CONSTITUTION (AMENDMENT No. 10) BILL, 1928. - DECLARATION UNDER ARTICLE 47 OF THE CONSTITUTION.
Contributions 1–145 of 278. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 23 of 1928 ›
I move:—
That it is hereby declared that the Bill entitled the Constitution (Amendment No. 10) Bill, 1928, which has this day been passed by Dáil Eireann, is necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace and safety.
The passage of a Resolution in this or in similar terms by the Dáil and by the Seanad is the means of securing that the Constitution (Amendment No. 10) Bill, which has for its object the removal of Article 47 of the Constitution on the ground that it is undesirable and dangerous, will not be held up by virtue of the particular Article which it is intended to remove. The speeches which have been delivered by some Deputies against this measure are themselves a fairly clear indication as to the intent and purpose of certain Deputies in the event of a Resolution of this sort not being carried. In view of that situation we have got to consider what would be likely to be put before the people in the event of a petition being served in accordance with the Article which it is proposed to remove by this measure. Might I bring to recollection some of the statements which have been made in the course of the debate on the Bill almost from its inception? Just a few things stand out prominently which merit our consideration.
Deputies have not been lax in bringing up some of the statements I made during the General Election, and in quoting them here in the House, but none of them has been so industrious as to find out what was said in connection with these two Articles. I find on looking up some of the statements I made that I addressed myself at meetings to those two Articles, one in Cork on the 13th September, 1927, and the other in Kilkenny on 9th September, 1927. We stood not alone for a particular policy or line of policy during the General Election, but through the courtesy of those who were opposed to us we were invited to stand practically over everything that had happened in recent times here and in the country. On those issues the result of that General Election is fresh in the minds of the people here. Following upon that is the usual course by which the President of the Executive Council is nominated by the Dáil, and he in turn nominates the other members of the Executive Council. The Dáil then proceeds to do its business by majorities, which is the well-known democratic method. According to what we have heard here during the past few days it is very desirable that the majority in a Parliament, according to the extraordinary doctrines we have heard during the last few days should only concern itself with what will please, convenience and placate the minority. That is not my interpretation; it is not the interpretation of the people of the country; and it is not the interpretation which will commend itself to any people who have any idea of democratic rights or freedom.
Examining some of the statements made in opposition to this measure, I find there has been a disposition on the part of those opposite to say that it is not and was not intended that the Referendum or the Initiative would be lightly used, though Deputy Ryan was candid enough to admit that questions that might not commend themselves to this House, such as the reduction of the liquor duties tax, might be presented to this House by certain persons so interested. On that question you would have not alone the trouble and expense in the first place of getting up the Initiative, but, secondly, in the event of the Dáil not accepting the recommendations of those who had an interest in having the liquor duties reduced, to put that as an issue to the people——
Comment on this
The President is moving a motion which does not seem to raise the question of the Initiative.
Comment on this
I was going on to say that one of the things which would be promised the people in connection with the Referendum on this particular Bill, that that particular item and every other item of social reform which any person in the country had propounded would be presented as a reason why the Initiative should be kept, and in the background would be the proposal that this is the only method of getting rid of Article 17 in the Constitution. In respect of that, from our experience during the last few days, and our knowledge of the various attempts to create heat and friction over that matter, we would have the public peace, the public health and public safety endangered. That is a thing that as long as I have any responsibility for administration in this country I will see is not going to happen. That was one of the principal objections to this measure, that it closed the door in respect of taking out Article 17 of the Constitution, that we had here pictured for us during the last few days. It is no longer love of this country but hatred of another country which constitutes their patriotism. I do not subscribe to that conception. This resolution is necessary for the public peace, health and safety, and I move it accordingly.
Comment on this
The members opposite have shown in the past that there is very little limit to their audacity, and when we see in cold blood this motion moved and the members here asked to subscribe to lies one realises that there is no limit—none whatever— to the audacity of the members on the opposite benches. Just listen to the motion:—
"That it is hereby declared that the Bill entitled the Constitution (Amendment No. 10) Bill, 1928, which has this day been passed by Dáil Eireann is necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace and safety."
The gentlemen who went out on that cry when they were panic-stricken a short time ago ought not to be in a condition of panic to-day. Now, apparently, they are panic-stricken lest the people should be appealed to, lest the people should have the opportunity of deciding whether they should give away and surrender the powers which in the last resort would enable them to keep an unscrupulous Executive within check. We heard some gentlemen this morning talk about the dignity of this House. I wonder what respect has the proposer of this motion for the dignity of this House, for the dignity of any individual in this House who does not want to subscribe his name to a lie?
Comment on this
If you wish to get a synonym of that kind for it, all right. It is quite obviously, manifestly untrue and false. There is no immediate danger from which the people have to be saved by the passing of this motion. They have to be saved from themselves, I suppose. I was wondering what excuse was going to be given by those who proposed this motion.
I was listening to see was there any reasonable excuse that could be given for it. The excuse is because heat was generated here that it was dangerous that this question of the rights of the people should go before the people. When here in this House a debate was in progress on the military resolutions, the result of which was the putting to death of 77 young Irishmen, this was the excuse that was given for it by the proposer of this motion, who thinks now there is such danger in referring this to the people that we must pass a lie or manifest falsehood, as the Ceann Comhairle prefers it to be called, in order that the people should be saved from themselves. The President of the Executive Council, speaking on the introduction of these military resolutions, said that these resolutions were necessary because of the action outside, which was a direct challenge to the authority of the people. Who is directly challenging the authority of the people now, and challenging them and trying to deprive the people of that authority not after consulting them and asking them, but after trying or proposing to this House anyhow that we should do it by means of a subterfuge or lie? At least the men who challenged it before did it openly and honestly; they did not attempt a subterfuge or lie for it. That is what is proposed here, and we are, in cold blood, every one of us, being asked to come and subscribe to that. I do not wish to quote from the dead, and consequently I leave some of this matter to be read by anybody who is interested in the reasons that were being put forward there for the execution of young Irishmen. I will ask some of the Deputies here to come and read the speeches made by the late Vice-President when these motions were being introduced, and I leave also aside for anybody who wants to read them and satisfy himself on them the statements made by some of the other gentlemen who are over there. The people are being asked—no, they are not being asked, we are told that they were told last June that they were going to be deprived of these rights and that nevertheless they returned the Executive. The people were told these Articles were to be cut out. Why? Because we outside this House were trying to use them as a means of getting in here honourably, without having to pretend or appear to acknowledge allegiance to an outside power. They were not talked of so much when it came to the next election, because we happened to be in.
Comment on this
As a matter of historical accuracy it is in September the statements were made which I referred to.
Comment on this
It is all right, the general election was the time that was put up. Probably. It was only when it was made quite clear that we were going to use that particular machinery, the only way open to us in the Constitution, in order to get in here and allow those we represent to be represented properly, that the question for the first time was raised of taking out Articles 47 and 48. When we came in here there was no question of the removing of these Articles. There was a Bill on the stocks which had passed a certain number of stages. There was no question of reintroducing that Bill. It was only when we, in accordance with that Article, produced in this House the 96,000 signatures, not merely 75,000, but 96,000 signatures, to a Petition asking that that Article should be put into operation that there was a question of removing it. You are trying to do the very same thing by this series of amendments as you are trying to do by this resolution; the resolution is an attempt to fool the people into thinking that you are acting constitutionally, when you know perfectly well that you are not. The present attempt by these Bills to get out of the obligations of Article 48 will not impose on anybody who tries to see beyond the surface. I hope this attempt by means of an obvious falsehood to get justification to prevent this Bill being sent to the people will fail. If ever there was a Bill that had a right to be sent to the people, that justified a Referendum, it was this Bill, because if you did get the authority of the people to act without the Referendum, to take these out, there would be some justification for your action. If the people wish to surrender the powers of being the final arbiters, well and good; but as long as these Articles are in the Constitution you are not entitled to deprive people of these powers. I say the action of the Executive in those two things is absolutely unconstitutional. We on those benches have not, as we indicated, very much respect for the Constitution, but at least we were honest and told the people we had no respect; but the gentlemen on the opposite benches went out and asked the people to support them because they were supporters of the Constitution, of the guarantee of the people's liberties and these Articles were pointed to. If you went to one of your political opponents and spoke in private with him and argued with him about the nature of this Constitution you were met with Article 47 and told: "Look how democratic it is; look at Articles 47 and 48. If the people want to do anything they can do it"; but the same audacity is going to be used on this occasion to get a majority who happen to be attached to this particular Party to forget all considerations of honour and decency and pass this lie.
Comment on this
I honestly confess that I feel myself in very great difficulty in finding arguments to use against the proposition which has been moved by the President. It is difficult to argue against a motion of this kind where a statement which is so obviously incorrect is put down in the form of a motion and we are seriously asked to pass it. It is quite difficult to find arguments, and it is quite useless evidently to put up any argument as to why a motion of this kind should not be passed. It is quite clear that the Government are prepared to stoop to anything in order to get their way in this matter. I remember discussing this very question about a week ago as to the future of this Bill or the possibility of a motion of this kind being moved. A certain member of my own Party said it was just possible that the Government would do this. I scouted the very idea that they would stoop to a thing like that. I said they would never do a thing like that. I am speaking sincerely and honestly——
Comment on this
——because I could not think, even knowing them as I do, that a motion of that kind would be put before this House. We are asked to say if the people of this country are asked to vote on a simple issue to answer a simple question, yes or no, that they will immediately destroy the peace of this country. I say that is a slander on the Irish people. I have no hesitation in saying that. The President goes to America and other countries. Many people here are in the association with people of outside countries for the purpose of securing peace and other things. It has been his and our boast that the blessings of peace have been brought to this country. We are now told that we are so little removed from a state of disturbance that the discussion of a political question like this is going to plunge the country into disorder. I do not believe it. I do not believe that the President himself believes it. I do not believe that any member of that Party believes that the discussion of this thing will endanger the peace of this country. Last year we had two general elections. We had public meetings of all kinds all over the country. Let the President stand up and say that the public peace of the country was in danger. He knows it was not. What becomes of the right of assembly? Is that Article of the Constitution going to go altogether?—the right of the people to assemble peacefully and without arms to discuss political questions. What danger does the President foresee when he asks this House to pass a resolution of this kind? Where is the danger? What is going to happen? Let us follow out calmly what is going to happen if this resolution is not passed by both Houses. Sixty-two members of this House, if they desire to do so, will have the right to sign a certain petition asking that this Bill be held up for ninety days. Sixty-two members of this House represent a very considerable number of the people of this country. If we base it on the numbers mentioned in the Constitution to the effect that one Deputy is supposed to represent some 20,000 or 30,000 of the people, sixty-two members of this House will represent one and a quarter million people of this country. That is a considerable proportion of the people of this country.
They ask that this Bill be held up for ninety days. In that ninety days there is a right given to one-twentieth, I think, of the people of this country to sign a petition that this measure be referred through machinery that is already there in our electoral Bill to the people. If one-twentieth of the voters on the register sign that petition and asked that the Referendum should be put into operation with regard to this particular measure, then the Referendum is put into operation. If the President is so sure as he says he is that the people want these Articles out—he states that definitely—then the people will express their wish in that direction and everybody will be satisfied. He thinks if a political discussion of that kind were to take place in the country that the public peace would be in danger. That is surely too much to ask us to believe. I think it would be good for the people of this country to discuss political issues of that kind, and to learn to discuss them in a calm and peaceful manner. The people that are preventing them from doing that are not doing what is best in the interests of the people. It would be far better to let them discuss them instead of to be always having the people, as it were, tied to their apron strings. They feel that they are constituted as the political guardians of the people, and that the people must not have the right to discuss these things. If there is to be political discussion in the country over these matters, does the President seriously think that that is going to endanger the public peace? The questions will be misrepresented, he says; the real issues will be misrepresented. Has the President ever fought a general election? Has it been always the case at the time of a general election, or a bye-election, that the real issues were correctly represented by one side or the other? I am sure the President is no child in these matters. I feel strongly that this proposal is not worthy of the Executive. It is, as I stated, a slander on the country. It is nothing else to say that the provisions of our Constitution could not be carried out without endangering the public peace of the country. I certainly will protest as strongly as I possibly can against a motion of this kind being carried.
Comment on this
Deputy de Valera has said that what is stated in this Resolution is manifestly untrue. Deputy O'Connell has spoken in the same sense. It seems to me, on the contrary, that what is averred here is manifestly true. Once this matter has been raised it must be settled with as little delay as possible if there is not to be a breach of the peace. Without wishing to lay too much stress upon it, I do say that the tone of the discussion in this House, the arguments that have been used, and the violent accusations that have been thrown out, do show that if the discussion of this particular matter was carried into the country it could not be peaceably carried out.
Comment on this
I would like to say this, if the main opposition in this House conducted their opposition to this Bill in the same temper as the Labour Party conducted their opposition, I would not for a moment believe that there was going to be any danger to the peace of the country.
Comment on this
The behaviour of the Deputies on the other side in this present discussion has been very closely similar to the behaviour in another discussion. (Interruptions). I have no doubt at all that the attitude would be that nobody who was supporting the Bills would be allowed to speak, and that any violence that may be used against them just, as any accusations that may be made would be justified. (Interruptions). I do not say that the public disorder would be such as could not be dealt with.
Comment on this
The fact that I will not be allowed to speak is another indication of the necessity for this motion. It is a magnificent argument for it. It certainly would be sufficient to prevent any fair discussion on the matter throughout the country. The Deputy talks about the rights which the people have. If there is anything in these particular Articles of the Constitution that are being removed they are duties that were contingently, at any rate, thrust on the people without being asked for. There was no public demand for setting up machinery for the Referendum.
Comment on this
These duties were contingently thrust on the people, and they shall be no longer thrust on the people, but if there is desire for a change, that change can be effected. I have already stated that it is our intention to amend Article 50, but even if it were not amended, if there was a substantial majority of the people strongly in favour of such a constitutional change, they would still be able to carry it out. It is proposed to make it easier. None of that would be said. It would be represented in the country in such a way as inevitably to cause great excitement and heated feeling, and it would be said that here was the last chance of effecting a constitutional change being taken away. I know very well, and I think that any Deputy who calmly considers the matter will feel, that the sort of argument and discussion which is being carried on here would undoubtedly, if carried on in the country, lead to serious breaches of the peace. For that reason, once the Bill has been inaugurated, once the issue becomes a live one, it was contemplated that it was one of the questions that should not be carried to the country in the way in which this particular change has been carried.
Comment on this
To my mind there is no answer to the statement made by Deputy O'Connell and, certainly, the last speaker has furnished none. The sole reason, so far as I could gather, as given by the Minister for Finance, why this portion of Article 47 should be invoked on this occasion is that, because of the temper and tone of a certain party in this House, when certain questions are raised here, there is likely to be a disturbance of the peace in the country. Does he mean to say that when scenes occur in this House they are inevitably going to be reflected in the country, and that on every occasion on which a Deputy may get out of order, or, perhaps, be suspended in this House, the subject matter for which he was suspended will be a source of danger to the future peace of the country? That is what his argument amounts to. I think it is positively childish, to say the least of it, to suggest that this portion of Article 47 should be invoked in regard to this measure. I want to make my position clear. I have stated already, and I state again, that I will never be in favour of the Initiative. I was never consulted about it. I shall never be in favour of the Referendum. I was never consulted about it, but I took my stand on the Constitution, as it was, on every platform and at every election at which I came forward since this Constitution came into being. I have declared myself as a supporter of it. I am in favour of amending the Constitution and of doing away with the Referendum and Initiative contained in it, but I am in favour of doing that in a constitutional way and according to the Constitution. I think that to invoke Article 47 in the manner in which this proposal of the President invokes it to-day is entirely unconstitutional. It cannot be, and it has not been, seriously suggested by either of the Government's spokesmen that there will be serious disturbance and disorder in the country if the Bill is allowed to take its ordinary course.
How do we know that a certain proportion of members of this House will insist on their right in holding it up? How do we know that the Seanad would do likewise and, even if they do, I say it is our bounden duty to allow the Constitution to take its proper course, and I believe that if that action is taken by either the Seanad or the Dáil, and if this Bill is held up and if it goes to a Referendum, the sending of this Bill itself to the country by way of Referendum will kill Referendum in this country. That is one of the principal reasons, apart from the constitutional one, why I am in favour of allowing this Bill to take the course of any other ordinary Bill passed through this House.
We have had previous experience of emergency Acts. We have had the Public Safety Act passed through this House, and we have had it declared on that occasion that it was necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health and safety that that Act should be immediately passed. At that time I thought there was no excuse for that proposal, but at the same time there might have been some scintilla of excuse for what was called, if it was not in fact, a Public Safety Bill. There is, however, no excuse for a Bill which merely proposed, in accordance with the Constitution, legitimately to alter that very Constitution itself. I certainly cannot support the proposal which this resolution demands of the House. I cannot find where this Bill, if allowed to take its ordinary course, would disturb the public peace and safety of the realm. As Deputy O'Connell has said, we have had two general elections during the last year. Since I came into this House I heard no such language as that used on the hustings, and is it to be suggested that the Irish people would not be able to conduct themselves as well in reference to a change in their Constitution as they were in reference to matters of very acute and intense interest which were before them during the last two general elections? I think the suggestion is hardly worthy of consideration. With Deputy O'Connell, I think that such a proposal, which I hope was hastily arrived at by the Government, is beneath them. I think it is beneath any constitutional Government.
Comment on this
As I say, it is beneath any constitutional Government to come along and having, as I give them credit for having, legitimately passed an Act amending the Constitution, then, in my view illegitimately, to invoke a portion of that Constitution to enable that Act to be brought into operation immediately. I cannot, for the life of me, see how the Government's position can be defended, and certainly up to this, as instanced by the Minister for Finance, it has not been defended. The only reason which he has given why this extraordinary course is being adopted is because there have been a few brawls in this House on the Fianna Fáil Benches.
Comment on this
It is not for that reason that I would be prepared to take the strictly unconstitutional line which the President and his Executive have taken and have come to the conclusion that they should ask this House to take to-day.
Comment on this
I hope that Deputies when they come to vote on this motion will keep in mind its terms, that there will be no attempt to get behind any of the dishonest arguments which have been advanced, and which will be advanced by Ministers, in order to dull their consciences and induce them to vote for something which they know is not true.
This motion declares that the Bill abolishing Articles 47 and 48 of the Constitution is necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace and safety, and when the Deputies opposite go into the division lobbies that is what they are voting for. They are voting it to be their conviction that in the constituencies which they represent it is necessary that this Constitution Bill should be made operative in order to preserve the public peace and safety in the immediate future. I hope Deputies opposite will tell us exactly how public peace and safety in their constituencies are going to be imperilled if this Bill is not passed. I hope Deputies opposite will tell us exactly what particular section of the community is going to be imperilled if this Bill is not immediately passed. I hope they will not sit there like dummies and then go into the Division Lobby and give a mean unreasoning vote, unsupported by any argument when the Government Whips chase them in like sheep. I hope the Deputies in Dublin city will tell me, as a representative of the city, how the peace of the city is going to be endangered by the rejection of the Bill. I hope Deputy Thrift will tell us about the revolution that is going to happen in Trinity College in consequence of this Bill, and if there is going to be any revolution in Trinity College as a result of it, I hope he will tell us——
Comment on this
The Minister is very disorderly. If he interrupts again, I will have to move his suspension.
Comment on this
The President in introducing this motion says that it was necessary to pass it because the reference of this Bill to the people would be undesirable and dangerous. I shall really have to move the suspension of the Minister for Industry and Commerce if he continues his interruptions.
Comment on this
The President stated that the reference of this Bill to the people was undesirable and dangerous. It is undesirable and dangerous to get the people to express by their votes whether they want the Bill or not. That is from the President, who, shortly prior to the execution of Erskine Childers, said, "We are going to see that the rule of democracy is going to be maintained, no matter what the cost and no matter what intellectuals may fall by the assertion of that right." We are going to assert the rule of democracy in 1922, no matter what the cost and no matter what intellectuals may fall by the roadside in consequence of the assertion of that right. The rule of democracy to-day is undesirable and dangerous. This is 1928. The intellectuals are in their grave, many others are in their grave, and the assertion of the rule of democracy is now undesirable and dangerous.
Comment on this
It is the other statement which I think the Deputy is misquoting.
Comment on this
I took a note of it. I understood the President to say that it was undesirable and dangerous that Article 47 of the Constitution should be availed of to prevent the enactment of this Bill. If he is prepared to withdraw these words. I am prepared to give him an adequate opportunity. He used the words "undesirable and dangerous." Article 47 of the Constitution provides the machinery by which the will of the people may be ascertained on this Bill, and it is undesirable and dangerous that that should be done! I hope that some semblance of the truth concerning what is happening now will filter through the paper wall of the Press to the people. It will be a great eye-opener to them. We are very glad to see this discussion taking place. We like to see the last of the people's illusions concerning the freedom they got and the defenders of that freedom killed. We are glad to see all the veils that covered Cumann na nGaedheal stripped from them, so that the people can see them exactly for what they are. As long as he had the responsibility, says President Cosgrave, he would not allow any action to be taken which might result in the abolition of Article 17 of the Constitution. These are not his exact words, but they are the substance of them. He has come out at last exactly for what he is, the custodian of the rights of the English King in this country.
As long as he has the responsibility for government in this country that oath of allegiance, that acknowledgment of the superiority of an alien authority, is not to be imperilled. It is well that the people should understand the new alignment of forces which has taken place in this House and the new direction which is to be given to the Government's policy. We hear nothing now about freedom to achieve freedom; we hear nothing about a Republican Constitution; we hear nothing about all the lies that were used to induce the young men to join their Army and to shoot their fellow-countrymen. As long as he has the responsibility, as long as they have authority, nothing will be done which will result in the removal of that degrading Article of the Constitution by which you are forced to acknowledge the authority of His Britannic Majesty in this State. The speeches on this side of the House, says the President, make clear the intentions of the Deputies to invoke the powers of this Article and to refer the Bill to the people. It has become a matter of immediate concern to the public peace and safety because somebody, some section of irresponsibles in this House, are thinking of ascertaining the people's will upon one of your Bills; because a number of Irregulars on this side of the House have sufficient regard for democratic rights to use the machinery still existing in this Constitution to get a vote of the people as to whether or not they want this Bill. We think this Resolution is manifestly untrue, and that it is an attempt to steam-roll the people's rights and to force through this Dáil a Bill which they have not the courage to put before the people.
The Minister for Finance was equally illuminating. Once this matter has been raised, it must be settled as soon as possible to prevent a breach of the peace. Once the people get to know what is doing there must be haste and urgency; there must be no delay, because the people would be likely to act. Once this matter has been introduced into the House, there might possibly be a breach of the peace if it is not rushed through with indecent haste. Some Deputies opposite have, I think, sufficient decency left in them to be ashamed of what their leaders are doing. I hope they will take the opportunity given to-day to express their shame, or else avow themselves to be sunk in the same pit as the Executive Council.
The Minister for Finance also informed us that there was no public demand for Articles 47 and 48 of the Constitution. Was there any public demand for the Constitution? In what way was that public demand for any section of the Constitution made manifest? You brought that Constitution over in secret from England and you forced a civil war on the country; you rammed it down the neck of the people, and you cost this country in blood and treasure more than it can recover in a generation to make the Constitution law. Then you come along and tell us that there was no public demand for certain sections of it, certain sections which were put into it to gull the people—the sugar on the pill—sections which were used to secure yourselves in office, to give yourselves the power by which you could introduce Bills of this kind into the House——
Comment on this
I agree. Deputies will remember that only this morning we were discussing the Bill with which this motion is concerned, and that the arguments used in favour of it were very different, if not contradictory, to the arguments used this evening. This morning we were told that Articles 47 and 48 were faddist theories, that they were frills upon the Constitution, that they were of no importance, that they represented the result of the youth, inexperience and inability of the Government five years ago, and that we were really improving the Constitution by deleting them. Deputies who were convinced by these arguments and voted for the Bill as a result are no doubt astonished now that the same Minister who moved the Bill comes here to move this motion and to represent as being essential to the immediate preservation of the peace and safety of the State the passage of this Bill. The removal of the faddist theories, the frills upon the Constitution, the unnecessary provisions of this morning, has become necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace. Surely not every member of Cumann na nGaedheal is a fool? There must be some who realise exactly how they are being taken in. There must be some who realise that they will not be able to stand before the people on the strength of those arguments? Or do you think the people are all fools? Do you think that you have gone one better than Abraham Lincoln, that you will be able to fool all the people all the time? "Immediately necessary for the preservation of the peace and safety of this State." I could mention every Deputy opposite by name, and I hope they will tell us exactly why this Bill is necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace and safety of this State. If they do not believe it, I hope they will have the moral courage to go into the Division Lobby and vote against it.
Comment on this
It is very important as to when the Division is taken. If it is taken within ten minutes we might.
Comment on this
Can I move the closure? However, I do not intend to delay the House. I intend to give an opportunity to Deputy Gorey to redeem his past, and I conclude my speech by hoping that he is speaking, not merely for himself, but for other members of Cumann na nGaedheal.
Comment on this
I should very much prefer to give way to some of the mute inglorious Miltons on the back Benches of Cumann na nGaedheal, the dumb, driven cattle, the people who intend to come here as long as this Parliament will last, who tear themselves away unwillingly occasionally from other parts of the House to come in and ask to which Division Lobby they have to go and nothing else; who for years have been here and never opened their mouths. These dumb, driven cattle——
Comment on this
I am prepared to say here, and to say outside of here, outside of the privileges, outside of the protections, and outside of the inhibitions of this Dáil all that I believe in this matter. I am not prepared to be one of the dumb, driven cattle of Cumann na nGaedheal, who come here just to register their votes in the Lobby.
Comment on this
Of course, it may be very useful to be allowed to deal with something outside the motion, rather than to deal with the motion itself.
Comment on this
It is important for the people of the country to know that the back bencher of Cumann na nGaedheal, the ordinary representative of the people, the man who has been sent up from Galway, from Roscommon, from Nenagh, from West Cork and from East Cork, has said no word, has sat dumb, and allowed merely his own Front Bench to make up his mind for him and speak for him. You are up against a frigid and calculated lie, and the silent members on the back benches of Cumann na nGaedheal are asked to go into the Lobby and declare that that frigid and calculated lie is the truth, because in the declaring a frigid and calculated lie the truth they are able to dish their political opponents, they are able to take away from the people control over this Dáil. They are prepared to save themselves the necessity of going back and convincing the people; they are able to save themselves from the necessity of going and meeting us on the hustings and hearing us give exactly the same reasons to the people that they do not dare to attempt to answer here. That is what the dumb driven cattle of Cumann na nGaedheal are going into the Lobby to vote for, and that is why I would infinitely rather give way and hear the ordinary representative of Cumann na nGaedheal, the ordinary representative of the people—five hundred thousand odd of them—who have sent them here to have wills, to have ideas, to have voices and opinions of their own, and to make their own contribution to the development and the existence and the strength of this State, not merely to be echoes of the caucus on the Front Bench. It is significant that Fianna Fáil Deputy after Fianna Fáil Deputy has to rise, and that though we stand and wait, not a single ordinary man on the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches has the courage to have or express an opinion.
Urgency, immediate urgency, violent urgency; the public safety in peril if you do not have immediate urgency. No evidence of it whatever, except party political necessity. There is immediate danger of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. There is distinct definite danger of the existence of everything that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party stands for if they do not pass this Bill at once. There is danger if they leave themselves to the people, immediate danger. That is the danger to be guarded against and in which this Constitution, bad as it is, is to be scandalised. Keep the people out of it, do not let them lay sacrilegious hands upon this Constitution for which so much blood and treasure has been spent. Keep the people away from it, that is the danger; there is no other danger. Members sitting on the Cumann na nGaedheal back benches shall never be allowed to submit this thing to their constituents. Their constituents are of such a character, their morale is so low, their respect for their members is so small, their regard for the decencies of public life is so nonexistent that Deputies cannot discuss these matters in their constituencies. That is what Deputies opposite are saying. Every man who goes into the Division Lobby and says this great constitutional question cannot be considered and discussed in the face of the people without endangering the public peace of this State is insulting his own constituents and doing a thing that he would not dare to do unless safeguarded by the removal of these Articles, and the particular overlay on this Bill in the passing of time that will enable them to forget the insult that was thrown back into their teeth in return for the vote they gave to the dumb driven cattle on the benches of Cumann na nGaedheal. The President says that in Cork on the 13th September and in Kilkenny on the 19th——
Comment on this
The 9th. The President said a lot of things. Does the fact that the President said that mean that he came here with a mandate to do it? On what date did the President say he was going to abolish proportional representation? On what date did he tell the people how at a certain by-election he did not get the amount of support he would have got if he had abolished it? Did he come here with a mandate also, I ask Deputies on the back benches of Cumann na nGaedheal, to gerrymander the constituencies in any way he liked and to tear out of the Constitution what they have boasted was one of its democratic elements? How has he a mandate for one thing and not for another? Has he merely to quote something he said somewhere, somehow, sometime, and so long as he has a majority, no matter how fundamental the alteration that he wants to carry, he has a mandate and a right and a duty to do it? That is the sort of argument that cuts deep into public peace in this country. That is the sort of argument which will, if it is believed, turn the people into looking for other ways. Personally this story of mandate to do all sorts of things, founded upon some obscure utterance of the President's in an obscure place to be quoted when it suits him and to be hidden when it does not, carries no conviction whatever to me.
We lose control over this measure, and it is suggested that we should freely do it because contingently some time, this year, next year, or some time, whenever it suits the political Party necessities of the Government opposite they are going to amend in some way, somehow and in some direction Article 50 of the Constitution. We are to buy this pig in a poke. We are to trust to the President, to trust to what we know of his method of manipulating the Constitution, and to keep his word for the carrying out of that. The greatest constitutional issue, greater altogether than this, because this is only part of the machinery, a great piece of the machinery, but on that fundamental matter of setting up in this country two States he gave an offer. He said, get your men to operate this portion of the Constitution and you can go ahead, but when he found it could be done he went back of his word. We are to accept the word of such a man with such a record. But the elision of Articles 47 and 48 is going to be compensated by the expansion in some direction at some time of Article 50. Does he realise that under the Bills passed through the House, under the extension of time that we are giving as part of the blackmail bargain to the Seanad, that they can hold up his amendment of Article 50 until it ceases to be operative under the Constitution and until he cannot put it in under the Constitution? Did the President explain that to Deputies of Cumann na nGaedheal? Did he tell them that the promise he made to them is contingent upon the Seanad not using the powers which he is giving them deliberately under another Bill for the purpose of making it inoperative? Is that what he does not want us to tell the electorate upon the hustings? Does he want us to go to the country and tell the people what power they are actually losing under this Bill? That is the danger—a danger to everything the Cumann na nGaedheal stands for to-day, the danger of the great betrayal, the danger of the building up in this system over the head and the authority of the people something that even the people altogether will not be able to get out of it except by use of means which are not contemplated in any civil Constitution. They do not dare to go to the country; that is the immediate danger, not to the State, not to the public safety. The President just managed to drag in these words at the end of his speech, just managed to drag them in by the scruff of the neck, that is all he could do. He could not show they had any connection; he had just dragged them in. That is all he did; this frigid and calculated lie.
It is suggested—and I do not know whether it is speeches like the speech I am delivering now and the speeches that have been delivered in this House —that these speeches are going to be a danger to the public peace, health and safety.
Comment on this
No, not lightly used. If this instrument is left in the hands of the people to be used by them as I believe it will be used, responsibly for high matters of national interest, how on earth is it going to interfere immediately with the public safety and public peace? Does this House really want that there shall be no means by which upon the larger Treaty-barred issues of the Constitution the people will be unable to express their opinions without coming to an immediate clash? Do they really want that there should be taken out of this Constitution the means by which—without coming to a definite and immediate clash with the co-signatory of that so-called Treaty—we can put before the world the visible demand of the people of this country that there shall be changes in the Treaty-barred portions of that Constitution? Will the keeping of that power in our possession produce immediate dangers to the public safety of the country?
Down in the country paid organisers of the Cumann na nGaedheal organisation were saying that we were a Party of accomplished liars. We can return that compliment because this frigid and calculated lie is a frigid and calculated lie upon the surface. Every man who hears it, and every man who endorses it, and every man who goes into the lobby in support of it, knows that it is what it is—a lie, a barefaced lie, and nothing but a lie. There is no necessity whatever for Article 47, we are told. The Seanad would under no condition, we are told, interfere with the liberty of the people. The Seanad would not hold anything up from them. They came to this House and asked for the Public Safety Act, which took out of the Treaty and which took out of the Constitution all the primal safeguards for personal liberty, they demanded it on twenty-four hours' notice from the Seanad, the very Seanad that passed round notes among themselves not to alter it by one single comma and by not one single word, for fear it might go back to a Dáil which was then in possession of a majority to defeat it. If that Seanad had held up that for them there might have been some justification, there might have been some respectability, from the national point of view, in regarding that as an institution which, in return for taking away its power from the people, should be put above the Dáil, which was capable of passing a Public Safety Act in the way it was. But it did not.
Under this thing you are giving the power out of your hand. You are losing control of the greatest democratic instrument in the Constitution, and you are doing it, not in the interests of the public safety, but in the interests of the continued existence of a Party and for what that Party stands—the betrayal of everything for which what all that is best in the country stands, and which makes for everything that is for the public safety and interest of this country. Unworthy of the Executive some one said. Worthy of the Executive! Worthy to be its gravestone. When its epitaph comes to be written it will be a very merciful and overstrainedly merciful epitaph which will simply label them "duds." It would be a strain upon honesty to put merely that title upon their graves. They are men who have taken every sacred thing they have laid their hands on and turned it into a Party purpose, coined it into a Party purpose, and to-day they are calling upon the public safety of this country, which they have no more regard for than they have had for anything else that is holy and sacred in the country. They are calling upon the public safety to shield and to cover faces in the most shameless misuse of the Constitution for Party and partisan purpose that has ever disgraced the history of any legislative assembly.
Comment on this
I think Deputies in most Parties will agree that if by passing this Resolution and by getting this Bill through the Dáil, and getting this Bill without a Referendum, we save the country from a fate that may possibly overtake it—such a fate as having Deputy Flinn going ranting through the country at a time when the people should be thinning their turnips— that would be a full justification for this Resolution. I ask the Parties to examine that aspect of the situation. There were a good many things said, and the Labour Party put up a point of view, and Deputy Redmond put up a point of view, and I ask them, if we are bound to have a Referendum on this Bill, to consider for a moment the position of having Deputy Flinn going from Galway to Nenagh—he will keep away from Cork for good reasons which are connected with the last election—to have the Deputy going to Galway and Nenagh and other parts of the country talking the sort of "blather" that we have listened to here this evening. I have listened to Deputy Flinn's speech very carefully. I seldom listen to his speech and I try to go to sleep. I listened carefully to this speech, and I could not get a single point out of it— not one. I tried even to get one. In the beginning, when the Deputy came to the Dáil with a certain reputation for oratory. I used to listen to him, but gradually I came to discover that I could not get a point from any speech that he made. He has ranted there for the last half-hour in the House and talked about "duds." He has carried on in the same way as a cheap jack would on a market day in the country. But he has never made a single point against our policy or against this Resolution.
Comment on this
I want to dispose of one point. We are told that it is unconstitutional. We should give up this misuse of words. This Bill is not unconstitutional, and if it were unconstitutional the courts are there and we can be stopped quickly at any time——
Comment on this
I may be allowed to say that the courts are impartial——
Comment on this
You will not have to get even a jury this time. This is a serious matter. I wish you would treat it seriously. Deputy Redmond made the point that this was unconstitutional. If it is unconstitutional the courts are there and they can deal with it. If we are to talk in this way of unconstitutional action of any kind —good, bad or indifferent—I want you to remember that the courts are there to stop us, and I have sufficient respect for the legal advisers of the Party opposite if not for themselves——
Comment on this
I have sufficient respect for the legal advisers of the Party opposite to know that if we on these Benches did take action of any kind which was in fact unconstitutional there would be a writ or appropriate action would be taken against us immediately.
Comment on this
Perhaps I would be allowed to explain my meaning of the word "unconstitutional." I mean unconstitutional in the wider sense, not altogether confined to a breach of our Constitution. When I used the word "unconstitutional" I used it to describe the action, as I consider it, of the Executive Council in invoking Article 47 of the Constitution for the passage of this Bill as unconstitutional. What I mean by that is this, that it was a misuse of Article 47, to my mind. Article 47 or that portion of it which is being invoked now, was never meant for any kind of a Bill but an emergency Bill which was necessary for the public safety of this State.
Comment on this
I quite follow the Deputy's meaning. That is not the sense in which it has been constantly used from those opposite benches. There is constantly the pretence put up here, which is not meant for the consumption of Deputies in this House, because speakers know that the Deputies are better informed, but it is meant for the country, that we are taking unconstitutional action. We cannot take unconstitutional action. We have an excellent judiciary and an excellent police force, and if we attempt to take unconstitutional action we can always be dealt with. I claim every right— good, bad or indifferent, direct or indirect—that we have got under the Constitution. I claim the right to use that in favour of the policy which we are trying to carry out. We will make no concession to the Party opposite in regard to fundamentals.
Comment on this
Do not get me on to the British. We will not make any concessions good, bad or indifferent to the Party opposite in regard to fundamentals.
Comment on this
The same thing. I believe firmly that the status we have now is far and away a greater status than the status of a Republic. On these matters we will not make any concession —on these and kindred matters. If the people decide against us, that is another matter.
Comment on this
Surely I ought to be allowed to develop my argument? That statement that I have referred to has been repeated in another form. Deputy Flinn has used it, Deputy de Valera has used it, and other Deputies have used it. We have been told that the people have no chance if this Article is taken out. That has been repeated. I want Deputies to understand that they are going to get nothing from us more or less than just their strict minimum rights, and they have to put up with that as men. When they get the majority we will not whine; we will not ask for any more or any less.
Comment on this
Perhaps not. If I am not, I will not complain. It was repeated here that if we take away this right the people have no chance. First of all, we are told we are taking away this right unconstitutionally, and if we take it away the people have no further method of, as Deputy de Valera calls it, marching forward; I call it marching backward. They have, of course, rights. For instance, there is an election every five years.
Comment on this
Of course you might. That point was put up here also. You might, we are told, take that away also. If you can get a majority in the Dáil capable of utter unscrupulousness——
Comment on this
I am making the opposite Party a present of a point. It is a point that one would think would be helpful, but they do not seem to like to hear it. If, as I say, you can get a sufficiently unscrupulous majority, then that majority can do practically anything. You have only one safeguard in this country, and that is the character of the people, and the character of the Deputies. That is the only safeguard. Deputy Flinn was looking for a safeguard.
Comment on this
I did not interrupt Deputy de Valera and why should I be interrupted? It must be that I am getting at the place where the shoe pinches; I must be getting on the raw. I want Deputies to realise that there is only one safeguard in any country and that is the character of the people. If you demoralise the people—and an attempt has been made in this country to demoralise them——
Comment on this
But that attempt did not succeed, although it was tried through institutions, referenda, and other things. There is another safeguard, and it is fundamental also, and that is the character of the people returned to the Dáil. That is the only safeguard in any democracy. You have that safeguard here, such as it is. You have it here and you have to be content with it.
Comment on this
Deputy Little was asleep while Deputy Flinn was speaking. I know that because I was looking across at him, and why he should wake up just when I am speaking I do not know. I tried to fall asleep, too, when Deputy Flinn was speaking, but I could not.
Comment on this
The whole thing arises on Deputy de Valera's statement. If you think that what I have pointed out is a real danger, you ought to consider it. I do not think you could get a majority in this House for it, and until you get a majority of the House to take away the right of election every four or five years, then the people have that safeguard. Meantime, do Deputies seriously suggest that the people of this country want to have all sorts of false and dishonest political issues raised year after year between general elections? Does any honest man in the country, any man worth anything to the country, any man who has the interests of the country at heart—or any woman, for that matter—want these dishonest political issues raised in this country—this country that needs more than all else a rest from politics and a chance of settling down and getting to hard work, the work that will leave the country free to improve its agricultural industry, to deal with unemployment and to attend to the other problems that could be and ought to be dealt with?
Comment on this
This is all neurotic; this is a form of neurosis. Deputies should remember that hysterics of that sort do not prove anything, but tend to the discredit of the person who engages in them. It is all very fine to discuss this matter in an academic way, but I say that I am speaking for the people of the country here when I say that every honest man wants a rest from politics. There is not an honest man or woman in the country who has any real hope for the future of the country while these political issues are being discussed. There is not one of them who does not want to see this country getting a chance to settle down, to do the work that will really make us independent.
The people of this country are beginning to realise what independence is. The people are beginning to realise that you require a lot more than political forms to become independent, and that you have a chance now to become comparatively independent. No country is absolutely independent; independence is conditioned by economics and other things, but, comparatively speaking, you have everything you need here to build up the country industrially, economically, agriculturally, and in every other direction, provided that the unfortunate country will get a chance of having a rest, that these false and dishonest political issues will be laid aside and not drawn across the path of the plain people who want to work. Everyone needs that. But what was the origin of all this pother that went on last week? Those Deputies came into the Dáil some time ago, with all sorts of economic committees, credit committees, financial committees and currency tees, financial committees and currency
Comment on this
Will Deputies on this side of the House be able to deal with the same matters as the Minister is dealing with? He has not said a word about the motion on the Paper yet.
Comment on this
I have kept as close to the motion as anyone who has spoken before me, and this is grossly unfair. If you press the point you carry it, but this is just the technique the whole time. Deputies get up on the other side and make statements and if one attempts to answer them the Chair is appealed to.
Comment on this
I want consideration for this question, so that Deputies on this side can deal with the same matters.
Comment on this
I asked what is the object of all this pother that is taking place to-day.
Comment on this
What is the origin of all the objections to this motion?
Comment on this
It is not. That is not the origin of it. I stated before that it seemed to be the object of Deputies to keep political issues like this always alive, issues that do not affect the lives of the people at all. That is their anxiety, because Deputies on the opposite benches realise that they are utterly incompetent to deal with any issues except political issues. I have been listening to them for a long time, and with one or two exceptions—and they are not the most vocal Deputies— on the other side they have shown themselves to be utterly incompetent to deal with any of the economic issues that come up. They have discovered that——
Comment on this
You have been a howling success, and your colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, has been a success too.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it in order for the Minister to start with thinning turnips and then to describe the character of individuals on these Benches when we are on a motion?
Comment on this
I think, in view of all that has been said, that the Deputy should not complain——
Comment on this
There is just one other matter that comes very close to the motion indeed. We are told here that we should take no action, good, bad, or indifferent, on what has occurred in the Dáil for the last three weeks. Of course, that would suit Deputies. There is nothing like having it both ways, nothing like a campaign of studied insolence and obstruction, openly and avowed, and at the same time not taking the consequences of that. We are perfectly entitled to assume that, looking across at those Benches, remembering the scenes of to-day, the scenes that were attempted, and also comparing them with the language which I heard five years ago, and which was an exact parallel. I listened to threats from those benches opposite. I listened perticularly to threats from Deputy de Valera and Deputy Flinn—I do not mind him; he will not be there when the threats are coming off. I listened to threats from Deputy de Valera on a few occasions—I have on the question of urgency there—stating again and again that unless this is left in the Constitution there will be shooting. That is what it came to. I heard those statements before——
Comment on this
I am not twisting as much as I can. I am very sorry I have not the Reports. Time and time again the Deputy has said, during the course of this debate, that unless they got their way in regard to this matter, some other people—the adventurous young men—or, he suggested, some other people outside would take other action.
Comment on this
What I have said was the truth, and we are only seeing it now twisted by knaves making a trap for fools.
Comment on this
Between the two of us, do you not think you said a little too much there on that?
Comment on this
I did not. The jury did not think so. I got the better of you there, anyway. The Division bell did not decide that question.
Comment on this
I wonder if that is the opinion of everyone in your Party. I doubt it.
Comment on this
I bow my head to the law generally. I listened to Deputy de Valera in these debates. Not once, but twice and three times, he suggested that unless they got their way on these Bills trouble would ensue. Of course, he did not say that he was going to bring it about. He never does. He made these suggestions, not once, but twice and three times, and when I compared these statements with another of his on another occasion, when I used to hear day after day dinned into my ears, "Is your Treaty worth civil war?" and other statements which I will not probe now, from the same Deputy, it does make me think that there is one thing I am quite sure of anyway, and that is that when it is all over again he will be looking at it through a wall of glass.
Comment on this
These statements were made specifically by Deputy de Valera. If I had the Reports in front of me I could be more specific.
Comment on this
No. You are a good judge of twisting. There is not a better in Ireland. I will say that for you. We had an avowed policy of obstruction, and we had a hysterical scene to-day from Deputies, and we are not to take cognisance of it. Would you carry that to the country in an appropriate way when we would be having this Referendum that the whole country wants? We are not taking the chance. You would, if you thought it would pay. I am not saying that we are not capable of dealing with any disorder that arises, if it does arise, but it is a perfectly fair question for me to ask, looking at what has occurred, looking at this gross flouting of the parliamentary rules we have here, looking at the conduct of Deputies opposite, and the suggestions and threats and insults, every weapon that could be used, and every suggestion that could be made, this is a perfectly straight question for me to ask: Are these to be carried to the country, with the adaptations that would be necessary? Our answer to that is that we are not going to take the chance. Nobody in this country wants another general election on a question like this. There are not five people—I will not say that—but there are not five per cent. of the people who would care twopence about this Article 48 or who ever heard of it——
Comment on this
—until a number of little girls and little boys ran around from one house to another with a document that they asked them to sign. There are not five per cent. of the people who would care twopence about it.
Comment on this
The big majority of the people in this country want to have as few general elections as possible. They want to have a chance to get on with their work in the meantime, and there is no doubt whatever about it that the people of this country, at this time, when there is just a little bit of prosperity coming back, do not want to be bothered listening to Deputy de Valera and Deputy Flinn showing their form on this utterly unreal political issue.
Comment on this
After the typical harangue in the manner of "The Playboy of the Western World," or "The Ploughboy of the Western World," which has made the name of Minister for Lands and Agriculture a byword in every constituency in Ireland, and which has already cost him, at any rate, the good opinion of the twelve men who heard him upon his oath in the witness-box——
Comment on this
—it is time for us to come back to the terms of the motion:
"That it is hereby declared that the Bill entitled the Constitution (Amendment No. 10) Bill, 1928. which has this day been passed by Dáil Eireann is necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace and safety.
With the passage of a Bill deleting an Article in the Constitution, which provides and confers upon the people a certain right, the Minister for Lands and Agriculture tells us the people value it so lightly that not five per cent. of them are concerned whether it is retained in the Constitution or not. That is his private opinion. I would like the Minister, or some member of the Government Party, who proposes to follow him, to answer the argument against this motion, which was put forward by the Minister, that there is an Article in the Constitution which the people think so lightly of that, unless it is deleted immediately, it will endanger the preservation of the public peace and safety. That is the motion we are considering. We are not considering what Deputy de Valera said, or is alleged to have said, six years ago—I do not want to repeat what I said at the beginning—by a person of the calibre of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture, who admittedly is one of the most unscrupulous politicians in Ireland. What we are concerned with is what is happening in Ireland to-day. If this motion does not go through, what cataclysm is there that will engulf the public safety, what man's life, and what man's property will be endangered, if it is not adopted by the Dáil? We have to consider this question each one for himself, and if there were any independent Deputies present, untrammelled by considerations of Party and still free to exercise their own judgment in the matter, I would put it to their own individual consciences to ask themselves whether the words contained in the motion, which has been proposed by the President, are true in fact or are false. That is what you have to decide. I think Deputy Redmond put his finger upon the issue. It is unconstitutional to use one portion of Article 47 to delete that Article without referring it to the people. It was held, and held by me on the Second Reading, that this Article was one of the fundamental Articles of the Constitution, in so far as it had been referred to in Article 50, in terms which I will again recall. Referring to future amendments of the Constitution it says:
Any such amendment may be made within the said period of eight years by way of ordinary legislation and as such shall be subject to the provisions of Article 47 hereof.
What does that indicate? That no matter what amendments may be made in the Constitution, Article 47 would still remain, and that all other constitutional amendments hereafter proposed and accepted by this House might be referred to a Referendum of the people. The President, in the course of his speech, said that the principal objection which had been urged to the Bill referred to in this motion is that it closes the door to the removal of Article 17. That is admittedly the real purpose of that Bill, to secure in that Constitution certain Articles which are repugnant to the general mass of the people, and are revolting to every man of honour who knows the history and the evolution of the oath. But this Bill is going to fail, because whenever the Irish people do desire their freedom, whatever the President may say, whatever Deputy Thrift and Deputy Cooper may think, the Irish people are not going to be held prisoners in the paper bag of this Constitution. That is the service—and possibly we have reason to be grateful to him—that the President has done to this nation. He has shown us how easy it is, by the use of a merciless majority, to tear up the Constitution, and he may be certain that the precedent which he has set will some time or other be availed of. They think they are wise in their generation. Against the rising tide of Irish nationality they are building a paper dam to preserve and to secure what the late Vice-President referred to in terms of contempt as "the trappings and insignia of a foreign monarchy"—the symbols of Irish serfdom and Irish slavery. They are not doing that. Make no mistake. We have directed the attack at the President and the members of the Executive Council, because they appear to be the immediate instruments of this, but we are very conscious that all the time they are not doing that of their own volition, they are doing it at the dictation of others. I wish there were some of them here for once to listen to some plain truths because another time will come when the Irish nation will speak to them, not by the voice of men pleading in this Dáil for the rights of minorities, but will speak to them, remembering that in this vital issue, when a fundamental right of the people in this Constitution was being taken from them, Trinity College and those who are associated with Trinity College stood where they always stood, on the side of England and against Ireland in every matter. The Minister may sneer.