In Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the President of the Executive Council.
Contributions 201–405 of 405. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
A voice from Donegal. The Minister has launched a Housing Act that is absolutely of no use to the local authorities inasmuch as the total amount that can be found for the building of a labourer's dwelling is £180.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is under the impression that he is discussing the Department of Local Government and Public Health.
Comment on this
I have heard statements made here to-night as to the prosperity of farm labourers in Ireland. I can tell this House that in my constituency 40 per cent. fewer farm labourers are employed to-day than were employed four years ago, owing to the fact that the farmers are absolutely unable to pay them. I expected when the Budget was introduced that the Executive Council would take some steps towards putting the Irish farmer on at least the same level as the farmers across the Border, or in Great Britain, seeing that they have to compete in the same market. But no; we have millions expended here and we go abroad every second year for a loan of five millions more in order to pay a horde of officials and to see that our own salaries are saved. At the same time, we cannot afford to give any reduction whatever in the rates to the Irish farmer. We cannot afford to give him an opportunity of living or of giving employment, as it should be given, on the land. I expected this year that the Minister for Finance, when introducing his Budget, would have definite proposals for de-rating.
Comment on this
I am alluding to the unemployment which is caused by the want of consideration on the part of the President of the Executive Council for the farming community.
Comment on this
I very definitely stated that the inactivity of the Executive Council in that respect is something which could not be tolerated anywhere. I would like to know whether the Executive Council has taken any steps to give the farmers, say, of the Border counties, an opportunity to compete in some way with the farmers across the Border. They have taken no steps to prevent the importation of farm produce across the Border, although the farmers across the Border pay no rates.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not in order, and if he persists in going on that line he will have to sit down.
Comment on this
There is no sum of £25,000 mentioned in this Estimate. I want to warn the Deputy again that if he pursues further these lines he will have to sit down.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have to confine himself to this Estimate strictly. If not, he will have to discontinue his speech.
Comment on this
I would refer the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to the Dáil debate of the 23rd May, 1929. When this matter was brought up on the Vote of the Office of Public Works it was stated by Deputy Bourke, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister, that the question of British military graves was a matter of Government policy, that the question had been decided by British Government representatives and by the Executive Council. As this is a question of policy, it is not a matter in which the Department is concerned; therefore I take it it is a matter which arises on this Vote.
Comment on this
I have only to say that it is not a Parliamentary Secretary or any Minister who decides what is or is not in order. It is the Chair. I have decided that what the Deputy is trying to get out is not in order, and he will have to accept that ruling.
Comment on this
If this is not in order on the Vote for the Department concerned, it is not in order anywhere. I am sorry the President is not here. He would be able to tell us what he did with the money he got for a motor car, whether he expended it on the car in Ireland or whether he went across for one of these cars that Deputy Lemass alluded to a while ago. I would like to get some information from him on that. I would also like to hear from him whether he considers that the Secretary, for instance, should be paid £1,200 a year and I presume war bonus, while men are unemployed and hungry in the country, whether he considers that a fair sum to pay to one individual or not. I do not think, considering the manner in which this Vote has been treated, that there is much more that I can say on it. Apparently, there is nobody responsible for anything here. When you ask an awkward question of any one of these Ministers they conveniently put it off or vanish.
Comment on this
Speaking on this Estimate, half an hour ago, the Minister for Local Government said that the Executive Council pleaded guilty to the fact that they would not contribute anything towards public health in the country. The policy of the Executive Council in matters of roads, housing and drainage has been to make State contributions, and I submit that questions of housing shortage and any other State schemes are less important than the question of public health. The Minister mentioned that the first step towards the improvement of public health schemes should be the fixing of the county-at-large as the area of charge. I should like to point cut that it rests with the Government to fix the area of charge and not with the local authority. Until the Government makes some provision to fix the area of charge, other than the area at present specified, they cannot improve the public health services. When Deputy Kennedy asked the Minister the question he was ruled out of order. I should like to put the question in this way: I should like the President in his reply to state definitely if it is the policy of the Executive Council to introduce legislation to fix the area of charge as the county-at-large.
Comment on this
The Minister for Local Government, in his speech, neglected altogether to deal with the issues raised in the amendment proposed by Deputy O'Connell. He quoted his usual litany of what the Government had done, especially his Department. I wonder will he deny that there is an unemployment problem, or are we to assume that the Government accept the present situation as normal? In every part of the country demands are being made on various Deputies to bring pressure on the Government with a view to having certain works carried out in different areas. I admit that some of them are not works which could be called remunerative, but surely there are various schemes in different parts of the country which could be looked upon as remunerative and which, in the end, would benefit the country to a great extent. Whether we like it or not, there is a big unemployment problem facing the country. The position to-day is very little better than it was two or three years ago, when the Government thought it absolutely necessary to include in their annual estimates a certain sum for the relief of unemployment. The Minister has spoken of the amount given by his Department in free grants to the various county councils. A certain amount in free grants is given each year, but since 1927 it has been decreasing rapidly, with the result that only about 50 per cent. of the road workers employed in 1927 are employed to-day. The Minister gave the proportion of men on the different classes of roads and mentioned especially that ten out of every eleven men employed on construction work are paid by the Government. That state of affairs may have prevailed about two years ago, but there is very little construction work being done to-day on the roads. The greater proportion of the money paid to county councils is by way of maintenance grant and it is laid down as essential in the regulations submitted to local authorities by the Local Government Department that a certain amount of money must be budgeted for by the county councils in order to get a certain amount of money. I do not disagree with that policy, because for the last three or four years a great many councils have been inclined to take advantage of the Government grant in order to reduce the rates. I will give the Government the credit by saying that that was not what they intended—that they gave the grant in order to relieve unemployment and to build up the roads as they should be built up.
The matter of housing has been mentioned, and the Minister for Local Government in answer to an interjection of mine, stated that the money from the Local Loans Fund was available now. The Minister for Finance a month ago gave me the same answer in reply to a question. I am beginning to wonder whether we are ever going to get the money. The Wexford Corporation submitted a scheme to the Local Government Department almost a month ago. It must be said to the credit of that Department that they accepted this scheme and recommended it to the Board of Works. Nobody can find out now whether it is with the Board of Works or the Finance Department. One wonders whether this is going to go on until winter comes, when it will cost at least 20 per cent. more to build a house than it would now when we have the long days. I would ask the President, who has always shown himself keenly interested in housing, to do something to have the money released at once. Some of us think that if the Dáil rises before the money is forthcoming we will have to renew the agitation when we come back for the Autumn Session. There is no use stating in the House that money from the Local Loans Fund is available if, when a council tries to get the money, they are sent from one Department to another in a sort of Herod-Pilate fashion.
Dealing with the question of unemployment, it is very hard for a Deputy who has not the ready access to statistics that the Government have to put up any scheme. But there is one thing that ought to engage the attention of the Government. From time to time it has been suggested that there should be a national housing council. To my mind, that is the proper way of dealing with housing, and when the Government see their way to approach housing from that angle and through that medium, I think it will become apparent to them—when that council is set up and if that council proposes to do anything— that we are importing a great amount of material which is available in this country.
In last year's returns, it is shown that we imported cement to the amount of half a million of money, notwithstanding the fact that in various parts of the Free State we have quarries capable of giving sufficient cement to cater for all the needs of the State. I have time and again drawn the attention of the Ministry to the fact that in my own constituency there is a cement works that could be worked but which, in my opinion, was bought up by an English syndicate with a view to wiping it out in the interest of a ring on the other side of the Channel. Again, when we come to the question of slates, we find that practically every house built now is roofed with asbestos slates made on the other side of the Channel. I am not objecting to that at present. I recognise it is almost impossible to buy Irish slates and to let a house at an economic rent, because of the fact that there is no certainty in the demand for these Irish slates. But I believe if the Government were to get into touch with the Killaloe quarry and to give them an idea of their requirements for the next two or three years and tell them what their housing programme was to be, slates would be forthcoming at a price that would enable the local authorities to buy Irish slates for their houses and thus save that amount to this country. These are two ideas that I think the Government ought to investigate, with a view to keeping money in the country, which would go ultimately to the betterment of the general community and especially to the benefit of people who are now idle. I would seriously suggest that the Government should go into this housing question through the medium of the suggested national housing council and thereby do something to keep a certain amount of money in the country along with providing a large number of houses. I again suggest to the President that he should bring pressure to bear upon the Finance Department or the Board of Works with a view to getting them to release the money that we were told was available a month ago, so that the local authorities could start building houses before the winter comes on. I am sure the President will agree, with his great experience of housing, that if it is left very much longer houses will cost at least 20 per cent. more owing to the short day.
Comment on this
Tá a lán cainnte déanta ar an gceist seo agus níl fúm-sa acht cúpla leagan do rá, Táim ag cur i n aghaidh an Vóta so mar badh mhaith liom a chur i gcéill do'n Uachtarán nach bhfuil na daoine in Iarthar na hEireann sásta leis an bpolasai atá aige agus nach bhfuil aon feabhas, no dul ar aghaidh, sa tír mar ba ceart a bheadh da mbeadh an tUachtarán agus an Rialtas dá ríríbh i dtaobh maitheas na tíre. Nuair a bhrethnuighim-se thart orm 'mo chonndae féin, ní fheicim aon feabhas acht gach rud a bhaineas leis na daoine coitchianta nios measa ná mar a bhí sé blianta o shoin. Ní fheicim aon nidh a fuair na daoine coitchianta as a gcuid oibre no as aon Acht a ritheadh ag an Riaghaltas ar feadh an téarma a bhfuil an chomacht acu. Ní fheicim aon nidh a rinne siad no a mhol siad ar son na ndaoine mbocht. Nuair a thainigeamar isteach annso ar dtús, shaoileas go ndeunfadh an Rialtas iarracht éigin Gaodhalach, go gceapfadh siad scéim éigin chun na Gaedhil—na daoine atá in íochtar le blianta—do chur in uachtar agus neamh—spleadhachas do thabhairt dóibh. Ach nuair a mholamar on dtaoibh seo den Tigh rud éigin no scéim éigin chun staid na ndaoine mbocht d'fheabhasú ní fhuaireamar acht searbhas ón dtaoibh eile agus rinneadh gach rud a b'fhéidir chun scoilt imeasc na nGaedheal do dhéanamh síorraí. I gContae Mhuigheo i mbliana, do réir mar a chonnaic mise, ní raibh níos mó daoine ag fáil cabhair phuiblí ó na rátaí o bhliaín an ghorta anuas. Is mór an rud sin do rá agus is mór an náire don Rialtas agus don Uachtarán go bhfuil sin le rá seacht mbliana ó cuireadh an Saorstát ar bun. Ní ar lucht oibre atá an locht no ar Fhianna Fáil go bhfuil an scéal amhlaidh. Ní hé nach dtig leis an Rialtas an t-airgead d'fháil. Ní h-é nach bhfuil na daoine sásta obair a dhéanamh gan bheith ag súil le cabhair phuiblí; ní h-é sin é. Sé an fáth atá leis sin, an fhaid is gheibheann an Rialtas an t-airgead ó na rátaí agus ó lucht cánach ní chaitheann siad an tairgead sin ar mhaithe le daoine coitchianta na tíre seo.
Níl daoine coitchianta na tíre seo ag fáil a gcion féin do réir an méid a íocann siad i rátaí agus i gcáin. Níl na daoine coitchianta ag fáil a gcuid féin in aon chontae agus na daoine a bhí in uachtar a riamh tá siad ag fáil níos mó ná a fuair siad riamh. Dubhairt an tUachtarán, sgathamh beag o shoin, go raibh feabhas le feiceál sa tír. B'fhéidir go bhfuil "corner" eile "rounded" aige. Tá a fhios agam go bhfuil an Rialtas ag meas an fheabhais do réir an méid gluaisteán mór a thagann isteach sa tír. Nuair a fheiceann an Rialtas an méid seo gluaisteán ag teacht thar sáile, agus nuair a fheiceann siad go bhfuil daoine in ann íoc asta, nuair a fheiceann siad go bhfuil daoine in ann dul go dtí "garden parties" ag caitheamh cótaí fada, breatha, deireann siad go bhfuil feabhas mór tagtha ar an tír. Ba cheart do'n Uacharán no d'Airí, anois agus arís, nuair nach mbíonn togha ar siúl dul síos an tír agus an riocht atá ar na daoine d'fheiceál. D'fheicfidís an bhfuil gluaisteáin mhóra ag na daoine nó an dtig leo éadaigh galánta do chaitheamh ag garden parties nó ar an Domhnach féin nó an dtig leo dul go dtí aon spraoi eile.
Sin é an locht atá agam-sa ar an Rialtas—go bhfuil faillighe déanta acu i ndaoine coitchianta na tíre seo. Má dhéanann aon bhall de Chumann na nGaedheal casaoid ag cruinniú den Phairtí no ag cruinniú puiblí, cuireann an tUachtarán 'na thost é le focal plámásach. Má leanann don chasaoid, gheobhaidh sé "job" no rud éicint den tsórt sin. Chuir mé ceist ar an Aire Cosanta—go sábháluighidh Dia sinn?—tamall ó shoin cé mhéid airgid a bhí ag dul do na daoine a d'fhág an t-Arm le bliain anuas. Dubhairt sé go raibh £300,000 no níos mo íoctha amach do na daoine a d'eirigh as an arm agus a dtig leo obair a dhéanamh agus a fuair obair, is dócha, in áit éicint eile. Teasbánann sé sin nach easbadh airgid an fáth leis an Uachtarán agus an Rialtas bheith ag déanamh dearmad ar dhaoine coitchianta na tíre. Chím, do réir an chláir annseo, go bhfuil Rúnaí Pairliminte ag an Uachtarán agus £1,200 de thuarastal aige. Tá an dara Rúnaí agus £1,200 de thuarastal aige agus tá Rúnaí Conganta agus oifigeach eile agus tá thimcheall £800 acu. Tá triúr no ceathrar rúnaithe agus leas-rúnaithe agus fó-rúnaithe agus chuile short eile rúnaithe, ag fáil ó £300 go £600 agus £700 sa mbliain.
Dá mbeadh ganntanas airgid ar an Rialtas agus dhá dteastóchadh uatha £1,000,000 do shábháil tuige nar chuir an tUachtarán cuireadh do dtí Míchéal O hIfearnáin, Teachta, teacht isteach san oifig chuige agus cuid den airgead sin do shábháil? B'fheidir go bhfaca an tUachtarán nach mbeadh móran maitheasa a leitheid sin de chuireadh do thabhairt don Teachta sin. Tá £1,200 a fháil ag Míchéal O hIfearnáin é fein ón phost atá aige agus ní bheadh sé ceart dó bheith chó cruaidh sin ar dhaoine eile atá cosamhail leis féin. Nuair a bhí airgead le sábháil agus nuair a theastuigh uatha laigheadú do dhéanamh ar na costaisí is go dtí na daoine bochta a chuaidh an Rialtas leis an airgead do shábháil.
Mar gheall ar sin agus ar a lán rudaí eile, tá mé ag cur i n aghaidh an Vótá seo. Nuair a thainig an "Budget" rómhainn, bhí súil ag 'chuile dhuine go bhfeicthí an feabhas a bhí le feiceál sa tír; ach ní raibh aon laigheadú ar chán-acha nó ar chíosa na ndaoine go raibh an t-ualach ba thruime ortha le bliantaí agus tá sé níos truime indiu ná ariamh.
Ar cheist na náisiúntachta, ón chéad lá a thainig an tUachtarán i gcomhacht ní fhaca me go ndeárna sé aon iarracht an cheist náisiúnta do phlé. Rinne sé dearmad gur Gaedheal do b'eadh é agus gur Náisún é seo ón chéad lá. Nuair a d'eirigh aon cheist idir an tír seo agus Sasana do theasbáin sé go raibh sé níos gallda ná na daoine thall annsin. Níl faic déanta ag baill an phairtí le gnóthai an Rialtais do Ghaedhlú, cé go bhfuil a leath acu, ar a laighead, míoshásta le obair an Rialtais. An é nách bhfuil an misneach acu an mhí-shástacht sin do chur i gcéill no an é nách dtuigeann siad an chomhacht atá acu?
Comment on this
I beg to support Deputy O'Connell's amendment to refer this Vote back. I confess I was rather surprised at the statement made by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health. He mentioned a few of what he considered were the good things that were accomplished. He also spoke of the policy of the Executive Council in connection with sewerage schemes, but he omitted to speak on the motion before the Chair, the question of unemployment. He omitted to tell the House of the increase in the rates struck by public bodies in the Saorstát for home assistance. In my own county of Wicklow, the assistance given to able-bodied men unable to procure work was for the year ending 31st March, 1923, £2,026. The expenditure for the year ending 31st March, 1929, was £3,397, notwithstanding that the amount of home assistance had to be reduced in the meantime from 10/-to 5/- a week in order to cope with the demand for it by the unemployed.
The Minister states that he himself put certain responsibilities upon local authorities. He denied, when it was charged here in this House, that the Executive Council should be responsible in respect of the unemployment fund. In two cases he went further. He increased the liabilities on public and local bodies because the housing scheme of public bodies can only be gone on with when they increase the rates or levy a special rate of 1/- in the £1. The Minister does not say if that applies to rural houses or to boards of public health. These bodies say that 35 years will not be a sufficiently long term to enable boards of health to avail of that Housing Act. There are, however, large numbers of rural workers unemployed, and those who are in employment have a very small wage. The result is that no local bodies can build houses which they can let at an economic rent because these men who are in employment are in receipt of very small wages.
The Minister suggests that sewerage schemes should be a county-at-large charge. Public bodies' liabilities have increased very much from 1919. First of all, there was the increased cost of maintenance of the insane. Then there was the increased cost as a result of the amalgamation scheme because of grants and pensions to ex-officials. There was, further, the increased cost of roads, and there is no grant given by the Local Government Department this year for the new roads. As Deputy Corish states, the only grants given are for road maintenance. In a large number of cases, the roads are maintained by contract, with the exception of trunk or link roads. It has been said here to-night that the Labour Party are asking for doles. I am asking for some scheme to be adopted by the Government to deal with the unemployment question. Apart altogether from the question of Government, I submit it is a Christian duty to solve the unemployment problem.
I ask the Minister to extend the unemployment insurance and not to ask public bodies to assist in solving the question of unemployment. It is not really the duty or the function of public bodies to do so. The rates are being increased two-fold, and these bodies will be unable to deal with the housing problem if they have to spend £5,000 or £6,000 a year in providing home assistance. There is no hope that the scheme that the Minister has announced for the building of houses to meet the demands or requirements of the Free State will be successful. Deputy O'Dowd has asked that sewerage schemes should be made county-at-large charges. That would mean that congested areas that are paying for their own schemes would also have to pay for special areas that fail to grapple with these problems. That would mean that double burdens would be placed on those people. Certainly if the Minister brings in legislation on those lines, he will meet with opposition even within his own ranks.
I wish to ask the President a question about a very serious matter. It is a national matter which would absorb a very large number of the unemployed in a number of places— the question of coast erosion. The President has told us that this is being considered by an inter-departmental committee. If it takes that inter-departmental committee as long as it took the departmental tribunal to deal with the question of harbours, then we can have no hope that there will be any relief for these people in the next five years.
Public bodies are, in their own small way, unable to deal further with this question, and I certainly join in the appeal made by Deputy Cassidy. That is not a question for the Labour Party or the Fianna Fáil Party or the Government Party. It should be grappled with as a national question and not in the same way as it was by the Committee appointed in 1927 to make suggestions about unemployment. We have never heard, up to the present, that the Government adopted any of the recommendations made by that Committee. The President will state, of course, when he is replying, that there is money lying to the credit of some local bodies in the matter of roads. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health made that statement during the last debate on this matter. He omitted to state that, though the money may be lying to the credit of these local bodies, in many cases that amount had already been spent on the roads. Consequently that money would not be available for the relief of unemployment.
Although the Minister for Industry and Commerce has helped Wicklow in connection with the mining in Avoca, still—notwithstanding that industry there, which we all hope will be a success—there was never so much unemployment as in Wicklow at the present time. The Board of Health have been given overdrafts by the banks with the sanction of the County Council, and there is no use in making appeals to the public bodies that are already living on overdrafts. There is no use in appealing to them to start house building that would only impose still further burdens on them. Notwithstanding objections made that certain people never pay rent and rates, I want to say that under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act, even where the public bodies have power to exempt people in receipt of home help, these people are now forced under the Acts to pay rates, because the rents are increased. Therefore, they are paying rates in the increased rents. Public bodies are finding a difficulty in trying to meet payment in these matters and it is no use for the Minister to get up and ask the public bodies to deal with this problem.
There is no use in the Government asking public bodies to bear a further burden. It is the duty of the Government to look after these matters. There is nothing to prevent them doing so, and they can economise in other directions. I observe that they can give big grants for amusements and races in the Phoenix Park, but they forget to come to the relief of the people who voted for the Government. My own policy is, instead of making those appeals time after time to the Government, to take other action. Probably I have a different opinion to other members, but I am prepared to put my opinion into practice in order to try and achieve my ends. If appeals fail in the constitutional Assembly, then I say—Ministers may laugh at me for saying it—that men should use their powers in other directions. Instead of making appeals in places like this, where they will fall on deaf ears, they will, if necessary, bring force against force. It would be much better for many workers if they were obliged to go to jail, because there they would be entitled to three meals a day. If they adopted such a course it would be a greater burden on the State, because they are doing nothing at the present time for those men.
Comment on this
I want the President to explain a few matters arising out of this Estimate. I notice that in the Estimates for this year there is a saving of £1,800,000. The President, who might be expected to show a good example, has increased his Estimate by 7 per cent. This year he has two higher executive officers in his Department, whereas up to the present one has sufficed. Where is the necessity this year, as compared with last year, for two higher executive officers? I notice that there is a staff officer who has taken control of four clerical officers. Two of the clerical officers have special duties for which they are paid extra; and another of the four has a pension, so there is really only one clerical officer left. A big saving was made in the Land Commission, but the biggest saving, perhaps, was made on the improvement of estates. If money had been voted this year, as in previous years, the benefit would go to people of the country who were getting employment under the Land Commission. Those people are badly in need of employment. They have nothing else to replace the work they were getting in districts where estates were being divided.
On the Fisheries Vote a saving was made by curtailing loans to fishermen. Under the Forestry Vote, a saving was made in connection with the acquisition of land. These are savings from which the country not only gets no value now, but the people actually lose the value that they were getting. It is not to the advantage of the country to make savings on the improvement of estates when employment is so badly wanted. It is not to the benefit of the fishermen to make savings by reducing the loans applicable to them. It is certainly not to the benefit of the people in the country who want employment to make a saving on the acquisition of land for forestry. In such Votes, the money spent in former years was of direct benefit to the country as a whole. The situation now is that where Votes are increased, the people get absolutely no benefit. I think, therefore, that an increase of 7 per cent. in this Vote is a thing that can be scarcely defended by the Dáil. I would like the President to tell us the necessity for employing an additional higher executive officer this year.
Comment on this
As far as the constituency which I represent is concerned, I must say that there is no visible sign of improvement in so far as unemployment goes. The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated here last week that 17,000 persons had been employed during the year. In my constituency there is no visible sign of any of the 17,000 who were employed being centred there. A lot of the people in that constituency are out of employment and they include railway workers, who have been dismissed, and many road workers. Road-work has not been progressing very favourably there. Absolutely no drainage work has been done. The Minister for Finance stated here some weeks ago that the drainage work that has been carried on is not giving good results. I was very sorry to hear the Minister saying that, but that was actually his statement.
There is no visible sign of improvement in Westmeath and, to instance that, I will give some figures representing the amount of home assistance given. The total amount of home assistance paid in County Westmeath for the year ending 31st March, 1927, was £8,829 12s. 8d.; in the year ending 31st March, 1928, the amount was £9,441 17s. 0d., and in the year ending 31st March, 1929, it was £9,808 9s. 10½d. During the last two years I have been a member of the Westmeath Board of Health. I can state definitely to the House that I do not know anyone receiving home assistance in that county who is not absolutely entitled to it. The members of the Board of Health there are unanimous in the belief that they could give very much more deservedly in the way of home assistance if they had the money to do it. There are large numbers of persons in the county entitled to home help who are not receiving it. These facts will go to prove that what I have stated is quite correct— there is no visible sign of improvement in the county. During the last year or two, no doubt, conditions have become worse by reason of the fact that numbers of men have been discharged from the National Army. In many instances they have been obliged to seek home assistance. I know for a fact that home assistance has increased considerably in Westmeath.
There is one matter that I would like to impress upon the President, and I am sure that he will use his influence with the Department responsible. I hope things will improve in County Westmeath, and I believe that in the coming year they will. What I want to draw the President's attention to is this: where an industry is started and that industry is looking for a site, it would be very advisable if State lands were allowed to be utilised. I hope that the President will use his influence with the Department concerned and see that that idea is carried into effect. It would be very advisable if State lands were granted for the purpose of starting industries. Industrial concerns could then build factories, stores and things of that sort, and all these things would ultimately tend to benefit the country.
Where State land is needed for the building of houses sites could be granted. I hope that the Minister will use his influence to have all these matters expedited. I know that certain formalities have to be gone through, but I think that they should be pushed through as speedily as possible. We hope, if that is done, not to be as bad in Westmeath as we have been for the last few years.
Comment on this
The Minister for Local Government referred to the Government's housing policy which is in existence, and also to the policy which he contemplates putting into operation in the near future. I am not in a position to say how far the present policy has been a success, but I can say that, so far as my knowledge in country districts goes, that policy has not attempted to deal with the situation there. I have had some absurd experiences as to the working out of the Government scheme in my part of the country. I have known instances in which men attempted to improve their homes and had gone to the expense of pulling them down, so far as could be reasonably expected, in order to conform with the housing regulations required for the erection of new buildings. They applied to the Department for grants but were told that they had not conformed with the regulations as they had allowed portion of the walls—to the extent of perhaps five feet—of the old building to remain. Because they did not destroy what was sound and good work they technically fell foul of the regulations and were not given grants. If such treatment as that be taken as an indication of the working of the Government's housing scheme I think it would be better described by leaving out any reference to a housing scheme, simply to refer to it as the Government's scheme for depriving people of money which was originally intended to help them. If the new scheme which the Government propose to introduce does not deal more generously with the rural areas, then it may be said that the Government never intended to give them any advantage.
The Minister referred to the question of roads. There again I must say that while the Department have endeavoured to spend a good deal of money on the improvement of roads there is a good deal of dissatisfaction at the manner in which the grants for such roads are allocated, and I would say that there is a good deal of justification for such dissatisfaction. The scheme of allotment of grants is based on the valuation of the counties and on other details. In my opinion what would be a more advisable course to adopt would be that those responsible for the allocation of grants would take into account the question of costs of construction and the cost of maintenance rather than the valuation or the amount of rates struck for such purpose. For instance, where road material has to be carried a long distance it is more expensive to make roads than where such material is at hand. It is also more expensive where the foundation of a road is of such a character that it is required to be made substantial.
These are big items which should be borne in mind when considering the cost of maintenance. There should also be taken into account the extent to which the people of the county use good roads. In the poorer counties, where the ratepayers are called on to pay increased charges compared with the pre-war or pre-motor days, they take very little advantage of the improved roads as they do not own motor cars. I have experience in County Leitrim where the Government spent a fair proportion of money on the improvement of roads. I have also experience where a strong application was made to the Government to allot money to improve a road in connection with the development of a coal mine. After various applications and deputations had been heard on behalf of the county council they were told by the Department that no money was available for that purpose. That is hardly treating the matter in a serious way. While the Department could find moneys for the improvement of roads for the benefit of motorists and to encourage tourist traffic, and while taxpayers are being taxed for improving such roads, surely when a substantial case is put forward for improving a road in connection with the development of a coal mine, thus giving employment, such application should not be turned down by the Department.
Underlying all the schemes for the improvement of roads and the building of houses to which the Minister referred, there is the fundamental question of the economic position of the people. If you have a good and sound economic position the housing problem will, to a large extent, solve itself, and so also will the problem of roads. When, however, you find the Department refusing to assist in the development of a service that offers decent employment you can say that such Department has not tackled the problem in the proper way. The Minister also referred to the sanitary arrangements provided by local bodies, and he was emphatic that the county councils and other responsible bodies must strike rates for that purpose. From the attitude of the Minister I can say that the likelihood of such bodies striking rates for that purpose is remote.
Comment on this
The Deputy is speaking on matters concerned more with the Vote of the Local Government Department.
Comment on this
I am criticising the speech made by the Minister, and these are the items he dealt with.
Comment on this
He did not deal with them in that way. The Deputy has dealt with specific cases where the Minister in his administration did not, according to the Deputy, behave properly.
Comment on this
These are the points of his speech which appealed to me, but if I am wrong in referring to them I shall cease.
Comment on this
There is no use to my mind in stating that all these schemes for the improvement of houses, sanitary arrangements and drainage schemes have proved successful when the Minister responsible must know from experience that his present line of action will not bring any beneficial results. In regard to the relief of unemployment, I would appeal urgently to him and to those responsible, that some consideration should be given to the position of that section of the community who are not usually classed as labourers but who, when their conditions are examined, will be found to be mainly labourers. I refer to the small farmers living in congested areas. In the old days that section of the community were very keen in looking after their interests. The old C. D. Board had at its disposal a sum of £231,000 annually and that was supplemented by other sums from the Government then in office. As a result of that, a good deal of very beneficial work was carried out in the poorer areas. The people in these areas, although nominally farmers, are people who derive their living from other sources of revenue. They are people who in the ordinary way spend three or four months of the year working on their farms. For the remainder of the year if they do not find suitable employment they are out of employment.
The old Congested Districts Board did much useful work in dealing with these people. They developed cottage and rural industries. These cottage industries for the last three years of the existence of the Board earned an annual average income of £70,000. That branch of the service, initiated by that body, has to a very great extent been neglected. It is surely permissible to suggest to the responsible authorities that some effort should be made to develop again the branch of the work formerly conducted by the Congested Districts Board so as to provide additional employment for small uneconomic farmers and their families. If a serious effort were made in that direction the situation in the west might not be at all as it is to-day. Speaking of the people in the west of Ireland and of a general improvement in housing I must say that the schemes of the Board of Works are merely infuriating the people because they fully realise that the present Executive are not in any way serious in their efforts. Not very long ago people in Co. Leitrim had practical experience of the insincerity of those Ministers who talk about the fine work they have done and the fine work they contemplate for the farmers. When recently these Ministers were down in Leitrim ——
Comment on this
I will not refer to the election if you will allow me to proceed. The Ministers are aware of what I am about to remind them. This occurred a few years ago.
Comment on this
If it occurred a few years ago the President is not responsible for it this year. I want to hear the Deputy on the Estimate. I have been listening to him about fourteen minutes now and he has not said a single word about it. We cannot have a discussion on the Congested Districts Board, rural industries, Ministerial promises, and so on, on this Estimate.
Comment on this
We do not want the Deputy to refer to the fact that we won that Sligo election, too.
Comment on this
The insincerity I referred to is the insincerity of the Ministers since they took office. They promised a number of things, as they have done in this election. It does not require any words of mine to show that that insincerity is consistent. It is generally applicable. If I wanted to refer to the general attitude of the Ministry towards the congested districts in the West, I have only to go back a few years to illustrate their insincerity when asked to receive a deputation.
Comment on this
The Deputy need not give us that example. It will lead us on to another line altogether.
Comment on this
Their insincerity is consistent with the attitude they have adopted in Leitrim and other areas.
Comment on this
I do not intend to take up much time of the House in this debate except to refer to two very important subjects that have already been dealt with. These are the subjects of unemployment and housing. Let me say at the outset that the Government have done fairly well in the way of providing houses for the people of the Free State. I have listened to many of the speeches, but I think many Deputies have missed the real point. That is, the cost of building. I maintain, as I have maintained for the last four or five years, that the question of housing shortage can be solved by the builders, the builders' operatives and the men who supply materials. By the co-operation of these three parties, the housing question can be solved in a very short space of time. I am not going into the question of the cost of building, but any man who knows anything about the business is painfully aware of the fact that it is impossible to build a house at the present time and let it at an economic rent. The Government, I believe, have done very well by way of subsidies and other means in endeavouring to solve this serious problem, but I maintain that the housing shortage will never be solved by subsidies. It is only by means of the co-operation of the three parties I have mentioned that this question of housing will be ultimately solved. The same remark can be applied to unemployment. I say that unemployment will never be solved in this country, or in any other country, until the people of the nation as a whole are prepared to make sacrifices; in other words, a national sacrifice on the part of everybody.
We are enjoying a standard of living in this country as if we were a rich country, which we are not. It is about time that the fact was recognised that if the problem of unemployment is to be solved every man who can make a sacrifice should do so, because it is only by means of a conservation of the wealth that will accrue as a result of these sacrifices that industries will be established and that those which exist in a languishing state will be resuscitated or enlarged. Coming to the question of my own constituency, as far as unemployment is concerned I maintain that the Government could do much to relieve unemployment there, if the President would make representations to the Northern Parliament to have some of the inconveniences occasioned by the border removed.
Comment on this
I only desired to ask the President to have some of these terrible inconveniences removed from the Border. Dealing with the question of unemployment, as far as Dundalk is concerned, I must say that I am more or less inclined to lay the blame on the Government for the closing down of certain industries which formerly existed there. One very fine industry existed there in the form of a distillery. A very flourishing business had been carried on for years, but whatever happened in the negotiations between the Government and the representatives of that concern, the fact remains that the distillery has been closed for the past six or seven years, thereby throwing out of employment a few hundred men who were constantly engaged for a very long time in that distillery. I think the Executive Council will admit that it is not good business to close down an industry in the Free State and to allow distilleries in other countries, particularly in Northern Ireland and Great Britain, to send their products into the Free State free of duty. I think it would be the duty of the Executive Council to take steps to prevent these people from having a monopoly of the trade in the Free State.
I think it would be the duty of the Executive Council to take steps to prevent these people from having a monopoly of the trade of the Free State so long as they think it fit and wise to close down industries that formerly were carried on in the Free State. Certain references have been made to the question of roads, and the Minister for Local Government said that his Department had done very well in the way of grants so far as roads are concerned. I may tell the Minister that the farming community, as a whole, are not in a position to pay any increased rates in the future for the upkeep of roads. The Minister may state that the amount of money granted to the county councils is very large, but I would also remind the Minister that the revenue derived from motor taxation, as far as County Louth is concerned, is from £17,000 to £20,000 per annum, and that would pay interest and sinking fund on a very tidy capital sum. So, after all, if the Minister makes a grant to the Louth County Council of £60,000 or £70,000 he is obtaining, by means of taxation on motors, the annual figure of £17,000 to £20,000. I maintain if the Minister wishes roads to be kept up to concert pitch he will have to increase his grants to the county council, because the small farmer in the country will naturally say: "The roads I was used to are good enough for me." He is in a position to say: "The old horse is good enough for me, and the ass and cart will take me to the market on any road. I do not want these fine tarred roads." If the Minister wishes to keep up these roads for the motorist he will have to increase the taxation on motorists, because I believe the farming community, and in particular the small farmer, judging by the price he has been receiving for his produce in the last three or four years, is not able to pay any increase. In fact the natural tendency should be to reduce rather than increase, as it is at the moment, and has been for the last three or four years.
I do not know whether I would be in order in referring to the question of drainage.
Comment on this
As it has been referred to, I would ask the President, or whoever is responsible, to speed up the question of the cleaning of the Rampart river. This has been on the stocks for the last three or four years.
Comment on this
With regard to drainage in general, and I was just mentioning this question of the river to draw the President's attention to it. It would be the means of giving much-needed employment at the moment, and as I said before, it has been a long time in contemplation. As this is the proper season of the year for such work, I hope it will be started very soon.
In conclusion, I have to state that if this question of employment is to be solved, all of us have to make a sacrifice, from the highest to the lowest, and if the provision of houses, as far as workers are concerned, is going to be speeded up, there will have to be a change also. We will have to realise that the cost of building at the moment is too high, that it is a financial impossibility for the present Government, or any other Government that may succeed it in the near future, to solve this problem. The cost of house building must go down, and the sooner the better it will be for all concerned. As workers at present are compelled to pay a weekly rent of 10/- for a single room, the sooner they will be provided with houses the sooner will the question of unemployment be solved. The nation as a whole should consider it has a duty to give a hand in the solving of this serious problem and not to leave it wholly in the hands of the present or any succeeding Government.
Comment on this
I was rather reluctant to rise seeing that nearly everything that could be said on this Vote has been said. I was wondering, and am still wondering, what is and what is not in order on this Vote. I think other speakers have so blazed the trail for me, that I can continue to be just as incoherent as many of the other speakers this evening.
Comment on this
I am urged to rise in any case because of the fact that I heard two speakers from the Fianna Fáil Benches making what I considered a veiled attack on the Labour Party, suggesting the Labour Party had no policy for unemployment. I want to suggest to the House that the Party which has stolen three-fourths of the Labour policy and programme and called it its own should be the last to upbraid the Labour Party for not having a policy for unemployment.
To come to the most serious portion of my statement, I want to say, as far as Cork is concerned at any rate that whilst I agree there is some improvement largely, if not altogether, due to the great enterprise of Henry Ford, with the assistance of the Executive, who undoubtedly did something towards adding to the success of the firm's activity, still, there is a very large number of people unemployed. One need only turn to the report of such institutions as the Vincent de Paul Society, and the returns from the Child Welfare League to understand the gravity of the situation. In addition to what we might term the normal numbers of unemployed we have, owing to the reduction of personnel in the Army, a large number of young men turned adrift without any means of livelihood, largely made up of what is termed the unskilled class. Many of them are not trained to any occupation, the result being that they are in many cases in receipt of home assistance, and are, in my view, a menace to the community. I have before stressed the point on other Votes, particularly the Vote in connection with the Ministry of Finance, that something should be done by way of deferred pay or otherwise, so that these men, when leaving the Army, could maintain themselves for at least six months and could have a chance of getting trained in some useful occupation or, in the alternative, get into some of the unskilled trades.
Mention has been made by Deputy Coburn of a contribution and that should be made in the shape of a sacrifice, the sacrifice to come from all parties in the State. As one who is always prepared to face up to economic facts, I would suggest that employers in the building trade should also face up to these facts. We, of the Labour Party, through trade unions in the building trades, have already submitted to a Commission set up by this House a very comprehensive programme which entails a certain amount of sacrifice so far as the workers in the industry are concerned. Embodied in that programme was a suggestion which meant buying in very large quantities the materials used in the construction of houses. Also embodied in the programme was a suggestion that you should have a continuous building policy for at least ten years, in order to house every person or nearly every person in this State comfortably and in hygienic surroundings. These proposals were placed before the Commission and many weeks elapsed before any contribution whatever came from the master builders of the twenty-six counties.
Comment on this
This is an answer to some suggestion made that a sacrifice ought to be made if we were ever to solve the housing difficulty in this country. It is admitted also that if a national housing scheme was undertaken in the proper spirit and on a scale that would meet the requirements of the people it would absorb a very large number of our unemployed. Another thing that makes for unemployment in this country is the large amount of imported wood work. You have, in one of the suburbs of Dublin—on the Howth Road—building in progress. On the woodwork which is going into these houses is the legend "made in U.S.A." No wonder we have unemployment.
Not so very long ago we had to call attention in Cork to the fact that a Belgian or French firm got a contract for wheel-barrows. The only thing Irish about them was that they were painted green, like our pillar boxes. I have already said that I am not one of those people who want to set up a wail that this country is going to the dogs. I am thankful and glad to say that the conditions in this country are improving and are going to continue to improve in spite of the lamentations and wailings of the grousers and grumblers. Whilst saying that, I do believe that there is necessity, so far as this Vote is concerned, for the President to give very serious consideration to at least some of the views expressed in the course of the debate. As I have already said, one does not know when he is in order or is out of order. So many matters have been referred to and so many matters have been touched upon that I do not want to inflict upon the House many of the things that I would like to deal with. I will reserve them for a future occasion. But I would urge upon the President that there were many things mentioned here to-night to which he should direct his very serious attention. The President is a man who has had very long practical experience of public work. He has had very long experience of work in connection with Local Government and I believe that, party or no party, he will give the attention that is required and that is possible so far as this problem is concerned.
I have mentioned the case of imported woodwork. I am not suggesting that a tariff or anything of that kind should be placed on this class of imported woodwork. At the same time it is one of the things that this House will have to take into consideration at a very early date. Numbers of our people engaged in that particular industry are being thrown out of employment from day to day. We have again, as I have already said, hundreds of young men being cast adrift from the Army. Here again I want to come down to brass tacks. We had, no later than last week, a discussion in this House as to the desirability or otherwise of continuing Haulbowline and of expending money on its upkeep. We had people in this House who declared we want money on the one hand and we want employment on the other, and yet they voted for the closing down of Haulbowline which supported many families. We cannot have it both ways. If we want increased social services we should be prepared to foot the bill. If the resources of the country cannot afford those extended social services then we should get ourselves into such a position by protective and constructive methods that we should be able to pay the expenses of those services.
So far as the contribution of the Labour Party to this unemployment discussion is concerned, I think it will be admitted that nearly every speech delivered in this House this evening has been based on the utterances of the Labour Party for the last four or five years. Nothing new has been added. I do not want to suggest that I have added anything new. I am simply making an appeal to the President, as the first citizen of this State, and perhaps, what is nearly as important, the senior member for Cork City, to take these matters into consideration. I appreciate his valuable services to the public and social life of this country. I believe he will take these things into consideration at a very early date.
Comment on this
There are just two aspects of policy, and they are the aspects that have been dealt with most by the speakers here to-day, that I would like to refer to very briefly. Deputy Anthony referred to one of them and said that Fianna Fáil had stolen the housing policy of the Labour Party. Therefore, Fianna Fáil have no policy. If that is his defence of the Labour Party's policy on housing I hope his colleagues are satisfied with it. Whatever our policy is or may be with regard to housing, I would like to put it to the President that, speaking of the area I know best and that he knows very well, that is the City of Dublin, I would certainly refute the statement of Deputy Anthony that there is any sign of improvement so far as this city is concerned. I do not know what the conditions may be in Cork. Perhaps Deputy Anthony is right in saying that there has been a vast improvement.
Comment on this
And I hope he and his constituents are satisfied with the improvement, but I am speaking for the area I know, that is the City of Dublin, where the neglect of the poor, so far as housing is concerned, is a lasting disgrace to everyone, this House in particular, and by no means least to the President. He knows the conditions here as well as anybody. He knows them as well as any Deputy representing the city should know them, and the neglect that he in his official capacity as head of the State has shown for the conditions in which the poor of this city exist should bring a blush of shame to him every time he thinks about it. He cannot think about it very often or else he would try to do more.
Statements of that kind are not new. Like Deputy Anthony, I have not anything very new or original to bring to this debate. But, in view of the conditions, when we are discussing a matter of this kind, it is the duty of a Deputy representing a constituency that is so badly hit as the constituency I represent, to bring, in as forcible a manner as he can, before those responsible, the shameful conditions that he knows to exist. It is a good number of years ago since the statement was made on official authority that there were twenty thousand families existing in one room in the City of Dublin.
Comment on this
Twenty thousand families in one-roomed tenements. The President can laugh at it. It is a long time since he visited any of the tenements.
Comment on this
It will be a long time again before he will visit them. He is too high and mighty now to visit them. It is no laughing matter for the poor to have to exist under these conditions, and he ought to be the last to treat it in such a lighthearted way. He can afford to treat it lightly now, when he has used the poor and their votes to climb into the position he occupies.
Comment on this
I am on the question of housing and it is necessary to bring it, as forcibly as I can, to the notice of everybody who has any share of responsibility in the matter. In that way, I think what I have said is not out of order. Twenty thousand families, and the number is on the increase! Instead of decreasing under the Government over which the President presides, the number is on the increase in Dublin, at any rate.
Comment on this
You will have your time to talk, and I will not interrupt you. You can gibe at the poor if you want to, but I am not going to gibe at them. The President did not gibe at them when he was using them. The number is on the increase. I have it on authority that, instead of decreasing, the number is increasing year by year in Dublin. Seventy-eight thousand people living in one-roomed tenements in Dublin! And then we are told that Dublin is prosperous and that there are signs of improvement! If that number had been decreased to any appreciable extent during the period that the President has been in control of all the powers, financial and otherwise, of this State, I would certainly be glad to give voice to any recognition that might be deserved by reason of such an improvement. I do not take any pleasure in saying that instead of improving there has been anything but improvement in these conditions. I wish it were otherwise. I wish the President and his Government could tell us that that number had been reduced, even by one thousand or five thousand. It certainly would be something to their credit. In 1918 the chief engineering inspector of the then Local Government Board told us that 29,500 houses were necessary in Dublin to house the poor properly.
Comment on this
29,500 tenements— 16,000 new houses, he said, were required, and 13,500 houses required to be reconstructed.
Comment on this
It is 29,500 apartments or houses required to house properly the poor of the city. Let the President change these figures any way he likes. It is 29,500 residences required for the poor of the city. What has been done in the eleven years? What has been done in the seven years that have elapsed since the President took control. without going outside the City of Dublin? What has been done in the City of Dublin to improve these conditions? There have been, to give a generous estimate, 3,500 houses built out of the 29,500 residences necessary for the poor. There has been an increased demand since that report was made. If Mr. Cowan were reporting now, on account of the increase in the population of Dublin, it would not be an over-estimate to say that there were probably 5,000 more to be added. Let us put it at 3,000 more. That means that one-fourth of the population of the city are housed in unsanitary conditions. It is no credit to anybody responsible to say that in the capital, under the very eyes of the legislature, and under the daily notice of members of the Executive Council, the poor are existing in such scandalous conditions. In proportion to what is required, practically nothing is being done to alleviate these conditions. In the whole of the Free State, houses at the rate of 2,500 per year have been built in recent years. Probably 50,000 houses would be required for the whole of the Free State. That is not good enough, considering how money can be spent on unnecessary luxuries. Some of these luxuries were referred to in recent debates on the Estimates, but I would be probably out of order if I referred to them now.
Reference was made to the provision of long-term loans for the building of houses. During the last twelve months the question of long-term loans has been raised by different Deputies on several occasions, and we were told that it was impossible to provide the money. The President, in referring to that subject and to the question of housing in general, said as recently as the 20th of March: "It is the merest nonsense to say that money can solve the housing problem, and those who persist in saying that money can solve the housing problem know they are talking nonsense." Well, if money is not the principal and the greatest obstacle I should like to know what is the greatest obstacle to the proper provision of houses, so far as this State is concerned.
There are other considerations, I admit. The cost of building enters into it to a large extent, but money is the primary consideration, and it is a very easy way to get out of it to say that money will not solve the problem. If we had the money here, I think it would be very easy to solve the problem; and considering what we are spending money on, even in this State with the people taxed as they are, ten times the sum that is being spent at present could be spent on the provision of houses for the poor. On the same date, or a day after, the Minister for Local Government and Public Health said, when he was speaking in the debate on this question of long-term loans and the provision of money for houses: "We are invited to borrow at present a large number of millions of pounds at 5 per cent. We would not be invited to do that by people shouldering any responsibility in connection with the actual borrowing or carrying out of the work." Those of us who know the conditions and that have them up against our door in the City of Dublin know quite well what the responsibility is upon us in this matter. We know quite well what responsibility we would be shouldering, if we had the power and asked our people to borrow millions of money for housing. We believe we would be doing the best work that could be done for the uplifting of the people by shouldering such respon-sibility——
Comment on this
Even at 5 per cent. for such schemes. I believe if an earnest effort was made, the Government stating the facts as they know them—and if they appealed to the people of Ireland for that money for the alleviation of the housing position alone—people would be prepared to give the money to the President and his Ministry to help to get the poor of the Free State in general, and of the City of Dublin in particular, out of the awful and disgraceful hovels they are obliged to live in at present. I have that much belief in my own people. I think an effort should be made to see what could be done in that direction, and put it in a way that would strike the imagination of those who could afford to put their hands in their pockets and help their helpless brethren out of the awful conditions in which they are exisiting at present.
A statement appeared in the "Irish Independent" recently on another aspect of public policy, particularly in regard to the city of Dublin, one that the Ministry, no doubt, is fully aware of, and that is the "startling increase," as the paper calls it, in the cost of outdoor relief in the Dublin area.
The "Irish Independent," 6th June, says: "A startling increase of £40,000 per annum in the cost of outdoor relief in the Dublin Union area was revealed to an ‘Irish Independent' representative who made inquiries on the subject," and the gentleman who gave the figures is Dr. O'Dwyer, Chairman of the Union Commissioners. Presumably Dr. O'Dwyer, who has been in that office for a number of years, knows what he is talking about. He said the chief cause is prolonged unemployment, which brings on sickness in family on account of want of nourishment. That statement alone, issued by one of the officials appointed by the Ministry of Local Government administering Poor Law relief in Dublin City, is a condemnation of the present Free State Executive. They ought to have taken some drastic steps to meet the situation that is confronting them every day in the City of Dublin. That statement alone is, to my mind, sufficient condemnation and proof of the ineptitude of the Executive Council, presided over by the President.
They have not made any sufficient effort to meet the awful situation that we here in Dublin know to exist. If we were to speak out freely and candidly, we would have to bear out the statement of Dr. O'Dwyer and say that the conditions in Dublin are really appalling. I do not know whether Deputies who represent Dublin in the President's Party are satisfied that the Executive Council and the members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party have done all that could be done for the last five or seven years. I certainly am not. I would give credit where credit was due if I saw an effort commensurate with the task made by the Government to meet the situation. Speaking of the conditions that exist in Dublin alone, the President and the Executive Council stand condemned and are proved to have neglected the task of relieving the poor or finding a method to give employment to the thousands of families that are now actually starving, or on the verge of starvation, in the city of Dublin.
Comment on this
Notwithstanding the case that has been made by Deputies that improvement has taken place in the unemployment problem in this country, I contend the opposite is the case. In my own county of Carlow, for instance, recently an industry has been closed down and a number of people have been thrown on the unemployed list. Then, again, the number of young men coming out of the Army owing to reorganisation has increased the numbers unemployed in the country. While we have this unemployment problem in the country, it will always be a source of weakness to any Government. I believe, however, there are means at the disposal of the Executive Council, if they would only put them into effect, in connection with the development of rural industries and agriculture that would help to decrease unemployment. We could find, as a matter of fact, employment for all the people if we could break up the ranches, go in for afforestation, drainage, road-making, and, of course, housing.
We could employ all our own people around the country if we would only develop agriculture. It would not so much be the employment of hundreds as of thousands. We could employ thousands in the production of our own butter, bacon, eggs, and those other things that agriculture is capable of producing. That would employ our own people instead of allowing all these goods to come in here and at the same time having our own people emigrating to other countries, the countries which supply us with these imports. We, as a matter of fact, by our insane policies support these countries. Unemployment is a source of weakness instead of a source of strength to any country. While you have that problem in a country, you will never have that peace or contentment which is so much desired by every Deputy in this House. Something will have to be done. There is no use in waiting. If you continue to wait, conditions will even get worse. It is no good for a country to have people with no means to keep themselves and those dependent on them in any state of comfort. I think the President will do well to look into this matter.
There is no use in making points by one side of the House against another side of the House. There is nothing to be gained by political parties trying to score off each other in a question like this. We have had too much washing of dirty linen in this House for the last couple of years and it would be better if Deputies would discuss ways and means so as to meet this problem and get a solution. I ask the President seriously to consider some of the things put forward in connection with agriculture which is so much neglected that it has become a source of weakness to the State and is not giving employment to the people.
The agricultural worker is the worst paid and the hardest worked man in the country. He is not getting a proper show. Even when employed, he is not properly paid. He does not get employment always because we have only 1,500,000 acres of land under the plough. The unemployed are in a serious condition. Some of them are living in abject misery with nothing to eat and with very little clothing. That statement of their position may appear farfetched but to any person who knows the real position in rural Ireland and who has some experience it is not an overdrawn picture. Some consideration should be given immediately to this problem and the Dáil should not wait until it is too late.
Comment on this
I know that Deputy O'Kelly knows a great deal about the housing problem in Dublin —a great deal more than I know. One reason for this problem is that everyone in the country appears to think that the streets of Dublin are paved with gold. They are all flocking up to Dublin. The population of the Free State has not increased out of proportion to the increase in the building of new houses. But I know that the population of Dublin has increased out of all proportion, and I do not know whether Deputy O'Kelly sees that that makes the problem, as far as the Dáil is concerned, and as far as every Deputy here is concerned, a very difficult one.
Comment on this
However distressing this debate, which has extended itself over a long space of time and over a still larger variety of topics, is to those Deputies who are in a great hurry to have their holidays, it will have a valuable effect if it helps to improve the situation generally by getting the Government, during the rest from legislative work, to tackle the various questions that we have been discussing to-day. It is true that a large number of the Deputies and the Ministers of the Executive Council are perturbed and worried by this constant reference to questions of unemployment. But the very fact that questions like them are brought up periodically here, and that you have had a number of Deputies speaking on them I think with sincerity and with a belief that things can be done and should be done which are not being done—the very fact that you have that state of affairs after this Parliament has run two years of its life, and after all Parties except a very small section are now represented here, must give all true Irishmen cause for anxiety. It must make us ask ourselves whether in fact this House is doing the work that the people expect it to do; whether, in fact, we and the Executive Council who rule here are worthy of the enconiums that we read so frequently in the Press, whether it is true this is a very prosperous country, that conditions are steadily improving, and that if people would only work hard, as they do in other countries, things would solve themselves.
Deputies have referred to the slums of Dublin; Deputies have referred to the slums in the Gaeltacht; Deputies have referred to derelict farms in the country; Deputies have referred to industries that have closed down. I say the Ministers who find themselves in contact with these different phases of the national life should get little charts hung up in their different offices, on which would be recorded the amount of employment given in the country and the number of industries, factories and workshops that have been closed down in their different spheres of activity. The fishing industry has been almost completely blotted out; although two or three Commissions were appointed to investigate the whole question, nothing has been done. The housing question has been held up by reason of the difficulty of long-term loans. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health believes he has found a new solution for that question by postulating a rate of 1/- in the £. I would remind the Minister, as Deputy Murphy has just reminded him, that the fact that you have a fairly prosperous population in the City of Dublin, drawing incomes out of all proportion to the incomes that persons in corresponding offices on the Continent draw, and that that and the number of motor cars which have been so frequently referred to here, are not any indication as to what the conditions are down the country. In fact, the more Dublin increases and prospers, the greater is the simple contrast between conditions here, as they appear superficially, and the conditions which Deputies on the opposite side, as well as on this side, know to exist in other parts of the country.
You have the small towns of Ireland, as a distinguished man of letters pointed out recently, threatened with extinction. You have a Government here which insists on centralising, as I understand it, in its policy of selective protection, industries about the City of Dublin; in centralising in Dublin, as far as we can see, all the offices of the State and a great deal of the work which hitherto was carried out under local departments. You have the transport of the country drawing the population and drawing the traffic of the country into Dublin. Now, you have the Minister for Local Government and Public Health telling us, if the country towns and the farmers could only be got to face this question of 1/- in the £ on the rates, for housing, that perhaps subsequently that problem can be dealt with. I say that you cannot increase the rates, or increase any other local charge until the Government that you have here first takes steps to increase the commercial activities down the country, until it takes steps to increase productivity, whether in agriculture or industry, and until it holds up its hands and says: "We have this number of derelict farms in the country. We are not going to have more. On the contrary, we are going to see that every farm that is not worked will be, as far as we can help it, set to work within the next twelve months." The same applies to the various offices and factories closed down. We want to see the Government taking the attitude next session that these things are going to be remedied; that instead of having this centralising business going on the Government is going to say that it is now time to give the country a chance.
The country has the greatest sympathy with the problems of Dublin. Every Deputy here wants to see the slums removed and worthy dwellings provided for the poor. But we have the fact that the rest of the country is threatened with depopulation. Certainly there is a wholesale exodus of the present population threatened. We want to put a stop to that, and we want the Government to say, knowing they are going to get the co-operation and support of the House, that they are prepared to put their shoulders to the wheel and to remedy that state of affairs. I do not want further to prolong this discussion. I congratulate the various Deputies who have spoken on this matter. I say that there is not a single Department, the Department of Industry and Commerce, Local Government and Public Health, the Fisheries Department, or the President's Department, that is not deserving of censure.
We want men of vision and imagination here. We want men who are not tired and who do not make every effort at the end of a session in order that they may have a holiday or that certain supporters of theirs, as the daily Press tells us, may have a holiday during the month of July. We are told that this House is going to close down and finish its labours just for that reason. We want to have the feeling before we break up that these problems which are troubling every one of us and that we all have at heart are being attended to by the Executive Council, and we want to feel that the Executive Council is doing its best to remedy matters. One problem which, in my opinion, overshadows all others is how to establish some policy or some economy in the country that will give the rural population and the population in the smaller towns hope that there is some other place in the Free State besides Dublin, some other place worthy of consideration, and some other place for which a genuine policy ought to be formulated here.
Comment on this
I just want to state that some time this afternoon I mentioned that I would give certain references before the debate closes. I have those references now. Deputy O'Kelly has given one reference with respect to the Minister for Local Government. I know that the Minister mentioned five per cent. I will make it quite clear that the Minister's objection was not based on 5 per cent., as he would like us to believe now, because immediately afterwards when the phrase was quoted he made another remark which, perhaps, I had better read for the House:—"We are invited to borrow at present a large number of millions of pounds at five per cent. We would not be invited to do that by people shouldering any responsibility in connection with the actual borrowing or carrying out of the work. That is the policy. We must transfer a large portion of whatever loss there is going to be for the provision of houses for the working classes on to the shoulders of the ratepayers." It is quite obvious from that, that it was not the five per cent——
Comment on this
The question of five per cent. is material. We were asked to borrow a large number of millions at five per cent. and to start building houses by means of State machinery at a time when the different sections in the House here argued that the whole business of house building was bankrupt.
Comment on this
My only remark to that is that if that were in the Minister's mind on that occasion he would be just as well able to make his point then as now. The fact is that he was not, and it was another point he was making.
Comment on this
Deputy Derrig stressed very much the fact that a large number of the Deputies on this side of the House were anxious to get away for their holidays. If the Deputy is not aware of the fact that a great number of his own colleagues on the opposite benches are very anxious to get away for their holidays, he is indeed making a great mistake. Everybody else is aware of that fact, and everybody else knows that the Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches are as keen on getting away as he declares Deputies on this side of the House are. Everybody knows that there is just as little anxiety for work on the part of the Deputies opposite as there is in any part of the country. We have every evidence of that here. The leader of the Party made two quotations, and when he was making the quotations he had neither of them before him. The time of the House is therefore wasted in order to give Deputy de Valera an opportunity of making explanations at the end of the debate.
Comment on this
I made a statement which was a correct summary of a statement made by the Minister and I was then asked for the quotations.
Comment on this
The Deputy was asked for another quotation by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and he did not have it at his fingers' ends. Neither did he tell the House that what he quoted was only portion of a statement made by the Minister. He did not tell the House that the Minister went on at great length to explain the Government policy. The mere quotation of a single sentence from a speech made here by the Minister was about as incorrect a method of giving expression to his view as it would be possible to get.
The Deputy is meticulous in his exactitude with regard to his own statements and with regard to the interpretation put upon his statements by people outside, and very often he goes to great length in the columns of the newspapers, and by way of speeches here and elsewhere to give explanations of what he said on different occasions. It would be well if the Deputy abided by the terms of the Gospel: "Do unto others ...."
Comment on this
Deputy Derrig, in the course of his speech, advised us to solve every problem but not to put one penny extra on the ratepayers. "Be popular at the expense of the people that we are endeavouring to shake the confidence of the people in."
Comment on this
Deputy O'Kelly is another example of one of those who addresses himself to a subject without making any study of it. Then when he is laughed at in respect of some faux pas he makes he declares "You are gibing at the poor," the poor being represented by himself; he is the poor. Nobody I ever heard of in this country, no Irishman, has ever gibed at the poor. The Deputy's statement in that connection is not worthy of him, and not worthy of a representative of this City. I will have a little gibe at the poor Deputy. Speaking on the Housing Bill—and I overlooked this on the last occasion out of charity to the Deputy—he said: "This Bill makes available a sum of £200,000. That will not go very far in helping to solve the problem, and £50,000 along with it would be required, at least, in the next five years in Dublin City alone, to do anything like what would be adequate to meet the need of the next five years, at any rate, for housing the working classes and the poorer classes in Dublin." Did anybody ever read greater nonsense than that? £250,000 in five years! Deputy Lemass laughed when he heard that statement. I looked across at him and shook my head and he smiled, as much as to say, "Go easy with him when you are replying to this." And so I did.
Later on, we had the Deputy's solution for the housing problem. It really shows that he did not make a study of the matter, for he said: "I suggest to the Government that within the next five years they should raise a sum of £2,600,000 a year. That would be £13,000,000 in five years. Of that amount, they should give one-fourth, £3,250,000, or thereabouts, in grants." After telling us that we would require £250,000 for the next five years, and that that would be an adequate sum, he immediately multiplies it by fifteen, forgetting what he had told us a few minutes before. I submit that this is the type of study reflected in these quotations. If the Deputy thinks that I am doing him an injustice, he can read the book. Sometimes in a circus, if there is any question of doubt about a matter, someone says, "Let us see what the book says." The book in this case is against the Deputy. I asked subsequently, if the Government were to give £3,250,000 during a period of five years and houses were erected at the Deputy's own computation of between £400 and £500 each, what sum would the municipality be asked to contribute towards the scheme. The same amount, namely £650,000. That would mean 11/- in the £. That is the great national scheme for housing in the City of Dublin. I hope that Deputy De Valera when looking for people to adorn his Front Bench will get people who will pay more attention to facts than has been shown by his second in command. The Deputy spoke of 3,500 houses. The actual figure is 5,394. The Deputy was a member of the Dublin Corporation from about 1905 and, going back thirty years before that time—the first date on which the Dublin Corporation entered on housing—the total number of houses provided up to the year 1922 was 2,251. If I am charged with having neglected the housing problem in Dublin I can show that in the seven years since we took office we have provided two and a half times more houses in Dublin than were provided in the previous forty years.
Comment on this
I am going to deal with the Deputy but I will let him down very easily. A statement has been referred to which was made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in 1924. Two Deputies referred to it but neither of them had the book.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce on that occasion said: "It is not the function of this Dáil to provide work, and the sooner that is realised the better." Further on he said: "To state broadly and definitely that the Dáil ought to be able to provide work for the country is giving the Dáil a function which it has no right to take on itself." I am speaking not only to the Leader of the Labour Party and to the Leader of Fianna Fáil, but also to the theologian who addressed himself to the subject last week, and I advise all persons concerned to read the whole speech made by the Minister on that occasion, and to read his speech made on the following day. The Minister stated on the 30th October, 1924, in regard to unemployment:
"Unemployment was the problem, and the only cure for it, as I said previously in this House, is employment. The question is how to increase production, how to increase the activity of industry, and how to increase it particularly in such a way that labour would be employed, not wastefully on roads and relief schemes, but in its normal occupations. That problem faced us last Easter, and certain lines of attack were developed to meet that problem. We have followed along these lines since. The situation has, however, recently been complicated by one other event, that there has been, partially, we believe, a failure of the harvest and an almost complete failure of the fuel supply in the poorer districts."
On the following day, 31st October, the Minister said:
"The other point raised by the Deputy was a very serious matter; it was founded rather on the ver balism to which other people object. He took my phrase of last night when I said, and said very definitely, that I believed it was not the function of the Dáil or of the Government to provide employment, and I stressed that point. It was a negative answer, and I stressed that negative answer. I said it because I was answering a very definite statement made by Deputy Morrissey, who said that the population of this country was small and that the Dáil ought to be able to provide employment. I want to stress this point, that there is no State control of industry here, and to that extent I have nothing to take away from the words I used last night."
Comment on this
The Deputy is irrepressible. The Minister, continuing, said:
"It is not the function of the Dáil directly and immediately to provide employment. I did say that. I used the same phrase last night to indicate that certain pressure could be put on people, that certain tendencies could be developed and that certain adjustments in the fiscal system could be made so as to ensure, as far as we could ensure without interfering directly with trade or enterprise, that there would be more employment; but beyond that we cannot go; we cannot for the moment enter into the field of State interference or State control of industry. There is a great deal of State interference at present, but you cannot go to the point of State control——
Mr. Johnson: Does the Minister repudiate any responsibility for securing that opportunities for employment shall be provided?
Mr. McGilligan: No. I think I have already stated that anything that can be done to see that employment will grow, and that employment will be provided for those eager and willing to work, that we will do. I made a statement last night of the approach of my Department to the problem by unemployment insurance, relief schemes, and certain remedial measures to foster trade and industry, and if there is anything that is missing from the chain which I revealed last night, I would like to have the gaps shown to me, and I would like to have further links put into my hand to forge into the chain."
That is a very different statement from the two statements we heard from two responsible Deputies here, knowing that they were speaking to the Dáil and to the people of the country. If I were a stranger to the country listening to the debate and hearing those statements I would say that it was either a poor House or a miserable country. These are the statements which are impeding progress, industrial expansion and business here as much as anything else.
Comment on this
Would the President state that in his view it is the duty of the State to provide work for the unemployed?
Comment on this
The Deputy can gather what he wishes from what I subsequently say.
Comment on this
Is the President making any attempt to qualify or modify the statement by the Minister for Industry and Commerce?
Comment on this
I am putting the true facts before the House, and the facts suppressed by Deputy de Valera and Deputy O'Connell which I have read out, which are there on record, and which were not quoted by those who criticised the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Government on this matter.
Comment on this
They do, and so do subsequent statements of the Minister. What is more, so do the various activities which the Minister outlined, and which I am now going to weary the Dáil by recounting.
Comment on this
And the results, if the Deputy wishes. Year after year we have this wail from one Party or the other Party. The Labour Party got in before the Fianna Fáil Party on this occasion, having a little more experience and more knowledge of Parliamentary work, and knowing more of the job perhaps. While they pretend to score off one another in debate we see them lining up in the same Lobby against the only sensible people in the country.
Comment on this
I shall now refer to the methods adopted for providing employment. Direct employment has been provided by:—(a) (1) Office of Public Works on buildings, drainage, etc., provided employment during each of the past four years for an average of 4,000 persons. This included certain special relief works, such as internal painting, to relieve seasonal unemployment. (2) Defence Department.—In addition to the 5,500 whole-time officers and men, and the payments to 7,000 reservists, the Army provides employment for 400 civilian tradesmen, chefs, waiters, and miscellaneous unskilled workers. (3) Department of Local Government and Public Health.—Roads: In the last five years grants to local authorities for the improvement and upkeep of roads, repair of damaged bridges, amounted to over 5½ million pounds. In addition, the local authorities expended about 7 million during that period. Returns for the period of 2½ years to-date show the number of men employed by direct labour on roads and bridges to average 16,113 per month. The State grants pay 1 out of every 2 men on repair of trunk roads; 3 out of every 10 men on repair of link roads; 10 out of every 11 men on improvement of all roads. (4) Industry and Commerce.—On the Shannon scheme and the Electricity Supply Board, though there is considerable variation from time to time in the number at work, the average, over the first six months of the current year, was 5,500 men in continuous employment. (5) Lands and Fisheries.—In the five years ended 31st March last, £1,371,000 was spent by the Land Commission on improvement of estates and on special works. These works were largely undertaken in places where and at times abnormal unemployment prevailed. The figure includes materials, but in work of this kind a very large proportion of the money goes in wages. Fisheries.—Department of Fisheries have given direct employment to 87 men for about 20 weeks in each of the past five years. About 1,000 girls are given employment in knitting, lace-making, and embroidery in the 34 industrial centres maintained by the Department. Most of these are part-time home workers. (6) Agriculture.— Forestry: The forestry operations of the Department provide employment, varying with the season of the year, from 240 to 520 workmen. The planting programme has been considerably extended in recent years. It is anticipated that further contemplated extensions in the programme will afford continuous employment for an additional 50 men each year.
(b) Indirect encouragement for employment has been provided by:— (1) Office of Public Works.—Under the Land Loan Service, loans amounting to almost £500,000 have been sanctioned. It is not possible to obtain accurate figures as to the amount of employment afforded out of these encouragements to building farmhouses, out-offices, etc., but it is estimated that about 300 men per annum are employed on this class of work. (2) Local Government.— Under the various housing grants to private persons and local authorities approximately 16,000 houses have been provided in the last five years, the unexpended balance will provide a further 3,500 houses. The number of persons given continuous employment during the period may be roughly calculated at 1½ persons per annum for each house built, say, 4,800 persons. The opening of the Local Loans Fund for financing schemes for local authorities under the Housing of the Working Classes Acts will greatly stimulate the activities of these bodies and provide further employment. If one takes Dublin City alone, 4,379 houses have been provided or are in course of being built. About 1,700 people have been continuously employed in this work. (3) Industry and Commerce. —It is estimated that the various tariffs imposed have increased the employment of Irish workers by about 12,000 persons, while the facilities afforded under the Trade Loans Guarantee Acts enabled about 2,000 persons to secure employment. (4) Lands and Fisheries.—In the last 5 years 600 fishermen have been assisted to obtain appliances such as boats, nets, and other gear. Schemes are in contemplation to secure increased employment in inshore fishing and to contribute to the development of deep sea trawling, as well as for an extensive building programme in Gaeltacht areas. Steps are being taken to revive the homespun industry in Donegal, to extend this to other parts of the Gaeltacht, and to put the rural industries in the Gaeltacht on a sounder and more extensive footing. (5) Agriculture.— Schemes for improvement of agriculture provide employment for farmers and increase production generally. Beet Sugar in addition to the extra farm labour which it provides has given employment to approximately 600 men during the manufacturing season which lasts between 5 and 6 months, and to between 120 and 180 people during the off season. Incidentally, increased employment is provided for carters, bag-makers, etc., apart from the employment afforded in the building of the factory. The policy of the Government Contracts Committee of giving preference to Saorstát manufacturers has resulted in many contracts being retained here which would otherwise go abroad. The figures are not very large in themselves, representing perhaps, £100,000 in wages during the last five years, but the importance to small firms of securing these contracts to keep them going is considerable.
Comment on this
I am prepared, if the Deputy will have just a little patience, to go on to deal with that on the most unfavourable basis which has been presented by the Labour Party. They have been a little more direct in their charge against us. The Deputy mentioned about 50,000. I am prepared to consider the figure as between 80,000 and 90,000, and compare that figure with the figures across the water and in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
Does the President suggest that the beet-sugar manufacturing season extends for five or six months? I think the period normally given is 92 days.
Comment on this
It lasts between five and six months, according to my information. I am not banking on the six hundred men employed as proving my case. I am prepared to take the Deputy's statement.
Comment on this
It is a negligible matter as it is one of the smallest groups.
Comment on this
May I ask a question? The President has stated that 87 fishermen got constant employment for some time in connection with the Fisheries Department, and that a few thousand girls got temporary employment for some months at packing fish.
Comment on this
I said that 87 men for a period of twenty weeks in each of the past five years got employment.
Comment on this
As President of the Executive Council, the President is responsible.
Comment on this
That is an impossible position in which to place the President of the Executive Council. The President cannot be expected to answer for each particular Department. The Department of Fisheries has still to be dealt with, and this point is bound to arise.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, for yourself, sir, you were not here during the whole of the debate. It ranged over a long period. I am held responsible for events so far back as the time of Wolfe Tone. Deputy de Valera did not go back so far as that but he criticised the policy of my predecessor in 1922. I do not know that that is altogether within the ambit of my Vote on this occasion, but I venture to say that most of the charges made against us of having lowered the flag and having been on the run from the British, having surrendered, and so on, have come from a Party whose most distinguished characteristic in the last few years has been "Cease fire" or "Haul down the flag." I regret that. I would like to see a Party opposed to me so that I could cheerfully leave office, satisfied that the dignity, the status, and the business of the country would be well maintained. and whose fighting spirit would be at least second only to my own. That is one of the things which make me most depressed— when I consider what is going to happen when this Ministry leaves office, and who will replace it. Amongst the criticisms of the Vote, it has been stated that the amount has been increased to £11,973. I was charged by Deputy Dr. Ryan with having an extra higher executive officer. My impression is that the Vote is too low, that the office is not sufficiently manned, that the personnel is overworked from top to bottom, and that, if at any time there is a change, the Vote will be certainly largely increased. There is no person in that establishment who has not done overtime without payment. All the work in connection with the Department has increased from year to year. We have lately been handed the baby of unemployment. It is not our child at all. It is handed round. Deputy O'Connell fathered it this year, and Deputy de Valera will father it next year. The office is undermanned and I anticipate an increase in the Vote. My notes here are so voluminous that it would take a much longer time than I have at my disposal to deal with them.
Comment on this
Deputies have all night. I shall not occupy very much of it. Deputy O'Connell says that our policy is too slow. In connection with the same thing, we have the criticism that the Minister for Local Government when borrowing money last March, announced from the Ministerial Benches that we did not consider it good policy to borrow money. There was every indication that the price of money was going to increase, that the discount rates would be increased. Occasionally, I see hangers-on of the Party opposite, or other people who do not know anything about finance, addressing themselves to the subject as if it were something which this or any other country could control. Last year, the Bank of England was most anxious to reduce the bank rate in order to help industry, but the fluctuations in the money market in Wall Street compelled an increase in the Bank of England rate in England. Was any Englishman small-minded enough to say, "We are controlled by Wall Street"?
Comment on this
Very few. I never read of one of them, and I never heard any person say that they had heard any Englishman say so.
Comment on this
We are advised not to look to England by Deputy Little, and by the banking expert, Deputy Kennedy, and at the same time as we are advised not to look to England we are given two gentlemen in English finance as authorities on that particular line of policy.
Comment on this
I am thinking on Irish lines, and have been doing so all my life. I am not by any means impressed by the fact that other people are depressed because things cannot go well; we must go to someone else. We got views on all these matters by very expert bankers from as far away as the United States and Australia. They considered our banking situation here and advised us. If I were to take the advice of Deputies opposite on this question of banking, I think I would be advised in the first place to bring in an Act to restrict banks from raising the bank rate of interest when every other bank in the world is doing it.
Comment on this
Counsels are even divided on banking. I leave it at that.
Comment on this
May I ask the President to refer to a single speech on this side where such a suggestion as he has made occurs?
Comment on this
I think I qualified the statement I made by saying "Some hangers-on or other persons like those." One particular gentleman who was presiding at a meeting at which very distinguished members of the Opposition were present, stated that we were controlled by British finance. Deputies opposite often make such a statement. I heard Deputy Flinn say that there was a stranglehold here.
Comment on this
I was not there. I did not see the report. I do not read everything the Deputy says, and even if I did it would not change my view that the person who puts his money in a bank has as good a right here to get his rate of interest as a man in England or in America who puts his money into a bank. Last March, every indication that could possibly be given was given in the money markets that money was tight and that there would be a difficulty in borrowing. Directly that situation eased, the Minister for Local Government, the Minister for Finance and myself had a conference in connection with local loans for housing. It was the one thing that stopped it. I believe, in a moment of weakness, I conveyed to a member of this House that he might not be uneasy in his mind, that it was possible we would be able to do that.
Exactly the same policy has been followed in the last four or five years with regard to the credit of this State. It is established. It is on a sound basis. That basis can be very seriously affected in a very short time by any administration. Borrow in respect of a service from which there is no return and the credit of the country is diminished. Borrow in respect of services for which repayment will not be made and the same thing will happen. All those things are known by financiers and to our own people who have their money in the banks and who cannot lend their money to any administration which does not show that it is capable of using it to the best public advantage.
I think Deputy Coburn was the one that addressed himself most to the fact that in respect to any service one must get value for money spent. Deputy Lemass said that we have to approach this thing in a straight line. Money has got to be put into circulation. Somebody has to pay for it. If the ten thousand pounds or whatever it is cannot be met, if there is not good value for it, if the purpose of the expenditure is not justified, it will all come back and have its reactions. In respect of our administration here for the last seven years, every possible attention was paid to getting value, as far as we could, for every service and those who addressed themselves lightly to housing ought to look back seven years and see what it cost to provide a house in the City of Dublin. It cost £750 seven years ago, and we can get practically the same house to-day for a shade over £500. Would it have been good business, when there was unemployment, to borrow and spend £750 and leave to people for the next fifteen or twenty years to pay back the service of a debt in respect of which value could not be shown.
A great advantage to the Party opposite, as I often said, is that they have such an example before them in respect of administration and that if ever they do get responsibility for administration, they will have very few precedents that are not sound, sensible and creditable.
The one person on the Fianna Fáil Benches who addressed himself very sensibly to this question of unemployment was Deputy Lemass. He only went off the deep end where it was clear he had not experience of administration, and that is quite an understandable proposition. It was not on this occasion alone but on other occasions that the Deputy laid it down that we should get value for money. Seven years ago, building was at a standstill; practically no building was being done. One need only go through any part of the country at the present moment, as far north as Donegal, as far south as Kerry, and even to Wexford, where Deputy Corish said they were not able to bear the burden of increased housing, and one sees housing all over. It took some time to nurture that and to improve it, and the situation now, compared with seven years ago, is one which is much more easily dealt with than was the position at that particular time.
Deputy de Valera addressed himself to the question of imports and exports. If his statement is read— and probably his own supporters occasionally read what he says—it will be entirely misleading. There was a figure of £19,000,000 which he omitted from the exports and a figure of one and a half million pounds from the imports which he might reasonably have added.
Comment on this
Does that mislead anybody? Does anybody draw the conclusion from it that it is the sum total of our exports?
Comment on this
Certainly not. That is what I object to in all those statements. Taking them as they stand, they do not give anything like a true picture of the country. We export nineteen million pounds' worth of live animals.
Comment on this
May I ask the President if it is a satisfactory situation that we should at the moment be importing, under the heading of food, drink and tobacco, twenty-three million pounds' worth, and that we should be exporting under those heads—remember we are an agricultural country—only twenty-one million pounds' worth?
Comment on this
It is apparently satisfactory to people who have experience in business, which the Deputy has not.
Comment on this
It is those people who are making the wealth of this country and not the talkers. It is those people who are responsible for the industry, the commerce and the agriculture of the country and not the Deputy and the other speakers on that side.
Comment on this
The President should leave the trade balance alone. He should remember what happened in Kilkenny.
Comment on this
Certainly, and it was a matter which was corrected directly my attention was drawn to it. The Deputy should remember that the first time he made a speech here he made a withdrawal when I pointed out to him his mistake. There was a full and complete withdrawal in my case. I always put the true facts before the people. If my attention is directed to any mistake in connection with any statement, written or otherwise, I will correct it like a man. The Deputy will remember that after the facts were explained he said, "I withdraw." The Deputy went on to say that there are 246 people in this country drawing £374,000—£1,300 each. One does not get a position like that in the service of the State without certain qualifications. If those positions are not available in this country, there is a market elsewhere for the most brilliant of our citizens.
Comment on this
I will talk about emigration in its own time. The people who emigrate from here are, in the main, persons who are not so well educated, unfortunately for themselves. But here is the cream of the country, 246 citizens having got positions by their qualifications at £1,300 a year each. The Deputy's proposal is that we are not able to pay, and that they should go elsewhere.
Comment on this
The principal one is sound common sense, a particular attribute which is almost absent from the benches over there.
Comment on this
I heard you the other day, when you had a certain gentleman sitting beside you—Deputy Briscoe—telling the Minister for Finance that he was acting like a Jewman in connection with income tax. Nobody else would have the indelicacy to have made the statement except a Deputy on the opposite benches.
Comment on this
If I heard them I would reply, but, unfortunately, they were made in the Deputy's own particular patois and I do not quite understand it sometimes. Several Deputies have addressed themselves to the fact that this is a dominant question. We know it is, but very few addressed themselves to the method of dealing with it in such a way that it would no longer be either a question or a problem with us. The policy of the Government in connection with it has been to do whatever necessary public works there are and to make it easy for local authorities to do whatever necessary public works there are, to place the least possible burden on either the ratepayer or the taxpayer, to stimulate industry, to eliminate waste and, generally, to improve every service of the State in such a way that the wealth of the country will increase and that there will be, in consequence, more employment. We are invited to embark on schemes which are hastily conceived and ill-digested, and which are not likely to add to the wealth of the country, and are merely palliatives. The list I have read out of employment which has been given here is practically unknown to the man in the street, and practically unheard of by most electors of the country. Yet it is a list which forms a very sound and sensible explanation of the Government's policy for the last five or six years. We could have, perhaps, cut a much better figure if, instead of that a couple of millions per year were voted to the relief of unemployment, which, the Deputy knows, would be an expensive and wasteful method of dealing with it. Unemployment is not peculiar to this country. In proportion to the population, the problem in this country compares favourably with the position in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Both of these countries are more highly industrialised than we are, and nobody will deny, as far as Great Britain is concerned, that it is a much richer country than this is. Taking the average number registered as unemployed in the months of March and April and May as a percentage of the total population, we find that the figure is .65 in Saorstát Eireann. as compared with 2.7 approximately in Northern Ireland and Great Britain.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy hold his patience a short time? I think it was Saint Paul who said "Possess your soul in patience." If Deputies read a little more about Saint Paul it would be very much better for this country.
Comment on this
And if the President read more about the Unemployment Insurance Act in England it would be better for him.
Comment on this
I know as much about it as it is possible for me to learn. The average number registered as unemployed in this country during the months I have mentioned, March, April and May, is 19,428. It is quite true that that figure does not cover the total number unemployed; there are people, such as agricultural labourers, domestic servants, and persons who have exhausted their benefits, to be added. The same is true of Northern Ireland and Great Britain, not, I will admit, to the same extent, but it is true nevertheless. It may be agreed that the relative proportion of unregistered to unemployed is, for various reasons, smaller in those countries than here. Definite figures as regards the total extent of unemployment will not be available until the Census Returns are complete. Even then, for various reasons, the Census figures will require adjustment before a proper figure can be given.
Comment on this
Might I inform the President that the number of unemployed in May was 9.9 per cent? I am quoting from the current issue of the "Economist."
Comment on this
We are probably dealing with different figures. What I am dealing with is the total number of persons registered as against the total number unemployed. Your figure is a percentage of the total insured persons. An estimate was given in the Dáil from the Labour Benches that there were between 80,000 and 90,000 persons unemployed. They do not make wild statements. These are the figures they mentioned within the last few years. I am taking that number. Supposing we take the figure 85,000 for the purpose of argument, the percentage of unemployed as against the total population in Saorstat Eireann would be about 2.8 as compared with 2.7 for the registered unemployed only in Great Britain. I hope I have made that point perfectly clear. Agricultural labourers are not registered over there.
Comment on this
The 80,000 they mentioned included agricultural workers. If it did not, of course, that will alter the situation.
I believe that they made the biggest case that they possibly could make when they said between 80,000 and 90,000. Assume that the figure is correct and compare it with the register of unemployed in Great Britain. The figures regarding the average number registered weekly as unemployed, while they cannot be regarded as giving complete information will, at least, serve as a basis for comparison as between one year and another in regard to the state of unemployment. Deputies will admit that. An examination of these figures shows that there has been a very material drop within the last four years. These figures are borne out by the increase which has taken place in the total contributions in respect of workers in employment. Deputies, if they look at the Estimate for this year, will find there a sum of £5,000 more in the way of a contribution towards the unemployment fund and for special schemes. It will be admitted, in dealing with the question of unemployment, that there will always be casual unemployment. There will be certain people in a process of transition from one job to another, there will be a number of people drawing sick benefit who are unable for the time being to work through illness, and there will be the more or less vagrant class whose aptitude for work is not of a normal order.
Comment on this
We are a little beyond the scheduled time to-night. There will be seasonal unemployment in certain trades, and these aspects of the situation do not readily lend themselves to a solution. When you add an unusual number, that does become a problem of some magnitude. In times of abnormal distress we have resorted to special relief works. Deputies know that our experience has been confirmed even by themselves, and that special expenditure so undertaken is generally unremunerative and uneconomic. Consequently, we have been more concerned to provide employment on constructive work calculated to produce permanent assets, or to facilitate the provision of new avenues for permanent employment. The measures which we have taken, most of which I have read out, such as the Shannon electricity scheme, the tariff policy which we have pursued, our large expenditure on roads and housing, have been dictated by these considerations. There are other considerations which people are sometimes apt to forget in discussing the problem. One is that there has been a considerable increase in the general standard of living since before the war. In many cases, wages have increased more rapidly than the standard of living without a compensatory increase in output, and all these factors contribute in some degree towards sending the weaker vessels to the wall.
There are just a few figures that I wish to give before concluding. The average number registered weekly as unemployed in 1925-26 was 30,031; in 1926-27 it was 23,394; 1927-28, 21,841; in 1928-29, 22,500. At present the average number registered as unemployed amounts to 19,713.
Comment on this
But does not the President recognise that the number registered as unemployed in the month of June is always much less than the average?
Comment on this
Take the three months March, April and May. March is not a good month. Deputy de Valera addressed himself only to a difference of 700 as between April and May in 1927.
Comment on this
No. Deputy de Valera mentioned about emigration. The number, three years ago, was 30,000 odd. Two years ago it was 27,000 and a year ago it was 24,000, so that there was a larger number apparently to be provided for.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, we have not gone to the full extent of our quota. I want to say one word on housing in conclusion. Deputy O'Kelly said that the sum of £250,000 was required for five years. In the last seven years Dublin has got the sum of £108,202 towards housing. 5,394 dwellings were provided at a very big cost and are not enough to meet the situation.
I suggest in all seriousness that Deputies, by reason of their position, get the worst side of affairs in the country. They naturally get complaints. Nobody who has been in a representative capacity ever had a call from a business man to say: "Business is fine; I never did as well, but do not tell the Revenue Commissioners." No, it does not happen. My office is almost a refugium peccatorum with letters showing what hard cases there are in all parts of the country. Deputies have had the same story. There are complaints one way or another. From what I have said to-night, Deputies can go back to the country and throw their chests out and say: "We are proud to be Irishmen, although we forgot it for a long time."
Comment on this
Is the President prepared to give a definite answer to the direct question asked by Deputy O'Connell, whether he is prepared to announce the policy of the Government arising out of the failure of the housing conference?
Comment on this
Would the President urge on the Board of Works the necessity for speeding up the granting of local loans for building purposes?
Comment on this
I asked the President to say if the Government were considering steps to deal with men who would be disemployed on the Shannon scheme within the next few months. I understand that 2,000 or 3,000 will be disemployed.
Comment on this
No. As regards Deputy O'Connell's question, that matter has not been considered.
Comment on this
We have quite a number of big topics to consider, one way or another. It is unreasonable to ask consideration of that matter at this stage. The men are still working. As regards the question raised by Deputy Davin, that was not my child. I was asked to set up that Committee, which undertook to provide a solution. From their first report they thought a solution would be possible by a conference between masters and men. The Government policy on housing is on the Statute Book. We are prepared to do more if we get a little more help.
Comment on this
Am I correct in interpreting the President as saying that in the last twelve months 2,500 houses have been built in Dublin?
Comment on this
According to the figures I received from the Dublin Corporation, 3,214 houses were built in the last eleven years.
Comment on this
The Deputy is leaving out of consideration that there are private persons who have got assistance as well as the Dublin Corporation. A number of public utility societies, and so on, have also been assisted.
Comment on this
I am satisfied with my figures. Evidently we were talking of different figures. I was talking of the houses built by the Dublin Corporation. Another point, the President suggested I said that £200,000 with £50,000 added was all that would be required in the next five years. If the President will read my remarks again he will see that what I said was that £200,000 was being provided by the Bill introduced this year. Bills have been introduced every year since 1925 for a number of years providing for houses. This year the sum of £200,000 was provided. I suggested that £50,000 more would be required. That is £250,000 per annum. Was that £250,000 to be spent in the way provided by the Bill in 1929?
Comment on this
Not necessarily. It might take nine months or eighteen months.
Comment on this
A Bill has been introduced every year. It was expected that at least inside of twelve months that £200,000 provided here would be spent. I suggested that we would require another £50,000.
Comment on this
Motion—"That the Vote be referred back for reconsideration"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?