ORDUITHE AN LAE—ORDERS OF THE DAY. - PUBLIC SAFETY BILL, 1927—THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).
Contributions 174–355 of 355. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1927 ›
I have listened with very great pleasure, and I trust with considerable profit, to this debate. It has helped to a large extent to get rid of some delusions under which I was suffering. When the debate opened I was under the impression that I knew something about courtsmartial. I doubt it very much now. At the opening of the debate one of my delusions was that I had often attended at British courtsmartial. I was under another delusion that I had often prosecuted at British courts-martial; indeed, I was under the hope that I could get corroboration within these walls of my latter statement. I was also under the delusion that I had defended at British naval courts-martial and Free State courtsmartial. All these delusions the debate has helped to wipe out. But I have, notwithstanding the existence of my delusions, one strong factor which is no delusion, and that was, and is, that whenever these courts were turned from the ordinary courtsmartial into what is called, in the words of this section "special courts," they turned out to be a failure. That is the history of the past, and, in my opinion, it will be the history of the future. I say nothing about the fairness or unfairness of British courtsmartial, except that, in my view, they were to the best of their lights an absolutely fair tribunal when dealing with British soldiers, but when dealing with Irishmen they were in a great many cases dealing with matters which they did not understand and consequently were unfit to judge fairly.
It is suggested that this House should set up in its worst form these special courts, and that with the knowledge that they have proved a disastrous failure. I, for one, will be no party towards allowing my fellow-countrymen to be tried by a court absolutely unfit to try them. What a confession of weakness we have had from the Ministerial Bench! I hope I took the Minister for Finance correctly when he told us that the object of this section was not to obtain the respect of the ordinary man. If that is not the object I take it that the reverse is, and I will at once concede to the Minister that his object will be most admirably carried out if this Bill is passed, because if it is not intended to obtain the respect of the man in the street it will to a large extent obtain his disrespect, and the disrespect of every law-abiding citizen. Then, we are told by the President that he wants to keep the judiciary above reproach, and hence he could not allow them to take part in these courts. Again, I humbly and respectfully agree with the President that if they were mixed up in any of these courts as outlined by the provisions of this Bill they would to a large extent obtain the disrespect of the man in the street, the ordinary citizen.
Then we have heard a confession from Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney which I hope will not get him into any serious trouble with the Government. He told us in effect that the real object underlying the section was that the duty of the jury, as he understood it, was to obtain fair play, and hence the functions of the jury would be of no use for the purpose of carrying out the objects of this section. I agree with him when he tells us these were the functions of a jury. I assume what he means, and we have this from a representative of the Government policy, a statement from a responsible Deputy, that the function of the jury as he and the Government understand is to acquit the prisoners. I never heard that before. I agree with the statement that the functions of a jury are to give to a man in the dock fair play. So far as I know, these functions have in the Free State been carried out in a very efficient manner. I was waiting to hear from some Deputy on the Government benches some suggestion that juries, from the passing of the Treaty down to the present, have not done their duty to Ireland. Nobody suggested they have not. They have done it in an especial degree. Why then cast a slur on the jury? Why is it suggested that the jury system has so far broken down that we must not only take it away——
Comment on this
How is it suggested that the jury system has, so far, broken down, that it has become so hopeless that we must establish instead of it a system that, all through time, has proved a failure, namely, the setting up of military special courts. The Minister for Agriculture is afraid that I overlooked him. He has spoken, and he wants to know if anybody ever heard courtsmartial spoken of with disrespect. I am not going to oblige him, except to a certain extent, and I will leave it to him to say whether it constituted disrespect or not. I have appeared before Free State courtsmartial. I have defended a Free State officer, and I think he would be in a much better position to give an opinion not merely of the file, but of the rank of the Free State Army than anybody speaking in this House. I will tell you what the opinion of the Free State officer of the courtmartial was.
Comment on this
The Deputy has defended an officer of the Army and is going to give us the opinion of that officer on the courtmartial. If the Deputy proposes to do that he is going to do a very dangerous and improper thing.
Comment on this
If you, A Chinn Comhairle, suggest that I should not pursue that subject, even at the risk of disappointing the Minister for Agriculture, I will not. I will content myself by saying that the subject is not one that he should pursue when he suggests that we should inquire as to the respect in which the Free State courtsmartial are held amongst the rank and file of his own Army. I have appeared before a Free State courtmartial quite recently and I am glad to say that I noticed a very marked improvement as compared with the time I went before such a tribunal four years ago. I can say, without getting anybody into trouble, that I went there by appointment to defend a Free State officer. He had full permission for his defence and was informed by the authorities that he was free to employ and consult with a legal agent. I was placed in a hut when I went there, and remained there about two hours. None of the officers would admit that the man was on the premises or would give him facilities for coming to see me. That was my experience of a Free State courtmartial on the 17th March, 1923. I hope none of the people brought up under this Act will be placed in the same position. I hope that an advocate called upon to defend accused persons will not be hunted from the doors of a barrack or kept waiting in a hut for two hours. If that does happen it will not increase the respect which he says—I take his word for it, because I know he would not say anything except what is in accord with the principles of George Washington— these courts command. That disrespect will disappear.
Comment on this
When the Minister for Agriculture spoke a little while ago he made a personal attack upon me. The words I took down as falling from his lips are something to this effect— that I represented a small and embittered section of the English who have left this country. If that be so, I am rather puzzled as to how I came into this House. I think that if the Minister wants to be personally offensive, he should at least temper his remarks with logic. I do not propose to deal with the other suggestions he made here, because I think some of them are more suited to the election platform than to this House.
Comment on this
When the Deputy takes down notes he should take them down completely. I do not propose to withdraw a single word I said. I think every word was deserved.
Comment on this
Might I say this about this debate: We are speaking here in the most important institution in this country. The country has not got so many institutions, and those which it has were conceived and born in very troubled times. Their growth was difficult, and their development is not improved by loose aspersions cast upon them in debate here. I think this debate on the subject of special courts can be conducted without Deputies casting aspersions either upon the Army or upon the police or any other of our institutions. If we could remember that, we would be doing good to this particular institution, which is the most important of them all.
Comment on this
I cannot deal with this matter in the very learned legal way in which it has been dealt with by previous speakers, but to me it seems that there can be two states in a country. You can have a state in which you can deal with crime by civil courts, and you can have a state of war or armed rebellion when you will want military courts. I think the promoters of this Bill should define which of these two states we are in, whether it is war or whether it is peace. Under the Constitution, we are provided with courts for either peace or war, and I do not see the necessity for these special courts. I join with Deputy Wolfe in condemning the statements made by the Vice-President, that these courts were set up not to win the respect of the people, but to put a cold shiver down the backs of the terrorists—he might have added—the men whom he made terrorists. He also went on to say that in dealing with this matter the ordinary machinery might break down. Will the Ministry give us one single instance where the ordinary machinery of the civil courts in dealing with crime has broken down, or what makes them think that they will break down? I do not want to be uncharitable, but are we to accept from their attitude that they want punishment that is not deserved to be meted out for crimes? If they do, I quite agree with the Vice-President that they are not out to win the respect of the people. The President stated that judges were not appointed for this sort of work. I might ask him were military officers appointed for this sort of work? The Judiciary wants to be kept above reproach. We all agree with that, but I should think that the Army and the Army officers should be kept above reproach.
Then we have special pleading on the part of a Deputy learned in the law. In effect, he says that this work would spoil judges. That is really what it means to the ordinary man—it would spoil judges. Well, if crime is dealt with in such a way that it will spoil the judges, then it will be improperly dealt with. Is that not the logical conclusion? The speeches made in support of this section, or any section, or the measure taken as a whole, have been the best speeches to damn the measure. The friends of the Bill are its greatest enemies. Judges will be spoiled if they are brought down from the fount of justice, where every citizen, according to the Constitution, has to get a fair trial by his fellows. In these special courts, if you put in that judge, he will not only be spoiled, but he can never be reclaimed if you send him back to the judiciary. He can never be fit for his old job. He can never be fit to get back to what Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney in a very ponderous way referred to, that state where he could keep his mind open and free. We may imagine, though we cannot describe, what sort of justice these special courts will mete out. Remarks have been made that certain Deputies here are English, or have belonged to a certain small pro-English faction. I do not think that these remarks were deserved. I do not think that it is a compliment to our sense of justice here, even if they did belong to the pro-English faction, that this machinery we Irish are devising is machinery to run to earth fellow-Irishmen. I think we stand condemned by the words spoken out of our own mouths. We have insulted ourselves by these remarks, and we have not insulted the Englishman or those who may be chosen to speak for a small minority with the English spirit or outlook. We have insulted those who claim to have the Irish outlook.
Comment on this
I am not one of those who think that this section, or the previous portion of the Bill, is the worst portion of the Bill, because, at least, there is the assurance, small as it may be, that Parliament shall be called together, and shall be at least sitting every three months while these courts are operating. Nevertheless, I think the case made for their establishment is very far from being conclusive. I draw attention to the point made by Deputy Belton in reference to the position of the judges. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and the President made a great point of the undesirability of the judiciary, or even legal persons, for fear of the consequences to their judicial temperament, acting as a court which had to decide a matter of life and death. But one of the members of the court is to be a person who has legal knowledge and experience, who may be, but need not be, an officer of the defence forces. If he is not an officer of the defence forces and has legal knowledge and experience, it is probably intended that he should be a barrister. Apparently he might give judgment on questions of life and death without spoiling his future career or future habit of mind in matters of criminality and of fact. He does not matter. The probabilities are that in our defence forces there are very few persons who have legal knowledge and experience. There are, let us say, one or two, or, perhaps, three or four. I imagine that their functions in normal times is to act on courts-martial or in respects to courtsmartial. When acting on these courts they may be allowed to form judgment on matters of fact involving the death penalty. But when they have ceased to act on these courts, what is to be their function? Are they to be judicial persons to any degree afterwards? Surely not, because they have been spoiled—their mentality is altered radically and they may not any further act as judicial persons. The Vice-President emphasised the case that these should be military tribunals by the statement that there is no question of civil war, but that there was a criminal, treasonable, terroristic conspiracy, which apparently is to be met by a counter-terror. I do not think that that is the way to approach it. I think that speech, the speeches of the Minister for Agriculture, and the speech of the President this afternoon really present to the House the strongest arguments against the Bill, because they are the arguments of people who want to meet terror by terror.
We are assured that the jury system has not broken down. No Minister is basing his case for these courts upon the proposition that it has failed. Presumably then, the courts are to be set up when that system has failed, and we are to wait until there is some evidence of its failure before the courts are to be set up. Section 20 says that, "Whenever the Executive Council is of opinion that it is necessary in order to secure the due administration of justice and the sure punishment of crime," a proclamation may be issued and the court set up. The jury system has not broken down, and there is no evidence that it is breaking down, and presumably, on the argument, these courts will not be set up until it has broken down. But is the jury system going to break down at one fell swoop? Are we to have the jury system in operation up to a certain date, and then suddenly is it to be declared that it has broken down? That must be the presumption of Ministers, because on previous sections they have refused to give even the House an opportunity to say whether the jury system has broken down until they have declared that it has. The Executive is to be the deciding voice as to whether the jury system has broken down, and the House may afterwards say, "Yes, we believe it has," or, "We believe it has not." But the courts have then been established.
This amendment is to ensure that the court to be set up will consist of judges, and that is the counter-proposition to that of the Ministry, that it should consist of two persons who are officers of the Defence Forces and one person who may be an officer of the Defence Forces, but must have legal knowledge and experience. That court is to act as jury and judge—the two members who are military officers to be the jury and the person with legal knowledge to be the judge. That is the case presented by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. I do not think it is any aspersion to say that military officers sitting to decide questions of fact and law in circumstances such as these, in a court, which on the assurance of Ministers, is only to deal with terroristic movements, treasonable conspiracies and seditious agitation, are not by their very training and antecedents capable of satisfying any impartial citizen that they will be a good court. In no case will military officers be able to give a fair judgment when they are trying their enemies.
Deputy Wolfe, I think it was, drew attention to the difference between British courts-martial as he knew them, when trying their own people, and when trying prisoners in Ireland. I think it is a very natural thing, and that it is no aspersion upon the character of any members of the forces, to say that when trying a prisoner who is charged with engaging in a movement or conspiracy to overthrow the State, these officers will not constitute the best kind of court or even a good court. There is a natural and inevitable prejudice. I do not hesitate, because I do not think I am doing the slightest wrong to anyone, to say that officers of an army, which has had its inception in a political movement, has grown out of that political movement, and has not had long enough tradition to get away from the effects of that movement and training, do not constitute the best court to try political prisoners—prisoners who are engaged in a political conspiracy to overthrow the State.
I know a great many men now in the Free State Army. I knew them long before they were in the Army—very good, decent workmen, and good trade unionists they were. I knew their mentality before they went into the Army, and I know their mentality now. It is not a fair thing to the officers concerned that this duty should be put upon them. I say this, and I know it is a fact from the officers themselves, that they dislike this proposition quite as much as the judges dislike it. I think there is less reason for putting it upon them. They say: "Yes, they ask us to do the dirty work." I say in reference to them that they know they are not competent to constitute fair courts, not because they will not try to be fair, but because they know that their training does not justify them in trying prisoners under these provisions. Coming back to the statement of the Minister for Finance, that the intention of these courts was to put down a terroristic conspiracy, I want again to point out, and to emphasise, that the duties of these courts are not confined to putting down terroristic or treasonable conspiracies. These courts will have to decide whether a person is in fact a member or has been associated with an unlawful conspiracy, that is to say, an unlawful association. There are a great many matters of much less gravity to be tried by these courts than the putting down of treasonable conspiracies. The proposition of the Minister for Finance, that the whole purpose of these courts is only to deal with treasonable conspiracy, is overstating the case; they will have much lesser things to do than that, and they will have much smaller offences to deal with than the activities of treasonable conspiracy.
I think that some such court as Deputy Redmond has suggested is a better court than a court of military officers. No one has met the point or suggestion of Deputy Redmond that if one has to go outside the judiciary or even outside the legal profession you are bound only to go to the military courts. Deputy Redmond made a suggestion—I do not know whether he laid stress upon it; it was not touched upon by Ministers—that a much more suitable court would be officers of the Gárda Síochána. I do not say anything either in commendation or condemnation of that, but it has not been met, and the proposition of Ministers is that the only court that can be established in substitution for the jury system when it has broken down is a military court.
I do not think, as a matter of fact, that this is going to wait for the breakdown of the jury system. I think that the likely outcome of the passing of this section will be that the courts will be established when, and if, any incident takes place which seems to show the continued existence and activity of a treasonable conspiracy. It will be a new answer to the new terroristic activity. It will not be because the courts have broken down, but it will be the new answer of the Executive to what they deem to be the requirements of a further answer to a terroristic act. I, therefore, will support the amendment moved by Deputy Redmond.
Comment on this
I should like to say why I feel strongly that the amendment of Deputy Redmond should be passed by the Committee. The special courts set up under this Act are for the special purpose of the detection of crime, and for dealing with crime and misdemeanours at a time of crisis. We may well agree that special courts, in special circumstances and special emergency may be necessary for the safety and well-being of the State. At the same time these special courts, we believe, should take into account the safety of the citizen, and I think it is apparent, and very evident, from the statement of Ministers in support of the Bill generally, and in support of this particular section, that while they are rightly concerned with bringing criminals to justice, at the same time they are having no regard to the fact that fair play should be given to the accused. I think the accused, in the sense of being, perhaps, not guilty, is being left out of account altogether, and I think that any legislation, even special legislation dealing with any emergency, should jealously guard the rights of the citizen to a fair trial. I do not want to say anything as regards the relative fairness of courtsmartial, English or Irish, but I think it will be agreed that military courts or special courts of the descriptions in this section are regarded with uneasiness by the general body of the people.
They are regarded with uneasiness and with grave concern in almost every country in the world, and I think history has shown that in the efforts to build up States and a proper system of jurisprudence every step has been taken by legislative assemblies to see that the judiciary would be on the same basis as we have it in this country in normal times, and it is only on the very rarest occasions that military courts are allowed to be set up by any assembly. I submit that we have not heard from the Ministerial benches anything to justify the belief that the times ahead of us are such as will warrant us departing from courts composed of ordinary judges. I think that Ministers, in approaching the question of the composition of the courts, in leaving out of account altogether the fair play that an accused should get, apparently believe that every man they arrest is a criminal and that every man arrested should therefore be convicted. I think that there is a little too much of that coming out, as it were, from the utterances of Ministers.
Dealing with another section regarding trial by jury this evening, the President asked Deputy Redmond in a very heated way what jury tried the late Minister and what kind of trial did he get. I can, and I think everyone of us can, sympathise with and appreciate the feelings of the President in thinking of and in referring to the murder of a valued colleague. But is that spirit the right spirit in which to approach legislation involving the lives of citizens? I submit that it is not. Whilst appreciating the feelings of the President, I think that he is not warranted in bringing that forward as any reason why we should support sections such as this, and for that reason I think the House should approach it in a calmer atmosphere, away altogether from the personal aspect or from the feelings brought about by this unfortunate occurrence, and whilst everyone of us is prepared to give the Government all the support possible in putting down crime, conspiracy, and such things, it seems to me that we require to guard the rights of the ordinary citizen and see that if he is accused he should at any rate have a fair trial.
Comment on this
It is really very difficult to decide on the relative merits of the case put forward, and the more we hear the more confused we get. Deputy Cullen concluded by saying: "We are prepared to do certain things; we are prepared to give the Government all the support that is necessary to enable them to put down crime." One must ask what does Deputy Cullen mean by that, and we have all to ask ourselves the same question. Is Deputy Cullen prepared to concede all the powers that the Government think are necessary to enable them to put down crime, or is he prepared to give only what he considers necessary for that purpose? If I am to make any comment at all on that statement of Deputy Cullen's, let me make this with regard to the attitude of the Labour Party, that that statement has been made time and again by their leader and by members of the Party with regard to this measure. This measure is as objectionable to my Party, and to me, as it is to the leader of the Labour Party, or to the members of that Party. I think, with the exception of two, they voted against every section in the Bill so far. These sections would be of very little value indeed in regard to the extra powers that the Government are seeking and which the Labour Party say they are prepared to concede. Even last night—and I passed it then and I passed it since, but I cannot help commenting on the fact— Constitutionalists, great defenders of the Constitution though they are, voted against the section that seeks to penalise men who come before properly constituted courts of the country and who will not recognise these courts I find it difficult to see exactly how that attitude squares with the high constitutional aspect which the Labour Party advanced here, and on which they want us to base decisions.
Comment on this
I do not know what point Deputy Baxter is on. He might as well have voted for it. What section of the Bill is Deputy Baxter on?
Comment on this
Let me say further that I have taken up much less time than most Labour Deputies. Neither myself nor my Party have made any attempt to obstruct or to detain other Parties when other Parties had business to do that called them elsewhere.
Comment on this
My Party and I have stood for whatever we said against the measure, and let me say this, and let the House and the country know it, that if the truth were known there may be men in this House who want this measure more than we do, but they would like others to put it through so that they would have a chance of being the grand people——
Comment on this
Deputy Redmond's amendment is definite and explicit. It asks us to accept "a tribunal consisting of three members who shall be judges of the High Court." I have not heard all the arguments for and against. On the one hand, the plea is made that a court consisting of three judges would be more competent than a military court, that the prisoner and justice would be better served by such a court. If I am to make a choice, I agree that it would be better to have such a court. As far as Deputy Johnson is concerned, he is not acting more constitutionally in supporting a court of three judges—that is, a special court —than in supporting the other type of court, drawn from officers of the defence forces of Saorstát Eireann. In that sense, either court is abrogating the Constitution. No one can plead that he is a greater defender of the Constitution in one point than in another.
In answering Deputy Redmond, the President stated that he was not prepared to ask the judges of the High Court to serve on these special courts. I think he said that it was not in the terms of their appointment. I would like it to be clear whether or not the terms of their appointment are so definite that, if they were called upon under an Act of this House to perform such functions in order to serve the ends of justice in a particular way, they could claim that it was outside their functions to serve in such a manner. I think that is hardly a justifiable attitude for the President to take up. I think it is hardly an answer to Deputy Redmond's case.
With regard to military courts, the point that they would not dispense justice in the fashion that three judges might do, largely because two members of that court will not have experience or knowledge of the law, has, I think, a certain amount of weight. Undoubtedly, our officers are young; many of them are less experienced in law and in the affairs of the world than the members of the Judiciary. I am not going to suggest—I think it is unworthy of any representative in this House to suggest—that any officer of the National Army would be such an unworthy citizen as to act unjustly towards any offender brought before him. I believe that an offender would stand as good a chance of a fair trial there, and be treated as justly as if he were before a jury of his countrymen in the courts. I can see no reason whatever for believing that the contrary would be the case.
To some extent, we have to remember how the defence forces of Saorstát Eireann were brought into existence. They were born in revolution, came through a period of civil war, and for a considerable time since then have been engaged in the work of hunting for arms and so on. I am conscious of the fact that these courts are to be set up if and when certain conditions exist—conditions which we, at least, do not anticipate will come about—on which military men are to serve to try offenders who had been possibly in arms against them at an earlier period in the life of this State. I am not going to suggest that that fact would influence the men on these courts. Nevertheless, the fact that the members of the court have stood at one time for one thing, and that those who are being tried by it were and even now are standing for something else, is a factor which we must take cognisance of. Weighing the whole matter up, we would prefer that these special courts should be constituted in the fashion suggested by Deputy Redmond or in the manner suggested in sub-section (a) of Section 22. On the other hand, I think that a case has, to some extent, been made that would warrant our believing that it was possible a decision on the part of this House—if and when certain conditions were created here by other people who have no sympathy with this House, no respect for the State and nothing but hate for some of its citizens—under such circumstances, to have a military court to try such men, if necessary, might act as a deterrent and even would be a threat to these people, that there was danger ahead for them if they committed a crime against the State or lives of citizens.
I think the existence of sub-section (b) in this section might actually strengthen the position of our civil courts as they operate at present, and might in fact be a protection for these courts, might make people who would be prepared to intimidate men who would serve on a jury, so as to prevent them doing their duty, just as some of these people might be found prepared to intimidate members of this House and prevent them doing their duty by the State. It might be a deterrent and might make these people believe that if they committed an offence the safest thing for them would be not to commit such an offence against the life of the State or the lives of citizens of the State. They might consider the best thing they could do would be to commit no offence against the civil courts, to do nothing that would prevent the civil courts functioning and continuing to dispense justice. Knowing that, and realising that if any action of theirs was responsible for creating a position in which this or another Executive Council could declare that the civil courts had failed, and could come to this House and ask for support for a proclamation to establish other special courts, these people might feel that the position they were creating for themselves was more serious and more difficult. With that belief and conviction, this section, standing as it is, might actually operate so as to preserve stability and order. In my view, there is no justification for the President proposing in amendment 49, which we are not prepared to countenance or support, not to ask the courts to do this work. Our attitude and belief is that if this House declares certain work to be the function of officers of the courts of this country, it is their duty to carry out its decisions, just as we have to take other decisions.
On the other hand, it seems to me that Deputy Redmond's amendment stands for one court and one court only, while serving the purpose perhaps of being the very best under the circumstances which a prisoner could expect from the point of view of trial and justice. Taking away the military court, leaving the Supreme Court alone, would weaken the section and have such an effect on the present position of our civil courts that we might be called upon to bring into existence these special courts much sooner than might be necessary; or by doing that we might be doing something that might prevent our ever having to meet here to bring these special courts into existence. I do not think that Deputy Redmond is wise in stressing his amendment. On the other hand, the President would, in our view, be asking for something wholly unjustifiable by attempting to take from the Bill this section.
Comment on this
I am quite at a loss to understand the irritation betrayed by Deputy Baxter at the attitude taken up by the Labour Deputies towards this Bill. I have been a frequent visitor to the Dáil for the past four years, during which Deputy Baxter has been a member and I found him a very strenuous critic of the Ministry and of the various measures introduced by them during that period. It does not seem an adequate justification to me, because certain things happened and because the mantle of Deputy Gorey fell on Deputy Baxter, to find that that justified him in changing his attitude towards the Ministry and that he should upbraid Deputies of the Labour Party because they were not as agile in changing their political outlook as he has been.
Comment on this
Neither was there any justification for saying that as far as the Labour Party are concerned there were certain Deputies who, while opposing the measure in this House, were anxious to have it passed. I do not think the members of the Labour Party are more deficient in courage than any other Deputies here, and I repudiate the innuendo contained in that remark. The Deputies of the Labour Party have always had the courage of their convictions. They have been prepared to stand up for what they believe. Like other members of the Party who have spoken, I deplore the decision of the Executive Council in coming down here and asking us to set up these special courts and thereby abrogating those rights and guarantees that citizens are given under the Constitution.
Reference has been made by Deputies that some Deputies appear to forget the history of the past ten or twelve years. But to anybody who is familiar with the remarkable and revolutionary period in which we have lived in that time, it is surprising that in such a short period after these events have taken place that things should be anything like normal. Just consider that eleven years ago the President of the Executive Council was a convict in an English prison serving a life sentence, after narrowly escaping being shot; that fifteen months later he was elected representative by the great majority of the people; that one and a half years after that he was a Minister of a revolutionary Government; that a year later again he was a fugitive, liable to be shot at sight; that two years after that he was the head of an established Government, and that a few months after that again he was the head of a State waging civil war; that it was his duty, and the duty of his colleagues, as they conceived it, to execute seventy-seven of their fellow-citizens, many of them close colleagues in the revolutionary movement through which they had passed, some of them personal friends; that they were called upon to send to prison hundreds of men who had been closely associated with them in the same movement, and to intern fifteen thousand citizens of the State.
Let me say, in case I may be misunderstood, that as references have been made by other Deputies to that state of affairs, that I personally do not doubt that in any steps taken by the President and his colleagues in that time they did anything except what they believed was absolutely necessary for the safeguarding of the State. The steps taken by them were taken with the greatest reluctance. I do not say that I agreed with what they did, but I am satisfied that they were convinced that these steps were necessary. But now, having regard to that, is it remarkable that there should be an aftermath of all that? That there should be not only what exists to-day, but a great deal more? I know my personal view was, and it was expressed to my friends on many occasions, that the end of the period of civil war would see wholesale assassinations of the leading figures who were concerned in it. I was most agreeably surprised and delighted that that state of affairs had not occurred, and that, up to the assassination of the late Vice-President, we had a state of affairs in which the passions aroused by the civil war, and the things surrounding it, had, to all appearances, almost died down, and we had advanced by giant strides towards a state of affairs in which political differences would flow in the ordinary accepted channels, and that the gun and the appeal to force were rapidly becoming things of the past.
We were all shocked and horrified, of course, to find that they were not. That single incident showed that that was not so. But I have the view that that was an isolated occurrence and that it does not indicate that we are likely to have an epidemic of that state of affairs. I have a firm hope in that. The Government, I know, hold the contrary view. Deputy Baxter asks us: "Are you prepared to trust the Ministry if they say this Bill is necessary?" Personally, I am not. I am not prepared to trust this Ministry or any other Ministry. We are here as elected Deputies of the people, to exercise our own judgment as to what legislation should be passed, and we are not to act on anybody else's judgment. If we have arrived at a state of affairs when we have to trust the judgment of the Ministry or the judgment of somebody else, then there is no case for us being here at all. Personally, if I were convinced that the only way to prevent Minister or men who go on discharging their public duties incurring the risk of assassination, if I were convinced that this was the only way to prevent it, I would be prepared to support this measure, but with reluctance. I am not convinced that it is the only way. I am rather inclined to believe that it would have the opposite effect.
Political assassination is not a new thing in the world. Most, if not all, countries have been troubled by it. Countries that have been governed in an autocratic fashion, like Russia up to 1917, and countries with a democratic constitution, like England and America, have been bothered by it. America, with its democratic constitution, lost two Presidents by assassination within twenty years, and I believe that it is not a coincidence that the country with the most autocratic government was the country with the most attempts at political assassination, and that in countries with the most democratic Constitution there were fewer of those attempts. I believe that measures such as this will promote and favour and encourage conspiracy and assassination. I believe that the only true remedies for it is to trust the people and not to adopt this measure. The President and the Ministers may say: "This is all very well, but we are the people who are running the risks, not you." That is perfectly true, but they ran risks before when they thought it was necessary, and I put it to the President that it is necessary to run this risk, and I admit it is a risk. It is necessary to run it.
The free development of this country upon democratic lines is a big thing, and it is worth taking a risk for. I put it to the Ministry that they should take that risk. I would refer to an incident that occurred, very closely associated with the late Vice-President. Right at the time that the civil war was still on it fell to the duty of the late Vice-President to establish a police force. At that time he took what appeared to a great many people a very great risk in establishing an unarmed police force. That act was described by Deputy Johnson, speaking for those he represented at the time, as a far-seeing act of statesmanship. It is one of the greatest monuments that the late Vice-President has left behind him. I think that a further risk should be taken by the President and his colleagues, and that he should regard what has happened as an isolated incident which, I believe, is condemned by all fair-minded people in the country, not excepting the vast majority of the political opponents of the present Government. I believe that this risk should be taken, and we offer our opposition to the setting up of these special courts and to this Bill in general not upon party grounds or to make party capital, but simply and honestly because we believe it is not the right way of going about what is intended and we believe it will have the contrary effect to what is intended.
Comment on this
I hope it is not impertinent of me to say that Deputy O'Brien's speech and manner were a model of what a speech on the subject should be.
Comment on this
It was a speech of serious argument, put forward temperately and reasonably. Having said that, I must disagree with some of his matter. He says that political assassination is no new thing, and that, alas, is true. I do not remember the murders of Lincoln and Garfield, but I do remember many murders of heads of States and responsible Ministers. I remember the murder of McKinley and I remember the murder of the King of Italy; I remember the murder of the Empress of Austria, and I remember many unsuccessful attempts at assassination against persons holding high powers in various States. What was the characteristic of all these murders? They were murders committed by men of unbalanced minds with no organisation behind them; the murderer was invariably apprehended. There was no motor car waiting, no men on the look-out, no organisation to enable the murderer to get away. We have gone back from those political assassinations. This is a very different one. The murder we have had to deal with recently and the murders we may have to deal with in future, are not murders committed by unbalanced boys, full of some crazy story of rights and wrongs; they are deliberate cold-blooded murders planned in advance, with motor cars stolen and arrangements made for escape. Surely they need some more serious mechanism to counteract and confront them than merely the expression of public opinion.
With all respect to Deputy O'Brien, my criticism of the Labour Party is that on this Bill they have offered us no alternative of any kind whatever; not a single amendment on the paper; divisions, discussions, always ending up in a negative. We must assume that in their view the present state of affairs is for the best, and that we should carry on our business now as we have done it for the past four years, punctuated by an occasional funeral procession. That is a risk that we must take in order to assure the multitude. Well, I will not take it.
It is not my business to defend Deputy Baxter; he is very well able to look after himself. I, like Deputy O'Brien, listened to Deputy Baxter criticising the Government, and I fancy I shall listen to Deputy Baxter criticising the Government again; but he generally put forward an alternative: he generally said what ought in his view to be done. He did not only say what the Government ought not to do: he gave a constructive line of advance, and I see no tendency of that constructive line of advance on the benches on my left. I do not want to detain the Dáil. I will only say I agree with every word Deputy Baxter said, including his comment on the amendment the President has tabled.
Comment on this
I would like also to express the view that the first sensible speech that I heard against this measure was uttered by Deputy O'Brien. I believe what he said to be the soundest conviction of his own mind. But he might have gone a little bit further and he might have reviewed the events of the last five years a little more closely. We have not met those events of five years by the methods that he recommended in his closing sentences. We had to take strong action, whether he agreed with it or not, and I must say that running through his speech there was at least an indication that there was there a mind which, if it had never exercised authority, at any rate knew something about the exercise of authority.
It would be an easy thing for us to take the line that this was an isolated incident and that the public condemnation which was expressed would have brought home to the minds of those engaged in the conspiracy that there was no support for any such action. But I listened to at least one speech from one of the Deputy's friends on that side and I never heard a single expression which would lead me to believe that there was a desire on the part of that person that the perpetrators should be apprehended. Deputy Lynch was the speaker, and he can now express the wish that he would like to see them apprehended if he desires. That is our position at the moment. Mr. de Valera did the same thing. He condemned it, but he did not express any wish to see the perpetrators brought to justice. It is not a spirit of revenge that animates us in doing our work here. We are introducing a measure of this sort with a view to the prevention of a crime such as that. I might be prepared to accept this as an isolated incident if we had not had some very considerable proof that it is no such thing—such as we had last November when various Gárda stations were invaded by young fellows with guns and when two of the best officers of their rank were shot dead. We have other evidence that there is a conspiracy behind this, and while I am prepared personally to take any risk in this State, I have others to look to besides myself. I have other Ministers. You must have a Ministry and we have had to take the same strong steps with regard to this measure that we had five years ago when an attempt was made to prevent the State being born.
I thought I had explained the reason why we were establishing military courts. It is that the policy of the Executive Council for five years has been to have an independent judiciary. It would not be an independent judiciary if we were to appoint three members of the High Court, or any of our judges, to perform the duties which would be allotted to them after this measure had been passed. Judges are not called upon to express an opinion as to the guilt or innocence of a prisoner. That is for the jury. We intend, as long as we have the responsibility, to keep the judiciary independent, and I hope that our successors will do the same thing. I hope it will be a characteristic of this country for all time. There is a remarkable difference between that particular line of policy and the mid-Victorian radical policy that prevailed here in which there was an association between the Executive and the judiciary. It did not bring public confidence in the judiciary in consequence. We have established the utmost possible safeguards, the utmost possible liberty with democratic rights and privileges for the people of this country, and yet with all that these crimes have been committed. Now it is the duty of a Government to punish crime and to take steps to prevent it.
The Minister for Finance explained at great length the reason for including Part 4 in this measure—the setting up of special courts. The Deputy is quite within his rights not to give that privilege or that responsibility to any Government, but he must remember that along with that right there is a very great responsibility. It is that responsibility that we are putting to the Dáil to-night: that a very serious attack has been made on the first institution in this country. This is not the ordinary assassination of a Minister. If it were one of the incidents the Deputy referred to I should have been the person upon whom the attempt should have been made for assassination. It was not. There was no attempt made upon me. The Dáil is now faced with the problem of dealing with this matter in the only way in which it can be dealt with. We can only again express the hope that it will not be necessary to set up these courts, but that if it be necessary they will be set up and the necessary action will be taken.
While accepting what Deputy O'Brien has said, I do not accept many of the extravagant and elaborate statements that have been made by critics of this measure. "Any offence which is declared by the Treasonable Offences Act, 1925, to be treason or a felony or a misdemeanour" will be triable by these special courts. "Any offence which is declared by this Act to be a misdemeanour, murder or attempted murder of the Governor-General or any member of the Oireachtas, or any judge of the Supreme Court, the High Court or the Circuit Court, or any Justice of the District Court" will be dealt with by these courts, but not all of them carry with them the maximum penalty.
Comment on this
Will the President look at Section 5, which says that every person who is a member of an unlawful association shall be guilty of a misdemeanour. Will such persons be triable by these courts?
Comment on this
"Any offence which is declared by this Act to be a misdemeanour." That is plain English, and ought to be understandable to everyone.
Comment on this
"Any offence which is declared by this Act to be a misdemeanour." That is plain English, and if it is not understood it is not my fault.
Comment on this
It is quite readily understood, but I want to explain my point. The President has detailed certain offences which are to be tried by these courts. Section 5 says that "every person who is a member of an unlawful association at any time after it has become by virtue of this Act an unlawful association shall be guilty of a misdemeanour and shall be liable on conviction to suffer penal servitude for any term not less than three years and not exceeding five years," so that I take it membership of an unlawful association is triable by these courts.
Comment on this
"Any offence which is declared by this Act to be a misdemeanour" will be triable by these courts. I understand that to be plain English, and I believe the Dáil understands it.
Comment on this
This Bill has been before the Dáil for the last ten days. We have, as Deputy Cooper has said, had no alternative except the one mentioned by Deputy O'Brien. That was the first honest attempt that was made. This is our contribution towards correcting the dangerous tendencies which have been evidenced by the conspiracy that brought about the death of a Minister of the State. If that had occurred in the year 1923 or 1924, it would not have the same character that it has now in 1927. It would not be so heinous, and it is on a par with most of the opposition there is to the State. Those who speak about the economic situation and about the need for ensuring stable conditions to persons likely to invest capital in this country, ought at least have a very big concern that conspiracies such as we know are in existence should be dealt with by law, and this is the law to deal with them.
Comment on this
The President's statement has rather surprised me. I think not only the President but every Deputy in this House ought to know that I not only deplore that murder which deprived us of a Member of this House but I absolutely condemn those who caused that murder, those who carried out that murder. It ought not to be necessary for me to say that there is nothing I believe more sacred than human life. Not only because the late Deputy O'Higgins was the Vice-President of this Council but even if he had been one of the most humble servants of this Government I believe his murderers would be just as equally entitled, if caught, to meet the just merits of their ghastly deed. It ought not to be necessary for me to make a statement of that kind, and I sincerely hope that they will be caught. The only difference is that I do not believe that there is anything in this Bill that will enable them to be caught. That is where we disagree.
Comment on this
We have a tendency to go back to Second Reading speeches on this Bill, and I think we will have to go back to Section 22, Amendment 48.
Comment on this
I think I was the first Member of this House to express the wish publicly that the perpetrators of the awful murder we all regret and deplore should be caught, and that I had never any hesitation in calling the deed, and I think I can speak for my party, murder, but some of the friends or the so-called friends of the Government carefully avoided the word "murder."
Comment on this
I think there is a good deal of loose thinking and talking in this whole debate and attempts are being made in this House to misrepresent the position that is being taken up by this Party in connection with the Bill. We have had, during the last couple of days, charges hurled at us because we opposed the Bill, or perhaps certain sections of the Bill, to be more correct, that we are shirking our responsibilities and taking the safer course. Those of us who were here in the 1922 Dáil during the all-night sitting in that Dáil, listened to those charges then as we are listening to them now. Surely it is not going to be contended that we are trying to save our own skins, trying to shirk our responsibilities, merely because we do not see eye to eye with every measure introduced in this House?
That is the gist of the speeches that have been made by at least one member of this House for the last two or three days. Deputy Baxter has done that in every speech he made. Those who have the temerity to oppose any section of this Bill are shirking their responsibilities. I have only to say this, that it comes well from Deputy Baxter.
Comment on this
Declarations were made by practically every member of his Party, and by the leader, that they were prepared to give support to any measure necessary to meet the present situation. That statement was made. I am sorry that I came on after Deputy Cullen. He has not cut across this debate very much, and is very reasonable. My complaint is that neither Deputy Johnson nor any member of his party as a whole gave any indication of the sections in this Bill that they were prepared to support. Deputy Johnson has repeatedly—I have listened, I have watched—incited his men to obstruct, telling them they could speak three times, and ordering them to stand up. That is not the kind of attitude to give us the kind of measure the House wants to have brought out. If I have to ask myself what kind of measure we are to get, I do not see a single section you are going to give, and you gave us nothing else. I leave it to Deputy Johnson and Deputy Morrissey to explain what they would give.
Comment on this
I explained what I would give. If I were to admit the truth of what Deputy Baxter said, and if all this matter were not as serious as it really is, I would be inclined to say that we were following the example of Deputy Baxter for the last four years, for the lifetime of the last Dáil.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would be only satisfied with saying that we could go on. Deputy Baxter made certain statements and I called on Deputy O'Brien in preference to Deputy Cooper because he was sitting on the front bench of the Labour Party. He dealt with the matter in a particular way. The President dealt with it in a particular way. We are going back instead of going forward. I know that is not Deputy Morrissey's own wishes. I know his wishes are to the contrary.
Comment on this
We will leave Deputy Baxter to his own conscience and consistency, but I want to say that we are as anxious for the safety of this State, and for every citizen in this State, as any Member of this House. We may differ as to the means for ensuring that safety, but in our opinion, and our opinion on this matter as in all other matters in this House is sincere and honest, this is not the best method to secure the safety of the citizens of this State, whether Members of the Oireachtas or not. So far as I am concerned we have never hesitated to denounce in the very plainest possible language the murder of the late Vice-President. We have never hesitated for one moment to say that we hope the people who are responsible for that murder will be brought to justice and get what they deserved. We go further and say that if it were possible that we were in a position to help to bring them to justice not one of us would refuse that help. I think when we have the courage to come here and face up to our responsibilities and give expression to our opinions that we ought not be charged with cowardice. I think most of the members of this House know that the Labour Party faced up to its responsibilities and shouldered its responsibilities when it was in much more danger than now in 1922. Most of the Members who were in the 1922 Dáil know quite well that the Labour Party as much as the Executive Council made it possible to carry on the Parliament of this nation, and the President knows well that the members of this party were in as much danger as any member of the Executive Council.
It was often thrown at us during the threats which we received that it was because the Labour Party were here acting as an Opposition that they gave this assembly the semblance of a Parliament, and that if we were not here it would be merely a mutual admiration society. I think we ought to get away from the cheap sneers and the loose talk which, I admit quite frankly, has come from all sides of the House in the past two days. I have heard during the past couple of days more loose talk than in the previous five years. I hope Deputies will thrash issues out in a reasonable way, and give all parties in the House credit for trying to do what they think the best, according to their lights, in the interests of the country.
Comment on this
We will have to have future speeches confined to this amendment in the narrowest possible way.
Comment on this
I was going to ask for a little latitude at this stage to avoid having to make the statement I wish to make at a later stage. I do not want to have recriminations.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy will let me say that we have had on Section 20 a discussion, which was technically out of order, on the military courts, and which has not been of the faintest assistance in relation to Deputy Redmond's amendment.
I have no regard for technical points of order, and I did not interfere. The discussion has contributed nothing of any importance on Deputy Redmond's amendment. If Deputy Johnson wants any latitude now, in preference to later on, he has to be sure that he will have it only now, and not later on also.
Comment on this
I think under the circumstances it is better I should not make the statement at this stage.
Amendment put. The Committee divided: Tá, 30; Níl, 50.
Tá
Richard S. Anthony.P. Belton.Alfred Byrne.Michael Carter.James Coburn.Hugh Colohan.Denis Cullen.William Davin.Séamus Eabhróid.Hugh Garahan.John F. Gill.David Hall.Gilbert Hewson.John Jinks.Thomas Johnson. | John Keating.Michael J. Keyes.Thomas Lawlor.Gilbert Lynch.Pádraig Mac Fhlannchadha.Daniel McMenamin.Daniel Morrissey.William O'Brien.John F. O'Hanlon.Tadhg O Murchadha.Timothy Quill.William Archer Redmond.Vincent Rice.James Shannon.Jasper Travers Wolfe.
Níl
Earnán Altún.Patrick F. Baxter.J. Walter Beckett.George Cecil Bennett.Earnán de Blaghd.Séamus Breathnach.Seán Brodrick.Séamus de Búrca.John Joseph Byrne.Bryan R. Cooper.Michael Davis.Michael Doyle.James Dwyer.Barry M. Egan.James Fitzgerald-Kenney.Denis J. Gorey.Michael R. Heffernan.John Hennigan.Mark C. Henry.Patrick Hogan (Galway).Richard Holohan.Patrick M. Kelly.Myles Keogh.Hugh A. Law.Liam T. Mac Cosgair.Martin McDonogh. | P. McGilligan.Mícheál Óg Mac Pháidín.James E. Murphy.Martin M. Nally.Mícheál O hAonghusa.Máirtín O Conalláin.Partholán O Conchubhair.Séamus O Cruadhlaoidh.Máighréad Ní Choileáin BeanUí Dhrisceóil.Eoghan O Dochartaigh.Séamus N. O Dóláin.P.S. O Dubhghaill.E.S. O Dúgáin.Fionán O Loingsigh.Dermot Gun O'Mahony.Risteárd O Maolchatha.John J. O'Reilly.Máirtín O Rodaigh.Seán O Súilleabháin.Patrick W. Shaw.Timothy Sheehy.William E. Thrift.Vincent J. White.George Wolfe.
Tellers.—Tá: Deputies Coburn and Morrissey. Níl: Deputies Duggan and P. S. Doyle.
Comment on this
The decision on amendment 48 governs amendment 50, and it, therefore, will not be moved.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (1), page 10, to delete all from the word "at," line 17, to the letter "(b)" at the beginning of line 22, both inclusive.
This follows a statement I made on the Second Reading, when I explained the reasons for it. It is unnecessary for me to go any further into it.
Comment on this
Question—"That the Title stand part of the Bill"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 51:—
In sub-section (1) (b), lines 24-25, to delete the words "a person certified by the Attorney-General to have legal knowledge and experience" and substitute therefor the words "at the date of his appointment a practising barrister or solicitor of six years' standing at least."
In moving this amendment, I have two objects in view. The first is, if the sub-section is carried setting up this court, that the odium of nominating the legal adviser should not rest on the shoulders of the Attorney-General. No question arises as to the fitness or bona fides of the Attorney-General to nominate anybody for the position, but what is liable to follow? It may be said that so-and-so has been appointed legal adviser and that he only qualified as a solicitor last year, or as a barrister six months ago. The other important thing is that this court will apparently have only one member who will have any legal training, and I think every Deputy knows that in admitting evidence in a criminal case, more particularly in one involving a question of life and death, there is nothing more highly technical than what should be admitted and what should not be admitted as evidence. I think that the odium or the responsibility should not be thrown on the Attorney-General of determining what person is qualified to act in this capacity, and that the Dáil should say that the person to be appointed should have certain specified qualifications. That would relieve the Attorney-General of any responsibility in the matter and would be a guarantee to the public that the man appointed was sufficiently long in the practice of his profession to know what he was doing.
Comment on this
It takes a late hour of the night to bring forward the greatest joke in the way of amendment and in the way of reasoning that could be put forward for an amendment. The Deputy wants the public to have confidence in the person with legal training who is to be associated with the military court. He proposes the amendment for the reason that confidence must be obtained for the court, and that the Attorney-General should not have the odium thrown upon him of selecting the person.
Comment on this
Leave the solicitor out of it for the moment. On the other hand, the Government's suggestion is a person certified by the Attorney-General to have legal knowledge and experience. There is many a practising barrister of six years' standing whom the Attorney-General could not certify to have legal knowledge and experience. Deputy McMenamin knows that full well. A practising barrister of six years' experience means a barrister who at the moment of his appointment is in practice, is attending the Bar Library, is looking for cases, is not retired from the Bar and is six years qualified. He may have passed his whole six years as a barrister without a single case. As long as he is still looking for practice at the Bar he is a practising barrister, and if he is six years qualified he is of six years' standing. That is the sort of type the Deputy would have the public have confidence in. On the other hand, we suggest that he should be a person certified by the Attorney-General to have legal knowledge and experience. The Attorney-General reaches his high position after he has been in practice at the Bar—not looking for practice at the Bar, but practising at the Bar— the leader of the Bar.
Comment on this
He has to certify that the person has legal knowledge and experience. Is the Attorney-General likely to certify that a person has legal knowledge and experience unless in fact he has? Are we going to get any better substitute by adopting the absurd suggestion that it should be any man called to the Bar six years ago, who has not given up the chance of practising, has not given up the hope of a brief at the moment at which he is appointed? That is the gist of the amendment.
Comment on this
Late as the hour is, it takes the Minister to bring about a discussion. Possibly there would have been very little discussion on this amendment were it not for the manner in which the Minister, in his usual style, received the amendment. This was not brought forward as a joke.
Comment on this
The Minister now is endeavouring perhaps to liven up the proceedings, but not exactly by turning them into a joke. He has completely misinterpreted the spirit of the amendment, and he knows perfectly well that the spirit of the amendment is precisely the same as that embodied in the Courts of Justice Act, which provides that no member of the Bar shall be appointed a judge unless he is a practising barrister of so many years' standing. What was the point of putting that into the Courts of Justice Act if it is not to be applied here? Was it done as a standing joke? Is it to be suggested that because a principle, which has been acted upon by the Government, is embodied in that Act, and because that same principle is put forward here by a member of the Minister's own profession for the same purpose, that it was done as a joke? I must say that I think the joke smacks very much of the North—of the part of the country that the Minister comes from.
Comment on this
There is just one point to which I should like to call attention, which I am not quite clear about.
The section reads: "As soon as may be after every occasion on which this part of the Act comes into force there shall be established by the Executive Council one or more tribunals," etc. It would seem from the wording of that, that the Executive Council would be the means of establishing the court. What I would like information on is as to whether the nomination of members of the court would rest with the Executive Council. Who would be the nominating authority? Who would be the authority that would actually nominate the three members of this court? Would it be the Executive Council or not? I think it would be wise to have some reply on that. In regard to the amendment which has just been voted upon and defeated, that amendment was described by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, rather hurriedly, I admit, as a joke at this late hour of the night. In reply, rather hurriedly also, I admit, I stated that a similar provision embodying a similar principle was inserted in the Courts of Justice Act, 1924. Since then I have discovered that this huge joke—which seems to have been a joke in the imagination of the Minister for Industry and Commerce—has also been perpetrated in every Emergency Powers Act passed already by his Party and his Government. I find in the Public Safety Emergency Powers Act of 1923 a provision——
Comment on this
I might remind the Deputy that the amendment has not been inserted in the section.
Comment on this
I quite admit that the amendment has not been inserted, and it is for that reason I am pointing out why it should be inserted in the section.
Comment on this
I am pointing out why it is a mistake not to have it inserted in the section, and, further, why I am going to vote against the section. One of the reasons why I shall vote against the section is the manner in which this amendment was so lightly disposed of by the Minister. This proposal was actually embodied in Section 4 of the 1923 Public Safety Act, where it states: "Councils consisting of not less than three members, of whom one shall be a practising barrister or solicitor of not less than five years' standing." It was not a joke under that Act; neither was it a joke under the Public Safety (Emergency Powers) Act, 1926. But, because it is proposed by an ordinary member of this Dáil, the Minister hurries in and informs the House at this late hour that it is a joke. I hope, as he seems to be so anxious to consume the time at this late hour, that he has seen the joke. I also hope that in future, when amendments are proposed to legislation brought in by the Government, especially amendments——
Comment on this
I must ask Deputy Redmond to resume his seat for a moment. I gave the Deputy plenty of time to explain why he wanted the amendment re-discussed, but I cannot allow him to get on with a discussion of an amendment that has been rejected by the House.
Comment on this
Very well, of course, I bow to your ruling, and I shall deal with the section. The section proposes that three or more members, of whom one (who may be or not be an officer in the Defence Forces of Saorstát Eireann) shall be a person certified by the Attorney-General to have legal knowledge and experience, and the others shall be officers of the Defence Forces of Saorstát Eireann not below the rank of commandant. This does not contain a provision similar to that contained in the Emergency Acts that I have recited, and there has been no reason advanced why such a similar provision should not be contained.
Apart altogether from this particular sub-section I think that it should be fairly obvious now that there has been no adequate reason advanced why this particular form of court should be set up, as distinct from and against any other form of special court. The trend of the debate which latterly largely took the form of a Second Reading debate seemed to point to the direction, especially from speeches made from the Government benches, that this was the only course open to them, that nothing else would be of any use or assistance, that nothing short of a military court, or a court composed of such military officers would serve the avowed purpose of this Bill. But no reasons have been advanced for that conclusion.
I asked during the course of my remarks, in moving my amendment, whether any reason could be given by the Government why a civil court, no matter how it was composed—whether of High Court judges, Supreme Court judges, Circuit Court judges or special Commissioners—could not effect a purpose similar to that required by the military court. I have got no reply whatever to that statement except perhaps the remarks passed by the Vice-President when he seemed to suggest that terror must be met by terror and, I suppose, stroke by counter stroke. There I beg profoundly to disagree with him. I think if there was not a certain anxiety to get to work and have what is called speedy justice brought about, if there was a desire to endeavour to allow things to improve instead of actually encouraging them to disimprove, such a drastic measure as this would not be adopted. There has not, as far as I am concerned, been any reason why courts composed of civilians rather than military officers would not more than adequately meet the case and would not be such a distinct breach of the Constitution as are the military courts provided by the section. It has been said that any kind of special courts are in fact a contravention of Article 70 of the Constitution. That is so, but at the same time, to my mind, courts composed of military officers go even one step further than special courts composed of civilians, because it is not only expressly laid down in the Article of the Constitution that no one shall be tried save in the courts of law and by the ordinary court but it is also expressly laid down that the jurisdiction of military tribunals shall not be extended to or exercised over the civilian population save in time of war or armed rebellion. Therefore, I am more than ever convinced that this proposal tends to aggravate the situation in which we find ourselves to-day rather than improve it, and it is because of that I propose to vote against the section.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
This section provides for ensuring that a person who is charged with an offence mentioned in the Schedule of the Bill shall, no matter whether he has been already before the courts, provided that no conviction has been obtained, and if there has been a disagreement, go forward to this special court. It is clearly a section which intends that there shall be a conviction, and I think that the section ought not be passed until we know what kind of regulations are to govern the conduct of the special courts. I think it is quite an important thing to ensure that when the person charged has in his defence been able to raise doubts in the minds of the jury as to his guilt, he should at least have similar opportunities in respect of his defence in the next court as he has had in the first court. If the regulations that are to be made respecting the method of trial are not of the kind and nature that would protect the accused, then the sending forward is undoubtedly prejudicial to the accused. and I hope that that will be taken into account when you come to the question of the regulations governing the conduct of these special courts.
Comment on this
In sub-section (4), line 63, to delete all words after the word "expire" to the end of the sub-section.— (Deputy Hewson, Deputy Redmond)
Do you agree with this result?
I move—
In sub-section (1), line 54, to delete the word "shall" and substitute therefor the word "may."
I do not think that the amendment requires much explanation. The Bill as it stands compels this unconstitutional court in certain circumstances to be blood-thirsty even against its better judgment. The amendment, on the other hand, would allow it to follow that better judgment. I do not think I require to say any more.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (1), line 55, after the words "to suffer death" to add the words "such sentence to be subject to confirmation or mitigation by the Executive Council."
During the course of the debate on other sections many Deputies practically dealt with this amendment. Its object is plain on the face of it, that as there is no appeal from the sentence of a special court there should be some tribunal to revise a sentence which might be regarded as too severe. I can conceive a state of circumstances, and it would not be the first time in this country when a great number of people would be brought before these special courts on whom sentence of death might be imposed, and a miscarriage of justice might occur in many cases if the sentence were carried out. The tribunal that is to try these people in the first instance, is one specially set up for the purpose. The House does not know, and has not the slightest information, as to what the personnel of the tribunal will be except that it will be composed of two military officers and a legal gentleman certified by the Attorney-General. They are nominated by the Executive Council. I think that the highest tribunal in the land, that is, the Executive Council, who nominate this court and who might make a mistake as to the calibre of the men nominated, should be the people to revise the sentences passed in these courts. Had the amendment for setting up the judiciary as the people to try offences of this sort been passed, I would have moved for a judicial court of appeal. At least, I would make that the final court of appeal. As that is not the case, I think the only way to meet this case at present is to have those who nominated the court in the first instance as the persons to revise the sentences, and, if necessary, to mitigate the penalties imposed by that court. We are going through a trying time, not made easier by the introduction of this Bill. It is quite conceivable that there may not be the necessity for this Bill that we are to-day led to believe is the case. But assuming for a moment that there is a necessity and that many people will be brought before these courts, I can foresee a change of attitude, after the softening influences of time, to an atmosphere very different from the atmosphere we are in to-day.
If numbers of men are to be sentenced to death for treason and murder—and there is no question as to what that sentence should be for those offences; it is the same in all countries in the world—I can imagine that time and, possibly, promises of good behaviour in the future, might alter the view of the Executive Council in dealing with these persons. It would be too late for them to change their minds if the sentences had been carried out, as would be the case if there was no court of appeal or any method of revising and possibly mitigating the sentences. I think this is a reasonable amendment, and I would like to see it go through by agreement. I would ask the President to accept the amendment in its present form.
Comment on this
This is an inherent right in the Executive Council. In every case during the last four years in which a sentence of death has been passed, the Executive Council could consider and could mitigate the sentence, and that has been done in several cases. Putting in this amendment does not give the power a second time; it is there already, and it is the duty of the Executive Council, in all these cases in which there is a sentence of death; very carefully to consider them. There has not been any case, as I have said, since July, 1923, or even earlier than that, in which a sentence of death has been passed that the matter has not been considered by the Executive Council, and I think if the Deputy looks at the records he will find quite a number of commutations of sentences since that time.
Comment on this
All that the President has said is no doubt true, but I do not think it entirely affects the desirability of having these words actually in the Bill. It would give the Executive Council no more power, but it would make it plain to those who have to administer the Act. No doubt the person versed in the law might realise the practice of the Executive Council, though I do not think it is a statutory practice. It is a reversion of the power of pardon or commutation originally enjoyed by the Crown, but it is not statutory. The two officers may not know of it, and there is a possibility that a court of this character, sitting in a remote part of the country, might carry out a sentence of death without referring it to the Executive Council. I believe that the officers who will sit in these courts, while they will not acquaint themselves with the whole body of statute law, will acquaint themselves with the Act under which they will be working, and it would be desirable to have words in the Act to make it clear that any sentence should be referred to the Executive Council for revision.
There was, at an earlier stage in the evening, certain competition as to who knew most about courtsmartial. I would say that the President knows them much more intimately, while I know them from another angle. These courts will be in the nature of courtsmartial, but no British courtmartial can carry out a sentence without having that sentence confirmed, and between the pronouncement of the sentence and its confirmation there is a delay, which, in one case at any rate, has been very beneficial to this State. I think that there should be an opportunity for revision. In the British Army Act it is definitely provided that the sentence must be confirmed, and not only that, but it provides, or did provide—I am afraid my edition of it is not very recent—that in the case of a courtmartial pronouncing a sentence in the Dominion of Canada or the Commonwealth of Australia, that sentence must not only be confirmed by the military officer who summoned the court but also by the Governor-General of that Commonwealth or Dominion, and the Governor-General of course would act on the advice of his Ministers. The last Imperial Conference has secured a new status for the Governor-General. That is a statutory provision in the British Army Act. Should we not have in the case of these exceptional courts a similar statutory provision so as to make it clear to every officer who acts in accordance with this measure that the sentence should not be carried out until it has been reviewed by the Executive Council?
The British court-martial can only have one final act. They can acquit, and the purpose of Deputy O'Hanlon's amendment is that sentence should be reviewed by the Executive Council, who have, after all, a fuller knowledge of the general situation of the country than two officers and a lawyer can possibly have. I think that the acceptance of this amendment would remove very many, if not all, of these objections to these courts.
Comment on this
Two points have been urged by Deputy Cooper. One is briefly that no sentence should be carried out until an opportunity for review is given. The President has stated that no sentence will be carried out until the penalty has been reviewed by the Executive Council. The second point is that this should be stated. I think it should not be stated. If it is stated, the entire responsibility is going to be thrown back upon the Executive Council. The whole objection urged in this House about any power being given to the Executive Council is based on the assumption that the Executive Council is mad, is going to do extraordinarily foolish things. Is a court of officers more likely to pass a heavy sentence if it thinks the Executive is behind it to review, than if it believes it has the final say? I suggest it is wrong to put down that the sentence should be subject to confirmation or mitigation by the Executive Council. The Executive Council always has the privilege of exercising the prerogative of mercy. It cannot be changed. That remains unless it is taken out by words in an Act. From the point of view of officers in a court it is better to leave them with the responsibility of believing that they decide the fate of certain people brought before them.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated that most of us who opposed this Bill have considered that the Executive Council are mad. I never intended to refer such a matter as this to people who are mad. It is stated that the prerogative of mercy rests with the Executive Council and remains with them. That is all right dealing with ordinary law, but we are not dealing with ordinary law. This Act is superior to the Constitution, to the ordinary law and the unwritten law, and is superior to custom. What objection can there be to having it put down in black and white in this Act that the sentence is subject to review, to confirmation, if they like, to mitigation if they like? I think in connection with the argument put forward by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that certain people think that the Executive Council are mad, this is the one thing to show that the Executive Council are not mad and are not out to have people sentenced to death by a tribunal which they themselves were responsible for setting up. It shows confidence in your own tribunal.
Comment on this
If you are perfectly confident what objection have you to putting it down in black and white?
Comment on this
If Deputy Cooper looks at the Bill I think he will see all through it that these courts are to carry out the ordinary criminal procedure. Also the Central Criminal Court is referred to again and again. I think he may take it the procedure laid down under Section 25 will be procedure closely modelled on the existing procedure in the Central Criminal Court. What will happen in one of these courts will be that the sentence will be delivered by the trained lawyer who will preside over the court. What happens in murder trials is this. Sentence of death is passed and a date is fixed for the execution, and the date fixed for the execution is about three weeks after the sentence is passed. The death sentence could not be passed by one of these courts and carried out the next day. Who would carry it out? If there is to be an execution it will be an ordinary execution to be carried out by a hangman. The sentence will be that a man is to be hanged by the neck until he is dead, and all the arrangements will have to be made by the Sheriff. That will take three weeks, and you may be perfectly certain that that period must elapse before any death sentence will be carried out.
On the general question it does not seem to me to be of great importance whether this appears or does not, but there can be no doubt that the prerogative does exist, and that sentences can be annulled or lessened or altered. The power existing is inherent. The only objection I see to the insertion of these words in the Bill is, that it might be subsequently argued that because these words are inserted in this Bill it therefore implies that the prerogative is being repealed. Frankly, I do not think that would carry much weight.
Comment on this
I am grateful for the clarification, but it would carry more weight with me if I believed the average military officer is not in the same unfortunate position of ignorance as I am myself as to the procedure of the Central Criminal Court.
Comment on this
There is no such provision in the Bill. The lawyer is a member of the court and can be over-ruled by his two colleagues.
Comment on this
There is a possibility; but there is no statutory stipulation. He might be over-ruled and two military officers ignorant of the procedure which is not specifically stated in the Bill, might take the law into their own hands. They might say we find this man guilty and will have him shot and the sentence might be carried out forthwith.
Comment on this
I would be convinced if the Minister for Industry and Commerce had not replied first. He stated that of course the Executive Council had the prerogative of mercy and the second branch of his argument was that it was undesirable that the officers should know that their judgment could be over-ruled. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney said that there could be no harm in making it clear that the final arbiter was the Executive Council. The only other argument was that perhaps it was an unfair responsibility to impose on the Executive Council. They have shouldered many responsibilities. I do not think they will be unequal to shouldering this one. I do not think the Minister intended to suggest that they could wish to devolve their responsibility on persons learned in the law. I am certain that they are prepared to review those courts and that these words would not weaken the section. In my view it is of considerable importance that officers who are the majority of the court should realise the scope of their position. I urge the acceptance of the amendment.
Comment on this
I want to draw Deputies' attention to sub-section (2), I do not think they appreciate the force of it. In sub-section (3) it is stated that every sentence order and judgment of a special court shall be subject to the same rules as those of the Central Criminal Court. It is even more explicit than Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney explained to us. I think it is a weakness to have the words of the amendment in because it would indicate that there was something missing as compared with the other case covered by the section.
Comment on this
I am not as much disposed, with all respect to my learned colleague, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, to take his view as to what may be intended by this Bill as Deputy Cooper appears to be. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney says that we may take it that the procedure will be the same as in the Central Criminal Court. With all respect to the Deputy I will not take anything that I do not see in this Bill for granted because it is well known, and I am rather surprised that for the second time the suggestion should come from the same quarter to the contrary, that one is not entitled to read things into Bills that are not in the Bills. The Minister, in supporting Deputy Kenney's suggestion, in answer to Deputy Cooper, said there was a likelihood of one legal member being President or Chairman of the Court. Are we legislating for likelihoods or are we legislating for acts that are to take place? I think it is time that this kind of talk about what you may take will be done, and the likelihood of certain contingencies arising, should cease. These are actual matters of life and death because the courts will have the question of conviction on a charge on which conviction would carry sentence of death. Are these matters to be treated as if we may take it something will be done or that there is a likelihood of something else taking place? I am not disposed to take either of the assumptions, whether that of the Minister or that of his supporter, upon these matters, and I think, we should not be satisfied, unless it is put in clear and explicit terms into the Bill, as to what will take place when it becomes an Act. In regard to the particular amendments the Minister has said, very rightly, that the prerogative of mercy rests with the Executive Council. That is so, but with all respect it is quite a different thing from making the operation of the discretion, let me put it, mandatory. I am not suggesting that the Executive Council must exercise the prerogative of mercy. What I am suggesting is that there must be an affirmation of the sentence. It is quite a different thing to say that the Executive Council have an inherent right or power of mercy. It is quite another thing to say that before sentence is carried out that sentence must be concurred in by the Executive Council, and that is, so far as I understand the British military law, the system in vogue there.
As stated by Deputy Cooper, it is not merely a right of revision only that the military have, but there is an actual operation of that power of revision whether by confirmation or by reduction which is performed by the authority there. From what I can gather that seems to be, if I interpret Deputy O'Hanlon's proposal correctly, his idea. Not that there shall be created a right which undoubtedly does exist, but that this right shall be used as a power of revision, and that no sentence shall be carried out unless it has been confirmed by the Executive Council. That is what I think to be the real usefulness and the purpose of the amendment, and in pressing this, which is confined to the death sentence, the Deputy has suggested some means whereby there shall, of necessity, be given to a body other than the actual court which convicted the power of revision which as far as I understand this amendment should in every case be exercised.
Comment on this
Deputy Redmond has apparently thought hard but I cannot say that he has thought lucidly in connection with Section 24 and the incidental matter in Section 22. I spoke of the likelihood of the legal member either presiding over or exercising at least a presiding influence over the other two members of the Board, and the Deputy, in a profound way, asked us not to read into the Bill more than was actually there, and in the same profound way he himself reads into the Bill more than is there. It is not stated that one of the non-legal members shall preside. Why read it into the Bill? He said that I read into the Bill that the legal member was to preside.
Comment on this
No, but neither is the Deputy right in making the assumption that one of the non-legal members shall preside.
Comment on this
It is very hard if the Deputy, when making his own speech, cannot make himself clear, but when he comes to try to make me clear——
Comment on this
I must not allow the Minister to misinterpret me. I never said I assumed that the non-legal member of the court was going to preside. I made no assumption. It is not provided in the Bill who shall preside, but the Minister did make the assumption that a certain person shall preside.
Comment on this
I said nothing of the sort. I said in the case of three people thrown together, two of them not necessarily being certified as having legal knowledge and the other having a certificate from the Attorney-General, there is the likelihood of certain things happening. I said nothing further than that. The Deputy proceeded to argue on the basis of what was going to happen. I leave the matter to the House to judge between us. We come now to the further point of confirmation. The Deputy has for the seventh or eighth time brought in what happens under British military law. We are not dealing with British military or Irish military law.
Comment on this
We are dealing with the law laid down in this section which is going to be the law quite soon. If the Deputy wants Irish military law we can give it to him, and that provides for confirmation. It seems he is ignorant of the fact that there is Irish military law. The Deputy is a practising barrister and would be certified by the Attorney-General as having legal knowledge; but he does not know that. Why bring in all this talk about English military law? If Deputy O'Hanlon is going to press this amendment I suggest that he should make a change if he accepts Deputy Redmond's argument. Deputy Redmond thinks some court other than the court that passes sentence should have the right of confirmation, but apparently he does not make the distinction that some body other than the confirming body should have the right of confirming the sentence thereafter. Is it reasonable to ask the same body to confirm a sentence and to exercise the prerogative of mercy? If we are to have both to do the same thing and if that body is the Executive Council, it seems to me that at this hour, ten minutes to one in the morning, wisdom has struck some people rather late. Is it suggested that the Executive Council should be the body to confirm a sentence passed by a tribunal of its own creation, and should thereafter sit down as the same Executive Council to exercise the prerogative of mercy? Does Deputy Cooper not consider that a body of officers set up as a tribunal to adjudicate on matters of life and death, are going to be made shoulder their responsibilities better by having it declared to them that they are really the last thing in the way of saying that is the sentence for the offence, and leaving it in the ordinary way to come before the Executive Council. If anyone says that the prerogative of mercy is affected by this Act then a new situation has arisen, and we can have that examined, but no one suggests that anything takes away the prerogative of mercy from the Executive Council even for special courts. If Deputy O'Hanlon sees any virtue in putting in such words into a statute, I ask him to consider the advisability of getting some confirming authority other than the body that is to proceed thereafter to mitigate the sentences. Sub-section (6) deals with certain consequences that will follow upon the judgment of the special court similarly to those that will follow upon the judgment of the Central Criminal Court. It is one of the ordinary pitfalls of law, that where you put in a seemingly innocent statement it may have consequences far beyond what you intend. I put it to the Deputy if he agrees that the prerogative of mercy is not defeated by anything in the Bill, it adds nothing with regard to mitigation, though it might add something by way of confirmation. Is there any virtue in having the Executive Council to decide, when the same Executive Council must proceed, not to confirm the sentence or not to refuse confirmation, but to mitigate it to nothing? Does the Deputy gain anything by that? Will he admit that there may be some consequence beyond what he thinks may follow from the insertion of this phrase? If he is determined to press this matter he must consider a confirming authority of a different type from the Executive Council. Is the Executive Council going to appoint a special tribunal to try people, and immediately afterwards going to proceed to mitigate the sentence?
Comment on this
If I were satisfied that this question of the prerogative of mercy were in the Bill, written or unwritten, I would agree that the word "mitigate" should be taken out of my amendment but I would not agree to withdrawing the word "confirmation." This Act when passed will stand upon its own legs, independent of other statutes passed in this country, or in any other. It stands independent of custom and law and I cannot see, for the life of me, what objection there can be to agreeing to this confirmation or mitigation of the sentences passed by these courts. Offenders brought before these courts may get a hasty trial. In fact I think it was mentioned that these things were done quickly. They may get a hasty trial, and a hasty sentence and they may get a hasty execution. It is to avoid these things that I have brought forward this amendment. Nothing was more foreign to my mind than to place more responsibility upon the shoulders of the Executive Council. I go further and say that the object of putting in this amendment is to relieve the Executive Council from some of the odium that this Bill has incurred already and to give them power afterwards in calmer moments to revise what it has done. There will not be merely one tribunal, there will be many of them up and down the country. There may be many men sentenced to death by them and I believe that the Executive Council would be very glad to have the power of mitigating such sentences if they were passed.
I hope that if such a thing does happen no man will be sentenced under it. I believe too that the Executive Council would mitigate the sentence. Deputy Thrift has raised a point about sub-section (3). Sub-section (3) does not meet my case at all. If you read down sub-section (5) that does not follow the procedure of the Central Criminal Court. There is an appeal from the Central Criminal Court. Here it distinctly specifies that there is no appeal. We have dealt with boys up to 16 years of age, but boys of 16½ years of age may come under these courts and be executed. Why? Because some older people may put guns into their hands and tell them to shoot somebody. I say if a case of that sort is not a proper one to bring before the Executive Council for confirmation or mitigation of sentence then I do not know what justice is. I cannot retreat from this amendment and must put it to a division.
Comment on this
Might I find out what there is in dispute between Deputy O'Hanlon and the Executive Council in this matter? The Deputy says if he could be convinced that the prerogative of mercy still existed the question of mitigation might be left out. How am I to convince the Deputy? I have asked for evidence to the contrary that anything that takes away the prerogative of mercy should be shown, but nobody has attempted to show it. We can, at any rate, leave it until we get some information going to show that the prerogative of mercy has disappeared in some way under the provisions of this section. As regards confirmation, we could consider the question of confirmation not by the Executive Council but by somebody else. As long as the Executive Council has the prerogative of mercy, and I hold it still has it, the matter of confirmation and mitigation should not be with the same people. I can promise the Deputy to have that matter considered between this and the Report Stage. That is, the question of some confirming authority, but that confirming authority not to be the Executive Council.
Comment on this
May I put it to the Minister as briefly as possible that in the case of a civil trial there are two safeguards. There is the possibility of an appeal, and then there is the prerogative of mercy. In the case of a trial by a military court, whether English or Irish, there are two safeguards: there is the necessary confirmation, and then there is still the prerogative of mercy. In this case there is only at present the prerogative of mercy. If the Minister could find a way out I do not think Deputy O'Hanlon would insist on the Executive Council being the authority. If the Minister provide some other confirming authority, so that a person tried by these special courts should be in no worse position than a man tried by a criminal or civil court, we should be satisfied.
Comment on this
Then it is definitely understood that the House must be convinced that the prerogative of mercy rests with the Executive Council in this matter.
Comment on this
Could the Minister say if a sentence of death is carried out under warrant of the Executive?
Comment on this
Sentences of death always come before the Executive Council. On the question of the confirming authority I undertake to get some thing before the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment 54 in sub-section (4), line 7, "to delete the words `save as is hereinafter provided,' " and amendment 55, to delete sub-section (5). Then sub-section 4 would read:—"Every conviction, sentence, order and judgment of a special court shall have the like consequences in law as a like conviction, sentence, order and judgment of the Central Criminal Court would have," and so on. The object in moving to delete these words is that there shall be an appeal from this court as there is from the Central Criminal Court, and in conjunction I am moving to delete sub-section (5). The result of the two amendments would be that there would be an appeal from this special court as there is from the Central Criminal Court. Of course, I put down these amendments at the same time as I put down the amendment which has been defeated, providing that the court should consist of judges, not of military officers. The position now is somewhat altered. At the same time, having the assurance of the Minister that on the Report Stage he will endeavour to provide some form of confirmation by another court or another body in the case of sentence of death, I am not moving these amendments so much in regard to that as in regard to the various other offences, the charges for which will be tried before this court and the sentences passed.
The offences have already been alluded to. They are offences, including misdemeanours, and various penalties attach to them throughout this Bill. There should be, in my view, some form of appeal, review, remission or confirmation of these sentences, just as has been suggested in regard to the sentence of death. In fact I would go further and say in regard to the sentences for these minor offences there should be some form of appeal. If these words are omitted there would be the form of appeal which is permitted from the Central Criminal Court, and that is not altogether a very wide form of appeal. There have to be special grounds and leave has to be granted for that appeal, and the Court of Appeal has to be satisfied that the grounds are justifiable before they grant leave to appeal. It is not altogether the same form of appeal as there would be from a lower court. Therefore, I do not think it would be a very great stretch of leniency to ask for this particular form of appeal in regard to these particular offences. Of course, there are two distinct forms of offence, one carrying the death penalty and the other not. I would like to hear what the Minister has to say in regard to these two classes and whether he would consider the wisdom and advisability of having some form of appeal such as I have suggested, especially in regard to the minor offences.
Comment on this
I did not think after the undertaking given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that Deputy Redmond would have moved these two amendments. I am not disposed to agree to them.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the President was here, but the assurance given by the Minister only dealt with the death sentence, and did not deal with any of the other offences.
Comment on this
The promise of some amendment to meet Deputy O'Hanlon under the previous amendment is, in effect, a promise to consider whether anything less than a death sentence should follow a verdict of guilty in respect of treason or murder. The proposition here, as I understand it, is really a different one. It is not merely to say whether a sentence of death should inevitably follow a verdict of guilty in a treason case or a murder case, but as to whether the circumstances surrounding a less heinous offence than treason or murder would warrant the sentence that is being imposed by the special court. Surely there is more reason for appeal from the military court in such a case. If the special court is qualified to decide a question of fact as to murder or treason, then the question of penalty is a very different one from these other cases. There are maximum penalties in the other cases, and a discretion is left to the court, and presumably they will take into account the circumstances surrounding the guilt. If there is that discretion in the less heinous offences than murder or treason, surely there is all the more reason why there should be an appeal from such a court where they have perchance inflicted the maximum penalty. If the court is competent to deal with the question of fact in relation to the capital offences, then the criminal law is altered completely if there is an appeal court. No doubt, as has been pointed out, the prerogative of mercy remains. But here you have an entirely different set of circumstances.
The penalty ranges from anything from one week up to death in the case of firearms. Anything from one week up to death is a discretion. Surely there is a case where some discretion might be allowed, or some court of appeal. A less sentence than death might be inflicted by the court. Twenty years' penal servitude might be inflicted. The circumstances should be reviewable by some authority above this court as to whether a sentence of 20 years is war ranted. Quite apart from the question of carrying firearms, in regard to which I am quite willing to admit the case that is made, that in these circumstances it is equivalent to an attempt at murder or practically to murder, there are very many much less serious offences. A person who is found guilty of being a member of an unlawful association is liable to five years' penal servitude. That is a case, surely, where there ought to be a higher tribunal to decide whether the circumstances justify the five years' sentence or not. I think the promise that was made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in respect to death sentences has no relation at all to the proposal in the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not know if I understood Deputy Redmond aright. I gathered from him that in the matter of confirmation and mitigation, in the sense that the prerogative of mercy would apply to a sentence other than death, he would not be disposed to press this matter of an appeal. If that is so, the undertaking that I gave already with regard to the confirming authority can be made to apply to all sentences passed by special courts.
Comment on this
I must admit that these are now courts composed of military officers. They are not in any sense ordinary courts, they are not even civilian courts and I would be disposed still to suggest that there should be an actual appeal from these courts, especially in view of the wording of sub-section (4), which would tend to suggest, were it not for these words "save as hereinafter provided," that the whole law in regard to the sentences of these courts should be the same as in regard to the Central Criminal Court. We had it quite recently from Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney—he informed us very gratuitously and kindly—that we might take it that the procedure and practice were to be the same as in the Central Criminal Court. Is it too much to suggest that there might be a similar appeal? The Minister has, I think, said that he would propose that there would be set up some body other than the Executive Council which would have the power of confirmation and mitigation.
Comment on this
Rather it would have the power of confirmation without mitigation. Certainly that is some advance on the position as it is in the Bill, and I suppose I should be grateful for small mercies. But it does not go quite as far as I should desire. However, in the circumstances, I think that the best thing for me to do is to hold over these amendments until the Report Stage and then I would be able to judge the nature of the Minister's proposal.
Comment on this
Before passing I would like to ask Deputy Redmond or any other Deputy who could help whether this proposed power of confirmation which is probably taken from the parallel case of a court-martial means anything more than confirming. Supposing the higher authority does not confirm, what is the effect? I think I have heard it stated that the effect of a refusal to confirm is "not guilty." I am not sure whether that is correct or not but I do not think it is right to say if the higher authority does not confirm it may mitigate. That presumably is intended to be a matter for another authority or the Executive Council in this case. Am I to understand then that the procedure would be if the higher authority is not prepared to confirm, that the case will not go back to the original court, but that the authority's comments would appear before the Executive Council and be taken into account when the question of mitigation arises. I do not understand exactly what is to happen if the sentence is not confirmed.
Comment on this
The proposition would be that no conviction or sentence by a special court would be valid save in so far as confirmed.
Comment on this
The two Deputies who have spoken on these amendments have stressed the point of review of sentence. I should like to call attention to the other point of review of conviction, which is a very different thing. The power of that review would be completely taken away by this section. Of the two reviews it seems to me that the review of conviction is a far more important one because the question of innocence is involved. Surely the question of the review of sentence which is a matter of degree of guilt is of less importance than the question of the possibility of conviction of the innocent. Sub-section (5) would completely take away that possibility of review and for that reason if Deputy Redmond sees his way to withdraw the amendment which stands in our two names I do not think that I can follow him.
Comment on this
On a point of order, was my amendment put or is the question only on the section? I made it clear that I could not withdraw my amendment. Was the amendment skipped and was the question only put upon the section?
Comment on this
We are now dividing on the question: "That Section 25 stand part of the Bill."
Comment on this
We cannot have any discussion now.
Comment on this
What are we to do about the amendment before the House? I think you will have to review the whole position.
Comment on this
This amendment is an alternative to Section 26, and we will get a decision by putting the section. The question is now: "That Section 26 stand part of the Bill."
Comment on this
Evidently I anticipated my friend Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney when I framed this amendment, because, as he stated, we might take it that the procedure will be the same as in the Central Criminal Court. I wanted to put that beyond question by having it in the Bill and I hope therefore that there would be no necessity for a division upon this amendment, as perhaps I may now assume that he was voicing the opinions of his Party when he asked me to take it that the procedure and practice of the special courts would be the same as the procedure and practice in the Central Criminal Court.
Comment on this
Amendment 56 is an alternative to Section 26. If the amendment were carried the section could not be put because the decision would have been taken against the section. A decision could be taken as well on the motion that Section 26 stand part of the Bill. If the section stands the amendment falls.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not seem to appreciate the fact that the special courts will have no juries; or perhaps he is aware of that fact. The procedure and practice in the Central Criminal Court is based entirely on the fact that it is a jury court.
Comment on this
This only goes to show what little credence one can place in statements made by Deputies, even when they are supporters of the Government. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney said: "The House may take it that the procedure will be the same as in the Central Criminal Court."
Comment on this
I am proposing that the procedure and practice should be the same. I quite follow, of course, what the President says with regard to juries.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was perfectly correct. It is based on the same procedure, and so far as there is a difference between the courts that is where the difference is.
Comment on this
This section proposes that an Executive Minister shall make regulations. Can the President give us an assurance that the regulations that will be made will be based upon the regulations in the Central Criminal Court?
Comment on this
I hope I did not speak so absurdly as Deputy Redmond suggested I did. My intention was to convey to the House that the procedure would be analogous to the procedure in the Central Criminal Court as far as it could be. In the Central Criminal Court a Judge presides and there is a jury. I never suggested that if a court were set up, composed of two military officers and a third person learned in the law, that they would be a judge and jury.
Comment on this
Obviously the best procedure in this case is to take a vote on the section, because the section is what is in the Bill, and the amendment proposes a completely different thing. If the section stands the amendment falls. I am proposing to put the section, then.
Comment on this
I want to suggest to the Minister that there is an omission from the Schedule that might be rectified. Members of the Oireachtas and members of the Judiciary are protected. Is it not also necessary to protect the Attorney-General and the Chief State Solicitor? I do not want to delay the Dáil. I merely suggest to the President that these persons are essential in the proper administration of justice and I think may require the same protection as is given to members of the Judiciary.
Comment on this
I wish to thank Deputy Cooper for reminding me of that. It was my original intention to have included the name of the Attorney-General in the list.
Comment on this
Question—"That Section 22, as amended, stand part of the Bill"— put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move that the Report Stage of the Public Safety Bill be taken this morning at 11 o'clock.
Comment on this
I move as an amendment to that that the Report Stage be taken on Tuesday next. The Bill has been considered with a certain amount of care in Committee, and Ministers have promised certain amendments. The amendments, no doubt, will be prepared and distributed to Deputies in due time for them to consider the new Bill as amended, or as it will be amended when the Committee Stage amendments have been inserted, and it is requested that there should be time to consider the new Bill. I do not think that it can be considered between now and the sitting that is to follow. I understand that it is a desire on the part of certain Deputies to have a free day to-morrow.
Comment on this
I have heard it said that certain Deputies want to go to the Horse Show, and in that case I think the House should allow Deputies who desire that relaxation to go to the Horse Show. I, therefore, move as an amendment to the proposition, that the Report Stage be taken on Tuesday.
Comment on this
On that amendment I would like to know when it would be possible to accept amendments to the Report Stage. I have one which I would like to put in.
Comment on this
I think it is unreasonable to expect Deputies to have amendments prepared and put in to-day. This is an attempt to stampede Deputies into allowing this Bill to go through without amendment.
Comment on this
I support the amendment principally because of a good deal of abuse which I have got from a good many members on the opposite benches owing to keeping them from the Horse Show. On Friday last it was a painful duty to be acting as teller. The Deputies were passing out to the barriers and were telling us that they could not get their lunch because divisions were so frequent.
Comment on this
I do not dispute that. This is a very serious measure, and I think it should be treated seriously.
Comment on this
It has not been treated seriously when it is suggested at ten minutes past two that the Report Stage should be taken at 11 o'clock. Deputy Gorey has very little interest in his Bill. He has not read the Bill. He does not propose to amend it. There are other members who may desire to put amendments to it.
Comment on this
That is the Minister's point of view. Members of this House have certain rights as well as duties and responsibilities, and if they think it is desirable to move certain amendments on the Report Stage of the measure they are entitled to do so, and entitled to get time in which to consider the amendments. I suggest it is most unreasonable that we should be expected to take the Report Stage of this measure at 11 o'clock. It seems to me to be holding up the big stick to members of the House. You have either to give this Bill a free passage, to refrain from criticising the Bill, from making amendments or challenging divisions, or else we will insist on your sitting continually until the Bill passes. That is the choice we have got from the opposite benches. I do not care if you sit all night to-morrow night again, and the night after, but I do not think we ought to approach the measure in that spirit. We ought to realise the seriousness of it, and give members opportunities to put down amendments. I suggest if Deputies want to move amendments, and are told by the President "you have got to get them in now," that is not dealing with the matter seriously. I think the amendment moved by Deputy Johnson is a very reasonable one, as I think the motion made by the President is an unreasonable one.
Comment on this
I rise to support the amendment of Deputy Johnson, and in doing so I would like to give time to the promoters of the Bill to explain to us why they are proposing to put the Safety Bill through at this Stage. I should like to know whether it is the state of Ireland that we have all visualised. Is it the State of Collins and Griffith, or is it the State of Birkenhead? I think they would want longer than eleven o'clock to-day to explain it. I suggest that they defer the taking of this Bill until next Tuesday.
Comment on this
I am putting the President's motion—in other words, the question that the words proposed to be deleted stand.