CONSTITUTION (AMENDMENT No. 10) BILL, 1928. - DECLARATION UNDER ARTICLE 47 OF THE CONSTITUTION.
Contributions 146–278 of 278. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 23 of 1928 ›
Not by the wish of the people of the University. That is what he is always afraid to test.
Comment on this
This faction, although it is a minority in this country, to-day enjoys a position of unexampled power and privilege. It is powerful within the counsels of the Executive Council. I might go further and say to the Minister that it controls the Executive Council, and I challenge him to deny it. To serve the purpose of that party, to secure its support in the House, the President introduced this Bill. Was there ever in all history so disgraceful a bargain, that the rights secured to the people by the Constitution should be stolen from them by the Government, taken without their consent, and virtually, on account of the attitude the Press has taken up, without their knowledge, stolen from them and used to purchase the support of a faction whose votes are necessary to maintain that Government in office?
There never was and never will be a bargain of that sort that did not inevitably and eventually drive those who made it to the potter's field of politicians. Clare and Castlereagh are not the only Irish politicians who found dishonoured graves. I have referred to the price which the Government has had to pay in order to secure themselves in office, in order that they might carry out and make dominant the political principles which the Minister for Lands and Agriculture avowed here openly, for the first time I believe in this House, a few minutes ago. This man who does not want dishonest political issues raised in Ireland, who says that the people are sick of politics and want to have a rest from them, is afraid to put before the people an issue which is not, in the sense in which the word is being used as a term of contempt or as a sneer, a political issue, but a big fundamental issue—he is afraid to put before the people a principle to which the Government you have to-day gave lip service in their Constitution. This Minister will not allow the people to vote and decide whether, in fact, they want to have the last word and the final judgment upon the action of the Executive Council, not five years afterwards when it may be too late to save the country from the ill-consequences of that action, but at the moment when the action is contemplated and before it is carried through. The people are not to have the last word upon such an issue. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture says that it is a dishonest trick to ask that they should, before this House passes a Bill which proposes to delete the Article of the Constitution that provides that every amendment practically to the Constitution shall, if a significant minority in the House require it, be submitted to the people for a final verdict. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture, who avowed himself a politician so unscrupulous, so determined and so incurably a politician that he was determined to use every article of the Constitution, every trick and every artifice which that twopenny lawyer's mind of his, as he said himself, could think of in order to defeat the policy of the minority party in this House, says it is a trick. I make bold to say this: that not only is it the policy of the minority party sitting here on the Fianna Fáil Benches as avowed Republicans, but that it is the policy of those sitting on the Labour Benches who, I verily believe, are Irish Nationalists. It is also the policy of a good many who, still misguided and still afraid to stand up and to assert their native manhood and still afraid to stand up for the rights of their country, nevertheless follow that Minister with distrust and with uneasiness, at the same time believing in the same fundamental principles of Irish nationality that we do.
The Minister for Lands and Agriculture, who thinks that the people are tired and sick of polities, because he himself is sick of politics, sick and tired of the politics which he expounded in order that he might rise to position and power on the ladder up which he has climbed, now when he finds himself entrenched in a position which some years ago he never dreamed of occupying, wants to kick that ladder aside and to say to the people: "Forget everything I told you and forget everything I preached to you, and above all things forget what I told you six years ago—that this Constitution which we are framing is going to be a weapon that you can use to secure the full measure of your rights," to secure, as the late Kevin O'Higgins himself said, "the things that you have written upon your banners."
I was going on to refer to the fact that there had been a bargain made in this House, a bargain which I said was a disgraceful and dishonourable bargain, and a bargain which I believe will ultimately end in disaster for those who have been parties to it. The minority in this House think that they have secured something by that bargain. That thought is wholly illusory and vam. They have secured nothing. When the majority of the Irish people, as I said at the beginning, declare for freedom, nothing that is in the Treaty, nothing that is in the Constitution, no power vested in the Seanad and no power vested in any officer of this House, no instrument of that Government is going to stand between them and their rights. The chain that Deputy Cooper set the Executive Council to forge for the Irish people will melt like a rope of snow, but before that happens something else will have disappeared. The Imperialists, notwithstanding the power which the present necessities of the Government has endowed them with, have purchased nothing, nothing of any permanence and nothing of any value. They have purchased nothing, but for the first time they have given all. The only practical safeguards that a minority had under this Constitution were the safeguards provided by Articles 47 and 48.
The character of the people, according to the Minister for Lands and Agriculture, was a great safeguard, but the character of the people, the justice and the sense of equity which is innate in the people, never can become operative when Articles 47 and 48 are removed. Those who sit on the Benches on this side know from sad experience that there is no safeguard whatever in the character of this House and of this assembly. This House is not a legislature. This House is not a deliberative assembly. This House is the instrument of a caucus which dominates, controls and determines for the majority Party in this House. Let us realise what constitutional government has come to. Since we came into this Dáil, was there ever upon any single vital issue a free vote of the House taken with the Whips off, when every man might vote as his own judgment and conscience dictated? Has that ever been known?
Many of you have been here for the last six years. Did any one of you, on any vital issue of truth and justice where a man's conscience had to decide for him, ever have the privilege of exercising that conscience and voting according to its dictates? When the time came, as Deputy Lemass said, you were driven like sheep by the Whips into the Lobby. Is not that the great defect of representative government at present? There is no open decision. The decision is by a caucus sitting in secret for a purpose which it never divulges, and the decision is made effective by the majority in this House. That is my answer to the Minister for Lands and Agriculture, and I tell him that, as the experience of the past few weeks has proved to us beyond denial, there is no safeguard in the character of the Deputies here, that the majority which could deprive the people of the rights conferred on them by Article 47 of the Constitution, without allowing that important issue to be submitted to the people directly in order to have the peoples' own unmistakable verdict on it, whether by five per cent. or fifty-five per cent. they declare for it, does not matter. But the majority that could do that, and is capable of it, that has the power under Article 50 of prolonging the life of this Parliament indefinitely, and suspending every member of this Party indefinitely, and of proclaiming a military dictatorship if it cared to do so, is what we are living under.
This Constitution has been time and again suspended. This Constitution never became a reality. It was never given full, complete, and unequivocal effect. When there was a measure that infringed Article 6, when there was a measure which affected the liberty of the person, which under this Constitution is declared to be inviolable, the President produced a resolution in the self-same terms as he has produced the Resolution to-day, and virtually suspended the Constitution in order that he might govern without it. We are told that there are certain fundamental Articles in the Constitution, but that Articles 47 and 48 are not fundamental Articles. Would any person in this Dáil tell me what are the fundamental Articles of the Constitution? We are told we are a free people living under a free Constitution, and yet we are told that the Articles which make the people undeniably and effectively sovereign over this Government and Dáil are now to be taken out of the Constitution on the grounds that they are not fundamental to the Constitution and can be dispensed with. What are the fundamental Articles of the Constitution? Are Articles 2, 3, 4 and 5 fundamental? Article 6 has been suspended time and again. Apparently one fundamental Article is Article 17, which compels every representative of the people sitting in this House to take an oath of allegiance that "I will be faithful to His Majesty King George." The Article of the Constitution which cannot be abrogated or deleted by this House, the only fundamental Article I know of, according to the arguments that have been put forward in justification for these Bills, and in justification for the motion, is Article 17 of the Constitution, "That I will be faithful to His Majesty King George V., his heirs and successors by law." When was that throne ever faithful to this people? What claim has it on the allegiance of this people?
Comment on this
I agree, but I was going to prove that, if the arguments put forward by other Deputies had any validity, the only Article in the Constitution that has any significance is the Article which compels every representative of the Irish people who is true to the innate motions of his heart, to the dictates of his mind, who feels a pride in the history of his country and the nationality that has come down to him from his forefathers, every Deputy here who as an Irishman, is proud of Ireland and who stands against foreign oppression, to dishonour himself before he can sit in this House and discharge his duties as a public representative.
Comment on this
According to the arguments that have been put forward from the opposite benches, that is the only fundamental Article of the Constitution. The President has declared, as I have said before, that one of the reasons why he is asking the House to pass these Bills and to adopt this motion is that he may close the door to the deletion of Article 17 of the Constitution by instruments provided in the Constitution for that purpose. I take it that that is the President's argument, that that is the justification——
Comment on this
I will give the President an opportunity of doing so. We are anxious to hear him explain the vague terms of the motion. What are the unseen dangers that threaten this State? What is the catastrophe that threatens to overwhelm us, for surely there must be something? The terms of the motion are extraordinary: that unless Articles 47 and 48 be deleted from the Constitution the public peace and safety are in danger. Will the President justify the terms of that extraordinary motion of his? Behind that mask of the politician there is a man who has a heart and a conscience, and who can decide for himself between truth and falsehood, irrespective of the Party interests he seeks to serve, and I ask him by the eternal verities of Heaven——
Comment on this
I ask him can he say in all sincerity within himself that the passage of this Bill is essential to the immediate preservation of the public peace and safety? I ask him to drop for a moment the mask of the politician, and as a man who can decide between truth and falsehood upon the facts, to point to one incident in the past three weeks in this country that would show that the public peace and safety, as implied in the terms of this resolution, are in danger. That does not mean to say that if we were to have a brawl at a street corner a Bill is to be rushed through to stop that brawl. There has not even been a brawl at a street corner. There is no indication in the Press which supports the Government, and is anxious to support them, that the people are so clamorous for this measure; that unless it is passed through the Dáil with indecent haste there will be a revolution, that the people will storm Leinster House, that they will surround the President in his residence and call upon him in the name of the people to pass this measure depriving them of their rights which the President guaranteed to them and sealed that guarantee with the blood of his own countrymen six years ago.
I do not think I have anything more to say. I do not think it is worth saying anything. We came to this House driven to it, as I said before, by force of circumstances. We came here not of our own volition, but to use this Constitution in a peaceful way to ask the people, by the exercise of the franchise, to amend that Constitution, so that it would be made acceptable to every Irishman who lives under it. We came here sincerely desirous of serving this country, anxious to put aside the history of civil turmoil and strife which had, if you like, disgraced the last five or six years. We came here realising with Tone that only a united people could win freedom for this nation. We have found every avenue to that barred by every trick and artifice, as the Minister for Lands and Agriculture admitted, that they could devise or resort to. They endeavoured to make it impossible for us to proceed by constitutional means. I am not going to make any threat, but I do know, as I said before, that once the Irish people make up their minds to be free nothing in that Constitution, nothing in the Treaty, no power now vested in the Seanad, no power conferred upon any officer of this House by that Treaty is going to stand between the Irish people and the realisation of their age-long desires.
Comment on this
It seems hardly necessary to add anything to the discussion that has gone on here during the day. It is obvious that no real arguments have been put up by the Government Party who defend this motion. The effect of the motion is, on the pretence that there is danger of commotion, rebellion or riot of some or other kind in the country, to rush through this legislation in such a way that all power to have it called back again would be taken away from this House, that the die will be finally cast, and that this safety valve will be closed down for ever. It seems to me that an occasion like this, where the issue undoubtedly is a big one, would call forth some bigness, some generosity and some element of statesmanship, if there is any such, from the Government benches, because since we came into this House we have played the game pretty squarely. We have done our best to show that we have a real interest in the affairs of the country. We do not give way to any member on the opposite benches, let it be the Minister for Agriculture or the President himself, in our desire to do what we can while we are here to advance the interests of the people. It was for that reason we came here; also because we believed we had these safeguards which the President attempted to do away with when he tried to pass certain legislation, which would mean one-third of the electorate of this country would be deprived of all representation on the lines on which they were proceeding. We took certain steps; we came in here believing there was some remedy, some way out, that of the stepping-stone which men on the other side have apparently slipped on, that there might be some part left, that whatever was there would remain, that we had now reached the position of a desire for peace, concord and all the rest the President speaks about, and that we had reached a position that if we did not agree on certain things we could agree to differ. We felt the methods laid down in the Constitution for the ultimate advance of this whole people to freedom, these methods and constitutional regulations, should be left there.
We thought that would be the case, and now it comes as a startling surprise to find that the President, who talks so loudly about religion, honour and public morality, who had these things flying on his banners down the country, goes back on all these. He spoke loudly about them. He wanted us to believe that he and his Party stood for the honour of compact. We hope he will not throw away this last chance. If there is any bigness in him he will rise to the occasion, and say that as well as honouring compacts with the foreigner there are people in his own country with whom he should do something to honour his obligation. There is a large section of people disgruntled and discontented because they feel these things which were promised — these aspirations which we thought would be fulfilled in due course, this path towards freedom upon which we were to march under the new Dominion — have not come to pass. These people have their ideas; there may be apathy and a lack of national spirit in the country, but assuredly that period will pass and there will be a new rising up if there is anything at all in the Irish Ireland movement, anything at all in the past traditions, assuredly the new generation will come forward with a national spirit and will demand to walk away. We want to leave that way open to them.
There was no immediate urgency in this matter. Even if the Referendum were left there you would require a majority of the voters on the Register or two-thirds of those who had voted to carry it. Was that not sufficient for the Cabinet, in addition to their majority here and a majority in the Seanad and the new powers they propose to bestow and the safeguards of proportional representation — are they not satisfied with all these things? Have they so far forgotten themselves? Are they so very weak and threatened with impending defeat that they have to come along, five or six years after, when we are anxious to have concord and when things are settling down, with this thing which will do more to create bitterness than anything else since the Civil War? I say not alone has the President not given us a clear deal in this matter, but we have not been granted fair play, and the rules of the game have not been played as the people who sent us here and we understood they would be played, but the President has deliberately tried to take advantage of us. He has tried to make us believe that you can set a boundary to the onward march of the nation by passing his resolution after discussion of a few hours, that you can put an end for all time to the spirit of 1916 and 1920 and the spirit that persists still on his side of the House as well as ours. He is quite mistaken and it cannot be done. No justification whatever has been made for this. I need only say as far as the preservation of the peace is concerned that this Bill by its passage will do more, not to create an immediate menace to peace or feeling of insecurity in the country, but will do more than anything else to give credence to the rumours that have been abroad that the Government Party have been slowly slipping into real imperialism, that instead of taking up a stand somewhere in order to advance towards the full national goal, instead of having got renewed courage from the fact that they have support here on all questions of general national interest, on questions in which they could legitimately demand our support, instead of advancing steadily in the proper direction, they are still being pulled by the tail by the old Unionist minority of this country.
I want to say one word more in conclusion with reference to the threats. I notice that the Press, in a report of a speech I made here yesterday, has the caption "Threats" and "More Threats" underneath. The statement that I made has been either deliberately or perhaps without malice interpreted to mean that I said there was a danger of conflict as between a military dictatorship and a constitutional dictatorship which is an absolute twisting of the argument. What I said was: you had a position in this country before we came in here, you had a military dictatorship outside looking for control and you had inside a constitutional dictatorship also which endeavoured to ride roughshod over the wishes of the people and which, in spite of the fact that it had to pass through a certain ceremonial and had a certain form of procedure, was passing legislation without any reference at all to the real desires of the people. I said it was time to put an end to that and that instead of precipitating a struggle between this House and the Seanad we should take our stand on the bedrock of national principle; that however we may disagree at the moment we are ultimately out for the same object and that is to do the best for our country and for freedom; that if we cannot see eye to eye we should not at any rate close the door. The President should take this opportunity of putting his name down possibly in the annals of our country as a man with some foresight; a man in whom there was something. He has missed opportunities in the past, but he shows, and the attitude of his whole Party to-day shows, that a small man and big issues go very ill together. I ask Deputies not to look at this matter from the small and narrow Party point of view, but to look at it from the history of their country and of the rightful aspirations of their people.
Comment on this
I would like to approach this motion from the point of view of someone coming into the House and listening to the debates which have taken place here within the last few days, some one person who is interested rather in the peace and work of the nation than in the immediate political issues, or shall we say in the immediate cross-current of political views. I would have heard to-day's speeches from the Government side showing a most extraordinary morbid fear of certain political events. I would have found their minds entirely devoted not to constructive measures but to changes in the political institutions in this country, purposes which are absolutely unwarranted and uncalled for at the present time. I would have listened in vain not merely to-day or yesterday, but for many days past, if I had attended the House as a visitor, for some real measure being brought in to cure the unemployment in and emigration from this country. I might have expected that the rushed tactics which have been adopted here on the false grounds of urgency in political matters would be applied to remedy the real evils of the country, some attempt to put the findings, say, of the Food Prices Tribunal into force or some attempt to make a real inquiry into the big problem of how to give cheap credit to the farmers — a matter in which the Government has wholly failed. I might have expected to hear something about many of the other really great problems with which the nation is faced. Instead of that we have the President getting up and in a short speech — I might say an unanswerable speech, because he said nothing that could be answered — telling us that for the sake of the peace and security of the country it was necessary to use rushed tactics that are diametrically opposed to the liberties which he is embodying in another Bill which we discussed yesterday. If he was consistent, at least he would give the Seanad the opportunity of exercising the new power that he is granting to them — the power of delay for twenty months. He would allow the Seanad to exercise that power in dealing with this Bill, but not only will he not do that, but he goes further — he removes the possibility of the safeguard of 90 days provided in Article 47 and the safeguard at least on this measure, of getting the views of the Irish people on it. This Government that believes in the will of the people when they talked about the will of the people in 1922 deceived not only the people but the pastors and the bishops of this country to such an extent as to draw them into public statements of a very serious nature. I hope the men with that point of view, who took the responsibility then, will look into the conduct of the Government at the present time and make their decision as to whether they consider men who can go back upon all they said are men of character who should be ruling in this country. Deputy Hogan said that the only safeguard we had in this country — he left the people out of it — was the question of character. Of course that was the old argument used by those who believed in a fancy franchise, in an aristocracy plain and simple.
Comment on this
Because there is another Deputy Hogan, and he might not like to have the words of the Minister attributed to him.
Comment on this
It was the Minister for Agriculture. Apparently he has gone away from the plea of consulting the will of the people as a safeguard. He falls back upon the old argument used by people who believed in aristocratic forms of Government, as the last ditch, I suppose. I would like to see some basis of understanding between the various Parties in this House. I do not like to see this House, or the nation, being turned into a house of hatred, because that is what is happening. I think most certainly all the members of this Party would be glad if never again there was a reference made to the various unfortunate happenings of the past five or six years. It is not in that way that any of us are really now interested. We may use past actions in order to drive home an argument about the present conduct of our opponents, but we do not raise these questions here in an idle way, and we are never first to raise them. Personally, I would be glad if they were never raised again.
I am far more interested in the strengthening of the Irish nation; I am far more interested in seeing the problem of unemployment dealt with, the problem of real poverty and the gradually decreasing purchasing power of the people which is the most dreadful problem that faces us. I do not want to see those problems dealt with in any slavish or purely materialistic way, because I do not believe that you can have a nation prosperous which is not free or going towards freedom, any more than a man can expect to make good on his farm if he has not got good title, because when he has not got good title he may have a rackrent put on him over which he has no control. The whole history of the agrarian question in Ireland exemplifies that point of view, namely, that as it was necessary for the Irish people to get good title in their land before they could become prosperous, so it is necessary for us to get the element of good title in national principle before we can expect to deal with such problems as credit, purchasing power, prices, and the rest. These things must go hand in hand.
Comment on this
I was dealing with the argument put forward by the Minister for Agriculture, and what I wanted to emphasise was that the hectic political activity did not come from this side of the House, but from the other side and that economic problems were being neglected. When the Minister for Finance was speaking I could not help thinking of his attitude towards the people. He recognises the people as masters, I suppose, but there are things which a master must not be consulted about because they might make him angry and might disturb his peace. It is just as if a servant smashed a valuable piece of crockery, and, in order to maintain the peace of the household, feared the jurisdiction of the master and hid the valuable piece of crockery. That is the attitude of the Minister for Finance. He will not consult the people when the people have a right to exercise their authority. In other words, he is willing to recognise the authority of his master only when it suits his convenience, and he will run away from him when he is afraid that he will get the punishment which is his due. The Minister for Agriculture actually put it forward as a serious constitutional argument that this measure of the Government was justified, if only to avoid the ranting, as he said, of Deputy Flinn. I think that this House deserves a little more respect than having an argument like that put before it.
After all, even if he disagrees with the speeches made on this side, even if he finds that some speeches more than others are unpleasant to him, even if he comes to the conclusion that some Deputies make the kind of speeches which he does not like, surely the Minister does not offer that as the only argument he could offer for setting aside the normal operations of the Constitution. He told us that we had a remedy in the courts. He did not elaborate the sort of remedy that was. He did not tell us what authority the Judicature has over the conduct of the Legislature, nor by what machinery a mandamus order of the courts could be enforced against the conduct of this House. He suggested it and said that that was our proper remedy. He said that what this country wants is a rest from politics, that we were only raising this question to distract the people from the poverty of our economic programme. If he wants to get the country a rest from politics let him and his Government postpone the enforcement of this measure. We shall give him the rest he wants from that sort of politics. If he carries out the normal operations of the Constitution he will get all the rest he wants and all the harmony he desires from this side of the House. We are willing to co-operate in every way to increase the purchasing power of the people and to end unemployment and emigration in this country.
Comment on this
I feel that to say anything on this motion is useless, since the President and his Party will not make any attempt to defend their attitude in bringing it forward. Evidently before they brought it forward they decided that they would not defend it in any way, so that they must have a guarantee from the majority of their members that they would be prepared to vote for it. They must have had a guarantee from their muzzled members that, no matter what they bring forward, they will support it. I wonder if any of those who vote for the motion have read it. If Deputies opposite are muzzled from speaking and expressing their views, surely they are not muzzled to prevent them reading the motion they are asked to vote on. It contains only five or six lines, and the least that Deputies might do for their constituents is to read motions on which they are asked to vote. Having read that motion no Deputy, in justice to his constituents, should vote for it. We have been listening to a certain amount of hypocrisy dished up by Deputies opposite for the last few weeks. There has been a lot of heat, but if it has been introduced it is because the Party opposite, especially the Front Bench, have been preaching nothing but hypocrisy from the beginning. From my position here on these Benches I can almost see the leer of hypocrisy coming through their faces. You can easily see that they are not in earnest about what they are saying. They have, I suppose, to put up a fight, and they are doing it as best they can. Deputies behind them know that it is bluff. They have to vote no matter what happens. There has been some talk about insults to the dignity of the House. They should realise that whatever little dignity is due to the House has certainly been dragged in the mire owing to their conduct. I have been in the country during the week-end. I met people who are supporters of the Free State Party, and I know what they think of the attitude of their Party in the House. They want to know what are they doing and why they are not tackling the questions which the country wants to have tackled. Has there been an upward curve, or has the country turned the corner since we began to sit all night and now to sit all day? Have we tackled questions affecting the farming or business community? Have we got down to bedrock? Have we left out of consideration things which the country do not want, and are we doing the things which the country requires to have done? We have not been doing the things which the country wants because the Government insist on keeping the House sitting all night. What have we been doing? Saving the country from a war by tearing out the much boosted Articles of the Constitution, Articles which, according to Ministers as they went through the country, were the very things upon which the people gave them their support.
Now, because the people of the country are waking up to the situation, and because there is a possibility of the people demanding that these Articles of the Constitution should be put into force, the Government say that it is against public peace and order if we do not immediately pass this Bill. That is certainly the kind of hypocrisy that will bring no dignity to this House. If there has been any heat since these matters were introduced, it is because the Government have created that atmosphere by bringing forward motions of this kind which cannot be said to have any respect for the Constitution, and if there are to be any heated scenes in future, it is only because such motions will be brought before the House. In the first place they know that there is no demand or no urgency for these measures. For the past few days we have been discussing a Bill in which the Government propose to give the Seanad the right to hold up a Bill for a year and a half. Now they say that if a Bill which has been only passed to-day is not put into immediate operation there is grave danger to the public peace. I think that even the back benchers on the Government side cannot believe that nonsense and hypocrisy, but they cannot give any other excuse for putting it through. They said that even the heated scene to-day — the Vice-President gave it as an excuse — was one of the reasons for bringing forward this motion, but has not this motion been on the Order Paper for some time? They just took advantage of the scene here to-day, and said that that justified them in bringing forward this motion. The real reason is that they are afraid that if this Bill is not immediately made law, the country cannot be bludgeoned into accepting it, and that the country will realise what it means in the meantime. The only way is to bludgeon the country into accepting it.
I am sorry that Deputy Thrift is not here, but at the same time I realise that it would be useless for me to say anything to him if he were. A few weeks ago he brought forward an amendment in opposition to a motion by our party for the Referendum, and he made a grand appeal for unity. He drew tears from all our eyes, asking us to see that this long-drawn-out campaign should cease. He asked us was there not other work to be done; were there not other things upon which we could agree to work, and why would we not tackle these things, but for the last three weeks, since the Executive brought in ten or twelve Bills, which do not deal with the things that Deputy Professor Thrift talked of, that have no relation to the relief of unemployment or the vital issues that affect the lives of the people, there was no talk from Deputy Thrift of the things upon which we might have agreed. The things that the Government are doing now are the very things that Deputy Thrift wanted to have done, and not the vital things which affect the Irish people, such as the provision of employment. I can quite see that Deputy Professor Thrift had just to play the villain of the piece for the President in this matter.
Comment on this
The President took advantage of the Dáil by getting Deputy Thrift to bring forward that motion. I am afraid it is not much use appealing to Deputies on the opposite Benches to oppose this motion, because I believe they will not. They probably have opinions of their own, but I feel it is little use in asking them to vote against the motion. They had their private meeting, and perhaps the President gave them reasons for this motion that have not been given to the House. He must have given them some reasons, because there are some men on the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches who, knowing them as I did at one time, I believe, would not vote for that motion on the plea the President has made to the House. They will not do it if they are honest men, honest to their constituents and honest to the Constitution as it is. If they want to give fair play to the people they will vote against this motion, otherwise they will bring off a mean trick on the country that no honest Irishman could stand over.
Comment on this
This motion reads: "That it is hereby declared that the Bill entitled `The Constitution (Amendment No. 10) Bill, 1928,' which has this day been passed by Dáil Eireann is necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace and safety." If this Bill is not passed, something dreadful is going to happen the country. There is going to be war or something else, some great cataclysm, some great disturbance in the country as the result of it. The whole fabric of democracy will potter and decay, to quote the words of Deputy Cooper. The President, some time ago, very valiantly indeed, stated in this House that he would not allow the people of this country to be threatened by any threat of force, but here the President comes along with a Bill, comes along with this thing here, and threatens the people with war if this amendment to the Constitution is not passed. "You are going to have war," says the President. Then the President will allow the people of this country to be threatened by any threat of force? Let loose the dogs of war. Does the President really think that the people of this country at this time of day are going to be taken in by claptrap like that, because if he does, he is an optimist; he is a prince of optimists. We have had the Minister for Lands and Agriculture, who seems to have adopted the role of Punchinello to the Government Party without the tragedy that attends Punchinello. He told us on these Benches that we would get certain rights, what we were entitled to, no more and no less. A Deputy on these Benches asked what were the rights and the Minister for Lands and Agriculture said "The Treaty."
In this debate the rights that we were going to get were contained in the Treaty, no more and no less. He did not explain whether it was the Treaty that originally existed or the thing that exists now. The Minister for Finance said there has been no great demand for the Referendum or the Initiative or Article 47 or Article 48 of the Constitution. Yet 98,000 people have signed and placed before the House a petition under one of those Articles. "There has been no demand!" There was no demand from a quarter of a million nationalists of Ulster for the carrying out of Article 12 of the Treaty — none at all. Their demand was ignored and Article 12 disappeared, and so did Article 5. Yet the Minister for Lands and Agriculture tells us, "You have your rights. Those rights are contained in the Treaty. You have no more and no less." And we have the mutilated Treaty. I wonder does the President or any member of the Executive Council think that any Deputy or any individual in the country is going to be hoodwinked by a motion like this; that if this Bill, which is intended to mutilate the Constitution — the Constitution that the President told us long ago could not be changed by one iota or one comma — is not passed there is going to be immediate and terrible war. Yet the President will not allow this country to be threatened with any threat of force.
We on these benches were taunted with having made threats, with having said that if certain safety valves were screwed down there must occur an explosion in the country some time. It was perfectly true, and if it had been stated 700 years ago it would have been perfectly true, because every time there was a safety valve screwed down there was an explosion. We have only to look back on the history of the country to see it for ourselves. We have been taunted with that, and yet the President — the acme of perfection — tells us that if a certain thing is not done there is going to be a war. We do not know who is going to make the war — we are not told that. But it is necessary that the Constitution should be mutilated or somebody somewhere in this country is going to wage war upon somebody else. "It is necessary for the preservation of the peace." When the President was told that he got a majority in this House, on the occasions that he did get a majority, simply because there was a threat put before the people — because the people were told, "There are certain things you shall not do, and one is that you must not fail to return us to power or there will be an immediate and terrible war"— the President denied it. Now, if we do not walk calmly and tamely into the Division Lobby and pass all these mushroom Bills that the President introduced, we are threatened with war.
"Come along," says the Minister for Lands and Agriculture. "Let us get down to bedrock. Let us get down to brass tacks and deal with the problems immediately before the country, the problems of agriculture, of unemployment and so on." Who interfered with these problems or with the efforts to solve them? Was it the Fianna Fáil Party? Not at all. The President comes along with a sheaf of Bills under his arm and in ten minutes he introduces them here, and since the President came along with his Bills we have been discussing them night and day. We have not interfered with them, but if one of these Bills is not passed somebody is going to fight somebody else. There were problems before the Dáil of unemployment, etc. There were motions down, such as the one dealing with widows' pensions, that could have been discussed. We were perfectly willing to discuss them on their merits — we would be willing to stay up all night and discuss them. Did we get an opportunity? Not at all. There was something which, at some future time, by the will of the people might have affected the grip that another country has on this country and might have affected the position of the Executive Council. Hence the President comes along with a sheaf of Bills and since that time there has been no motion discussed in this House regarding unemployment, widows' pensions, agriculture or anything else. The President can get us to stay up all night to talk about his Bills — to mutilate the Constitution. They told us that when they were framing the Constitution they were absolutely incapable and incompetent — that is what it amounts to. The Minister for Finance admitted that two Articles which were supposed to give power to the people were only the "pipe dreams" of faddists — useless things. We have been told for the last couple of weeks that they were useless. Still, because of these two Articles something might happen sometime. Hence the President must interrupt the work of the Dáil, hold up the work of the country, hold up his own Estimates, and stultify the work of the people's representatives, in order that these Bills shall be passed. Because there was delay in passing a certain Bill he tells us that there is going to be a war. How valiant he is if there is a threat of war from any section of the Irish people, but the President is not so valiant if there is a threat of war from any other country.
Why should anyone in this country wage war against anyone else if this Bill is not passed? The Minister for Lands and Agriculture — the Punchinello — has not told us. In his usual bantering way he has tried to get the people's "goat"— I will put it that way — but he has certainly made no contribution to the debate. He has given no strong reason for anything that has been put forward by the President. I could not class the statement made by the Minister for Finance as an argument. Surely the President is not going to have the audacity to tell us that he put up any argument?
I know he is audacious and that he can pervert things in certain ways, but I certainly thought he had not the audacity to tell us that this is to be an argument for us. Perhaps the President, if he gets an opportunity of trying to say a word or two later on, will tell us who is going to fight somebody else. What is it all about? I had some sort of notion that all the fighting men in the country were away in America. Where all the mythical legions are to come from is more than I know. Perhaps the President would tell us and perhaps he would tell us again what is the urgency and hurry for all this. Why rush this motion along? Why are we threatened with war if this thing is not done simply in the twinkling of an eye: it must be very urgent. Does not the President know that there are 90,000 unemployed in this country, that these 90,000 are entered on the books of the Labour Exchanges without taking any account of the rest? Does he not recollect that we have to vote money for several things that will be of benefit to the country? Why could not the President go on with the job? Why blame us for holding up the Dáil when he himself is holding it up with his footy Bills? If the President or the Minister for Lands and Agriculture wants to come down to bedrock and deal with urgent problems that affect the country we are perfectly willing to go ahead with them and after a twelve hours' day if the President came here and said, "We will have to sit on until eight in the morning," we will sit on to solve these problems. But this does nothing to solve the problems of the country. This is not the way the country should be held up in its work. By introducing Bills — if you like I will make you a present of the fact — to amend your own defective Constitution from your own point of view the Government is wasting time. If the Constitution was defective from the point of view of having these Articles included in it they are wasting the time of the country now by trying to amend it. They have wasted three weeks of the country's time in trying to do something which should not have been done according to them. Still, we have Deputy Thrift and the Minister for Lands and Agriculture and the whole bunch telling us, "Let us get down to bedrock and discuss the immediate problems that confront us in the country." If they want to put anything across the country quietly, if they want to give anything away the same as they gave our people in the North away, they say, "Do not discuss politics; let us do that sub rosa. Carry on the good work. Mind the bread-and-butter problems all the time, because we can keep on working the hidden hand behind the scenes. We can do what selling is necessary and we can get all the damn good bargains necessary.”
Perhaps the President, if he is going to wind up this debate, will give some reasons and some explanation to the House why this holding up of the country so long is necessary. Perhaps he would tell us why he has left men walking the streets and starving, and why he has held up the Estimates, why he has held up every Deputy who should be doing the work of the country. Perhaps he will explain that, and afterwards, if he succeeds in convincing his own automatic voting machine, as I would call it, perhaps he would go to the country and come upon a platform and convince the country that he was perfectly right in holding up the work of the country, perfectly right in seeing people starving because they were unemployed, and seeing the good work of the country held up in order to cut Articles out of the Constitution which should have been left in, or else never should have been put in. They were put in there for the express purpose of "pulling the wool" over the eyes of the Irish people. It has come to the stage now when the President thinks it is perfectly safe to remove the wool, and so the President has brought in two Bills to remove it; that is all there is to it. The President thinks the time is opportune to tear away the mask and expose himself to the people. Perhaps he will tell the people why he held up the country so long in having this removed, and why he is telling the country now that if we get the wind up and pass this Bill everything will be right, but if not we are faced with immediate and terrible war. Perhaps the President will try to explain his own words, when he said definitely and clearly, "I shall not allow the people of this country to be threatened by any threat or force."
Comment on this
To-day we buried Articles 47 and 48 of the Constitution, and those of us who were present at the funeral will recollect that the scenes which were enacted at that funeral were not scenes which one would expect to witness at any burial. This evening, on resuming, we had sufficient evidence before us that the corpse which we buried in the forenoon session was a corpse of something which died an unnatural death, and already the spirit is haunting us, and consequently the necessity to exorcise that spirit. Hence we have a Resolution from the President. It is hoped that by that resolution, or motion, everything will be made safe for all time in the future. In common with many of my colleagues on these Benches I again want to ask members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party to point out, or give some scintilla of evidence of the truth of their fears, that the defeat of this motion is going to lead to bloodshed in the country. I challenge my colleague for North Dublin City to tell me how the defeat of President Cosgrave's motion is going to lead to revolution in the North City. Except it is going to be the revolution of "Shamrock shovels" I cannot for the life of me think that there is any serious danger of the slightest disturbance of the peace.
On a previous occasion in this House I did warn the Government that they were taking an action which was likely to lead to serious disturbance. That was when we were debating the adjournment for a period of three months last November, and when we had ample proof of the fact that there were thousands of people in the city on the verge of starvation and on the verge of despair, in such a condition of poverty and misery that one really did fear, and had good cause to fear, that the peace might be disturbed and that the good order of the community might be disturbed, and when I put forward that view and appealed to the Government to continue in session, to continue to keep the doors of this House open and to continue giving us and any other Deputy in this House who desired to do so an opportunity of suggesting ways and means of alleviating those pitiable conditions, I was met with the sneers of the Ministers. As a matter of fact those sneers are all we have ever received since we came in here. Perhaps it is best so. Let them continue sneering. The line of demarcation, at any rate, is being kept very clear between those who stand for the people's rights and those who either have not the courage to do so or who are deliberately conniving at denying the people their rights.
The manner in which Article 47 and Article 48 have been abolished and the methods that accompanied their abolition are sufficient proof that we are under the heel of a tyrannical Government. Someone, I think, on one occasion named it the Cooper-Cosgrave-Jacob Government. Those three interests combined are working insidiously day and night for the purpose of getting into their control all the resources of this country. Presumably when the motion is passed they will have secured an obedient majority in this House to carry out their dictates whenever the necessity arises. But I really do submit, in all sincerity, that it is fair and just to ask the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies, those who still have the audacity to go through the country talking to the people on occasions, to give us some statement in the matter, no matter how brief, justifying their support for this motion. The only point which the Minister for Agriculture made in supporting the motion, so far as I gathered, was that he feared if it were defeated the people would have to submit to the rantings of Deputy Flinn. There are two ways of looking at that statement. I think one can see it in the light in which the Minister did not intend. The rantings of Deputy Flinn are nothing more or less than an expression of the desire in the hearts of the people for their rights. That is the very kind of ranting which the Minister certainly does not want to hear. He is prepared to take all necessary steps to prevent such ranting. He has to submit to it here, however, but he hopes that that ranting will be so altered in its context that by the time the people see it in the Press, they will view it as ridiculous and without any point.
Any Deputy who sat here listening to Deputy Flinn to-day, and who could not see and understand the various points with which he dealt, and dealt clearly and intelligently, is certainly not worthy of occupying a position in the Ministerial ranks. With reference to the scenes which were witnessed here to-day, let those who regret those scenes understand the cause. If they come to understand the cause, then perhaps we will be able to avoid it in future. The cause of those scenes was the deliberate flouting of the people's rights by the Ministers in their action in bringing to a close the discussion on such an important motion. That was a flagrant disregard of our view-point. I, at any rate, gather when that incident occurred here——
Comment on this
Really we ought not to discuss the incident. These incidents ought to be let alone, and the less said about them, if the Deputy does not want to repeat them, the better. Those incidents should not be discussed at all. They are concluded.
Comment on this
At any rate, I may fall into the same position on a future occasion, and I want to make it quite clear that I will have no hesitation on all occasions in demonstrating my hostility and opposition to any Imperialistic display in this House.
Comment on this
Very well, then. I want to quote President Cosgrave, and if he were here present to remind him — but I see he is absent — that he gave an interview to the "Daily Express" some months ago, in which he said: "You can tell your people that all is well in the Free State." Those were the exact words. I committed them to memory at the time. His statements in America were also worthy of recollection. He took the trouble when in America to endeavour to convince the people that he and his Ministry had secured peace, order and stability. The Minister for Agriculture, speaking here yesterday, made the very same statement. "We have brought you peace," he said. "We have established all the institutions of Government in this country. We have established the will of the people."
How does he reconcile that statement with his attitude here to-day, and that of his colleagues, in asking this House to pass a motion on the pretence that if it is not passed we are going to have an immediate upheaval? We are asked to pass a motion with reference to an alteration in the Constitution, the Constitution for which so many sacrifices were made, and to which, he alleges, they had won the people's allegiance either through love or fear.
Talking of mandates, it is interesting to recall the fact that in the June election from various platforms we asked the people to give us a mandate to come in here without subscribing to a particular condition of entry. We said that every vote cast for our candidates would be an indication of the people's approval of that method. We challenged from those platforms any representative of the Government to come forward and deny the people the right to give us that mandate. We challenged them from the platforms and in the Press, and never did we hear one Minister or one representative of the Government deny that the people had the right to give us that mandate. The fact that they returned some forty-five Deputies was proof that they did give those forty-five a definite and clear mandate. We know how that mandate was treated and how those Deputies were received when they came up here. That was one of the series of proofs of the respect which these Ministers have for the will of the people. We can go on for another little while, of course, as long as this machine remains, protesting against and submitting to these sneers, to this contempt, deceit and cheating. We can continue to do so, but, as the late Terence MacSwiney said, it is not with those who can inflict most, but those who can endure most, that victory will ultimately rest. We are enduring here on behalf of the people insults from day to day. We will continue that, because we are confident that the policy for which we stand, and the methods which we are following, both being founded upon truth, must ultimately win out.
This is called, I suppose, a motion of peace. I can use an appropriate quotation under that heading which was uttered on another occasion by the late Padraig Pearse. It is an appropriate quotation, just by changing it from a motion of peace and using the words "a place of peace." This is a place of peace where men are supposed to speak with all charity and with all restraint, but I hold it a Christian thing to hate evil, to hate untruth. Those are the things which we have been listening to here to-day. To hate evil, to hate untruth, to hate oppression, and, hating these things, we must strive to overthrow them. The defenders of this realm have worked well, the late Padraig Pearse said, in secret and in the open. They think that they have pacified Ireland. They think that they have purchased half of us and intimidated the other half. They think that they have foreseen everything. Oh, how true that is of the attitude of the Ministry here to-day. They think that they have foreseen everything and provided against everything; but they are fools; they have left our Fenian dead, and while Ireland holds its graves, Ireland unfree shall never be at peace.
Comment on this
I was rather astounded this evening to be invited so frequently to take part in this debate. My colleague for the North City, who has just sat down, threw out a very visible challenge and really convinced me that I should get up and say something.
Comment on this
I was rather surprised to be invited by Deputy Lemass to say something on the particular issue before us. When speaking on this Bill before, Deputy Lemass was good enough to say. "They put up Deputy Byrne to make a case, adding insult to injury." Now, in the face of this wonderful piece of statecraft and this wonderful piece of oratory, Deputy Lemass invites me to participate in this debate.
Comment on this
I deny that. I would like to make it clear to the House that I am not guilty of the offence of inviting Deputy Byrne to address the House. I did not invite him to participate in this debate.
Comment on this
We have listened to the great hero of the fight, Deputy Hugo Flinn, and we endeavoured to take down the great arguments he made as to why this motion should not be passed. On these Benches we have a learned professor of a certain University and, as a matter of curiosity, I asked him to be good enough to take out the main arguments of the speech. He told me the only arguments he could find were not actually arguments, but, at the same time, they were the main things upon which the whole speech was based. The Deputy referred to dumb driven cattle and a frigid calculated lie. These were all he put before us this evening as a reason why this very important measure should not be passed with the consent of the House.
Comment on this
I endeavoured to take down the points myself, and I find in my notes that I got the very same thing.
Comment on this
An appeal has been made to the back benchers to say something now on this question. I will say that we here stand wholeheartedly behind the Front Bench in asking this House to pass this motion. We consider this motion is certainly in the interests of the State.
Comment on this
We stand wholeheartedly behind them because we consider this motion is necessary for the future welfare of the State.
Comment on this
"...is necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace and safety." Any person can read that unless, of course, one is illiterate.
Comment on this
We were asked here to accept a petition from the opposite side of the House, a petition to violate a Treaty-barred Article of the Constitution. I think it is time that this House should realise that the plot and plan of Fianna Fáil, insidious as it may have appeared in the guise of constitutionalism, was well known to those sitting behind the front benches on this side of the House. We are not such a silly pack of fools as perhaps Deputies on the other side may take us to be. We have some little intelligence left to understand the difference and to understand the wisdom or the folly of the two courses that have been presented to this House. Two courses were presented to this House, one in the shape of a petition, and the other in the shape of the motion we are now considering. If we had followed in the first instance this great piece of constitutionalism presented in the motion moved by the leader of the Opposition, what would have been the consequences to this country? Deputy de Valera told us that we could, by constitutional means, remove this Treaty-barred Article from the Constitution. Deputy de Valera told us that within the Constitution the people had certain rights, the exercise of which would solve all the internal dissensions of the country. Deputy de Valera knows as well as I do that there is not a scintilla of truth in that statement; Deputy de Valera knows as well as I do that the special Article which he wanted to remove from the Constitution was, as has been admitted by Deputies on the opposite side to-day, a Treaty-barred Article of the Constitution.
Comment on this
On a previous occasion I bowed most respectfully to your ruling upon this particular issue. In the debate on the Constitution (No. 10) Bill I was ruled out of order for dealing with Article 17, and I protested most vehemently when the leader of the Opposition dealt with that Article when I was debarred from dealing with it. The same position is now presented to me. If we are to reply to arguments put forward from the other side some liberty of debate must be given to us, and surely, we are not stretching the patience of the Chair in anything we say.
Comment on this
The Deputy, and other Deputies, will be allowed all the liberty that can be given, within the bounds of order, on this motion, but no more.
Comment on this
Well, I intend to say, unless you tell me that I must desist, that two courses were open to this House. We were asked to do one thing by the Opposition, and we are asked to do another thing in the motion that is now before us. Each of these is relevant to the other. It is almost impossible to discuss one without discussing the other, and I suggest that if I am to reply effectually to any little arguments that have been put forward from the opposite side I must deal with the case as it now stands. If this issue is brought into the country and if I have to expound it to the citizens of North Dublin, what will I have to say to them? Will I be afraid to meet members of the Fianna Fáil Party on constitutional issues?
Comment on this
Will I be afraid to tell the people that if the course marked out by the Fianna Fáil Party had been followed it would have meant the abrogation of the whole status of the State? Will I be afraid to tell them that within the Constitution no such power exists as Deputies opposite claim? These are the plain constitutional issues before us that are involved in this motion, and also in the Petition. We will tell the people frankly that the Petition which was presented a few weeks ago had one object, and one object only, that was to disrupt the Treaty, to disrupt the Constitution and to disrupt the whole State.
Comment on this
In the Constitution we possess certain powers. Under the Constitution we are absolutely politically and economically free, but in the Constitution there is a certain inter-dependent clause externally over which we have no power.
Comment on this
That interdependent external clause is the Article of the Constitution which the leader of the Opposition told the House could be removed by constitutional means, but he knows as well as I do that no constitutional means exist whereby it could be removed.
Comment on this
I have been asked what are the means. Are there any means by which Article 17 of the Constitution can be got rid of? I have been lectured by Deputy Lemass with great authority upon constitutional law, and Deputy Lemass has not the faintest element of idea as to the meaning of constitutional law.
Comment on this
If Deputy Lemass knew anything about it he would know that the foundation of this Constitution is Dominion status, and he would know that there was contained in Article 17 of the Constitution a thing which this House has no right to interfere with in a constitutional way.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot go into any argument on Article 17. This motion deals only with Article 47.
Comment on this
I have finished all I have to say on Article 17. There is a very simple course open to the Opposition if they care to follow it when they become a majority in this House, but not before. If they want to get rid of this Article to which they object, if they want to get rid of this oath of allegiance, they have a perfect right to do so by withdrawing from the British Commonwealth of Nations. We do not wish to have any cant or humbug about this. There was one bond imposed upon this country, and that was a recognition of the headship of the King in the association of nations known as the British Commonwealth.
Comment on this
I now come to the motion by saying that I think I have cleared the air when I said that if I have to go to my constituents in the North City of Dublin and explain these constitutional issues to them, and if they ask me if I stood behind the motion that has been moved to-day, I would have no hesitation in saying that in my opinion, and with some knowledge of constitutional law, in reply to the bulk of those on the Opposition Benches, who have no knowledge of constitutional law, that the thing that was vital for the safety of the State and for the peace of the country was this motion.
Comment on this
I suppose there are Deputies who do not look on this as being of very great importance. There are others who look on it as being, I suppose, of average importance, and a good few who look upon is as a very serious business. The constitutional history of most countries is largely comprised of contests between people and governments for the people's rights. The people generally succeeded. They wrung their rights from kings and other forms of government. In Ireland, for the last five or six years, we seem to have more or less reversed the position, and the Government seem to have embarked on a campaign of wringing rights from the people. This motion we are dealing with is one which should give rise to very serious consideration. We have, for the last three or four months, at times embarked on serious economic problems. We made efforts to solve these problems, and I believe that is really what the people of Ireland want. They do not possess a very large number of rights, but simply because their economic position is in such a state, they do not seem to have the heart to look for these things. But I believe that this particular motion should not be necessary. When the Constitution was being framed certain individuals, I suppose, proposed certain clauses. These men must have been convinced that they were good and would be useful things, or else they would not have been put there. I do not think it is an argument that can be used, that these men were not sensible, that they were not statesmen. I am quite confident that these men could foresee, and did foresee, that some great advantages could be derived from these clauses, but for some reason or other, when a section of the nation proceeded to make use of these clauses, and proceeded to test them, immediately we had all the economic policy thrown to the winds, and there was a mad rush to embark on amendments of the Constitution, and on bringing in motions for safety. We have been at this for the last three or four weeks, and, as I say, the most important things have been left completely out of the question. Really I believe that the policy at the back of all this is a policy of mere political convenience. These clauses would not have been put into the Constitution if it was not intended that some use would be made of them, and if it was not intended that the use that was to be made of them would be good for the country, so that it leads me to believe that it is simply a matter of political convenience. I believe that the judges of this will be the people of the future, or some historian, who will be inclined to put it down to being a matter simply of political convenience. What will be the feeling amongst the people of Ireland, who are really hard pressed — what will be the feeling in the United States, where they were told that we were prosperous, or, at least, that we had turned the famous corner, when they read that this Bill, passed by the Dáil, is necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace and safety? They, just as the people down the country, will, I am sure, begin to wonder where the danger lurks, where the danger lies of this terrible eruption that this particular motion is supposed to save. That is not the way to bring about the economic revival of the country.
The real effect of this will be to tighten credit. I understand it has been inclined to get a little freer lately. The real effect this will have, as I said, will be to tighten that credit. Capitalists are not inclined to invest money in a country that has such motions as these tabled. The reason given is that it is necessary to hurry this. What is the necessity for hurry, or why should it be there at all? If, as I said, the effect is to disturb credit in a country that is already famishing for the want of that credit, I believe it is a very wrong thing for this House to pass. It is strange that after all the talk we have heard, after all the good prospects that have been held out to us, we should be faced to-day with a motion of this description. It is really a disheartening thing for a nation already disheartened. There is no danger. They do not want any such precautions as these, because there is no danger of anything like a disturbance of public safety or of public peace. We simply availed ourselves of what was there for the purpose of being availed of. Why was it put there if it is wrong to avail of it, and why was not this Article taken out when the mistake was discovered, or when it was found that it was unhealthy and bad for the Constitution of this nation to have it there? That brings me back to giving the same reason — I cannot find any other for it — that it is simply a matter of political convenience. Another reason that I could give for it would be this: Young governments are inclined to embark on such expeditions. They imagine, I suppose, like young people, that they are complete masters of the art of government. The art of government consists of a good deal of consistency. It consists a good deal in creating in the people a belief that the Constitution is a sacred thing. It has been taught that it is a sacred thing. It will not sound very well amongst the people if in a few days' time they are told that we are able to wipe away two or three clauses of this particular Constitution. The people will imagine, and quite justly that any number of clauses can be wiped away in the same fashion, and they can always say to themselves: "Well, such-and-such a clause is there this week, but it will probably vanish next week."
That is one thing that will weaken the whole position, and it is the one thing that young and inexperienced governments embark upon. As I have said, the people expect consistency in Governments, that there will be a certain amount of consistency in the Constitution, and that the rights they had in the Constitution will be preserved and defended by their representatives. My reason for intervening in this debate was that I felt it was necessary that I, on behalf of the people I represent, should make my protest against the quick and unreasonable change proposed in the present Constitution. The people believe that not only had they rights, but that it was their duty to exercise them. What has been the result of that? That in two or three weeks the whole Constitution has been changed, and those particular Articles are wiped out just because the people attempted to take advantage of what they had a perfect right to take advantage of. The Minister for Agriculture made some remarks on the necessity of giving up political discussions. We did not raise any political discussions here. We did not raise this as a political discussion, but simply tried to carry out, in a perfectly legal and orderly manner, what we were led to believe we had a perfect right to do. That is what has caused all these discussions that have taken place during the last three weeks.
Perhaps the Minister for Agriculture is right that political discussions should be eliminated, and that what the people need are purely industrial and economic discussions. I say it is very difficult for people to settle down to industrial and economic discussions as long as the present Government continue amending and eliminating clauses from the Constitution, especially the clause that a portion of these people consider they have a perfect right to use and enjoy. The Minister for Agriculture also spoke of decisions by the people on what are fundamentals. Now what is fundamental to the Constitution and what is fundamental to the people from the people's point of view is eventually what will win out. What may be fundamental to a particular Party under the Constitution is quite another thing. The people are generally always wiser and are always right, and it is the people of this country who will eventually decide what is fundamental to them, and what they believe are the fundamentals will be the fundamentals of the Constitution. I agree thoroughly with the leader of the Labour Party that this motion is a blemish on the name of the Irish people, that it is a motion that should never have been brought in here. I believe it is a motion that will do harm to the credit of this country, and if it does that it is doing very serious injury indeed. These are my reasons for opposing the motion.
Comment on this
I did not intend to intervene in this debate at all, but Deputy J.J. Byrne left me no option. I flatter myself, whether it is a thing on which I should flatter myself or not, on being a constitutionalist, a full-blooded, die-in-the-ditch constitutionalist, and when I see the Constitution of this State being riddled, as it has been for the past few weeks, I am somewhat perturbed. When I see the motion that is on the Order Paper to-day asking that this Bill should not go through the ordinary procedure and should not be referred to the people, I ask myself what is the reason for it. I must say that I got no answer whatever when listening to any of the Ministers who spoke. I got no answer until Deputy J.J. Byrne spoke and, no doubt, as he always does, he voiced the true feelings and the true opinions of the Government Party. He said that there were certain inter-dependent clauses in the Constitution over which we had no control. These are his words, not mine. Therefore, the Irish people who, we were told, had complete control in their own house, who had complete control over the Constitution, and complete control over their freedom and destinies, have no control over the Constitution. The Deputy let the cat out of the bag. He said that, seeing that we have no control over certain inter-dependent clauses in the Constitution therefore we must not submit these things to the people, and that is the reason I see why there is anxiety on the part of the Executive Council in getting this motion through the Dáil.
We must not tell the people that, what certain parties in this country have been telling them for the past seven or eight years, is a terminological inexactitude. I do not want to quote Deputy Flinn. I want to use another phrase that we got from another place like the Constitution probably. It is with some regret that I say that, because I did think that there was never any use in belittling what we had won. I think there was never any use in making little of the Treaty or the Constitution framed within the Treaty. I did think that we could make each advance a starting point towards something else. I thought that we could model the Constitution so as to give us greater and fuller freedom, but now I find, on the words of the learned spokesman of the Government Party, that there are clauses in the Constitution that we dare not touch, that there are conditions governing us from outside, and that there are people of greater importance than the Irish people in this Constitution, that the Treaty is of greater importance than the Irish people, and that we dare not submit certain clauses of it to them. That is exactly what Deputy Byrne told us, and it is a source of some regret to me that that is the case. That is the reason why I think we should not allow this motion to go through. If there are clauses in the Constitution over which the Irish people have no control there should not be such clauses. Deputy Byrne ought to be the last man to try and have them in a Constitution governing the lives and liberties of the Irish people. They should not be there without the sanction of the Irish people or having been submitted for their sanction.
Comment on this
On a point of information, does Deputy Hogan know that the same clause is in the Constitution of every Dominion within the British Commonwealth?
Comment on this
I am not concerned with what is in the Constitution of the Dominions. I am sorry that Deputy Byrne is leaving. I endeavoured to hold on while he was speaking, and I thought that he might pay the same compliment to me, and I might be just as interesting. I am not concerned with what is in the Constitution of the Dominions or in the Constitution of monarchies. What I am solely concerned with, and what the Dáil should be solely concerned with, is what the Irish people think should be in the Constitution. We should not model our Constitution on that of Australia, Canada, or anywhere else, but upon what the Irish people think should be in it. We should not be afraid to submit any Article of the Constitution to them and say, "This is the freedom we asked you to sacrifice so many lives for. This is the Constitution we asked you to engage in war for. This is the Constitution which those who defended it and put before you said was the whole Constitution and every comma of the Constitution," knowing at the same time that there were clauses in it over which they had no control, according to the statement of Deputy Byrne. So, therefore, it is outside influence that still controls us and is still our master. I wish to make my protest against this attempt to prevent the Irish people from having a say in any of the clauses of the Constitution. They should have their say in them, and this attempt to take from them that right is the only reason I can see for this motion. Therefore this motion is an attempt to muzzle the Irish people and prevent them from having their say. That is the only thing that is in danger. The public safety is not in danger, but the reputation, the character and the veracity of those people who stood for that Constitution is in danger, and that, I suggest, is the reason this motion is being rushed through the Dáil. It is because there are inter-dependent clauses in the Constitution over which we have no control, that the reputation of the people who stood for that Constitution and recommended it to the Irish people knowing there were these inter-dependent clauses in it, that their honesty of purpose, their intelligence if you like, their life as a political Party, and nothing else, are in danger. The public safety is perfectly safe, and the people are perfectly safe. It is only the character of a political Party that is in danger.
Comment on this
The statement that was most applauded here this evening was that by the Minister for Agriculture, a modern version of "Get on with the work." He said, and I think truly, that the country generally was fed up with politics, and that the people were much more concerned with questions of agricultural and industrial improvement at present. Undoubtedly that is the case. We here are not to be taken as not appreciating the desire of the people to get on with the work. I believe we are at least as keen to get on with the work as the Government Deputies. I think I used the very same arguments as the Minister for Agriculture myself yesterday in regard to another Bill before the House. I think I asked what was the importance of it, and whether there were not more urgent problems than settling the powers of the Seanad with regard to the holding up of Bills.
Could not the present powers be left a little while longer, so that more urgent legislation could be attended to? We appreciate the point made by the Minister for Agriculture, but we must remember that that cry to which he gave utterance has been familiar now for some six or seven years. Notwithstanding all that the dominant Party have said on their platforms, and through their various organs of expression — the newspapers certainly have never missed an opportunity of pressing it home — there has not been that agricultural and industrial progress. The point arises then whether you can have agricultural and industrial progress merely by crying out for it.
Are there not other things to do than merely talk about agricultural progress? Are there not other things to be considered? Are there not deeper motives in the people? Are there not longings and yearnings higher than the mere desire for bread and butter? Have they not to be satisfied before agricultural or industrial progress can be achieved? I think the Government more or less realises that these longings do prevail. The Minister for Agriculture is a realist, and as a practical man he has to take this into account. He must be conscious of some mystic character in the people because we remember that only last Sunday week, I think, one of his fellow-Ministers went down in state to Tone's grave and gave an idealistic address on Tone, and he tried to connect up Tone with the present position in Ireland. I wonder was that done simply as a pastime, or was it a recognition that there was something in the people other than a desire for bread and butter? If the Minister is the realist and practical man he pretends to be — the man that the "Irish Times" praises him so much as being — is he not very impatient of that ceremonial at Bodenstown? I think that it is all a pretence of realism and practicality, and he too is uneasy. He feels that it is not enough to say "Get on with the work," that the people do not respond to a mere commonplace, superficial thing like that, for he is far too deep a man not to realise that that as a cry is a failure, that it gets nowhere, and that it attracts nobody.
If he comes along with a programme that is repugnant to them, to their traditions and aspirations, no matter how willing they are, they will not welcome him if he has that programme as part of his policy. I think it is quite safe to say that the Minister realises that, and that speech of his to-day was merely an effort to appeal to the superficial qualities of Deputies in the House, to appeal to the superficial inclinations and aspirations of people. Well, as I have said, the cry, "Get on with the work" has been going on. We are here very eager to get on with the work. We feel stability is an important thing; it is more important to the people on these benches than to the Deputies opposite because many of us here are not, as many of the other Deputies on the other side are, men of property. We have to live by earning our living and to those who are not professional politicians who have to live by day-to-day labour, stability is an important thing. To me, anyway, it is a desirable thing, and I know many Deputies of my Party for whom I can say the same, but we know stability can only be attained on certain conditions. We know what we have been doing this week and last week is not going to lead to stability, to agricultural or industrial improvement. There are many, low as the vitality of the country is at present, many thousands who are watching this debate and the progress of things here, and when they see what is being done this week they will not be encouraged, they will not feel that they have at last reached stability and done with politics. So far from that, in my opinion it is going to be a very disturbing element. The fact that such an unconstitutional thing can be done under the name of constitutionalism, the fact that a Government because it has a small majority in this House, can make use of that majority to carry a ridiculous motion like this without putting up a single argument to support it, without making a pretence that it has any truth or reality behind it, such action is going to make people disappointed. These people may not be the majority of the people, but they are key people; their influence is going to tell, and instead of establishing the Constitution, instead of making people feel that anyhow the way is now clear for evolutionary progress, that things are going at least to proceed in a normal way, I think a great many people will feel more disappointed and dissatisfied with conditions than ever. There will be very few in the country satisfied with the statement that if those two Bills were carried to the country and a vote of the people were asked it would lead to disturbance and disorder. I do not think there are very many fools in the country who will be deceived by that cry.
Two general elections were fought last summer, one under rather extraordinary conditions sprung at a moment's notice. There was, I admit, on both sides very strong propaganda, in posters, newspapers and so on, of the matter appertaining to the election which tended to develop excitement if the tendency to excitement were there at all. Yet, we found those two elections passed off in an almost model fashion. Now within the past week there have been local elections conducted throughout the country and local elections have often led to something like disorder and to a great deal of excitement. You find the newspaper comment is almost universally agreed that there was apathy on the part of people and that there was no interest in elections, 30 per cent., voted in some part of Meath, 32 per cent. in some other part and so on. Yet the Government tell us that if this harmless Initiative and Referendum, this product of faddists like the Chief Justice, Senator Douglas, and Judge Murnaghan is to be explained to the people and they are asked to vote there will certainly be such excitement and disorder as will endanger the peace of the country. Deputy J.J. Byrne and a few others may be deceived by it, but I think if one could see into the hearts of the Government's supporters at present, they do not feel too happy with the case put up for it. Certainly, when Deputy J.J. Byrne asked what was he to say to the electors of North City I felt like telling him that if he minded as little what he said to the electors of North City as he minded what he told a public meeting in Donnybrook last September it should not worry him much. But I suppose Deputy Byrne's remarks did not influence a great many people and we need not worry about them. Anyway, I have heard no case made out for this resolution. I think if it is passed it is going to have a most unfortunate effect. As one who believes in evolutionary progress; that great progress can be made here if things were conducted in a normal way, I believe it will be a most unfortunate thing if this resolution is passed and that it will create discontent and contempt for the Constitution and contempt for representative government. It will do nothing but injury, and if I thought I would influence anyone not to vote for it I would appeal very strongly to him to think, at least two or three times, before he gives his consent to the measure.
Comment on this
It is a terrible state of affairs when you have a man like Deputy McDonogh from Galway, who was always a constitutionalist falling asleep during this debate and not realising the terrible danger that he is in from rebellion and revolution. It is not fair for the Government.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear it. I just wanted to warn you that there is going to be a terrible revolution in this country. I was afraid you might not know it.
Comment on this
The sort of revolution you will bring will not make much difference. A half dozen of your sort would not make a man.
Comment on this
It was not fair for the Government to suddenly announce that there was going to be serious disorder in this country unless there was a danger of serious trouble, probably revolution and rebellion, and to keep this fact hidden for years past. I understood from the President that the dangerous people in this country had their teeth drawn, that murder was by the throat, and that we had reached a condition of stable government, that we had turned corners until we were as tired turning them as we are tired turning around the lobbies here. He boasted down the country, and so did every member of his Party, that we had arrived at a stage when law and order were supreme, that there was no fear or danger that people would object to law in any way except the constitutional way. Suddenly, and without any notice, he comes along here to this sovereign Assembly and tells us that there is an extreme danger of revolution and trouble. Really, I cannot understand it, considering the amount of money that has been spent on the Army and the very efficient Civic Guard force that we have, considering the amount of money that was spent in stabilising the Government and the number of speeches that were made proving to the people that we had stable government. We suddenly discover now that we have not, that there is grave danger that this State is going to fall unless a certain Bill is passed within a certain number of hours. It is up to the President to take some precaution to prevent this state of anarchy or chaos or, as one of his Party said, "chouse," arising here. It is extraordinary, if this country is on the edge of a volcano, that we are going to allow games like the Tailteann Games to be played and visitors to be brought into a country that is in such a troubled state, that we are going to allow visitors from all over the Continent and from America to be brought in here, to endanger their lives for the sport of the thing. It is strange that boxers are being brought over from Germany to box the Civic Guards, unless it is to train them for this terrible thing that is going to happen. Then there is the reception for the airmen. Really, it is a very serious question, much more serious than the passing of this Bill. I believe if there is such a danger of trouble in the country that the Tailteann Games, the Aonach an Ghárda, and all these receptions and sports should be stopped, and that serious measures should be taken to prevent this danger that is going to arise. Another thing, there are a lot of innocent men like myself, Deputies up from the country, who should be allowed to go home. If there is going to be such a serious state of affairs within the next few days I think we should be allowed to go home. I am sure Deputy McDonogh will thoroughly agree with me in that, if he never agreed with me before.
Comment on this
What I would like to know is if there is to be such a serious state of unrest who are the individuals concerned in this conspiracy? Is it the fishermen? Are they going to unite and to come up here to drive out the Minister for Fisheries, Fionan Lynch? Is it really the public safety, or is it simply the safety of Cumann na nGaedheal? Is it the disgusted people of the Gaeltacht that are going to come up en masse to drive the steel helmets out? I would really like to know what is at the bottom of this serious disorder that is impending.
Comment on this
I am at a disadvantage. I did not hear Deputy Tubridy's references to me, as he did not speak loud enough. But I would like to say that I only arrived here this evening. I was at home yesterday at an election. I have heard a lot of people talking about the desire of the people to vote at elections, but yesterday in Galway scarcely 42 per cent. of the electors voted. In the urban area some of the people refused to vote for the County Council. They said they did not care about it or know anything about it. Yet we are told that these are the people who are so anxious to have another try at the Dáil. What the Minister for Agriculture said here to-day is the thing that is going to influence the country. The people want peace; they want to be allowed to go on with their work, and this hot air and nonsense we hear from the other benches goes for nothing. What good do these men do? I employ more men than the whole lot of them over there, and do more good. Yet we have this little whipper-snapper from Carraroe giving cheek. I do not intervene in those discussions. All this discussion is simply a waste of time and for the purpose of obstruction. We are anxious to go home. Of course they have nothing much to do at home. I do not want to take part in discussions that end nowhere, and the sooner you people on the other side realise it——
Comment on this
They know who I am, sonny, what they do not know about some people. I have a pedigree, at any rate.
Comment on this
Put up your record. I have never done anything I was ashamed of or what I want to retract. The sooner you stop these small speeches and the wasting of time the better. If speeches and passing resolutions were any good Ireland would be the most wonderful country in the world. That is all you are able to do; you are not able to do any work, but you are able to waste other people's time.
Comment on this
Are we to have our time wasted here listening to Deputy McDonogh telling us about the men he employed?
Comment on this
Just as the President comes along and tells us about the furniture he has in his house, and as some other men come along and tell us about some other attributes we will have someone else coming along and telling us to go on with the work and not to mind this political talk. The Minister for Agriculture told us here to-day that he had the key to the situation, why we were always wanting to have some political subject before the people, because we were afraid to come down to the economic subject. First of all it is not our fault that these political subjects are before the Dáil. We did not introduce any of these political subjects. We were quite satisfied to go on with the economic programme. These Bills were not brought in by us. We are prepared to-night or to-morrow to discuss the motions down in our own names, to answer for economic programme if the Government are prepared to face us on it. It is over three months since I asked the President for a special day to discuss a motion that is down in my name. It has no political significance whatever. It is purely an economic matter. But the President said he had not time, yet he has time to come along here and tell us that the Referendum and Initiative would endanger the public peace and safety. There are other motions down here. There is a motion in the names of Deputies de Valera and Sean Lemass asking that some consideration be given to the flour milling industry. It is only within the last couple of weeks that a flour mill was closed down in Rathdrum. That thing is allowed to go on. Flour mills are closing down and men are thrown out of employment who are not lucky enough to have people like Deputy McDonogh to employ them.
Comment on this
That is what I say, that the people in Rathdrum are not lucky enough to have persons like Deputy McDonogh to employ them. While these people are facing unemployment we are brought here to talk about the Referendum and the Initiative being dangerous to the public peace and safety. There are other resolutions on the Order Paper also, not only from our Party, but from the Labour Party. There is one which, if brought forward for discussion, might have a political tinge as well as an economic effect, but, if it could be carried out, it would save this country £3,000,000 a year. The Minister for Agriculture accused us of keeping this political bogey before the people and of trying to get the people worked up on political subjects to keep their mind off the advantages to be derived from supporting the present Government. Yet, as somebody remarked, for the last six or seven years, while all this talk was going on and while this programme was being put into force, nobody in this House or anywhere else could see an improvement in the economic conditions of the people. We have been accused by Deputy McDonogh and others about our conduct in this Dáil.
Comment on this
I beg to intervene. Is the Deputy aware that himself and those connected with him are the cause of a good deal of depression in this country?
Comment on this
Will any sensible man come along and invest money in this country while that is going on?
[Interjection by Deputy Killilea.]
Comment on this
I wish that Deputy Killilea would give an opportunity to other Deputies in the House to make a remark occasionally.
Comment on this
The sooner the better. We have been taken to task here about our conduct, and were told that we could not conduct ourselves in this House. Perhaps if we were imbued with a little of the courtesy of the President, and referred to our opponents as toe-rags, we might be all right. We are opposing these Bills as best we can, and we believe that they are an infringement on the rights of the Irish people, and, if any of us have got into trouble during that opposition, we cannot help it. There have been very few Deputies—I do not know any on the opposite side—who have got down to the motion before the House and tried to show what is the real danger to the public peace and safety if these two Bills are not passed through.
It would appear from some of the speeches on the opposite side that Deputies do not realise or do not know what this motion is about. They do not realise that the motion implies that unless the Referendum and the Initiative are removed from the Constitution there will be an immediate danger to the public peace and safety, that unless these two Articles which have been in the Constitution for practically six years are removed there will be a danger to the public peace and safety. That is what we are asked to vote on, on this question. We are accused of threatening but I do not think we have ever made such a silly threat as that—that there is going to be public commotion or danger to the public peace and safety unless these two Articles are removed from the Constitution. It has not been shown that there will be. As a matter of fact Deputy McDonogh told us that there is absolute apathy at the local elections and that there is only between a 30 and 40 per cent. vote. If there is going to be that apathy, if a Referendum is taken, where is the commotion to come from? There might be some justification for this motion if Deputy McDonogh came back from the country and told us that the people were scrambling round the polling booths, that 98 per cent. had voted and that the other 2 per cent. were knocked out of action and could not poll, but that did not happen and there is no necessity at all for it. But they have a reason of their own. It is because the Government are afraid that there would be apathy amongst their followers to defeat this, if a Referendum were taken on the question.
We were told by the Minister for Agriculture that there were not five people in the country to-day interested in the Initiative or the Referendum. Yet, these five people are going to work up what must amount practically to a rebellion if there is to be a Referendum. Five or six people are interested; the other 3,000,000 do not care about it, but these five or six people are going to endanger the public peace and safety if this question is put to a Referendum. That is the sort of argument put up from the Galway Deputies. I do not know if we had contributions on the subject from any other constituency. Deputy J.J. Byrne from North Dublin did not deal with that aspect of the question. He introduced himself as an authority on constitutional law and ruled anybody on this side of the House out as knowing nothing about constitutional law and he then went on to expound the subject of Dominion status. In that connection his exposition on Dominion status does give us an insight into what is really behind this motion. What is really behind this motion is not that there is any danger to the public peace and safety in referring this particular Bill to the people, because everybody knows that a vote can be taken on that Bill with the greatest safety, but what the Government is afraid of, in case the Referendum and the Initiative were established, is their own safety. That is what they are afraid of. They are afraid of the public peace and safety, always meaning by the "public peace and safety" the peace and safety of the Government and the keeping of power by that Government. I do not remember that we used any threats on this matter; I have not heard any such threats used by anybody on this side of the House while I was present but I say that if they were used, we have certainly this to say, at any rate, that we did not use as silly and ludicrous a threat as the threat involved in the resolution before the House.
Comment on this
Question—"That the question be now put"—put.
Do you agree with this result?