We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

PUBLIC BUSINESS. - CORK CITY MANAGEMENT BILL, 1928—THIRD STAGE.

Contributions 199–408 of 408. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Cork City Management Bill, 1928
Enacted

No. 32 of 1928 ›

Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

I think the amendment will have to be redrafted, in view of the form which the Bill is taking now.

Comment on this

That is, of course, the difficulty with all these amendments. Once the Committee has taken a decision that is counter to one you have got to re-arrange them. Under these conditions perhaps it would be better if I moved the amendment at a later stage.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Amendments 15, 16 and 17 depend on amendment 3:—

15. In sub-section (2), line 63, before the word "members" to insert the words "first seven."—(John F. O'Hanlon.)

16. In sub-section (2), line 64, after the figures "1928" to insert the words "and at subsequent elections."—(John F. O'Hanlon.)

17. In sub-section (2), line 64, to delete all words after the word "aldermen" to the end of the subsection.—(John F. O'Hanlon.)

Amendment 18 also depends on a previous amendment.

18. To insert below sub-section (3) a new sub-section as follows:—

Each alderman so elected shall hold the office of alderman until the fifth day after the election of aldermen next following and unless previously re-elected shall then retire from such office.—(Eamon de Valera.)

Comment on this

On the section, would the Minister tell us why he has embodied aldermen at all in the scheme seeing that they serve no function whatever?

Comment on this

It is considered desirable to continue the title of alderman as a mark of distinction for those members of the council who get the most prominent public support at the elections. I do not know that an alderman had any function in the past. At any rate, as far as I know, he has not had any particular function in the recent past, and it is not proposed to give him a particular function under this scheme. It does, I think, help in some way to reward men giving the type of public service that can be given on a city council, men who have the greatest confidence of the people reposed in them, with a title somewhat distinct from the ordinary members of the council.

Comment on this

It is merely an ornament.

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

In the old days, the aldermen used to wear a cocked hat and a type of robe that was distinctive in colour from that worn by the other members. Will that be incorporated in this Bill?

Comment on this

There is nothing to prevent it being done.

Comment on this

I remember a distinguished member of a corporation who was an alderman, but being mayor as well, wished to be addressed as "Mr. So-and-So, Mayor of——"

Comment on this

Is it not possible that under the Bill as at present the majority of the council may eventually be aldermen?

Comment on this

I propose to bring in an amendment dealing with the question of aldermen when we are quite clear as to the numbers of the council.

Comment on this

I move amendment 21:—

To delete sub-sections (1) and (2) and substitute a new sub-section as follows:—

"(1) The Minister may, notwithstanding anything to the contrary provided in the foregoing section of this Act, by Order require that any powers, functions and duties of the Corporation conferred on them by this Act shall be exercised and performed by the person appointed under this Act as the Cork City Manager (in this Act referred to as the Manager)."

The purport of the amendment is pretty plain. It proposes to delete sub-sections (1) and (2) and to substitute a new sub-section. As Deputies may see, sub-section (1) deals with the reserved services, that is, with the functions the Minister intends to give the council. Sub-section (2) gives the Minister power to extend these functions, from time to time. The object of my amendment is that while I would like to see the Corporation elected by the ratepayers getting all the powers possible. I do not want to take out of the hands of the Minister the right to clip their wings, if necessary, if they misbehave themselves. This gives the Minister power to deal with the council should they transgress in any way in the future. There are other amendments to come on later that I think hinge on it, but for the moment I will leave it as it is.

Comment on this

The effect of putting the amendment into the Bill would be that the Minister could not confer any of the functions of the Corporation, say, on the manager without the consent of two-thirds of the members of the council. It would be completely tieing the Minister's hands.

Comment on this

I submit that it gives the Minister power. It states that the Minister may, "notwithstanding anything to the contrary provided in the foregoing section of this Act, by Order require that any powers, functions and duties conferred on him by this Act shall be exercised and performed by the person appointed under this Act as the Cork City Manager." If you take out the reserved ones, it means all the powers which the first section of the Bill gives them. The Bill restores the powers to the Corporation and then takes them all back again. I want to take out the dangerous part, with this distinction, that I do not want to take from the Minister the right to take these powers out of their hands if the Corporation do not conduct themselves, and unless there is any justification for it, I am sure the Minister would not do it without justification. Therefore, I am proposing to give the right to the Minister to reserve certain things or take certain powers out of the hands of the Corporation should circumstances warrant it. It is otherwise provided under what conditions he can add to their powers. Earlier the Minister is given power to confer certain powers on them that are not already specified in the Bill. But this removes all the reservations and gives new power to the Minister to come along and say: "These things are not done properly: we have to take certain powers from you and put them entirely in the hands of the manager."

Comment on this

I wonder if Deputy O'Hanlon, when drafting this amendment, considered the advisability of examining the terms of the Public Safety Act. which might be made to apply to the arrest, internment and deporting of members of the council.

Comment on this

What would happen under the amendment is, that all power would be taken from the Minister to confer any of the powers of the Corporation on the manager without a vote of two-thirds of the council. Sub-section 5 of Section 2 says that the duties of the Corporation shall be exercised by the council or the manager. Section 8 proposes that the council shall exercise directly certain powers. As far as I can see, these are powers that ought to be given to the council if the council is to govern the City of Cork; giving them these powers gives them complete governmental control of the city. For the proper carrying out of his executive work by the manager it is not necessary to give him all the other powers until such time as it is arranged that certain other functions after examination should be reserved to the council as distinct from the manager. If Deputy O'Hanlon's amendment were to fit in with the section the Minister would have to specify by order all the different powers he was going to hand over to the manager. It is much simpler to specify the powers reserved to the council and give the rest to the manager.

Comment on this

I do not quite see that. Section 2 of the Bill, giving power to dissolve the Board, is wiped out and you restore to the Corporation all the powers they had before.

Comment on this

The Deputy must distinguish between the Corporation and the council. The Corporation is a corporate body and the council is a body elected to carry on the duties and responsibilities of the Corporation.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) of Section 2 does not make it very plain.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) of Section 2 restores all the powers taken from the Corporation and handed over to the Commissioner.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Amendment 22 proposes to reserve to the council the making of all contracts over £200. Paragraph J, amendment 26, proposes another scheme with regard to regulations for the making of contracts. There is a further amendment, number 41, by Deputy O'Hanlon, which proposes to delete sub-section (7) of Section 10, which gives to the manager power to do all such matters and things, including the making of contracts to the Corporation, and so on. It seems to me the best way to get a discussion on the contract question would be on amendment number 41, under which the manager gets power to make contracts.

Comment on this

Why skip Section 9?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Section 9 will be put, but the question of contracts will be discussed on sub-section (7) of Section 10, and when that has been decided Deputies can make up their minds regarding other amendments.

Comment on this

The suggestion from the Chair is that we should leave over the question of this particular amendment and go on to contracts. At a later stage we can bring on these amendments, when a decision has been taken by the Committee on the question of contracts.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Either at this stage or at a later stage.

Comment on this

The difficulty to me is that the passing of Deputy de Valera's amendment, number 26, does not involve any alteration in sub-section (7) of Section 10.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Take paragraph J.

Comment on this

It does not involve any alteration of the other sub-section.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

I will take a discussion on that then. I am only concerned with taking a discussion on one particular point covering the whole matter, and if we can get a decision which would be clear.

Comment on this

I think it would be better to take a discussion on Deputy Anthony's amendment, No. 22, for sub-section (7) is rather wider than contracts.

Comment on this

If Deputy Anthony's amendment were put, I would vote against it, but I would vote for Deputy de Valera's. If the two amendments were to be decided on one vote there would be a difficulty.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Deputy Anthony's amendment makes a very clear restriction, and it would be easy to vote on it. Deputy de Valera's amendment is another suggestion for making regulations with regard to contracts. I would prefer to take a decision on amendment No. 26, paragraph J, if we do not go on to amendment 41.

Comment on this

It is more in connection with the question of reserved powers. The question of contract comes in only incidentally.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Then we will take Deputy Anthony's amendment, and at a later stage take a discussion on contracts by taking Deputy de Valera's amendment 26, paragraph J.

Comment on this

I take it that amendments 25, 26 and 27 are intended to retain in the hands of the council the powers of determining the salary of a manager and his responsibilities to the council. I suggest that they should be taken together, if that would suit Deputy de Valera.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

We will postpone amendment 22.

Comment on this

I move amendment 23, which is as follows:—

In sub-section (1), before paragraph (e), to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

(e) the making of any order under Section 5 of the Shops Act, 1912 (in that Act referred to as a closing order).

This amendment is put in to make clear the position with regard to the Shops Act. Under that Act there is power in certain areas over definite shops and trades to which the Order applies—fixing the hours of opening and so forth. The amendment is put in to make it clear that it is the council that will make regulations in regard to the Shops Act and not the manager.

Comment on this

I move amendment 24, which reads:—

In sub-section (1) (h) to delete the words "an allowance or" and to substitute the word "a" and insert after the word "granting" the words "if the Council so desire."

This amendment brings up the whole question of the position of the manager, whether he is to be, so to speak, an expert employed for a certain period— five years is the period we indicate in our scheme—with possible reappointment, or whether he should be, so to speak, in the position of a civil servant with a long period of office and be a pensionable officer. Leaving aside for the moment the question as to whether there should be a pension attached to this office, if there is to be a long period, we have to consider the question of the period. If the period is to be a short one, such as we suggest, five years, we think that "allowance," in so far as it might suggest a yearly allowance or superannuation, should not be there. The Minister's scheme seems to envisage a manager who is to be a permanent officer like a town cleark, with the right to pension. An "allowance" would be an allowance which would attach to that particular office, and the question of giving that allowance should be at the will of the council. We propose to eliminate the word "allowance" and suggest that the question of gratuity or bonus be at the will of the council if they thought that the manager was going out after a short period of office and should get such gratuity.

Comment on this

The proposal in the Bill is that the manager should be an officer of the Corporation, like a town cleark, county surveyor, or county officer of health, an expert with definite functions such as those of a county officer of health. If you look for men of energy, enthusiasm, and experience and realise that the administration of civic affairs is a very technical matter, and if a man goes into the position of a city manager and is carrying out his duties satisfactorily, you, at any rate, require to ensure him a tenure of office for the satisfactory carrying on of his business. Otherwise there is no inducement for a person of energy, experience, and with the necessary qualifications, at perhaps an important period of his life, to take up such position and find himself after five years in the position of having no claim on his office. Under Deputy de Valera's scheme he would have no claim at any time, because he would continue from one period of five years to another period of five years without any guarantee, whereas if you make him an officer of the Corporation he comes in, like a county surveyor or county officer of health, with a definite tenure of office and a definite guarantee that if his term of office is terminated for any particular purpose not brought about through his own fault, if he has less than ten years' service he gets a gratuity which is within the power of the Minister to determine. If his tenure of office terminates after more than ten years' service he is entitled to a pension, which is also within the power of the Minister to determine.

Comment on this

Now that we have heard the Minister on this point may I say that this is not the main amendment dealing with this particular matter? It is consequential on another amendment later. That being so, I would prefer not to have a vote on this, as it is only a side-issue at this particular stage. I suggest that we should argue the general question, whether it should, or should not, be a pensionable office, in connection with a later amendment. Perhaps the Minister will be prepared to let it go at that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Amendments 25 and 27 raise in another form what is set out in amendments 38 and 39. We can take them here, or, if the Deputy wishes, the matter can be decided on amendments 38 and 39. Here the Deputy is reserving to the council power over the manager, and in amendments 38 and 39 he is giving power to the council. Which amendment will the Deputy move?

Comment on this

In amendment 25 and amendment 27 I want to provide for the retention, in the hands of the council, of the power of determining the salary of the manager, and also to fix his position as one subordinate to the council. I move amendment 25 now:

"In sub-section (1) (i), line 9, to add after the words ‘Lord Mayor' the words ‘and the manager.'"

Comment on this

These amendments practically seek to take away from the Minister the power which he has with regard to most of the important offices in the Local Government services. At the present moment the Minister has power under Section 15 of the Local Government (Temporary Provisions) Act of 1923 to fix, over the heads of local bodies, if necessary, the salary of any officer to which the section applies. Under the Public Health Act of 1898, Section 11, he has power to fix over the heads of local bodies, if necessary, the salary of any sanitary officer, including town clerks, medical officers or dispensary doctors. Under the Local Government Act of 1898 special powers are given in regard to the salaries of county secretaries, county surveyors, assistant county surveyors, and, probably, the resident medical superintendents of asylums. The matter of practice is very strong in the case of county secretaries, county surveyors and assistant county surveyors. This Bill proposes to give the Minister plainly the power which he already has in the case of other officers. I consider that it is important that the Minister should have this particular power. He is in a better position than a local body to decide what the salary should be of a person carrying out the work of a city manager. He is more in touch with the salaries paid in the Civil Service and elsewhere than the Council would be, and it is more satisfactory to fix the matter definitely in the Bill that the Minister should be responsible.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister does not want to contend that a Minister would have better knowledge of the economic conditions in any given city or town than the local council would have?

Comment on this

It is not a question of the economic conditions; it is a question of what remuneration the city manager should have.

Comment on this

To remove any suspicion which the amendment may have created in the mind of the Minister, I might say that he may rest assured that the people elected to this council will treat their manager generously, but at least they should be allowed the privilege of saying what the salary should be. It would be just as well, and it would come as a good gesture from the Minister himself, if he were to leave that in the hands of the newly elected council, because there is a suspicion abroad, founded or unfounded I cannot say, that certain positions will be made in the near future for pets of the Government. I want to be quite frank in this matter. It would be a very good gesture on the part of the Minister if he would allow my amendment to stand. Founded or unfounded, there is a suspicion abroad that the Bill may create jobs for certain pets of the Minister's Department or of some other Department. The sooner that suspicion is removed the better it will be for the country and for all concerned.

Comment on this

I take it that a decision on this amendment will not be taken as ruling out amendments 38 and 39?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

No, that is another scheme.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move amendment 26:

In sub-section (1) to add after paragraph (i) two new paragraphs as follows:—

(j) make regulations, which regulations shall be subject to the approval of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, concerning the making of contracts for and on behalf of the Corporation;

(k) except where otherwise provided for by law to make general regulations concerning the appointment, promotion and removal of officers and servants of the Corporation (not including the Manager), and fix the minimum and maximum rates of remuneration to be paid to such officers and servants.

I think that the best way to meet the question of contracts on the one hand is by giving the manager such powers as the council thinks right over negotiating these contracts and making them. The best way of dealing with them would be to enable the council itself to make regulations. The question of contracts is a very important and serious one, and I think it is altogether wrong that the power of making contracts should be in the hands of the manager without at least the council being able to say what type the contract should be and under what conditions the manager should be able to make these contracts on behalf of the Corporation. I do not think it is necessary to make a speech about it, but the idea ought to commend itself generally. Everybody will agree that it is a serious matter to put into the hands of the manager the power to make contracts on behalf of the Corporation or council without giving the council the right to indicate what type of contract he should make on their behalf.

Comment on this

I wonder whether Deputy de Valera would say whether the making of a contract is a legislative or executive act?

Comment on this

I would say that the actual making of it would be an executive act, but the regulations under which the executive should make it would be a legislative act, if you like. It is very hard, of course, to draw a clear, well-defined line between certain executive and administrative functions, at least in their general character; but the actual act, I should say, should be an executive act. But there should be something in the form of ratification beforehand or after— ratification in the first instance. The power of negotiating ought to be in the hands of the manager. The power to conclude ought be in his hands under conditions, and the conditions ought to be definitely in the regulations made by the council, or else the power of ratification afterwards can be reserved to the council. It is not right to give a man power to conclude on his own any contracts he pleases without giving the council power to define the nature of the contracts he is at liberty to make.

Comment on this

I suggest that Deputy de Valera has not divided in his mind in the way in which the Bill definitely divides them the legislative side of the work, as he calls it, from the executive side. The position is further obscured by himself by the introduction of the board of aldermen idea. If the manager is going to be the manager, and going to have on his shoulders complete responsibility to answer to the council for the carrying out of the executive side of the work, he must be perfectly free to shoulder that responsibility. The council must do its work in such a way that when it takes a decision it has taken that decision in the clearest possible way, so that the manager can take up his responsibility and get on with his work. You cannot have a manager shouldering a matter and make him answerable to the council for carrying out properly the working of any particular contract, the making of any particular contract, if he has the council or a member of the council or anyone else meddling with him in that contract. I cannot imagine what things might be dealt with in a set of regulations framed by the council instructing the manager how he was to make his contract. The council requires that a certain scheme be carried out. The plans of that scheme are prepared and passed by the council. The question of entering into a contract to carry out the work is taken up by the manager, and the manager should be fully responsible for the complete performance of that work. If the manager is going to be butted in upon by the council, by people who have no responsibility for the executive work, then he cannot stand fairly and squarely over the work, and he cannot be brought fairly and squarely to account afterwards if his work is not properly carried out. For that reason I am opposed to putting provisions into the Bill along these lines.

Comment on this

The Minister states that he cannot imagine what regulations the council would make under Section 8 of this Bill. It seems to me obvious that it is the Minister and not Deputy de Valera who is a bit confused with reference to the division between legislative and administrative functions. I would say that it is the duty of the council and not the duty of the manager to arrive at a decision, for example, say, that trade union rates of wages and trade union hours would be observed in all work carried out for the council, or carried out under contracts made for the council; or that it should be the duty of the council to decide that preference would be given to Irish goods purchased by the council, and to decide the extent of the preference. These would be matters of policy, matters on which the elected representatives of the people should be consulted. They are not matters which the manager should decide on his own initiative. It is regulations of that kind which are contemplated in the section, the general terms and conditions under which contracts can be made. If the council and the manager keep clear in their own minds the division between the functions of each, I am quite clear that there can be no misunderstanding concerning the regulations that may be made.

Comment on this

I put it again to the Minister as regards the actual position of the manager in this respect. It is really negotiation in the first instance. It is right as an executive act that negotiations should be in the hands of the manager, but I hold that the final approval of contracts should be in the hands of the council either before or after—either by defining beforehand the extent of the powers which the manager has or else that there is to be subsequent ratification. Now, the simplest way out of it is to give the council power of making regulations. These regulations, you will notice, are to be subject to the approval of the Minister for Local Government, and therefore, if there was any attempt to abuse these reserved powers the Minister could object. If, for instance, it was obvious that the power was being used so as to fetter the manager and so as to make it impossible for him to carry out his functions efficiently, naturally the Minister would object and would not approve. But I think it is altogether dangerous to give to the manager uncontrolled powers as are proposed in this section. The Minister talks about the council being the government. That word "government" is used ambiguously; when the Minister is talking about the government he is talking about the executive. He himself would not be talking about the Dáil when talking of the government. He would be talking about the executive at the moment. I have not seen in this Bill any clear indication of the control that the council is to have over the manager in certain cases. I think that power ought to be there continuously, and in particular in respect of this making of contracts.

Comment on this

The Bill makes provision under sub-section (2) whereby on two-thirds of the council asking for additional reserved functions, these functions can be reserved to the council by the Minister. I do not want to put in, as Deputies have said, in a theoretic way, a clause reserving specifically under these reserved functions the power to make regulations for any particular thing. If in the course of the council's work below they get clear in their minds that there are certain regulations that they would require, and that it would be useful and advisable for them to have guiding them in their work, that matter can be considered, and sub-section (2) of this section can be operated to give the council any additional reserved functions they require in the matter. I am not clear, in spite of what the Deputy suggests, that it would be advisable by, say, legislative or Ministerial action that a clause should be put in any contract making things obligatory in that contract. For instance, it might not be advisable that a fair wages clause should be included, or that trade union rates should be paid by any particular contractor to the council.

Comment on this

Will the Minister not agree that that is a matter which the council should decide in respect of a contract given by the Cork Corporation?

Comment on this

I would not like to give a judgment now whether or not the Cork Corporation would be right in doing so. In Great Britain, where they have given a good lot of attention to these matters, they have never embodied in their legislation any statutory regulations that would force a local body carrying out a particular contract to put in a fair wages clause.

Comment on this

The Minister misunderstood me. I am not suggesting that the Cork Corporation should put such a clause in their contract; but the decision as to whether such a clause should go in should rest with the council and not with the manager. The council has not that right under this Bill. The other illustration I gave applies equally well. There might be a decision as to whether preference should be given to Irish goods. That decision should be arrived at by the council and not by the manager. If arrived at by the council it should be obligatory on the manager.

Comment on this

I would like to give some further consideration to the matter, and I would like the Deputy to leave it over until the Report Stage. What I am particularly anxious about is that there is so much innuendo and suggestion going on in the discussion. I do not want to enshrine in our legislation things that are simply innuendoes and suggestions and things that are put in simply because certain people feel the manager is going to be the governor of Cork and not the servant of the Corporation. I would be prepared to consider the matter further with a view to deciding whether or not the course suggested is advisable.

Comment on this

I will accept that, and I may take it that I will have an opportunity of putting down a further amendment if the Minister has not dealt with this matter on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

It is merely a question of the proper division of legislative and administrative functions.

Comment on this

I would like to give some further consideration to paragraph (k). This would be putting the Corporation of Cork in a different category to other local bodies. It might take them out of the general scheme for the control of remuneration and salary that at present exists.

Comment on this

The idea is not to let the manager do just as he pleases. Just as there should be regulations with regard to contracts, so there ought to be general regulations governing the salaries of officials.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Does the Deputy mean individual officials?

Comment on this

No; general classes.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

It is not quite clear.

Comment on this

I intended it to mean general regulations, and not regulations for an individual case.

Comment on this

Again, it is the proper division of the legislative and administrative functions.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

It is not contended in respect, say, of official A that his case would be a matter for consideration by the council?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

It is contended that the council should decide, for instance, that clerical officerships should be filled up by competitive examination.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Part of amendment 27 has been defeated with amendment 25. Anyhow, the subject-matter will arise again on amendment 38.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 29:—

In sub-section (4), line 23, to delete all words after the word "resolution" to the end of the sub-section, and substitute therefor the following words:—

"of the Council—

(a) of which not less than one month's notice shall have been given in writing by the Town Clerk to every member of the Council, and

(b) for which not less than two-thirds of the members of the Council shall have voted."

This is for the purpose of making the drafting of the original section clear. It means that where the council decides that there are certain functions they consider ought to be further reserved to them as reserved functions, the resolution stating that to the Minister must have passed, two-thirds of the total members of the council voting, and the resolution must have been passed at a meeting of which one month's notice shall have been given.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Amendment 30 falls with amendment 21.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 33:

In sub-section (1), line 49, to delete the words "including the Town Clerk but."

As the Bill stands the manager will appoint the town clerk and will have power to dismiss him. My object in this amendment is to secure that the town clerk cannot be interfered with by the manager—that the manager should have no power over him and no power to dismiss him.

Comment on this

The position is that certain functions of the Corporation have to be discharged by the manager and certain functions by the council, and the town clerk must act in respect to the manager, in so far as the manager is exercising certain functions of the Corporation, in the very same way as the town clerk will act to the council when the council is discharging functions. That is one point. The next point is that the manager must have complete control over the administrative machinery—over the machinery in his hands for carrying out his work. To create a position in which the town clerk would not be responsible to the manager would cause a great lack of co-ordination and would be a very fruitful source of friction. It would put the manager in the position that he would not be quite satisfied as to where he stood. There is certain work that the town clerk would have to perform for him and it would put the town clerk in the position that he would not know where he stood from the point of view of his responsibility. You are putting the manager in charge as the executive head of the city machine with complete executive responsibility, and you cannot say that any particular officer shall not be subordinate to him and shall not be as fully under his control as anyone else. The manager will have no power to dismiss the town clerk for any reason that the council would not have power to cause his dismissal. The town clerk has ample appeal to the Minister in case of any wrong that might be done him by the manager.

Comment on this

Has a town clerk in an ordinary town the right of appeal at present if he is dismissed by the Corporation?

Comment on this

Any officer of a local body, such as a town clerk, would have the right of appeal to the Minister if he was being unfairly dealt with by the council.

Comment on this

According to Section 10 (7) the manager has power to make contracts, while he has absolute control over all officers according to Section 13. I have another amendment down to remove that word "absolute." According to Section 15, he may make payments by order in respect of any expense or liability incurred by the council or the manager. Section 15 also provides for the counter-signature of paying orders by the town clerk. Presumably that is for the purpose of a check. But what value as a check is the signature of the town clerk if he is under the absolute control and possibly at the mercy of the manager? In my view, and in the view of many people whom I have consulted, the town clerk should be absolutely independent of the manager. I do not want to refer to matters that have occurred in another part of Ireland, but we have seen quite recently what occurred over housing scandals in another part of Ireland. Assuming that there was no council there, and that the city was being run by a manager, it is very doubtful if these scandals would ever have come to light. The whole thing could have been hushed up by a few officials. I want to preserve at least some independence amongst the officials of the Corporation and to ensure that the town clerk at any rate shall be independent of the manager.

Comment on this

I think there is something very definite in the point raised by Deputy Anthony. You are putting this manager in charge of the whole machine, very much with the authority which a Minister has over his own staff. To all intents and purposes the town clerk and others are local civil servants. I think that is so. We had a rather extraordinary statement a few days ago from, I think, the Minister for Finance. It arose, I think, over the Tariff Commission, as a matter of fact.

That Minister was defining the position of civil servants, and he said two very extraordinary things in conjunction. He repeated the statement that civil servants hold their office at the will and pleasure of the Executive Council, and he went on to say that civil servants in their ordinary capacity were there to carry out orders— to do what they were told. This is the extraordinary phrase used—that no question of personal honour arose if a civil servant did what he was told. I am speaking from recollection, without the book, but that is my impression, that he used the expression that no question of personal honour arose if the civil servant did what he was told. If the town clerk, who is supposed to countersign paying orders, is in the position of a local civil servant to any degree whatever, and if the official definition of the functions and status of local civil servants is to be anything at all in the nature of the definition of the status of civil servants as given by the Minister—that they are to obey orders and that no question of personal honour arises in the doing of the things that they are told to do—it seems to be imperative that there should be some method of check, especially in the specific matter of payments.

Deputy Anthony has suggested that certain scandals which arose and which did leak out and come to the surface at a time before absolute collapse was occasioned by their hiding up, might have been delayed in their discovery or divulgement if there had been a close corporation of this kind; a close corporation such as would be constituted by a manager with a servant whom he apparently had complete authority over and had power to dismiss—or if his position had any shadow of relation to the position of an ordinary civil servant who, according to my recollection, was defined by the Minister as there to obey the orders of his chief without any question of personal honour arising in the discharge of any duty which he was instructed to do.

Comment on this

There is no doubt in my mind that the manager must be responsible for the whole staff and that the making of an appointment is work that is executive work. If there is a difficulty about the town clerk countersigning paying orders of the manager we may have to arrange that the manager shall countersign the paying orders of the town clerk and get payments made in that way. That is the only other way out of it. If you want a check by a person who is not under the control of the manager on the payments made by the manager, you will have to appoint a kind of official who will stand aloof as a kind of paying-inspector-general and countersign the order. I do not think there is very much in the point with regard to the counter-signature of the paying orders, but if there is it can be looked into. You could not have the manager's work carried out if the town clerk were independent of him. He must be part of the operating machine of the city manager.

Comment on this

I am not so sure that the Minister is right in thinking that the manager ought necessarily have control of the town clerk. I am not quite clear personally as to the functions that the town clerk will have now that we have got a manager appointed. I suppose it will be left to the manager under this scheme to define the duties of the town clerk. If I was thinking in general terms about it, I would say that the town clerk ought to be an officer of the council comparable, for instance, to the Clerk of the Dáil, and ought not necessarily to be subject to the Executive. He ought to be an officer of the body as a whole to deal with certain matters assigned to him by the council—an independent officer and not directly under the control of the manager at all. If the question of cheques came up, I certainly would be very much opposed to a subordinate officer being entitled to sign cheques, but if he was in an independent position as an officer directly of the council, as the Clerk of the Dáil is an officer of this House as a whole, then there would not be the same objection at all. He would be acting on behalf of the council with definite authority given. I must, at the present time, vote with Deputy Anthony for the deletion of this particular phrase until I can see the functions of the town clerk and his relations to the manager more clearly defined. When I read it first I did not notice that particular point, and had in my mind generally that the town clerk would bear to the manager the same relation, roughly, that the Clerk of the Dáil would bear to the Minister, that is, that he would be an independent officer and the immediate officer of the council as a whole.

Comment on this

One thing which has been pointed out is that the managerial system will enable the council to do away, in a large way, with the operation of a number of committees. The city manager will be a permanent city committee on all kinds of things, and the town clerk must act towards him in that capacity, as the town clerk acts towards the council. The manager cannot be a manager of a city if the town clerk is independent of him.

Comment on this

How does the Minister propose to meet the objection in relation to the counter-signing of paying orders? Is a subordinate to be put into the position of being ordered to do these things without any question of personal honour arising in the matter? I do not know whether the Minister recollects that most extraordinary and amazing definition of the functions of civil servants, or whether it is communicated to civil servants in the terms of their appointment. If that particular statement is correct it means that if the Minister gave orders to one of his subordinates to write a letter to-day and to date it a fortnight ago, no question except that of obedience to his superior arises; that if it is a question of altering or arranging anything for the purpose of making something seem what it otherwise would not be, no question except the question of obedience arises, and no question of whether the thing is right, moral, legal, honest or anything else arises. We have had that extraordinary definition, and that definition stands in relation to the central authority which is setting up this system throughout the Local Government bodies for having purity and efficiency of administration. There must not be a lower standard down the country than in the Departments, and if the definition stands that a civil servant by the terms of his appointment holds that appointment at the will and pleasure of the Executive Council, and subject to obeying his chief, without any relation to the question of personal honour, then it seems to be essential that certainly in all financial transactions, however it is done, however awkward it is to do, whatever Health Robinsonian machinery is required to do it, there must be some independent check made by which some man will countersign paying orders for whom the question of personal honour does directly arise as distinct from mere obedience to his people. Deputy Anthony has offered an amendment which, though it has very considerable consequential difficulties, as I think he will recognise, does provide a solution of that. If the Minister does not like that, it seems to me that the onus is on him to provide some machinery.

Comment on this

I have suggested some machinery.

Comment on this

It did not seem to me to be adequate. I certainly do not think it would pass in a court as adequate.

Comment on this

I suggested that if the manager signing an order and having it countersigned by the town clerk is a difficulty, then I see no reason why a payment would not be made by the town clerk signing the order and the manager counter-signing it. At any rate I am sure some arrangement could be made to have payments made by the Cork Corporation without making the town clerk independent of the manager.

Comment on this

On the general question, apart from the payment of orders, there seems to be a good deal to be said for some measure, at any rate, of independence in relation to other matters. Paying orders are only one thing. He may be ordered to do something else. I am speaking now of the Front Bench definition of the duties and obligations of civil servants, and I am assuming that the Minister is not suggesting anything different in relation to other people, but if that definition stands it looks to one as if every second office will have to be changed.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I do not accept Deputy Flinn's recollection of what the Minister for Finance stated. Nor, in fact, as I explained to you before, am I going to accept what is published about what any person or any other member of the Government says outside the House.

Comment on this

You said "in the House."

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

In the House. I am not going to accept the Deputy's recollection of what took place. I want it in black and white, and further, no interpretation of what he said would lead anyone to believe that if the Minister ordered a payment to be made which was not properly due for payment it would be done by a civil servant. A civil servant would be bound to refuse to do so.

Comment on this

I said quite frankly I was speaking from recollection. I am speaking from a very clear recollection. I may be wrong. The fact that the President has said what he has said is to me a matter of great gratification. Even if it turns out to be that in black and white, it is valuable to know that that does not represent the interpretation of the Ministry of those words. They seemed to me, at the time, to be very clear. I will take the trouble of producing them.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

It does not follow that if a Minister told an official to date a letter a fortnight ago in sending it out that the official would be bound to do that. He would be bound, in my opinion, to refuse to do it, and perfectly entitled to refuse.

Comment on this

I am extremely glad to have that definition of the duties of civil servants. What my recollection of it was is that he used the two phrases in conjunction—that a civil servant held his position at the will and pleasure of the Executive Council, and that in the carrying out of his orders no question of personal honour arose, and a question of personal honour would arise in the particular definition I have given.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

In the other case, fearing any misapprehension, the manager just simply takes the place of the three members who sign the order. I do not know the Deputy's experience. I think it is a very elaborate proceeding, and, as a matter of fact, very little opportunity was afforded in a large municipality for the check which was supposed to take place by the members in the payment of those accounts. It took anything from fifteen minutes to half an hour to check the items alone, without going into the subject matter of them. In this case I think there is additional security, and security which, before, sometimes was discounted by the fact that an appeal to the Minister might allow members to escape liabilities which were incurred in making payments after some little irregularity had occurred. However, that is No. 15.

Comment on this

Apart from that altogether there is a great principle involved in this amendment of mine, and as I pointed out, in clause 9 the Cork City manager shall exercise and perform for and on behalf of the Corporation the powers, functions and duties of the Corporation in relation to the appointment and removal of officers and servants of the Corporation (including the town clerk). I submit that is placing in the hands of one official arbitrary power, apart altogether from the big wrench it is and the parting with traditions, as one might call it, surrounding the office of the town clerk which might be the sentimental side of the question. I do not expect much support in that. We do not look for it. The fact remains that a particular clause is not acceptable to the people of Cork as a whole. While we are not asking for dual responsibility we still believe the town clerk should be free and independent of the city manager, whilst prepared to co-operate with him in every way. It is implied in the Bill, at any rate. Whilst, as I say, the town clerk should be expected to co-operate with the city manager, he should not be put under the control of the city manager who, at any time for any whim or any supposed grievance, may dispense with the services of the town clerk. That is the principle I would like to direct the attention of Deputies to.

Comment on this

I wonder if there is any hope of getting the Minister to consider this whole question of the relations between the town clerk and the manager? The trouble, as far as I see, is that you are taking an old officer into a new system. The old officer was in relation to the council in its deliberate functions in much the same position as the Clerk of the Dáil is here to us. In other functions he was the executive officer for certain committees. Those committees are going to be done away with and you have the manager really doing the work which they did formerly. That is as I understand it. If the town clerk is going to be carried over as he was before and act with the manager as a clerk in that capacity he must be subordinate to the manager. There is no doubt in my mind as to that, but if he is acting as clerk for the deliberative body and acting as their secretary, so to speak, he ought to be independent of the manager, and I think that the whole question of drawing up relations between them ought to be considered. Here until I see some attempt to define their relative duties, or the duties of the town clerk in connection with his position as secretary for the deliberative body, I am going to support Deputy Anthony's amendment. But I quite see the Minister's point of view at the same time, and that is when he is acting as clerk or secretary for the manager in the particular position in which the manager is acting for the old sub-committees. I quite agree he should be a subordinate officer.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

The Deputy will admit that it is an impossible position to have two heads.

Comment on this

I see that. That is in executive matters, but there is the position on account of the new arrangement you are suggesting. The secretary to the council would be independent of the Executive. For instance, we have a perfect example in the case of the Clerk of the Dáil.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

That is not the same.

Comment on this

He is practically the same. There are records and other matters of this kind here in connection with the deliberative assembly and you want an officer of that kind. If he is to be independent, and if he is to do his work in that capacity properly, he ought not to be subject to the manager. For instance, if the Clerk of the Dáil had to be taken in to do executive work he should be subordinate to the Executive, but here he is not acting as an officer of the Executive. In the same way there are cases in which the town clerk ought to be in the position of acting as an independent officer. If he were an independent officer, as the Clerk of the Dáil is, independent of the Executive, I would be quite prepared to say, in the case of signing cheques, his counter-signature on behalf of the body to which he was responsible would be of great value, but if he is a subordinate officer I agree with Deputy Flinn that his signature is of very little value as a check.

Comment on this

I rise to offer a suggestion which might be acceptable to the Minister and Deputy Anthony. I can see the difficulties that arise on both sides. Would it not be acceptable to provide that in the case of considering the dispensing with the services of the town clerk such action shall only be taken jointly by the manager and the council? That would preserve a certain link between the town clerk and the council and at the same time it would not undermine the authority of the manager with regard to the town clerk. If a question arose of dispensing with the services of the town clerk, it should be considered jointly by the council and the manager. I offer that suggestion in the hope that it will be acceptable both to the Minister and to Deputy Anthony. It would overcome the difficulty of making the manager absolute dictator and at the same time it would give the town clerk the idea that his boss is not the manager but the council.

Comment on this

We must organise on clear lines. I see no greater difficulty for the town clerk than for an assistant county surveyor. It may be taken in general terms that the manager's instructions to, say, the assistant engineer in Cork will be that he should carry out the instructions of the borough engineer. I see no reason why the manager's instructions to the town clerk in respect of his duties to the council would not be that he carry out the instructions of the council. But the organisation of the clerk's office and the way in which the work has to be done have to be under the instructions of the manager. I do not see any other way of dealing with the matter than making the manager responsible for the whole staff, including the town clerk. In so far as we differ on the question of the manager dismissing the town clerk the Minister stands there as a safeguard to the town clerk. If the Minister acquiesces in the dismissal of the town clerk as against the council's wishes and if the manager dismisses the clerk in opposition to the wishes of the council, I consider that there would be a grave case for the council pointing out that the manager had not their confidence and for making a case for his removal. We are considering an absolutely hypothetical matter, trying to build up difficulties. Whatever difficulties may arise through the town clerk being under the manager I cannot see any other arrangement.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister sees my point of view. It is quite possible that strained relations might exist at some time or other between the council and their manager. While these strained relations exist the council may want to get certain information or certain records. They will always have their own clerk there; he will enjoy their full confidence, and the town clerk, in return, will enjoy the full confidence of the manager. It is not a case of a fight between the manager and the town clerk, but between the manager and the council, and documents may have to be exchanged with the Minister's Department. It is a case of establishing confidence and preserving a certain element of democracy. If the council can call the town clerk their own official, and if he can feel, in the case of strained relations between himself and the manager, he is not going to lose his position, I do not see any great difficulty. I thought that the suggestion I offered would be acceptable. I would be reluctant to suggest it, but I believe there is a great deal in what Deputy Anthony stated. The President himself, from his own experience in civic affairs in Dublin, can realise the position of the town clerk and the assistance he was to every member of the old Corporation. The town clerk stands in a different position altogether from the ordinary official.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

That is one of the matters that I thought, all through my experience in connection with public matters, was rather unfortunate, that there were certain officials in a different position from others. I was not satisfied that it was a good system. In this case there is a new organisation. If we agree with the principle of a managership, obviously the manager ought to have the maximum of control. In this case, I admit that it is a shock, having regard to our experience of the position of town clerk, to place him under another person. If the town clerk had ten or twenty years' standing a different situation would arise. I do not think the present town clerk has ten or twenty years' standing as town clerk. I think the personal question scarcely arises here, and it makes it rather easy for us to come to a conclusion. If the manager is to have the power which the Bill intends him to have, it can be seen that it is rather stretching matters to have one official outside. I do not agree with Deputy de Valera that the position of town clerk is anything like the position of the Clerk of the Dáil. The town clerk has many duties in respect of the local authority which are very different in their ramifications. As a matter of fact, one might say that his smallest duties are at the council meeting. It is afterwards, in carrying out the decisions of the council, that the larger sphere of activity arises and greater responsibility. I cannot see how this Bill in its principle would stand if the town clerk were placed in a different position from other officials.

The question of the town clerk's personal position arises. Is it weakened by reason of this arrangement? I gather from what I have heard that Deputies are of opinion that it is weakened. I am satisfied that it is not. It will not be possible in the future to dispense with the services of the town clerk for any reason other than that the council, with the sanction of the Minister, could have done in the past. The manager gets no more power in connection with the town clerk than the council have. If the manager were to decide on asking for the resignation of the town clerk he would have to show to the Minister such reasons for that action as the council would. The position of the town clerk, as I see it, is just as strong in respect of the holding of his office as it was under the council. If that be the objection, the question then arises as to a derogation of status. Personally, I do not see a derogation of status where there is a new institution. His office will have perhaps in the future different lines of treatment from what it had before. He is responsible to the manager in respect of certain duties, and to the council in respect of other certain duties, but he has no duties other than what he has had up to the present. Examining it from all its aspects, I would say that the position of the town clerk is no weaker. He is not degraded. Number two, all the rights and privileges that he has had he still has. Number three, is he to be a part of this new machine and to fall into it or not? If it is decided that he should not be part of it then there is a case for Deputy Anthony's amendment, but I do not think Deputy Anthony's proposal is one which would be in line with the rest of the measure.

Comment on this

The President has told us that this is a new organisation of business. I would ask the Minister in charge of the Bill if this new organisation will affect the relation of the city manager to the auditor, and what will be the position of the city manager in the case of a surcharge. I want to have that position defined. I can find no information in the Bill in relation to that query. The President tells us now that the town clerk will be in the same position under the manager as he was formerly in under the Corporation. To put it in another way, the manager when performing the functions of the Corporation will exercise the same powers as the old Corporation did. But, in the case of the relationship between the Corporation and the town clerk, before dismissing the town clerk the Corporation, which consisted of the combined intelligence of a number of men, would weigh the pros and cons of the matter. In this case you are giving unlimited power to one man. We consider that an autocracy, and I cannot see how the President, whom I know to be very democratic, could stand over such a thing. I am not so much surprised at the Minister, because I suppose he has not got away from the clanking of the spurs and sabres. I know it is difficult for an ex-military man to come back to such mundane things as the appointment of a commissioner under the Cork City Management Bill. I know that it is far easier to talk in terms of war-planes and artillery and all that kind of thing, and it may be that the old influences of the Army are still operating in the Minister's mind, where you have authority of this kind centralised in one man. In this case, to pursue the simile further, you are converting the city manager into a sort of provost of the Army— the general hangman as he was known by Tommy Atkins. To come back to the original question I asked, I want the Minister to tell the House what is the position of the manager in relation to the auditor and a surcharge. There is nothing in the Bill on that point. I want to know who will examine his account. Is it the Minister? Is it the Local Government Department auditor? If so will he, in turn, report to the Minister any irregularity that he sees, and who will foot the Bill? In the old days of the Corporation if a number of members passed a cheque that was afterwards challenged by the auditor they were surcharged. In this case I want to know if the manager will be surcharged or if the Corporation will be.

Comment on this

The Minister remarked that the manager must be responsible for the clerk. If he is responsible for the clerk you might as well say that he is responsible for the council, because when the clerk is acting as secretary to the council, and not interfering in executive matters, you might as well put it down plainly that he is responsible for the council, and thus cut away all pretence of democracy. That is really what is in the Minister's mind. Let him say it out.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

It is not.

Comment on this
Mr. BOLAND

I would like to be shown how it is not. I admit that as long as the town clerk is interfering in executive work the manager should have a veto over him, but when he is acting, as the leader of this Party said, as secretary of the council, to say that he must be responsible to the manager is to say that the council must also be responsible, and therefore you might as well have no council at all. That is what is intended—to continue the old commissioner system. Do you think you will get people with self-respect to put themselves in that position, or that you will get the pick of Cork to be put in the position that they are to be responsible to this man, and to let him do what he likes in their names? That is what it means. The town clerk, as the secretary, should be responsible to the council subject, of course, to the Minister and not to the manager.

Comment on this

I must apologise for not being in the House when my amendment was called. I had to go to answer an important trunk call. Possibly I may be allowed to go back on the amendment. Deputy Anthony's amendment about the town clerk is, I think, a small matter having regard to the general terms of this section. I had an amendment down which I hope to move later. The real point in this sub-section is not so much the town clerk as the powers that are not defined which are given to the manager. The council's powers and authority are strictly defined, but if you go to court to seek a definition of anything in connection with them you are kept within the four walls of the definition that is there. But the manager, according to this section, "shall exercise and perform for and on behalf of the Corporation the powers, functions, and duties of the Corporation." The reserved functions are what are left to the council, which are really nothing. The manager has absolute and complete power, no matter what Act you pass after this. No matter what crops up in the council under this section the manager has complete and absolute authority and power to flout the council on any question, save and except the few reserved functions. What powers do they confer? They confer the power, first of all, of striking a rate and incurring the odium of the people, where it is high, while letting the manager slide out. He is the man who makes the contracts for which the rate is struck. That is the position in which you are putting the council. The members have to bear the brunt of the responsibility of striking the rate and other things. The manager is the man with the expenditure of the money.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

I am afraid the Deputy is wandering a good deal from the amendment.

Comment on this

I do not think any Deputy who spoke confined himself to the amendment. At least I did not hear any, not even the Minister. I have not wandered very far, because I am dealing with the amendment to Section 9. Is not that correct?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Amendment 33, in the name of Deputy Anthony.

Comment on this

This is the amendment to that section.

Comment on this

However, if you think I am out of order I will sit down.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

No. The Deputy is wandering from the amendment. He would be in order in making that sort of speech on the section itself, but not on this amendment dealing with the town clerk.

Comment on this

I will reserve the speech for the section.

Comment on this

Unfortunately the President is not here now. He said that he did not agree with me that the position of the Clerk of the Dáil was comparable with that of the town clerk. I did not say it was, except in respect of the position in which the town clerk would be acting as secretary for the council. In that respect the positions are comparable, I hold. The difficulty is this, that you are trying to separate the deliberative from the executive functions. If the main functions of the town clerk were executive, then take them over by all means, but you should have some other officer appointed if you are to have an independent secretary to the council. The question is: Are you going to leave the council without an independent officer to be their secretary? If the Minister says that he is simply taking over the town clerk as a subordinate officer to the manager on the executive side I have no objection. If the major portion of his work were executive it is quite natural that that should be done. But in order to understand the scheme completely I want to know what provision is going to be made to give the council an independent officer who will be their secretary.

Comment on this

I do not understand the point of giving the council an independent officer who will be their secretary.

Comment on this

Take time to consider it.

Comment on this

The person acting as the secretary to the council must do the council's work, and must do it properly, and I see no reason at all why he should not be subject to the supervision of the manager as to whether the council's work is done properly by him in so far as part of his work refers to the council. I do not see the slightest difficulty about it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister think that this House would be prepared, for example, to take his chief clerk as Clerk of the Dáil and to have him subordinate to him and at the same time be Clerk of the Dáil? Would members of the House be satisfied that his direct subordinate officer, who is supposed to do what the Minister tells him, should sit here at the same time occupying the position of an independent officer of the House? I for one would object, and I feel that we would all be entitled to object and to say that for this particular work we want an independent officer, that the Minister is acting in an executive capacity and is answerable to us, but that the Clerk is in an independent position and that we want to have him in that position. It seems to me that what you are trying to do in the case of this Bill is to take over an officer who, for certain duties and in certain respects, is in the position of the Clerk of the Dáil, make him part of your staff, and make him subordinate to your Executive.

Comment on this

As far as the case for a manager is concerned I think it has been said more than once that a far better case could be made for getting a manager to run this House—to have a manager to do the work, or in other words, to have a dictator. That is what it would really boil down to. Undoubtedly this gentleman is going to be a dictator in a small way. Deputy de Valera's point brings that forward, and by just stretching it a little further you could easily imagine some superman of that description running the whole Twenty-six Counties, that we should do what he tells us, with a principal officer here, simply responsible to him. That is what we are heading for. It is the fashion in Europe. It may turn out very well or it may not, but in any case it is not democratic, and so far we have not decided to abandon democratic institutions. It is no joke at all; we are heading straight for it, and the House will need to be very careful or it will find itself landed in such a position very soon.

Comment on this

I am not at all impressed with Deputy de Valera's attempt to draw an analogy between this assembly here and the Clerk and the clerk and the council in Cork, because the town clerk in Cork has as town clerk to serve both the council and the manager in the position of clerk and, as the President said, the greater part of his work will be in the region of serving the manager as town clerk rather than of serving the council. The extent to which the council will meet under the new conditions will not be very great, and the work that the clerk will have to do for the council will simply be the recording of their decisions and the conveying of them to the executive officer.

Comment on this

I can see the difference of our points of view quite clearly now, from what the Minister has said. He thinks of the council as having very little to do. Of course, he wants all the work to be done by the manager in complete control. I have had a very different idea, the idea that the council in its deliberative functions would be meeting very often and where there would be, for instance, a general purposes committee in the board of aldermen doing work, in which case the town clerk also would have an important position. Of course, that is obviously the difference between us.

Comment on this

A Cork City Parliament, clerk and all.

Comment on this

Yes, a Cork City Parliament, by all means, in a small way. That is the whole idea, as far as I understand it, of local government— a little parliament. Why not? It is a little parliament, and the only difference that I can conceive between local government and national government in this particular case is that the Ministry, instead of having a number of Ministers in charge of different Departments, would have one man in charge of all Departments, and that is the principle that I would support in the Bill. But, as I said from the start, I am opposed to the idea of putting the manager into a position in which he will be purely an autocrat, responsible directly to nobody except perhaps to the Minister, and if he is appointed by the Minister and is on good terms with headquarters, he can snap his fingers at the local representatives.

Comment on this

I do not want to be unfair to the Minister, because I do believe it would be unfair to fire a number of questions at him which he might be unable to answer, but I have asked a question which I hope he will be able to answer before the next stage of the Bill is taken up. I asked what the position of the manager with regard to the auditor would be in the case of a surcharge.

Comment on this

The manager will be in the position of any other accounting officer. He will come under the rule of the auditor, and he will have to pay any surcharges that the auditor brings against him because of losses to the public purse, arising out of his negligence or carelessness, or misconduct of any kind.

Comment on this

Is it contemplated that the city manager should have sureties or a bond? There is nothing in the Bill about that. A town clerk usually has a bond, but the city manager is going to be an angel who can do nothing wrong. He will have the whole responsibility for the funds of the Corporation.

Comment on this

The Minister has just stated that the position of the town clerk is that he will be serving both the council and the manager. That is just the point that brought about the suggestion I made. He serves both, but by this section of the Bill he is dismissible only by one. Therefore, he is serving only one. I contend that there is every justification for a distinction there between the town clerk and the rest of the officials of the Corporation. I maintain that if he has, in every sense of the word, to serve the council and the manager he should not be dismissible by either, but by both.

Comment on this

I would like to press a little further the point made by Deputy Anthony in relation to surcharges. This official will be dealing with very large sums of money. Roughly speaking, I think a quarter of a million pounds is the income of Cork. A few hundred thousand pounds one way or the other will not matter when you come to work the calculation out. The city manager will be dealing with the till. The area of his operations is very considerable, and his capacity to make contracts within that area is very ample. The power of surcharge by the Minister and his officials is very interesting indeed, but not likely to produce much of a dividend. I happened to have heard of a case of a bank cashier who did not turn down to his work on a particular day, a very unwise thing in certain circumstances. They went through his accounts and found that he was £187,000 short. This was in the old days of private banking. So they sent for him and found he was not as ill as was expected. He said he was coming down to the office, and came down. He told them when they challenged him, "Yes," he said, "not £187,000 short am I, but £186,994 8s.4d. short." They said, "What are you going to do about it?" and he said, "Nothing. I will get seven years, and be better paid than for any other seven years' work I have ever done in my life, because I know where the stuff is and you do not."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

That has nothing to do with the amendment.

Comment on this

I submit with every possible respect that it has. We are dealing here with the question of the capacity of a man completely unchecked during one accounting period and another entering into financial transactions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

We are dealing with the immediate question as to whether the manager should have any control over the town clerk or not.

Comment on this

Exactly, that is the point.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

That is the amendment, and the Deputy can make the speech that he is making on the section itself.

Comment on this

I am making it on the section in relation to the amendment. What we are contending is this: That unless there is some independent check on the manager, a check by someone who is not his servant, that he during that particular period, between his accounting period, is in a position to tackle very much larger finances than any surcharging powers the Minister will be able to provide. I am giving you an illustration of a man who between his accounting period did succeed in putting away more than any surcharging period would have got back from him. As a matter of fact, the story goes that that particular man agreed to pay back £140,000, and that private bank was very much better off with the £140,000 back than it would be if the man were imprisoned for seven years. So they agreed, and when he turned up with the securities they counted them and found that there was the sum of £186,994 13s. 4d. He said: "I am an honest man, but I have been underpaid and you are not to underpay a man in future who can do that with you. Pay me properly." There you have a case that is on all fours with the capacity of a manager without any control dealing with an income of about £250,000 and the credit which belongs to it, engaging in financial transactions uncontrolled and unchecked by anyone who is not his servant within his accounting period. I think that is a very serious matter.

As the President has returned I should like to come back to what I said a few minutes ago. I spoke from recollection, and said I would be very willing if my recollection was wrong to alter and correct it. I extremely regret that I am not in a position to correct it. I refer the House to column 778 of the 2nd March, 1928, volume 22 of the Official Debates. The Minister for Finance, speaking on the constitution of the Tariff Commission and contrasting the functions, duties and responsibilities of civil servants when acting as members of the Tariff Commission and acting as ordinary members of their Departments, made the following statement. I am prepared to read as much of it as is required. He said: "A civil servant must do in his department what the Minister tells him in the last resort. His personal feelings, his personal honour or his personal views do not come into the matter at all, but when you appoint a civil servant on a Commission he is placed on the Commission in the same capacity as anybody outside."

I am not concerned in any way with his personal feelings or his personal views, but I am concerned with the fact that a civil servant must do in his Department what the Minister tells him in the last resort. His personal honour does not come into the matter at all, and when you appoint a civil servant on a Commission he is placed on the Commission in the same capacity as anybody else.

I recall that not to stress it but to have, if possible, a repudiation of the view in relation to their duties and responsibilities which would be given by that document, that statement in the official records of this House, and to put against it the statement of the President that the obvious meaning of that, that the man may be ordered to do and shall do and carry out the orders of his departmental chief independent of his personal honour, is not the view of the Minister.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I simply adhere to what I said: No. 1, that a civil servant would be perfectly entitled to refuse to put on a letter a date other than the date upon which it was written. No. 2, that no Minister or the Executive Council itself can compel an officer in any department to pay out money to any person except a person to whom it is due.

Comment on this

That is the repudiation I wanted.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

As to the other question, I happened to be a little late for Deputy Flinn's speech, but I understand he mentioned that a very considerable sum of money was in the hands of the manager in connection with the administration of Cork. I think he said he had a revenue of £240,000, which might be misused or something of that sort.

Comment on this

If I may, I will give the President a case which came within my knowledge.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I only want it in connection with the manager. I do not want any other one. Is it the case that the manager can spend moneys which he should not spend, that he can maladminister or pay out moneys to persons who should not be paid?

Comment on this

That he could enter into contracts and could deal with the moneys, that he could incur obligations and could do anything which anybody in an ordinary case could do with money. The case which I have in my mind was that of a manager of a particular business.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

We do not want any of that.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with what you want.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I asked the Deputy a particular thing when he had finished his speech.

Comment on this

I am prepared to give way to the President when he asks permission courteously, but I am not prepared to be brow-beaten by the President.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

The Deputy had finished his speech.

Comment on this

I had not; I was on my feet.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

I understood that the Deputy had finished his speech. The President was on his feet.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I do not want any explanation of something that happened elsewhere. I only wanted the Deputy to speak with regard to the manager. I want to say now that the Deputy has no experience whatever of municipal matters or he would not have made the statement he did.

Comment on this

The question that arose is as to what would happen in the case of a surcharge. The fact that we were in a position to discuss the possibility of a surcharge meant that there was some possibility of a surcharge. In relation to these surcharges, Deputy Anthony wanted to know what was the position. The President was not here.

Comment on this

The President asked Deputy Flinn a question and he should not try to throw him off.

Comment on this

The President is at his old game of side-tracking and running away. He is a back-chat comedian, and we have to put up with him.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

The Deputy is an excellent comedian.

Comment on this

The President should not interrupt.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

I ask Deputy Flinn to deal with the amendment.

Comment on this

I will, if allowed.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The Deputy has not yet come to deal with the amendment on the paper.

Comment on this

Deputy Anthony raised the question as to what would happen in the case of surcharges. He was told by the Minister those surcharges would be payable by the manager. What I am suggesting to the Minister is that the manager, when acting inside the area of finance, can get into difficulties and do things indiscreetly, illegally, or wrongly. In such case an attempt to recover the amount of the surcharge would be waste of time. That is a difficulty that the Minister would have to face by a guarantee or bonds.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

All I have to say is that the Deputy has no experience of municipal administration when he makes that extravagant statement. If he had any experience of it, or had one-twentieth of my experience, he would not have made that statement.

Comment on this

Would the President state what experience he has of city managers?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I had many years of experience of the Corporation.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted from the Bill stand."

Tá 71
·
Níl 62
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move the following amendment:—

To delete sub-section (2) and substitute the following:—

"Every person appointed by or under this Act to be the manager shall by virtue of such appointment be a non-pensionable officer of the Corporation during the period of his office."

I think I have already referred to this particular point. Everything depends on the view that is taken of the manager; whether he is to be an expert, so to speak, as a manager of a business firm, appointed for a short period—for such period as he gives satisfaction— and his appointment would then be renewable, or whether he is to be in a position analogous to that of a permanent civil servant. I know that there is a good deal to be said for making the position pensionable, but we all know how slow a body, an elected body particularly, is to remove a servant even though he has not given satisfaction. If you are going to make this experiment of appointing a city manager you ought to make it possible for the council to regard him as an expert manager who has been brought in for a period, say, of five years. If he gives satisfaction during that period he could be re-appointed for another five years and even for a third period of five years. When I say that it should not be made a pensionable office I mean that he should not be regarded as a permanent officer.

I do not say, for example, that a scheme should not be drawn up by which a gratuity could be given by the council to an officer whose services they were going to dispense with if they thought it right, or that if a manager had served for two or three periods of five years the scheme should not be drawn up so that he may get a pension. I think it is wrong, however, if you are going to have this idea of a manager, in the sense of an expert manager who would have to the council in general the same relations which a manager in a business firm would have to a board of directors, that you should regard him in the same position as a permanent officer or civil servant. If you do that you may as well make the town clerk the manager and keep on practically the old system except that you get rid of your committees. I do not see in the new system anything, except in so far as there would be subordination at all of the manager to the council, other than that of the old town clerk. I say that if the idea of making him really responsible to the council were to be followed out. I am moving this amendment as the best way at this stage of getting the question decided whether he is to be appointed just as the manager of a business firm would be appointed for a short period or whether he is to be appointed as if he were a civil servant.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not, I am sure dream of suggesting that a county officer of health or a county surveyor would be appointed on the same terms as a city manager.

Comment on this

It is quite a different position.

Comment on this

The Deputy suggests that the position of city manager is the same as that of a manager of a business firm. The position of city manager is very different from that of a manager of a business firm in many respects. In the first place, so far as we are concerned, a manager of a business firm might reasonably leave one business and get employed as manager in another. The sphere in business open to him is very wide. There is not the same sphere in city management to attract people in the same way. Setting out to get men, particularly young men, to turn their minds to a future for themselves in this particular direction, and looking, as I said before, for men of energy and ability, at perhaps the most formative period of their careers, we must offer them, if we are to get proper city managers, satisfactory terms and fairly secure tenure of office. If we are to get the type of person we want we are not going to entice the type of person with the brains and ability which we want by issuing an advertisement for a city manager, and saying that we want him for five years. After five years there is nothing before him unless he gets appointed again, and after the next five years there is nothing before him unless his appointment is renewed, and so on with every period of five years. In no circumstances is he promised pensionable rights. He is dependent on the council that is dispensing with his services for a gratuity, or, as the Bill stands at present, for an allowance or a gratuity. The council that is going to dispense with a man's services and say: "We are going to advertise for a new manager at the end of five years," is not a council that can afford, if they are going to stand in a reasonable light in the public eye, to give a decent gratuity to a man who proved himself to be a proper person. In our view, the most satisfactory way to get a satisfactory city manager is to do, as we propose in the Bill, namely, to have him as an officer of the Corporation entitled to a tenure of office, except he is removed under the arrangement provided under Section 10, sub-section (5), and entitled to a pension or, if his services are discontinued inside ten years, entitled to whatever gratuity which seems to be proper to the Minister.

Comment on this

In the discussion upon this amendment I think it would be very advisable if Deputies were to bear in mind that this Bill creates an office in connection with local government much more important than any similar office which has existed before. It would be in the power of a city manager to affect in a very material and a very permanent way the entire prosperity and future of the city with which he was associated. We cannot of course take any chances that a person will be placed in such a responsible position who will not be in every way thoroughly competent to perform the duties devolving on him. In the system proposed in this Bill, adequate provision or satisfactory provision is made in the first place to secure a satisfactory manager, and in the second place, to dismiss that manager if he proves a failure. In so far as the Bill provides that, it is all right. But the Bill does not provide for the case which is much more likely to arise than the case of a thoroughly unsatisfactory manager and that is, the case of the manager who is just not good enough. We know it has been the experience of public bodies that it is very hard to get a vote in favour of the dismissal of any servant against whom no definite allegations can be made and who can only be judged by the fact that the results he has produced by his work are not thoroughly satisfactory. A number of arguments can always be advanced in favour of giving such a servant a second chance.

The same would apply in the case of a manager appointed under this Bill. If he is a very good man, the system proposed in this Bill or the system proposed in the amendment, will both have the same effect. He will continue in that office. If he is a very unsatisfactory man, he will cease to hold office. The council will be forced by circumstances, or by public opinion, to dismiss him; but if he is neither very satisfactory nor very unsatisfactory, if he is just merely good enough to conduct things in a manner in which there is no definite complaint, but which is not giving the best results possible for the city, then it is advisable that his continuity in office should be periodically reviewed or at least that the council should have an opportunity of reviewing it. That is why we think it would be a more satisfactory arrangement to have this position of manager regarded as an expert position in which you would endeavour to place some person thoroughly competent to perform the duties attaching to it and to pay that person an expert salary, a salary based on the fact that you know he will not be a pensionable officer of the council, and then to bring up that man's appointment for revision at regular intervals every five years. That five years' review of his appointment gives you an opportunity of getting out of any commitment you made with him, when you appointed him. If you find that his work is not all that it might have been, even though he is not directly and positively unsatisfactory, you can at the end of his five year period pay him a gratuity which will be ample compensation for the interruption in his livelihood.

The effects of this experiment in city government will be very hard to foretell. It may prove that we will find by experience that the old system was the better. Personally, I do not think we will, but we should not take the risk of the experiment being proved a failure by the chance of a wrong appointment at the beginning—and that chance is there. We have very few experts in city government. I do not suppose there are any persons who could claim to be experts except those who have been acting as commissioners in Dublin and Cork, and it would be a moot point whether or not they could honestly be described as experts. Some of the commissioners appointed to replace county councils which were suppressed proved themselves anything but experts. We must recognise the fact that the number of persons who will be able to send in applications for any of these positions that become vacant will be very few. We may be forced to choose a person who is not good enough. We will be appointing that person for life and appointing him in circumstances which will make it difficult to remove him unless he does something decidedly wrong. At the end of five, ten or fifteen years, there may be a number of better persons available and we should not close the avenue by which these better persons can come in and be given charge of administrative functions in Dublin and Cork. That is why I think that a very strong case can be made out for an appointment for a limited period. If it is the purpose of the Minister to provide a satisfactory scheme, and not nerely to leave the appointment for a particular individual, he will very seriously consider the amendment which Deputy de Valera has moved.

Comment on this

I wish to support the amendment. Since this experiment of camouflage dictatorship is going to be inflicted on Cork, and in view of that experiment and the other similar experiments they made in the last few years, each experiment carrying with it its host of pensioned officials, and the appointment of new officials, we should consider that surely to goodness there are enough of pensioned officials in Ireland at present without the need for passing further laws to pay compensation and pensions to new officials as soon as this new experiment has proved a failure. When I look at this section I am surprised that there has not been included in this Bill a proposal to enact that for every year this new city manager served as Commissioner there should be added a period of ten years to his pensionable service. That is, I think, the usual thing with the Department of Local Government and Public Health. I am surprised that when they started on the game of giving this man a pension they did not consider his years of faithful service as a Commissioner. I even yet wonder are these years that he served as Commissioner to be considered when his pension is to be fixed? And is that pension to be payable by the Government who bring in this sort of camouflage dictatorship as an experiment? If the experiment proves a failure, are they prepared to pay that pension themselves or is it to fall on the unfortunate citizens of Cork? We have already enough pensions to pay in Cork County——

Comment on this

Including what you are getting yourself.

Comment on this

There are pensions paid by the Government for national services——

Comment on this

Oh no; the pension is for services previous to that.

Comment on this

When we take into consideration that a large portion of the work of the National Government is shoved upon the local officials by way of emolument, we can realise how the public are pressed down by taxation. We have already enough pensions to pay, but it is rather hard that the people of Cork should be called upon to pay new pensions to dictators who were sent there to Cork against the will of the people of Cork. I object to paying pensions now to these camouflage dictators.

Comment on this

I realise that it is very dangerous for me, not being a Corkman, to interfere in the argument that is going on about this Bill for Cork.

Comment on this

You are running no risk.

Comment on this

Our friend says more by interruption than he does in his speeches. In the ordinary course of things I would agree with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health that the chief executive officer of any local governing body should have pensionable rights. But I cannot take the view in this particular case in view of the peculiar circumstances that this person should appoint himself in the first instance with the consent of the Minister for Local Government and then afterwards declare that the office is a pensionable one. This amendment must be considered in conjunction with Section 10 of the Bill, which is that the existing Commissioner in the City of Cork, who has been appointed by the Minister for Local Government, with the consent of the Government and without the authority of the ratepayers of Cork, who have to find his salary, is to be appointed as the first manager of the Cork Corporation. We must consider the amendment in connection with that particular section. I am opposed to the commissioner system and I look upon the appointment of the Commissioner regardless of whether he is qualified for the job or not and I look upon this appointment to the Corporation of Cork without the consent of the ratepayers there as dictatorship. He was appointed, without the authority of the people of Cork, by the Government. He was appointed without pensionable rights, and now, under Section 10, he is going to be duly appointed— also without the consent of the ratepayers of Cork. The Minister, with the consent again of the existing Commissioner, is going to appoint him to a pensionable office. I would like, if possible, that the present Commissioner should hold office for a short period, and that at the end of a certain period the council or the county borough of Cork should have authority to review his work. For instance, at the end of five years, the council that would then be in office in Cork as the result of this Bill, should have a right to say whether he should continue in office or not, and they should have a right to say afterwards whether his office should be pensionable or not. At any rate, I believe that the chief executive officer of a local authority, an ordinary democratic body, should have a pensionable office, But I would not say that he should have a pension until that is agreed to by the body elected by the ratepayers of Cork. They should be empowered to consider the matter and to say whether they are satisfied that he has discharged the duty of the office in a highly satisfactory way, and then they should be allowed to decide the question of his pensionable rights.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Deputy Davin said that this Commissioner was appointed by the Minister for Local Government with the consent of the Government. He has made that as a statement of fact. As a matter of fact, that is not so. The appointment of the Commissioner was not a matter that fell for the consideration of the Government and, consequently, Government sanction was not given to it.

Comment on this

I take the view that the Commissioner who is the local authority at the moment is by Section 10 of this Bill appointing himself as chief executive officer to the City of Cork without any regard to the views or wishes of the local ratepayers. I say that is a most uncalled for proposal. We must consider Deputy de Valera's amendment in the light of existing circumstances. I would say that the position should not be declared a pensionable one, and that Philip Monahan should not be entitled to pensionable rights until he has been properly appointed by some democratic body which may be set up as a result of this Bill or some other Bill of this kind.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I do not think the Deputy is right in saying that the Commissioner appoints himself.

Comment on this

The position is that Deputy Davin does not agree with Deputy de Valera's amendment. That is quite sound. Deputy Lemass considers it is very difficult to get public bodies to discharge public servants who are not giving them useful services. There is a difficulty about getting public bodies to discharge servants like that.

Comment on this

No; I said discharging servants who are not giving as useful service as might be given by somebody else.

Comment on this

But the Deputy wants to make it more difficult in the case of an important office to get the council to face up to their responsibilities and get rid of a manager who is not doing his work properly or not doing it up to the standard the work should be done. He wants to put the council into the position that they cannot adequately recompense such a man when his removal from office would be desirable in the interests of more efficient administration. It may be that the manager has been there for five years, and he gets appointed again for another five years. Then through falling into ill-health or through one thing or another, it happens that he is not giving efficient service. The council do not want to stand over him. After ten years' service they want to get rid of him. It is then that the question of pension arises.

Comment on this

I said to give him an adequate gratuity.

Comment on this

At any rate, the Deputy is making it more difficult for the public body to make up its mind to get rid of such a manager. You have a position like this: a manager is appointed for five years, and at the end of that five years he wants another five years of office. There are many ways in which the manager can play up to his council in the last five years of office, so that he would get another five years of office. It is much more satisfactory to make the manager an officer of the Corporation, giving them the power of removal if he is not satisfactory.

Comment on this

Surely, the fact that the office is a pensionable one, means that the council will be reluctant to avail of any opportunity they may get, if they so desire, to dispense with his services as manager. It is the universal opinion that councils, like governments, are not anxious to get rid of their officials when they feel that those officials are to be paid pensions. We believe the fact that the city manager will be a pensionable official will mean, in the minds of the council, that he ought to be retained, because if his services are dispensed with, then he will have to get a pension. Therefore, we believe that the whole question of the appointment of a manager should be left to the council. It has been the practice in other countries, and I think this experiment which it is now proposed to make is the first one in which it is sought to appoint a city manager for life.

As far as I understand, city managers are experts appointed for particular periods, and as Deputy Flinn has said, we have no objection to paying an expert the highest fees; but we believe in the necessity for keeping as many avenues as possible open to our educated young men. When we are filling specialist appointments we ought not fill them for life, but for temporary periods, so that better men can come along later and they will have a chance of filling these positions. The Minister proposes to confine this appointment in Cork, and presumably an appointment in Dublin, to the gentlemen who at present happen to be Commissioners. There is no reason why some avenue should not be left in the Bill by which university graduates or other men specially trained in city management could have a chance of getting the post after five or ten years.

Comment on this

The Minister has tried to make out that I am in conflict with Deputy de Valera's amendment. That is true to a certain extent, but I qualified it by saying that if in the ordinary course of events the position of chief executive officer became vacant under the existing system, the appointment should be advertised and made by the Local Appointments Commissioners. What I object to in the Bill, and where my mind is confused on the question of the amendment, is that the Commissioner who is administering the affairs of Cork Borough has actually recommended himself for the appointment of city manager and the Minister, in Section 10, agrees. That is done behind the backs of the Cork ratepayers and I object to that. If, after the setting up of this new body which is to supervise the work of the city manager, the members consider as a result of their experience of this man that he is fit and capable for the work, under those circumstances only would I agree that he should hold a pensionable post.

Comment on this

The Deputy is now proceeding to discuss Section 10. The proposal contained in Section 10 is that the present Commissioner will be the first manager. That is not being done behind the backs of anyone and it is because it should not be done behind the backs of anyone that it is put in this Bill. It is quite easy for a clause to be put in here setting out that the Minister shall appoint the first manager.

Comment on this

Why not the council?

Comment on this

As I explained earlier, what we are doing in Cork is a continuing experiment. We are passing from the Commissioner system to a council with a manager. The Bill proposes that the present Commissioner should be the first manager. If in five years' time the council persuade the Minister by the majority mentioned here in Section 10 (5) that they can get a better manager, then the first manager can be dispensed with. A gratuity can be paid to the out-going manager. I do not see that there is anything unreasonable in that or that there is any necessity to go behind anyone's back in the doing of it.

Comment on this

Why not leave the name out in this particular case? I am not making any statement that the person mentioned is unfit or incapable. I know nothing about him whatsoever. I am prepared to agree that he is a fit and proper person. Why not leave his name out of the Bill and adopt the procedure which is ordinarily adopted where a chief executive officer is to be appointed?

Comment on this

Are we discussing Section 10 or Section 9?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Deputy Davin is discussing Section 10.

Comment on this

So is the Minister.

Comment on this

I made a remark upon it simply because the Deputy had referred to it.

Comment on this

We are not even discussing Section 9; we are discussing the amendment.

Comment on this

I can quite see that the Minister desires to hand back restricted functions to the people of Cork in the shape of certain representation on a council with a manager. The same thing may well happen in Dublin, and I cannot see by what right this House should take upon itself the responsibility of saddling the Cork or the Dublin people with a pensionable officer not of their own choice. I can quite see that the Minister may want to have a certain person appointed. It is necessary to have a person well suited and specially adapted for the position. Deputy de Valera's amendment leaves the matter open, so that if after a certain period the Cork people are satisfied that the man appointed is the most competent person and they want to retain him, they may, with the Minister's sanction, make arrangements whereby after a certain period of years he will be entitled to a pension or gratuity. It is not fair to saddle these people without leaving them some choice in the matter. Deputy Corry said that the payment of the pension would come out of the rates. I do not think that is quite correct, because the State provides certain grants towards the alleviation of rates. In the circumstances I maintain we are doing a double injustice; we are saddling the ratepayers in Cork and the ordinary taxpayers over the whole twenty-six counties. If the Minister is adamant and is not prepared to give way on Deputy de Valera's amendment, I suppose we will have to go through the usual procedure, as Deputy Flinn pointed out, and this amendment will be defeated in the Division Lobby. I do not believe it is right for us to pass this matter over lightly and be satisfied that this man will be appointed by the House, so that whether he is liked or not, retained or not, the Cork people will have to pay him a pension when they get rid of him. The same thing will confront us in Dublin, and it is the principle involved that concerns me. I should like to know if the Minister is prepared to consider giving the Cork Council some slight semblance of authority, so that they can satisfy themselves before this man is appointed that he is the right and proper person and that they wish to appoint him. If they wish to show appreciation of the Minister's selection by a vote, he can get a pension when his services are terminated.

Comment on this

I am opposed to the amendment for very obvious reasons. If we want to secure at any time in Cork an official who would conscientiously carry out the duties imposed upon him——

Comment on this

Come to Dublin.

Comment on this

Or in Dublin, which is, of course, of lesser importance than Cork. At any rate, Corkmen have sufficient intelligence to know that if they want to attract to a position of this kind a man of ability they will have to pay him. I never had any sympathy with cheap talk about high salaries to competent and efficient officials. For that reason I am opposed to the amendment. As far as the Cork people are concerned, and those who will be their representatives in the Corporation in future, I feel confident that they will not quibble about a few pounds, so far as the salary of the city manager is concerned. I also know that, acting in their own interests, apart from anything else, they will make the position sufficiently attractive to keep the present man. I shall have something to say on later sections, but I am not going to follow the bad example shown to-night by Ministers and others in discussing subsequent sections now. I am going to confine myself strictly to Section 9. So far as we in Cork are concerned, we believe when we get a good man in paying him. I am speaking for a considerable section of the community when I say that we believe that this office should be made pensionable. I shall have something to say when we come to the next section, but I want to say now that I cannot understand the mentality behind this amendment. I want to find out the reason why an important official of an important city, holding such an appointment as this, should be a non-pensionable officer when, in places like Dublin and places less important than Cork, people holding positions not at all so important as that of city manager for Cork are pensionable officers. I say that a man in the position of city manager of Cork might be easily compared with a chief of a Department of Government. I, for one, am not going to subscribe to the doctrine that a man appointed to manage the affairs of an important city like Cork should be a non-pensionable officer and enjoy fewer advantages than the chief of a Civil Service Department. We have made this strictly a non-party question, but I am sorry to say that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party did not follow our example——

Comment on this

All parties have shown themselves worthy of the trust reposed in them.

Comment on this

When the division lists are published we can analyse them, and I think they will show that no matter what arguments have been advanced or what amendments put down by the Fianna Fáil Party or the Labour Party, the Cumann na nGaedheal Party was always solidly behind this measure.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Are we not considering a couple of these amendments now?

Comment on this

I want to lay stress upon the fact that Cumann na nGaedheal has made this a party question. The Labour Party has not made it a party question, as will be seen in the Division Lobby when we come to the vote on the other amendments on the Paper. The Fianna Fáil Party voted with us, or shall I say with me, on one or two occasions, and I voted with them, but on no occasion, in any division, do I find that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party voted with me or with the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

You did not vote in the right way.

Comment on this

I am speaking as an individual. In this case, I do not know whether or not the Fianna Fáil Party has taken any decision on the matter, but I am going to vote against Deputy de Valera's amendment. I would like some gesture from the other side.

Comment on this

They are steel-bound.

Comment on this

I will not say they are steel-bound, but I would like some gesture to show that they are not moribund. At any rate, I would like that they would give us some assurance as to their non-party attitude upon this amendment. I see the President smile.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

We had no Party meetings with regard to this Bill.

Progress ordered to be reported.

Comment on this