We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

FINANCE BILL, 1928—THIRD STAGE.

Contributions 145–277 of 277. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1928
Enacted

No. 14 of 1928 ›

Would the Deputy explain why these gentlemen reduced the bottle of stout from 8d. to 6d. within the last month?

Comment on this

I have nothing to explain. I say that they are engaged in a trade in which they pay licence duty and that before they got that licence their character had to be investigated. The character of the men in the licensed trade can compare with the character of any men in this House. I say that these men and their families are not people who should be sneered at by any section in this House. In moving this amendment, I am merely asking that those traders in the Saorstát should be put in the same position as are the traders in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. I move the amendment, and I hope the Minister will be a little more sympathetic towards it than some of the Deputies in the House at present appear to be.

Comment on this
Vincent Rice Mr. RICE

As the mover of this amendment has stated, a motion in similar terms was brought before the House two years ago. It was practically in identical terms. The matter was then discussed at some length. I find that on that occasion the Minister for Finance stated: "The production of beer in this country is not falling to pieces; the brewing industry is a prosperous industry. There may have been some decline, but at present it is a prosperous industry." I suggest that the Minister is not in a position to-day to repeat the statement he made in 1926. Deputy Byrne has quoted figures showing the immence decline in revenue derived from this source since 1926. On that occasion one of the speakers in favour of the amendment stated that if the existing duties were to continue there was no reason why the revenue should not continue to decrease. We know now from the figures before us that the revenue has immensely decreased from that time. I should like to know on what ground the reduction is refused. Is it on the grounds that it is necessary to keep up the present duty in order to raise revenue, or is it on the ground—which I think some Deputies are in favour of—that it is in aid of the advance of temperance? Some Deputies are not old enough to remember it, but others of us may remember that there was an immense change in the habits of the people as regards temperance long before the duties on beer and spirits were increased. I can remember distinctly the nineties, when there was a considerable amount of drunkenness in the country, a degree of drunkenness which perhaps any thinking person would have to feel rather ashamed of. But that has changed very considerably. I saw some places in the years before the duties were increased, prior to the war, where there was an immense change. That was not owing to any increase in price, but not owing to an improvement in the habits of the people, a change as regards education and a change amongst them in their feelings of self-respect.

I do suggest to those who advocate the keeping up of these duties as an aid to temperance that they are wholly unnecessary as an aid to temperance. Even if the decrease that is now asked for is given there will be very little temptation to any person, except to people who are very rich, to drink more than is good for them. Deputy Byrne has referred to one aspect of this question, namely, to the closing down of numbers of breweries and distilleries. That is an aspect of the question which I do commend to the serious consideration of Deputies. This is an industry which did give an enormous amount of employment, and a great deal of that employment has now disappeared. It has been going steadily year after year, and as has been stated, in the last five years, five breweries have been closed down. Ten years ago there were in the whole of Ireland twenty-two distilleries carrying on, twelve of which were in the Saorstát and ten in Northern Ireland. What is the position to-day? No doubt it will be pointed out that, despite the decrease of duties in Northern Ireland, the number of distilleries there has decreased. That is true. As we know, the duties in Northern Ireland have been reduced in the same way as they were reduced in England. That is to say, a reduction has been made on the peak war duties; but no reduction has been made here. What is the result? I think it is a fair inference that this is the result: While in Northern Ireland 50 per cent. of these distilleries are going, three-fourths of those in the Saorstát have closed down under that policy. I do suggest to the House that a fair inference to be drawn from that is that these enormous duties that are kept on in this State are causing the closing down of the distilleries and breweries at a rate altogether out of proportion to what is happening elsewhere. I submit that for these reasons, and having regard to the existing amount of unemployment in this country, it is not for this House, in pursuing the shadowy cause of increased temperance—which I think is an unsound argument—to cause increased unemployment, and for that reason I would suggest that this reduction should be given so as to keep alive the industries that we have.

Comment on this
Timothy Sheehy Mr. T. SHEEHY (West Cork) Cumann na nGaedheal

I rise to support the appeal of Deputy Byrne and Deputy Rice. I am a licensed vintner of fifty years standing, and I proclaim, on behalf of the members of that profession, that we are as honourable, as straightforward and as good citizens of the Saorstát as any other section in the community. We do not come here for charity; we come here for justice and for fair play. In the year 1915 Mr. Lloyd George, in the zenith of his power and in his anxiety to build up in Great Britain industries like Bass's ale and Scotch whiskey, closed down and dismantled our breweries and distilleries and sent 17,000 families into the workhouses of Ireland. What did he do that for? He did it simply to wipe out an industry that was forging its way ahead and holding its own all over, the world. At the Golden Gate of San Francisco and down on the other side of Hong Kong a bottle of Irish whiskey or a bottle of Irish stout is appreciated and looked for, and if the Government had the courage to sustain these two great industries they might rest assured that the export trade would pull up the leeway for them. No alcohol manufactured all over the world has a greater fame or name than Irish whiskey and stout. Are we here, in cold blood, going to wipe that out, simply because there are extreme temperance men here and there all over the country crying: "Away with the publican; away with the distilleries; away with the breweries"? Well, then, I say, as an honest proposition to them, that if they are satisfied in their hearts that the Saorstát will be saved by having prohibition let them, in God's name, advocate that. We in the trade will have no objection to it. We will proclaim that we are as good Irishmen and as ready to come to the assistance of the country as anyone else. But we demand justice, and we look on our interests in our licensed houses in the same way as the farmer looks on his land.

I was put into a public-house in my twenty-first year by my father, who believed that he was giving me a property with which I would earn an honest living, and I have earned it. Never from the day that I took up the key of my public-house did I get a summons for a breach of the Licensing Acts. My story is the story of thousands of vintners all over the country. I am not speaking now of the vintners in Dublin, who are well able to speak for themselves. I say that the vintners are honest and honourable men, that they are conscientious men, and that they are men who will serve nobody who comes into their houses under the influence of drink. There may be a few black sheep. Is there any flock without black sheep? Why, then, should an honourable and an honest trade be victimised because a few men break the law? I appeal to the Minister for Finance to rise to the situation, to have courage, to make a bold stroke and grant a reduction in the prices of beer and spirits. If he does, the farmer, the artisan, the fisherman and the labourer will appreciate it. He will be coming to the rescue of men who cannot have seven-course dinners. What they want is a legitimate bottle of stout at their tables. They are satisfied with that, and if the Minister lessens the price and gives them that he need not be a bit afraid in his conscience that he will be promoting intemperance.

Comment on this

Like my friend Deputy Sheehy, I am a publican too. I was called to the bar when I was 26. Not very long ago, in another place, I pressed the Minister very hard, but it was put to me by the Minister for Finance, whether I would rather see a poor child suffering 1½d. in the £ on tea and sugar for a reduction in the duty on stout. The Minister beat me. I can see by the attitude of the House that there is no hope. I could see by the attitude in another place that there was no hope of a reduction this year. But I think, after all, that we are not getting fair play. Mr. Lloyd George, bad as he was when he slaughtered the trade——

Comment on this
Mr. SHEEHY

He failed.

Comment on this

—reduced the licence duty during those years, but our friend, the Minister for Finance, did not do any such thing. He is like a lion looking for money everywhere he can get it. I suppose he wants it. What I would like to see—but there is no hope of getting it, I fear, when I see the humorous mood in which the Dáil treated Deputy Byrne's amendment— would be a change in the licensing law. I did not ask for a reduction in the duty on whiskey. I pointed out that stout was the food of the working man, but I found that even then I had not the killing fly. In a short time—a few months hence—some of the publicans will be eliminated and the remainder will have to pay for their passage out of public life. In every other grade of society in this country if such a thing occurred, for instance, in the case of the farmers, would payment of the compensation be confined to the remainder? What is the cause of the publicans being bought out at all? It is said that it is for the betterment of the nation. Perhaps it is. If it is let the nation pay for it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The Deputy is going a long way from the amendment. If he is going to discuss the compensation clauses of the Intoxicating Liquor Act he is going a long way from the amendment.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I went outside the amendment, but this concerns compensation. I must come back to the poor child again. We are face to face with it, and I am sure the Minister for Finance will not forget it when winding up. At least he will give no reduction. As I pointed out a few moments ago, I stressed the case very hard, not on behalf of the man who would take a glass of whiskey, but on the part of the workman who would want a pint of porter. After all, he is only passing through this life and is entitled to some luxuries while here, as well as the rich man. That is not considered, however. He has plenty of water to drink, but the stout and the whiskey can remain to be drunk by the men with money. I do not think there is any use continuing. I will stress the case no further, but I will express my deep sympathy with the object which moved Deputy Byrne to come along with his amendment. At the same time, I think if it is at all possible, now or in the near future, the Minister for Finance should not forget to reduce the duty on stout. I will not go any further as far as drink is concerned, because I consider whiskey is a luxury.

Comment on this

I wish to support the amendment moved by Deputy Byrne. We have two main industries, distilling and brewing, and as we all know very well, they are decaying. As a result great unemployment exists. We have heard Deputies in all parties discussing unemployment and how to relieve it. The two industries, distilling and brewing, employed a large number of men. To-day there are not half the number employed in these industries that were formerly employed. The taxation that was put on beer was war taxation, I think it is £5 a barrel. It still continues, and I think there is no hope of getting a reduction in this year's Finance Bill from the Minister, because he stated that if he took the tax off beer he must put it on the necessaries of life. Well, if the Minister takes the tax off beer he has a staff of able civil servants who, I am sure, could find other articles that come into this country to tax, so as to give relief to the workingman who always drinks stout. Instead of trying to do something for the poor man the whole burden of taxation is being placed on his shoulders. Sugar is costing 1/4d. per lb. more than it cost formerly, and the price of stout remains the same. Stout is food for the workingman. I think if the Minister could see his way he should give a reduction in the duty on stout, and get revenue from articles coming into the country which, if made here, would give employment.

Comment on this
Joseph X. Murphy Mr. J.F.X. MURPHY Independent

I would like to support the amendment. I think the House realises that the Minister is not in a position to do anything this year, and that the amendment is moved more with a view to urging him to look into the matter next year, and to try to give some relief to the distilleries and the breweries. Deputy Daly and another Deputy urged a reduction in the price of stout. I think the case of whiskey is just as important. I do not think that anyone wants to encourage too much drinking, but a slight reduction in the duty on whiskey would enable people to have an occasional glass of whiskey. As I said, I do not think the Minister can do anything this year, but the President, when addressing the Chamber of Commerce last week, indicated that something might be done in the future.

Comment on this

Deputy Murphy and Deputy Daly have made it plain that this is a sham fight. Although I am sorry to disagree with Deputy Byrne and the other Deputies there is one fact worth looking into. If we take off this tax we must put on some other tax to make up for the loss of revenue. Will not the putting on of almost any tax lead to unemployment? Because it will do one of two things, either tax an existing industry or it will increase the cost of living. Would Deputy Byrne be willing to re-impose the duty on tea in order to allow for the removal of the duty on beer and stout? Is that a tenable proposition?

Comment on this

Other articles could be taxed.

Comment on this

What other articles would bring in revenue amounting to hundreds of thousands of pounds?

Comment on this

Ladies' handbags.

Comment on this

Cement.

Comment on this

Ladies handbags! I think the sacrifice in revenue effected by the amendment would come to £150,000. Deputy Vaughan will have to qualify as a pickpocket in order to get £150,000 from ladies' handbags. There would have to be an increase in taxation and I do not know what luxuries that could be taxed would make up for the loss of revenue involved here.

In other words industry will suffer. To relieve unemployment in the brewing and distilling industry you are to create unemployment in other industries. It has often been said, and I believe with accuracy, that in proportion to the capital invested, and the output of the industry, the amount of labour employed in the brewing and distilling industry shows the lowest percentage of any industry in the State. I should like to say that this is a most respectable industry. I am not a prohibitionist, and I agree with Deputy Daly in what he said about the publicans. They are the licensed trade. They are honourable, fair-dealing, conscientious men. They are also wise men. Most of them are teetotallers; they know too much about what they sell. But it comes to this: that you are to relieve unemployment and to assist an industry that gives the least employment proportionately and put the burden on another industry that gives more employment—the farming industry. I do not often hear Deputy Vaughan speaking, but I have heard other farmers saying that all the taxation was levied off the farmer. There is an element of truth in it. I suppose some farmer's wives even use handbags. But I am quite sure that there is no means of raising the substantial amount of revenue that would be required by this amendment without imposing some new tax. If it were possible to do it without imposing fresh taxation, I should be in favour of it. I agree that the existing scale of duties on liquor is high and was imposed as a war measure, but it cannot be done this year. I do not believe it can be done next year, and there is no use in raising false hopes that can never be realised.

Comment on this

I wish to support this amendment. I quite understand that it is only to get an expression of opinion from the House as to whether it should be put into effect this year or not. Those of us in the trade realise the position we are in. While the Minister for Finance may find it very difficult to raise the money that he would lose by reducing the taxes on beer and spirits, the time will come next year when he will find himself in a predicament, as the decrease in revenue from this source will be double what it is this year. Even if it is not possible to reduce the taxes on beer and spirits this year, I suggest to the Minister the advisability of looking into the question of the hours of opening of public houses. Traders in the seaside resorts, for instance, find themselves at present at a great disadvantage owing to the hours of opening, and the people visiting these resorts also are not speaking in very high terms of the restrictions imposed. These people after travelling long distances arrive in these places at 11 or 12 o'clock on a Sunday and find they cannot get any refreshment until after 1 o'clock. Then in the evening the licensed houses are closed at 8 o'clock and the people cannot get any refreshments after that hour. If the Minister cannot see his way to do anything by way of reducing the taxes on beer and spirits, he can come to the aid of the vintners by regulating the hours to suit the people. If he did that, it would alleviate to some extent the grievances of those who are trying to make a living by the trade.

People talk about the employment given by the trade. Do they realise the employment that is given to porters, shop assistants and others? After all, licensed traders are not the worst people in the country. When subscriptions are needed for charities, or for public amusements, such as racing, the men they look to for the big subscriptions are the vintners. People may laugh at what I say, but you will find some of these people when they come for a subscription to a publican saying: "We will look after your interests next year; we will see that the Executive will give you better hours, and that the pint can be sold for sixpence." That is the sort of camouflage that is used when the publican is asked for a subscription of £20 or £50. Even though the grievance we have at present cannot be taken into account on the Finance Bill, I think the Minister for Justice will be doing the right thing if he could see his way to give some concession in regard to the trading hours.

Comment on this

I think everybody will agree with Deputy Cooper that there is nothing in this but a sham fight, that if the Whips are put on the Deputies on the other side are going to go into the Lobby very definitely against the amendment. As far as we on this side are concerned, we are quite straightforward. We have decided, as a Party, that we, at any rate, will go into the Lobby against it, and we will go as a solid body. We have very carefully considered the whole question. The first argument that naturally occurs to us in connection with it is, if this reduction is granted, how are we to make up the alternative taxation? Can anybody suggest any alternative that is not very much less desirable than the present taxation? If reliefs were to be given, is there anyone who would not say that it would be better to give these reliefs, for example, in increasing the old age pension, as we were unable to do to the extent we required recently, or give relief even in tobacco? I mention these as just the first things that occur to me. But to speak of the reduction of the liquor taxes at the same time that there is a question of increasing the tax on sugar is surely ridiculous. There is nobody who really considers the national interest who will think of agreeing to this amendment.

You must get an alternative, as I said. The only way in which an alternative would be avoided would be if there was an increase in consumption to make up for the deficiency created by the diminution of the tax. I think it is most unlikely that there would be such an increase in consumption as would make up the difference. But are we prepared to face an increase in consumption? Do we want an increase in consumption? Would it be wise for us to take steps that would lead to an increase in the consumption of liquor, either from a social or national standpoint? I do not think there is anybody who seriously examines this who will, apart from making speeches about it, vote for this particular amendment.

As to the question of relief, the argument put up is that it would benefit the workingman. It is very questionable whether these reliefs, if granted, will be passed on to the workingman. We know from past experience that, in fact, in the case of relief of that kind it has not been passed on to the workingman. Recently beer is not as cheap as it could be made if there was not the amount of profiteering that was going on. That is revealed by a circular which, I believe, every Deputy has got showing that this diminution of 24/- in the barrel would amount to a penny on the pint of stout, and would be passed on and something more. That does not seem as if they were very hard pressed at the present moment. Regarding the industry from the national standpoint, as Deputy Cooper remarked already, there is scarcely any industry which employs less labour comparatively, that there is per unit of labour less capital in, and that gives less aid to the fundamental agricultural industry in the country. I think there is no real case made out for the decrease of the duties on that basis.

We also think it is an industry which ultimately is going to go down, and it would be most unwise—and that is why I felt from the beginning that at this moment it would be unwise—to give any encouragement to people by holding out hopes to them that there is going to be any improvement in the future. So far as our Party is concerned, I am perfectly certain that neither are we going to support an amendment of this kind now nor so long as there are social services requiring expenditure which must be met, and met as far as possible without putting a further burden on the indirect taxpayer, such as a sugar tax upon the portion of the community least able to bear it. As to the falling off in trade, is not that due mostly to the falling off in exports? We have had this thing examined, and examined as impartially as we could. We had a Committee that was not by any means a temperance committee. They got circulars, and they made inquiries both from those who are temperance advocates and, also, from the trade interests, and we got a report, the main terms of which I am explaining now. One of the items in the report was that this falling off was due mainly to the falling off in export. Consequently it would not be made up, and it is most unlikely that it can be made up, by an increase in home consumption. As for the falling off of the small breweries throughout the country, is it not a fact that what is happening is that the big breweries and distilleries are capturing all the trade of the smaller breweries and distilleries by the centralisation process and superior equipment and so on? They are just doing that in a way that was held out yesterday as if it were an admirable thing. I myself regret it. I, for one, think we could very well lose by this over centralisation, and lose in ways on which it is hard to put one's finger, but there are really ultimate losses to the community by centralising in ways of that particular kind. We can pay too big a price for this so-called efficiency in mass production and standardisation which are associated with big businesses in America and elsewhere. I thought, perhaps, there might be some amendments coming forward that would put a graded tax on beer, particularly in favour, perhaps, of the lighter beer and in favour, if it could be managed, of the local breweries and consumers of home barley.

I am not going to express the opinion, because generally I try to speak only when I am expressing the Party's view on matters of this kind. I am not going to express what would be the Party's attitude, but there would be some consideration at any rate given to a proposal of that particular kind, but this proposal seems to us to be altogether unreasonable under present conditions.

There is another thing which I wish to say before I sit down. The spirit and beer interest and the liquor interests generally are strongly organised in this country; they are a menace politically to political parties in this country and I want to say on behalf of those on these Benches, that we will support anybody, no matter what Party or Government, that will stand up against things of that particular kind. We are prepared to stand up against it ourselves and we are prepared to assist anybody to prevent interests of that kind having it in their power to make and unmake Governments. We think nothing could be worse for the country than that that should happen. We have considered this matter very carefully and we believe it would be altogether wrong and unjustifiable from any standpoint and that it would be from the point of view of the national interests the worst possible thing that could happen. Thinking of it at the same time as a tax on sugar continues in effect, it is almost unthinkable.

Comment on this

This motion or motions like it have been before the House on many occasions. They have always been supported by two different sets of arguments. We have been told on certain occasions that there would be no loss of revenue, that the consumption would increase, and that the Exchequer would lose nothing. That particular argument is not correct. There was a reduction of the beer duty in England in 1923-24 and the result of that was, roughly, this: That there was an increase of slightly over 10 per cent. in consumption, but there was a decreased duty yielding about 18 per cent. I believe, if this amendment were passed, there might be an increase of 10 per cent. in the consumption, and if there was that increase of 10 per cent in the consumption the amount the Exchequer would lose would be £450,000. As far as I can come to a conclusion, I believe that the passage of this amendment would mean to the Exchequer a loss of £450,000 which would have to be made up in taxation on articles of necessity, because you cannot get a sum as large as £450,000 by the taxation of handbags or any sort of luxury. You must go to some articles of common and general use in order to get it.

There were people when the amendment was previously put forward who accepted the fact that it would mean a loss of revenue, but said that for social reasons we ought to face up to the loss of revenue and impose fresh taxation. It seems to me that there is really only one difficulty in this matter, and that is that the consumption of alcoholic liquor has declined at an exceedingly rapid rate. As far as I am concerned, I am glad to see that decline in the consumption of alcoholic liquor. I think the country has benefited by it, and will benefit by it. I think a great change for the better has taken place in comparatively recent years, but the continuance of this decline does undoubtedly cause a great deal of dislocation. It means that people who have made a respectable and legitimate livelihood in business are finding, after spending many years at this business, that it is difficult if not impossible to continue to make a livelihood at it.

There is also this factor about it, that while a year or two ago we thought that the consumption of alcoholic liquor had been almost stabilised and that the decline, if it continued, would be very slow, I must say that in such circumstances I could see no necessity for giving very serious consideration to this whole matter. As it stands, I do think it merits very serious consideration. I would go this far with Deputy de Valera at least, that there is no chance that I can see this year, or the year after, of any such amendment as this being passed. If it were possible to do something, it could only be done on a much more moderate scale than is suggested. While I think that there is very little drunkenness in the country, and that a small increase in the consumption of alcoholic liquor would do little or no harm, I would not like to see any substantial increase in consumption. I would not like to see an increase of 25 per cent. or less. I would rather see no increase, but I think it would be a good thing if it were possible by any adjustment of taxation—I do not know whether it would be possible or not—but if it were possible, I think it would be a good thing to reduce the comparatively great rapidity of the decline, so that the people in the various businesses might adjust themselves to the new conditions, and so that there might not be the losses, the heart-breakings and the upset that are involved where any big trade or industry suddenly loses its prosperity.

I am giving my own view on that matter to the House quite frankly. I do not deplore the decline in the consumption. I am not anxious to see an increase in consumption, but I do think that the great rapidity with which the change has taken place has involved very great hardships on individuals which they could not foresee, and I think that a continuance of that decline will involve very great and very serious hardships to many more individuals. Whatever we may think of the particular change that is taking place in the country and in the habits of the people, we must, I think, have regard to such factors as I have indicated. It is our duty to try and see that any dislocation that takes place will do the least possible injury to any respectable class of people who have been carrying on a legitimate and proper business.

So far as the beer duty is concerned, I would be inclined to agree with Deputy de Valera, that if we were giving relief it would probably be desirable to try and give some discrimination in favour of the lighter beers, although that is not what the people interested in the trade here have demanded at all. I think there would be a good deal to be said for that, but the present position in regard to brewing is this: That a great deal more beer is brewed here than is required for the consumption of the people. It is possible, in one sense, to say that the brewing industry is comparatively prosperous. Undoubtedly, a number of small breweries have ceased to operate. That has been largely due to the fact that they have been unable to compete with the big industry which exists here in Dublin. The decline in consumption has affected them, but if there had been no decline in consumption at all, I think that many of the small breweries would have found themselves in great difficulties.

So far as distilleries are concerned, what has happened there is that for one reason and another the distilleries here have very largely lost their export market. In some ways they have great difficulties to contend with. They manufacture a special article by a special process. Their competitors produce the other article by a much cheaper process, and have a margin for advertising and pushing and popularising their wares, that the Irish distilleries have not. During the war certain circumstances also, I think, gave an advantage to the distilleries using the patent still process, but before that, as a matter of fact, Irish whiskey had very largely lost its export market. I think that they can recover it only in one way and that is by trying to make an article of superlative excellence and to cater for a special trade. It will not be able to compete with the article made by the cheaper process for exactly the same market. No concession that we could give would restore the prosperity of the distilling industry here. That can only come about by a very substantial recovery of the export market. If the consumption of whiskey here was increased by 33? per cent., it would not make the distilling industry prosperous or even comparatively prosperous. It would, of course, be an advantage to the distilleries, but it would not put them as it were on their feet at all. They must look for their salvation to regaining the export market.

I do not agree with Deputy de Valera as to the publicans and the people who are engaged in the manufacture of beer and whiskey constituting a danger to the political life of the country. Undoubtedly the people who are engaged in that trade do desire and press for remissions of taxation that would be advantageous to them in their business. That is done by all sorts of interests, but anybody who has observed both the fact that the liquor taxes have been maintained here at their pre-war level, and the fact that licensing legislation has been introduced here which very substantially tightened up the code—when they see that happening on the one hand, and when they see the other political party in the State taking the line of action that Deputy de Valera indicated himself to-day, I do not think it can be contended that there is any danger that the political life of the country or the public affairs of the country are going to be dominated by this trade. I cannot speak very well from personal experience myself, but I believe there was a time when the liquor trade had, perhaps, too much influence in the political life of the country. Changed times have done away with all that, and therefore I do not think there is any need for us, in considering this matter, to consider it with any animus in our minds against that trade, or any feeling that we must defeat it lest we increase the power of that trade. I do not think that the passing of these amendments or any changes would have the effect of increasing the power of that trade so as to make it dangerous. It has undoubtedly fallen on very evil times. I do not think that there is the slightest chance that it will dominate the political life of the country and bend the institutions of the State to its will.

I think that we can face this whole matter of liquor duties simply as an economic and financial problem. It is first a financial problem in the narrower sense because we must get revenue. If we reduce these liquor duties, we lose substantially in our taxation. I have always argued in this House that it is not possible to reduce the liquor duties and put, say, fresh taxation on tea or sugar. That is the financial problem. It is extremely difficult to do anything, and as a matter of fact if anything were to be done it could only be by way of something that would prevent a rapid decline in this trade. I think it would be fair and reasonable to aim at that, something that would induce an element of stability, but I admit that is difficult.

That is one aspect of the matter. If we look at the economic situation the question is, what is the importance of this industry? It has capital that has linked up in it employment. So far as its prospects are concerned, these depend on the recovery and extension of its export trade. I think there is every hope these two industries will continue to bring very substantial sums into the country. We should not lightly turn down any possibilities of giving them some assistance or relief. I say that because I think there is a slight tendency, as I think Deputy Byrne or Deputy Daly said, to treat this matter with levity. There is a certain tendency to think that the matter does not merit consideration. I think it does, but it is full of difficulties. It is sometimes supported with arguments that make it difficult for one to treat it quite fairly. If a man asks for the imposition of fresh duties on necessities and at the same time speaks pathetically about the fact that the workingman cannot get a glass of whiskey it is rather hard to take that quite seriously. We must admit it is not as necessary that whiskey should be cheap as that tea or sugar or other articles of common necessity should be cheap. From the public point of view a tax on liquor is preferable to a tax on any of those necessities. If we are to find support for the liquor trade we must find it on other grounds, such as the grounds of mitigating the dislocation that occurs through the sudden collapse of trade or industry, and the unemployment dislocation that might occur if there were a further serious decline. As to the policy of looking forward from the point of view of revenue, we have to realise that while some concession to the liquor trade would mean an immediate drop in revenue, the effect of that immediate drop might be rather to fix the revenue at a specified point, whereas if we decline to make any concession the revenue might continue to decline year after year, and might fall very substantially below that specified point. That is a matter we have to consider.

The concession given in England seems to have had this effect so far as beer is concerned, that it practically stabilises consumption. While the figures for the last couple of years have not been comparable, as credit was shortened and introduced a disturbing factor, the position seems to be that the reduction of one pound per barrel stabilised consumption and left it practically where it was. Suppose this was worthy of consideration, we cannot attempt it. I do not see any way at the moment of giving a concession to liquor people, but leaving that out of account, I think there would be a great deal to be said, with the consumption of liquors so low comparatively, and having regard to the fact that there is no drunkenness worth talking about at present, for stabilising revenue at the existing point. By stabilisation I do not mean fixing it permanently at that point, but fixing it so as to check the comparatively rapid decline that has been going on. There is no possibility of accepting the amendment. If the Dáil were to pass the amendment the position would be very serious, and would, I think, involve very great hardships because of the methods that would have to be adopted to meet it. I cannot hold out any definite hope to Deputy Byrne, except to this extent, that up to this year I thought the consumption was somewhat stabilised, and that any decline that might take place would be a gradual one to which we need pay no particular attention. Last year's figures seemed to indicate that that hope was not justified. I admit that the matter has now reached a point where it merits careful consideration, but, frankly, I do not see at the moment where the means are to be found of giving it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister take into consideration the advisability of extending the hours during the summer time for the tourists?

Comment on this

I do not know anything about that.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister whether he or his Department has considered the question of protecting, as far as home consumption is concerned, Irish spirits? We do not wish anybody to encourage the drinking of either beer or stout, but we think that if beer and stout are being drunk, it should be either Irish beer or stout.

Comment on this

We had that under consideration. Certain people proposed to us that we should have a differentiating duty. That is, Excise duty and Customs duty apart from certain allowances are the same, and it was suggested that the Customs duty should be increased above the Excise duty. On the other hand, others interested in the trade pointed out to us, what we believe to be the fact, that the only hope of any recovery in distilling was in the recovery of the export market. They said that even if there was no retaliation tax in Great Britain, the fact that it was published abroad that Scotch whiskey was penalised here would result in the creation of a certain feeling there which would make it more difficult to recover the market. There is a view abroad that the law gives preference to Scotch whiskey. That is not so. Irish whiskey can be sold at the same strength as Scotch whiskey, but the distillers for reasons of their own prefer it being sold at the present strength.

Comment on this

The reason for doing that is that they manufacture spirit at a certain strength which is typical of the spirit. They would change its whole quality by reducing it to the level of the Scotch and imported whiskey; in fact there is on that very account a preference being given to the Scotch whiskey. It works out at a preference in favour of the Scotch whiskey.

Comment on this

It does not. Both spirits are manufactured at a greater strength than they are sold, and are actually bonded at very much greater strength. When they are ready for sale they reduce the Irish to 25 underproof, and the Scotch to 30 underproof. It may be that the character of the Irish spirit would be destroyed or altered if they were to reduce it to the Scotch level. I do not know, but I believe there is a certain difference of opinion in regard to that. We have several times been in conference with the distilling trade, and it has not been put to us, for instance, that we should prohibit the selling of any whiskey at any weaker strength than 25 underproof.

That would be a possible thing, but it has not been put up to us. What we have done heretofore is that we increased the maturing period from three to five years. As a matter of fact, that had a certain effect on checking the importation of Scotch whiskey. which normally would not be kept beyond three years. Owing to the process of its manufacture it does not benefit by being kept beyond that time. On the other hand, Irish whiskey has to be kept longer. It ought to be kept seven years, and we would propose, probably later on, an increase in the maturing period of Irish whiskey from five to seven and, perhaps, nine years. That is a matter that has been under consideration. That destroys a certain advantage which Scotch whiskey has had up to the present. Many brands of Irish whiskey are kept for nine years. There is an actual loss of spirits and there are costs involved through keeping whiskey in bond for nine years. Up to the time we made the change Scotch whiskey had to be kept three years, but now it has to be kept five years. That is a matter with which we may proceed further, and we have been in conference with the distillers in regard to it. In this matter I would not like to proceed in any direction without, at any rate, having consulted the trade and having their views. As I pointed out, the big problem which they are up against is the recovery of an export market, and all sorts of factors have to be taken into account when a trade is trying to recover its export market. We might do something here which would nullify a good deal of the expenditure which they incurred by way of propaganda and in advertising their wares. The whole matter is one of some difficulty.

Comment on this

I see that matter all right but what I see in the Minister's answer is that he will defer taking action until it will probably be too late. Already Scotch whiskey has got into a substantial preferential position in the country—that, at least, is my information.

Comment on this

It is small, it is only about one-fifth.

Comment on this

That is due to the specially privileged position in which it is.

Comment on this

In view of the sympathetic tone of the Minister's speech, all I can do at the moment is to ask the permission of the House to withdraw this amendment and the next one in my name. They have practically been discussed as if they were one amendment, and I may say that I am glad that the Minister changed the whole tone of the House and showed Deputies that the subject was not as flippant as they thought.

Comment on this

In regard to Section 18, perhaps the Minister would tell us what benefit we derive by maintaining imperial preference on imported dry fruits. I think it applies to South Africa and Australia, and, so far as I know, they do not give us the same imperial preference which we give them.. I doubt, in fact, if they give us any preference at all.

Comment on this

I am not sure that we should not consider the withdrawal of the imperial preference so far as this particular commodity is concerned. It simply has remained because it was there when we took over the duty and we did not make any change in regard to it. I am not sure that there is any particular advantage in it. I will look into the matter and perhaps discuss it on Report. It may be there are cases where if we abolish imperial preference what we would be actually doing would be increasing the rates. Take the case of confectionery. We have a certain rate and an imperial preference rate, and the latter is really the effective rate. If we abolish imperial preference we would really be increasing the rate. I cannot say what the position is in regard to dry fruits, but I will look into it.

Comment on this

In regard to Section 19, our attitude has been expressed so often that there is no use in talking about it further. We are opposed in principle to the imposition of this extra duty on sugar. We think that the Minister just took the easy road, as he did when he cut off the shilling from the old age pensioners. He saw a big sum coming to him and did not go to the trouble of considering it further. We believe that the ground has not been investigated by him sufficiently in his search for alternative taxes. Besides, we have expressed already our view that reductions were possible which would have enabled him to avoid this extra tax altogether. As I say, we have spoken about it so often there is no use in repeating the arguments against it. We intend to put the matter to a division and vote against it.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I have nothing to add to what Deputy de Valera has said. We also have expressed our views on the matter, and we propose to vote against this section which increases the sugar duty.

Comment on this

There is one matter on which I would like the Minister to give us some information, and that is in regard to the present Customs duty on sugar, confectionery and chocolate confectionery. I think that the decrease which took place in the duty in England and the increase which took place here, and also as a result of the drawback, the preference given to sugar confectionery here means only 1½d a lb., and in the case of chocolate 2½d. That represents a substantial reduction—in one case 25 per cent. and in the other 16 per cent. In consequence of the changes that took place here and in England in the sugar duty, does the Minister propose to take any steps to restore the former preference?

As well as that, I think there is the question of certain confectionery which, while purporting to be chocolate or having the appearance of chocolate, is in actual fact not chocolate. There is a very cheap quality of confectionery sold in the Saorstát which purports to be chocolate. It is called chocolate; but it is really coated with a chocolate shell. That comes in here as sugar confectionery at the rate of 1½d. per lb., as contrasted with 2½d. per lb., which. I presume, was intended to be charged when this duty was imposed by the original section. I think the Minister might look into that to see if, on the Report Stage, he could not introduce an amendment which would cover goods purporting to be chocolate goods or some imitation of chocolate.

Comment on this

As far as the latter is concerned at present it is charged at the lower rate. To charge it at the higher rate it would be necessary to have a resolution and machinery to deal with it. If the position is as stated, it can be rectified later on. In regard to the first question, the change in the sugar duty in England does not affect the chocolate trade here. What has happened is that they are paying a farthing more for their sugar here. Of course, in many classes of confectionery only about 50 per cent. of sugar is used. Theer are other ingredients, In no case has the cost of the article been increased entirely by the farthing per lb., so that while there may be some little decrease in the amount of protection there was afforded when the confectionery duty was imposed and when the sugar duty was at 2¾d. per lb., they have a substantial protection even yet. As a matter of fact, when imposing confectionery duty we changed the sugar duty in such a way as to increase very greatly the protection we gave to confectionery, and I think even with the increase of one farthing per lb. in the duty, they have a protection which is quite sufficient. As a matter of fact the rapid strides made by the confectionery industry and the jam industry indicate that the amount of protection they got was quite sufficient, and I do not think any change is required when so small an increase as a farthing is made in the sugar duty.

Comment on this

Admittedly, while there has been an extension in the sugar confectionery industry here, it has been confined to the cheaper grades only. As a matter of fact the present tariff does not seem to be effective as far as the better quality of chocolates is concerned. The flat rate means, of course, that the percentage of protection on the better quality of chocolate is very much less than on the cheaper quality. The consequence has been to compel the Irish chocolate factories to devote their attion almost entirely to the cheaper grades. That is not a desirable thing, I think, because if the Irish chocolate manufacturers are associated with the cheaper quality of goods, that undoubtedly will create a prejudice in the mind of the buying public against them. I do not believe you will ever get that industry on a strong, sound foundation unless the factories are able to hold their own in the better-class lines. As well as that, if they develop the manufacture of the better-class lines there is a possibility of developing an export trade in chocolate. Any person who has taken the trouble to go into a place where confectionery is sold in Dublin will know the extraordinary number of varieties and the different qualities not only of English but of Continental chocolates which are sold. Of course, they are all of the highest price. It seems to me that there is a possibility, if the Irish manufacturer provides the necessary quality and meets public requirements in regard to tastes, that you can develop an export trade in chocolates, and provided the manufacturer by a preference of some sort is able to secure a place in the home market for his own superior quality of chocolate. At the present moment it would not pay to produce that better quality of chocolate in competition with foreign factories.

Comment on this

I admit that the chocolate trade has not gone ahead in the same way as the sugar confectionery trade. It may be that the effective rate of fivepence is not sufficient, but I would not like to conclude that at present, because I understand it is one of the trades in which a great deal of special skill, almost scientific skill, is required. It is one of the trades in which there might be some delay before the tariff becomes effective. I have been struck, as the Deputy has been struck, by the fact that the chocolate trade has not made the progress that the sugar confectionery trade has, but, at the same time, I am not yet satisfied that the tariff will not operate sufficiently, really to put the industry on its feet. As the Deputy knows, so far as confectionery is concerned, not only has progress been made at home, but there are firms which are doing a substantial export trade. The sugar confectionery trade has gone on as well as could be expected and has certainly made remarkable progress. The Deputy must remember, however, that for a long time there had not been any phenomenal progress even in the sugar confectionery trade, and it may be that the other trade has not had time to develop yet. I feel that this is the sort of tariff which affects a luxury and which there need be no great compunction about increasing. It is different to very many tariffs which would be given consideration. I would be prepared to consider it later if the facts merit consideration, but I think, on the other hand, we ought not too hastily to come to the conclusion that the tariff is insufficient.

Comment on this

That is satisfactory.

Comment on this
Division

Question: "That Section 19 stand part of the Bill," put.

Tá 70
·
Níl 57
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I want to ask the Minister whether, on Section 20, he is prepared to consider the admission of ginger preserved in syrup imported in casks of a capacity of not less than 1 cwt. at the lower rating—viz., 1¼d. per lb.? It is a small concession that the trade want, and I think the Minister might consider the matter on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy will give me some notice of the question. I think ginger imported as he suggests is raw material connected with the confectionery trade, and I would be prepared to admit it at the lower rate. I am prepared to bring forward an amendment on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

On Section 21, may I ask the Minister whether it would be possible to get the State Chemist to hurry up the manufacture of spirit varnish in this country? Surely it is not beyond the power of the State Chemist to get a spirit varnish that would be suitable?

Comment on this

That is a new matter. I will consider whether there is a possibility of getting the State Chemist to deal with that matter. I know that big efforts were made by the firm of Jacobs to get it. It is really a question of a very quick-drying varnish. There are spirit varnishes made in the country for ordinary uses, but owing to the system of manufacture it was necessary to get a varnish that dried practically immediately. Various firms which make spirit varnish here have tried to supply Jacobs' with one suitable, and they were not able. I understand the firm that supplies has some sort of a trade secret. After all, the State Chemist is largely engaged in a supervising capacity, and the members of the staff in the State Chemist's Department are very busily engaged on routine analyses, and whether it would be proper to detach any of them for a sort of research experiment which might or might not produce results is a matter I have not considered.

Comment on this

Will the Minister bear the matter in mind?

Comment on this

I will give it consideration.

Comment on this

I have knowledge of an industrial chemist of very great eminence in matters of that kind who has done very remarkable work, and I think possibly if the inquiry were transmitted to the intellectual and spiritual centre of Ireland, better results might be achieved.

Comment on this

I move:—

"To insert after the word ‘payments,' in line 44, the words ‘not exceeding ten shillings.'"

This is intended to insure that the remission of the entertainments tax will be confined to the cheaper kinds of admission. It is generally agreed that people who pay more than ten shillings into a race meeting would not be deterred from going by being charged the entertainments duty on prices above that. At the same time, we feel if the remission of the tax goes through in its present form that the racecourse executives, instead of passing the remission on to the public and reducing their charges proportionately, will be inclined to profiteer and put the remission, so to speak, into their own pockets. For that reason I propose that amendment in my my name.

Comment on this

Since the entertainments tax has been remitted, various racecourse committees have already made announcements of substantial reductions, and many of the race companies who were awaiting the Minister's announcement before they would decide whether they would apply for a fixture have now considerably reduced their charges of admission. Mullingar and Naas meetings are two places that had been awaiting the Minister's announcements, and they have reduced their charges. They made very substantial reductions, and prior to the announcement of the remission they had not decided as to whether they would apply for fixtures. I do not see that there is any necessity for this amendment.

Comment on this

I do not profess to be extremely interested in this particular matter, but a good deal of consideration was given to it by officials of my Department and the Department of Agriculture, who considered the present position of racing. As a result of their consideration they came to the conclusion that racing in this country was in such a state that the entertainment tax would have to be abandoned if there was not to be a collapse of racing. On the Committee there were really two finance officials, a representative of the Revenue Commissioners and a representative of the Department of Finance. The third was a representative of the Department of Agriculture, and they agreed that in the interests of horse-breeding—and we have a considerable export of horses from Ireland—it was necessary to maintain racing. That Committee, after considerable consideration and after hearing an enormous number of witnesses, came to the conclusion that it was necessary that the tax should be remitted. I feel that, as a good deal of money is made at race meetings by people who would buy tickets at ten shilling or more, we would be destroying a good deal of the effect of the concession by adopting Deputy McEntee's amendment. And I feel, on the whole that, racing having fallen to such a parlous condition, when giving the concession we should give it on the whole.

Comment on this

The main purpose of the amendment was to insure that, first of all, prices would be reduced so as to popularise race meetings and to take away the people from the betting saloons to the race meeting—to take the people who wish to bet in the city to the race meeting. The question is whether, if you will allow the remission to go without any condition, the race-course people will not put the tax they save into their own pockets and so leave the position exactly as it was before, thus taking so much easy money and making no attempt by reducing prices to attract the public to their meetings. Deputy Shaw mentions that in one or two particular instances reductions have been made.

Comment on this

I might have mentioned that the Curragh and other places as well have also reduced the charges of admission.

Comment on this

Even if they have done so, I do not see that there is any strong case made against the amendment, even granting that in some cases the prices had been reduced, so that the race meetings are now more popular. At the same time, I feel, as I said before, that any person who is prepared to pay ten shillings for admission to a racecourse will not be deterred from going to that racecourse if he has to pay the entertainments tax as well. There are other people—the poorer class of people—who pay their shilling or their two-and-six for admission to the popular enclosure. They may possibly be deterred if the tax remains, and it is possibly due to the fact that the public as a whole have forsaken race meetings, that race meetings have gone down. But I do not think that any person who is willing to pay a substantial sum for admission will object to pay the entertainments tax. After all, the admission money is a very small proportion of what a day at the races is going to cost. There is the entrances to the various enclosures, apart altogether from the tax which he will pay to the bookmaker, and the amount he will have to pay in respect of luncheon and the libations which accompany it. On the whole I think the admission portion of the money represents a very small proportion of the cost of going to the races, and if we add to that very small proportion the amount of the entertainment duty which could be collected in respect thereof, I think the Exchequer will gain, and that race-courses and racing as a whole will not be the losers.

Comment on this

Really, I feel that I cannot accept the amendment. As I say, I do not want to say that I have very strong views on it, but I think that even people who can afford to pay 10/- or 10/6 for entrance to the meeting will feel the cost of an extra shilling or two, as they often go in family parties to the races, and one individual might be paying the tax three or four times. It will, I think, serve to some extent as a deterrent.

Comment on this

You ought not to inculcate bad habits in this country.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I move:—

To add at the end of the section, line 51, the words "or by the Irish Racing Association."

This point was raised by me on the Second Reading of the Bill. I think something the Minister has said in connection with the last amendment gives me a certain amount of encouragement. He says that if we are going to give the concession at all we should make a clean sweep or something to that effect. I believe that is what should be done. I have no particular views on the question as to whether this tax should be remitted or not, but I say that if you are going to remit it on the races run under one particular code of rules, then you ought to remit it in races run under another code of rules. I can see no argument at all for the remission in one case, and for the continuance of the tax in another case. Personally I do not believe, as far as the smaller classes of race meetings are concerned, that it is worth while, or that it will pay for the collection and for the trouble. As I pointed out before, many of the smaller race meetings are got up in the interests of local funds of some kind or another, and I think it will seem peculiar if one town runs races under the National Hunt Rules, or the Turf Club Rules, and the next town runs them under another set of rules, that in one case the tax will be collected and in the other they will be tax free. No one has demonstrated what Deputy Flinn asked for—the connection between racing and horse breeding—to our complete satisfaction, but Deputy Flinn and myself think there is a connection, and that if it is demonstrated it will either have to be demonstrated as a connection between horse breeding and the horse industry and the particular races run under the rules I am speaking of. I think it will be very difficult indeed to point out where the difference lies, and I press the Minister to wipe out the entertainments tax on all horse races. I do not see where the distinction comes in. He pointed out before that the other races had some sort of particular advantage, that they are commercial concerns. I do not know why that fact should entitle them to special consideration over and above those got up for some laudable object like the improvement of the local town hall. There are quite a number of races run under these rules. Most of the smaller towns and villages hold races under these rules. The only reason is because the fees are smaller. I do not profess to be an expert in this matter, but I can see no case for keeping the tax on this particular class of races and removing it from the other class. I would be prepared even to support keeping it on all classes of racing, but, if you make an exemption in one, it should not be kept on the other. People have urged me and others to bring this matter before the House and they pointed out that dog racing at Shelbourne Park and Harold's Cross is free of entertainments tax. I do not know if that is the case, and I speak subject to correction, but certainly I cannot understand the principle by which the entertainments tax is enacted, if these races are free, while the tax is kept on small race meetings in villages and towns in the rural districts.

Comment on this

With regard to the last matter raised by the Deputy, the question of a tax on dog racing, there was no intention of exempting dog racing. What happened was that coursing was exempted from the entertainments tax, and there was no dog racing at that time. The section was so drawn that probably it makes it impossible to collect the tax on dog racing, though, as a matter of fact, we are at present receiving legal advice in regard to dog racing, and may bring a test prosecution, because if it turns out to be free of tax it is only by accident. I want to put that aside in considering this question.

With regard to the exemption of horse races, racing under this so-called Irish Racing Association, if there is any such thing, there is no money involved. From the flapper meetings very little money will be collected. It does not matter in the slightest from the money point of view. Of course if the amendment were going to be accepted, I would not like to give statutory recognition to the Irish Racing Association. I do not know if there is any such body. There are one or two self-constituted individuals who perhaps make some money by calling themselves the Irish Racing Association, but the races carried on under the Irish Racing Association are really not carried on under any association. If the Dáil were of the opinion that we should exempt all racing, I would move at a later stage to delete everything after the word "races" in line 47. I would not think of adding the name of the Irish Racing Association to the list. That is rather a detail. We are exempting racing, not because we regard it as an entertainment specially worthy of being exempted and specially worthy of encouragement— we do not put it in the same line with athletic meetings, football, or other games, which a year or two ago were exempted from tax—we are not exempting racing from the entertainments tax along these lines, we are exempting it simply because we believe —I do not speak with any deep personal conviction—and everybody who has anything to do with horse-racing seems to be in agreement, that racing is necessary for the maintenance of horse-breeding. Horses can only be sold if either they or their relatives have own races. In order that they may win races and be sold at a good price, we must have a certain number of race meetings, and for that purpose only recognised race meetings under the Irish Turf Club or the Irish National Hunt Club are of any use. As a matter of fact, if a horse is raced at one of these flapper meetings it is not allowed to be raced at any other meeting either here or in Great Britain, so that instead of gaining in value and becoming more saleable by winning a race at a flapper meeting it loses.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

It loses its moral character.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

What are horses bought for but racing?

Comment on this

Flapper races are got up for one or two purposes. Sometimes you have a conspiracy, such as that depicted in Brinsley McNamara's "Glorious Uncertainty." In other cases the local licensed trader may wish to serve liquid refreshments to the assembled multitude. In other cases a man gets up a race meeting and says it is in the interests of the town hall, or something like that. It seems to me that the flapper meetings are not deserving of any encouragement or assistance. If you have a meeting genuinely got up for charity it can be exempted from tax in the ordinary way, the same as a concert got up for charity or anything of that sort can be exempted. Leaving the tax on will not prevent special exemptions where the meeting is for a charitable purpose.

There is just one other point in connection with this. The Inter-Departmental Committee which considered the matter was of opinion that there are too many of the recognised race meetings, that the wealth and population of the country do not enable as many fixtures to be held as have been held, and they recommend that steps should be taken by the Turf Club and by other people interested to reduce the number of fixtures so that there may be better support for and better racing at those that continue. I accept that view as correct. I think it is, and it has certainly been agreed with by people outside, and that being so, we should not encourage these flapper meetings, which are of no value to horse racing, by specifically exempting them from the tax. I do not say that the maintenance of the entertainments tax will be a serious discouragement to them, because a great many of them are organised on such a basis that there is not an admission fee; there is, perhaps, a parking fee for cars, on which tax is not chargeable, and in respect of the great majority of them no tax would be collected. As I say, this is a matter of very trivial importance, but it has been raised and these people have been sending circulars round, I suppose to all sorts of Deputies. I did not get one myself, but I suppose I was regarded as hopeless.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

To all sorts of Deputies!

Comment on this

To a representative selection of Deputies, and they have written to the newspapers. But I do not think that this is worth much talk, one way or the other. I certainly would not resign if I were beaten on this.

Comment on this

I want to support Deputy O'Connell. I think somebody said that the liquor question was treated with levity, but this is also treated with a great deal of levity. It is really a trivial matter and as the Minister has stated that the revenue derived by the State from this racing is so small, I think he might give way to Deputy O'Connell. These race meetings do not do any harm. They may not do any good to horse-racing, but, after all, greyhound racing does not do any good either.

Comment on this

It is very seldom that the Minister for Finance and I agree on anything in connection with racing, but I am in agreement with his remarks on this. The matter is a very small one. I do not think that the revenue that will be collected at any of these meetings will pay for the stamps to go on the cards, so that that aspect of it does not arise. I would not like to see these meetings encouraged, because they are handicapping legitimate meetings, and the legitimate meetings are handicapped enough at present. The flapper meetings encourage dishonesty, because it is often the worst horse that wins, and not the best.

Comment on this

That happens at the Curragh too.

Comment on this

I believe that the country would be better off without them. Donkey races are popular, and they are sporting events, but the flapper meetings are in most cases held because they make money for sharps who go to them from Dublin and other places and who obtain whatever little money the mugs have got who are fools enough to bet. So that whilst I think it may be said that I am in agreement with the Minister possibly the acceptance of the amendment would make no difference, at the same time I would not like to see any encouragement whatever given to the development of these flapper meetings.

Comment on this

Is it not an amazing statement for a responsible Deputy to make that taxation should be inflicted which was producing less than the cost of collection? That seems an amazing statement for a responsible man to make.

Comment on this

That is not so, of course. If I were advised by the Revenue authorities that it would cost more to collect than is obtained, I would certainly say that the tax should be abolished, but that is not so. On the other hand, the amount that would come into the Revenue is of no real consequence. I do not want to mention the figure, but perhaps I might say £100 or so.

Comment on this

I think the Minister might celebrate the agreement between Deputy O'Connell and myself by removing this tax. The situation is that it is a sort of trade union regulation for discouraging these meetings, and if the amount is so small, there does not seem to be much occasion for keeping it on.

Comment on this

In justice to some of the promoters of the flapper meetings, as they are called, I do not think it is right that Deputy Shaw should be let get away with the statement that all the rogues are on the one side. I have been at race meetings, both flapper and legalised, as they call them, and often the best horse did not win at the class meeting either, because it would not suit the owner to let him win; he was waiting until he got a long price. If the people who promote flapper meetings want to do a little squaring too, it ought not to be thrown in their faces in this House.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I do not wish to have this amendment put in its present form. The Minister does not seem to have turned it down definitely. There is really a great deal of interest in this matter in the country. I have a list of over 140 centres where these meetings were organised last year. The Minister referred to the necessity for reducing the number of fixtures in order to get a bigger attendance at the fixtures that are held. I think this would not help very much, because the people who go to this class of meeting are the people who will not travel far to them; they come from a radius of three or four miles, and they are not able to make a habit of going to races. They are just out for one day in the year, and it will not affect the question of what is called legitimate racing one way or the other. The people who go are not regular racegoers. They go to the local meeting, and that is perhaps all they will go to in the year. As the amount of money is negligible, as a great many people are interested in the matter, and nothing will be gained, comparatively speaking, by keeping the tax on, I think the Minister might very well give way on the matter.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would put down the amendment in the other form, this is, by deleting all the words after "races," for the Report Stage, I would at least agree to leave it to a free vote of the House.

Comment on this

Why not remove the specific mention of the other organisations?

Comment on this

That is what I am proposing.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

That is the effect of it—to leave out the words "and that the holding of the entertainment has been authorised either by the Turf Club of Ireland or by the Irish National Hunt Steeplechase Committee or by both the said Turf Club of Ireland and the said Irish National Hunt Steeplechase Committee."

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

To stop after the words "one or more horse races."

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

The Deputy withdraws the amendment and will put down an amendment for the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment 19:—

To insert before section 24 a new section as follows:—

"On and after the first day of May, 1928, entertainments duty within the meaning of section 1 of the Finance (New Duties) Act, 1916, shall not be charged or levied on payments for admission to any entertainment as respects which it is proved to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that the entertainment is merely subsidiary to an agricultural show, exhibition or competition."

I received a certain amount of encouragement in putting down this amendment when I discovered the attitude taken by the Minister in regard to the demands made upon him by Deputy Shaw and those associated with him. Deputy Shaw, as a result of his persuasive methods and the eloquence of those behind him, persuaded the Minister to remove the entertainments tax so far as it affected races under the rules of the Turf Club. The main argument put forward in support of that, and which was accepted by the Minister, was that the amount was so small—it was in or about £10,000—that the removal of the tax was in indication of the measure of support which the Government were prepared to give the horse-breeding industry. Racing is only carried on in this country under the rules of the Turf Club by reason of the fact that a certain number of wealthy gentlemen, whether trainers, owners or other people, can come together and form a company. Obviously the object of the formation of that company is to enable these people to run races under the Turf Club rules for what most people regard as profit-making purposes. I take it from what Deputy Shaw says that certain race companies have been carrying on under great difficulties and at a loss. The Deputy will admit that the members of the Labour Party supported him in the attitude which he adopted in regard to the demand which eventually resulted in the concession being given. On the other hand, agricultural shows are only carried on by a collection of individuals who come together to carry out the work on voluntary lines. Not only do they do the work necessary in connection with the organisation of the show, but in most cases they actually help to finance it. Many shows, including some in my own constituency, have been carried on at a loss. That can be proved to the satisfaction of the Minister by the production of the balance sheet of those shows. I think it cannot be disputed that the shows were carried on for the purpose of encouraging the breeding of live stock. There may be side-shows, but, as far as one can see from attending the agricultural shows, these side-shows as well are closely related to the encouragement and development of the breeding of live stock.

The amount represented by the concession given to the race-course companies and the racehorse owners, trainers and other wealthy people associated with the carrying on of racing is about ten thousand pounds. I have no idea, I admit, as to what the amount of the concessions asked for in this amendment would be. It would be a very small amount compared with that involved in the concession to race meetings. I hope the Minister will realise that if he agrees to this amendment he will be giving a concession to the people who organise these shows and who do all the work on a voluntary basis, and in many cases support the shows from their own private resources. The concession would only mean a small amount to the Government. I hope the Minister will agree that in removing the entertainments tax in this case he will help to reduce the losses of some of the people responsible for the carrying on of these shows. I cannot give any accurate idea as to the amount involved, but I hope the Minister will take into consideration the fact that this is a very important part of the work that is being done, and that I hope will be carried on, to develop the live stock industry, and that for the same reason as he gave the concession to the race-course companies he will give this small concession to the people who do this voluntary work, which is of a very useful kind.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any idea of what the actual amount involved will be?

Comment on this

If it were not abused it would be very small. I would be quite prepared to accept the principle of the amendment, but I think it ought to be drafted rather differently. It ought to be drafted in such a way as to give the Revenue Commissioners power to exempt. As it is drafted, it would be difficult to administer. I am prepared to accept the principle of it, and if the Deputy withdraws it I shall bring up an amendment on the Report Stage that will have the same effect. We must take care to see that we do not give exemption to something where the other entertainments are the main feature and the agricultural show is subsidiary. In order to make sure of that in practice we must draft the amendments separately. At present the position is that a cattle show is exempted, even if it has a band. Some thing like a small Féis in connection with a show does not render it liable to tax. By agreeing to the principle of the amendment, I do not think any appreciable revenue is going to be lost. As a matter of fact, only a comparatively small number of shows are liable to tax.

Comment on this

In drafting the amendment I tried to give whatever power the Revenue Commissioners required to decide as to whether it was possible to remove the entertainments tax in certain cases where application might be made. I thank the Minister for agreeing to accept the principle and I shall leave it to him to bring in an amendment which will cover the matter.

Comment on this

I should like to put a point to the Minister in connection with the entertainments tax with which I think he is familiar. It is a case which I raised with him as to exemption from entertainment duty of a particular body which was giving entertainments which were, in our opinion, absolutely essential to the educative purposes of the Association. The difficulty is that, as far as we can see, education is defined to exclude cultural matters. I do not want to go elaborately into the case, because the Minister has full particulars.

What I am suggesting to the Minister is that between now and the Report Stage he might find some other and wider definition of that term. I wish to say, quite frankly, that I accept, without any hesitation, the idea that the entertainments tax should be levied upon a whole lot of bodies of an amateur character engaged in entertainment. But there are some whose claim to be educational is so clear and definite and whose actual educative functions and results on the lives of individual people engaged in them are so marked that the mere fact that the machinery which they use for education is cultural ought not to rule them out. I would be inclined to say that we should in this case have to apply and satisfy the Minister for Education that the purposes are educative and that the effect is educational.

I am asking the Minister if he can to consider and find between now and the Report Stage some terms by which we could bring this matter to a test. The one I have in mind happens to be the Cork Shakespearean Society, a body made up of very ordinary people, apprentices, shopkeepers, assistants and people of that kind. Yet they actually rehearsed concurrently in a loft—and this is an amazing statement —seven uncut Shakespearean plays, and produced these in public at a very high standard of professional ability, without a single previous public performance. That is an achievement which, from a cultural and an educational point of view, ranks with the achievement of the Abbey Theatre in acting. They have taken a man with an absolutely fatal impediment in his speech to perform an important part. There was one case I knew of a man who could not speak at all practically. That man produced and acted in my presence the part of Hamlet better than I have ever seen it done. There was a cripple in another case, and it is a rather extraordinary psychological reaction of the training given there that this man was capable of allowing his deformity to be used for artistic purposes. This deformed man took the part of Richard III., and performed that part with amazing skill. There are certain numbers of associations and bodies which are apparently excluded from the concession the Minister would like to give, and I am suggesting that he should try to find some definition by which we could ascertain whether or not, within a reasonable meaning, the function of these bodies is educative, and educative up to a standard at which the State ought not to tax it.

Comment on this

I would like to associate myself with Deputy Flinn's appeal on behalf of a similar society in the city of Waterford.

Comment on this

The difficulty in this case, of course, is to draft a section which will exempt bodies whom most people would agree have a certain claim, at any rate, to be exempted, without exempting others. It is very difficult to draft a section that might not mean our losing a good deal of our entertainment tax. I have had representations from the Deputy and from a good number of other people in this matter, and I have given it some consideration. I shall have it looked into as sympathetically as possible, but I do not know if it would be possible for me, between this and the Report Stage, to come to any conclusion upon it. It really is quite a delicate case. There are always borderline cases, and they cause great difficulty. You finally might be driven by a carelessly or hastily drafted section actually to repeal it because its scope was much greater than was intended. I can only repeat that, in view of the very strong representations made, of which I frankly recognise the force, the matter is under consideration, but I do not think I could give a definite promise.

Comment on this

That is perfectly satisfactory.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 20.

Before Section 24 to insert a new section as follows:—

"Entertainments duty within the meaning of Section 1 of the Finance (New Duties) Act, 1916, shall not be charged or levied on payments for admission to any entertainment held under the Council of Aonach Tailteann, and this section shall have effect from the first day of August, nineteen hundred and twenty-four."

I have hopes that the Minister will feel favourably disposed towards this amendment, because the primary object is in line with the policy he referred to a few minutes ago, and of which the Dáil has already approved, and that is that it is a good thing as far as we can to encourage healthy outdoor athletics. The second reason is that the effect of the amendment is to endeavour to help, in a rather effective way, without possibly much expense, national games. I confine myself in the first place to the amendment without the last two lines, because An Ceann Comhairle has pointed out to me that there is at least a doubt as to whether it would be allowable for me to move these two lines in my amendment. Without trying to argue that as a point of order, I should be quite satisfied if I could bring forward certain facts in connection with the 1924 Tailteann Games, and ask the Minister to consider these facts with a view, if he feels favourably disposed to the whole idea, of seeing whether they could be extended so far as the 1924 games are concerned.

The actual entertainment tax in 1924 which these games would have produced would be something like £1,200, but I do not think that the corresponding sum in this year's games will be anything like that, because owing to that provision which the Minister mentioned a few minutes ago definite athletic games would be free from entertainments tax. So I do not think that there is that amount of money involved in any case. Further it is questionable whether money is involved in the matter at all, because one can certainly put it this way: If the entertainment tax is levied it will postpone to a longer date and, possibly a very considerably longer date, the repayment of the loan which was made by the Dáil to the Tailteann Games in 1924. It certainly is hoped this year, and in future years, that the Tailteann Games will pay their way, and very probably, more than pay their way. The length of time that would be taken up making such profit as would enable that loan to be repaid will be very perceptibly increased by the enforcement of this tax and, therefore, I say it is not so much a matter of money really at all. My point is that on principle we ought rather to encourage the games than to make a profit out of them.

Now with regard to the 1924 games and the enforcement of the tax for them, I do not like to do anything of a retrospective kind, but, nevertheless, there are these facts that the Dáil granted to the Tailteann Games in 1924 a loan of £7,500. There was difficulty about the levying and the collection of the entertainment tax of which I think the Minister is aware, and which, if attention had not been paid to, might have endangered the success of the games. Therefore, the tax was not collected when the entrance money was being taken, but the effect of that was that the Revenue Commissioners, I suppose—I do not know whom, but somebody at any rate —held that a greater sum than £1,200 was really due by the games. And as a consequence, a sum of £3,000 was deducted from the £7,500 loan which was made by the Dáil and only £4,500 paid over. Therefore, the effect of making this retrospective would be simply that the loan of £7,500 was made and the Tailteann Games would owe more. But, in order to get them to owe more, the Government would have to pay back £3,000. That is to say, it is practically in that respect very largely a book transaction. But it has this vital point for the Tailteann Games themselves, that the profit that was made in reference to the games was only a few hundred pounds, and that profit—I use the term perhaps wrongly—because it was a profit on the £4,000 that was handed over by the Government as a loan and not paid back. It really was a loss, and if that were attempted to be repaid all that could be brought forward to enable the present year's games to be set going was this sum of £500. Now it is obvious that a considerable sum of money is required to start and keep the organisation going, in order to make the games a success before any revenue can be received, so that having in hand that sum of £3,000, as well as the £500, would have made all the difference between the starting of and the running of these games as compared with the difficulties which they actually have had. I would ask the Minister when he is considering the general principle for the future, to see if he cannot reconsider the decision that was come to with reference to 1924.

Comment on this

I would like to say that the Deputy's amendment, as it stands, is thoroughly vicious. If this amendment were accepted by the Chair and passed, I can see no reason why some other Deputy—Deputy Flinn for instance—should not bring forward an amendment saying that the income tax should only be a shilling in the pound, with effect as from the 1st April, 1922. I really do not think the amendment should be passed in this form.

Comment on this

I did not suggest that it should.

Comment on this

In any case, it would not take effect. If Deputy Thrift's suggestion were adopted what would happen is this: the Revenue Commissioners would pay back £3,000 to the Exchequer, and Aonach Tailteann would be no better off. If they want money immediately, we have provision made in this year's Estimates for giving them a certain sum. If that is not sufficient, and if a suitable case can be made, and it might be possible to do so—I do not say that I would like to hear the case— but in such an event it would be possible to introduce a Supplementary Estimate giving them more, if we thought it would have support in the Dáil. If anything is to be done for them so as to give them more money it must be done by means of a Supplementary Estimate in the House. That is really the only way of effecting that.

Comment on this

What about levying on them?

Comment on this

For the future?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, I think we might agree to the matter. I doubt whether there will be a liability to pay tax on it, but I would like to examine that with the Deputy, who probably is in touch with Aonach Tailteann. If it were necessary, I would be prepared to introduce an amendment exempting them for the future, but not just in this way. I would allow the Revenue Commissioners to exempt them, but if exemption were given in the words of the Deputy's amendment, I think the council of Aonach Tailteann, over which we have really no control—I do not know who has control over it— might go and organise any sort of entertainment for any object. We would have to tie them down somewhat. As to the principle of exempting the actual funds of Aonach Tailteann, I think I could agree to that.

Comment on this

Of course, I never anticipated that the amendment, in its present form, would be accepted, but I just merely wanted to bring the matter up.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

On the point of order, having listened to Deputy Thrift and the Minister, I am not yet clear as to what the effect of the last part of the amendment would actually be, that is the retrospective part of it, which reads:—"This section shall have effect from the first day of August, nineteen hundred and twenty-four." From the point of view of the Chair, that part of the amendment is clearly out of order, because presumably a tax was chargeable and leviable, and either it means that money which has been paid into the Exchequer would be paid out again, which is imposing a charge, or that a debt due to the Exchequer would be remitted. In either case a Deputy other than a Minister could not move a proposal to that effect. The amendment actually before the House is in this form:—"Entertainments duty within the meaning of Section 1 of the Finance (New Duties) Act, 1916, shall not be charged or levied on payments for admission to any entertainment held under the Council of Aonach Tailteann."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy PROINNSIAS O FATHAIGH Fianna Fáil

Ba mhaith liom cuidiú leis an leas-rún so mar is dó liom go mba cheart don Dáil congnamh do thabhairt d'Aonach Tailteann. Is fiú dhúinn an tAonach a bheith againn. I dtíortha eile ar Roinn na hEurópa—níl fhios agam i dtaobh Sasana—nuair a bhíonn cluichí ar siúl cuidíonn an Rialtas leo. Ba chóir do Rialtas an Stáit seo cuidiú le hAonach Tailteann. Níl fhios agam an bhfuil cead agam tagairt do dhéanamh don líne deiridh san leas-rún.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Tá.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy PROINNSIAS O FATHAIGH Fianna Fáil

Isé an brí atá leis ná na trí míle púint d'fháil ar ais no an tsuim sin do scrios amach mar dhroch-fhiach. Sin é an brí atá leis. Ba mhaith liom a iar- ar an Aire, má tá cead agam, a mhíniú dhúinn conus is féidir sin do dhéanamh.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Ní féidir le h-aon teachta acht leis an aire é sin do dhéanamh.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy PROINNSIAS O FATHAIGH Fianna Fáil

Bhal, d'iarrfainn ar an Aire an rud san do dhéanamh.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Is the Deputy withdrawing the amendment?

Comment on this

Yes. The Minister has undertaken practically to bring forward an amendment which will meet the case. He has stated that he will reconsider the matter or see what can be done in order to put the games in funds from one period to the next. That is the one point that I wanted to urge, that there should be the possibility of carrying forward enough money so that the Council would be able to restart proceedings for the games that are to come on after the period of four years.

Comment on this

I think representatives who are familiar with the whole matter should come and consider the financial aspect of it.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Minister to say that he is prepared to receive them?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

I move amendment 21:—

Before section 24 to insert a new section as follows:—

"On and after the first day of July, nineteen hundred and twenty-eight, section 1 of the Finance (New Duties) Act, 1916, as amended by section 3 of the Finance Act, 1917, by section 11 of the Finance Act, 1918, and by section 7 of the Finance Act, 1919, shall have effect as if the following scale of rates of entertainment duty were substituted for the scale set forth in the section:—

Where the payment, excluding the amount of duty, does not exceed 6d.—nil.

Exceeds | 6d. and does not exceed | 1s. | 0d.—one penny.

,, | 1s. 0d.,,,,,,,, | 2s. | 0d.—twopence.

,, | 2s. 0d.,,,,,,,, | 2s. | 6d.—fourpence.

,, | 2s. 6d.,,,,,,,, | 3s. | 6d.—sixpence.

,, | 3s. 6d.,,,,,,,, | 5s. | 0d.—ninepence.

,, | 5s. 0d.,,,,,,,, | 7s. | 6d.—one shilling.

,, | 7s. 6d.,,,,,,,, | 10s. | 6d.—one shilling and sixpence.

,, | 10s. 6d.,,,,,,,, | 15s. | 0d.—two shillings.

15s.—Two shillings for the first 15s. and sixpence for every 5s. or part of 5s. over fifteen shillings.

During the debates this afternoon there has been a great deal of consideration given to what one might call physical entertainments. Now, I should like to turn to something more or less in the nature of intellectual entertainments. I should like, in the first instance, to refer to what Deputy Flinn described a few moments ago as the services of individuals. I refer to services—he referred to individuals, I think—which have active educational functions in the lives of individuals in the country. In the first place, I would like to refer to the incidence of the present taxation. Where the price of admission is 3d. there is a tax of 1d., or thirty-three and one-third per cent.; where it is 4d. the tax is 1d., or 25 per cent.; where it is 4½d. the tax is 1½d., or 33? per cent.; where it is 5d. the tax is 2d., or 40 per cent.; where it is 7d. the tax is 2d., or 28 4-7 per cent.; where it is 9d. the tax is 3d., or 33? per cent.; Where it is 1s. the tax is 3d. or 25 per cent.; where it is 1s. 2d. the tax is 4d., or 28 4-7 per cent.; where it is 1s. 6d. the tax is 4d., or 22 2-9 per cent.; where it is 2s. the tax is 4d., or 16? per cent.; where it is 3s. the tax is 6d., or 16? per cent.; and where it is 5s. the tax is 9d., or 15 per cent.

It will be noted from the way the percentages run that the incidence of the taxation is clearly unfair. The percentage is heaviest on the small amounts for admission, that is to say, on the people who can only afford to pay 3d. for entertainment, and who possibly can only go to that entertainment once a week or so. They have to pay the highest amount of tax. The incidence of that is clearly unfair. It might be just as well that the history attached to this tax would be recounted.

This entertainment tax was originally introduced by the British Government as a war measure in 1915. The war has no effect upon us at present, and as a war measure it ought to be dropped. Some years ago the British Chancellor of the Exchequer abolished the tax in Great Britain in connection with the lower prices and gave a considerable concession in favour of the higher prices. We ought to have at least a similar concession here. No relief has been given to the cinema trade on this side, whilst extra burdens have been put on the trade in the way of film censorship. Other forms of entertainment were referred to a few moments ago, such as greyhound racing, that are free from tax. I know the Minister made certain qualifications with regard to that, though these entertainments are at hours when the cinemas are in operation. A competition is allowed between these two forms of amusement which is not fair, and which seems to work against what is at least the more intellectual of these two entertainments, for the cinema affords intellectual amusement and gives people an opportunity of seeing things as they really are throughout the world, and if some of these things are not true to life, surely the scenery and surroundings are. I think the Minister might easily allow the incidence of this taxation to work out more favourably, and I hope he will be in the same sympathetic mood with regard to this as he has been when deal ing with the other amendments.

Comment on this

We would be inclined to support the amendment on the general ground that the more popular amusements, provided they are not detrimental to the people, ought to be interfered with only as little as can possibly be avoided. We feel that a remission could possibly be made in the tax in respect of the lower rates of admission, and possibly the Minister might find compensation for that by making a slight increase in respect of the higher rates. We think, in general, that no remission of taxes for anything in the nature of a luxury could very well be granted when you have to put a tax on the necessaries of life. We believe this is one of the taxes where some alteration might be made in the incidence. The particular form of tax in this case affects very seriously the cinemas throughout the country. Reference was made during the discussion of the amendment to Section 15, to the decline which has taken place in the consumption of alcoholic liquor. I think that decline to a great extent is due to the change which has taken place in the habits of the people, and to the fact that they have some other alternative place to resort than to the publichouse. In the present instance I do not want to make any political point about it, but the times are so hard people really require some little amusement and relaxation in which they can forget their ordinary daily worries. If you do not allow them to enjoy relaxation in a place like a cinema they might seek an alternative in the publichouse. For that reason I think the amendment should receive the very serious consideration of the Minister. Although the cinemas, and places of entertainment of that sort, are taxed in respect of admission, I do not think that the dancing halls are taxed. If it is necessary that the Minister should find some compensation, possibly he would take into consideration the question of imposing a tax upon the dancing places of amusement, and, as my friend Deputy Little reminds me, you have also the dogs.

Comment on this

I should like to join with Deputy Hogan and Deputy MacEntee in urging the Minister to consider this proposal as sympathetically as possible, and to give some remission in the taxation at present imposed on the cinema trade. I think the case for doing so was very cogently put by Deputy MacEntee, and I can add very little to what he has urged upon the Minister. I am of the opinion of Deputy MacEntee that a great deal of the sobriety at present is due to the effect of the cinema on the people, and that a great deal of the money which was formerly spent on alcoholic drink is now being spent in necessary amusement. Deputy Hogan stressed the part the cinemas were playing educationally and from the point of view of amusement. I am in complete agreement with his argument in that respect. I would point out that the cinemas give employment to something like 10,000 persons, according to my information. I am further informed that unless some relief is given to them in the way of taxation, which the Minister is now asked to consider, they will be forced to close during the months of July, August and September. That would be exceedingly regrettable, not only as regards the owners, but also the general public. There can be no doubt that in these times of economic stress the people require some relaxation. I ask the Minister to consider if the cinemas were closed during these three months what effect and reactions that would have on the people, especially from the point of view of sobriety. Nobody will deny that the cinemas are playing a very useful and creditable part, and I think they are entitled to sympathetic consideration from the Minister. Looking at cinemas from the municipal point of view, they are bearing a very great burden in the way of rates in the cities and towns. I have in mind one cinema in O'Connell Street, which is not by any means gigantic, and which pays the enormous sum by way of rates of £834. Now those are things that I feel sure any Minister for Finance will certainly consider sympathetically, and we urge upon him to take action. It has been suggested by those who have already spoken that some other method of taxation to replace the remitted taxes could be introduced. It has been pointed out here that greyhound racing is not at the moment taxed, and from what fell from the Minister I gather he did not view that with any particular equanimity or satisfaction, and that he would be inclined to redress that if it were possible. I gathered from him that it was not only possible but probable.

I would point out to the Minister that in the case of people going to a cinema and paying 1/6 admission that is the beginning and end of their expenditure, but in the case of people going to a race meeting or greyhound races the admission fee is the smallest item in their expenditure. I think it is common knowledge in this city anyhow that a great deal more money is spent by gambling upon these particular dog racing courses than really the people of this city can afford. If such racing is free from tax, as I gather it is at present, I suggest that a considerable portion of the revenue which would be lost by giving the relief the cinema people are asking can be recouped easily by putting a tax on dog racing. I have been informed that something like 10,000 people have frequented, in one week, Harold's Cross and Shelbourne Park. That information should afford the Minister for Finance means to recoup the taxes which the cinema people now ask him to remit. I have also been informed that there was a certain venue of greyhound racing with a capital of £5,000 that made a profit of £15,000 in a single year.

Comment on this
Mr. JORDAN

Because the best dogs did not always win.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that, Deputy Jordan. I am endeavouring to arrive at an even balance between dogs and pictures if I can. If £15,000 can be made on a capital of £5,000 in one year by a form of amusement entirely free from tax I suggest to the Minister that some alteration is not only necessary but equitable. Deputy MacEntee, I think, referred to the fact that the dancing halls in the city were entirely free from amusement tax. Possibly that is correct, and if that is so the revenue these people are drawing from this particular form of amusement is much greater than the ordinary Deputy can realise. Moreover, those people are actually infringing at present upon the rights of variety theatres which are already taxed. I have in mind one particular dance hall in the city which I have been told has brought over a turn which cost the sum of £200. No tax whatever is imposed upon that form of amusement. Here we have this particular dance hall, with no imposition by way of taxation whatever, infringing upon the rights of other modes of entertainment which have to pay tax. There can be little doubt about it that if, as I have already stated, it should come about that the cinemas should be closed for a period of three months very great hardship would result both to the owners of the cinemas and to the public. I would also point out that not alone is very considerable employment given by means of the cinema trade but they are also a source of revenue to local authorities. I have already referred to the question of local taxation and then there are huge electrical charges in addition to the entertainment tax we now ask the Minister to remit. The Minister, I feel sure, will consider the request sympathetically. I would urge him from these Benches in common with my colleagues on the Labour and official Opposition Benches to deal with the matter as sympathetically as he can, and give the relief sought equitably and from the point of view of necessity as far as the cinema trade is concerned.

Comment on this

I view this particular matter from a slightly different angle from that referred to by the previous Deputies. I am certainly in sympathy with the sense of the amendment itself, but I wonder would the Minister try to realise how many children are affected by this tax, particularly in connection with the lower-priced seats. He may judge it purely and simply from the point of view of revenue, from the point of view of how many tickets are sold. He may not care to try and differentiate between where the tax will come from, whether it will come from adults or children. It may have a serious effect from the point of view of revenue if alterations were made, but, nevertheless. I do not believe for a moment that this House would desire the children to contribute to the upkeep of the State, as they do chiefly in the case of those low-priced seats. I am not at all anxious with reference to luxuries that any tax on a luxury should be remitted. In fact, from a table which I have had submitted to me, it appears that some of these prices could stand a little extra tax, but certainly from seats ranging from prices up to 6d. that tax should be remitted and should not be collected. The percentage of tax collected is 33?, and I am sure that if the people who run those cinemas could get a revenue of 33? per cent. they would be very happy. The point I want to urge on the Minister is that there are many cinemas in the city of Dublin and throughout the country which cater specially for children's performances on certain afternoons and evenings, and I think that where it can be shown that a great many of those present in the lowest-priced seats are children, the tax should not be collected. I would ask the Minister to consider the low-priced seats, and to hold out some hope that there will be some alteration made in the amount of tax to be charged.

Comment on this

The amendment, as it stands, would cost £40,000. It might be possible to gain something by increasing the tax on the higher-priced seats, but not so very much. The difficulty is that if you make the price of a seat which is 3/6 now 4/-, the person who has been going to that 3/6 seat will go down to the 2/4 seat rather than pay 4/-. An increase in the prices of the dearer seats tends to drive people down to the cheaper seats. Only a limited amount can be gained by increasing the tax on the higher seats. I would not entirely agree with the Deputy who said that it is obviously unfair that the tax should be proportionately high in the case of the lower-priced seats. I think that must be. As long as the tax is to be reasonably remunerative, that must be so. The person going to the higher-priced seats is paying on the double. He is paying more to keep the cinema open than the person going to the lower seats, and he is paying more to the Exchequer directly. The whole matter is somewhat difficult. I believe that only a portion of the £40,000 that the Exchequer would lose would go to the public. A great deal more of it would go into the pockets of the cinema owners, and the prices would remain as at present.

Comment on this

May I interrupt the Minister to say that I have been given to understand that any remission of taxation given to the cinema owners will be passed on in full to the public?

Comment on this

I do not really accept that. At one time, the cinema people stated frankly that they would not pass on any remission. When they found, as a result of a discussion in the Dáil, that that was not a very good line of argument to take, they turned round and said, "We will pass it on." Possibly some of them would, but possibly some of them would not. In order to make up the deficit, it has been suggested that dance halls should be taxed. There is one type of dance hall which obviously seems the sort of place entrance to which should be taxed. It is a case, too, in which tax could be easily collected. In the case of some other dance halls, there would be certain difficulties in effectively and easily collecting the tax. It may be that we can find means of giving some remission to the cheaper seats in the cinemas by some increase in the dearer seats—though that would give us very little—and by some system of taxing dancing in the dance halls. We have given a certain amount of consideration to that, because it always that before a Budget members of the public in large numbers write in, making suggestions. Most of the suggestions have to do with remissions of taxation, but many people write in making suggestions for the imposition of taxation. We had the suggestion before us that dance halls should be taxed. We were not able, in time for this Budget, to work out a scheme which we could regard as satisfactory for taxing dance halls. I do not know whether or not, if the matter had been further considered and a scheme evolved, it would be one which could be approved of. The matter had not advanced to that stage.

As things stand at present we could not give any concession like this to the lower-priced seats. The actual deficit that would be occasioned would be too great. I should be prepared to look further into the matter before the Report Stage and to see whether, within the entertainments tax itself, without losing money, anything could be done We have budgeted without a margin We cannot really afford to give away taxation at the present stage. It may not turn out to be possible to do anything in this connection in this Finance Bill. I am inclined to think that it would be possible, if further consideration were given to the question of dancing, and careful consideration were given to getting more out of certain seats, to give some concession without loss. But as I see the matter at present, we could not give as much as Deputy Hogan asks. As a matter of fact, dog-racing would not give a very big contribution towards this loss. It is estimated that if we were to succeed in collecting tax in respect of entrance to dog races we would get from £5,000 to £6,000. The loss here is £40,000. I do not see that it would be possible by any adjustment of the tax on the higher-priced seats to make more than another £5,000 or £6,000. I have not gone fully into that. It would be difficult to make up, on entertainment tax, a sum as large as £40,000, or even half of it. At the moment I do not see that the amendment can be accepted, and I do not see how a substantial concession along the lines asked for by Deputy Hogan could be given.

It is true, I think, that the cinemas are labouring under certain difficulties. That is due to a number of reasons as well as the tax. It is due in part to the difficult conditions in the country. The tendency is, as in everything else, for the custom or trade to drift towards the larger picture theatres— that is so, at any rate, in Dublin. People in the trade have told me that no matter what concessions with regard to entertainment tax are given, we are not going to do any good to quite a number of the smaller cinemas, that the people are simply going to go to the big houses which are able to afford more attractive, fresher and more widely-advertised pictures. I believe it is the owners of the smaller picture houses who are mostly clamouring for this concession. They are clamouring for a thing that I am told—and I believe it is in line with what happened elsewhere—will not substantially help them. I do not know whether I shall have anything more to say on the matter on Report Stage or not, but I must oppose the amendment as it stands.

Comment on this

I can speak with a certain amount of personal experience on this matter, because I have some financial interest in it. The point I am making is that, due to these watertight compartments you have, it is very difficult even to regulate the prices in the way you want. In many cases you are driven to put the lower prices on an uneconomic level, because if you do not you drop into a stage in which your taxation proportion runs right up. I have a graph here showing the rates, and if you take a case here at one shilling your taxation percentage is 25. By the time you have gone down to ninepence, your taxation percentage has gone up to about 40. You are not able to vary it in little stages. You come to a place and you say, "I should like to take a penny off here." You cannot do that without sacrificing two or three times the amount of revenue. The broad tendency, undoubtedly, is that as the people become poorer entertainment becomes more of as necessity. The necessity comes in certain classes of lives for a certain amount of amusement in one place or another. That becomes an actual psychological necessity. If the Minister cannot start to make a concession along the whole of the scale, I would suggest to him that he concentrate very severely upon the lower side of the scale—that is, from one shilling down. He took the case of the little cinemas which, he said, were being pressed. I cannot say that I speak with any particular knowledge of this, but the particular case he put rather suggested that in those cases they would pass on the advantage. Those places are hard-driven, and, probably due to the watertight compartments into which they are forced by the present gradation of the tax, they are forced to put up a price very often which they would rather not, because if they came down at all they would lose very much more than they would gain.

It is along those lines he should proceed and, simply and solely, concentrate on the lower side. I think the Minister is entitled to the revenue he is now getting from the entertainment tax, but it ought to be done down on the other side. Another point I wish to put—it is quite easy to do it in relation to big places and places where the tax is collected by revenue officials and where payment is made by cheque—is that the Minister might perhaps fix 25 or 20 per cent. of the total receipts and leave the people who arranged the entertainment to vary their allocations as they liked without being tied in watertight compartments. I am sure that the people would get considerably more value for their money. I have known cases where the receipts have been reduced and the taxes increased. You are often between the devil and the deep sea. You may want to do a thing which may be right commercially but which, owing to the present allocation of water-tight compartments, it is impossible to do. I suggest that the Minister goes into that and, if he cannot meet the case over a considerable area, he should concentrate on the lower end of the scale. There you get down to pence and halfpence and you cannot make a lower concession. In the lower scale people are paying large amounts and you are driving them, if not into injustice, into hardship. I think the Minister might consider coming to a certain point where he would stop taxing altogether. He might, for instance, say that he would not tax under sixpence. Whatever way he works it out he will find that his best plan will be to concentrate on the lower rates.

Comment on this

I want to say a word against Deputy J.J. Byrne's suggestion to put a tax on greyhound racing. A case was made for the abolition of the entertainment tax on horse-racing on the ground that it is an industry but, if it is, the same applies in the case of greyhound racing.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

There is no suggestion in the amendment about any such tax.

Comment on this

No; but Deputy Byrne advocated a tax.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

That does not put it into order.

Comment on this

Am I in order in speaking?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Yes, to the amendment, but not in reference to a tax on greyhound racing.

Comment on this

It is suggested as an alternative tax.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

I understand that the objection is to the suggestion that a tax should be put on greyhound racing.

Comment on this

Yes, and I am entitled to give my reasons.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Not now.

Comment on this

I would like to join the Deputies who have made an appeal for a lower rate of tax in the case of smaller theatres with low prices seats such as 5d., 6d., and 9d. The Minister in his reply made the case that people were inclined to drift to the bigger houses. That may be so with a certain class, but there is a class who visit the picture houses I have in mind where there are cheap seats from 5d. to 9d.— seats which you have not in the bigger houses. Such people will not drift to the bigger houses. I suggest that these small houses, to which I refer, should not have a tax of twopence on a five-penny admission ticket. That is really asking people in low priced seats to pay 40 per cent. amusement tax as against the 20 per cent. paid by people in higher priced seats. I maintain that these smaller houses should not be crushed out, and that the tax as applied to them should be reduced. A few theatres which were started in Dublin in the early days of the pictures have seating capacity for not more than three or four hundred people. Such a tax is unfair to them and they will be crushed out if it remains as it is. Some of the houses which I have in mind employ staffs of, at least, a dozen. In one case the theatre has a staff of eight, but even a staff of eight employees ought to be considered and such theatres should not be crushed out of existence if it is in the Minister's power to avoid it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. HOGAN (An Clár) Labour Party

I think the case has been very well made. The Minister said that he could not realise much out of dog racing. If I were in a position to introduce an amendment for the increase of taxation in certain quarters I could probably show him where an amount of money could be got, but as I am not entitled to do that I must refrain from doing so. I would like to get something more definite from the Minister as to what he is prepared to do between this and the Report Stage, as I am anxious that whatever benefits may be derived from this will pass to the public. That is mainly why I moved in the matter. Before we decide what shall be the fate of the amendment I would like the Minister to state more definitely what help he is prepared to give in the matter.

Comment on this

I could not accept this. In view of the general Budget position I could not accept an amendment that would really lose revenue on entertainment tax. It may be possible to lose perhaps a thousand pounds, but, generally speaking, it is impossible to accept an amendment that will mean a loss of revenue. I am prepared to examine the scale and see whether it is possible by readjustment to relieve the lower priced seats or, rather, some of them, but I would not promise to consider any proposal that would mean a loss of revenue.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

In view of that statement I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

To insert before Section 25 a new section as follows: "Section 36 of the Finance Act, 1926, is hereby repealed."

Section 36 of the Finance Act of 1926 is the last remnant of the excess profits tax. That tax was amongst the taxes put on during the war. It has gone for all practical purposes except in this case where, when it is decided by the Revenue Commissioners that there is a case of fraud or wilful neglect "on the part of any person who has been owner of a trade or business liable to excess profits duty, and on which such duty has not been assessed, the Commissioners may make an assessment, etc." It gives the Commissioners power to act as judge and jury in deciding the question as to whether there was fraud or neglect, and then to impose the excess profits tax which they consider should have been paid previously. The actual effect of that in a considerable number of cases is to prevent people paying arrears of income tax. Anyone who has committed deliberate fraud or wilful neglect, and who has done it on a large scale, is not going to pay arrears of income tax if they can avoid it. Such people have taken up the attitude, more or less, of clearing out of this country. They have probably put the money into some investment in England and the dividends are paid into an English bank. If these people are in a position to reside elsewhere, and if they think they are going to be followed up closely, they will go elsewhere, and then of course they cannot be followed at all, so that really the only people who might be caught under this clause are people who conscientiously think they have not committed fraud or wilful neglect. You have people who may have committed a kind of technical fraud or neglect, but they are not criminals in any sense of the word. They now find themselves placed in the position—and I know cases of the kind—where they say, "If I could get rid of my liabilities by paying the arrears of income tax I would do so, but when I am also faced with the prospect of having extra profits charged against me I cannot do it, or I am not going to do it, because it would mean such an enormous sum."

Take, for instance, the case of a man who would be willing to pay £4,000 arrears of income tax. Such a man might have to pay £15,000 if excess profits were charged against him. It is a principle of equity and a principle which should be observed in making law, that you should not make the law so difficult that people will do their best to break that law and evade it. It is rather to get rid of this imposition and to get rid of something which is wrong from the point of view of the principle of law-making that I move this amendment. It may probably affect the Government in that they will get in more tax. People will be glad to get rid of this threat which overshadows them. They are anxious to live in the country and to invest money in the country if they can do it, and if the excess profits threat is removed they might very likely come along and make it easier for the Inland Revenue authorities to collect arrears of income tax. If in any shape the Minister for Finance could recognise this principle and consider it. I think it would have a good effect, because although there may be cases of abuse or fraud, possibly the amount of money which the Revenue authorities are going to get in cases where there is obvious fraud may very well be counter-balanced and exceeded considerably by the amount of money which will be brought in if the clause were got rid of altogether.

Comment on this

Since the Deputy mentioned this matter on the Second Reading of the Bill I have had consideration given to it. At that time I was not quite sure whether I might not be able to go some way to meet the Deputy, but on examination of the position I find it will not be possible to do so. So far as I could find the adoption of the amendment would probably lose us a very large sum of money. We would remain liable to make repayments, and we would lose revenue that is coming in. The matter has been examined by officials who are familiar with the whole income tax position and the excess profits tax position, and who know something about the evasions that have to be contended with. The view taken is that a very large sum of money would actually be lost. We are very near the end of this task, but we cannot drop off our repayments, and we could not drop off the recovery of tax, on which a great deal of work has already been expended, because the investigations have brought matters up to the point where the Revenue Commis- sioners can certify that there was certain or wilful neglect. There are not so many other cases on which work will have to be undertaken. In a year or two this thing will pass away, but at the present stage a great deal of that work has been done. A number of cases have ripened, or almost ripened, for action, and the passage of the amendment would mean that these people who are going to be brought to book would escape and the tax would be lost.

The Revenue Commissioners' position, as the Deputy knows, is that they have to give a decision as to whether or not there was fraud or wilful neglect. Once they have decided that, it only enables them to proceed for the recovery of the tax. No tax can be recovered that is not due, and the taxpayer has all the ordinary avenues of appeal open to him if he challenges the assessment or if he challenges them on a point of law. The only point he cannot challenge is as to whether they will or will not proceed. I have not any sympathy with these people, and I have no sympathy with the patriot who will stick to the country if he is allowed to put £15,000 of the Exchequer's money into his pocket. That is really the patriotism of the people who would stay here if they are not asked to pay arrears of income tax. I fear that if we let these people off some other people who owe income tax arrears would hold off and would create an agitation in the belief that they would be relieved of their liabilities. In any case I am not satisfied, as Deputy Little thinks, that the Exchequer might gain such a large sum by letting these people off. It would lose a lot. Taking such cases as there are of frauds or abuse, I think it is true that where their neighbours, perhaps a next door neighbour, has just been brought to book, there is an element of unfairness to people who have already been made to pay if we allowed other defaulters to escape. It would be unfair if by the adoption of Deputy Little's amendment such people could say they had been mulcted because their cases were handled a little more rapidly than those of their neighbours. Undoubtedly they would have some grounds for a sense of grievance, and, taking all the factors into consideration, and taking into account that a substantial sum of money would be lost, I feel that the amendment of the Deputy is one that I cannot accept.

Comment on this

We, on this side of the House, have no sympathy with any person who attempts to evade the payment of income tax. That person is in the position of trying to make his less fortunate fellow-citizen pay by indirect taxation some portion of the burdens that the man who is evading his income tax should bear. I think this is a question that we can consider on the grounds of expediency. Neither have we any sympathy with the patriot who, as the Minister for Finance says, would like to invest £15,000 of ill-gotten money in this country, provided he would be free from retrospective proceedings from abroad. I think the point we have to consider is whether it would be to the advantage of the community as a whole that certain sums of money which are at present locked up and, therefore, unproductive, should, by some sort of widening-out of these arrears and past malpractices, be made available for the benefit of the community or whether on the whole that would not be a good thing to do. That is the sort of problem we have to consider quantitatively.

I should like if the Minister could give us some indication as to the amount of money he anticipates he will be able to recover under this particular section, and, on the other hand, the amount of repayment of the excess profits duty which he expects to get. If he could give some information like that to the Dáil we would not be inclined to press the amendment. It may be that the time is not ripe to wipe out everything that occurred up to the present, but it is a question whether some of these are sums of money which would not probably be paid at any time. I feel that at some time he will have to make such a final balance and wipe out these accounts.

Comment on this

It is difficult, of course, to make an estimate of these matters, but the estimate that the Revenue Commissioners have made as to the effect of the passage of this amendment is that it would be a loss to the Exchequer of £100,000, not necessarily this year, but this year and next year and the year after, perhaps.

Comment on this

I move an amendment to the Second Schedule:—

In the title to the Schedule on page 15, after the word "rates" to insert the word "of" and delete the word "allowance" and substitute therefor the word "allowances."

This is a drafting amendment for the purpose of making the matter clear.

Second Schedule, as amended, put and agreed to.

Third Schedule and the Title put and agreed to.

Comment on this