In Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the President of the Executive Council.
Contributions 1–200 of 405. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
"Go ndeontar suim ná raghaidh thar £7,973 chun slánuithe na suime is gá chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1930, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Roinn Uachtarán na hArd-Chomhairle."
"That a sum not exceeding £7,973 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1930, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Department of the President of the Executive Council."
As Deputies will see, there is comparatively little change in the Estimate. There has been a small increase in the staff of the office which accounts for that.
Comment on this
I move:—"That the Estimate be referred back for re-consideration." I put down that amendment by way of censure on the Government, of which the President is the head, because the Government has not, in our opinion, during the year that has passed or for the coming year, made adequate provision to meet the great social evil of unemployment which is, unhappily, still with us. We are not in a position to say definitely what the extent of that evil is. On several occasions we have endeavoured to obtain statistics from the Government Departments—to get definite figures about unemployment. We believe that these figures are available, but they have not been presented to us or to the public generally. They have been promised for quite a long time, but we are still without them. We can only judge by the figures from the unemployment exchanges. These figures do not represent the number of people unemployed even in the skilled trades, because we know that the people who sign the unemployment register are only those who are entitled to unemployment benefit. That is a very small proportion of the number of people unemployed. We have our own observations to help us. Any of us who go about the country, and who are especially acquainted with the conditions in Dublin, knows very well that there are very great numbers of people unemployed. The same applies to a very large extent to provincial towns.
We have had a rather remarkable statement which confirms my assertion that there are large numbers of unemployed in Dublin. That statement is borne out by the authoritative declaration made some weeks ago in the course of a discussion which took place between the Dublin County Council and the Commissioners with regard to the proposed alteration of the law in connection with outdoor relief. It has been stated that there are in Dublin no less than 5,000 families who would be entitled to obtain outdoor relief if the law in Dublin were the same as in other parts of the country. There are 5,000 families, the breadwinners of whom are able and willing to work, but they are not in the position to obtain work. They are fit subjects because of that for outdoor relief. I think that statement would be sufficient for us to say that this is a problem of such an extent that it ought to be one of the problems to engage the most serious consideration of the Government.
We have the present number of unemployed, and we know that the Shannon Scheme will be completed inside the next few months—within the present financial year, at any rate. It is expected that that will involve the throwing out of employment of a very considerable number of unskilled workers. We have heard nothing from the Government, no indication whatever, of any steps being taken by them to meet the increased unemployment which will result from the completion of the Shannon Scheme. No adequate measures, in our opinion, have been taken, and we have heard of no plans and no proposals from the Government to deal with this question, which, as I say, is a question which affects our whole social and economic life. Of course, we have the statement on record from the spokesman of the Government that it is no part of the duty of the Government to provide employment for the people. I trust that the Minister for Industry and Commerce will have his attention called to the very important pronouncement regarding that particular question which was made no later than last week by a very distinguished theologian, speaking at the Maynooth Union. He referred to the pernicious doctrine which was being preached to the effect that the State had nothing to do with unemployment, and stated definitely that "it was not only the duty of the State, but the interest of the State, to deal with unemployment, for indigence and unemployment in creased not only the number of the sick, but the number of the malcontents and the criminals, who are a blot on and a source of danger to the State."
I think it can be stated that it is as much part of the work of the Government to deal with the social evils created by unemployment as it would be their duty to deal with social evils which might arise from any other cause. If there was a danger of an epidemic of a serious, contagious disease, the State would not deny that it was its duty to take measures to protect the people from an evil of that kind. They might as well deny their obligation in that case as deny their obligation to deal with what is undoubtedly and admittedly a grave social evil. We have three classes of people to consider in this matter. We have what might be regarded as the normally employed people, mainly skilled people, who suffer from occasional unemployment, due to trade depression.
Comment on this
Or unemployment, due to movement of trade or the completion of works here and there. That is the position that is met by our unemployment insurance. It is intended to be met by unemployment insurance. We have, in addition, what might be termed the normally unemployed, and those constitute a very large number, indeed. We have many other people who get casual employment —short periods of employment on the roads or something of that kind —but who normally are unemployed. These are mainly unskilled people. It is for these we say that the Government have not made the efforts that we think ought to have been made, and could be made. You have, in addition, a great number of people who might be described as being normally under-employed. Among these, I would class many of our small farmers, especially the uneconomic landholders and their sons. To these, I would add the fishermen and people of that kind.
Attention has already been drawn on several occasions here to the fact that when the Government set out on what they call "a policy of economy," they effect economies by cutting down certain Estimates which provide money which normally would give employment. We have had various instances of that. We have an instance this year; there were very considerable reductions in the land improvement schemes on the Land Commission Vote. In fact, it always seems to us that whenever the Government set out on a campaign of economy of that particular type, the economy is effected by cutting down sums intended mainly to provide employment. That is not "economy" that can have any other than the opposite effect to that which, apparently, the Government intends. Surely, that is not economy. Moneys are saved nationally, or apparently saved nationally, at the expense of the ratepayers; that is really what happens. If the money is not available for distribution for useful work, then the local authorities and the ratepayers must come to the relief of the unemployed, because we have these men with us, and they must be supported. They must live, and they are a burden on the community. The community must support them.
It will not be sufficient for the Government to say, and certainly they are not doing their duty when they say: "We will not provide this money; we will not provide any further money which, under this head, in the past gave employment. We will leave that to the local authorities." That has been, as far as we can gather, the attitude taken by the Ministry on several occasions here.
What has been done by the Government in this matter? We have heard repeatedly trotted out here all the steps the Government have taken to increase industry, to revive trade, and, thereby, to create employment. I submit to the Government, without detracting in any way from what they have done in that particular connection, that these things in themselves are not sufficient to deal in an adequate way with this problem. They are too slow. Men must live while the Government schemes are being developed. We have heard in previous years of the fine things that the Trade Loans (Guarantee) Acts were to do.
I wonder could we get an estimate from any Minister of the actual number of people who have been employed as a result of the Trade Loans Facilities Act? I think we heard a statement here a few weeks ago to the effect that people had not made the use of that Act which they might have made, or which it was thought by the Government they would have made. If that is so, it is practically what some of us prophesied when that Act was going through, that it would not be able to do all the things expected of it, in the way of creating employment, by the Government at that time. About eighteen months ago, as a result of pressure from this House, the Government set up a committee to look into the question of unemployment. That committee made certain recommendations. What has been the result? I would like, especially as the President is here, to know what has become of the special sub-committee set up for the purpose of dealing with the question of housing? Certain recommendations were made in regard to matters of housing. The committee was confined to Dublin people under the chairmanship of a Deputy of this House. Although reference was made on many occasions to that committee, we do not know exactly what it has done, or what it proposes to do. The question which I want to ask the President is: has he thrown off his own responsibility, has the Government shifted its responsibility in this matter on to that committee? Is that the position? If the committee chooses for one reason or another—I am not saying who is responsible—not to make a report, and to do nothing, does the President propose to sit down and say: "I can do no more"? Is that the attitude of the Government in regard to that matter?
We were promised early in this session that a very comprehensive housing scheme would be introduced some time during the year. The only proposal we have is the extension, if it can be called an extension, of the present Act and of the grants available. Is that the last word of the Ministry on the matter of housing? A few days ago I was looking over the Report of the Gaeltacht Commission. I was looking at several recommendations which have been made. The Minister for Local Government was Chairman of the Commission, and, in the statement issued by the Government afterwards, observations were made in regard to those recommendations. In Recommendation 55, for instance, it was stated that a special system of loans and grants would be introduced for the improvement of houses in the Gaeltacht. In Recommendation 59, in regard to the question of State grants for the encouragement of land reclamation, it was stated that the Government were prepared to give effect to the recommendation and would have the matter explored with a view to the preparation of a suitable scheme. They are, however, still on that voyage of exploration, and we have had nothing tangible as a result of it.
In connection with recommendations for a comprehensive scheme of arterial drainage for the Gaeltacht we have it stated that one large scheme, which is outside the Act of 1925, for the improvement of Lough Corrib and the River Corrib was being examined. I expect that Deputy Fahy could tell us whether it has passed the stage of examination. So far as I know it has not, and the people in that area may still look forward to employment when its examination is complete. The same may be said in regard to other recommendations of that Committee. We have still to see their fruition. We have nothing but Government promises to depend on, and a comparison with the broken reed would be too good in that connection. Here we have this problem. We have work to be done. No one will deny that. There are many schemes of national development. They need not be enumerated as they are well known. Perhaps the Minister for Finance would not call them economic because they would not return five or ten per cent. on the money invested, but they are works of national importance which would add to the national well-being. As I say, the work is there to be done. The men are available to do it. The Minister for Finance will not deny that it would be possible to obtain money to spend on such work. You have those three factors present. What more is required except organisation and, perhaps, imagination and a little courage on the part of the Ministry to attack this problem in the way that it ought to be attacked? It has never been made the dominant issue that it should have been made, and no genuine attempt has been made to tackle it in the way that it ought to have been tackled.
We have now, at least, examples of the steps that have been taken in a neighbouring country to deal with this problem. Not alone, however, has no special Minister been appointed here, but the Government have not set up a special committee of the Ministry to handle the problem in the way it ought to be handled. We have those schemes to which I have referred, and I have no doubt that the Minister will sing out the litany again of all the various things they are doing. The fact, however, is that we have the problem of unemployment with us, and that is the test. Has there been a steady diminution in the number of unemployed people in the country? Take the City of Dublin, for instance. I have quoted figures which show that in Dublin, in any case, the problem is such that it should not be allowed by any responsible Government to continue. The Minister for Local Government, whenever this problem is raised, has always the one remedy —namely, the local authorities are empowered to deal with any man in a state of distress owing to unemployment. As I have said, I do not desire in any way to detract from the schemes which the Government have endeavoured, in a small and piece-meal way, to set on foot with the ultimate object of creating industry and providing employment. but I say that that is not sufficient, as, in the meantime, those who are unemployed must live. Whether is it better that we should simply throw these people on to home assistance or that we should provide employment for them which might not be fully economic, in the sense which the Minister for Finance would say is economic. I have no hesitation at all in saying that it would be a much better economic proposition for the country as a whole that such works should be provided, and that money should be specially provided for such work. That is why we have here repeatedly urged that money should be provided by way of special schemes, whether relief schemes or any other schemes, to give employment to men who are able and willing to work, but who are not in a position to find work, to give employment to such people until such time as they will be absorbed into other industries as a result of the Government's measures for the development of industry and for increasing trade.
The Government have deliberately taken up the attitude that they will not provide sums of that kind. Not only that, but they have gone further. They have reduced very considerably indeed the money which was available in the ordinary Estimates for employment, especially for the employment of unskilled men, who are the people normally unemployed. I do not wish to dwell on this matter in any great detail. I just want to deal with the question in a very general way, and to say that it is our belief that is the duty of any Government in power to make special provision so that people will be normally employed. It is because there is no doubt in our minds that the present Ministry have failed lamentably in their duty in that respect that I am moving to have this Vote referred back for re-consideration.
Comment on this
We intend to support the amendment to refer back the Estimate. We intend voting against the Estimate as a whole, because in our opinion scarcely any of the things that one would expect an Executive that had any regard for national interests to do have been done. In the first place, let us look at the Estimate itself. We have an increase in the Estimate for the Department of the President of the Executive Council. In our opinion, there is no reason for this increase at all. Some of us, at any rate, expected to see the Vote for this Department diminishing year by year to a much smaller standard than at present. The work of the Government is now thoroughly departmentalised. If all the branches of Government are departmentalised, as they are, why should we have to spend a sum, which is pretty well standardised at about £13,000 per year, on a central Department? After all, a great deal of the work of the office of that Department merely consists of sending along matters that come to them for attention by the proper Department. We think, accordingly, that a staff of these dimensions is quite unnecessary. Instead of a diminution we have an increase. The estimated expenditure on the Vote itself is increased by £668, and the expenditure on other votes in connection with it by £97. Instead of the decrease one would naturally expect, we have a total increase this year of £765. That is typical of the extravagant way in which all the Departments are run as far as we can see.
The amount estimated for this year for Central Fund Charges and Supply Services after deducting possible amounts for over-estimation, is £25,000,000. That is becoming practically a standard figure. It is pretty well stabilised now. If we look at the figure for last year and compare it with that for this year, we will see that it is pretty well stabilised at £25,000,000. If we remember that the total net product of our industry is only £20,000,000— that is the estimate given by the Department of Industry and Commerce of the new portable goods manufactured here—we see the extravagant way in which we are living. The Census returns give us £24,100,000 odd. If we deduct from that the products of industry which cannot be classed as portable goods, we come to the amount given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce—£20,000,000—so that we are spending on Government one and a quarter times as much money as represents the total net products of our industry in portable goods. I think no body of representatives who are interested in the well-being of the country can be content with that. When we make an examination to see how that money is spent, we have, of course, to go back to the items we have so frequently brought to the attention of the Executive, items like the Civic Guards, which are still at the standard of over £1,500,000; the Army roughly £1,500,000, and pensions running up to £2,350,000.
I have had an attempt made to extract from the Estimates the salaries over £1,000 a year. It is very difficult to do it thoroughly, or to do it exactly, on account of the way the figures are presented in the Estimate. I have estimated that 246 individuals receive in the way of salaries from the State, a total sum of £324,945. That is an average of £1,321 each. When we know that there are people starving here in Dublin, and that this country is paying 246 persons an average of £1,321, we get another picture of the type of administration and the costliness of the administration which we have. It is in order to call attention to that fact and to the general administration that we propose in the first instance to vote against granting this money. It is not with respect to administration alone that we are dissatisfied. If you take any one of the big problems that the Executive should have tackled, we find that in every one of them it has a record of absolute futility. Deputy O'Connell has mentioned the problem of unemployment.
He has pointed out that recently it was shown that there would be about 5,000 families here in Dublin that, if the statutory conditions were the same, would be entitled to outdoor relief, and everybody who knows at all the conditions of the city knows that there are numbers of families starving at present. We see no effort whatever made by the Executive to deal with the problem of unemployment. Some years ago I think it was the Minister for Industry and Commerce disclaimed on the part of the State any responsibility for relieving unemployment.
Comment on this
The quotation will not affect the fact that the Minister disclaimed responsibility for finding work for the unemployed as part of the duty of the State. When that statement was made we pointed out that it was the duty of any civilised State under present conditions to see that employment was available and opportunities for work available for those willing to work. It was one of the primary duties of the State, and last year I pointed out that the present Primate of Ireland supported that view and said it was definitely part of the obligations of a modern State to see that the citizens were given an opportunity of getting work or else were given the necessary means to live. A couple of days ago from a responsible authority also you have a similar statement made. Deputy O'Connell this evening drew our attention to it, and we want to know whether the Government still keep to the attitude which was indicated by the Minister for Industry and Commerce some years ago or whether they are going to accept definitely the responsibility which should be theirs.
Comment on this
The Minister will have an opportunity of telling us what exactly is their policy, because even though he may now say he did not make that statement, so far as we can judge the actions of the Executive are in consonance with that statement, because if they took seriously the responsibility of getting employment, or giving to people out of work, work equivalent to the work they had been doing, then we would not have the conditions we have at present. If they took seriously that responsibility, they would not treat as they have treated suggestions by which employment could be given in this country. Suggestions have been made by members on this side of the House which have indicated the direction in which employment could be given to 100,000 people.
We have still the same thing going on in the way of imports into this country of unnecessary articles. If you look at the last returns and see the position, in Class II., under the heading of food, drink and tobacco, we import into this country £23,020,000 worth of goods. Remember we are an agricultural country, and this is under the heading of food, drink and tobacco, whereas our exports under the same head amount to £21,173,000. Is it not obvious to anybody that there is something fundamentally wrong with that? Side by side with this unemployment we have emigration from this country at the rate of 500 persons a week. Between the years 1924 and 1928 we have had the total number of 131,137 young people emigrating out of this country, and that is only to countries outside of Europe and not within the Mediterranean Sea, so that altogether our total emigration is much higher than that. The figure for countries out of Europe last year was 24,691. That is roughly an average of 500 a week. The fact that the Government has failed to deal with unemployment and with the emigration problem is quite sufficient to condemn them.
Then, with regard to housing, something like 40,000 are needed. We pointed out here that the best way to deal with that was by giving to the local authority loans on long terms, and thus give them an opportunity of going on with their schemes. That was pooh-poohed here. We had the President and the Minister for Local Government, when that suggestion was made, saying that people with any sense of responsibility would not make suggestions of that kind.
Comment on this
I have just sent for the quotation. You will have it before the debate is out. It was definitely suggested that it was nonsense to talk on those lines, but when an election was on there was, a very short time afterwards, a great cry to suggest to the public that there would be loans made for houses.
Comment on this
I saw them beforehand and verified them. In any case, it is not so much that they pretended, in a time of election, to deal with this problem, but the fact that they have absolutely failed to deal with it in the past is our ground for complaint.
Then, again, we come along to the question of the treatment of agriculture. They brought in an Agricultural Credit Bill after it had been heralded for a long time as something which was going completely to change the position of the farmer and put him on his feet. We know the result of that. When it was brought in it was meant to deal with a different question altogether, practically the question of financing agriculture in normal times, and there was no effort whatever made to deal with the farmers who, as a result of the depression immediately following the war and the changed conditions, were in the position that some of the very best of them were unable to carry on. Their farms were unstocked, and generally the capital which was necessary to enable them to get on with their work was not available.
Then we come to the question of putting them on something like equal terms with those with whom they would be competing in the North of Ireland and Britain, the question of derating. We are told, of course, that that cannot be thought of, simply because the Executive persists in doing a thing they should not do, and doing a thing that there is no legal obligation on them to do.
Comment on this
Yes, it is very important. Why should it not be with me a case of "King George's head"?
Comment on this
Be it King George or King Charles, it does not matter. It is a question of £3,000,000. and I will constantly come back to it.
Comment on this
It arises in as much as the whole policy of the Executive in respect to the farming community is involved in it.
Comment on this
It is a matter of what is going to be the policy of the Government. It is part of the Government policy not to deal with the present condition of the farmers, and put them on something like an equality when dealing with their rivals. I hold that is a definitely pertinent remark in the present connection.
Comment on this
That is a matter which is being brought before the House and is being decided on, but irrespective of that, it is not in order on this Estimate.
Comment on this
The point which the Deputy has been trying to make; not only that point, but other points as well.
Comment on this
Can I not point out that it is not part of the policy of the present Executive to make any attempt to derate the agricultural community and to put farmers of this part of the country on a level with the farmers with whom they are competing in the North of Ireland and Great Britain?
Comment on this
It seems an extraordinary thing that we are not allowed to deal on this Estimate with the present policy of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
A question of policy is relevant, but the Deputy is not in order. He will have to accept that.
Comment on this
It was laid down here some years ago that no question should arise on the Estimates which contemplated legislation. That was accepted.
Comment on this
Recently we had the Minister for Finance making his Budget statement. That Budget statement indicated the policy of the Executive for the year. He spent a considerable time in dealing with the question of derating and in explaining why it was not possible for the Government to derate. I say that we have a right, on this Estimate, to deal with that question, and to say that it should be the policy of the Executive to derate.
Comment on this
What the Deputy is really claiming now is a right to make a speech on the Vote for the Department of the President of the Executive Council which would be more properly made on the Budget. The Deputy simply cannot go over on this Estimate every item contained in the Estimates, the Budget and Bills which come before the House.
Comment on this
If that rule is going to be acted upon as a general principle, then the whole question of unemployment would equally be ruled out. The question of housing would be ruled out, and practically every question that we want to discuss on this Vote would be ruled out. If this Vote is going to be dealt with only in the way of pounds, shillings and pence, and the number of officials the President has in his office. then the whole discussion on this Vote of the Executive Council has been out of order every year up to the present.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy does not understand the position. The Deputy has an opportunity to criticise the policy of the Executive Council, but he is not at liberty to advocate legislation on an Estimate. The ruling which is now being given is the same ruling that has been given every year on this and on every other Estimate. There is no change.
Comment on this
How can I or anybody else criticise the policy of the Government if we are not able to refer to the particular instances in which the Government's policy is in operation?
Comment on this
It is not for me to tell the Deputy how he can deal with this. I am telling him that the line on which he is going is not in order.
Comment on this
Then I must not speak of the question of derating and of the policy of the Government in respect to derating. Similarly, I must not speak of the policy of the Government with respect to housing, and I must not deal with the policy or want of policy of the Government with respect to unemployment, if that ruling is to be carried out rigidly.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been allowed to deal with the question of housing; he has been allowed to refer to the policy of the Government with regard to unemployment. The Deputy will not be ruled out of order, unless he is out of order.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot enter into an argument with the Chair. The Chair has ruled on a particular point.
Comment on this
The difficulty is that if I am ruled out on this particular point, it practically means that I am going to be ruled out on everything. I took unemployment as dealing with a certain section of the community. In taking housing, I am dealing with a section of the community. We have 78,000 people, an increase of 5,000 in two or three years, without suitable houses. I intended naturally to go on to consider other sections of the community whose position is largely influenced by the policy of the Government. I was taking the farming community and asking what was the policy of the Government with regard to the farmers. I had asked what was the policy of the Government with respect to the whole question of our trade. I find it very difficult to criticise the Government policy if I cannot proceed in a natural way to look at the sections of the community who are affected. In saying that, I do not wish, in any way, to disobey the ruling of the Chair. I am simply pointing out a natural difficulty.
Similarly, there is the question of land distribution. It has been estimated that at the rate at which land has been distributed under the 1923 Act, it would take something like 63 years to complete land purchase in this country. I am dealing with the Executive Council, and looking at the different Departments in their work. If we look at the Department of Fisheries, we find that the returns are diminishing yearly. We want to know, for example, what the Minister for Fisheries is doing.
Comment on this
I take it that the Executive Council have common responsibility ultimately for the policy which is carried out by any member of the Executive Council. In other words, when dealing with the Department of Fisheries, we have, in the first place, to deal with the Minister who is responsible, but we have also to deal with the Executive Council, for whom this Vote is, because they have common responsibility for all these Departments. It is the duty of the President of the Executive Council, if one of these Departments is not functioning as it ought to function, to take action with respect to the matter.
Fisheries and Lands have been put into one Department. There is a Parliamentary Secretary. I would like in passing to say that, in our opinion, most of these Parliamentary Secretaries are unnecessary. Now that the work has been departmentalised, the Ministers should do their own work directly. There may be some excuse made for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. But take other Departments, particularly the Department of Fisheries. Fisheries are particularly important as they have close reference to the economic life of the Gaeltacht.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell spoke of the Gaeltacht and of the attitude of the Government towards the Gaeltacht. Have I not the right to speak of a particular Department which has close relation to the Gaeltacht? One of the reasons why some of us here take a particular interest in that Department is because its work naturally impinges upon the Gaeltacht. If it is an efficient Department it will help the Gaeltacht. If it is inefficient, as it is, it is damaging to the Gaeltacht.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell dealt with the Gaeltacht in a general way, without reference to any particular Department. There is no distinction, as far as the Chair is concerned, between Deputy O'Connell and Deputy de Valera. Deputy de Valera will get just as much opportunity in debate as any other member of this House.
Comment on this
If I speak in generalities I will be attacked by Ministers on the opposite Benches for not mentioning specific instances. I am anxious to talk definitely to the point about things which can be definitely argued, but not about things which are vague or general. Let me now turn to the general financial conduct of the Ministry in their relations, for instance, with Great Britain. We have the thing exemplified in the condition of the Teachers' Pension Fund, where they took over a fund which was bankrupt, and we have to make good the deficiency—either the State has to do it or else the individual teachers will have to do it. That is typical of the way in which the present Ministry have conducted the business of the Government.
Comment on this
The President of the Executive Council is the very same President to-day as in 1922.
Comment on this
I regret to say that is not the case, and the Deputy knows it.
Comment on this
In any case, it does not matter. It is not material to this, or relevant. This only deals with the present year.
Comment on this
It will be dealing with the present year when we have the policy of the Executive Council, or want of policy, in connection with that; it will be very much a present-day matter either for the teachers or the community as a whole when they have to make good that deficiency. I was pointing out on de-rating how the interests of the farming section were neglected, and I wish to point out in that connection that when we raised the question of the annuities we were told that if that had been done there were ten millions which we are not taking into account. What is the position with respect to that ten millions?
Comment on this
The want of policy on the part of the Executive Council to conduct the financial business of the country properly when they are dealing with England and elsewhere. Surely, when we see the coinage question coming up this year and the deficiency in the Teachers' Pension Fund also coming up, we have a very good reason for bringing it up now and indicating why, in our opnion, the present Executive Council are not fit to continue in their present position.
Comment on this
The policy of the Government, as far as we can see, has been simply to run away on every occasion from the responsibilities which they undertook—the responsibilities which any body of men in the Executive Council should undertake. We had the Minister for External Affairs some time ago challenging us to deal with the question of status. I suppose that will also be regarded as not germane to this debate. Surely, when we are voting the salary of the President of the Executive Council, who ought, in general, to have a directing influence on policy as a whole, we ought to be allowed to comment upon the attitude which the Executive Council take in large public matters. Take this question of status. I should like to read what the Minister said. It was a carefully-prepared statement which he read.
Comment on this
It seems as if the Deputy was trying to lay down an absolutely new procedure altogether on this question of dealing with Estimates. The question of External Affairs was dealt with under the appropriate Vote. The matter was put before the House and a decision come to, and, under the Standing Orders, it cannot be reopened. The Deputy's contention apparently is that the Votes should be discussed separately, as they are at present, and that then, on this particular Vote, there should be a rehash of all that was said on the other Votes. That cannot be allowed.
Comment on this
If I might explain my attitude, it is this: that on this Vote we do get an opportunity of dealing with the general policy of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
Within certain limits. All we can do is to go ahead until we are pulled up by the Chair, because it is not possible for each one to define the limits. We will not come to anything like universal agreement as to what the "certain limits" are. I admit there is a difficulty; that it is better for us to say straight off that we cannot deal with the policy of the Executive Council on this particular Vote. I thought there was agreement that on this Vote the whole question of Executive policy should come up for discussion. I have been dealing up to the present with the policy of the Government with respect to internal affairs. I came on to the question of external affairs in the financial relations between this country and Great Britain.
Comment on this
I was trying to confine the Deputy relevantly to home affairs—I did not want to allow him to expand it.
Comment on this
If you are going to tell us that the Executive are only to deal with internal affairs, that is all right; but I understand that the Government are to deal not only with internal affairs but are to look after the interests of the State in external matters as well.
Comment on this
That matter was dealt with and decided upon by the House in the last couple of weeks.
Comment on this
As I say, it seems to be impossible, except in vague generalities, which our opponents on the other side will not hesitate to call such, to deal with this Vote at all. Surely we would want to deal with specific instances. Apparently, I am not permitted to deal with the foreign policy—if we might call it the foreign policy—of the Executive.
Comment on this
It seems extraordinary, at any rate, that we are not allowed to deal with it on this Vote for the President of the Executive Council, whose Department ought to be primarily responsible for dealing with external affairs. Perhaps it will satisfy the Leas-Cheann Comhairle if I say that there has not been a single noble national ideal put before the representatives of the people by the Government. There has not been, as Pádraic Pearse said, a way of wisdom or a counsel of courage put up to us. In every one of our main problems they have failed. Their attitude towards former comrades has been simply that of brute force, as evidenced by the Juries Bill and Coercion Act. Their attitude towards the foreigner has been one of surrender all along the line. The list of surrenders is getting longer day by day—is being added to day by day—and our contention is that an Executive whose record is of that type ought not to be voted the money asked for here.
Comment on this
The members of this Party decided to put down the amendment which has been moved by Deputy O'Connell for the purpose of giving the President, who is head of the Executive Council, an opportunity of defending his policy in regard to the general question of unemployment. So far as we are aware, the only indication of the Government's policy up to the present has been expressed in a statement made in this House by the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the 30th October, 1924. I hope he will come in to correct, wherever he can, the official record of that particular statement, or qualify it if he cannot correct it. On page 551 of the Official Report of the 30th October, 1924, the Minister is given as stating:—
"It is not any function of this Dáil to provide work, and the sooner that is realised the better. I do not refer to the point referred to by later speakers; that in critical moments, where there is an abnormally large unemployment problem, there should be immediate approach made to it by the Government. That is actually taking place, and there will be some approach to it, but the Government or this Dáil should not be held responsible for the provision of work in the country. It is not its business.
Mr. Morrissey: Does the Minister say it is not the business of this Dáil to see that people do not die of hunger in the country?
Mr. McGilligan: That is a totally different thing. The Government has, in so far as the Unemployment Insurance Act is concerned, seen that hunger will be stopped. I do not say it goes far enough. They have started certain relief schemes to keep off hunger from other people in the country. To state broadly and definitely that this Dáil ought to be able to provide work for the country is giving this Dáil functions which it has no right to take upon itself."
Now that, as far as we know up to the present, is the policy of the Government, and has not been qualified in any respect by the President or any other Minister in this House. That policy is clearly seen and shown in the action of the Ministry in cutting down by a very large sum the Estimates that provide work and give relief to the unemployment problem from year to year. I have been looking through the Estimate for this year, and comparing it with that Estimate which provides a State grant for housing, for drainage and for land improvement services. I find that on the Board of Works Estimate, under the heading of "New Works and Alterations," there is a decrease compared with last year of £208,110; for drainage maintenance there is a decrease of £1,000; for arterial drainage there is a decrease of £6,000, and for the Barrow Drainage there is a decrease of £55,000. In the Land Improvements Schemes, which give considerable employment in the rural areas, as the President knows, there is a decrease of £161,550, and under the heading of Posts and Telegraphs— Vote No. 62—there is a decrease in the labour charges in that particular Department of £128,565.
Now, we hear a great deal in this House and outside about the saving of the one million in expenditure this year, as compared with last year, but out of that total saving of one million no less than £560,225 is saving at the expense of unemployed people in this country. Added to that £560,225, there is a decrease in the Estimate under the head of Property Loss Compensation of £275,300, and under the condition under which the money was voted, employment to a certain extent has been given. Therefore, adding £560,225 and the £275,300, you find that the so-called saving has been at the expense of those who hitherto secured work as a result of the Votes passed by this House.
I come to the other side of the balance-sheet. In Vote 8—Local Loans Fund Grant-in-Aid—there is a large increase of £193,000 which, presumably, will give some employment and might be set aside for housing purposes in that way. There is also under the head of Local Government—Vote 40—an increase of £59,915, which Vote is for the purpose of giving State grants at a considerably reduced figure to persons and local authorities for the purpose of building houses. These are the only figures we have upon which we could give a considered judgment on the policy of the Government in the present financial year; in addition, we have it stated by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the Government did not regard it as their duty to provide employment for the citizens of this State. Their policy seems to me to be to shift the onus for unemployment from this House and the taxpayers on to those of the ratepayers. That is clearly proved from the policy of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, which, I presume, is approved by the President, and which, I hope, he will deal with when replying to the discussion on this Vote. Compared with last year, I find there is an increase of 16 per cent. in the rates raised for road maintenance purposes, which shows that notwithstanding that there has been an increase in revenue to the Road Fund, there is a considerable additional sum to be borne by the ratepayers for the maintenance of the roads and in giving the employment which goes with ordinary normal road maintenance.
Comment on this
The Minister can add to my remarks or qualify them in any way he likes, but I am giving the figures he himself gave to the House in support of his own Estimate. I cannot understand why there should be an added liability to the ratepayers for road maintenance charges when we have a gradually increased revenue coming into the Road Fund, but I quote it as an illustration of the policy of shifting the onus from the Ministry to the ordinary ratepayers.
We have also this supposed indication, although I do not take it as such, of the policy of the Government on the housing question—a considerable decrease in the amount of the State grant hitherto given to persons and public authorities for the building of houses throughout the State. Does the Minister really try to convince the House that that is a definite indication and prove that the Government are anxious to provide houses by way of State assistance so sadly and badly needed throughout the towns and the country districts of the State?
On the general question of housing, I am very glad that Deputy O'Connell has put a very definite question to the President, and as this is his own Vote, I hope that the President will give us a straight answer to that question. The President and the Minister, with the co-operation of other people who are interested in looking after the housing needs of the people, set up a particular committee to deal with the general problem of unemployment and that committee made certain recommendations. Arising out of the proceedings of that committee, a conference was called both of employers and operatives in the building trade as affecting the City of Dublin. As we all know, the President's outlook in regard to housing is confined entirely to Dublin.
Comment on this
The Deputy is now wandering even beyond the limits of Deputy de Valera.
Comment on this
Now that the President is senior representative of the City of Cork, I hope he will take an interest in the housing question in Cork as well as in Dublin. That conference was called together under the auspices of the Ministry and, I believe, at the request of the President who, I think, knows more about the housing needs of the people in this country and the finances of the housing problem than any other Deputy in this House. I give him credit for that and I hope he will, when he comes to reply on this Vote, state whether he is satisfied that that conference has failed to bring in any recommendation that would enable him and the Ministry to proceed with a national housing scheme, which seems to be as far off as when it was promised three or four years ago during some particular bye-election or general election.
Deputy O'Connell was right in stating that the responsibility for dealing with the housing problem which calls for the immediate provision of at least 40,000 houses is not a responsibility which can be delegated by the President or the Ministry to any particular conference, whether employers or representatives of the building operatives. If it has failed, let us hear from the President, whose Vote we are now discussing, the reason why it failed, and, what is far more important, let us have a statement of the Government policy arising out of the failure of that particular conference. We talk a good deal about selective protection and of building a stone wall and a steel wall about the country, and of keeping out anything that could be made or manufactured in the country, but the President must be aware that there is coming into this country cement to the amount of £500,000. My suggestion is, that if this problem is to be dealt with, it will have to be dealt with by using the raw material produced in the State and by having the brickyards that are idle opened, even if it adds an additional item to the cost of the housing scheme.
If we are in favour of selective protection let us give the benefit of that policy to the people who own the brickyards. Let us open up the brickyards and give employment rather than continue to import cement to the value of £500,000 per annum.
Comment on this
I am entitled to deal with the conference that was called by the President in connection with the housing problem, with the failure of that conference, and the results that have come to the State as a result of the failure of that conference.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy will give me the figures in connection with cement?
Comment on this
For 1928. I am sure the President has all this upon his finger tips. He knows a great deal about this matter. He has the returns that were supplied to all Deputies, and those returns will confirm the figure that I have quoted. It may not suit the President's particular purpose to turn up that very figure and say that it is correct. I do not want to go into the question of the foreign policy of the Government, or the problem that is created by the deficiency in the Teachers' Superannuation Fund, or any of those other questions, because none of them, whether it has a bearing on the Estimate or not, has a direct bearing on the points we are raising under this amendment. We all know that a good deal of employment has been given during the past few years by the Department, which provided large sums of money for buildings by the Board of Works and for drainage and land improvement schemes. I want the President to submit any figures at his disposal which will go to show that the unemployment problem this year is less acute than last year. The very fact that there has been a reduction of £560,225 in the Estimates which make provision for drainage, housing and building schemes generally, is proof that there must be a smaller number of men employed in that work than there were last year. I will wait patiently and listen with the greatest attention to any figures the President may give when he is attempting to refute the statement contained in the Estimates which he asks the House to pass.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin and Deputy O'Connell informed us that the reason the Labour Party moved to refer the Estimate back for re-consideration was to enable the House to have an opportunity of discussing the policy of the Government in the matter of unemployment. The raising of the question of unemployment undoubtedly gave the Labour Party an opportunity of conducting a general assault on the Government; but from the two speeches which have been delivered from the Labour Benches, we cannot conclude that Deputies there have any very clear ideas on the subject. Their conception of the manner in which the problem of unemployment appears to be dealt with would seem to be nebulous.
Comment on this
Yes, but I disapprove of the way in which the case was presented. The case is quite a good one, but it was not presented as it should be. The whole trend of the case made by Deputies Davin and O'Connell was the giving of Government grants in one form or another. It must be quite obvious that we cannot find a permanent solution of the problem on the basis of Government grants. We can tinker with the problem in that way, and we can give some temporary alleviation, but if the present unemployment evil is to disappear, it has to be tackled in some other manner.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy is not interpreting my statement as being entirely in favour of Government grants? I made the point that a Government grant would be necessary in the interval while a scheme was being prepared by the Government to provide a permanent solution. My point was that a Government grant would be essential until such time as a permanent scheme would fructify. Temporary schemes would, of course, have to be met by relief votes.
Comment on this
I agree that in any scheme for the ending of unemployment which may be devised there will be a period during which temporary distress will have to be met and temporary expedients will be essential. My criticism of the Labour Party is based on the ground that they have failed to face the fact that the main difficulty in ending the unemployment problem is the attitude of the Government. They do not appear to have grasped clearly what the attitude of the Government is.
Comment on this
I am going to explain. The attitude of the Government is that the degree of unemployment which exists is normal. They do not think that any special circumstances exist that would call for special attention or special measures. They appear to hold that a large volume of unemployment, such as there is at the moment, is a necessary phenomenon and, therefore, they can proceed by the ordinary recognised methods adopted in other countries where there are no abnormal conditions. The problem can only be considered in relation to its size. For three years the Government has succeeded in suppressing the information ascertained by the census of production in 1926 as to the size of unemployment. We could argue for hours as to the number of unemployed in the country. A certain number there is. It may be much larger than I think, and it may be much smaller, but on no occasion since we came into this House have we or the Labour Party, or anybody else, succeeded in nailing down any Minister to the definite statement that a particular number of unemployed exist in the country. Let us take a number that will not be so large as to call for the immediate contradiction of any Minister. Let us say there are 50,000. There are approximately 30,000 unemployed in insurable occupations—25,000 or 30,000. The number of occupied persons in insurable occupations probably does not exceed 30 per cent. of the whole. We know, in addition, that the particular period of depression through which we have passed has affected those engaged in uninsurable occupations just as severely as, if not more severely, than those engaged in insurable occupations. We know fairly accurately that there are some 25,000 persons unemployed in insurable occupations. The total number of persons in these not being 30 per cent. of the whole, we can safely assume there are 50,000 unemployed. That is a figure on which we can work.
Let us examine the economic situation that exists in order to see what are the possibilities of absorbing into normal employment 50,000 persons within a specified period. In the discussion upon the Estimate of the Department of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, certain figures were given by the Minister which will be of value to us in this connection. He pointed out that the total net value of the agricultural produce of the country during the year 1926, as ascertained in the census of production, was £53,500,000, and the total net value of the new transportable goods manufactured in this country was £20,000,000. He estimated that the net value of commodities produced by each person employed in agriculture in that year was £80, and the net value of the goods produced by each person in the manufacturing industry was £266. I have examined these figures myself and I got somewhat different results from those of the Minister, but it is not unlikely that we worked on a different basis, and I am quite prepared to accept his figures. It is quite obvious from the figures that if the existing unemployment, taken at 50,000 people, could be absorbed into agriculture the production of wealth could be increased by £4,000,000 in the year, and if they were absorbed into industry the increase would be £13,300,000. The increase was in the one case of 7.4 per cent., and in the other case of 66.5 per cent.
A calculation based on these figures would seem to indicate that if we worked from the opposite direction and concentrated upon increasing agricultural production by 7.4 per cent. and industrial production by 66.5 per cent., then we would have entirely ended the unemployment evil. Judging from these figures, one would naturally concentrate upon agriculture as offering the greater prospects and ensuring quick results. However, in that matter we have to take certain other things into our calculation as well. The low value of the wealth produced per year per head by persons engaged in agriculture indicates that many of those engaged in that industry are, as Deputy O'Connell described them, under-employed. Of course under-employment is just as serious a problem for the nation as unemployment. We could check that fact by reference to the figures published by the Ministry for Industry and Commerce in relation to the agricultural industry.
We have in this country 51 permanent agriculture workers for every thousand acres under crops and pasture. There are 31 in Denmark. We plough here 225 acres for every hundred permanent workers. They plough 1,007 acres for every one hundred permanent workers in Denmark. We have here per one hundred workers 165 milch cows as against 308 in Denmark. We have here 143 pigs as against 644 in Denmark. We have here 2,378 poultry as against 3,362 in Denmark. It is only in cattle other than milch cows and sheep that we exceed Denmark, and it is in the production of these animals that the least amount of labour is required. It is quite obvious from these figures that the agricultural production in the Free State could be increased by several hundred per cent. before those engaged in that industry here would be employed to the same extent as those in that industry in Denmark are at present. We could increase agricultural production by several hundred per cent. before we would have absorbed into that industry one single person mentioned as at present unemployed.
If therefore we are going to find a solution of the unemployment problem we will find it in the stimulation of some other form of production than agricultural production. I am not arguing against concentration upon increasing agricultural production, because under-employment is just as serious in agricultural production as in industry. Anything that the Minister for Agriculture, the greatest Minister for Agriculture in the world, can do to increase production of wealth in the agricultural industry will be supported by us if for no other reason than that it will result in increasing the standard of living for those at present engaged in that industry. We must, however, concentrate on industry if the 50,000 people who are without work at present are to be given work. The task will, I think, be found not as difficult as it would appear at first sight.
The figure of £266 per head given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce relates only to those engaged in the manufacturing of transportable goods and it does not include those engaged in such industries as house building, road making, electrical concerns, gas works and similar undertakings. If means were found to employ the greatest possible number in the construction and repair of what I think could fairly be described as the Nation's fixed assets, the number left to be absorbed into productive industry would be very greatly reduced. Deputy O'Connell referred to the matter of house building, and undoubtedly the construction of the houses which are at present urgently needed by our people, could be made a most hopeful avenue for the relief of the unemployment that is existing. We are aware that in embarking upon any scheme for the immediate provision of the 40,000 houses required, certain dangers and difficulties will be met with but none of them will be incapable of being surmounted. We had the matter of the Local Loans Fund discussed here. During the recent by-election in Sligo the Minister for Local Government made a statement before the poll that the Local Loans Fund was to be opened to local authorities for housing purposes. I wonder how many local authorities have succeeded in getting loans from the Local Loans Fund for the purpose of building houses, or was that merely an election promise made to be broken as soon as it had served its puropse?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy consider that it will be possible to make these loans in the short time that has since elapsed?
Comment on this
Perhaps the President will inform me whether it is necessary to have the Act amended so as to enable loans to be got for that purpose?
Comment on this
Will the Deputy understand that the local authorities will have to be ready with their plans to avail of those loans? The Deputy should know that schemes must be prepared for the acquisition of the lands, and there are the other details, and that all this takes time.
Comment on this
I will put the question this way—will the President inform us the number of local authorities whose schemes have been approved but who have not yet succeeded in getting funds from the Board of Works?
Comment on this
In any case even the provision of money from the Local Loans Fund to the local authorities is not going to solve the housing problem, but it goes a considerable step, because the provision of cheap finance is one of the main difficulties. If houses are to be constructed to meet the present requirements and to cope with unemployment it should be done as a national scheme. It cannot be left entirely to the local authorities to do it. That national scheme would involve the production within this country of as much as possible of the building materials required and which are capable of being economically produced here. I am not arguing in favour of the production of materials which cannot be economically produced under present conditions. Because if they could only be bought here at uneconomic prices then we should leave that aside until a more normal situation had arisen. But I submit that it is in periods like the present that the Government should embark upon capital work, building up the credit of the nation and making the necessary funds available.
Comment on this
There is not merely in the matter of housing but in a number of other matters a great deal of constructive work waiting to be done in this country, and that work, while not immediately reproductive, would, if done, increase the wealth and the wealth-producing capacity of the country to a very considerable extent. This Government has followed what has been described as a very conservative policy in the matter of finance. I think that the conservative policy of the Government in the matter of finance is as much responsible as anything else for the degree of unemployment which now exists, and for the volume of emigration which statistics disclose.
Undoubtedly, they occupy a strong position in the international markets. They can point with pride to the position which they occupy upon the American Exchange, but these advantages are very small when weighed in the balance against 50,000 people and their dependents in dire need and 500 of the best of our citizens emigrating every week. I do not know whether the President will maintain that the credit of the State is not sufficiently strong to allow more extended borrowing. It is, I submit, in a period such as the present that borrowing should be embarked on to finance constructive schemes and to enable the abnormal problem of unemployment to be dealt with. If those who are at present without work can be given employment at a normal wage the whole industry of the country will be stimulated. You cannot spend £1,000 in building a bridge and merely find yourself in the end when the bridge has been built with the completed bridge and a debt for £1,000. That sum of £1,000 has been introduced and is in circulation in the country, and every form of commercial and industrial life receives the benefit of its expenditure.
Let us examine the prospects of getting constructive work going and what the nature of such work would be. There are very few towns in Ireland of any size which are provided with decent sewerage schemes or proper water supplies. The absence of such conveniences has in many cases had serious effects on public health. A very considerable amount of public good could be done, as well as a very considerable amount of unemployment relieved, if means were found available to make it possible for these towns to equip themselves with proper public facilities. It is useless to say, as the Minister will no doubt say, that the Local Loans Fund is available for that purpose. The provision of loans to local authorities will not meet the difficulty. The question of the burden on the rates, the question of the difficulty which is generally experienced in regard to the area of charge, will still remain. If we want such work to be undertaken now by local authorities it is not loans but grants that will have to be made available. It is, I submit, only a matter of book-keeping whether the money is borrowed by the local or the national authority for national work. The undertaking of schemes for the relief of unemployment is at present national work, and whether the loan has to be repaid by the taxpayer or by the ratepayer is a minor matter. The one factor that really counts is the fact that if you can absorb 50,000 people into work, the capacity of the taxpayer to pay will be increased and it will not be necessary to impose new taxes because the yield of existing taxation will raise more than sufficient to repay the interest and sinking fund charges on the money borrowed for that purpose.
There are a number of other works. There is, for instance, the matter of land reclamation. I do not know if any survey has been carried out as to the possibility of undertaking big reclamation schemes in respect of tidal lands. I think it will be found that there are many thousands of acres capable of being reclaimed from the sea at an expenditure which would be small in comparison with the wealth to be created by such schemes. If the Government have carried out such survey I would be glad to hear it, but I do not think they have. Such survey would repay itself. Then there is the matter of erecting adequate defences against coast erosion, and also the matter of speeding up affairs in regard to afforestation. On the Forestry Vote the Minister for Lands and Agriculture informed us that there are 200,000 acres capable of being planted, and that it was the policy of his Department to have them planted in forty years. I submit that it is during an abnormal period like the present, when you have an abnormal number of unemployed, that such work should be undertaken, and not when the country is prosperous, and when workers have little difficulty in finding work from private employers. It would, in my opinion, be better to double or treble the work of afforestation now and to stop it in better times than to carry out the mechanical programme of the Minister, which does not take into account the economic conditions of the country.
There is also the matter of reconstructing dangerous bridges which are unsuitable to modern traffic. There are a large number of such bridges, even on trunk roads. It would be a useful way of providing work for the unemployed if the reconstruction of these bridges were undertaken. There is, in addition, the matter of the construction of decent schoolhouses. In many parts of the country the schoolhouses are a blot on our civilisation, and are altogether unsuitable for the housing of young children. A considerable amount of capital expenditure could be undertaken in that direction at present if the right policy animated the country. There is plenty of work to be done, and it is sufficient to absorb all those who are without work at present, if only some means were found to enable it to be undertaken, and if money were available. In connection with all the matters I have mentioned, there is one outstanding fact which should be noticed, namely, that they are not dependent for completion on supplies of foreign materials. The materials can be supplied within the country, and consequently there need be no export of wealth if we embark on such schemes. As I have already said, if we embarked on such schemes we would give trade and industry the necessary fillip to get them out of their post-war depression. The whole industrial body would be rejuvenated and the workers who would find temporary employment on these schemes would be gradually absorbed into permanent and normal employment in private enterprise. It would not, of course, be possible, nor would it be necessary, to absorb all of them into works of that nature, as the balance of them can and should be absorbed into industry. I am not going to deal with the question of tariffs, as the Chair objects, except in a general way, and in so far as it bears on the policy of the Government.
Comment on this
I do not think that we should have a debate on that matter, as tariffs require statutes and we cannot proceed to discuss the question of making laws on this particular Vote. I do not know how the Deputy can discuss tariffs generally.
Comment on this
People must take the opportunity of discussing the question of unemployment in the right way. This way precludes discussion on the question of tariffs. On the Finance Bill, for instance, we had tariffs, tariffs, tariffs.
Comment on this
Here is a quotation from the "Motor Trader," dated June 19th, 1929: I am not advocating tariffs, but I am reading this for the information of the House. It is entitled "Britain's Best Market," and it goes on to say:
"Australia is maintaining its position as the principal buyer of British car chassis, having taken 4,270 valued at £491,135 of the 7,020 chassis which were exported from this country during the first five months of this year. During the same period she took 218 complete vehicles worth £65,328. The principal customer for complete cars is the Irish Free State which, by taking 2,705 vehicles valued at £435,553 in five months more than double her purchases during the same period of last year when 1,261 cars worth £228,013 were bought."
Comment on this
That disproves some of the statements made opposite.
Comment on this
If the President will take these figures and make a simple calculation he will realise that we have paid something like 60 per cent. of £435,000 for goods that could be produced in this country and in respect of which we have established factories which are as good as any in the world, and we have workmen who were recognised all over the world as the most skilled in the trade.
Comment on this
We are dealing with the matter of unemployment, and I shall confine myself to the statement that 12,000 additional persons have received employment in tariffed industries since 1925. That fact, as I have said in a previous debate, constitutes a sign-post which points out, or should point out, to the Government, the direction in which they must move if unemployment is to be diminished in this country. I believe we can find work for at least another 25,000 hands in existing industries in this country if the necessary steps are taken to protect them. The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated that 50 per cent. of the goods coming into this country were at present subject to tariffs.
Comment on this
I want to develop this argument. From figures made available by the Minister of Industry and Commerce, he calculated that if we could increase the production of goods apart from agricultural goods in this country, by £13,300,000, we would wipe out unemployment. If the production per head remains as at present we will have to increase industrial production by that amount in order to absorb 50,000 unemployed. We are at present importing £25,000,000 worth of goods which are not tariffed and £14,300,000 worth of tariffed goods, which are not excluded by the tariffs now in operation. I submit that either if the tariffs now in operation were increased so as to exclude goods to which they relate or if the non-taxed but taxable goods were submitted to the same process as the taxed goods, we would have in a short period completely wiped out unemployment in this country. That is what all parties profess to desire, but the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, as represented on the Executive Council, which is the only Party who can give effect to their desires are deliberately ignoring the only possible avenues for reaching that end.
There are other expedients that can be employed in order to deal with the matter of unemployment. I am not suggesting them here. No doubt Ministers are taking a very keen note of the proposal advocated by the Labour Government in Britain who are giving very serious consideration to this matter of unemployment, although their problem in relation to their total population is less serious than ours. We have a higher percentage of our population unemployed in relation to the number of occupied persons than they have.
Comment on this
I am not sure of it. You have succeeded in suppressing the figures made available by the Census of 1926 in this matter of the total unemployed. We made a certain calculation based on the number employed in insurable occupations which we know, and related that to the number of occupied persons and we got 50,000.
Comment on this
If the Deputy added 50 per cent. to that we would still be under the English figure.
Comment on this
I do not think so. The last figure was 9.9 per cent. In Britain, for example, they have suggested that the Old Age Pension should be given at 65. That is done already in the case of certain classes of persons. They have also suggested increasing the school-leaving age and increasing the facilities given to widows and mothers. All that is to be done in order to keep them out of the employment market. By these three expedients alone, they hope to decrease the number of unemployed in England by 600,000 persons. That is a very substantial decrease, because if boys have to remain at school and if old men get pensions, vacancies will be created of which the middle-aged and other unemployed can avail. I am not suggesting that these expedients should be adopted here, because the cost would be probably prohibitive, nor do I think it is necessary. If we can do so, well and good. Quite a number of such simple expedients exist which can be utilised in order to decrease the volume of unemployment.
It seems to me that the Government, like a great many people in this country, suffer from an inferiority complex in this matter. There are a number of people, for example, who seem to think that Irish goods cannot possibly be as good as British goods although, as the facts prove, they are in many cases—in nearly all cases—better. The Government do not see this country supplying its own goods at any time. They lack vision in this matter. They do not seem to contemplate the possibility of its being at any time a self-sufficing and a self-supporting country. We, on the other hand, see Ireland not merely a self-supporting country but with a possibility of developing an export trade in certain goods. There is no country in the world, as far as I can see, doing an export trade at present with advantages that so greatly surpass ours as to make it idle to hope that we will ever have such a trade. We have, or will have, we are assured, in the very near future, available a supply of cheap power. We have raw materials in adequate quantity, and they at present constitute the bulk of our exports. We have workers who are as good as any in the world. I think all foreign capitalists who have come in here to start industries have testified to the good qualities of the workers available.
In the case of practically every application that came before the Tariff Commission the same testimonial was given to those engaged in industry here. We have a large amount of surplus capital available for investment which at present is invested abroad because of the unsatisfactory conditions and the lack of suitable opportunities here. The only thing we require is to have the co-ordinating influence of the Government brought into play so that all these various factors will be brought into line and welded together in support of a general forward movement to develop our industries. The Government have treated this whole matter in such an indifferent and casual manner that we can only conclude that they have no desire to foster industry in this country or that they are utterly incapable of undertaking the task. The latter is the true explanation, I believe. I hope that Deputies will support Deputy O'Connell's amendment to refer the Vote back for reconsideration, such action being, as the President said, a vote of no confidence in the Executive Council.
Comment on this
I suppose it would be too much to expect even in a debate of this kind, that we should escape the lecture with which Deputy Lemass commenced his statement here. We have been accustomed to lectures of this kind, and considering the line he has taken previously I suppose we may be thankful for the mildness of his statement this evening. I remember, before we had the advantage of having Deputy Lemass here to lecture us, reading a speech made by him in which he described the members of this Party as political mendicants. That was at a time when members of this Party, at least, were asking questions that now appear every day on the Order Paper from members of his Party in connection with roads, improvement works, and with the general line that should be taken in the matter of having better services extended to the people of the country generally. I am not going to refer at all to the fact that the mendicancy of that Party in another direction was going on outside this country, and is still going on. However, that, I suppose, is a side issue.
In case there should be any difficulty or doubt as to the policy of this Department in connection with unemployment, although I think it has been made sufficiently clear already, it is, perhaps, no harm to state again for the information of people who complain about the vagueness of the Labour policy in the matter of unemployment, that we have complained over and over again and felt that the responsibility for dealing with unemployment should rest with the Government. We have pressed, time and again, for the solution of this question on national lines. We have made the claim repeatedly, which has been running through Deputy Lemass's speech this evening, that until that question is dealt with the interval should be occupied with producing the temporary methods to tide people over the situation that they would be confronted with in that interval. We have reaffirmed repeatedly that it is the duty of the Government to take up that position.
Dealing with a matter dealt with this evening, the question of housing, not many months ago the operatives engaged in the housing industry presented a concrete housing policy whereby for a certain number of years they would be prepared to deliver the goods. In the face of all that, a debate of this kind is made the lever for charges that have been lightly, and with very little foundation, made time and again. It was doubly strange, coming after the statement of the official leader of the Opposition. That, in my opinion, was the most vague and disjointed series of generalities I have ever listened to in this House. I want to congratulate Deputy Davin on bringing back this debate to something like reality by pointing out where the failure has come in, and where we can point, on the present Estimates, to the very things that have been done, not to help the question of unemployment but to make it worse in this country.
On the Land Improvement Vote, a tremendous reduction was made in the sum available for improvement works. In the Office of Public Works a tremendous reduction was made in the moneys available for work in the country. We complain with very great reason, that instead of any contribution towards improving the situation, in the financial provisions that have been made, the situation has been considerably aggravated. I would echo what has been said in this debate, that the real failure of the Government in this matter is their failure to make unemployment a dominant issue in the country. The people in England who are entrusted with the responsibility of Government have declared that they intend to make this a dominant question, and that as this question is dealt with other matters of smaller importance will right themselves in the ordinary way. We want to urge that even now, after continuous neglect, an attempt should be made to give this question the place it is entitled to in the consideration national problems should get in this House from the Government responsible.
I want to urge that the whole policy in connection with improvement work and marine works should be reviewed. Even at the risk of being accused of continuously looking for doles here, we ought to point out the practical needs of large sections of the community and urge that a connected and national policy should be evolved, taking into account the whole question nationally and the many factors locally applicable to this question.
I saw within the last few days a paragraph in an English newspaper referring to prosperity in Cork. I am not enabled to speak on behalf of the citizens of Cork City but I did notice a paragraph referring to alleged prosperity amongst farm labourers in Cork County. If it does exist, it exists in some portion of Cork County I never heard of. In the rural areas of Cork County which I know anything about, there is no such thing as prosperity but there is acute poverty in the homes of the rural labourers and we, who have something to do with local authorities in that part of the country, are faced month after month with the task of trying to decide cases where able bodied men with families who, I am perfectly satisfied, are willing to work, come before the Boards making applications for assistance. I want to ask the Government again the question asked by Deputy O'Connell this evening as to what their attitude on the question of unemployment measures is—for instance, the question of home assistance. Is it suggested that it is really reproductive or economic to pay home assistance to unfortunate people with no means of employment? The Local Authorities are bound to make provision under the Local Government Act of 1925 for destitute people but is that the remedy or the proper way of dealing with it? It has been pointed out, time and again, that there is danger in embarking on uneconomic schemes. Could anything be more uneconomic than paying relief to people and compelling them to live in a state of semi-starvation with the few shillings they get from a local authority and denying them the right to live as decent citizens by giving them work that would enable them to do something for their homes and their children. That seems to be the issue. We have no doubts whatever as to how it should be solved or how we would attempt to solve it if we had the responsibility entrusted to us. We have complete decay not alone in the rural areas, but in a good many of the towns in the constituency I come from. I regret that year after year, during the four or five years some of us have been here, we should have to argue this question and point out complete failure to do anything in connection with it. There is no substantial employment that I know of in any of the rural areas.
I was discussing a matter with a constituent of mine within the last week. He pointed out a tract of country extending over several miles and said that in that large tract of country not one farmer employed a labourer. Either they were too poor to employ a labourer or they were able to do the work with the labour of their own families. I do not know whether the paragraphs that have appeared in English newspapers are inspired or not, but I do know that they do not represent the facts. People who believe that things are prosperous in the rural areas are simply living in a fools' paradise.
I want to urge again that something should be done in connection with the different matters mentioned here in connection with housing, and greater facilities to local authorities to embark on schemes benefiting the public health and relieving unemployment. All that work should be encouraged, financed and developed, and we should have from the Executive Council a statement showing that they are willing to reconsider the whole position in regard to the moneys which they refused to make available this year in the Estimates for improvement works, and that as an alternative an estimate to deal with this particular matter should be introduced into this House. The example has been set in another country of appointing a Minister specially to deal with this problem. Perhaps we are not able to do that, but we might do something in showing that we consider this matter seriously and in showing that we realise the responsibility that is and ought to be cast on the Government of dealing with it, not in a tinkering fashion but on a national basis, and on lines that are the only sound lines on which it can be tackled if there is a real desire to settle it.
Comment on this
This debate has taken the turn of dealing with a subject which is perhaps the most serious subject that could have arisen in this house. Naturally it arises on the Vote for the President, because he has responsibility for the policy, not merely of this year but of last year and of the whole period during which emigration has been so great and unemployment has been a continuing evil. The quarrel which we have with him in this matter is based on his failure to strike out a national line, a line which would break away from conditions in England which are affecting Ireland. He has been appealed to from time to time to find a common policy which would be a national policy. If he found a really national policy in economics to-morrow he would find people throughout the whole country to back him up. If he could cast aside his mere party timidities and look at the thing from a purely Irish point of view, and apply the principles of Wolfe Tone in the region of economies, the principle of complete separation economically, he would not find many critics from this side of the House. The atmosphere for which he is responsible in this country is an atmosphere of cynical reaction. I ask him to compare it with the atmosphere which was in the country between the years 1918 and 1920 when we had succeeded in joining the ideals of James Connolly with those preached by Arthur Griffith, the ideals of a democratic advance with the ideals of Sinn Féin. If we had got the Republic in the year 1919 we would have gone ahead with a set of principles of a progressive kind second to none in Europe.
Comment on this
Arising out of the complaint that the Deputies opposite were driven to vague generalities, might I ask if the Deputy is driven to these generalities by the attitude of the Chair?
Comment on this
I think I am entitled, a Chinn Comhairle, to compare a set of principles which would be really healthy for this country and which did exist and actuate us at one time, with the principles present, and to appeal even to the Minister for Local Government to get back to the old principles. Talking of vague generalities reminds me of a definition of vague generalities. Real principles are called vague generalities by men who either do not understand them or want to shirk them.
Comment on this
I understood that Deputies on the far side objected to being driven to talk vague generalities.
Comment on this
There came a time in England when the full flow of employment was changed into a condition of unemployment. That followed upon the Cunliffe Report. Subsequent to that, men like J. M. Keynes and Reginald McKenna carried on a strong controversy against Churchill and others because of the effects which the change in the credit system in England was producing, as a result of what Mr. Keynes called the economic consequences of Mr. Churchill; that is to say, the Government policy and the Bank of England's policy, which restricted credit and raised the rate of interest. That was the beginning of the economic slump and of unemployment, and that affected this country just as much as it affected England.
Comment on this
I am surprised at the Minister for Industry and Commerce, because usually his interruptions are intelligent. I submit that that is not. I suppose he appreciates that the subject I am dealing with is difficult and that any interruption is sufficient to interrupt a line of thought. The effect of the policy upon Ireland has been such that it could not possibly have escaped the mind of the President. He must have realised and known, as we all knew, that certain things were being done to produce certain effects. He has had ample time to see that the same causes in this country would not be allowed to exist, so as to produce the same effect. In the meantime we have lost between 300,000 and 400,000 young men and women who have gone out of the country. The evil still continues, and we acquiesce in a policy which is producing the same effect as the causes of the famine produced. There you had a British economic policy which glorified the rights of the individual and subjected the rights of the community to them. At present, the attitude is that the interests of the big financiers in London must dominate and that the interests of the producers and ordinary people must be sacrificed. And so the interests of the Irish people are being sacrificed.
I do not suggest that the President should set out upon a very radical policy suddenly. We have never suggested that. What has been suggested is that at least we should go as far as men who are sufficiently conservative-minded—such men as Reginald McKenna—have suggested, namely, that we should have a fundamental inquiry with a view to seeing what can be done in the matter of credit, as the root cause of unemployment. The President might even inquire as to what credit is, whether it is a mere plaything for the bankers, for the group of men who can ring the changes on the people's poverty generally, who can ring the changes on the rates of exchange, and so on, without there being any fundamental reality in the background.
He could find out whether there is anything in the theory that credit depends ultimately upon the prosperity of the whole people, that it is the people themselves who supply the fundamentals of credit, and that financial credit is only a connecting link, a ticket system, something which can be created by a little book-keeping. He could look back to see what had been done in the Great War when enormous loans were floated and the bankers were instructed by the Government to give individuals large overdrafts so that they could take up those loans. Where did that credit come from? So far as the finance end of it is concerned, it was simply created by a book-keeping transaction. These are fundamental to us as much as they are to Great Britain, and so long as we allow our thinking to be done across the water we are not going to get any further. We must try and inquire in relation to Irish conditions what are the effects of certain fundamental principles. At present any little prosperity that comes to this country is largely due to gambling on foreign exchanges. So far as producing in this country is concerned, the farmer cannot make it pay, the ordinary small business man can hardly make his business pay. With the exception of a few industries which have been protected, there is very little that is paying in this country. Any money made is made by the rotten system by which men spend their brains thinking what is going to rise or fall on the foreign stock exchanges. I think it is almost more degrading than betting on horses.
Comment on this
If the President were to carry out the policy of making a real inquiry into credit he would discover on his way that there is an enormous amount of Irish money invested outside this country which should be invested in the country. He would be looking for ways and means not merely of increasing the prosperity of the country, but of removing the real source of demoralisation and degradation, which is this gambling on foreign exchanges. We have had one example in the House, where we have been able to get a common policy on the question of the Irish language. There is no reason why the President should not have said to himself or to his Executive Council: "We will find a national economic policy, and if we put up a strong national economic policy we may be sure that we will not be opposed by the other side." We on this side are only too willing and anxious to see the country saved. It is not a question of moving the country up from one stage of prosperity to another stage. It is a question of saving the life of the nation. It is a question of saving it from the rot of emigration. We must set out upon a policy which will create industries in this country. Another fact which is staring us in the face is that we are too dependent upon English markets, and when there is a slump in England we suffer. Unless we are prepared to face that fact, by the development of Irish industries, we are not going to do anything real to change the situation. Our quarrel with the Labour Party is that they will not take as fundamental a view on this matter as we do—that they will not take as radical a view as men like James Connolly.
Comment on this
I do not like the introduction of the name of James Connolly. There is nothing in this Vote that goes back to James Connolly. The real point we have to discuss is, what administrative measures the President could take now that would give some relief to unemployment. I think that was Deputy O'Connell's line in his speech on the amendment. That was the purpose in putting down the amendment. It is manifest that on a Vote which occurs every year for the expenses of the Department of the President of the Executive Council we could not have a discussion, for example, on the credit system, or any of these fundamental questions. We are really dealing with whether the President, in his administration, could do something immediately, as distinct from fundamental or legislative changes.
Comment on this
The kind of administration that we have in mind must be actuated by a certain set of principles, and any mere tinkering with symptomatic remedies is not going to get us anywhere. Unless we are in a position in the House to discuss those principles upon which the country is to be saved it is absolutely idle for us to be here at all.
Comment on this
In rising to support the motion that this Vote be referred back for reconsideration I must express surprise that up to the present no Deputy has yet spoken from the Government Benches on this question of unemployment. It is a big and vital problem which should be tackled by all parties, and which should not be left to the Labour Party or to the Fianna Fáil Party. On vital political principles let Deputies remain as uncompromising as they like, but when a question comes up affecting unemployment, Deputies of all parties should throw off their coats in order to endeavour to solve it. The Government have not approached this problem in the way that they should. Instead of attacking the problem of unemployment, they have really attacked the people who are suffering by being unemployed. In order to prove that statement, I would point to the fact that this is the first year since the Government took office that they have not introduced any estimate for relief schemes. I am reminded that there was one other year in which they did not introduce such an estimate—this is the second year—but in that year a certain amount of money was voted for the purpose of building which helped, at any rate, in a small way to absorb some of the unemployed.
I am one of those persons who do not believe that relief schemes are going to solve the unemployment problem, but I do believe that half a loaf is better than no bread. Naturally one would infer from the fact that the unemployment insurance Estimate is reduced in comparison with what it was two or three years ago, and taking also into consideration the fact that no money is being voted for relief schemes this year one would come to the conclusion that unemployment was not so acute this year as in previous years. But it is no use for Ministers to try to bury their heads ostrich-like in the sands by saying that unemployment does not exist. It exists not only in Dublin and Cork and Limerick but right through the twenty-six counties and especially in Co. Donegal. The Government have not been paying enough attention to the problem. They have paid attention to matters that do not matter so much, but they have neglected their paramount duty in regard to this problem which is of vital importance to the people of the country. I believe that the principal duty of the Government is to look after the interests and welfare of the people. I believe that any Government that allows thousands upon thousands of men to be unemployed and to be in a state of hunger, and to have their wives and families hungry, is failing in its primary duty towards the people.
No doubt the President in his reply will refer to the fact that in recent years certain additional industries have been established, but I would point out that all those industries established, with the exception of the sugar beet and starch and the Shannon scheme, have been centralised in Dublin, and that the rural portions of the country are neglected to a great extent. In confirmation of that statement I would point out that, as far as the County Donegal is concerned, there is not as much attention being paid now to the problem of unemployment as there was under the Congested Districts Board. As far as the old Congested Districts Board was concerned, they did a lot to help rural industries, whereas the present Government, unfortunately, has done practically nothing to develop rural industries. Some time ago I raised this question, and I referred to the fact that over two years ago the Government made a promise that they would endeavour to develop the hand-spun industry in Donegal. Two years have elapsed since that time and still not one man or woman has been employed at the hand-spun industry. As far as the old Congested Districts Board was concerned, it gave facilities to fishermen which helped them to provide a livelihood for themselves and their families, but as far as the present Government are concerned, they have absolutely neglected not only to help the fishermen in Tirconnell, but also right along the whole coast. I believe if they did help, as they should do, a lot of employment would be found for people unemployed at the present time amongst the full-time fishermen and amongst the part-time fishermen.
It is true that for the past few years emigration from this country has been great. In that respect I would like to quote some figures. The numbers of natives of Ireland living abroad is out of all reasonable proportion to the emigration from other civilised and progressive countries. The percentages published by the Department of Commerce are: Ireland, 30.5 per cent. of her native population; Norway. 14.8; Scotland, 14.1; England and Wales, 6.3, down to France with .5. There are practically 26,000 people emigrating from this country every year. These people do not emigrate to America or other countries in any spirit of adventure or to go and see their friends in far-off lands. They emigrate because of the fact that they are not able to eke out an existence in the land of their birth.
Let us take as a modest estimate that it costs £300 to rear a boy or girl up to the age of twenty-one or twenty-two years. Seeing that 26,000 people emigrate out of this country annually, we export each year in human wealth £7,800,000. Let us see, for instance, if we exported cattle to America or Australia or any other country to the value of over seven million pounds and got no payment for that, what an outcry there would be amongst the financiers, and I suppose in the dovecotes of the Executive Council. I suppose efforts would be made to see that that outflow of wealth was stopped, but in this case this human wealth is emigrating owing to the fact that people cannot get an existence at home. While all that is going on, I believe sufficient attention is not paid to the problem of unemployment. To my mind, unfortunately, the Executive Council view this question of unemployment as a necessary evil which always must exist. I do not believe that is so. I do not believe it is a problem that would exist if properly tackled. I believe it is a problem that the Government should give every attention in their power to in order to cure it.
Comment on this
An aspect of the unemployment problem that probably has not been dealt with up to the present is the fact that unemployment breaks down the health of the unemployed people. In that connection I would point out that in the Estimates each year the Government vote a certain amount of money for public health services. I should like to quote an extract from a report made at a recent meeting of the Donegal Board of Health by Dr. Anthony Doherty, Acting Tuberculosis Officer for County Donegal. I may be drifting a little from the strict lines of the Vote but I just want to prove the effect that unemployment has upon the health of the people.
Comment on this
I only want to say that Dr. Anthony Doherty in the course of his report dealing with tuberculosis pointed out that while occurring amongst the wealthiest classes due to the inevitable hereditary influences, the vast majority of the cases of tuberculosis were from the poorer portions of the population who never would contract the disease if they were provided with proper food, clothing and housing conditions. He said further that owing to poverty the staple diet amongst many of the people were potatoes and that meat was a very rare visitor and consequently the resistance of the poor people to the disease was thereby decreased. Now this is a problem worth considering and I think it is a part of the question probably that enough attention has not been devoted to. No doubt Deputies will realise that when a worker becomes unemployed and if he has been in an insurable occupation after six months he is cut off from Insurance Benefit, he has no way of providing food for himself or shelter for his wife and children and I submit that the health of that man and his children are affected by such circumstances. No doubt the President in his reply will taunt Deputies who have spoken with not suggesting any remedy for this evil. One of the ways in which a large number of the unemployed could be absorbed is by the Local Government Department offering long term loans to local authorities for the purpose of erecting houses. We have been promised for quite a considerable time that legislation will be introduced along those lines.
Comment on this
We have been promised for a considerable time that local authorities would be enabled to get these long term loans, but unfortunately up to the present time they have not received them. We have also been promised that there would be a national housing scheme and we are still awaiting that. In Dublin, Cork and Limerick there are thousands of families occupying single rooms in tenements and there are thousands of people unemployed. There is a necessity for thousands of houses, and the erection of them would help to absorb the unemployed. The housing scarcity is not confined to the cities and towns. In the rural areas in Co. Donegal there are large numbers of labourers' cottages required. If long term loans, together with subsidies, were given these cottages could be built, and it would help to give employment in the rural areas.
As far as the Gaeltacht is concerned, we find that the Government have not dealt with the question of housing there although legislation has been promised. If houses had been built in the Gaeltacht area, and they are very necessary, it would have helped to absorb some of the unemployed. Another way in which to absorb large numbers of unemployed in the rural areas is by the division of land. We have been told that under the 1923 Act it will take 60 years to complete land purchase. I suggest to the Government that if they would speed up this matter it would help to absorb at least some of the unemployed. A lot of useful work could be done by paying more attention to the question of afforestation. We have been told on numerous occasions that as far as the Government are concerned they are anxious to improve the position in the Gaeltacht. We were told they were anxious to keep the Irish speakers at home. They have spent thousands and thousands upon afforestation in the Midlands and the South of Ireland, but we find that as far as the Gaeltacht area in Tirconaill is concerned not one halfpenny has been spent, not one tree has been planted, and not one acre has been acquired for afforestation. The Minister for Local Government, as Chairman of the Gaeltacht Commission, will recollect that certain recommendations were made. If those had been carried out I believe there would not be the same necessity, probably there would be no necessity, for referring to the question of unemployment as affecting the Gaeltacht. In recommendation 55 the Commission suggests that a system of loans or grants be introduced for the improvement of housing. That has not been done. It was recommended also that a comprehensive scheme of arterial drainage should be proceeded with in the Gaeltacht. That has been done to a very small extent, but there has been no comprehensive scheme of arterial drainage introduced at any rate in Tirconaill.
Comment on this
The report also mentions that loans should be made available for the purpose of setting up carding and spinning mills. That has not been done. I submit that the Minister for Local Government should impress on the Government the necessity for putting into operation the findings of the Commission. If they did so, it would help to absorb the unemployed to a very large extent as far as the Gaeltacht is concerned. Deputy Murphy referred to the steps proposed by the Government in Britain in order to cure the very important problem of unemployment. I believe that the Executive Council are not paying enough attention to that problem here, and I believe also that the Deputies on the Government Party are not paying enough attention to it. If they were they would have taken some part in the debate in order to impress on the Ministry the necessity for providing work for the unemployed. Until work is available it should be the duty of the Government to provide maintenance in the way of food, clothing and shelter for the unemployed and their families.
Comment on this
The President, during the course of Deputy Little's speech, asked if Deputy Little could explain certain things that existed, namely, the gambling of Irish money in ventures outside the country. In answer to that question I say that we certainly could, because if the Executive Council established a state of things here whereby you would have stability of industry, industries would go ahead and the people here would find means of speculating their money instead of having to go abroad. Until you have a Government that, by an adequate system of protection and a national system of credit, speeds up the industrial side, the people will gamble abroad. As regards this problem of unemployment, I grant you that you cannot solve it out of taxation. Even by increasing taxation limitlessly you will not solve the question of unemployment. There are other ways of solving it. Somebody asked for a definition of credit. Credit is the capacity to produce and deliver goods when and where required. With national economy the issue of credit should be related. We find in connection with the Shannon scheme that the period of repayment, if there is an issue of credit, is so short as to be detrimental to the community. The machinery for the Shannon scheme, let us say, is capable of working for a period of 60 or 100 years. Yet we find that the money advanced for that scheme must be paid within ten or twenty years.
Comment on this
I understand that the repayments of advances for the Shannon scheme are to be charged into the price of the unit over a certain period according to the valuation of the premises involved.
Comment on this
You will have to bring in much heavier metal before you get them out.
Comment on this
Take the Shannon scheme that the Ministry supports. When the Shannon scheme comes into operation hundreds and hundreds of workers will be knocked out of employment. What provision is being made for these workers? There is no provision made for them. There you have natural powers for creating forces and you have no provision made for a national dividend to pay these workers who are displaced from work by this force which is created by natural means. There is no provision made for them. Until this Government and other Governments realise these facts, any benefits that are to accrue from the labour-saving devices thus created are in the air. Take the question of machinery and applying it agriculturally. It is not so many years ago that the people went out and meadows were reaped with scythes and labourers were employed. Now the reaper and binder has come in and so have various other labour-saving devices. All this affects the local agricultural population in this way, that the labourers who would naturally get employment at home at this agricultural work have now to emigrate to Scotland, England and America. With those labour-saving devices which come into existence there is no provision made for a national dividend to pay the workers who are displaced by forces which sometimes cost nothing.
Arising out of this matter, I want to know will anyone on the opposite benches deny this fact, that the potential material required for manufacture and production are there to a limitless extent, that there are willing workers there ready and prepared to manufacture the raw materials that are there, in whatever form they are needed? All that is necessary is the linking up of these willing workers to the production with the raw materials. That can easily be done by national credit through a national State bank. The minute you do that you put purchasing power into the hands of the workers. The minute purchasing power begins to operate a bigger demand starts in the factories, and so you increase prosperity.
I was already speaking of long-term loans, and when Deputy Cassidy addressed remarks to the Minister for Local Government the Minister said "not necessarily" would legislation be brought in to deal with this question. We were given to understand at the Leitrim-Sligo election that it was to be immediately.
Comment on this
Oh, no. What I announced and what I remarked to Deputy Cassidy was that there was no necessity to get legislation to enable the Minister for Finance to give long-term loans to local bodies for housing, that it could be done without legislation.
Comment on this
It is like the analogy on the part of the local authorities. It is to their benefit to have these housing conditions in the rural areas. Housing conditions in the rural areas have been condemned by the sanitary authorities for a period of over twenty years past, and there has been no loan got to replace these houses. The sooner the Minister looks into the matter the better. I do not believe that the solution of the unemployment problem is going to come out of taxation. We could talk here for months about schemes and possibly the Deputies opposite could retort: "Where is the money to come from?" Unless we have somebody ready to say where it is to come from we would be talking for years with no results. My idea is that there are certain communal prerogatives, and one communal prerogative which will have to be established is that credit is a national asset, and that the benefits and profits accruing from that asset belong to the nation, and should be directed in a national way towards solving this problem of unemployment.
Somebody on the Labour Benches spoke about the steps taken by the incoming Labour Government in England on this question of unemployment. I am going to tell them that they will get no further than Mr. Baldwin got in that matter unless they take up and tackle the question of national credit.
Comment on this
I should like to intervene, sir, to make clear certain aspects of Government policy on some individual items that were raised here. Deputy Brady to-day, at question time, asked a certain number of questions dealing with the percentage to be allowed by the local authorities to Irish manufacture. The questions were along very general lines and the answers were along very general lines, and were, therefore, not so very satisfactory as either the Deputy himself or any other person in the House might like. The only contribution that can be made towards improving a situation like that is to take one particular item and to get thoroughly clear with that. Because you cannot improve the purchasing of Irish-manufactured goods by local authorities, you cannot improve the position of Irish manufacture in the country by saying simply that local authorities may give a particular preference to Irish manufacture. In the same way when dealing with the particular question of unemployment, Deputies on the far side are right to be extremely nervous of having it thrown up at them that they are simply talking in vague generalities. The only thing to do is to get one particular aspect—to get one type of work that can be done and state the case against the Executive Council here with reference to that particular class of work. In order that Deputies may be in a position to attack more clearly the Executive Council in the matter, for that and for the general benefit I want to state the policy with regard to certain things. Housing has been referred to here. Deputy Murphy on the Labour Benches said that the Deputies of the Labour Party had declared that, given certain conditions, they were prepared to throw their whole weight in with a national housing policy. The policy of the members of the Executive Council is this: that they are prepared to give the local authorities, in the matter of building houses for the working classes, a grant of £60 per house plus a long-term loan, a loan for 35 years at 5¾ per cent. forthwith.
Comment on this
In addition, where the local authorities will strike a rate of 1/- in the £, the Executive Council is prepared to increase the grant in respect of the house to £72. The Executive Council is prepared to give a grant of £45 to every private person building a house within the regulations laid down by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, and it is prepared to give a grant of £50 in respect of houses built under the Labourers Acts. Deputies have been charging us with promising that there was going to be a national housing policy. Like some other quotations that have been mentioned here, I would like to see the quotation of a national housing policy given from these benches. It is true, as Deputies on the other side have said, that it should not be left to the Labour Party or to the Fianna Fáil Party to produce this policy. It has not been left to them. What I would like to hear from the Deputies on the Labour Benches or the Fianna Fáil Benches is a criticism of the details of that policy.
Deputies have stated that the idea of giving long-term loans was brought forward in connection with the Sligo-Leitrim election. Deputies ought not to be too sensitive in regard to elections. I hope that Deputy Cassidy will not say, when he sees a circular to local authorities either to-day or to-morrow in regard to the whole position, that it was because of some remarks of his to-day that it was sent out so quickly. Unfortunately responsible Ministers dealing with such matters cannot get a vague and general idea and say that that is a solution. They have to work out the details of it. The details of the housing policy and of the assistance given to local authorities in the matter will, as part of the Government's policy, be based upon the summing up by the local authority of the housing needs of their districts and the shouldering by them of fifty per cent. of the cost over and above the amount due and which cannot be paid in rent by the tenants. That is the Government's policy in regard to housing.
It has been suggested that part of the Government's policy in the matter of roads has been to throw on local authorities more responsibility for their cost. That is not a fact. Every year since the end of 1924 the actual amount of work done by money provided by ratepayers, whether through rates or loans, has been decreasing. It decreased in the year 1925 from £1,404,000 to £1,410,000 in 1926; from £1,336,000 in 1927 to £1,202,000 in 1928 and to £1,107,000 in 1929. So far as the Road Fund is concerned, the road users are responsible for the employment of every one out of two men employed on trunk roads, for every three out of ten men employed on link roads, and for every ten out of eleven men employed on road construction. It is not therefore a fact that the Government's policy with regard to roads is increasing the burden on ratepayers.
As I explained on the Local Government Estimate, certain counties have been shirking their responsibility in the matter of roads. These counties have been brought to heel this year, to a certain extent at any rate. There are other counties which, compared with 1914, are contributing more in regard to roads than we might reasonably expect them to contribute. The question of State policy in regard to assisting local authorities to carry out necessary public health works, such as water and sewerage schemes, has been mentioned, and it has been suggested that the total cost of that work should not be allowed to fall on local authorities. It is not the policy of the Executive Council to make a State contribution to local authorities for that work. At present I think that there is only one county for which the charges for these matters are county-at-large charges. I feel that the first step in bringing about any change in the financing of these schemes must be to pass to a county-at-large charge. Deputy Everett shakes his head. At any rate, I am not prepared to subscribe to the suggestion that there should be a State grant for these matters. You cannot, economically and efficiently, review the position of the country as regards public health services and safely deal with the financing of them until you have a County Medical Officer of Health standing over the health position in each county, taking such problems as those which exist, and putting them into their proper order of urgency and importance, considering the amount of money that may be required for the immediate solving of all these problems.
The Executive Council plead guilty to having a policy of not giving State grants to assist local authorities to carry out such matters, but every possible encouragement is being given to them and they are being urged to solve these problems and the necessary loans are being given and have been provided for years past. I do not at all subscribe to the suggestion which Deputy Lemass makes that if you put unemployed persons to mending bridges and carrying out works of that kind the cost will not have to be met. The cost will have to be met, and it is because the cost will have to be met that the Government's policy in these particular matters is what it is.
Deputy Cassidy and others spoke of the Gaeltacht. Deputy Cassidy referred to the recommendations which the Committee made in regard to housing, drainage, and carding mills. The Executive Council have already taken decisions with regard to additional housing facilities which have to be made available in the Gaeltacht. The final administrative details of the matter have to be settled, but it is very near being an established fact that additional facilities will be available which will be on lines somewhat similar to those recommended in the Gaeltacht report. The position in regard to drainage is that you have an Act dealing with minor drainage schemes and another Act dealing with major schemes. If the Deputy can point out, as perhaps it could be pointed out, that there are schemes of drainage to be done in the area he speaks of which do not come within the Acts, or, if they do, which have not received proper attention, it would be a definite contribution to the debate and it might be even a definite charge against the Executive Council. Until, however, the Deputy gets down to closer grips with regard to these districts, one is unable to give him a complete answer in regard to such arterial drainage schemes.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say how far the minor Drainage Act has been utilised up to the present?
Comment on this
I have not the information at hand to answer the Deputy, but I ask him to recall that in the matter of minor schemes, in order to facilitate their being carried out, we cut out central interference entirely. We embodied in the Act a definite percentage grant on the total expenditure and we left the carrying out of the schemes to the county councils and their machinery.
Comment on this
The reason I ask is that it was admitted during the debate on that Bill that it was an experiment. I thought that, as the Minister mentioned it, we might be told how far it has been successful up to the present.
Comment on this
The Deputy can get such information as we have in the Department by putting down a question. Definite arrangements have been made in the Department for supervising to such extent as is desirable minor schemes in drainage but, in so far as interference with them or the holding up of schemes, there is no central machinery that can interfere with them. On the question of the woollen industry, I do not agree with the Deputy that nothing has been done in the matter. I would like the Deputy to repeat what he said on the Estimate for the Ministry of Fisheries with regard to the woollen industry.
Comment on this
I said that as far as the hand-spun industry, as apart from the home-spun industry, is concerned nothing has been done up to the present time and no employment has been given in Co. Donegal. It was promised that carders, breakers and dyeing vats would be sent to Ardara. That promise has not been carried out although it was given before Christmas.
Comment on this
I want to answer the Deputy as completely as I can. I have said all I can with regard to the questions of housing and drainage. The matter of the woollen industry has been given a very great amount of consideration by the Department responsible for it. As far as details are concerned, I would suggest that he could raise them on the Estimate of the Minister for Fisheries. It has been suggested by Deputies on previous occasions that I said that the Government's contribution to the unemployment problem was that there was home assistance to be got. The fact is that where it has not been possible to absorb the total number of unemployed in the work that the Executive Council by its help has stimulated in the country, the policy of the Executive Council has been to make such provision as it has made, so that the able-bodied destitute are entitled to home relief to which they were not entitled until the present Executive Council changed the position.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that the housing grants were available under the Labourers Acts. If they are available under the Labourers Acts, does he not take into consideration that labourers' cottages are in a different category from ordinary houses? In the case of ordinary houses the citizen builds his own house, but in the case of labourers' cottages, land has to be acquired for the site. I think the Department should take into consideration the advisability of increasing the grant. The other question I want to ask refers to county-at-large charges for sewerage systems and water supply schemes. Does the Minister intend to introduce legislation to bring that into operation?
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister what price has he in mind? What will be the cost of these labourers' houses? Has he a fixed sum in his mind as to what they will cost?
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned certain things to which the Executive Council would have to plead guilty. He mentioned one specific thing, but I am afraid there are other matters to which the Executive Council would be compelled to plead guilty if they were only honest about their policy. Of course, as might be said in regard to myself, there are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in the Minister's philosophy. What is the policy of the Executive Council in regard to all those things to which we should have been entitled under the Treaty or as a result of the Treaty? Our past should have taught us that there were certain things to which we were entitled. At least we thought we were entitled to those things, but when it came to putting the matter to a test, we discovered that they were not our property at all. A few matters have arisen very recently which bring up the question of ownership of the territorial waters which we were led to believe were the property of the Free State. We were led to believe that the territorial waters not only around the immediate shores of the Free State but the territorial waters around the Six Counties were the property of the Free State.
I remember a prosecution arising out of a case in Belfast Lough, and at that time the case was dismissed for the simple reason that the contention was put up that Belfast Lough was included in the territorial waters of the Free State. Whether that is so or not I do not know. It does not immediately concern us as the moment, but there is one thing which does concern us, and it is this: whether or not we are entitled to the territorial waters around the Free State we want to know the attitude of the Executive Council towards the things which are supposed to be their property and which were supposed to be our exclusive right according to the Treaty. We have the case of the Derry Bridge. We asked the Minister to oppose the erection of the bridge across the Foyle at Derry unless there was an opening span, so that the waters of the Free State should be kept exclusively for the Free State, and so that there should be a free pass for any boats that might come in there. We never got any expression of opinion from the Executive Council as to whether they owned the territorial waters or not. If they do not own the territorial waters then all this talk has been humbug from the time of the Treaty.
Comment on this
I want to know whether we own the territorial waters this year or last year. The bridge has been built this year. Last week nets and boats were seized on the Foyle by armed people who came from the Six Counties. If we owned the territorial waters this year we owned them last year and every other year. If we do not own them this year we never owned them. I want to know the policy of the Executive Council in regard to that matter.
Deputy Cassidy referred to the question of unemployment in Donegal. For the past four or five years we have had nothing but rank humbug in regard to the Gaeltacht as a whole and Donegal in particular. The treatment of Donegal is so noticeable that it has been called by people who, one could not say, had any special sympathy with it, the Cinderella of the Free State. It has been left even without the glass slippers. There has been nothing but humbug in regard to the Gaeltacht, and in regard to everything that was supposed to have been done by the Commission set up to examine the whole question of the congested areas. Certain recommendations were made, and we were informed two years ago, last year, and this year that all these things were to be done.
They have not been done yet. Last October I was informed that in four months' time everything in regard to the cottage industries, the hand-spun and home-spun industries would be under way. Not a thing has been done from that day until this—not even a stamp, that probably would only have cost 2/-, for the stamping of home-spun cloth has been provided. The Minister said that certain things had been done in the home-spun. Not even in the home-spun has anything been done to relieve unemployment, to give poor people in the cottages an opportunity of eking out an existence. The Committee in Ardara offered to put up £600 for the purpose of setting up breaking and carding machines, and dyeing vats, and the policy of the Executive Council as exemplified by the Minister for Fisheries is this. Let somebody else come in and do it. Let a Scotchman come in and do it, but we in the meantime must do nothing. Humbug. Since October last, nothing but humbug.
Another important thing in connection with the Gaeltacht was the starting of navigation schools to teach the young how to fish and navigate. Those things would be eminently suitable to the districts in which those schools were to have been erected. They would have provided young men with a good knowledge of navigation, if in the future we decide —at least if it be the policy of the Executive Council—to give some help towards the formation of a mercantile marine. That has not been done and we are still waiting for something in connection with a report to materialise. It has departed into the limbo of things forgotten, a Government pigeon hole. The President is one of those who pretends to understand the psychology of the emigrant. His reading of it is this. Those who depart from this country to a land across the sea go there for the express purpose of visiting their friends. Others tell you no matter what would be or could be done for the congested areas and the people therein it would not prevent people from emigrating to the United States. They tell you that these people want to see life. Things are too dull here. If I understand the psychology of the emigrants who go from Donegal— and I have seen enough of them to be able to do it—it is this, that they go because they have to go. Far more would be going at present if they had the money to go. They go because it is a steady grind, if they have work, from morning to night. But then they are glad to do it. They go to Scotland and England where they have the opportunity of doing it because they cannot get it here. They go because they cannot live here. Young men and women go because they cannot bear to see their fathers and mothers, their young brothers and sisters starving and they send money home. That money takes out the rest of the family. As they grow up they all go. The President's reading of the psychology of the emigrants is that they go to America to see their friends. There is not as much money amongst the poor in the congested areas of Donegal as would take two people across to America to see their friends, not to mind taking 6,000 inside three or four years.
It seems to me that when there is any pressing matter to be raised in regard to the condition of the people in the congested areas that the best way to deal with it according to the policy of the Executive Council is to form a committee. The committee sits indefinitely. Some of those committees you will find are covered with ashes, the same as if they had been overflown by Mount Vesuvius. People will pick them out a thousand years hence and they will be still sitting. We never can see any result from the Piers and Harbours Committee. You ask for a report but there is nothing doing.
Comment on this
Very good. There are certain points I have brought up and if the President of the Executive Council has got a satisfactory answer to them I will be very much delighted and surprised. If he has an answer let it be forthcoming. We do not like to be groping about in the dark all the time. The President always sets out to educate us on those benches, for which, O Lord, we return thanks. If the President can tell us whether we own the territorial waters of the Free State or not it is going to settle a few urgent problems we have to deal with in Donegal.
Comment on this
In dealing with this Vote there are a few matters I am anxious to bring to the attention of the House, particularly with regard to the unemployment problem. I think it is very little use discussing unemployment here whilst you have a Bill of twenty-one million pounds odd to meet for the drones of the community, and whilst we have a generous Executive in office who are prepared to throw £250 a year to gentlemen having £1,000 or £1,500. I think there is very little use in discussing unemployment when that state of affairs exists. You have a Minister for Local Government who coolly tells how he is doing everything and who has a grand Bill with regard to housing. He tells us what the local authorities are doing, and when he is asked what it would cost to build labourers' cottages he is dumb and tells you—as cheaply as possible.
You find the grant he is prepared to give under the Housing of the Working Classes Act is £60, while at the same time he has a special clause in by which the local authorities can only give loans not exceeding twice that amount. So the total amount that would be available to build a house for a working man to-day would be £180. When you compare that with the amount they consider necessary to expend on every house you become amazed. I wonder would the Minister for Local Government or the Minister for Industry and Commerce explain to us whether, in his opinion, you could build labourers' houses for £180, provide a site and all, or if so, how it is that he has spent £1,700 for a police barracks at Dungourney?
Comment on this
I am alluding to unnecessary and useless expenditure on the part of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
I consider this a very appropriate Vote to speak on it. Members of his own Party who are dumb here, when they go down to Cork make statements that there should be no Civic Guard station at Dungourney.