PUBLIC SAFETY (EMERGENCY POWERS) BILL, 1926. - THE UNEMPLOYMENT PROBLEM
Contributions 1–136 of 259. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 40 of 1926 ›
I beg to move:—
That this House views with grave anxiety the continuance of widespread and prolonged unemployment, deplores the inadequacy of the measures so far taken by the Government to ensure opportunities of employment for unemployed workers, and disapproves of the Government's decision not to introduce legislation to amend the Unemployment Insurance Acts so as to provide subsistence for workers unable to find employment.
It is not easy—I was going to say it was not possible—to add very much to the frequent claims we have made in the Dáil for greater activity and greater consideration on the part of the Ministry in dealing with the problem of unemployment. Shortly before the summer adjournment, on the 24th June, the matter was discussed in the House, and the only thing that has happened since has been an increase in the number of men whom we ought to be concerned about, and whose means of livelihood is less, in prospect at least, than it was at that time. That is to say, the problem of unemployment is greater to-day than it was in June. I do not think anybody will disagree with the statement that we do view with grave anxiety the continuance of widespread and prolonged unemployment. Everybody at times repeats the statement that the case is serious and requires treatment of an abnormal kind; that is to say, it is a disease which must be treated in a way apart and different from the ordinary course of life. I think we will also deplore the fact that the measures so far taken by the Government to ensure opportunities of employment have been inadequate. We have been told frequently of the measures that have been taken and the moneys that have been voted to assist local authorities, or by means of direct works to promote employment and reduce the number of unemployed persons; but whatever may be the claim on behalf of the Government in respect of that, nobody will contend, I think, that they have been adequate.
They have not been adequate because they have not resulted in reducing the number of unemployed persons to any material degree. Undoubtedly, had such moneys not been spent the numbers would have been greater. How much greater it is impossible to say, because as things are in the Department of Industry and Commerce it is impossible to get adequate and accurate statistics of the number of persons unemployed. I think the figures that are available are more unreliable than ever they were, not from any fault of the Department, but by the fault of the machinery that is available. The steps taken so far have been inadequate. A certain number of public works have been started and a large sum of money has been provided. Notwithstanding the provision of those large sums of money we still have immense numbers of people unemployed, and an ever-growing number—growing weekly at any rate—of people who are not only unemployed but are going out of resources to keep themselves alive. The claim is made, and has been made continually, that it is much better to deal with the problem of unemployment by means of the provision of employment than by means of insurance, or the payment of money in any form without return in labour.
I am making the claim that, if means of obtaining employment are not available, it is our duty to provide subsistence, and the best way to do that is by means of an extension of the unemployment benefit scheme. When we were discussing this problem in June, I made an appeal to the Ministry that they would, in the interim between the adjournment and the resumption, go into the question of extended benefits, of improving and extending the Unemployment Insurance Scheme, so as to ensure to the unemployed man who was willing to work benefits by means of an insurance scheme to cover the whole time that he was unemployed, certainly to extend considerably the period in which unemployment benefit would be paid. The Minister responded with sympathy to that suggestion. He said that the problem of providing employment was a very great one and could not be solved easily. "I am pointing out," he stated, "that when we are asked here to provide a remedy for unemployment we are being asked to do what is not, I think, possible for us to do. The best we can do is to alleviate it. There can be alleviation by way of relief and by way of extended unemployment benefit."
I think he meant by that that there could be alleviation by way of relief work and by way of extended unemployment benefits. Then he went on to say: "We had some hesitation in arriving at the decision not to pay uncovenanted benefit any longer. We had the position under review at various times since then and we are not tied in the matter. If, on further consideration of the situation, and if other measures do not sufficiently lessen the unemployment problem, we would be prepared to restore uncovenanted benefit. We do not want to do that, because we believe that the payment of uncovenanted benefit gives rise to abuses and has its own economic disadvantages; that it is not as good as a scheme of work, which perhaps might not cover as many people, but if we could meet an appreciable number of individual cases by works it would be better than meeting the larger number of cases by unemployment benefit."
The specific promise there was that "If on further consideration of the situation any further measures do not sufficiently lessen the unemployment problem we would be prepared to restore uncovenanted benefit." I take it that further consideration has been given to the situation and we must ask ourselves, and the Minister must ask himself, whether the other measures that have been taken have sufficiently lessened the unemployment problem to warrant him in not restoring uncovenanted benefit. I do not know what evidence the Minister may have as to the number of unemployed in the Saorstát to-day, as compared with the numbers in June, 1926, but I say it is very difficult to obtain any figures that can be relied on to indicate the number of unemployed persons. We have, from time to time, records of the numbers registered at the Labour Employment Exchanges. We have also the number of those who have current claims for insurance benefit. The latter are, of course, very much smaller than the number on the register, but those figures, at any rate, may constitute some index of the relative position as between June and November, though they do not do more than give an indication of the persons who are registered.
Those of us who are any way familiar with the problem know how true it is to say that comparatively few persons register after they have ceased to be in benefit. The figures that were given in July of this year as to the number on the Unemployment Register was 21,931 and the latest figures on the Register— I think last week's figures—are 22,496, so that even on that showing there is an increase of 500 since July, that is an increase of the registered unemployed. Therefore, there has not been any result in the way of lessening the number by virtue of the measures that have already been taken. In view of those figures, apart from any other knowledge that we may have of the extent of unemployment, it was a great disappointment to learn from the Minister for Industry and Commerce that because of the position of the Unemployment Insurance Fund he could not recommend such a change in the scheme as would involve a further deficit upon the funds. I have not got the exact terms of it, but some such answer as that was made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and I take it that he was speaking, in making such an answer, the decision of the Executive Council.
I cannot reconcile the promise with the performance, and I therefore am asking the Dáil to agree with me that we disapprove of the Government's decision not to introduce legislation to amend the Unemployment Insurance Acts so as to provide subsistence for workers unable to find employment. Those figures, as I have said, can only be taken as an index, and they show an increase as compared with June. But to show how unsatisfactory those figures are, as a picture of the position in fact, I would remind Deputies from the country areas that they are now in November and that considerable numbers of men who are employed on the land in the summer become disemployed in November, and they do not register because they are not entitled to Unemployment Insurance, and it is not usual for the landworkers to register in the Unemployment Exchanges. So the number of men who have finished their summer employment on the land has to be added to those who figure on those registers.
Another factor that must be observed is that there is a growing stringency noted in the Department in respect of depriving of benefits men who may have a couple of acres of land on which they may work at certain times of the year. I read in the newspapers a couple of days ago a statement which may be taken as the views of responsible men, and while it may contain considerable exaggeration, it is for somebody to disprove the exaggerations if they prove to be so. It is an appeal for British ex-Servicemen issued by the Southern Irish Loyalists' Relief Association. It is signed by the Duke of Portland, the Duke of Northumberland, the Marquis of Lansdowne, the Earl of Selborne, Lord Danesford, and Colonel J. Gretton, M.P. These gentlemen are not intimately associated with the condition of the unemployed in the Saorstát, but no doubt they are advised by men in the country who claim to be intimately associated and directly interested in the conditions of the unemployed ex-Servicemen. This particular statement is not one which is, on the face of it at any rate, antagonistic to the Government of the Free State. On the contrary, it shows evidence of friendliness.
Comment on this
They even go so far as to say this: "Considerable sums of public money have been expended by the Free State Government on relief works in an effort to alleviate some of the distress arising out of unemployment, but in the selection of applicants for work preference is, perhaps not unnaturally, given to men who have served in the Free State Army." They give some figures and it is to the figures I am asking the Minister to direct his attention. The statement says that "there are about 186,000 British ex-Servicemen in the Irish Free State, including some 18,000 in Dublin and 12,000 in the Cork area. Of these, approximately one-third are unemployed"—one-third of the 186,000. In the view of these people who are supplied with information from the ranks of the organised British ex-Servicemen there are 60,000 odd of them unemployed. I think it is possible that that is an exaggeration—how great an exaggeration I have no means of knowing. I do know, though, that many thousands who are not British ex-Servicemen are unemployed, and if we discount their estimate by 50 per cent. I have not the slightest doubt but that there remain in the neighbourhood of 50,000 unemployed men. While I say I have not the slightest doubt, I confess I can produce no evidence. No figures are available as to the complete extent of this problem. We know, however, that there are 26,000 registered, and we know that large numbers, because of their ineligibility for unemployment insurance, do not register. We know there are large numbers who have become out of benefit and who ceased to continue their registration.
This does not apply solely to the unskilled men. It may surprise some Deputies to learn, for instance, that outside the larger cities quite a considerable proportion of skilled tradesmen in the building trade are unemployed. I have the figures of the Amalgamated Society of Woodworkers, the percentage of unemployed from a number of the smaller towns of the country. It is appalling to learn that there are no less than 36 per cent. in Cobh of organised trade union woodworkers unemployed; in Dundalk 25 per cent.; Fermoy 28 per cent.; Droichead Nua and the Curragh 30 per cent., and Sligo 57 per cent. These figures are taken from the November Journal of the Amalgamated Society of Woodworkers. Even in the City of Dublin to-day—we cannot, I find, omit bricklayers from any discussion on unemployment—there are 71 unemployed bricklayers out of a total of 450, or 16 per cent. If that applies to skilled men in the building trade, how much more serious is it in respect of the unskilled men? If you take engineers and ironworkers generally unemployed and on short time, their position is very serious indeed. It is an unfortunate fact, but it is a fact, that there are certain classes of men who have been brought up and lived in that state of casualness, if I might so put it, where irregularity of employment is normal—men who work for a week and are off for three weeks, who then work, perhaps, for a month or six weeks, and are then off for another four or five weeks—and the irregularity of employment has inured them to all kinds of hardship and carelessness, if one likes to put it that way, as to their way of life.
But when you take the other class of men who have lived for years in fairly regular work, who might look upon it as fairly sure that they would have, perhaps, 35 to 45 weeks' regular work in the year—it might be enlightening to some Deputies to know that it is quite a fortunate workman who has 40 to 45 weeks' work in the year— those are the fortunate men. When we realise that men who, perhaps, for 20 years have lived in that state of regular work have come down now to long periods of enforced unemployment, with the demoralising effect that unemployment has when it is long continued, you can begin to realise some of the evils of this state of affairs, and the effect upon the stamina of the people that will result from it if it is not remedied.
I am emphasising in this case that, the Ministry having done everything they can do to promote employment and to assist in the creation of employment, there still remain the 22,000, or 50,000, or 60,000 of those various estimates. What do we expect these people to do for a livelihood? The majority of them, perhaps, certainly a very large proportion of them, are married men with dependants. How are they to live? They did prepare, through the aid of the compulsory insurance, for normal periods, or for the unemployment that might come in the normal course of industry, and the insurance has been eaten up. Very large numbers indeed, and growing numbers of people every week, are now out of benefit. Somebody has to answer the question how they are expected to live. They cannot borrow without pawning and without their furniture and clothing gradually finding its way surreptitiously to the pawnshop, hidden in the case of the respectable families not used to visiting pawnshops. The furniture and clothing gradually disappear. The house is not as pleasant-looking as it was, nor as comfortable as it was, in good times, and other places become more attractive.
They cannot borrow, I say, because they can give no security. Their trade societies have exhausted their benefits. We are not going to ask them, I hope, to resort to the poor relief schemes, or to the workhouse. That surely, we will agree, is their last resort, and many of them would prefer anything to doing it. Foolish men, nevertheless they do it. We dare not suggest that they should steal. And what do we suggest? Charity? Again we cannot ask 50,000 men to go begging.
I know of no other method that will retain men's self-respect, that will have fewer evil consequences, if any, than the continuance of unemployment insurance benefit to men while they are unemployed. The Minister will tell us that the Fund cannot stand it, that it would be no longer insurance. Well, it may not be. It can be replenished by grants, and can be put in funds. If the evil that has to be remedied and prevented, that fund can be put within a reasonable possibility of being made solvent; it may have to be made up by a definite grant, as distinct from an advance. But however it is made up, or in whatever way, I think it is undoubtedly deplorable that the Ministry have come to the conclusion not to extend unemployment insurance benefits.
I can see no alternative to condemning the action of the Government in this matter unless and until they can find the means to provide employment for unemployed workmen. I said nothing about unemployed women. I am told that they are growing in numbers, notwithstanding the successful efforts in respect of one or two industries. I shall not say any more on this matter because I should like to know what the Ministry have to say in defence of its position as indicated by the Minister for Industry and Commerce yesterday. I can only think of it as a decision, though it was not put in that straightforward fashion. He said he was not prepared to recommend the extension because the Fund was in debt. I hope I misread his answer and I hope he will be able to tell us that that was not the decision, but that on the contrary they have decided to introduce at the earliest stage a Bill which will provide continued benefit for unemployed workmen. I beg to move the motion.
Comment on this
I beg to second the motion, and I think it is well worthy of note that when such a vital problem as unemployment is under discussion that less than a dozen Deputies of the Government Party think it worth their while to sit in this House. We had the Minister for Agriculture yesterday boasting of his sixty followers, and only one-fifth of that number can come along here to-day and sit in the House while the problem of unemployment, which goes to the root of the very existence of human beings, is under discussion. Unemployment and the measures to deal with unemployment and the steps to be taken to deal with unemployment have been under consideration in the Dáil for quite a long time.
Notwithstanding all the consideration and notwithstanding the statements of Ministers and Deputies of the Government Party that the prospects of employment are better, that trade is improving and that the prospects of employment are likely to brighten, we find that unemployment is worse to-day than ever it was in any period during the last four years. The Minister may quote figures to disprove what I am saying, but I am going to ask the House to subject the problem of unemployment to one simple test. That test is—is it more easy to-day for an unemployed man to get a job than it was four years ago? Take any unemployed man in the streets and ask him whether he finds it easier to-day to get work than at any time during the past four years. That, in my opinion, is the only reliable test which can be applied to the present situation. If that test is applied, I venture to say that in every instance the answer will be that it is much more difficult to-day to secure employment than it has been at any time in the past four years.
The local authorities in Dublin and throughout the Saorstát are being deluged with deputations of people asking them to do this, that and the other thing with a view to relieving unemployed workers. When asked to do something to relieve unemployment, local authorities find, before anything can be done for the relief of unemployment, that money is necessary, and money to-day is not available to local authorities to carry out many of the schemes which they could carry out if the money were available.
There is no better example of that than on the question of housing. Let any local authority endeavour to borrow money from the Irish banks for housing and they will find that it is practically impossible to get money. That is the experience of many local authorities, and not only in regard to housing but in regard to other matters as well. We are approaching the Christmas season, the season that ought to be for every person a season of joy and happiness. We are approaching it with tens of thousands of workers unemployed and with no funds available from which grants could be made for relief purposes.
When the Housing Act of 1926 was being discussed here I suggested that a loan of about ten millions might be raised, that figure being half the amount that certain Deputies promised the electors of North Dublin would be raised if two Government nominees were returned. At the time I made that suggestion the President pooh-poohed the idea of raising a loan; he said it was impracticable and a dangerous thing. The House might take note of the fact that the talk of raising a loan is becoming more general now, although there has been no change in the industrial or economic situation; there is no change beyond the fact that an election is likely to be held in the near future. I am still convinced, and I have heard no arguments to the contrary, that a loan to deal with the problem of unemployment is absolutely essential. I can see no other satisfactory way in which money can be raised. If we have a small national debt, and certain Deputies of the Government Party take pride in that fact, surely there ought to be very little hesitation in increasing that debt. Even if the national debt were increased by 100 per cent. it would still be very much lower than the national debt of any other country in Europe, or for that matter in the world.
I am of opinion that the only satisfactory way in which we can deal with unemployment is to make money available so that employment can be given. On that point I suggest that employment should not be confined to certain phases of work—for instance, drainage or road work—because in certain areas there may be no drainage needed, and in other areas local authorities may consider that the roads do not need attention. I suggest to the Minister for Industry and Commerce that this matter can be tackled in a satisfactory and economic way if the Government raise a substantial loan and make money available for use by local authorities at easy rates so that the local authorities, scattered as they are throughout the Saorstát, can each undertake work of a constructive kind in the area under their jurisdiction. If that were done I venture to think the local authorities would be prepared to borrow the money on reasonable terms, and with that borrowed money they could put into operation schemes of work which would do a good deal to relieve the unemployment that exists.
Deputy Johnson has referred to the need for the restoration of continuous unemployment benefit. I also desire to favour that. I think it is preferable— and I think Deputy Johnson agrees with me—that, if possible, work should be provided for these people; but if work is not available the minimum that should be conceded is the restoration of uncovenanted benefit. We have had experience of this unemployment problem for four years. During the period this Government has been in power employment has got less and less, men have got hungrier and hungrier, and children are feeling more and more the pinch of unemployment which their parents are forced to endure.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce thinks that the solvency of the Unemployment Insurance Fund is a very desirable thing. No doubt that may be so in normal times, but I suggest there is now something more important than the solvency of the Unemployment Insurance Fund, and that is the saving of men and women and helpless children from the poverty and destitution which inevitably follow in the wake of idleness. I suggest to the Minister, in conclusion, that he should not pay so much attention to the solvency of the Unemployment Insurance Fund; he should pay much more attention to the saving of men, women and children from the poverty and misery which they have been compelled to endure for the past four years.
Comment on this
I wish to join in this protest against the Government's inadequate efforts to deal with the unemployment question and, further, to state that the speeches, to which we have just listened in support of the motion, practically repeated a case made here last June. From last June until to-day nothing has been done for the unemployed or their dependants and, as Labour members have stated, unemployment has been on the increase. I must be careful as regards the words I use, so that I will not say that men are being put out of the Army, but I do say that a small number are being demobilised weekly—time-expired men— and they are being added to the unemployed list, with not even stamped cards. I have a letter here, one of the latest I have received, and it is as follows:—
"Dear Alderman Byrne, —Some time in September I wrote asking you to help me to get employment. Since then I heard nothing. As you are aware, I am a married man with a wife and four children, aged from one-and-a-half to twelve years. I was discharged last March from the National Army, time-expired, after three years and eight months' service; I am not getting any unemployment money or pension, and I do not know in God's name what to do."
That is only one of the bagful of letters which I could produce from married men with families in which they say that they do not know, in God's name, what to do to provide the ordinary means of livelihood for their wives and children. I notice in this morning's papers an announcement by a public authority that, as the fuel shortage has been unsatisfactorily dealt with, they are prepared to give to poor persons— they do not say working-classes—a bag of coal at certain depots on the production of five shillings. Some of these poor persons have not seen five shillings for the past two years. The man to whom I have referred says that he has had no unemployment benefit since his discharge from the Army. When did he last see five shillings? I think the time has arrived for the Government to face this problem and make up their minds that there is a duty cast upon them to save the women and children of this country from the hardships which, personally, I know they are enduring in the slums of Dublin to-day.
In O'Connell Street you can see the barefooted child coming back amongst us. We had hoped that the barefooted child which had been provided for during the period of the war would not return, but to-day you can see barefooted children parading the principal streets. They do not beg, they are simply trying to get away from the destitution that surrounds them in the slums. According to the Unemployed Register, there are 22,496 persons unemployed. You could multiply that number by three, or probably five, to ascertain the number of dependants of the unemployed, and you would find that you would have practically from seventy-five thousand to a hundred thousand dependants who are hoping that some day the Government will wake up and do its duty towards them. There is another class of which I frequently hear. I refer to young persons, boys and girls, whose ages range from sixteen to twenty-one years, who are not allowed to register, but from the day that they left school they have not, as a result of bad trade, been able to get any kind of employment. The unfortunate parents of these boys and girls are deserving of the sympathy of every member of this House. They do not know what to do or where to turn to get employment for their children. If you add that number of young people who reach the age of sixteen and who leave school every year, say, for the past four or five years, with no outlet for their energy or brains, you will get a substantial increase in the number of unemployed.
On a previous occasion in connection with this question I drew attention to the wholesale dumping of foreign goods in Dublin. In the woollen trade I am told that thirty-three per cent. of the workers are unemployed. In the printing trade we had a meeting a few nights ago in the Mansion House and it was stated that practically twentyfive per cent. of the members of that trade are idle. You can go to the North Wall any morning and see the wholesale dumping of printed matter. Go to any book-shop, ask to buy an ordinary prayer-book, and you will find that it has been printed and bound either in Belgium or Germany. You see handsome posters on the hoardings of the city, but these are printed in London or Glasgow. No effort is made to stop these coming in so as to provide work for a deserving class of unemployed persons. As a result of the appeal made to-day, I hope that the Minister for Industry and Commerce will make some effort, even only a temporary one, to alleviate the suffering of the unemployed and give them some that the coming Christmas will not be as dark as those of the past few years. I earnestly trust that the Government will make up its mind and do something quickly.
Comment on this
I suppose that in discussing this motion we cannot look for a lot of sympathy; it comes up so regularly the Government Party are getting tired of it. They only speak about unemployment when they are in the country gulling the workers. Deputy Norton referred to the few members who thought it worth their while to sit here while Deputy Johnson was introducing the motion. That is not strange. Last Friday night there was a meeting called in Newbridge by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party to discuss means of alleviating unemployment in the district. How many turned up to show their sympathy with the unemployed? Two or three, and they went away without finding out how they would alleviate unemployment. That is the situation all over the country so far as the Cumann na nGaedheal Party are concerned. They do not give one damn about the unemployed. Yesterday I had a question on the Order Paper asking the Minister for Local Government to start work in connection with the widening of the bridge over the Liffey at Newbridge, but I was told that that was not an urgent case.
Urgency in relieving unemployment is not an urgency of which the Government will be guilty, though I must say they have given employment to about 350 men in South Kildare who are standing up to their knees in the swamps of the Barrow at the miserable wage of thirty shillings a week. These men have been debarred from being insured under the Unemployment Insurance scheme. That has been done in order to cheapen the estimates for the Barrow drainage. There are about three thousand persons unemployed in Kildare and no relief schemes have been put forward there in the last two or three years. Very little money has been spent in North Kildare either in the Carbury, Ballymore, Celbridge or Leixlip districts. I ask the Minister to provide some relief for the unemployed in those districts. From our experience here in the last three or four years, I am afraid we will get very little satisfaction. In view of the general election, I think it would be wise if the Government would realise their responsibility in the matter, otherwise I hope that the workers will have more sense than they had on the last occasion.
Comment on this
Some time ago when reading reports of speeches made by Ministers, a statement was credited to the President, I think in Cork, in which he said that the country had at last turned the corner. Having in mind the state of my constituency, I was wondering whether the President meant it to be understood that the country was on the way to bankruptcy or national prosperity. If the condition of things in my constituency now is compared with its state at any time during the last three or four years, I say that down there we have turned the corner towards bankruptcy and not towards prosperity. I would be very glad if I could agree with the statement made by the President. I am sorry that I cannot do so. I think it is the duty of every Deputy to state frankly what the situation is in his constituency.
Deputy Johnson has drawn the attention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to a statement made by some British nobleman regarding the number of British ex-Servicemen who are unemployed in the Irish Free State. The individual who made that statement may have been unfriendly towards the Ministry in the past, but there is plenty of evidence, from what we saw of recent happenings in London, to show that the enemies of the past are the friends of to-day. Therefore, we may take the statement attributed to the Duke of Northumberland and other distinguished noblemen in England as having some relation to facts that exist regarding British ex-Servicemen. If the position is such as was stated, it is a very serious one——
Comment on this
That was the statement, and I am surprised that it came to the total of 186,000 in the Free State.
Comment on this
It states that one-third of the British ex-Servicemen in the Free State are unemployed at present.
Comment on this
I take it that the President, who has been recently in the company of the Duke's friends in London, knows something about it.
Comment on this
I think the statement should be dealt with in a serious way and, if the Minister has figures at his disposal, he should contradict it. I would be glad if the Minister could give his reasons, and contradict such a statement. The Minister stated that many measures had been undertaken by the Government to deal with the unemployment problem. As far as I could follow the statement made last night, it was to the effect that the position to-day is much better than it was twelve months ago. Speaking from what I know, I emphatically contradict that, and Deputies from my constituency on the Government benches, who are not now in the Dáil, will, I hope, come in before the debate concludes and contradict me if I am wrong. I have received numerous communications from portions of my constituency asking that influence should be used to secure grants for the relief of unemployment in localities where distress is acute. I have had to reply to these communications stating that as far as I knew no money was available for the relief of distress.
A considerable amount of money was set aside last year by the Minister for Finance for relief schemes, as a result of which hundreds of men were engaged in work of a useful nature. We are now only five or six weeks from Christmas and, up to the present, there has been no indication that anything of that kind will be done this year. I can promise the Minister, if he can tell the Dáil this evening, before the debate concludes, that funds for work of a similar nature will be available before Christmas, that so far as my constituency is concerned, schemes will be put up, and they have already been put up, to absorb a certain amount of such money, and give useful employment at this critical period to hundreds of people.
In Leix, one of the counties in my constituency, there are only 23 men employed on normal road maintenance work over 1,100 miles, and on last Saturday the County Council had only £511 to credit for road maintenance work for the remaining twenty weeks of the financial year. I think the Minister will agree that that is a serious state of affairs, especially when he takes into consideration the fact that the normal road maintenance work in this county gave employment to about 300 men. I visited the constituency and saw the material on the roadside, but unless money is available the work cannot be carried on for the remaining twenty weeks of this financial year. I believe a scheme was sent to the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government asking for a grant of £15,000 to enable work of that kind to be completed in areas where unemployment was most acute.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce, and probably other Ministers, may say that 2,000 men are engaged on the Shannon scheme, and some hundreds in the beet factory at Carlow. As far as Leix and Offaly are concerned there is a considerable acreage under beet but very little employment will be given to unemployed workers in that area in the factory. I saw a communication from one of the managers of the factory, in which he stated that there were six applications for every vacancy in the factory. The employment given there will be only for three months and it was indicated—and I sympathise with the policy of the firm—that it was the intention of the directors of the factory to give employment to suitable applicants in Carlow urban and rural areas. That means that while beet may be grown to a considerable extent in Wexford, Leix and Offaly and North and Mid-Tipperary very little employment will be provided for unemployed workers in the beet factory. To that extent the Carlow beet factory does not relieve the unemployment that exists in my constituency. Deputy Colohan referred to the employment given on the Barrow at Athy, and to the conditions under which they were working, and the wage they were receiving. I should like to draw the attention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to another aspect of that matter. I understand that the wheelbarrows used by the workers have been imported from outside the country. I wonder what the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has to say to that?
Comment on this
He may not have been consulted. I give him credit also for the fact that if he were consulted he would probably be able to find, as the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Industry and Commerce could have found, factories and works in this country that could provide wheelbarrows for this work. The Minister for Local Government is compelling the local councils to purchase whatever they may require for the County Homes and other administrative institutions through the Trade Department. I wonder why he did not intervene in this case and give the carpenters of Wicklow or somewhere else a few weeks' work in making wheelbarrows, instead of sending to America or elsewhere for them. These things count when we come to the question of relieving unemployment. A few weeks' work could at least be given to a few carpenters in the Free State if the wheelbarrows were not imported from America, as I understand they have been.
What is really occurring in my constituency is this, and I hope the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs will pay attention to it: the people who are engaged in tillage, who are producing the wealth of the country, are selling below the cost of production, and instead of there being more prosperity as a result of increased tillage they are facing bankruptcy without any hope of relief. Potatoes, for instance, are being sold by farmers in the Midlands at five-pence and sixpence per stone, while in Blackrock, Williamstown, Dun Laoghaire and the City of Dublin they are being retailed at 1s. 7d. The result is that the tillage farmer, the person that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is interested in, and that the Minister for Agriculture should be interested in, is unable to find a market at an economic price for his produce, and he cannot give employment without having such a market. Failing to find a market at a reasonable price, he is being put into the position that he cannot give the employment that he was able to give formerly. The tillage farmers in my constituency have been in that position for the last three or four years. They have now come to the end of their tether. They have been drawing on their resources for the last three or four years and now they have no resources to fall back upon, with the result that hundreds of agricultural workers are without employment who would have work if the position of the tillage farmers was looked after. The Minister for Agriculture may smile. He knows the reasons well, because they have been explained to him on several occasions. He may wake up to a realisation of the situation when it is too late for him to come to their assistance.
Deputy Byrne referred to the fact that his attache case was filled with applications from persons looking for employment. We are all unfortunately in that position. In my twenty years' knowledge of Dublin, I have never experienced anything like the pitiable appeals made to-day for jobs for men out of work. I do not think it is the duty of a Deputy to go round to influential people looking for jobs for men out of work. It is the responsibility of the Government to prepare and undertake schemes which will find employment at this time of the year, at any rate, for the largest number of available men suitable for such employment. Such schemes can be produced in my constituency if the Minister will find the money for them. I am not supporting this motion for the purpose of asking the Government to provide doles, because I know that work of a useful nature can be undertaken if the money is forthcoming. The Government is proceeding to set this State on what they call a firm foundation by a policy of reducing the purchasing power of the community. They will have to look in the other direction, and they will be forced to realise before long that their policy is a wrong one. Deputy Johnson referred to the unemployment that existed in the building trades. I was recently informed that a number of building schemes in the Fairview and Marino district had been stopped since the storm. As a result of that, probably the figures and percentages given by Deputy Johnson would be increased.
Comment on this
The general tendency in my constituency and in neighbouring constituencies at present is for the young men in the country districts to drift into the cities and towns, otherwise they are doing their best to get away to America or some other foreign country. If the country has turned the corner on the road to prosperity, that certainly is not an indication of it. To-day we passed a Bill through its final stages, and probably as a result of it we will have a state of national emergency proclaimed. I have been studying the situation seriously for the last two or three years and I can assert that the unemployed workers here are the most law-abiding citizens to be found in any country. They have tolerated this state of privation and destitution far too long and I would not blame them for resorting to any kind of tactics that would rouse the Government out of the sleepy condition in which they are at present. I have never regarded it as my duty to come here and exaggerate the condition of the area I represent. I see no ray of hope whatever in that area unless something is done for the producers of wealth that will enable them to give more employment to the agricultural workers, who were employed in far greater numbers three or four years ago.
Let us look at the situation from one point of view. Three years ago we had in the National Army 50,000 men who could find no other kind of work. To-day there are only 15,000 men in the Army. Can any Deputy say that the men demobilised from the Army, representing the difference between 50,000 and 15,000, have been absorbed into some form of employment? Personally I cannot say they have been. Therefore, to that extent the situation is worse to-day than it was three years ago. I could deal with other aspects of the situation which might not come within the terms of the resolution but which have a considerable effect on the unemployment problem. I support the resolution for the purpose of asking the Government to bring in a vote for relief schemes that will enable the local authorities in Leix and Offaly to give employment on schemes that are necessary and that will be a lasting benefit to the people of the locality. The schemes are ready—some of them have been put forward; some of them are in the Department of Finance and others in the Department of Local Government. Let the Government supply the money, and then the schemes can go ahead. If that is done there will be an improvement in the position as I see it to-day, and the position in my constituency is utterly hopeless from every point of view.
Comment on this
Those of us who have sat here for the last three years know that unemployment has been very frequently discussed in this House, and it is rather sad at this time in the life of the present Dáil that we find ourselves again dealing with the subject and having to confess that very little progress has been made in the situation. I am glad the President is in his place, because he was in Cork recently. I am going to deal with the position from the facts as I see them and as I know them in the part of the country that I come from, and I take it that that reflects the position all over the country. The President toured the constituency that I represent; he had the advantage of seeing the best parts of it, and he was not in touch perhaps there with the part of the county where the position is at its worst. But I doubt whether throughout his tour he had made one single stop without finding the case as regards unemployment put up to him. I do not know whether that is a fact, but I know it ought to be the fact in view of the position that exists there.
Public assistance affairs in Cork are administered by a Local Government Department Commissioner. He has found it absolutely impossible to deal with the applications for home assistance put up to him at the present time. And he has had to ask the local authorities in the county to co-operate with him in putting the section of the Local Government Act that provides for relief of able-bodied destitute people, into operation. In one area in South Cork he is looking for a loan of £14,000 to relieve distress, a great portion of which has already been spent by him in exceeding his estimates. The same will have to be done with regard to the North Cork area and the West Cork area, with the result that local taxation will be simply unbearable if the needs of the people are to be met locally.
The Commissioner is powerless to deal with the position; he is dealing with it as well as he can, and I am glad to pay this tribute to him and to say that he is doing his best. Is it not very sad to be faced with conditions in the county at the present time, that the local authorities are being asked to help in framing a joint scheme of outdoor relief? I have here some documentary evidence in support of the arguments I am putting forward. I have a letter from a clergyman in one of the islands in the constituency I represent. He is not a man to exaggerate the position. He simply states the facts that are in existence in his own place. He says:
"I have no hesitation in saying that, without immediate help, there will be starvation and deaths due to cold and hunger. In the interests of those poor and suffering specimens of humanity I would ask you to petition the Government or the powers that be to grant them a sum of money to tide them over the winter. I had a man lately who came to my house for a bit of bread who is out about the country at present trying to get a little money to help him to buy the necessaries of life. I go to those people and find them famishing with cold, and no fuel whatever to burn. It is pitiable to see their little ones without a boot or stocking in such terrible cold weather as we experience here. The shopkeepers have told me that if something is not done immediately to relieve those unfortunate people Skibbereen and West Schull will be stormed with beggars during the winter. I do not doubt if the Government really understood the dire distress of the people of this island, that a grant would be given to relieve those unfortunate islanders. I have seen old people crying with cold and hunger, and if there is a spark of humanity amongst the rulers of the country it is up to them to show us sympathy and consideration in the hour of need."
Then he goes on to mention the works of one kind or another that could be done. What has occurred here is similar to what has occurred in many other places—though, perhaps, this is one of the worst districts. There is very considerable distress, though not, perhaps, to that extent, obtaining elsewhere. I have heard decent people in the town I am living in declaring that they had no food for a day-and-a-half and asking for a note to the Home Assistance Officer in order that they may get temporary assistance. It is an awful position, and we would be lacking in our duties if we did not endeavour to call attention to this evil, having regard to the fact that it might be said the real position is not known. I know what the position will be in that area during the winter.
In many parts of the constituency that I represent, certainly in four or five extensive districts, the potato crop is practically a failure. The people have no fuel for the winter. The turf has been cut and taken away to Cork and other places. I leave it to deputies and to the Government to try and picture what the situation will be in these circumstances. There are a number of cases of acute distress in the Castletownbere district. The worst cases, perhaps, are those of people slightly ibetter off in position than agricultural labourers. There are a number of small farmers with one, two, or three cows who are unable to obtain home assistance because they are farmers, and these men are starving at the present time. Decrees from the Land Commission for the non-payment of annuities, and from the banks and shopkeepers, are hanging over their heads. That is the position in that area, and that is the position that obtains all over the peninsula.
The Minister for Local Government will say, so far as Cork County is concerned, that a very considerable amount of money is available for road work. So it is. But the local authority has cut down the estimates for the road work by 50 per cent. I believe that is unwise and I believe it is wrong, but it is a fact, and the ordinary road staff of the County Council has been reduced to a considerable extent.
We were discussing the other day at a meeting of the County Council the amount of money that would be available for work in the future, and both the County Surveyors inform us that they have entirely too many applications for the work that they can give. A good deal of this money will be spent by contract. Many formalities have to be complied with yet, and it will be some time before the money is available, and what I am trying to urge now on the House is that in Cork, as everywhere else, there is need for procuring something immediately. I very strongly urge on the Government the need for doing something between now and Christmas. A great many people are giving up hope. I was at a meeting last Sunday and some person there, a victim, apparently, of what I have described, asked: What was the use of talking, things were going from bad to worse. That represents the view of a great many affected people at the present time. I am satisfied that the members of the Government are not, perhaps, entirely aware of the position in many parts of the country. If they are, then I am very much amazed. I urge that something should be cone quickly, between this and Christmas, because, in my opinion, we are going to have the hardest winter we have had for a very long time. We are, I fear, going to have a shortage of food as well as a shortage of fuel, and in addition, a shortage of employment. All this is making the people desperate, and if there is going to be any hope for the people of this country then this question must be tackled at once. I urge that it be tackled not in a grudging but in a generous manner. I trust that some message of hope will be given tu the people that this serious question is to be dealt with at once.
Comment on this
As one of the representatives of Dublin I desire to join in urging on the Government to give further consideration to the question of unemployment, and particularly as it affects the City of Dublin. For some time I have been in communication with the City Commissioners on the matter of their providing works or schemes which would give some relief to those unemployed. As a result of the communications that have passed between the Commissioners and the Local Government Department, a deputation waited on the Minister for Finance last week, when a number of schemes were put up which, if carried into effect, would be of considerable improvement to the city. I understand that a conference took place afterwards, but I have not heard the result of it. At any rate the City Commissioners, I believe, are most anxious to do something to meet this problem which they are confronted with day after day, but as they have no funds available they are unable to cope with it as they would desire. I think the method employed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Local Government to ascertain the number of unemployed in the city and in the country generally needs to be remedied to some extent for this reason: I for one dispute the argument that unemployment is not as bad in the city now as it has been for some years. When there is a difference of opinion with the Government and Deputies who are urging this point, there ought to be some other method, I think, of ascertaining the number. Personally, I would be delighted to know that unemployment was not as grave as has been represented. If the Government considered the schemes that I have referred to, it would be far better to adopt them than to be giving relief grants. I know that there is a certain objection to relief grants. At this time of the year, particularly around Christmas, it has been the custom to give relief grants in the city. Now, if there is an objection to that, some method ought, I think, to be employed by which local authorities could put schemes in hands when money was made available. Good results, I think, would follow from work undertaken in that way. I desire again to urge on the Government the consideration of the schemes that have been submitted to the City Commissioners. I believe that if money were made available to put these schemes into operation, good use would be made of it.
Comment on this
After the discussion that has taken place it ought to be manifest to the most unprejudiced Deputy that the position of unemployed workers in the country to-day is regrettable. Though I come from a part of a constituency which has had the advantage of getting a certain amount of employment in the erection of the beet factory, I must say with frankness that this undertaking has not provided work for all the unemployed people in the County Carlow. In Bagnalstown, which is about nine miles from Carlow, there are about fifty people who have been unemployed for a considerable time. I sought to get a waterworks scheme started there with a view to providing them with work, but when I went about the matter I found that the County Carlow Board of Health was not in a position to finance the scheme. We all know, of course, that the ratepayers of the country are at their wits' end to pay the rates demanded from them. The position in the City of Kilkenny is also very bad. If the President, when he goes down there, were to visit some of the back slums he would find many people with, I might say, nothing to exist on. I am inclined to call the Minister for Industry and Commerce the hard-hearted man. If he were to see the condition of things that exists there he would not say that we cannot get the money to provide relief for these people. After all, it is the health and happiness of the people that is to be considered, and that is the work that I consider a nation ought to engage on. We ought to see that our people are well fed, well clothed and well sheltered. The condition of things at present in parts of my constituency would make you believe that we were not far removed from primitive man. The people have no employment and no unemployment insurance.
In most of the rural parts of Kilkenny and Carlow, numbers of agricultural workers are to be found who are not entitled to draw unemployment insurance. These people are living lives of abject misery. There is no employment on the land for them. I do not blame the farmers for that, because they themselves are not getting reasonable prices for their produce. That such a condition of affairs exists is, of course, not surprising in view of the fact that we allow millions of tons of foreign barley and grain into our country. While we allow that, thousands of the sons and daughters of the people of the country have to leave and go to foreign parts to seek the living they cannot get at home. This is the position of affairs that confronts the Government at the moment. I ask that the Government do something in the way of providing relief schemes. Much employment, for instance, could be given by cutting bad turns on many of our roads, and by levelling steep hills that make it impossible for the people to draw their produce to home or market. Down in my constituency, too, there are many broken bridges that have been left derelict and that need to be reconstructed. Work of that kind would provide employment for a great number of people, and would help, to some extent at least, to relieve the present condition of affairs. There is widespread distress in the country, parts of which are rapidly becoming like a prairie. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture knows that there are thousands of acres of land in the counties of Carlow and Kilkenny which, if divided, would provide much-needed employment for the rural workers. Because that is not being done the rural workers are rushing into the towns and cities where many of the people at the moment are living lives not lit lor human beings. In Tullow, in the Co. Carlow, you have at present forty or fifty people who are not eligible to draw unemployment insurance, and at the same time there is no work for them to do. We hear catch-cries from some parties in this country asking, "Why do not the people work," and stating that there is plenty of work for them to do. In regard to that, I can say that if someone will come along and tell me that they have work to be done, I can provide four or five hundred people who are prepared to take up the challenge. I sincerely hope that something will be done to provide work for the people. In my constituency we have got no money at all for any relief schemes. Some persons seem to think that the beet factory in Carlow would provide employment for all the people in that county. I can tell the Dáil that nine or ten per cent. of the people employed in the beet factory are from other counties. The building of the factory is not going to last for a lifetime. I sincerely hope that something will be done to provide work for the people or to give them maintenance.
Comment on this
I feel like agreeing with the last speaker that "it must be apparent to the most unprejudiced Deputy that the position of the unemployed is deplorable," but I would go a little further in defining in what respects it is deplorable. It is deplorable mainly in the fact that the people who are supposed to put up a case to show "that there is widespread and continued unemployment" have failed to produce any facts. That is the most deplorable feature of the whole unemployment situation to-day. Let me take the three people who have dealt with it. Deputy Johnson simply says that the only thing that has happened since some date last June is that there has been an increase in the number of men who have no means of livelihood. That is his statement.
Deputy Davin says that if anybody said there is less employment now than a year ago he contradicts him. Deputy Norton is the only member who advanced a test. What is the test? That it is as hard now to get a job as at any time in the last four years. That is the net sum of evidence with regard to unemployment in the country. I got one item of information from Deputy Johnson with regard to organised wood-workers. I did not gather by whom those figures were put together.
Comment on this
On that I have one simple test, but I do not want to rule out all trade union statistics on account of it. I was sent by, I think, the Secretary to the Trade Union Council Executive a statement about a year ago with regard to unemployment in three places. The only place that comes to my memory is Ferrycarrig. I compared these figures with the census returns, and I found there were more unemployed by 50 per cent. than there-were people living in the districts. These were the trade union figures supplied to me with regard to three small places. There has been no attempt to deal with this matter in a serious way.
Comment on this
No serious attempt has been made to put up a case with regard to this question that I can deal with. I am told by Deputy Johnson that the only change has been that there has been an increase in the number of men who have not the means of livelihood. Deputy Davin is prepared to contradict me when I say that there is less unemployment than a year ago. Deputy Norton faces me with a test— is it as easy now to get work? My own employment exchanges placed in the six months, May to October, 8,300 in employment.
Comment on this
Let us take up the test as to easiness to get posts. There have been 8,300 placed.
Comment on this
That is not part of Deputy Norton's test. That is going to get us into other figures. I have no idea of the rise and fall of these things because of one reason, and one reason only, and that is the failure of the unemployed to register through the means provided.
Comment on this
I do not know how many branch exchanges there are, but there is a considerable number of them, and the administration of the Unemployment Insurance Acts plus the State contribution costs this country something like 75 per cent. of the total Vote given for my Department by this Dáil. There is even a certain amount of leave given to register by post. Notwithstanding that I am told the unemployment register as a criterion of the number employed in the country at any date is not reliable. I am not going to say that it presents a complete picture, but if it does not the fact is due as much, and even more, to the unemployed than to anybody else. We give every facility possible within the money at our disposal. The administration expenses of our unemployment insurance code are high, but facilities are given within the moneys allowed. If the unemployed do not fill up the registration forms that is not my fault. I cannot be expected to go round and seek out the unemployed in every area.
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson says further he thinks it will be admitted, or rather that no one will deny, I think, is the phrase, that we view with anxiety the continuance of widespread and prolonged unemployment. A very general statement, but the implication is not to be neglected without proof or attempt at evidence that there is widespread and prolonged unemployment, while Deputy Davin says that there is more unemployment to-day than a year ago.
Comment on this
The ordinary course with regard to a statement is that the person who makes the statement proves his case, or makes a prima facie case, and then there is a rebuttal.
Comment on this
I go further and say that the ordinary course of evidence is that when a person is in a particularly privileged position, and has access to documents, the rule of evidence turns about and the person with the documents should be asked to make the case. My documents are known to Deputy Johnson. I quoted figures from the Exchange, and I made the simple statement the other day when I was speaking on the industrial insured only that the position to-day is better than a year ago. I simply take two or three things into consideration. There have been at least a few thousand extra men employed in tariff industries over last year, and that about this time last year there may have been 300 employed on the Shannon Scheme while there are 2,500 now, and there are about 400 employed on the Beet Sugar Factory. These things alone are sufficient reason for me to say that the position to-day with regard to unemployment is better than last year.
Comment on this
Why cannot the Deputy keep himself in a department? I spoke only of the industrial insured people, or such agricultural people as are brought into such things as the Shannon Scheme or the Beet Sugar Scheme—I will leave the Barrow out of these calculations. Deputy Colohan contributed a further item, and when the phrase is used, "men willing to work and not able to find it," we know that it means willing to work on conditions and rates which are considered the standard and which some union has made for them. That is an addition which must be made in the future when it is said that there are people willing to work and cannot get it.
Comment on this
Does the Minister contend that the workers on the Barrow are satisfied with 30/- a week?
Comment on this
I want to get clear as to where we are. We are told, and a piteous appeal is made for them, that people are anxious to work and not able to find it, but we now find brought in as an argument backing that statement up that there is a certain number of people engaged in the Barrow at 30/- a week. Incidentally our abused Shannon Scheme might easily have had good effect up around the Barrow area.
Comment on this
We got, further, a statement from Deputy Johnson that the measures are inadequate. I waited to hear proof of that.
Comment on this
The measures are inadequate! I am facing the resolution which states that the measures are inadequate.
Comment on this
You are facing nothing. You are quibbling with words. It is scandalous and callous treatment of hungry people in this country.
Comment on this
I am facing the unemployment situation as put up by the representatives of the unemployed.
Comment on this
If we are going to have a debate conducted on the lines of——
Comment on this
We want no more quibbling. Deal with the situation, as it should be dealt with, like a Christian.
Comment on this
In regard to the inadequacy of the measures, there was one measure referred to on which there was some comment as to inadequacy— housing. Somebody put up the proposition that Local Authorities had not been allowed to spend money on housing schemes in their areas.
Comment on this
I may point out that I made the remark in connection with housing that the Local Authorities could not get money for housing. The Minister is not entitled to misrepresent the case I made.
Comment on this
Inadequacy with regard to the question of housing! They could not get money! From whom? From the Government?
Comment on this
From the banks. You know perfectly well. If the Minister does not, the Government knows it.
Comment on this
From the banks! Very definitely the single item put forward here is that the banks are the people who are holding up housing schemes in local areas. That is put forward here as a complaint against the Government regarding the measures.
Comment on this
It is a complaint in regard to your inactivity, and rightly so.
Comment on this
I will tell you. I will go on in my own way or I will not go on at all.
Comment on this
The Deputy is assisting me in my desires because he is interrupting so much I can very easily stop. There have been adequate measures which the local authorities have not been able to avail of. I have here certain information about road schemes. For 26 counties in the country a sum of £652,000 has been allocated to county councils.
Comment on this
That £652,000 is to be paid over to the county councils as soon as the work is completed. If the work is completed to-morrow the money will be paid.
Comment on this
I must ask Deputies to refrain from interrupting the Minister. They will get an opportunity of replying to the Minister's statement.
Comment on this
This is unwelcome talk. There are 26 counties which have received £650,000, and they have only been able to spend
Comment on this
It is not the case that the money is not available or that the unemployed are not available. I want to make the conjunction between the two things. I wonder does the Deputy refer to his own case. He came forward with a scheme for tarring roads in wet weather which would have been a most unbusinesslike proposition.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not have read the scheme he brought forward, but that is what it amounted to. There was a sum of £650,000 at the disposal of the county councils for a national road scheme. That is divided amongst 27 local authorities.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy should restrain himself and try to have an answer to the set of figures that are being put to him. Can the Deputy give me an answer to this? As far as Government assistance is concerned the Government has done apparently more than the people can absorb; they have at least sanctioned payment and the money is ready to be paid out the moment schemes are put up. Of the £650,000 allocated only £70,000 has been availed of.
Comment on this
I challenge the Minister to disprove, notwithstanding all he claims for the Government, that there are more unemployed in the coun try than there was at any time since the Free State came into power.
Comment on this
The Minister is not concluding the debate. He is merely intervening in the debate, and if eight Deputies make a speech on a particular side surely another Deputy is entitled to speak on the other side. When the Minister has concluded Deputy Morrissey can speak. If Deputies do not agree with the Minister they can speak after him, but if they prevent him from speaking it simply leads to the conclusion that they do not want to hear him. Surely they raised this matter in order to hear him and not to prevent him from being heard.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I might point out that this motion was put down to have a discussion on this matter. We thought the Government was prepared to deal with the matter seriously. If the Minister is prepared to deal with the matter seriously he will get all the order and all the respect he is entitled to, but if the Minister seeks to deal with the matter in a flippant, sneering, cynical manner, we are not going to sit down here to listen to it.
Comment on this
I have not heard sufficient of the Minister to know what kind of speech he is making, but I think it would be better for us to hear him for a certain time now and let us judge whether he is serious or not. He may have points to make which have not been reached yet and which cannot be reached unless he is allowed to proceed. If the Minister is in order he must be allowed to speak.
Comment on this
I presume also that when I am going to be allowed to speak, you are to judge when I am to be interrupted and not Deputy Morrissey. To get back to this Road Fund, there is money waiting for the unemployed, more than the county councils have been able to absorb, and as long as this £570,000 is still available out of moneys for which sanction has been given—there is £1,260,000 to be spent on these roads alone—I cannot see that there has been no adequate provision for the relief of unemployment. Deputy Davin has spoken of the Leix district and says there is only £500 in hands. I understood him to say for ordinary road maintenance work on a certain date——
Comment on this
That, of course, has nothing to do with the money to which I am referring, but I wonder would Deputy Davin have any knowledge of what the Leix Council did when they were striking the rate, and as to whether they acted in accordance with what the Surveyor thought would be necessary for the maintenance of the roads. They cut it down, I understand.
Comment on this
As regards that, it was turned down by the Council and not through any interference from the Local Government Department.
Comment on this
Without any interference from the Local Government Department, although they knew it could not meet the situation as far as the normal maintenance work was concerned.
Comment on this
So that the County Council is directly responsible for the fact that there is only £511 there.
Comment on this
Might I intervene to ask the Minister does he think that these trunk roads are run to to suit the unemployed in every district and to absorb all that money?
Comment on this
I can make this point: that when only such a small amount as £70,000 out of a grant of £652,000 has been availed of, nobody can say that the Government is at fault in the matter of the big unemployment in any of these counties.
Comment on this
The Minister knows that the trunk roads are run at every disadvantage to tap centres of unemployment, and that the trunk roads can not be run through all places where unemployment exists.
Comment on this
I may make a suggestion to the Minister, and it is that he should move the closure; there is no other method for arriving at a decision in this matter.
Comment on this
I have given Deputies on this side of the House as much liberty as they are entitled to, and more liberty than they are entitled to under the rules of the House, and they will have to respect the Chair. Deputy Hogan knows that he will have an opportunity of speaking later. He has not spoken yet, but the only method of conducting a debate is to listen to a speech and make another speech against it.
There can be no such thing as a debate on unemployment unless the Minister for Industry and Commerce is allowed to make a speech. There can be no debate on unemployment by means of questions, not asking for information but inviting the Minister to make a statement of some kind. If Deputies do not want a debate, then we can conclude. If they do want the debate, I put it to their own good sense that the Minister must be allowed to proceed. A motion has been made to sit late. We can sit late and we can hear what everybody has to say. What is happening now is that we are hearing only one side. We have heard one side very fully. We should hear the other side now. It may not be very palatable, but at least it must be heard. That is what Deputies come here for. If we get into the position that a person speaking on a particular side is going to be continually interrupted by what is really a series of small speeches we cannot conduct the debate. I suggest to Deputies that I should be given an opportunity of hearing the Minister for Industry and Commerce myself and of making up my mind as to the tone of the Minister's speech of which complaint is made——
Comment on this
It is not in order to interrupt the Minister at all, even to ask him for information, but, as I said before, I am not against interruptions—they keep us awake. I have never been against interruptions. Whatever would Deputy Davin do if I had been against interruptions? I do not know. Deputy Davin and perhaps some of the members of the Ministry would have disappeared long ago.
Comment on this
The most intelligent form of interruption— I will put it like that—is, at the end of a speech, to ask questions for information, but to ask the Minister argumentative questions—it is obstruction. We are approaching now a position when we are not going to have any interruptions at all allowed. Speaking for myself, I would be very sorry to see the day when no interruptions would be allowed; I enjoy them thoroughly, but I must say that what we have at this stage is not interruptions at all: it is simply obstruction, an endeavour to prevent the Minister speaking. One of the functions of the Chair is to protect the minority, but the majority has some rights too. There is no constitutional provision to make the Minister for Industry and Commerce responsible for members, alleged to belong to his party, on county councils. We will have to leave county councils out of it; the Minister for Industry and Commerce is not responsible for them.
Comment on this
I am told that the main centres of unemployment are not touched by the road money. I rather understood that the trunk road schemes joined up the main towns, and to that extent it certainly touches the main spots where unemployment is bad. When Deputy Norton comes forward with his specific for unemployment— that there should be a loan raised and put at the disposal of the local authorities for schemes—my answer is that the money put at the disposal of the local authorities for a particular type of scheme has not been availed of. The money has been set out on the basis of some estimate as to the cost of repairing the roads in certain places. At the same time it has not been availed of. I do not think the Government can be asked to do any more than to say that two millions of money is going to be spent on roads and that they are pushing forward that as a policy deliberately chosen in order to relieve unemployment in the country. That is the response we got, and notwithstanding the fact that the money is there and has not been availed of, we have these complaints of inadequacy as to the measures taken.
I had to refer to that because there was a complaint that there was a failure to provide local authorities with money for a particular type of housing scheme. My answer is that the proportion likely to be employed and not now employed is very small; and. secondly, as a counter to it, that there is a huge amount of money ready to be spent and that the people are not able to spend it. I have made a reference already to a summary on the question of the tariffed industries and the employment given on the Shannon, Sugar Beet and the Barrow Schemes. On these schemes alone I simply founded the statement I made the other day that as far as industrial employment is concerned the situation to-day is better than it was this time a year ago. I received a summarised report from the Department of Agriculture in which their opinion is that as far as the agricultural workers are concerned the position is better than it was this time last year.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister for Lands and Agriculture from what source was that information supplied? Was it from the Gárda?
Comment on this
With regard to agricultural labourers, no. There are agricultural inspectors and instructors and County officials of the different departments who have a knowledge of agricultural conditions in the country, and they supplied the information. I have been met to-day, as is constantly occurring in debates on this matter— and I think it was Deputy Johnson brought it forward first—with the viewpoint which comes to this: that the information available to my Department, or from it to the public, as regards the number of unemployed is not accurate and cannot be considered to be accurate, and we get the usual point put up that the live claims, current register, that is, claims that have been adjudicated upon and allowed, show the number of people who have contributions to credit, and who, therefore, are signing with a definite object, and whose object is about to be achieved. Beyond that we have what is called the live register, the number registered as unemployed, and we are told that that is a completely inaccurate summary, because only those register who think they are going to get benefit.
That I deny as an accurate statement of fact. I take a six months' period, and I find that throughout the difference between the number of persons registered as unemployed and the number of claims current is such that there is a difference running between the two, running through the six months' period, of about 7,000 people, and that keeps pretty steadily there without variation. That means that there are people coming on our registers; that we include all those who have contributions to their credit who may at some time become unemployed; and we have in addition to that something about 35 per cent. of the entire registered people who have not claimed and who, therefore, are registered as unemployed, although, according to the views put forward by Deputy Johnson, they should not be there at all.
The curious thing is that between that proportion of 65 to 70 per cent., of the entire number regularly unemployed is very much the proportion between the industrially insured and the insured for purposes of the National Health Insurance Acts. A glance at the figures and a comparison with what I have just stated lead one to the conclusion that there is very little unemployment which is not notified in the ordinary register, very little unemployment indeed.
Comment on this
I would like to have that point cleared up, if I may be allowed to ask the Minister to do so. Do I understand him to say that the conclusion he draws from that statement is that the numbers registered as unemployed approximate to the actual number of unemployed?
Comment on this
Yes, of the industrial type. Now I come to the other part of the resolution. It is proposed to "disapprove of the Government's decision not to introduce legislation to amend the Unemployment Insurance Acts so as to provide subsistence for workers unable to find employment." I told Deputy Johnson, in answer to a question here the other day, that the Fund was now in the condition that there was a deficit of £1,515,000, and that in the ordinary way it would take fifteen years to make the Fund decently solvent. Notwithstanding that, it is proposed that we should amend the Unemployment Insurance Acts so as to provide subsistence for workers unable to find employment. Deputy Johnson went a little further to-day and said even if it does become insolvent it can always be re-made by a grant. That is a better and more honest way in which to face the position. What is now being asked is not a contribution to be voted from certain classes of the community but that the taxpayers should foot the bill for whatever is necessary to pay all the people in the country unemployment benefit so long as they are out of work.
Comment on this
Now, let it be viewed in that way. All I was indicating was that there is no reason whatever to amend the Acts so as to allow for extended benefit. It may seem that that is an academic distinction, but it is not. It is my anxiety to realise what the state of that Fund is, and I want to preserve what I believe to be a useful piece of social legislation. I believe that useful legislation will disappear if there is any attempt to put on that Fund extra demands. If any greater deficiency arises in connection with that Fund there is only one way to meet it, and that is to increase the contributions from the employers and those who find employment in industrial occupations for a generation. Does anybody think that industry is in so flourishing a state that any extra burden could be thrown particularly on the class who have to pay under the Unemployment Acts, so as to keep the Fund in such a state that it eventually will become solvent? This is not a mere academic point. If there is to be any demand for this let the machinery of the Employment Exchanges which are there be used. The administrative expenses are running against them and they might as well be utilised. Let it be faced that what is demanded is a grant not to be met from industry. That is what I cannot and will not advise, a grant to be made by the taxpayers generally for the relief of an unnamed, undiscovered number of unemployed for an indefinite period as long as they remain out of employment. That is the situation, and that is what the resolution suggests. There can be no question of amending the Unemployment Insurance Acts so as to let the thing run against the Fund that has been built up on a contributory basis.
I was anxious to-night to hear from the Labour benches some idea on their part as to the numbers out of employment at the moment, that is to say, the people who are vaguely described as people willing to work and unable to find it; and how long, in their estimation, is that state likely to last, and what sum of money per week is supposed to be covered by the term "subsistence." Because it is on that one has to make a calculation. The normal thing in the benefit year is that twenty-six weeks' benefit is allowed, provided there are contributions against it. To give that to a man and to give the ordinary unemployment benefit to a man for a half-year would cost £20 to £22. These have to be averaged. All are not adults drawing 17/- a week, but let us take 17/- a week as a fair average, and it is going to cost £20 to £23 to keep a man for the normal benefit, say 26 weeks out of 52 weeks. I would like to have some idea from the Labour benches as to how many men are to be provided. This is a thing into which finance must enter. I heard a statement the other day from Deputy A. Byrne. He was talking about the coal question. He said, quite honestly, I am sure, that he did not care who paid for it. But somebody must take care who pays for it. Deputy Davin spoke of the policy of the Government in reducing purchasing prices. I suppose the counter to that would be that we should all get better salaries and better wages. Where is the fund out of which this is to come? If there is any money stagnant in this country, and not being put into industry and employed, then there is the case for that. But let those people with soft hearts who talk in this ill-defined fashion about an indefinite number of workmen being paid for an indefinite time, get to hard economic facts and look up the Blue Books for some time.
Comment on this
The Deputy has at least enough to go on to make a case with regard to prices. I would like to hear him if he has any estimate of his own——
Comment on this
I am referring to claims current as against the live register.
Comment on this
The case I have made was on the basis of the Minister's own figures, and I dealt with the fact that there are 22,496 on the register today—or at least there were on the register last week—as compared with 21,931 in July. There are over 21,000 persons who want work and cannot get it. What is the Minister going to do with them?
Comment on this
The figures given by the Minister related to the number of unemployed on the register on the 12th July, 1926, and that number was 21,931. I am not talking about insurance claims but about the number of persons registered.
Comment on this
We register claims; we never register individuals as current claims. If a man makes a claim which has been adjudicated upon and passed, and if that man gets employment even for a day, and comes out of that employment again and re-applies, that would mean two claims, although the claims related to a single person. I am not going to say that there is any big difference between the number of persons and the number of claims.
Comment on this
What is referred to are claims. I take it there are twenty-two thousand claims or persons —take it either way—registered, representing unemployed, of whom, say, about sixteen thousand have claims current. The remainder are the unemployed; that is to say, the remainder are those who at some time registered as unemployed and who are not getting benefit from our register. But they may be getting benefit elsewhere; they may be getting benefit from a number of places and from any number of schemes. There is no investigation of a person registering as unemployed until the question arises of paying on a contribution; then there is an investigation as to whether certain conditions have been fulfilled. There is an investigation to find out if the person is out of work, if he is available for suitable employment, and if it is true that he cannot find suitable employment.
Now, as regards the twenty-two thousand on the register, every one of these without a claim current may be actually in employment at the moment of registration. When one gets the problem down to some sort of a definite stage, and when one begins to realise the situation, there are other aspects that present themselves. If one considers it desirable that money should pour out plentifully, one should not omit to look at the other side of the picture and see what are the reserves of this State with regard to meeting claims of this sort.
I would like to know what has been the approach of Labour leaders ordinarily to the conditions in this country during the last two or three years. I would like to know how far has there been any attempt to change Trade Union regulations which may have been very suitable for normal times of unemployment and industrial activity, but which one might expect would have been re-adjusted to meet periods when the wheel of industrial work was not going round as fast as might be desired. What appreciation has there been on the part of men actually in employment of the difficulty of getting employment?
Deputy Norton, in the course of his speech, put the question: Is it easier to get a job now than it was four years ago? I would like to place before him a list of the cases reported to me week by week of people who are in employment and who think fit to stop their employment for two or three days because of demands they make, ninety per cent. of the demands never being conceded. Casually, and you might almost say light-heartedly, they leave their employment in order to press a claim which is not conceded and those men go back to work on the old rates. That may not be considered a conclusive answer, but it is just as conclusive as anything that Deputy Norton has put up with regard to the ease of people getting into occupations.
As I have stated, there are people who very light-heartedly leave their occupation for the purpose of pressing claims which, in the majority of cases, are never granted. If those people were able to press their claims successfully, one would not mind at all.