FINANCE BILL, 1928—THIRD STAGE.
Contributions 1–144 of 277. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 14 of 1928 ›
I move Section 1. This is the section which fixes the rate of income tax and the rate of super-tax.
Comment on this
There are two amendments down to this section dealing with practically the same thing. The first amendment is in my name and the other in the name of Deputy MacEntee. Deputy MacEntee's amendment, if passed, would not cost as much as mine, but it would satisfy me. If Deputy MacEntee's amendment is moved I am prepared to withdraw mine and support his.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell's amendment is the wider, and that is why it comes first. It proposes to make the greater change.
Amendment 1:—Before sub-section (2) to insert a new section as follows:—
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy MacEntee I move amendment 2:—
To insert before sub-section (2) a new sub-section as follows:—
Section 16 of the Finance Act, 1920, is hereby amended by the deletion of the words "equal to one-tenth of the amount of that income" and the substitution therefor of the following:—
(a) in respect of an income of less than £400, equal to one-sixth of the amount of that income; and
(b) in respect of an income in excess of four hundred pounds, £66 13s. 4d., together with a sum equal to one-tenth of the amount of that income in excess of four hundred pounds.
Comment on this
I rise to support this amendment. It will be seen the amendment proposes to give a greater proportion of relief than is given at present in the case of small earned incomes. In this case the limit to which the one-sixth relief would apply is put at £400, and above that figure there is lesser relief given. In Northern Ireland and Great Britain, for the past two or three years, the amount of relief given is one-sixth up to a higher limit than is indicated here. I think we have the Minister's own statement, made two or three years ago, that even one-tenth was not a sufficient distinction to make as between earned and unearned incomes. A case has been made so often for this that there is hardly any necessity to go into it at any great length. I have taken this proposal of Deputy MacEntee's in preference to my own because it is not so wide, and therefore would not cost so much from the revenue point of view if it were agreed upon. I trust the Minister will see his way to grant this concession that has been pressed upon him from various parts of the House for a great many years.
Comment on this
I am unable to accept this amendment because of the cost that would be involved. I have had an estimate prepared of the amount of revenue that would be lost if this amendment were accepted. The amount is about £100,000. The Deputy is quite correct in saying that this matter has been the subject of discussion in this House on former occasions. He is also correct in saying that I have admitted that there is a good deal of force in the arguments that have been used. But there is another side to the case. We cannot give reliefs on the scale that can be given in Great Britain without losing a much greater proportion of our revenue. Reliefs which, in the British case, might perhaps cost one-tenth of the revenue would be likely in our case to cost say one-fourth of the revenue. A much greater proportion of British income tax is obtained from people with very large incomes than is the case here, and consequently exemptions of this character do not affect the total revenue to the same extent.
I cannot see that we will necessarily be able to follow the British precedent in the matter of reliefs because of the conditions being different. I do admit, however, that we must take note of what is done in countries that are close to us and in countries with which many people in this State have a great many relations. Consequently, I admit that our attitude cannot remain unaffected by reliefs that are given in Great Britain. As these particular classes of reliefs for the small taxpayers, either by way of exemption of portion of earned incomes or of allowances for children, have been increased in Great Britain, I do feel that we have reached the position where, to some extent at any rate, we must follow suit. If we are to follow suit without increasing the rate, we can only do it by a reconsideration of our whole scheme of allowances. At present allowances in respect of children and in respect of earned income are given to the very rich as well as to the very poor. Even this proposal, moved on behalf of Deputy MacEntee, will give a greater relief to the rich man than to the poor man. A man with say £400 per annum would get about £2 per annum relief if this amendment were passed. A wealthier man would get double that.
It seems to me that if we are to aim at giving greater reliefs to the poorer taxpayers we must examine the whole system. I see no reason why, in the case of a man with one, two, three or four thousand pounds a year, 25 per cent. of his income should necessarily be at half rate. It is half rate at present. That is because there is uniformity throughout, and all reliefs are given to the rich taxpayer as well as to the poor taxpayer. If we are to give additional reliefs to the poor taxpayers I feel that we must examine the whole system and I would propose to have a departmental examination carried out and to have a scheme for the re-casting of reliefs prepared that would enable us to give concessions to the poorer taxpayer either by way of exemption of a greater proportion of earned income or of greater allowances in respect to children. But that is a matter which presents a good deal of difficulty and great care would have to be taken in the drawing up of such a scheme to see that it did not involve injustice and that it did not make the lot of certain classes of taxpayers worse than it is at present. It is not a matter that can be done now.
I feel unable to accept this amendment now. If the amendment were passed, there would be, as I have stated, a loss of revenue to the extent of about £100,000 a year, and that loss would have to be made up. It could not be made up at this juncture by a re-casting of the system of reliefs because that would take too long. It could only be made up by some fresh imposition of taxation. I am not able to say at the moment what amount could be obtained by a recasting of relief, but it is quite clear that by going over the whole system a substantial amount could be obtained that could be devoted to the relief of the smaller taxpayers, I would propose a scheme prepared along these lines recognising the increase of these reliefs in England, and the feelings of the people in regard to them make it necessary for us to go some distance in that direction. However, it is impossible at the present stage to accept an amendment of this kind unless we went out for an increased rate, or the imposition of a new tax to make up the amount of revenue that would be lost.
Comment on this
Is it not strange that the Minister has not already held an inquiry of the type indicated? With the experts at his disposal, an investigation such as is necessary for overhauling the reliefs would not take the long time he seems to think. It would be possible surely to get work of that particular character done in a fortnight or three weeks at most. As this burden is to press on the taxpayers for a year I think the Minister, if he is to have a re-casting of the whole question of reliefs, ought to be prepared to set up an inquiry at once so that the taxpayers this year would have the benefit of it.
Comment on this
It would be impossible. At this stage if we were to make substantial changes of the character indicated it would interfere with our collection. Preparation has to be made in advance for things of this character, and with any attempt to rush them through, while theoretically you might concoct a scheme it might have faults, or you might succeed in getting it through without faults, but the passage of it and the disturbance it would cause in the case of nearly every taxpayer would involve delays in the collection of taxes which would mean that our collection would be substantially short for the year.
Comment on this
Does not that mean that practically all the amendments are ruled out? There would be the same difficulty in respect of any one of them if passed, so that we might as well not consider them at all.
Comment on this
Any amendment which involves a substantial loss of revenue is impossible of adoption at this stage unless we are prepared to find the revenue that would be lost by some other means. In my Budget proposals I provided for the collection by means of an extra staff, and other methods, of £250,000 more than the Revenue Commissioners had estimated as the amount that would be obtained. If I had not devised a scheme to obtain that amount of money it would have been necessary to impose taxation to obtain it in some other way. If we are to make changes in regard to income tax by relief at this stage—which means a reduction of this year's collection—we must, in order to keep ourselves right and face to face with people from whom we would be borrowing money, take some other means of replenishing the Exchequer to the extent it would be cut short by any steps now taken.
Comment on this
The purpose of the amendment is to call attention to the very serious discrepancy in the amount of the income tax as between unearned and earned incomes by the smaller income taxpayer. The rate of income tax here is 3s. in the £ and in Great Britain it is 4s., but in actual fact the possessor of earned income which does not exceed something in the nature of £380,000 in the Free State pays rather more in the way of income tax than in Great Britain. That only applies to earned income. With respect to unearned income the taxpayer here has undoubtedly a very great advantage. A married man, who has no allowances in respect of children, here on an income of £300 a year has to pay £3 7s. 6d., but a man with a similar income and in the same circumstances in England would only pay £2 10s. If a man had an unearned income and were living at his leisure and drawing his income from investments, he would pay £11 5s. here as against £15 on the same income in Great Britain. I think that is a very serious injustice. I believe—though I have not been able to secure the necessary data to make any sort of exact calculation, because although I put down a question intended to secure these figures the Revenue Department or the Ministry of Finance were not able to furnish me with them—that the remission asked for in this case will not cost anything like £100,000 a year. First of all, I have looked at the allowances which are granted in respect of earned income, and I find they amount approximately to only one-seventeenth of the total income payable, and at the same time they represent approximately one-tenth of the income which is earned income. I have not been able to make an exact calculation, but assuming that everybody would secure the maximum remission of tax under this amendment, I believe that the number of taxpayers in respect of whom it would be claimed would not exceed more than 30,000, so that at the very outside the amendment, I think, would not cost more than £60,000. On the other hand, you have a considerable number of taxpayers whose incomes range between £250 and £400 a year, and the amount of allowances in respect of them would be something in the neighbourhood of 30s. per taxpayer. I believe that by far the greater proportion of income tax is paid by people whose incomes lie between the range of £250 to £450. The maximum amount which can be claimed in respect of any income, as I said before, would not be more than £2 per head as regards the greater number of income taxpayers, under this amendment.
Comment on this
Applied only to earned incomes. Remember, I am leaving out for the moment the inconsiderable number of people who do not have to pay over the 1/6 rate, and taking into consideration the fact, as I have said, that by far the greater number of income taxpayers have incomes not exceeding £400, the total cost of this amendment, if accepted, would be something in the neighbourhood of £45,000. The Minister may not see his way to accept an amendment which would cost that amount at this stage. There is another aspect of the question, and if he considers it he might see his way to do something and that is: The present condition of affairs presses most heavily on the married people. In the case of single people I admit the hardship is not so great. If the Minister would see his way to accept this amendment in respect of married incomes only, that I think, would reduce the actual cost to something like £30,000. If, of course, he cannot see his way to meet us, we will regret it, but if he gives a promise that he will endeavour, as already suggested, to set up a Departmental Committee and to have recommendations for next year's Budget considered and if he would have considered the whole question of allowances, accepting the principle that greater relief should be given to men with smaller incomes than is given under the present scale, I do not think that we would press the matter to a division.
Comment on this
There is just one preliminary point. I think the Deputy is making a mistake when he says that only relief to the extent of £2 is received by any taxpayer.
Comment on this
But there would be a substantial number who would receive relief at the full rate and would be relieved to the extent of £4. There is that difficulty in the amendment and in practically all the amendments put down on the Order Paper, namely, that while they give relief to smaller taxpayers they give greater relief—in some cases double, and in others more than double—to the well-off taxpayers. I can only promise that I will at once set some of the officials of the Department to work on the re-casting of the schemes of relief so as to let the reliefs fall entirely, or almost entirely, on the poorer taxpayers so as to be able, at any rate, to go a considerable distance towards putting our reliefs towards smaller taxpayers in line with those given in an adjacent country.
Comment on this
I can quite see the Minister's difficulty. It is something, however, to have brought him even so far after five years of agitation of one kind or another. Do I take it that his statement covers the second amendment in regard to children?
Comment on this
In regard to amendment 5, I think the matter could be dealt with this year. Am I now to take it that amendments 3 and 4 are not moved?
Comment on this
I presume that the situation now is that amendment 1 was not moved and that leave was asked to withdraw No. 2. Amendments 3 and 4 will, presumably, not arise.
Comment on this
I am afraid that amendment 4 is not in order, and I would be prepared to argue a point of order on it.
Comment on this
Very good. Then amendment 2 is withdrawn, and we will leave the point in regard to amendment 5 to be raised when we come to it.
Comment on this
Amendments 3 and 4 both raise the question of relief for children. Amendment 3 is the wider amendment and will therefore be taken first. In regard to paragraph (b) of amendment 4, there is a point of order to be raised.
Comment on this
In regard to amendment 4, I take it from the Minister's statement in connection with amendment 2, that this is one of the things which he will include in his inquiry. I understood him to say that the question of giving greater relief in the case of children is to be included. If that is the case, I take it that the position in regard to this amendment is the same as that in regard to amendment 2. If I get a definite promise that the Minister will include in the inquiry the question of giving more substantial relief than is given in the case of lower incomes, I am satisfied.
Comment on this
I indicated that that and the question of earned income will be discussed by the inquiry.
Comment on this
When will we have an opportunity of discussing these proposals? I am not in entire sympathy with what the Minister said on the question of earned income. There is a good deal more behind this proposal than possibly appears on the surface. I am not going to discuss it now, but I would like to have an opportunity of doing so if any drastic action is proposed to be taken. I am in entire sympathy with the other suggestion, but on this one I would like to see more clearly before agreeing to it.
Comment on this
I do not know if it would be possible to find an opportunity of discussing it before the Budget. It probably would be, and, in any event, towards the end of the autumn, if the Deputy would inquire, I could have a scheme ready and could see whether there was any way of discussing it in advance.
Comment on this
The Minister sees the difficulty. If he bases his Budget on the altered proposal in regard to earned income tax and, if we discuss it later, we will be told that it will upset the basis of the Budget. Therefore, we will be precluded from discussing it, as Deputy de Valera was to-day.
Comment on this
A discussion without a decision could be arranged, as it was arranged yesterday evening in connection with the tariff on flour, whenever the Minister is prepared to say that his investigations have had some definite results.
Amendment 3.—Before sub-section (2) to insert a new section as follows:—
"Section 21 of the Finance Act, 1920, is hereby amended by the substitution of sixty pounds for thirty-six pounds and of fifty pounds for twenty-seven pounds as the deductions in respect of children."—(Not moved.)
Comment on this
I move:—
To insert before sub-section (2) a new sub-section as follows:—
Section 21 of the Finance Act, 1920, is hereby amended by the deletion of the words "in respect of one child to a deduction of £36, and in respect of each subsequent child to a deduction of £27," and the substitution therefor of the following:—
"(a) In respect of an income of not more than £400 to a deduction in respect of one child of £50, and in respect of each subsequent child to a deduction of £40, which deductions are referred to hereinafter as the basic allowances; and
(b) in respect of an income of more than £400, to proportionate deductions in respect of one child and each subsequent child, which proportionate deductions shall in each case be equal to the basic allowance or allowances, less a pro rata reduction or reductions therein of twenty per cent. of income in excess of £400."
Comment on this
This proposes a graduated scale of allowances. Where the income does not exceed £400 the allowance would be £50; where it does not exceed £500 it would be £40; where it does not exceed £600 the amount would be £30; where it does not exceed £700 the amount would be £20; and where it does not exceed £800 the amount would be £10. If that is the effect, then the amendment would mean that people in receipt of incomes of, say, £600 and upwards would get less relief than they are at present entitled to. Consequently, the amendment is a proposal to increase the charges so far as certain people are concerned and is, therefore, out of order.
Comment on this
Could it be held to contravene Standing Orders if it was intended to restrict allowances and not to impose a charge?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy prepared to agree with the Minister's interpretation as to the meaning of paragraph (b)?
Comment on this
Perhaps I would be permitted to explain the effect of the amendment before agreeing to the Minister's proposition. The amendment was devised to meet a well-founded objection to any flat rate relief in respect of children or earned income which undoubtedly benefits the richer income taxpayer as against the poorer. Under the amendment the effect would be as the Minister has stated, but we feel that it is a desirable principle to introduce into income tax law because, as it is at present, an income taxpayer with an income of £300 and with one child would receive a remission in respect of that child of £2 14s. If he were fortunate enough to enjoy an income of £900 he would receive in respect of one child a remission of £5 8s. That is not a just basis of taxation. Under the amendment an income taxpayer with an income of £310 would receive a remission of £4 in respect of one child. If his income were £500 the remission would be reduced to £3. If his income were £800 the remission will be reduced to £1 10s., and if his income were £900 he would receive no allowance. I need only submit, in answer to the Minister's point of order, as I said before, that this may be held to impose a charge, but it is rather a removal of a privilege or allowance. In view of that, I feel that the Dáil would be in order in considering the amendment now before it.
Comment on this
After I have made my statement I will leave it for you to judge, sir. The principle that is sought to be established—as a matter of fact it is not a principle, because it is in every Act—seems to be that a greater amount should be allowed for the first child and a lesser amount for every additional child. I would like to point out to the Minister that it should be the other way round, that there should be a certain amount for the first child and an increasing amount for every other child.
Comment on this
The amendment is really in two parts, part (a) and part (b). Part (a) is, in effect, the same as Deputy O'Connell's amendment, No. 3, except that instead of £60 it substitutes £50, and for £50 in respect of every child after the first it substitutes £40. In regard to the second part of the amendment, it is, I think, now admitted that it would have the effect of increasing the income tax which would be payable by certain persons. That, I think, is imposing a charge. The Deputy is quite in order in moving for any relief in taxation, but the part of the amendment which finds money for the Minister by increasing the charge on other taxpayers is out of order. The point is, perhaps, rather a fine point here, but if it were extended in any way I think it would be quite clear that it would strike at the root of the whole principle by which only the Minister can move for the imposition or increase of a charge. The Deputy's amendment, to be in order, should be to the effect that "Section 21 of the Finance Act of 1921 is hereby amended by substituting £50 for £36 and £40 for £37." I think that is the form in which it should be proposed, because to remove the distinction between people under £400 and over £400, as proposed, is out of order.
Comment on this
We may take it then that for the moment point (b) has to be withdrawn as out of order, and we find the Minister in the embarrassing position of possessing more money than he otherwise would have. We might be allowed to relieve any anxiety he has on his mind by suggesting that when he comes to consider an amendment, and when he decides to put down an amendment for the purpose of dealing with this matter, an amendment framed somewhat like the amendment that is now withdrawn might fulfil the point. When the Minister comes to consider something to substitute for the whole of Section 4 he might consider doing what Deputy MacEntee is not in order in proposing. Having envisaged that possibility, and now envisaging the whole of Section 4 as if he had proposed it, which would have been in order, he might be able to indicate that the principle of that amendment would be one which he would be prepared to consider—that is to say, increasing the reliefs to what I would call the hardship limits. Income tax on a man with a salary of up to £400 is rather different, say, to income tax on a man who has £10,000. It is rather a hardship in that it hits at necessities. What I am suggesting to the Minister is that it would be very little use our moving that first part of the resolution alone, and he might indicate whether he would be prepared to consider himself the principle of the whole amendment, (a) and (b) together, sympathetically.
Comment on this
I can express general agreement with the principle. In regard to the method of what I would call fixing layers of taxation, I would like to say that that presents difficulties.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister is right in that description. It is a pro rata reduction of 20 per cent. It does not go in strata. It is gradual.
Comment on this
I just confine myself to saying that I accept the general principle that it would be a good thing to increase the allowances to people with small incomes and find the means of doing that by taking it off people whose incomes are substantial.
Comment on this
We cannot do any of these things at this stage, as it would mean interference with the principles on which assessments of tax on practically all taxpayers would be fixed. It is impossible to take on anything like that at this stage without, as I have said, taking the staff away from the straightforward collection of tax, and without involving our falling short substantially of the Estimate.
Comment on this
Would the Minister give any data with regard to the effect on revenue of this proposal?
Comment on this
Might I suggest to the Minister that this is a line along which we should move cautiously. In reply to a question of mine, the Minister stated to-day, on the question of super-tax, that in the years 1923-24 we had 1,361 payers of super-tax in the Free State. In the year 1924-25 the number was 1,344. In the year 1925-26, the number had fallen to 1,197. Last year, that is, 1926-27, the total number of super-tax payers in the Free State was 1,181, showing a falling-off of 180 in a period of five years. If we are going further to burden that particular section of the community with heavy taxation in the future, we will have an even larger diminution in the number of these taxpayers in the future than we have had during the five years I have mentioned.
Comment on this
I would rather like to express agreement with the caveat entered by Deputy Good. The idea that we are going to benefit the State permanently from a productive point of view by actually increasing the load upon the big taxpayers is unsound, in my opinion. I say that quite frankly, and I do not want that there should be any doubt about it. What we are dealing with here for the moment is a restricted area in which income taxation is a hardship taxation as distinct from taxation which is more directly inimical to production. I say quite deliberately that I believe this country wants people who are earning big incomes and getting them. I believe on that basis you will get more production and more enterprise in industry. This thing is not intended to deal with that general principle. We are dealing with a segregated area where you have actually hardship to income taxpayers.
Comment on this
I feel constrained to make one or two remarks. I agree with what has been said by the last two speakers. It is quite impossible to lay down hard and fast rules and to say that because the head of a family is earning £200 or £300 or even more per year, his family is necessarily in a state of hardship. There are many cases where the head of the family is earning an income and members of the family are also earning and it becomes really a matter that is quite difficult to deal with. I know many cases where the total income may be brought in by the head of the family and may amount to £500 or £600 and where it is more difficult for that man to bring up his family than in the case of other men where the total income amounts to considerably more, even though the head of the family is earning only £200 or £300.
Comment on this
The amendment which is properly before us in lieu of amendment 4 on the Paper is this:—
Before sub-section (2) to insert a new section as follows:—
Section 21 of the Finance Act, 1920, is hereby amended by the substitution of fifty pounds for thirty-six pounds and of forty pounds for twenty-seven pounds as the deductions in respect of children.
In view of the points raised by the Minister with regard to an investigation, on which I presume the amendment will be withdrawn in the end, the Deputy is in order in referring to the actual text of the amendment as on the Paper.
Comment on this
In that case, I must say that I have more sympathy with the latter portion of the amendment than with the first portion. The Finance Act here and the Finance Act in England follow out much the same principle as the amendment—the first child should deserve more consideration. The principle appears to be that the first child is more welcome than the second.
Comment on this
One in family would be an ideal family, according to that. Well, that is not so. I would be inclined to leave the amount in respect of the first child as it was and increase it to £40 in the case of the second and subsequent children. It is a joke to have it otherwise. Where there are four, five, or six in family it is at that period that the cost of the family begins to increase and it is there you ought to mark your appreciation because it is there relief is needed. Relief is not so much needed in the case of the man with one child. It is the second and subsequent children that really should get consideration. We ought to depart from the old principle altogether and strike out on a new line. That is the right thing to do. There is no disputing the fact and when you examine the subject on its merits you will realise there can be no dispute about it. I recommend the Minister to adopt that line.
Comment on this
I look upon this matter from a very different point of view. I think the amendment would place a limit on the industrial capacity of a man, and I look upon it as more or less putting a premium on inefficiency. I do not think that the amendment ought to be accepted, or that it should go to form the basis of consideration by the Minister in the near future. If the amendment were introduced on a broad scale, giving equal rights to every citizen, no matter what his earning capacity or his income might be, then it could be reviewed from the broader aspect; but when it narrows down the position to persons earning only a limited amount of money and specifies that those persons only should get special relief, it more or less creates an anxiety to earn only that limited amount. If it were put upon the broad basis, say £50 for the first child, £40 for the second, and £40 down along, it would be more reasonable and possibly would be acceptable to the country in general. To ask the Minister to form a basis on the views as expressed would not be at all right. It does not lend itself to progress or universal expansion of any kind. It is more or less a premium on indolence, and I hope the Minister will not consider it.
Comment on this
I do not know whether it is necessary to reply to the points raised, but I should like to make a few remarks in regard to them. As regards Deputy Connolly's point, I do not see how an amendment of this description will at all tend to curb enterprise. If an income of £900 is not a greater inducement to a man than any allowance he might be able to secure under this amendment in respect of income tax I am afraid nothing will stimulate that man either to industry or enterprise. In connection with Deputy Gorey's criticism, I must say I have a great deal of sympathy with his point of view, but at the same time I think the idea that remissions of income tax in respect of children stimulate the production of large families is a very ill-founded one.
Comment on this
As Deputy Flinn says, it is only a consolation prize. The fact that a man is going to secure a remission of £5 per year in respect of one child is certainly not going to induce him to incur the expense, if you like, of having to maintain the child.
Comment on this
If a man cannot provide for his family without depending on the income tax collector to help him the children are likely to go hungry before they die.
Comment on this
With reference to the point raised by Deputy Good, he quoted certain figures I gave to-day in answer to a question, but I do not think his deductions are justified. In respect of the latter years shown in the table there are assessments still to be made. These are super-tax matters in connection with which there is great difficulty and delay. I do not think there has been the decline in the number of persons liable to super-tax that Deputy Good fears.
Comment on this
If the Deputy will look at the returns he will see that the numbers in the years 1923-24 and 1924-25 were practically the same. In respect of 1925-26 and 1926-27 there are still assessments to be made. With respect to the question of not imposing a heavy burden on the people with larger incomes there is a fact to be remembered that they have at present a substantial advantage in the 3/- rate as compared with the 4/- rate heretofore, and the loss of certain allowances would not be a very great factor in their cases.
Comment on this
I move amendment 5:—
Before sub-section (2) to insert a new section as follows:—
Section 21 of the Finance Act, 1920, is hereby amended by the substitution for the deduction specified in that section of a deduction of eighty pounds in respect of any child who is over the age of 16 years at the commencement of the year of assessment and who is receiving full-time instruction at any university, college, school or other educational establishment.
This is an amendment which I am satisfied is not of such a nature that it will impose a specially big drain on the Minister's resources, even this year, and for that reason I would urge him to accept it. Its purpose is to give greater allowances in respect of any child over the age of 16 who is being educated at a school, college or university. It seems perfectly ridiculous that the same allowance is given in the case of a baby six months old and a boy or girl, eighteen, nineteen or twenty years of age who may be maintained at a university. That is absolutely unsound in principle, and, from the point of view of encouraging people to keep their child for a year or two or longer at school, I think it would be well from the point of view of the community as a whole if this concession were given. At the present time the amount of actual relief to the general taxpayer, taking half the standard rate he would be allowed off the income tax, would be £2 14s. 0d. Under my amendment that would be increased to £6. Even that £6 relief is not a very big inducement to a man to keep his child at school for a year or two longer, but it is something. It would not, in any case, cover the cost of books or if it did it would not be very much more. I do not believe that this concession would cost a very great deal and I believe that it would be advisable from many points of view to have these allowances given in the case of this particular class of children. While we are prepared to give way on the others and leave them over for the next year, I think this is one which the Minister could very well give way on even in the present Budget.
Comment on this
With reference to this particular amendment, the best estimate that I could make as to the cost is about fifty thousand pounds. This amendment has this disadvantage —perhaps Deputy O'Connell might not think it a disadvantage, but it has this quality—that the amount that the smaller taxpayer is likely to get out of it is very much less than in the case of the larger taxpayer. If you take a man with £500 income who has one child receiving full time instruction whether at a university, college or other educational establishment, the amount of extra relief that he will get will be £3 6s. 0d. per annum. A better-off person would be likely to have more than one child obtaining this full time instruction at this age. You might have a person with four children receiving such instruction, and that person would get relief to the amount of £30 per annum so that most of the benefit of this relief would go in actual money, not to the people who are in the very low ranges of income but to the people who are fairly well up. I do not think that this could be adopted this year but I would just like to hear the opinion of the Dáil as to whether substantially greater relief should be given in respect of children who are, say, at universities or such institutions than in respect of other children.
That is not a matter that I remember hearing debated at any length in the Dáil, and, as we are considering the whole question of relief, I would be interested to hear what is the general opinion of the Dáil on this question. At present the highest relief for a child is £36. Would the Dáil be prepared to accept the principle that in respect of a child at a university or a training college or some such institution the total of the ordinary amount of relief would be doubled or more than doubled? Without being able to accept the amendment at this stage, but in view of the proposed overhauling of the whole system of reliefs in these cases, I would like to hear that principle discussed— as to whether if we are to give reliefs upon these lines, a good deal of the benefit in money will go to the comparatively well-off, and consequently there will be some curtailments of the reliefs that can be given to people whose incomes are much lower down the scale. This is a matter on the merits of which I have not personally made up my mind. As I say, while I could not accept it, I am satisfied that it would cost in the neighbourhood of £50,000 a year, a sum which we could not lose without making up in some other way, and that, I do not think, would be desirable. At the same time, as the matter has been proposed, I would certainly welcome some general expression of the opinion of the Dáil on the principle. I do not know whether Deputy O'Connell would state it as his principle that twice or more than twice the ordinary relief should go in respect of a child that is over the age of 16 years and that is receiving full-time instruction at a university or other educational establishment.
Comment on this
Before dealing with the point raised by the Minister, I would like to put it to him whether he would this year accept this amendment confining it to the lower range of income. He made the point that this amendment would give a greater amount of relief to the higher taxpayers. I would like to know from him whether he would be prepared to accept an extension, say, in the case of incomes up to £400, because, even as it is, I can hardly understand how this proposal will cost £50,000. Of course, the Minister has means for calculating these things, but I can hardly realise how it would cost £50,000. But if the Minister would agree to confine the amendment to the cases of lower incomes, say £400 or so, then it would cost the State very much less. I would ask him in the first place to re-consider between this and the Report Stage as to whether it would be possible to extend the relief and increase the allowances for children at school in the case of the smaller taxpayers up to, say, four hundred or five hundred pounds. On the general question, I have no hesitation in saying that the principle upon which the same allowance is given in respect of a baby of six or eight months as in the case of a young man or woman at a university is wrong. It is unsound in principle and undoubtedly the proposal that a much greater relief should be given in the case of children over the age of 16 who are being maintained at school or college, would have my very strong support. As to what the relief should be, that would be a matter for consideration. As a general principle, it is sound that the allowances for children who are being maintained at school over the age of sixteen should be greater than the allowances made in the case of children who are of more tender years, because it is only at sixteen years and after it that the expenses of children begin to mount up.
Comment on this
It would be a some what difficult matter to get statistics that would enable me to know what the cost would be if it were confined to lower incomes, but I know it would be a substantial sum, and the Budget proposals were drawn in such a way that any concession involving a substantial loss of revenue has to be countered by some other proposal. It is for that reason that I do not feel able to agree to any concession in this respect this year. Personally, I am inclined to the view that there is ground for some extra relief in respect of children, at any rate, of people with small incomes who are maintained in such institutions, but I think it is a matter that could and would be best dealt with in a general review of schemes of relief. I do not know that I need go into the bases on which we arrived at the estimate of £50,000, except to say that we have statistics showing that there are 18,000 children over the age of sixteen receiving whole-time instruction. Of course, a considerable number of these are the children of people who would be exempt from income tax, but there must be a balance of 9,000 who are the children of parents paying income tax. We have made a calculation on those lines, which I think is a reasonably accurate calculation, and it shows that there would be a loss of about £50,000 yearly. That might be five or six thousand pounds out one way or the other. It is only an estimate, but it has been gone over carefully, and I believe it is correct. There is one point which was not raised here but was raised by representations from people outside, with reference to children who are needlessly, and out of motives of snobbery, shall we say, sent out of the country for education. I have received many letters urging that these particular children's allowances, or any allowances even for those under sixteen, should not be paid in respect of such children. That is a matter that perhaps might also be considered.
Comment on this
Is it not rather a limitation to apply this only to children who are in educational establishments? I am in sympathy with the proposal, even in its narrow limits, but I would like to see the principle, if adopted, extended. An educational establishment is a training establishment for a future career. A great many parents are making sacrifices by having their children trained for future careers, but they are not in educational establishments. Are such parents to be cut out from the benefits in this proposal? I do not think that is the intention of Deputy O'Connell. If the amendment is to be considered by the Departmental Committee, I think it should be considered in its wider aspect, because, as I said, just as great sacrifices are being made by other parents in the training of young people for future careers. Those people ought to be taken into account in a question of this kind.
Comment on this
I would even go as far as apprentices. The term "apprentice" is a very wide one. I think apprentices should be included, as they are training for future careers, and their parents have to make sacrifices. The proposal Deputy O'Connell makes is that when parents have to make these sacrifices the State ought to give some assistance. I would be in favour of the term embracing apprentices, as Deputy Flinn suggests.
Comment on this
I would like Deputy Good to indicate the particular class he was referring to between educational establishments and apprentices. There is evidently some intermediate stage that the Deputy has in mind. Would it be those attending technical or secondary schools?
Comment on this
This is a matter that it is difficult to discuss here. A great many apprentices would not come within the scope of the proposal at all, because the parents would not be income tax payers.
Comment on this
That question is a very debatable one and cannot be discussed now, but in the cases I have in mind the parents of apprentices are income tax payers, and I think ought to get assistance. That is the principle in Deputy O'Connell's mind as embodied in the amendment.
Comment on this
Possibly Deputy Good would formulate a memorandum for the benefit of the Committee which will inquire into it. Deputy Good evidently has some definite class of people in mind and I would like to know what that class is. I am not objecting in any way, but I want to know what is the ambit of his idea.
Comment on this
I only want to say that I trust the Minister will look into this proposal and the principle that underlies it. I urged it some years ago. The Minister for Education the other day pointed out that in this country, more than in any other country, the cost of education falls on the State and not on the locality nor on the parent. I think it is desirable that some concession should be made to these parents, who will face the self-sacrifice of giving their children a profession or skilled trade. Such a class is of extreme value to the State as craftsmen in every profession. They are needed, and the State does not contribute as much directly perhaps, in this case, as it does in the case of other branches of education. I think the parents who have to make sacrifices should be encouraged. I would certainly recommend the principle that underlies Deputy O'Connell's amendment to the Minister, and I would go further and suggest that none of the money spent on education should be subject to income tax. But perhaps that is going too far.
Comment on this
I agree that this would be a very good thing, especially in the case of people with incomes under £400. I think beyond that it might not be reasonable, but certainly up to £400 it would be. If you look at it in an actual kind of way, a parent has to consider whether it will be possible for him to allow his child to get a better education or be forced to let that child become a wage-earner at once. For that reason, the immediate effect would be to raise the standard of education.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister if he could tell me roughly what is the amount the State contributes now for University education. I think it is about £80,000. Would it be more beneficial on the average to the children of these parents if it were directly applied by the State to higher education or should it be distributed in this way indirectly to the parents? I am only suggesting that for consideration.
Comment on this
The Minister has invited the Dáil to express its opinion on the principle of this proposal of Deputy O'Connell. I want to say that I am entirely in favour of it, and I hope in another year the Minister will see his way to accept it in its entirety. I should like, as Deputy Alton has stated, to go considerably further. I think there is a real reason for discriminating in the way this amendment favours. That is the particular point which the Minister has asked us to direct attention to. He has asked whether there is ground for giving higher relief for children undergoing university education, or higher education of some form later than 16 years, than in respect of younger people. I think there is. I think one's experience as a parent is that the expense of children's education steadily increases from the time they are six or seven years of age until they have completed their university course. Therefore, I think there is really a substantial ground for this concession. I would like to see a greater allowance given in respect of children's education all-round from the start, certainly from twelve or fourteen years of age; but if you are to discriminate, I think there is ground for the discrimination that Deputy O'Connell has suggested.
I would rather deprecate the suggestion that a benefit of this sort should be confined to a particular range of income, for this reason: That would be a perfectly sound principle if our income-tax system was one under which an income of £400 a year was always divisable by the same factor—by one, by two or by three. We all know that that is not so; the head of the family is treated as the unit, and for income-tax purposes, apart from these very slight modifications, we are getting no discrimination, broadly speaking, between the man who has £500 a year who is a bachelor and the man who has £500 a year and who has a wife and four children, though in one case the income has to be divided by one and in the other case it has to be divided by six. That makes a very substantial difference. It may very well happen that in actual practice a man with £600 or £700 a year is in fact very much worse off and may find it very much more difficult to bring up his children than a man with £400 a year and with one child. That is a fact that I think ought to be borne in mind when this matter is under discussion.
Comment on this
I would feel better satisfied with this discussion if Deputies had indicated from whom they were to get these reliefs. No Deputy has so far suggested who is to bear the reliefs that it is proposed to give to the particular class we are discussing.
Comment on this
I do not think that any Deputy would admit that the working classes should be more highly taxed than they are at present. If it be true that a man with £2 a week is paying such a high proportion of his income in taxation as was stated by Mr. Johnson in a recent contribution to a weekly paper, then I suggest that he is the man whose relief we ought to be considering and not the man with £500 or £600 a year. It is much more important, I think, that the man who is making a struggle for bread for his family should have his wants considered, rather than the man who is endeavouring to give a university education to his children. I would certainly be in favour of all these things if I thought that they could be done at the expense of people who could afford them, but nobody, so far, has given any hint as to where these reliefs are to come from. As a matter of fact, I think we have very little information, either in this House or anywhere within the country, as to the real incidence of taxation. I think that if this question is going to be considered it might be broadened into a really big review of the incidence of taxation, and as to whether the present principles are fair to the community, whether they mean equity as between class and class, or whether the aim of legislation should not be to relieve entirely those who are merely able to afford absolute requirements for themselves and their children.
I think it will be a bit of a shock to a number of people outside, if anybody is reading about these proceedings at all at present, to hear that we, as a body, almost without exception, are discussing proposals for the relief of taxation on incomes of £600 a year, and so on, in order that families with these incomes may have more or less free university education for their children. I have nothing in the way of scientific statement to go on, but I am satisfied in my own mind from my observations that the national income of the country is not big enough to afford any consideration for people with incomes of £600 a year. I am quite satisfied that the average earning is so low that the people with £600 a year would have to pay, if we endeavour to arrive at a really fair system, in full for the education of their children, and that the State cannot afford to give any relief to them.
Comment on this
In reply to the point raised by Deputy Flinn: The only figures on which I can lay my hands are those in the Estimates. We provide about £183,000 per annum in respect of university education. Ordinary grants to the Universities are £153,000; there is about £27,000 for the Agricultural Faculties in Dublin and Cork, and there is a grant of £3,000 a year to Trinity College. The expenditure on secondary education is £312,000. In addition, there is a contribution from local sources in the form of university scholarships, the total amount of which I have not at hand.
Comment on this
I support Deputy Good's contention in this matter with reference to apprenticeships and apprentices in general. These are a class of children that involve the greatest possible demand on the resources and or the income of the parent. He has no means of getting relief from the State; he has no grants from the State, and he does not ask for any grants from the State, but he asks to be relieved from the payment of income tax on the amount which it is necessary for him to expend on a child, and I think it is only reasonable and fair that he should get it. I should also like to call attention to the fact that Deputies on the opposite side are circling round the figure of £400. It would appear that the majority in this House have about reached that figure, and I do not think when we have reached that figure that we should be specially exempted people in the circumstances. If there is to be an allowance for apprentices, or for university students, it should be applicable to all, no matter what their incomes are, and I think the burdens that are in many cases inflicted upon people with large incomes are greater than what would be inflicted upon some of the Deputies on the other side.
Comment on this
As the Minister has asked the House to give a general indication of its attitude in this matter, I would point out that I think there is a considerable section of the House which feels that any great increase in the allowances by a reduction in income tax cannot be afforded until there has been, first of all, a very substantial reduction in expenditure and a very substantial remission of taxation in other respects. The difficulty I see in connection with this amendment is the one which the Minister himself expressed, the fact that people with larger incomes will undoubtedly benefit, people who hardly require a remission or concession. On the other hand, it is a very difficult matter to cut the relief off at a limit of £400, or anything like that, and if while a case can be made for relief in respect to the lower income, at the same time a transition from the absolute refusal of relief on any one limit would be a difficult matter, and would possibly be unjust, taking into consideration that a man with an income of £500 or £600 a year may have two or three members of his family at a university and may be able to establish a very good case for relief.
On the other hand, as the Minister himself said on a former occasion, it is not a very simple relief to grant. There are considerations in respect of children who are educated outside the country, in respect of children who are enjoying county council and university scholarships, which would have to be taken into consideration, and which might make the granting of the relief a very difficult matter. As well as that, we also have the fact that a considerable sum of public money is already expended on education. A point has been made, and I think we ought to devote some consideration to it, that people should be encouraged to educate their children. I agree. At the same time, those who are sending their children to universities, and who are making present sacrifices, are doing so possibly in the hope of reaping future rewards. There are considerations of that sort which can be set off against the fact that it is a burden on them at present to educate the children. They are also only discharging their duty as parents to the children, and when the children are educated in many cases they repay the cost of their education to the parents. Consequently, I think, while the principle is at first sight a good one, in many cases it is very difficult to apply.
Comment on this
In view of the attitude taken by the Minister there is nothing left but to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
There is one point I should like to make with regard to this proposal. This proposal to give a deduction in respect of income tax for children receiving education really amounts in fact to the provision of extra scholarships for education. It means that you are proposing to give scholarships all round without any differentiation between the children who are going to get the scholarships, whether they deserve them or not, or are likely to make full use of them or not. I believe that if the State wishes to make further provision in respect of cheaper education it should be done by giving an advantage to the poorer children, who are qualified and fit to receive a good education, and who show they are fit to receive it by giving proof of their capacity in primary or secondary schools; that we should not go in for universal free education for everybody, no matter whether fit to receive such an education or not, as is implied in this. We have a good deal of that already, and I think that giving it in the way implied in this would be going altogether too far. It would be far better, if the State is prepared to spend £50,000 extra on education, that it should be spent in such a way that the people who would get the value of it would be the people who will, in the first place, need the money and will, in the second place, be able to give a better return to the State for the money they are going to get.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Tierney, who is an educationist, explain whether he is purposely excluding technical students from the benefits of this proposal and whether he has in mind preserving this concession for university students?
Comment on this
I was rather opposing the proposal altogether and, therefore, inclined to oppose it both for university and technical education. It does seem to me, certainly, that if extra money is to be spent—because this does mean that the State should spend £50,000 a year extra on education—it would probably be better spent on technical education and by the definite and direct provision of methods for secondary education, rather than by giving universal all-round relief to everybody, whether the children are capable of making the best use of that education or not.
Comment on this
I find myself in agreement with Deputy O'Connell's proposal and with most of the speakers, and in disagreement with Deputy Tierney. I do not know by what stretch of the imagination he can imagine that a sum, say, of £3 6s. relief in income tax should be regarded as a scholarship. That is what it amounts to. If it serves no other purpose, the fact that it is on the income tax return that such relief is to be got for education will remind parents that there is such a thing as giving better education to children, even though it is very small relief. With regard to the point raised by Deputy Good, I did not quite follow whom he had in mind or what type of occupation the child might be put at. Apprentices might come under the heading of this, and those apprenticed to solicitors and engineers and those going on to be doctors. They would also come under the heading of those who would be the subject of relief. With regard to the question of confining it to the lower incomes, I think we are rather beating the air in discussing that. I would suggest to the Minister, when he is considering this matter, that the income taxpayers should be graded in regard to families, so that when we are discussing this he will be able to know exactly what it would be for salaries of £400 up to £1,000, and then the Minister and the House would be able to come to a conclusion as to what the result would be on the revenue as a whole. I hope that this proposal will be broadened out, and I think Deputy O'Connell deserves credit for having brought it forward.
Comment on this
It seems to me that what Deputy O'Hanlon has said is in favour of what I was arguing. He said it will amount to about £3 6s. each. If that is the way you are going to spend £50,000, you can find many ways of spending it better. We are to dole out £50,000 in small sums simply to remind parents, apparently, that they ought to educate their children. We cannot afford that sum very easily at present. If we want to spend £50,000 on education, let us make up our minds to do it, and spend it in some way that will give a good return for the money —on children, for one thing, who are deserving of a good education, and on technical education—but let us not dole it out in this equalitarian fashion and spend it as a kind of inducement, by way of advertisement on income tax forms, to parents to get their children educated.
Comment on this
I am rather surprised to hear Deputy Tierney advance these views, because if there is one thing more than another that this country is noted for, it is this rather foolish worship at the shrine of scholarships—the idea of picking out one or two children in a district, getting them specially educated, and leaving the average child to paddle its own canoe. I would prefer to see a general average education rather than have one or two picked out and treated as something special above their fellows. This is neither the time nor the place to go into that. The amount of relief to be given may be small, but it may just make the difference to a parent when he is calculating whether he will keep his child another year at school; it may be just sufficient to throw the balance on the side of keeping the child at school for another year. I suppose there is no use in pressing the amendment on this occasion, but I hope the Minister will give serious consideration to the points put forward. Perhaps when this Departmental Committee is sitting, it might be possible to give an opportunity to people on various sides of the House, who may have various points of view, to put their views before the Committee.
Comment on this
Amendments 6, 7, 8 and 9 are all amendments for certain deductions and appear to be based on the same principle. I wonder whether it would not be possible to get a discussion on the whole principle involved in the four amendments on amendment No. 6. It would be difficult to discuss them separately, I think.
Comment on this
6 and 7 might be taken together, but in regard to 8 and 9 there might be difficulty.
Comment on this
For the purpose of discussion, not decision. Amendments 8 and 9 deal with distribution, but the principle is practically the same in all. The best way would be to take a decision on 6 as embodying the principle and not have any further general debate.
Comment on this
I move amendment 6:—
To insert before sub-section (3) a new sub-section as follows:—
"If any claimant proves that any portion of his income arose directly from stocks, shares or other investments in a manufacturing undertaking (or undertakings, as the case may be) established in Saorstát Eireann he shall, for the purpose of arriving at his assessible income, be entitled to a deduction of one-fifth of the income which thus arose."
The purpose of the amendment is to render Irish productive and manufacturing enterprises more attractive to Irish investors. It is also to a certain extent intended to counteract the tendency which the lower rate of income tax ruling here has to make foreign investments—British investments, for example—more attractive to the citizens of Saorstát Eireann than to the citizens of Great Britain itself I think one of the indirect effects, and I seldom advert to it, is that the tax on unearned incomes in the Free State is 25 per cent. lower than the tax on unearned incomes in Great Britain. The effect is, as I said, to make it easy for an Irish investor to pick up stock in Great Britain at what he thinks will be a remunerative price. If you had a British undertaking whose £1 shares stood in the market at 30/-, and you have an investor anxious to invest £750, and this particular concern was a long-established and well-managed one, as the price of the shares shows, there would be a prospect of some capital appreciation. Obviously the margin of price at which the British investor will purchase such shares in the existing circumstances will be 30/- per share, and if a British resident buys them he will receive in due course on £750 a nominal dividend of £35. From this dividend there will be a deduction of 4/- per £, or £7 in all, on account of income tax, and the net return he will receive will be only £28. The Irish investor, on the other hand, in that concern buying shares at the same price will receive a nominal dividend of £35, and in due course he will have returned to him £1 15s. in respect of unearned income here, and if you allow 5/- for the income tax recovery agent the actual return he will receive will be £29 10s.
The British investor receives an average of 3.73 per cent. The Irish investor in the same stock will get 3.92 per cent., and as the market is fixed, presumably, by the British investor, and Irish buying will not appreciably affect the price of the stock, there is always an inducement for the stockbroker here or in England taking an English valuation of the stock to say: "Look, here is a thing which is a very good thing; you get a little more than the ordinary return for it. You get 3.92 per cent. for this English stock, for which the Englishman is content to receive 3.73 per cent., and in addition you have the prospect that it is going to go further."
I feel the general effect of that is to make it more attractive for the Irish investor to go in for certain stock that can be picked up in the British market and to invest his money there. One effect of this amendment would be to offer to the Irish investor, at any rate, an inducement to put his money into Irish enterprise, if there were an Irish enterprise that would offer the same inducement and nominal return. If he were to put £750 in an Irish industry and to receive a nominal dividend of £35 the amount he would receive under present circumstances would be £29 15s. The actual net return, after deduction of income tax, would be £29 15s., as opposed to £29 10s. across the water. I do not think that in the present circumstances there is any definite inducement so far as the fiscal policy of the Government is concerned for the Irish investor to put his money into enterprise here. On the other hand, if this amendment is carried the net return he would receive in respect of £750 would be £30 16s., and that would be equivalent to 4.13 per cent. return. So that £750 invested in Irish industry will bring him the same return as if it were £785 invested in Great Britain. That is the chief recommendation which we have to make in respect of this amendment.
Comment on this
It is already attractive, by the reduction of 1/- in the £ in income tax.
Comment on this
Not exactly. It is only attractive to the extent of 5/- out of £30. An Irish investor, say, buying 500 one pound Cunard shares for £750 would at the present moment here in Dublin get an annual net return of £29 10s. If he put that £750 into Irish industry of equal status and was content with the same nominal dividend, the amount he would receive would be £29 15s., so the net advantage of the 1/- in the £ in the income tax to the Irish investor is only 5/- out of £29 15s., which is something less than 1 per cent. Under the circumstances, while we suggest a deduction of one-fifth we feel that that deduction might be increased. We put it there more or less as a token deduction rather than one to which we actually pin our faith. We are concerned with bringing this principle before the Dáil and the Government in the hope that they may see their way to accept it. It does offer to the Irish investor a tangible inducement, and a very appreciable inducement, to invest in Irish enterprise. That principle runs through amendments 6, 7 and 8. There may be some difficulty raised in regard to amendments 8 and 9 in so far as they deal with Irish distributive undertakings. We feel we are trying to do two things there. We offer, first of all, to the Irish investor in distributive undertakings an inducement to put his money into such an undertaking provided it does its duty and helps the Irish manufacturer and worker and the State as a whole. All of us at one time or another have tried to buy Irish manufactured goods and we know the extraordinary difficulty that we have experienced in getting the shopkeeper and salesman to show those goods or to try to sell them.
Under amendments 8 and 9 we are making it a sound proposition for the Irish distributor to push and sell Irish-manufactured goods. Certain machinery will have to be provided. The form in which the amendment has been drafted enables the Minister to provide that machinery if he accepts the amendment. I take it that will be a matter for departmental regulation rather than for actual enactment by statute, but my belief is that the machinery required could be very easily and inexpensively provided. Every Irish manufacturer can issue to the wholesalers, or where a distributor buys direct from him, a certificate stating that so-and-so bought a certain quantity of his goods at such and such a price on such and such a date. At the end of the year the distributor can collect these certificates and file them on his income tax return or, and perhaps the Minister for Finance would prefer this, deposit them with his books showing his turnover. If 50 per cent. of his turnover was represented by Irish manufactured commodities, then he would be entitled to the deduction mentioned here.
I think that the machinery suggested is simple. It will cost very little to the Minister. Manufacturers will be only too glad to print these forms and send them out with the goods, because they are an additional inducement to the shopkeeper and distributor who buys those goods to push them. They represent something which costs the manufacturer nothing and which, ultimately, I believe will cost the State nothing, because the general industrial development and the stimulus which would be consequent upon the acceptance of the principle here advanced would, I suggest, more than repay anything which the State loses. There is also the fact that before the distributor can recover anything, or receive any allowance under amendments 8 and 9, he will have to show all his books. The Minister for Finance may be certain that in that event this will prove an additional preventive of fraud. It will compel the ordinary distributors to make an honest return to the income tax collector, which in certain cases at any rate some of them do not do at the present time. I feel that the general effect of the principles embodied in the amendments will be good. I feel, too, their acceptance will be a stimulus and a help to Irish enterprise. I hope that if the Government cannot see its way immediately to adopt the amendments, it will at all events consider favourably the principle underlying them.
Comment on this
I understand that Deputies will be able to speak several times on this particular question. Deputy MacEntee, as I understand it, has put down this amendment for the purpose of discussion. As that is so, I need not use some of the arguments that I was going to use, because it would be impossible in the short time that has been available to estimate the financial effect of the acceptance of the amendment. There are various defects in the drafting of it that I could point to, but as the Deputy has stated that he has merely put down the amendment for the purpose of having a discussion on it, I will not go into that.
It seems to me that the real difficulty as regards getting money invested in Irish industries is the uncertainty as to profit. It is the fear investors have that, owing to the conditions operating here, they would not obtain any profit. There are certain industries which are well established and which make good profits. In regard to these, there is no difficulty in obtaining further capital if it should be needed for the purposes of extension. These industries do not suffer from the difficulties which this amendment sets out to cure. By this amendment you do nothing for these industries. You simply, perhaps, bid up their shares and bring about an appreciation of them because they gave certain advantages to the people who have investments in them. That does not seem to me to be desirable. Besides the amount of income that would be lost in this way, unless we actually could bring about a great extension of industry, it would mean that non-income taxpayers would somehow or another have to be burdened in order that we might obtain it.
There are many arguments that could be made for the encouragement of industry. There is one type of proposal which has a good deal of support from writers on economics, and that is that where a firm or a concern invests money in extending premises or in installing new plant, it might do that out of revenue and the particular revenue expended on that might be exempted from tax. That is one of the matters which, for some time I have thought that we could explore. I do feel with Deputies on the other side that it is desirable for us, in our particular circumstances, to consider whether in respect to our scheme of income tax we cannot do something to encourage manufacture. It may be that there will be a case for such a thing. I think that to encourage firms to put a part of their earnings or the greater part of their earnings into extensions, if we agreed on a scheme like that, it would not mean a great loss of revenue. I have not had the proposal fully examined, but even without having given it careful consideration, I do not think it would mean a great loss of revenue. There might be some case for doing that.
It seems to me that under the proposal that is set down by Deputy MacEntee in quite a considerable number of cases revenue would be lost, and there would be no return in increased manufacturing activity. Where I join issue with Deputy MacEntee is that any difficulty that may exist in regard to the obtaining of capital for manufacturing industry in Ireland arises not directly out of the attractiveness of foreign investment, but really out of the fears, which are not altogether unjustifiable fears in view of the industrial history of the country, that profits will not be earned.
Without going into a tariff debate, something has been done towards encouraging the investment of money in industries by means of tariffs. It may be the argument is that more should be done, but it seems to me the Deputy has not made a case that is convincing for this particular scheme. In regard to the two amendments, of course there is a very great difficulty where you fix on a particular part of the trading turn-over as qualifying the trader for the concession. It might be very easy for a particular concern to do 50 per cent. in turnover in Irish manufacture and really be entitled to no consideration. It is possible to conceive of an establishment that would trade in Irish meat, bacon, and such like, and 50 per cent. of whose turn-over would be in Irish goods, and yet not really be putting itself out in any particular way. The difficulties of administration in regard to distribution would be very much greater than in respect of manufacture, though I do not think it would be an easy matter to arrange even in respect of manufacture, but in regard to distribution it would, I believe, so far as it has been possible to examine it in the time, be very troublesome and would involve a great deal of staff work. As to the extent to which it would actually encourage people to sell and push Irish manufactures, I do not know, but I would like to say I place more reliance on the tariff weapon, as I think we get direct results there. It is very uncertain as to what you will get in the other respect.
You can never know whether a particular firm is really doing anything to earn a concession. Then there is the other question: if you have people earning large incomes, and if you cannot see a direct result from a concession to them in increased economic activity it is extremely difficult to justify a very substantial concession. There is no doubt that if you do not get increased economic activity immediately, or soon, you have to cast a heavier burden on the people who are less able to bear it. I am glad the Deputy brought forward these particular amendments, because, while it cannot take place for a year or two, we must overhaul our income tax code in general. We can do the particular matter I referred to earlier in regard to allowances. We can do that even within a few months. Regarding the matter of income tax, it has been impossible, owing to shortage of trained staff and the strain put on the office with respect to outstanding arrears, and the work involved in that. But it has been recognised that we must overhaul our income tax code, and substantially. In that process we might incorporate new principles. One principle that has so far recommended itself to me is that which I have already mentioned, the encouraging of firms by exemption from income tax to extend and put in new and improved machinery. I am not convinced you would get results commensurate with the loss of revenue from the particular proposals put forward by the Deputy. I think it is a good thing these proposals have been brought forward, and that attention should be directed to possible changes.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance may be familiar with a formula somewhat as follows: That on and from a certain date in Saorstát Eireann all incomes derived from investments in productive industries in Ireland shall be abolished. Behind that particular formula is the very eminent Irish economist whose pupil I am—John Punch, of Cork. One word I want the Minister to get hold of is—discrimination. He has raised a good many points, and raised them sympathetically, in relation to the details of these amendments. We have put down four amendments which deal with the principle of discrimination. If we had put down all the amendments which would have covered all the points the Minister desires we would have had exactly the same discussion we are going to have on these. First, let me say I unhesitatingly agree with the suggestion made by the Minister that the first thing to be dealt with is capital which is not taken out in profits, but is put back into the development of business, and in every form in gradation as we find it immediately affecting it. The natural thing you would say would be: "Well, let us encourage new money which goes into Irish industry." By that I mean putting it into an industry which is engaged in employing labour in Ireland, producing wealth in and for Ireland. The difficulty is if you give discrimination in favour of such capital you are discriminating against old capital which has already been doing its work. In the same way, broadly speaking, every proposal that you tackle has its disadvantages.
The Minister may find fault with one particular clause or another, but so long as the principle is accepted that in relation to taxation and taxation reliefs we will give preferential treatment to those who are prepared to engage their money and energy in the development of Irish industry, the particular form in which it comes at once does not matter. I have looked up a whole series of figures relating to different companies and enterprises. A chartered accountant was good enough to give them to me. I said: "I simply want a series of typical cases. I do not want to know the names of the firms or anything of that kind." We took out the benefit which the State got in income tax and we put that against the amount which was distributed in this country in wages, rates, rents and taxes, and other moneys which were distributed in this country, and went into consumption in this country, and the relation between the income tax got from them, and the benefit given really means that in many cases the collection of that income tax was a ridiculously small proportion compared to the total amount of benefit that was given. There is one other point which, in my opinion, is very important in this matter, and especially in relation to the income tax, and that is that only legislation of a compulsory or a restrictive character can counter the tendency to the transfer of ownership in Irish industrial and distributive processes to outside. If you take the case of income derived in this country and taxed, say, at 4/- in the £—it does not matter what the figure is at this moment—you will see that out of £100 a man gets £80—that is, £20 is deducted at the source. If he is an Irish resident owning that Irish capital he gets it back.
If it is some outsider who gets it, his State naturally takes it. That is no business of ours but the result is that the shares of a firm which is functioning in this country are more value on the market to an Irish shareholder than to a foreign shareholder and the tendency is to transfer the ownership—I mean to retain the ownership of the Irish-owned firm in this country and transfer the ownership of a foreign enterprise which is not producing or distributing in this country to the native inhabitants. The difficulty is put quite fairly by the Minister when he says that profit is not the only thing. Capital gets its mixed wage. It gets its profit, convertibility and security. Our difficulty is to give him that. I am out to see that he gets the inducement of that proht, and let me say quite frankly that the profit will not be earned unless there is enterprise behind it. That is the object of it. The idea that you are going to make an artificial permanent present to anybody by doing this is nonsense. If it works at all, capital flows into that enterprise and there is more competition. There has to be more effective machinery of production and, broadly speaking, the pressure of inflowing capital tends again to reduce the rate, so that eventually the man who works hardest, who is the most enterprising, and who puts his heart and brains into the job is the man who will survive.
This will not permanently benefit the slothful and the sluggard. We do not want to discuss in detail these particular provisions. If the Minister will accept, as I think he has accepted, the principle that to whatever extent taxation relief would be effective for the purpose of stimulating Irish industry, to that extent preference and discrimination will be made in favour of Irish enterprise holding Irish capital, that is satisfactory. If the Minister goes so far as to say that he will consider that intention and give so far as possible effect to his own suggestion that capital which is left in a business, for the purpose of expanding it, will have the first preference in the direction of discrimination, that will also be perfectly satisfactory. We simply want to get to-day the principle of taxation discrimination in favour of enterprise employing Irish labour accepted by the Dáil. The detail does not matter. We want the principle of discrimination accepted. I suggest that the Minister could best do that by saying that he will suggest to this Committee, which is to revise the income-tax proposals with more sympathetic consideration, that arrangements should be made for the relief of money which is left in for the purpose of developing plant. I think that is the most effective way it could be done.
Comment on this
In reply to Deputy Flinn, I can only say that I have given some examination to that one aspect of it which I mentioned, and so far as that examination has gone I see no objection to the principle. While I do not want to pledge myself in advance, I promise further sympathetic consideration with a view to early action. I do not want to put it further than that because it has not yet been fully examined.
Comment on this
That assurance is fully satisfactory and with the leave of the House I withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move:—
Before Section 5 to insert a new section as follows:—
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary that may be contained in the Income Tax Act, 1918, as amended by any subsequent Act:—
(a) An Inspector of Taxes shall at the request, in a form to be prescribed by the Revenue Commissioners, of any person assessed or liable to pay Income Tax under Schedule A or Schedule B of the Income Tax Act, 1918, and on payment of a fee prescribed by the Revenue Commissioners issue a certificate showing the amount for the time being due and payable under the said Schedules A and B, or either of them, out of the premises in respect of which the certificate is required.
(b) The Minister for Finance and the Revenue Commissioners shall be bound by such certificate as aforesaid to the extent necessary to release the premises contained therein from any liability to such tax as aforesaid on payment of the amount of tax therein specified and on the bona fide conveyance, assignment or demise for value of the said premises, but without prejudice to the liability of any person other than the purchaser or lessee thereof.
This amendment is put down for the purpose of trying to get rid of an existing anomaly. At present it is very difficult to get property cleared of charges for income tax. Take a case in point, in which property—let us suppose it is called "Ashville"—was involved. When application was made to the income tax people to state exactly how much was due they replied saying that it was, let us say, £100. On the transfer of the property that money was paid, and a year afterwards another application was made in respect of the same property, but it was called another name. That was possibly because the source of information of the income tax people was different from the actual title, or, perhaps, because for convenience they had it described under another name. If a certificate could be given, such as is given in the case of death duties, in this connection it would clear the whole matter up and would make it possible for any portion of the property to be transferred after the payment of duty and the title of the property would be cleared from any further charges. The certificate of discharge from death duties was introduced some years ago and, if a similar certificate were given in this instance, it would be very useful. The amendment suggests that the Revenue Commissioners would draft their own form. If that were done it would simply state that there was no outstanding income tax due in respect of the property hereinafter described. You would have set out in columns the exact extent of the land and a full description of the property, so that no question of confusion could arise and it would mean the saving of a considerable amount of annoyance and difficulty in selling or transferring property.
It should be noticed that this certificate would be very limited. At present the receipt given by the Commissioners is not binding. When an inspector gives a receipt it may, on the face of it, appear to cover the whole situation, but it is not binding or final. This amendment would make it binding and final, and would apply to Government offices the ordinary law which applies to everybody. If a man is asked how much is due to him he sends in his bill and says so much is due. He is bound by that, and if he is paid he is bound by the payment. We can give ample opportunity to the inspector to make full inquiries to find what taxes are due and to supply full details so that the property may be cleared of any further charges. The amendment even does not go so far as to clear all individuals. It only clears the specific property under sub-section (d). If he has any other claims he can make them against other parties.
Comment on this
It is true that difficulties arise in this connection. I have had brought to my notice instances in which purchasers were very seriously mulcted because of taxes being due on property which they were not aware of. In the most serious case that came to my notice it was due to the negligence of the purchaser's solicitor, but there may occur cases where no care on the part of the solicitor would make them safe, or cases in which if the solicitor took care to make them safe, it might hold up the purchase of the property very seriously. The Deputy's amendment does go a little further than the existing provisions in respect of death duties. However, I am impressed by this case. I think that from the drafting point of view I would make certain objections to the Deputy's amendment, but if he would agree to let the matter stand over to the Report Stage, I would consider whether it would not be possible to put down an amendment, perhaps not going exactly as far as the Deputy's but at any rate meeting his point substantially. If there is no agreement on that amendment, we can discuss the Deputy's amendment, but I think I will be able to meet him.
Comment on this
Section 9 proposes to do away with the posting of notices on church gates and to substitute publication in newspapers and in "Irish Oifigiúil."
Comment on this
Amendment 11 to this section, in the name of Deputy Lemass, is out of order because it introduces a new principle into the Bill, the principle of the prohibition of imports.
Comment on this
The section which it is proposed to amend provides for the imposition of a customs tariff on motor cars and motor parts. The intention of the amendment is to effect the same purpose, only to a greater degree, that is the purpose of protecting one particular motor car. The Bill proposes to impose a duty of 33? per cent. on cars and component parts, that is, to impose the amount of protection allowed by an ad valorem duty of 33? per cent. The amendment proposes to extend protection in the case of a particular class of motor bodies, and it can hardly be maintained that it is outside the principle of the Bill. Whether or not the prohibition of the import of any particular article is a matter that can be introduced into a Bill of this nature is another question. I would submit that the principle of restricting the importation of motor cars was contained in the Bill when it passed its Second Reading and that an amendment having a direct relation to that matter would be in order at this stage.
Comment on this
This introduces a principle of far-reaching importance with which the Bill has nothing to do—that is, the prohibition of imports. I suggest to the Deputy that even if the Minister wanted to introduce this principle he could not get it into this Bill.
Comment on this
Is not the principle of the Bill the restriction of imports of motor cars and component parts? If that is the principle, the question of the degree of the restriction to be imposed is, I suggest, in order.
Comment on this
On the section itself, during the debate on the Report Stage of the resolution, some matters concerning this duty were considered and the Minister gave a couple of conditional promises in respect to the matter, one of which he has fulfilled by extending the period of credit for the payment of the duty on motor bodies. The other matter, of course, would be dealt with by an order issued by the Department of Industry and Commerce as successors to the Board of Trade. I would be glad to know if he has discussed the matter with that Department, as promised, and if an order increasing the percentage of the imported article which must be manufactured in England will be issued.
Comment on this
The matter is not finally settled. We have been in correspondence and officials of the two Departments have been meeting to ascertain what increase should be made in the percentage. We have not fixed the point at which it will be raised, but a statement will be issued shortly.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister appreciates the importance of this preferential tariff, because in effect it defeats the original preference given. I have had a case brought before me where a chassis and body in England cost £1,100. If, on the other hand, a foreign chassis is imported into England and has a body put on it costing £400 the actual import duty is only charged at the rate of 22½ per cent on the whole £1,100.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (1), line 34, to add after the words "Public Road" the words "except for journeys from place to place for such agricultural purposes."
Section 12 exempts tractors for agricultural purposes from the motor duty. A tractor, as Deputies know, is used for a great many purposes in agriculture.
It is used for the purpose of threshing on different farms, and in discharging that particular work it has to be taken from farm to farm. In other cases a tractor is used by a group of farmers for different purposes in a particular district. To discharge those uses it has to be taken from one farm to another. This entails the tractor travelling over public roads. The Bill states that the tractor is only exempt from motor car duty provided it is not used on a public road. That means, of course, the uses of the tractors would be very few if they cannot pass over a public road. The suggestion I have to put forward on behalf of those who have drawn my attention to the matter is that the words embodied in the amendment should be added after the words "public road" in line 34. The words are as follow: "except for journeys from place to place for such agricultural purposes." That would make the section in the Act quite clear and would enable the section to help agriculturists. I am sure the Minister will meet those who desire that this section should be amended in that way so as to enable those tractors to discharge the uses for which they are imported. I move accordingly.
Comment on this
The Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that they have powers to effect this administratively because, as a matter of fact, if the Act were read in the strict way that the people who have been speaking to Deputy Good read it, it would mean that the tractor would be exempt so long as it stayed at home and by taking longer routes to the farmer's land it would lose the exemption.
Comment on this
That would be ridiculous and the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that they can do all the Deputy wants done administratively. However, if the Deputy will let this matter stand over I will have it further considered, and if there is any doubt about their power to meet all cases administratively, I will bring in an amendment on the Report Stage. I agree entirely with the purpose.
Comment on this
There is just one point that I would like consideration given to. That is the position of farmers who use light lorries for carrying agricultural produce to the market. I have particularly in mind the district of Rush, Co. Dublin. Lorries are very extensively in use by the farmers there for bringing products to the Dublin markets early in the morning. At the present moment they feel that the tax on the lorry is an excessive burden on them. Owing to the improvement in the roads that made them more suitable for motor transport, the farmers complain that they are restricted to the use of motor transport. Formerly all their produce was brought in on horse-drawn vehicles and a good deal of it comes in very early in the morning. The difficulty now is that they cannot use horses because in the early morning, particularly in winter and spring, the roads are so slippery that they cannot get the horses to travel. They are restricted, therefore, to the use of the motor lorry. The horses, of course, are not taxed. By the deliberate policy of the Government in improving the roads, those men have been compelled to use the light lorries much against their will and they feel that in view of the particular circumstances in that district they ought to be exempt from this particular tax.
That refers to Rush only, but I am sure there are other districts in the country equally affected. I feel the Minister ought to give some consideration to the question whether it would not be possible for him to exempt these light lorries.
Comment on this
Exactly, if you like; but if there is any other Deputy who wishes to reap the advantage of my initiative in the matter, I am perfectly prepared to let him have it free of cost, and let him reap whatever advantages there may be. It is, however, a matter that should be considered.
Comment on this
In my capacity as an agriculturist I have been engaged recently in experiments which involved the use of motor lorries in combination with threshing machines. The idea was to combine the two. It seems to me in this case the threshing machine would be an agricultural implement, but in so far as some of it is raw material, it would be liable to this tax. The point I am making is that there may be similar cases of that kind in which lorries and lorry chassis are used for the purpose of part of an agricultural implement. I suggest the Minister should study the question of exempting them.
Comment on this
I will see if there are any other further cases to be considered. I am afraid the particular plea made by Deputy MacEntee would carry us very far. It would be impossible to confine it to his constituency. He will see that, and he will also see that it would be very difficult to confine it to farmers' lorries. Generally, I am afraid it would be a question of abandoning the tax on lorries altogether. If there are any chassis imported for use otherwise than simply as part of road vehicles, they are in a different category, and I would consider whether there were any other vehicles that ought to be treated somewhat as the tractors are treated. I am afraid the ordinary road vehicles cannot be considered.
Comment on this
I move amendment 13:
In sub-section (1), line 37, to delete the word "or" and substitute therefor the word "and."
This is purely a drafting amendment to make the wording of the section more clear. It is at the moment slightly obscure.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 14:
In sub-section (3), line 56, to insert immediately before the words "a component" the word "to."
This is also a drafting amendment to remove a possible ambiguity.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
To insert before Section 15 a new section as follows:—
"(1) There shall be allowed in respect of beer brewed in Saorstát Eireann on or after the 1st day of June, 1928, the following rebate from the Excise duty now payable in respect thereof, that is to say:—
In the case of beer brewed by a brewer for sale, for every thirty-six gallons of beer of whatever original gravity charged with duty and delivered from the brewery, a rebate of one pound, or where the duty now payable in respect of thirty-six gallons of any beer so charged and delivered is less than two pounds four shillings, a rebate equal to the amount by which that duty exceeds the sum of one pound four shillings; and so in proportion for any less quantity.
(2) The Excise drawback now payable on the exportation of any beer or on the deposit thereof in a warehouse for exportation from Saorstát Eireann as merchandise or for ship's stores shall unless it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that no rebate has been allowed in respect of that beer under this section be reduced by an amount equal to the amount of the rebate allowable under this section in respect thereof.
This sub-section shall be deemed to have had effect as from the 1st day of June, 1928.
(3) The Revenue Commissioners may make such regulations as they consider necessary for the purpose of carrying this section into effect, and in particular for the purpose of facilitating and controlling the calculation of the amount of the rebate to be allowed under this section and with respect to the method of computing the quantity of the beer in respect of which rebate is to be allowed."
In moving the amendment I do so with a full sense of my responsibility and a full regard of the position of the Government from the point of view of national revenue. I am convinced that in the best interests of the country the time has arrived when even possibly with a certain element of risk of revenue that some relief should be given to the two great industries which the Free State has. I have no interest in the licensed trade—good, bad or indifferent—and my sole reason for coming along with this amendment is to do what I think is right. Two years ago a similar amendment was moved, and while it got a good deal of support from all parts of the House, some who spoke in favour of it afterwards voted against it, and it was defeated by 33 votes to 17. The situation in regard to these industries and all connected with them has advanced very considerably since then, and not, I regret to say, in a direction favourable to either of the industries. I believe the stage has now been reached when something must be done to check the destruction which is taking place.
In his Budget statement the Minister stated there is a falling-off of over £100,000 in the duty compared with beer duty for the previous year. But as he was only dealing with revenueraising his reference only came up to the end of December last, owing to the three months brewer's credit which has now lasted for some years. But what are the facts? If we compare the six months ending 31st March last with the six months ending 31st March, 1927, we find a falling-off of 104,292 barrels in the quantity of beer retained for home consumption, or a reduction in revenue of £521,460. The decline has been taking place each year since 1923, but the most significant drop has been in the six months referred to. I take it, as an indication of the future and a warning to the Minister, that if he persists in keeping the beer duty on at the present level, this source of revenue to the State will be very largely dried up in the near future.
I know I will be told that revenue must be got, but I do submit that in my considered judgment it is an unwise course to pursue that. Because a certain amount of money must be obtained by a certain time, in order to get money you will be putting upon one particular industry such a strain as to endanger its very existence. But there is another argument in favour of relief, and it is that a reduction in duty will naturally be followed by a reduction in price to the consumer. In view of certain remarks made by a Deputy two years ago to the effect that he would oppose relief in duty because the public would not get the benefit of it, I have made it my business to find out if this would be the case, and I am in a position to state that if there is relief, the public will get the benefit of it. It is reasonable to assume also that there will be a corresponding increase in the output also, and the loss of revenue would not be anything like that anticipated, for you would be helping industry and employment. I am also inclined to the view, bearing in mind the alarming drop in the six months up to the end of March last, that there will possibly be a bigger falling-off in revenue by keeping the duty at its present rate than there would be by having the rate of duty brought down to that which obtains in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. I am only asking for the same duties as in Great Britain and Northern Ireland.
During the past few years several of the smaller breweries have been closed down. We all know what a blow it was to employment when D'Arcy's, the oldest brewery in Dublin, was forced to close its doors a little over a year ago. It may be stated that these concerns would go to the wall in any case, and that mass capital and mass production would squeeze them out. I do not hold with this view at all, and I am convinced if the beer duty were reduced in the Saorstát when the concession of 24/- a barrel was made in Great Britain and Northern Ireland in 1923, that Murphy's in Clonmel, the Castlebellingham Brewery in Louth, Egan's of Tullamore, D'Arcy's in Dublin, Cassidy's at Monasterevan, and others which were great sources of wealth and employment, would still be working. When one bears in mind that before the European War the duty on a barrel of beer stood at 7/9 and that this duty now stands at £5, it is easy, to me at all events, to understand the great falling off in revenue which has taken place and the alarming collapse which has taken place in the last six months of the financial year. I do not know why some Deputies in the House have just sneered at this matter. I wonder why they sneer, because I can assure these Deputies that those engaged in the trade are engaged in a legitimate trade. They are all men of the highest character. If they were not men of the highest character they would not get a licence. It is not an occasion to sneer at men whose means of livelihood are threatened, men who have put their all into the business believing that they would get the protection that all other trades are entitled to get, and now when there are efforts made to squeeze them out, not by the Government but by the banking system of to-day, I think it is unfair for any Deputy in this House to sneer at the proposal which I have suggested.