We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

IN COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - VOTE ON ACCOUNT.

Contributions 1–107 of 207. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Ernest Blythe MINISTER for FINANCE (Mr. Blythe) Cumann na nGaedheal

I move:—

Go ndeontar i geuntas suim nách mó ná £8,081,717 chun no le haghaidh íoctha na muirearacha a thioc fidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1928, i gcóir seirbhísí áirithe puiblí, eadhon:— | That a sum not exceeding £8,081,717 be granted on account for or towards defraying the charges that will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1928, for certain public services, namely:—

£ | £

1 | Teaghlachas an tSeanascail | 2,200 | 1 | Governor-General's Establishment | 2,200

2 | An t-Oireachtas | 38,700 | 2 | Oireachtas | 38,700

3 | Roinn Uachtarán na hArd-Chomhairle | 4,000 | 3 | Department of the President of the Executive Council | 4,000

4 | An Stát-Chiste agus Iniúchoireacht | 6,000 | 4 | Exchequer and Audit | 6,000

5 | Oifig an Aire Airgid | 21,000 | 5 | Office of the Minister for Finance | 21,000

6 | An Roinn Ioncuim | 226,000 | 6 | Revenue Department | 226,000

7 | Pinsin tSean-Aoise | 869,000 | 7 | Old Age Pensions | 869,000

8. | Iasachtaí Aitiúla | 378,000 | 8 | Local Loans | 378,000

9 | Coimisiúin Shealadacha | 4,500 | 9 | Temporary Commissions | 4,500

10 | Oifig na nOibreacha Puiblí | 41,000 | 10 | Public Works Office | 41,000

11 | Oibreacha agus Foirgintí Puiblí | 290,000 | 11 | Public Works and Buildings | 290,000

12 | Saotharlann Stáit | 2,284 | 12 | State Laboratory | 2,284

13 | Coimisiún na Stát-Sheirbhíse | 3,700 | 13 | Civil Service Commission | 3,700

14 | Cúiteamh i gCailliúna Maoine | 326,500 | 14 | Property Losses Compensation | 326,500

15 | Cúiteamh i nDíobhála Pearsanta | 1,700 | 15 | Personal Injuries Compensation | 1,700

16 | Aois-Liúntaisí agus Liúntaisí Fágála | 596,000 | 16 | Superannuation and Retired Allowances | 596,000

17 | Rátaí ar Mhaoin an Rialtais | 27,800 | 17 | Rates on Government Property | 27,800

18 | An tSeirbhís Shicréideach | 3,300 | 18 | Secret Service | 3,300

19 | Coimisiún na nDleacht | 550 | 19 | Tariff Commission | 550

20 | Costaisí fén Representation of the People Act, fén Acht Timpeal Toghachán, agus fé Acht na gCoistí Dharéag (Leasú) | 9,000 | 20 | Expenses under the Representation of the People Act, the Electoral Act, and the Juries (Amendment) Act | 9,000

21 | Costaisí Ilghnéitheacha | 3,477 | 21 | Miscellaneous Expenses | 3,477

22 | Oifig an tSoláthair | 50,000 | 22 | Stationery Office | 50,000

23 | Measadóireacht agus Suibhéireacht Teorann | 11,925 | 23 | Valuation and Boundary Survey | 11,925

24 | Suirbhéireacht an Ordonáis | 16,367 | 24 | Ordnance Survey | 16,367

25 | Deontas Breise Talmhaíochta | 300,000 | 25 | Supplementary Agricultural Grant | 300,000

26 | Muirearacha Dlí | 28,000 | 26 | Law Charges | 28,000

27 | Longlann Inis Sionnach | 5,600 | 27 | Haulbowline Dockyard | 5,600

28 | Príomh-scoileanna agus Coláistí | 76,500 | 28 | Universities and Colleges | 76,500

29 | Congnamh Airgid do Bhiatas Siúicre | Nil | 29 | Beet Sugar Subsidy | Nil

30 | Oifig an tSaor-Chíosa | 1,392 | 30 | Quit Rent Office | 1,392

31 | Oifig an Aire Dlí agus Cirt | 10,000 | 31 | Office of the Minister for Justice | 10,000

32 | Gárda Síochána | 560,000 | 32 | Gárda Síochána | 560,000

33 | Bórd Generálta an bPríosún | 43,500 | 33 | General Prisons Board | 43,500

34 | Cúirt Dúithche | 5,300 | 34 | District Court | 5,300

35 | Cúirt Uachtarach agus Ard-Chúirt an Bhreithiúnais | 23,000 | 35 | Supreme Court and High Court of Justice | 23,000

36 | Oifig Chlárathachta na Talmhan agus Oifig Chlárahachta na nDintiúirí | 17,000 | 36 | Land Registry and Registry of Deeds | 17,000

37 | Oifigigh Chúirte Cuarda | 23,600 | 37 | Circuit Court Officers | 23,600

38 | Oifig na nAnnálacha Puiblí | 1,997 | 38 | Public Record Office | 1,997

39 | Tabhartaisí agus Tiomanta Déirciúla | 1,000 | 39 | Charitable Donations and Bequests | 1,000

40 | Oifig an Aire Rialtais agus Sláinte Puiblí | 162,250 | 40 | Office of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health | 162,250

41 | Oifig an Ard-Chlárathóra | 4,588 | 41 | General Register Office | 4,588

42 | Gealtlann Dúndroma | 6,500 | 42 | Dundrum Asylum | 6,500

43 | An Coimisiún Arachais Sláinte Náisiúnta | 114,907 | 43 | National Health Insurance Commission | 114,907

44 | Oispidéil agus Déarcaisí | 15,000 | 44 | Hospitals and Charities | 15,000

45 | Oifig an Aire Oideachais | 61,000 | 45 | Office of the Minister for Education | 61,000

46 | Bun-Oideachas | 1,290,000 | 46 | Primary Education | 1,290,000

47 | Meadhon-Oideachas | 90,000 | 47 | Secondary Education | 90,000

48 | Ceárd-Oideachas | 50,000 | 48 | Technical Instruction | 50,000

49 | Eolaíocht agus Ealadhantacht | 13,500 | 49 | Science and Art | 13,500

50 | Scoileanna Ceartúcháin agus Saothair | 38,000 | 50 | Reformatory and Industrial Schools | 38,000

51 | An Gailerí Náisiúnta | 1,494 | 51 | National Gallery | 1,494

52 | Oifig an Aire Tailte agus Talmhaíochta | 156,000 | 52 | Office of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture | 156,000

53 | An Ciste Foraoiseachta | 53 | Forestry Fund (Grant in

(Deontas i gCabhair) | 18,000 | Aid) | 18,000

54 | Coimisiún na Talmhan | 200,000 | 54 | Land Commission | 200,000

55 | Roimh-íocanna le Cumainn Chreidiúna Thalmhaíochta | 28,000 | 55 | Advances to Agricultural Credit Societies | 28,000

56 | Oifig an Aire Tionnscail agus Tráchtála | 41,000 | 56 | Office of the Minister for Industry and Commerce | 41,000

57 | Bóithre Iarainn | 28,000 | 57 | Railways | 28,000

58 | An Bínse Bóthair Iarainn | 2,600 | 58 | Railway Tribunal | 2,600

59 | Muir-Sheirbhísí | 3,500 | 59 | Marine Service | 3,500

60 | Arachas Díomhaointis | 78,000 | 60 | Unemployment Insurance | 78,000

61 | Oifig an Aire Iascaigh | 17,000 | 61 | Office of the Minister for Fisheries | 17,000

62 | Oifig an Phuist | 810,000 | 62 | Post Office | 810,000

63 | Fóirleatha Nea-shrangach | 7,260 | 63 | Wireless Broadcasting | 7,260

64 | An t-Arm | 725,000 | 64 | Army | 725,000

65 | Arm-Phinsin | 72,000 | 65 | Army Pensions | 72,000

66 | Oifig an Aire Gnóthaí Coigríche | 14,906 | 66 | Office of the Minister for External Affairs | 14,906

67 | Cumann na Náisiún | 3,320 | 67 | League of Nations | 3,320

68 | Luach saothair chun costais Bhainistí Stoc Rialtais is le Saorstát Eireann | Nil | 68 | Remuneration for cost of management of Government Stocks of Saorstát Eireann | Nil

An t-Iomlán | £8,081,717 | Total | £8,081,717

Deputies will remember that the Vote on Account was not introduced until a later date in previous years. As a matter of fact, I think every year heretofore I have been obliged to go to the Seanad on 31st March with the Central Fund Bill and ask them to pass it that day, without giving them any reasonable opportunity of discussing it. We hope this year to be able to give such time to the Seanad for the discussion of the Central Fund Bill— the Estimates, of course, will not come before them—that they will have no reasonable ground for complaint. We have issued this year the volume of Estimates a fortnight earlier than they were issued last year, so that there has been a fair interval between the issue of the Estimates and the presentation of the Vote on Account. The sum asked for in the Vote on Account is, as a rule, one-third of the total Estimates. The intention is that sufficient money should be granted to carry on the various services of the State until the end of July. By our Standing Orders, all the financial legislation consequent on the Estimates must be completed before 1st August. It is intended this year that the Estimates shall not be discussed until after the general election. There will, however, be enough time after the reassembly of the Oireachtas for the new Dáil either to sit three or four weeks and take the Estimates or, if it thinks it better, to pass a further Vote on Account and adjourn the detailed consideration of the Estimates until it has had time to look around it. In any case, we are asking for the usual provision by the way of Vote on Account.

As I have said, the amount asked for is, as a rule, one-third of each vote, but in certain cases a greater or a lesser sum is asked for. In some cases nothing is asked for, because the expenditure on the vote will not take place in the first four months of the financial year. For instance, we are not asking for any sum on account in the case of the sugar beet subsidy or payments to banks in respect of management of Government stock and loans. In certain other cases, as, for instance, in the case of hospitals and charities we are asking for practically the entire sum, because it has been the habit always to pay practically the entire vote in the first few months of the financial year. In the case of the Agricultural Grant, we are asking for a good deal more than one-third, because it is expected that half of the sum will have to be paid before 1st July. There are variations in some votes, but they are matters for which some such explanation is available in each case.

It is customary in Great Britain, whose financial system we have adopted, for parties to use the occasion of the Vote on Account for the discussion of a number of important matters of policy. It is not possible on a Vote of Account to have a detailed discussion of any estimate, but it is possible to raise the policy of any department or of a group of departments or any matter of general policy. I think, therefore, that it is better I should formally introduce the Vote on Account and allow Deputies to bring before the House such matters as they may think most urgent and most worthy of consideration at the present time. In view of the fact that the Estimates will not be discussed until after the General Election, we were anxious to give as much time as we could to the Vote on Account, so that urgent questions which might trouble Deputies might be brought before the Dáil.

Comment on this

On a point of order, might I draw the attention of the Minister to certain wording in the motion, which I hope is due to a clerical error? In number 53 of the Vote on Account the amount to be voted to the Forestry Fund is described as a "grant in aid." I notice that in the White Paper which has been circulated and also in the Estimates, page 211, this important item is not mentioned as a grant in aid. I have, I fear, frequently bored the House by urging the uniformity of public accounts, and I am glad to see that in the Estimates the "grants in aid" in respect of this fund and other funds have been abolished. This vote has been placed on a regular footing and I hope, therefore, that the wording of No. 53 in this motion is due to a clerical error and that it should not have been written down as a grant in aid. It is a technical matter, but it is one which affects the public accounts, and I hope the Minister will say that the wording is inaccurate.

Comment on this

I will look into the point.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That point will be settled before the motion is actually put.

Comment on this

The Minister has mentioned that no Vote on Account is asked for in respect of the sugar beet subsidy. Does that preclude a Deputy from mentioning the matter in the course of the discussion?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I think it does. If there is no mention in the motion of a vote for beet sugar, the question does not arise.

Comment on this

Can it be discussed as a matter of policy on number 3—Department of the President of the Executive Council?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I would be prepared to waive any technical objection if what the Deputy wants to raise is a matter of policy. But questions of detail would properly arise on the Estimates and they will arise when the Estimates are being considered, as they must be considered.

Comment on this

After the General Election?

Comment on this

I move:—

"To reduce the sum by £500."

I put down this amendment as a protest against the policy of the Government on the question of national expenditure. I am not approaching this question in any partisan spirit, nor do I intend to go into any detailed examination of the financial position at this stage. But I want an answer from the House as to whether or not the Dáil approves of the policy of the Government in the matter of national expenditure, and whether the Dáil does not think that the Government are demanding too large a sum for keeping the machinery of Government going. I also want the opinion of the Dáil as to whether the machinery of Government in this State should not be run, and must not be run, at a lower figure than the Government demands, taking into account the circumstances and conditions of the times.

I recognise that the position of the Government in this matter is undoubtedly difficult. It is their responsibility to govern and to obtain the money requisite for that purpose. The Government is maintained for the benefit of the citizens. But it strikes me, whatever the Government may think about the money that is necessary for this purpose, that their policy should be regulated in such a way as to take into account that conditions in the country are not good. Whether the Government like it or not, because of these conditions the amount that they are demanding must be reduced, for the reason that the people cannot afford to pay it.

Last year our expenditure on national services amounted to something over twenty-five millions, and the expenditure on local services was approximately seven millions—something about thirty-two millions and a half altogether. That is an extraordinary when we take into account that the total value of our exports last year was approximately £40,000,000. When we consider that we have to add to the national and local taxation £3,000,000 for land purchase annuities and other sums, we must wonder how it is possible for the people to survive. I cannot imagine a man being able to carry on unless the product of his labour commands such a figure as will enable him to maintain himself and have something left over, and the conditions in this country are such, and the taxpayers' plight is so serious, that we have to make up our minds that we cannot afford to spend the amount of money demanded by the Government. We are up against the proposition: Can this country not be governed for a smaller sum, and can we not have essential services maintained at a lower cost than is demanded? I recognise that we can have very efficient government indeed, that we can add to the number of services and spend more money, but the services are for the benefit of the people. I can be very well served personally provided I can afford to spend the money.

Last year at this period there was a great outcry, both in the Press and in the country, against the figure at which national taxation stood. If that outcry was overdone to some extent, there was a great deal of justification for it. Conditions have not improved very much since then, if at all, economically. The demand that the Government is making this year is very little less than last year. The Estimates reveal that if there is a reduction the greater portion of it is under one head—compensation. There is comparative silence in the country at present on the Government policy with regard to national expenditure. The Government would be very foolish to think that because less is being said now than twelve months ago the capacity of the taxpayers to pay is better than it was then. The position has not improved. While Government policy is being evolved along the line that we must expect an annual expenditure of about £25,000,000, I submit that that figure is more than the country can bear and can continue to pay. I have no doubt that the mind of the country on this matter is definitely made up and that Government policy does not reflect it.

It has repeatedly been said that we do not point out where savings could be effected. During the debates on the Estimates last year we indicated how expenditure might be reduced. On one of those votes we find a reduction this year, but on others we find an increase. The major point that stands out, on which the Dáil will have to give a decision and on which the country must give a decision later, is whether or not there must be collected from the taxpayers and spent annually a sum of about £25,000,000. Does the Government consider that national policy must be developed along a line which demands the collection and spending of such a sum, or does the Government think that our affairs can be managed tolerably efficiently—because that is as much as you can get from the best of governments at the best of times—at a smaller sum than is being asked for? Can they manage in future at a smaller cost than the State is being asked to pay at present? Our feeling is that the cost must be reduced, because of conditions in the country. If Ministers were as closely in touch with conditions as some Deputies who go down the country every week, they would understand that there has been very little improvement in economic conditions in the past twelve months.

I am not one of those who have a pessimistic outlook, and I have no regard for people who say that everything is going to the bad and that there is no hope for the country. I do not accept that view at all. I have more faith in the people than to accept that doctrine. But I am putting forward my point of view, because I think we should try to face up to the conditions as we see them, and because I think we should try to face up to the conditions should be prepared to help those who will work to make them better.

We have no use for the man who tells us that there is no hope and that we should clear out of the country. While such a man is doing a national disservice, and perhaps doing a good deal to weaken the fibre of our people, instead of making them face their difficulties and overcome them, we will not be acting justly if we do not face up to the fact that conditions are not good. Even though the President tells our people, and people in other countries, that everything is going on very well here and that we have rounded the corner, and while, to some extent, it might be true to speak of the country in those terms, there are a great number of people in the country who I fear will not round the corner but fall by the wayside. When we meet those people and are taken to account, as we are sometimes, for the conduct of affairs in the legislature, we have to admit that the capacity of those people to meet Government expenditure is not improving.

The Government will be compelled to recognise the fact that a reduction in taxation is essential and must come. The Government sometimes urge, with some justification, that a reduction in taxation alone is not sufficient. I admit that a reduction in taxation is not sufficient and will not achieve all things. But when we remember that the money spent on national services must come from the people, we must admit that if we take less and leave more with them—even a couple of million pounds—the people will be somewhat better off and will have more hope. As far as I can see, our local authorities are making a supreme effort to reduce local taxation—an effort that is being applauded locally. But it seems to me that the Government, which should give the lead, should make a better effort than they are making. Why are they not making that effort? Do they argue that there is no room for a reduction and that come what may the services cannot be maintained for less? Is that their attitude? The President, and I think the Minister for Finance, publicly confessed that taxation was too high and would have to come down. If the point is made that services cannot be maintained for less, the Government must face up to the question: Are the services giving value for the money? They will have to recognise the fact that a poverty-stricken people cannot afford to have as good and as efficient services as people who are better off, because they cannot pay for them. The sum that the Government are asking this year is very little less than last year, and our hopes are dashed because there is not that reduction in the Estimates that there should be. Even if we take the point of view of the President and the Minister for Finance as to the conditions, we have to say that we do not approve of the Government policy.

It has been repeatedly urged on the Government that an examination of the financial position and of the administration was essential to satisfy the country that to run the machinery of the Government the sums that were demanded were necessary. If the Government's answer to me to-day is that the services cannot be run for less and that the country must face up to the position of having to contribute yearly approximately £25,000,000 for the machinery of government, I say that there must be an examination of that position by others. When its turn comes, no doubt, the country will pass judgment upon it. Some people might make demands for reductions that would be unreasonable, perhaps, from the point of view of the efficiency of the service, and unreasonable on account of the amount that would be saved by the reduction, but if the Government still stand by their view that there is no room for a reduction we must urge once more that they should appoint some committee, after consultation with the House, which will, if necessary, devote a period of twelve months to examining administration and policy and recommend where and how changes may be brought about which, while leaving the Governmental machine efficient, will, at the same time, cost the taxpayers a sum commensurate with their ability to pay.

Comment on this

I should like to reinforce Deputy Baxter's arguments with somewhat more detail than he presented. Let us consider first of all what is the effect of the procedure that the Government propose to adopt in dealing with the Estimates this year. Practically this is the only discussion that this Dáil will have on the Estimates. I am not one of those who decry the value of discussion on the Estimates. I rather gather from Deputy Baxter—I do not think he intended the suggestion—that there has not been much economy. There has been economy in the past, and a great deal of that economy has been due to discussion on the Estimates. Let us take, for instance, one of the features in the Army Vote. Last year Deputy Sir James Craig raised the question of the number of medical officers and the amount paid to medical officers. This year it has been found possible to reduce the number of medical officers by ten, at a saving of £6,000 a year. Then, again, the Farmers' Party raised the question on the amount spent last year on medicines for horses. This year this amount has been reduced from £1,450 to £320.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

And it is still too high.

Comment on this

It is, possibly, still too high, and this is the only opportunity we have of discussing it. I have in the past raised the question of the extra pay to tradesmen in the Army. The numbers have been reduced from 2,750 to 2,158 within two years, and that has caused a saving of £30,000 a year to the taxpayer. These are some of the effects of the discussion on the Estimates. I moved a number of amendments last year. I see that in almost every case where I moved an amendment the expenditure has come down this year.

Comment on this

Do you think that that has anything to do with your amendments?

Comment on this

Not necessarily, but will the Minister say that the saving on army tradesmen has nothing to do with them? I am of opinion that although the Minister for Defence hardened his heart the Minister for Finance hardened his head. If the Minister for Finance says that discussion on the Estimates never makes for economy he is denying the opinions of his colleagues because we were always told, when we asked for a committee to be appointed to go into these matters, that when the Estimates were being considered was the time when you got a chance to enforce economy. The fact that amendments are moved to the Estimates is a very powerful factor, not only in securing economy in the departments, but in enabling the Minister for Finance to resist the demands of departments, and if the Estimates went through easily and without discussion the Minister for Finance would not be in as strong a position to oppose the demands of departments as he is to-day. This year there will be no discussion on the Estimates——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy is unduly pessimistic on that matter.

Comment on this

This year there will be a perfunctory discussion. There will be a discussion conducted in a new Dáil with many inexperienced Deputies. I am not always an optimist. No doubt other Deputies have assured themselves of an unopposed return. I have not. But there will be certainly some inexperienced Deputies, and, almost certainly, some inexperienced Ministers, possibly a whole crowd of inexperienced Ministers. The discussion will be conducted in the dog days, when everybody is worn out after the election campaign, and it will be condensed into three or four weeks, so that it is bound to be an unsatisfactory and perfunctory discussion. I want to bring forward one aspect of the case which I should prefer to deal with on each separate Estimate, but I will deal with it in general. That is, the increase in cost and in personnel in Government departments which is shown in almost every case under sub-head A of the Estimates. Let me say at once that I am not complaining that excessive salaries are being paid. I do not think that civil servants as a whole are over-paid, and I am quite confident that if you want to get good men you will have to pay them as much as they would be paid in commercial life, and that the responsibility of the secretary of a department is at least as great as that of the secretary of a railway company or the chief officer of a bank. I am not complaining of the salaries. If the Minister defends the salaries I will stand by it, but I am complaining of the numbers and the total cost.

I have had a survey made extending over the four years that this Dáil has been in existence, giving a comparison of the figures in the Estimates for 1923-4 and those in the present Estimates.

I had it made specially in relation to sub-head A, though in some cases salaries also come in under sub-head B, as in Education, and where that has happened I have brought them in as well. I find that some Departments have made substantial reductions on the sums they were spending in 1923-4. These figures deal with salaries only. The Stationery Office has reduced its expenditure from £28,000 to £24,024, a reduction of very nearly one-seventh. That is a very satisfactory reduction. The Department of Local Government has done even better. It has reduced its expenditure on staff from £102,000 to £85,000, and I have not heard any complaints that the work in the Department of Local Government is carried out with less efficiency than in the case of other Government departments. These are the two good boys. Now we come to the bad boys. To begin with, the cost of the Revenue Commissioners' staff has gone up very considerably, from £490,000 to £610,400. Of course the Minister will tell me, with perfect truth, that that is part of the price we must pay for protective tariffs, because the Revenue Commissioners have more work to do, and that is perfectly true.

Comment on this

To collect a diminishing revenue.

Comment on this

The cost of the staff of the Office of Works has gone up from £76,131 to £108,374, an increase of more than 25 per cent., and whereas it employed 193 persons four years ago it now employs 314 persons. That is the kind of process that ought to be changed. It is possible in every instance I give that a case can be made for these increases, as could undoubtedly be done in the case of the Revenue Commissioners, but I think it would need more investigation than we have been able to give it. The next case is that of the Department of Industry and Commerce, including unemployment insurance. Apparently the cost of the office of the Minister has decreased in this period, but I then discovered that the staffs dealing with unemployment insurance and unemployment exchanges were all included under other heads but in the earlier Estimate they were added to the cost of the Minister's Office, which was, I think, a fair thing to do. In 1923 it cost £180,000, and this year it is costing £225,496. The Office of the Minister for Education, including inspection, cost £99,846. This year it costs £152,500.

That is in relation to primary education. I have left secondary education out of consideration altogether because it was shown separately in the earlier Estimates. That is an increase of over 50 per cent., and yet the Department of Education does not appear to be performing very much greater functions than it did four years ago. The cost of the Land Commission has gone up from £159,839 to £264,088. There, of course, the Land Act of 1923 is, no doubt, largely responsible, and Deputy Redmond may be interested to hear that the cost of the Legal Branch of the Land Commission has gone up from £5,142 to £8,750. Most interesting of all is the Department of Lands and Agriculture. In 1923 the staff of that Ministry cost £149,708. That is deducting £10,000 for technical instruction, which has now been transferred to the Department of Education. It appeared at first that this particular sub-head A was only £112,000, but when I came to look at the Estimate in detail I found that all sorts of salaries that appeared under sub-head A in 1923 had been peppered down in the Estimates—E.1— Technical and Advisory Work in Agriculture, £7,033; E.2—Veterinary Research Work, £2,161; F.1 — Agricultural Schools and Farms, £13,821, though you can write off the Albert Agricultural College, because it has been transferred to the National University; F.3— Veterinary College, £4,849; G.1—Improvement of Flax Growing, £2,166; G.2 — Improvement of Milk Production, £4,148; I.—Special Schemes in Congested Districts, £15,445, which I am not sure should be included; M.1—Miscellaneous Works, £3,326; and N.1— Diseases of Animals Act, £7,906. These are all for salaries. All these things come to £173,357, as against £149,000 in 1923. Even if you take off the £15,000 for special schemes in the Congested Districts it is still £10,000 above what it was in 1923, and I have not included in these figures the cost of the Acts which have recently been passed, the Dairy Produce Act, the Live Stock Act, and the Agricultural Produce Act, but simply the functions that the Minister was exercising in 1923 and is exercising to-day, and which are costing £10,000 more to-day.

Leaving these details, which I fear have been rather wearisome to the Dáil, I suggest that the fact that we cannot examine in detail what may be called the overhead charges of the Government Department makes it likely that the discussion in future is likely to be perfunctory. A different situation exists from that in a normal year, so that the case for the appointment of a committee of inquiry, either a committee of the Dáil or an outside committee, is much stronger now, and it is essential that such committee should examine the figures and find out the reasons for the increase. There may, of course, be sound reasons for it. In view of the fact that a general election is impending, and in view of other circumstances, it is impossible for us to exercise our proper functions, so that there is a far stronger case now for the appointment of such committee even than there has been heretofore. I urge the committee to accept Deputy Baxter's suggestion.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I propose to vote for the amendment in so far as its object is a protest against the financial policy of the Government generally. My object in voting for it is entirely different from that mentioned by Deputy Baxter. In looking over the Estimates we find that there is a general net reduction of £2,280,000. In the first place, it is interesting to see how that reduction is made up. Take three items which may be regarded, more or less, as abnormal expenditure, namely, £1,190,000 for Property Losses Compensation, £300,000 for the Army, and £212,000 for Army Pensions, the latter, of course, being accounted for by the fact that last year we had to pay arrears. If you take these three items they bring the reduction to £1,704,000. Practically all the balance, with the exception of a few hundred pounds, is made up of a reduction in services which are calculated specially to give employment. We have, for instance, no Estimates this year for relief schemes. There was an Estimates last year of £50,000, but that was only the balance of a grant made the year before. In the Estimates for the Local Government Department there is a reduction in housing schemes and building grants of £80,000. Local Loans are reduced by £266,000—the portion which is used for Government grants for drainage purposes and grants to municipal authorities for carrying out works of improvement. In the Land Commission there is a reduction of £26,000 on the improvement of estates. In the Fisheries Department there is a reduction of £9,700 under the heading of fishery development and rural industries, although there is an increase in other branches of that department. Under the heading Public Works and Buildings, there is a decrease of £148,000. The total under these headings shows a decrease of £580,000.

It seems that the policy of the Government, as indicated by these decreases, is that when they set out to effect economies they effect them in those services which are calculated to give employment, and which, in my opinion, would be the most useful way in which money could be spent. That is only a continuation of the policy which was adopted last year, namely, that where there are economies in the normal expenditure they are effected in services best calculated to give general employment to the people. When this national Government was first set on its feet, so far back as 1919, it was declared to the world that it was the right of the citizen to demand of the nation an opportunity to work for an adequate reward. If an outsider examined the economic conditions of the State at present I do not think that he could fail to be struck by the fact that the greatest economic evil from which the country is suffering is shown by the emigration tables. A country from which its citizens are flying at the rate of 25,000 or 30,000 a year cannot be prosperous and, no matter what we hear about turning the corner, about improvements created by agricultural schemes and by the Dairy Produce and other Acts, while that stream goes on there can be nobody who will say that the country is prosperous or is in anything but a bad condition.

My principal criticism of the financial policy of the Government is that, so far as one can see, no effective steps have been, or are proposed to be, taken whereby that tide of emigration could be stemmed. So long as it goes on, let us not pretend that there is any real improvement in the conditions of the country. It is unnecessary to say that it is only the cream of the people who are emigrating. The energetic, the enterprising, the active and the healthy people are anxious to get away and, as a result, we are gradually building up here a C.3 nation. Worst of all, it is from those counties which are the cradle of our Gaelic race that the tide is heaviest, namely, the western seaboard counties. A year or two ago the Government set up a special Commission which at great expense examined the economic conditions of the western seaboard and, so far as I can see from these Estimates or from any statement made by the Government, no steps have been taken to give effect to any of the recommendations of that Commission. The principal recommendations, made after very careful investigation by that Commission, dealt almost entirely with the economic conditions of the people. The question of saving the Irish language was involved, but, I think, there can be no doubt in the mind of anybody interested in the question of saving the Irish language that it is mainly, if not entirely, an economic question. You may spend hundreds of thousands of pounds on the language movement and on scholarships and so forth, but if you do not take steps to better the economic conditions of the people in those areas there is no hope for the survival of the language.

A strange thing about the position in the West is that, apparently, it has now been discovered that under the British regime more care was taken for dealing with the special conditions which exist in the West than are being taken by our own Government. The general opinion of the people in the western area is confirmed in the report of the Commission when it is stated that the withdrawal of the Congested Districts Board and placing in the hands of ordinary Government Departments matters previously dealt with by the Board has been a serious drawback in many ways to the districts concerned. That opinion was fairly generally held before the Commission confirmed it in their report. The western areas may be regarded as the slum areas of the agricultural districts, and it is only special measures which do not fit in to the ordinary machinery of government of the country that can effectively deal with the special conditions existing in those areas.

As I say, it is from those areas that you have emigration. It is in those areas that employment is most needed, and the Government, in cutting down these services which were calculated to give employment—such as the improvement of estates under the Land Commission Vote, drainage schemes and other schemes which were provided for like those for fishery development and rural industries—have only added still more to the difficulties under which those areas suffer, and they have swelled the tide of emigration which must ensue as a result. We hear it stated that the credit of this country is good. It is good. There is no doubt of that, but, when I hear that, it reminds me of a man who has thousands of pounds in the bank while his children are starving. If the credit of the country is good, that credit should be used for the benefit of the people of the whole of the country, and the credit and resources of the country ought to be made available so that all the people can be guaranteed useful employment within their own land. Schemes of reclamation, of drainage, of afforestation, and other schemes of national development of that kind, ought to be instituted by the Government on a very much larger scale than has yet been attempted. It is only in that way, by using the credit and resources of the country, that we can ever hope to make the country prosperous. If people are leaving the country at the rate at which they have been leaving it, if 140,000 people are to go away within the next few years, what are we coming to, what state of prosperity do we expect to reach?

I do not agree at all with the general clamour "reduce expenditure" and "reduce taxation." What I am more concerned about is, how the money that is collected is spent and to what purpose it is spent. If new services are created and if old services are enlarged, that can only be done by the expenditure of money. If the money is expended to provide employment and enable the people to remain and live in the country, then it will be usefully employed. There is a clamour and a call for the reduction of taxation. In the minds of most people who call for it, in so far as it is defined at all, that means a reduction, say, in income tax. I cannot see that that is going to benefit the people in the country who are in the worst position. It may be argued, although it has never been proved to my satisfaction, that such a reduction would react favourably on the whole country. I certainly cannot see that any considerable reduction in income tax is going to improve, for instance, the position of the small agriculturist. If this amendment involved a substantial reduction, as was the proposal last year, I certainly would not support it, but the amount mentioned is small, insignificant and negligible, and in so far as it is a protest against the financial policy of the Government generally, I am prepared to vote for it.

Comment on this

I rise to support the amendment for the reason that it gives me an opportunity of entering my protest against the failure of the Government to make anything like adequate provision for the unemployed. It will be noted in the general reductions mentioned in this Vote on Account that these will eventually cause additional unemployment. The housing grants are reduced. That will mean that less houses will be built next year. There is nothing at all provided for relief schemes, and I also note with regret that the amount for unemployment insurance is also reduced. That being the case, it means, I suppose, that the Government must have something in their minds regarding alterations in the Unemployment Insurance Act for next year that will not be to the advantage of the unemployed. Speaking for Dublin only, there are, as we are all aware, many thousands registered for employment in the city. There is no means, however, of finding employment for them. They are told that they are not entitled to unemployment benefit unless they have at least twelve stamps on their insurance cards. There is a general complaint that an effort has been made, so far as relief work is concerned for these people, to see that they will never get the twelve stamps on their cards, and thus save the Unemployment Insurance Fund in the future. Many Deputies, as well as myself, must have had the experience of coming in contact with numbers of stalwart, able-bodied young men, most of them with families, clamouring for employment. They tell you that they cannot get work and that they are not getting unemployment benefit. Most of them came out of the Army without their cards being stamped. They cannot get unemployment benefit until their cards are stamped, and even then they only get a miserable pittance of one day's pay for every stamp on the card.

The House will note that the Unemployment Insurance Estimate is reduced for next year. That, I think, is very regrettable. I think the Minister ought to see his way to give some word of encouragement to the unemployed, and take this opportunity to indicate what his intentions are for the coming year. It will also be noted that further unemployment will be caused by the fact that the Estimate for Public Works and Buildings is considerably reduced. That means that those who are engaged on Government work, such as alterations, buildings, etc., will be put on the unemployed list when these works are completed. What puzzles me is, what is to become of these three or four hundred men when they are put on the unemployed list if no provision is made now in the Unemployment Insurance Fund to meet their cases. From the Estimate before us no provided sion whatever has been made for them. The Estimate is reduced this year. There was a resonable sum provided for relief grants last year, but there is no such provision being made this year. I support Deputy Baxter's amendment for the reason that it enables me to enter my protest against the failure of the Government to handle in anything like a reasonable form the conditions that prevail in Dublin to-day regarding the problem of unemployment.

Comment on this

We often hear Deputy Baxter as a critic in this House. Listening to him to-day, and remembering his criticism on former occasions, we must ask ourselves what has brought about the great change. Formerly we were told that the country was heading for disaster and that we had a dark future in front of us. Those who painted the picture in those colours always found that Deputy Baxter had a darker colour to add than anybody else, but to-day he is not in the role of the sad pessimist; he is full of hope. Accordingly his position was extremely difficult, and it needed a man with the courage of Deputy Baxter to put down a motion at all. That also accounted for the fact that he said nothing about details. He spoke about taxation, but he kept off the items. We all know the reason why. There are some very large items and the Deputy knows that they cannot be reduced. He did not ask to have any of them reduced. Taking some of the larger items, Deputy Baxter did not ask, for instance, that the Old Age Pensions Estimate should be reduced. He knows that it could not be reduced any further, and he knows that it accounts for a considerable share of the millions he spoke of. He did not suggest that the cost of education should be reduced—another very large item. The Government is asking for the sum of £600,000 to increase the Agricultural Grant, but the Deputy did not suggest for a moment that a penny of that should not be given.

Comment on this

Take your chance of reducing that any time you like.

Comment on this

Wait until a Farmers' Government comes in.

Comment on this

That will be a good while.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that the farmers had to pay taxes plus annuities, and he found a grievance in that. But when they had a pay taxes plus rent, they had to pay a great deal more, because the annuities are from 30 to 40 per cent. less than what the rents used to be. The Deputy did not give the Government credit for the great reduction in the Army and in other Departments. He omitted to mention the fact that in one Department alone, the Post Office, there has been a reduction of from four to six hundred thousand pounds during the last few years.

Comment on this

What is the total reduction in that department?

Comment on this

It is a very large item.

Comment on this

Look at the estimate and see.

Comment on this

It has been made at the expense of the rural community.

Comment on this

We are talking of reductions, and I am pointing to reductions that have been effected. The Deputy did not question the Government's financial policy during the last few years, because if he had done so he would have found himself in that matter up against general opinion in this State and outside it. That opinion is that the Government have shown remarkable courage in its policy generally. Take the case of the Shannon scheme. It is admitted in commercial and engineering circles, not alone in Ireland but outside of it, that it is one of the boldest schemes introduced by any Government in Europe or elsewhere. The Deputy did not suggest either that the £2,000,000 to be given to finance the sugar beet scheme should be reduced.

Comment on this

£3,000,000.

Comment on this

You cannot discuss that scheme under this.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Deputy Sears is quite in order. The Standing Orders apply all round, even to the members of the majority party.

Comment on this

That is a scheme that the country has approved of. Then we have the case of the co-operative creameries, on which money is to be expended. The Deputy put down his motion and spoke to it in a half-hearted way. I call it half-hearted, because he did not speak to it in the energetic or full-hearted way in which he supported other motions in which he fully believed. The whole policy of the Government is built on those fine schemes on the one hand and on economy on the other hand. I come from a county and province that I think has been a little neglected. I hope that the Government that has been so generous in dealing with other provinces will not forget the poorest province of all. We read about the Shannon scheme, about the sugar beet scheme, about the Barrow drainage scheme, and about the scheme for co-operative creameries. We approve of all these schemes and say they are good; they are great national schemes, and we vote for them, and what we say to ourselves is: "When will the turn of the poorest province of all come?"

Comment on this

After the elections?

Comment on this

What to do with the congested districts is undoubtedly a big problem. Undoubtedly the Government proceeded on the right lines when it appointed a Commission. It appointed the Gaeltacht Commission, and that Commission has made a report. The report may be divided into two parts, one dealing with the language side of the question, and the other with the economic side. I wish to speak about the economic side. Most of the people in this Dáil have only a slight knowledge of the poor situation in which the bulk of the people in Connaught are at the present moment. If farming is depressed in other provinces we know that the farms in the other provinces are larger, and contain much better land. It would take three or four farms in the West to make one farm in the East, in the matter of size. When you take into consideration the fact that the land is inferior, you have an idea of the terrible struggle those poor people have. The work of dividing the ranches is going on, but there is not enough land for the people there. I hope the Government will tell us what policy they have for the other people. The land, when divided, will satisfy a certain proportion of the small-holders, let us say one-third of them. What is going to happen to the two-thirds? Many of them will be worse, because they will see the other people have got something, that they have a chance of rearing their families in decency, but that there is nothing for them. I say that is a very serious situation.

I understand that the Government are considering, at the present moment, the findings of the Gaeltacht Commission, and I would urge them to go very fully into the matter and realise the seriousness and gravity of the whole position in the West of Ireland. I know one parish in the West from which 1,400 people go every year to Scotland or England to earn a living, and they come back to the parish again. That is a very hard lot on the part of those people. Generally they are in a bad way. The small towns are in a bad way. Many people in the towns of Mayo, this year, would have a difficulty in avoiding bankruptcy but for the generosity of their relatives in America. Fifty thousand pounds came to Mayo from the exiled children of the people this Christmas, and that saved the little shops. The people in Mayo are greatly indebted to these generous people in America, but it is a poor way to live. The Gaeltacht Commission has suggested one remedy for the evil of the West. The Government, I hope, will either adopt that way or suggest a way of their own. There are idle people in the towns and villages. Work should be found for them. We have a great market in Ireland. I dare say there are several hundred factories in England that are kept going by the demand for their goods in Ireland. It should not be without the wit of statesmanship to have that work done in Ireland, to have such factories as are now busy in England making goods for the Irish market in our towns and to have the wages provided by these factories circulated in the country. It should not be an impossible task to make that change. Other countries have done it, and their example might be followed in this country. On the whole, I think the Government have done well, and I must vote against Deputy Baxter's amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

A Vote on Account gives the Dáil an opportunity of examining how far the policy of the Government is in accord with the needs of the people of the country, and how far the resources of the country have to be stretched to meet the expenditure. Deputy Sear's principal fault with Deputy Baxter was that he did not enumerate, sufficiently, where savings might be made, that he did not say the savings might be made here or savings might be made there. My support of Deputy Baxter's motion is not because of the expenditure, but because of the method of expenditure— how the money is going to be employed —and I think I cannot do better than start at the head of the White Paper that is supplied to us, and point out to Deputy Sears that there is a proposition there for the expenditure of an amount on account of £2,200 for the Governor-General's establishment. One might be prepared to reconcile such expenditure with his conscience if that was the total estimate, but when one finds that public money will be voted for that institution under the Office of Public Works and Buildings, rates on Government property, Stationery Office, etc., one must come to the conclusion that really this establishment is a very expensive one, and when I look down the list and find that there is no vote for the relief of unemployment I am forced to the conclusion that the dignity of the office seems to be more important to the Government than the dignity of the people from whom the dignity of that office springs. We are not asking to maintain any reflected dignity in the 50,000 unemployed who are to-day in the State, or their dependents. We are asking that the Government would make some allowance to preserve the lives of the people which may be— dignity notwithstanding—of greater importance to the State and perhaps of greater importance to humanity. And might I suggest to the Government that there is a dignity in self-sacrifice and that even the office of the Governor-General might receive a certain amount of increased dignity by practising self-sacrifice at the top.

We are also asked to vote £725,000, on account, for the dignity of an Army. Possibly that expenditure could also be defended if we were sure what the Army is going to be employed on, if we could assure ourselves that this Army is going to be employed, as every other National Army is, for the defence of the country. That is probably the sentiment in the Army, but we must pass away from the sentiment in the Army to the policy, as expressed by the Government. Individual soldiers when joining the Army made a declaration such as this:

"I further solemnly swear that I will bear true faith and allegiance to our country and faithfully serve and defend her against all her enemies."

No doubt, the ordinary soldier understood that that was all he was to be employed for; that that was the end of his obligations and the end of his engagement. But a member of the Executive Council, and a Minister responsible for the administration of foreign policy, tells us in a statement made in this Dáil:

"We need not blink the fact that it is quite possible, in the event of a general attack on these islands—it is perfectly obvious—our Army must co-operate with the British Army."

I have tried to reconcile the declaration that the ordinary soldier makes on joining the Army with that statement of policy on the part of the Minister responsible to the Dáil and responsible to the country for his statement, and I have failed to reconcile the two. We are not likely to be attacked, we are told, in this island because of any desire on the part of any foreign power to take possession of this island. We are only likely to be attacked because this island may prove a jumping-off ground to attack a neighbouring island. Well, sir, we are asked to vote £725,000, on account, to make ourselves a frontline trench to defend the shores of another country, because this is actually what it amounts to.

We were told by another Minister, a member of the Executive Council, a Minister who has been described in this House as the steward of the finances of the country, that if we did not maintain an Army in this country it would be garrisoned by an English army; we would find ourselves in the vortex of war if England was attacked. I remember when this country was garrisoned by 100,000 British soldiers, when England was in the throes of war, and was attacked from the air and from the sea and not a cup or a saucer was broken in this island by any enemies of England. Therefore, the argument that if we do not maintain an Army here other people will maintain an Army for us is scarcely one that can be sustained. We were told by the Minister for Justice that wars are not governed by the application of two-foot rules, but I have a hazy idea that most wars are due to the machinations of the "Square and Compass," and that, probably, a good part of the arrangements made before such wars are also arranged by the same machinations. In order to make this country the cockpit of wars waged against England we are asked to spend £725,000 of the taxpayers' money. We want to have this country, or its towns and cities sacked, the country devastated for the sake of saying to the world that it is inconceivable that we should ever find ourselves except on the side of England. In this Vote on Account also we are endeavouring to make ourselves responsible for such ornamental addenda as the League of Nations.

If we were in a position to afford it, possibly there would be a defence for it, but I cannot recollect one instance in which this country got any advantage by being a member of the League of Nations. I cannot imagine any advantage that will accrue to this country except that it will, perhaps, afford members of the Government an opportunity of trying their pidgin French wherever these meetings are held on the Continent.

In the matter of agriculture, it is just as well that we should try to find out what is the policy of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture relative to this extreme depression existing in the agricultural districts. I come from a purely agricultural area. Others and I have endeavoured to put before the Minister the necessity of making suitable provision for the relief of distress in Co. Clare. Yet when my colleague yesterday asked for time to make clear to the House the position in that area, he did not get sufficient opportunity. I will give the Dáil an example of the distress prevailing amongst the agricultural community in the country. I will quote only one instance, but that will show the necessity for the taking of immediate action by the Minister. I find no statement in the Estimates touching on such relief on the part of the Minister. I will mention the case of a woman whose stock were swept away—ten milch cows, eleven other head of stock, and two horses—and no later than a couple of days ago I was told no provision could be made for the relief of distress in that case. We can afford to spend money on an ornamental Army, an ornamental League of Nations, and an ornamental Governor-General's establishment. The country seems to be based on ornaments, and the sooner we get rid of the ornamental trappings and the sooner the country gets down to facts, probably the better.

What are the miscellaneous expenses that are mentioned here? I wonder are we going to have another thousand pounds for the Abbey Theatre? I wonder if the "mist that does be on the bogs and on the hills" has left those places and developed amongst the members of the Executive Council to such an extent that they are going to subsidise a theatre for propagating a kind of speech never heard before on sea or land? I suggest to the Minister for Finance that if that item is included amongst miscellaneous expenses, it is an item he might, with some benefit to the country, drop.

Comment on this

Is that Deputy Johnson's opinion?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

I am not responsible for anybody's opinions except my own, and I will express my opinions no matter who agrees or disagrees with them. There are many other items in this that I would like to go into more fully. At the outset I said I was opposing the motion not because of the expenditure, but because of the methods by which it is proposed to expend the money. The Government will probably be able to account for the expenditure.

Deputy Sears suggested such things as the starting of factories. I was forcibly struck with the idea that, in the Defence Forces Bill, there is an opportunity given to the Army authorities to set up a factory for the manufacture of equipment and the manufacture of clothing. The Minister for Defence is here, and I am sure he will be able to tell us how much clothing that factory that he has power to establish could turn out. I am sure he could tell us how far it would advance in the manufacture of equipment and clothing. These are matters that might be attended to with some success. When we come to deal with the Estimates in detail probably we will have time to go into them at greater length and discuss the idiosyncrasies of the Department of Finance.

Comment on this

I am sure Deputies on these Benches, as well as the members of the Farmers' Party and others who have spoken, recognise the absolute necessity for a reduction of taxation in the Free State. I would appreciate Deputy Baxter's amendment much more if he and the others who have spoken gave a little sound advice, both in this House and through the country, to the people who were the cause of all the trouble. Very many millions have to be spent at the present time, not on unemployment, but to protect the country against its own people. I did not hear any advice given on that subject. If any agreement could be arrived at on that matter the millions that are being spent on the Army and the Gárda Síochána could be spent on unemployment.

I am in complete agreement as to the necessity for the reduction of taxation, but I am satisfied that the Government are doing their best in that matter. At the same time, I hope that the Minister, when introducing his Budget, will put as large a sum as possible to capital expenditure, and I hope he may be able to reduce the income tax along with other taxation.

Deputy O'Connell stated that he did not see why income tax should be reduced. Anybody who understands what income tax is, is perfectly aware that it prevents industries being started in the country and, therefore, creates unemployment. I believe that all the Deputies on these Benches are as anxious for a reduction of taxation as any other Deputies here. The Government have, under the most difficult circumstances, and without any help, made much headway. The attack made by Deputies on the Farmers' Benches and by other Deputies is unfair when they leave out the real cause of the trouble.

Comment on this

What was the cause?

Comment on this

We would like to know what the cause was.

Comment on this

Were it not for that the country would have saved millions. We have two armies in a country where there should only be one.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Are we responsible for that?

Comment on this

Well, you have not advised them.

Comment on this

Will they accept our advice?

Comment on this

You did not try; you did not give them the chance.

Comment on this

We never sowed seeds.

Comment on this

I have nothing further to say beyond that I am in complete agreement that it is a matter of necessity to reduce taxation. I am satisfied the Government intend to do it. They have even reduced the Estimates by £2,000,000. I hope the Minister will follow my advice, and I trust that we will have a reduction in both income tax and taxation.

Comment on this

I welcome a resolution of this kind, because it gives us in this House an opportunity of seeing ourselves as other people see us. There were many things Deputy Baxter said that I am not in agreement with; but there was one thing he referred to that I am in agreement with. He stated that this State of ours—this Government of ours, if you like to be more particular —was modelled on too expensive lines. That is a matter on which I have expressed opinions on more than one occasion. The Government, as we find it to-day, is set up for the purpose of governing some four millions of people. That Government is organised on, and follows the lines of, a Government that is functioning to-day and governing some forty-four millions of people. I have never been able to understand why it is essential we should follow the lines of the British Government in forming our own Government. We are, as I say, only in the relation of four to forty-four millions. Let me illustrate the point I have in view by a practical reference. Some of you have had the privilege of going over the much-discussed scheme known as the Shannon scheme. I had the privilege of being over it some months ago. What struck me about that scheme was the wonderful mechanical equipment.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

took the Chair.

Comment on this

That was interesting to me, as one having some knowledge of the operations that were being carried on there. In addition to that huge mechanical equipment one saw electrical equipment of the most up-to-date kind spread all over the area. That is all absolutely essential for the economical carrying out of a work of that magnitude.

Now, let us take a very much smaller work; let us take, if you like, the illustration of the sugar beet factory. Most of you have been over that factory. It bears much the same relation in figures to the Shannon scheme as this country bears from the point of population to Great Britain. As you go over the sugar beet factory you do not see that huge mechanical equipment, that huge electrical equipment, so noticeable on the Shannon scheme. The equipment for that particular work was in due proportion to the magnitude of the work. If those contractors had decided to lay down mechanical equipment in Carlow of the character we saw on the Shannon scheme, of course we would all naturally say that it was a very undesirable expenditure. That is exactly what I have in mind when I say that our Government is set up on too expensive a scale.

We have a huge number of departments, ministries, secretaries, and staffs. I am not very experienced in the art of government, but I am satisfied from the knowledge I have of it that there is room for considerable economies in the reformation and re-organisation of our methods. In saying that, I would like to add that our Government is in no way responsible for the form of government which we find ourselves working under to-day. It was a form of government carried on by Great Britain. It was handed over to our Government and to our State. I should like to see an inquiry into our whole system and method of government. Deputies will say that that is impossible, that you cannot get it done. But I am not satisfied that it is an impossible task. I am not satisfied that it is a thing which should not be taken in hands. Even if we fail, we will have made an effort to effect that economy in government that the people of the State are calling for. Until that step is taken by our Government, and until thorough inquiry is made into the methods and the departments of government by a committee in whom our people will have confidence, you will have this question cropping up year after year when these Estimates come forward for consideration.

When we talk of lightening the burden of taxation, we talk upon a subject on which all Parties in this House are, I think, in agreement. I am sure that if we were to know the minds of the members of the Government Party they would be just as enthusiastic as regards reduction of the burden of taxation as we on the other Benches are. When we come to discuss the particular taxes in respect of which it is desirable to lighten the burden, we will, of course, differ. But I agree with Deputy Shaw that it is eminently desirable, when we talk of reductions, to consider the question of income tax. I do not know any tax, amongst the many taxes in our State, that has the same ramifications that income tax has. I do not know any tax the lightening of which would do more to throw that enthusiasm into industry which is so necessary to-day. If we could get that enthusiasm into industry, we could do a great deal towards solving the problem of unemployment which it seems hopeless to deal with otherwise. Those of us who are engaged in industry know the difficulty that exists, in view of the past history of the country, in getting capital to flow into industry. What will do more to encourage that capital to flow into this country than the reduction of income tax to a markedly lower level than obtains in the sister island? Therefore, I say that, considering its ramifications, the lightening of that tax will do more to solve the many problems we are faced with to-day than any other reduction that one could suggest.

As we are on this question of reduction of taxation, I should like to direct attention to one other tax which I should like to see removed—that is the Corporation Profits Tax. I know of no tax that is more inequitable than that particular tax. It is one of the relics we have of the war taxes. It only existed for a short time in the sister island and each Chancellor of the Exchequer, when his attention was drawn to the incidence of the tax, agreed, without a moment's hesitation, that it was one of the first taxes that should be removed. That tax, I am sorry to say, still remains, in part, in this country. It is true the burden of it has been lightened by raising the level, but that does not make the tax one bit more acceptable or one whit more justifiable. I hope that this year our Minister will see his way to wipe out that inequitable tax. We might also help our citizens to a considerable extent by removing the anomalies that exist in the allowances given in respect of income tax. Those who have gone into those figures, as I have, know that there are certain anomalies that ought to be inquired into and adjusted. They would not amount, in the gross total, to a great deal, but the relief that would be given would be widespread.

Deputy Sears referred to-day to the land policy of the Government, and the desirability of its extension in the West of Ireland. I have discussed this question of land policy with several well-known people in the West of Ireland. Their view is that the conditions we find in the West to-day have been largely accentuated by our land policy. The taking of the land from the landlords—and by landlords we knew some of the best old families who were associated for generations with this country—has led to these people leaving the country and to the land being divided amongst a number of tenants. These tenants have neither the knowledge nor the capital to work the land, with the result that, in many cases, they are clamouring for the return of the people who gave them employment and assistance in the past.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Would the Deputy tell us where he got that information?

Comment on this

What county does the Deputy refer to?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Is the Deputy aware that the whole cause of the trouble is that the people have not got land? They are clamouring for land and not for landlords.

Comment on this

I expected some such interruption and I brought with me a letter which I received a little while ago from a well-known landowner in the Midlands. He writes as follows:—

"In March, 1925, the Land Commission took over from me about 700 acres, 100 of which is bog, which I previously farmed myself. This meant that I parted with 10 of my permanent staff. The Commissioners divided the land into lots containing from 6 to 20 acres apiece. Eight of my former employees were offered portions. Some of them have begged for re-employment, stating they could not live on the land. I was there on Friday and found that three of them have sold their interest in the lots. Another is trying to sell his. Some of them will get along all right, I think. The land is almost all in grass, and I am informed that a considerable portion of the stock on it belongs to shopkeepers in the neighbouring town. A number of newly erected dividing fences have collapsed."

He winds up with these remarkable words:

"I fail to see how this sort of division of land is going to benefit the country."

I only desire to add that we should hasten slowly with any policy which drives people with capital, who have been associated with this country for so many years, from those homes they have so long inhabited.

Comment on this

I very seldom agree either with Deputy Good or with Deputy Shaw, so, on this occasion, I enjoy the rare pleasure of finding myself at one with those two Deputies with regard to their expression of desire for a more economic Government. I could wish, however, that Deputy Good had expressed that view, and voted according to it, in December, 1925. We hear about the overlapping of services and the costly duplication of public offices, but we have, in a little island with a population of 4,000,000, two Governments, two judiciaries, two sets duplicating everything. The machinery by which that duality could eventually have been removed was sacrificed by the Executive Council, with the approval, recorded by his vote, of Deputy Good.

Deputy Shaw complains about the income tax; so does Deputy Good. Deputy Shaw's remedy is to secure stability in the country. I believe he is right. "We require to get capital to flow in"—I think those are the words of Deputy Good—and capital, as has been said so often, is notoriously a shy bird. Capital will not flow into any country where the conditions are not conditions of stability. Deputy Shaw knows as well as I do that from the hour at which the "cease fire" order was given we could have all the makings of stable government without dread of armed insurrection later if the representatives elected by the constituencies were provided with the opportunity of coming here to serve the constituencies that returned them. Deputy Shaw, as a member for a constituency in the West, must be well aware of the feeling of his own constituency. I was there quite recently and had an opportunity of informing myself of what the people think.

Comment on this

Yes, with forty of an audience.

Comment on this

Has Deputy Shaw any other interruption to make before I go on? We had an Imperial Conference recently at which it was declared that the Irish Free State is a co-equal member of the British Commonwealth, and so anxious were those statesmen of Empire to convince the public of that fact that it was quite feasible for our Minister for External Affairs to secure from them the declaration that that formula which was imposed under the Constitution is no longer requisite, if for no other reason than that it is the direct negation of co-equality. The sister country, as Deputy Good facetiously calls Great Britain, imposes upon this legislature, and entrance to it of elected representatives of the people, subscription to a formula. Unless the elected representative of a constituency subscribe that formula he will not be allowed to serve his electors in this House. That could have been removed quite easily by proper representations from the Ministers who were representing this country at the Imperial Conference. Anyone who knows anything about the state of feeling in the country must be well aware that so long as a large percentage of Deputies are refused admission to this House because of a formula which is out of date——

Comment on this

Is this in order?

Comment on this

I submit, sir, that I am perfectly in order. This is an act of omission on the part of the Minister for External Affairs, and Deputy Shaw distinctly introduced the question of stabilisation of peace and its influence upon the possibility of reducing expenditure. There is the same rule for members on this side of the House as there is for those of the Government Party. I know very well that the President does not like me to continue on this line. It makes him uncomfortable — it stirs his guilty conscience.

Comment on this

I can quite understand your difficulty in ruling a member of your own Party out of order, but I ask for a ruling on the subject.

Comment on this

I really must protest against the expression that has been used by the President to you in the Chair. The President has put to you a point of order about a Deputy in this House, and he has referred to him as "a member of your Party." I say that is casting a reflection on the Chair unworthy of any Deputy, and especially the leader of the House.

Comment on this

He should withdraw.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

As regards the point of order, discussions on motions of this kind are pretty wide, but the question of the constitution of the House is regulated by an Act of the Dáil, and it would require an Act of the Oireachtas to change it.

Comment on this

I think, as a matter of good taste, the President should withdraw the remark he has made. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle was put in the Chair by the President's Party, and has sat in the Chair with the confidence of the majority of the House, and that remark should not be made.

Comment on this

Might I remind the Deputy that it was made a rule last year that no matter which required legislation could be discussed on the Estimates. We are discussing a Vote on Account — the Estimates, in other words. I asked was the Deputy in order.

Comment on this

You did not ask that.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon. I am speaking to the Leas-Cheann Comhairle. I put it to him, was it in order?

Comment on this

You asked was a member of his Party in order.

Comment on this

I asked first was it in order.

Comment on this

Do you deny the words you used?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

I think we can allow the matter to rest there.

Comment on this

I think it is not fair to the Chair, apart from your being in the Chair. I think the disrespect offered by the President to the Chair should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle can say himself whether I raised it as a point of order in the first instance.

Comment on this

You said: "I can understand your difficulty in ruling out a member of your own Party."

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

As regards my position here, the very fact of Deputy Magennis and myself being politically associated would make me all the more anxious to rule him out of order if I thought it right. I have tried, as far as I can, to be fair and impartial to all members. There is no man perfect—any man is liable to make a mistake, but I have done my best. We want good-will amongst all the Parties in the House, and I think I can say that this House has conducted its business in an excellent way—far ahead of many Houses of Parliament that were established long before this Assembly.

Comment on this

I come to the Vote for the President of the Executive Council, to let the other incident pass as a further addition to the examples of the President's manners. I promised that I would raise the question of the President's disregard of the treatment of a citizen of the Free State in connection with his business across the Border. When I asked a question as to what steps, if any, the President had taken in the matter, following his usual procedure and insolence, he suggested that I had no authority from the citizen in question.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation. Yesterday, or the day before, the Deputy asked me a question and I asked him was he authorised to ask that question. He has now suggested quite a different meaning to what actually was the case.

Comment on this

The implication in asking that question was——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

How do we come to be discussing a detail like this on a Vote on Account? In what way does a particular question of this kind arise now?

Comment on this

I understood that the policy of the particular Department for which the vote is taken is subject to review on this occasion. If it is not, I submit to your ruling and subside.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I think the policy of a particular Department, as illustrated by a particular instance, is hardly under review. What is under review is general Government financial policy and matters of general import, not matters which might be raised in detail on consideration of the Estimates. That was emphasised at the very beginning. The obvious objection to the raising of specific matters dealing with each vote is that there are over 60 votes and over 100 Deputies, and that it would be impossible to allow the same latitude to each Deputy. Manifestly, therefore, some rule must be enforced which would allow to every Deputy the same fair play. I did not hear the beginning of Deputy Magennis's statement on this particular matter, but I think that to raise a grievance—if I may call it so, without worrying about a particular word— arising out of an answer to a question, obviously opens up quite a number of details which could not possibly be gone into.

Comment on this

The question I was about to raise, and it would be well to have your ruling on it, is what I call a dereliction of duty on the part of the President in refusing to move, at the instance of a citizen of the Free State, to have his property protected from destruction and loss. If I am not at liberty to deal with that, of course I shall pass on. Do I understand you, sir, to rule in that way?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

How can the Deputy deal with that as a matter of policy?

Comment on this

What I respectfully submit is that the conduct of the President of the Executive Council in leaving a citizen without the defence that a citizen is entitled to look for from his own Government when he is being victimised by another Government, is a fair matter for criticism on a vote for the President's Department.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I think it is a matter which could be raised in the House; an occasion for raising it could be found; but I think this is not the occasion, because it is a particular matter and a great number of similar matters could be raised. If the Deputy wants to raise a question on a particular matter an occasion could be found, but I think this occasion is not the right one.

Comment on this

I was conscious that the strictly proper occasion would be on the Estimates, but inasmuch as the Estimates are postponed, it seemed to me that this provided an opportunity. However, I will pass away from that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

If the Chair were to agree that the fact that the Estimates are not being discussed, and are not likely to be discussed, by this House should enable Deputies to raise questions now on matters that would properly arise on the Estimates, we would, of course, enter into an Estimates' discussion. Deputy Magennis will realise that fully himself. I think, apart from the Estimates, an opportunity could be found for this.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that Deputy Magennis could raise this matter on Vote 3 for the Department of the President of the Executive Council?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I am afraid that is the matter we have decided.

Comment on this

I was very much interested in the speech of Deputy Sears. I should have thought that from him, if not from a Minister of the Executive Council, we would have had an authoritative exposition of Government policy. Strangely enough, he appears to be as ignorant as to what is the Government policy as I am. I hope the Government will tell us what policy they have for our people. I am sorry Deputy Sears is not here. In another connection, that of the Gaeltacht Commission's Report, he hopes the Government will find a solution that way—the way recommended by the Report—or some other way. That does not display very much confidence in the ability of the Government to find a solution for pressing national problems. So that his failure to make an act of faith in the practical wisdom of his own leaders is on a par with his ignorance of what exactly they intend by way of policy.

He commended two things in connection with the Government's expenditure, the Shannon scheme and the sugar beet subsidy. He apparently forgets that commendation of the Shannon scheme is essential, and, as regards the subsidy for sugar beet, he does not seem to be aware of the recent disclosures. It may be within the recollection of the House that when the proposal to establish the sugar industry in the Free State was before the Dáil it was strongly insisted, as against my proposition to have two factories set up by means of a subsidy, that the country could afford only one, and that, it alleged repeatedly, was by way of experiment. And yet, within a few months of these declarations, the subsidy was increased. What I, in common with those who were pressing this aspect of the beet industry upon the Government, feared in the case of the setting up of only one factory was that it might be on too small a scale to give the new project a chance of that success which we knew was bound to come to a factory of the proper dimensions. Now, the original factory is on a large scale. The subsidy is on a large scale. What is the result? It excludes the competition that would be possible if another factory had been set up in another district. Does the President wish to interrupt me?

Comment on this

On a point of order. I notice that we are not asked to vote any money for the beet sugar subsidy, and, therefore, I wish to know if it is in order to discuss it at this stage?

Comment on this

General policy.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That point was raised. Strictly speaking, it is not in order, but, as was decided at the opening of the discussion, in so far as it is a question of policy it can be discussed.

Comment on this

Deputy Sears went into it, and that is why I took notice of it. Deputy Esmonde is correct to this extent, that the vote for the purpose is nil. We have a vote for the Tariff Commission. Another of the topics upon which Deputy Sears was cheerful was unemployment and the lack of hope for people in the west. That I interpreted to be as distant and as timid a reference as the Chairman of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party dared make to the policy of the Executive Council. The Tariff Commission, constituted of civil servants, has been set up. Would it be in order to discuss it? I am afraid it would not.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I think that Deputy Sears' timidity was due to the fact that he felt that tariffs would be more suitable for the Budget speech and that he thought an expression of opinion might come from the Chair to that effect. The question of the imposition of tariffs generally will arise on the Budget and on more than one occasion in connection with the Budget.

Comment on this

There are only two other topics to which I wish to refer. I would have had something to say about the National Gallery but I leave that for later. Then there is the Office of the Minister for Fisheries, £17,000. Since the last time that we had an opportunity of discussing that department, which is so necessary for the development of the State, a step has been taken to create another central market. But the speeding-up process is very slow, and as yet we have no prospects of a subsidy or grant-in-aid for transport purposes, to facilitate the distribution of the fishermen's catches. I think that it would be useful to awaken the Minister for Finance to the needs of his colleague, and I utilise this opportunity to do so. The Office of the Minister for External Affairs presents so many points of attack, that I think I had better leave it for the Budget also.

Comment on this

I support this motion, but in doing so I want it to be clearly understood that I am not asking for a reduction in expenditure that would lead towards a further reduction in the purchasing power of the community. I take the view that in many of the departments of the State too much money is made available for the administration side, and too little for the development side. There is no more glaring instance of that than in the case of the Department of Fisheries. I want it to be clearly understood that I do not stand for the abolition of that department, but if it is to serve the purpose for which it was established the Government will have to give more money for the development of that national service. We had two remarkable speeches made this evening—one by Deputy Shaw, who accused the members of all parties except his own of not having done enough in his own little way to cool the temperatures of the people who are outside, and who, in his opinion, have been responsible for imposing a good deal of taxation on the State which it should not in normal circumstances be called upon to bear. Speaking for myself, I do not think that I have any mission in that direction. We had, on the other hand, Deputy Good proclaiming his hostility to the operation of the Land Act on the ground that it was driving people out of the country who would remain and render service to its citizens if the Act was not put into operation and their land taken from them. I hold the view—and this is in answer to Deputy Shaw and Deputy Good—that there is enough room in this small country for every Irishman who has a proper Irish outlook, and who can, in his own little way, help his own country if he wants to do so. I say that to the public representatives who are outside this House, and they should regard this country and its future as greater than themselves as individuals.

We heard from Deputy O'Connell particulars of reductions in the amounts for development works in different votes. It is true that we have a few votes in which increases are provided. For instance, the Old Age Pensions Vote had been increased from £2,597,300 to £2,627,300. I take that as meaning that the Minister will announce in his Budget statement that he is restoring the shilling and that he will apologise to the public for having cut the shilling off the aged poor.

Comment on this

It means that there will be fifty-three pay days next year instead of fifty-two, which is the usual number.

Comment on this

We will wait and see.

Comment on this

That has exploded that.

Comment on this

We are now supposed to have received information for which we might otherwise have to wait until April 20th. I agree with Deputy Baxter that the taxation imposed should have some bearing on the capacity of the people to pay. I believe that the country is not in that rosy and ideal condition of which Deputy Sears speaks, and I am forced to take that view by a study of the statistics that are available. This is an agricultural country, and I thought it was the aim and the intention of the Government, when it passed the Land Act of 1923, to make provision for a greater number of Irish citizens to live in this country, rather than to continue the policy of sending out the bullocks as well as the young men. From the statistics with regard to agriculture I find that from 1922 to 1926 there has been a reduction of 218,000 acres of land under tillage. If tillage farming is paying why should the people go out of tillage and allow the land to go into grass? If you had that 218,000 acres under tillage instead of under grass, how many more citizens would it provide employment for? I believe that in the ordinary course with that acreage under tillage it would provide all round the year employment for about 10,000 people. That may be an exaggerated estimate. It is merely a rough one.

A fortnight ago I saw the Government programme of legislation which was submitted by the President to Deputy Johnson, and I was delighted to see under it that provision was made for the introduction of a Bill for the drainage of the River Barrow. I took that as an indication to start the real work ment's intention to start the real work of drainage this year. But when I received the Estimates I found that only a small additional sum is provided for this year's work, for preliminary work similar to that in progress for the last five or six months. Last year £20,000 was provided for preliminary work, and this year there is a sum of £75,000 for the continuation of the same work. That is a clear indication, if we had no other, that the Government does not really intend to start that work this year. I had hoped when I heard the Minister asking for leave to introduce the Bill yesterday evening that we would have had it in our hands to-day, and that I would now be in a better position to know what the Government's intentions really are in this direction.

I will hold my own view as to what the Government means by introducing that Bill but not making provision for carrying out the work for which it will provide.

Comment on this

Wait until you see the Bill.

Comment on this

Now as to arterial drainage, last year there was a sum of £15,000 provided for in connection with work under the Act of 1925. Notwithstanding the fact that the Act was passed two years ago and that there has been almost 400 schemes submitted by the county councils in connection with work to be carried out under that Act, the Government only make provision for £50,000 for such work during the coming financial year. In one of the counties of my constituency seven schemes were submitted, but in only one case has the preliminary inspection work been carried out, and it is doubtful whether the actual work in connection with that scheme will ever be undertaken. When the Bill was before the House I took the view that it was one of the most important measures that could be submitted, and that it would lead to the employment of a greater number of men in rural Ireland than any other Government measure. I do not see what can be done with the limited sum of £50,000 provided for in the Estimate. I think I raised the question some time ago with the Minister for Finance as to why a greater number of engineers was not being employed on arterial drainage work, and the Minister expressed the view that there was not a sufficient number of qualified engineers in this country to enable them to undertake the work with any greater effect than they were doing. Studying the Estimates and looking at the salaries provided for the payment of engineers, one is amazed to find that qualified engineers are asked to work for £200 a year. I am not surprised that the Minister cannot find men for such work when he is only prepared to pay qualified engineers a miserable pittance of £200 a year. I hope he will reconsider the position from that point of view and see the advisability of paying engineers a salary which will induce the proper type of men to come along and do valuable work of that kind.

On the question of the beet subsidy, I raise this question as a matter of policy, and my complaint against the Government is that they have recently been responsible for the extension of an agreement which went beyond the authority which the Dáil gave them under the Beet Subsidy Act of 1925. When that Bill was going through the House I was one of the most enthusiastic supporters of the Government on the matter, and we were led to believe that the figure which the Government intended to pay as a subsidy would not exceed £2,000,000. We find, however, in an answer of the Minister to a question by Deputy Johnson on the 15th February that the subsidy will probably amount to £2,800,000. I protest against the Government's policy on that matter. I believe that the Government, instead of putting a premium on the Carlow factory, should have aimed at establishing another factory elsewhere. I have read the agreement, which has been laid on the Table of the Dáil, between the Government and Lippens & Co. It is definitely stated that the Government would not agree to the establishment of another factory within a certain radius of the Carlow factory. I can, of course, quite understand that. The Minister, in his answer to Deputy Johnson's question, justifying the unreliable estimate upon which the original agreement was based, said:—

"The concession with regard to the first three years of the period was made because there were at the time of the agreement no reliable data with reference to the production of sugar beet in the Saorstát on a commercial scale, and no one could state with any certainty how many acres of sugar beet would require to be under cultivation in order to produce 10,000 tons of sugar. The company, consequently, did not know with certainty at that time what acreage to aim at in making their contract with beet growers."

I was one of twelve individuals who, at the request of some of my constituents, went to Brussels in connection with the site for the factory and those acting on behalf of the Athy site, like those who acted in the interests of Carlow, had to make a careful case, giving figures including the guaranteed acreage. Those who acted on behalf of Athy handed to the company guarantees to the extent of 5,698 acres. The Carlow people handed in guarantees of the extent of 8,000 acres. Now it has turned out that there is something over 9,000 acres under cultivation in the country. I can produce copies of the case which was compiled by solicitors and other people to prove my statement. It is not correct for the Minister to say that the company did not know what acreage to aim at. The information as to acreage was at the disposal of Messrs. Lippens in August and the agreement was not signed until October. The acreage was guaranteed, and the written guarantees of individual farmers were handed over to the firm. I raise the question because in one of the counties of my constituency the people supply to the Carlow factory 18.9 per cent. of the beet grown throughout the whole of the Saorstát.

I have received several individual communications on behalf of prospective beet-growers who are anxious to be allowed to grow beet this year. I understand that the policy of the company is to allow a certain increased percentage to those who grew beet last year. I agree that that is a good policy, but I can say with confidence that if there was another factory—say, in Thurles, Tullamore, Buttevant, or elsewhere — there would be a sufficient acreage guaranteed for the establishment of that factory.

I protest against the policy of the Government in increasing without authority the subsidy to be given to the Carlow factory. Looking up the record. I find that the authorised capital of the Irish Sugar Manufacturing Company is £400,000, and, I regret to say, that less than £10,000 of that capital is owned or controlled by Irishmen. These figures have been given to our Party by the Minister's department. If the factory had been established at Athy, the amount of Irish share capital guaranteed would be £16,543. I make that point to show that the Government are over-generous in their dealings with foreign capitalists, even though those dealings may mean business done in the interests of Irishmen. Contrast with that the Government's policy in regard to old age pensions, and when we come to consider their policy in regard to the ultimate financial settlement with the British, we find that they committed themselves to agreements by which they will collect Land Commission annuities to the extent of £3,000,000, free of all cost of collection. One would imagine that the taxpayers of this country are so prosperous that we can afford to collect taxes for outsiders, and make our own taxpayers pay the cost of collection.

Deputy Hogan referred to the Army and to the necessity for abolishing the Estimate asked for it. I take the view, and I think it is the view of a great many other Deputies, that the meaning of the statement recently made by the Minister for External Affairs is that the Irish Army of the future is really going to be a mere regiment of the British Army. It means, in effect, that the Irish Army will be almost a menace to the country rather than a means of protecting it. We were told that if any country was foolish enough to declare war and attack Great Britain, the expectation is that the Irish Army will assist the British. With regard to the general conditions of the country, it has been claimed by Deputy Sears that the country is much more prosperous now than it was in the last three or four years, and he claimed that that happy condition, which I challenge, is due to the Government's policy. The recent Census figures show that there is a rush of population from the country to the towns and to foreign countries. If the country is as prosperous as Deputy Sears says, why is it that there is such a rush from the country? It is the young men who are going because they see no hope for themselves in the future. If the conditions were such as Deputy Sears pictures, I do not think that you would have so many applications to the Office of the American Consul as there are at present.

Many Deputies have received letters from young Irishmen asking them to make an appointment at the American Consulate at an earlier date than that arranged, so as to enable them to get out of the country as quickly as they can. That, I think, is clear proof that the country is not in the prosperous condition to which Deputy Sears referred. I recognise that the policy of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture is helping, and will further help to improve the position of the average farmer, but I think it is rather calculated to create wealth for the grass farmer than for the tillage farmer. Whatever policy, at any rate, is put forward, so long as it will help to create a ready cash return for the farmer, I think that is the only way in which we can aim at putting the people on the land in a more prosperous position than they are in at present. I would like to hear from the Minister for Finance as to why he is not able to make better provision for carrying out work under the Arterial Drainage Act. As I said, it is, perhaps, the only scheme that could create really useful employment for our rural population. I hope he will reconsider the position and see his way to provide a larger sum for giving employment and carrying out the very useful work that remains to be done under the Act of 1925.

Comment on this