RAILWAYS (EXISTING OFFICERS AND SERVANTS) BILL, 1926—SECOND STAGE (RESUMED).
Contributions 174–352 of 352. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1926 ›
I think we suggested it should be one-sixtieth and one-eightieth, and apparently this one-eightieth has been misinterpreted. May I suggest to the Minister why not leave everything one-sixtieth? Let us put ourselves into a practical position about the one-sixtieth and the one-eightieth. Would it not be better for the railway company to pay a man, who would not be able to carry out his work, the full one-sixtieth on his being retired?
Comment on this
No; it is a Manx cat now. I think it is only giving rise to difficulty even with the Labour Party. If the Labour Party think there may be something behind the one-eightieth I suggest it would be better to get, say, one-sixtieth multiplied by the number of years of the man's employment, and when he gets too old he might be willing to take under one-sixtieth.
Comment on this
Deputy Beamish has the disadvantage of not having listened to the debate. That is the only explanation of such an extraordinary interruption. I hope that the Minister will not answer it. It would make it worse.
Comment on this
Deputy Hewat made a very slight contribution to this debate. Deputy Hewat is apparently going to die with the railways company in the last ditch. He died several times before when the Railways Bill was going through. He said: "The Minister should not have left us in the position in which we are now." That was after Deputy Hewat had made a speech in which he described himself for the benefit of the Dáil as having been the watch-dog of all the proceedings during the passing of the 1924 Act. This self-appointed watch-dog failed to discover this flaw, and Deputy Hewat, of everybody outside myself, probably bears the greatest responsibility because, being on the qui vive for everything that might harm the railways, everything that might be used as an argument against the unhappy interference by the Government in the affairs of the railways, he did not advert to the very obvious flaws that are now discovered.
Comment on this
The Minister must recognise that Deputy Hewat was overwhelmed by the combined opposition he met with on the Bill. What he could say was only what he could interject.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton came close to this point of stereotyping the railway employees in the place they are now. He made some point with regard to a motor lorry coming to a certain area and tapping the traffic, when the company would decide that because traffic had diminished there was reason for the dismissal of men, and Deputy Norton pleaded that such cases should be compensated. Take the Great Northern Railway Company at the moment. It is finding a considerable amount of its traffic tapped by motors and men have been and are being dismissed in the ordinary way without compensation. Nobody stood up in this House to advocate the giving against the amalgamated company any right to the employee which the employee previously had not against the unamalgamated companies.
Comment on this
But the arbitrator has no power to decide whether a dismissal is due to amalgamation or to uneconomic causes. He is told that it is due solely to amalgamation.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that for years—as far back as one can bring one's memory—there have been thousands of men in the employment of the different railway companies who were casual and who were always subject to dismissal or removal with the ups and downs of traffic?
Comment on this
Deputy Norton's claim is that it must be due solely to amalgamation. I do not know whether the Deputy is now simply going on the Bill as it stands. If that is what he argues I give in to him.
Comment on this
No, but the amendment which you suggested on the first day.
Comment on this
Does the amendment which I suggested on the first day mean a change?
Comment on this
I want to make provision where dismissal may be due both to economic causes and amalgamation.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not realise that what I said on moving the Second Reading of the Bill comes to that position?
Comment on this
And I said that in so far as it was not in the Bill I thought the omission of the words "or contributed to" met that point. Does the Deputy now want the words "and solely" left out?
Comment on this
I told the Minister that I wanted to make provision for a man dismissed partly on account of amalgamation and partly because of economic causes.
Comment on this
I want to put it to the Deputy that if a man's services have become unnecessary in consequence of the amalgamation of the companies he should be compensated, but if they are caused by the other things he should not be. If there is any point in dispute between us it can be dealt with in an amendment. Deputy Norton was the only person who took up this point of the seven years' limitation in the Bill. The seven years is a new point in this, and it had better be adverted to. In the case of the Railway Clearing House system, under the 1924 Act there is a five years' limit within which the case must fall, and I put it to the House that if amalgamation is really going to be the cause of a person becoming redundant that will have to show itself within a seven years' period from date. I think it is a sound conclusion that if redundancy is caused by amalgamation, the amalgamation will have had the effect of causing the redundancy within seven years. If that does not seem to be the case, it is a detail that we can discuss in Committee, but I stand on the seven years' period. I think it is sound and wise to have some period within which the incidence of these claims must terminate.
Several Deputies, including Deputy Baxter, have referred to the railwaymen who gave service in troubled times. Nobody has denied that at all, but I do not think anybody here means to put up the case that they should be compensated by the railways company. If there should be compensation it is a case to be met by the State, and in connection with the case pleaded by Deputy Johnson there is recognition of the service done by railwaymen, as by a great many others in the community, but that will not be dealt with sectionally in Bills dealing with economic matters. If there is anything to be done in regard to that it should be done by other people, but I do not think that plea has ever been advanced. I doubt if the men want it advanced.
A number of people have made the complaint that this should have been a bargain as between the men and the management or—another way of putting it—that this has been introduced at the request of the management, and that it is on behalf of the shareholders and the dividend-earning class. As far as dividends are concerned, they do not enter into the scope of this Bill at all. The dividends are fixed.
There is a clause allowing for the fixation of standard revenue and for rates to bring that in, and no matter what has to be paid, that clause still remains. To bring the shareholders and the dividends into this is merely trying to cloud a clear issue. Neither is this Bill in the interests of the railway management. What does it matter to the railway management except that they are the proper guardians of the property for the proprietors, and what does it matter to me, except that I am looking at this from the standpoint of the railway users? If people here want to burden the company with indefensible payments, and if those payments would possibly prevent the bringing about of an economic situation in the railways——
Comment on this
Does not this question of litigation that has been referred to point to a very unfortunate atmosphere? My interruption, as far as I referred to it, was that the matter was one that ought to have been considered before it became embodied in the Bill at all.
Comment on this
On the question of agreement, there was a schedule in the 1924 Act which could have operated smoothly, and, if attempts had not been made to drive all sorts of coaches through certain flaws that were discovered in it, it probably would have worked smoothly. But a situation developed which had to be taken in hand. Probably Deputy Hewat has views on that matter which are, no doubt, sound. Whatever I say here is not for the benefit of shareholders or for the benefit of any management; it is for the benefit of railway users. I simply make that point. Deputy Good holds that the principle with regard to the superannuation fund is just the same as in connection with an insurance fund. I am afraid I cannot consider it so. If these men had been in an insurance fund there would be no question at issue at all. The fact is that they are in a fund that was built up by contributions. There is a further fact, and that is that two of the funds are insolvent, and that makes the position peculiarly difficult.
Comment on this
I spoke of a solvent fund. If the fund is insolvent I hold that the company could not be held liable any more than an insurance company in the same position could be held liable. But where the fund is solvent it ought to pay.
Comment on this
I think I have admitted that. As far as the B Fund is concerned there will have to be one point of view.
Comment on this
I hope the Bill will be amended accordingly, and if it is I will withdraw my opposition.
Comment on this
The Minister has based most of his case on cases insured under Clause B. The amount granted is based on the very contribution to this fund which the Minister now says a man is entitled to get.
Comment on this
I have said he is entitled to get his contributions, but I have doubts as to how far he is entitled to get the whole thing. The big majority of railway servants are outside superannuation altogether.
Comment on this
Is not the Minister attempting to interfere with the rights of Irish railway officials, members of a superannuation fund which is protected by a British statute?
Comment on this
What am I interfering with? Can the Deputy read ordinary English as printed? Can the Deputy say whether there is any question of interference with the superannuation fund in the Bill?
Comment on this
If the Bill passes you will be attempting to prevent certain men from getting what they are entitled to from the railway superannuation fund which is protected by a British statute.
Comment on this
Where does that come about under the Bill? Where do I prevent anybody?
Comment on this
What I am interfering with, if anything, is compensation, not superannuation. I am saying that compensation is to be assessed, taking into consideration superannuation. As regards interfering with superannuation, or robbing the superannuation fund, there is not a word about it.
Comment on this
I desire to make the point that the Bill the Minister is now dealing with has a new aspect, and if we are not allowed to get information in this way we must ask for another opportunity of expressing our views.
Comment on this
Deputies will be given an opportunity for putting their questions when the Minister has concluded.
Comment on this
I am quite willing to reply to any points that may be raised. Sub-section (d) does not interfere with superannuation. It avoids the point of interfering with the superannuation fund. It points out that the superannuation fund is to be taken into account when fixing the nature and amount of compensation. From statements made here and reported, or misreported, in the Press, it would seem as if some fund was being taken hold of.
Comment on this
The effect of this sub-section is that except the amount of the award under the superannuation scheme is in excess of the amount of the compensation under sub-section (d), the employee gets nothing out of the superannuation fund.
Comment on this
No; it is quite the opposite. If there was a case made to me that a person was to get compensation under the Third Schedule of the 1924 Act, and that compensation was less than the amount of superannuation, then you would have clearly proved that there was interference with the superannuation fund; but that cannot happen.
Comment on this
Has the Minister heard of the case of Metcalfe that was tried before the arbitrator?
Comment on this
I will accept the details if the Deputy gives them to me.
Comment on this
May I return to the early party of my statement? The Secretary to the Railway Clerks' Association is a gentleman who knows his business so well that he wrote this:—
I feel compelled in the interests of truth to characterise this (referring to certain statements) as a very grave misrepresentation of fact, and one calculated to seriously mislead the Dáil. In such a case what would happen would be this:
We are not arguing now about what is in the mind of a certain Senator under the stress of amending legislation as to what ought to happen, but what could happen. The writer then goes on to instance the case of the railway servant. I would ask Deputies to look at paragraph 5 of the Third Schedule of the Railways Act, 1924:
Every existing officer or servant whose office or situation is so abolished, or who so relinquishes his office or situation, or whose services are dispensed with on the ground that they are not required for any other reason, not being on account of any misconduct or incapacity, or whose remuneration or emoluments are reduced on the ground that his duties have been diminished, or who otherwise suffers any direct pecuniary loss by reason of the amalgamation or absorption ... shall be entitled to be paid compensation by the amalgamated company....
Under Section 5 the case I speak of can happen; I never stated it had happened.
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell us what the case is? Did he not say the officer or servant whose remuneration is reduced by one shilling per week?
Comment on this
The paragraph the Minister has read states:
Every existing officer or servant whose office or situation is so abolished or ... whose services are dispensed with...
Comment on this
The paragraph continues:
... on the ground that they are not required or for any other reason not being on account of any misconduct or incapacity, or whose remuneration or emoluments are reduced on the ground that his duties have been diminished ....
Comment on this
The previous sub-section says:—
If any existing officer or servant so transferred is, without his consent, in any such worse position ... he shall be entitled to be paid by the amalgamated company such lump sum ....
His appeal is to the arbitrator, and it is left to the company to say whether he shall be diminished in salary or not. They need not diminish him at all if they do not wish to do so.
Comment on this
I put to the Deputy Section 5 of Part II of the Second Schedule, which says:—
Every existing officer or servant whose office or situation is so abolished, or who so relinquishes his office or situation, or whose services are dispensed with on the ground that they are not required or for any other reason not being on account of any misconduct or incapacity, or whose remuneration or emoluments are reduced on the ground that his duties have been diminished, or who otherwise suffers any direct pecuniary loss by reason of the amalgamation or absorption (including any loss of prospective superannuation or other retiring or death allowances, and allowances to his widow or orphan children whether obtaining legally or by customary practice of the amalgamating or absorbed company), shall be entitled to be paid compensation by the amalgamated company, the amount of such compensation to be determined by the amalgamated company (subject to appeal as hereinafter provided) in accordance with the following rule, that is to say—
(a) the compensation shall be an annual allowance to be paid to the existing officer or servant during his life not exceeding in any case two-thirds of his remuneration and emoluments, and, subject to that limitation, to be calculated at the rate of one-sixtieth of his remuneration and emoluments for every completed year of his service with the amalgamated company.
So that under Section 5 of the Schedule he would get one-sixtieth for every year's service. He would get 30/- a week for life for the loss of one shilling and yet that is described by the Secretary to the Railway Clerks' Association as mythical and hypothetical.
Comment on this
Have not the company means at their disposal to fight cases of this kind and to come before the arbitrator?
Comment on this
I am seeking to amend the section in a certain way, and I am now pointing out what can happen under the section if left unamended.
Comment on this
I am pointing out what could happen under the unamended section. I am asking people not to allow that absurd thing to happen. I got from the Secretary of the Railway Clerks' Association a statement that it cannot happen, but I state that it can happen and he characterises my statement as a grave misrepresentation of facts calculated to seriously mislead the Dáil. Is it a grave misrepresentation of facts? Could it really happen?
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson says it could not happen. I wish the Deputy was arbitrator. We ought feel safer.
Comment on this
I do not think railway companies are such fools as to put themselves in such a position unless this is some particularly favoured person to whom they want to make a present of 30/- for life.
Comment on this
No matter what the railway companies may or may not do, they might be forced into this position. It is going to cost the Dáil nothing to obviate that absurd position. I am asking that an amendment should be made so that no such thing could happen.
Comment on this
Will the Minister prevent any other consequences from his amendment except the one he is now trying to remedy? Will he confine the remedy to the kind of case that he is speaking of?
Comment on this
No. Is there anything won on that admission by me? I have stated I think it would be an injustice to allow people to get a pension which must be calculated at a minimum of one-sixtieth, and I have got the House to agree with that. I will not confine it to the one case. I will confine it to the case on which Senator O'Farrell has sent this absurd letter.
Comment on this
Have the railway companies made representations to you about the one-sixtieth, or has it begun with yourself?
Comment on this
No; but even on Deputy Johnson's amendment to the Electricity Supply (Special Powers) Bill he showed his mind clear.
Comment on this
If I answered it negatively you would not believe me.
Comment on this
I never said that, but I want to get your answer on the records of the House. I want to know if the railway companies made representation on the question of the alteration of the figure for one-sixtieth to one-eightieth?
Comment on this
I never heard the figure of one-eightieth until it was raised here in the House to-day.
Comment on this
Deputy Wilson did not seem to be in the same antagonism towards retrospection as some people. I do not ask him whether he is or no as the matter is no longer before us. He led Deputy Johnson to a point in which they were seemingly in agreement. Deputy Johnson on an interjection seemed to say that individual cases not defined might be looked into, retrospectively. That was the position as put to me yesterday; that the cases of double payment might be reheard.
Comment on this
The Deputy made an interjection to Deputy Wilson like that.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy say that he did not say anything about individual cases?
Comment on this
I cannot remember the incident. I cannot charge myself that here or anywhere else I suggested that existing cases already decided should be reviewed and a liability imposed upon the recipients.
Comment on this
Let me take this Bill. The second section has reference to the short service men becoming servants of the amalgamated company and being put into particular positions that they did not occupy at the moment. Two objections are raised to that. One is the objection raised to Section 4 that the onus of proof must be put on the railway company, and that the unfortunate man is in the position that he cannot rebut the evidence of the railway company and which the company brings forward. So far as he is in that position you cannot help him; there is no help except to provide that every man discharged is compensated. There is no help except the Dáil provides it. I cannot think that they are in such an inferior position as that.
Comment on this
When the onus is thrown on the company it means the company will bring the case before the arbitrator whether they believe it just or not. I want an assurance from the Minister that if a man successfully defends his case before the arbitrator he will get his costs against the company if he wins. On the other hand the Minister can have vice versa if he likes.
Comment on this
The Deputy wants that assurance from me, but the Deputy wants not to be bound at all himself; he wants an assurance from me, but it must end there. I can give him the assurance. I want an amendment in regard to this question of costs making the thing work each way, having the trade union funds liable if the man has no funds of his own, and if the union takes his case in hands.
Comment on this
Will you accept an amendment also that where the cases have been won before the arbitrator under the law in existence that the men should be entitled to recover their expenses?
Comment on this
That is that it should be retrospective against the company? Retrospection seems to be less of a vice when it is in favour of the men. If we make them responsible for the question of costs will he allow Section 6 to stand? The case of the officers and servants is dealt with in the third part of the schedule. As far as these men are concerned does the Deputy mean them to come within the cases to be brought before the arbitrator if they so desire? The third section is an abolition one also. The fourth section is the main one. It puts railway servants here on the same basis as railway servants under corresponding legislation in England. This again is to be amended by the abolition of these words "contributed to," and the onus of proof is thrown on the railway company, as I have indicated.
Comment on this
If any action, such as the Minister indicated in Letterkenny, came about—if a case of that kind arose arising out of the Government policy would the onus be upon the company in this particular case or would the Minister take any responsibility? For instance, would he take responsibility for the abolition of branch lines, and the consequent loss of emoluments and salaries on the part of the men?
Comment on this
Deputies must please refrain from asking questions until the Minister has concluded. He must get the same latitude as other Deputies.
Comment on this
The question of the item that stands on page 4 (c) is the second important section of the Bill—That it shall not exceed an annual sum calculated at the rate of one-sixtieth of his remuneration. Deputy Norton raised a very definite point there. I had previously considered it in conference. It may be possible to provide for the two cases I have spoken of—dismissal cost and reduction of duties. Dismissal costs ought to be on the Civil Service basis at the rate of one-sixtieth.
The retention, with the diminished duty and pay, ought to be at a rate, if it is only an allowance, not exceeding one-sixtieth. I hope that that is understood. The sub-section lettered (c) is the one I stand on, for the abolition of which no one has made a case, with the one exception—the matter of trade apprentices. That is the matter I stand on in Committee in order to see what the House has to say to it; (d) as lettered here, deals with a matter that I have indicated with regard to one of the funds. There may be arguments put up, and they can be put up, in Committee, as some adjustment is possible, with regard to the solvent funds, either by giving the whole amount due, which I consider wrong, or by repayment of contributions which I would consider a fair proposition. In regard to the other two, I would ask the Dáil to consider in Committee whether this section should stand as it now reads with regard to "A" Fund and the Railway Clearing House Fund.
Comment on this
We have been asked to withdraw this Bill and to bring it in in another form. That has been put in a variety of ways. It has been put on the ground that people did not know what was in the Bill, and it has been put on the ground that Deputy Davin cannot follow it. I do not know that any one is going to stand by that.
Comment on this
I doubt if the Minister can get anyone behind him in his own Party to get up and explain the Bill as it is now.
Comment on this
I will wager as an equivalent that the Deputy could not explain the Third Schedule which is being amended.
Comment on this
I will have an examination privately with the Deputy afterwards. I have been asked to withdraw this Bill for a variety of reasons. People put that suggestion forward in an open sort of way. I cannot agree with that. I think it is understood what is at stake. There is at stake a change of the minimum of one-sixtieth to the maximum of one-sixtieth, and a rate of one-sixtieth in other cases. Whatever be the doubt about stereotyping the number of railway employees prior to amalgamation there is no question of that now. Whatever right the company had prior to amalgamation with regard to dismissal that same right still lasts. Where there is redundancy by reason of amalgamation or absorption there must be compensation. These are really the things about which we have been voting. I have been asked to withdraw the Bill on other grounds that I cannot consider. One was on the ground that to prove my honesty with regard to assurances I gave here I must withdraw it. I am sorry that Deputy Morrissey is not here, as I do not think he meant that his remarks should be construed in that way. Deputy Morrissey put it in a way, that to show my honesty in the matter, this Bill should be withdrawn. I have it that certain people made the suggestion that I had been so dishonest in matters of this sort before that reliance could not be put on my assurances. Deputy Morrissey did not say that.
Comment on this
I do not think that I said anything like what the Minister has suggested. If I did convey anything like that to the Minister I would like to withdraw it unreservedly. While I may have a shot occasionally at the Minister across the House I must say that I have as much respect for him as any Deputy in the House, and I would be the last to suggest that he was dishonest. I did say that he was not fair to the working-classes of the country. If the Minister thinks that anything I said conveyed anything approaching dishonesty to him, I withdraw it.
Comment on this
I felt sure that what I had taken down was possibly due to an error on my part. I wanted to make that clear. I accept the Deputy's withdrawal very definitely. There was another suggestion of the same sort made. Whatever it may have been it was certainly taken up by a Deputy who is not here. I am very glad that Deputy Byrne accuses me of dishonesty. I should not like to have his recommendation for honesty. I hope, as long as I remain in this House, I will have Deputy Byrne's disapprobation and that he will never dishonour me by alleging honesty or anything of the sort against me.
Comment on this
I do not think it is fair to use such expressions about the Deputy in his absence. It may be another mistake on the Minister's part, as in the case of Deputy Morrissey. I do not think it is right to speak in such terms about the Deputy, particularly when he is not here.
Comment on this
The Deputy stated "Get something in writing," as he was not willing to believe my words. That was his interjection.
Comment on this
It is not the same case as that of Deputy Morrissey. I was very anxious to be put on a footing of cordial relations with Deputy Morrissey and I would regret any imputation that might proceed from him. But I say as regards Deputy Byrne that I hope as long as he is in the House he will continue to impute dishonesty to me. The sort of honesty Deputy Byrne understands is not the honesty I understand. I sat here yesterday listening to two Deputies. I have always had a certain admiration for a novelist whose works I read long ago, Charles Dickens. I sat here and my wonder grew, as I listened to two Deputies, how Dickens had been able to portray a character such as Uriah Heep without ever having known Deputy Byrne, and to a small extent—
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister should refer to a Deputy in this way. It would be well if the Minister would withdraw.
Comment on this
The Minister has just now rivalled his previous performances in corner-boy vituperation.
Comment on this
Pardon me, he referred to me as Uriah Heep. That is, of course, not in order, but I regard it as a tribute coming from the source from which it emanated.
Comment on this
I think it is very undesirable to have matters of this kind introduced from any side of the House, and I ask the Minister to withdraw his reference to the Deputies.
Comment on this
I may say that I took exception to the interjection of Deputy Byrne last night when he advised me to have this matter written down.
Comment on this
The rules of this House have been transgressed by the Minister. Personally I do not care what vituperation comes from that source. I expected nothing but that from that particular source.
Comment on this
In this case the Minister ought to justify what he has said. There are many epithets in his stock-in-trade which he may apply to me.
Comment on this
I ask Deputy Magennis to resume his seat. This is not improving the decorum of the House, and it is very undesirable that allegations against Deputies from other Deputies, or from Ministers, should take place. Those observations are resented in all quarters of the House.
Comment on this
And outside also. I would ask the Minister to withdraw his remarks in reference to Deputy Byrne. So far as I understand, the remarks were not made in reference to Deputy Professor Magennis.
Comment on this
They were so. If I have to withdraw, I do so in both cases, if so desired by the Chairman.
Comment on this
I wish to ask the Minister to clear up a point about which I am in doubt with regard to superannuation. Take the case of two men, one of whom has been contributing for 50 years into a superannuation fund. The other man has never contributed. Both men have the same wages and both are being got rid of as redundant men. Under this Bill what difference will there be in the compensation? As far as I understand from reading the Bill there will be no difference as the superannuation will be taken into account in making up the compensation. Will there be a difference in the amount of compensation that each man will get?
Comment on this
That is the effect of the section as it stands. I hold that that should be the effect with regard to A, a man who did not contribute to any superannuation fund, and B, a man who contributed to the "A" or Railway Clearing House Fund, because these are now insolvent. With regard to a man who contributed to the "B" fund, I think whatever his compensation is as awarded by the arbitrator, it should exclude a refund of his contributions with interest.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say, in the case of a man who did contribute to the fund, and who was not regarded as redundant but went on in the normal way, if he would be entitled to get anything out of the superannuation fund?
Comment on this
Why deprive him of that right because he is got rid of as a redundant man?
Comment on this
Because he is getting more as compensation and far more than the superannuation fund would give him.
Comment on this
The compensation is for removal and loss of salary. Why use superannuation to make up for compensation?
Comment on this
That is the real matter. There will have to be a division of the two classes of funds that I have referred to. That is a Committee point more than one for Second Reading. I want to put the case to the House that where a fund is insolvent and where, in fact, a railway company is going to pay what is classed as superannuation and in addition compensation, that that is unfair. Where there is a fund actually in existence outside the railway companies' resources, from which money can be withdrawn, then it is fair that the amount paid should be an amount of the refund of the contributions in addition to the interest plus the amount of compensation.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say who is to judge as to the solvency or insolvency of the fund? Is he going to take the latest report on the fund actuarially or is he setting himself up as a judge as to whether the funds are solvent or insolvent?
Comment on this
I would like the Deputy to put the condition of the three funds before Deputies and see whether they would not come to a definite conclusion about them.
Comment on this
When the Minister refers to the insolvency of the fund may I take it that he has in mind the latest report of the actuaries?
Comment on this
The latest reports I have show that two funds are insolvent and one is pretty well solvent. It is solvent if certain bulk benefits are taken. It is insolvent if, instead of bulk benefits, they take annuities.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister if he proposes to make provision for the case of men dismissed partly from economic reasons and partly from amalgamation?
Comment on this
I think what would happen under English legislation and what is intended here is, that the arbitrator would make a decision on the question, whether it is mainly due to amalgamation or mainly due to other circumstances. Then there would be a clear cut case.
Comment on this
If it is not mainly due to amalgamation has the arbitrator any power to make an award? That is not clear from the Bill.
Comment on this
Let us leave out the word "solely." I am not proposing to keep that in.
Comment on this
Take a case where it is partly due to amalgamation and partly due to economic causes.
Comment on this
I think the arbitrator will have to make up his mind as to whether it is due to amalgamation or to economic causes.
Comment on this
That would be a matter for the arbitrators to make a decision on one way or the other.
Comment on this
Are we to understand that the retrospective clause will be withdrawn on the Committee Stage, and that there will be a Government amendment to delete the section?
Comment on this
If no one else puts down a motion to delete it I will put it down myself.
Comment on this
May I suggest to the Minister—and it is not Parliamentary tactics in this particular case, because the Minister does not appear to have quite definitely turned down the suggestion that came from one part of the House—that he should withdraw?
Comment on this
I do not suggest it from party tactics, but as a matter of good business. As the matter is not urgent he should withdraw the Bill and reprint it. No Bill should be submitted to the House in this shape, and you, Sir, have pointed out that the Bill we are discussing is not the same as that which is printed. In his speech the Minister said that it was a different one. I think Deputies will have to vote on your ruling with regard to the Bill as it stands. With all due respect to the Minister I suggest that it is not fair to ask, even his own supporters, to walk into the Division Lobby and vote on a Bill of that kind.
Comment on this
When does the Minister propose to take the next stage?
Comment on this
Might I suggest that we should be given a longer time? Might I also suggest that the Minister's amendments be circulated and still give Deputies, after that, time to put in any further amendments, because we do not really know where we are at present? It is unwise, I think, to have amateur attempts at framing amendments to deal with the same matter that the Minister is himself dealing with. If the Minister would circulate his amendments and give us time, from then, to put in further amendments for Committee Stage, it would be much more satisfactory.
Comment on this
The people who would be responsible, from our side of the House, for putting forward amendments would not care to do so until they had carefully read the Official Report of the Minister's statement and reply. I think the Minister should take that into consideration when suggesting a suitable day for Committee Stage.
Comment on this
I could have the amendments I am going to suggest, with the possible exception of one, out to-morrow. I think I could have all of them—including that one—in the hands of Deputies on Saturday. If delivered at the Clerk's Office to-morrow, they would, I expect, be in the hands of Deputies on Saturday. If we pass Wednesday of next week, Thursday and Friday will be devoted to financial business, so that Tuesday week will be the earliest day for Committee Stage.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider the desirability of remitting this Bill to a Special Committee? I think it is a Bill which—especially in view of these amendments—could be much more satisfactorily dealt with by a small Committee.
Comment on this
Would that Committee be selected prior to the amendments going out? Would it be selected, say, to-morrow and meet as soon as the amendments are in hands?
Comment on this
The Committee would be nominated by the Committee of Selection, which could meet to-morrow. The nomination of a Special Committee could, therefore, take place immediately.
Comment on this
Might I suggest to you, A Chinn Comhairle, the desirability of having distributed among Ministers a book on etiquette and manners for use in the House?
Comment on this
I would be quite agreeable to this Special Committee if it could be moved for to-morrow without notice.
Comment on this
If the Minister desires to refer the Bill to a Special Committee, he can move now that it be so referred, instead of referring it to a Committee of the whole Dáil. He has the option of doing that now without notice.
Comment on this
I am quite agreeable to move that the Bill be referred to a Special Committee to be nominated by the Committee of Selection.
Comment on this
We can postpone the fixing of the Committee Stage of the Bill until after the tea adjournment. In the meantime, a motion can be drafted in proper form.
Agreed.