LOCAL AUTHORITIES (OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES) BILL, 1926—SECOND STAGE (RESUMED).
Contributions 123–256 of 256. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 14 of 1926 ›
Why should they be elected to represent the people if that was so? Why should they be more iniquitous than the people elected to the county council? Still you made provision to save them from themselves. I believe—and I have a fair knowledge of the country—that you will find that every self-respecting man in the country, and many men who are on the public boards, will welcome this Bill.
Comment on this
They have frequently told me that the most distasteful thing in their experience of public life and public administration was the canvassing that was taking place, and their having to vote for people that they would not vote for if the voting were by ballot. Let us consider for a moment the volume of opinion in favour of this Bill. The General Council of the County Councils—the bodies that preceded the present county councils—passed a unanimous resolution at different meetings advocating the filling of appointments to local bodies by a Civil Service Commission.
Comment on this
Ought you not have as high ideals as these men? You claim to have higher ideals. Then show them to us. The medical profession shared some of the moral obloquy of the boards for nepotism, and for any corruption that may have taken place. As far back as 1911, on a plebiscite, 94 per cent. of them voted for entrance to the local government service by competitive examination. That was under the British régime. Now, we know that Arthur Griffith advocated this system for local appointments, and we know, too, that his advocacy of that very policy strengthened Sinn Fein, and attracted forces to Sinn Fein that it would never have otherwise. They saw the purity of the man's ideals and the purity of his policy. I have already quoted the opinion of Labour, and, added to this, I have already given quite a respectable body of organised opinion in favour of the present Bill.
Comment on this
Potential candidates for county health appointments have gone to America and have gone to England, and have been away from their homes for six or eight months studying public health questions. I know that many of these men have gone abroad for these studies. I can tell you that if these men thought that the local authorities would have the making of these public health appointments, not one of them would have stirred a foot to go abroad in order to have improved their studies or to make themselves better qualified. I believe that if you adopted the so-called panel system that has been advocated here by some Deputies and if you sent down a panel to the local authorities, and put one of these men who have studied at the top place, that the twenty-sixth man, with friends and relations, as in my own case, would get elected. I am candid about the whole thing. It was only on the assurance that the Civil Service Commission for making appointments to local bodies would be created, that these men went to America and England, and are spending their time and their money there in study. I know some of these men would not, with all their qualifications, get as much as a proposer or seconder if the appointments were to be filled by the local bodies, and that the local man who never stirred from home to gain any special or extra knowledge would beat them easily.
Comment on this
That word "panel" has been used very loosely. He might not get on the panel or get elected for that matter. If the Civil Service adopted the panel system, one of these men would be put, say, first place on the panel, but the fact of his being number one on the panel would not get him elected. Every man here who has any connection with local bodies, where blood relationship counts for so much in Ireland, knows that I am speaking the truth. We have heard a good deal that the man who pays the piper should call the tune. I hold, and it is a fact, that the salaries of the local officials in Ireland are paid out of the central funds. The grants voted here pay far more than the salaries of these men. There are places in Ireland in which, I am told, it is unnecessary, owing to these grants, to strike a poor rate at all. The poor rate goes to defray the county health board charges. These county health board charges are comprehensive charges. They mean the salaries of dispensary doctors, county home assistants, outdoor assistants, and so on. All the grants paid to local bodies pay these salaries.
Comment on this
Now, take the case of the County Wicklow. I am a ratepayer there. I am a farmer. Perhaps that accounts for my predilection for these benches. The county health board charges there, when you deduct the grants, just work out at 6d. in the £. That is the amount that falls upon the farmer. That is the modest sum when the agricultural grant in aid is deducted. Under the circumstances, what is the use of saying that the local authorities find the money to pay the officials? With the grants, they do not, and the tendency will be—I believe it is a rightful tendency—that all these public health charges, the charges of the sick and the poor, will be a national charge. They are, in fact, a national charge largely, at the moment, and I believe they must be continued as a national charge.
In the circumstances, I do not see what is wrong about these appointments being made centrally. We hear a lot about bureaucracy and centralisation. We ought to remember that we have a population of about three millions, and that for that population of three millions, between the central and local authorities we have about 150 boards. To my mind, the Dáil, and its Departments, should be able to do central government and local government. That is the way to have economy. You will not have economy otherwise. I have heard—and it was not a kind thing to say—that these men on public boards should not be deprived of the appointment of officials. I do not think that that was a carefully-thought-out argument on the part of those who used it, because the suggestion is that they went on these boards for the patronage that was to be dispensed. That was the suggestion, because there cannot be any other loss. What are they losing if they do not go on them?
Comment on this
I think that the Bill is a wonderful step towards clean government. I was never prouder of being a member of the Government Party than I am this minute. I am an unpledged member of the Government Party, mind you, but every day that I see the Government at work I see that they are the one Government that go in for clean administration. They ignore the clamour of the vote——
Comment on this
We will have an alternative Government some time, perhaps. I heartily congratulate the Minister and the Government for having brought forward this measure. You are all anxious to lop off patronage from the Government. Why complain now at lopping it off from the local authorities? Is there any honesty and consistency at all to be found among politicians? I am beginning to despair.
Comment on this
Having listened to Deputy Dr. Hennessy, one can only come to one conclusion, and that is that he has had rather shady experiences in his time, and I believe he has candidly admitted that. He has told us that it was not merit that got him these local appointments, but his friends who had a pull.
Comment on this
Deputy Hennessy has made a very open confession. His experience has been very unfortunate, as far as public administration is concerned. Corruption was rampant in his appointments——
Comment on this
Very well, I will accept it. That will put all the onus on you of removing the nepotism.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Gorey should not make that allegation against Deputy Hennessy. Will Deputy Gorey please sit down? Deputy Hennessy made a very simple statement, which was quite understandable, namely, that he got an appointment, not because of his merits, but because of his relations. That is not an imputation against Deputy Hennessy.
Comment on this
Oh, no, because he had the pull and used the pull, pulled for all he was worth. Now we are told about what local authorities are likely to do and what they have done in the past. A picture is being held up to us of what this Commission will be like, and we are told that they will be free from political and family influences. Probably family influences will not have as much pull there, but I am certain that political preferences will have as much pull as, or more than, on local boards. We have no doubts that these Commissioners will not be supermen; they will be men of ordinary clay and will not be better than anybody else, and we look for patronage there much more marked and much more in operation than in the case of the local bodies. Probably a commission set up by the Government will have one political colouring. I might take it at that from my experience.
Comment on this
It is a plain question. What does the Deputy mean by his last remark, that he might take it at that from his experience? Let us have that.
Comment on this
When two or three candidates of equal merit are put up, the candidate who is favourable to the political influences of those who make the appointment will get it.
Comment on this
The Deputy was speaking about the probable constitution of the board and he referred to "my experience" in that connection.
Comment on this
Perhaps that was rather an unfortunate way of putting it. It might not be quite accurate, but I say that the local authorities are composed of several political elements, that all the political elements in the country are represented on the local boards. Every body with a political viewpoint sets up a party for election to the local boards on a different ticket and it is unfair to say that politics will have a pull. Why not set a standard? If you do not think the standard is sufficiently high, raise the standard. Let candidates pass examinations before a commission, or some other authority, and let local appointments be made by the local people. If you take away all the methods of what I call administration from the local authorities they will not function at all. You had better concentrate all the government of the country in Dublin and set up another branch of the Civil Service to deal with this part of it.
Comment on this
It has to do with administration inasmuch as the men you are going to set up to carry out your orders are the men who will select and send down these officials, and the people who want their administration carried on and who will pay for it are the people who ought to be allowed to elect the officers to carry it out. Set any standard you like; raise the standard as high as you like; let candidates come up to that standard, and then let the local authorities make the appointments. That ought not to be impossible, and under that system we would have a great deal less patronage and a great deal less suspicion than we will have under the suggested system. I hazard the guess that you had better, when appointing this commission, also set up a school of commissioners to carry out all local administration, because from my experience—I may not be as unfortunate as some Deputies, including Deputy Dr. Hennessy—this will be considered an insult by the local authorities that I am and have been acquainted with for 20 or 30 years. I do not believe that they will function at all. I would not be surprised if they all resigned in a body. That is what I would advise in my own county.
Comment on this
This is not a question of patronage at all. There are other things besides examinations and answering questions. There is something like commonsense, and is it suggested that the proposed commissioners are the people who will have a monopoly of commonsense? I think that is very clearly and very definitely suggested in the Bill. I am opposed to the Bill, and I think you will find that the majority of the county councils will be opposed to it. If you are going to do this, send down your commissioners to the country——
Comment on this
There is enough of intelligence amongst the Government's hangers-on in the country to do that.
Comment on this
It is not a bit cheap. We know the men are going round the country promising jobs, and we know how you go on at elections on local platforms promising drainage, and things like that.
Comment on this
It is not unworthy of the Deputy. We know how the wires are pulled. We know how your organisers go round the country. We have brought cases here from Cavan and elsewhere.
Comment on this
I am supporting this Bill, as I believe it will make for clean and pure administration in the public affairs of the country. Deputies have picked holes in and have found fault with the present administration. I think that ought to be sufficient reason why we should try to support the Bill. It must be admitted that canvassing for public positions under the local boards is most objectionable. Most of us know men capable of discharging public duties, who are prepared to give their services on the public boards, but who would not touch public life owing to canvassing. We know that canvassing has gone even as far as bribery for votes. These men would not touch local boards because of the manner in which they were approached by men who were looking for positions.
Comment on this
I must say that I was rather surprised at the reception this Bill got from Deputies in the Farmers' and Labour Parties. I thought it would be an agreed measure, and that, while there might be some discussion on the Committee Stage about the various sections, the principle of the Bill would be accepted.
Comment on this
The voices of Labour Deputies, with the possible exception of my fellow-countyman, Deputy Morrissey, have a very different ring from the voice in the Seanad of Senator O'Farrell, who was practically responsible for this measure in embryo.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Morrissey has gone a great deal further than any of the other Deputies on the Labour benches. A measure of this kind was strongly advocated in the Seanad, and, as far as I could gather, by Deputies, when the Local Government Act was going through. I thought this Bill would have got a very favourable reception from all parties. The objection of Deputy Baxter and Deputy Corish seems to be, first, to Section 2 sub-section (c). In criticising Bills of this kind I think Deputies should give the Government and Government Departments credit for having some judgment. It is preposterous to suggest that we are bringing forward a Bill which would make it obligatory on local authorities to have all appointments, even roadmakers——
Comment on this
——typists, locum tenens for doctors, and people of that kind, made by a central body. Of course that is absurd. I would be prepared to give every possible consideration to any proposal Deputy Baxter or Deputy Corish makes that would improve sub-section (c). My whole difficulty is this: the Local Government net is a very widely cast one, and includes a great number of officials of very different kinds. Sub-section (c) is devised with the object of making it possible for me not to include a large number of officers and employees, and, at the same time, to leave machinery wide enough to include classes of individuals who may not be in existence at all at the present time, or who may be in existence, or whom it is not advisable to include just now, but whom it may be advisable to include later on. If any one can devise some other form of wording which will achieve that idea I would be quite willing to agree to it.
Comment on this
Would the Minister help us by indicating the kind of appointments of that character which could not be included under (b)? I am anxious to know what the Minister has in mind.
Comment on this
I have not even a class of person in mind. It is quite obvious that at the outset our machinery may not be working properly and we might consider it advisable later on to include classes that we do not feel justified in making a provision for at this stage. The general atmosphere surrounding the arguments in opposition to the Bill seems to be that the whole idea is to concentrate power in the hands of the Minister and to leave no power whatever to the local authorities. In fact one Deputy suggested that it was merely transferring patronage from the local authorities to the hands of the Minister for Local Government. I do not see how any Deputy who has read Section 5 could say that. That section gives local authorities absolute power as regards the promotion of suitable officials at present in their service, and power to elect suitable pensioners who had experience of similar work in the past. There is absolute power to make those appointments without any reference to the Commissioners. It is only in cases where they failed to make these appointments that the machinery of the Commissioners comes into operation at all. When the Commissioners' powers do come into operation they are restricted to the making of appointments by competitive examination. That deprives them and the Minister of any power of patronage, if they were willing to exercise such power. The only limitation on that is the limitation contained in Section 9. Deputy Heffernan and other Deputies who condemned the Bill very strenuously admitted, and in fact argued as something against the Bill, that in some cases competitive examinations do not provide the best and most suitable candidates. That is particularly true in the case of county medical officers of health which is pre-eminently a position where administrative abilities will count far more than theoretical knowledge. The next exception is that contained in Section 10. That section is merely devised with the object of protecting officials under local authorities who should in the ordinary course of events be promoted, who are the obvious people for promotion, but who, owing to the fact that they may not have a pull in a particular council, or perhaps a particular council may have a grudge against them, are not put forward for the appointment. In such a case the section is a safeguard for those particular officials so that the Minister should have power in cases of hardship to put forward their names.
Comment on this
That is the intention. In order to meet the wishes of the Dáil I am prepared to leave this to an open vote. But I hope if it is defeated there will not be any complaints lodged with me, if there are cases of hardship, where officials who should be promoted are not promoted, owing to the machinery of the Bill being defective.
Some Deputies contended that the power given in sub-section (3) of Section 6 to the Ministers should be vested in the council. As a matter of fact, I think in most cases local commissioners will recommend just one individual. I do not think there will be many cases where they will give power to the Minister to select from more than one, but in cases where they do I think it is necessary that that power should be left to the Minister, because in very many cases local authorities will probably have an objection to the appointment made. They will be in favour of some particular man amongst the candidates going for the position, and if that man is not selected pressure will be brought to bear on the council to refuse to accept the man selected by the Commission. They may refuse to make the appointment, and if they resign it is necessary that the power of making the appointment should be left to the Minister.
Comment on this
When it is a question of equal merit between two candidates what is the position? You said there would be only one name sent forward.
Comment on this
In that case, under the provisions of the Bill the Minister could decide, but those are matters which may be discussed on Committee Stage. In connection with Section 6, Deputies have asked: why not get this Commission to pick out three names, supposing you have a vacancy in a dispensary? The Civil Service Commission have taken up a position which, I think, we should acquiesce in. They will refuse to make an odious distinction between professional men. The mere fact that a man is registered on the General Medical Register qualifies him for the post, and if we were to pick out one man and say "You are qualified and the other two are not," I think it would leave us open to an action.
Comment on this
When they make the appointment do they not determine that one man is more capable than another?
Comment on this
They do, but they do not determine that that man is qualified and that the others are not qualified.
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson took up a line that I was surprised at. He said, and several other Deputies followed him, more especially those on the Farmers' benches, that they were all afraid that if the power of patronage were lost the best type of representative would refuse to go forward for those positions as representatives on local authorities. I think that is an unfair statement to make about representatives on local authorities. He contends that the only reason that they go forward is that they are anxious for the use and enjoyment of patronage, and I think if we reach that stage the sooner that dies irae, which Deputy Johnson is looking forward to with such foreboding when I am going to sweep away all local authorities with a wave of my hand, comes, and when I am to put in commissioners in their place, the better. I do not think we have reached that stage. I believe the majority of the best type of representatives will welcome this provision.
Comment on this
There has been talk about having set up a local or municipal Civil Service. That is one of those catch-cries I do not understand and I wish Deputies would put forward some specific proposals. The idea seems to be to make a kind of entrance examination for all the classes of officials under local authorities and to promote them gradually from this particular panel. I do not think it can be done. It is a very difficult thing to promote an assistant county, surveyor to be a county medical officer of health. You would have so many different classes to divide your panel into that the thing would be impossible. There may be some possible means of getting over the difficulty, but so far as I am concerned I cannot say.
Deputy Sir James Craig quoted the words of Section 7, which decides the qualifications of officers appointed. I admit that is somewhat clumsy phraseology, but we cannot get literature, like what would come from the pen of Robert Louis Stephenson, worked into an Act of Parliament. It is in order to put the position clearly from the lawyer's point of view, rather than from that of the layman, that that language is used. The object of the section is to make it possible to limit the class who can be appointed to a particular office, according to professional qualifications and also to qualifications of various kinds. Senator O'Farrell, in his proposed amendment to the Local Government Bill in the Seanad, brought in a provision whereby an examination for a particular post should be restricted to people living in a particular area. We thought that it might, perhaps, be advisable to leave that power still in the Bill. It is rather difficult to get a phrase which would enable us to restrict qualifications for an examination, say, to a medical practitioner, a nurse, or a midwife and, at the same time, to a person who was born or who lived in a particular area.
With regard to the personnel of the Commission, that point has not been definitely decided, and I do not think that it is very material at this stage. Our intention is, if possible, to have some, if not all, of the Civil Service Commissioners act upon it. One of these Commissioners is a native speaker and is very familiar with the Irish language. That, I think, should satisfy Deputy Roddy.
Comment on this
So far, neither of these Commissioners is a member of the Local Government Department. I do not think that there is anything further for me to say on the Bill. There is nothing sinister, nothing of the trick-o'-the-loop method about it. It is open and above board, and if Deputies have any reasonable amendments to introduce I will be very pleased to consider them on the Committee Stage.
Comment on this
Will the Minister deal with Section 12? Can he give any indication of the approximate number of vacancies annually in the offices under (a) and (b)—what number of vacancies per annum are there in contemplation?
Comment on this
Will the Minister also say if there is any intention in this Bill to interfere with the present salaries of existing officers, inasmuch as power is taken to regulate the remuneration paid?
Comment on this
Will the Minister further say, under Section 12, if he is taking to himself the right to determine when an official, say, a town clerk or secretary to a county council, is to be superannuated, and if he is going to fix any age limit for retiring?
Comment on this
It is our intention to fix an age limit. We have done so already. With regard to Deputy Johnson's point, I think that we may count on there being something less than fifty vacancies in the normal year under (a) and (b).
Comment on this
Then they are all to be civil servants, so that the doctor and lawyer, of whom Deputy Roddy spoke, are to be ruled out?
Comment on this
The Minister has not replied to my question as regards remuneration. Does he mean to take power to alter the salaries payable to existing officers?
Comment on this
I suggest that the Committee Stage be not taken until Friday of next week so that Deputies will have an opportunity of preparing amendments.
Comment on this
I do not know how this is going to fit in with the programme of legislation which has been submitted. I think the Minister would be well advised to see if it would be possible to delete by agreement such sections in the Bill as are objected to by a large number of Deputies, and make provision in this Bill or in some amending Bill to meet the case of urgency that Deputy Sir James Craig spoke of yesterday—the case of the appointment of county medical officers of health. I do not think any Deputy in the House would object to securing the appointment of medical officers by some outside central authority. If that is the urgency, I think the Minister could get an agreed Bill hurried through the House without much difficulty.
Comment on this
The whole Bill, from my point of view, is necessary, and to a great extent it is an urgent measure. Some parts of it are more urgent than others. My difficulty is to know what part of the Bill any large section in the House objects to. In the debate that took place on the Second Reading it was difficult to find out if there was anything in the Bill that was objected to. It was something that was not in the Bill but which they read into it themselves that certain Deputies objected to.
Comment on this
I suggest for the consideration of the House that if the Minister intends to stand by this Bill in its present form, or anything like its present form, it will be strenuously objected to in many parts of the House. That will mean delay, not only in respect to this Bill but in respect to other portions of the legislative programme.
Comment on this
I am in favour of the Bill and have just voted for its Second Reading. Except for the urgent part of the Bill, the part dealing with the appointment of county medical officers of health, I do not see any prospect of it getting through the Dáil before the Summer Recess, because it is a contentious Bill. It is a Bill in connection with which many amendments will be prepared. We have to deal with the Estimates and four or five measures of considerable importance have also to be considered, and unless the Dáil is prepared to sit to the end of July I do not think the Minister can get this Bill through. I would urge him to bring in a Bill dealing with the question of the appointment of county medical officers of health, which would be an agreed measure and passed without debate, and to leave over the remainder of this Bill, which I am in favour of, and which I believe to be necessary and desirable, but which I do not believe to be so urgent that it ought to be rushed through the Oireachtas before the end of June. I would suggest to the Minister, in the interest of getting adequate discussion for all our measures, that he should bring in a separate measure dealing with the question of the appointment of county medical officers of health and allow the remainder of the Bill to be postponed until the autumn.
Comment on this
I think I am entitled to say that I do not know precisely what was the reason for the opposition to the Second Reading of this Bill.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy address himself to the question now before the House, whether the Committee Stage of this Bill should be taken this day week or not?
Comment on this
There is no objection whatever to the Bill even from the doctrinaires on the Labour benches who have made an unholy alliance with certain other Deputies.
Comment on this
The position I am in is that every part of the Bill is necessary. It is all urgent, some parts of it more urgent than others. I do not see why an exception should be made in the case of this Bill any more than in that of any other Bill. If Deputies find it necessary to stay a little longer in order to give the Bill adequate consideration I am just as willing to inconvenience myself in that respect as any other Deputy. I think it is an unfair thing to put forward this suggestion at this stage.
Comment on this
Then there will be opposition to the proposal to sit late and to sit on Mondays and late on Fridays.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Committee Stage of the Bill be not taken until Monday week. If the Bill were to be taken on Thursday of next week it would leave very little time for the framing of amendments to it.
Comment on this
I want to put it to the Minister that at a meeting of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges held this morning the President put up the proposal that the Dáil should sit on Mondays and that it should sit until 8.30 on Fridays. We, the representatives of the Opposition Parties, consented to that on the grounds of great urgency. The President in return said that no measure that was not absolutely of immediate urgency should be proceeded with. I agree with Deputy Johnson that if this measure, which is not entirely of urgency—it has one factor that is of great urgency, but the other factors could be postponed until the autumn—is going to be pressed forward, then we must oppose sitting on Mondays and sitting until 8.30 on Fridays. We agreed to the time-table put forward by the Government. If that time-table is going to be upset by the action of the Minister for Local Government, well then there will have to be opposition all along the time-table and not only on this particular measure. There has been a great desire to co-operate with the Government in getting the adjournment at the end of the month of June, but if suggestions put forward by the Government are not going to be acted on, then we on our side are released from any adumbrations that have been made.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy a question? Was not this Bill before the Committee on Procedure and Privileges when they were considering this matter, and did they not know that it had got a First Reading and was before the Dáil? Why should they assume then that I would be willing to agree to the mutilation of this Bill any more than any other Minister would in regard to a Bill of his?
Comment on this
The Committee on Procedure and Privileges obviously cannot find any Deputy who is not represented on it, but it is definitely stated in the Standing Orders that the business of the Dáil shall be arranged by the President of the Executive Council in conjunction with the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. Therefore, when they arrive at an agreement if any individual Deputy, whether it be the Minister or otherwise, refuses to abide by the agreement then any member of the Committee is released from any agreement made.
Comment on this
Are we to take it that these adumbrations of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges were arrived at on the basis of assuming that the Minister for Local Government would be prepared to jettison three-fourths of his Bill?
Comment on this
It was agreed on the basis put forward by the President and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Executive Council. It was believed that might happen, and as it has not happened then, in my opinion, Deputy Wilson, Deputy Johnson, Deputy Thrift and myself are not bound by the undertaking arrived at then. If individual Deputies or Ministers refuse to abide by the agreement then every party is released. That is what I want to emphasise.
Comment on this
Deputy Cooper will remember that I stated an extern Minister asked for time for a measure, that it was given, and that the word of the Executive Council had passed in that connection. If the Minister considered that his measure was a necessity the Government was bound by its original promise and undertaking.
Comment on this
As my name has been mentioned I would like to state that my recollection of what occurred is that certain suggestions as to a programme were put forward by the President, and in reply it was pointed out that this Bill did not appear to be as urgent as others, and that it might be possible to sub-divide the Bill into two parts, bringing in one part with reference to the county medical officers and postponing the other part. But I do not recall that there was anything like an undertaking or promise of any kind on the part of the President as to what would be done when the other suggestions were agreed to on our part.
Comment on this
I agree with all the President has said. Only I want to make it clear there should be no charge of bad faith on the part of any nonmember of the Government Party on that Committee. If it is found impossible to carry out the programme suggested by the President, then we have a free hand and are not bound, but provisionally we accepted the programme put forward by the President. If now it is impossible to fulfil that programme, at any rate it releases everybody. I am not charging bad faith against the President, but equally I am anxious that we should not be charged with bad faith.
Comment on this
The Committee on Procedure and Privileges arrived at an agreement to-day as to the programme for the remainder of the session, and that agreement was on the lines described by Deputy Cooper. The President told us he could make no promise with regard to this Bill, but it was the opinion of the Committee that the Minister should be asked to drop a portion of the Bill until the autumn session, and that the more urgent portion of the Bill might be proceeded with. The Committee arrived at that conclusion after having gone into all the Bills and Estimates, and they drafted a time-table. They agreed it was absolutely impossible to adhere to that time-table if this Bill was proceeded with fully. I also would appeal to the Minister to drop portion of the Bill until the autumn session, and to proceed now only with the portion dealing with medical officers, as a matter of urgency, and that is all he can get through. Deputies representing all parties in the House agreed with the programme, and I think it should be adhered to.
Comment on this
I would suggest that if this matter were adjourned until to-morrow the Minister would have an opportunity to consider the position. All parties, I understand, have agreed to the time-table—one with which I am not satisfied—conditional on the Minister for Local Government adopting a certain policy regarding this Bill. I think the Minister should take some time to consider the question that has been raised.
Comment on this
I do not want to be put in the position of being the stubborn member of the Dáil, keeping everybody here after they decided on getting away, but I must say that I think it was a rather high-handed act on the part of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges to attempt to carve up this particular Bill in a way that had never been done before, without giving me any notice whatever of it, especially considering that the Bill was before the Dáil. If it had not gone through the First Reading it would be a different matter.
Comment on this
I consider that I am being treated very unfairly in this matter. However, in order to meet the views of the Deputy in the matter, I am willing to give way. The Second Reading of the Bill having been passed the whole principle of the Bill is agreed to. I will just go ahead with the machinery of the Bill that enables the county medical officers of health to be appointed, without prejudice to what is going to happen in the autumn, but I must say that I do it under protest.
Comment on this
It is only right to say that the Committee on Procedure did not really take any steps about this particular Bill. The Committee on Procedure considered, generally, the work that has to be done before the summer adjournment. The question of this particular Bill arose. The President made it quite clear that he could not, seeing that the Bill was a Bill introduced by an extern Minister, give any promise about it, but that he did understand, and the Committee, generally, was given to understand, that there was one particular thing in the Bill that was very urgent. I do not think it right to say that there was any proposal made by the Committee that the Bill should be carved up. I very much doubt that it is possible to do what is actually suggested; that is read this particular Bill a Second Time, and then, in Committee, do the exact thing that is suggested now. The understanding of the Committee was that the particular thing but that the rest, although urgent, was regarding, I think, these county medical officers of health was urgent, not so urgent that it could not wait until the autumn.
Before we continue this matter, the suggestion that the Minister should have an opportunity of thinking it over is the best suggestion that has been made, that instead of fixing the Committee Stage of this Bill now we should postpone the fixing of it until to-morrow, so that the Minister might not be charged with having made some promise that possibly he may not be able to carry out. But the Committee on Procedure did not take on itself any power, or make any suggestion with regard to the Bill before the Dáil.
Comment on this
I certainly did not understand that if that agreement or, at least, the representations that were made to the Committee on Procedure, were not acceded to by the Minister for Local Government, it would upset the whole arrangement. As nobody asked whether or not I saw the Minister in the meantime I would like to say that I did spend a very considerable time with the Minister informing him of the circumstances of the proceedings that took place before the Committee on Procedure and of the request that was there made.
Comment on this
I do not think the programme was contingent upon something particular happening about this Bill, although the adoption of the programme, with general goodwill, might be made more difficult if something did not happen about this Bill. It is not right to say that the programme absolutely depended on the Minister doing something about the Bill.
Comment on this
That is quite right. My opinion is that this matter was mentioned. We agreed, consequently, on a programme that, with the goodwill of everybody, we could carry out.
Comment on this
Perhaps if this matter were adjourned until to-morrow and the Whips of the different parties got together it might be possible to make some more satisfactory arrangement than at the moment.
Comment on this
We will leave over the question of fixing the Committee Stage until to-morrow.
Ordered accordingly.