We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

PUBLIC BUSINESS. - CORK CITY MANAGEMENT BILL, 1928—THIRD STAGE.

Contributions 1–198 of 408. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Cork City Management Bill, 1928
Enacted

No. 32 of 1928 ›

Richard James Mulcahy MINISTER for LOCAL GOVERNMENT and PUBLIC HEALTH (General Mulcahy) Cumann na nGaedheal

I move amendment 1.

In sub-section (2), page 2, line 36, to delete the words "County Borough of Cork" and substitute the words "Cork County Borough."

The purpose of the amendment is simply to correct a wrong description.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

There are a number of amendments here dealing with similar matters. The first deals with the question whether there should be annual or triennial elections. I propose to take Deputy de Valera's amendment, and then put the question that in Section 3, sub-section (1) the words "and in every year thereafter" stand. If these words stand, then annual elections will have been agreed to by the Committee. The other amendments will depend on that to a certain extent.

Comment on this

I move amendment 2:—

"To delete sub-section (1) and to substitute the following:—

"(1) A borough election shall be held in the year 1928 and subsequently in every third year thereafter."

I was one of those who voted for the Second Reading of this Bill because I believed that it was possible to amend it in Committee so as to bring it in accord with an idea to which, personally, I was not opposed. There was no clear principle running through the Bill to which this would run counter, and, accordingly, I felt that the amendments that I wished to propose would be in order. As I said on the Second Reading, a good case can certainly be made for the separation of the executive from the deliberative functions of the council, and in so far as the Bill has that purpose in view, I, for one, will not oppose it. As I said, a good deal can be said, undoubtedly, for putting the executive powers in the control of a single individual, provided that it is quite clear that that individual is really the executive servant of the council as a whole. All the amendments that I wish to propose are intended to secure that the manager shall in fact be subject to the control of the elected body. If we are going to make the elected body a deliberative body, I see no reason why we should be anxious at all to limit the numbers. Consequently, I am in favour of a much larger council than is proposed in this Bill. Again, if we are going to have a large council, the question arises whether that council is to be elected altogether and retire altogether, or whether it is to be so formed that a part of it will retire at stated periods say every year, as is clearly outlined in the Bill itself.

Now we in our Party have discussed the whole question of whether the council should go out piece-meal, or whether the council should go out all in a body. Our members comprise men who have had a good deal of experience of local government, and we were almost unanimous in the view that the council should go out as a body at a period of three years. Against any argument that continuity is necessary is the practical fact that in reality continuity is got: that when a council goes out there is always a very large proportion of its members re-elected, and there is no necessity at all to make any special legal provision so that that should follow. I think then that, at this stage, it is not necessary to say very much more in support of having an election every third year. All these amendments hang largely together. The idea which the council hangs on is the idea of regarding it largely as a deliberative body. The idea of having the elections all at once comes from the idea that, if you want the people to have control over their elected representatives and to change policy, they ought not to be compelled, for example, to put up with a policy for a longer period than is absolutely necessary.

There is another point, that there is constant disturbance by new members, or a possible disturbance, anyhow, to the policy of the council as a whole. If the body is elected for a definite period of three years, they can set to work immediately and decide their policy with the feeling that that policy at any rate will have an opportunity of being worked out in a definite period of three years. If, on the other hand, some of the members come in new after a period of a year, there is a possible disturbance of that. You have new arrangements, and consequently a general disturbance, so that the general consideration and the particular consideration that I have mentioned have decided me in proposing this amendment. I think that it will have the support of practically every member of our Party.

Comment on this

I, unlike Deputy de Valera, am opposed to the principle of this Bill of the government of a city by a manager. As, however, the House has decided that such an experiment should get a trial, I have endeavoured, as far as possible within the principle of the Bill, to secure that the utmost possible power should be given to the elected representatives of the people, and that if the manager is to be elected or nominated by the Minister, that he should be under the control of the Corporation and under the authority of the Minister. I can see all the objections that Deputy de Valera has pointed out to having what I may call piece-meal elections. One of the points that I particularly object to does not immediately arise on this amendment. What we are now dealing with is the question of elections every year thereafter.

The main objection I have to that, in the first instance, is that under the Bill, as drafted, Cork Corporation will not be fully constituted for three years. That is apart altogether from the question as to whether a section of the Corporation should be elected every third year or every year. Here we have the fact that if the Bill is passed in its present form the Cork Corporation will not be fully constituted for three years. There are many objections to that. First of all, there is the question of policy. This Bill contemplates the election of five members the first year, five others coming in the next year, and another five the year after, and if after three years five go out, there is no such thing as giving the Corporation a fair chance of setting their minds towards adopting a proper policy of control in the City of Cork. If the people in control—perhaps I am wrong in saying people in control, as this Bill anticipates that they will not be in control but that it is the manager who will be—have any administrative powers they will be constantly upset by fresh minds coming in, and whatever was done this year by five men will probably be upset the next year by ten men, and whatever they do would probably be upset by fifteen men.

I think if we go a long way towards meeting the Minister's ideas in reorganising affairs in Cork he ought to go the whole way himself and say, "We are prepared here and now to allow the people of Cork to constitute a Corporation at once," instead of having this feeling of distrust of the people which I hold is in the Bill, and saying, "We will have five men for a year to see how they behave, and the next year another five," which would make it utterly impossible for those who are put by the ratepayers to carry out whatever executive functions they have, or to adopt any line of policy which would be likely to have Cork administration carried out in a proper way. We cannot deal with the question of numbers now, but I would appeal to the House to vote in favour of having an election for the whole body. Whatever number of representatives is decided upon, I would ask the Dáil to vote in favour of having the Cork Corporation fully constituted after the Bill is passed.

Comment on this

I desire to take advantage of the courtesy which has been extended by the Chair to the House to speak generally, and perhaps a little more broadly, on this matter than under the strict limitations of a particular amendment. I have no desire to go far outside that, but, having regard to what has been already said, I think it is necessary that certain things should be said by a representative from Cork, representing what we do represent. Our concern in relation to "The Government of Cork Bill" is, first and last, that we should have a good democratic administration. Given that the rest are details. I am entirely in favour of as complete a separation as is possible between executive and legislative functions so long as it is clearly understood that the authority under which executive functions are exercised comes from and goes back to the people. Deputy O'Hanlon said that this was a Bill for the government of the city by a manager. If it is I am absolutely opposed to it. Some of the implications and intentions of the Bill are not entirely obvious, and I for one approach the consideration of this Bill with the intention of putting the best interpretation I can on the intentions of those who framed it. The government of the people is what we must have. Administration by a manager for the people, yes; but government of the city by a manager, no. That is a clear issue.

If we can make it made perfectly clear that all the authority which the manager exercises comes from the people and goes back to the people, and can be taken from a particular manager by the people, then I am in favour of the widest possible extension of the administrative powers of the manager. And that, in my opinion, is the opinion and the wish of the ordinary people of Cork. There was a letter in the paper the other day from a very respected Cork citizen, Sir Stanley Harrington, in which he said that this Bill as it stood was approved by the people of Cork. That Bill may be approved of by Sir Stanley Harrington, and his opinion is a valuable one and worth having, but Sir Stanley Harrington has no authority whatever of any sort or kind to say that the Bill is approved as it now stands by the people of Cork. There was a discussion in Cork by the two Chambers of Commerce there—the Associated Chamber of Shipping and Commerce and the Cork Chamber of Commerce—of the proposal in this Bill. The proposition I put up to them was this: that if the functions of that manager, or whatever other name you like to call him, in relation to the elected representatives were to be the functions of the ordinary manager of an ordinary limited company in relation to the directors who appointed him, paid him, and dismissed him if necessary, then I was in favour of it.

Broadly speaking, that principle seemed to be accepted even at that gathering, but I want to be entirely frank; there is a certain amount of feeling that they would like possibly some stronger powers, and that there was underlying, as there naturally would be underlying in the minds of a body such as the two Chambers of Commerce of Cork, a distrust of the ability of the ordinary citizen to do what they thought they could do very much better. That being clear, as far as I can speak for my constituents in Cork, if it is clearly understood that the government of Cork is to be by the people of Cork, and that all authority which is exercised in its administration is to be exercised as a delegation of that authority, then we are in favour of it, but if it means putting over the City of Cork some outside manager, some outside authority who does not derive authority directly, and whose authority does not go back to the citizens of Cork, to the extent to which it is short of that idea I have stated we are opposed to it. I see no derogation whatever from democratic principles in the delegation of authority.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Will not that come on later? Would the Deputy address himself to this particular amendment now?

Comment on this

I think you have given me very considerable latitude and I appreciate it. So far as the three years are concerned, I investigated the method in this Bill, and there is a good deal of ingenuity and thought in it, and something to be said for the idea here, namely, the gradual building up, an interregnum, a change-over period between the period in which a number of people will administer and that in which one is administering. You are gradually building up from unity to plurality. There is something to be said for that principle, but on the balance, having regard to all the arguments, and, above all, having regard to all the opinions, misunderstandings, the natural distrust of this particular method, the fact that the people do not like it—and it is their business, it is they who have to be satisfied in relation to their government—I am satisfied that this experiment should not be tried upon Cork, that we should elect at the beginning the whole council, that we should elect a council of a reasonable number, and that they should be given as a body at the beginning the whole of the authority which is required to administer the city. I am in favour of the whole body being elected and the whole body going out together.

Comment on this

I do not intend to take up much time, because, as you are aware, I have a number of amendments down to which I will speak at the appropriate time. So far as Deputy de Valera's amendment is concerned, it will have my support and the support of many, if not all, of my colleagues. There was and there is inherent in this Bill many things which are repugnant to democrats and democracy. I and other Deputies have endeavoured to make this Bill more acceptable, or, perhaps, I should say less unacceptable, to the citizens of Cork. I have discussed the terms of the Bill with many citizens of all classes, and the general opinion seems to be that the Bill in its present form is not acceptable. As I have said, I will deal with the amendments in my name when the proper time comes. Deputy O'Hanlon suggested that the whole 21 members, that is, if that number is agreed to, should be elected at the first election. That would commend itself to me and those whom I represent. Whilst continuity might be preserved by having an election every three years—that is, either five or seven, whichever number is decided on —continuity would be preserved each year. At the same time, for the reasons given by Deputy de Valera and, in a sense, for those given by Deputy O'Hanlon, it would meet my views if the whole 21 were elected the first year and then have triennial elections afterwards.

Comment on this

As it is pretty certain that if this Bill proves to be a success and a satisfaction to the Minister for Local Government it will be tried on other municipal areas, I feel that it is incumbent on me to say something on it. I am in entire agreement with the amendment proposed by Deputy de Valera. For the life of me I do not know what purpose the Minister proposes to serve by saying that there should be only one-third of the members elected in the first year. I agree with Deputy O'Hanlon that Cork is to be on trial for three years, that there is a certain amount of mistrust displayed towards the people of Cork. I wonder has the Minister counted what the cost will be to have an election every year. Anyone who has had much to do with elections in recent times under the proportional representation system knows that the smallest election under it costs far more than it would under the old arrangement. That fact should be taken into consideration. If there is such a small proportion of members to be elected each year, especially at the beginning of the new system of management in Cork, to my mind the different interests will not be able to secure representation. All interests would be able to secure better representation if the whole council were elected together, and I believe you would secure better administration if the whole 15 members were elected in the first year. Cork has not had a council to administer its affairs for a considerable time. I have no doubt that many people in Cork disagree with what has been done by Mr. Monahan, against whom I have nothing to say, and I am certain that the people on the spot see that a great many things are required to be done and that they will not be able to do them through the medium of five members. I appeal to the Minister to withdraw the sub-section and to accept the amendment. The mover has expressed himself as being in agreement with the principle underlying the Bill. In view of that, and in order to secure unanimity, which I believe the Minister is anxious to secure, he should accept the amendment.

Comment on this

As far as I can see, there is no use, with a very definite responsibility and wanting to do a very definite thing, namely, fixing the responsibility for the government of Cork, in looking for unanimity. A scheme that would be unanimous would be a very flabby one and one that would surely break down. A yearly election in Cork is proposed on the merits of a yearly election itself in the first place. It is being proposed because it is felt that it will give a steadier administration in the affairs of the city, a steadier pursuing of a policy, less pulsing at the end of three years in either the development or dropping of policies, in regard to salaries or reduction of rates. To provide a Corporation, one-third of which is elected every year, is going back to a system that existed before and introducing, so far as we are concerned to-day, a system which we think will give better results—a steadier administration and a steadier continuance of policy thoughtfully embarked on. Deputy de Valera wants a three-year election in order to enable the people to change policies and he is against a yearly election because he does not want policies changed.

Reviewing the state of affairs in the city in June after a year's administration and after the public discussion that will take place about the rating plans and the general plans for the city administration, if the city wants a change of policy in anything that is foreshadowed it is, I submit, entitled to have that change. As far as a change of policy or as far as controlling the administration of the government of Cork City by the people is concerned, a yearly election gives you a much better opportunity than a triennial election. The proposals that are embodied in this Bill, while they lay the foundation for the better carrying on of the government of Cork, apart altogether from the present-day position, are intended to lead up to the most satisfactory form of government for the city in the future. It is also a transition stage in the policy that was adopted when the Commissioner was appointed to replace the old Corporation of fifty-six members. There is a transition from the present Commissioner system to a system with a manager completely controlling the executive side and completely subjecting policy to an elected Corporation.

Deputy O'Hanlon speaks of this being a Bill for the government of Cork City by a manager. Not a scrap of government goes into the manager's hands. The government of Cork City is a matter for the council. The administration of the city is what is put into the manager's hands. You are changing from a position in which you have a Commissioner in whose hands government and executive powers are vested, to a position in which you will have a larger council. In a position like this I, like Deputy Flinn, see that very great benefit may arise from starting off with a small groups of men acting as the council, but not as a quarter or half a corporation or council, but as a whole council, a body complete in itself, elected completely by the people, and handed over the complete powers that you will be handing over in later years to the larger council. The government of the city by the council, acting through a manager who is in charge of the administrative and the executive side of the work, will call for a very great amount of consideration and cooperation, and I think that it can be best begun by a council of five members, developing gradually to a council of fifteen.

There is another point that makes a yearly election necessary. If you have not a yearly election you will have to divide up the city of Cork into wards. Quite a number of things have been said as to what the people of Cork want in respect of this and that, and what Deputies know about them. In so far as it was possible for me to get at the desires and the wishes of the people of Cork in the matter of the drafting of this Bill, I left nothing undone to get at them, and I found that there was no section in Cork which wanted Cork City divided up into wards. There was no section in Cork that had not a big lot to say about the disadvantages and the undesirable things that followed in the train of having wards in the city. The annual election, as distinct from the triennial election, will enable you to get men or women elected from the city of Cork as a whole. There will be no mosaic made of the city or its interests for the purposes of the civil government of the city. That in itself would be a very strong argument in favour of the annual election.

An annual election also gives you this: that while giving you a council of fifteen as the ultimate and permanent council, it will give you men on that council who will be elected on it by three times the number of votes that would be necessary to put a man on the council with a triennial election system. I suggest that a council elected from Cork in any way you wish, of fifteen members in one year will not be a satisfactory council from the point of view of the proper government of the city. This council of fifteen, with five members elected in three annual elections, will be more representative inasmuch as the members will be men or women appealing to a wider section of the electorate as the type proper to represent them in the carrying on of the city's government. For all those reasons I oppose the amendment. I stick very strongly to the provisions of the Bill and to there being an election this year, or if it is not possible to have it this year, next year, and at any rate that the election shall be yearly and not triennial.

Comment on this

I do not know if the various Parties in the House are regarding the question which is now being discussed as a Party matter to be decided by the Whips and not by the free exercise of our intelligence. I hope not. As Deputy Corish pointed out, there can be very little doubt that this Bill, in the form in which it will emerge from this House, will be taken as a model for similar Bills in future. I would particularly ask that the Deputies from Dublin who are here would give this Bill very careful attention, and bear in mind that if Ministerial promises are going to be carried out we will have a Dublin City Management Bill under discussion before the 31st of next March. When this Bill first came before us I was one of those who were prepared to give favourable consideration to the suggestion contained in it with reference to annual elections. When we discussed the Bill in the councils of the Party I spoke in favour of that system originally, and I put forward in favour of my point of view the identical arguments which the Minister for Local Government and Public Health has put forward here to-day. He stated, as I stated, that this system of annual elections will mean that there will be a more continuous and a more effective control over the members of the council by the people than there would be under the triennial system. He stated, as I stated, that it would avoid the possibility of a violent change in policy on the part of the council such as would be likely to happen if there was a complete sweep of the old Board and its replacement by an entirely new set of persons. He also argued, and it is a fairly strong argument in favour of his contention, that the system suggested in the Bill makes possible having the whole of the borough area as one constituency without any sub-division. He seemed to think that the system proposed in the Bill would prevent members utilising their position on the council for the purpose of gaining popularity prior to the election. That is an argument I did not use. I have no such hope.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy does not suggest that I used it.

Comment on this

The Minister was quite clear in saying that one of the dangers of triennial elections was that prior to the election, the majority party would endeavour to manipulate affairs in order to gain popularity.

Comment on this

Courting popularity towards the local elections, yes.

Comment on this

My view is that the majority party in the council will be doing that three times as often under the Minister's system as under the triennial system of election. I found on examining these arguments subsequently that the advantages which the system outlined in the Bill gives are more theoretical than real. As regards the giving to the people more effective control over the action of the members of the council, we have to strike a balance between democratic rights and efficient government. It seems to me that we can preserve all the rights of the citizens of Cork or all the rights of the citizens of any other city by allowing them to elect the entire council every three years, and we can get much more efficient management by putting upon that council for a definite period of three years full responsibility for the management of the city and allowing them to map out a policy which might take three years to give full effect to and to put into operation. If it is undesirable that there should be a violent change in policy following an election, and if in consequence of that it is desirable that there should be annual elections, it seems strange to me that the Government when amending their Constitution lately did not establish such a system for election to this Dáil. If it is undesirable that these things should happen in the municipal government of Cork, surely it is much more undesirable that they should happen in the government of the State, and I think if we examine that idea more closely we will find that the possibility of a violent change of policy in administration is not avoided by the system proposed in the Bill. In fact, it is made more likely that it will happen much more frequently than once every three years. It is quite obvious that a very small change in the personnel of this assembly could produce a complete reversal in the policy of the Executive appointed by the assembly. If one-third of the members of the Dáil were to retire this year it is extremely likely that it would mean that there would be a different majority in this House, and, as I said, a complete reversal of policy.

The same thing might happen just as well in Cork. It is very likely that there will be conflicting interests in the council so that these interests will group themselves into parties, and the numerical differences between parties in the council will not be very great. It is likely that that numerical difference will be so small that it might easily be reversed in one election or another. You have been told that by having annual elections, instead of triennial elections, you will avoid great and violent changes of policy and preserve what is generally called continuity. For the reasons I have stated, I say that these arguments are groundless.

The Minister also stated that the system of annual election would provide steadier administration. I am not sure what he meant by that, because it appears to me that the very purpose of this Bill, the purpose of replacing the old system by this one, is to provide steady administration by taking the actual control for administration out of the hands of the elected council and giving it into the hands of a paid manager. Now, it is when we examine the question of having the whole area as one constituency instead of subdividing it, that we see more clearly that the advantages mentioned by the Minister are theoretical and not real. Undoubtedly the ward system which existed in Dublin, in Cork and in other constituencies produced evils. These evils were not due to the fact that the areas were subdivided into wards but that the wards were too small. We have 27,000 voters in the borough of Cork, and by dividing the constituency into three more or less equal divisions we will be able to ensure that in each division there will be approximately 9,000 voters. It is when the wards are much smaller that that evil arises. It is when we have, as here in Dublin, wards where a vote of five hundred or six hundred will secure the election of an individual that the evil of the "ward-heeler" develops, and where you have individuals who concentrate their activities upon retaining the support of five or six hundred people sacrificing for that purpose the interest of the city as a whole.

The advantage of not dividing the city would be, of course, that the persons elected on the council would consider themselves as representing the city as a whole and not a particular part of it, and, therefore, they would be much more inclined to support projects benefiting the city as a whole, even though the projects might inflict injuries on particular parts of the city.

But when we turn to this Dáil, we find that these advantages exist in theory and not in reality. I remember drawing attention to this matter during the Second Reading of this Bill by taking as an example the constituency of Galway. There is not a person who understands conditions as they exist in Galway who does not know that the Deputies coming from that constituency do not represent Galway as a whole, and who does not know that they do not claim to represent the county as a whole. In general, you have one or two representatives for Connemara, you have one or two as representatives of North Galway, and one or two as representatives of South Galway, and these Deputies will confine their particular activities as Deputies to the areas in which they received the bulk of their support. The same thing would apply to Cork or to any other constituency. There you would have the members going forward for election to the council relying on getting the bulk of their support in some one or two of the old wards. When they would be members of the council, they would remember that their presence there was due to the fact that they had got the bulk of their support in one or two parts of the city. The temptation to sacrifice the city as a whole for one or two parts would be still there. Therefore, the dangers that undoubtedly arise when the whole city is divided into a great number of small parts will be avoided by this system. I suggest that the Minister is more anxious to produce a theoretically good scheme than to devise a method of government for Cork that will meet the requirements on the spot.

The other point which arises is a very important one. It is the point mentioned by Deputy O'Hanlon and also by the Minister. That is the fact that the council will not be constituted fully for three years after the scheme has come into operation. There seems to be an idea in the mind of the Minister that this scheme provides for a gradual restoration to the people of Cork of the rights of governing their city which were taken when the Commissioner was appointed. That is not the case. As soon as the scheme comes into operation the Commissioner system is ended. You have the manager in possession, and then you must consider all the powers he will have, even when the council is fully constituted. The only thing wrong with the scheme at the beginning is that the council itself will not be fully constituted. It will consist of five members and not the full number of 15. There is no need to point out to any person who knows the conditions existing in any of our principal towns that it would not be possible to secure adequate representation for all interests in any city on a council of five members, and particularly, as will happen in this case, when one or two particular issues are likely to be the bone of contention at an election. It may happen that two members will hold one view, two will hold another view, and the fifth will have still another view. They will be elected, and then all the various interests constituting our city life will be without representation.

Personally, I think that what Deputy O'Hanlon said is correct, that the Government appear to be afraid of the people; they are afraid to give the people an adequate opportunity of expressing their views on municipal government and municipal matters generally. I hope this question will not be treated as a party question; that we will remember that we are not dealing with Cork alone and that we are setting a model for the future city government of this country. I hope that each Deputy will cast his vote on this amendment in accordance with his own judgment. I do not think it would be fair to the experiment in city government which is about to be tried to have the council only partly constituted during the most critical period of the experiment. I believe a scheme somewhat similar to that outlined in the Bill is the best scheme for the government of our cities. I would like to make sure that the idea of the provision of legislative and administrative functions between the manager and the council would not be prevented from coming into operation by the failure of the first experiment. That is why I would like Deputies to pay particular attention when voting in this matter and let them endeavour to remove anything that would give rise to failure.

Comment on this

The Minister referred to the idea of triennial elections as a flabby scheme. I do not see anything flabby or wrong about it. I think his idea constitutes a much more flabby scheme.

Comment on this

I would like to correct the Deputy. I did not refer to the idea of a triennial election as a flabby scheme; I spoke of reconciling all the different opinions on different points in the Bill into one unified and agreed measure as being likely to result in a flabby scheme.

Comment on this

I do not think that any of the amendments are flabby. As regards the city of Cork, the Minister said he consulted the people there, and he did not move in this matter until he was perfectly satisfied he had ascertained their views, and then he incorporated them in this Bill. So far as I am personally concerned, if the people of Cork unanimously asked for this Bill and sent up a deputation, it is the principle in the Bill that I am opposing, and I do not care a row of pins about the people of Cork.

Comment on this

Treason!

Comment on this

What is the meaning of this consultation with the people of Cork? It is on all fours with the position of a man going to visit a prisoner in a cell. Cork had no Corporation when the Minister went to consult the people there, and very naturally the people there said: "If you let us run this place and give us some kind of administration, we will agree to almost anything."

Comment on this

So far as the Labour Party in Cork are concerned, they never used any such expression.

Comment on this

The sterner administration that the Minister speaks of is, I think, illustrated very largely in his own amendment. Under this Bill there would be five members elected for the first year. There are several very important functions connected with the Corporation. The Corporation are given some powers, and in order to carry out those powers it is absolutely necessary to have a two-thirds majority of five. That is what is called sterner administration. Two-thirds majority of five would amount to four. That means four to one, and unless you get four of the five to agree at a certain point there can be no change in Cork, and the manager still reigns supreme. That is the actual fact, and that is the amendment in the Minister's own hand. That is the form of sterner administration that I object to.

I cannot see why the Minister is against constituting the Cork Corporation on its full basis. He agrees there should be 15 members. Let us all agree on 15 members. Why does he object to putting the 15 members in control of Cork here and now under this measure? He did not state why, but I will assume that later on he will say that if we elect all the Corporation members in one lot—15 members would be involved—it would involve a very large ballot paper. That could really be the only objection. When you come to amendment 10 later on I think I will simplify the ballot paper and the mode of election. However, that is anticipating events.

Suppose the Minister does not give way on that—personally, I am not going to give way on the question of having them all changed at once—why does he not reverse engines in regard to the constitution of the Corporation of 15 men and let five of them go up for election every year? Would not that be a much better scheme than the scheme which the Minister has submitted? If there are five low down on the list they would come out in the first year; that is, if we are to have an upset in the administration every year. I think that my scheme is a better one than the Minister's. I would appeal to the Minister to consider the question of the rather humiliating position that he is placing Cork and other cities in by putting it to them: "We cannot trust you to elect more than five good men; you are not capable of selecting more than five men at a time." I do not know whether that is in the Minister's mind, or whether he wants to secure that the manager is going to be dominant there and have as few people to deal with as possible in the early stages, so that he will get his feet under him and be able to handle the others as they come along.

Comment on this

I wish to speak in favour of the amendment. This Bill, which is called the Cork City Management Bill, is in reality a cloak for dictatorship. The fact that the Minister has found it necessary to get a cloak for the dictator, or to get so many scapegoats to whom he can point as being in fault whenever the manager makes a mess, is a good job at any rate. When we see the Minister solemnly standing up here asking to have an election every twelve months, and when we consider that the same Minister yesterday was looking to have an election only every nine years, we wonder where the change comes in. Yesterday he only wanted Senators elected every nine years. To-day he wants this Corporation elected every twelve months.

Comment on this

We want one-third of them elected every third year.

Comment on this

One-third of them— what is wrong with the rest? He expressed the opinion that by having the election every three years, at the end of the three-year period they would be looking for popularity and looking to hold their seats. By having an election every twelve months you will have them all the time trying to keep their leg in. We all know what that means. I should like a little explanation as to why he states that the three-year election system would mean a ward system and that the twelve months' election system would mean that you would have the election for the whole city. I should like to have it explained why the three years' election system would not mean an election for the whole city, or why the ward system would be introduced in that particular respect. I do not think I am in favour of any portion of this Bill, because from what I can read of it, it is only a cloak for the present dictatorship that exists in Cork City, of which the people of Cork City are heartily sick. I am speaking with a little personal experience of the Commissioner system, because I was a member of a Committee which took over the South Cork Board of Public Assistance from the Commissioner, and I know the mess we found there. I know very well that a continuance in power of this Commissioner under the new cloak——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

That is a different subject.

Comment on this

To come back to the annual election, the election of only five each year is most ridiculous. I think Deputy O'Hanlon's allusion to it, that you wanted two-thirds majority, and that the two-thirds majority is to consist of four out of the five, proves how ridiculous it is to expect these five to do anything whatsoever.

Comment on this

I should like to convince the House that the statement made by Deputy O'Hanlon to the effect that this Bill represented in any way the opinions of anything like the majority of the people of Cork is absolutely incorrect. I was present at a few of the conferences that the Minister had in Cork in reference to this Bill, and I do not think it can be contended that any of the conferences I was at put up any other suggestion for the future local government of Cork than that the public representatives should have full authority over the government of the City. That fundamental idea is essential if there is going to be got behind this Bill the goodwill of the people of Cork. It is from that point of view that I point out to the Government, if Cork is going to be made the trial-ground for the future municipal government of boroughs, that at least the goodwill of the people of Cork is worth looking for.

If this is going to be an experiment for future municipal government, for instance, we will say, for the Greater Dublin Borough Scheme, then I will state without fear of contradiction that the people of Cork would tell you to suspend your Bill and make your experiment on Greater Dublin; the people of Cork are prepared to stand by their own Bill and leave the people of Ireland to judge them by the public representatives they will choose themselves. The idea is developing in Cork every day that the people there are not trusted to elect proper and fit people to govern them. I should like it to be made more clear that complete control of policy will be in the hands of the public representatives. The Minister stated that the people of Cork would have full authority and that the manager would only have administrative authority. I should like that to be more clearly defined, because I am not satisfied that they will have complete authority in their hands.

However, I will keep more or less to the particular amendment of which I am speaking in support. Whether individuals like it or not, the majority of the people of Cork to-day want the whole of the Corporation elected at one time. I readily admit that there are individuals who hold other views. There are many individuals who hold that the triennial election has many advantages. But public opinion in Cork is in favour of having the Corporation elected at one time. In support of that argument I may say that the very people whom you will have possibly to rely on for assistance in making this Bill a success will tell you that continuity of policy will be better preserved by the whole Council being elected annually, for the reason that whether the number is to be fifteen, twenty-one or thirty, there was never an election that did not return a very large majority of the members sitting in the previous Council. Individuals will have established a reputation as local administrators and they will be returned again for the services they have rendered. Therefore, you will get that succession of policy without resorting to this form of election. Again, there is a very big division of opinion as to whether the borough should be one constituency or three. I would say that the majority would favour divisions, if the divisions were large enough so that a person would have to poll a large number of votes to entitle him to be a representative. I readily admit that there are people who favour the one constituency for the borough and there is a lot to be said for that.

It has been said by Deputy Lemass that an individual, if he were representing a ward instead of a whole city, would more or less confine his energies to the development of one particular end of the city rather than the whole. There is, of course, the argument, and it is really a good one, that when a man is elected for a whole city he will have a broader outlook and will be inclined to develop the city from the standpoint of the whole rather than that of a particular section. Without going into the system, I wonder would the Minister tell me whether, on coming to his definite conclusion on this Bill, he ever had the necessity of making a comparison in administration, as let us say, between the periods January, 1920, to December, 1922, and the best two years' administration from the years 1924 to 1928, or the period during which the city was governed under the commissioner system.

Frankly, I say that I stand over the policy of the manager system as against the old system. I am convinced it is best to place the administrative authority in a particular individual, but I certainly say that that individual must be subject to the elected representatives and he must be subject to them in a very definite manner. There must be no question of doubt about it; he is positively safe in their hands. But the way I look at it and the way the people of Cork are looking at it is that if the public representatives do not get proper authority over the manager, it means that they are not trusted to control their own affairs.

Comment on this

The question of a manager being in Cork or not being in Cork has nothing, good, bad or indifferent, except on one point—the transition period—to do with the advisability or otherwise of having triennial elections. I do not understand Deputy Lemass's idea of having a three-year policy for city government. The government of cities should flow on in a more or less uninterrupted way. I do not really understand the idea of having an election every three years in order that they may have a three-year policy. I do not really understand the idea of having a party policy in connection with the general development of a city and the carrying out of its work. I do not understand the fear that five members coming in in a particular year might swing by a small majority the balance to one particular policy over another. If some of these statements could be brought down to the practical things that would have to be dealt with in connection with the work of the city, we would understand them better, but as it stands at present it is simply nebulous kind of talk. In regard to the charge, that these advantages in this Bill are theoretical instead of real, it might be argued equally that the advantages of putting in a Commissioner in 1924 were theoretical rather than real.

The position generally is that if you have annual elections you can have, in my opinion, and in the opinion of the Department generally, which has given very careful thought to this matter, a free flow for your city policy. You can have more representative persons as your representatives on your city council. They will stand upon three times a larger number of cast votes and that is a guarantee that your policy will be better thought out and——

Comment on this

Is it the experience of the Minister and the Department behind him that any scheme of any magnitude for a city can be carried out in twelve months?

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to explain how it is that five people elected annually will be more representative than fifteen people elected at one time, because I maintain that at the annual elections there will be a minority of voters left out all the time. I do not want to make a speech, but the Minister definitely said in his speech that these people will be more representative and will get three times more votes. What is really going to happen is that the people who succeed in putting in the first five members will have three votes, and there will be a section of the population without any vote.

Comment on this

What section?

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

Those who under the ordinary system of P.R. would have returned so many of the fifteen if elected together. Under the system of P.R., which you pretend you are going to have in Cork, some people would be elected who, when five are being elected at a time, would have no chance whatever. They would be of the Deputy Good type.

Comment on this

If they are going to be of that type, I shall vote for the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not know how far down in the matter of the size of parties or organisations Deputies want to go in having representatives on the city councils. I say if you are going to come down to small fractions and classes of society, you are going to have a very large council.

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

I hope the Minister will not side-step the question I put to him. Will he explain how it is more representative to elect five people at a time than to elect fifteen at one time, which is the way I maintain that minorities can get representatives on the council? Let the Minister not try to get away from that.

Comment on this

It will be a council consisting of a number of people who will be standing on an electoral vote of three times greater number than some members, at any rate, of the council elected at a triennial election.

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

That is not so.

Comment on this

Just figure it out.

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

It is for you to prove that statement.

Comment on this

Will the Minister state why he stopped at five? If his argument is valid four would be very much better than five and two would be better than three, until eventually you would come down to a one-man council.

Comment on this

I stopped at five in relation to a council of fifteen for the reason that I oppose a council of thirty, as I would oppose a council of twenty-one.

Comment on this

Why not have a council of one?

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

I want the Minister to prove the statement he made or else withdraw it—that is, why the five members he proposes to elect at a time would be more representative than a council fully constituted? Why will a council elected by his system be more representative than if the whole fifteen were voted in at one time over the whole borough of Cork? Although I have a liking for the ward system I admit it is not the best system. Admitting we had the one constituency I want it proved that fifteen elected for that constituency altogether are not more representative than five at a time. I maintain it cannot be done.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is able to take a large number like the electorate of Cork, approximately 27,000 and divide it by five, then take the original number and divide it by three and divide that by five he will have the answer.

Comment on this

He will not have a very convincing answer.

Comment on this

I think in so far as my case for the annual election goes I have made it perfectly clear to people who do not want to drag suggestions of one kind or another about democratic rights and managers' positions across them.

Comment on this

I am very sorry that the Minister for Local Government is taking this stand on this particular matter, because I think he really does not know the amount of hostility there is abroad to this Bill, even were it to be modified in the way some of use who would support it if it were so modified would like. It seems to me that this whole idea of getting five every year originated in the desire to have the whole of the city one area, that that is the beginning and end of it, that either he thought it out himself or when he put the matter before his expert staffs they got what he regards as this ingenious way of getting over the difficulty, and that has hypnotised him to the other faults that are in the thing itself. There is no doubt that on first looking through the Bill it has all the appearance of an armchair measure, a theoretic measure, and that when you go and examine it in the light of all the facts, with the experience every one of us has had, even those of us who have not had direct participation in local government, you see that they are illusory for the most part. If the Minister is anxious to try to get this idea carried out—that is the idea of delegating administrative functions to a single individual—I think he had better from the start, if he wants not merely to get it passed by his majority here but to get a really workable local government scheme, change his attitude as he has shown it up to the present. I for one am willing to admit that I would like to see this scheme worked out properly, but I do not think it is worked out properly in the way in which it is in this Bill. If you want to give the administrative functions to one man, you must make certain of two things, first, that the council as a whole does represent the people generally, that the council is a proper deliberative body, so that all interests and classes will be properly represented in it, and, second, that they have effective control at all times—not to go into the details of administration and interfere with every single idea, but effective control to this extent that if the manager takes the bit between his teeth and wants to become an autocrat, he cannot do so; that they can dismiss him finally, that there is against arbitrary action on his part some court of appeal and that the court of appeal be the representatives of the people. I believe you can manage to get these things worked out properly provided you keep these two essentials in view, when considering the deliberative body. But the smallness of the numbers is going to preclude that if you keep it down to fifteen, even if they were all elected at a single election. If you do what is done in this Bill, then the objection Deputy Boland pointed out arises. It is the same class on each subsequent occasion who will be able to get the majority of the rights when the minority, those with less than one-fifth of the total amount, do not get a show at all in the representation.

I am for a big number, as I said. I am for election of all at the one time. I see, of course, the theoretical advantage in the idea of continuity of policy by having yearly elections and a certain number remaining in, but that is opposed to the proper idea of representative government, because if they are to come for judgment, you ought to have the council as a whole judged on its period of office.

I take it there will be definite policies put forward by certain groups. We may talk about parties and the elimination of parties. We will always have groups and parties of one kind or another. There are bound to be classes of citizens with common ideals and purposes certain to organise and bind themselves into parties, so there is no use in talking that we do not want parties in local government. You are certain to have them, and, therefore, we may take it for granted that a certain section, representing a certain bulk of the majority of the citizens, will have control for a certain period and their policy will be given effect to by a general resolution, or what would correspond here to our general Acts, and the manager is supposed to give expression to those in his administration, administering what would be, so to speak, the city laws, as it would be here in a sense, in the best possible way, in accordance with the policy laid down. If the period comes and they stand for judgment before the people, the people want to be able to change it effectively, and they cannot do it effectively with the present system of election every year when they go for an election, because when five are elected, no matter how they may be opposed to the policy, they cannot change it completely. They may, if the parties are nicely balanced, but they may not be, and, therefore, you are not giving people an opportunity of passing judgment on the council elected for a certain period.

I urge on the Minister not to adopt, in this particular matter, the attitude he has taken. He says the people of Cork would like it to be a single area. Possibly if we could manage it we would like the whole of Ireland, or in this place where we are dealing with only 26 counties, to be a single area. There may be advantages. When certain matters are cropping up for decision, we would not have conflicting interests urging one individual to go for one thing and another individual to go for another, but we know first of all that that cannot be managed, and, therefore, we content ourselves in dividing it up into 28 constituencies, I think, besides the University constituencies. We have to put up with that. Some of us may regard it as an evil, but we have to put up with it, because if a practical suggestion were made, and if it were another area, the point that Deputy Lemass made arises—we would necessarily be resident in one particular area. There would be one particular area in which we would get greater support than elsewhere, and, in fact, our activities and knowledge would be confined to a particular area. I am not going to say that the considerations which arise in the case of the 26 Counties as a whole arise in Cork. The size is not so great, and so on. But I hold that there is no argument definitely put forward by the Minister to induce us to sacrifice great advantages to get this particular advantage of having Cork as a single area. I have heard people talk of the objections to the ward system. Fortunately or unfortunately, I am not in a position to know exactly what they were. None of them has been pointed out to me to induce me to lose the advantages there would be in a triennial election of a fairly large number and sacrifice it for this particular scheme which, I hold, was primarily devised to make Cork a single area and has no other consideration in its favour.

The Minister knows his own mind, but I would be willing to wager that it was that primary consideration and no other that induced the Minister to stand by this particular method of election. Possibly if he were doing it he would begin with the larger number. If he were taking 15 he would retire five a year. That is a more natural way of beginning than the way he is begining. Probably he would do that, but that particular way of working would necessitate a large ballot paper, and the other difficulties there would be if you were to take Cork as a single unit. It is possible—and I have consulted local people about the matter—to have three natural divisions of the city. I heard no argument from the Minister as to why it would be wrong or why it would be bad to divide up the city into three parts. There are three areas that the city would naturally fall into. Local people have told me that there are no objections from their point of view to that. I put down some numbers in connection with it. The figures which the Minister would easily have at his disposal would enable us to get perhaps a more accurate proportion than would be got from the figures I have given. I am not standing definitely on these numbers. They were the best I could get from the information at my disposal. I am referring to that now because I am asking the Minister at the very beginning, when our whole attitude towards the rest of the Bill is going to be determined, to try to give the main idea in this Bill a chance and to meet the natural objections of those who stand for real democratic control. At least, while they are prepared to delegate the administrative functions to a single individual, they do want that the policy of the city should be determined effectively, and that its administration, too, should be effectively controlled by the elected representatives of the people.

Comment on this

I think I paid, and I think Deputy French also paid, as generous a tribute to this Bill as it was possible to do. We recognised that this particular clause that we are trying to amend is not merely an interesting scheme, but that it is an ingenious and clever scheme. I have no hesitation in saying that I regard it purely and simply as an ingenious way out of the difficulty, and it is a great credit to the imagination and the invention of those who constructed it. If one was simply criticising it on that basis, no one does admire brains, ingenuity and invention more than I do, and to any extent that any testimonial of that kind is given to this particular scheme I do pay that tribute. But it has the original defect which has been pointed out by Deputy Boland. If they were only electing five there is going to be permanent disfranchisement of the first preference votes of minorities. Is not that true?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy give us some idea of what the minorities are likely to be?

Comment on this

I am rather glad that the Minister has put that point. The Minister is getting a little ratty, and this is going to be a difficult case. We do not want to use terms; we do not want debating points; we do not want, if possible, to cut across one another in what is going to be very close debate. We want to keep very close to the issues, and on every side, as far as possible, let us try to keep the discussion clean and above board. It is in the spirit of answering in co-operation a question that is put to me that I speak. That is the sort of question we want discussed. Take it that in Cork you are electing five members under this scheme. We elect five Parliamentary representatives at the present moment. At the last election before this the National Party had a representative in Cork. The fact that it was able to elect a representative in Cork at that election meant that there is a body of that particular kind of opinion there. This year it disappeared under the five-member system. At the last election but this, you had an Independent candidate who got twice as many first preference votes as I did, in this election, and under the five-member system he disappeared at this election. Deputy Egan will bear me out. At that same election there were individuals lower down in the poll in the end than either Deputy Egan or myself who did have a definite following. I do not mind using myself or my colleagues merely as examples. We are talking as people anxious to co-operate. The third Fianna Fáil candidate got within ten first preference votes of myself, and we remained very close together all the way up until there was a big break up in the transfer vote and I went in. That man had a definite first preference following at least as large as mine, but he had not a second preference following of the same size. As a result his first preference votes were disfranchised under the system of five. That is the point I am putting. It has been put very well by Deputy Boland and it ought to be answered. Under this system of merely electing five representatives you are permanently disfranchising the first preference votes of minorities. A boy was once asked if he liked chicken. He said: "I don't know; I do not like the neck of chicken." That is all he had ever got. His portion was always the neck of chicken, and under this system there will be a section of the people who are always getting the neck of the chicken. Now they are entitled to their turn at the breast, and unless the Minister can show us some way in which the first preference votes of minorities are not going to be disfranchised he cannot stand over the idea that he is carrying out the election on a democratic principle under proportional representation, because he has the opportunity of doing something different. He can claim in relation to a national election that that must be limited by the fact that Cork cannot be given in this Assembly a reputation which its eminence and importance do not entitle it to. It must be satisfied with merely five, but you cannot put that claim in relation to a municipality and, therefore, it boils down simply to the difficulty of machinery. Is it impossible? There are two alternatives. One of these he has answered, and the Minister must direct himself directly to this point and answer directly on this point or he must say that he cannot.

If we are under a system of electing only five, permanently disfranchising the first preference votes of minorities, there are two alternatives. One is to increase the number. No matter how far you increase it you will never, theoretically, do away with that, but you can increase it to the extent that the disability of disfranchisement will be reduced to the lowest limits. Having done that, the Minister can tackle it in either of two ways. He can tackle it by his large ballot paper, to which he seems to have an objection that, frankly, I cannot see. Remember that this is an experiment which is going to be tried in Ireland, and you are beginning to try it in Cork. I am perfectly sure that my colleague on the other side will not suggest for a moment that a large ballot paper is above the intelligence of the people of Cork. We do not see that difficulty. He can get over it that way if he wants one single body to elect an undivided city. An undivided city means a larger ballot paper. That is the whole difficulty. A larger representation, all elected together by one body, means a larger ballot paper. That is the only difficulty. We think that difficulty can be easily solved, having regard to the intelligence of the people with whom he is dealing. But if he cannot solve that difficulty he has the alternative—to divide the city as little as possible. I am quite clear about it. I do not want it to be divided into a lot of small wards. If by dividing it into three— and I think that is a feasible proposition—he can get over his difficulty— mind, the only difficulty he has is a large ballot paper—he can cut that terribly long ballot paper into three, we are prepared to assist him.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

took the Chair.

Comment on this

Let us get the issue clear. The present system permanently disfranchises the first preferences of minorities. That can be got over by increasing the number, and facing either a larger ballot paper or more than one section. The city is so constituted that you can get more than one section in which an election under reasonable terms can be held. I appeal to the Minister, and I appeal to the whole House, to regard this as an open matter—I mean to try to get the people behind local government. At the present moment there is a whole propaganda of disgust, a tendency to tell the people that they are not to be trusted. The people have turned their backs upon local government, and this Bill, if it is to do any good, should contain these provisions, and be so framed as to destroy that tendency, and bring back behind the city government the will and the enthusiasm of the people. It is in that spirit, and it is because I think that would be done by meeting the amendment I offer, that I ask the Minister to accept it.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

This is the Cork City Management Bill, and the Second Reading Stage was disposed of a very considerable time ago. In the course of the discussion on the amendment that has been moved, we went back a good deal on the question of the Second Reading. The manager was discussed, the whole principle of the Bill was brought under review, and even the question of representation has arisen. My view about this measure—and with great respect to every member of this House I do not think anybody here has a longer experience of local government than I have—is that its success depends on the persons who are to be elected. It all depends on the persons who will occupy the office of representatives for the City of Cork. They are the people upon whom responsibility for the success of this Bill will depend. The details of the measure, once the principle has been passed, are of very small account. It so happened that in the course of the discussion very little attention was devoted to an examination of the system which was in operation previous to 1920. We seemed to have been only alive from 1920 up to date.

If my recollection is correct, in the City of Cork, and certainly in the City of Dublin, there were annual elections. It was arranged in this way: that a councillor had a three-years' term of office, an alderman six years, and so every year a councillor was due for election, and every sixth year a councillor and an alderman had to stand for election. That had at least this advantage about it, that you had an individual there to answer for his administration during his term. Now we have advanced to the period that we can only govern by groups. I do not believe it. I never believed it. It was just as bad after the election of 1920 as it was before. In fact, I might say that certain things could not have been worse. The group system is a bad system, and this question of seeking for representation of every minority is certainly not a good system of government. It may be an excellent system of representation, but not of government. It does not and did not necessarily follow that one was elected a representative on a local authority according to one's political convictions; certainly not in the old days, because I recollect several members being elected for various wards in complete opposition to the Parliamentary representative, and perhaps at the same time that these individuals would be elected in opposition to the Parliamentary representative that Parliamentary representative would have an immense majority. They got elected in respect of whatever contribution they could make towards local administration. That is the real issue. A man may be an excellent business man and politician—and I have known both—and be absolutely useless as a representative on a local authority. What is looked for in connection with this measure is to give lines upon which public representation can be associated with, and make a success of, municipal administration. One does not approach, and one will not, I think, arrive at the point where you can effect that by simply looking for representation of minorities.

Comment on this

I want to ask the President a question.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I was just going to answer the Deputy's question.

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

You do not know what it is, all the same.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

The point was how were we going to secure representation for minorities by this system.

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

Wrong.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

The Deputy has abandoned that?

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

No, he has not.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Will the Deputy allow me to satisfy him that he ought to abandon it?

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

Certainly, fire away. I am always open to conviction.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

In the election that took place in 1920 some wards were added together which had been separate wards before that. To give an example. Usher's Quay and New Kilmainham, as it was called, were added together, and New Kilmainham was a pretty considerable district, having been at one time a township. The number of voters in Usher's Quay before the extension of the franchise amounted to 3,500. The number was much greater when the franchise was extended. The number of votes cast would be about 2,500, divided roughly into 1,500 for the winner, and 1,000 for the loser. Something like seven or eight candidates were elected. The last person elected got perhaps one-tenth of the number of the first preferences of the first candidate elected. I would like to know if it is contended that representation should be secured in respect of a person getting one-tenth of the number of first preference votes that another representative got. What are the minorities in respect of which safeguards are sought to be effected? Deputy Flinn mentioned some candidates in respect of the representation of Cork, as if the people had never the right to change their minds. It does not follow because people vote one man in to-day that they must vote that man in in twelve months' time, in three months' time, or in three years' time. They have a perfect right to change. Having elected a man once, is the case being made that he would not be able to get the quota the next time, and that we must make sure that the minority he represents is going to get the quota the next time? Is that the case?

Comment on this

No, sir; that would be a very foolish case.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

It was said that safeguards ought to be provided in respect of minorities.

Comment on this

I can assure the President that he will not get away from the point I want raised.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I will give way to the Deputy so that he can put the point.

Comment on this

I have been accused here of standing up for democracy. The point I raised was an answer to an assertion by the Minister that this council, when elected on the system proposed in the Bill, would be more representative—I take representation to mean representative of all sections of the community in Cork— and I want him to prove that. I have not said what my own views on democracy are at all. As a matter of fact, I would be inclined to agree that if we could get a good Mussolini it would not be a bad idea at all. I believe there is a good deal to be said for autocracy, especially if it is benevolent. I am saying that in all seriousness. The President thinks that he has disposed of my case, whereas the Minister said that this system will make for a more representative council, and I asked the Minister to prove that. The President has very kindly side-stepped the thing and put me in the position of asserting that I am standing for democracy. I may be, or I may not be, but that has not arisen. I simply asked the Minister to do something which he has been unable to do, and which the President has side-stepped. He is going off on another tangent altogether and making a case to show that another system—that is, a more autocratic system—would be a better system of government. He may be right in that, but it would not be what his Minister said—a more representative system. For goodness sake, try to keep to the point.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I take it that what the Minister meant was——

Comment on this

What he meant? Does he withdraw what he said?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I have been asked what he meant, and I cannot say, but I take it that what he meant was that the person securing——

Comment on this

I have not referred to what he meant at all, but to what he said.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Five public representatives having secured, let us assume, 20,000 votes, have certainly, from one aspect of the case, a much more representative character than ten public representatives securing 19,000 votes. Is the Deputy satisfied now?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

In any case, whether he is or not, I am afraid I will have to leave that point.

Comment on this

It is still unanswered.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

The question we have got to consider here is not the manager, not the autocracy within the Cork City Management Bill, but the difference between an annual election and a triennial election. A triennial election, to my mind, has this disadvantage about it, that it presents a greater number of persons to be elected, and in my experience where a great number was to be elected in municipal matters the best persons were not elected. The best persons had the best chance of being elected when there was a smaller number. You develop what Deputy de Valera calls the group system. Under the group system certain persons are carried who would not otherwise be carried. The smaller the number, the greater the responsibility upon each person to show his usefulness in his representative capacity. When Deputies address themselves to policy one would think it was something that could only be mentioned with a wet towel on one's head and a pair of slippers on one's feet. What is policy? Whether or not you will have a certain extension of the municipal services that there are, whether or not you will build more houses, whether you will have streets paved with wood or concrete, as the case may be; whether you will develop one side of the city or another, whether you will have libraries, whether you will continue your scholarship schemes; whether, if drainage is not in existence in the whole of the area, it will not be extended in certain directions, and so on. And what you want for that is good public representatives, who, in the consideration of the matters before them, will consider the whole management of the city. The view that is held by those who have much experience of public matters is that where there are wards the individual is more concerned with the wards than with the city——

Comment on this

Is that the President's own experience?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

—and that does not make for good government. It so happens that if one is to consider a triennial election, if one were to make any attempt to avoid getting in a poor class of representative one ought to have a division of the city. I submit that that is a bad thing, and it ought to be avoided. It may be that the avoidance of it will create a greater evil, and this is a matter which can be considered by every member of the Dáil without being interested particularly as to what party he belongs. We were invited to consider it free from party affiliations. It was considered by the Deputy's Party opposite. They considered it, they deliberated on it. Deputies on these benches can express their views here. They were not forced to make any decision in the Party as to what they were going to do on it, and it is not a matter upon which we need have any great temerity about addressing ourselves to on party or other lines.

Comment on this

Am I to understand from the President that he is going to take off the Party Whips on this matter?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I have not put them on. Is the Deputy in the same position? Can he place his hand on his heart?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

And the Party opposite?

Comment on this

We had not the Whips on on the Second Reading.

Comment on this

Have you them on now?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

It is a mistake to say that this is making an experiment of Cork. It is Cork itself that is making the experiment, and the experiment will take place on the day of the nominations. Certain people will be elected, and they will have made up their minds as to what policy they are going to adopt in connection with the management of the city. If they go on the right lines this Bill is going to be a success, no matter what defects there are in its details. I am confident that they will make every effort to make it a success, and I think that they will make a still bigger effort if they leave the group system on one side when discharging their duties.

Comment on this

I have been listening very carefully to the President and to the Minister for Local Government, looking for some hope that this whole idea was not going to be wrecked at the very beginning. I am afraid after listening to the President that there is very little hope left. In all these matters the President seems to me to be a person acting as one who wanted to kick away the ladder by which he is able to be in a position to press this measure at the present time. He spoke about the group system as being a bad thing. My recollection is that when the President himself was first elected into public life as a member of the Dublin Corporation he went in as a member of a group.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Certainly.

Comment on this

Why did the President go in as a member of a group? Because there was a definite class of citizens who had certain definite grievances and they banded themselves together to redress them.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Do not be talking nonsense. It was from that that I learned the evils of it. I do not want it to be inferred from that that it was in my group that I learned the evils of it, but in the membership of the body.

Comment on this

The group system, whether the President likes it or not, is inherent in humanity and in common sense, because any class of citizens who have a common grievance, if they are not fools, are going to band themselves together in order that their united strength may be more effective than their efforts as individuals would be. No matter what you try in this Bill, you are not going, if you are going to keep public representatives at all, to avoid people banding themselves together to get their representatives elected. The President evidently has in mind a number of super people, those highly respectable elements in the community who must not soil themselves with the plain classes of the community. They must be captains of industry and all the rest of it, who are splendid for looking after their own business, but very often, when it comes to looking after public business, are neglectful, just the same as we see in the Seanad at present.

Comment on this

Does not Deputy Boland say that these are the people who will not get in?

Comment on this

Deputy Boland has his point of view. I know what can be made out for benevolent despots occasionally, but no one with any common sense or with any regard for human rights is going to stand for it— I believe that human beings have rights—and if anyone is going to take the right to govern me he must get my consent, anyhow. Otherwise I will not feel bound to give respect to any authority that he may claim.

Comment on this

The question now is annual versus triennial elections.

Comment on this

As I said before, all these amendments hang together. The whole idea of the Bill, in my opinion, is involved in this, and there are two ways of doing it, the right way or the wrong way. If you do it the wrong way at the start, then you will be on the wrong line all the time, and even people who would like to support the measure will feel bound to oppose the various articles in it. If there are any modifications made in the Bill, people may find themselves in a position to support it. I have often thought of the advantages of benevolent despotism, but I know that human beings who know and feel and reason with themselves are not going to stand for it as a system. If an occasional super-man comes along, the people may be quite content to delegate power to him and allow him to rule them. If that is done with their consent, it is all right.

We now come to the question of the management of Cork city. As I see it, I believe that there has been a lot of criticism of the Bill which has been quite beside the mark. I believe that the Bill could be made to work, but as it stands at present, I could not vote for it. I believe that the Bill could be modified, and that a substantial body of opinion would be prepared to support the Minister as regards the main idea in the Bill who would not stand for the details in it. I am anxious at the beginning to know clearly whether it is to be a definite contest from the beginning with the Minister step by step, or whether there is going to be a chance of getting out of this a measure which will secure the main idea that is in the Bill as far as I understand it. The question of the triennial election or of the single election is involved in this. The size of the council is involved too. If the council is a small council it matters very little. The difficulty with regard to the ballot paper will not be so great as with a large one. We can hardly keep down to the narrow issue of a three years' election or a single year's election, and that was why at the start I gave an example which has been very widely followed—a bad example apparently from the point of view of order in discussing the Bill as a whole—but I felt it was necessary to do that so that we might see the bearing of this period of three years.

You must simply select between the three years and one year. On the step that you will take now will depend whether you are going to proceed on autocratic lines, as the Minister apparently is, or whether you are going to proceed on democratic lines. If you are going to proceed on democratic lines, then you must give the people an opportunity of passing judgment upon their elected representatives. You must give the people an opportunity of having all sections and all interests reasonably represented. I hold that the Minister's method does not do that, that the annual election means a smaller number, and that, therefore, the result of it will be that some people will be getting an undue preponderance in the matter of representation. You have that in by-elections, even though held under the principles of proportional representation. A by-election is always in favour of the party that is strongest, and the Minister knows that very well. They have applied it more than once. If you apply it to the Cork Corporation the same thing is going to happen, only in a slightly different way. That is what you are going to have if you divide up the council into three parts. I have not seen, as I have said, a single argument put forward in favour of the one-year system. The only fundamental thing that I have been able to see in connection with it is that it was an ingenious system to avoid a big ballot paper, and the splitting up of the city is an alternative. I believe it originated that way. I may be wrong, but that is my belief. If that is to be the effect of it, then I think that the Minister is simply acting in a headstrong fashion and is going to wreck the whole possibilities of this Bill. He will wreck its prospects by holding on to the system for a reason of that kind.

The President spoke about the bad results of the ward system. I have not heard a single one tell me yet of the bad results that are going to follow in the case of Cork if we were to divide the city into three areas. If there are bad results, what are they? Let us know them. I am quite prepared to take any steps to obviate any evils that may result, and to support any measure that would prevent those evils. Let us hear what the evils are, so that we may know them and see in what way we can avoid them.

The President says that he knows about the evils of the ward system, and he tried to throw ridicule on it. I hold that in all these matters the people should be sufficiently represented in the council, and that their representatives should be able to defend their interests and give expression to their viewpoint. I have not heard, as I have said, a single argument put forward for the one-year annual election. The only one I saw any basis for was that about splitting up the city. The President said under the old system they had annual elections in Dublin, and so on. If they had, and if it was wrong and there was no basis for it, surely now is the time to change and not to continue it. I have not heard the President defend it. It is quite possible to talk about evils in connection with it. Are we going to start now on the new with the opportunity of getting the people behind us —to start in this particular case with a form of government that will have to be changed, as I am certain I can predict, if put into operation in this particular way?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

As an outsider who knows nothing about and has no experience whatever of city administration, I would like to intervene in this debate for a few moments. There is no use getting into a temper on this subject, as Deputy de Valera has done. Deputy Flinn has shown a good example for the first time in dealing with this. The object of this Bill is to try to get away from the parish or ward system. In so far as that is its object it is a sound measure. I know from experience that administrators can get elected on the ward system who would not get elected on the whole city system, because they have been able to swing the lead in the interests of wards and of groups, and in their administration they have been able to get appointments and jobs for their friends. They are able to confer benefits on a ward, but not on a city as a whole. A ward administrator is a bad administrator for the city and the community as a whole. If you can do away with him so much the better. Experience shows that a man could get elected for a local area who would not be elected for the city as a whole, and he is a poor type of administrator of whom that can be said. In fact, it is a black mark against him. An administrator who can get elected by the community as a whole, and who can command their respect is the best administrator. If we are to have fifteen candidates elected at the one time what sort of ballot paper would we need? It is almost certain we will have on that ballot paper the names of four times as many people as there are vacancies for. If there are thirty vacancies at a triennial election it may be anticipated that there would be at least one hundred candidates. To deal with these is a job for a university professor. Deputy Flinn may be able to mark intelligently such a paper, and to give his preferences in the order of merit as regards the whole one hundred, but he would be cutting it very fine when he is going from the ninety-ninth to the one hundredth. I had the experience of marking a ballot paper in a Seanad election, and after marking fifteen or twenty I found it no easy matter to go further. In my opinion the Bill is a good one, because it provides for the election of only five at a time, and because a man who can get elected on a big franchise and who can command the respect of the whole city will make the best administrator.

Comment on this

They are not to administer at all.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

I know they are not, but we are aiming at creating a body who will.

Comment on this

No, they have nothing to do with administration.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

According to the Bill five will be elected this year, five the next year, and five the year after.

Comment on this

We have heard a great deal about what, to my mind, is a very unimportant point in the Bill. We have had hair-splitting arguments about the number of people who will be elected and the method of election— whether you will have five elected each year for three years, or fifteen in one year. The fact is that at the end of three years we will from that on have a full Corporation. What is aimed at and what you will get, I believe, in Cork is a Corporation composed of men who are worthy to govern the city, and they will not be confined, as Deputy de Valera said, to any one class. They will not be confined to captains of industry, for the people of Cork know very well that they have in the various classes of society men of outstanding merits, and they will not hesitate to elect these men. It will be a relief to the citizens of Cork to know that they will have a body of men elected who will govern the city in a progressive fashion, and that they will not belong to distinct political parties, that they will be above all parties. That is what I think the Bill is aiming at, to enable the citizens to get men who will work in the interests of the city as a whole, and lift it out of the state of depression which has been caused by the economic conditions of the last ten years. There has been a good deal of extraordinary and rather wild talk regarding this Bill. I do not say that there is any great sincerity behind the appeal not to deal with this in a party fashion. It would be a wonderfully good thing if we could, but I do not see that there is any give and take. There has been a good deal spoken about what is autocratic and what is democratic, and because a speaker said it was so he was an infallible judge of what is good and bad. The Government has produced a Bill that was for the good of Cork city, but in a Deputy's opinion that was not true, and it was a bad Bill. I must say my opinion is the opposite.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy's opinion? I would like to dispose of the arguments of some of the Deputies, particularly Deputy Gorey's, as far as the ward system is concerned. Personally I do not stand for the ward system, but to show that there are points of difference between even members of the Labour Party on this particular portion of the Bill, I want to make myself vocal on that. Many evils have arisen as a result of the ward system. I do not favour the Bill as a whole, but would suggest making the whole city one area, and that will satisfy perhaps the misgivings of Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

I have no misgivings. I said that an extended representation as suggested by Deputy Boland amounts to the same thing, and that it was bad because of that.

Comment on this

I want to direct the attention of the House to what has already been said, that many of these amendments stand together. In considering one of the amendments you have to link it up with another. Taking the Bill as a whole, it is an insult to the intelligence of the citizens of Cork. Whether the House decides to have elections annually, or to have the city divided into wards, or have the city one electoral area, I do not much mind, but underlying the Bill is a negation of the whole democratic idea.

What I want to see done here is to have the whole Bill inverted, to place power in the hands of the elected representatives of the people and to make the manager the servant of the people through their elected representatives. While admitting that the manager system may be an improvement on the old Corporation system. I seek at the same time, as I indicated earlier in the debate, by my amendments, to make this Bill more acceptable to the people. I am not enamoured of the Bill in its original form, and for that reason I put down amendments. I want to disabuse the minds of Deputies who may think that the citizens of Cork are unanimous in having the city split up into wards. They are not. I have endeavoured to elucidate the views of citizens of all classes. There is no consensus of opinion amongst them so far as the ward system is concerned. So far as I can gather, the whole idea is to have the city one area of election, have all the members elected in one year, and have triennial elections afterwards. It is only by such system that you will get proper representation and have all classes of the community represented.

A number of the citizens of Cork, those who do any thinking at all, believe if this Bill were adopted in its present form, even if you had a ward system, that the present administration is capable of gerrymandering the wards. It has been done in another part of the country. From what I know of the Minister's Department, I believe they are capable of doing that and of gerrymandering the wards so as to return the type of representative mentioned by Deputy Flinn, a type that does not represent the people of Cork, namely, men like Sir Stanley Harrington and his class. We here are the representatives of Cork—Deputy Lord Mayor French. Deputy Flinn, myself and a lesser light in the shape of Deputy Barry Egan. Surely we three, at any rate, are entitled to speak for the citizens, as we have been duly elected, and we should be able to translate the opinions of those with whom we have discussed the question. I submit that the Minister should allow the Deputies in his Party to vote on this matter as a non-Party question. To show that I am not taking it in a Party manner, I intend to vote with the Government Party, so far as I take it to be their policy to make the city one area, but I am out against them so far as the other provisions of the Bill are concerned.

Comment on this

There has been a Corporation of fifty-five members, and no one has complained that that was not democratic representation, but everyone admitted that it was too large to carry out the business of the city. We are at a process now of finding out what size the council should be, and how we could get a council that would be representative of the people and able to do the work of the city. Deputy de Valera wants an election every three years, giving a council of thirty. If we go back to Deputy Flinn's point, that electing five people in the city as a whole at one time is not going to give representation to certain minorities that should be represented, that means that a minority of one-sixth of the electorate is going to get representation. If he is satisfied that a minority smaller than one-sixth should get representation, I say that dividing the city into three parts and having triennial elections is not going to make any difference as compared with having the city as the area and having annual elections. He must increase the number beyond fifteen if he is going to get these people represented. We have in Deputy de Valera's own suggestion in connection with the Bill the belief that thirty members could not, as a group, properly discharge the functions of the council, and he has to fall back on an executive council.

Comment on this

I am sure that the Minister does not wish to misrepresent me or my amendment, but his statement is a misrepresentation. Inasmuch as this Bill is going to give administrative functions to a single individual, a lot of the difficulties of a large body disappear. They had a lot of difficulty in large bodies before, because they had not merely deliberative but administrative functions. When you are going to relieve them of their administrative functions and when they have only to decide on large lines of policy, it seems to me that a large number is not a disadvantage but the reverse. The question is what should the number be? My suggestion of a board of aldermen was to have a general purposes committee of the whole body, a standing general purposes committee, that would be available for consultation with the manager. The Minister will please not say that I do not think that the body as a whole could not discharge their functions. They discharge the functions they are intended to discharge, such as deciding matters of policy, while the details of administration would be in the hands of the manager and there would be portion of the council available for consultation when required.

Comment on this

I do not understand the Deputy's idea of what the manager is to be, but to me his introduction of a board of aldermen shows that he believes that 30 would be too large a council to do the work.

Comment on this

What work?

Comment on this

To do the work that is going to fall on the council.

Comment on this

What is the work?

Comment on this

Is any work going to fall on them?

Comment on this

The administrative and deliberative functions are separated. In so far as the deliberative functions are concerned, I hold that a big council is not a disadvantage but, within reasonable limits, an advantage. When you come down to associate the manager with the details of administration then you do want a small body. That is the purpose of my amendment in regard to a board of aldermen—that there would be a small body to keep in closer contact with the administrative side of the work—that is, with the manager's administrative functions, and to keep in closer contact with him on behalf of the council as a whole. That is where we differ, probably. You want to give him greater power or rather more independence, than I do.

Comment on this

At any rate a large council stands condemned. You look for a small council, and we are discussing whether we shall get that small council at annual or triennial elections. We were told by Deputy de Valera in his previous outburst that if he does not carry his amendment as to a triennial election as against an annual election, then his guns are to be unmasked against the manager system. He asked me if I am going to oppose him steadfastly on that attitude. I am, I am going to stand absolutely stout for the principles in this Bill in which I believe. I believe that by an annual election you are safeguarding the city as a whole; you are going to have a homogeneous and not a heterogeneous Cork divided into wards, and you are going to get a representative council. In reply to Deputy Boland, I say if you have 15,000 votes cast in Cork for five persons going up for the whole city, with 3,000 votes to each person, and if you put against that five persons going up in three wards, having the same 15,000 votes cast, each averaging 1,000 votes, the council you would get of the three fives, each of whom received 3,000 votes, will be more representative than the council of 15, each of whom received 1,000 votes. You get a better representation, and you get an evener flow in the work of the city, less party policies and less party politics. You get what is important at the present moment: you get a transition from the commissioner system to the manager system plus a council, by means of a small council with a manager at the start off. The council will deal more satisfactorily with the manager and the manager will deal more satisfactorily with the council when you have in the beginning a small council rather than a big council.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill"—put.

Tá 68
·
Níl 64
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The decision in regard to amendment No. 2 affects amendment No. 3. Amendment No. 3 falls with amendment No. 2.

Amendment 4:—To delete sub-section (2) and to substitute the following:—

"(2) At every borough election the borough shall form three electoral areas, as set out in the Schedule hereunder, and the total number of members elected shall be 30."—(Deputy de Valera.)

It is suggested that amendment No. 4 should be amended by the omission of the words "and the total number of members elected shall be thirty."

Comment on this

It is obvious from what I have said that I am not in favour of the ward system for its own sake at all or in favour of the system that is called the division of the city into parts for its own sake. The whole process of dividing the city into parts was to make it possible to have a large council. It is very difficult to deal with this particular amendment without debating at the same time or having a decision on the size of the council. If you are going to have a yearly election, as is suggested here, of five members, then the size of the council will be fifteen. What I want to see is how far the last decision is going to affect this or what is its possible effect on this. So far as I know, the only section that has been passed so far is that in every borough election the borough shall form one electoral area. "A borough election shall be held in the year 1928 and in every year thereafter." That is all that has been passed. Then, that being so, it is a question of what the size of the council is going to be. Personally, I do not like yearly elections. I would not like yearly elections for the whole council. That is the difficulty we are involved in, that we do not want yearly elections for the whole council. That is certainly not the best thing. The whole question, as I take it, is that we will be compelled more or less by this to have a portion retiring every year, though it is not specifically passed—the whole question is that portion will retire every year and that we will have only a portion of the council. So the alternative that we are now left with as a result of the last decision is whether we would have yearly elections or a large council with a certain number retiring each year. As far as I am concerned, I am in favour of a large council. When it is finally constituted, I believe in having a large council, and when I say a large council it would be more accurate to say not a very small council as is proposed—a council of fifteen members.

I indicated, on the First Reading of the Bill, that I believed that a council consisting of twenty-five to thirty members would be a fair size, and I put down thirty, working out the whole scheme in accordance with these electoral areas. It seems, therefore, that we are working out to a position that we will have about ten retiring each year if my amendment is agreed to. I think it is better, at this stage not to press the amendment, but to wait until the Report Stage or some other stage until the decisions shall have developed the scheme further. I am afraid that we would simply get into a position in which no finality would be reached at all. I will not press the amendment at this stage.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 5, standing in my name, reads:

In Section 2, line 13, to delete the word "five" and to substitute the word "seven."

I think we will now be able to get unanimity on the question of the electoral areas, and in view of the fact that I anticipate that unanimity, I think that the objections which the Minister raised in reference to the numbers are met. I seek to have twenty-one members elected ultimately to the Corporation, and though I would much prefer to see the whole twenty-one elected at the beginning, if you accept the three sevens, we may be able to come to some arrangement or compromise, if you like, as to the period over which the election will be spread. I would suggest at this stage what I indicated in my amendment, that we would have the figure of "seven" inserted in the Bill instead of "five." This would give you an ultimate Corporation of twenty-one.

Comment on this

If there is no other way out of it, I would agree with Deputy Anthony and I would ask the Minister would he consider in the first place to put in the word "fifteen" instead of "five," and at the end of that sub-section to add in the words "in the year 1928," and afterwards make provision for five to retire annually. I think that would go a long way to meet some of the objections that have been put up to the Bill, and in any case it would constitute the Corporation in the first year. Elect the fifteen highest on the ballot, and then the five lowest of these in that list would retire at the end of the first year.

Comment on this

If the Minister would accept Deputy O'Hanlon's suggestion, I would be prepared to withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this

I find myself torn between Deputy Anthony's recommendation, putting in seven now and having an ultimate council of twenty-one, and Deputy O'Hanlon's suggestion to have a Corporation of fifteen now and have five going out each year. I do feel that a council of fifteen ultimately is a better council for the government of Cork than a council of twenty-one. On the other hand, I feel that a smaller council put in now is going to settle down more harmoniously, to find out the actual work that lies before it, than a larger council. I will undertake that if this amendment of Deputy Anthony's is not moved now to bring on the Report Stage an amendment to change "five" to "seven," or an amendment that will carry out the alternative proposal made by Deputy O'Hanlon.

Comment on this

One of my reasons for having the Corporation fully constituted in the first year is that I have consideration for the five men who will be elected, assuming there are five. Remember that you are constituting a Corporation now after a lapse of time. You are correcting, say, the Commissioner system, and we will assume that your efforts are to improve on the Commissioner system. Let us say that five men are elected and they carry on for twelve months with a manager. I think it is due to those five men to say that that is the wrong way to start. Mind you, the eyes of the people of Cork and of the Saorstát will be on this experiment. These five men will be watched very carefully, and the ratepayers will say either of two things—that these five men are working hand-in-glove with the manager, have decided to work in with all his ideas, or there will be suggestions made as to the manner in which the work is carried out. It may be said that this small number of men who can only effect a change by a majority of four to one, is being dominated by the manager, that they are only jelly-fish and should not be elected at all. Such a state of affairs could not occur if you constitute the full Corporation of fifteen men. Whatever their functions may be, and they will be limited, and whatever is going to happen, it is better to have the whole council constituted at once and have it properly working than to give the idea that the manager and the first five are working together and, perhaps, working against the interests of the people, as might easily be assumed.

Comment on this

In view of the Minister's assurance, I will withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this

Is it not necessary to get the consent of the House in order to withdraw an amendment?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

It is well to get the Deputy's consent first. Is there any objection to the amendment being withdrawn?

Comment on this

Yes. As far as we are concerned, we will not be satisfied with the arrangement now suggested between Deputy Anthony and the Minister. We think this matter of city government is too serious to be settled in this way. We are convinced that a council of at least thirty would be required to ensure that there will be adequate representation for every section in the life of Cork city, and to ensure that there will be the fullest possible discussion upon the proper policy to adopt for the development of the city. Not merely are we convinced that the council which it is proposed to establish is numerically too small, but if the city government is to be successful the full council must be constituted in the first year. It is not a question of alternative; it is not a question of a larger council or a fully constituted council in the first year. We want both, and any suggestion to the contrary will be opposed as far as we are concerned.

Deputy Anthony's amendment is the only amendment on the paper which will enable us to discuss the size of a council under this scheme. We have already discussed the question of size in relation to an alternative scheme of election which was suggested. As that alternative has been rejected, we have to consider now the size of the council in relation to the scheme. This scheme involves the annual election of one-third. The two questions which arise are those which I have already mentioned. The first is, what should be the size of the council in order to ensure the best form of administration for the city? Secondly, is it going to help or retard this scheme to have the full council constituted the first year? I believe that the scheme embodied in the Bill is the result of wrong thinking on the part of those who drafted it. There appears to be an impression in the minds of the Government, in the first place, that any Council elected by the people is going to be untrustworthy and possibly corrupt. I was very glad to hear the President, on the occasion of another Bill yesterday, vigorously denying that there was anything like corruption in the public life of this country, and was particularly surprised to hear him say that, in view of the attitude he and his Government took up on another Bill which was discussed last session.

The Minister repeatedly gave us the impression throughout the course of the discussion on this Bill that it is his view that you would not get good city government if you took the course of giving back to the people of Cork the rights which you have already taken from them. I say that wrong thinking is responsible for the drafting of the Bill, particularly the idea to which I have already referred, that you are, by some process in this Bill, giving back these democratic rights in a gradual manner. You are not doing that at all. The full powers of the council of the Corporation will repose in the first body elected, whether that body consists of only five members or of thirty members. The suggestion which has been put forward by the Minister, that that system will enable them to settle down more harmoniously and to realise the difficulties of their work, is just nonsense. The five members who constitute the first council will, undoubtedly, know the difficulty of the work at the end of the first year, but I think they will have to spend a considerable portion of the next year educating the new five and so on until the third year. Any person here who has been a member of a public board I think will admit that it took him a good year as a member before he felt that he understood what was happening at the majority of the meetings. It would be much better, both in the interest of the scheme as it stands and in the interest of the scheme as I would like to see it, if the Government trusted the people a little more and agreed to the proposal that the full council should be constituted at the beginning. I believe it would help the scheme. I believe you are endangering its success by the method suggested. The Minister may, no doubt, tell us that he feels, as he said, that a council of fifteen is better than a council of twenty-one. But that surely is not a matter on which the Dáil is going to be satisfied. The Dáil will not, I hope, adopt this suggestion merely because the Minister feels it is the right one. We must be satisfied that it is right. He has not as yet put forward any satisfactory argument to lead us to that conclusion. He, no doubt, advanced the theory, which has already been questioned, that a council consisting of five members elected on one occasion will be more representative than a council consisting of fifteen members elected on one occasion.

Comment on this

I never said anything like it.

Comment on this

That members who are elected on an occasion when only five are elected will be more representative than members elected on an occasion when fifteen are elected. Otherwise, that when I was elected for Dublin City South on the occasion of a by-election I was more representative than when I was elected at a general election. That is the Minister's theory, but it does not work out. We are not concerned with the representativess of the members; what we are concerned with is the representativeness of the council.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Some members.

Comment on this

We want a council that would be representative of all the various interests that constitute the life of Cork or any other city. To suggest that if you have a major interest represented on the council you will have secured a good council for your purpose is think, erroneous. We will have to get a council that will reflect in every way the various interests that undoubtedly exist in every city. That reflection of these interests can best be secured in a council consisting of about thirty members or twenty-seven members. I would be in favour of one member per thousand voters on the register, and that would give a council of twenty-seven. Whether twenty-seven or thirty, we are convinced that fifteen is too few, particularly when elected in the manner suggested. As far as the withdrawal of the amendment is concerned, we are opposed to it. We would rather get a decision on the size of the council now and not to wait until there have been any behind-the-scene negotiations between the Minister and Deputy Anthony.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I wonder if that is a reasonable request? The Deputy's leader has just asked permission to withdraw an amendment he had down, and the permission was granted and the question was left over.

Comment on this

As far as we are concerned the amendment which Deputy de Valera referred to can be discussed now, but it will mean a repetition of the discussion we have had.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

He discussed the amendment and then asked permission to withdraw it.

Comment on this

I want the President to be clear about what was actually done. There was an arrangement made with the Ceann Comhairle to divide the amendment into two parts and discuss at this particular stage only the portion dealing with the wards. Now, to me the division of the city into areas is simply a device to enable a large council to be elected without an unreasonably large ballot paper. I am leaving over, as far as I am concerned, the question of electoral areas until we have come to a decision upon this question.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Not without the permission of the House.

Comment on this

With the permission of the House.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Deputy Anthony asks now the same courtesy from the House in respect of another matter which may not be decided now but may be decided later on.

Comment on this

On different grounds.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

It arose out of a proposal made by Deputy O'Hanlon, and the decision that has just been taken in respect of Section 3 (1) leaves the matter, so far as the Minister is concerned, in a different position from what it was. It may be that the Minister might, on reflection, consider that a large ballot paper occuring only once was something which might be contemplated, allowing for one-third of the persons elected going out the following year. I submit that it is scarcely fair to object to Deputy Anthony withdrawing the amendment in order to have the matter reviewed before the next stage, as the courtesy of the House has just been extended to the Party opposite in respect of another amendment. That amendment affects, to a very considerable extent, the same question—the number of the council. Both are concerned with that, and the amendment as it stood was not one which lent itself to easy settlement, having regard to the decision which has just been taken. I think it is not fair to Deputy Anthony and Deputy O'Hanlon to object to this amendment being withdrawn, having had that courtesy extended to themselves.

Comment on this

I should like Deputy Lemass and the House to know that I was influenced largely by the remarks of Deputy O'Hanlon. I have, at the same time, not bound myself to accept any scheme the Minister may bring forward. I have not bound myself to anything. I should also like to tell Deputy Lemass that I have never gone behind the scenes in any period of my life and that I am not going to go behind the scenes now. I do not care a tuppenny ticket about Deputy Lemass or any Minister, if that is any use to him. The Minister has indicated that he has seen something good in my amendment and something good in Deputy O'Hanlon's suggestion, and that he may evolve from the two something that may be acceptable to all.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Alternatively, it is open to the Deputies to put down the amendments again.

Comment on this

As well as the portion about electoral areas will that portion of Deputy de Valera's amendment (No. 4) which proposes that the total number of members elected shall be thirty, come forward again?

Comment on this

Perhaps it would settle the matter if we agree that the whole question of the numbers be left over. Is that the position?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Deputy Lemass objected to that.

Comment on this

Deputy Anthony gave me the impression that he wanted to withdraw his amendment and that he was agreeing to what the Minister said, that on the Report Stage he would bring forward an amendment that would either be that suggested by Deputy Anthony or Deputy O'Hanlon——

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

That was the minimum of the Minister's undertaking.

Comment on this

He gave me the impression that he would be satisfied with either. We want both.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I did not think so. Deputy Anthony was prepared to wait until he saw what the Minister's best effort would be, and I was prepared, for my own part, to do my endeavour to convince the Minister, in the meantime, if that would not be considered an irregularity by Deputy Lemass, of the advisability of having the whole council elected at the first time. One of the troubles I see is the huge ballot paper, but that will only occur once. My objection to a huge ballot paper was that in my previous experience of elections, persons who came towards the end of the ballot paper in connection with certain elections—municipal elections, so that Deputy Flinn need not be offended—were not always the class that would be elected if a smaller number were under consideration.

Comment on this

We would be willing to leave over that question of the size of the council to the Report Stage.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

That is, that these two amendments will not be moved now.

Comment on this

Will the section be moved?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

The section will have to be moved, because we will have to get on.

Comment on this

Then we will vote against the section. We shall be content by indicating our view by voting against the section.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

With regard to amendment 7, it seeks to extend the law as at present existing.

Comment on this

That would arise afterwards, whatever arrangement is come to.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

I was going to suggest that if that amendment were carried, Section 4 would have to be deleted. I suggest that that could come on for discussion on the question that Section 4 stand part of the Bill.

Comment on this

If this amendment was carried, then every time a casual vacancy occurred there would have to be an election.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Amendment 13, I think, makes arrangements by which casual vacancies can be filled in a particular way.

Comment on this

No. If this amendment was carried, it would leave the filling of casual vacancies as they are at present.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

I suggest that the matter can be discussed on the question that Section 4 stand part of the Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment 10:—

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"The voting at a borough election shall be on the principle of proportional representation, and each elector shall have one non-transferable vote which shall be given by ballot."

This is what might be termed a rather revolutionary amendment. I have heard much since the debate started, from the President and others, to convince me that this is going to be a solution of the most knotty point in the Bill—that is, the question of a large ballot paper and the President's view about the group system. The President's words were that certain persons would be carried by the group system that would otherwise not be carried. I shall make it clear that this is the purest form of proportional representation. What we have in operation at present is proportional representation by the single transferable vote system. I suppose it is hardly necessary to explain to the House, but it might be to about ninety per cent. of the electorate, that when they vote under the present system of proportional representation whoever gets that vote ultimately only gets that vote and nothing more—the 100 per cent. vote. But there is also under the present system the possibility of a candidate getting, say, 75 per cent. of your vote and another 25 per cent. or whatever percentage you like. That is to say, a candidate with a surplus is credited with your vote in the first instance. He does not require it, and the percentage of your vote goes on to the next candidate in order. Now one of the great difficulties under the present system of proportional representation is just what the President said a few moments ago: that there are good men carrying bad men on their backs too often. To avoid that system, I suggest the adoption of the single non-transferable vote.

A great number of people confuse this idea with the old system of voting with a cross. Take this case dealing with a ballot paper with fifteen candidates to be elected. Under the old system in operation, prior to the present proportional representation system, an elector went into the polling booth and marked fifteen crosses on his ballot paper. He was not bound to do that, and he might plump for one, or vote for two, three or four candidates, but as long as he did not exceed the number of vacancies to be filled he had a perfectly valid paper. If there were fifteen vancancies and he marked sixteen crosses, then his paper was spoiled. Under the system which I suggest, every elector has the same power to vote as under the present system of proportional representation—that is, he has one vote, but he cannot transfer that vote. The effect of this system would be this. Take it in groups or parties or sections of the community. Let us take the two big parties in this House as a case in point, and I do not reflect in any way on one side or another as to how they were elected. I am only using them in illustration. Let us suppose that in a certain instance there are five seats to be filled and the Cumann na nGaedheal Party decide to run five candidates and the Fianna Fáil Party decide to run five— they are both looking for the full number. In nine cases out of ten, both Parties probably have only two good men each, but they have got to put forward five candidates. There is always the chance of getting three by one side and the other side may get three or even four, as the case may be, but they will only get them if they run the full number of candidates. The first and most important effect of this system is that these Parties, when they want to secure a vacancy and when they have the necessary support in whatever constituency they are fighting, run five on the off-chance of getting in four. They want, say, two good men, but there is no discrimination used as to who are to follow the one or two good men that they are pretty certain of returning, only the foolishness of the elector, who does what he is told and gives his preference 1, 2, 3 or 4—without the slightest knowledge of the capability of the second, third or fourth to whom he gives his preferences. I would like to see this adopted as an experiment in Cork.

Comment on this

Why Cork? Why not try it in Dublin?

Comment on this

Cork is the only place where we have the opportunity of trying it at the moment. What is wanted in Cork, and what we are now discussing, is the best means of securing that the best men will put up for election. You will secure that the best men in Cork will be put up for election. A man who is popular and able and is going to devote his time to the business knows there is a quota of people that will support him. He knows very well that his votes are not going to be thrown away to anyone else, and every mark put down for him is put down for him alone. Take an illustration. Take Cork, with twenty-seven thousand of a voting strength; there are fifteen vacancies to be filled. We will leave out of consideration parties. Say there are thirty candidates. Deputy Gorey suggests there might be a hundred. One thing is certain, you will have much fewer candidates under this system than under the transferable system. Say there are five or six outstanding men, the popular choice of the people, bound to be elected. Those five men may represent amongt them, say, eighteen thousand; that is, two-thirds of the whole. They get those eighteen thousand votes and hold them. There are nine thousand votes remaining. They will be distributed proportionately for the remaining ten to be elected. There will be no transfer and no one riding in on anyone else's back, and the people of Cork, when they go to the polling booth, will not be confused by a large ballot paper simply because they have made up their minds, have had the common foresight, to vote for Smith—that is the man they want. There is no question of somebody putting a long list into their hands and saying, "Vote 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5." The people up to the present have not been voting for men with capacity to adMinister, but like machines for numbers for what is put into their hands. If you adopt this system you will get people to make up their minds to say. "There is one good man I know, and I will vote for that man." The elector comes in and looks for the name of the man he wants to vote for. He puts his mark down for that man, and goes home satisfied that no one else will get that vote. Under the present system 35 per cent. of the voters who record their votes and give five or six preferences could not tell you who got the votes except that they voted for the first man. I do not want to rush this thing. I wrote a great deal about it four or five years ago, and have discussed this matter with the man who introduced proportional representation into this country, Mr. Humphries. I have had a long controversy with him, and I am perfectly satisfied, as he is satisfied, that it is a workable scheme. It is a question entirely of whether it is a better scheme than the other. My idea is that it saves confusion to the electors.

There is nothing more satisfying to the electors and nothing which would bring a larger percentage to the ballot as the knowledge of the fact that where the elector records his vote he knows exactly what he is doing. At present 75 per cent. do not know what they are doing. They are not acting off their own bat or on their own knowledge, political or otherwise, when they vote for people. If the Deputies would like further to consider this scheme I would be prepared, with the will of the House, to defer it for consideration to the Report Stage. I would for several reasons prefer it was left over to the Report Stage until the general idea got into the heads of the Deputies and people outside. I am satisfied if this system of voting were brought in you would have the best council that ever administered in Cork simply because it would be a council that, without any question, would be the choice of the majority of Cork, and it would not be a council simply in which there was only one outstanding man acting in a group with four or five who would not make good administrators. It is no experiment. It is perfectly sound. If you adopt it in Cork I have no doubt that this system of voting will be adopted generally and bring about, perhaps even in this House, a better system of administration.

Comment on this

I am very interested in the proposition, and very greatful to Deputy O'Hanlon who has had the originality to bring forward something that is new and individual. I do not know if I understand him. I get a ballot paper and a list out of which I am to elect fifteen people.

Comment on this

You only take one.

Comment on this

I am going to put my difficulties to you. There are fifteen people to be elected for Cork. I get a ballot paper with 30 names. I am allowed to put one vote and one mark on that, nothing else. I have got the whole scheme?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

There are no tails tied to it either.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Hanlon states that that system is going to produce something that will get us perfectly clear of the effects of groups.

Comment on this

Right.

Comment on this

Oh, for the illusions of Deputy O'Hanlon. A man went to another and said: "Will you lend me ——""Money," said the other. "No, not money; I want illusions. I have got none. I am bankrupt of illusions." When I am bankrupt of illusions again I will go to Deputy O'Hanlon because I know how that system works and have worked it. How did we elect in Liverpool the members of the school boards? By that system exactly. Now what happened? The Catholics, because they were well organised and because they did exactly what they were told, returned about twice as many people as they were entitled to until the others woke up to what was happening. What used to happen was that every single elector— as far as I am concerned, and I was concerned—got a piece of paper which told him to vote X. His group sent him a note to vote X. Another man got from his group the intimation to vote Y. And the next man got Z. This is what happened in the election. The first man on the other side got seventeen thousand votes. The second man on the other side got sixteen thousand votes. Somewhere down along the list there was a list of our men: 8,421, 8,420, 8,319, dead accurate. If you want the system by which sound organisation can really log-roll an election the perfect system offered to you by Deputy O'Hanlon will give it to you, and I speak with knowledge of the practice.

Comment on this

I listened with much interest to Deputy Flinn, and I was rather surprised at his speech, coming from possibly one of the best organised Parties in the Dáil. He objects to this system.

Comment on this

I am not saying one word against the system.

Comment on this

He objects to the system because it is a system by which the people can understand what they are doing, and elect X, Y and Z because they are good men. What is the difference between three groups, one voting X, another Y, and another Z, and one group, the lot of them combined, all voting X, Y and Z, when X is the only man that is worth electing? That is the difference between the two systems. We have it on Deputy Flinn's own admission that there were three good candidates, and that the three of them got elected on their own strength. He put that case as against the system at present of putting in X, Y and Z, or 1, 2, 3 and 4 into the voter's hands, and he does not know who the 1, 2, 3 and 4 are. There is one advantage, if there is no other, and even granted that Deputy Flinn's argument holds good, which it does not—it is absurd—is it not a better idea that the voter votes for X rather than for No. 1? Is it not better that he should know the name of the candidate for whom he votes?

Comment on this

We knew the names and nothing else.

Comment on this

You did not tell the names of the candidates.

Comment on this

I will explain to you.

Comment on this

You made a most outrageous statement that they got twice as many as they were entitled to.

Comment on this

The others wasted their votes.

Comment on this

With all respect to Deputy Flinn, he does not understand this system—wherever he got his ideas about Liverpool—he must have had a bad dream last night. There was never an election such as Deputy Flinn spoke of. It could not occur under this system.

Comment on this

I am in a difficulty. I want to ask Deputy O'Hanlon if he has considered this one possible defect in his system of election. There are 27,000 votes in Cork. There will be five candidates elected. I presume Deputy Flinn goes forward as a candidate and gets 26,000 votes and Deputy Anthony goes forward and gets the other 1,000. How are you going to get the others elected?

Comment on this

The complete answer to that is that no man should stand for a constituency in which he will not get a vote.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass, I think, has disposed of the plan, but to disabuse Deputy O'Hanlon's mind as to the terrible results that are brought about by the present system, take the results of the General Elections. Look at a few constituencies. Compare the first preferences with the men who were first on the list. If you take the first eight in Donegal, those who got the first preferences were the same eight who were subsequently elected, except that the final order was different from the order of the first preferences. It was the same in West Cork, North Cork, and East Cork. We had to wait until we got to Cork borough to find a change. The business vote won one seat and Labour lost one. If you go through the whole there is only a fractional change here and there. So that the bringing in of the objectionable tail is not borne out by the results any more than it is borne out by looking around the Chamber. As far as the objections to the scheme itself are concerned, Deputy Lemass pointed out in an exaggerated form that the people would not be able to elect the candidates they wanted to elect. As between two good administrators in any particular area, a person who has a genial disposition gets all the votes, whereas the numbers two go to the others, but they cannot be transferred even though the surplus may be large.

Comment on this

Do you not think that a voter would be better satisfied by having only one vote rather than having a number that he or she does not understand? You can beat any system or suggestion by making an exaggerated statement such as Deputy Lemass has put forward. I do not think what he suggested is possible. I have seen an election in this country where Deputy de Valera was elected first, getting something like 22,000 votes, whereas the man next to him got only 114.

Comment on this

Suppose it occurred under your system, what would happen?

Comment on this

No man could be elected without votes, but if a candidate got one vote and the others got none of course he would be elected, just as some of the gentlemen sitting here did not get 100 first preference votes.

Comment on this

I am quite genuine in congratulating Deputy O'Hanlon on bringing forward a new proposal. Even if it has very beautiful mechanism it has one defect, that it will not work. The point I am putting to Deputy O'Hanlon is that we have had actual experience where a group which was organised and thoroughly disciplined was capable of doing all the things he thought it ought not to do. In other words, this particular group would come together, go through the names and select the number of candidates, which they worked out mathematically, that they thought they would be entitled to carry. This was at the other side. That is the ordinary method. It all depends on who is the best organised. All I was concerned with was in voting to put in one man of a particular kidney. Every one of us would have sacrificed our personal predilections, because it meant the looking after of the religion of our children in the schools. We simply knew that we had to vote one of that ticket. It did not matter to us who the man was; he had been vetted by the organisation to which we were for the moment loyal or servient, and whether I got the name Quinn, Jones, Williams or O'Hanlon, I voted, and because our organisation was better than the other organisation, and because the loyalty of our voters to that organisation was greater, we did, in fact, get more seats than we were entitled to, until the others woke up. I am not at all against the system; I am not saying one word against it, because I believe that our organisation is the better of the two, and no doubt if it did come to a thing of this kind, because we are the better organisation we probably would get the better result. I am not dealing with that question at all. What I want Deputy O'Hanlon to get out of his mind is that groups and organisations cannot carry in as he said, on the shoulders of one man another. That is a perfect system of organisation that given an organisation and given loyalty among the members of that organisation, the nominees of the organisation shall be carried quite apart from the knowledge of the individual elector of the qualities of the men themselves. That is my actual experience.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That Section 3 stand part of the Bill"—put.

Tá 67
·
Níl 63
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

The next three amendments deal with casual vacancies and the method of filling them. It is proposed to take a discussion on these amendments on amendment 11, in the name of Deputy de Valera:—

To delete in sub-section (2), line 39, all words after the words "any member thereof" and to substitute the words "such vacancy shall be filled by co-option at the quarterly meeting of the Council next following."

To delete sub-section (3).

Comment on this

I have been considering the first of these amendments, and, in view of the fact that it was originally intended as a simple means of election, where you had a three years' period, and as that period of three years has gone by the board, with the permission of the House, I will not move these amendments. I may bring in a further amendment later. At this stage, I am prepared to accept the Minister's amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

At the end of sub-section (3) to add two new sub-sections as follows:

(4) The council may in their absolute discretion by resolution passed for that purpose determine to fill by co-option in accordance with this sub-section the casual vacancy to which such resolution relates, and upon such resolution being passed the council may either at the meeting at which such resolution was passed or any subsequent meeting thereof fill such casual vacancy by the votes of a simple majority of the members of the council present and voting at such meeting.

(5) Every person chosen in pursuance of the provisions of the foregoing sub-section to fill a casual vacancy shall unless he sooner dies, resigns, or becomes disqualified hold office until the day on which the borough election to be held under this Act next after the occurrence of the casual vacancy so filled is so held.

This amendment enables a council, at their discretion, by resolution to fill a casual vacancy by co-option, and the person so co-opted shall remain a member of the council until the next election.

Comment on this

I move:—

To delete sub-section (2) and substitute the following:—

"(2) The members of the Council at the first meeting after their election and at the first quarterly meeting in each subsequent year shall elect from their number by proportional representation six persons who shall be aldermen. Any casual vacancy in the body of aldermen shall be filled by election by members of the council."

That would be part of the general alternative scheme. Leaving aside for the moment the question of triennial elections, which is partly involved, there are two main ideas in it. One is that the aldermen should be chosen by the council rather than be the first members elected at the popular election. There were two reasons in our scheme for that. One was that we believed that giving the mere title of "alderman" without any particular functions was foolish, that there was nothing in it, and that it did not correspond to any particular functions. Under the Minister's scheme "alderman" is now simply an ornamental title, whereas in our scheme the alderman would have a definite function. The functions of aldermen, as I said already, would be as a general purposes committee, to keep in close touch with the administration of the manager. They would be available for him as a consultative body, in certain cases as a board of appeal, and so on. The fact that they were to get definite functions, that they were to act on behalf of the council, made it advisable that they should be selected by the council, and not simply be taken as the first elected. If the scheme of keeping in close touch with the manager is accepted, I think it will be necessary to accept this amendment. If, on the other hand, the Dáil decides that the council is not to be kept in close touch with the administration of the manager then, of course, this amendment will be defeated. I have no particular preference for having the aldermen elected by the council as against being elected by the people if the aldermen have no special functions. If it is to be a purely ornamental title I am not very much interested in how they are to be elected. But if they are to have functions such as I have indicated in the alternative scheme, then I hold it is important that they should be elected by the council as a whole.

Comment on this

The amendment is not being moved?

Comment on this

I am moving the amendment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

The amendment could hardly be moved in that form. Part of it would depend on a triennial election. It deals with six persons.

Comment on this

The number is left open, and the only effect, as far as I can see, of the passing of the amendment on the question of the number would be to make sure that there would be at least six. There would have to be six at least; if you are to have this piecemeal election, so to speak, you must have a number not less than six at the start.

Comment on this

I oppose the amendment. The proposal is that the council should set up a smaller body which could come in in some kind of way between the council and the manager. That smaller body cannot, at any rate in my opinion ought not, take on itself any of the functions that are being reserved to the council as a whole.

Comment on this

I think it would help matters if we agreed to take that in connection with the question of the manager's powers.

Comment on this