cases. He made a point about a railway official who recently had to litigate in order to get his payment from the superannuation fund when he had previously got compensation awarded to him. Deputy Davin raised that case in this House, and talked about the litigation having ended in favour of that gentleman. Then Senator O'Farrell writes a letter as Secretary of the Railway Clerks' Association, and says:—
"May I say also that your allegation that a certain redundant employee is drawing £200 per annum more now than when he was working, is absolutely inaccurate, as no such case exists at the moment, except those of senior officers dealt with by the directors (some of whom are better off than when they were working), whose cases are not covered by your Bill. The case you may have in mind is clearly a hypothetical one, which in all probability is as mythical as the case already dealt with in the preceding paragraphs."
Deputy Davin had previously outlined a case for Senator O'Farrell, but apparently Senator O'Farrell turned his deaf ear to it. The gentleman did get compensation, and he litigated about his award from the superannuation fund and he got that. The result is that he is getting more than he was getting when in full harness.
Comment on this
Will the Minister quote the figures and compare them with the figures given yesterday?
Comment on this
I talked of three cases yesterday. I have two cases here. This is the case of Patrick Kearney: salary on date of retirement, £495; awarded under the Third Schedule, £330; and entitled under the fund which he has litigated about, either to a lump sum payment of £1,420 or a pension of £222 3s. 10d., plus a cash bonus of £113. Let us assume it is the latter. Then it is £552, plus a cash bonus of £113, while he was working at a salary of £495.
Comment on this
The same as he would have got from the Provident Clerks' Association if he had paid a premium of 2½ per cent. on his salary during his 52 years' service. He got what he was entitled to according to the rules of the Superannuation Fund Association.
Comment on this
When I quoted the case I said distinctly that I was not making a case that all this was coming from compensation. I have been challenged by a person who is Irish Secretary to the Railway Clerks' Association that no case of the sort exists and Deputy Davin called attention in this House yesterday to the fact that this gentleman, Kearney, had to litigate about superannuation. The result of the two things is that he certainly gets more on retirement than he had when in full working order.
Comment on this
Is it not the fact that although he has got a judgment in the High Court before Mr. Justice Sullivan he has not yet actually been paid that amount? My information is that if this Bill goes through the company will appeal, if they have not already done so, to prevent him getting what he was entitled to by the rules of the Superannuation Fund Association of which he was a member for 52 years.
Comment on this
These are all hypotheses. Admit every one of them and the case is that under the Act as it stood that man would have got that amount of money. He may not in fact have proceeded to the point where he had established his case for more money in idleness than he had when in full working order. That was the only case I made and that is challenged by the letter.
Comment on this
Will the Minister read the case he made yesterday about a man receiving £200 more than he received when he was working?
Comment on this
The Minister made a case yesterday. He said there was a case where £200 per annum more was paid to a man in idleness than he had been receiving in pay. That was quoted here to-day. It was challenged by Senator O'Farrell. Now the Minister says that he can quote such a case as having existed. I questioned the Minister as to whether it was the case he quoted yesterday. Now he says £552 against £495 was the case in question. I do not know where we are.
Comment on this
I will let the Deputy know where we are if he will just let me go on. Senator O'Farrell challenges that there is any case of the sort, and I urge the point made by his colleague, Deputy Davin.
Comment on this
Is Kearney in receipt to-day of £200 more than he received when he retired from the service of the company as a redundant man?
Comment on this
I was arguing as to what would happen under the Bill and what I think should be prevented. Is Deputy Davin's case that this man has not yet got his hands on the money?
Comment on this
I admit that I am beaten on that. The second case is that of Blackham. His salary at the date of retirement was £728. The pension he was entitled to under the fund was £446 18s. 7d.; the award that he got under the Third Schedule to the Act of 1920 was £485 6s. 8d. The full salary was £728 and he was entitled in idleness to a sum of £932. That is a bit more than the £200. Now, does Deputy Johnson know where he is?
Comment on this
I only know the case that the Minister is alleged to have quoted yesterday, which is challenged here to-day.
Comment on this
The case that was challenged was the first case of Kearney which, I am sure, is fresh in the minds of Deputies. I know nothing about the second case. I only know something about the first case, and the Minister can probably wait until there are further challenges in regard to the other hypothetical cases.
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson is pleased to think that he has won a victory, because I said that one man was entitled to £200 a year more in idleness than he got when engaged at work. The only case of a man having his rights established for him by law is that of the second man, who is actually getting more than he was receiving when at full work, but not £200. I told the Deputy that there is the other case that I spoke of the case where a man is getting £200 more than he had when working.
Comment on this
Might I be allowed to put a question to the Minister? Senator O'Farrell, in his letter, states:
"May I say also that your allegation that a certain redundant employee is drawing £200 per annum more now than when he was working is absolutely inaccurate, as no such case exists at the moment except those of senior officers dealt with by the directors (some of whom are better off than when they were working), whose cases are not covered by your Bill."
Is that correct?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy insinuating that the cases of Blackham or Kearney are cases that were dealt with by the directors?
Comment on this
I am simply asking a question. The Minister has quoted from this letter, and there is a paragraph in the letter which purports to deal with the case of an employee receiving £200 more. I ask the Minister for the courtesy of saying whether or not the allegation in Senator O'Farrell's letter is correct.
Comment on this
I cannot understand it as being correct. I have put two cases, and I have said to Deputy Davin that if he makes the statement to me that Senator O'Farrell is riding off on that—that the man is not at the moment actually in receipt of this money—he is probably right, and I give the Deputy the palm of victory for that.
Comment on this
If you have agreed to withdraw the retrospective portion of the Bill, what is the use in arguing about it? You have surrendered yourself.
Comment on this
I was arguing with regard to the Bill and to the Third Schedule to the Act of 1924. I was pointing out the anomalous things that have happened under the Third Schedule to the Act, and I gave the case of a man who would get £200 more in idleness than when at work.
Comment on this
On this I think the Minister should be a little more detailed. As regards the case of Blackham, I know nothing about it, but I would like to know whether the Minister avers that his salary was £728 when he retired; that he received an award of £485 on account of salary and that he received, out of the superannuation fund, the sum of £446 per annum. I would like to know if that is the position.
Comment on this
Yes. Deputy Davin's point arises there again, and the answer is that he is entitled to receive that.
Comment on this
Could the Minister go further and tell us what age the man is, and how long he has been paying into that fund?
Comment on this
He is 73 years of age and he has been paying into the A Fund, which is insolvent.
Comment on this
Yes. The Deputy, I think, has mixed up the A and B Funds. The man was paying into what the Deputy classes as the B Fund which, in the Deputy's mind, is insolvent, but to anybody who knows anything about the ordinary lettering of these funds, it will be clear that it is the A Fund which is insolvent.
Comment on this
I do not mind what you say. That would mean that he was paying in since he was 20.
Comment on this
It was shown yesterday that there were many people in the House who did not mind what the Minister was saying about this Bill.
Comment on this
This case of Kearney's is one of the unsound cases, presumably, on which people will be forced to incur additional expenditure in order to get their rights. If people consider that they have these rights, then, of course, that is a correct statement. I put it that there were certain anomalies arising under the Bill, namely, with regard to Blackham's case and Kearney's case. For the future, cases such as these, with the retrospective section knocked out, cannot be touched, but we should surely see that no such anomalies are going to arise again.
Comment on this
If you had a conference you would have got what you wanted, but you have lost a lot by not having it.
Comment on this
I had agreed to a number of things about noon yesterday, and there was no case made to me at that time for the complete withdrawal of the retrospective clause. What was put to me was this: that there may be a rehearing of cases where this absurd double payment was being made. That was the case made to me even by a Deputy in the House. We have gone further than that now apparently, so that you have to be either in the position here of an autocrat standing out against everything, or else if you give in to something, then you are told that is butchering. That was the politest description used yesterday. Deputy Davin spoke of directors' fees as if I had anything to do with them.
Comment on this
The Deputy referred to managers, directors and people of that sort. I have nothing to do with them. I do not own the railway company and I have not a share in it. It is the business of the proprietors to see that the funds of the railway are being properly administered. If I had brought in legislation to deal with managers, assistant managers and so on, and if these people were to get large sums, then of course the Deputy would be in order in criticising me, but I have nothing whatever to do with them.
Comment on this
It is quite a good debating point to load the case on one side. It is certainly a thing that must weigh in the minds of railwaymen who have been given small pensions in comparison to the pensions given to those at the other end of the scale. Is it the Deputy's suggestion that we should take that in hands and rectify it? I think that is a matter for the shareholders and I leave it at that. The Deputy's argument was: Is the railway company in such a desperate position? If the railway company was rolling in wealth and if it had not the slightest bit of embarrassment with regard to moneys I hold that some of the things that have been effected under the Third Schedule to the Act of 1924 are wrong and that in spite of this great wealth on the part of the railway company these things should now be rectified. The position of the railway company has nothing whatever to do with this Bill. It has been said that this Bill has been introduced on behalf of railway directors and railway managers. All these allegations may be made, but what I ask the House to consider is the position of the railway user. Do we want to have an efficient, economical railway system in a few years time and are we to prevent steps being taken which would lead to the railway company becoming economic for the railway user?
Comment on this
Will the Minister inform the House whether he intends, under the Bill, to deal with one individual who received as a retiring pension over four-fifths of his salary without having paid anything whatever into a pension fund, and with another case where an official by agreement, which this Bill does not interfere with, received over three-fourths of his salary as a retiring allowance, plus £2,500? How does the Minister propose to deal with these cases?
Comment on this
I do not propose to deal with them. I said they seemed to me to be matters for the railway shareholders to deal with.
Comment on this
But are not these charges a burden on the railway and incidentally on the travelling public?
Comment on this
If they are charged against the revenue account and come into consideration when rates are being fixed so as to bring down the standard revenue under the head of economic management, then that can be queried. There is provision for that. The object of Section 4, the Deputy stated, was to offer a maximum of one-sixtieth, and the object of the company was to offer one-eightieth.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy's presumption is based on, but I put it this way, that we are bringing in what corresponds to the Civil Service scale. I ask the House to consider whether railway employees are entitled to more than the Civil Service retiring allowance, and I have in negotiations that have gone on, and gone even further than anything that has been referred to in the Dáil, with regard to that particular section, a matter that would be for the benefit of the people who are concerned under it. It is hopeful at any rate to find Deputy Davin declaring himself against any absurd claim that the number of railway employees should be stereotyped. Deputy Norton seemed to me to get close to that idea, and Deputy Johnson did get to that idea.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister to quote any occasion in his recollection, or that of his officials, where any such demand was made by the railwaymen or their accredited representatives.
Comment on this
I am saying now I am glad that the Deputy is against what he described as the absurd claim that the number of railway employees should be stereotyped.
Comment on this
I never said it. What I did say was that under the old schedule as it stood that more or less the arbitrator was coerced into the position that he had to count the number of railway employees in the employment of the railway company at the date of amalgamation, and thereafter, unless two things were proved, physical incapacity or misconduct, that number was stereotyped. I said if that was the case, as I believed it to be the case, that that should be removed, and that is being removed by this Bill, and is one of the things in the Bill.
Comment on this
We will see how much more. Deputy Johnson, I say, more or less broached this point, that the number should be stereotyped, for that was his argument. I admit he said he lost his cue. I wish he had kept it, for I was interested here following out the new argument. As far as I got it, it was this, that the amending Bill set out that where the redundancy was due to economic causes there should be no compensation. Then the Deputy went on to give an example of what might be considered redundancy due to economic causes, and, by a process which I was not able to follow completely, he drifted into this: that there had been a reduction of rates, and that the reduction had been a cause of redundancy. I suggest that there is a middle term missing. You have to argue that the reduction of rates caused a reduction of traffic, and that the reduction of traffic caused a redundancy. If it is to be argued what the scale should be——
Comment on this
A loss of revenue does not imply redundancy. It might imply an attempt on the part of the railway company to make it redundant, but redundancy has to be proved before an arbitrator, so that we have got it that a reduction of rates means a reduction not of traffic but of receipts or revenue, and, therefore, a reduction in revenue means redundancy. The thing is absurd. The Deputy said he had lost his cue, and I do not know whether I have taken him up right, and I may have lost it also. He said implicit in the Bill was the right of compensation on anything that might accrue out of redundancy due to reduction of rates. Let the House consider what the positive of that is, that you should allow compensation for anything that might accrue, even redundancy caused by reduced rates of the railway companies. That is the positive side of what Deputy Johnson would like to see put forward in an amending Bill.
Comment on this
I think the Minister would like to be fair—a reduction of rates compulsorily against the will of the railway company brought about by the operations of this compulsory Act.
Comment on this
Leading to redundancy. How the loss of revenue is to lead to redundancy I cannot see. Assuming that a dishonest railway company attempted to prove that because they have less money coming in they must get rid of a number of men, they cannot get rid of a number of men because there is less revenue. They must prove redundancy. But the fact that they have reduced rates would mean that they would get more traffic. If the traffic is not there, and the traffic receipts show definitely a case for dismissal, that case would be good for any of the component parts of the amalgamated company prior to amalgamation. There was no attempt to give to the employees as against the amalgamated company any rights they had not prior to the company's amalgamation.
Deputy Johnson has been well briefed, and knew his case in this Bill up to a point, but he was apparently arguing against the Civil Service rate as to the one-sixtieth maximum. Yes, but the Civil Service is more or less permanent employment, and the people in it are not thrown out of it hurriedly. What about compensation for disturbance? That point is made as if it were a serious point. Does the Deputy believe now that there is any account taken of compensation for disturbance?
Does he know that is in the Schedule, and is not being amended by the present legislation, and that an added number of years for abolition are given, and these are being continued? So far as he made any case against an introduction of the Civil Service rate that point is groundless.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say that the Civil Service rate is fixed as a maximum, that is, that there is an option on anything within the Civil Service rate?
Comment on this
I cannot understand the Deputy's point. If it is a point that seems to the Deputy to be material I will try to answer it.
Comment on this
I think it is material. As I understand, there is a definite scale fixed in respect of the Civil Service. It is neither a maximum nor a minimum, but a fixed standard. In the proposal of the Bill before us a Civil Service rate is named, but that is to be a maximum and not a fixed standard.
Comment on this
This, as I understand it, is in line with the Civil Service regulation in so far as it deals with the Civil Service rate—so far as it deals with a matter that would be dealt with by Civil Service regulations.
Comment on this
If I understand aright, there is a definite scale fixed in respect of the Civil Service which is neither a maximum nor a minimum.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say if the railway company would be obliged to pay one-sixtieth and not one-eightieth?
Comment on this
Then why compare with the Civil Service where the rate is fixed at one-sixtieth?
Comment on this
One-sixtieth of the salary and emoluments for each year's service. There is a lump sum in addition. There is a maximum of one-sixtieth. Would the Minister insist that the railway company should pay one-sixtieth and not less?
Comment on this
In the case where Civil Service regulations would apply. I ask the question: do the Civil Service regulations deal with any cases except those of civil servants who leave the Civil Service? Is there any compensation for civil servants otherwise?
Comment on this
If a civil servant resigns voluntarily he gets one-sixtieth.
Comment on this
If he is discharged or if his office is abolished he also gets one-sixtieth.
Comment on this
Yes, he may. I will put it this way to the Deputy. Arising out of the operations of the amalgamation scheme there may be either of two cases. A servant may be dismissed. His office may be abolished. Various things may happen, with the result that he is out of work and out of the service of the railways company. That is all the Civil Service regulations cover. A second case may arise in the matter of the railway that a railway servant may be kept on in the employment of the railways company but be given duties which he considers not analagous to the duties he previously had. He is not discharged. He is retained in the service of the company, but at a lesser rate. He may suffer some loss in his emoluments or pecuniary loss. That has to be met. Are you going to meet all that by the one-sixtieth rate rule, not the one-sixtieth maximum rate rule? I say the one-sixtieth rate rule is proper for people who leave the service, who are absolutely as civil servants are, but not proper for railway employees who are kept on but who suffer some pecuniary loss. I do not know if I have made that clear and whether that is an answer to Deputy Johnson, but the Deputy stated that civil servants were in permanent employment and that there was no necessity in their case to consider the question of compensation for disturbance. There is a question of compensating for disturbance in the Third Schedule to the Railways Act of 1924, and that is continued in the amending legislation.
Deputy Johnson said further on this matter of superannuation that superannuation was one of the points that was always pointed to when people were pushing railway service. They said: "Look at the extraordinarily good condition you are in with your superannuation." That is a point I think the Deputy made, and it certainly was one of the things a man had before him when entering the railway service, and consequently to interfere with whatever superannuation is coming to him would be a grave injustice. I take it with regard to what the Deputy said that superannuation is one of the things looked to, and when a man pays into a superannuation fund he has a right to look to that certainly, but as there is no such thing of the same type with regard to the civil service, surely the rate for compensation and for disturbance ought to be less in the case of the railway employee than in the case of the civil servant. We are taking the exact terms. We are taking the abolition years for disturbance and doing what Deputy Johnson asked us to do in an amendment to another Bill. We are giving exactly that right. The Deputy went on to refer to those superannuation funds as the men's funds of which they were being robbed. The men have paid into the funds to the extent of 50 per cent. The railway company has paid in to the extent of 50 per cent. Why not say the railway company's funds and that we are robbing the railway company, if there is anybody to be robbed? That is the case I made in opening.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister on this point when the railway company gave away the money they gave it away deliberately and finally and not with any reservation that it was to be taken back?
Comment on this
Yes, and the trouble is, if Deputy Hewat could only understand it, that there is nothing to take back, that the fund is exhausted and that people who retired have got more than actuarially they are entitled to get, and that there is no money to take back.
Comment on this
That is an argument for penalising the man who is unfortunate enough to be discharged. What about private hardship in that case?
Comment on this
If you are taking away from a man something he has built up you are robbing him of some of his own contributions.
Comment on this
Yes, because there is nothing to give. His colleagues, who retired earlier, got more than they were entitled, on any actuarial basis, to get. Deputy Good referred to what I called the B fund, which is more or less solvent, but with regard to the A fund and the railway clearing house fund, the pool from which benefits might be drawn is exhausted.
Comment on this
As a matter of information, who is responsible for the state those funds are in to-day?
Comment on this
The people responsible are mainly the employees. The question was, can you build up a fund? What sort of insurance fund can you build up by a man paying in 2½ per cent. of his wages even with the railway contribution? What fund can be built up on 5 per cent.? Those funds are matters of agreement. I am being pressed, at the moment, to get the railway company to act up to their commitments under the 1924 Act in another respect and bring forward for discussion on the main superannuation fund——
Comment on this
I may have led the Deputy into that statement—paying out on what was agreed upon but what turns out to be in excess. As the thing developed, the original fund was declared afterwards to be insolvent, and the men were transferred to the railway clearing house fund. That is insolvent now, and the company more or less guaranteed it, but the whole thing depends on the solvency of the railway company. You speak of people's old rights, but the old rights have been dissipated. There is no money except it comes out of the railway company's ordinary resources.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say if the railway companies were represented on the management of this fund?
Comment on this
No. I beg pardon. I was asked to say who were responsible for having the contribution so small. I said I presumed it was the employees.
Comment on this
Then I withdraw any allegations that the employees were concerned in the distribution of those funds. I do not know who were. I presume there was a board of management and that they carried out the scheme on an agreed basis. The net result is that two of the funds are bankrupt, and so far as any payments are concerned they are to be made from the general resources of the company.