We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

IN COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - ELECTRICITY SUPPLY BILL, 1927—COMMITTEE STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 1–198 of 392. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electricity (Supply) Bill 1927
Enacted

No. 10 of 1927 ›

I move—

To delete sub-sections (2), (3) and (4) and substitute therefor the following new sub-sections:—

"(2) The accounts of the Board shall be audited annually by the Comptroller and Auditor-General, who shall submit to the Dáil a report of such Audit together with a copy of the balance sheet, and profit and loss account, and copies of such accounts, as may be at any time prescribed by the Minister.

"(3) This Report shall be taken into consideration in such a manner as the Dáil shall from time to time direct."

This amendment is intended to substitute for the method of audit prescribed by the Minister in this section, a more impartial and more effective audit, and to bring the accounts of the scheme under the more direct control of the Dáil. I raised this point on Second Reading, and the Minister replied to me in a most convincing and emphatic manner: "This Board is not a State Department and we do not want the accounts audited by the Comptroller and Auditor-General because that would be bringing the Board within the scope and ambit of a Government Department. We do not want the Board to have that appearance." Of course, as Deputies have begun to realise, the Minister for Industry and Commerce is never more convincing and never more emphatic than when he is on rather delicate ground. This amendment will not bring the Board into line with an ordinary Government Department. An ordinary Government Department has its accounts audited by the Comptroller and Auditor-General automatically under the Comptroller and Auditor-General Act. A summary of that audit goes into the Appropriation Accounts and is automatically considered by the Committee of Public Accounts.

In order to meet this unusual timidity on the part of the Minister I have proposed a very different procedure. The accounts are audited by the Comptroller and Auditor-General who sends a separate report of these accounts to the Dáil, and the Dáil considers that report in such manner as it may think fit. It may consider it in Committee of the whole Dáil which, I think, is the Minister's view. It may set up a Special Committee to consider the accounts of the Electricity Board or it may, if it thinks fit, refer them to the Committee of Public Accounts, but that will be done by a separate act of reference and will not be, in any sense, automatic. The Minister spoke last night about the necessity for having on the Board a member with a proper and conscientious point of view as to the handling of public money, and he instanced, as a suitable member if he could be spared, which he cannot, Deputy Johnson. Deputy Johnson, I am sure, if he was on that Board would be the first person to desire to have an absolutely impartial audit of the accounts of the Board. If I could visualise Deputy Johnson at that Board, I can see that his first step would be to suggest that the accounts should go to the Comptroller and Auditor-General.

The amendment has two purposes, firstly to secure an impartial audit. As the section stands the Minister may appoint any person he thinks fit to be auditor. He may appoint an officer of the Department of Industry and Commerce. He may even appoint an employee of the Electricity Supply Board to audit the accounts of that Board. There is no limitation on it whatever. I suggest that the accounts should be submitted to a public official, already in existence who is a civil servant and absolutely immune from and impervious to any opinions or any pressure that might be brought to bear on him. That is the first purpose, but on the whole it is the smaller purpose of this amendment.

The more important purpose I am putting forward in this amendment is that the Dáil should receive the balance sheet and the profit and loss account. In the Bill, as it stands there is absolutely no provision of any kind whatever that the Dáil shall ever see these important documents. There are two provisions in the Bill dealing with audit and report. There is the provision in this Section 6, but that is entirely between the Board and the Minister. That has nothing to do with the Dáil. Section 30 is the section that lays down what the Dáil has to get and the Dáil and the Seanad are to receive a copy of every report made. But the audit is not a report. It is differentiated—"and all such statistics and returns furnished to him under this section together with a copy of such of the accounts of the Board furnished to him under this Act as in his opinion are necessary for the proper understanding of any such report." Now this Section 6 expressly differentiates between the balance sheet and the profit and loss account and such accounts as the Minister may require to have furnished to him. The result will be if the Minister thinks fit he can withhold from the Dáil the result of the audit, the balance sheet and the profit and loss account.

There are moments when I am sorry to say I am tempted to think that the Minister thinks the Shannon scheme is his private property and that it is an impertinence for the Dáil to require any information on it. That was evidenced by some of his replies yesterday to Deputy Good.

It is even more forcibly made plain by some of the sections of this Bill. Now this is not the Minister's private property, and of course it would be liable to great alterations in the event of a change of Ministers. We are not legislating in perpetuity, as the Minister says, and I am quite sure that if a Labour Government or a Farmers' Government came into power an amending Bill would be brought in. But there are sometimes changes of Ministers in the same Party. Imagine a change between the Minister for Defence and the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The new Minister for Industry and Commerce would give us a very much quieter time, but he might construe the provisions of this Bill in a somewhat different spirit, while Heaven defend us from the present Minister for Industry and Commerce as Minister for Defence, because his activity is such that we should be involved in a war some time. It is not wise to allow the whole of this Bill to depend on the Minister. It is, after all, a commercial measure, and we in the Dáil are in the position of representatives of the shareholders who have advanced the capital to enable this scheme to be carried out. I do not know of any limited commercial concern in which the auditor is not appointed by the shareholders and in which the shareholders do not receive a copy of the audit, the balance-sheet and the profit and loss account. I suggest that we, as representing the citizens of the State, whose money is being embarked in the scheme, should be entitled to appoint our auditor, and I suggest a civil servant, the Comptroller and Auditor-General.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Comptroller and Auditor-General is not a civil servant.

Comment on this

An official of the Dáil, I should have said. I accept the correction. He is not a civil servant; he is actually an official of the Dáil, and that strengthens my case. I say that we should appoint one of our own officials as auditor, and that we should, by statute, be entitled to the results of the audit, the balance-sheet and the profit and loss account. As the Bill stands we have to rely for these on the good-will of the Minister, and I suggest we should have them as of right and not as of privilege.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Deputy Cooper says that his amendment is to get a more effective and a more impartial audit. That is the first purpose. The Deputy did question this matter on Second Reading, but questioned it in such a way that he left the House entirely in the dark as to his second idea, that he wanted to bring this whole scheme, and the whole operations of the Board from year to year, under the control of the Dáil and under the supervision of the Public Accounts Committee.

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The particular point to which I had devoted a certain amount of my time in opening the Second Reading debate, and a point which had been approved of by the Dáil, was that the main thing to aim at was to get this business undertaking run in a businesslike way, without supervision of the type that we are accustomed to have by means of the Public Accounts Committee, or by means of questions in this House or by means of discussions on Estimates. It was quite clear to the Dáil on Second Reading that it was one of the fundamental points about this Bill that there should not be any interference in the matter by the Dáil. On the other hand, I did say, on Second Reading, that the one thing that people could ask for, and should be entitled to ask for, was that there should be the clearest publicity as to everything the Board did, that there should be no hiding of anything that was done. I am with Deputy Cooper in wanting to have an impartial audit. I have taken the only means open to me, as far as I could discover from other legislation dealing with concerns similar to this, that is to say, that there should be an auditor who would not be appointed by the Board that was to be set up, to preclude the Board from appointing an auditor who might gloss over matters in the accounts to which the Board did not want attention directed, and that this auditor, when appointed, would, however, have to be paid by the Board. I was thinking of going a step further and taking a hint from Canadian legislation by even saying that the Minister should go through the formality of handing over the fee to the auditor and that he should get that back from the Board afterwards so that there would be in no way any liaison between the auditor and the Board. But instead of looking for something which was merely an impartial audit, Deputy Cooper now thinks there would be a more effective audit through the Comptroller and Auditor-General. The duty of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, as laid down by the Act of 1923, is: "to control all disbursements and to audit all accounts of moneys administered by or under the authority of the Oireachtas at such times and in such manner as shall from time to time be prescribed by law." There is nothing prescribed by law with regard to these accounts. All that the Comptroller and Auditor-General could do under this amendment would simply be to say whether or not the disbursements were in order, and that is what the Deputy considers to be a more effective audit than that of an ordinary auditor in the case of an ordinary commercial concern. It is not a more effective audit than can be given in the way I have suggested, and if there is not enough impartiality about the method I have suggested, other steps might be taken to secure impartiality, without going to the length of bringing in the Comptroller and Auditor-General, who has very specialised functions and who operated in a particular way.

But the second point is a much more important one—bringing all the operations under the control of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, who would report to the Dáil, and then the Public Accounts Committee would sit upon that audit and report and discuss them, which is simply bringing in the thing that the Dáil had been specially invited to consider on Second Reading—this Section 6. The Dáil had, as far as I can discover, unanimously agreed to that. The only one who raised any objection at all to Section 6 was Deputy Cooper on the point as to whether the impartiality of the auditor had been sufficiently achieved. As to the limitations, if there is an amendment to Section 6 required to ensure that certain things must be published—not such of them as are prescribed in that behalf, by regulations to be made under certain authorities—if there is an insistence that the public ought to have certain accounts proceeding from the auditor, and these accounts with the auditor's report on them, let us deal with these things in detail. I am out for giving all the publicity possible to the accounts of the Board, and to any audit of them, but I object entirely to having any accounts of the Board dragged back again into this House through the supervision of the Comptroller and Auditor-General. I am told that I have come to regard this scheme as more or less my private property, and the strange comment was made that my answer to Deputy Hewat yesterday showed that. I think that Deputy Hewat must have been in a jocose vein yesterday when he asked me to do some of the things he put up to me. On reading some of the things he asked me I am more than ever convinced of that. The Deputy wanted me, for instance, to state what was the sum allotted in the £600,000 or in the £2,500,000 for compensation.

Comment on this

I never asked that.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy wanted to know if I could give a clear indication as to the amounts under the different headings, and that was one of the headings of which he spoke.

Comment on this

I am not aware that there was anything in the Money Vote that would indicate that the money is to go in compensation.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy has voted money without understanding what he was voting for. Quite clearly the Board will have no money to pay in compensation if it is not the money voted yesterday, and undoubtedly compensation has to be paid. I would like the House to consider, say, in connection with the recent negotiations that have been almost concluded by the Minister for Lands and Agriculture in regard to the creameries, what would have been the position if the Minister had come here before making his offer, and had announced what money he was prepared to offer? I wonder would he have got as good a bargain as he is now supposed to have got?

Comment on this

Can the Minister say if the Minister for Lands and Agriculture made an arrangement before he came to the House?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

We are wandering away from amendment 10.

Comment on this

I hope you will absolve me from having done any such thing?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I absolve Deputy Hewat.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Deputy Cooper says it is a commercial concern and we are the shareholders and are entitled to the accounts. Certainly if the shareholders indicate what accounts they want and can persuade their fellow-shareholders that that is a fair thing to ask for, then it will be put in. But the Deputy wants to throw it all back again to the Comptroller and Auditor-General, who apparently is to be put in by a certain body of shareholders against the present Executive Council, who are presumably not shareholders in this matter, or at least are open to suspicion as being prejudiced and unfair towards their fellow-shareholders. It was quite clear here on Second Reading that the whole aim and object of the Bill was to get a Board set up to run a business undertaking and to have that Board removed from anything which was merely going to be an interference. There is no objection to an audit of accounts, but there is quite clearly stated this purpose of having the accounts removed at any rate from the Comptroller and Auditor-General, removed certainly from the Public Accounts Committee, removed as far as possible from ordinary year-to-year discussion by the Dáil, and it seemed to me that that had been approved— I heard no objection to it. Let it be realised what is intended. There are two parts in this amendment. In so far as it aims at a more impartial audit, I would like to have the audit as impartial as can be achieved. In so far as it aims at greater publicity, more accounts to be given to the public who are the shareholders, I am all for that, but let us have a clear-cut decision what accounts are to be given. The second part of the amendment is what I object to—the bringing back of all the accounts and the whole operations of the Board from year to year for discussion in the Dáil, in view of the political reactions that are bound to follow from that. I thought we had decided on Second Reading to launch this Board, to see that there was as much publicity as possible given to their doings, but not to have every action of theirs criticised from the political point of view in the House.

Comment on this

I hope I never introduced undue partisanship into my criticism in this House, but I must say that the Minister's statement is very largely camouflage. Either it is camouflage or the Minister has not read the amendment. There is not a word in it about the Public Accounts Committee. It is expressly laid down that there should be a separate function from the normal review of accounts by the Comptroller and Auditor-General, that it should go through an entirely different procedure. It will be in the hands of the Dáil— which I presume means in the hands of the Executive Council—to say what this report and this audit shall consist of.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Did the Deputy mention the Public Accounts Committee?

Comment on this

I said that if the Dáil thought fit and the Executive Council thought fit—the Executive Council control the majority of the Dáil at present—they could send it to the Public Accounts Committee. But it would be open to them either to have it considered in committee of the full Dáil or to set up a special committee to deal with it. The only difference between myself and the Minister on this point is that the Minister visualises discussion in the Dáil. He said so in his Second Reading speech. He visualises in Section 30 a report from the Electricity Supply Board to be considered in the Dáil, and the only difference between us is that he is content to have a report furnished by the Board which need not contain any of the really important facts as to finance that we need when discussing it; while I seek to have a report from an impartial authority with full details on the finances of the Board. I do not think the Minister has realised the implications of his argument. He suggested that he would give full information, but did not wish the Dáil to discuss and debate the finances of the scheme. The only inference that can be drawn from that is that the finances cannot bear discussion. I do not for a moment think that that is the case. I do not for a moment believe that the Board will indulge in rash and dangerous experiments, but if the public mind in this country is to be satisfied that they are not doing so, you will have to give all the information possible, and not only all the information possible, but opportunity for discussing that information. My amendment does provide that machinery.

References to the Comptroller and Auditor-General are entirely irrelevant to this discussion. This is an additional function to be imposed on the Comptroller and Auditor-General, and I have reason to believe that he has a staff of officers who are capable of carrying out an ordinary audit on commercial lines, who before they became officers of his department had outside experience of carrying out commercial audits and are as a matter fact qualified accountants. It is an entirely additional function that we are imposing on the Comptroller and Auditor-General, and he is the only impartial official we can charge with it. There is nothing in this amendment to prescribe that his report should go to the Public Accounts Committee. It can be considered in the Dáil, if that is considered to be the most satisfactory method. I say it does provide a safeguard and will do much to prevent the rise of suspicions and implications which are the curse of every progressive undertaking in this country. It is well to provide against that beforehand, and that is the purpose of this amendment.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 23
·
Níl 36
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I desire to say that I voted against Deputy Cooper's amendment on the strength of two statements made by the Minister which seem to me to be most important. I agree that it is desirable to keep the doings of this Board as far as possible from general discussion in the Dáil. I agree with the Minister also that it is desirable that as much publicity as possible should be given to the financial work of the Board. I wish now to ask the Minister whether between this and the Report Stage he would consider some form of amendment to secure what he himself has expressed as important: that is that a statement of accounts must be published. Perhaps that statement of accounts would include a revenue account, a capital account, profit and loss account, balance sheet, auditor's report, and such other things as he might think desirable when he came to consider the matter. I think it is important that a special auditor should be chosen for this purpose, and also that full publicity should be given to the accounts of the Board. I would wish that to be secured in the Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I would be prepared to enlarge Section 4 so as to make it clear that certain accounts would necessarily be published. I cannot say myself that I am clear as to what the really important accounts would be. I have here a publication containing a statement of accounts of the Dublin Corporation. If we take the accounts given there it would necessitate that certain named accounts would definitely be published, and such others as might be prescribed by regulations made from time to time. I will bring forward an amendment setting down that certain accounts must be in the booklet published, and the Deputy can add to that.

Comment on this

That would meet my point.

Comment on this

I suggest that, in addition, there should be some means of bringing the matter before the Dáil. It must be recognised that the setting up of the Board which is to control the total supply of electrical energy is to lie in the Minister's hands. Assume for a moment that an unsatisfactory position is disclosed as regards any of the accounts of the Board, as to the cost, for instance, of generating electricity per unit or as to various other things visualised by the Minister, the Dáil would be precluded from discussing the financial position of the Board, and I maintain that would be entirely wrong. We all agree with the Minister that it is desirable that anything of the sort should be free from political control. But I suggest that to take the operation of a large undertaking of this kind in which are involved considerable sums of public money out of the purview of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, or to take it away from the range of criticism by this House under certain conditions, would be entirely wrong. I ask the Minister, in considering the question raised by Deputy Thrift, to review the whole matter in its fullest aspects, recognising the responsibility that must still remain with this House. We should not forget that no matter how this Board is composed its work is certain to react on the fortunes of the country, and its operations cannot be taken entirely out of the realm of criticism by this House.

Comment on this

Is not that secured by Section 30?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is.

Comment on this

I would like to make one suggestion to the Minister which, if accepted, would mitigate some of the dislike with which I view this section. It is that the auditors to be appointed under this section should be appointed, not by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, but by the Minister for Finance. The relations between the Board and the Department of Industry and Commerce will certainly be intimate. The Board will be the creation of the Department of Industry and Commerce, and its failure would reflect on the policy of that Department. It is, therefore, desirable that there should be some outside authority to audit its accounts. The Department of Finance seems to me to be the most suitable body to make the arrangements for that purpose. I suggest that, if the Minister can see his way to agree to what I suggest, he need have no fear but that the Department of Finance will nominate suitable people. It will almost certainly nominate qualified or incorporated accountants. The adoption of such a course would, I suggest, remove some of the apprehensions that are felt in regard to this matter.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Then, apparently, I would have to consider a situation in which the Minister for Industry and Commerce would need to be a thorough rogue and the Minister for Finance, who accepts him as a colleague, will put in better auditors than any the Minister for Industry and Commerce will appoint.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister has met the point of my argument. The Minister for Finance has to prescribe a form of accounts. He has to approve a form of accounts. Why should he not also approve the auditor?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I will accept the suggestion, but it is open to the other suspicion that the Minister for Finance might be of the type it is now assumed the Minister for Industry and Commerce will be.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 12—

At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—

"(4) The Board shall pay to the Local Appointments Commissioners out of the funds at its disposal under this Act such expenses in respect of the selection and recommendation by the said Commissioners under this section of persons to fill situations in the service of the Board as shall be fixed by agreement between the Board and the said Commissioners with the consent of the Minister for Finance or, in default of such agreement, by the Minister for Finance."

This is simply to give power to the Board to pay the Local Appointments Commissioners for any duties which the Board may ask the Commissioners to undertake under sub-section (3) of Section 7.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 14:—

In sub-section (4), page 9, line 18, after the word "electricity" to insert the words "or the manufacture of or wholesale or retail dealing in electrical apparatus and includes any share or interest in any unincorporated undertaking similarly engaged" and in lines 18 and 19 to delete the words "in Great Britain or Ireland."

This amendment is necessary if the idea that is contained in sub-sections (3) and (4) of Section 10 are acceptable. It simply means that anyone having an interest or shares in a concern dealing in electrical apparatus would also be precluded from membership of the Board or would have to sever connection or remove his interest in the undertaking before he could act.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 15:—

In sub-section (2) line 33, after the word "exceed" to insert the words "such sum as with the said sums advanced whether before or after the passing of this Act to the said separate fund out of the Central Fund under Section 11 of the Shannon Electricity Act, 1925 (No. 26 of 1925) amounts to the sum of five millions, two hundred and ten thousand pounds, and, subject to that limitation, shall not exceed."

This is an amendment brought forward because of comments made on the Second Reading with regard to sums of money voted under the first Shannon Electricity Act, and now voted here. It is to make clear that the £600,000 referred to is not an additional sum of money to the £5,210,000 voted originally. It was expected that that sum would have been divided into £4,600,000 for constructional work and £600,000 to meet interest. Certain interest will have to be paid while the undertaking is in charge of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Board will be handed over whatever portion of the £600,000 has not been disbursed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in accordance with the powers already given to him. It is to be noted that there are two limitations. One is that the sums advanced under Section 11 of the Shannon Electricity Act amount to the sum of £5,210,000, and subject to that limitation shall not exceed £600,000. It is simply to make it quite clear that there is not an additional sum of money being voted.

Comment on this

I think we understood that from the discussion yesterday, but my point is that the matter might have been met by leaving the £600,000 out of this Vote.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Then no portion of the £600,000 could have been handed over to the Board, the Deputy will realise.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 16—

In sub-section (3) line 41, after the word "half-year" to insert the words "except in the half-year ending 31st December, 1932."

There may be an important point in this amendment. On reading the sub-section it seemed to me that it tied the Board down rather unnecessarily. It seems to me worth while leaving a margin over for the final half-year, in order to be able to claim sums not advanced before that time.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I did not know what the amendment meant when I saw it put down. I would like to point out to Deputy Thrift that the total sum that may be advanced under sub-section (b) is £2,500,000, and that it may go in maximum sums of £400,000 every half-year. As between the date on which the Board is likely to be set up and, say, the beginning of 1933, there will be nine half-years. But if we take the sums there could be a claim made for a maximum of £3,600,000. I am not sure that there is any necessity for putting it in, but as it gives greater elasticity with regard to the last half-year, in which there may be a certain sum of money lying over to which the Board would be entitled. I would be prepared to accept it.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied if the Minister considers this.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Do you wish the amendment inserted now?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Subject to the approval of the draftsman.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 17—

At the end of the section to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(6) The sums to be advanced under this section shall be advanced by the Minister for Finance, and shall be expended by the Board solely for the purpose of the exercise and performance of the powers and functions conferred on the Board by this Act."

This amendment is very necessary. It will be observed that under a later section, the Board might advance money to various undertakings, and unless there is some phrase used such as this, the Board would apparently have power to advance money for purposes different entirely from electricity matters. This section says that all moneys to be expended must be expended solely for the purpose of the exercise and performance of the powers and functions conferred on the Board by this Act.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Cole, I wish to move amendment 17a:—

"In paragraph (c), lines 45-46, to delete the words ‘in Saorstát Eireann.'"

I simply want to bring this point before the Minister—that there might arise occasions when it would be possible to supply electricity along the Border. Take, for instance, a railway station; it might be advantageous to everybody concerned that we should go outside the bounds for that area. I also put it to the Minister that he might look further afield and that in the future he would be in a position to supply electricity further into the Northern area. The amendment is put forward at the present moment to meet the case of a railway station just over the Border.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I agree to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Would it not be necessary that the words "in Saorstát Eireann" should go out also in sub-section (d)?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

I do not think so. There is a different question of jurisdiction there.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 18:—

In sub-sections (1) and (2) to delete the figures "1932" in lines 40, 45 and 48 respectively, and substitute therefor in each case the figures "1942."

This section deals with the fixing of rates and scales of charges for electricity. To explain the amendment to the House, it is necessary for me to call your attention to the section as a whole. The substance of the section is that in the year 1932 the Board are to be in a position to pay all the charges and interest and sinking fund in connection with the undertaking. That, of course, is the implication in the section. My amendment is brought forward with the intention of exploring the position of affairs in 1932. It is clearly anticipated that during the years of construction there will be outgoings, and the amount of incomings, until the Shannon works are in operation, will, of course, be nil. We do not know exactly when the Shannon scheme will be in working operation. I would like the Minister to give the House a reasonable indication of when it will be in operation. As between the time it will be in operation and the year 1932, this section visualises that the enterprise will, in whatever period that is, have reached a stage of development that in the year 1932 the Board would be able, out of the revenue derived from the undertaking, to pay the interest and sinking fund and working expenses that will fall to be payable by the Board. I think this is an important question, and my amendment is put down with the idea that the Shannon scheme, in the year 1932, will not be in a position to pay any such sum. It does not matter what date I put in. I put in 1942, which gives a further ten years. But I would like the Minister to indicate on what lines he could possibly justify the inclusion of this section as an indication that the Board will be in a position to pay the charges that are being placed on this undertaking. Remember, first of all, we have the original capital expenditure of over £5,000,000. Yesterday the Minister introduced a new estimate of £2,500,000, and I think that the whole, 7½ millions or thereabouts, will fall on the Board for interest and sinking fund by these provisions in the year 1932.

If that is so, the undertaking will be burdened with a very large sum, in addition to the ordinary working costs, which will be very substantial, in connection with the further developments that are bound to take place. The original scheme of partial construction provided for an estimated output of 110,000,000 units. That was the amount contemplated when the scheme would be in full working order. We are now dealing with 1928 without any power from the Shannon scheme. The Minister has all the information; I have none. I would like the Minister to say what output he claims will be put on the station when it is started. What output does he see in the interval between the time the works are in full operation and the year 1932? I would ask him to be kind enough to give information elucidating this clause on which he assumes that in the year 1932 the Shannon scheme, under the auspices of the new Board, will be able to bear the charges that will be put on it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Deputy Hewat asked me to give him certain information and, after that request, he said he had no information. Nevertheless, previously, although he had no information, he stated that this amendment was put down on the assumption that the Shannon plant could not be made remunerative before 1942. A little later he indicated that he might enlarge that period by another ten years —although he "has no information." In other words, Deputy Hewat is working on the old prejudice of two years ago—the question as to whether this scheme should or should not be brought along. The Deputy is without information and just haphazardly puts down 1942.

Comment on this

Following the example of the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If the Deputy had said this was the merest guess, and that as far as he could make out the plant would not begin to pay its way until some date—I do not care what date—we would have had some indication as to the way his mind was working.

Comment on this

How could I put that in an amendment?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We are simply told that the Deputy thinks that apparently in 1942 the charges made for electricity to the consumer ought to bring in such revenue as would meet the outgoings.

Comment on this

I did not say any such thing.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I presume that is the effect of the amendment.

Comment on this

I explained that 1942 was put down as being a more likely date than 1932, that the Minister put down. I asked the Minister to justify his figure. I could not put in any figure without being equally hazardous.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The figure is simply a guess. It does not mean anything. I have been asked when the plant will begin to deliver current. As the Deputy knows, I have, as yet, no indication that the plant will not be delivering current at the date originally indicated, February, 1929. I am asked as to the conditions. The experts drew up a report and made certain estimates. They made what I said, when I was arguing this scheme before the House, was a conservative estimate. If I take their estimate of the year to year increase and simply gauge that by the sale of units in the country at the moment, without any propaganda having been done for the Shannon scheme, or any extra effort made concerning the scheme, their estimate has proved to be conservative. Where at one time I looked forward to facing in 1929 a situation in which, if there had been no extra effort put into propaganda or educational matters, the sale would have had to be doubled before the plant would become remunerative, I now believe, from the estimate given me, that there will be this situation—that without anything extra being done or any extra current being sold by reason of propaganda on behalf of the Shannon scheme, or any work the Board may do when set up, when the plant begins to operate, there will be a sale in the country of 75,000,000 units.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

In 1929, and there has to be 110,000,000 units to make the scheme pay from that date.

Comment on this

May I accept that as the Minister's considered opinion? I take it that he knows the output of electricity from all the works in the Free State. Am I to take it as a deliberate statement that in the year 1929 the Minister can see 75,000,000 units coming out of the Shannon scheme?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I can see a great many more if the Deputy means "production." I can see 132,000,000 units produced in 1932. I am taking the sales and the demand for current—demand, without any extra effort, for the number of units I have spoken of in 1929. The situation has eased, if anything, with regard to the scheme. When I take into consideration the number of towns that I know are clamouring along the single circuit we have started to build and the immediate increase there is going to be in the demand for electricity along that circuit, I am more than ever convinced that the experts' estimate, that the scheme should be revenue producing and a remunerative concern in 1932 is justified. Until I see reason to doubt that, and some more figures placed before me, I do not think we should get away from the figure the experts set out. It will be time enough to begin to put that back and look for further subventions from public funds—for that is what it will mean—when we see some indication that further subventions will be required.

I do not think it is right, simply because certain people never did believe, and do not now believe, that there will be any demand, that we should casually change 1932 to 1942, remembering at the same time that increasing the figure means nothing, because so long as the Board is tied up to a certain sum of money to meet interest and losses on working expenses, to say that you will postpone for ten years the date when their revenue shall be sufficient to meet their outgoings, makes no difference. After the Board has exhausted the sums of money given it under this Bill, it has to make both ends meet or get further moneys from this House. Merely to increase the period of years without recognising that, shows that this amendment is put down for the sake of revealing Deputy Hewat's consistently-revealed pessimism with regard to this whole matter.

I stated yesterday, with regard to the moneys, that if and when it seemed to me that the scheme was not going to be built out for the moneys voted, then I would come to this House and ask for more. I notice that that has been taken as a definite statement that the scheme is going to cost more. I made no statement of that sort. The Minister for Finance said yesterday that under no circumstances could the scheme cost more than £5,210,000. I thought it necessary to correct that. Under a lot of circumstances, it may cost more, but I have nothing in front of me yet to show it is going to cost more, and it will be time enough when it is borne in on me by the progress of the works that in fact there is going to be greater cost than I foresaw, to indicate that to the House. I am in the same position as regards the date—the date of opening of the plant and the date that this undertaking should become remunerative. Remember that when the experts talked of this plant becoming remunerative in 1932, they took into consideration simply the sale of Shannon electric current at certain prices. The Board which has to give the service to consumers under the terms of this Bill is going to have a great deal more to deal with than the mere selling of Shannon current. With the extra aids that are given—aids that, of course, go to the consumer in giving him an excellent service at the cheapest possible rate—I see no reason for changing the date 1932 to 1942.

Again, as I had to correct the Minister for Finance yesterday, let me correct any wrong impression that may be created by that statement. In 1931 the point of view put forward by Deputy Johnson, when the scheme was going through, may occur to people as being the best way to treat this scheme —that it should not be asked to meet all its charges in the early years. But we will have a much better appreciation of all the circumstances round about 1929 or 1930 or 1931 than we have now. At the moment, all the indications are that the plant will begin to operate on the date that is estimated, and that the Board will be able to meet, according to experts' indications, all its outgoings. Until I see something to the contrary, I will ask the Dáil not to change casually this figure and not to put it back ten years further.

Comment on this

I think the putting down of this amendment has served its purpose. The Minister has given us a considerable amount of information that we required. We were completely in the dark as to the exact ideas the Minister had as to when the scheme would be actually self-supporting. He has given us that information and his reasons and, as I think the amendment has served its purpose, I ask the leave of the Committee to withdraw it.

Comment on this

The Minister explained that the output of electricity in 1929 would be 75,000,000 units. Does that figure correspond with the estimates given here on the Shannon Bill, when an automatic 15 per cent increase per annum was taken into consideration?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is rather a reduction on what has been the automatic increase since the Shannon scheme went through.

Comment on this

There has been that increase over and above the 15 per cent. estimated?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes.

Comment on this

Does the Minister consider that that automatic increase will continue until the year 1932?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Decidedly, and even more than that. If the Deputy will pardon me, I said that that was a sort of ordinary increase, cutting out everything to do with the Shannon. Our entering on the first circuit—the south-eastern circuit—has definitely tended to show that the increase is going to be more than the normal percentage increase.

Comment on this

I think everybody will be pleased at the very reassuring statements made by the Minister. One would have to be somewhat of a prophet to form an opinion about Deputy Hewat's amendment. But so long as the point is recognised, that it may prove to be good business to run the scheme even at a loss for a certain number of years in order to make it pay in the end, I think the Minister is quite right in saying that the proper time to put that notion to the Dáil is much later than now.

Comment on this

The Minister has, of course, commented upon my putting down the year 1942 without any definite intention as being somewhat foolish. I took the opportunity to say, when I was proposing the amendment, that that date had no special significance. I wanted to extract from the Minister his ideas of the prospects of the concern, for the reason that he claims that the Shannon scheme will provide current in bulk at a lower cost than it can be produced. It would be instructive to tot up the interest and sinking fund, to estimate what the working expenses are going to be, and then to calculate what electricity is going to cost in bulk on the basis of a full supply. That is the bearing that the discussion on this amendment has on the position. The Minister says I am a pessimist as regards the Shannon scheme. I do not dispute that at all. Nobody in this House or outside it will be better pleased than I to acknowledge that I am wrong if the Shannon scheme is an absolute success. Nobody in the House or outside it wishes to greater success than I do.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

May I point out that the Deputy is developing his pessimism at the expense of his business instinct. He charges to the bulk supply of electricity the extra sums now being voted to the Board. What are these extra sums being voted for? Is it for the supply in bulk? The Deputy at least knows that. The Deputy is going to charge up interest on moneys to be supplied for working expenses against the supply in bulk. He is charging all that on the unit figure in bulk.

Comment on this

I certainly would charge it. If this money is to be applied, as the Minister said, in compensation, is it not capital that has to be recovered in interest and sinking fund? If you are not going to charge it, how are you going to get it back?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Compensation for what?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If the Board is only going to supply in bulk who has to be compensated? Has it to compensate the people for taking a cheaper supply? That is a funny idea.

Comment on this

The Minister, as usual, is drawing red herrings across the trail. He is a past master in that. If the undertaking is going to buy out and compensate other undertakings, so as to enable Shannon power to be supplied, surely that is in furtherance of the undertaking? Who is going to pay it?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The consumer. There is a good deal of difference between the supply in bulk and the consumer, as the Deputy knows.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 19—

In sub-section (2), line 61, after the word "fund" to insert the word "extension."

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move:—

In page 14, line 63, after the word "undertaker" to insert the words "permitted undertaker or statutory undertaker for the purpose of his undertaking," and in page 15, line 1, after the word "undertaker" to insert the words "permitted undertaker or statutory undertaker," and in line 3 to delete the word "authorised."

The effect of this amendment is to allow the Board to make advances not only to authorised undertakers but to permitted or statutory undertakers.

Comment on this

At the moment, any capital expenditure that is incurred in connection with these authorised undertakings has to go through certain procedure. Inquiries have to be held under this clause, and, apparently, inquiries held under the Public Health Acts would be done away with. Inquiries will be made by the Board which will deal direct with authorised undertakings. One would like an explanation from the Minister as to whether this amendment alters the present procedure and whether authorised undertakings will have to apply directly to the Board.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is the suggestion. Advances may be made to any authorised undertaker on such terms as the Board thinks proper. I would like again to make it clear that the Board is, for all purposes connected with electricity, to take the place of my Department. Inquiries used to be held under the auspices of my Department plus the Ministry for Local Government. In future all such applications will be made to the Board, and the Board will decide.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I propose amendment 21, which is as follows:—

Before Section 22 to insert a new section as follows:—

The Board may require any authorised undertaker to give to the Board and every such undertaker when so required shall give to the Board such information relating to his undertaking as the Board considers necessary and every authorised undertaker who on being so required fails or refuses to give to the Board such information as aforesaid shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding twenty-five pounds.

The general trend of the Bill is that once the Board is instituted it may hold inquiries and cause investigations to be held. This amendment gives power to the Board to get all information necessary from those connected with the sale or supply of electricity and also from the people using it. The trend of the section is towards the formal type of procedure by which an investigator is appointed and sent out to hold an inquiry into a certain undertaking. Previously one could not get information about unauthorised undertakings, but now it will be possible to send out certain sets of questions and have them attended to, instead of having the formal process of investigation referred to in the next section. This power is very necessary.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister think that he has sufficient power already to deal with this? Is there not sufficient terror already without putting on a heavy penal clause?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Is not this a nicer way to do it?

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Would the Deputy prefer to have a letter sent to an unauthorised undertaker stating that he would not get a permit unless he supplied the following information? As a matter of fact, the Deputy has done me a service, because I notice that the marginal note says: "Authorised undertakers and permitted undertakers to give information to the Board." I will therefore alter my amendment before the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment 22. as follows:—

At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—

(3) The authorised undertaker shall have the right to be represented at such investigation, either by counsel or otherwise as he may think fit, and the costs of such investigation, including the costs of the authorised undertaker, shall be paid by the Board.

I was approached by an authorised undertaker, which is also a local authority, namely, the Rathmines Urban Council, with a view to opposing the whole of Section 22. I stated that I did not think that that was reasonable, and I said that the Board should have certain powers of inquiry into the conduct of authorised undertakings. As the section stands it applies only to authorised undertakings. I think that that is reasonable, but I think that the authorised undertaker, who holds his power under Act of Parliament and who has gone to the expense of promoting an Act, either in the British House or in the Oireachtas, should have some safeguard against unnecessary and frivolous inquiries. Consequently I drafted this amendment. The first part of the amendment is that in any investigation contemplated the undertaker whose conduct is being inquired into should have the right to be represented either by counsel or otherwise. Personally, if my conduct was to be inquired into, I should prefer "otherwise" and get an engineer or chartered accountant to represent me. When you lay down a procedure akin to that of the courts by imposing a penalty on witnesses who fail to appear, and when you take evidence on oath, you must, in common justice, give the party into whose conduct inquiry is being made the right to be represented at such inquiry. The second part is intended to discourage unnecessary or frivolous investigation. It lays down that the Board should bear the cost of the inquiry, so far as the authorised undertaker is concerned. That would tend to discourage the Board from starting an inquiry unless there is good ground for so doing. It is a safeguard against the Board inquiring into the conduct of all undertakings and calling upon them to submit their books and undergo an investigation. This amendment is a via media between the great powers which the Minister has taken and the attitude my constituents took up in regard to refusing all inquiries. I do not think that it is wise to refuse all inquiries, hence I have put down the amendment.

Comment on this

Might I suggest to Deputy Cooper that he omit from his amendment the words "either by counsel or otherwise"? If he does so, it would enable authorised undertakers to be represented as they think fit. According to the amendment as drafted, they would have to be represented either by counsel or someone else, but not by both.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

There is a great desire to pile up costs against the Board. The Board is looked upon apparently as something of a bogey and the best thing to do is to throw up a tremendous obstacle by piling up costs against it. Who is to pay the costs in the end? The consumer of electricity. After 1932 the charges for electricity have to be such that outgoings are to be met by revenue. Now according to the amendment, in order to prevent the Board from making what are regarded as necessary investigations there is a threat to have an army of counsel and experts, and the Board is to meet all the expense. The Board cannot be segregated in the way that people think the Government can be segregated in believing that the Government has a private purse from which all expenses are to be met. The Board has no private purse and will have to draw on consumers to meet the outgoings. According to the amendment, undertakers are to appear at the inquiry with an array of counsel and experts, the costs of whom are to be borne by the Board. Thus it is thought to defeat the purposes of the Board. In so far as it is their right to be represented at such inquiry, nobody could object; but when it comes to saying that the undertaker may bring in counsel and chartered accountants, and no matter what the result is the Board shall pay the costs, I say that that is quite unreasonable. I will accept the amendment so far as it says that the authorised undertaker shall have the right to be represented at such investigation, but that the costs shall be paid by the undertaker. Let the undertaker have the onus of justifying his conduct by bringing in counsel, and let him justify himself afterwards to the consumers whom he represents. It is quite unfair to say that once an investigation is ordered all costs must be borne by the Board.

Comment on this

The Minister has directed his argument entirely to the second part of the amendment, and I assume he accepts the first part. He says the Board is looked upon as a bogey Board. If so, that is the Minister's own fault. We have no information about the Board except that it is to be given extensive powers, and that there is the possibility of appointing Deputy Johnson on it. Even that latter proposal does not remove my fears regarding the Board. Who is to pay the cost of investigation? Presumably the person appointed to hold the investigation will have some qualifications for doing so, and will be an engineer, or an accountant or somebody learned in the law, and he will have to be remunerated. Who is to pay for that? Presumably a certain staff will be needed, and possibly shorthand writers.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

These people will be on the staff of the Board and will be paid by the Board.

Comment on this

So the staff of the Board will have to hold an impartial investigation when the Board makes a complaint against an undertaker?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Where is the idea of complaint with regard to Section 22?

Comment on this

"The Board may at any time hold or appoint any person to hold an investigation into the administration and financial position of the undertaking of any authorised undertaker." I think if anybody were to hold an investigation into my financial position, I should have some locus standi if it was suggested that my financial position was not satisfactory. I suggest the same should apply with regard to an authorised undertaker.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Does the Deputy realise that the Board hereafter is given power to fix the charges, and for the fixing of the charges there will have to be an investigation beforehand? There is no question of complaint arising.

Comment on this

I do not follow the Minister's argument. I think efficient authorised undertakers under this section have no safeguard against the Board suddenly ordering an investigation into their business. These undertakers have statutory powers and have gone to the expense of promoting Acts in order to enjoy their powers. They have the right to certain consideration. Under this section the Board may, as the Minister says, without any complaint, and of its own action, say "We are going to inquire into your financial position." The Minister knows that every inquiry of that character involves a certain amount of expense which would tend to stop an extension of development of any kind, and yet all safeguards are rejected. At the same time, I am prepared to meet the Minister half way. If I remodel the first part of my amendment and put it down for the Report Stage, so that the authorised undertaker shall have a right to be represented at such investigations——

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is that they shall have representation?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I would agree to that.

Comment on this

Then I will act on Deputy Redmond's suggestion, and withdraw the words "by counsel or otherwise."

Comment on this

The Minister says that the Board, according to this section, will have the right of investigation into these undertakings, and that it will be given powers to fix charges. I submit to him that the presentation of the position of the authorised undertaking by a proper representation at this hearing will be part of the investigation, and that the Board, who will presumably have to pay for their side of the case by paying their staff, should equally be liable for the charges which will have to be borne by the undertaking, which will have to submit their side of the case. I submit, therefore, that the costs, whatever they may be, either to the Board or to the undertaking, should be borne by the Board, and that they should be all part and parcel of the investigation which the Board shall have the right to make. The investigation will embrace the case as put forward by the Board, and as by the representatives of the undertaking. I do not think it is too extravagant to ask that the cost of not only the staff of the Board but also those who will have to appear on behalf of an undertaking should be borne by the Board.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

These costs must be kept as low as possible. In the case of an ordinary investigation, an engineer on the staff of the Board, and a member of the accounting department will go down to look into some matter regarding an undertaking. They will be met by the engineer, or somebody on behalf of the accounting branch of the undertaking, and that will be the beginning and end of it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider an amendment so as to prevent pressure being brought to bear on the Board by any particular authority that, for one reason or another, are anxious to harass by continually demanding investigations? I think if the Minister put in a provision that in any investigation held under this section the undertaking should be immune from investigation for the next year or two it would meet the case. There is an apprehension that local authorities, and most of these authorised undertakings are local authorities, will be harassed by the Board, and there is the fear of bureaucratic methods which, I hope, will not be realised, but which certainly do exist.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I would like to see the amendment which Deputy Cooper would produce on these lines.

Comment on this

I was hoping the Minister would produce it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am taking a different view of the Board, and I am looking on it as a reasonable corporation which will not do absurd things. If the Deputy put down an amendment dealing with the point of vexatious interference I would consider it. The Board would have regard only to the interests of the consumers of electricity and would be actuated by the desire to get current sold as cheaply as possible and to get units as cheaply as possible. There is no attempt to pile up charges. As to harassing an undertaking, the Deputy will find there is no necessity to have repeated investigations every week, simply to drive somebody out of business. The Board will be given sufficient powers, and I cannot see how it would act in a foolish manner under this provision.

Comment on this

The difficulty is that no one will have any control over it. We are, wisely, I think, giving the Board very extensive powers. We do not know how the Board is going to be composed, and it is desirable to limit its powers of interference to a certain extent.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The amendment has been reduced merely to giving the right of representation.

Comment on this

I will move later to delete all words after "investigation."

Comment on this

This section appears to me to be rather one-sided. It sets out exactly what the Board is to do, and what powers it is to have, but apparently it does not consider the other side of the question, and give any powers as to what witnesses may be summoned or otherwise by the authorised undertaking.

If the Minister will read it impartially—I do not mean that in any offensive sense—he will see that the Board shall have power to summon witnesses to attend such an investigation, to examine them on oath, and so forth. But it does not appear to me at all that there is any power on the other side for the authorised undertaking to summon witnesses and to have them examined.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

We will first dispose of the amendment. Is Deputy Cooper withdrawing his amendment?

Comment on this

If the leave of the Dáil is given to amend my amendment, it will save time and trouble. I propose to delete all words after "investigation." I gather the Minister is prepared to accept that.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

That would not constitute a sub-section in the Bill. It might be better to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

To the truncated form of Deputy Cooper's amendment I was going to suggest an addition to meet Deputy Good's point, that the undertaking shall have the right to be represented at such investigations and to produce witnesses. I do not pretend to be a draughtsman, but I would suggest to add to that the matter of the undertaking also bringing in witnesses.

Comment on this

If the Minister will put that down for the Report Stage I will withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I will.

Comment on this

There are some points on the section that I had intended to make. I referred to them last week. What will lead up to the investigation? Must there be a complaint of mismanagement before the Board decides to hold an investigation into any concern? If the concern is a well-managed, profit-making concern to-day and is doing well, will the Minister or the Board have power without cause to go in and call for an investigation or must there be some complaint that the place could be better managed or that something better for the citizens could be done if the Board stepped in and took control? The Bill as it stands repeals all existing Electricity Acts under which various concerns are protected. I find, and Deputy Cooper was surprised to find, that it is the Board which is to hold the inquiry. That is not to be an independent inquiry.

I would hold that in cases like this a proper independent inquiry should be held probably at the suggestion of the Board and that the authorities should be represented. If they succeed in proving to the Inspector or whoever holds the inquiry that their concern was well managed there should be no interference.

I have in my mind the concern in Dublin City as Deputy Cooper had in his mind the Rathmines concern. They are two well-managed concerns, Dublin City showing a very handsome profit, and occasionally it has given relief to the rates of the city. I can well see the Board urging an inquiry with a view to taking over the concern in Dublin City and getting control of its finances in order that they might, instead of developing Dublin City or giving relief to the rates, develop the Shannon scheme elsewhere. I think on the whole, that while the inquiry might be suggested by the Board or by the undertaking itself it should be an independent inquiry. I would also suggest that some word should be brought into this section that would limit the investigation so that the members of the Board could not at any time they took the notion demand an inquiry into this or that undertaking and call from the undertaking its principal officials to the detriment of the future working of the concern.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not know what are the objective signs of good management. The Deputy has talked of profits. In the case of a municipal undertaking the fact that big profits were being made would be obviously a matter for investigation at once because a municipal undertaking should not make big profits.

Comment on this

Might I remind the Minister that under other Acts up to the introduction of this Bill, that was already provided for, and the Dublin Corporation gave relief to the rates from the profits of the electric lighting undertaking?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Certainly if that was found to be the practice, and if it is going to continue as a practice, there would be an immediate cause for investigation. The Deputy may take that as one of the things that would be immediately inquired into—a municipal undertaking making profits to be distributed for the relief of the general rates.

Comment on this

Should they run it at a loss?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I have not said that.

Comment on this

Suppose it had been run at a loss in the past?

Comment on this

I think the Minister has raised an extraordinarily broad question in this matter. A municipal authority is not to make anything out of any undertaking it runs and the citizens are put in the position that they are to bear the whole of the losses if losses are occasioned.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Is the Deputy presuming to give me a case? I said "big profits."

Comment on this

I think the Minister said that a municipal undertaking should not make any profits.

Comment on this

I think the Minister was emphatic in saying that a municipal undertaking should not make any profits.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I will explain that. I said first that the question of big profits being made is a matter for immediate inquiry. We can come on afterwards under Section 37 to the question of any profits.

Comment on this

That starts the very large question, that in various places in Great Britain and Ireland municipal undertakings have occasionally been successful. We can take for instance the Glasgow Trams, the Belfast Gas, and various undertakings of that sort. I think the Minister lays it down that a concern of that sort running at considerable risk has to be run on such bare lines that it will not show any margin for reserve or for building up.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Any margin for distribution to the general ratepayers.

Comment on this

Even though there has been a loss in the past?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We will deal with that on Section 37.

Comment on this

Yes, but we cannot separate it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I separate it this way: I say distinctly that it is the intention under this Bill that the Board should be allowed to hold investigations in cases where complaints have not been made. If you are to say that some complaint should be made, I know that some Canadian Act talks about a complaint lodged by, I think, four people. I wonder if there is any Deputy who does not believe that in regard to any municipal undertaking you could get four people to lodge a complaint. Deputy Byrne has talked of a well-managed undertaking. The investigation might simply be held for the purpose of seeing if it was well managed, without there being any prejudice to that point of view. The Board will not go in and say: "We believe this is badly managed, and we want to find out." I hope that an investigation will not be looked on as necessarily implying a complaint, and there will be no necessity for a long-drawn-out investigation that would take people away from their business. I should say that, ordinarily speaking, an investigation would follow when the information to be required under the section had not been given, or had not been given sufficiently, or, when given, revealed something for which a formal type of investigation was called for.

Comment on this

The dictum of the Minister that municipal undertakings should not give big profits is certainly a novelty in the way of public utterances. I remember the great struggle for the municipal control of electricity in Dublin when the principal opposition to that undertaking was on the ground that it was not likely to be profitable, and not likely to be profitable to the citizens of Dublin. Is it to be laid down that because a municipal undertaking is well managed there should be an investigation, or is it to be laid down that an investigation should take place where there has been a loss? I cannot at all understand the attitude of mind of the Minister in this matter. If an undertaking which has been under the control of a municipality is proved to have been self-supporting to such an extent that it was able to produce big profits, that those big profits were devoted to the reduction of rates, and thereby to the benefit of the citizens generally, and at the same time if the charges for the products of that undertaking were not exorbitant, I certainly think that that undertaking should be left as it is, and that there should be no investigation.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

In that connection would the Deputy approve of the water rate being raised in order to allow profits to be made on water, and be distributed to the relief of the ratepayers?

Comment on this

I am talking of a municipal undertaking. I am not talking of a necessity of life, such as water.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It might be under a municipal undertaking.

Comment on this

I am dealing with a different subject. I suggest that if a municipal undertaking has proved itself to be one that has produced big profits and that these profits have gone to the reduction of the rates for the benefit of the citizens, along with proper charges for the products of that undertaking, that is certainly an undertaking which does not warrant any investigation. But if, on the other hand, the undertaking had proved to be a loss, and if the ratepayers had to pay for that loss, I think there would be grounds for an investigation.

Comment on this

I do not want to mislead the House in any way regarding the question of big profits being devoted to the relief of rates. But small profits have been so devoted. Occasionally sums have been devoted to the relief of the rates out of the Dublin electricity undertaking. But valuable improvements were made in the plant out of revenue in the hope that some day, when the plant was complete, the ratepayers who contributed towards it, both out of the rates and by means of taking expensive electricity in its early stages, would get relief in the near future. If the Corporation had thought that a Bill to confiscate their property, after they had taken this course, was likely to be passed, these improvements would have been carried out out of borrowed money instead of out of revenue, and the profits would have been given back to the ratepayers. By taking the course that they did they have in Dublin to-day a valuable concern for which a million pounds was offered a few years ago.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is Section 37.

Comment on this

What I am trying to get at are the powers that are to be given to the Board to hold an inquiry with their eyes on these profits, instead of having an independent inquiry. I say that such an inquiry would not be fair when, as a result of its findings, the Board would take control, in order to take from the city of Dublin the profits that should go to the relief of the rates and devote them towards the development of the Shannon scheme elsewhere. An offer of £1,000,000 was made for the city electricity works seven years ago, but under this Bill I say that it can be taken for £400,000.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Under this section?

Comment on this

Not under this section.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

It does not arise then.

Comment on this

I quite agree, but what I want to bring out is that an inquiry would be held by a Board that will hope some day—and I think I am entitled to say that they would go into that inquiry with prejudiced minds— to put their hands on Dublin city property and, as all other Electricity Acts will have been repealed, the powers that the city has under other Acts to give relief to the rates out of this very valuable concern would be taken from it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not want to follow this argument, because it will arise again on Section 37, but I would like to have it indicated if I am right in assuming that Deputy Redmond holds that it is right for a municipal undertaking to make profits?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

To make profits which may be used for the relief of the ratepayers?

Comment on this

Providing that the rates that they charge for their products are reasonable rates.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Providing that a municipal undertaking should be entitled to make profits from a number of people and spreading these profits out for the relief of the general ratepayers? Deputy Byrne would agree with that?

Comment on this

Not altogether. I say that the Dublin ratepayers are entitled to get a little relief for what they contributed towards making the supply twenty-five years ago.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If there was any subvention from the general rates to the electricity concern, that the electricity concern, when successful, should pay back? Is that where it begins and ends, or does the Deputy go further and think that they should be allowed a certain margin of the profits derived from the electricity undertaking and that that profit should go to the relief of the general ratepayer?

Comment on this

I quite see what is in the Minister's mind. I say that electricity consumers should not have to pay a price that would make a profit to be given back to other people who are not consumers of electricity.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

And the Deputy disagrees with Deputy Redmond?

Comment on this

But the point I want to get at is that the ratepayers had to contribute in days gone by, out of the rates, and that the Corporation of Dublin has power, at present, under the Electricity Acts, to devote money made out of the concern to the relief of the rates, and I say that there is nothing wrong in asking that such a reduction should be given.

Comment on this

Will not all this arise on Section 37?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment 23:—

In line 33 to add at the end of the section the words:—

"Nothing in this section shall prevent the ordinary use of current for experimental purposes, nor shall this section confer any obligation on the user to disclose the nature or object of such experimental work."

This section has created some alarm in the minds of some users of electricity. Possibly they do not understand exactly what it means. There are a number of users of electrical apparatus who are experimenting and I do not know whether it was the intention of the Minister to give the Board the right to call upon these experimenters to reveal exactly what is the intention of the experiments. Of course there are cases where the Board should have the right to call upon the user of electric current to explain what he is doing with it under certain circumstances. In order to clear up the matter and to allow these experimenters to continue I put down this amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If I were sure that the amendment as drafted did not go beyond what the Deputy says I should accept it right away, but I want to be sure. I am agreeing to the principle of the amendment, but I want to hold it over to look at the drafting, in order to see that a user of electrical apparatus could not refuse or could not block the Board in asking him for information by merely saying "experiment" and that then the Board would be cut out.

Comment on this

On the understanding that the matter will be considered on the Report Stage, I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I wish to suggest a small verbal correction in line 27. I suggest that the second "such" should be deleted, and "aforesaid" substituted.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Amendments 24 and 25 are more or less identical. Perhaps an arrangement can be come to between the Minister and Deputy Thrift.

Comment on this

I think we are agreed that the words used in two places in the section are not satisfactory. "Generation of electrical energy." I could not allow to pass without protest. I suggest that we should insert the words "generating electricity" in both places, or, what would be better even, "production of electrical current."

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am agreeable to have the word "electricity" put in instead of "electrical energy" in both places.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 25 then in this amended form:—

In lines 45 and 48-49 to delete the words "electrical energy" and substitute therefor the word "electricity."

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 26:—

In line 50 to delete the words "and lines" and to add at the end of the section the following words—"and on such other matters arising out of the exercise and performance by the Minister of the powers, functions and duties conferred and imposed on him by the said Act as the Minister may think fit to refer to the Board for their advice."

The intention is that the Board, as soon as set up, would be the people to make the inquiry as to the demand and to make provisional contracts as quickly as possible, and thereafter to advise as to the transmission circuits that were to be built, and where they were to be located. The section, as drafted, would cover that, but there might be also referred to the Board in its advisory capacity, over the construction period, not merely the location of lines but a whole lot of other matters that would not be covered by the words here. Consequently it is proposed to add the words in the amendment. It is simply that the Board would be in a better position than I would be hereafter to get information—in fact, it is set up for the purpose of getting information and would be the best authority to advise on such matters as might be referred to it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 27:—

At the end of sub-section (1) to add the words—"and may establish and maintain a testing laboratory for the testing and standardisation of electrical instruments."

I do not think that what the amendment aims at is covered by the words used in the section. What I am driving at has been hanging fire for some time, namely, that we should have a system of testing available within our own borders. I think it would be quite a good thing to have this power specifically set out in reference to this Board.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think this amendment is certainly rendered necessary by Section 104.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

resumed the Chair.

SECTION 27.

(Exhibitions and Displays of Electrical Apparatus, etc.)

Comment on this

There is just one question I desire to ask in connection with this section, which states that the Board may, for the purpose of promoting and extending the uses of electricity for domestic, industrial, agricultural and other purposes, open or arrange for the opening of show rooms for the exhibition and display of electrical apparatus and appliances. What I am anxious to know is, if the section, as it stands, takes away from other undertakings the power to do what it is provided this Board may do.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Obviously this section does not take away power from any other person.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 28:—

In line 19, after the word "may" to insert the words "with the consent of the Minister for Finance."

The amendment is moved simply for the purpose of arranging for the consent of the Minister for Finance with regard to Departments of State making contracts with the Board.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I understand that Deputy Thrift is anxious to ask a question on this section.

Comment on this

I think the question really produces its own answer. I think that, undoubtedly, the Dáil would have the right to discuss such a Report. I would be glad, sir, if you could confirm that view.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I suppose there would be a right to get some kind of a discussion on a Report presented, but one would require to see what the Report was like. There will be this difficulty, that the Minister will not be responsible for the operations of the Board. Is not that so?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is so, but there could be a ventilation of ideas in the House with regard to the Report.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

There could be some kind of discussion.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 29:—

In page 17, before paragraph (c), to insert two new paragraphs as follow:—

"(c) the granting by the Board of permits to generate, distribute, and supply or to distribute and supply electricity.

(d) the fees to be paid in respect of the making by the Board of special orders authorising and in respect of the granting by the Board of permits empowering the generation, distribution and supply or the distribution and supply of electricity."

These are two matters about which it is thought desirable to give the Board power to make regulations. The two matters explain themselves.

Comment on this

I move amendment 30:—

In sub-section (7), page 18, to delete the word "each," line 16, and substitute therefor the word "either," and in line 18 after the word "regulation" to insert the words "the same" and to delete from the word "as," line 18, to the word "passed," inclusive, line 20.

The amendment provides that the vote of one House, instead of the two, is all that will be necessary to prevent hasty legislation on this matter.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The section as drafted is the usual one with regard to regulations: that they shall be laid before both Houses, and that it requires a vote of both Houses within certain periods to annul.

Comment on this

Is not the usual form in which we pass similar regulations to this: a vote of either House?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think not. I was certainly under the impression that the procedure which the Oireachtas had adopted with regard to these regulations was that it required a vote of both Houses to annul.

Comment on this

I think the other form is the more usual. As a matter of fact there are precedents for both. Perhaps the Minister would agree to consider the matter and deal with it on Report.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I will have inquiries made as to the precedents and see which would be the most suitable for this, if they are different.

Comment on this

I move the following amendments as they are bound together:—

31. In sub-section (1) to insert after the word "Board," line 28, the words "and the persons mentioned in sub-section (5) hereof."

32. To insert before sub-section (4) the following sub-section:—

Any person who on the 1st day of March, 1927, was selling or supplying electricity for sale shall be entitled to continue to sell or supply until an order is made by the Board terminating his right so to do.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Amendments 31 and 32 are bound together. Would the Deputy state what is bound up with 31: is it amendment 32 or amendment 32a?

Comment on this

It is 32. I would draw your attention to a clerical error in amendment 32; the words "to insert before sub-section (4)" should be "to insert after sub-section (4)." My reason for bringing forward this is that when an Act of Parliament is passed it does not reach the ears of everybody. I know ignorance of the law is no excuse. But there must be hundreds, particularly small people supplying electricity, who will be breaking the law when this Act is passed. A great number of those people may not hear that they are committing an offence against this Act. Therefore I think it right that the Board should notify those people terminating their powers to sell electricity rather than that they should become, unwittingly, breakers of the law.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If what the Deputy requires is that notice must be given to people concerned before Section 33 would operate upon them I can give that consideration but I do not like the form of this amendment.

Comment on this

That is all I want, and I am satisfied if the Minister will undertake that the Board shall notify all those people before they become criminals.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Undoubtedly notice will have to be given and I shall see that that is put into the Bill.

Comment on this

Then I ask leave to withdraw amendments 31 and 32.

Comment on this

I move:—

To insert before sub-section (4) a new sub-section as follows:—

"Any person who (other than an authorised undertaker or a person with a permit under Section 35) but for the provisions of the last preceding sub-section, would not have been entitled to carry on an undertaking for supply of electricity for sale, and whose right to do so is terminated by an order of the Board, on satisfying the Board or the arbitrator hereinafter mentioned, as the case may be, that such undertaking at the date on which such order was made was being worked in an efficient manner, and that he has suffered loss by reason of such order having been made, shall be entitled to be paid by the Board such compensation in respect of such loss as in default of agreement shall be fixed by an arbitrator to be appointed by the Chief Justice of Saorstát Eireann."

The principle underlying the question of compensation is, and it will be running through the Bill, that all persons who have had the right to carry on the generating and distribution of electricity will have a right to compensation, if the Board is going to say to them that they are not to carry on their business or to interfere with their means of livelihood or the carrying on of their work. In other words, the principle of compensation will be recognised. In this Bill you raise the question, and it is a very important one. In discussing this Bill we are at a considerable loss to know whether we are to take the wording of the Bill or the intentions of the Minister when interpreting it as an Act. I would like to hear at this stage from the Minister whether he proposes that anybody should be cleared out of the industry without adequate compensation. I think it ought to be a recognised principle that, where a business, private interest, or other interest, is interfered with by legislation, or in connection with private negotiation, a scale of compensation for disturbance shall be laid down and accepted. That is far-reaching in connection with this Bill. I raised a question at an earlier stage when £2,500,000 were voted by the House to go to the credit of this Board, and I was told that an indefinite sum in connection with that was for compensation. I accept that as something in the right direction. I would like the Minister to be good enough to say whether he draws the line anywhere in connection with the operation of this Bill. I think, perhaps, at this stage, the Minister might go even further than that as far as compensation is concerned, and give us some little explanation of the underlying principle involved in the Bill. At present there are large authorised undertakings scattered throughout the country; there are also small, and very small, undertakings, and if a measure for the public good is being advanced would the Minister say that he would be prepared to deal with all interests in the same way as, in the Schedule to the Bill, he is providing for the interests of the employees that are being disemployed? Will the same principle apply to all the undertakers who are permitted or otherwise?

Adopting the principle that all existing undertakings will automatically come under the same head and continue to exist, until the Board in its wisdom shall decide that some of the undertakings are inefficient and will, therefore, have to be wiped out, this whole question is very serious from top to bottom. I should like to know on what ground the Minister is going to terminate or suggest the termination of such undertakings. Under the powers of this Bill, even when you come down to small undertakings, there may be reasons that will induce the Board to say they will not continue their permits, or perhaps that they will revoke the permits that might have been originally given to them. I understand from the last amendment that the Minister practically accepts the definition that an undertaking, as it exists, will start afresh under a new order until the Board makes an order for the termination or taking over, or whatever it may be, of such undertakings. Will the Minister follow that principle up and say that he recognises their right to exist? And if the Board recognises them, but in the public interest, or the general interest of the electricity scheme, considers that they should be abolished, he will accept the principle of compensation on a reasonable scale?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The form of this amendment is peculiar. First of all, it is in addition to the last preceding sub-section which has been withdrawn. I am taking this now as it has to be construed in the light of what happened to the last two amendments. The last two amendments in regard to the order have been withdrawn by Deputy Myles on the basis that notice would be given to every unauthorised undertaker before what Deputy Myles calls the criminal atmosphere of sub-section (4) would advert to any unauthorised persons carrying on business without a permit from the Board. I have promised that notice will be given.

Comment on this

May I interrupt the Minister? He referred back to the two sub-sections I have withdrawn but the amendment here does not refer to these sub-sections; it refers to the sub-section in the Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

"Any person who (other than an authorised undertaker or a person with a permit under Section 35) but for the provisions of the last preceding sub-section would not have been entitled to carry on an undertaking for the supply of electricity for sale and whose right to do so is terminated by an order of the Board." That has disappeared in the withdrawn amendment. I am construing this: the sense is obvious.

Deputy Hewat wants to set up this state of things: That if there is an undertaking which is unauthorised and can prove it is working in an efficient manner and that it has suffered loss by reason of—I am putting it in my own words—not being granted a permit, then compensation shall be paid and that compensation shall be agreed upon or fixed by an arbitrator to be appointed by the Chief Justice of Saorstát Eireann. That is what we are discussing—the right of an unauthorised undertaking not granted a permit, or I presume the same will apply to those granted a permit, but from whom it is afterwards withdrawn——

Comment on this

No. It is not exactly the same thing, in this way. I would like the Minister to accept the principle that no authorised distributors or generators will be refused a permit to continue until the Board comes to a decision on the matter.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is not going to carry the unauthorised undertaker very far. It simply means that though they can be given a permit the permit may be withdrawn under a later section of the Bill. Let me avoid all argument as to the terms of the amendment. What the Deputy wants to carry off is that compensation shall be paid to unauthorised undertakers and, thereby, put them on the same basis as the authorised private undertaker as there is no such thing as compensation to a municipal undertaking.

Comment on this

We will come to that later.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We will come to that later. There are two fallacies in what the Deputy is putting forward in his amendment. It is based upon wrong grounds. There is the question of efficiency. The matter of efficiency is really not one upon which there is going to be any determination. It is not the question whether an undertaking is efficient that will lead to its continuance, and it is not the question of inefficiency only that will lead to its discontinuance. Even without very much knowledge of what the Board may hereafter do, I can say quite clearly that privately-owned undertakings managed and run however efficiently will have to be taken over by the Board in the interests of rural electrification. Efficiency is not the test and inefficiency is not the reason why an undertaking should disappear. This, as well as many other things contained in it, is an amalgamating and consolidating Bill in regard to electricity supply, and efficient undertakings will have to disappear after being compensated, but the question of efficient working is not the test. That comes in with other amendments, but that is my point on that particular item.

In the matter of compensation, I do not want to give the Board powers, as they are undoubtedly given in the Bill, to proceed on a campaign of wholesale destruction of unauthorised undertakers with no compensation given. That is not the intention. The Board are given certain powers and, of course, the suspicious mind can bring to me this consideration: "But the Board may not use these powers." I will admit they may not, and they may wipe out, and pay no compensation to, an unauthorised undertaker. But the Board may make every unauthorised undertaker sooner or later an authorised undertaker, and the moment it does those fall into the line for compensation on the same basis as the authorised undertaker. My difficulty in approaching this matter is this: we have not enough information about the unauthorised undertakings to know how they should be treated. We had not power to get the information and, when we tried to get it, the information was mainly refused to us because we had no right to apply for it. The unauthorised undertaker was free and beyond our control, and in the majority of cases the unauthorised undertakers refused to give us any information whatsoever.

There is a further point of difference. The authorised concern has an area marked out for it by an order. Within that area it is supreme. It is under control with regard to the maximum rate that it is to charge. It has obligations to supply all consumers indifferently within that area, and it is granted a monopoly in perpetuity for the sale of electricity in that area. One can see, in estimating profits of an undertaking which has achieved a monopoly in a particular area, but which also has the obligation to supply all customers indifferently, that the profits likely to be made by such an undertaking are likely to be lower than those made by the unauthorised undertaking. The unauthorised undertaker can go to a district, start a generating plant, make a network, sell to selected customers at any rate he likes, and change his rates according to his contracts with his customers.

Take an ordinary example that would apply to the majority of unauthorised undertakings in this country. The majority of them started in this way: a man who has a mill wants power for that mill. He gets a plant and generates power for use in the mill or factory. Later on he throws out a line and supplies his own house with current for lighting, and then, later still, he throws out lines in order to supply his neighbours. Obviously that man has charged all the overhead expenses against his factory and he can count on every item he gets in for the sale of current distributed to his neighbours as profit. If we are to take him and assess him on the basis of so many years' profits, we will be paying very heavily for a man who really has done no public service whatever. He is subject to this: anybody else can start against him in that district, and if the newcomer can give better service and cheaper rates he can wipe him out.

The statutory undertaker is in a different category. He has been given rights and guaranteed rights, put under obligations, and he may sell indifferently to all customers. We think such a man deserves compensation for the money he has put into the generation of current. There are, of course, a great many unauthorised undertakers who have done good public service. They have supplied lighting for streets and for a community. There are many of that type who would ordinarily become authorised undertakers if they had applied for an order.

Comment on this

Supposing some did and did not get it?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That would apply to about two. They are in a different category. I am speaking of the majority. It is wrong to treat all unauthorised undertakers in the manner Deputy Hewat suggests. I think the man who, according to Deputy Myles, had to apply to the House of Commons long ago and paid upwards of a thousand pounds for his order obviously has a grievance if he is going to be assessed on the basis of profits, as he had to bear that expense when other men had not. Obviously again the man who is authorised and who has to supply all customers within a maximum and who is under various obligations is not in the same position as the man who could be described as a free-lance. The Board simply might be told "Go ahead; go down into any community where there is an unauthorised undertaker at the moment and that man has no rights against the Board." At least he has equal rights with the Board to sell in that area. The Board could build another network and I wonder is there any doubt in anybody's mind that three weeks after the Board had built its network the consumers attached to the unauthorised undertaker would not be clamouring to be taken over by the Board and no compensation would be paid to anybody?

If I had sufficient information I believe one could schedule two categories in this Bill. One would be a group of undertakers who have sold at reasonably low rates to a sufficient number of customers, have a network of some value to the Board for distribution purposes, have come in on the same footing as authorised undertakers and stand for compensation on the same basis. Then you would have another group, also with a network, who have done public service but who have sold indifferently to all customers. The claim may be made that they should be put on the same basis as the authorised undertaker and fall in for compensation. There would be a third group, such as the man with the factory supplying a few neighbours with current. The Board need not worry about him; let him carry on his supply for his few neighbours. The Board will not want his network; they will not have anything to do with it. It would be a burden on the consumers generally to say that anything should be paid for that small network which is going to be of no value to the Board.

I think the Board ought, at least, to be made do this: pay a fair value for any network it takes over and uses. It must start from that and that is the minimum. If we have sufficient information six months hence we might easily schedule a certain number of undertakings as people who have supplied sufficiently well and at a low price to a big enough number of consumers and have done a certain amount of public service to warrant becoming authorised undertakers and getting compensation on the same basis as the authorised undertakers. I have had to present the Bill in a rather weak form on that point, for the reasons that I could not get the information from the unauthorised undertakers of the country.

Their attitude was: "You have no business to inquire, it is none of your concern; we will have nothing to do with you." They would not supply us with any information on which we could have based some sort of distinction between them. There are times when I am disposed to leave them to their fate. I think it is only right that they should suffer for that now. I am often wondering what they were thinking of then when they were asked to become a statutory undertaking, and when they were persuaded by their association that they should not become a statutory undertaking. I would like to know what is in their minds now on this matter with regard to the association that so advised them.

Comment on this